Latest / Restricted Handling Daily Intel Brief / Iran, China, Russia, and U.S. Strategy w/ Amb David Satterfield and CIA Officer (Ret) Glenn Corn
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone.
- 0:00And welcome to another episode of the restricted
- 0:03handling podcast.
- 0:04Glenn and I are very fortunate to be joined
- 0:06today with a special guest, Ambassador David
- 0:09Satterfield, who is a, I would say a heavyweight
- 0:12diplomat behind decades of experience in
- 0:15US foreign policy and some really difficult and
- 0:18challenging parts of the world.
- 0:19A lot of experience in the middle East, done a
- 0:23lot of work in Turkey, Iraq, Lebanon, Syria.
- 0:26uh North Africa, of course, you've worked
- 0:28NATO tensions extensively, and you've
- 0:30been in the middle of what I would just call it
- 0:33many times.
- 0:34You know how Washington handles crises from home
- 0:36and abroad, having worked obviously in Foggy Bottom
- 0:39and then in many embassies overseas.
- 0:42just looking at your background, Ambassador,
- 0:44it looks like your career overlaps with almost
- 0:47every major post-911 diplomatic effort we've
- 0:49had in the Middle East.
- 0:51We're so fortunate to have you, and I know you
- 0:53and Glenn know each other.
- 0:54We can't say exactly from where, but I would just
- 0:57like to start by asking, how was it working with
- 1:00Glenn those years ago?
- 1:03It was a superb experience.
- 1:05Look, I had a 45 year uh plus career with the
- 1:10Foreign Service.
- 1:12I saw many, many country teams, many of which I
- 1:15headed.
- 1:16I'm very pleased to have had the association that
- 1:20I did both during the time of our services in
- 1:23government and afterwards with Glenn He's a real
- 1:26pro and a great guy.
- 1:27And I will, I was going say, will say, will Venmo
- 1:31you some money after this call.
- 1:33After this, yeah.
- 1:36Now Ryan, I mean, just from my end, listen, I
- 1:38love working for ambassador Satterfield.
- 1:41He's a great ambassador, great American.
- 1:43I don't think I saw anyone that understood
- 1:46the way that the national security apparatus should
- 1:49work the way he did.
- 1:50And, uh, was a team player across the board.
- 1:54So it was.
- 1:55Every day with him was uh an education.
- 1:58So thank you.
- 1:59I know you're very busy, Ambassador Satterfield
- 2:01You have another big job after government,
- 2:03post-government.
- 2:04Ambassador, if we could start out just with how
- 2:07hectic and chaotic things feel in the Middle East
- 2:10right now, I think just looking back over the
- 2:13decades, it would rarely be
- 2:14called quiet, but I would say right now with Hamas,
- 2:18Hezbollah, Iran, strait,
- 2:20it, OPEC changing with the UAE pulling out, how
- 2:23crazy are things at Foggy Bottom and in embassies
- 2:26in that region right now?
- 2:27If you were back in the frenzy, is this one of
- 2:31the-
- 2:31more chaotic moments.
- 2:33Well, Ryan, you really asked two questions.
- 2:36One is what's going on in the Middle East and how
- 2:39does it contrast with with previous times of
- 2:42let's call them highly dynamic circumstances.
- 2:45um The second question, though, is what if I were
- 2:48back at the Department of State, the NSC and the
- 2:51U.S.
- 2:52government, which are two very different things.
- 2:54Let's talk about the Middle East first.
- 2:55Look, the Middle East is not an area which is
- 2:59stagnant, nor has it been for many decades.
- 3:03There's change going on and some of that change
- 3:06is actually quite positive.
- 3:08You cannot look at the evolution ah within Saudi
- 3:12Arabia for all of the problems and beyond
- 3:15problems ah under Crown Prince Mohammed bin
- 3:19Salman.
- 3:19The changes that have been wrought in that
- 3:23country in the past 10 years justify any
- 3:25prediction if you walked the clock back to his
- 3:29initial period as Crown Prince.
- 3:31UAE.
- 3:33The UAE's withdrawal from OPEC was not a surprise.
- 3:38The only surprise was the question of timing.
- 3:41This was a shoe we all knew was going to fall
- 3:44for many years now for different reasons, uh
- 3:48some of which have to do with policy differences
- 3:51with Saudi Arabia.
- 3:53And we can talk a little bit more about the
- 3:56strategic different directions in a regional
- 3:59and transregional fashion.
- 4:01the Saudis and the Emiratis have taken
- 4:03because they're significant.
- 4:04uh But the real reason they left is UAE is
- 4:06moving in a different direction in terms of its
- 4:09own economics.
- 4:10uh When they withdrew from MOPPE, ah their
- 4:14ambassador to the US, one of the most senior
- 4:17diplomats serving in Washington, um issued a
- 4:21long statement.
- 4:22The statement noted the UAE depends for less than
- 4:2730 % of its GDP on hydrocarbons.
- 4:30The rest is generated by other sources of income,
- 4:34from tourism to chemicals to investment income to a
- 4:38variety of other ventures, including
- 4:41notably AI and the tech transformation of
- 4:44the world.
- 4:45uh The UAE did not wish to be bound for that
- 4:49section of its economy that was indeed
- 4:53hydrocarbon based by the production focuses of
- 4:57Saudi Arabia.
- 4:59for whom hydrocarbons are the main, almost entire
- 5:02source of income to the country.
- 5:04So of all of the dynamic events in the region, UAE
- 5:07withdrawal from MOPAC was not really one of them.
- 5:10It was an expected development.
- 5:11It is not going to shake up very much.
- 5:13And the fact that it came at a moment of closure of
- 5:16the straight meant that it had zero impact on
- 5:19markets, none whatsoever.
- 5:21But let's go to the region.
- 5:23Look, for all the positive dynamics,
- 5:26that had been at play in the region.
- 5:27I'll include the Abraham Accords, the coming out
- 5:30from behind the curtains under the table of what
- 5:33had been longstanding, Gulf and other Arab
- 5:36relations with Israel, usually in the
- 5:38intelligence and security area, now overt and
- 5:42political and formal, very positive step.
- 5:46Something else has been happening as well, which
- 5:50is the growing role of asymmetrical challenges,
- 5:54asymmetrical
- 5:55conflicts in which classic military might,
- 6:00technical prowess, Israeli, US in the case
- 6:04of Iran, put up against an asymmetric opponent.
- 6:09And Iran really is still more in that asymmetric
- 6:13opponent class than state on state.
- 6:16Certainly Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis
- 6:19absolutely fall into that.
- 6:21You have had now several years experience.
- 6:25And in the case of Lebanon and Hezbollah, 40
- 6:29years experience in the application of classic
- 6:33military kinetic force against that asymmetrical
- 6:37actor, that sub-state actor.
- 6:39And in the case of Iran, almost two years of
- 6:42varying forms of conflict, some of which
- 6:46the U.S.
- 6:46is engaged in, some of which has been
- 6:49exclusively Israeli, some of which has been largely
- 6:52intelligence-driven, others overtly kinetic.
- 6:55But still, in each of these cases, the
- 7:00inability of the state actor to effect the
- 7:05strategic objective through use of force.
- 7:10This is a puzzlement and it is a frustration.
- 7:12And boy, if I had to use a single word to describe
- 7:16the current situation in the Middle East, ranging
- 7:20from US to Israel to the Gulf States, it's
- 7:24frustration.
- 7:25Why can't we open the strait?
- 7:29Why couldn't we eliminate, in quote
- 7:32marks, Iran's ballistic missile force?
- 7:35What about the drones?
- 7:37What about, quote, sinking their navy?
- 7:40Close quote.
- 7:41And then there's Hezbollah.
- 7:42Decapitation of leadership, massively.
- 7:47Strikes against their weapons facilities.
- 7:50High-end production places.
- 7:54yet has Bala remains maintains its sad death
- 7:58grip on the Lebanese polity.
- 8:00Hamas, almost two years of devastating,
- 8:04devastating combat on the ground and from the air.
- 8:09And right now, who governs two million
- 8:13Gazans with the gun?
- 8:14It's Hamas.
- 8:16Diminished, disrupted, degraded, but still
- 8:22potent.
- 8:23and still a potential threat, as are the
- 8:25Houthis.
- 8:26After all the U.S.
- 8:27Navy rocketing of launch sites, the Houthis remain
- 8:32capable, should they choose or Iran direct to
- 8:36interdict shipping or raise the war risk
- 8:39insurance to the point that shipping
- 8:43would not move through the Bab al-Mandin.
