Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / WTKE: Beyond the Annual Review -- Transforming Performance Management
Transcript
- 0:09Hello, and welcome to Working Together with Kelly Elkins. I'm your host,
- 0:12Kelly Elkins, your Chief Operating Officer for MaineHealth.
- 0:15In this podcast series, I will be joined each episode by guests who are participating
- 0:20on teams focused on how we can support and enhance how we work together across MaineHealth
- 0:26so that we can achieve our vision of working together so that our communities
- 0:30are the healthiest in America.
- 0:32In particular, we will highlight work we are doing in further development of
- 0:35our operating model for MaineHealth and how we are creating structure and processes
- 0:39that make it easier for you to do your work.
- 0:42Today's episode is titled, Beyond the Annual Review -- Transforming Performance Management.
- 0:48Today's conversation is about something that touches every one of us across
- 0:52MaineHealth, how we define, support, and recognize performance.
- 0:57Over the past year, we've listened closely to feedback from our care teams,
- 1:01leaders, and HR partners.
- 1:03What we heard was clear, people want more meaningful and timely feedback,
- 1:07clearer goals, and a process that feels fair, consistent, and actually helps
- 1:12them grow, not just something that happens once a year.
- 1:15At the same time, healthcare organizations across the country are moving toward more continuous.
- 1:22Coaching-focused performance management, emphasizing regular check-ins and development
- 1:28over retrospective annual reviews.
- 1:31Today, we're going to talk about how MaineHealth is evolving our approach,
- 1:35what's changing, why it matters, and what it means for you as either a leader or a care team member.
- 1:43To join me in my conversation today is my guest, Ryan Polly,
- 1:47Vice President, Inclusion and Leadership Development for MaineHealth.
- 1:51Welcome back to the podcast, Ryan. Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:54So, Ryan, big topic here in terms of performance, not just management,
- 2:00but really that process to get that meaningful feedback.
- 2:04And historically, we've done that intentionally once a year with the annual review process.
- 2:11And we know we have pockets of leaders who do this differently,
- 2:15maybe throughout the year.
- 2:17But a lot of folks maybe only get to have that conversation that one time where
- 2:21they go a little deeper and say.
- 2:23We want, I think, more and better for our care team in this space.
- 2:27So I would love for you to start maybe at a higher level to go a little deeper
- 2:34into what prompted us to really rethink how we might approach performance management in the future.
- 2:42Yeah, absolutely. And a lot of it, you know, you said in your intro,
- 2:45a big part of it was just feedback.
- 2:47As we look at the engagement results year over year, we consistently see that,
- 2:51our care team really want to have more meaningful conversations and clarity
- 2:55of, you know, where they can focus their time to have the biggest outcomes.
- 2:59A lot of conversation around feeling like they want the work to connect to something
- 3:04more meaningful, something bigger.
- 3:07How do they connect to the strategic plan? These kinds of things were pretty
- 3:10consistently themes. And so we put together a group of folks to start to look
- 3:14at that, really starting a few years ago.
- 3:17And we did several focus groups across both our workforce, as well as our leadership,
- 3:23as well as we sent out a survey.
- 3:25Pretty much universally, what we heard from everyone was, yes,
- 3:29we want more meaningful conversation. Yes, we want check-ins more regularly.
- 3:33We don't want to only hear about our progress once a year after the fact.
- 3:38We'd really like an opportunity to know, am I on track or not throughout the year?
- 3:42And so really, that was the precipice to putting together our plan.
- 3:47Again, over the last few years, we worked on doing things like what are the,
- 3:52you just mentioned the industry trends, both in healthcare and outside of healthcare.
- 3:56Where have other organizations moved? And more importantly, how have they seen
- 4:01that that move is successful?
- 4:03We didn't want to just follow an organization just because we wanted to make
- 4:06sure what we do will have success. So we did all that deep dive research,
- 4:10and we have put together the plan that we'll be moving forward with this year.
