Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #61🎙️ |Public Inquiry Roads Week Beginning 18th May 2026 | Day 1
Transcript
- 0:04Sitting through a public inquiry is an excruciating business for
- 0:08all sides. I cannot imagine the commissioners or the people in
- 0:13suits and all their underlings waking up overjoyed to be going
- 0:17to work. The thoughts of sitting day after day listening to
- 0:21endless details about the most esoteric of topics, such as
- 0:24geometry of a turning circle on a road, or who, or hearing about
- 0:29the flow of peak hour of traffic counts on 13 tip from junctions
- 0:34over a period of nine years, like, how disinteresting does
- 0:38your life have to be to find stuff like this, so riveting
- 0:41that you'd make a career out of it. I, for one, could not be
- 0:45paid to do it. More fool me. Instead, I choose here to sit
- 0:50out of a sense of duty without being paid at all. And right
- 0:54now, the novelty of that is wearing very thin, but you know,
- 0:58I've started, so I'll finish. Today was a tough day. It seemed
- 1:02to drag on endlessly, and simple topics that ought to have been
- 1:05quite straightforward instead assumed a complexity that I
- 1:09guess is designed to frustrate, annoy, and confuse third parties
- 1:13in the room. I should have guessed it started badly.
- 1:17Commissioner Donahue was leading the charge today for the first
- 1:20time, and in an attempt to gain control of the room from the
- 1:24beginning, put the boot down and said that when he presented the
- 1:28questions to the room, he would first go to third parties with
- 1:32each of the relevant questions and ask them, does the
- 1:35applicant's response satisfy third parties? One could be
- 1:40forgiven for asking oneself, how could the third parties be
- 1:44satisfied with the applicant's response if they haven't heard
- 1:47the applicant's answer to the question, instead have to rely
- 1:51on written evidence submitted by the applicants as far back as
- 1:54January, sifted out of their memory from 1000s and 1000s of
- 1:58other documents, and each time there's a new question, this is
- 2:05how the process would go, and whilst I can understand the
- 2:08commissioners wanting to gain back control, as sometimes the
- 2:12room had collapsed into chaos in the preceding weeks, today's new
- 2:17way of working felt a bit like using a hammer to crack an egg,
- 2:21or maybe several heads. I am lucky enough to say I can count
- 2:25on one hand the times in my life I have felt totally
- 2:29disempowered. Sadly, today was one of those occasions. It's not
- 2:34a nice experience. The difficulty with this method is
- 2:38we do not know what the commissioner is going to ask
- 2:40next, the questions are often long, convoluted, difficult to
- 2:45follow, and are read out quickly, making it extremely
- 2:49challenging to record everything accurately. At times, it feels
- 2:53like three separate questions wrapped into one. Several people
- 2:58struggle today to grasp exactly what was being asked because of
- 3:01these built-in difficulties. Once again, it leaves me feeling
- 3:06that the process is designed to wear down third parties and
- 3:09further undermine any real equality of arms. I also wonder
- 3:14why the questions could not be projected onto the screen behind
- 3:17the commissioners and kept there for the duration of the
- 3:20question, I suppose that would make it too easy for us, the
- 3:23third parties. I imagine them to be collectively saying rub it
- 3:27up, you, if you can't keep up. It felt contrived,
- 3:31disrespectful, serving to make an already deeply flawed process
- 3:36feel even more meaningless. I suppose I should move on to the
- 3:40questions. Broadly, this is what happened. Oh, by the way, we had
- 3:44new people in the room today. Department of Rhodes were there
- 3:47for the first time. Very rare creatures had to be flushed out
- 3:52of hiding after several years. Their plumage is pretty much
- 3:55like all the other males in the room, relatively dull, not given
- 3:59to speaking much, and when they did, seemed uncomfortable,
- 4:03uneasy, unsure. You got the feeling they wanted to go back
- 4:07into hiding fairly quickly. Batting on our team was Douglas
- 4:12Hill, retired roads engineer, and he was adamant that, in his
- 4:16expert opinion of 45 years in road engineering, there wasn't
- 4:20any circumstances that the baseline surveys for the roads
- 4:24could not have been substantially changed between
- 4:272015 and were first recorded up until May 2026 He said, "First,
- 4:35this is about public safety. There was no evidence of due
- 4:39diligence being carried out on the B 46 There is no evidence of
