Latest / Journey to the Fringe / But who will blow the whistle for the whistleblowers?
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:11Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, blowing the whistle on the mistreatment of
- 0:16whistle blowers.
- 0:17Chelsea, that actually is the episode that we're doing.
- 0:20I just thought it would make a good opener.
- 0:22You really did.
- 0:24Blew it out of the water.
- 0:26The weird segue from coming out just after the episode on disclosure and that UFO coming
- 0:32in 2027 where they're talking about whistle blowers being uneasy coming forward so they
- 0:37had to submit it anonymously.
- 0:39Well, I guess what we're going to be going over is stories why these people might feel
- 0:44bad coming forward as whistle blowers, that something might happen to them.
- 0:48We're going to talk about people who apparently committed suicide in the process of blowing
- 0:53the whistle on a corporation that they worked for.
- 0:56Okay, I'm ready for it.
- 0:58I believe I have five examples of this happening.
- 1:01What can you don't know?
- 1:02It's either five or six.
- 1:03I can't remember off the top of my head.
- 1:05It's a script that doesn't have the numbers at the top.
- 1:08You would think it would but hey.
- 1:11I limited it to everything 2000 onwards.
- 1:15Some less recent, some more recent.
- 1:17Not all of them are going to necessarily have suicide not as the highest likelihood of what
- 1:23happened but nonetheless it is always odd when people come forward and then mysteriously
- 1:28they end up not being able to come forward anymore.
- 1:30That's true.
- 1:31Can I just ask a quick question?
- 1:33Yeah, go ahead.
- 1:34Do you be a whistleblower?
- 1:36For doing this episode or do you just mean like in general would I be a whistleblower
- 1:39if I got information?
- 1:40Yeah, if you got information like what would it take for you to become a whistleblower?
- 1:45I mean it really depends on the situation and is it harming somebody I think is always
- 1:50the biggest thing.
- 1:52Do you whistleblow if you knew UFOs existed?
- 1:55That's not whistleblowing though.
- 1:58You fabricated a document saying you selected all this whistleblower testimony.
- 2:04The important thing with a whistleblower is normally should be handled through a proper
- 2:08hierarchy but it's not being handled correctly so you have to go elsewhere to deal with it.
- 2:14Whether that be the government, the police, a competitor, the media, you need to go outside
- 2:19of your normal hierarchy to deal with it.
- 2:22I think that's an easy enough explanation of what a whistleblower is.
- 2:25Okay, when I hear that I don't think of UFO people as whistleblowers then because they're
- 2:30not trying to go through proper channels to like fix something.
- 2:34Like when you say that I think you're trying to fix something.
- 2:36Well generally that is what you should be doing as a whistleblower.
- 2:40They are trying to fix something.
- 2:41I guess if you're doing it for the UFO purposes you're saying that how we're handling this
- 2:45and the secrecy is the problem so they can't whistleblow through their hierarchy because
- 2:50it is secrecy in itself that is their issue with it.
- 2:54Does that make sense?
- 2:55Yeah, this is all very good conversation that I need to deal my way through right now.
- 3:01And that does bring up a question is if you're anonymously doing it are you really blowing
- 3:05a whistle?
- 3:06Because I find that is an odd way to do it.
- 3:08If there's no evidence outside of an anonymous whistleblower to show that there's a wrong
- 3:13doing that needs to be fixed.
- 3:14That's true but it makes me take pause if it's something bad enough that might cause
- 3:22a big company to lose money or something like that.
- 3:27Something that somebody wants to keep secret that would give me pause to not do either whistleblow
- 3:35or give my name.
- 3:37I should also say that just because you're whistleblowing doesn't mean that any illegal
- 3:41activities have actually taken place.
- 3:43You may just disagree with the practice that is at hand.
- 3:47You may incorrectly understand what you actually saw or are saying and it may actually not
- 3:53be any issue or it just might not be something that you agree with.
- 3:56It's not wrong.
- 3:58It's not illegal but it's something that you don't ethically agree with.
- 4:02Okay.
- 4:03An example might be hiring practices and just saying that we only hire people from Yale
- 4:07that's not something publicly disclosed.
- 4:09You can say that.
- 4:10There's actually nothing legally wrong with that.
- 4:13Or would I whistleblow something like that?
- 4:16You might say that to the media and say like look I feel like this is a discriminatory
- 4:20practice.
- 4:21This is something that people should know about and hey that's not actually something that
- 4:24you can't be discriminated against weirdly enough not being educated in the right place.
- 4:28Although that brings up a whole issue with the rich being able to get jobs.
- 4:32Let's leave that out there.
- 4:33Okay, I think this provided me a lot of clarity going into episode about whistleblowing.
- 4:38And of course where can any whistleblower episodes start but the Enron crisis of the
- 4:44early 2000s.
- 4:45Chelsea, you've heard of Enron, right?
- 4:48Yeah, they're the ones in the that oh no we haven't covered him in so long.
- 4:53What's his name?
- 4:54Lawyer.
- 4:55You're thinking of Exxon?
- 4:56Oh, okay.
- 4:57No, Enron also is an energy company.
- 5:01Enron famously crashed hard in the early 2000s when it turns out that they were cooking
- 5:06their books to make it look like they were incredibly profitable by basically shifting
- 5:10all of their losses off to a bunch of shell companies to make it look like they're unprofitable
- 5:15and it turns out they were not.
- 5:17Some people ended up going to jail for this huge deal.
- 5:19And spoiler alert, there's going to be a lot of death in these stories and basically the
- 5:23first person's name that I say in every story, they're going to die.
- 5:26So just don't get too attached.
- 5:27Okay, well thanks for spoiling the whole episode.
- 5:30I won't get too attached to these first people.
- 5:33John Clifford Baxter was an Enron executive when the company's massive criminal activities
- 5:37were discovered.
- 5:38By the way, you should know it's illegal to cook your books to make you look more profitable
- 5:42than you are for a publicly traded company.
