Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / Gifted and Talented?
Transcript
- 0:01The sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:09Hello and welcome to my Sister's a Therapist.
- 0:11My name is Virginia Jones. I'm a stand up comedian but my
- 0:13sister's a therapist. Hello, I'm Laura Ryan.
- 0:16My first credit is to be Virginia Jones's sister.
- 0:19Second credit. Licensed marriage and family
- 0:21therapist. You've been a therapist for a
- 0:23long time, but you've been my sister for even longer.
- 0:26So recently, as sometimes happens in a family, we compared
- 0:30notes on a memory that I had a totally different recollection
- 0:33of. And you mentioned that it was
- 0:35about me and Robbie being in talented and gifted.
- 0:38And I've been reflecting on that.
- 0:40I've had conversations with other people from that program,
- 0:44and so today's topic is basically talented and gifted.
- 0:47Is it a benefit? Is it good for kids?
- 0:50Is it good for parents? Is it good for anything?
- 0:52Gifted and talented? Is it just a bunch of kids with
- 0:54ADHD in US? See, that's the question.
- 0:57So first of all, like I'm assuming that most of our
- 0:59listeners, maybe some of our international listeners are not
- 1:02aware in the States, usually a teacher will say, hey, I think
- 1:06we might maybe have one and then they send them for testing.
- 1:09Sometimes parents will pressure a teacher to send their kid for
- 1:12testing. These days you just get a letter
- 1:15and say would you like to have your kid put in it?
- 1:17And then we'll test them. I see.
- 1:19And then when you are in the TAG program or the GAP program, you
- 1:23spend at least part of your day sequestered from the rest of the
- 1:26school doing different activities.
- 1:28In Round Rock, TX, when I was in the program, we were in a
- 1:31portable classroom, which is a fancy word for trailer.
- 1:34So they put all the kids in, the smart kids in the trailer.
- 1:37We didn't really interact with the other kids.
- 1:40We got very tight with each other.
- 1:41And then they taught us chess and they taught us math puzzles.
- 1:43But I'm not certain if it helped me academically or not.
- 1:47Your kid is smart. We know your kid is smart.
- 1:50What would it say about you or your kid for him to be in
- 1:54talented and gifted? Well he is in talented and
- 1:56gifted. I just wanted him to try it
- 1:58because I thought well he's a genius right?
- 2:01The story that I make up about what GNT is, is that it's a time
- 2:05for him to get out of the day-to-day grind of school and
- 2:09be around kids who are like him AKA kids with ADHD and maybe
- 2:13learn. The world is not about training
- 2:16to work in a factory, so. He's not in that classroom all
- 2:19day. No, they take him out I think
- 2:20once a week. So some benefits of these
- 2:23programs, they can challenge high ability kids, they can
- 2:27provide. I had accelerated and enrichment
- 2:29programs to help students in school improve self esteem.
- 2:32And definitely when I was in the program that was something that
- 2:35I identified with and thought was very important about myself.
- 2:38But here's one reduced behavioral problems.
- 2:42Engaged students are less likely to develop behavioral problems.
- 2:45And I saw a tic tac with a lady saying hey these programs were
- 2:49not to help us, they were for the teachers to get us the F out
- 2:54of their classrooms because we were disruptive and we were
- 2:57annoying. Yeah, we had too many questions.
- 3:01Yeah, too many questions. Like I had my arm posted in the
- 3:04air at all times at the same time, wouldn't turn in
- 3:08assignments. Well, that's the thing that's so
- 3:09irritating about Let's just take a quick moment to complain about
- 3:13my child. And he knows everything.
- 3:16And he tells me school is so boring, but yet at the end of
- 3:19the year he hasn't turned in 16 assignments.
- 3:22That's a good amount. Hey, guess what?
- 3:24Why don't here's a way to relieve boredom?
- 3:26Why don't you do some of your work right?
- 3:28That could really keep you busy. So some issues with talented
- 3:31gifted programs can be like a student, especially young
- 3:34students like as they start them as early as kindergarten now, a
- 3:37young student can feel overwhelmed, they start feeling
- 3:39inadequate. And most importantly, it's not a
- 3:43level playing field that favors students who have an enriched
- 3:46environment at home, whose parents have a lot of time to
- 3:48read to them, Whose? Parents would pay Caucasian.