- 4:14Why don't we get right into it? So what is the plan? Paint the future for us. Yeah.
- 4:19And again, so a lot of it you said. So I think when you think about retroactive
- 4:23versus proactive, so it starts at the beginning of the sort of,
- 4:27quote, annual review process. That's not going to go away. It's just that we're going to augment it.
- 4:32So folks will have that review and they'll have an opportunity to really set meaningful goals.
- 4:38So the shift we're going to make is now people may or may not set goals.
- 4:42You mentioned it's some leaders do that, some leaders don't.
- 4:45But that will be really a standard process is everyone will have an opportunity
- 4:49to set goals with line of sight to the five foundational commitments of the
- 4:54organization, to the strategic plan and the direction we're all headed.
- 4:59The goal is to sort of have us rowing the boat the same way, right?
- 5:03And to make sure everyone feels connected to those larger goals.
- 5:06So that's where it starts. They're going to set goals and have that really goal-driven
- 5:10discussion with their leader.
- 5:11So it's not arbitrary. It's not like, I want to just go do this thing.
- 5:15It's a discussion to make sure those goals make sense. And the leader certainly
- 5:19needs to look across everyone that reports to them to ensure the goals are all
- 5:23sort of syncing up in alignment within the department or unit that that leader leads.
- 5:28So that's the beginning. In addition to that, then there will be more regular
- 5:33check-ins. So we can use the word triannual or three check-ins in that year.
- 5:37Certainly certain leaders may do that more often, but there'll be a structured
- 5:42process, that additional couple check-ins.
- 5:45And those structured processes are meant to be relatively short.
- 5:48We're not talking 90-minute conversations. We're talking, you know,
- 5:5115 to 20 minutes that's very focused
- 5:54so that folks can understand how am I doing with my goal, what sort of help
- 5:59do I need, and what kind of development opportunities do I need to just continue to grow.
- 6:04And so that becomes the basis of those annual reviews. So then the next year
- 6:09it would be, how did we do on those goals? Where did we get stuck?
- 6:13But it's a continuous coaching and feedback loop as opposed to the annual sort
- 6:17of check the box that some people feel we have today.
- 6:20I think in addition to that, it's really around continuous feedback towards
- 6:24those of us who are sort of managing that process, what's working, what's not.
- 6:28Everything will be in in-force, so it's digital.
- 6:32And even those check-ins as they fill them out will populate the annual review.
- 6:37So there'll be less sort of paperwork, which is something that we heard both
- 6:41from workforce and leaders would be a preference. Nice.
- 6:44We're using the term what versus how. Yeah. And so with what versus how,
- 6:49basically what we're saying is what the leader does, or not just leader,
- 6:54anybody, what we do is as important as how we get it done.
- 6:58And so that'll be another shift we make, meaning I can drive my goal,
- 7:03but am I doing it in alignment with our values and in collaboration with my partners in the space?
- 7:08So both of those things are sort of equally measured. Well, that was going to
- 7:11be my question, which is the
- 7:15annual review process, which will be a part of it because we use that to help inform things like,
- 7:23merit and other elements of performance.
- 7:27We're not moving away from the job description itself, right?
- 7:32It's really the combination of what's expected of you in your daily work plus
- 7:37how you execute, right, and live out, and I think using the values example.
- 7:44Any further way to unpack that for folks? So it's not just about these goals
- 7:49you set, right? It's going to be a couple of other elements that are part of
- 7:54the bigger conversation.
- 7:56Yeah, so the what would be, you know, depending on whether you're in a leadership
- 8:00position or not, might look a little bit different.
- 8:02But it's essentially, what is the essential things I need to do to sort of do
- 8:07my job well, right? We all need to do the job we've been hired to do.
- 8:11So that's sort of baseline. That's what I'm expected to do.
- 8:14And then how do I help drive the organization toward these larger successes?
