Latest / Reformed Thinking / A Farewell Sermon (2 Corinthians 1:14) | Jonathan Edwards

Transcript

A Farewell Sermon (2 Corinthians 1:14) | Jonathan Edwards · Reformed Thinking

0:00
Imagine packing your desk after 23 years at a job.
0:04
You load up your boxes, you hand over your keys, and you walk out
0:06
the door. Right.
0:07
And usually when you reach that moment, the relationship is
0:10
finished, the contract is severed and you just move on.
0:13
Precisely. But on July 1st, 1750, when
0:17
Jonathan Edwards stood in the pulpit of Northampton, MA to
0:21
give his farewell address after being fired by his own
0:24
congregation, he did not just say goodbye.
0:26
No, he did something much heavier.
0:28
He really did. He looked at the very people who
0:30
had just terminated his livelihood, and he told them he
0:33
was scheduling one final, inescapable performance review.
0:37
Welcome to reformed thinking. Today we are taking a historical
0:41
theological document and pulling out the most vital truths for
0:44
your own faith and understanding.
0:46
We are jumping straight into a moment in history that
0:48
completely shatters our modern casual assumptions about church
0:51
life. And for this deep dive, we're
0:53
going to examine the staggering theological claim Edwards makes
0:56
in his final address. He states that a minister and
0:59
his congregation will have a specific, distinct meeting at
1:03
the Day of Judgement to account for their relationship.
1:06
To grasp the gravity of that claim, we have to look at the
1:09
specific circumstances of this farewell.
1:12
We are stepping into a very particular time and place.
1:16
Picture the dirt roads in the sprawling meetinghouse of
1:19
Northampton. Jonathan Edwards is widely
1:21
considered the greatest theologian the American
1:23
continent has ever produced. I mean, he was a man of
1:26
staggering intellect and intense pastoral devotion.
1:29
But he is not standing in this pulpit to celebrate a joyful
1:32
retirement, and he's not leaving for a more lucrative position in
1:36
Boston or New Haven. Not at all.
1:38
He has been voted out after 23 years of exhaustive labor.
1:42
His own congregation has formally dismissed him.
1:45
Today's source material is the address he gave on that
1:47
occasion. It is called a farewell sermon,
1:50
and it is based on the Apostle Paul's words in Second
1:52
Corinthians, chapter one, verse 14.
1:55
Before we analyze the doctrine of that sermon, you need to
1:57
understand the historical and personal mechanics of this
2:01
rupture. Edwards spent over 2 decades
2:03
with this flock. He states plainly in his text
2:06
that he labored through intense physical infirmity.
2:10
We are talking about a man who spent up to 13 hours a day in
2:14
the study. Yes, agonizing over the Texas
2:17
Scripture, writing out sermons, and praying for the eternal
2:20
state of the people in his town. He did not spend his prime years
2:24
building a financial empire. He did not seek temporal gain or
2:28
tried to secure worldly status for his family.
2:31
He spent his life working for the eternal welfare of their
2:34
souls. And their response was to hand
2:36
him his walking papers. So what actually broke this
2:40
relationship apart? What was the catalyst?
2:42
Edwards refers to the situation in his text as the late Grand
2:46
Controversy. To understand the mechanics of
2:49
this dispute, we have to look through the lens of Reformed
2:51
ecclesiology. Specifically, how the
2:54
Westminster Confession articulates the purity of the
2:56
visible Church and the administration of the
2:58
sacraments. Right Edwards was dismissed over
3:01
a fierce dispute regarding the qualifications necessary for
3:04
full communion. His predecessor in Northampton
3:07
was his own grandfather, Solomon Stoddard.
3:10
Stoddard was a massive figure. Was he?
3:12
Oh, absolutely. He was often called the Pope of
3:14
the Connecticut River Valley, and he had instituted a practice
3:18
known widely as the Halfway Covenant, though Stoddard pushed
3:21
it even further. How?
3:22
Far did he push it? He allowed individuals who were
3:25
not professing converted believers to partake of the
3:28
Lord's Supper. Stoddard viewed the sacrament as
3:32
a converting ordinance. I need to pause right there.
3:35
That concept is completely foreign to how most believers
3:39
understand the sacraments today. It definitely is.
3:42
Why would anyone think eating the bread and drinking the cup
3:46
could convert a spiritually dead heart?
3:48
Doesn't the Apostle Paul explicitly warn against taking
3:51
communion in an unworthy manner? He certainly does, and that is
3:54
precisely the tension. Stoddard's logic was born out of
3:57
a specific historical panic. A panic about what?
4:00
Well, the first generation of Puritans who settled New England
4:03
were intensely devout, but by the 2nd and 3rd generations,
4:06
religious fervor was cooling. Fewer people were experiencing
4:10
the dramatic, identifiable conversions that their early
4:13
Puritans demanded for church membership.
4:15
So. The church numbers were
4:15
dropping. Yes, Stoddard saw his pews
4:18
filling up with moral, decent townspeople who attended church
4:22
every Sunday, but could not point to a specific moment of
4:25
living faith. He reasoned that since preaching
4:28
is a means of grace used to convert sinners, the Lord's
4:31
Supper could also function as a means of grace to convert them.