- 5:45That should go without saying, but that's incredibly illegal.
- 5:49I appreciate that.
- 5:50But like, rich person illegal, not poor person illegal.
- 5:53That's a different thing.
- 5:54Okay, I could never commit it.
- 5:56That's okay.
- 5:57Earlier, he have reportedly challenged Enron's management team, including CEO Jeff Skilling
- 6:02about the company's corrupt transactions and then resigned in protest.
- 6:05Congress initiated hearings to investigate Enron.
- 6:09Baxter was considered to be crucial to the case because his close relationship to Enron
- 6:13CEO could have provided valuable insights into the company's criminal activities.
- 6:17But two weeks before he was set to testify, Baxter was found in his car with a gunshot
- 6:22wound to the head.
- 6:23He said the death was a suicide, but many details of Baxter's death did raise doubts
- 6:27about that conclusion.
- 6:28And this is weird.
- 6:29I'm going to go through this article that I found from that time, and then we're going
- 6:34to go through the Wiki article right after that just to kind of give you a balance of
- 6:38what they look like.
- 6:39I'm interested.
- 6:40I feel like the Wiki article is going to be very contradictory.
- 6:44And weirdly enough, it's going to cite the article that we read for what they're saying.
- 6:49So let's just follow along with that.
- 6:51On the morning of January 25th, he was found in his car shot dead.
- 6:55Police were criticized for calling it a suicide before investigating, so they kept the case
- 6:59open.
- 7:00The fact that it's still open more than two months later has made the cliff Baxter
- 7:03case prime fodder for murder conspiracy theories.
- 7:06Reported CBS News correspondent Cheryl Atkinson adding to the mystery as a letter, perhaps
- 7:10a suicide note that Baxter's wife is fighting to keep private.
- 7:13Groups like the Texas Freedom of Information Foundation want at least part of it made public.
- 7:17Quote, I believe very strongly that Enron is mentioned in it, and quote, said Joel White,
- 7:21the group's attorney.
- 7:22More questions are raised in police autopsy and lab reports obtained by CBS News.
- 7:27Police won't talk while the case is open, so CBS News asked two experts, Independent
- 7:31Coroner, Ciro Watt and former homicide detective Bill Wagner to review the reports.
- 7:36While suicide appears likely, both experts say the document's making it impossible to
- 7:40discount foul play.
- 7:41Asked why he couldn't rule out murder, Wagner said quote, because murder can be made to
- 7:45look like a suicide.
- 7:47Someone who is knowledgeable about forensics can very well have the ability to stage a
- 7:51murder, commit a murder, and stage it to look as if it was a suicide, understanding what
- 7:55the police are going to be looking for, end quote.
- 7:58The experts found several things highly unusual.
- 8:00First, the Peel Your Ammunition, not regular bullets, but something called rat shot.
- 8:05Quote, this kind of ammunition cannot be easily or readily traced back to the gun from which
- 8:09it was fired, end quote explained Wacht.
- 8:12Quote, it's not as frequently used by people for any reason.
- 8:15It's not the type of ammunition one finds in guns, it has a specific purpose, shooting
- 8:18at snakes and rodents in order to get a distribution pattern of the small pellets contained within
- 8:23the nose portion of the bullet.
- 8:25It's not something that a person is likely to have and to use if they intend to kill
- 8:29themselves, end quote said Wacht.
- 8:31Other unanswered questions include mysterious wounds on one hand and unexplained shards of
- 8:36glass in Baxter's shirt.
- 8:37All reasons still look deeper to rule out murder, but Wagner says the laring police
- 8:41errors may make it harder to close the books on the Baxter case.
- 8:44First, nobody wrapped the hands to preserve evidence.
- 8:46Quote, when the body finally did arrive for the autopsy, the hands hadn't even been
- 8:51bagged, end quote said Wagner.
- 8:53Quote, I'm just amazed frankly that the hands were not bagged.
- 8:56From what I've seen looking at the vehicle, it doesn't appear that they have fingerprinted
- 8:59it either, end quote continued Wagner.
- 9:01Quote, the police narrative is vague for this type of investigation, supporting to get a
- 9:05timeline of the events that took place through the course of the investigation that appears
- 9:09to be lacking in the original report from the crime scene.
- 9:12Quote, being able to piece together what was done when, it's very difficult to understand
- 9:17the events that took place and how they unfolded from that report, end quote said Wagner.
- 9:22The gun and other evidence were moved before photos were taken.
- 9:25The body was moved as well.
- 9:26There's a puzzling mention of blood outside the car from someone laying Baxter on the
- 9:30ground.
- 9:31Wagner says that only should have happened if rescuers put him out to revive him, but
- 9:35even that scenario doesn't add up.
- 9:36The body is back in the car when the funeral home arrives, quote, and that's something
- 9:40that is not explained in the police report.
- 9:42I think there were some very important things omitted from the original investigation report
- 9:46that should have been included in it.
- 9:48I would like to have known what were the first couple things the fire department did to treat
- 9:53the victim allegedly as he was sitting in the car and from that point, how did they change
- 9:58the initial crime scene?
- 9:59What was moved?
- 10:00Did they remove the body from the vehicle?
- 10:02It's actually unclear how they treated the actual scene, end quote said Wagner.
- 10:06Incredibly even though an autopsy is required by law, none was ordered by the time that
- 10:10the decision was reversed, Baxter's body was being processed at a funeral home.
- 10:14Coroner says police still won't tell her exactly who handled and who saw the body before it
- 10:19finally reached her and won't even give her routine information.
- 10:23The official finding on Baxter's death may well end up being suicide, but for now this
- 10:27death certificate remains unsigned and at least one provocative question is left permanently
- 10:31unanswered.
- 10:32What exactly Cliff Baxter would have told investigators about the biggest corporate
- 10:36scandal in history?
