Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Legal Fixtures and Your Home Purchase
Transcript
- 0:00Rob Buffam: And we're going to be talking now and hearing some sage advice from one, mike Mulligan barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 0:07Rob Buffam: Mike, welcome to the program.
- 0:08Rob Buffam: Hey, thanks so much.
- 0:10Rob Buffam: It's always great to be here, yeah, and great to chat with you.
- 0:12Rob Buffam: It's been a little while since I've had the chance to do that.
- 0:15Rob Buffam: You've got a bunch of issues you've been digging into to talk to our listeners about.
- 0:20Rob Buffam: Today, one of the things I think that you'd highlighted was this idea of fixtures what today?
- 0:24Rob Buffam: One of the things I think that you'd highlighted was this idea of fixtures what are so-called fixtures and what comes with a house when you buy it?
- 0:28Rob Buffam: This is the kind of time of year when people are looking at selling or buying their house or homes.
- 0:32Rob Buffam: Rather so they might well be interested in what comes with the house when you look at it and you see something that you're not sure if that actually is included with the purchase of the house, but you really like it.
- 0:41Rob Buffam: What can you tell us about this?
- 0:49Michael Mulligan: Sure, I think it's a good cautionary tale for people to be aware of when they're doing exactly that buying or selling.
- 0:53Michael Mulligan: And this was a case that wound up in court, I guess, as all my tales of woe do.
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: And it was a case involving a contract to buy and sell a home and ultimately there was a back and forth exchange of contracts and offers and so on that were finally agreed upon and, as is commonly the case, the contract to buy and sell the house indicated that fixtures would be included with the house.
- 1:20Michael Mulligan: So the first question is what's a fixture?
- 1:21Michael Mulligan: And then the specific contract in this case specified something.
- 1:26Michael Mulligan: So that's not uncommon, you know.
- 1:28Michael Mulligan: If somebody goes through a house and says, gee, I really love that, you know chair or something, you could write that into the contract.
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: And here, in addition to specifying that fixtures would be included with the house, it specified that a conversation sets on the patios would be included.
- 1:46Michael Mulligan: Well, you can just imagine what happened the purchasers showed up and they took possession of it and a few things that they had expected to be present were gone.
- 1:56Michael Mulligan: And it wasn't controversial that they were taken.
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: The issue was whether they should have remained or not, and that's how the case wound up in court.
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: The first item in question was what was described variously as a dresser in a bedroom, but was also referred to by different people as perhaps it was a cabinet or maybe a vanity, somebody else called it a desk, any case a big wooden thing, and the issue arose because it was present when the purchasers walked through the house and when they took possession of the house, that item the judge referred to as the dresser was gone and behind it there were a couple of holes in the wall.
- 2:35Michael Mulligan: And the significance of the holes in the wall is because what the definition of a fixture is.
- 2:42Michael Mulligan: And so there was nothing in the contract that specified whether you got this dresser or not.
- 2:46Michael Mulligan: But the contract did specify you got the fixtures.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: And so there's been a long history of litigation over what is a fixture, because, you know, human affairs are endlessly variable.
- 2:58Michael Mulligan: But one of the starting points for determining whether a particular thing in a home is a fixture is to determine whether it's attached to the property in some way.
- 3:10Rob Buffam: That's one of the definitions.
- 3:11Rob Buffam: Result of damage.
- 3:12Michael Mulligan: Okay, interesting that's one of the criteria Okay yeah, so you start with.
- 3:16Michael Mulligan: If the thing's attached to the property by something other than its own weight, one of the first things to be looked at is can you remove it without damaging the property?
- 3:25Michael Mulligan: And that's important, because some things might be attached to the property, like, let's say, your television set.
- 3:30Michael Mulligan: If it's just sitting on the floor and plugged in.
- 3:32Michael Mulligan: If you could just unplug it without causing any damage, it presumptively won't be a fixture, right?
- 3:39Michael Mulligan: But what do you do with the in this case, where there are holes?
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: And the purchaser's theory of it was well, the dresser thing was quite large, and so they concluded it must have been affixed to the wall.
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: And sometimes you'll see that, right.
- 3:53Michael Mulligan: You know, if you buy a piece of furniture, there'll be something saying well, you'll bolt this to the wall.
- 3:57Michael Mulligan: In case of earthquakes, Screw it in.
- 3:59Michael Mulligan: And if you do screw it in, you may turn that thing into, in fact, a fixture.
- 4:04Rob Buffam: Can I stop you there for a second?