4:34
He opened the doors wide. He did.
4:37
He allowed the unconverted to come to the table, hoping the
4:39
physical elements would stir their affections toward Christ.
4:43
So Edwards inherits this massive compromise legacy from his
4:47
grandfather, and for years he maintains the status quo.
4:51
He did, but eventually Edwards decides he must fence the table.
4:55
He comes to the resolute conviction that his
4:57
grandfather's practice was entirely unbiblical.
5:00
He insisted only those who make a credible profession of faith,
5:03
those who possess the wedding garment of true conversion,
5:07
should be admitted to the Lord's Supper.
5:09
This was a direct challenge to the established tradition of the
5:11
town. It was an earthquake in the
5:13
community. Edwards was enforcing the purity
5:15
of church ordinances. In Reformed theology, the
5:18
sacraments are signs and seals of the Covenant of Grace,
5:22
intended only for those who are already in the covenant.
5:25
Exactly right. Giving the Lord's Supper to an
5:28
unregenerate person is like giving a wedding ring to someone
5:30
who refuses to say their vows. It makes a mockery of the
5:34
institution. Edwards recognized that treating
5:36
Communion as a converting ordinance was filling his church
5:40
with hypocrites and giving false assurance to spiritually dead
5:43
people. He realized he was essentially
5:46
administering spiritual poison to his flock by allowing them to
5:49
eat and drink judgement upon themselves and the.
5:52
Congregation turned on him for that.
5:53
They wanted the status quo. They liked their cultural
5:56
Christianity left intact. They like the social
5:59
respectability of taking communion without the rigorous
6:02
demand of true repentance. But Edwards refused to bend his
6:05
theological convictions for job security.
6:08
He stood his ground and it cost him his livelihood.
6:11
It plunged his large family into severe financial distress.
6:15
He was left without a salary, with a wife and numerous
6:17
children to feed. That historical context sets the
6:20
stage for the tone of this farewell sermon.
6:23
Edwards is not speaking from a place of petty vindictiveness.
6:27
He's not groveling for his job back, nor is he trying to win a
6:31
popularity contest. He approaches this farewell with
6:34
a sober eschatological weight. He views his pastoral office not
6:39
as a contract negotiated with a human committee, but as a divine
6:43
Commission. The congregation may have
6:45
severed the earthly contract, but Edwards tells them the
6:48
divine Commission has an eternal audit.
6:51
Attached to it, the relationship between a pastor and his flock
6:54
is forged in the context of eternity.
6:57
Therefore, it's dissolution on Earth does not mean the
6:59
accounting is finished. This shifts the entire paradigm.
7:02
Think about a complex legal trial where you fire your
7:05
defense attorney because you don't like his strategy.
7:07
You walk out of the courtroom thinking you have solved your
7:10
problem. But Edwards is telling his
7:11
congregation that the trial is not over.
7:14
He is saying you fired your defense attorney.
7:17
But when the final court convenes, I am going to be
7:19
called back into the room as the star witness for the
7:21
prosecution. He looks at this congregation
7:24
and tells them this conversation is not over, We're going to have
7:28
a follow up meeting at the judgement seat of Christ.
7:30
That is the core doctrine he extracts from the Apostle Paul
7:33
in Second Corinthians. Ministers and the people under
7:36
their care must meet one another before Christ's tribunal at the
7:40
day of judgement. If they are separated in this
7:43
changeable world by distance, by disputes or by death, this final
7:47
meeting is an absolute certainty.
7:50
Edwards adds A fascinating nuance regarding the mechanics
7:52
of the crowd at the final judgement.
7:55
We often picture the Judgement Day as a massive,
7:57
incomprehensible sea of humanity.
8:00
Edwards acknowledges the sheer volume of souls.
8:03
Millions upon millions will be there.
8:05
The elect, the fallen angels, all of humanity from every
8:08
generation since Adam. The scope is terrifying, but he.
8:11
Points out a specific limitation of human nature that we rarely
8:15
consider when thinking about eternity.
8:17
We will be glorified, yes. Our capacities will be enlarged,
8:20
our understanding will be vast, and we will be free from sin.
8:24
But our minds will still be finite.
8:25
We will not suddenly become omniscient.
8:27
A human mind cannot simultaneously process
8:30
individual, meaningful interactions with billions of
8:33
people. We cannot look at a crowd of 10
8:36
billion souls and comprehend our relationship to each one at the
8:40
exact same moment. So if we are finite beings
8:43
standing in an infinite crowd, how does the judgement actually
8:47
function on a personal level? Edwards argues that God will
8:50
grant special notice to specific individuals.
8:54
The logic here is rigorous and thoroughly biblical.
8:57
Because our finite minds cannot focus on everyone, God will
9:00
actively direct our attention. He will draw our gaze toward
9:04
those with whom we had special concerns during our earthly
9:07
probation. Our earthly lives are a state of
9:10
probation, a time of testing, hearing, and responding to the
9:13
gospel. The relationships that carry the
9:15
most spiritual weight during this probationary period will be
9:18
brought to the forefront of our consciousness.
