Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 85: Ceasefire Holds While the World Waits for Tehran’s Answer
Transcript
- 0:16A deal is closer than at any point since this war began, but
- 0:20it is not done. On Friday, Secretary of State
- 0:24Marco Rubio told reporters there were good signs that an
- 0:27agreement to end the conflict was insight.
- 0:29On Thursday, Trump called off a military strike that had been
- 0:32scheduled for Tuesday at the request of Gulf Arab leaders to
- 0:36createspace for what the White House described as serious
- 0:39negotiations. A1 page memorandum of
- 0:42understanding, 14 points covering the end of the war, the
- 0:45opening of the Strait of Hormuz and a framework for nuclear
- 0:48talks was under active review in Tehran.
- 0:51Iran had not yet formally responded, but two issues
- 0:55remained unresolved and both of them cut to the very core of
- 0:59what this war has been about, what happens to Iran's enriched
- 1:03uranium stockpile and whether Iran can impose tolls on ships
- 1:07passing through the Strait of Hormuz.
- 1:09Day 85. The ceasefire is still holding.
- 1:13The deal is within reach, and the gap between within reach and
- 1:17done is proving very difficult to close.
- 1:20This is Epic Fury, the US Iran war podcast.
- 1:24There is a great deal to work through today.
- 1:27Let us get straight into it. The central diplomatic
- 1:30development of the past 24 hours is the continued review of the
- 1:34one page memorandum of understanding that both sides
- 1:36have been circulating through Pakistan's mediation channel.
- 1:40The document, described by sources familiar with its
- 1:42contents as a 14 point framework, would formally
- 1:45declare an end to the war, set out a timetable for opening the
- 1:49Strait of Hormuz to international shipping and
- 1:51establish a 30 day window for more detailed negotiations on
- 1:55Iran's nuclear program. United States officials speaking
- 1:58to multiple news outlets describe Friday as a day of
- 2:01cautious but genuine optimism. The talks, which have been
- 2:05proceeding through a combination of direct and indirect channels,
- 2:08produce what 1 senior official characterized as progress on
- 2:12several fronts. The broad architecture of the
- 2:15deal, the end of hostilities, the lifting of the American
- 2:18naval blockade, the unfreezing of billions of dollars in
- 2:21Iranian assets, the removal of sanctions, appear to be broadly
- 2:25accepted by both sides in principle.
- 2:27The argument was now over the details and the details, as is
- 2:31so often the case, and diplomacy of this complexity.
- 2:34We're doing the hardest work. Trump himself, speaking to
- 2:37reporters on Wednesday, said there was a very good chance the
- 2:40two sides were nearing a deal. He added, as he has done before,
- 2:45that he had felt that confidence previously, only for nothing to
- 2:48materialize. But this time, he said, felt
- 2:51different. He wrote on Truth Social that
- 2:54assuming Iran agreed to give what had been agreed to, the
- 2:57operation would be at an end and the blockade would allow the
- 3:00straight to be open to all, including Iran.
- 3:03He paired that statement with a threat.
- 3:05Any failure to reach an acceptable deal would result in
- 3:08a full, large scale assault on a moment's notice.
- 3:11The two messages together, Peace within reach, war on standby
- 3:15with a defining posture of the Trump administration as the 85th
- 3:19day of this conflict came to a close.
- 3:21Rubio, speaking at a press briefing on Thursday, was direct
- 3:25about where the fault lines were.
- 3:27He said the United States had absolutely no interest in any
- 3:30arrangement that allowed Iran to control, restrict or profit from
- 3:34traffic through the Strait of Hormuz.
- 3:36He said no one in the world supported A tolling system on
- 3:39the Strait. He said any deal that contains
- 3:42such a provision would be, in his word, unfeasible.
- 3:46Trump was more blunt, saying the administration had total control
- 3:50of the waterway and intended to keep it open and free.
- 3:53He described the Strait as international and made clear
- 3:56Washington had no intention of endorsing any framework that
- 4:00suggested otherwise. The context behind that position
- 4:04required some unpacking. Iranian officials had been
- 4:07exploring, in discussions with Oman, A framework that would
- 4:10allow Tehran to impose fees on commercial vessels transiting
- 4:14the straight. The idea, from Iran's
- 4:16perspective, carried a certain logic.