- 3:51Rich, white and Asian kids. In 2021, Mayor Bill de Blasio
- 3:56announced that New York City was going to phase out all gifted
- 3:59and talented programs, and he called it desegregation.
- 4:02The main points are the selection processes flawed.
- 4:05In New York in particular, there's a test and wealthy
- 4:08families will pay their kids to get tutored to take the test.
- 4:12And then that test will say, oh, this is a talented gifted kid.
- 4:15But like, what does that mean? Right?
- 4:18If you're a wealthy family and you pay your kid to study for
- 4:22this test, that then tells you the thing that you want to think
- 4:26about your kid anyway, which is that they're extra smart.
- 4:28That's just a self fulfilling prophecy like the monarchy
- 4:31saying well we are super people chosen by God.
- 4:36You can tell we are because we're the monarchy.
- 4:38Just talking about statistics here.
- 4:39It feels obvious that white and Asian kids have preference in
- 4:43TAG programs. But I think what what led de
- 4:46Blasio to this decision was 70% of public school students in New
- 4:51York are black and Latino, but 75% of students in gifted
- 4:56elementary school classes are white or Asian.
- 4:58There's something in the milk ain't clean there.
- 5:01Right. Another question is schools are
- 5:03starting to test kids in kindergarten when the
- 5:06conventional wisdom is the real time to test is between 6:00 and
- 5:109:00. Kindergartners are too similar
- 5:12to one another. They don't have the resources to
- 5:15determine whether they're advanced or not.
- 5:18So what is the history? How did this all begin?
- 5:20Who who decided this was a good idea?
- 5:22So the. History of gifted programming in
- 5:24the states kind of starts from the 1860s.
- 5:29The term gifted comes out of a book called Hereditary Genius,
- 5:35and it's a British study, but indicates that intelligence was
- 5:38passed through generations. So the idea that intelligence is
- 5:42something that you are born with, that's innate.
- 5:45OK, so it's it's giving eugenics.
- 5:48Yeah, it is giving a bit of eugenics.
- 5:50The first gifted school was established in 19 O one in
- 5:54Worcester, MA. In 19 O 52, researchers named
- 5:58Benet and Simon start developing a series of tests to identify
- 6:03children of inferior intelligence for the purpose of
- 6:06separating them from regular. Kids again, eugenics.
- 6:10Again, it's giving eugenics. In 1916, Louis Terman, who was
- 6:16considered the father of the gifted movement, publishes the
- 6:19Stanford Benet test. Which I think is what I took all
- 6:23the way in the 1980s, in 20s and 30s is when gifted classes
- 6:27really take off and become kind of a commonplace thing in
- 6:30American education. And towards the end of the 20th
- 6:34century, federal funding for talented and gifted programs
- 6:37increased. And like, it just grew and grew
- 6:40and grew. Now we're here today and looking
- 6:43at the history of this thing and saying, wow, yeah, this is, this
- 6:46is gross. Telling one kid that they are
- 6:49smarter or inherently better than another kid is gross
- 6:52because how does that other kid feel like?
- 6:54How does Laura? How does Laura?
- 6:56Wait, yeah. How?
- 6:56Well, how does a Laura Ryan feel when her Big Brother and sister
- 7:00are in this thing that she's not in?
- 7:02And are getting interviewed for the local newspaper and she
- 7:06instead has a giant knot between her eyes.
- 7:09OK, because she and her younger brother ran into each other all
- 7:14the way. So a reporter came to our house
- 7:17and what I remember about it was that we had matching dresses
- 7:20that I hated. They were white with lilac
- 7:23flowers. Yes, I thought they were
- 7:25beautiful. So that's another place where we
- 7:27diverge. Bad little Lacy collars and my
- 7:31adorable sister had a great big purple lump on her forehead
- 7:36which made her look extra not. Right between the I looked like
- 7:42what they would term in the in the 1920s and 30s as subnormal.
- 7:48Also, I don't think that I'm less intelligent than you and
- 7:51Robbie. I just think I don't.
- 7:52I don't test well and I've always known that.
- 7:55So Colin Seal, who is part of a a think tank called Think Law
- 7:59and he developed enrichment curricula.