9:20
Edwards lists rulers and subjects, parent and children,
9:23
husbands and wives. But he zeroes in on the
9:25
relationship between pastors and congregants, elevating it above
9:29
almost all others. This relationship involves the
9:32
administration of the means of grace, the preaching of the
9:35
Word, the Sacraments, the discipline of the Church.
9:39
These are the very mechanisms God uses to gather and perfect
9:43
His elect. Therefore, the individuals
9:45
involved in these specific interactions must be brought
9:48
face to face to give an account of how those means were
9:51
administered and received. It is a sobering reality.
9:55
I am struggling with a massive theological tension here though,
9:57
and I know you listening, you're probably thinking the same
9:59
thing. What is the tension?
10:01
If I am justified by faith alone, clothed in the imputed
10:05
righteousness of Christ, why am I standing in front of my former
10:08
pastor for a performance review? Doesn't scripture say Christ is
10:11
the sole judge of mankind? It does if my sins are cast as
10:15
far as the East is from the West.
10:17
How does Edwards justify placing a human minister on the tribunal
10:21
without violating Christ's supremacy?
10:24
This feels like it drags me back under the law and threatens the
10:27
assurance of my salvation. That is a brilliant question,
10:30
and it strikes at the heart of Reformed theology.
10:32
We must distinguish between justification and the final
10:36
public vindication of God's justice.
10:38
OK, lay that out for us. Justification by faith alone
10:42
secures your eternal state. The moment you believe your sins
10:46
are pardoned and the righteousness of Christ is
10:48
credited to your account, you are adopted and your entrance
10:52
into glory is guaranteed. So the judgement is not about my
10:55
salvation. Right.
10:57
The final judgement is not a second trial to determine if
11:00
your justification was real. It is not a moment where your
11:03
salvation hangs in the balance. Then what is it for?
11:06
The final judgement is the public vindication of God's
11:09
perfect righteous justice. It is the moment when the hidden
11:13
things of darkness are brought to light and the equity of God's
11:16
dealings is manifested to the entire universe.
11:19
So it is about exposure and agreement, not about retrying
11:23
the case of my salvation. Precisely.
11:25
Furthermore, Scripture clearly teaches a final accounting of
11:28
stewardship for believers. The Apostle Paul writes in
11:31
Second Corinthians chapter 5 that we must all appear before
11:34
the judgement seat of Christ to receive what is due for what we
11:37
have done in the body, whether good or evil.
11:39
For the minister, this involves an accounting of his the
11:42
stewardship of the mysteries of God.
11:45
Did he preach the whole counsel of God that he warned the
11:47
wicked? And for the congregant, it
11:49
involves an accounting of their stewardship of the privileges
11:52
they received. How did they respond to the
11:54
gospel? Did they submit to the
11:56
discipline of the church? The meeting between the pastor
11:59
and the congregant is not to establish justification.
12:02
It is to demonstrate the truth of all earthly interactions and
12:06
to show the universe that Christ's judgments are entirely
12:09
just. Christ remains the sole supreme
12:12
judge, but He uses the testimony of his appointed ministers to
12:15
publicly confirm the righteousness of his verdicts.
12:18
That distinction brings a lot of clarity.
12:21
It is about God's justice being seen, acknowledged and praised
12:25
by all creation. Since this final meeting is a
12:27
guaranteed certainty, Edward spends a massive portion of his
12:31
sermon contrasting how different this future meeting will be from
12:34
a standard Sunday morning church service.
12:37
He wants his listeners to feel the shock of that future.
12:41
He sets up 4 stark contrasts between earthly gatherings and
12:45
the final tribunal, blending them logically to strip away any
12:49
casual assumptions. The first major shift Edwards
12:52
highlights is the transition from a mutable changeable state
12:55
to an unchangeable state. In this earthly life we gather
12:59
in a condition of probation. This point carries immense
13:02
theological gravity. Right now, sinners can still be
13:05
converted. Through the blessing of God on
13:07
the preaching of the Word, a person can be brought from a
13:10
state of wrath and condemnation into a state of favor with God.
13:14
The means of grace are active. The door of the Ark is still
13:17
open. Saints, too, are in a mutable
13:19
state. They battle remaining
13:21
corruption, they face affliction, and they gather
13:23
under the preaching of the Word to be sanctified, to be
13:25
comforted, and to grow in grace. The pastor functions as an
13:29
active instrument of that grace. Every single Sunday is an
13:32
opportunity for a happy alteration of a person's
13:35
spiritual trajectory. But Edwards paints A terrifying
13:37
picture of the heavenly meeting. When that day comes, the state
13:41
of every single soul is entirely fixed.
13:44
There is no more flux. He quotes the chilling words
13:47
from the Book of Revelation. He that is filthy, let him be
13:51
filthy still, and he that is righteous, let him be righteous
13:54
still. The time for repentance is over.
13:57
The time for sanctification is over.
13:59
The minister will stand afore his people, and he will have
14:02
absolutely no gospel to offer the unrepentant.
14:05
The function of the minister as an instrument of grace is
14:08
completely, totally finished. There are no more appeals, no
14:11
more altar calls, no more pastoral counseling sessions.