- 8:46What do you do in these circumstances?
- 8:48Well, it requires patience, strategic
- 8:51patience.
- 8:52And it requires beyond kinetic application of
- 8:55force, political application of force,
- 8:58meaning you've got to accompany what you
- 9:01possess in terms of military might with
- 9:04political
- 9:05frameworks.
- 9:06sadly, in Gaza, that was completely missing, even
- 9:09though the Israeli national security
- 9:12establishment at the highest levels, quite
- 9:15rarely in my almost 50 year history of working
- 9:19with Israel, called publicly.
- 9:21for a political framework because we have done, we
- 9:25the IDF, all we can do kinetically to achieve
- 9:28strategic objectives.
- 9:30Similarly, Hezbollah in Lebanon, deeply
- 9:32frustrating.
- 9:33The Lebanese government, this government wants a
- 9:36peace with Israel.
- 9:37They've said that.
- 9:38There's no hidden message there.
- 9:41They want a peace, not just normalization.
- 9:44But Hezbollah maintains its grip.
- 9:47Hezbollah threatens their lives, the lives of
- 9:50Lebanese, as it has done in one incarnation or
- 9:53another for 50 years.
- 9:55How do you break that?
- 9:56There are political ways to isolate Hezbollah, but
- 10:00to go at it frontally, ground occupation,
- 10:03strikes on infrastructure,
- 10:05destruction of housing doesn't take you there.
- 10:09And then we come to the great problem of Iran.
- 10:13Look, uh I hate to be reductionist, but I will
- 10:17be.
- 10:18ah And you can come back at me on this from any
- 10:20direction you want.
- 10:21I'm perfectly susceptible to other persuasive
- 10:25argumentation here.
- 10:26I was not a fan of the 2015 JCPOA because of the
- 10:30sunset clauses and because it did not
- 10:32address either ballistic missile program, which
- 10:36was still relatively nascent, but
- 10:38threatening at that point, nor did it affect
- 10:42at all Iran's support for the proxies, the Houthis
- 10:46Hamas Hezbollah.
- 10:47terror around the
- 10:48However, I have come to recognize over the years
- 10:53since that withdrawal was a mistake.
- 10:58Withdrawal was a mistake, and my comments now are
- 11:02going to be echoed by those of the most senior
- 11:05Israeli intelligence community and nuclear
- 11:09enrichment bomb acquisition specialists.
- 11:12It was a mistake because it shortened the window.
- 11:17shortened the period of time that Iran would have
- 11:22required to build those centrifuge cascades to
- 11:26enrich beyond the 3.67 levels of the JCPOA.
- 11:30That's radio isotopes for medicine, as well as a
- 11:33civilian nuclear program.
- 11:35Iran does have a nuclear reactor in Boucher uh
- 11:39that's under construction.
- 11:41It shortened that.
- 11:42And in doing that, again, I'll quote the Israelis.
- 11:46It chopped five to eight years off of the period
- 11:51we had to adapt to other protective measures in
- 11:56the event Iran went to an enrichment program or a
- 12:01device acquisition program.
- 12:03And that latter had not been pursued by Iran,
- 12:06hasn't been pursued by Iran since 2003, based on
- 12:10what I believe are still current US assessments.
- 12:14We lost that window.
- 12:15That was the first mistake.
- 12:18The second mistake was February 28th, to go into
- 12:22a conflict with Iran.
- 12:24And the decision, let's be clear here, was the
- 12:27president's.
- 12:28He was not duped by Benjamin Netanyahu.
- 12:31Netanyahu has long sought, throughout his
- 12:33political career, a definitive strategic end
- 12:36to the Iranian threat, a threat to Israel, a
- 12:39threat to Jews around the world.
- 12:41That is a genuine motivation for
- 12:43Netanyahu.
- 12:45And so certainly he has tried to argue the case
- 12:48as he argued the case for withdrawal from the
- 12:51JCPOA, quite famously in front of the US Congress
- 12:55and the UN.
- 12:56But it was President Trump's decision, and a
- 13:00decision I believe was very much informed by his
- 13:03experiences, plural, the assassination of Qasem
- 13:07Soleimani outside Baghdad airport,
- 13:10which I think was an extraordinarily
- 13:13appropriate, smart move.
- 13:16No one in the IRGC possessed the expertise,
- 13:20the command, the experience of Soleimani.
- 13:25And the volume of American and allied dead
- 13:29on that man's hands was profound.
- 13:32So no tears shed at all for this.
- 13:34But there was virtually no consequence to that
- 13:37act in terms of an Iranian response.
- 13:40Then came June of last year.
- 13:43the end to the 12-day Israeli campaign, which
- 13:47eliminated Iran's air defense network, when the
- 13:50U.S., again in my view, very appropriately,
- 13:54stepped in for those famous three hours in
- 13:57which we used the weaponry and the delivery
- 14:00vehicles that only we possess to significantly
- 14:04damage, I'm using the most conservative
- 14:07language, significantly damage, Natanz, Isfahan,
- 14:10and of course, Fordow.
- 14:11very limited and in fact almost entirely
- 14:14performative response to al-Udayid from the
- 14:17Iranians.
- 14:17Then came Venezuela, the removal of the president
- 14:22and his wife and the quote acquisition close
- 14:26quote of Venezuelan oil.
- 14:29Great success is all of them in and out, one and
- 14:32done.
- 14:32I believe the president believed he could effect
- 14:36a variety of strategic objectives in Iran in
- 14:40similar rapid fashion.
- 14:42Whether regime change was ever really part of that
- 14:46or not, unclear.
- 14:47And I'm not going to indict on this podcast,
- 14:50Mossad, ah which has been variously accused or
- 14:53exonerated from having overestimated the chances
- 14:57of regime change, because I didn't
- 14:59have those conversations and have heard varying
- 15:02different uh points of view on this issue from a
- 15:06variety of Mossad directors over many, many
- 15:09years.
- 15:09I'm going to hold this one in abeyance.
- 15:12But the president certainly believed he
- 15:15could achieve on the nuclear program, beyond
- 15:19JCPOA objectives, a long-term 20-year or
- 15:23permanent freeze to enrichment, uh
- 15:26accountability for
- 15:27removal from Iran of the legendary 900 plus pounds
- 15:31of 60 % enriched uranium.
- 15:34By the way, folks, oh this is a bit of a red
- 15:37herring.
- 15:38Iran possesses 11 tons
- 15:41of enriched uranium beyond civil nuclear
- 15:46levels.
- 15:47The fixation has been on the 60 % because, quote,
- 15:50it would be less than two weeks if you had the
- 15:54cascades running to bring it up to bomb grade
- 15:57quantity and then convert it into
- 16:00metal from hexafluoride gas.
- 16:02But you know what?
- 16:04You could bring tons of Iran's uranium up to that
- 16:1060 % level.
- 16:11with the centrifuges in a relatively short period
- 16:15of time.
- 16:16people want to focus on things that are
- 16:18graspable.
- 16:19So it's the 900 pounds might be at Isfahan,
- 16:22might be at Natanz, who knows.
- 16:25But that's been the focal point.
- 16:27President thought he could get those things.
- 16:29And he could say this was better than the JCPOA, no
- 16:32sunset clauses.
- 16:33I got it.
- 16:34I closed this down.
- 16:35All of the sucker presidents before me who
- 16:39couldn't do this.
- 16:40going back to 79 to Jimmy Carter.
- 16:43Look what I did.
- 16:45And if regime change comes, I'll take credit
- 16:47for that as well.
- 16:49And I've devastated their Navy, their Air Force.
- 16:53They are in a weaker position and I've taken
- 16:55out their missile force.
- 16:57Well, guess what?
- 16:58Iran's threat, its power projection challenge of
- 17:04maybe acquiring a nuclear device,
- 17:08maybe, and being viewed as a potential nuclear
- 17:12threat to its neighbors and beyond, sort of as
- 17:15Pakistan was before it actually put the pieces
- 17:19together and assembled the device.
- 17:22That was a theoretical threat.
- 17:25So was closing the Strait of Tehran, I'm sorry, the
- 17:29Strait of Hormuz.
- 17:30That strait and its closure has been debated
- 17:33for years within the U.S.
- 17:35community.
- 17:36military and intelligence and political.
- 17:38The assumption was, you know, we're not quite
- 17:42sure they could do it.
- 17:43If they could do it, we're not sure they would
- 17:46because of the consequences they bring
- 17:48on themselves, given the fact that they need those
- 17:51exports every day and imports that come
- 17:53into Iran to survive.
