Latest / Bloomberg Law / Will Theranos Ex-CEO Play the Victim at Trial?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: You're listening to Bloomberg Law with June Grasso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:06Speaker 1: When you have that passion, you will get back up
- 0:09Speaker 1: when you get knocked down, and you will get knocked
- 0:11Speaker 1: down over and over and over and over again, and
- 0:14Speaker 1: you win by getting back up. And our journey has
- 0:17Speaker 1: been nothing but that. But will Elizabeth Holmes be able
- 0:20Speaker 1: to get back up after facing criminal charges? That was
- 0:24Speaker 1: a very confident Holmes at a Forbes conference in when
- 0:28Speaker 1: she was still the world's youngest female self made billionaire
- 0:32Speaker 1: and the darling of the tech and media worlds with
- 0:35Speaker 1: her promise to revolutionize blood testing. Home spectacular fall from
- 0:39Speaker 1: Grace has been plotted in books, countless news stories, and
- 0:42Speaker 1: an HBO documentary Is this was real? Secret? I don't
- 0:51Speaker 1: have many secrets. Her net worth was estimated at four
- 0:54Speaker 1: point five billion dollars, but that was before Thereas her
- 0:58Speaker 1: blood testing start up unraveled amid allegations that her main
- 1:02Speaker 1: product was really fraud, Holmes and her boyfriend were charged
- 1:06Speaker 1: with defrauding investors with homes, facing years in prison. Her
- 1:11Speaker 1: lawyers are now exploring whether she can beat the charges
- 1:14Speaker 1: by asking jurors to delve into her psychological state. The
- 1:18Speaker 1: exact strategy remains a question mark. Joining me is Anne Coughlin,
- 1:22Speaker 1: a criminal law professor at the University of Virginia Law
- 1:25Speaker 1: School who specializes in feminist jurisprudence. Her lawyers say they
- 1:30Speaker 1: may tell jurors about a mental disease or defect or
- 1:33Speaker 1: some other mental condition bearing on her guilt. Is that
- 1:37Speaker 1: an insanity defense or not an insanity defense? So, as
- 1:41Speaker 1: I read the documents that relate to this interesting claim,
- 1:46Speaker 1: I don't think she's raising an insanity defense. It's true
- 1:50Speaker 1: that her notice refers to men's disease or defect, but
- 1:56Speaker 1: when you read her motion papers carefully, she seems to
- 2:00Speaker 1: be invoking the theory that she's going to put forward
- 2:04Speaker 1: a mental disease or defects that in some way bears
- 2:08Speaker 1: on the question of whether she's guilty, And that's separate
- 2:12Speaker 1: from an insanity defense. It's a different kind of use
- 2:15Speaker 1: of a mental health disorder. When a defendant invokes a
- 2:20Speaker 1: mental health disorder, there's more than one way in which
- 2:24Speaker 1: they might be using the claim. One highly visible claim
- 2:29Speaker 1: is the insanity defense. But I think she's arguing that
- 2:33Speaker 1: she is going to use evidence of some kind of
- 2:36Speaker 1: mental health disorder to negate her guilt on the wire
- 2:41Speaker 1: fraud charges. And this is not a full blown insanity claim.
- 2:46Speaker 1: And we don't know how she's going to use this,
- 2:48Speaker 1: in part because a lot of the judge's order and
- 2:51Speaker 1: the motion papers were blacked out when it came to specifics.
- 2:56Speaker 1: So is it likely that she's going to try to
- 2:59Speaker 1: use it to show that she did not have intent
- 3:02Speaker 1: to commit wire fraud? That would be one of her claims.
- 3:05Speaker 1: And again, I want to just back up and say
- 3:07Speaker 1: to you, you're exactly right. One of us sort of
- 3:09Speaker 1: tantalizing things about Elizabeth Holmes case generally is we really
- 3:15Speaker 1: don't know a whole lot about the backstory, at least
- 3:19Speaker 1: we don't know about that backstory from her. So there's
- 3:23Speaker 1: been tons of reporting in the media, as you well know.