- 10:37So he didn't actually whistle blow anything, he was just going to, he was set to testify.
- 10:44This was in another article as well when talking with a former business associate two days
- 10:48before his death, Baxter said that he might need a body art after agreeing to assist in
- 10:52the Enron investigation.
- 10:54But this is now from the Wikipedia article which gives different information.
- 10:58Which is so weird because you can't at all edit Wikipedia.
- 11:02First off, very important, Baxter would suit personally when the Enron stuff was going
- 11:06on for $30 million after the bankruptcy of Enron due to his sale of $30 million worth
- 11:12of Enron stocks in the months prior to Enron's bankruptcy in December of 2001.
- 11:17Fortune magazine writer Bethany McLean described Baxter in Enron the smartest guys in the room
- 11:21as being a good deal maker but also being a manic depressive.
- 11:26Skilling stated before Congress in February of 2002 that Baxter had visited Skilling shortly
- 11:31after Enron had declared bankruptcy and was heartbroken by what had happened to Enron.
- 11:35In his testimony, Skilling quoted Baxter saying quote, they're calling us child molesters
- 11:40that will never wash off end quote.
- 11:42Whoa, they're linking back to that article with the stuff?
- 11:46No, that was before Congress.
- 11:47Okay.
- 11:48And sorry, this is in the Wikipedia.
- 11:50This part is where it links back to the article.
- 11:52I will tell you when it links back to the article.
- 11:54On January 25th, 2002, after agreeing to testify before congressional committees in February
- 11:59of 2002, after being subpoenaed regarding his knowledge and evidence of the scandal
- 12:03of Enron, Baxter was found dead in his black Mercedes in Sugarland, Texas with a self-inflicted
- 12:08gunshot wound.
- 12:09The ammunition used was a Glazer safety slug, which at the time was misreported as a snake
- 12:14shot.
- 12:15That's the added context.
- 12:16That cites back to the story we read, which doesn't bring that up at all.
- 12:20No, it didn't.
- 12:21Although they could be saying that that was misreported that it was a snake shot in that
- 12:25article.
- 12:26I can't quite understand what they meant by that.
- 12:28Well, usually when you're citing something, you're citing it on Wikipedia to the source
- 12:33that you found.
- 12:34Yeah, which now that I'm reading it might be saying that this article misreported as
- 12:37a snake shot.
- 12:38Okay.
- 12:39So that makes a little more sense.
- 12:40But in any event, there are some weird peculiarities with that story.
- 12:45Definitely.
- 12:46Next up, do you remember the invasion of Iraq in 2003 and server of discontent with what
- 12:53Iraq was doing in those times?
- 12:55Oh.
- 12:56How Iraq had weapons of mass destruction.
- 12:58Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 12:59And that lead us to invade them.
- 13:00Okay, that's.
- 13:01This story has to do with that.
- 13:04In 2003, David Kelly, a weapons inspector for the British government was thrust into
- 13:08the public spotlight when BBC journalist Andrew Gilligan published their off the record conversation,
- 13:13revealing that British government's investigators had not found any weapons of mass destruction
- 13:17in Iraq, despite the Bush administration's claims otherwise.
- 13:21Uh-oh.
- 13:22Which, by the way, we never found any weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, which justified
- 13:26the war that was done there.
- 13:28Hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people died thanks to our invasion of that
- 13:32country, which Saddam Hussein was probably horrible.
- 13:35I don't think we needed to murder all those people.
- 13:37We Canada did not invade them.
- 13:40I don't think we.
- 13:41You know, I can't remember.
- 13:42I know we did Afghanistan.
- 13:43I would have to actually look, but yeah, in any event, it was a horrible war.
- 13:47I have to have my opinion on that, which was not just by in any way.
- 13:50Horrible.
- 13:51Unknown to Kelly, the journalist then published the information he had received from Kelly
- 13:54and cited him as the source.
- 13:55So this is an unbeknownst whistleblower, unbeknownst to him.
- 13:59The British and American public, if not the world altogether, was outraged by the revelation,
- 14:04which suggested that Bush administration and the British government were lying about their
- 14:07reasons for inviting Iraq.
- 14:08Kelly was summoned to appear at a committee hearing in British Parliament on July 15,
- 14:122003.
- 14:13He was rigorously questioned about his conversation with the BBC journalist and why it was revealed
- 14:17to the public.
- 14:18Around the same time, Kelly met with British Ambassador David Broucher.
- 14:21Kelly told Broucher that he had promised Iraqi officials that there would be no war if they
- 14:25cooperated, but that he would probably be found dead if Iraq were invaded.
- 14:29Two days after Kelly's testimony to the British Parliament, he was found dead outside his
- 14:34home.
- 14:35He had answered some emails that morning and then left for his morning walk.
- 14:38Kelly's body was found in the woodlands area about 1.5 kilometers from his home.
- 14:43He had ingested 29 pain pills and his left wrist was slashed with a knife he had owned
- 14:48since childhood.
- 14:49A lot of painkillers and cut his wrist.
- 14:52An investigation was launched into the suspicious circumstances surrounding his death.
- 14:55The official conclusion was that Kelly committed suicide after the announcement his medical
- 14:59reports were sealed from public view for 70 years.
- 15:02However, a series of doctors published a rebuttal of the cause of death in The Guardian,
- 15:07arguing that the cuts on Kelly's wrist would not have resulted in a fatal amount of blood
- 15:11loss.
- 15:12They also claimed that the amount of painkillers that Kelly had ingested were not enough to
- 15:15kill him.
- 15:16As a result, Dr. Andrew Watt told British authorities that he believed Kelly had been
- 15:19murdered.
- 15:20Another leader of the Conservative Party, Michael Howard and the former Liberal Democrat,
- 15:25MP Norman Baker, both thought Kelly was murdered.
- 15:28In 2007, Baker published the strange death of David Kelly in which he argued that Kelly
- 15:33did not die by suicide.
