Latest / Pod of the Damned / Return To Silent Hill (2026)
Transcript
- 0:28That's. The new To Be Honest to be fit
- 0:32for this film. Well, I mean, I've hit record
- 0:34now. Oh yeah.
- 0:36Oh, OK. So all of this is just, you
- 0:39know, maybe this could be just the cold open to the podcast,
- 0:42but. You you've missed the yawn that
- 0:44introduced all this conversation.
- 0:46Don't you worry, I'll easily yawn again as you well know.
- 0:49But hi everyone, welcome back to the Pot of the Damned.
- 0:54I'm your host Ian and joining me this week as my Co host Nico.
- 0:58How's it going, buddy? I'm good.
- 1:00How are you? I'm good.
- 1:01It's been a while since it's just been the two of us.
- 1:03And I was thinking up myself. Was it violent?
- 1:06Was it violent night? Our last one.
- 1:09Probably would have been I I would have been at Christmas
- 1:11time. Just before Christmas time.
- 1:12Well, yeah, obviously at Christmas time.
- 1:14It's Violent Night, isn't it? You know, we don't generally
- 1:17cover Christmas movies out with Christmas time, do we?
- 1:21We kind of save them. So, but this time, and there's,
- 1:25I think this is a, this is a first for 2020.
- 1:27This is our first sort of new release episode that we're
- 1:30talking about for 2026. Last year we spent quite a big
- 1:34focus on reviewing newer releases and things that had
- 1:37just came out. And so far this year, we've kind
- 1:40of flipped a little bit back and we've been going back and
- 1:42looking at some classics that we've not done yet.
- 1:44But myself and Nico, we went to the cinema, what, 2 weeks ago?
- 1:50I would be 9. 222 weeks ago and we decided to watch Return to
- 1:55Silent Hill. And yeah, I think, I think we
- 1:58both have very strong feelings about this.
- 2:00So I think we're both really keen to make sure that we did.
- 2:03We did an episode on it. Yeah.
- 2:07I think we don't have that much different opinion on it though.
- 2:11No, I don't think this is going to be one of those episodes
- 2:13where me and you have a huge argument and have great
- 2:16differences. No, I think you're right there.
- 2:18We're even agreeing about that already.
- 2:21Yeah, but I think we both might have a lot to say.
- 2:24So anyways, before we get into it, just a reminder that we are
- 2:27a horror podcast that deep dives into a different topic every
- 2:30single week in our quest to create a leaderboard of the best
- 2:33and worst horror movies of all time.
- 2:35This is episode #160 and in today's show, we're talking all
- 2:39about Return to Silent Hill. If you would like to support us
- 2:42across our social media platforms, you can do so.
- 2:44We're on Facebook, Instagram Threads, Blue Sky, YouTube,
- 2:47TikTok, all at Pod of the Damned, and you can e-mail us at
- 2:50podofthedamned@gmail.com. For for you know what we haven't
- 2:54actually done like a huge amount of recordings over the past sort
- 2:57of 3-4 months. And I think that's possibly the
- 2:59best I've delivered that whole spiel in about two years.
- 3:03I know. I'm quite happy with myself
- 3:06there, Nico. Why?
- 3:08Why do I even bother fucking asking you where?
- 3:11Where can you be found? Give us give us your social
- 3:14media handles. I'm on Facebook.
- 3:21You are on Facebook. You can't.
- 3:25You can't remember your handles, can you?
- 3:27No, I've literally just clicked on Facebook to try and do it
- 3:31now. No, I thought I'd be a smart
- 3:33arse and do it that way quick but it didn't work.
- 3:35No, I see I called you out on your bullshit because I could
- 3:37see. I could see behind the camera
- 3:39what you were doing to the untrained eye.
- 3:42To the untrained eye, it might look like you're having a wank,
- 3:45but I know you're furiously typing on your phone.
- 3:53Oh, we've lost Nico completely. There he goes.
- 3:57This is going to be 1 hell of an episode I think.
- 4:00Nico, before we get into it, I know we are.
- 4:04I asked you on our last recording and our last show for
- 4:08scores on Night of the Living Dead in Wolf Creek.
- 4:10Have you had a chance to review those?
- 4:13No chance for. Fuck's sake Nico.
- 4:15Honestly, your your your list of movies that you need to pick
- 4:18your scores in for is growing all the time.
- 4:21We can just do an episode where I'd just do all them at once.
- 4:23So that's it. We're just we could do a little
- 4:25bonus episode that means you have to watch about fucking 10
- 4:28movies though before we could record it.
- 4:31I can do that. Apparently you can't fucking
- 4:33watch one. Well, I can.
- 4:37I can do that. I'm back to work on Monday so I
- 4:39can do that. But if you've had the whole
- 4:41weekend, haven't you? And it's now Thursday.
- 4:44Yeah, but I did lots of shit. Did you?
- 4:46I don't want. I don't want to know anyways.
- 4:49I was, I was in a pub quiz that I got cheated in.
- 4:52I was in, I was doing, I was at the secret screamings and I, I
- 5:00watched Ready or Not too, which was, that's definitely worth the
- 5:04review. And I I did heaps of shit.
- 5:07So you've been a busy, busy man. Wow.
- 5:10And in that case, then let's just crack on and let's talk
- 5:14about today's movie. So today we're talking all about
- 5:18Return to Silent Hill. James, so much time has passed,
- 5:31but I'm asking to please come back to our special place.
- 5:37Something's happened. Love Mary.
- 5:45Hello. Can anyone hear me?
- 5:49Everyone got sick in Silent Hill.
- 5:52Something's happened here. Something really, really bad.
- 6:16What you're doing, you did. It didn't you, Jimmy.
- 6:24You woke up. No one said it would be easy.
- 6:41I'm here. I'll.
- 6:42Always be here. This movie was released in 2026,
- 6:53was directed by Christoph Gantz, and stars Jeremy Irvine, Hannah
- 6:56Emily Anderson, and Evie Templeton.
- 6:58The IMDb plot is as follows. When a man receives A mysterious
- 7:02letter from his lost love, he is drawn to Silent Hill, a once
- 7:07familiar town now consumed by darkness.
- 7:11Right. So Silent Hill is possibly one
- 7:16of my absolute favorite IPS of all time.
- 7:19I've been no bones about the fact that my love for Silent
- 7:23Hill 2 as the video game, that's obviously what this movie is
- 7:27heavily. Well, it's not heavily.
- 7:29It just is based on the story from Silent Hill 2.
- 7:34We've obviously had a couple of Silent Hill movies before, 1 by
- 7:37Christoph Gantz, the original Silent Hill movie, I think 2009.