- 3:26Speaker 1: There's been books and magazine articles and documentaries in which
- 3:30Speaker 1: people are trying to put together a coherent story of
- 3:33Speaker 1: her life and what led up to the conducts that
- 3:37Speaker 1: ultimately culminates in these charges. But we really don't know
- 3:41Speaker 1: what facts she's going to allege, so we don't know
- 3:44Speaker 1: what her story is going to be that supports the
- 3:47Speaker 1: claim that she has a mental health disorder. But one
- 3:50Speaker 1: way that she could use a mental health disorder is
- 3:53Speaker 1: to support the so called diminished capacity defense, and the
- 3:58Speaker 1: idea would be that, yes, she did all these things.
- 4:02Speaker 1: She committed all the conduct that the government alleges, but
- 4:06Speaker 1: when she was doing those things, her purpose was not
- 4:09Speaker 1: to defraud people, but was for some other reason. Right,
- 4:14Speaker 1: And then we're left to try to speculate again what
- 4:19Speaker 1: she's going to claim her purpose was. So in order
- 4:22Speaker 1: for the government to please these wire fraud charges, they
- 4:26Speaker 1: have to prove not only that she lied, that she
- 4:30Speaker 1: made false representations, but that she did so for the
- 4:34Speaker 1: purpose of defrauding people of their money. So one way
- 4:38Speaker 1: to think about this is that she's going to argue, yes,
- 4:40Speaker 1: I did these things, they were lies, but I wasn't
- 4:44Speaker 1: doing it to defraud people. I was doing it for
- 4:47Speaker 1: some other reason that's explained by the mental health disorder.
- 4:52Speaker 1: You know, I was doing it because I had such
- 4:55Speaker 1: a fragile ego. You Know, one thing she might claim
- 4:58Speaker 1: is that at the inception of my activity, I honestly
- 5:03Speaker 1: thought that I was going to be able to come
- 5:05Speaker 1: up with this miracle way to do blood tests. You know,
- 5:10Speaker 1: that was my objective as a young person, and I
- 5:13Speaker 1: actually thought I was going to be able to pull
- 5:15Speaker 1: it off right, so that in the beginning I wasn't
- 5:18Speaker 1: lying to people. I was describing for them my aspiration
- 5:22Speaker 1: in this technological space. Okay, fine, I don't see how
- 5:26Speaker 1: that story can hold up for the many, many years.
- 5:28Speaker 1: But that's one claim that she might try to make.
- 5:31Speaker 1: Does it seem as if any kind of defense like
- 5:34Speaker 1: this is going to be difficult in light of the
- 5:37Speaker 1: accusations that she adopted this persona based on Silicon Valley elites,
- 5:43Speaker 1: that she even adopted a deep baritone voice. Does it
- 5:46Speaker 1: seem like any claim of mental disease would fail in
- 5:50Speaker 1: light of that persona she kept up so successfully for
- 5:54Speaker 1: so many years. From where we sit now, and again,
- 5:58Speaker 1: you know, I'm a lawyer, I'm a law professor here,
- 6:00Speaker 1: and so we always want to be careful when we're
- 6:03Speaker 1: talking in ignorance of the facts. You know, we still
- 6:07Speaker 1: don't know what her story would be. But from where
- 6:10Speaker 1: we sit, her claim, whatever it is, looks really really
- 6:16Speaker 1: like a tough sell. The alleged MI mis conduct took
- 6:20Speaker 1: place over many years. Whatever her motive may have been
- 6:23Speaker 1: at the beginning, whatever she thought she could achieve at
- 6:26Speaker 1: the beginning. Clearly there came a time when it's proper
- 6:31Speaker 1: for a jury to infer beyond a reasonable death that
- 6:34Speaker 1: she knew she couldn't achieve what she had plied, And
- 6:39Speaker 1: so it's very, very tough to imagine that her back
- 6:43Speaker 1: story is going to be convincing. You're exactly right. She
- 6:47Speaker 1: appears to have been deliberately playing a role. She appears
- 6:52Speaker 1: to have modeled her behavior as a tech mogul along
- 6:58Speaker 1: the lines of what she was seeing there in that world.
