Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #24: Is There a 2nd Term Curse on US Presidencies?
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Leiter.
- 0:07Today, what we're gonna talk about, do 2 term presidents experience a second term curse?
- 0:16This idea that presidents have considerably, noticeably worse second terms for their records
- 0:25and their legacies than they do for their first terms.
- 0:29Donald Trump has started his 2nd presidential term joining the ranks of presidents who
- 0:34experienced more than a first 4 years in office, and many political observers of various
- 0:41political stripes, however, have remarked
- 0:44in the past about this so called second term curse whenever a president starts another term.
- 0:52Might be because of scandals, some sort of disaster, obstinacy from Congress to the
- 0:59president's agenda, economic downturns, Supreme court cases unfavorable to that president's
- 1:05policy and so on and so forth.
- 1:09But is this second term curse real?
- 1:13Is there really a rule that second terms for presidents are usually, if not always worse for
- 1:19their reputations?
- 1:21Maybe it's a matter of survivorship bias where presidents who did well in their 1st term are
- 1:27more likely to have a second term.
- 1:30So it is easier for a second term to look worse in comparison, sort of a regression to the
- 1:35mean where your your first term was so great, it's hard to top that.
- 1:41Or maybe other government officials and the public just gets sick of the guy in charge
- 1:47after more than 4 years and just want something different.
- 1:51There are a
- 1:51lot of data points you could point to to make your case for or against the theory of the
- 1:57second term curse.
- 1:59But in any case, we're going to examine various data points, including presidential approval
- 2:04ratings and how the president's party has fared in certain elections.
- 2:08And when applicable, we'll then compare these points to Donald Trump's 1st term and his 2nd
- 2:14term so far.
- 2:16So let's dive in.
- 2:18So first off, who are the 2nd term presidents in US history?
- 2:23Now this list includes people who did not serve 2 full terms, but they went over one full term.
- 2:30The full two term presidents are there's 14 of them.
- 2:36George Washington, George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, James Monroe, Andrew
- 2:42Jackson, Ulysses s Grant, Grover Cleveland.
- 2:46It was the 1st guy to serve nonconsecutive terms as president.
- 2:49Now Donald Trump is joining him.
- 2:52Woodrow Wilson, Franklin d Roosevelt, who actually went into the beginning of a
- 2:574th term, Dwight Eisenhower, Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton, George w Bush, and Barack
- 3:04Obama.
- 3:05Now some unfortunately died shortly into their second terms.
- 3:10Abraham Lincoln and William McKinley both were assassinated shortly after they started their
- 3:15second term.
- 3:17Richard Nixon resigned during his second term, following the infamous Watergate scandal.
- 3:23And then some presidents that served over one full term took over during the previous
- 3:28president's 1st term, Teddy Roosevelt after William McKinley was assassinated, and then
- 3:34Lyndon B Johnson after John F.
- 3:35Kennedy was assassinated.
- 3:38And then a couple just took over for the previous president following the previous
- 3:42president's health related death.
- 3:44So Calvin Coolidge took over after Warren Harding died and Harry Truman took over after
- 3:51FDR died in office.
- 3:56Now most of these presidents are during the existence of the Republican party because the
- 4:02Republican party has only been around since the 18 fifties.
- 4:07So therefore, most of these presidents are going to be when presidents or excuse me, when
- 4:13politics turned into democrats versus republicans.
- 4:16But 2 term presidents before the existence of the Republican Party were George Washington,
- 4:22Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, James Monroe, and Andrew Jackson.
- 4:26And, technically, George Washington did not survey 2 full terms.
- 4:30That's just because there were some logistical issues since he was the first president trying
- 4:34to get him into office.
- 4:36So he technically did not serve as long as other 2 full term presidents, but for all
- 4:41intents and purposes, he served for 2 full terms.
- 4:45He didn't resign or or pass before the end of his 2nd term.
- 4:51The Federalist party never officially had a 2 term president.
- 4:54Technically, George Washington was a federalist.
- 4:57He never officially identified as such, but he tend to decide with them on policy issues,
- 5:04particularly with Alexander Hamilton.