- 7:41And then we had Silent Hill Revelations come out, I think it
- 7:45was a couple of years later, which is not by Christoph Gantz,
- 7:47But so that's kind of where we are with things.
- 7:50And I think it's fair to say that of the two movies that
- 7:54we've had so far in this franchise, they have been very
- 7:56much of A varying quality. And personally, even though it's
- 8:03maybe not critically seen as being a particularly popular
- 8:08movie, I am quite a big fan of the original Silent Hill movie.
- 8:12I don't think you were quite as high on it when when we reviewed
- 8:15it. Yeah, remember I was like, I
- 8:17preferred the second game anyway.
- 8:19I wasn't really in the first. I sort of joined it later.
- 8:21Yeah. I was really looking forward to
- 8:24this. Yeah, so that was it.
- 8:26So. But I was still really high in
- 8:28that first movie. I thought I had felt was because
- 8:30sometimes, right and I think this is definitely something we
- 8:33can talk about, right. So if you're going to do a video
- 8:36game adaptation, especially something that is so wildly
- 8:39popular as Silent Hill, and we've seen this before with
- 8:43Resident Evil as well, you have to sort of figure out, are you
- 8:47going to go and stick very true to the story of the source
- 8:51material that you're doing? Or are you kind of going to
- 8:53adapt into the universe and create kind of your own
- 8:56storyline? Now, obviously with Resident
- 9:00Evil, they decided to adapt and create essentially their own
- 9:04storyline. And you know, that went on to
- 9:08spawn multiple movies of varying quality and but made an absolute
- 9:14shit ton of money. The first Silent Hill movie,
- 9:17like you say, is obviously, you know, the first silent is is
- 9:21closer to the first Silent Hill game, but they make a lot of
- 9:25they they make a lot of creative decisions that takes it away
- 9:28from that. So it's still kind of its own
- 9:29entity. And I think that's possibly one
- 9:32reason why I do like that first game is it sort of tracks that
- 9:34line of here we go, because not everything translate.
- 9:38It's like translating book to screen, isn't it?
- 9:41Not everything translates into movie particularly well.
- 9:43So you need to learn right what to re keep in here.
- 9:46What do we cut? What do we, you know, expand on
- 9:49what do we change? And I think the first movie does
- 9:52find that balance pretty well. Really does, yeah.
- 9:56And this movie, on the other hand, does none of that.
- 10:01Right. This movie essentially tries to
- 10:05be Silent Hill to the game and cuts out pretty much all the
- 10:09good shit. Yeah, so I was looking forward
- 10:15to this because I prefer saying game, but the problem is you've
- 10:20got to hear that thing where it's like you can't like stuff
- 10:26will work in a game but will work in a movie.
- 10:29And it seems like they've kept all that shit in this movie.
- 10:32Like I'm just coming straight out with it.
- 10:34I'm I'm not, I'm spoiling it straight to start.
- 10:36This is fucking dog shit. Yeah, this isn't good.
- 10:44This really isn't good. And I, I'm with you, right?
- 10:46So Silent Hill two, I've said multiple times on the show, is
- 10:50the game that really sort of kick started my love for horror.
- 10:53I'd seen horror movies before that, but it wasn't until I was
- 10:55a little bit older and played Silent Hill 2 for the first time
- 10:58that I was like, yeah, I'm, I'm, I'm into this shit, right?
- 11:02And I still vividly remember the very first time playing Silent
- 11:06Hill 2 on the PS2, be absolutely fucking terrified by it and just
- 11:11having the best fucking time, right?
- 11:14And and you know, I I going into this movie, right, I knew I
- 11:20wouldn't have that good a time. I knew I wasn't going to come
- 11:23out of this movie and be like, Oh, this changes my fucking
- 11:25life. But I kind of was hoping that I
- 11:29would come out of it and just be like, you know what it is what
- 11:33it is. It's you know, it's made a good
- 11:35attempt to sort of recreating the game.
- 11:37It's maybe made its changes, blah, blah, blah.
- 11:39But no, we both came out of this and we were just like, this is,
- 11:42this is. We should have went to see it.
- 11:45I can't remember what the other movie was we had the choice of,
- 11:48but we both came outgoing. We should have went to see that
- 11:50instead. What?
- 11:51Was the other movie we should have went I.
- 11:53Can't even remember. We did.
- 11:54We did pick this, but we were both, again, we were both very
- 11:57excited by the prospect of going to see this.
- 12:00This wasn't something that we were like forced to go in to
- 12:02see. We were happy to go and see
- 12:04this. When, when you told me I do want
- 12:07to go see it, I'm like, fuck yes, let's yes, yes.
- 12:10I was like, get the tickets now. You're not bucking out, you
- 12:12bitch. Fucking get done.
- 12:14And I think The thing is as well, you know, so Christophe
- 12:15Gantz obviously did the original Silent Hill, but didn't do
- 12:18Revelations. Revelations.
- 12:20Is this movie better or worse than Revelations?
- 12:23Worse. I still think.
- 12:26Because the the reason this is worse is because they had the
- 12:31fundamental core material that should have fucking worked.
- 12:35They had everything at their disposal to fucking make it
- 12:39work. And this should be the best one
- 12:41out of all of them so far. And for some reason, they did it
- 12:45in a way that it's not even, it's just boring.
- 12:50Do you know what reminds me of it reminds me of that fucking
- 12:52walking movie. That would be the second one of
- 12:55the. The one with.
- 12:57Yeah, it reminds me of that because it's it's trying to be
- 13:01better than what is. It's trying to be artsy.
- 13:03It's trying to be all of the things that you're not looking
- 13:06for, you're looking for based on the game, get a lot of scares.
- 13:12Your core material is just phenomenal.
- 13:14So you've got heaps of stuff to go for and it just fucks it.
- 13:18It just fucks it right royally in the ass.
- 13:21So I think I would agree with you.
- 13:22Like if you're comparing things to like the source material and
- 13:25the expectations and what it could have been, Yeah, I would
- 13:28say this is probably the worst one.
- 13:29I think if you boil it down and you just you take that
- 13:32expectation out, I still think Revelations is a worse movie.
- 13:37No, I still think at least I was not fighting sleep.
- 13:42What revelations? I absolutely was fighting sleep
- 13:44with Revelations. That's the I.
- 13:47I don't know, maybe maybe it's like recency bias, but I think
- 13:51you forget Revelations is a fucking horrendous pile of dog
- 13:55shit movie. Revelations is shit but it's not
- 13:59as bad as this dog shit. I would this, I'm going to this.