- 7:02Speaker 1: She was affecting behaviors that she'd seen other successful CEO
- 7:07Speaker 1: s u So all of that looks deliberate, and it
- 7:10Speaker 1: looks like it was put on to defraud people, to
- 7:13Speaker 1: make them believe in her and give her her money
- 7:17Speaker 1: because she appeared to be one of them. And the
- 7:20Speaker 1: other problem that I see for her is if the
- 7:23Speaker 1: jury will see all of the evidence of the role
- 7:28Speaker 1: that she played, the artificial ways in which she is
- 7:31Speaker 1: alleged to have styled herself, they're gonna think, oh, my gosh,
- 7:36Speaker 1: you know she was lying then, and then they're likely
- 7:40Speaker 1: to doubt the backstory she's telling now. You know, they
- 7:43Speaker 1: may just think she was lying then she's lying now,
- 7:46Speaker 1: So this is an awfully difficult cell, and I take
- 7:50Speaker 1: it she's going to try to tell some kind of
- 7:52Speaker 1: story that says, Yep, I did these things, but I
- 7:57Speaker 1: didn't do them for the purpose of bilking people of
- 8:01Speaker 1: their money. I did it because I had some kind
- 8:04Speaker 1: of psychological deficit, you know, some kind of psychological wound
- 8:09Speaker 1: that I was trying to fill. You know that I
- 8:11Speaker 1: was trying to please my boyfriend. I was trying to
- 8:14Speaker 1: make up for loss of affluence in my family when
- 8:18Speaker 1: I was a child, something like that. Again, it's very,
- 8:21Speaker 1: very tough from where we sit now to see how
- 8:24Speaker 1: this claim could succeed. But we don't yet know the
- 8:26Speaker 1: story she's going to tell. Now you mentioned her boyfriend
- 8:29Speaker 1: who was accused of the same crime. There has been
- 8:32Speaker 1: some suggestion that she might paint him as this sort
- 8:35Speaker 1: of spin gali and that she was under his influence
- 8:40Speaker 1: and they're not going to be tried together, So that's
- 8:42Speaker 1: something she could do. How would that help her in
- 8:45Speaker 1: a criminal case. It's going to be, again, an extremely
- 8:48Speaker 1: tough sell, and it's hard to know without the facts
- 8:51Speaker 1: exactly how she would try to present that defense. But
- 8:55Speaker 1: from reading the news reports, there are suggestions that for
- 9:00Speaker 1: her boyfriend, who was a top executive in the company,
- 9:05Speaker 1: whom she had known since she was nineteen years old,
- 9:08Speaker 1: I think, and he was quite a bit older than she,
- 9:11Speaker 1: So the idea was that she fell under his influence
- 9:14Speaker 1: and that she was carrying out a plan that was
- 9:18Speaker 1: being dictated by him. It's possible that that story is true.
- 9:23Speaker 1: The question for the jury will be, so what what
- 9:28Speaker 1: relevance does that story have to her guilt. People frequently
- 9:33Speaker 1: commit crimes acting under the influence of other people who
- 9:37Speaker 1: are under various kinds of influences, and it makes no
- 9:40Speaker 1: difference whatsoever to their liability. So one suggestion that I've
- 9:44Speaker 1: seen is that her ex boyfriend was a bully, and
- 9:49Speaker 1: maybe the claim is that he was very violent with her.
- 9:52Speaker 1: I'm just speculating now, but one argument might be that
- 9:56Speaker 1: she was so terrified as him that she carried out
- 9:59Speaker 1: the fraud because she was in fear of suffering further
- 10:03Speaker 1: abuse at his hands. That's almost an impossible claim to
- 10:07Speaker 1: mount in any case, but in a case like this
- 10:10Speaker 1: it looks truly impossible because of the amount of time
- 10:14Speaker 1: that the fraud occupied. In other words, sometimes defendants can
- 10:19Speaker 1: claim that they acted under dress. They acted because they
- 10:22Speaker 1: were afraid that some other powerful person was going to
- 10:25Speaker 1: harm them physically, really badly. You know, think of committing
- 10:29Speaker 1: a crime under the threat of death from with a
- 10:31Speaker 1: gun to the head. But even in those cases where
- 10:34Speaker 1: someone can show that they were mixed up with a
- 10:36Speaker 1: character who had threatened to harm them, if you had
- 10:39Speaker 1: time to go to the police and report that person,
- 10:42Speaker 1: if there were periods of time in which the person
- 10:45Speaker 1: didn't have a gun to your head, then the claim
- 10:48Speaker 1: will not succeed. And we have no evidence here that
- 10:51Speaker 1: she was committing this fraud under imminent or immediate threats
- 10:55Speaker 1: from this character. Thanks for being on the show, and
- 10:58Speaker 1: that's a conflint, A professor to University of Virginia Law School.