14:14
The medicine of the soul is no longer available because the
14:17
eternal condition is locked. The finality of that moment is
14:20
absolute. The minister who spent his
14:22
entire life begging people to flee from the wrath to come.
14:26
We'll look at the unrepentant members of his flock and feel no
14:29
more pity. He will offer no more prayers
14:31
and shed no more tears. His alignment with the
14:34
vindicative justice of God will be so complete that he will
14:37
fully agree with their condemnation.
14:39
But the. Terror of this fixed state isn't
14:41
just that you cannot change your condition, it is that you can no
14:44
longer hide your true condition. This brings us to the second
14:47
major contrast Edwards draws the shift from the varying obscured
14:52
light of this world to the infallible light of the
14:56
Judgement Day. Think about the stage play.
14:59
The actors wear cheap makeup. They stand in front of painted
15:01
cardboard sets and under the dim theatrical lighting.
15:05
The illusion works. The audience believes they're
15:07
looking at a castle or a forest. But if someone suddenly throws
15:11
the house lights on, the harsh, bright bulbs expose every scene,
15:15
every brushstroke, and every piece of tape holding the set
15:17
together. The illusion is shattered
15:19
instantly. That is how Edwards describes
15:22
our current earthly gatherings. In our current state, ministers
15:25
lack infallible discernment. They try to apply the word
15:29
faithfully. They attempt to guide the flock,
15:31
but they make mistakes. Debates happen.
15:33
Prejudices cloud our judgement. Unresolved controversies linger
15:37
for decades. In the visible Church,
15:39
hypocrites often pass for eminent Saints, and true
15:42
believers are sometimes wrongly censured or misunderstood.
15:45
We look at the people in the pews next to us and we only see
15:47
the cardboard set. We see through a glass darkly.
15:50
Edwards brings up a truth that is simultaneously terrifying and
15:54
immensely comforting. He states that when Christ
15:58
returns, all delusion will vanish like the darkness of the
16:01
night before the rising sun. Every single secret of every
16:05
heart will be made manifest. The true spiritual state of
16:08
every person sitting in the pews will be exposed for all the
16:12
universe to see. Every hidden sin, every silent
16:15
rebellion, every act of secret hypocrisy will be laid bare
16:19
under the blinding light of omniscience.
16:21
And it's not just the congregation whose secrets are
16:23
revealed. The pastor's true motives will
16:26
be exposed as well. That is a sobering thought for
16:28
anyone in ministry. It's devastating.
16:30
The light will reveal exactly why the pastor preached.
16:33
Was he seeking the applause of men?
16:35
Was he acting out of pride, a desire for financial security or
16:38
a need for control? Or was he genuinely motivated by
16:41
a love for Christ and a desire to see souls saved?
16:45
The infallible light of Christ will strip away every disguise,
16:48
every religious mask. There will be no more
16:50
disagreements about doctrine or motives because the truth will
16:52
be universally apparent. The church in Northampton have
16:55
been arguing for years about who was truly qualified to take
16:59
communion. At the judgement, Christ will
17:01
end the argument by revealing precisely who possessed the
17:04
wedding garment and who did not. This shifts the focus from the
17:08
nature of the light to the nature of the presence.
17:11
In this world. We gather to wait upon an unseen
17:14
Lord. When you go to church on Sunday,
17:16
the minister preaches about an invisible king.
17:18
He declares the realities of a God in heaven, the intercession
17:22
of Christ at the right hand of the Father, and a future state
17:25
of rewards and punishments. The congregation must exercise
17:28
faith in things not currently seen with the physical eye.
17:32
But at the final tribunal, the meeting will take place in the
17:35
blinding, immediate, visible presence of the judge.
17:39
You will not be hearing sermons about an absent Christ.
17:41
You will be standing before the immense glory and awful majesty
17:44
of the Incarnate Son of God, surrounded by 10s of thousands
17:48
of His holy angels. The mediation of the Word gives
17:51
way to immediate, terrifying sight.
17:54
The physical reality of the Incarnation is brought to bear
17:56
on the judgement. Christ is not a concept or a
17:59
distant theological premise. He is a resurrected man with
18:03
blazing eyes, functioning as the Sovereign Judge of the universe.
18:06
When the pastor and the congregation meet, they will not
18:09
be meeting in a quiet office. They will be meeting at the foot
18:13
of a throne that radiates absolute holiness.
18:16
That leads directly to the final contrast Edwards draws, and it
18:19
is incredibly relatable even hundreds of years later.
18:23
He compares the careless hearts found in earthly gatherings with
18:27
the rapt attention that will characterize the final meeting.