- 14:02Maybe this can be the area where we disagree that because I
- 14:05disagree with that statement. I just don't think this is a
- 14:07shit movie. I just don't think it's white is
- 14:10shit. And I don't know, maybe that's
- 14:12my love for Silent Hill too, sort of shining through and
- 14:16maybe just giving a little bit more credit because of that.
- 14:20Because ultimately this is still telling that story, and the
- 14:23story is a great story, but the movie?
- 14:28Just gets it this one too much that's.
- 14:29What I'm saying the movie just gets it wrong, but the base?
- 14:33I think you like that better because this is associated with
- 14:37it. I think you're biased because of
- 14:40the game is still good. First I went the other way
- 14:43because the game was so good. I've went against it.
- 14:45I. Guess that's like I I guess it's
- 14:48just. So boring this one.
- 14:50Like honestly. I'm not sitting here defending
- 14:54the movie by any stretches. No, I don't mean that.
- 14:57This movie is so dull, is incredibly dull.
- 15:01The action sequences are way too short.
- 15:05Yeah, we'll get into more depth through the terms of the
- 15:09monsters and how this movie looks a bit.
- 15:11Ultimately, yeah, you're right. This movie is really dull.
- 15:13It's very angsty. This movie, it's got so much
- 15:17angst in it. And I think ultimately what they
- 15:19do is they just get the messaging of this movie
- 15:22completely wrong. So, and I think this is maybe
- 15:24where we're going to have like our sort of the crux of our
- 15:26discussion. It's like comparison, isn't it?
- 15:28Between the story that should have been told, that is told in
- 15:31Silent Hill too, and the story we actually get.
- 15:34Because obviously in Silent Hill to the game that the what
- 15:39happens is actually in the end quite wildly different from what
- 15:43happens here in the movie. Yep, and the the thing like she
- 15:51won't know what annoys me most about this movie I.
- 15:53Mean you're going to tell me anyway, aren't you?
- 15:55Hi, it gets it gets so fucking artsy.
- 15:59Like it gets so like there's heaps of bits where they're
- 16:02zooming out and like oh look this looks like the game but not
- 16:06quite the game. And it like there's heaps of
- 16:11scenes like that where so 2 characters just talking like.
- 16:16So that's. Where the mountains in the
- 16:17background? You know what I mean?
- 16:18So. Here's the thing, right?
- 16:19So they've obviously listen. Christoph Gantz has not made a
- 16:23good Silent Hill movie here. I still will maintain that his
- 16:26first Silent Hill movie was a good movie.
- 16:29Yeah, He clearly is someone who has a lot of love for Silent
- 16:34Hill. He clearly is someone who cares
- 16:36a lot about the IP. He's clearly someone who's
- 16:38played it. He's clearly someone who likes
- 16:40it, right? He wouldn't continue to be
- 16:43involved in the franchise if he wasn't someone who has a lot of
- 16:48love and time for Silent Hill as an intellectual property.
- 16:52But yeah, he get, and you can see that through some of the
- 16:55shots because some of the shots are very much just lifted, like
- 16:58you say out of the game. You know, you're right at the
- 17:00start. You've got James looking in the
- 17:01mirror with the water running down.
- 17:03That's a really iconic shot. You know, you've got pyramid
- 17:07heads and we'll talk about pyramid heads in more detail as
- 17:11well and some of the other monsters because oh boy, do I
- 17:14have some issues there. You know, you've got the shots
- 17:17of Eddie. You've got, you know, like
- 17:18Eddie's plumber Eddie's, you know, builders bum sticking out,
- 17:22you know, things like that proves that you know, he plays
- 17:25the games, he likes the games. He's, you know, he's a fan
- 17:28because he's paying that and it's, he's trying to pay that
- 17:31sort of lip service, isn't he, to die hard fans of this
- 17:34franchise. But fortunately, I think that
- 17:38only works if you're getting the story right, if you're doing.
- 17:41That this is what I was going to say.
- 17:43Like you've just thought that right on what I was going to say
- 17:45next, that he seems to go shot for shot with bits of the game
- 17:50that weren't really that important to the story.
- 17:54And I think that's why it brings up enough nostalgia for folks
- 17:58that are like proper die hard fans of the game that they're
- 18:01like, well, it's not as bad as you think.
- 18:03And then you talk to them and they'd realized how bad that
- 18:06actually is. You can quite easily convince
- 18:10them that this is a shit movie. It's not like it's a hard push,
- 18:14you know? I mean, and it's the whole, I
- 18:19think he concentrates on the stuff that's stuck in his head
- 18:23with this, not what the fans would want, which is the story.
- 18:28Yeah. So like I say again, there's
- 18:29obviously been a slight reinterpretation of the story
- 18:34and he's maybe made that decision because of transferring
- 18:38to movie purposes. Like we've said earlier, not
- 18:40everything is, you know, transferable from game to movie
- 18:45to book to movie and vice versa and all of that.
- 18:48However, what he's actually done is he's kind of just ripped the
- 18:50soul out of the story. So if you're getting the story
- 18:54right, then fine, you can have those sort of shot for shot
- 18:58lifts. Like I say, like the mirror
- 19:00scene, you know that bath, the bathroom at the beginning of the
- 19:02movie, that's the exact same bathroom as in the beginning of
- 19:06the game. You know, you can have those
- 19:08moments and then, you know, fans will sit there and go, yeah,
- 19:11that's fucking cool, right? Because I think, I think I
- 19:14nudged you in the cinema and was like, yeah, that's fucking.
- 19:17I nudged you in the cinema. I was like, yeah, that's the
- 19:19bathroom. That's fucking cool.
- 19:20Obviously by that point we didn't really know what we were
- 19:22going to get after it. So at that point I still had a
- 19:25bit of goodwill in the tank and was like, yeah, that's fucking
- 19:27cool. We're watching a Silent Hill Two
- 19:29movie. This is Ace.
- 19:30And then the rest of the movie happened and you're like, what
- 19:33the fuck has he done to this? Because he has fundamentally
- 19:37changed major aspects of the story, but he's not only done
- 19:40that, but he's fundamentally changed characters within that
- 19:44as well. So every so in the game, every
- 19:48monster and every character represents a part of James
- 19:52Sunderland's psyche, right? That's the entire point of the
- 19:56game. All the monsters and everything
- 19:58are actually a figment of his own imagination.
- 20:02They're part of his own subconscious because he murdered
- 20:07his wife. Yeah, and that is literally the
- 20:11plot of the game, right? That is literally it.
- 20:13These are all manifestations and people put in there.
- 20:17So for example, let's take let's take Pyramid Head as your big
- 20:25example, right? So we've got Pyramid Head here.
- 20:28Let's say Pyramid Head wasn't in the original Silence.