- 8:18That's the other piece of the what. That's the goals that I'm going to set.
- 8:21Because it could be really easy for me to think this makes sense.
- 8:24But then when the leader looks across the board, it's like, well,
- 8:27that might not make sense. Right. Because it's not all connected. So that's the what.
- 8:31And then the how really is our values. And for leaders, it's our leadership
- 8:35competencies. But it's in, am I doing that at the expense of my peers?
- 8:41Yeah. I can be very successful.
- 8:43That way or with my peers in collaboration, with respect and partnership and all these other things.
- 8:49And so both, you know, historically, we may have weighed more heavily on the
- 8:54what, but now we're going to have an equal weight and balance on both of those. Excellent.
- 8:59So I want to talk a little bit more about the check-ins. I think you can come
- 9:03from both perspectives here. So one,
- 9:06If you're a leader thinking about the check-in process, but even a care team
- 9:10member, how do we really ensure that those check-ins are truly meaningful conversations
- 9:16and don't just become a transaction? I'm checking the box.
- 9:20I needed to do this three times, and I got to fill this form out in N4.
- 9:25How do we avoid the latter?
- 9:27And for both parties, right? Like this meeting isn't just about the leader.
- 9:31It's about the care team members. It's about both, I feel.
- 9:34Oh, it's absolutely about bull. I mean, it's going to start with a lot of training.
- 9:38So, you know, we're going to
- 9:39be rolling training through those who are starting the process this year.
- 9:43They're eligible for training that really starts this month.
- 9:46And that's number one, teaching them not just the tools that we're going to
- 9:51have accessible to them, but also helping support them in learning how to do
- 9:55what you just said, right?
- 9:56There's a big difference between, I'm going to sit down and have my form and
- 10:00just check the box as we go, and turning the conversation into one that's really
- 10:04centering the person receiving the conversation or receiving the review.
- 10:10And so there's definitely some upskilling we all need to do.
- 10:13I would say for care team members, it's really around being able to understand
- 10:19what to expect from those conversations and have the willingness and comfort
- 10:23to say to their leader, hey, I don't think we're following this process.
- 10:26I'd like to get a little bit more. So I think that the feedback has to go both directions.
- 10:31We'll certainly monitor the process. We'll do some focus groups about a year
- 10:36in, what's working, what's not, because continuous improvement isn't just about
- 10:40this process. It's about all the processes we roll out, right?
- 10:43And if we find that it becomes a check the box, we'll try to understand how
- 10:47do we better support leaders.
- 10:49But I think it's going to start right now with let's train them up and make
- 10:52sure that expectation is very clear that it's not a checkbox and then see how we do.
- 10:58And I think we've talked about it throughout, but really reinforcing from a
- 11:02care team member's perspective, what will feel different or better than perhaps
- 11:08the experience they have today?
- 11:11I think that for care team, when they began to receive this review process,
- 11:17you know, what the biggest feedback they gave us was, I just don't feel like it's meaningful.
- 11:22I just don't feel like the process really matters. It's just a check the box.
- 11:27So I think that the shift will be, wow, I'm more connected to the work of the
- 11:33organization. And I can see where my role, regardless of where I sit, impacts patient care.
- 11:40And that's why I work at a health care center anyway.
- 11:42So that should give our care team a much more positive, meaningful connection
- 11:49to our organizational strategies and outcomes.
- 11:52It'll also give them a more positive and meaningful connection to their leader.
- 11:56Because in many cases conversations with leaders become really focused on perhaps
- 12:02you know this one thing as opposed to the breadth of that care team members
- 12:06contributions so that's what we would we would expect we'd also expect care team to feel like.
- 12:12They're getting the feedback they need yeah so they're not surprised no one
- 12:15should be surprised at the end of a year review process so this should be a okay yep i'm on track
- 12:20maybe i'm not let me course correct right but it's it's that iterative coaching
- 12:25conversation that we do feel the care team members will really appreciate.