- 17:56And if they tried it, well, you know, it
- 17:58wouldn't last very long.
- 18:00It could be broken.
- 18:02It was a theoretical threat.
- 18:05Now it's not.
- 18:06Now it is a genuine weapon with global
- 18:10import.
- 18:1112 % of the world's maritime transport goes
- 18:14through that straight.
- 18:1530 % of the world's helium, that's an
- 18:19irreplaceable component in semiconductor
- 18:22manufacturing.
- 18:2330 % of the world's aluminum, not just any
- 18:27aluminum, but the very highest grades used in
- 18:32the US and other
- 18:33military and strategic systems, about the same
- 18:38amount of the world's highest quality steel
- 18:42that can't be replicated easily, not by the US,
- 18:46not by Europe, not by Japan, and 50 % of
- 18:50the feedstocks outside the US demand for
- 18:53fertilizer.
- 18:55Those are huge global economic supply chains,
- 19:00all of them halted.
- 19:02Plus, of course,
- 19:04natural gas and crude.
- 19:0730 % of one, 20 % of the other.
- 19:09Iran has demonstrated they can and they will
- 19:12close it.
- 19:13They can keep it closed.
- 19:15And the US in the Parsi phrase can't do a damn
- 19:20thing about it.
- 19:21Now, why is that?
- 19:23How could that possibly be?
- 19:25Because the threat doesn't require a tanker
- 19:28to be hit.
- 19:29It doesn't require a plastic lint-net mine,
- 19:33carried by an inflatable zodiac boat, cruising
- 19:37along at high speed at wave height, difficult to
- 19:41detect.
- 19:42Doesn't need any of that.
- 19:43It's the threat that it could happen that
- 19:46resulted in the dropping of war risk insurance and
- 19:50the refusal of shippers to move their vessels
- 19:54through the strait.
- 19:56That was, that is the situation right now.
- 19:59How about those other fronts?
- 20:00Nuclear program.
- 20:02Well, the nuclear program has been hit hard.
- 20:04There's no question about it.
- 20:06Has it been set back further since February
- 20:0928th and was the case last June after the US
- 20:12bombings?
- 20:13Doesn't appear to be the case.
- 20:14What about missiles?
- 20:16Well, there was a known unknown here in Don
- 20:18Rumsfeld's famous term.
- 20:20We didn't know how many ballistic missiles Iran
- 20:22had.
- 20:23We sure didn't know how many drones they had.
- 20:26And we knew that.
- 20:28What has been the impact of the massive campaign?
- 20:32Tens of thousands of strikes on at least 10 to
- 20:3715,000 separate targets?
- 20:39Well, in Jim Mattis's phrase, target tree
- 20:43doesn't substitute for strategy.
- 20:47You can hit any number of targets you want.
- 20:49Those are outputs.
- 20:51What are your outcomes?
- 20:53And I think you have all seen the public reportage
- 20:57of the outcome, which is Iran possesses still a
- 21:00massive, perhaps even over 50 % or
- 21:03significantly over 50 % of its original
- 21:06capacity of both missiles and on drones.
- 21:09um The quantity was so vast, the production so
- 21:12rapid, it's very difficult to see how you
- 21:15constrain that at all.
- 21:17Drone technology goes by leaps and bounds.
- 21:23as those of you who follow Ukraine more
- 21:26closely than I do recognize, uh you now
- 21:29have drones that are pilotable through
- 21:32microfiber optic cables that can go as long as 30
- 21:36miles,
- 21:37that can't be jammed.
- 21:39They're all made of plastic or carbon
- 21:41materials.
- 21:41They have no radar signature.
- 21:44They're on you or coming in through your window.
- 21:47I don't exaggerate the case here.
- 21:49And being detonated with a first-person view.
- 21:52by the controller, POV.
- 21:56How do you defeat those technologies?
- 21:58Iran's got them in spades.
- 22:00Was any of this a surprise?
- 22:01And here, Ryan, I'll come to the close of this.
- 22:05Should it have been a surprise to Israel,
- 22:07should it have been a to the United States?
- 22:09I do not believe there was an intelligence
- 22:12community failure or a failure on the part of
- 22:15our military professionals in
- 22:17assessing what we knew and what we did not know.
- 22:21and in presenting those in a factual manner.
- 22:24But there was a political override of all of that.
- 22:29None of this should have been surprising.
- 22:32Now, how is it that Iran, which has been blockaded
- 22:36now, or has itself mutually blockaded the
- 22:40strait for all this time, how are they not near
- 22:44collapse?
- 22:45Because no state on earth is more experienced in
- 22:48dealing
- 22:49with the most extreme sanctions in the world,
- 22:52including constraints on production.
- 22:54Iran ratcheted down in 2020, not all that long
- 22:59ago, to only 300,000 barrels a day of
- 23:03production.
- 23:05They can do it.
- 23:06They know how.
- 23:08And they are a security regime top to bottom.
- 23:11They killed at least 8,000 of their people in
- 23:14January, maybe many more than that.
- 23:17They would kill again if they needed to.
- 23:19There is no organized structured opposition in
- 23:23Iran, and they could care less what the situation
- 23:27of their people are.
- 23:28I think a conservative estimate is it would take
- 23:32a matter of months to inflict enough economic
- 23:36pain on Iran that they would begin to bend.
- 23:40But bending is possible, but you need patience.
- 23:43You need patience that is not interrupted by
- 23:47escalatory actions.
- 23:48And that's what happened last weekend when the
- 23:52U.S.
- 23:52switched from a patient strategy of quite
- 23:55effective maritime blockade coupled with
- 23:58going after shadow fleet elements and fund
- 24:01transfers around the world, something the
- 24:04Treasury
- 24:05and the intelligence community in the U.S.
- 24:07are expert at doing.
- 24:09It moved from that to something new.
- 24:12For reasons I don't fully grasp, we were going to
- 24:16take another step.
- 24:17we were going to overtly challenge the blockade
- 24:21through some form of military guidance and
- 24:24largely aerial protection of ships.
- 24:27The Iranians saw that as an escalation, attacked
- 24:31the UAE now three times over the last five days
- 24:34as a signal to us and to the other Gulf states,
- 24:38back off.
- 24:39This in the midst of negotiations, back off we
- 24:43did when Saudi Arabia told us to, worried at
- 24:46the consequences.
- 24:48You cannot engage a strategic adversary like
- 24:52Iran, whose leadership was always hard-line, but
- 24:57now of an even harder, more rigid posture,
- 25:01focused now not on the nuclear program, but
- 25:05on the strait itself and what governs the strait
- 25:08after this all comes to a close.
- 25:11Much harder issue than the nuclear program ever
- 25:14was.
- 25:14You cannot deal
- 25:16by tweets every 30 minutes, shifting your
- 25:19position, threatening, belittling, insulting.
- 25:23We've never done that in the history of U.S.
- 25:25diplomacy, and it isn't working now.
- 25:29That was excellent.
- 25:30Thank you for sharing that.
- 25:32know the students under your tutelage probably
- 25:34get a lot of that.
- 25:35Glenn, I'm going to go to you, please.
- 25:37didn't answer the last part of your question.
- 25:39What would I do if I were in foggy bottom or the
- 25:43NSC?
- 25:44Answer is I would be unable to do anything
- 25:47because there is no functional department of
- 25:51state or national security council.
- 25:55There are a handful of associates of the
- 25:59president in whose hands lie, you fill in the
- 26:03blank, Ukraine.
- 26:05Iran.
- 26:06Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, plus a galaxy of other
- 26:10issues that used to be managed by, what was the
- 26:15word for it?
- 26:17The US executive branch and its various cabinet
- 26:23agencies.
- 26:24That's not the case today.
- 26:26So the answer is there is very little I could do,
- 26:29were I in a department which itself can do very
- 26:33little.
- 26:34Indeed.
- 26:34Thanks.
- 26:35No.
- 26:35So Ambassador Satterfield, mean,
- 26:37there's so much unpack here and talk about, but
- 26:40let's, let's start at the end there.
- 26:41mean, you were the, you were the U S ambassador
- 26:45to Turkey, the Republic of Turkey, right?
- 26:47And I always find it interesting.
- 26:49Like we have now an ambassador in Ankara
- 26:51who's also covering Syria.
- 26:53And if I still, he's also the special envoy, envoy
- 26:55for you were also the ambassador in Lebanon.
- 26:58And what do you think?
- 26:59Like, can you, can one person handle all those
- 27:02three?
