Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Post-IPO Companies Are Buying Back Their Own Stock
Transcript
- Lucas: So you've got a company that just went public, say eighteen months ago. They raised a bunch of cash, the stock is trading, and instead of plowing that cash into R&D or acquisitions, they start buying their own shares back. That's not the typical post ipo script — but it's happening more often. Luna: It feels almost counterintuitive, right? You finally have access to public capital, and you turn around and use it to shrink your share count. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not a fringe thing anymore. Shopify announced a $1.5 billion buyback in their Q1 2026 earnings release. That's a big number for a company that's been public since 2015 but is still in a growth and investment phase. Palantir did something similar — a $1 billion authorization, announced right around their lockup expiration earlier this year. Luna: Palantir's stock has come under pressure recently, down over nine percent in the last five days. Was the buyback a response to that? Lucas: Partially, but it's more strategic. Lockup expirations let insiders sell shares, which can flood the market. A buyback absorbs some of that supply and signals that management thinks the stock is undervalued. It's a confidence play. But the question is whether that's the best use of cash. Luna: I remember when buybacks were mostly a mature-company thing — Apple, Microsoft, that crowd. Now you've got younger tech firms doing it. What changed? Lucas: A few things. One, the IPO process itself has changed. Companies are going public with larger cash reserves than they used to, partly because they've raised huge private rounds and partly because they're staying private longer. So when they do list, they have a war chest. Two, the opportunity cost of holding cash is higher now — interest rates are still elevated relative to the pre-2022 era, but they've started to come down, and markets are forward-looking. If you're sitting on a billion dollars earning four-point-five percent, and you think your own stock can deliver a better return, buying back shares starts to look attractive. Luna: But there's also the signaling risk. If a company buys back stock and then the share price keeps falling, management looks like they misjudged the market. Lucas: That's the danger. And it's not just reputational — it's real cash. Palantir's stock is off more than nine percent in the last week alone. If they executed buybacks at higher prices, those shares are now underwater. But the counterargument is that buybacks are a long-term capital allocation tool, not a short-term price support. Luna: Let me play devil's advocate. Some critics say buybacks are just a way to boost earnings per share and executive compensation, since many comp plans are tied to EPS. Lucas: That's a fair critique. When you reduce the share count, EPS goes up mechanically, even if the company's actual operating performance hasn't improved. And if CEO bonuses are tied to EPS targets, buybacks can inflate them. But I think it depends on the context. Shopify's buyback was accompanied by strong revenue growth — their recurring revenue is still expanding — so the EPS boost is a bonus, not the main event. Luna: What about the tax treatment? Buybacks now have a one percent excise tax under the Inflation Reduction Act, right? Lucas: Yes, as of 2023, there's a one percent tax on share repurchases. That's not a huge drag, but it's a factor. Companies have to weigh that cost against the benefits. So far, it hasn't deterred them. Total buybacks in the S&P 500 were still over $800 billion in 2025. For tech IPOs, the numbers are smaller but growing. Luna: Let's talk about how investors should evaluate this. If I'm a shareholder in a post ipo company that announces a buyback, what should I look for? Lucas: Three things. One, the company's free cash flow. If they're generating enough cash to fund operations and growth, and they're using surplus for buybacks, that's healthy. Two, the valuation at which they're buying. If they're buying back shares at a reasonable price to earnings ratio relative to peers, it's a vote of confidence. Three, their R&D and capital expenditure plans. If a buyback starves investment in the core business, that's a red flag. Shopify and Palantir both have strong cash positions — Shopify had over $5 billion in cash and equivalents at the end of last quarter — so the buyback doesn't seem to compromise their growth spending. Luna: There's also the question of timing. Some companies announce a buyback but never fully execute it. Is that common? Lucas: It happens. Buyback authorizations are often open-ended — management can decide to buy or not based on market conditions. But if a company announces a big number and then doesn't follow through, it can look like they were trying to pump the stock. Credibility matters. Shopify has a good track record — they executed about $1.2 billion of their current authorization in Q1 alone. Luna: So is