18:30
Edwards complaints about people sleeping in church, having
18:32
wandering minds and completely ignoring the solemnity of
18:36
worship. It is amazing to think that
18:38
Jonathan Edwards, preaching some of the most rigorous,
18:41
intellectually demanding theological discourses in
18:44
history, looked out from his pulpit and saw people nodding
18:48
off in the pews. It speaks to the Reformed
18:50
doctrine of total depravity and the inherent dullness of the
18:52
human heart. We have an astonishing capacity
18:55
to trivialize the sacred. We can sit in the presence of
18:58
the means of grace, hearing the very words of eternal life, and
19:02
be completely indifferent. We allow our minds to drift to
19:05
our secular affairs, our financial anxieties, our weekend
19:08
plans, or our petty grievances with the person sitting in the
19:12
next row. We treat the gathering of the
19:14
visible church as a mundane civic duty rather than a cosmic
19:18
event. Think about your posture last
19:21
Sunday. Were you mentally drafting your
19:23
grocery list during the sermon? Were you checking your watch,
19:27
wondering when the pastor would finally wrap up so you could
19:29
beat the lunch rush at the restaurant?
19:31
Edwards is arguing that your boredom in that exact moment is
19:34
being logged as evidence for a cosmic trial.
19:37
At the judgement seat, there will be an utter absence of
19:40
distraction. Every single soul will be fully
19:43
awakened to the reality of the moment.
19:45
There will be no sleeping, no careless thoughts, no wandering
19:47
eyes. The overwhelming presence of the
19:49
judge and the absolute finality of the proceedings will command
19:52
the complete, undivided attention of every individual.
19:56
You will not be able to look away.
19:58
When you take this framework and apply it to our modern context,
20:01
it functions as a devastating critique of how casual church
20:04
culture has become. We often treat Sunday mornings
20:07
like a consumer experience. We evaluate the music, we
20:10
critique the speaker's presentation skills, We grab our
20:13
coffee and we leave unchanged. If we don't like the vibe, we
20:17
just shop for a different church down the street.
20:20
Edwards radically shifts the gravity of simply sitting in a
20:23
Pew. If his theology is correct,
20:26
listening to a sermon is never a passive activity.
20:29
It is the active gathering of evidence for a future tribunal.
20:33
Every time you sit under the preaching of the Word, you are
20:36
adding weight to the account you will one day render.
20:40
The Word of God never returns void.
20:42
It is always accomplishing a purpose.
20:44
It is either functioning to soften a heart and to salvation,
20:47
or is functioning to harden a heart unto judgement.
20:50
The casual approach to worship completely ignores the
20:53
eschatological stakes of hearing the gospel proclaimed.
20:56
With a terrifying clarity of this heavenly courtroom
20:58
established, we have to ask what the actual agenda of this
21:01
meeting will be. We know the environment is
21:03
infallible, unchangeable, and perfectly quickly focused.
21:06
But why are the pastor in the congregation brought face to
21:09
face in front of the throne? What are they actually doing
21:11
there? Edwards outlines 3 specific
21:14
purposes for this final meeting. The first purpose is the giving
21:18
of an account. The theological framework here
21:21
is stewardship rooted in the parables of Christ.
21:24
Ministers are sent by Christ on his business.
21:27
They are his servants, His messengers, entrusted with the
21:30
most valuable commodity in the universe, the Gospel.
21:33
When their earthly labor is done, they must return to their
21:36
master to give a rigorous report of their conduct and their
21:40
success. Edwards references the parable
21:42
in Luke 14 where the servant is sent to call guests to the Great
21:46
Supper. The servant must return to the
21:48
master to report who accepted the invitation and who made
21:51
excuses and refused. He also cites Hebrews chapter
21:55
13, which states that leaders watch over souls, as those who
21:59
must give an account. The faithful pastors will stand
22:01
there and present the receptive congregants as their crown of
22:04
rejoicing the. Apostle Paul uses this exact
22:06
imagery with the Thessalonians. The pastor can point to those
22:09
who believe the gospel, those who repented, those who grew in
22:12
holiness under his ministry. He can say, Lord, here's the
22:15
fruit of the ministry you and trusted to me.
22:18
Here are the souls won by Your grace through my weak preaching.
22:22
But the text also reveals a chilling reality that completely
22:26
upends our modern sentimental view of pastors.
22:30
Casters will not only meet the believers, they will also meet
22:33
those who rejected the gospel. And they will not meet them to
22:36
offer one last we they will meet them to act as judges and
22:40
assessors with Christ to condemn them.
22:42
I have to admit that sounds incredibly harsh.
22:45
A pastor acting as an assessor to condemn his own flock.
22:48
It sounds harsh to modern ears because we have detached the
22:51
love of God from the justice of God, but this aligns perfectly
22:54
with the Apostle Paul's teaching in First Corinthians chapter 6
22:58
where he states that the Saints will judge the world.
23:00
In Reformed theology, the final judgment involves the righteous
23:03
agreeing completely with the verdicts of Christ.
23:05
The faithful minister whose warnings were ignored, whose
23:08
counsel was mocked, and whose life was spent pleading with
23:11
obstinate sinners, will stand in perfect agreement with the
23:15
righteous judgment of Christ against those unrepentant
23:18
individuals. The minister will testify to the
23:20
fact that the truth was proclaimed, the warnings were
23:23
clear, the offers of mercy were genuine, and the rejection was
23:26
willful. His testimony will silence every
23:29
excuse the Sinner might try to make.