- 20:31He made his first appearance in Silent Hill too, you know, So
- 20:35again, that's maybe where, you know, in that first movie, he's
- 20:39made that creative decision. We're going to include Pyramid
- 20:42Head here. And in actual fact, it kind of
- 20:44worked in that first movie, ended up being one of the cooler
- 20:47parts of the movie. You know, you got that scene
- 20:49where he rips the girl's skin completely off and it's fucking,
- 20:53it's sick as fuck right here. However, they've pretty much
- 20:58tried to recreate, you know, that opening scene you remember
- 21:02when you're in? I think it's the apartment block
- 21:04you're in, in Silent Hill too. And that's where you have your
- 21:06first meeting with Pyramid Head. And he's just standing behind
- 21:10the grate. He doesn't actually do anything.
- 21:12But here, no one else is supposed to be able to see
- 21:16Pyramid Head as well. But here, everyone can.
- 21:22And this is where things like, for me, the story gets too
- 21:24muddled because, well, is it a figment of James''s psyche?
- 21:29Is it a part of his imagination? Is it something that is supposed
- 21:33to represent? Because it's supposed to
- 21:35represent James's unfulfilled desire for punishment for
- 21:39murdering his wife. That is the whole point of
- 21:42pyramid. That's what he represents,
- 21:44right? But there's also theories that
- 21:46it represents A darker side of James's soul, which includes
- 21:50that murder, but also includes like, and there's quite a lot of
- 21:53sort of sexual deviancy and sexual connotations to a lot of
- 21:57this as well, because he became deeply unattracted to his wife
- 22:01due to her her illness. She had a very bad illness and
- 22:06all of that is lost in this movie.
- 22:10And thanks, by the way, for telling me about the whole
- 22:13Pyramid Head thing that's on the Internet.
- 22:15By the way, I looked up. It was fucking mental.
- 22:23Did you like, do you remember the last episode we're talking
- 22:27about? I don't get why girls are really
- 22:28into Pyramid Head. I've looked up.
- 22:30That's fucked up. Oh, right, OK.
- 22:32I was so confused by what the fuck you were talking about
- 22:35there. Yeah.
- 22:36It's just because you. Yeah, it's so fucked up.
- 22:40Oh, if you look at the origins of Pyramid Head and girls like
- 22:43him that way, you're like, what the fuck?
- 22:46Oh yeah, you girl. Oh yeah, like Pyramid Head is,
- 22:49he's a sex symbol. He is a more and more and more
- 22:53ways than one. But yeah, so like they've just
- 22:57completely ripped that out. And then you can literally go
- 23:00through all the characters as well.
- 23:02And it's kind of similar. So for example, Laura, the young
- 23:07girl, you know, she is supposed to represent like the innocent
- 23:12and the, the, the the pure side of Silent Hill and of James as
- 23:17well. So in the game, she doesn't
- 23:20actually see any of the atrocities that's happening
- 23:22around her. She sees a normal city.
- 23:24And that's why in the game she treats James so badly because
- 23:27she thinks she's just living her everyday life.
- 23:29And there's this really weird guy James approaching her, you
- 23:32know, so it's kind of like, you know, stranger danger a little
- 23:34bit, but in the game. And but they've, again,
- 23:38completely changed that here in the movie and for the other
- 23:43characters as well. They just don't give them
- 23:45anywhere near as much depth as they shoot.
- 23:48Eddie as a character has so much more depth in the game.
- 23:52I'm also going to say, like, the actual performances by the
- 23:54actors in this movie are pretty substandard, I'm not going to
- 23:57lie. Yeah, I don't really want to go
- 24:00too much into that because it's just relatively poor all around.
- 24:06But again, with Maria as well. So Maria is supposed to
- 24:09represent the version of Mary that James desires the most.
- 24:12That's why she's kind of hyper sexualized in the game, but
- 24:17she's not at the same level here in the movie, you know?
- 24:20And it just detracts from the plot of this thing.
- 24:25Silent Hill 2 has one of the most intricate and interesting
- 24:28plots out there in in entertainment.
- 24:31Like the plot is so the lore goes so deep and the plot is so
- 24:35interesting and there's just none of it here.
- 24:39Yeah, it's a like I'm trying to say something nice about.
- 24:48I genuinely can't. I have a couple of nice things
- 24:51to say about this. Do that then, because fucking I
- 24:55split shit all over this. So the score of this movie is
- 25:01the is partly the original score from the game, but anything
- 25:04that's been adapted has been adapted by the the man who did
- 25:07the score for Silent Hill too. And I think again, it's very,
- 25:10you know, it's a very beautiful score.
- 25:12This this movie is scored very, very well.
- 25:16Like that is probably one of my big positives from this movie.
- 25:21I just thought they ripped it from the game, so yeah, I'd
- 25:23never noticed. But that's what I'm saying they
- 25:25they had the rights to do that. It is his score from the game
- 25:29and he is scoring the movie. So he has the rights.
- 25:32He does obviously directly take some extracts because it also
- 25:36has very iconic moments in the game.
- 25:38This it's, you know, especially to horror fans as well.
- 25:42And if you're a horror gamer, a big horror gaming fan, you can
- 25:45play, you know, that main portion of I can't remember
- 25:48what's called James's Reprise or something, I think is the
- 25:51entire, and it is a very iconic, you know, piece of music to
- 25:56people who are fans of the genre.
- 25:58So of course they're going to take parts of that and put it in
- 26:01the game, you know, But what else has been added and adopted?
- 26:05I thought that was pretty good. I thought that was that was a
- 26:07good part aspect of the game. And I think for large parts as
- 26:11well, aesthetically, the movie doesn't, there are, there are
- 26:14some quite bad moments of CGI, right?
- 26:17There are. But in general, I would say this
- 26:20is still a relatively good looking movie.
- 26:23I think there's, there's some nice shots in there.
- 26:25They obviously they're they're trying to get the creature
- 26:28design quite right. I I don't necessarily think it's
- 26:30the worst looking movie in the world.
- 26:32I do think there's some moments where the CGI is pretty bad, But
- 26:37I think given the scale of this movie as well when you read
- 26:40about it actually wasn't made for a huge amount of money as
- 26:43well. I'll give them some of the
- 26:46creatures are decent, but I am going to go and say the CGI is
- 26:52pretty bad in some of it. Like there's a lot of bits when
- 26:57I was in the cinema going. This feels like a budget version
- 27:00of fucking this movie should be you know, I mean, and I can't
- 27:05remember how much you said it was like 25 mile or something.
- 27:08Like I remember you looked up and we left and I was like
- 27:11fucking. It looks like they just.
- 27:14I didn't even spend on anything to be honest.