- 4:05Rob Buffam: That's what they were arguing, okay, well, that's interesting because I'm thinking of our own den, where we've got some Ikea bookshelves that I think we've probably attached so that the top of them doesn't extend out a bit more than the bottom.
- 4:22Rob Buffam: I guess it would depend on judgment on this, but are we setting ourselves up to be selling those bookshelves with our house if we ever sell it and we've attached them in some even modest way to the room?
- 4:33Michael Mulligan: Yes, that's a common term, right, it's sort of these contracts will often use that term fixtures.
- 4:39Michael Mulligan: And so if you've done what IKEA recommended and screwed the top of the bookshelf in so it doesn't topple over on you in the event of an earthquake, presumptively you've turned that into a fixture.
- 4:50Michael Mulligan: And so if you don't want that going with the house and you sell it, you should specify that in the contract, not including the bookshelves in the den, for example.
- 5:00Michael Mulligan: If you don't, the starting point is going to be those are a fixture.
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: And that's what was claimed here.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: That, exactly that.
- 5:06Michael Mulligan: Now the challenge for the plaintiff buyer was that the seller defendant also testified.
- 5:13Michael Mulligan: They agreed they took the dresser with them, but their evidence was that, no, the holes in the wall weren't caused by that dresser being screwed into it, despite the fact that it was tall.
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: Their evidence was that was caused by a shelf that used to be there and the dresser was put there to stage the home and hide the holes.
- 5:29Michael Mulligan: And the trouble is that in a case where you're suing somebody, the person doing the suing making the claim, they're the one who has the burden of proof.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: Now, in a civil case, you only have to prove it on the basis of probability right, not like a criminal case where it's got to be beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: But the judge accepted what the defendant had to say and there was no really contrary evidence from the buyers.
- 5:54Michael Mulligan: They hadn't looked back there or seen the back of the dresser, and so on that basis the dresser wasn't a fixture and so their claim for they were trying to get $7,430 for this thing, that was dismissed.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: And the judge that had to move on to this issue of the and this was written in specifically in the contract written in was that the purchasers would get the conversation sets.
- 6:17Michael Mulligan: And here's what happened with those.
- 6:19Michael Mulligan: When they looked at the home, in the front there was a table with four chairs around it and in the back there was a big wicker item of some kind that could seat capable of seating nine people was the description.
- 6:30Michael Mulligan: The problem for the plaintiffs here was what is a conversation set, and so the judge was struggling with that and obviously there are inquiries made, including looking online by, I guess, one of the parties about like what is a conversation set?
- 6:46Michael Mulligan: And the sellers left behind a table and two of the four chairs in the front, but not the other two chairs.
- 6:52Michael Mulligan: So Is that enough for a conversation?
- 6:54Michael Mulligan: Two people?
- 6:55Michael Mulligan: What about this wicker thing?
- 6:57Michael Mulligan: Is that a conversation?
- 6:58Rob Buffam: An intimate conversation.
- 6:59Rob Buffam: So it's not a term of art then it's not a legal term of art a conversation set.
- 7:03Rob Buffam: This was just a phrase that had been inserted into the contract.
- 7:08Michael Mulligan: Yeah, one of the real estate agents had written in that term, conversation sets, and so the judge was struggling with well, what do you make of that?
- 7:16Michael Mulligan: And like one of the principles that the judge was struggling with.
- 7:17Michael Mulligan: Well, what do you make of that?
- 7:18Michael Mulligan: And like, one of the principles that the judge at least considered was this there's a concept called contra preferendum, and the concept there is if one party drafts the contract and the contract is ambiguous, it can be interpreted in favor of the other party.
- 7:32Michael Mulligan: But that wasn't really the case here, because if there wasn't an unequal power relationship, there were two real estate agents who drafted these things, and so the judge didn't use that to try to settle it, but ultimately concluded that just that term conversation set was vague, and the judge couldn't determine whether this big wicker thing in the back, which was described by some people as a sectional furniture, constituted a quote conversation set.
- 7:57Michael Mulligan: Was a sectional furniture constituted a quote conversation set?
- 8:01Michael Mulligan: But the judge was prepared to go as far as to say that the table with four chairs around it did meet the definition of a conversation set, which then led to the question of well, they got two of the chairs and the table.
- 8:11Michael Mulligan: What are your damages, and the plaintiffs had tried to.
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: They found, I guess online from Home Depot or someplace, what was described as a luxury five-piece patio furniture set, and so they were trying to get $1,117.76 for the missing two chairs.