- 5:07And the Whig party was, they never had a president serve a full term because they had a
- 5:14penchant for dying early.
- 5:15William Henry Harrison died a month into his term, and then Zachary Taylor died about a year
- 5:21and a half into his term.
- 5:23And then John Tyler took over for William Henry Harrison, and then Millard Fillmore took over
- 5:29for Zachary Taylor to fill out the rest of those respective presidents' terms.
- 5:37So now let's see the actual data points on
- 5:40these 2 term presidents as to whether there is a second term curse.
- 5:46Well, we'll first talk about their presidential approval ratings.
- 5:50Now, this has not been around since the very beginning of the nation.
- 5:55In fact, the the presidential approval rating has only really been around since towards the
- 6:01end of FDR's tenure.
- 6:04And, been it's been refined over time, but the approval rating as we know it has only been
- 6:10around since then.
- 6:11And and Gallup,
- 6:12the the polling organization, Gallup, has done it since then.
- 6:17It was the first one to do it since then.
- 6:18There are other organizations that also measure presidential approval rating, but Gallup is
- 6:25usually considered the one to go to because they have been doing it for so long.
- 6:30And so because it is a relatively new thing that has been started, we're only gonna be able
- 6:38to examine 8 presidents here that fit this criteria of two terms.
- 6:42So Harry Truman, Dwight Eisenhower, Lyndon B Johnson, Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan, Bill
- 6:50Clinton, George w Bush, and Barack Obama.
- 6:54Now Truman, LBJ,
- 6:57Lyndon b Johnson, the acronym that he often goes by or is often treated by.
- 7:03Richard Nixon, those 3 did not serve 2 full terms, but for the purposes of this particular
- 7:11data, they can be treated the same here because we're just looking at the highest percentage
- 7:17approval rating, lowest percentage approval rating, and the average percentage approval
- 7:22rating for both their first and second terms.
- 7:26And this data comes from the American presidency projects repository of Gallup's
- 7:31presidential approval rating poll.
- 7:34Bottom line here is that 2 term presidents have generally polled worse in presidential approval
- 7:41ratings in their 2nd term compared to their 1st term.
- 7:466 of 8 of
- 7:47these presidents so pre before Trump, because obviously he hasn't been
- 7:51off in office much for a second term to really compare, but 6 of the 8 presidents we mentioned
- 7:57earlier, again, those being Truman, Eisenhower, LBJ, Nixon, Reagan, Clinton, w Bush, and Obama,
- 8:066 of 8 of these presidents had a lower average approval rating in their 2nd term than their
- 8:121st term.
- 8:13The exceptions here being Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton.
- 8:175 of 8 of them had a lower lowest percentage in their 2nd term than in their 1st term.
- 8:23So in other words, they had a lower trough in approval rating in their 2nd term than at any
- 8:32point that they had in their 1st term.
- 8:35Exceptions to this being Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton, Barack Obama had a 40% in both terms,
- 8:41so had about the same depth in approval rating for both terms in his case.
- 8:49And then 5 of 8 of these presidents had a lower highest percentage approval rating in the 2nd
- 8:55term than in the 1st term, except, Bill Clinton.
- 8:59Nixon had a 67% approval rating at some point in both of his terms, and then Ronald Reagan
- 9:05had 68% at both points, or at some point in both of his terms.
- 9:13So Donald Trump, how does he compare so far?
- 9:16So the average throughout his first term was 40%.
- 9:21Litter than any president who served 2 full terms since the presidential approval rating
- 9:26poll was created, that was 7 points lower than Bill Clinton who had a average of 47% in his
- 9:33first term, and he was the the next lowest first term average after Donald Trump.
- 9:41Now while most presidents have had a lower second term average than their first term,
- 9:48there's
- 9:48not much room for that to happen to Donald Trump.
- 9:51His second term being nonconsecutive might also impact the rating as opposed to if his second
- 9:58term was consecutive to the first term, but, we'll have to see.
- 10:02And it wasn't around when the presidential approval ring wasn't around when Grover
- 10:07Cleveland was in office, so we can't really use that as the comparison point.