- 27:03critical and super complicated issues.
- 27:06mean, how much espresso do you have to drink a
- 27:09day?
- 27:10How many cigarettes do have to smoke to stay up?
- 27:13truth in lending here.
- 27:15um I do have regard for Tom Barrack I think Tom
- 27:19has spoken bluntly in a fashion that a career
- 27:23diplomat would never have used, I would not have,
- 27:27about some basic ground truths
- 27:29and realities.
- 27:30And those range from the US relationship with the
- 27:34so-called SDF, uh the Kurdish Armed Force in
- 27:39the what used to be the
- 27:41Court of Autonomous Administration of
- 27:44Northeast Syria.
- 27:45He has spoken quite bluntly and I think
- 27:48factually about realities in Lebanon and the
- 27:51complexities of dealing with not just Hezbollah,
- 27:54but self-invested Lebanese elites.
- 27:57uh And he's spoken about the value of Turkey at a
- 28:00meta level to the NATO alliance with all of the
- 28:03difficulties that are attended in that
- 28:06relationship uh because of reasons Glenn,
- 28:09you and I know.
- 28:10extremely well with respect to the leadership
- 28:13of Turkey, for whom I have great regard, but I
- 28:16also acknowledge the problematic character of
- 28:18many of their actions.
- 28:21So Tom is an extraordinary individual.
- 28:23And with respect to Syria, I will extend my
- 28:27acknowledgement of the right thing being done,
- 28:31not just to Tom, but to President Trump.
- 28:35President Trump overrode many of the classic
- 28:39voices
- 28:40at the time of that dramatic collapse of the
- 28:43Assad regime in late November, December of
- 28:472024, who would have seen an elaborate set of US
- 28:51guided constitution drafting, withholding
- 28:54of assets and support.
- 28:56president made a comment, and I agree with every
- 28:59word of it, when he was in, believe, Abu Dhabi.
- 29:01And he said, I don't know what's going to happen in
- 29:03Syria.
- 29:04I don't know if this leadership now ah is
- 29:07going to be jihadi in character.
- 29:09turn to the jihadists, be taken over by the
- 29:12jihadists, but I do know this.
- 29:13If we don't move swiftly to provide relief from
- 29:16sanctions and strictures, if we don't give them a
- 29:19chance to stabilize the place, it will go in only
- 29:23one direction, which is
- 29:24fragmentation and threat generation for the
- 29:27region.
- 29:27The president was absolutely correct,
- 29:30wouldn't change a word of that.
- 29:32And Tom was a critical implementer in all of
- 29:34that.
- 29:34And you know the administration held to
- 29:37its rhetoric.
- 29:38We did remove all of the executive branch and then
- 29:41legislated the Caesar Act.
- 29:43Restrictions on Syria, it was the right thing to
- 29:48do, as was the extraordinarily, and to
- 29:51me surprisingly in a positive sense, smooth
- 29:56working out of the fate of the Kurdish entity in
- 30:01the northeast of Syria and its allied forces.
- 30:04It did not come as I expected.
- 30:07with Kurdish forces in Kobani, with Kurdish
- 30:12forces in Qamishli, Hesseke, fighting, dying.
- 30:18It didn't.
- 30:18It came out in an extraordinarily peaceful
- 30:21fashion.
- 30:22There reasons for that, but some of it was Tom's
- 30:26diplomacy, backed up by the president.
- 30:29So I give him credit for that.
- 30:30As I give credit to Jared Kushner for his work in
- 30:33the previous Trump administration on the
- 30:36Abraham Accords.
- 30:37Strong supporter of that.
- 30:39And Jared did things which no conventional
- 30:42career diplomat could have done.
- 30:44So credit where it's due.
- 30:46But you asked Glenn, can one person manage all of
- 30:50these different issues entirely?
- 30:52No.
- 30:53No, they can't.
- 30:54They really can't.
- 30:55You need embassies.
- 30:57You need qualified country teams.
- 30:59You need a backup in the Washington environment,
- 31:03which isn't just intelligence and
- 31:06military.
- 31:06You need a functional State Department at all
- 31:10levels, and you need a functional NSC to strip
- 31:13down the bloated NSC, which grew after the
- 31:16second term of the Clinton administration
- 31:20out of all conceivable proportion to its actual
- 31:23tasks.
- 31:24Absolutely.
- 31:25I'll raise my hand in support of that.
- 31:28The George H.W.
- 31:30Bush NSC, which is what Bill Clinton inherited in
- 31:33his first term, had 72 people total.
- 31:36including technicians, administrative staff,
- 31:40secretaries.
- 31:41It grew to the hundreds, the many hundreds, packed
- 31:45like sardines into the old executive office
- 31:49building.
- 31:50That was too big, too small to be the
- 31:52government of the United States, too big to be an
- 31:55advisory group for the president.
- 31:56So if you want to cut there, absolutely, but
- 32:00you cannot eliminate it.
- 32:02It is supposed to present
- 32:05a variety of views to the president.
- 32:08It is supposed to articulate what are at
- 32:11times differing positions of agencies.
- 32:14You're not getting this.
- 32:15Yep.
- 32:16You know, I've said everything that you said,
- 32:18Mr.
- 32:18Ambassador, I agree with that 100%.
- 32:20I think the president gets a lot of credit for
- 32:22doing things that are bold, that many people
- 32:25traditionally would have been objected against.
- 32:27They would have argued against.
- 32:28They would have probably fought against in the
- 32:31bureaucracy.
- 32:31We've seen that ourselves in our careers.
- 32:34But what worries me is the sustainment of like
- 32:37we have opportunities that he's taken advantage
- 32:39of.
- 32:40Let's just use Syria.
- 32:41Can we sustain it?
- 32:43And there, think I agree with you.
- 32:44You have to have teams that can do that.
- 32:47You can't rely on one person.
- 32:49You can't rely on, you know, a very close inner
- 32:52circle.
- 32:53I think you're going to have to, at some point,
- 32:55trust some people outside of that inner circle to
- 32:58get the job done who have the regional experience
- 33:00in the background, because we
- 33:01see that in some cases you may be very, very
- 33:04talented, but if you don't know the region,
- 33:06you don't know the issue, you don't know the
- 33:09country, the history, that could be
- 33:10problematic.
- 33:11because you keep stepping on landmines uh without,
- 33:14because you just don't know the background.
- 33:17Absolutely, Glenn.
- 33:19But look, while everything you have said
- 33:21is absolutely true, it's certainly been the
- 33:23experience during my career, you need a
- 33:25balance here.
- 33:26You need a mix, whether it comes from career,
- 33:29Foreign Service or career bureaucrats, Treasury
- 33:33Department, oh others who are capable of thinking
- 33:37outside the box, who are not
- 33:39bound by their or others prior experiences.
- 33:44And this is a powerful challenge.
- 33:45It certainly is for all of us.
- 33:47The longer you stay in service, whatever your
- 33:50service is, and the more senior you become, the
- 33:54more policy ventures you become vested in and
- 33:58with, both failures and successes, you
- 34:01start ruling out automatically certain
- 34:04choices.
- 34:05David Petraeus used to say, 36 months in Iraq,
- 34:09you should cut and go.
- 34:11Don't stay.
- 34:11I stayed for 48, which was probably an error,
- 34:14but I had a negotiation to do.
- 34:17But it's because you believe you've seen it
- 34:19all and you know what the options are.
- 34:22You don't have to have somebody talk to you.
- 34:24You've lived through it.
- 34:26That becomes a constraining factor.
- 34:28So I am all about creative thinking, bold
- 34:31leadership, proximity to the president.
- 34:34For certain issues, it's absolutely critical.
- 34:37There could have been no Abraham Accord.
- 34:40There could have been no resolution in Syria,
- 34:44particularly the Northeast.
- 34:46highly sensitive issue, deeply fraught and fought
- 34:50over within the Congress and the U.S.
- 34:53bureaucracy and within the U.S.
- 34:55military.
- 34:57Our battle buddies, the Kurds, we will never
- 34:59abandon you.
- 35:01We'll be there forever with you.
- 35:02Well, you know, but that message was never getting
- 35:06through.
- 35:07It took a combination of that forward thinking out
- 35:11of the box, a president willing to back and
- 35:14support in the face
- 35:16of Washington opposition, sometimes powerful
- 35:19opposition, to make it work.
- 35:22You need the balance, but in the end, when you make
- 35:25your breakthrough, you need a team.
- 35:27You need a team to carry the ball, to sustain the
- 35:31motion, to see the problems coming before
- 35:35they become crises.