- 8:29Michael Mulligan: That didn't fly.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: The judge found it's just not appropriate damages here, and so ultimately they were awarded $100 for the two chairs from the conversation set at the front.
- 8:41Michael Mulligan: The other thing which, interestingly, was dismissed and this is something people should know about is that the sellers they had set a counterclaim when they got sued for the conversation set and the dresser, and they had made a counterclaim asking for things like 23 and a half hours of their own time for $100 an hour and stress, not enjoying a weekend away for $1,000 and losing a day of work for another $1,000.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: Now, you can't get any of those things anywhere, frankly, but you're certainly not getting them in small claims court, and so all of those things were dismissed.
- 9:16Michael Mulligan: You can't bill for your time or for not enjoying your weekend as a result of being sued, and so the successful buyer, for all of their effort in going to court, wound up with $100, and they wound up with a small amount of money like the filing fees you pay when you go to a small claims court and so at the end of the day, no doubt if their time was worth anything, this entire exercise in litigation was not worthwhile.
- 9:38Michael Mulligan: But what is worthwhile if either you're buying or selling a home and you're particularly keen on the big wicker thing in the backyard or you want to make sure you get what might be a dresser it might be a vanity or could be a desk in the other room?
- 9:51Michael Mulligan: Carefully describe it in the contract and you will avoid spending a day or more in provincial court trying to litigate whether something is a conversation set, whether you get the wicker and whether the bookshelf was screwed into the wall.
- 10:05Michael Mulligan: So I guess the takeaway is be clear.
- 10:07Michael Mulligan: But the starting point of whether something's a fixture and usually fixtures are going to go with the house the starting point is going to be is it attached in some way that you're going to cause damage getting it out, as opposed to just like unplugging the toaster and taking that away, even though I guess in some theoretical way the toaster is attached to the wall.
- 10:25Michael Mulligan: It's just attached in a way you could unplug it without doing any damage.
- 10:28Michael Mulligan: So that's what a fixture is and that's why you should be careful and specific so you don't wind up spending your time in provincial court for $100.
- 10:36Rob Buffam: Interesting and this group that are a family that purchased the house ended up with a hole in the wall as well.
- 10:41Rob Buffam: They didn't anticipate.
- 10:42Rob Buffam: I wonder, if you can, just before we go to commercial I mean, I guess it would depend on each case, but you you know.
- 10:48Rob Buffam: Should you be vigilant about asking what's behind that dress?
- 10:51Rob Buffam: Or is there a hole?
- 10:53Michael Mulligan: Well, that's interesting too.
- 10:54Michael Mulligan: What's often done and this contract did this is often contracts for purchase and sale will specify that the property would be in the condition that it was viewed when the person went in and viewed it.
- 11:04Michael Mulligan: Right about, you know, it's going to be in the condition.
- 11:17Michael Mulligan: I saw it when I came through the open house or came and viewed it with my real estate agent and somebody the seller punches a hole in the wall, you know, while getting their bookcase out of the house or something.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: That's something that the seller is going to be responsible for.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: But here there's no disagreement.
- 11:30Michael Mulligan: There definitely was a hole in the wall, but the evidence from the seller was that, yeah, that was there already and the plaintiff, I guess, didn't look by or didn't look behind the bookcase.
- 11:40Michael Mulligan: So no compensation for the hole.
- 11:42Rob Buffam: Interesting.
- 11:42Rob Buffam: But just before I let you go I wonder is there a reasonableness threshold there that you know?
- 11:52Rob Buffam: You reasonably ought to have known there was a hole in the wall, or is that?
- 11:54Rob Buffam: Are we getting too far into?
- 11:55Rob Buffam: You know a negligence standard.
- 11:56Rob Buffam: You know a negligence standard.
- 11:57Rob Buffam: I mean, it does seem.
- 11:57Rob Buffam: In some sense it seems a little bit unfair to have somebody assume that there is a hole in the wall behind a bookcase or something like that.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: Sure, yeah, there, probably there would be a reasonable consideration.
- 12:07Michael Mulligan: And this wasn't some gaping hole in the wall that you can see through the next room.
- 12:11Michael Mulligan: What it sounded like from the judgment was a couple of screw holes, like somebody had screwed something into the wall.
- 12:16Michael Mulligan: In this case it was a screwed-in shelf on the evidence of the seller, rather than the earthquake-preventing strap from the then-missing dresser.
- 12:24Michael Mulligan: And so, yeah, there is going to be always an element of reasonableness.