- 4:19The straight passes through Iranian territorial waters on
- 4:22one side. Tehran's argument was that every
- 4:24tanker transiting its portion of the waterway was using Iranian
- 4:28maritime space and that a toll regime will provide a
- 4:31sustainable income stream to help offset the devastating
- 4:34economic damage this war has caused.
- 4:36That damage has been severe. Iran's oil exports have been
- 4:40choked by the American naval blockade since April.
- 4:44Sanctions have cut off access to foreign exchange infrastructure.
- 4:48Strikes in the first weeks of the conflict disrupted
- 4:50industrial production across multiple provinces.
- 4:54The Iranian economy is under acute strain, and any deal that
- 4:57provides Tehran with ongoing revenue from the Strait has a
- 5:00domestic political logic that is not difficult to understand. the
- 5:04United States rejected that framing entirely.
- 5:08The Strait of Hormuz is governed by International Maritime law.
- 5:12The right of transit passage through international straits is
- 5:15established in the United Nations Convention on the Law of
- 5:18the Sea. No country has the right to
- 5:20charge tolls on international waters, regardless of the
- 5:24geographical proximity of those waters to its coastline.
- 5:27For the United States to sign an agreement that legitimized an
- 5:30Iranian tolling regime would, in Washington's view, set a
- 5:34precedent that could undermine freedom of navigation across the
- 5:37globe. The implications for other
- 5:39contested straits and waterways would be significant.
- 5:42That impasse, as of Saturday morning, remained open.
- 5:46The second outstanding issue is the uranium question, and in
- 5:49some respects it is the more consequential of the two.
- 5:53At the heart of the argument is a simple but heavily charged
- 5:56question. Where does Iran's enriched
- 5:58uranium stockpile go when the war ends?
- 6:00Iran is believed to hold several 100kg of uranium enriched to 60%
- 6:05purity, as well as quantities enriched to lower levels.
- 6:09The United States has insisted throughout the negotiations that
- 6:12this material must leave Iranian soil.
- 6:15Earlier in the talks, American officials floated transferring
- 6:18the stockpile to the United States itself.
- 6:21Russia, during the first months of the conflict, had offered to
- 6:25take the material. Trump reportedly rejected that
- 6:28option, unwilling to allow Moscow a role in one of the
- 6:31defining outcomes of his foreign policy.
- 6:34Tehran had at various points indicated it might accept the
- 6:37transfer principle in theory, though nothing was ever
- 6:40formalized. In recent days, however, Iranian
- 6:43officials made clear that removal of the uranium from
- 6:46Iranian territory was not something they were prepared to
- 6:49accept without significant concessions.
- 6:51In return, the supreme leader issued A directive stating the
- 6:55enriched uranium must not leave the country.
- 6:58Iranian sources told Reuters that Tehran was prepared to
- 7:01accept strict international monitoring, snap inspections by
- 7:04the International Atomic Energy Agency and a moratorium on
- 7:08further enrichment, but that the physical transfer of existing
- 7:11stockpiles to a foreign state was a different category of
- 7:14concession entirely. It touched on Iranian
- 7:17sovereignty and on the domestic political constraints facing a
- 7:20government that had already yielded more than a hard line
- 7:23base was comfortable with. Trump responded by saying the
- 7:26United States would recover the uranium and would probably
- 7:29destroy it. He said the goal was
- 7:31straightforward. No nuclear bomb, no nuclear
- 7:34weapon, not even close to it. Whether that outcome could be
- 7:38achieved through enhanced inspections in a moratorium
- 7:41rather than physical removal of the material remained as of
- 7:44Saturday, the central unresolved point in the negotiations.
- 7:49Oil markets moved significantly across the week as the signals
- 7:52from Washington shifted from imminent escalation to cautious
- 7:55optimism. Brent crude, which had climbed
- 7:58above $111.00 a barrel earlier in the week when a new round of
- 8:02strikes appeared imminent, fell back to close around $103.00 on
- 8:06Friday. The weekly decline was the
- 8:08largest in months. Brent fell more than 5%.
- 8:13United States West TX intermediate fell more than 8%.
- 8:17Analysts noted that the markets were pricing in the increased
- 8:20probability of a deal, but that significant uncertainty remained
- 8:24and that any breakdown in talks could reverse the moves rapidly.