- 35:36And when there are crises, to have a team
- 35:39that can manage them, deal with them, analyze
- 35:42them, coach them.
- 35:43You you haven't asked about AID.
- 35:46I'll tell you this, I have no nostalgia for
- 35:50AID.
- 35:50As chief of mission four times, ah I had profound
- 35:55concerns over the content of legacy AID
- 35:59programming.
- 36:01I understood much of it was congressionally
- 36:03mandated.
- 36:04There wasn't a choice here, but I was rarely
- 36:07happy with it.
- 36:08Occasionally we got it to the right place.
- 36:11There was a lot of bathwater to be thrown
- 36:15out here, but there were also a number of
- 36:18extremely healthy, promising, and changing
- 36:22babies to hold to that analogy.
- 36:24And that was a bad thing to do, and a hell of a
- 36:27lot of expertise that went out the window with
- 36:30it.
- 36:31So massive reform, absolutely.
- 36:34Cut programs that do not serve demonstrably,
- 36:39credible U.S.
- 36:40interests,
- 36:40either regarded as such by the Congress, the
- 36:43Executive, or the people of the United States?
- 36:46Sure.
- 36:47But this went too far, too blindly, and frankly,
- 36:50for no logical reason whatsoever.
- 36:53Right.
- 36:55I want to pivot us to China in the interest of
- 36:58time, Ambassador, but there is one thing you
- 37:00mentioned with your former colleague, the
- 37:03ambassador in the region, Tom.
- 37:05I did not catch his last name, so I apologize.
- 37:07When you were describing that he has recently been
- 37:10speaking in a way that you felt like you
- 37:12probably would not have done, can you just
- 37:14describe that a little bit more?
- 37:15What is it that might be driving that?
- 37:19Is it just the political climate?
- 37:21I'd just love to hear more about that.
- 37:23Sure, Tom reflected the views of many of us who
- 37:28have devoted a great deal of our lives and seen our
- 37:33colleagues' lives lost in Lebanon by making a
- 37:37separate set of not indictments,
- 37:41but simply observation.
- 37:43Lebanon has two problems.
- 37:45One is Hezbollah.
- 37:46It is a massive problem, the dimensions of which I
- 37:49think all three of us
- 37:50And most of the people listening to this podcast
- 37:54will certainly grasp and understand, goes back to
- 37:581982, at least to Islamic Amal, Hezbollah's cover,
- 38:02before it declared itself
- 38:03openly.
- 38:05But the other problem, Tom said, it's the
- 38:07Lebanese elites.
- 38:08It's the Lebanese themselves and their
- 38:10unwillingness to give up privilege and confront
- 38:14national responsibilities if it means any form of
- 38:17sacrifice.
- 38:18Well, Tom Bravo.
- 38:19It is what all of us know and understand.
- 38:22But no ambassador ever speaks that way, at least
- 38:25while they remain ambassador or desirous of
- 38:28having a continued career dealing with Lebanese.
- 38:31So I applaud him for that.
- 38:34Tom, speaking of Syria, very recently, I believe
- 38:38in the last two to three weeks, was criticized for
- 38:42saying, look, there's a problem here.
- 38:45Problem is indeed
- 38:46the conduct of the Syrian regime or its inability
- 38:50and willingness to constrain other elements,
- 38:53Bedouin, some other jihadi, foreign jihadi
- 38:55groups present, but it's mainly a
- 38:57Bedouin issue, targeting Druze communities in
- 39:02Southeast Syria, in Sweda.
- 39:05That's a problem, and it's a Syrian problem,
- 39:08but there's also an Israeli problem here.
- 39:10He's vocalizing this now and you're saying this
- 39:12probably wouldn't have happened in the past.
- 39:14Is it frustration?
- 39:15it just...
- 39:16It is that Tom does not feel constrained by the
- 39:22classic factors which govern all of us.
- 39:28As I think Tom would say, you're unhappy with what
- 39:32I've said or I'm doing, so fire me.
- 39:35Love it.
- 39:35All right.
- 39:36um Ambassador, we were, this is great.
- 39:43As we were hitting record, we had asked you,
- 39:46if you were advising the administration, they're
- 39:50coming up on this fairly significant trip to
- 39:54Beijing soon.
- 39:55How would you advise the administration?
- 39:57We'd just love to get your take on that so
- 39:59people can hear this interesting perspective.
- 40:02I'll respond in two different ways.
- 40:05First is contextual.
- 40:06China is a formidable adversary, the most
- 40:10formidable adversary we confront because of its
- 40:15economic weight, because of its technical weight.
- 40:19And here I'll foot stomp home a point that needs
- 40:23reinforcement always.
- 40:26Up until a year, year and a half ago,
- 40:28China was regarded as a major competitor in sort
- 40:32of fourth generation as opposed to cutting edge
- 40:36fifth generation fill in the blanks, chips,
- 40:39systems, aircraft, whatever it
- 40:42might be.
- 40:43They could make more of them more quickly and
- 40:47more cheaply than the US could.
- 40:50And they had better marketing, but they
- 40:52couldn't do fifth generation.
- 40:54We got to wake up Paul when deep sea.
- 40:57was suddenly sprung.
- 40:59Guess what?
- 41:00China is at fifth generation capacity.
- 41:04It's education of hundreds of thousands of
- 41:09individuals who have material applied or
- 41:13process ahead of their specialty, engineering,
- 41:18chemistry, physics.
- 41:20They've taken over a field now where the US
- 41:24has lagged, which is educating people for
- 41:28cutting edge work and then educating them for
- 41:32the production facilities to move them out
- 41:35at high quality, at high speed and cheaper than
- 41:39can be done elsewhere.
- 41:41China is formidable.
- 41:42I'm less concerned, frankly, about the South
- 41:46China Sea threat.
- 41:48I think that is largely power projection.
- 41:50and performative rather than an indicator of
- 41:55intent to fill in the blank, invade Taiwan,
- 41:59blockade Taiwan, take other action against the
- 42:04Philippines, Vietnam, South Korea, Japan.
- 42:09I'm most concerned about the competition, which is
- 42:12very much of an adversarial character at
- 42:15a technical level.
- 42:17at an industrial espionage level, which is
- 42:20extraordinarily sophisticated and global
- 42:24in its scope, and China's ability to establish
- 42:28itself with access to possession of critical
- 42:31minerals, rare earth elements globally in a
- 42:35campaign that began a long time ago and where
- 42:39the US is playing catch up and not playing it all
- 42:43that well.
- 42:44Not everywhere China is active around the world
- 42:48requires the U.S.
- 42:49to intervene.
- 42:50Some of it is purely performative.
- 42:52I don't care if they build a sports stadium or
- 42:55a ministry of defense in countries X or Y, because
- 42:59you guess what?
- 43:00The facades are going to be falling off in about
- 43:03seven or eight years.
- 43:04And China doesn't do things for free.
- 43:07There's a price tag attached to all this
- 43:09stuff.
- 43:09But I am worried.
- 43:11where they attempt to expand a presence which
- 43:14threatens infrastructure, which threatens our or
- 43:17partner national security networks or public
- 43:20networks, that worries me greatly.
- 43:22Port facilities and the acquisition and control
- 43:25of those critical minerals where earth
- 43:27elements, that's a worry as well, the strategic
- 43:30character.
- 43:31Shaping presence.
- 43:34We didn't want Saudi Arabia, Ryan, to go the
- 43:38way of the UAE.
- 43:39where we had to move heaven and earth to get
- 43:43the UAE to block and unroll a very significant
- 43:47Chinese security challenge to the United
- 43:51States and to our partners.
- 43:53It took quite a lot of pressure to do that.
- 43:56We didn't want Saudi Arabia to ever be in that
- 43:58place.
- 43:59And so that famous US-Saudi deal you've all
- 44:02heard so much about, it's not really about
- 44:05normalization with Israel at all.
- 44:08It is primarily about strategic concerns and
- 44:12constraints regarding the Saudi-China relationship,
- 44:16regarding the US dollar as a reserve currency,
- 44:20regarding certain guidelines,
- 44:22guardrails for some future date where
- 44:24sustained consistent production levels and
- 44:27supplies of hydrocarbons might become an issue.
- 44:31They're not now.
- 44:32I don't foresee it coming, but that was in
- 44:34there as well.
- 44:35But the Saudis wanted two things out of all this.
- 44:38They wanted an indigenous nuclear enrichment
- 44:41program, but they weren't willing to sign up to a
- 44:44123 agreement or an additional protocol.