- 12:29Michael Mulligan: And the other thing about that is that sometimes, of course, in a contract to buy and sell a house, you'll have a clause which would involve a home inspection.
- 12:39Michael Mulligan: Those are interesting things in their own right, because usually the home inspectors usually say their only liability are for things that they could reasonably see walking through it, and so the really tough cases get into things.
- 12:51Michael Mulligan: Like you know, should you have noticed the hole behind the wallpaper or the, you know, the mirror that was left hanging in the hallway, that sort of thing?
- 13:00Michael Mulligan: But here it wasn't a gaping chasm, it sounds like it was a couple of screw holes that they assumed was used to hold the missing dresser up.
- 13:09Rob Buffam: Interesting.
- 13:10Rob Buffam: We've got to take a quick break.
- 13:11Rob Buffam: We're speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defenselers.
- 13:13Rob Buffam: When we come back, we're going to hear about a case involving sexual assault, damages and bankruptcy.
- 13:18Rob Buffam: We will be right back.
- 13:20Rob Buffam: Welcome back to the program.
- 13:21Rob Buffam: I'm Rob Buffum filling in today for Adam Sterling.
- 13:24Rob Buffam: Our guest at the moment is Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 13:28Rob Buffam: Welcome back, Mike.
- 13:29Rob Buffam: Hey, always good to be back.
- 13:32Rob Buffam: Sorry I interrupted you, but there's a case coming up that sounds like it's quite interesting that you were going to tell our listeners about.
- 13:42Michael Mulligan: Yes, it's a case that troublingly involves a former lawyer, now disbarred, who was charged criminally and in fact convicted, of sexually assaulting a woman in his office when she came to hire him.
- 13:57Michael Mulligan: And obviously there's something seriously wrong with this person.
- 14:01Michael Mulligan: He apparently was wearing socks and disheveled and came around his desk, sat by the woman and put his head on her chest and then rubbed her leg that was the nature of the sexual assault while she was in a vulnerable state trying to hire him.
- 14:15Michael Mulligan: He was convicted and disbarred over that but then most recently sued for damages resulting from that.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: That experience had a long-term negative effect on the person who he did that to and one of the interesting elements to it is that the civil case got to the point of discussing what the damages should be for that activity and the the plaintiff made counsel for.
- 14:48Michael Mulligan: The plaintiff, made submissions about various heads of damages and suggested an amount of $270,000.
- 14:54Michael Mulligan: And the former lawyer indicated that he had already gone bankrupt, that he was dealing with health issues, including a cancer diagnosis, and that he had no submissions to make in terms of the amount because the plaintiff would not even get a dollar because another $270,000 award would make no difference since he would just declare bankruptcy again.
- 15:18Michael Mulligan: Now here's.
- 15:20Michael Mulligan: The judge quite properly said well, you're not really making any submissions about how much the award should be, so I guess it's going to be $270,000 and awarded that.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: And first of all going to be $270,000 and awarded that, and first of all, that's appropriate.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: The ability to pay a judgment is not a consideration in determining what the judgment should be right.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: If you sue somebody successfully and the judge determines what the appropriate award would be to put you back in the position you would have been in, but for what happened, ability to pay is not a consideration, but you do that, have to go about getting the money.
- 15:53Michael Mulligan: And so what's to be made about this fellow's claim that he would just declare bankruptcy again?
- 15:59Michael Mulligan: Well, what people should know about is that you can, of course you can declare bankruptcy.
- 16:05Michael Mulligan: It's not like Michael from the Office where you just stand up and yell and I declare bankruptcy before that's required, but you could in fact declare bankruptcy more than once.
- 16:21Michael Mulligan: The trouble, and the reason why that submission that he made demonstrates a lack of understanding about how the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act works is that, while you can declare bankruptcy, various kinds of debts are not what's called discharged as a result of bankruptcy, and there's a whole list of things.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: You can look them up in Section 178 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act for those playing at home, and there's a whole list of things including things like fines and penalties imposed by a court.
- 16:45Michael Mulligan: That kind of makes sense, right?
- 16:47Michael Mulligan: Otherwise you could just be fined for something and declare bankruptcy and not have to pay it, right?
- 16:50Michael Mulligan: Otherwise you could just be fined for something and declare bankruptcy and not have to pay it.
- 16:54Michael Mulligan: But other things listed include awards made for intentional torts or things like sexual assault.
- 16:59Michael Mulligan: Also things like alimony payments, debts as a result of fraud or embezzlement various things of that are excluded from discharge, and so even if you go through the bankruptcy process, you still owe that money.