- 10:11And that was also a much longer time ago, so might not be all that comparable anyways.
- 10:16But, in any case, obviously, we'll have to see what happens with Donald Trump, but he could
- 10:22become one of the exceptions where his 2nd term presidential approval rating was higher than
- 10:26his first term.
- 10:28We'll have to see.
- 10:30Now let's talk about 2nd term presidents and their party in congressional elections.
- 10:36Basically, looking at the net gains and losses of seats by
- 10:41the president's party in 1st versus second terms in both the US House and the US Senate.
- 10:47So the first term being the 1st president presidential election, the one that they got
- 10:53elected in the first time and the first midterm
- 10:56following that presidential election, and then
- 10:59the second term being the second time that president got elected and the second midterm
- 11:04that they experienced during their tenure.
- 11:07And for fair comparisons, we're only gonna use presidents that served 2 full terms since there
- 11:13have been 435 US house seats, which there are now, and 100 US senate seats, which are now,
- 11:21except for FDR, since there were 96 US Senate seats throughout his whole tenure.
- 11:26So it's pretty comparable.
- 11:29But the reason why beyond before that, I don't really want to use those.
- 11:35Our previous presidents before then is because the total number of US House Representatives
- 11:41and US senators shifted a lot, in in those previous years and during presidency.
- 11:48So it I don't think it'd be really fair to, compare unless you took, like, maybe
- 11:54percentages of the chambers.
- 11:56But even then, that gets a
- 11:57little bit, maybe
- 12:01not quite an apples to oranges comparison, but it be the comparison does become more
- 12:05difficult.
- 12:06And so we're also presidents that serve more than one full term, but not 2 full terms.
- 12:14They don't have enough federal elections for fair comparison to presidents with 2 full terms
- 12:19because they might not have had that 1st presidential election to compare.
- 12:24Because if they took over for a previous president during that president's first term,
- 12:29then they only got elected one time.
- 12:31So they might have taken over 2 years into the previous president's presidency and maybe even
- 12:36after that midterm, but then they only had one time that that president got elected
- 12:42themselves.
- 12:43So for a fair comparison, only presidents that had 2 full terms.
- 12:50So ones like Lyndon v Johnson are not gonna be, included in here.
- 12:55And you have to be careful with US senate seats, in comparisons because only a third of
- 13:02the chamber is up for election in a given year.
- 13:05So one president's party may have more seats to defend than another president has to deal with.
- 13:12But in any case that's just a caveat to keep in mind we're still gonna use it for a comparison
- 13:18point.
- 13:19So the president's examined here we only have 6 that are gonna be examined here.
- 13:23So FDR, Eisenhower, Reagan, Clinton, w Bush, and Obama.
- 13:43Bottom line here is, it's kind of mixed results as to whether the president's party has lost
- 13:51more seats overall in their 2nd term than in their 1st term.
- 13:55So 3 of 6 presidents saw their party lose more seats in the US house in their 2nd term than
- 14:02they did in their 1st term.
- 14:04So that was FDR, Eisenhower, w Bush.
- 14:08FDR being a Democrat, Eisenhower and w Bush being Republicans.
- 14:144 of 6 presidents saw their party lose more seats in the US Senate in their 2nd term than
- 14:20they did in their 1st term.
- 14:22That being FDR, Eisenhower, Reagan, and Obama.
- 14:29For all 6 of these presidents, however, there was a net loss in total US senate seats in the
- 14:36second term, except for FDR who had a net change of 0 seats during his second term.
- 14:43So that's including his second reelection and then the midterm that followed that reelection.
- 14:51So Donald Trump, how does he compare so far?
- 14:55So for the US House, during his first term, he had a net loss of 46 seats.
- 15:02And so far in his second term, he had a net loss of 2 US house seats.
- 15:10Only president that had a lower, or, that had a greater net loss in seats in his first term was
- 15:17Bill Clinton who lost 62 seats.
- 15:21And Donald Trump was just ahead of Barack Obama for a 1st term, and Obama had lost 40 seats in
- 15:30his 1st term in the US House.