23:31
Conversely, Edwards notes that a flock that was abused by an
23:35
unfaithful self seeking minister will rise up in judgment against
23:39
that false shepherd. The sheep will testify against
23:42
the hireling who fed himself rather than the flock, the man
23:46
who preached smooth things and prophesied deceits to keep his
23:50
salary secure. The second purpose of the
23:52
meeting is the adjudicating of controversies.
23:55
We know that earthly disputes are frequently settled by church
23:58
politics, by the majority vote, or by whoever has the most
24:01
influence or the loudest voice. Truth is often a casualty in
24:05
human conflicts. Edwards, his own situation in
24:08
Northampton is the perfect example of this.
24:10
He was voted out by a majority. The council of neighboring
24:13
churches that oversaw his dismissal voted against him by a
24:16
margin of just one single vote. But a majority vote does not
24:19
determine theological truth. Edwards tells his congregation
24:23
that the infallible judge will definitively setter their
24:25
Communion controversy. Human church courts are
24:28
fallible. Even the Westminster Confession,
24:30
which provides the bedrock for Reformed ecclesiology,
24:34
explicitly acknowledges that all synods and councils since the
24:37
apostles times may err, and many have erred.
24:40
Therefore, they're not to be made the rule of faith or
24:42
practice, but to be used as a help.
24:45
Earthly decisions, even those made by solemn Church councils,
24:48
are not the final word. The divine court is infallible.
24:52
Christ, the infinite fountain of light and truth, will declare
24:55
who was in the right. He will examine the doctrines
24:58
preached, the motives behind the actions, and the spirit in which
25:01
the controversy was handled. Every specious pretense, every
25:05
backroom political maneuver, and every false reasoning will be
25:08
abolished. The justice that was denied on
25:10
earth will be perfectly executed in heaven.
25:12
If Edwards was right to fence the table, Christ will publicly
25:15
vindicate him and condemn the town's rebellion.
25:17
If Edwards was acting out of pride, Christ will expose it.
25:21
That leads to the third purpose of the meeting, eternal
25:23
retribution. Perfect equity takes place.
25:26
There will be rewards for the faithful.
25:28
And Edwards includes a beautiful, heartbreaking detail
25:31
here. He says there will be rewards
25:33
even for those ministers who labored in vain.
25:36
He quotes the prophet Isaiah. I have labored in vain, I have
25:39
spent my strength for naughty, yet surely my judgement is with
25:42
the Lord and my reward with my God.
25:45
A minister's reward is not based on the size of his church, the
25:49
number of his book sales, or the volume of conversions under his
25:52
ministry. It is based entirely on his
25:54
fidelity to the King. That is an immense comfort to
25:58
any pastor ministering in a hard, unresponsive context.
26:02
God rewards faithfulness, not statistical success, but the
26:05
flip. Side of that retribution is
26:07
severe. Edwards warns his congregation
26:09
that those who evil intrigue Christ's faithful ministers will
26:12
face terrible punishment. He references Christ's
26:15
instruction to his disciples in the Gospels.
26:17
Jesus told them that if a town rejects their message, they are
26:20
to shake the dust off their feet as a testimony against.
26:23
Them Christ stated it will be more tolerable for Sodom and
26:25
Gomorrah on the day of Judgement than for that town.
26:28
The rejection of a faithful minister is not a minor offense,
26:31
like giving a bad review to a local business.
26:33
It is the rejection of the one who sent him.
26:36
Perfect justice requires that every action toward the means of
26:39
grace be recompensed. Why does the pastor congregation
26:42
dynamic warrant such intense cosmic scrutiny at the end of
26:46
the age? Why is this specific
26:48
relationship highlighted above almost all others?
26:51
It is a fair question to ask. We have parents and children,
26:54
husbands and wives, relationships that feel so much
26:57
more intimate and permanent. But Edwards argues that the
27:00
mutual concerns of a minister and his church are of far
27:03
greater consequence than the temporal affairs of the greatest
27:06
earthly monarchs or empires. We have to view this through a
27:09
robust reformed theocratic framework.
27:13
The spiritual realm dictates the eternal.
27:16
The affairs of earthly kings deal with temporary borders,
27:19
temporary wealth and human bodies that will eventually die
27:21
and turn to dust, but the minister is dealing with
27:24
immortal souls that will exist forever in either unimaginable
27:27
joy or unutterable torment. The minister is a direct
27:31
messenger of the King of Kings. He holds the keys of the Kingdom
27:35
as described in Matthew 16. By faithfully preaching the
27:39
Gospel, he opens the Kingdom to believers and shuts it against
27:43
the unrepentant. The minister administers the
27:46
exact medicine required to cure the soul's terminal illness of
27:49
sin. Think about it like an embassy
27:51
in a foreign country. If you mistreat an ambassador,
27:55
you are not just insulting a person in a suit, You are not
27:57
just being rude to a civil servant.
27:59
You are declaring war on the sovereign nation that the
28:02
ambassador represents. The disrespect shown to the
28:05
representative is accounted as disrespect shown to the
28:07
sovereign himself. Edwards is telling his
28:10
congregation that their treatment of his ministry was a
28:13
direct reflection of their posture toward Christ.