- 8:02He says that students who are exceptionally gifted, he
- 8:05considers them to be special needs students.
- 8:07And he says a lot of people confuse gifted with high
- 8:12achieving and those things do not correlate.
- 8:15Because that that was mom's biggest concern because they
- 8:17changed the criteria and made you have you had to meet grade
- 8:20criterion. So Robbie couldn't do it
- 8:22anymore. He wasn't.
- 8:23He wasn't cutting it right with his grades.
- 8:26Well, I'm like, what does that mean as a kid?
- 8:27To be told one year that you're extra smart and then the next
- 8:32year you're not. Because it's all gobbledygook.
- 8:35It's not real. There is a quote that I ran
- 8:37across that this guy Colin Seals used an allegory for for kids.
- 8:43Everybody's a genius, but if you judge a fish by its ability to
- 8:47climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it's
- 8:50stupid. That's a quote attributed to
- 8:52Albert Einstein, but there's no documentation.
- 8:54We found out it's probably Shakespeare, right?
- 8:58Everything's Shakespeare. A fish is stupid.
- 9:00But yeah, only dumb people think that Albert Einstein said that.
- 9:03So your intelligence is not an intelligence that tests Well.
- 9:07My intelligence is super verbal, super spatial.
- 9:13I have been good at math, but there's a lot of things that I'm
- 9:16not good at. Just a name drop for a hot
- 9:18second. I was talking to Moon Unit Zappa
- 9:21at brunch and we were talking about this idea and she said,
- 9:25you know, genius is a weird word.
- 9:27A lot of people thought my father Frank Zappa was a genius,
- 9:30but there were a whole lot of things he couldn't do and wasn't
- 9:34good at. Intelligence does not just mean
- 9:36super capable in all ways. Also, people sometimes think
- 9:39intelligence is the ability to memorize stuff.
- 9:43Well, I'm terrible at that, which is why I don't test well.
- 9:46I've always thought that intelligence truly is the
- 9:49ability to get your arms around big concepts and the ability to
- 9:53solve problems more than I know what the capital of Indiana is,
- 9:59which I don't. The story that I make up about
- 10:01what intelligence means is the ability to have your own mindset
- 10:06and your own very clearly thought out opinion.
- 10:09Also to always be seeking learning and knowledge.
- 10:13And also I think having the EQ, emotional quotient, being able
- 10:17to understand your emotional life, being able to relate to
- 10:21other people. I hear this a lot in my office
- 10:23where specifically women will say well I'm just dumb and I
- 10:28will always say have you ever met dumb people?
- 10:33Because because you're not that. A dumb person to me is someone
- 10:37who is ignorant, who doesn't understand concepts, isn't
- 10:40curious about the world and just is getting by and not thinking
- 10:44about things too much. Well, and we also conflate
- 10:48education with intelligence in this country.
- 10:51Like you say, I've known many people who did not have higher
- 10:55education at all, but the term is autodidact.
- 10:57They are drawn to learn, they educate themselves, they find
- 11:01out things in their own way and on their own path.
- 11:03Like I think that intelligence is more relevant than being a
- 11:06rich kid who has a master's degree because they had the
- 11:09money to do it. Yeah, I'm reading Madeleine
- 11:12Pendleton's book I Survived Capitalism, and all I got was a
- 11:15salsy T-shirt. We follow her on Tick.
- 11:17Tock and I guess she's a tick tock celeb.
- 11:18She was talking about her book on one of the tick tocks today
- 11:22and I was thinking about the the fact that she had nothing.
- 11:24Like she had no resources at all.
- 11:26Her dad basically homeless most of her childhood.
- 11:29Her mom wasn't well educated but she had this tenacity for
- 11:34knowledge. I also suspect that she's ASD
- 11:37because of the way she talks about the way she relates to
- 11:39people. She wants to know everything and
- 11:41I think that to me is what makes someone intelligent just to.
- 11:46Blow Madeleine's Horner for a second.
- 11:47Not only did she write a book about her worldview, but she's
- 11:51also like a successful fashion designer, runs her own company,
- 11:54pays her workers fairly. She's done a lot for someone who
- 11:57didn't come from anything. Right.
- 11:58And so to me, some of that maybe was innate.