- 11:03Speaker 1: The late Robert Indiana is the pop artist whose Love
- 11:06Speaker 1: Sculpture became one of the most recognizable artworks of the
- 11:09Speaker 1: twentieth century, with an estate worth somewhere between fifty and
- 11:13Speaker 1: ninety million dollars. The legal fight over the rights to
- 11:16Speaker 1: Indiana's artwork and the control of his legacy has been
- 11:19Speaker 1: bitter and complicated, including allegations of art fraud and elder abuse,
- 11:24Speaker 1: but now a step has been taken toward resolution of
- 11:27Speaker 1: the dispute as Indiana's longtime representative. The Morgan Art Foundation,
- 11:32Speaker 1: a for profit company which originally brought the lawsuit, reached
- 11:36Speaker 1: an agreement with the nonprofit that's the sole beneficiary of
- 11:39Speaker 1: Indiana's a state, the Star of Hope Foundation. My guest
- 11:43Speaker 1: is the attorney who represents the Morgan Art Foundation, mar
- 11:47Speaker 1: And Shah, who has the art litigation practice at Quinn Emmanuel.
- 11:52Speaker 1: There are so many parties involved here, can you tell
- 11:54Speaker 1: us who the main parties are? Sure? So? The parties
- 11:59Speaker 1: in this litigation are my clients, who are the Morgan
- 12:02Speaker 1: Art Foundation and Simon salamkaro Um, who were the artist
- 12:07Speaker 1: Robert Indiana's patrons and partners on many of his projects
- 12:11Speaker 1: during his lifetime. The defendants in the case are James Brannon,
- 12:16Speaker 1: who is the personal representative or in other words, the
- 12:19Speaker 1: executor of indianas the state. Michael Mackenzie and his company
- 12:24Speaker 1: American Image Art, who produced certain works that were attributed
- 12:28Speaker 1: to Robert Indiana during the later years of his life.
- 12:32Speaker 1: And Jamie Thomas, who was Indiana's caretaker on the island
- 12:36Speaker 1: of vinyl Haven where he lived during the later years
- 12:39Speaker 1: of his life. So you initially sued Indiana as well.
- 12:44Speaker 1: We did, and the reason we did that was just
- 12:47Speaker 1: for technical legal reasons, even the structure of our my
- 12:50Speaker 1: client's contracts with Robert Indianna. But the intent in filing
- 12:54Speaker 1: the lawsuit, which you'll have to remember was filed when
- 12:57Speaker 1: the artist was alive, was really intend to protect the
- 13:01Speaker 1: artists and to protect his works against exploitation by we
- 13:05Speaker 1: believed Michael mackenzie and Jamie Thomas, who was then acting
- 13:08Speaker 1: as his power of attorney. Why did the Morgan Foundation
- 13:13Speaker 1: decide that it wanted to file or needed to file
- 13:16Speaker 1: a lawsuit. So, as part of their work with Indiana,
- 13:20Speaker 1: Indiana and Morgan had signed a series of contracts many
- 13:24Speaker 1: many years ago that gave Morgan the rights to certain
- 13:28Speaker 1: of Indiana's works, the rights to police the intellectual property
- 13:31Speaker 1: in those works, and the exclusive rights to fabricate and
- 13:34Speaker 1: sell certain additioned works. And Morgan Art Foundation and my
- 13:39Speaker 1: and and Mr Salamakaro and his family were very very
- 13:42Speaker 1: close to the artists um for decades and worked with
- 13:45Speaker 1: him in close collaboration during that whole time. And in
- 13:49Speaker 1: a couple of years prior to the artists stuffed, they
- 13:52Speaker 1: noticed a real shift in their ability to contact the
- 13:55Speaker 1: artists and to work with the artists. His health was
- 13:58Speaker 1: failing and his care had been taken over by a
- 14:01Speaker 1: new assistant who is Jamie Thomas, who my clients felt
- 14:05Speaker 1: were was progressively isolating the artist from his friends and
- 14:09Speaker 1: supporters and increasingly controlling his affairs um. And at the
- 14:13Speaker 1: same time as this was happening, my clients and many
- 14:16Speaker 1: others in the art market noticed that there were a
- 14:18Speaker 1: lot of new, low quality reproductions of Indiana's work that
- 14:23Speaker 1: we're starting to flood the market that nobody had ever
- 14:25Speaker 1: seen before and didn't believe we're really by the artists.