28:16
When they rejected his demand for purity at the Kenyan table,
28:19
they were not just rejecting Jonathan Edwards, the man who
28:21
lived down the street. They were rejecting the holy
28:24
standards of the King he represented.
28:26
The work of the ministry is the very mechanism God uses to
28:29
prepare people for the Day of Judgement.
28:32
The minister is sent to warn people of the coming wrath and
28:35
to point them to the only refuge, the cross of Jesus
28:38
Christ. Because the minister's work is
28:40
directly tied to the final eternal state of the
28:42
congregation, it is entirely logical that this specific
28:46
relationship must be audited and settled before the great judge.
28:51
The business of the church is not a civic club.
28:53
It is the most serious business in the universe.
28:56
Having laid out these massive theological stakes, having built
29:00
this terrifying and awe inspiring courtroom scene in the
29:03
minds of his listeners, Edwards does something devastating.
29:06
He turns his bays from the abstract doctrine to the
29:08
specific people sitting right in front of him.
29:10
He moves into the application portion of his sermon and he
29:14
addresses 5 distinct audiences within his congregation.
29:17
He does not offer generic parting advice.
29:20
The way he speaks to each group is chilling in his precision.
29:24
Let's look at the first group. He turns to the professors of
29:27
godliness. These are the individuals who
29:29
claim to be converted, they have made a public profession of
29:32
faith, they partake of the sacraments, and they believe
29:35
themselves to be secure in Christ.
29:37
They're the ones who supported Edward's rigorous views on
29:40
Communion. But Edwards, acting with the
29:43
severe love of a Puritan pastor, fears that some of them are
29:46
deluded hypocrites. He knows the human heart's
29:49
capacity for self deception is vast.
29:52
He urges them to recall the stripped marks of piety he
29:55
taught them over the years. He wants them to examine their
29:58
affections, their hatred of sin, and their reliance on Christ.
30:01
He warns them that a mere outward profession will not
30:04
survive the fire of the final judgement.
30:07
I cannot even fathom the pastoral burden of that moment.
30:10
Imagine walking away from a church you have led for 23
30:13
years, looking at the people who consider themselves the pillars
30:16
of the congregation, your most loyal supporters, and wondering
30:20
if some of them are actually heading for hell while holding a
30:22
false assurance of salvation. He knows he won't be there next
30:25
Sunday to correct them. Edwards tells them that the time
30:28
for self examination is running out.
30:30
At the judgement day, the rules of trial he preached to them
30:33
will be brought out again. The standard will not change.
30:36
It will be proven whether they truly possess saving grace or if
30:39
they were just playing religion to maintain their social
30:43
standing in the town. The second group he addresses is
30:46
the Christ Less and Graceless. This section is an absolute
30:50
master class in the doctrine of total depravity, and it carries
30:53
an immense emotional weight. Edwards does not mince words or
30:57
offer false hope. He bluntly states that he leaves
31:00
them in the gall of bitterness as captives of Satan and
31:03
prisoners of vindictive justice. The phrase gall of bitterness
31:07
comes from the book of Acts where Peter rebukes Simon the
31:09
magician, telling him his heart is not right before God.
31:13
Edwards looks at these unrepentant members of his town
31:15
and tells them he exhausted himself trying to win them.
31:18
He studied, he prayed, he sought acceptable words, he tried every
31:22
method of persuasion to awaken their dead consciences.
31:25
But he acknowledges that his efforts failed entirely.
31:28
He quotes a haunting verse in the prophet Jeremiah.
31:30
The bellows are burnt, the lead is consumed of the fire.
31:34
The founder melteth in vain. The imagery is vivid, the fire
31:38
of his preaching burn hot. He pumped the bellows of warning
31:41
and gospel invitation for decades, but the metal of their
31:44
hearts refused to melt. The impurities would not burn
31:48
away. It is a The third group Edwards
31:50
turns to are those under awakenings.
31:54
In the Puritan understanding of conversion, an awakening was the
31:57
initial stage where a person became acutely aware of their
32:00
sin and their danger of judgement.
32:02
They were not yet converted, they had not yet laid hold of
32:05
Christ by faith, but they were seeking, They were anxious about
32:08
their souls. Their consciences were pricked.
32:11
Edwards knows exactly how fragile this state is.
32:14
He warns them that the devil will use the chaos of this
32:16
church, split, the anger in the town and the disruption of the
32:20
pastoral transition to kill their convictions.
32:22
The enemy loves to use church drama to distract people from
32:25
their own need for repentance. When the town is arguing about
32:29
church politics, no one is weeping over their sin.
32:32
Edwards pleads with them to double their diligence, to cry
32:35
mightily to God, and not to let the controversy in the church
32:38
become the graveyard of their spiritual awakening.
32:41
He understands human psychology perfectly.
32:43
A distracted mind quickly loses its sense of spiritual danger.
32:47
If Satan can get these awakened individuals to focus on the
32:50
injustice of Edwards firing or the details of the council's
32:53
vote, he can cause the heat of their conviction to cool until
32:57
they slide back into apathy. The fourth group he addresses is
33:01
the young people. Throughout his ministry, Edwards
33:04
engaged in fierce, ongoing battles over the behavior of the
33:07
youth in Northampton. He frequently disciplined them
33:10
for what he called frolicking, for keeping late hours,
33:14
gathering in Taverns and indulging in vanity and levity.