- 12:01Like I think she's just a curious person and wants to
- 12:04learn. On that talk, I found a study
- 12:06from 2022 indicating that gifted programs provide children with
- 12:10little to no academic boost if they had high test scores
- 12:14before. They're going to continue.
- 12:16They're going to continue to have high test scores, they
- 12:18said. So small it was moving kids from
- 12:20the 78th to the 80th percentile in reading.
- 12:23See. I I never thought of gifted and
- 12:25talented as a way to boost grades.
- 12:27What did you think it was for? I thought it was to get him out
- 12:30of the class, right? Well, not.
- 12:32Bothering people, and also to find other kids who are like
- 12:36minded, other kids who are curious, who want to learn, who
- 12:40do fun activities. I think of school as the story
- 12:43I've made-up about it. And a lot of people have told me
- 12:45is that the educational system, at least in America, is designed
- 12:49to create good workers. Yeah, it's a prison for kids.
- 12:53I really do think it's like factory workers.
- 12:55That's why we have the bells and all the things and you have the
- 12:58lunch hour and it's getting kids used to what it's going to be
- 13:01like to work in a factory. And I don't want my son to work
- 13:04in a factory. So we don't have any factories
- 13:06so. Thanks.
- 13:07We're Reaganomics. Yeah, we're preparing kids for
- 13:10jobs that do not exist. Yeah, we're preparing kids for a
- 13:13lifestyle that doesn't exist for anyone.
- 13:15That's another tangent for another day.
- 13:17But doing something like this, taking brain breaks, going
- 13:20somewhere, learning new stuff, using his his little mental
- 13:24muscles in a different way. I just want him to be more
- 13:26creative and have a more expansive mindset and that's why
- 13:29I want him to be in gifted and talented.
- 13:31Of a realization that I had like on that tack of it's about
- 13:33getting them out of the normal classrooms I always assumed that
- 13:36my teachers loved me because I was the smartest smarty always
- 13:40had my hand in the air and. Was also.
- 13:41I assure you they did not. Exactly.
- 13:43It was an immense brown noser. I I only realized like I started
- 13:48doing some after school teaching in chess and other stuff and I'm
- 13:51like, Oh my God, my teachers hated me.
- 13:53I was an enormous pain in the butt for them I was taking.
- 13:56It just trying to get through the lesson.
- 13:59We don't. We don't need to know your sub
- 14:01sub sub heading question. Yeah, we don't need you to weed
- 14:05off into something that you find interesting that doesn't have
- 14:07anything to do with anything. And that was that was a shock to
- 14:10the system. I'm like, oh.
- 14:11Wow, OK, I was really annoying. I was really annoying.
- 14:14Also a lot of tag programs, they're not necessarily doing
- 14:18advanced curricula. It's a lot of enrichment like
- 14:21you say. I remember doing a lot of
- 14:23puzzles and fun stuff and fun discussions, but not necessarily
- 14:28educational, more just taking our time during the day.
- 14:33And that's the difference between TAG that's for younger
- 14:35children and AP classes where you are studying more advanced
- 14:39material and getting an advanced curriculum.
- 14:41Were you in any AP classes in high school?
- 14:43No, I don't think so. I took some honors classes but I
- 14:46don't think I did any AP. I did mostly AP English.
- 14:49I was in an AP math class and bombed out pretty spectacularly.
- 14:54That tracks. Not because I am not good at
- 14:56math, but because I did not want to spend the time working on
- 14:59math. But I was in AP Algebra.
- 15:01That's where I met Keith C, my first serious boyfriend.
- 15:04I didn't realize he went to your school.
- 15:05I thought we met him outside of school.
- 15:07That was Jason B that I met out of school.
- 15:10You just say their first name. That's true.
- 15:12I found this list that I found interesting because you've
- 15:15sometimes happened. You have run headlong into the
- 15:18point I wanted to make this podcast and that's fine, that's
- 15:20fine. Here is a list of signs of
- 15:23giftedness in children and extreme need for constant mental
- 15:27stimulation. I definitely had that.
- 15:28And ability to learn and process complex information rapidly
- 15:32despite the fact that I can't read it.
- 15:34I can't do it. A need or desire to explore
- 15:37subjects and surprise and depth. That's that.
- 15:38Curiosity that you were talking about.