- 15:35As for the US Senate, he had a net gain of 0 seats in the US Senate for his first term and
- 15:43so far has gained 4 seats in the US Senate for his second election.
- 15:48His first term is tied with Eisenhower and is ahead of Clinton who had a net loss of 8 seats,
- 15:55and w Bush who had a net loss of 2 seats.
- 15:59Now second term has started off well for Donald Trump so far for the US Senate, But even for
- 16:05other presidents that started off well in the US Senate for or at least their party started
- 16:12off well in that president's second term, the next midterm really tanked their party
- 16:17representation.
- 16:18So we'll have to see how 2026, the midterm elections then, how they shape up for Donald
- 16:24Trump and the Republican Party.
- 16:28Now let's look at how second term presidents compare in regards to their partisan majorities
- 16:33in Congress.
- 16:34So not specific numbers of seats won or lost, but simply which party kept the or or won the
- 16:43partisan majority in Congress.
- 16:45So again, 1st term being that president's 1st election and then the 1st midterm during their
- 16:52presidency, and then the 2nd term being their presidential election they got reelected in,
- 16:57and then the midterm following that, their 2nd midterm.
- 17:01So for prior comparisons, we're gonna use only the 15th presidents that served 2 full terms so
- 17:08we can see how partisan majorities in congress changed or stayed the same for all four
- 17:14elections they are around for.
- 17:15That 1st presidential election, 1st midterm, 2nd presidential election, 2nd midterm.
- 17:21And we can use the presidents that came, that that actually that came before there was it was
- 17:29Democrat versus Republican.
- 17:32The forcing presidents here, Washington, Jefferson, Madison, Monroe, Andrew Jackson,
- 17:39Ulysses Grant, Cleveland, Wilson, FDR, Eisenhower, Reagan, Clinton, w Bush, and Obama.
- 17:49So remember, Washington, Jefferson, Madison, Monroe, and Jackson served before the
- 17:54Republican Party was created in the 18 fifties.
- 17:58Bottom line here is it's a bit complicated as there is a noticeable difference when you
- 18:04account for politics prior to the emergence of the Republican party and then after
- 18:10in terms of whether a, president in their 2nd term faced more opposing, partisan majorities
- 18:21in either chamber of Congress compared to their 1st term.
- 18:25So overall stats, any of 14 presidents saw their party win or hold the majority in the US
- 18:31house fewer times in their second term than in their first term.
- 18:36So 2nd term curse, little bit iffy in that regard.
- 18:41And 8 of 14 presidents saw their party win or hold the majority in the US senate fewer times
- 18:47in their 2nd term than they did in their 1st term.
- 18:50Not necessarily the same 8 presidents as for the US house, though.
- 18:55However, much of that is due to the weakness of the federalist party following John Adams' loss
- 19:01in his presidential reelection bid.
- 19:03And then Andrew Jackson, when he became president, it was a one party system.
- 19:09It was just Democrats, although they were definitely written by factions, but it was
- 19:16still technically one party during then.
- 19:18So that's part of the reason why
- 19:20I didn't really see partisan majority change all that much prior to the emergence of the
- 19:29Republican party,
- 19:31at least in this context context.
- 19:34So since politics became Democrat versus Republican, 7 of 9 presidents saw their party
- 19:43win or hold the majority in the US house fewer times in their 2nd term than in their 1st term,
- 19:50and 6 of 9 presidents saw their party win or hold the majority in the US senate fewer times
- 19:57in their 2nd term than in their 1st term.
- 20:01So when you put it in that context of democrat versus republican, definitely seems to be a
- 20:07sort of second term curse at play here.
- 20:11But Donald Trump, how does he compare so far?
- 20:14So in his first term, the majority party of the US House was the same as his Republican for 2
- 20:21years.
- 20:21And then following that the his first midterm, it became Democratic for the other 2 years.
- 20:28Now starting off his second term, it's back to being Republican again, or rather Republicans
- 20:34held their majority.
- 20:36So at least so far, the 2nd term curse doesn't seem to apply to Trump in regards to majority
- 20:42party control in the US house.