- 15:34Kelly's family expressed their displeasure at the publication.
- 15:37His sister-in-law said, quote, It's just raking over old bones.
- 15:41I can't speak for the whole family, but I've read it all.
- 15:44That is theories about Baker's death.
- 15:46Every word and I don't believe it.
- 15:48End quote.
- 15:49In December 2009, six doctors applied to the Oxford Coroner's office to reopen the
- 15:54inquest, claiming that there was insufficient evidence for Hutton's conclusion of suicide.
- 15:59Their request was turned down on legal advice, and they were informed that the evidence relating
- 16:03to Kelly's death was to be kept secret for 70 years.
- 16:07Hutton stated that he did this, quote, solely in order to protect Dr. Kelly's widow and
- 16:12daughter for the remainder of their lives, the daughters being in their 20s at the time.
- 16:17From the distress, which they would suffer from further discussion of the details of
- 16:21Dr. Kelly's death in the media, end quote.
- 16:24That doesn't happen, though.
- 16:26That it is weird.
- 16:28Both very weirdly handled.
- 16:30Next up, Chelsea, we're going to move to the wonderful world of AI.
- 16:34Okay.
- 16:35With a guy by the name of Sushir Balaji.
- 16:38Sushir Balaji spent four years as an artificial intelligence researcher at OpenAI.
- 16:42Among other projects, he was involved in gathering and organizing the internet data used to train
- 16:47GPT-4.
- 16:48I should say OpenAI is the company who makes chat GPT, a language model used by the company's
- 16:53online chatbot, chatGBT.
- 16:55He also worked on a precursor model called WebGPT.
- 16:58He left the company in August, 2024, after becoming disillusioned with its business practices.
- 17:04After leaving OpenAI, Balaji said he had been working on personal projects.
- 17:09He planned to create a nonprofit centered on machine learning and neurosciences, according
- 17:12to his mother.
- 17:13On October 23, 2024, New York Times profile, Balaji alleged that the products like chatGBT
- 17:20violated United States copyright law because they're trained on products of business competitors
- 17:25and because the chatbot's output can then imitate and substitute other products.
- 17:29He said that chatGBT and similar chatbots are ruining the commercial viability of the
- 17:34individuals and organizations who produce the data that the AI systems are trained on.
- 17:38He was quoted as saying, quote, if you believe what I believe you have to just leave the company,
- 17:44end quote.
- 17:45New York Times piece contains a summary of Balaji's essay called When Does Generative
- 17:49AI Qualify for Fair Use?
- 17:51Published on his website earlier that week.
- 17:54In the essay, he mathematically analyzed outputs of large language models such as chatGBT
- 17:58and argues that they fail the four factor test for determining fair use under US copyright
- 18:02law.
- 18:03He further suggests that the arguments could be applied to other generative artificial
- 18:07intelligences products as well.
- 18:10At the time, open AI was being sued for copyright infringement by prominent authors and publishers,
- 18:15including the New York Times.
- 18:16In a November 18, 2024 court filing, Balaji was identified by the New York Times attorneys
- 18:22as one of a number of people who might have relevant documents in the copyright case against
- 18:27open AI.
- 18:28Balaji had said that he would testify against the AI company.
- 18:32Open AI argued that its software was, quote, grounded in fair use and related international
- 18:37copyright principles that are fair for creators and support innovation and was trained on
- 18:42publicly available data, end quote.
- 18:45But on November 26, 2024, police said they found Balaji dead in his apartment in San
- 18:49Francisco when they arrived there after being requested to conduct a well-being check.
- 18:54He was 26 years old at that time.
- 18:56Police claim that there was no evidence of foul play during the initial investigation
- 19:00and the San Francisco chief medical examiner determined the death was a suicide, as has
- 19:05the San Francisco police department.
- 19:07San Francisco police have said the investigation is open and active as of January 20, 2025.
- 19:13No official documents of the medical examiner's autopsy have been released.
- 19:16The office said that they would be released once toxicology tests are completed.
- 19:21Balaji's death has prompted public and media interest, particularly given his whistleblowing
- 19:26claims and status as a custodian witness in a lawsuit against open AI.
- 19:30A spokesperson for his former employer, Open AI, said he was devastated by the news of
- 19:36Balaji's death.
- 19:37Balaji's parents and friends believe the circumstances of his death are unclear.
- 19:41His family and close friends report that he had had no history of mental health issues
- 19:46or distress and was in generally good spirits after his birthday that week.
- 19:50The parents say they hired an independent investigator to determine the cause of death.
- 19:54They have a private autopsy conducted by Dr. Joseph Cohen, which Balaji's mother said,
- 19:59quote, doesn't confirm the cause of death stated by the police, end quote.
- 20:03Balaji's parents believe their son was murdered by a firearm and have called for an FBI investigation.
- 20:09They cite evidence from the independent investigation such as a downward bullet travel path that
- 20:14would be impossible by a self-administered gunshot and unexplained evidence like a tuft of hair
- 20:19found at the scene that did not belong to Sushir.
- 20:21Balaji's mother declined to share the second autopsy with the Mercury News and Washington
- 20:26Examiner to San Francisco newspapers.
- 20:29And then a few assholes that I don't actually like but their names come up.
- 20:31Elon Musk, Tucker Carlson, California Congress and Rolcona and San Francisco Supervisor Jackie
- 20:36Fielder have publicly echoed Balaji's parents' skepticism and calls for an investigation.
- 20:41Balaji's mother discussed her son's death on Carlson's podcast, the Tucker Carlson
- 20:45show on January 15th, 2025.
- 20:47I hate that I had to bring that up, but whatever we're here.
- 20:52Doubts about the cause of death spread on social media even before Balaji's parents had
- 20:56made their public statements.