- 15:40Insatiable curiosity. Endless questions, endless
- 15:43inquiries. Ability to comprehend material
- 15:45several grade levels above their age.
- 15:47Surprising emotional depth and sensitivity.
- 15:50Hey. Enthusiastic about unique
- 15:52interests and topics. A quirky or mature sense of
- 15:55humor and creative problem solving.
- 15:58Imaginative expression Absorbs information quickly with few
- 16:01repetitions needed. Self aware, socially aware,
- 16:04aware of like big picture issues.
- 16:06In what way is that not a list of neurodivergence?
- 16:08Right, this is just ASD. This is just like is your kid
- 16:14ASD? Very hurtful.
- 16:15How many of these still apply to me?
- 16:17Are we seeing a pattern here they need to talk about?
- 16:21So I found an article by Doctor Talley Shenfield, 5 Common
- 16:25Problems experienced by Gifted Children in Adolescence.
- 16:28The term she uses this asynchronous development.
- 16:31They're developing at a different speed, and then taking
- 16:34them out of the flow of normal classes exacerbates that.
- 16:38Oh I see. So it actually makes them do
- 16:40worse with their cohort, right? They would otherwise so.
- 16:43Gifted kids face an increased risk of anxiety, depression and
- 16:47low self esteem. Up to one in 50 gifted kids.
- 16:50Kids that were singled out for being extra smart in elementary
- 16:54and middle school drop out of high school.
- 16:56That makes sense because they don't fit in.
- 16:57They don't fit in. I was talking to my friend Scott
- 17:00about his experience in AP classes and he hated them.
- 17:04He wasn't with kids his own age. He always felt a little on the
- 17:08back foot, a little bit out of the loop.
- 17:10And he was talking specifically about science classes because
- 17:13his English classes, he had more kids his own age and my AP
- 17:16English classes, I think was was all kids my own age.
- 17:19We were just reading college material because he already felt
- 17:22a little bit out of place and this didn't help that.
- 17:25You know, it's just more of the same, like it's.
- 17:27More of the same. We were comparing notes because
- 17:29we both grew up on some level in a cult.
- 17:31We both grew up in tag programs and the one that I had over him
- 17:36was part of our childhood was spent in the South of France.
- 17:40Which sounds cool when you're an adult, but I got off that
- 17:43airplane with not a perfect understanding of American slang.
- 17:48Dressed very weird already, felt like I didn't fit in.
- 17:52I mean, I feel like the Mormonism knocks.
- 17:54Most of everything else. All Pearl references out at the
- 17:57from the jump. But being set aside in other
- 18:00classes with other kids and not knowing most of my grade cohort,
- 18:04it only contributed to that feeling of loneliness and of
- 18:08being a part. Isolation.
- 18:10Isolation mother. I tried.
- 18:15Please believe me. I'm doing the best that I can.
- 18:19I think Ian Curtis said it best in 1980.
- 18:22I'm. Going to say Ian Curtis is
- 18:24probably neurodivergent, let's be real and epileptic.
- 18:27Not an easy life. A couple like random thoughts on
- 18:30being smart in general and like what people expect from you when
- 18:33you're smart is because we're Americans, people think that
- 18:36extremely smart people are going to make a lot of money because
- 18:39that's what's worthwhile to us. Like, oh, they're going to be
- 18:42good business people. And that is very rarely true.
- 18:47Accurate. I'm not a good business person,
- 18:49but I'm incredibly smart. You are incredibly smart, like
- 18:52most of the people from my high school and college.
- 18:55You know, the handful of people that I met who I found really
- 18:57like off the chart smart, They're not successful in that
- 19:00way. No, like I think about the most
- 19:02brilliant, creative people that I've ever known, and none of
- 19:05them are rich. It's the same branch.
- 19:07I was talking to another adult who'd been in talented and
- 19:10gifted, and he said a real disadvantage that it put him at
- 19:14was that he got used to getting a certain amount of positive
- 19:18reinforcement kind of on a schedule.
- 19:20You take a test, you get a pat on the back and a Scooby snack.
- 19:23You do well at a presentation. Like smart kids are good at
- 19:26school or good at some parts of school at least, and you get
- 19:29positive reinforcement. And then when you're in the
- 19:31world, that just goes away. Yeah, Madeline Pendleton was
- 19:35talking about it in her book. Oh, wow.