this a trend we should expect to see more of? More post ipo buybacks? Lucas: I think so, as long as the IPO pipeline stays active and companies list with big cash positions. The math is compelling when your stock is down and you believe in your own trajectory. But it also puts pressure on management to get the timing right. And there's a broader consideration: buybacks reduce the number of shares available for trading, which can increase volatility. For a stock that's already volatile — like Palantir or Coinbase — that's something to watch. Luna: Speaking of which, Coinbase is down over twelve percent in the last five days. And they have a buyback program too. Lucas: They do — a $500 million authorization from last year. But they've been cautious about executing it, probably because the stock has been choppy. That's the kind of nuance investors need to track. It's not just whether a buyback is announced; it's whether it's actually happening in the market. Luna: And we should note that buybacks aren't the only way to return capital. Dividends are still rare among younger tech companies. Lucas: Right. Dividends signal a more mature, steady-state business. Most post ipo tech companies aren't there yet. Buybacks give them flexibility — they can be done sporadically, and they don't set an expectation of ongoing payments. So for now, buybacks are the preferred tool for companies that want to signal confidence without locking themselves into a dividend policy. Luna: Let's take a quick step back — these conversations we have on the show, digging into stuff like buyback mechanics or IPO strategy, they take time to research and produce. And honestly, a lot of that is made possible by listeners who chip in a few bucks through platforms like Buy Me a Coffee. It's not a big ask — a couple of dollars a month genuinely makes a difference in keeping this ad-free and focused on the details. If you've gotten value from episodes like this one, you can find us at buymeacoffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small gesture that goes a long way. We appreciate everyone who supports the show. Now back to buybacks — one angle we haven't touched on is the regulatory side. The SEC has been looking at buyback disclosure more closely. Since 2023, companies have to report their daily buyback activity in quarterly reports, not just quarterly aggregates. Luna: That gives investors more transparency. You can see if a company is buying on down days, or if they're just propping the stock at month-end. Lucas: Exactly. And some critics argue that buybacks exacerbate inequality — that they enrich shareholders at the expense of workers and investment. But the research is mixed. A Harvard study from last year found that companies that do buybacks actually tend to invest more in R&D overall, not less. The causality is hard to pin down. Luna: What's your take? Are post ipo buybacks a net positive for the market? Lucas: I think they're a tool, not a moral statement. In the right context — strong cash flow, reasonable valuation, no sacrifice of growth — they can be efficient. But they can also be a sign that a company has run out of ideas for deploying capital. The key is to look at the whole picture: cash position, growth rate, and the rationale management gives. For Shopify and Palantir, I lean positive. For others, I'd want to see more detail. Luna: Any other post ipo companies with notable buyback programs you're watching? Lucas: Airbnb has one — $2 billion authorized, and they've been active. Their stock is up about two percent in the last five days, relatively stable. Rivian is interesting because they're not profitable yet, but they have a buyback program too. That's more unusual — using cash when you're still burning it. But their stock popped almost ten percent this week, so maybe it's working as a signal. Luna: Rivian's buyback is controversial. Some analysts say they should be conserving cash for production expansion. Lucas: Totally. And that's the tension. For a pre-profit company, every dollar spent on buybacks is a dollar not spent on scaling the business. But if the stock is deeply undervalued — and Rivian's market cap is under $20 billion — buying back shares can be a better use of cash than, say, a new factory that might take years to pay off. It's a bet on your own equity. Luna: Alright, let's wrap with a forward look. If interest rates keep declining through the rest of 2026, does that make buybacks more or less attractive? Lucas: Lower rates make the opportunity cost of holding cash higher, because you earn less on cash equivalents. That could push more companies toward buybacks. But lower rates also boost stock valuations, which makes buybacks more expensive. So it cuts both ways. I think the bigger driver is cash on hand — and right now, post ipo companies have plenty of it. So expect more buyback announcements, not fewer. Luna: And as always, the devil's in the execution. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. That's all for this episode of Tech IPO Conversations.