- 20:58California State University East Bay lecturer Nolan Higdon described the public discourse
- 21:02as quote baseless conspiracy theory and quote, and mentioned social media monetization schemes
- 21:07and advertising revenue as a financial incentive for social media influencers and podcasters
- 21:13of propagated and a quote end of this story.
- 21:15Because this one's still unfolding.
- 21:17Next up Chelsea, of course, none of these could be complete without us focusing in on the
- 21:22Boeing scandal.
- 21:24And I know you're aware of this one.
- 21:25I was waiting for this one to come up.
- 21:27Chelsea, did you know there are cases involved with the Boeing scandal?
- 21:31I mean cases.
- 21:32As in more than one whistleblower we're going to be talking about.
- 21:35The other ones definitely have been in the news, but this one is quite prominent, not
- 21:40at the moment, but in recent moments.
- 21:43I think Boeing is still trying to figure out how the hell they're going to be a company
- 21:46from here.
- 21:47Well, let's face it, they're just going to get bailed out by the government, but they're
- 21:50not really recovering well from this.
- 21:52They're saying a lot of pretty bad stuff.
- 21:54And people keep mysteriously dying.
- 21:56Case in point, we're going to talk about John Barnett.
- 21:58John Barnett was born February of 1962 in Mount Shasta, California.
- 22:02In 1988 he moved to Camano Island where he lived for 25 years.
- 22:06Joined Boeing in 1988 where he became a quality inspector.
- 22:10Barnett worked his way into a leading position while at the Boeing Everett factory, which
- 22:14produces the 747, 767, and 777 planes, where he said he was impressed with Boeing's attention
- 22:20to quality and safety.
- 22:21While there he developed an 11 course curriculum for training other auditors.
- 22:25From 2010 to 17 he worked as a quality control manager for Boeing's South Carolina plant,
- 22:30which produces the 787.
- 22:31Barnett blamed a culture shift between the Everett and South Carolina plants on the
- 22:35latter's management being from the military, where he said he was pressured not to document
- 22:39defects and follow non- Boeing procedures.
- 22:42He characterized the defense-based management's motto as, what we're in Charleston and we
- 22:45can do anything we want.
- 22:48And there wishes to, quote, push planes out the door, make the cash register.
- 22:51Ring, end quote.
- 22:53He later said the factory and its management, quote, the whole place smelled of French fries,
- 22:57end quote, referring to the practice power mechanics whose previous experience was in
- 23:00fast food.
- 23:01Barnett said he was demoted and removed from management in 2013, for which he filed an
- 23:05ethics complaint.
- 23:06He was reassigned by the same manager that demoted him to another department in 2015.
- 23:10In 17, Barnett filed an FAA Air 21 whistleblower complaint against Boeing with OSHA, which is
- 23:16occupational health and safety.
- 23:18In 2013, a senior manager downgraded Barnett's employment level for, quote, using email to
- 23:23express process violations, end quote, in place of face-to-face communications, which
- 23:27Barnett took to mean he shouldn't put problems in writing.
- 23:31The manager also pushed Barnett to get better at working in the gray areas and help find
- 23:35a way while maintaining compliance.
- 23:38Barnett said that management was pressuring and encouraging workers not to document defects,
- 23:42resulting in inaccurate build records, a violation of FAA regulations.
- 23:46He also said that Boeing was implementing a program that allowed mechanics to inspect
- 23:50and verify their own work, eliminating quality inspection employees altogether.
- 23:55During the investigation of a Spear AeroSystem section, with four quality inspectors, Barnett
- 23:59documented 300 defects, for which he was told they found too many defects.
- 24:05On a follow-up trip, Barnett was excluded and only two inspectors were given a truncated
- 24:09timeline that only allowed them to document 50 defects, a reduction for which they were
- 24:13given accolades.
- 24:15Barnett attributed the pressure for management to overcome production delays with the 787,
- 24:19stating that documenting defects slows down the assembly line.
- 24:23In April 2024, another quality manager in Everett, Washington, Rome Myers, who had been
- 24:27at Boeing for 30 years, told the New York Times that the airline's manufacturer re-prioritized
- 24:31schedule over quality.
- 24:33Also in April of 2024, quality engineer Sam Sellepour, Sellepour, whatever, reported similar
- 24:39issues after a 2021 delay of the 787 due to an unacceptable fuselage gap.
- 24:44Sellepour claimed that to address the flaws of the company took shortcuts that forced
- 24:49the gaps closed instead of engineering new parts.
- 24:52Sellepour has also filed a whistleblower complaint with the FAA against Boeing.
- 24:56Barnett claimed that in 2016, a senior manager installed a scrapped, dented hydraulic tube
- 25:01in a plane.
- 25:02He filed a complaint with Human Resources, Boeing stated that they had investigated and
- 25:06did not substantiate those claims.
- 25:08He raised issues of more missing defective parts to management, fearing that they had
- 25:12been installed.
- 25:13He claimed his bosses directed him to finish paperwork on missing parts without determining
- 25:17where they ended up.
- 25:18No action was taken by managers.
- 25:20Barnett claimed workers did not follow procedures to track components, allowing the loss of
- 25:25parts and later installations of defective parts.
- 25:27He stated that these installations were to prevent delays on the production line, as
- 25:31was the lack of following procedure.
- 25:33In 2017, Barnett's team found that 25% of the oxygen systems on the 787 would fail to
- 25:38send oxygen through the cylinders to passengers in the case of an emergency.
- 25:44Barnett said that his report to management was stonewalled, so he alerted the FAA.
- 25:48Boeing's internal investigation found malfunctioning oxygen masks.
- 25:52A 2017 FAA report determined that at least 53 quote non-conforming end quote parts were
- 25:57missing in order Boeing to take remedial action, which is a big deal in the airline industry.
- 26:03There's a lot more that he complains about.
- 26:06We're just going to skip down a little bit.
- 26:08In 2019, Barnett came forward to discuss numerous malpractices of Boeing with British broadcaster
- 26:13BBC, including overworking employees and not providing proper maintenance to aircrafts.