- 20:46In the US senate, however, the majority party has been the same as Trump's each time so far.
- 20:52So if Republicans lose the US majority US Senate majority in the 2026 elections, you can
- 20:59maybe argue that there's a second term curse in that regard.
- 21:03So another big data point we're gonna look at here, this one's a little bit, more finicky, I
- 21:10guess you could say.
- 21:11We're gonna look at scandals slash major negative events.
- 21:15Now,
- 21:18obviously, big thing for me here, try
- 21:19to be as impartial as possible.
- 21:21I'm not passing judgments on presidents saying they were or they weren't at fault for these
- 21:26problems.
- 21:27Just that these scandals and negative events became associated with them.
- 21:332nd terms for presidents, though, have also often been marked by major scandals, though
- 21:38they've happened in first terms for presidents to, there's just too many potential scandals
- 21:45and image damaging events to cover here and to compare numbers between 1st and second terms.
- 21:51Not really a at least from what I've gathered, there's not really a concrete study into how
- 21:59many scandals a president has experienced in their 1st term versus their 2nd term.
- 22:03But I will highlight some notable second term problems here for both parties.
- 22:08So a couple of Democrats and then a couple of
- 22:12Republicans.
- 22:13Franklin Roosevelt.
- 22:15He had, his what came to be called a court packing plan.
- 22:19It was legislation he was pushing to add a that would have allowed him to add a new SCOTUS
- 22:25justice for each justice that reached 70 years old and did not retire, and that would have
- 22:31given him up to a maximum of 6 more justices.
- 22:34It was 9 then.
- 22:35Still 9 now.
- 22:36There was 9 justices then, and then that would have become 15 on the court.
- 22:42Now that legislation failed, and he lost a lot of support, though he'd still win a 3rd term as
- 22:49president and keep majorities in both chambers of Congress at least for, a little while.
- 22:57Now we fast forward a couple decades later, Lyndon Johnson, at the time, the Vietnam War
- 23:05was raging and public opinion was starting to sour a bit on it, but then when the Tet
- 23:11Offensive hit, which was a surprise attack from North Vietnamese forces, that was a major
- 23:18catalyst for fully turning not
- 23:20maybe not fully, but turning a lot more public opinion against the Vietnam War.
- 23:26And the the progress of the Vietnam War, including the Tet Offensive, was one of the
- 23:31biggest reasons that Lyndon b Johnson chose not to run for reelection in 1968, which he could
- 23:37have actually done under the 22nd amendment.
- 23:40Because even though he had served a couple of years before that term full term that he won,
- 23:45Under the 22nd Amendment, you can actually serve a maximum of 10 years as president.
- 23:51You would have had to have taken over for a previous president no earlier than halfway
- 23:57between, halfway through that president's term.
- 24:02So JFK had just gone over a couple of years.
- 24:06Lyndon b Johnson finished out close to 2 years there.
- 24:11Won a full term there, so he actually served 6 years.
- 24:14Could have run again for another term to become president for 10 years, but he chose not to and
- 24:22very likely would not have won if he did run for reelection because his approval was sagging
- 24:30quite a bit.
- 24:31Now the guy who took over after Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, we have the infamous Watergate
- 24:38scandal, which we mentioned earlier on where there was there was a break in of Democratic
- 24:44National Committee offices at the Watergate Hotel by high level members of the Nixon
- 24:50administration.
- 24:51And now every scandal
- 24:53has to have gate at
- 24:55the end of its nickname because we're very unoriginal and can't just call something
- 25:03a word without gate at the end.
- 25:04It was it's there's called the Watergate Hotel.
- 25:07They didn't add gate just because they could.
- 25:11Anyways, that's just another gripe of mine.
- 25:14I can't stand when all these all these controversies and scandals need to have gate at
- 25:20the end
- 25:21of it.
- 25:21We don't need gate at the
- 25:22end of every one of them.
- 25:23Any case, Richard Nixon resigns not too long after the Watergate scandal really comes to
- 25:31light.
- 25:32And then see, about,
- 25:36well, so about 7 years after Ronald Reagan comes into office, but during his second term,
- 25:44so even later than that, you had the Iran contra affair.