- 8:27Fadi Bairall, the executive director of the International
- 8:30Energy Agency, reiterated on Friday his warning that global
- 8:34oil stocks were depleting and that if the straight remained
- 8:37effectively closed through the summer travel season, energy
- 8:40markets could enter what he called the red zone by July.
- 8:43He said developing nations in Asia and Africa were already
- 8:46bearing the greatest pain from this crisis.
- 8:49He said the Straits reopening was not just an American or
- 8:52Iranian interest, it was a global one and the world was
- 8:55watching the negotiations with that understanding.
- 8:58Energy executives warned against premature optimism even in the
- 9:02event of a deal. A note from the banking group
- 9:04MUFG warned that full normalization of Middle East oil
- 9:07supply may not occur until 2027, given the scale of
- 9:11infrastructure damage, the disruption to shipping insurance
- 9:14markets, and the time required to recommission tanker routes
- 9:17that have been dormant for nearly three months.
- 9:19The economic scarring from this conflict was not going to
- 9:22disappear the moment an agreement was signed.
- 9:25On the military side, the ceasefire that Pakistan brokered
- 9:28on April the 8th and that has been extended multiple times
- 9:32since continue to hold on Saturday.
- 9:34There were no confirmed American or Israeli strikes on Iranian
- 9:38territory overnight. Iran's military did not launch
- 9:42any ballistic missile or drone attacks against regional
- 9:45targets. The silence was conspicuous
- 9:47after nearly three months of near daily fire exchanges, and
- 9:51diplomats in Islamabad and elsewhere were interpreting it
- 9:53as evidence that both sides have shared interest in maintaining
- 9:56conditions under which a deal might still be reached.
- 9:59The Gulf Arab states have played an important and underreported
- 10:02role in the current diplomatic moment.
- 10:04Trump specifically named the leaders of Qatar, Saudi Arabia
- 10:08and the United Arab Emirates as the parties who urged him on
- 10:11Monday to hold off on the planned strikes and open space
- 10:14for diplomacy. That those 3 governments, all of
- 10:17which had spent months bearing the consequences of Iranian
- 10:19missile and drone attacks on their soil, we're now actively
- 10:23lobbying Washington for a negotiated settlement rather
- 10:26than continued military pressure, was a meaningful
- 10:28development. It pointed to fatigue in the
- 10:30Gulf, with extended disruption to regional commerce, into a
- 10:34calculation that a deal, even an imperfect 1, was preferable to
- 10:38an open-ended conflict whose resolution no one could clearly
- 10:41map. Israel's position remained the
- 10:43most complicated variable. Netanyahu had publicly signaled
- 10:47that the military gains of Operation Epic Fury had created
- 10:50an opportunity to reach an agreement that would protect
- 10:53Israel's vital interests. But Israeli officials continue
- 10:56to express skepticism about whether the deal on the table
- 11:00went far enough on the nuclear question.
- 11:02Israel had gone to war in part to ensure Iran could never
- 11:06obtain a nuclear weapon. An agreement that allowed Iran
- 11:10to retain enriched uranium on its soil, subject to monitoring,
- 11:14was not the same as the dismantlement of Iran's nuclear
- 11:17infrastructure that had originally been the stated aim.
- 11:20How far Netanyahu was ultimately prepared to accept such a
- 11:23framework remained one of the most consequential unknowns in
- 11:26the negotiations. The domestic political picture
- 11:29in Washington had also been shifting.
- 11:32Republican support for the president handling of the
- 11:34conflict had remained broadly solid through the months of
- 11:37fighting, but there were signs of restlessness among members
- 11:40representing states where the economic impact of sustained
- 11:43high oil prices was felt most directly.
- 11:45Democrats continue to argue, with some purchase among
- 11:48independent voters that the administration had entered the
- 11:51conflict without a clear definition of what victory meant
- 11:54and without a sufficient plan for what came after.
- 11:57Those arguments were gaining slightly more traction as the
- 12:00conflict entered its fourth month with no definitive end
- 12:03insight. The humanitarian dimension of
- 12:05the conflict continued to draw international condemnation.
- 12:09The death toll inside Iran over the course of the war had
- 12:12exceeded 1500. In Lebanon, where Hezbollah had
- 12:16been engaged in its own sustained exchange of fire with
- 12:19Israel, more than 1000 people had died.