- 26:18In 2019, Barnett appeared in New York Times article raising additional quality issues
- 26:23with his former facility.
- 26:24Speaking about the metal shavings, which I skipped over, unfortunately, Boeing subsequently
- 26:29denied his allegations.
- 26:30However, a 2017 review by the FAA had upheld several of Barnett's concerns.
- 26:34It was discovered that over 50 quote non-conforming end quote plant components in the facility
- 26:39were considered missing as their location could not be found.
- 26:42In 2021, after a four year long investigation, Osser closed the whistleblower complaint in
- 26:47favor of Boeing.
- 26:48Barnett and his lawyer appealed the decision and amended the lawsuit, claiming the firm
- 26:51had quote undermined his career because he had raised safety concerns at the Charleston
- 26:55plant end quote.
- 26:57His attorney Robert Turkowitz criticized the effectiveness of whistleblower court systems
- 27:01because they do not have the power to subpoena documents from the defendant.
- 27:06In December 2021, the United States Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation
- 27:10released a whistleblower report determining that the FAA failed to administer adequate
- 27:13oversight to address concerns from Boeing and FAA whistleblowers.
- 27:17Boeing had settled a criminal charge with the United States Department of Justice in September
- 27:21of that year for conspiracy to defraud the government regarding fatal design flaws in
- 27:25the maneuvering characteristics augmentation system of the 737 MAX.
- 27:30I did not know about that.
- 27:31In early 2024, Barnett issued further warnings regarding Boeing's work culture and vehicle
- 27:37safety following Alaska Airlines flight 1282 in which a door was blown off.
- 27:44Barnett was in Charleston, South Carolina the week of March 12, 2024 for his deposition
- 27:48stemming from his 2017 whistleblower complaint against Boeing.
- 27:53Before his death, he had given a deposition and had been undergoing direct examination
- 27:57by his own legal team and cross-examination by Boeing's.
- 28:00According to a March 2024 interview with his lawyer, Brian Knowles, Barnett was supported
- 28:05to report for the third day of his deposition for further questioning but did not show up
- 28:10or respond to calls the next day.
- 28:12At 9.42 a.m. on March 9, a hotel staff member heard a gunshot.
- 28:16At 10 a.m. Barnett's attorney called the hotel asking for a wellness check.
- 28:20He was found dead shortly afterwards in the hotel parking lot in his truck with a single
- 28:24gunshot wound to the head.
- 28:26He had his legally owned pistol in his hand with his finger still on the trigger and left
- 28:31a suicide note in the passenger seat on which he wrote, quote, I can't do this any longer.
- 28:35I pray Boeing pays, end quote.
- 28:38Video surveillance showed Barnett left the hotel on the evening of March 8 but returned
- 28:42a few minutes later and reparked remaining inside his vehicle.
- 28:45No activity was observed of Barnett or his vehicle until the following morning on March
- 28:509 when at 7.20 a.m. the vehicle lights blinked on and off.
- 28:53This vehicle was found to be locked and the key fob was in Barnett's pocket.
- 28:57On March 11, the Charleston County Coroner's office characterized his death as self-inflicted.
- 29:02After requests from his family and Barnett's attorney, the Charleston Police Department
- 29:06investigated the circumstances that led to his death.
- 29:09They found Barnett to be going through a period of serious personal distress and on May 17
- 29:15they concluded that Barnett's death was a suicide related to chronic stress, anxiety,
- 29:19and post-traumatic stress disorder caused by the whistleblower case.
- 29:23There's video on the trap that you never looked.
- 29:27That's a long time though.
- 29:28He's in there for over 12 hours.
- 29:30I find that strange.
- 29:33During the investigation, the police obtained his cell phone and medical records which showed
- 29:36participation in the ongoing legal battle with Boeing exacerbated.
- 29:40Numerous mental health issues related to the whistleblower case he was suffering from.
- 29:45Fingerprint analysis found only Barnett's and a ballistic report confirmed the trajectory
- 29:49of the bullet was consistent as originating from Barnett's hand.
- 29:52As of March 12, the lawsuit against Boeing was pending, continuation under Barnett's
- 29:56estate.
- 29:57His attorney stated that the case would still go to trial in June.
- 30:01My question is, we're thinking there's ulterior motives to this but there's no one else seen
- 30:06on the video.
- 30:07That's what I'm gathering from that.
- 30:09Now we are going to go through the conspiracy theories for it though.
- 30:12Great.
- 30:13Because I'm just like what?
- 30:14Yeah.
- 30:15It seems like why would this guy be fighting so hard that all of a sudden just give up?
- 30:20That is two out of three days and it would basically be the end because that's deposition.
- 30:25You might have to talk in court but it's not going to be as hard as deposition.
- 30:28There is a conspiracy out there alleging that Boeing had assassinated Barnett, spread widely
- 30:32after a woman who identified herself as a friend of Barnett said that Barnett told her,
- 30:37quote, if anything happens to me it's not suicide, end quote.
- 30:40She said, quote, they made his death look like a suicide, end quote.
- 30:45I have no idea who this she is.
- 30:48It's just what the Wikipedia article says.
- 30:50Boeing released a statement saying, quote, we are saddened by Mr. Barnett's death and
- 30:54our thoughts are with his friends and family, end quote.
- 30:58Knowles and Turkowitz told CBS News that Barnett was in very good spirits and really looking
- 31:02forward to putting this phase of his life behind him and moving on, those being his
- 31:06lawyers.
- 31:07We didn't see any indication he would take his own life.
- 31:09No one can believe it, end quote.
- 31:11Turkowitz called for a police investigation into his death but later told Fox News that
- 31:15he did not believe Boeing had orchestrated his death.
- 31:17This family said that, quote, he was looking forward to having his day in court and hoped
- 31:21that it would force Boeing to change its culture.