- 12:29This is a big change. How are we going to do this? All at once,
- 12:33big bang. Will it be a rollout? Will it be phased, waves?
- 12:39How are we going to approach this? I will say that we considered the rip the
- 12:43bandaid off approach and recognized that something of this importance,
- 12:48we really want to make sure it does stick in the organization.
- 12:51It goes back to your question around how do we make sure that it doesn't become a check the box.
- 12:57In order to make sure it doesn't become a check the box, we also need to make
- 13:00sure leaders can adopt their behaviors and we can adopt the process if necessary.
- 13:06So we are going to roll out in a phased approach. This coming year,
- 13:10directors and above will start the process.
- 13:13So all directors will receive the new process and those who have directors reporting
- 13:19to them will be going through, you know, holding the process for them.
- 13:23There's a couple of reasons we're starting with that level, mostly because we
- 13:27need the directors to really understand how to set well-written goals,
- 13:32make sure the goals are really driving forward,
- 13:35and to experience the process themselves so that when they go to turn it around
- 13:39with their leaders and the staff that report through them, they're going to be able to do that.
- 13:42They've got a good understanding of what works and what doesn't work.
- 13:45We'll also take that group, receive feedback from them, and then that feedback
- 13:49will roll into the bigger rollout when we get to everybody else.
- 13:52So for CARE team members listening to this podcast, this first year,
- 13:56they might feel like nothing's happening because we do need to sort of upskill
- 14:00our leaders, but assure everyone listening that it's going to hit everybody
- 14:06within the next few years.
- 14:07And if there's folks who have an interest in giving feedback along the way, we'd love to hear it.
- 14:12Yeah. Well, you know, one, I love that this really originated from the feedback
- 14:19we received directly from our care team members.
- 14:22And, you know, that's why folks sharing their voice, whether it's in an annual
- 14:28survey or in town halls or huddles, the voices really matter and we take it very seriously.
- 14:35And this is, I think, a place that done very well and with everyone fully engaging
- 14:42really has the potential to just amplify our strength as a system and ultimately
- 14:49how we deliver care for our patients and our communities.
- 14:52Absolutely. And I think that's the big piece, right? It's really about making
- 14:56sure the work we do connects to something meaningful and the opportunity to
- 15:01give feedback. Sometimes we give feedback and.
- 15:04In a survey and might feel like we're not seeing change quickly.
- 15:08And hopefully people hearing this process can see it takes a while to make big
- 15:11changes like this, right?
- 15:12So it was feedback we've received over the years, and it's taken two years to
- 15:16get to the point of let's roll out, because we want it to be really meaningful.
- 15:21You don't rush this kind of change.
- 15:23But we are, to your point, we are listening and figuring out how to make changes as we go.
- 15:29Awesome. Well, one, thank you for being a champion and executive sponsor of
- 15:34this work and really excited to see this start to emerge over the next year.
- 15:41And I think even though our all care team members won't necessarily feel the
- 15:46change, the first kind of go around because it really is oriented around some of our leadership.
- 15:52I think they'll hear about it from their leaders, and I'm hoping folks will
- 15:56be excited when it's time for them to move into the model.
- 16:00So thank you so much, Ryan, for joining us again on the podcast and really bringing
- 16:05forward this amazing journey and evolution to getting us beyond an annual review,
- 16:11but really a performance-oriented culture.
- 16:14Absolutely. You're welcome. Thanks for having me. Absolutely. Thank you.
- 16:17Well, I hope that you found this episode informative and provides a deeper insight
- 16:21into one of our major areas of focus as we continue to enhance how we work together as MaineHealth
- 16:27to achieve our vision of working together so that our communities are the healthiest in America.
- 16:33If you have ideas for topics for
- 16:35future podcasts, please email those to workingtogetheratmainehealth.org.
- 16:41Thank you and have a blessed day.