- 27:16Yeah, and I just for me, right, I can forgive some poor CGII can
- 27:25forgive a little bit of bad acting, but it keeps coming back
- 27:28ultimately for me, it keeps coming back to the story that
- 27:31we're trying to tell. And this is the most, the most
- 27:33egregious thing about this movie, because we also have this
- 27:37like cult in this film. And this is the whole point
- 27:41they're they're putting some sort of curse or whatever you
- 27:44want to call on Mary. I don't actually, I think I
- 27:48might have just lost Nico. His camera's gone.
- 27:50I don't. Know no, I'm still here.
- 27:51Oh. Your camera's gone.
- 27:53Oh, is it? Oh, sorry.
- 27:54There you go, you're back. But we, we never really get told
- 28:00the purpose of this cult. It's it's, it's like what, what
- 28:04are they actually hoping to achieve?
- 28:07You know it. Again, it just gets so muddled
- 28:11and mixed up and rushed and which is?
- 28:14Shocking. Rushed in 106 minute long Silent
- 28:17Hill movie is quite something. Yeah, like it, it's, it's the
- 28:22way they do the like the videos of the cult and everything.
- 28:25When they do all that, you're just like, that's the bit that
- 28:28seems rushed. That's the bit that seems like
- 28:31they've thrown it and really, really quick.
- 28:33And I don't know why they've done it that way.
- 28:36I don't know what what the fuck they were thinking of, but it
- 28:41makes it, it makes it fucking awful.
- 28:45Like I generally can I just give the score now?
- 28:49No you cannot. Because it.
- 28:57I think we have actually lost Nico this time, but that's
- 29:02possibly not a bad thing that he wants to give his score out.
- 29:05So hold on, I think you might be back.
- 29:13You there I'm. Here.
- 29:16Oh, you're screaming. Oh, you're sorry?
- 29:18Your screen went off. It went off with a second too,
- 29:23so yeah, where'd I get to? What did you hear me say?
- 29:32The whole cult stuff just annoys me and this like it, it goes
- 29:38nowhere, it starts from nowhere. It's just there's no point in
- 29:42it. And that's the bit that seems
- 29:43Russian. That's the bit that seems like
- 29:45it's fucked up the movie. Yeah, because it's, it feels
- 29:50just like an unnecessary plot point in this movie that doesn't
- 29:53really exist in the game. You know?
- 29:57I know, I know. Obviously it's there, and it's
- 29:59there for, you know, the whole, you know, the sort of whole IP,
- 30:04but it isn't the focus of this game.
- 30:07You know, the focus is just on Mary's illness and yes, you
- 30:11know, James's guilt and James's grief.
- 30:14And then, you know, because ultimately when you boil it
- 30:19down, James is the villain. James is the villain of Silent
- 30:22Hill too. He is the one who murdered his
- 30:25wife. His wife was ill, but it was his
- 30:29frustrations, his deviations from that that made him kill his
- 30:33wife. And in the movie, they, they
- 30:35flipped it to almost give him this big redemption arc where
- 30:40she forgives him. She asks him to kill her.
- 30:44You know, they give him this almost like sympathetic plot
- 30:47line, you know, where she kinda is a bit mean to him because he
- 30:52wants her to leave the cult. And then and then that whole
- 30:56thing just gets muddled as well because right at the very
- 30:58beginning of the movie when James and Mary meet, she's
- 31:01trying to escape the city, right?
- 31:03She's he stops her from being able to escape the city.
- 31:07Just got to point out that bus could have waited for more than
- 31:10the 2.5 seconds that it did actually wait for her.
- 31:15But that's probably by and and you're not there apparently is
- 31:19only 1 bus in and out of Silent Hill.
- 31:22And that if she didn't catch it, there's no stakes in that
- 31:26opening scene. It's not like, you know, she
- 31:28missed the bus. OK.
- 31:30And what get the next thing. They're acting as if it's the
- 31:34last ever boss out of Silent Hill.
- 31:36Yeah. You know, so immediately, like
- 31:38you're just like, what the fuck is this?
- 31:40What is what is going on? And then she goes, but like, he
- 31:44takes her back and she starts sympathizing and defending the
- 31:48cult that she was trying to escape from.
- 31:51The whole thing then just becomes muddied and muddled.
- 31:55When in actual fact, we're never really supposed to be rooting
- 31:58for James at any point. He is a murderer.
- 32:02Everything we see is a manifestation of his grief, of
- 32:06his guilt, and it is completely wiped out by this cult plot line
- 32:10that we get there. There is absolutely zero pay off
- 32:14for. Yeah, and I think it's 'cause
- 32:18they're focusing too much on all that bullshit and try to give
- 32:21him that arc that this movie is fucking it.
- 32:25If they just stuck to the original, it would have been so
- 32:28much better. Yeah, but it's because they've
- 32:31tried to make it more than what is.
- 32:35They fucked up and they've not just fucked up as in trying to
- 32:42make it better than what they could have.
- 32:45They made it boring because of that.
- 32:47Yeah, they've they, as you said, they've taken the soul out of
- 32:51it. They've, they've just destroyed
- 32:53something that could have been so good.
- 32:55The. Thing is as well though, they've
- 32:56taken some of the big the best set pieces of the game and just
- 33:01completely bypassed it as well. That whole sequence in Toluca
- 33:04prison, which is one of the most famous sequences in horror
- 33:09gaming and is one of probably one of the scariest sort of
- 33:12periods in Silent Hill too as well.
- 33:14And it's completely missing from this movie.
- 33:17They haven't even bothered to go in.
- 33:19I know we go into the apartments.
- 33:21I know we go into the hospital. But even then they're they're
- 33:25they're they're too brief in the games.
- 33:27We spend a lot of time in these locations.
- 33:30You spend a lot of time in the prison, in the apartments, in
- 33:33the in the hospital. The hospital Steve's rushed as
- 33:37well. Yeah, Well, exactly.
- 33:39There's no, there's no, there's no concept of letting the story
- 33:44breathe. And I think that's one of the
- 33:45things about Silent Hill too. And again, you have a lot more
- 33:48time in a game to tell a story, right?
- 33:50I think Silent Hill, I think it clocks in around.
- 33:55I can't actually remember how long the main plot line clocks
- 33:57in around. I'll probably check that up.
- 34:01But they just rushed through so much stuff that could have been
- 34:10could have been more explored. And I think again, that would
- 34:13have given you just a little bit more credit in the bank from die
- 34:16hard fans for full. So Silent Hill 2, this is the
- 34:20remake version. It takes 16 to 18 hours to
- 34:24complete for a standard playthrough.