- 14:28Speaker 1: And so these two circumstances kind of consulated, and my
- 14:31Speaker 1: clients were really only able to visit the artist once
- 14:35Speaker 1: in the years before his death. They were they were
- 14:37Speaker 1: precluded from seeing him. Jamie Thomas barred them from coming
- 14:40Speaker 1: to visit him or talking to him, and when they
- 14:43Speaker 1: visited him, they found him in extremely poor health, living
- 14:46Speaker 1: in smaller and seemingly unaware of these things that were
- 14:50Speaker 1: going on um And so they ultimately filed the lawsuit
- 14:54Speaker 1: because they felt like they had no choice in order
- 14:57Speaker 1: to protect his art and his market from these quality infringements,
- 15:01Speaker 1: but also infringe own UM the rights that my clients
- 15:04Speaker 1: had under contracts with in Vienna, and also to bring
- 15:07Speaker 1: to light the condition that they had found him in
- 15:10Speaker 1: and what they believed to be the mistreatment and isolation
- 15:13Speaker 1: of him is in his elder years and unfortunately UM,
- 15:17Speaker 1: as it turned out, the lawsuit was filed just one
- 15:20Speaker 1: day before he ultimately passed away UM. So sadly they
- 15:24Speaker 1: were not able to help him personally during his lifetime UM,
- 15:28Speaker 1: but it was their hope that they would be able
- 15:29Speaker 1: to help and protect his legacy and the legacy of
- 15:32Speaker 1: his art UM from these low quality and fringements going forward.
- 15:36Speaker 1: So tell us about the allegations of the lawsuit. So
- 15:41Speaker 1: the law the lawsuit originally UM, which again was filed
- 15:45Speaker 1: while the artist was alive, alleged that in the later
- 15:49Speaker 1: years of his life, as I said, he had been
- 15:51Speaker 1: isolated and was being controlled by his caretaker UM, who
- 15:58Speaker 1: was essentially collaborating. It was alleged with Michael mackenzie and
- 16:02Speaker 1: his company American Image Arts, who were art publishers, and
- 16:06Speaker 1: what they did was produced certain additioned works which were
- 16:09Speaker 1: mostly prints UM of Robert Indiana Images UM and the
- 16:15Speaker 1: lawsuit alleged that these prints that they produced, uh, that
- 16:19Speaker 1: were attributed to Robert Indiana were essentially forgeries, that they
- 16:23Speaker 1: either were not authorized by the artists or were authorized
- 16:27Speaker 1: by him only under dress um, that they infringed on
- 16:31Speaker 1: copyrights and other rights that my clients had exclusively under
- 16:35Speaker 1: their contracts with the artists to produce and promote and
- 16:38Speaker 1: sell works that contain these images, um. And that they
- 16:43Speaker 1: you know, that they were damaging his art market um
- 16:46Speaker 1: and were essentially illegal reproductions of his work. It seems
- 16:49Speaker 1: as if this legal fight got bitter and nasty pretty quickly.