- 12:22Millions have been displaced from their homes across both
- 12:25countries. United Nations Secretary General
- 12:28Antonio Guterres called on all parties to facilitate unimpeded
- 12:32access for humanitarian workers and to allow the delivery of
- 12:35essential supplies to civilian populations caught in the areas
- 12:39of conflict. Pakistan's role as the mediating
- 12:41power had been largely thankless.
- 12:44Frequently disrupted and quietly essential, Islamabad had
- 12:48absorbed multiple rounds of negotiation that collapsed
- 12:51without result. It had maintained the
- 12:53communication channel between Washington and Tehran even when
- 12:56both sides publicly denied that any such channel existed.
- 13:00Prime Minister Shahbaz Sharif and Army Chief General Asim
- 13:03Munir had invested enormous political capital in positioning
- 13:07Pakistan as the indispensable intermediary.
- 13:10That investment was approaching a moment of genuine reckoning.
- 13:14If a deal was reached, it would represent a defining diplomatic
- 13:17achievement for Islamabad. If the talks fell apart and
- 13:20fighting began again, some share the consequences Would be
- 13:24Pakistan's to carry. The question being asked in
- 13:27every capital on Saturday morning was the same one.
- 13:30Would Tehran say yes? Iran's formal response to the 14
- 13:34point memorandum have been expected Within 48 hours of its
- 13:38transmission. That window had passed without a
- 13:41definitive answer. American officials told
- 13:44reporters they were still waiting.
- 13:46They said they were not alarmed by the delay.
- 13:49Decisions of this magnitude made by a government that had
- 13:52suffered the destruction of its military infrastructure and the
- 13:55deaths of senior officials across three months of war did
- 13:59not happen on a timetable set in Washington.
- 14:02What was known was this. Iran's supreme leader Mojtaba
- 14:05Khamenei, who had come to power and circumstances no one
- 14:08anticipated and whose legitimacy at home rested in part are not
- 14:12appearing to capitulate under foreign military pressure, was
- 14:15weighing a set of concessions that would have been considered
- 14:17politically inconceivable just 12 months ago.
- 14:20The question was whether the terms on offer were ones he
- 14:23could accept and still govern. There was another dimension to
- 14:26the negotiations that had received less attention but was
- 14:29integral to understanding why a deal remained elusive even at
- 14:33this late stage. That was the question of what
- 14:36Iran's leadership was actually capable of agreeing to much.
- 14:40Taba Khamenei had now been in office for nearly three months.
- 14:44He had not been the first choice of many within the Assembly of
- 14:47Experts. His appointment had been
- 14:49controversial, rushed through under battlefield conditions,
- 14:52with a country under bombardment and much of the senior
- 14:55leadership dead or in hiding. His base of support within the
- 14:58Islamic Republic's power structure rested primarily on
- 15:01the hardliners within the IRGC and among the most conservative
- 15:05elements of the clerical establishment.
- 15:07Those constituencies had not gone to war to end up signing an
- 15:10agreement that involves surrendering enriched uranium to
- 15:13a foreign power. That political reality was not
- 15:17an abstraction. It was the concrete constraint
- 15:20within which Common A was operating.
- 15:23Every concession he made carried a domestic cost.
- 15:26The Americans understood this, or at least the more experienced
- 15:30diplomats in the room did. The question was whether the
- 15:33domestic cost of the concessions on offer have been reduced
- 15:36enough by the military and economic pressure of the
- 15:38preceding months to fall within a range that Common A could
- 15:41manage politically and still remain in power.
- 15:44If it had, a deal was possible. If it had not, no amount of
- 15:49American optimism will produce 1 Western analysts who had studied
- 15:53Iranian elite politics for decades cautioned against
- 15:56assuming that the Supreme Leader had unlimited freedom of action
- 16:00simply because he had agreed to negotiate.
- 16:03The system of governance in the Islamic Republic was not a
- 16:05unitary hierarchy in which the supreme leader decided
- 16:09everything and everyone else complied.
- 16:11It was a system of competing power centers, the IRGC, the
- 16:15clergy, the presidency, the economic elite whose interest
- 16:19had to be balanced. An agreement that the IRGC
- 16:22believed was a capitulation would face resistance regardless
- 16:25of what Khamenei put his name to.
- 16:28That was part of why the uranium question was so difficult.