- 34:27So yeah, you have obviously got that significantly more time,
- 34:31but you know, a lot of that is probably people running around
- 34:34not really sure how to kill things.
- 34:36And you don't obviously have to do that in the movie.
- 34:38So. And I guess you don't want to
- 34:39put all the like, puzzles in there because it doesn't
- 34:42translate very well to the big screen, you know, But there's
- 34:47just so much of the story like that they missed out.
- 34:49There was no strip club like there is in the game.
- 34:52And that ends up being quite and, and again, that it's quite
- 34:55an integral part to the whole story because it's about lust.
- 34:58And you know, Eddie, the character is meant to represent
- 35:01gluttony, and all of that is missing.
- 35:06Yeah, it's it's. It's like they've tried to
- 35:12condense it but took the wrong but so is the only way of
- 35:17describing it. I can't say only like honestly,
- 35:26it's just it's, it's it's just awful.
- 35:30Like I I never ever say do not watch this movie, right?
- 35:36Oh, you're about to tell people to not form their own opinions?
- 35:41But I would recommend not watching this movie because if
- 35:44you think this movie is good, you're stuck up your own arse.
- 35:48You're just looking it for the nice scenery.
- 35:50In spite of everything that we've said, giving a gun to my
- 35:54head and given the choice, I would still watch this over
- 35:57Revelations. Yeah, but I think that's because
- 36:00of the nostalgic factor, because there is some bits that like is
- 36:03to the game. Nostalgia factor is a valid,
- 36:06it's a no factor. And then again, it is possible.
- 36:09It is probably the reason why I'm willing to give this thing a
- 36:12little bit of credit and a little bit of time.
- 36:15And you're right, it's probably mostly down to that nostalgic
- 36:18factor, but at least the nostalgic factor is there.
- 36:21Yeah, at least you've got some of it.
- 36:23You know you can. See.
- 36:25It's not the right some of it. No, no, no, no, 100%.
- 36:28And they could have been so much better and so much more done
- 36:30with it. But at least that is there, I
- 36:32guess. Listen, if you want to watch a
- 36:34Silent Hill movie, go watch the 2009 one.
- 36:38It's it's, if nothing else, it's significantly better acted.
- 36:42You've got much bigger. And that's the thing as well.
- 36:45You've got much bigger stars in that movie as well.
- 36:49Yeah. You know, you've got Sean Bean,
- 36:50you've got Laurie Holden, you've got, you know, the like, I
- 36:54immediately forget everyone else is in that movie.
- 36:56But like the star power in that movie is so much greater than
- 37:02than what we have here. And it's that alone is very
- 37:07telling, I think for me, because you can.
- 37:11Like I get the word trying to get folk that would be goodness
- 37:19right? That we're unknowns to save on
- 37:21budget, that's understandable, but at least get folks are good.
- 37:29But like, surely, surely the cost of that they're seeing how
- 37:34like there's zero chemistry between them.
- 37:36And I listen again. I would be remissed if I didn't
- 37:41say that. You know, part of the charm of
- 37:43the original Silent Hilton game is it's bad voice acting.
- 37:46Just like it was in in Resident Evil as well when those games
- 37:50first came out. The bad voice acting kind of
- 37:52goes hand in hand with it. I put it if you turn it to a
- 37:57movie, you can't exactly go all get shit folk to do this.
- 38:00You know, I mean employee thought is different.
- 38:02You're fucking trained the character on the screen, you
- 38:04know, I mean, you're still seeing decent if you cannot
- 38:08fucking act like I'm they saying they're shit actors, but they're
- 38:14definitely shitting this, put it that way.
- 38:16Yeah, Listen again, yeah, I think it's important to know we
- 38:19don't, I don't, we never really like to make it.
- 38:22So it's not a personal thing. We don't want to like just shit
- 38:25on specific people for a relatively poor performance.
- 38:29This is not filled with good performances.
- 38:31But like you say, that's not a saying that you're about that
- 38:34it's bad actors. It's maybe just, you know, not
- 38:36the right roles or not the right scripts or anything like that.
- 38:40So. It, it feels like they're very
- 38:43monotone through the whole, but it feels like they're very, it
- 38:47just, it feels like, it feels like they're bored.
- 38:49That's the problem. It just felt like it felt like
- 38:54Christophe Ganz didn't really know what he wanted to say with
- 38:59this. Yeah, if you see if you had
- 39:00changed things dramatically. But there was real conviction in
- 39:03the plot and real conviction you could really clearly define the
- 39:07story that he was trying to tell.
- 39:09Again, you can forgive missteps because at least then, but
- 39:14there's so it feels like an incomplete story because there's
- 39:18so many tie up, there's so many loose ends.
- 39:20You know, the character Eddie in the movie just just disappears.
- 39:24Yeah, for for such a long movie as well that it goes fucking
- 39:29nowhere. It doesn't tie up everything
- 39:31that it's got it just it drugs. Yeah.
- 39:36And it drugs his heels a lot. Yeah, and you know, again, it
- 39:42had like all the creature design come across come off really
- 39:45well. Again, I think I'll be forgiven.
- 39:47In that original Silent Hill movie, Pyramid Head looks, he
- 39:49looks sick as fuck, right? He looked like, and I think in
- 39:53this movie he looks like dog shit.
- 39:56Yeah. And you know, I'm not a big fan
- 39:59of hearing him like Grunt as he goes through his movements.
- 40:03I don't think Pyramid Tag is someone you should hear.
- 40:07It's kind of like, it's kind of a little bit like Art the Clown
- 40:09in that way, Whereas I don't think you should ever hear, even
- 40:13if it is just grunting noises, I don't think you should hear.
- 40:15Pyramid had because his. I think that's because of the
- 40:18following he's got in that other thing that you and Candy were
- 40:20talking about that I didn't know about.
- 40:21That's why that grunting noises are there.
- 40:24But The thing is, I think his physicality should speak for
- 40:27itself. He should be massive in
- 40:29imposing. And, you know, and I remember
- 40:32playing those games back when you're, when you're younger and
- 40:35you're playing those games for the first time.
- 40:36He is terrifying. Yeah.
- 40:38You know, and he's just not in here.
- 40:41If anything, it looks like he's going to have sex with a spider
- 40:44creature at one point. Yeah, and.
- 40:46I don't know why, and I get that.
- 40:48Like you know, hyper sexualization and sexual divancy
- 40:52and all that are big themes in this movie.
- 40:54I don't know why they gave that spider creature such a fat ass.
- 41:00It's that scene is just, it's weird.
- 41:05It feels like it doesn't belong. I feel like you would sleep with
- 41:08the spider creature. I'd be.