- 16:54Speaker 1: Is that indicative of these kinds of fights and or
- 16:58Speaker 1: was this particularly nasty? Yes, you know, I think it's
- 17:02Speaker 1: an unfortunate fact that artists, the States and foundations very
- 17:06Speaker 1: commonly encounter incredible difficulty after an artist dies, and they
- 17:10Speaker 1: often become embroiled in power struggles and litigations after an
- 17:14Speaker 1: artist's death, and surprisingly few of them are successful over
- 17:18Speaker 1: the long term. And I do think this case was
- 17:20Speaker 1: a prime example of that. It's it's an unusual example
- 17:24Speaker 1: of that in the way it developed, but it is
- 17:26Speaker 1: not unusual in the art world. In the art world,
- 17:29Speaker 1: and I just want you to respond to some claims
- 17:32Speaker 1: that were made against the foundation that you hadn't properly
- 17:36Speaker 1: compensated Indiana for sales of his work, and you unfairly
- 17:40Speaker 1: interfered with his business and some unauthorized reproductions. Yes, those
- 17:47Speaker 1: were all untrue, UM, and discovery in the case I
- 17:50Speaker 1: you know, I believe revealed that, and if the case
- 17:52Speaker 1: moved forward, that will become plain um at trial. But
- 17:56Speaker 1: my clients always provided um the accounting to Indiana that
- 18:00Speaker 1: they were required to under their contracts and that he
- 18:03Speaker 1: asked for. Um. They always paid him all the royalties
- 18:06Speaker 1: that he would do under the sales they made of
- 18:08Speaker 1: his works. Um. They did this for literally decades. He
- 18:12Speaker 1: you know, in close collaboration with him, talk to him
- 18:14Speaker 1: all the time. He never complained about it. Um. And
- 18:17Speaker 1: the projects that they undertook were undertaken with the express
- 18:20Speaker 1: permission and approval and cooperation of the artists during his law. Now,
- 18:25Speaker 1: how did the main attorney general get involved in this,
- 18:29Speaker 1: you know, dispute between private parties? Right? Well, in Maine,
- 18:34Speaker 1: the Attorney General's office has oversight functions over main nonprofit
- 18:38Speaker 1: organizations and the foundation that was established after the artist's death,
- 18:43Speaker 1: that was the sole beneficiary in his will of all
- 18:46Speaker 1: his assets and had a charitable mission to promote his
- 18:49Speaker 1: legacy going forward. Is a five O one C three
- 18:52Speaker 1: nonprofit organized under the laws of Maine, and so it
- 18:54Speaker 1: comes under the oversight powers of the main Attorney General.
- 18:58Speaker 1: And how much is at stake here, I've heard different
- 19:01Speaker 1: figures for what the estate is valued at I have
- 19:05Speaker 1: as well, And frankly, I don't have much insight into
- 19:08Speaker 1: what is the real value of these states, So I
- 19:10Speaker 1: probably can't tell you more than you read publicly. But
- 19:13Speaker 1: I think public estimates are somewhere between fifty and ninety million,
- 19:16Speaker 1: and I would say that's that's very likely correct. Tell
- 19:19Speaker 1: us about this settlement. So it's not a settlement per se,
- 19:23Speaker 1: and I can get into the kind of weird complexity
- 19:25Speaker 1: of that if if you'd be interested. But what it
- 19:28Speaker 1: is is an agreement between my clients, the Morgan Art Foundation,
- 19:32Speaker 1: UH and Simon Salamacaro and his family, and the Star
- 19:36Speaker 1: of Hope Foundation, which is the foundation that was established
- 19:40Speaker 1: for the terms of Indiana as well. That is the
- 19:42Speaker 1: sole beneficiary to all his assets under his will and
- 19:45Speaker 1: has the charitable mission going forward to promote his Works
- 19:49Speaker 1: and Legacy UM, and those parties agreed. So the Star
- 19:53Speaker 1: of Hope Foundation is not a party to this litigation,
- 19:56Speaker 1: but it is the sole beneficiary to the end of
- 19:57Speaker 1: the state UM. And so the Star of Hope agreed
- 20:01Speaker 1: directly with my clients outside the confines of the litigation
- 20:05Speaker 1: to uh productive business resolution and relationship going forward. And
- 20:10Speaker 1: the agreement governs the party's respective rights and obligations with
- 20:14Speaker 1: respect to Indiana's works and legacy, both in resolving past
- 20:18Speaker 1: issues and UM to move forward productively in the future.
- 20:23Speaker 1: So the litigation is ongoing. Then the litigation is ongoing.
- 20:27Speaker 1: But what we have done is we on Monday, as
- 20:30Speaker 1: a result of this agreement, which was signed on Friday last,
- 20:35Speaker 1: we filed a motion in the litigation to dismiss the
- 20:39Speaker 1: estate claims against my clients as moot. Because what the
- 20:42Speaker 1: settlement with the Star of Hope does is conclusively resolve
- 20:46Speaker 1: all of the outstanding claims that were an issue between
- 20:49Speaker 1: the estate and my clients in the litigation and makes
- 20:51Speaker 1: them so. It is our hope and we believe UM
- 20:54Speaker 1: that what should happen in the best interests of the
- 20:57Speaker 1: artists and legally is for those claims to be dismissed
- 20:59Speaker 1: and part of the litigation to come to an end.