- 25:48And senior officials in Reagan's administration secretly sold weapons to Iran while it was
- 25:55under an arms embargo.
- 25:57And the reason they were selling arms to Iran was so they could use the proceeds from those
- 26:02arms sales to fund the contrast who were an anti communist group in Nicaragua fighting the
- 26:10ruling Sandinistas who had just seized power in that country.
- 26:14Now Reagan was never implicated, but it was a stain on his second term.
- 26:18Although his pro approval rating did go back up toward the end of his tenure.
- 26:23So just a few examples of major second term scandals that presidents of both parties have
- 26:31experienced.
- 26:32Not saying that they were weren't responsible for any
- 26:35of them, but they did happen and they did become, synonymous with those presidents.
- 26:46Now Okay.
- 26:49So
- 26:54to end things off before the actual ending of this episode, is there a second term curse?
- 27:00At least just on the day that we just talked about, Ida.
- 27:06Presidents have generally pulled worse in their 2nd term overall than in their 1st term.
- 27:12They've also usually faced opposing partisan majorities in Congress more often in their 2nd
- 27:18terms than in their 1st term since politics became primarily Democrat versus Republican.
- 27:25The data though is more mixed when you're looking at specific numbers of seats gained or
- 27:31lost in the US house and US Senate comparing 2nd term versus 1st term in that context.
- 27:39And for scandals, again, there's no concrete study, at least to my knowledge, that
- 27:44demonstrates presidential scandals are more common or damaging in second terms than in
- 27:50first terms.
- 27:50Though one might suspect that the 2nd term would see more of those because if they were
- 27:57more common in the first term, that president would have been much less likely to win a
- 28:01second term.
- 28:03But we can't really say for sure.
- 28:05But what do others have to say?
- 28:07I wanna highlight several other viewpoints in this regard because the second term curse,
- 28:12while it gets bandied about a lot of times, it's not a consensus opinion that second terms
- 28:20for presidents are more challenging than
- 28:25their first terms or that there's an actual curse.
- 28:30Though I will note that several of these viewpoints I am highlighting came from 2013, so
- 28:35they may have changed since then.
- 28:36But couple of the people that would say the second term curse theory sucks or is a meh
- 28:42concept at least.
- 28:44Nate Silver, statistician, founder of 538.
- 28:48To quote him, my view then is that the idea of the second term curse is sloppy as an
- 28:55analytical concept.
- 28:56There is certainly a historical tendency for presidents, presidents who are in a second term
- 29:01to become less popular, but some of this reflects reversion to the mean.
- 29:06Again, this idea that their first term was so great, and that's why they got a second term.
- 29:12But it's hard to top the 1st term, so the 2nd term is gonna look worse in comparison,
- 29:17generally speaking, because they're usually not gonna have 2 incredible terms to point to.
- 29:23They're gonna run into some sort of roadblock.
- 29:26Michael Burrowan, historian, commentator, and one of the authors of the biennial almanac of
- 29:32American politics.
- 29:34Quote from him, 2nd term problems results in more often from the failure to adjust to
- 29:39changed circumstances and unanticipated challenges.
- 29:42More of basically the president doing it to himself, the the having a worse second term
- 29:49than a first term.
- 29:52So, really, has nobody to blame but himself.
- 29:54Now some people would still call that a curse, but in any case, Michael Barone is kind of
- 30:00skeptical
- 30:00of that concept.
- 30:02Now, those who would say the 2nd term curse
- 30:04is real or at least has some merit, you have Ron, and I hope hoping I'm saying this right,
- 30:10Fauciu, political analyst, newsletter writer, and pollster.
- 30:15He says, for starters, popular mandates tend to dissipate over time, and public familiarity
- 30:21tends to curdle into boredom or contempt.
- 30:242nd terms often lack purpose and are tarnished by missteps, scandals, and hubris.
- 30:30So at least in his eyes, it seems that the second term curse theory has some merit and
- 30:39data backing it.