- 41:14You're just, excuse me, you're just like, what do those, what
- 41:19can those eight hands do? That's what I was just thinking.
- 41:22I I was like. If I can spit my words out, but
- 41:25yeah. That spider creature, there's
- 41:29there's attributes are nice. But again, it's a spider
- 41:33creature that was really poorly CGI.
- 41:35You know that last scene where like it's hat comes off and is
- 41:38rolling towards him on the floor?
- 41:39It looks so shit. Yeah.
- 41:43And then you get the fight scene.
- 41:45And this is perhaps one of the other things, right?
- 41:47Why are we still making Silent Hill movies that are 15 rated?
- 41:52I know like. It should be 80.
- 41:55Like or you know, if you're an American, why are we not making
- 41:58R rateds? So like just like it always
- 42:02feels like then you're trying to hold back.
- 42:04Go balls. This is an IP.
- 42:06Go balls to the fucking wall. This is like, in my opinion,
- 42:11this was the most terrifying game of franchise ever.
- 42:15Some people, some people still feel that way.
- 42:18And it the way like you're more than your horror games than I
- 42:22am. But I I would say it's probably
- 42:24what I would say the second one is probably the most terrifying
- 42:26one I've ever played. Yeah, I.
- 42:28Would say. That I've not played, I've not
- 42:31played the most recent Silent Hill game yet.
- 42:33Silent Hill F I've not played that yet, but from what I've
- 42:37heard, it's it's I've heard a bit mixed things, but it's
- 42:40generally pretty well received. But yeah, Silent Hill 2 still
- 42:44sort of stands as the as the king of the.
- 42:47Benchmark, basically. So if you're taking the scariest
- 42:51one out of the law, you're ripping the fucking soul out the
- 42:55storyline, you're going for a 15 rating.
- 42:59You're changing it so badly that you're like glued to the cult
- 43:07aspect of it. You're doing all this shit to
- 43:10change it. Change it, go for it.
- 43:13Fucking change it all. Don't try and include all the
- 43:16other shit so it doesn't make sense.
- 43:20And that's and. That's what the problem is.
- 43:24They've they've fucked this right royally in the ass.
- 43:28Like I said earlier, they've they've generally just went it's
- 43:32there, it's a hole, let's see what we can do.
- 43:35This is it. Like it has aspects of
- 43:37everything that it should have, but none of it feels fully
- 43:40fleshed out or followed through. And it just leaves it leaves it
- 43:44feeling like a rushed, unfinished mass of a movie,
- 43:48especially like plot wise, you know, we're talking about here,
- 43:52you know, again, you know, we've we've said it before, there are
- 43:55movies out there where, you know, we can forgive a bit about
- 43:58CGI, we can forgive a bit about acting.
- 44:00We can forgive, we can forgive a lot of things.
- 44:03If you're telling something that is compelling and especially
- 44:07when it's an adaptation for something, you know, and we've
- 44:10seen this before as well. When you think of Resident Evil,
- 44:14welcome to Raccoon City. You know, that is very much a
- 44:18huge, you know, lifting of Resident Evil 2 as a game and
- 44:25men, I think sort of the overriding opinion is they tried
- 44:28too hard to recreate the game and.
- 44:31Yeah, but it's not like they've tried too hard to recreate this
- 44:33game. They've literally just taken the
- 44:35iconic scenes in it, shown them and then.
- 44:38But that's the thing. But they haven't as well because
- 44:42they're. So if you're if you're going to
- 44:44do that, go one way or the other, you know, don't start off
- 44:47by showing us the bathroom and him looking at himself in the
- 44:51mirror and, you know, giving us literally almost every creature
- 44:54from the game and things, but then miss out the entire prison
- 44:58section. Yeah, this is, I mean, so it's
- 45:02like they've went, right? I've got whoever's done it.
- 45:05They've went, this is the scenes I want to include because this
- 45:08is my most memorable moments. That's what they've done.
- 45:11And then they've fucking shown that and then just fucked it up.
- 45:14Because in my mind, right, you could I get that you don't want
- 45:17to make this movie over long. You can cut most of those
- 45:21flashback scenes. Yeah, they're not necessary.
- 45:24You can cut them and you can tell the story as you go along
- 45:28in a much more succinct and quick manner and then include
- 45:32the fucking prison scene. Like it's so it's so important
- 45:36to the game. It's so important to the story.
- 45:39I I just. And then it gives, it gives you
- 45:42a whole new area of set pieces that you can do.
- 45:46And then you can have more stuff that's like, yeah, that's cool
- 45:49as fuck. But, you know, it's a horror
- 45:52game. It's supposed to be filled with
- 45:54scares and violence and guts and gore and yes, it's
- 45:57psychological. And we're supposed to have all
- 45:59of that. There's none of that in here for
- 46:01being a Silent Hill game. There's so little violence in
- 46:05this movie. Yeah, Like so little.
- 46:08It's like, it's like the bit of Pyramid Head where he's cutting
- 46:11her up. It instantly cuts away from that
- 46:14and goes to fucking him, painting over his own head.
- 46:17Yeah, and you're like get into the gore there again if what's
- 46:22happening show the reactions to everything other other other
- 46:25than the fucking bullshit you. Know, other than getting to see
- 46:29the guy melting from the the acid at the beginning.
- 46:33That's literally it. That's kind of it.
- 46:35Yeah. Guts and gore in this movie.
- 46:37And that to me is so disappointing.
- 46:40You remember, remember the first Silent Hill?
- 46:43You know, I've already talked about the scene where Pyramid
- 46:45had ripped her skin off, right. But we literally watch people
- 46:48getting burned alive in that movie, you know, when they're at
- 46:51the top of the lot and that's. It's cool as fuck.
- 46:55It looks so good. You're sitting there and you're
- 46:58going. That would like, it makes you
- 47:01cringe. It makes you like squirm because
- 47:03you're thinking about like how awful that would be.
- 47:06It's showing you what it needs to show you.
- 47:09It's still not a particularly gratuitous movie, but it shows
- 47:14you enough, you know that, you know, you see the barbed wire go
- 47:18up between her legs. You don't get to see anything
- 47:20else, but you know. Yeah, you know what's doing.
- 47:23It's at least in moments like that, it's at least implied as
- 47:27well. It's just they, they just don't
- 47:30go anywhere near far enough with that sort of stuff in this
- 47:33movie. Yeah, yeah.
- 47:34Like I can't disagree with any you've said apart from you
- 47:38thinking that it's like the game part, you know?
- 47:43It's I giant think that's the only thing that's making you
- 47:46think this is a better one. I'm not necessarily disagreeing
- 47:48with you as well, but I I take at least that factors there.