- 19:38She was talking about how when she went to design school, she
- 19:40made this dress and she got AC on it.
- 19:43Well I can't accept AC, can I make the whole dress over again?
- 19:47And the teachers like you passed.
- 19:49It's fine. Most of us when we do work for
- 19:53other companies and other people, we might get a review
- 19:56every six months or a year, but your boss is not kind of
- 19:58constantly be coming into your office and saying you did really
- 20:01good at that chart today. And I think that's sad.
- 20:04I think that's wrong. I remember my first grown up
- 20:08job. I was a hypnotherapist.
- 20:10Spoiler alert. And then I got promoted and I
- 20:13became the manager of the hypnosis center and I, I
- 20:16realized, oh, I actually can't, I can't do this job because all
- 20:20I'm getting is negative reinforcement all day long.
- 20:23Whereas when I'm working with clients, I get to see their
- 20:26progress and I get to see how happy they are.
- 20:28And so I'm getting a positive reinforcement.
- 20:31I went off and started private practice so that I can avoid
- 20:35being in an office all day getting yelled at by people.
- 20:38That was the old school style of management is like not feeling
- 20:43like you're doing a good job as a manager.
- 20:44If you're not finding places you're employee could improve
- 20:48and that's been documented not to help anything, it just made
- 20:51your employee hate you. It wasn't just the management,
- 20:53it was anytime a client had a complaint, it would come to me.
- 20:57Anytime an employee had a complaint, it came to me.
- 20:59It was just all day long, basically listening to people
- 21:02whine and complain and never validating anything I've done
- 21:07ever. So it's basically like being a
- 21:08mom. You just got to do that early to
- 21:10Madeline's point or to Madeline's teacher's point.
- 21:13Apparel design is 1° where no one gives a sweet FA what your
- 21:18grades were. It is not an academic degree.
- 21:22But I mean, basically what you said is I had defined myself as
- 21:24an A student my whole life. That's where I got a lot of
- 21:26myself worth. So having somebody tell me I got
- 21:28to see it was just not acceptable.
- 21:30Right. And but like, that stuff
- 21:32happened to me in art school, because art is more objective.
- 21:35Everybody's not going to see it your way.
- 21:38And it's not. Yeah, it's not like you can
- 21:39always excel by putting a lot of time into a project or putting a
- 21:43bunch of information into a project that may not be
- 21:45successful. Yeah, Madeline Umloff tried to
- 21:49give me AC in body drawing. I think that was the class.
- 21:53It was like drawing the human body.
- 21:54And I was like, no. And she said, well, when I went
- 22:00to art school, blah, blah, blah, lady, I'm not in art school.
- 22:03I'm at Austin Community College. I'm not going to.
- 22:06Everybody involved. I'm not.
- 22:07Taking AC? I'm not taking AC.
- 22:10Yeah, this is not some elite thing.
- 22:12I had to draw a bunch of hands and feet.
- 22:13Thanks a lot Madeline Umwa to bring my grade to AB.
- 22:17But you got pretty good at them hands and feet, right?
- 22:19Not really, but I just drew them a lot.
- 22:21I've mentioned it before, but like in in in art school, I was
- 22:24told you have 1000 bad drawings in your hands and you just have
- 22:29to draw and draw and draw and draw until you've gotten them
- 22:31all out. And that's how you become good
- 22:32at trying. Well, that's what Salvador Dali
- 22:34says, so I trust him. Salvador Dali can be trusted for
- 22:37almost anything. Except for being a good husband
- 22:40or friend. He's not a good husband, he's
- 22:42not a good friend. Probably not a good citizen.
- 22:46He was pro fascist like this. There's problems.