33:17
His strictness in these matters was one of the underlying causes
33:21
of the congregation's resentment toward him.
33:23
The parents felt he was too hard on their children.
33:26
But Edwards does not apologize for his strictness.
33:28
Even as he's being fired, even as he is packing his bags, he
33:32
defends his past discipline. He leaves a parting testimony
33:35
against their cultural liberties.
33:36
He tells the young people that they might laugh at his warnings
33:39
now, and they might easily find adults in the town who will
33:42
justify their careless behavior and call Edwards a legalist.
33:45
But he predicts with absolute certainty that God will
33:48
vindicate His strictness on the last day.
33:51
He sought their eternal happiness, not their temporary
33:54
amusement, and He leaves the results of the Judge.
33:57
He essentially says you fired me for being too strict, but when
34:01
we meet at the tribunal you will see that my strictness was the
34:04
only appropriate response to the reality of hell.
34:06
The final group he addresses are the children, or as he
34:10
affectionately calls them, the lambs of the flock.
34:13
The way Edward speaks to the children is a stark contrast to
34:16
modern methods of youth ministry.
34:18
There is no sugar coating, no attempt to make the message
34:21
palatable through entertainment or games.
34:23
He operates with intense Puritan realism.
34:26
He reminds them of the instruction he gave them, the
34:28
times he called them together to warn them of their danger and
34:31
point them to Christ. I read this section and I
34:33
honestly struggled with it. It feels so blunt, almost cruel
34:36
to our modern sensibilities. He tells the children the brutal
34:39
truth about mortality. He warns them that children die
34:42
too. He points out that multitudes
34:44
die before they grow up, and of those who do reach adulthood,
34:48
comparatively few ever show evidence of true conversion.
34:52
He does not offer them a false sense of security based on their
34:55
young age, their innocence or their parents faith.
34:58
He looks at the children of the town that just fired him, and he
35:00
leaves them in a miserable condition, possessing no
35:04
interest in Christ and in danger of eternal destruction.
35:07
He begs them to pray in secret, to seek God as their Father, and
35:11
to keep in mind that they too will stand before the judgement
35:14
seat. Why would a pastor speak to
35:16
children with a such terrifying severity?
35:18
His unflinching honesty is rooted directly in his theology
35:22
of total depravity. He believes they are born dead
35:25
in sin, inheriting the guilt of Adam.
35:27
Without the regenerating work of the Holy Spirit, their youth
35:30
will not save them. A child who dies outside of
35:32
Christ faces the same eternal justice as an adult.
35:35
Edwards loves these children enough to tell them the truth
35:38
about their condition. He commits them to the sovereign
35:40
mercy of God, acknowledging that his pastoral influence over them
35:43
is finished. He can no longer gather them for
35:46
catechism. He can no longer warn them.
35:48
All he can do is point them to the only judge who can grant
35:51
them mercy and pray that the seed of the word he planted will
35:54
bear fruit after he is gone. When you synthesize the sheer
35:58
weight of this historical document, it leaves you
36:02
breathless. Edwards strips away all the
36:05
pretense, all the cultural habits, all the consumer driven
36:08
mindsets of church attendance. He takes a magnifying glass to
36:11
the relationship between a pastor and a congregation, and
36:14
he sets it ablaze with the light of eternity.
36:17
He. Replaces our casual view of the
36:18
church with a sober, eternal perspective.
36:22
The visible church is not a social club.
36:24
The preaching of the Word is not a weekly lecture or a
36:27
motivational speech. He is the administration of the
36:29
keys of the Kingdom of Heaven, and it has everlasting
36:32
consequences. This text challenges every
36:34
listener to evaluate with their own posture toward the means of
36:37
grace. How do you hear the Word of God?
36:39
How do you treat the messengers God has placed in your life?
36:42
Are you engaging with the church as a consumer, evaluating the
36:46
aesthetics and the production value?
36:48
Or are you sitting under the Word with the fearful
36:50
realization that you are gathering evidence for a future
36:53
tribunal? The reality of the final
36:55
judgement should govern our behavior in the Pew every single
36:58
Sunday. It should make us tremble at the
37:01
privilege and the danger of hearing the gospel preached.
37:04
And that leads to a final thought for you to ponder.
37:07
Consider the relationships you value most in this world.
37:10
We place so much focus on our families, our careers, our
37:14
friendships. We invest our time and emotional
37:16
energy into building those connections.
37:18
But what if the most consequential relationship in
37:21
your life is not with your spouse, your boss, or your best
37:24
friend? What if the relationship that
37:26
carries the most weight and eternity is your relationship
37:29
with a person tasked with speaking the word of God to your
37:31
soul? When the books are opened and
37:34
the infallible light shines on your life, exposing every secret
37:38
and stripping away every excuse, will your response to their
37:41
instruction be a crown of rejoicing, or will it stand as a
37:44
terrifying testimony against you?