- 31:24And he was suffering from PTSD and anxiety attacks as a result of being subjected to
- 31:28the hostile work environment at Boeing which he believed led to his death, end quote.
- 31:32His attorney said in a statement after the release of the coroner's report, quote, Mr.
- 31:36Barnett's last words make clear that while Boeing may not have pulled the trigger of the
- 31:40company's responsible for his death, end quote.
- 31:43It should be noted though, after this death, 10 new whistleblowers from Boeing and this
- 31:47other company that we're going to talk about end up coming forward.
- 31:50So this doesn't exactly stop anything.
- 31:52Are we going to talk about more because I know there's more deaths associated with the
- 31:58Boeing?
- 31:59I could only find the two.
- 32:00We're going to talk about Joshua Dean now.
- 32:02And there's not a nice Wikipedia story about it.
- 32:05I found a good NPR article but because it's an article that's set up in a weird way, we
- 32:09talk about the death very early on and then we get to everything else.
- 32:12Okay.
- 32:13This one's weird though because it's not a suicide.
- 32:16Interesting.
- 32:17Quote, he passed away yesterday morning and his absence will be deeply felt.
- 32:22We will always love you, end quote.
- 32:24Dean is and Carol Dean Parsons said via Facebook.
- 32:27This is Joshua Dean.
- 32:29Dean was one of the first to flag potentially dangerous defects with 737 Max Jets at Spirit
- 32:34Aero Systems, a major Boeing supplier that was spun off from the playmaker in 2005.
- 32:38Now federal investigators are looking more closely at Spirit and Boeing to understand what
- 32:42went wrong with the door panel that blew off an Alaska Airlines Boeing 737 Max in midair
- 32:47in January.
- 32:48The latest chapter in a long and troubled relationship between the two companies.
- 32:52Quote, our thoughts are with Josh Dean's family.
- 32:54This is a sudden loss and it's stunning news here and for his loved ones.
- 32:59End quote said spirit spokesman Joe Buccino in a statement.
- 33:02Dean and Barnett were both represented by the same lawyer, Brian Knowles.
- 33:07That being the last guy we just talked about.
- 33:09Quote, Josh's passing is a loss to the aviation community and the flying public.
- 33:14End quote.
- 33:15Knowles said in a statement.
- 33:16Quote, he possessed tremendous courage to stand up for what he felt was true and right
- 33:20and raised quality and safety issues.
- 33:23Aviation companies should encourage and incentivize those that do raise these concerns.
- 33:28End quote.
- 33:29Dean's mother and stepfather describe him as a studious and odd-est man, a health nut
- 33:32who rarely drank and attended church regularly.
- 33:36His career was helped by his prodigious memory and attention to detail.
- 33:40They said, quote, he was just amazing.
- 33:42He could read something and then he could just tell you word for word what he read
- 33:46days later.
- 33:47End quote said when we are Dean stepfather, Dean started feeling sick around two weeks
- 33:53prior to this story.
- 33:54I believe this was about April of 2024.
- 33:57His mother, Virginia Green, told NPR he stayed home from work for a couple of days, but things
- 34:03got worse.
- 34:04Quote, Sunday, April 21st is when I got a call from him that he was really sick and having
- 34:09trouble breathing.
- 34:10Said he went to an immediate care and they told him he had strep throat.
- 34:14End quote.
- 34:15Green said.
- 34:16Green went to check on her son at his home telling him to call her if he felt worse.
- 34:20Quote, he did call me a couple hours later, told me he was in the emergency room and he
- 34:24was scared and they found something in his lungs.
- 34:26End quote she said.
- 34:27He tested positive for influenza B. He tested positive for MRSA.
- 34:31He had pneumonia, his lungs were completely filled up and from there he just went downhill.
- 34:36End quote.
- 34:37Dean was initially treated at St. Joseph's Hospital in Wichita, but as he got worse he
- 34:41was sent to an integrist hospital in Oklahoma City.
- 34:43It was a stunning turn of events for Dean and his family.
- 34:46Green say he was very healthy.
- 34:48Green says he was very healthy.
- 34:49Someone went to the gym, ran nearly every day and was very careful about his diet.
- 34:53Quote, this was his first time ever in the hospital.
- 34:56He didn't even have a doctor because he never was sick.
- 34:59End quote she said.
- 35:00But within days, Dean's kidneys gave out and he was relying on an ECMO life support
- 35:05machine to do the work for his heart and lungs.
- 35:07The night before Dean died, Green said the medical staff in Oklahoma did a bronchoscopy
- 35:12on his lungs.
- 35:13Quote, the doctor said he'd never seen anything like this before in his life.
- 35:16His lungs were totally gummed up and like a mesh over them.
- 35:20End quote.
- 35:21Green says that she asked for an autoxy to determine exactly what killed her son.
- 35:24Results likely take months, she said.
- 35:26Quote, we're not sure what he died of.
- 35:28We know that he had a bunch of viruses, but we don't know if somebody did something to
- 35:32him or did he just get really sick.
- 35:35End quote she said.
- 35:36Dean followed his father and grandfather into the commercial aviation industry holding
- 35:39a series of jobs in the same factory in Wichita where they had both worked before.
- 35:44During two interviews in January, Dean said that spirit pressured employees not to report
- 35:48defects in order to get planes out the factory faster.
- 35:51Quote, no, I'm not saying they don't want you to go out there and inspect a job.
- 35:55You know they do.
- 35:56Dean told NPR, but if you make too much trouble, you will get the Josh treatment.
- 36:02You will get what happened to me.
- 36:04End quote, Dean told NPR.
- 36:06Dean was fired in April of last year in retaliation.
- 36:08He said for flagging improperly drilled holes in fuselages.
- 36:11Quote, I think they were sending out a message to anybody else.
- 36:15If you are too loud, we will silence you.
- 36:17End quote, Dean said.