- 22:49A couple of hiccups. But boy, oh boy, could he draw a
- 22:54lobster. You know, No one's saying he
- 22:56couldn't. He could draw a melting clock
- 22:58with the best of them. So what is it like negotiating
- 23:01the world? As a former talented and gifted
- 23:05student, I do think that I have a huge wound around being seem
- 23:10to be smart. It's important to me that other
- 23:13people think that I'm smart. I didn't graduate college any
- 23:15sooner than other people. I didn't pursue an advanced
- 23:18degree because the the field that I chose, there is no
- 23:20purpose to it. No one cares what grades you got
- 23:22in fashion design. No one needs you to have an
- 23:24advanced degree. But it definitely has changed
- 23:27the way I approach the world. I need to be the smartest kid in
- 23:30the room if I can. Most of my challenges at work
- 23:33have been people questioning decisions I've made or or saying
- 23:37it wasn't the right decision when I need to be the smartest
- 23:39person and so I can't make the wrong decision.
- 23:42That sounds healthy. It's.
- 23:43Super healthy and it's really served me super well to be a
- 23:47person who can never be wrong and.
- 23:49Definitely helped our relationship.
- 23:53Well, the cool thing about me and my sisters is that none of
- 23:55us can be wrong in our own ways. Can I be wrong?
- 23:58If I'm always right, that's right.
- 24:02How's it been for you growing up as a dumb person?
- 24:05Well, that's what's funny. I graduated from high school two
- 24:08years early. I I have a master's degree.
- 24:11I have lots of pieces of paper. Lots of people look to me as an
- 24:14intelligent person, but yet I did not pass whatever test it
- 24:17was to get into gifted and talented.
- 24:19That's why I think it's all irrelevant.
- 24:21I really do think it's all eugenics based and it's old
- 24:24white people crap and it's dumb. But I still want my son to do it
- 24:27because I think I think of it as like a break.
- 24:29I don't think it has merit. I don't think it's going to help
- 24:32him with his education, but I think it might help him with his
- 24:34emotional development. I think it might help him being
- 24:37able to relate to other kids who are like him that honestly I
- 24:40think of it as more of a social. Program I definitely think that
- 24:43being in those programs early promoted, you know, just
- 24:46thinking outside the box and and approaching things from a
- 24:48different way and it helped me see the world as a bigger place
- 24:52than my elementary school. And that that's what I want to
- 24:55promote. I want him to understand that
- 24:57school is not the thing. School is a stepping stone we
- 25:01all have to do. But ultimately, there's a whole
- 25:03big wide world out there. And I want you to be curious
- 25:05about that world, and I want you to learn.
- 25:06About it. OK, So what have we learned
- 25:08today that we learned a little bit about the history of
- 25:11talented and gifted? We've learned that it's based on
- 25:13eugenics and racism and doesn't necessarily help kids.
- 25:17And classism. And classism.
- 25:19What it's mostly about is getting the obnoxious kid who
- 25:23wants to talk about trains all the time out of your.
- 25:24Class So Virginia Virginia, what are your final thoughts on this
- 25:30topic that you so humbly brought to the table?
- 25:33I did not do this topic just so I could talk about how I was and
- 25:36talented and gifted. Right.
- 25:38It has affected me as an adult, I feel.
- 25:41I. Think that that feeling of being
- 25:45set apart or chosen. I skipped a grade not for
- 25:47academic reasons, but I also always carried that with me as
- 25:51like a way that I was set apart. I was always a little bit ahead
- 25:54of my peers and I'll actually like that has formed who I am.
- 25:57Even though it did not result in a change in my academic career.
- 26:01It has done a lot about myself, image and self perception in not
- 26:05necessarily good ways, but not necessarily bad ways, just ways.
- 26:08I would fight you on them. OK?
- 26:10I don't know how healthy it is to spend your life trying to
- 26:14prove that you're this certain way.
- 26:16I don't know how good that is for your mental health or self
- 26:19esteem. What are your final thoughts on
- 26:21the topic of talented and gifted programs for kids?
- 26:23I have a friend who's really obsessed with this topic and
- 26:26she's a teacher and she has two kids and are gifted and talented
- 26:31because they are from a wealthy white family.
- 26:34Right, good for them. She always says, you know, we
- 26:36need to do something more for these kids.
- 26:39And I agree with her. And like, as we've been talking
- 26:41about today, I really think that that probably kids in in that
- 26:44group do need to be doing more stuff outside of just the
- 26:47regular regular public school. There should be a whole wing for
- 26:51those kids because I've just been catching up on homework all
- 26:54week. I'll help are beneficial to my
- 26:58son. Is it going to be to know what
- 27:00an inherited trait is versus a learned?