- 30:41And then there was a 2013 Economist article for presidents, and using a chart, from there for
- 30:48so for presidents from 1901 to 2009, and that chart reports that second terms for presidents
- 30:55in that time frame saw noticeably worse performance in various economic indicators,
- 31:00including industrial production, federal debt, GDP, the stock market, household income, and
- 31:07real house prices.
- 31:09Real meaning if you were to compare house prices, you know, regardless of, when you're
- 31:17accounting for inflation, real house prices were worth less in 2nd terms.
- 31:25So it seems the jury is still out as to whether there is truly a second term curse, but never
- 31:31go ask some helpful insights into second term performance for presidents compared to their
- 31:371st terms.
- 31:38And that's gonna do it for this episode of the podcast.
- 31:42Let's end off on a random fact of the day.
- 31:46So today's random fact of
- 31:48the day, Donald Trump joined Grover Cleveland as
- 31:52the only presidents to serve nonconsecutive terms in US history.
- 31:55But did you know quite a few other prominent offices in American politics have also seen
- 32:01nonconsecutive term occupants as well.
- 32:05There's a lot of those that we can point to, but just some examples here.
- 32:10Some of the examples include the following.
- 32:12For speakers of the US House, we've had 7 people that have served non consecutive terms
- 32:18as the speaker of the US House.
- 32:21The very first speaker, who is also the 3rd speaker, Frederick Muilenburg.
- 32:27Then we also had Henry Clay, who is a prominent political figure in his time beyond just being
- 32:33a speaker, also a a presidential candidate at least once or twice.
- 32:40He had 3 different stints as a speaker.
- 32:43There was also John w Taylor, Thomas b Reed, Sam Rayburn, who is one of the most
- 32:49consequential speakers in US history.
- 32:51He had 3 different stints as speaker.
- 32:54And interspersed between his stints was Joseph w Martin junior.
- 32:58And then the most recent nonconsecutively serving speaker of the US House, Nancy Pelosi,
- 33:05Supreme Court Justices, Despite being lifetime appointments, there have been a couple members
- 33:11that have served non executive terms, and both also became chief justice upon their second
- 33:17stint.
- 33:18We had John Rutledge, who was one of the original SCOTUS justices, Supreme Court of the
- 33:23United States, and the 2nd chief justice of the United States, although
- 33:28did not serve long in that,
- 33:33capacity at all.
- 33:35He, in fact, I think was about 4 months as a chief justice, and then when he served as just
- 33:40an associate justice, it was only a couple years, so
- 33:43he didn't serve all that long in the Supreme Court.
- 33:47And then we also had Charles Evans Hughes, who was chief justice during part of the Herbert
- 33:53Hoover presidency and for much of the Franklin Roosevelt presidency.
- 33:59And then lastly, a bunch of governors, including Walter j Hickle for Alaska.
- 34:05He had about 20 REM years between stints.
- 34:09A handful of Alabama governors served nonconsecutive terms, including George Wallace,
- 34:14who had three different stints.
- 34:17You may recognize that name as an ardent segregationist who stood on the steps of the
- 34:22University of Alabama to prevent black students from attending the school, although he at least
- 34:28supposedly renounced his segregationist views later on during his life.
- 34:35Jerry Brown of California, he had about 28 years between stints.
- 34:39And then Terry Branstad of Iowa.
- 34:42He is actually the longest serving governor in US history, not just Iowa history, but in all
- 34:48of US history, serving from 1983 to 1999, and then again from 2011 to 2017.
- 34:55So that is going to do it for today's podcast.
- 35:00As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 35:02Please like, comment, subscribe, share with your networks and your friends and family, any
- 35:10and even any random strangers that you know.
- 35:12Share it
- 35:13with them, please.
- 35:13And, links in
- 35:15the show notes for my Facebook, LinkedIn, my book, why independence rarely win elections and
- 35:20how they could become more repetitive.
- 35:23And Matchmaker FM Profile, where you can have me as a guest on your podcast or possibly even
- 35:30be a guest on my podcast.
- 35:33And that's gonna do it.
- 35:35So as as always, thank you again for listening.
- 35:38And until next time,
- 35:40take care.