- 44:46We substituted for those the most intrusive U.S.
- 44:50direct presence in that system start to finish
- 44:54that's ever been done anywhere.
- 44:56And we would acquire the fuel when it came out
- 44:59because, by the way, we need it because we're not
- 45:02getting it from Russia anymore for U.S.
- 45:04nuclear needs.
- 45:05To make all of that hold together, they wanted a
- 45:09treaty-level, pacific-style South
- 45:12Korea-Japan security treaty pledge.
- 45:15Not an executive agreement worth the paper
- 45:18it is or isn't signed on.
- 45:20They wanted a Senate-binding
- 45:22commitment.
- 45:22To get that Senate vote, we needed normalization
- 45:26with Israel.
- 45:26So I've just unwrapped for you what is often
- 45:29misrepresented in the press.
- 45:31This was about China, almost all the way down
- 45:34the
- 45:35including the dollars reserve currency.
- 45:37So how do you negotiate with an adversary like
- 45:41this?
- 45:41You know going in what your toolbox contains.
- 45:45Your toolbox contains a full awareness of your
- 45:49vulnerabilities and Chinese vulnerabilities
- 45:52of where their power center has worries and
- 45:56concerns, where you've got worries and
- 45:59concerns.
- 46:00China is not a Titan bestriding the earth.
- 46:03It'd like to be seen that
- 46:05But it isn't.
- 46:06It does have weaknesses, partly because of its
- 46:09presence in the global economy and its massive
- 46:12holding of U.S.
- 46:13Treasury paper.
- 46:14It cannot damage the dollar without basically
- 46:18shooting itself in the head, not just the foot.
- 46:22You got to understand that.
- 46:24Then you have to understand your market
- 46:27tools.
- 46:27The Chinese are market rule violators massively.
- 46:32That's what the 301A
- 46:34trade barriers and 301e labor related.
- 46:39Read Winger's forced labor here.
- 46:42Trade provisions are built upon, but guess
- 46:45what?
- 46:46To use 301 authorities, which are a great tool,
- 46:51powerful as hell, you need to item, issue,
- 46:56process, case specific argumentation.
- 47:00You got to get it vetted.
- 47:02through the ITC, and then you can go to town with
- 47:06this stuff.
- 47:08You can put any kind of reciprocal tariff in
- 47:11place you want, and it is solid as steel.
- 47:15But it requires Glenn, a professional team at
- 47:20USTR, and at Commerce, and Treasury, and State,
- 47:25to build that case, get it through, vet it, and
- 47:30then apply it.
- 47:31And you got to be patient with it.
- 47:33Hell, we used these with the EU for years, and we
- 47:37eventually broke through.
- 47:38And that was with the EU partners, much less
- 47:42China.
- 47:42This administration has shown no interest
- 47:46whatsoever in building or having the patience to
- 47:50build and then execute these kinds of classic
- 47:54reciprocal tariff cases.
- 47:57None.
- 47:57And I question whether the expertise to even do
- 48:00it still exists.
- 48:01between USTR.
- 48:02Now, I have no case for the Biden administration
- 48:05on international trade whatsoever, but at least
- 48:08they were open.
- 48:09They didn't want to engage in any
- 48:11international trade negotiations because the
- 48:14putative damage to the, quote, blue collar
- 48:17factory worker, close quote, in the United
- 48:20States.
- 48:20Well, how did that work out in terms of
- 48:23electrical, electoral outcomes?
- 48:25So I'm not defending or justifying one
- 48:28administration.
- 48:29Deep problems with Biden.
- 48:31on these issues, huge problems with Trump.
- 48:34So China, what would my recommendation be?
- 48:37Don't go.
- 48:38And that's not a trite answer.
- 48:41Don't go.
- 48:42Mr.
- 48:42President, you are at a disadvantage already
- 48:47because of your mercurial flip-flops on tariffs
- 48:51when they apply to China.
- 48:54The Chinese believe they have you on the run, that
- 48:58they can convince you
- 49:01not to impose those types of tariffs, which now you
- 49:05have more and more limited, thanks to the
- 49:09courts, authority to use.
- 49:12The original uh authority, he cited, was
- 49:16struck down.
- 49:17Now the 122 authority was struck down, no surprise.
- 49:21What's he got left?
- 49:23301.
- 49:23But that takes a legal case to be built.
- 49:28That's part one.
- 49:29Don't go until you're set.
- 49:31You know exactly what your tools are and what
- 49:33you're going to get and what you threaten them
- 49:35with.
- 49:35Point two, the timing.
- 49:38The Iranians right now have you caught in this
- 49:44frustrating stalemate.
- 49:47They know, the world knows, you want to make
- 49:49your way out of this.
- 49:50The Chinese want an end to this as well.
- 49:52Believe me, they want to see this end.
- 49:55They had a 120-day stockpile of crude.
- 49:58and an unknown quantity of natural gas, but
- 50:02enough.
- 50:03But they're still now drawing down that.
- 50:05That may be half gone.
- 50:07They've brought in a lot off of floating Iranian
- 50:10shipments that were on the high seas when the
- 50:13blockade began.
- 50:14But in time, this is going to be exhausted.
- 50:17They want an end to this.
- 50:19But they think you're vulnerable, Mr.
- 50:22President.
- 50:23They think that clock
- 50:25is ticking against you.
- 50:27And their advantage is you don't need to buy
- 50:31another confrontation in the global marketplace.
- 50:35You're about ending these confrontations as quickly
- 50:39as you can.
- 50:39They will take that and they will go to town with
- 50:43it.
- 50:43So you tell them the timing's not right.
- 50:47And by the way, your pressure on Tehran to
- 50:51restore the status quo ante February 28th.
- 50:55is what really needs to be done right now.
- 50:58We get the straight reopened on that
- 51:01pre-February 28 basis, then we can talk about
- 51:04trade issues.
- 51:05Don't be in a hurry.
- 51:08That would be my advice.
- 51:09Because I want to see him succeed.
- 51:12China is a violator, huge violator, but you got to
- 51:16go after this in a prepared, careful
- 51:20fashion, not based on 3 a.m.
- 51:22in the morning.
- 51:24tweets on X.
- 51:25Great point.
- 51:26Agreed.
- 51:27So Ambassador Seifeld, speaking of tweets, the
- 51:30president has announced that the Russians and
- 51:34Ukrainians have agreed to a three day ceasefire
- 51:37over the Victory Day celebration in
- 51:40what would be the former Soviet Union.
- 51:43What is your assessment of this ceasefire?
- 51:44You think it could lead to something greater or
- 51:46you think this is a ploy by or something just
- 51:49Putin wants because he's afraid his
- 51:50Traditional nine May parade will be ruined by
- 51:54the threat of Ukrainian drones.
- 51:56uh What do you think?
- 51:59Glenn, you know this far better than I ever can,
- 52:04but Putin's already got a problem with his May 9th
- 52:08Great Patriotic War parade, and it's very
- 52:12much in the public.
- 52:14This is going to be, I guess, the smallest, most
- 52:20downscaled parade in Soviet slash Russian
- 52:25Federation history.
- 52:27I think this is a ploy.
- 52:29I don't think it's going to lead anywhere.
- 52:31It was preceded by some of the heaviest attacks
- 52:34on Ukrainian infrastructure that we've
- 52:37seen in a long while.
- 52:39And I have no doubt it will be followed by
- 52:42similar such attacks.
- 52:43Why is that?
- 52:44Again, Glenn, I'll turn to you for the answer.
- 52:47But I believe a victory as Putin defines it in
- 52:51Ukraine, which is to say a Ukraine in which there
- 52:56is no government.
- 52:58capable of moving to quote the West whether
- 53:02that's the literal West or the global West as
- 53:06Putin describes it Which is wholly subordinate a
- 53:10la Belarus to Russian Dictat Maybe an
- 53:13independent country but closer to the old Ukraine
- 53:18SSR Than what has happened after the fall
- 53:21of the Soviet Union.
- 53:23That's what he wants
- 53:25It's inherent in his narrative of power and
- 53:29authority in Russia.
- 53:31It is also part and parcel, Glenn, you and I
- 53:34have talked about this in the past, of what Yevgeny
- 53:38Primakov described to me as Putin's view of the
- 53:42world, which is he hates you all,
- 53:45north, south, east, west.
- 53:47It's not about the US.
- 53:49It's not about NATO.
- 53:50It is the world.
