Latest / Alabama's Morning News with JT / Immigration Expert Pallavi Ahluwalia discusses pushback against ICE
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Little chaos happening in Minnesota. Just outrageous. How all these
- 0:03people are just pushing back against law and order in
- 0:05this country. Outrageous here and joining us and now talk
- 0:08a little bit more about what's happening. An immigration expert,
- 0:11as an immigrant herself, certainly very aware of what the
- 0:14pathway to citizenship like is like here in our country.
- 0:18Palab Ali Wali Ali Walla, I'm sorry, paulave welcome in.
- 0:22Thanks for being with me.
- 0:23Speaker 2: Thank you so much. I'm glad to be here this morning.
- 0:26Good morning to.
- 0:26Speaker 1: You, Good morning. So where are you from?
- 0:29Speaker 2: Originally from India and came here as a twenty three
- 0:34year old, went to law school here and became a
- 0:38Green cord holder several years later, and then got my citizenship.
- 0:43I've been here practicing law for about twenty three years.
- 0:46And the areas of open it, family and immigration.
- 0:50Speaker 1: You know, I love the fact that you came, you
- 0:52wanted to be here, You went through the legal process
- 0:55of getting your citizenship, became a productive citizen in society here,
- 1:01assimilated into the United States, and are now a Lawyer's
- 1:05I mean, congratulations, My hat's off to you. Welcome to
- 1:09the United States of America. I know it's been a while,
- 1:11but you know, fantastic, Yes, all right, so let's talk
- 1:17about what's happening. First of all, let's back up. Four
- 1:20years of Joe Biden's open borders created just a nightmare
- 1:24for the United States and cities across America that became
- 1:28extremely dangerous. The flow of a lot of people saw
- 1:31this as an opportunity. Yes, I will give credit to
- 1:33some of those folks that just wanted to better their
- 1:36family life and get into a better situation potentially, you know,
- 1:39get out of the harm that was you know in
- 1:41some cities they lived in south of the border. But
- 1:44let's just call it. With this comes the bad guys
- 1:47and the drugs and the influx and just tons of it.
- 1:50It was basically disregard immigration laws and policies. We have
- 1:55just come on and we'll figure it out once you
- 1:56get here. And it's created a nightmare right now in
- 1:59the city suation in Minneapolis. Has our own elected officials
- 2:03pushing back on law and order in this country as
- 2:06ICE is trying to do their job, and they have
- 2:09every right to, you know, enforce law and order in
- 2:13our country. We are a nation of law and order.
- 2:16What are your thoughts with the current situation involving ice
- 2:20and involving our immigration system. Let's start with, first of all,
- 2:23the law and order part, and then we'll talk immigration
- 2:25reform if you believe we ought to have it all.
- 2:27Speaker 2: Right, So we're talking about section one one one of
- 2:31Title eighteen, who punishes anyone who forcibly assaults business, opposes.
- 2:36Speaker 3: Impedes, intimidates, or interfares with any person designated who served
- 2:43as a federal officer and who's performing their official duties.
- 2:47Speaker 2: So and the element of force has to be reasonable
- 2:54to justify an equal kind of force that's applied to
- 3:00those threats. So there is something to be said with
- 3:04how the law does protect federal officers who are performing
- 3:09their duties. There is also and I'm just going to
- 3:12bring this to youth, there is also a policy manual
- 3:16in place from twenty twenty three that tells the government
- 3:21as to how to use force and the appropriateness of
- 3:26a particular force is guided by constitutional law and it
- 3:31is interpreted by the US Supreme Court the Fourth Amendment
- 3:36that supply a constitutional baseline for the permissible use of
- 3:40force by law enforcement officers in the course of their
- 3:43official duties and law enforcement has to adopt policies that
- 3:50constrain the uniforce. So we have an alliance of force
- 3:55based on the statute, and then we have memos that
- 4:00gone down that the amount of force to be used. Yes,
- 4:06if someone is performing their duties and they're therefore deportation,
- 4:10they should not be thwarted in their effort because they're
- 4:14carrying on what the law allows them for deportation. But
- 4:19I think what is at play is the amount of
- 4:21force and whether it's justified or not, and whether the
- 4:24constitution permits it or not.
- 4:26Speaker 1: Well, the current situation in Minneapolis, we had the shooting
- 4:29where the woman lost her life. She was in a
- 4:31motor vehicle and the officer that was standing in front
- 4:33of that vehicle felt his life was threatened. Do you
- 4:35believe that he had the right to respond the way
- 4:38he did.
- 4:39Speaker 2: So, I think this is going to be looked at
- 4:43an investigated in several ways. If someone is being threatened,
- 4:48they do have the right to use force. And again,
- 4:52what if is playing out is playing out in front
- 4:55of everyone. People will make their own judgments based on
- 4:58the videos that are floating around, But eventually this would
- 5:01be something that can perhaps be resolved by the branch
- 5:07of government called the judiciary. Right, so it has to
- 5:10be resolved properly at a partway. It's not Partisian. It
- 5:15is going to be based on facts, witnesses who saw what.