- 27:03Really what does that matter at all?
- 27:04Why does he need to know about the snowfox and how it's fur
- 27:09changes? It's not important to society or
- 27:12the world or I don't get it. I love knowing about the Snowfox
- 27:16and what I learned when we went to go see the crown jewels in
- 27:21London. Are that the ermine fur that
- 27:24they use on a King's crown and cloak?
- 27:26That's from an urban in the winter when its coat turns white
- 27:31because he's a brown guy the rest of the year.
- 27:33And he was lucky enough to be murdered in the right season so
- 27:37that he could look good on this kinks.
- 27:39But also, in especially Renaissance paintings, you'll
- 27:42see women holding Urmans. It means something about sex,
- 27:46because the story was that an ermine, rather than mess up its
- 27:51coat by fighting, a hunter, would just lay down and be ready
- 27:55to be executed. Just keep the coat nice.
- 27:57And so it was about virginity. Gross.
- 28:01Virginia Speaking of virginity. Thank you.
- 28:04The source of your name. I mean after the Queen of
- 28:07England. Technically, yeah, for the same
- 28:10reason. Virginia, if people want to
- 28:12reach out to you, how would they do it?
- 28:14You can find me at vidinia.com and I want to thank everybody
- 28:19who found our podcast through Jackie and Laurie.
- 28:22That seems to be happening more and more.
- 28:24You can find me at my TikTok is virginia.com.
- 28:27Everything's virginia.com and you can write us as a podcast at
- 28:32Hello, my sister's a therapist. You can find a real bare bones
- 28:36website at my sister's a therapist.com because I'm.
- 28:39Proud of our website, I think it's fantastic.
- 28:41It's very clean. Oddly, no one else had that
- 28:44name. Laura, where can people find you
- 28:46on the Internet? Well, they can find me at
- 28:48lauraryan.org. They can follow me on my TikTok
- 28:52account, I am Laura Ryan, or they can find the show on
- 28:55Instagram at my sister's a therapist.
- 28:58Also, if you would like to hire us to speak at your women's
- 29:01conference, mental health conference, women's leadership
- 29:03event, Wellness event, educational seminar, corporate
- 29:07retreat, women's retreat or workshop, you can e-mail us at
- 29:10hire us at my sisters a therapist.com.
- 29:14We are also talking about starting our own women's
- 29:17retreat. If you're interested in that,
- 29:20you can e-mail us at all the places.
- 29:22I've just realized something really embarrassing about myself
- 29:24that I'm going to share with you guys, my listeners, and I think
- 29:28that one of the things that I have always liked about the
- 29:31X-Men and related to about the X-Men is the idea that they are
- 29:36gifted. Yep.
- 29:38Even though I can't shoot rays out of my eyes.
- 29:41I have no psychic ability that anyone has confirmed, but I
- 29:44think the idea that these kids are on a special school is why I
- 29:48like that story. Oh God.
- 29:50You are what the kids would say. Cringe AF cringe.
- 29:54AF ladies and gentlemen. Speaking of cringe, Laura, this
- 29:58is the part of the show where you usually read a a a listener
- 30:01review. Do you have one for us this
- 30:02week? I most certainly do, thanks for
- 30:05asking. And I don't find this at all
- 30:07cringe. In fact, I think all of you are
- 30:09very special and I'm grateful for your listenership and I'm
- 30:12grateful for your reviews. That's where I get myself esteem
- 30:16from Anyone's wondering, we have a review.
- 30:19The title is smart and funny from Poppy Dat.
- 30:23This show reminds me of times when I was younger and would
- 30:25stay up all night laughing with my friends, diagnosing ourselves
- 30:29in our relationship except we didn't know what we were talking
- 30:32about. Super fun and I learned
- 30:35something new in every episode. Thank you, Poppy, Poppy dot.
- 30:39Thank you, Poppy dot. This week it's about Ermans.
- 30:41Probably Poppy dot wasn't in gifted and talented and needed
- 30:44to know all about it. In closing, we would like to
- 30:47share with you the words of one of society's great thinkers,
- 30:52Billy Ray Valentine. Capricorn.
- 30:54Capricorn. We can make it, baby.
- 30:57Me and you. Bye bye.
- 31:00Bye.