- 53:52The world destroyed
- 53:54his world, this mid-grade administrative KGB major,
- 53:59not a spymaster as the legend has built, forced
- 54:04him out of his station, forced him into a period
- 54:08of doing things which he
- 54:11did very cleverly and very well to ascend to
- 54:15power, but then the world in his view deliberately
- 54:19collapsed in 95 the rubble.
- 54:22and danced on the bones of the Russian
- 54:24Federation, all to humiliate Russia.
- 54:27Well, he is damned and determined.
- 54:29Russia will get its comeuppance under him.
- 54:32It's not just a narrative of power in a sort of
- 54:36transactional fashion.
- 54:38He genuinely is out for blood.
- 54:42And Ukraine is part of it as he evokes not Lenin,
- 54:46quote, the bungler, close quote.
- 54:49but Alexander the Second.
- 54:51Right.
- 54:52Yeah.
- 54:54Yeah, know, question for Putin now is how's it
- 54:58working out for him?
- 55:00How's his game of revenge working out for him?
- 55:03And I have to say, I just wrote an article about
- 55:07this, but President Trump has an opportunity now, I
- 55:10think, to really put pressure on Putin with
- 55:13the new sanctions package.
- 55:15know, Lindsey Graham has gotten it ready.
- 55:17My understanding is 80, at least 80 members of
- 55:20Congress have signed onto this.
- 55:23And the president, in my own opinion, just needs
- 55:26to move forward and stop allowing Putin to drag
- 55:29out these negotiations, these ceasefires.
- 55:32I mean, I think we all would love to see peace.
- 55:34We'd all love to see this war come to an end.
- 55:37But Putin is not going to stop fighting until he
- 55:40sees that there are serious consequences for
- 55:42him.
- 55:43The consequences are beginning to build up,
- 55:45but I think we need another
- 55:46my own assessment, pushed from the US and signed to
- 55:50the world that we're done listening to Putin's
- 55:53narrative on this.
- 55:55But you know, Glenn, I agree with you.
- 55:58I agree with every word you have said.
- 56:00But that gas station with nuclear bombs, as John
- 56:05McCain famously described ah Russia, it has just
- 56:11gotten a huge shot in the arm.
- 56:14There is one country on the face of the earth
- 56:17that has benefited, start to finish, from the
- 56:21closure of the Strait of Hormuz, and that is
- 56:24Russia.
- 56:25No more heavily discounted oil and gas.
- 56:28They're getting premium prices for it.
- 56:31This is a gift that just keeps on giving.
- 56:33Putin would like to see the strait closed
- 56:36forever, if he could, because of the gains to
- 56:39the economy.
- 56:39So right now, he has gotten a very unhelpful
- 56:43reinforcement.
- 56:44But the real question you're asking, Glenn, is
- 56:49what will Donald Trump do?
- 56:52And I cannot answer that.
- 56:54question.
- 56:55I still believe the president by his own
- 56:59wording sees Zelensky as a weakling, um a loser in
- 57:04a world he believes is divided into killers and
- 57:08victims.
- 57:09Putin's a killer.
- 57:11Zelensky is a victim.
- 57:13Why would you support another loser?
- 57:17For all the reasons you and I know, that is
- 57:20absolutely the wrong logic from a strictly US
- 57:24America first standpoint, much less America, NATO,
- 57:28the allies standpoint or a moral standpoint.
- 57:33But I don't know if his thinking has shifted on
- 57:35this.
- 57:35I really don't.
- 57:36Yeah, neither do I.
- 57:38The one thing I don't understand is how can you
- 57:41argue that Ukraine is a loser in this?
- 57:43Because if you remember, you go back to December
- 57:46when we were rushing, or US officials were telling
- 57:49Ukrainians, make a deal now because the front's
- 57:51going to collapse.
- 57:52And actually, since then, the Ukrainians have taken
- 57:55back territory.
- 57:56And the Ukrainians will tell you, they're not on
- 57:59the roll to Moscow tomorrow.
- 58:01They don't have the resources to do that, but
- 58:03they are holding the line.
- 58:04They are fighting a very, very valiant fight.
- 58:06And the president himself has said that, that they
- 58:08have been incredibly courageous and very good
- 58:11at what they're doing.
- 58:12So I, you know,
- 58:14I can't answer because all of this lies within
- 58:19one man's view of the world, of himself and
- 58:24decisions.
- 58:25But I will say this.
- 58:26I see in Ukraine and in Iran, um opposite, not
- 58:33opposite, opposite cases.
- 58:37To the president's consternation, Zelensky
- 58:41and Ukraine like
- 58:43The IRGC hardline leadership in Tehran and
- 58:47Iran itself have demonstrated agency.
- 58:51They have shown will and capacity to stand up
- 58:57despite rhetoric, despite kinetic action.
- 59:03They're challenging.
- 59:04That is something I believe the president
- 59:07finds extremely difficult to deal with.
- 59:10Glenn, can I fire a question at you and we'll
- 59:13wrap up here shortly, Ambassador.
- 59:14em And it's back uh to the May parade topic.
- 59:20There was a report in the past two days of a leaked
- 59:24GRU document suggesting that Russia was going to
- 59:28send something north of 5,000 drones, including
- 59:32FPV drones to Iran that would
- 59:34aid them in holding out today.
- 59:38Separate from that, just looking at what's going
- 59:41on in Russia with Putin really wanting this
- 59:43ceasefire, initially suggesting it would be
- 59:46unilateral, sounds like announcement that
- 59:48you just mentioned was a three-day ceasefire
- 59:50that's going to take place.
- 59:52When you're advising the Ukrainians, and I know
- 59:54this is a tactical question and it'll sound
- 59:56crass, but I think it's more illustrative of a
- 59:59broader concern, would you advise
- 1:00:00them to attack on that day from a propaganda
- 1:00:03standpoint, or is that entirely
- 1:00:05counterproductive?
- 1:00:06to what they should or could be doing.
- 1:00:08Well, to be clear, I wouldn't advise the
- 1:00:10Ukrainians because I think that they're much
- 1:00:11smarter than I am.
- 1:00:12That's what I've seen.
- 1:00:13think they don't need a lot of advice from
- 1:00:15Americans.
- 1:00:16think, you know, I, I, now, if you ask me if
- 1:00:19that would be a good idea now, no, because it would
- 1:00:22look bad for them.
- 1:00:24And, know, Putin is going to sell this.
- 1:00:26The Russians are going to sell this is that, you
- 1:00:29know, Putin and Trump had an agreement for a
- 1:00:32ceasefire.
- 1:00:33Putin's being, you know, a good guy by saying, I
- 1:00:36want to ceasefire.
- 1:00:38course, he gets he wins more in this the
- 1:00:40Ukrainians are going to have, you know, they have
- 1:00:43a different view of uh May Day, sorry, of uh the
- 1:00:46Victory Day parade.
- 1:00:48Even though many Ukrainians died fighting.
- 1:00:51They have a whole different uh view of
- 1:00:54this.
- 1:00:54And you know, for the Russians, it's it's a
- 1:00:56big, big celebration.
- 1:00:57And as Ambassador Satterfield said, this is
- 1:00:59going to be the smallest one they've ever had.
- 1:01:01There's a lot of security, they're very
- 1:01:03afraid they're not going to deploy a lot of the
- 1:01:06traditional equipment that they
- 1:01:08deploy for those parades.
- 1:01:11so, I think Putin is also upset because a lot of
- 1:01:14they've invited, they invite a lot of foreign
- 1:01:17dignitaries and many will probably not go now
- 1:01:19because they're concerned that there
- 1:01:21will be disruption.
- 1:01:22So it doesn't look good for Putin, right?
- 1:01:25He's trying to make the best of this propaganda
- 1:01:28wise information space wise, they'll try and
- 1:01:31claim that he is doing this because he's a good
- 1:01:34guy.
- 1:01:34And, and, you know, he's maybe president Trump.
- 1:01:38agrees that he's a good guy.
- 1:01:41you know, Zelensky said, and the Ukrainians said a
- 1:01:43couple, a couple of days ago, okay, let's just, if
- 1:01:46you want to ceasefire, let's do a ceasefire, but
- 1:01:48not one day.
- 1:01:49Right.
- 1:01:49So now again, the Ukrainians, they're,
- 1:01:52they're pretty smart.
- 1:01:54They know what they're doing.
- 1:01:55Uh, what concerns me is that the Russians could
- 1:01:59very well stage something during that parade, which
- 1:02:02would include killing you, killing Russians.
- 1:02:06They've done that before.