- 16:31The IRGC had been the custodian of Iran's nuclear program for
- 16:35years. The decision to hand that
- 16:37program's most tangible asset, the enriched material itself, to
- 16:41a foreign power was not a decision that Khamenei could
- 16:44make without the Irgc's acceptance.
- 16:47Whether that acceptance had been secured, or whether it could be
- 16:50secured was something that outside observers could not know
- 16:53with confidence. What was visible from the
- 16:55outside was a negotiation that had travelled further than many
- 16:59had thought possible. In February, Iran had accepted a
- 17:02ceasefire. It had engaged in direct talks.
- 17:06It had allowed the concept of a moratorium on enrichment to be
- 17:09placed on the table. Months ago, any one of those
- 17:12steps would have been described as a red line.
- 17:15The war had moved those lines. The question is day 85 ended was
- 17:19whether the remaining red lines could be moved far enough to
- 17:22produce an agreement, or whether the negotiation with Stall and
- 17:26the military option would once again become the answer.
- 17:29Trump had told the military to stand ready to strike on a
- 17:32moment's notice if an acceptable deal was not reached.
- 17:35Those were not words he had walked back.
- 17:38They sat alongside every optimistic briefing from Rubio,
- 17:42every cautiously worded progress report from Islamabad, like a
- 17:45sentence that had not yet been finished.
- 17:48The world was learning to hold 2 possibilities at once, that this
- 17:51ended in a deal and that it did not.
- 17:54The broader international reaction to the weeks diplomatic
- 17:57developments was mixed. China's Foreign Minister Wang He
- 18:00called on both sides to reach an agreement and urged the
- 18:03immediate reopening of the Strait of Hormuz, emphasizing
- 18:06that the waterway was critical to the Chinese economy and to
- 18:09global trade flows. Beijing had been consistent in
- 18:12its public calls for a negotiated settlement throughout
- 18:15the conflict, even as its private communications with
- 18:18Tehran had been the subject of ongoing speculation in
- 18:21intelligence circles. Russia maintained its position
- 18:24of formal opposition to the American military campaign,
- 18:27while quietly acknowledging through back channels that
- 18:30negotiated into the conflict would serve Moscow's interests.
- 18:34European governments, led by France and Germany, continue to
- 18:37push for a diplomatic outcome and expressed cautious support
- 18:40for the mediation framework being advanced through Pakistan.
- 18:44the United Kingdom maintained its position of publicly backing
- 18:47American policy while privately urging a faster path to
- 18:50negotiations. Prime Minister Keir Starmer had
- 18:53said consistently that Iran could end this by accepting
- 18:56terms and that Britain would support any credible diplomatic
- 19:00process that brought the conflict to a close.
- 19:02That position had not changed. What had changed was the sense
- 19:06in London, as in most Western capitals, that the end of this
- 19:10conflict was now within the realm of the near future, rather
- 19:13than the indefinite horizon it had seemed to occupy from much
- 19:16of March and April. The mood in financial markets on
- 19:19Friday reflected that shift. Global equities recovered some
- 19:24of the losses sustained earlier in the week.
- 19:27Gold, which had risen sharply when the prospect of renewed
- 19:29American strikes loomed largest earlier in the week, edged back
- 19:33from recent highs. Shipping insurance premiums for
- 19:36vessels in the Gulf region ticked slightly lower, though
- 19:39they remained at historically elevated levels.
- 19:42The markets were not declaring victory.
- 19:45They were tentatively pricing in the possibility that the end was
- 19:48closer than it had been. If this podcast is helping you
- 19:51make sense of what's happening, take 2 seconds to leave a five
- 19:54star rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 19:57It makes a huge difference to how many people find the show.
- 20:01And if you want the deeper breakdown of what's really going
- 20:03on and where this is heading, you can unlock the premium
- 20:06episodes directly in Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 20:10Day 85 ends with a straight still closed, the uranium still
- 20:13in Iran, the ceasefire still holding and a deal still within
- 20:17reach but not yet signed. Somewhere in the space between
- 20:20those facts lies the answer to whether three months of war ends
- 20:23with an agreement or with a new escalation.
- 20:26The response is expected. The world is watching.
- 20:31We will be back with the latest the moment it comes.
- 20:34This is Epic Fury, the US Iran war podcast.