- 5:19Speaker 1: Yeah, and as Tom Holman said, let's let the investigation
- 5:24play out and not emotionally react to the way we
- 5:27see it and think we see it. Let's wait and
- 5:29see the investigation. Another incident yesterday where an ICE officer
- 5:34shot as somebody else in the leg They survived because
- 5:38this person was coming at him with a shovel, swinging
- 5:40it at his head as he was trying to do
- 5:42his job and taking out a bad guy and arresting
- 5:46them once again. You know, the left will paint this
- 5:49as look at Ice and the mayor says, get the
- 5:53f out of our city. The governor says, we don't
- 5:56need Trump and his National Guarden ice agents here, Get
- 6:00get rid of them. Do you think that they're feeding
- 6:02the beast to push back on law enforcement? Is wrong?
- 6:08Should they just leave this alone? And what did what
- 6:12would your message be to these protesters if you were
- 6:14brought into their room.
- 6:16Speaker 2: Well, I mean, first of all, and I think I
- 6:18did hear the mayor say yesterday that everybody, let's look
- 6:21for peace here. Protesting calmly is everyone's right. It's the
- 6:27First Amendment right to protest, and everyone in the United
- 6:30States is allowed that by the law. That's one point.
- 6:34The second point is we have the supremacy Clause that establishes,
- 6:40you know, the federal role, and where the federal role
- 6:44is being carried out by federal officers, it becomes the
- 6:49federal role does preempt the state law. But there is
- 6:53also the Tenth Amendment that preserves powers that is not
- 6:56given to the federal government to the states. That establishes
- 7:01state police powers, which is local law enforcement and public safety.
- 7:05So if people are not safe in any way, I'm
- 7:09sure that you know they everyone at this point has
- 7:13to stand down. Protests can should continue if they feel
- 7:18that anything is being done unfairly, they can continue, but
- 7:22not with violence, not with coming at federal officers. Because
- 7:26the federal officers are carrying out their duties, as has
- 7:30their employees of the federal government. They've been given a
- 7:33task to do. When they go out to do to
- 7:36carry on deportations, which is what they are tasked with.
- 7:39They're expecting to go back home at night. Right, They're
- 7:42not expecting to die in the line of duty. Similarly,
- 7:45people who are protesting are just going to are going
- 7:50out there to say that they don't agree with what's
- 7:53going on, and they have the full right to do so.
- 7:55But either if you're in the way of the federal
- 8:00officers carrying out their duties and you're threatening them in
- 8:03any way and you stand to you know, yes, well,
- 8:11but what those consequences would be, should it be somebody
- 8:14shocked in their face, I'm going to have to let
- 8:18the investigation play out on that. Or if it is
- 8:21a minor thing that you can say, Okay, I shot
- 8:24someone's tech. Is that minor or what? Well?
- 8:28Speaker 1: I agree with you. And there are laws that allow
- 8:33not only law enforcement, also US citizens if they feel
- 8:37they are being threatened and their life is in danger,
- 8:41laws protect the person to do what they want to
- 8:44do to protect themselves from being attacked or killed. So
- 8:48if this ice agent felt that a woman in a
- 8:51motor vehicle was coming at him and his split second
- 8:55reaction was to protect his life by shooting, I think
- 8:59he'll be cleared in this. Secondly, the guy that shot
- 9:03the person in the leg because they were getting a
- 9:06shovel swung at their head will also be cleared in
- 9:09all of this, I think at the end of the day,
- 9:13I agree with you one hundred percent. Protesting is part
- 9:15of what this country's about. Violent protesting is not allowed
- 9:19for a good reason. So my message would be protest.
- 9:24But the minute you cross the line and start impeding
- 9:27law enforcement, it's like me protesting to an officer that
- 9:30just pulled me over for running a red light and
- 9:33me trying to justify nobody else was around. It's okay,
- 9:36don't argue the case on the scene. You kind of
- 9:40have to give the law enforcement agent the benefit of
- 9:43the doubt. Argue it once you get your lawyer and
- 9:46in front of a judge, not on the street, because
- 9:49that law enforcement officer has no idea what you could
- 9:52be pulling out of your pocket, your jacket or whatever.
- 9:54And to get violent ain't the answer.
- 9:57Speaker 2: And when you JD, I have something that I want
- 10:01to say, Uh, one more thing, and we've brought up
- 10:05eighteen USC. One one one right, So profanility or personal
- 10:09insults directed at officers and is not a violation root
- 10:14gestures directed at officers are not arguing with the officers
- 10:18is not. Challenging authority, may not be. Talking back to
- 10:22officers is also not. But when it comes to the
- 10:25physical part, it is, uh, it is not allowed to you.
- 10:30And when that comes in the way when you're coming
- 10:32at someone either with you know, a weapon or whatever
- 10:36you're weaponizing, you're not allowed to do that. And that's
- 10:39where you'll have a force against you. But the other things,
- 10:45I mean, there is something that's floating around, which you know,
- 10:49it's floating around right now in social media, and it's
- 10:53on the government let ahead, and it is what they
- 10:57call a legal refresher to the ice officers. And what
- 11:00I read out to you is exactly that all of
- 11:03those are within people's right to again the First Amendment,
- 11:08right to protest. Yeah, but not with force, not with weapons,
- 11:14and that is to be agreed with.
- 11:16Speaker 1: Yeah, one hundred percent. I'm on the same page with
- 11:18you absolutely. Paula be Allo Wallow, Thank you so much
- 11:22for being with me. I really appreciate you and we'll
- 11:24have you back.
- 11:24Speaker 2: Thank you so much. Take care that a good day
- 11:27you too.