- 1:02:07at their own hand and then use that to try and
- 1:02:10blacken, know, or undermine our
- 1:02:12relationship with the Ukrainians, blacken the
- 1:02:15image of Kiev.
- 1:02:16And I'm sure the Ukrainians are well aware
- 1:02:19of that too.
- 1:02:19And I hope it doesn't happen, but there have
- 1:02:22been cases in Russian history where the regime
- 1:02:26itself will use a provocation, which
- 1:02:28results in the death of a lot of justify some
- 1:02:31other action.
- 1:02:33Ryan, I will just add to this from my
- 1:02:36understanding of the military picture in Iran.
- 1:02:40Iran doesn't need 5,000 Russian drones.
- 1:02:44Russia needs drones from Iran, and Iran has got
- 1:02:52them.
- 1:02:52I don't see the supply line going in the
- 1:02:55opposite direction.
- 1:02:55Ambassador, this has been fantastic.
- 1:02:58I've learned a ton here.
- 1:02:59Is there anything that you think people should
- 1:03:02be talking about or thinking about more that
- 1:03:05might get crowded out with everything going on
- 1:03:07in the front pages?
- 1:03:09Great question.
- 1:03:10the real issue here is not Iran or Gaza or
- 1:03:15Lebanon, it is, or China.
- 1:03:18It's how do you conduct national security policy
- 1:03:23in defense of fundamental U.S.
- 1:03:26interests?
- 1:03:27And we all start from that same point.
- 1:03:29Absolutely.
- 1:03:30Fundamental U.S.
- 1:03:31interests.
- 1:03:31They are first and foremost.
- 1:03:34Don't need to be told that by any particular
- 1:03:36administration.
- 1:03:37How do you best advance them or mitigate harm?
- 1:03:41Because sometimes that's the best you can do.
- 1:03:45You cannot move the needle into the green
- 1:03:47very far, but you can keep it from going
- 1:03:50further into the red.
- 1:03:52Look, for 35 years, after, well, 45 years,
- 1:03:55after the end of the Second World War, that's
- 1:03:59where we were.
- 1:04:00Containment strategy.
- 1:04:01And it worked.
- 1:04:02Patience, strategic patience, but you apply
- 1:04:06force.
- 1:04:06and you apply diplomacy where you see
- 1:04:08opportunities.
- 1:04:09But you've got to be consistent.
- 1:04:11You must be strategic.
- 1:04:13You must be prepared to acknowledge the enemy
- 1:04:17gets a vote.
- 1:04:18Sometimes that vote doesn't mean very much,
- 1:04:21Venezuela.
- 1:04:22Sometimes it means a heck of a lot, Iran.
- 1:04:26And you base your policy and the conduct of that
- 1:04:30policy on a constant self-correcting manner
- 1:04:33based upon a professional team willing
- 1:04:36always to speak truth to themselves and to power.
- 1:04:41Amen.
- 1:04:43Yeah, amen.
- 1:04:44have a just a very personal selfish question
- 1:04:47of all the rooms you've been an ambassador 45
- 1:04:50years.
- 1:04:51You've probably run up against some amazing,
- 1:04:54interesting people, some surreal events.
- 1:04:58Who's the most interesting person that
- 1:05:01comes back to mind for you?
- 1:05:03um It's actually a mix of two people.
- 1:05:09It's Yitzhak Rabin, because he was the most
- 1:05:13extraordinarily self-examined individual
- 1:05:17I believe I have ever met.
- 1:05:20This is Mr.
- 1:05:21Security, the man who established more
- 1:05:23settlements than any prime minister of Israel
- 1:05:26until this most recent Netanyahu government.
- 1:05:29uh
- 1:05:31A man who fought tooth and nail against Yasser
- 1:05:34Arafat and the PLA.
- 1:05:35Who told us, told President Clinton, the
- 1:05:38rest of us in the Oval, September 13th, 93, the
- 1:05:42famous handshake on the South Lawn with Arafat.
- 1:05:47I will not shake hands with the murderer of that
- 1:05:50Israeli baby.
- 1:05:52This is a man who told us, I'm not happy.
- 1:05:57I'm not at ease or comfort with myself.
- 1:06:00for what I am doing, but I can see no other way of
- 1:06:05mitigating harm to Israel over the time ahead.
- 1:06:10If there were a better way, I would choose it.
- 1:06:13This wasn't my process.
- 1:06:14This was Shimon Peres' process.
- 1:06:17Rabin was focused on Syria.
- 1:06:19So were we.
- 1:06:20But he could not find.
- 1:06:23Now, he tore himself to pieces.
- 1:06:26Wow.
- 1:06:27But the fact that despite all of this inner
- 1:06:31torment, he not only could do the handshake—
- 1:06:34Bill Clinton had a powerful role in that—
- 1:06:38but sustained for two years that process, which
- 1:06:42fell apart the moment he was assassinated.
- 1:06:44That was extraordinary.
- 1:06:46I have rarely seen individuals with that
- 1:06:49kind of vision and conduct.
- 1:06:50The other guy for whom I have enormous regard is
- 1:06:55Jim Baker.
- 1:06:57Jim Baker, my boss in a number of different
- 1:07:00capacities, my fishing pal.
- 1:07:02Jim Baker combined pragmatism with
- 1:07:06principle, practicality in policy formation and
- 1:07:12execution with values.
- 1:07:15And I think it's that unique combination plus
- 1:07:19simple personality, not because he was a wonk on
- 1:07:23every minutia of a negotiation.
- 1:07:25Of course, he was when he had to enter a room, but
- 1:07:28he was knowing how to conduct.
- 1:07:30a negotiation, or as he puts it, when to sit down
- 1:07:34and when to close your briefcase and get up.
- 1:07:37Both are critical and the highest integrity
- 1:07:41possible.
- 1:07:42So Jim Baker is a personal hero to me.
- 1:07:46I think he is one of the greatest public servants
- 1:07:51ever post-World War II to serve, but he would tell
- 1:07:56you, don't look at me
- 1:07:58Jim Baker is the reason for that.
- 1:07:59Look at Brent Scowcroft.
- 1:08:02Look at Bush 41.
- 1:08:04Without Bush 41, neither Brent nor I could have
- 1:08:08done what we did.
- 1:08:09George Shultz, the Treasury.
- 1:08:12Everybody worked together.
- 1:08:15Extraordinarily talented people.
- 1:08:18George Bush 41 had skill sets, knowledge,
- 1:08:21understanding that exceeded that of, I
- 1:08:24think, any president.
- 1:08:26in modern history.
- 1:08:27He knew the world and he knew the United States.
- 1:08:30He knew business.
- 1:08:31That's a rare combination.
- 1:08:33When we can see, Ryan, I think we have to say that
- 1:08:35Ambassador Satterfield, you are now the head of
- 1:08:37the Baker Center, correct?
- 1:08:39I am the director of the Rice University Baker
- 1:08:42Center for Public Policy and have been since I
- 1:08:46left Ankara in 2022.
- 1:08:48It is a great job because I get to work not with
- 1:08:51academics, but with experts in their field.
- 1:08:54And those fields go from U.S.-Mexican relations to
- 1:08:58tax policy to demographics in the
- 1:09:01United States and the implication on everything
- 1:09:04from flood control to civil
- 1:09:06infrastructure.
- 1:09:07where you build highways and where you don't, to
- 1:09:10classic Middle East issues.
- 1:09:12And of course, energy, energy, and more energy.
- 1:09:15We are in Houston, the energy capital of the
- 1:09:19world.
- 1:09:19That's a trademarked phrase.
- 1:09:21Glym, why don't you round us out here?
- 1:09:23Yeah, I that I just say that, you know, Jim
- 1:09:25Baker, you said is the great, great public
- 1:09:28servant you were as well.
- 1:09:29You've done so much for this country and many,
- 1:09:32many hard jobs.
- 1:09:33You've I've seen it, the dedication, the
- 1:09:35commitment to mission.
- 1:09:37So the Americans that are following this should
- 1:09:41just know how much you left on the on the
- 1:09:44battlefield for them.
- 1:09:46And your diplomacy was amazing.
- 1:09:47You're just like this podcast, like
- 1:09:50I learned something from you every day when we
- 1:09:53work together and it's an honor to know you and
- 1:09:55thank you for taking the time with us today.
- 1:09:58And Ryan, it's an honor to know you too.
- 1:10:01Brian, thank you.
- 1:10:02Glenn, thank you as always.
- 1:10:05Wishing you guys a great weekend.
- 1:10:07The same.