- 36:18Dean described what he saw while working for spirit in a death position for a lawsuit
- 36:22filed by the company's shareholders who accused the company of misleading investors by attempting
- 36:26to conceal excessive numbers of defects at the Kansas factory, he was not a plaintiff in the case.
- 36:32In the shareholder lawsuit, Dean said he flagged a significant defect,
- 36:36mistrilled holes in the aft pressure bulkhead of 737 Max fuselages. Months before he was fired,
- 36:41his deposition lays out a series of pivotal dates. October 2022, in his auditor role,
- 36:47Dean realizes Spirit workers mistrilled holes on the 737 Max aft pressure bulkhead representing
- 36:53potential threat to maintaining cabin pressure during flight. The lawsuit accuses the company of
- 36:57concealing the problem. April 13, 2023, Boeing publicly reveals learning of a separate defect
- 37:03related to the tail fin fitting on certain 737 Max aircrafts. Spirit then confirms that defect.
- 37:08April 26, 2023, Spirit fires Dean, saying he failed to flag the tail issue. In his testimony,
- 37:15Dean said he told the company officials that he might have missed the tail fin defect because he
- 37:19had just discovered the problem with bulkheads and he insisted he was focused on that. August 23,
- 37:252023, yes, I couldn't focus on that other defect because you had this other defect that I was really
- 37:31focused on. August 23, 2023, Boeing announces it had found fastener holes in the aft pressure bulkhead
- 37:38on certain 737 Max airplanes that don't match its specifications, resulting in snowmen due to the
- 37:43multiple holes elongated shape. It's the problem Dean flagged 10 months earlier on the same day.
- 37:48Spirit releases a statement acknowledging the issue. The shareholder lawsuit accuses Spirit
- 37:52of concealing the bulkhead defect quote not only from investors but also apparently from Boeing
- 37:57end quote. The spirit spokesman says the company strongly disagrees with the lawsuit's allegations
- 38:02is fighting the pace in court. Boeing is currently in talks to acquire Spirit at the plane makers
- 38:07leader concede that they may have outsourced too many parts for the manufacturing chain quote did
- 38:12it go too far yeah probably did. Now it's here and now and now I've got to deal with it end quote
- 38:18Boeing CEO Dave Calhoun said in an interview with CNBC earlier this year. Boeing agreed last month to
- 38:24advance 425 million to Spirit as it works to improve its manufacturing quality. In interviews
- 38:29with NPR, Joshua Dean depicted it would be difficult to replace the experience workforce that Spirit
- 38:34lost during the COVID-19 pandemic quote the mechanics aren't as experienced neither are the
- 38:39inspectors we've just lost that end quote Dean said but even after going public with his concerns
- 38:44with spirit quality control Dean said there were reasons for optimism about the future and he said
- 38:49that CEO Patrick Shanahan it took over in late 2023 was a unique opportunity to change Spirit's
- 38:55culture for the better quote what you really want is you want someone to be able to play the hero
- 39:00end quote Dean said saying Shanahan was a chance to play the new sheriff in town quote we need to
- 39:06make sure that there is no retaliation or intimidation this culture of you're too loud you'll be moved
- 39:11or silent that's got to go end quote Dean said end of article that's what we know like that is
- 39:17super weird is it not like he just comes down with like all these ailments and dies within weeks
- 39:23I mean it can't be a coincidence something like that can't be a coincidence and be a coincidence
- 39:28but it's really weird and that's not only that two people with the same lawyer just really weird
- 39:37coincidences yeah stay away from that weird what's his name again he's not advertising it I know it
- 39:43but his clients die his last name's nobles with a K he's not talking about time traveling is he
- 39:49Brian Knowles just so that we all know oh man I'm so sad he's not president we missed a good timeline
- 39:57we missed a good president what was his name sorry I need to look that up because he's from
- 40:02Washington it's right on the tip of my tongue I know Bozzi Agu Andrew Bozzi Agu thank you that is
- 40:10terrifying all the defects yeah that they're finding but yeah that that has to be one of the
- 40:18bigger ones right now with the whistleblowers that one's still going on and well the open AI one is
- 40:23just in its infancy so that one could be huge like that whole thing if they can't use copyrighted
- 40:29information to train AI they can't make AI yeah the implications of that are pretty huge as well
- 40:36didn't even think about that one AI would be recent and I do have some updates on them too but
- 40:42those will come out leaked through the fringy minis when I'm not feeling sad okay which is never so
- 40:47so but yeah Chelsea those are my whistleblowers that's it it actually weirdly started out as an
- 40:54assassination episode but ended up here I don't know how well sorry I do know how and it has to
- 41:00do with Luigi Mangione being found who's Luigi again it's the guy who shot the United Healthcare
- 41:05CEO allegedly right okay because I started the episode with the intentions of covering unanswered
- 41:12assassinations in corporate work but that one was answered and it kind of killed a lot of that
- 41:16episode that makes me not want a whistleblow because I don't want to be assassinated I'm
- 41:21still confused about the one in the trek though nobody saw anything I know it is weird that you
- 41:27would pick that time but also depositions can be very emotional like they're asking you very hard
- 41:32questions and you have to answer them I'm leaning more that way I think I don't know I also don't
- 41:38feel like it's a coincidence so but in invent they are all weird and that's what we're here for is the
- 41:43weird and and trans praise me to trans ma I have been Taylor here with Chelsea we are journey to the
- 41:50fringe thank you all for listening we'll see you next week hi thank you for listening to journey
- 41:56to the fringe if you have liked what you have listened to please like share subscribe or follow
- 42:03depending on what venue you are listening to us through also please if possible leave a five star
- 42:09review as that really helps us in the algorithms should you wish to interact with us please check
- 42:15us out on your social media of choice I bet you we are there and if you really want to communicate
- 42:21with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell us that we're wrong and terrible either way
- 42:26please send us an email at journey to the fringe at gmail.com for now I'll see you in the next episode