- 21:01Speaker 1: So in response to this, the state Attorney, James Brannon
- 21:06Speaker 1: said he was preparing to move forward with plans to
- 21:09Speaker 1: depose key figures in the case and to take the
- 21:11Speaker 1: case to trial. Yes, I did read that statement by
- 21:15Speaker 1: him as well. UM, And I can't tell you what
- 21:17Speaker 1: intentions are. UM. I can tell you that his apparent
- 21:21Speaker 1: strategy and the litigation has long been at odds with
- 21:24Speaker 1: the wishes of the foundation. The Foundation has directly instructed
- 21:29Speaker 1: him to settle the litigation many times he has refused
- 21:32Speaker 1: to do so. And that's how we ended up where
- 21:34Speaker 1: we are now, which is a litigation that is extremely
- 21:37Speaker 1: costly and wasteful um to all parties, yet with both
- 21:41Speaker 1: of the parties who are real parties and interests, wanting
- 21:43Speaker 1: to settle it and wanting to move forward productively. UM.
- 21:47Speaker 1: And which is how we ended up with an agreement
- 21:49Speaker 1: directly with the Star of Hope Foundation. UM. I can
- 21:52Speaker 1: tell you June that since Mr Brandon made that statement,
- 21:56Speaker 1: we have in fact postponed for a small period of
- 21:58Speaker 1: time the depositions that were supposed to be taken this week,
- 22:01Speaker 1: so that they're not actually going forward right now. It's
- 22:04Speaker 1: also the press. Harold reported that the art publisher Michael
- 22:09Speaker 1: mackenzie denounced the agreement, saying it smells bad. That's like
- 22:13Speaker 1: saying I just made a deal with the devil. He
- 22:16Speaker 1: said when I go to hell, he's not going to
- 22:17Speaker 1: have it that hot. Yes, I read that also. Um,
- 22:22Speaker 1: you know he uh, he has not seen the agreement. Um.
- 22:26Speaker 1: He's not a party to the agreement. I can't speculate
- 22:29Speaker 1: on the reasons why he may or may not like it,
- 22:31Speaker 1: but he has been known to make very inflamatory statements
- 22:34Speaker 1: in the past against my clients. They're all completely unfounded. Um.
- 22:38Speaker 1: But you know that's where we are. You know, it's
- 22:40Speaker 1: hard for an outside observer to understand, you know, how
- 22:45Speaker 1: this agreement settles things when the defendants in the case
- 22:49Speaker 1: say it hasn't. Yeah, it's a great question. Um. And
- 22:53Speaker 1: it is a bit of legal complexity there. So it
- 22:56Speaker 1: is um well established law, as we've set fourth in
- 22:59Speaker 1: our ocean that again, this is not a settlement of
- 23:02Speaker 1: the case because settlement is you typically think of it
- 23:05Speaker 1: occurs between two parties to the litigation. Um, in settlement
- 23:09Speaker 1: of the litigation claims, and that's not what's happened here.
- 23:12Speaker 1: What's happened here is that our client, who is the
- 23:15Speaker 1: party to the litigation, and a third party have come
- 23:18Speaker 1: to a consensual resolution that essentially renders moot all of
- 23:24Speaker 1: the dispute between the estate and my clients in the
- 23:27Speaker 1: litigation UM. And it is well established law that a
- 23:32Speaker 1: number of outside event events UM can have the effect
- 23:36Speaker 1: during the pendency of a litigation of rendering the dispute
- 23:40Speaker 1: moot um. And a court, a federal court UM like
- 23:43Speaker 1: the Southern District of New York, who has the case here,
- 23:46Speaker 1: is empowered and has jurisdiction only to hear disputes to
- 23:50Speaker 1: present a quote live case or controversy, meaning they can
- 23:54Speaker 1: only hear issues that are actually live disputes and where
- 23:58Speaker 1: the court's judgment will actually have an effect on the party.
- 24:02Speaker 1: And if anything changes during the litigation UM that makes
- 24:05Speaker 1: the dispute no longer active and makes it such a
- 24:09Speaker 1: court judgment will be irrelevant or ineffective, then the court
- 24:14Speaker 1: loses jurisdiction over the case and has to dismiss it.
- 24:17Speaker 1: And that is essentially what's happened here. UM. For example,
- 24:20Speaker 1: you know this happened in cases where one party sues
- 24:23Speaker 1: another over the disclosure of documents, and then a third
- 24:27Speaker 1: party agency releases the documents during the litigation, and even
- 24:31Speaker 1: though the third party agency isn't a party to be lawsuit,
- 24:35Speaker 1: that action has rendered the claims moods, and then those
- 24:37Speaker 1: claims will be dismissed. So, you know, it's not the
- 24:40Speaker 1: exact same situation here, but it's the same principle. Is
- 24:43Speaker 1: this unique in any way in an art litigation fight?