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: And so if if you go through the bankruptcy process, you still owe that money, and so if you think you could avoid paying the sexual assault judgment or the debt for your fine, or the money you got by embezzling it from somebody.
- 17:22Michael Mulligan: You're going to be very unhappy at the end of your bankruptcy process when you're told that you no longer have to pay your Canadian Tire credit card debt but you're still on the hook for the $270,000.
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: Thanks, so much Now, with that being said, and so that was just completely mistaken.
- 17:40Michael Mulligan: This is a lawyer himself who made that error in understanding and even more ironically, on the criminal trial for the same conduct.
- 17:49Michael Mulligan: He was convicted and then he appealed it on the basis that he had inadequate, poor representation by his lawyer at the first trial.
- 17:56Michael Mulligan: That went absolutely nowhere.
- 17:58Michael Mulligan: Pointing out in part he was a lawyer, but I suppose that has some additional resonance given his misleading or misinformed submission to the judge about the damages award here.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: Now, all that being said, it's not smooth sailing for the successful plaintiff here.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: Bankruptcy won't help at all.
- 18:15Michael Mulligan: But the fact that this person has already gone bankrupt virtually by definition means he won't have any assets.
- 18:23Michael Mulligan: And if he's got cancer and no assets, whether a second bankruptcy would do anything about the $270,000 judgment may be neither here nor there, because when you're a judgment creditor you can do various things to try to collect on that, but that's up to you.
- 18:39Michael Mulligan: You could do things like getting an application of the person's property sold or have their car sold or garnish money from their bank account.
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: But if they have no car, no home and no money and no job his fellow's been disbarred.
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: You're probably going to have a pretty tough time collecting your $270,000.
- 18:59Rob Buffam: Interesting.
- 19:00Rob Buffam: If somebody is considering the impact of somebody not having much financial means, I guess that would be a factor to weigh in and something you might get advice on if you're contemplating bringing a court action or a lawsuit against somebody who may declare bankruptcy.
- 19:15Rob Buffam: But it would not be a factor involved in the judgment of what any damages would be if you succeed in your lawsuit.
- 19:23Michael Mulligan: That's absolutely the case.
- 19:24Michael Mulligan: When somebody's making a decision about whether you want to pursue litigation, that can be expensive and time-consuming.
- 19:30Michael Mulligan: One of the things to remember is that in a civil case, really at the end of the day, the only thing you may walk away with that from if you succeed is an order that the person pay you money, and if they have no money, there's going to be nothing to collect from.
- 19:45Michael Mulligan: Now, the other side of it, I guess in that consideration and people should know this too is when you have, like in this case, a criminal conviction for what amounts to the same conduct, that you're suing somebody for, that part is not going to be controversial, right, because in the criminal context, the sexual assault he he was convicted, that was upheld on appeal and for that it would be required to be proven beyond all reasonable doubt and that was established at the criminal trial.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: And when that happens, if there's then a civil claim made for what amounts to the same conduct and sexual assault is one of those things that has both a criminal and civil element to it you're not going to have any issue at all proving that that occurred.
- 20:31Michael Mulligan: You're going to basically move right on to.
- 20:33Michael Mulligan: Well, okay, what are the appropriate damages for that, and that's what happened here and that's the context in which that exchange occurred.
- 20:41Michael Mulligan: Now also remember, of course and people will remember this from OJ Simpson, you know, even if you're acquitted criminally of something, you could be successfully sued for the very same conduct.
- 20:53Michael Mulligan: Right, because there's a lower standard of proof in the criminal in the civil case.
- 20:56Michael Mulligan: Right, the fact that the glove doesn't fit doesn't mean that you couldn't persuade a judge or a jury that you probably committed the murder or probably committed the sexual assault.
- 21:05Michael Mulligan: And so this is the opposite of that, where, if there's a criminal conviction, at least there isn't going to be any issue of proof that the tort occurred.
- 21:14Michael Mulligan: It's just going to be on to what are the appropriate damages for that?
- 21:17Michael Mulligan: And now I suppose for this person, whether she will be able to collect the $270,000 from the now disbarred, convicted and bankrupt former lawyer Interesting.
- 21:27Rob Buffam: Well, there's different standards of proof.
- 21:29Rob Buffam: Well, thank you very much, Michael.
- 21:30Rob Buffam: We've been speaking with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 21:34Rob Buffam: Thank you so much.
- 21:35Michael Mulligan: It's always great to be here.