- 4:44modelling done by the DFI. He said that in that time frame
- 4:49there will be significant changes of traffic patterns. He
- 4:53suggested it had been a desktop procedure. Lots of issues have
- 4:58not been looked at, according to Fellow. Fidelmo Kane, including
- 5:01the new patterns of people holding at home in Ireland due
- 5:05to constraints in the Middle East, increase in car ownership
- 5:09in rural families, new tourism such as Dava Forest and Dark
- 5:13Skies combined with clamping pods, etc. and so on. When the
- 5:18question was passed over to the lesser spotted, dark-backed
- 5:22Department of Roads, O'Hara. He indicated they were satisfied
- 5:26with the collection of data as presented by the applicant. Then
- 5:30Dorman from the company, Hoy Dorman, executor of the database
- 5:34line study, went on to explain in detail the level of
- 5:38non-detail they had gone into their 2015 topic surveys to make
- 5:42it sound like detail turns out theirs is the only baseline
- 5:46study that has happened or likely to happen that has been
- 5:49fully approved by the Department of Roads accepting all the
- 5:53figures and DFI are not concerned. Interestingly, a
- 5:57query came up about the Hoy Dorman accreditation today, and
- 6:02out of curiosity, I had a search online this evening, and as far
- 6:06as I can discern, there is no publicly available evidence
- 6:09confirming that Hoy Dorman hold ISO 9001 ISO 14 101
- 6:15accreditation, which is essential criteria for
- 6:18department work and contracts. Mary Brawley, third party
- 6:22solicitor, was concerned was no independent verification, but
- 6:25just passive acceptance once again by the department. An
- 6:30interesting aside to all of this was FODC sat quietly through
- 6:34these discussions today with one comment near the start, nothing
- 6:39further to add, and then putting a marker at the end of the day
- 6:43about splays of existing infrastructure. I think that was
- 6:47in reference to what Nile McLear brought up into about the
- 6:50substandard access visibility and the extended temporary
- 6:54permission at the site. As you might have guessed by now, it
- 6:58was all about roads and road networks, and again, there were
- 7:01submissions by third parties, and again we had to go first.
- 7:06Barbara Ward spoke eloquently about living directly opposite
- 7:09Kankosi Road, which is a one vehicle road, big drops on
- 7:13either side, that is easy for vehicles to be bugged in a
- 7:16ditch, even though there are 24 lay-bys on the road. It is the
- 7:21locals that will have to give way to mine traffic in the
- 7:23future. She talked about future noise, fumes, potholes,
- 7:29vibrations, and how the local walking group from Ruski use it
- 7:32to walk on, and that there is no way you can convert a one
- 7:36vehicle road into a road for heavy goods vehicles without
- 7:40health and safety issues. There was much discussion about the
- 7:43turning point at Lena Road, and how inadequate the passing bays
- 7:47were. Bill Donnelly wrote about his experience of the roads at
- 7:50Cavanagh, coal mine, when the trucks went from one per day to
- 7:55145 per day, and he was adamant that is why the road network is
- 8:00not suitable for what is proposed here. Kavanaugh call
- 8:03was meant to be limited by planning conditions, and these
- 8:06were completely ignored by the trucks. A couple of times during
- 8:10the afternoon, there was a brief outbreak of ceremonial
- 8:13peacocking when Councillor Donahue reminded Pat Haughey
- 8:16that his correct title was Councillor rather than mr.
- 8:19Donohue. Towards the end of the day, the discussion moved to
- 8:24Article 11, and from what I can gather, in large developments or
- 8:27controversial schemes, Article 11 discussions become
- 8:31significant because they go directly to road safety, traffic
- 8:34impacts, construction traffic, and whether road infrastructure
- 8:38is suitable for their proposed development, but they seem to
- 8:41want it to become a section 76 agreement, which apparently is
- 8:45less cumbersome. This is basically a legal promise tied
- 8:48to land, a way of making the developer commit to things like
- 8:52restoration, pollution, clean up, and long-term monitoring.
- 8:55The big question, though, is whether these promises actually
- 8:58protect the public if something goes wrong decades down the
- 9:02line, because once the gold is gone, it certainly won't be the
- 9:06lawyers or shareholders left dealing with the consequences.
- 9:11At this point, this discussion was deferred until tomorrow, and
- 9:14I, for one, was mighty glad, as I think was everyone else on the
- 9:18SOS journey. That's it for now. See you all tomorrow, you.