- 24:47Speaker 1: You know, it is fairly unique. This is the first
- 24:50Speaker 1: time that I'm aware, um, that a solution like this
- 24:54Speaker 1: has been reached. I think it is a fairly unprecedented result, um.
- 24:59Speaker 1: But it came about due to the unique situation that
- 25:03Speaker 1: we found ourselves in in this litigation, which is that
- 25:06Speaker 1: the wishes of the artists and the wishes of the
- 25:09Speaker 1: foundation that he left behind were simply not being respected
- 25:12Speaker 1: by the executive executor of his estate. And it was
- 25:16Speaker 1: the executor who was in charge of the litigation um
- 25:19Speaker 1: and who refused instructions by the foundation to settle the
- 25:22Speaker 1: litigation um and instead spent millions of dollars of estate funds,
- 25:28Speaker 1: drained the artist bank account of literally all of the
- 25:31Speaker 1: money he left behind, sold many millions of dollars worth
- 25:35Speaker 1: of works of arts that had been housed in the
- 25:37Speaker 1: artists private collection, all of which were supposed to go
- 25:40Speaker 1: to the foundation to fund UH and enable its charitable mission. UM.
- 25:45Speaker 1: And so you have an executor who was really kind
- 25:48Speaker 1: of running rampant in the litigation, spending a ton of
- 25:52Speaker 1: the estates on litigation sees against the express wishes of
- 25:56Speaker 1: both the artists and the Artists Foundation who were the
- 25:58Speaker 1: beneficiary of eight UM. And it's, I would say, is
- 26:02Speaker 1: fairly unusual and with an unexpected situation that we found
- 26:06Speaker 1: ourselves in, and that's what led to this somewhat unprecedented results.
- 26:10Speaker 1: So let me ask you this. You know, there are
- 26:12Speaker 1: a lot of legal fights over artists work, as you know,
- 26:15Speaker 1: in this case, it seems like Indiana did have things
- 26:19Speaker 1: in place. I was thinking forward, but yet it still
- 26:23Speaker 1: fell apart. How do you prevent that them happening? You know,
- 26:28Speaker 1: I don't know how you prevent that from happening. I
- 26:30Speaker 1: would say, it really behooves artists, and they very rarely
- 26:34Speaker 1: do this during their lifetime, which is why you end
- 26:37Speaker 1: up with issues like this UM. But it behooves artists
- 26:40Speaker 1: during their lifetime especial if they've become well renowned during
- 26:45Speaker 1: their lifetime for their art, to really put in place
- 26:48Speaker 1: an active foundation that is set up during their lifetime,
- 26:52Speaker 1: to appoint an executor of their estate who they can
- 26:55Speaker 1: trust and they know will fulfill their wishes. You know,
- 26:58Speaker 1: it's very hard to control the actions of pep well
- 27:00Speaker 1: after the artist passes away. I don't know what you
- 27:03Speaker 1: can do to prevent that, um, but I do think
- 27:06Speaker 1: it is very worthwhile. And again this this is something
- 27:09Speaker 1: that doesn't necessarily uh go in tandem with the creative
- 27:13Speaker 1: personality and someone that is focused on on creating art
- 27:16Speaker 1: during their life rather than than leaving the archives and
- 27:20Speaker 1: the art and the foundation and in functioning order. But um,
- 27:24Speaker 1: you know, I think the more artists can do to
- 27:26Speaker 1: set up the structures that will be necessary to continue
- 27:29Speaker 1: their legacy after their death, and to do that well
- 27:31Speaker 1: in advance during their lifetime, probably the less likelihood of
- 27:35Speaker 1: problems like this we will see. Thanks Maren. That's Maren Shaw,
- 27:39Speaker 1: a partner at Quinn Emanuel. And that's it for the
- 27:42Speaker 1: edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. I'm June Grasso. Thanks
- 27:45Speaker 1: so much for listening, and please remember to tune to
- 27:47Speaker 1: the Bloomberg Law Show every week night at ten pm Eastern,
- 27:50Speaker 1: right here on Bloomberg Radio.