- 47:51That's what I'm saying, like if you're going to have a reason to
- 47:56watch this movie, you're watching it to see what hits
- 48:00you're getting from the game. Like you rewatched them after
- 48:03the first time watching as like, do I, right?
- 48:06Yeah. See, when you're watching again,
- 48:07were you getting more and more pissed off the further on it was
- 48:10getting? I was getting more and more.
- 48:11Because I was. Well So what happened is my my
- 48:13second watch through I actually kind of stopped watching halfway
- 48:16through and started playing Cyberpunk instead.
- 48:20I I stopped and fucking started playing COD to fucking waking
- 48:23myself up. Oh.
- 48:24Well, we had pretty similar, pretty similar, yeah, reactions
- 48:27then. I think that's quite funny you
- 48:29say that. Yeah.
- 48:31I had to go shoot people because fuck.
- 48:33And I was like, yeah, I need to fucking like, do something to my
- 48:36brain to just fucking get kick started again, Yeah.
- 48:40But listen, I don't think there's much else for me to
- 48:42really say about this film. I think we've kind of, you know,
- 48:46we'll just, I think if we continue to go on, we'll just be
- 48:49repeating ourselves over and over about, yeah, you know, how
- 48:52shitty this, this film. There, there's not a lot to say
- 48:54about this movie. That's the fucking problem, no?
- 48:57Listen, we've, we've talked about the story.
- 48:58The story is what's key here for me, you know, and for me in
- 49:03terms of horror gaming. Silent Hill 2 is the great I
- 49:07would go as far to say Silent Hill 2 is the greatest horror
- 49:10game of all time. That's my that's obviously my
- 49:13personal opinion. People have different things,
- 49:15but for me, Silent Hill two, it's the greatest horror game of
- 49:18all time. It tells such a deep, dark,
- 49:20interesting story and you know, it's got some great as a game.
- 49:25It's got some great puzzles, you know, it's got and it's created
- 49:29one of the most iconic sort of villains in Pyramid Head.
- 49:33Although technically, again speaking, is Pyramid Head even a
- 49:36villain? No, because James is actually
- 49:38our villain. You know, you've got some really
- 49:40interesting side characters in there and some really cool
- 49:43moments. And for me, this just tries to
- 49:47retell the same story but change some of the really key aspects
- 49:51of the storytelling. And that it just, it just rips
- 49:55the soul out of the story for me.
- 49:59Yeah. Like, why?
- 50:00Why is James being forgiven? Yeah, like it's.
- 50:10It's not often you're speechless, Nico.
- 50:13Like remember how we all say either be absolute shit or
- 50:17absolute good? The worst thing in B is
- 50:18mediocre. Well, I would say this is even
- 50:21worse. It's not even mediocre.
- 50:23It's it's boring. It's, it's not mediocre, it's
- 50:27not shit, it's not entertaining in any way shape or form.
- 50:30It's not even mediocre in my opinion.
- 50:32It's just if you want to fall asleep, watch this.
- 50:36Yeah, because it doesn't give you it doesn't.
- 50:39It feels like it's trying to give you so much lip service
- 50:41with what it's showing you from the game, but it doesn't
- 50:44actually give you anything of what you're actually wanting.
- 50:47You know, that like the scene of Pyramid Head fighting the spider
- 50:51monster could have been some big fucking gory, grotesque battle.
- 50:55Didn't get that. You know, there's there's
- 50:57there's no real other. Like, like I say, you know, in
- 51:01that original Silent Hill movie, you got the burn, you got the
- 51:04skin. RIP and everything, even even
- 51:07the dark side of Silent Hill went like post Siren in that
- 51:11original movie. It just looked so much more
- 51:13dirty and filthy and gritty. And here it kind of looks a bit
- 51:17too clean cut and a bit polished and that's CG.
- 51:22And I get obviously it's the 2009 films heavily CGI D as
- 51:25well, but that's that's modern CGI doing that to this movie.
- 51:29Yeah. So the CGI should be better than
- 51:32this one. It's I'm certainly, I would say
- 51:35it's worse. I would agree with you.
- 51:39So that's the other thing I was going to say I'm like, I was
- 51:42going to say like when I was trying to think of something
- 51:45good to say, I was like, well, this CGI and I thought, but I'm
- 51:50like, no, the original CGI is better.
- 51:51And I'm like, the only thing is the score and everything else is
- 51:56just awful. Like I never ever say don't
- 52:00watch this movie. I'm saying don't watch this
- 52:03movie. I, I'm not going to go as far as
- 52:06to say don't watch this movie because I think everyone should
- 52:08watch all the movies they can. And The thing is as well, like,
- 52:15I, I, I still love Silent Hill. I, I still want to get good
- 52:20Silent Hill movies. I don't.
- 52:23Has Christophe Ghanz done some irreparable damage to this IP as
- 52:27a film IP? Yes.
- 52:30Do you think we will? I think we will see another
- 52:34Silent Hill movie. I don't.
- 52:36I just. But don't think he'll be
- 52:38involved. Well, I hope he's not.
- 52:40He can't be involved anymore with Silent Hill.
- 52:44Any goodwill he had from that first movie is completely gone
- 52:47with this one. Gone.
- 52:49If a studio decides to take a punt and give us a new style,
- 52:52no, I don't think it's going to be for a long time now as well.
- 52:55I think that that. Because this leaves a bad taste
- 52:57in the mud. That ship has sailed.
- 52:59So and then if you do decide to do a new Silent Hill movie,
- 53:03what, what the fuck do you even go and do?
- 53:05Do you do you do what we maybe suggested and just go create
- 53:08your own story within? So because there's so much scope
- 53:11for that Silent Hill as a metaphor and as a representation
- 53:15of grief and guilt, There's so much more you can do with that
- 53:18as a story that doesn't involve any characters from the games.
- 53:21You can literally, it can be, it can be almost less like Twilight
- 53:24Zone kind of thing, couldn't it? Like where you you then take or
- 53:29and do multiple stories or conversely, do you can do you do
- 53:33another movie that tries to lift from the games?
- 53:37Do you do some sort of weird hybrids?
- 53:40I don't know. I think there's a lot of
- 53:42goodwill gone out the window for Silent Hill as a property.
- 53:45And that makes me so sad to say. Like so so sad to say.
- 53:51It I know it sounds bad but can we not just get to the reviews
- 53:56and stuff because I hate this. Yeah, where that was kind of,
- 54:00that was kind of my last word. I was going to ask you if there
- 54:02was anything else we wanted to talk about.
- 54:03No the the only thing I want to talk about is like fucking get
- 54:08this over with now. I'm not normally like that
- 54:10either. I would rather talk for days
- 54:12about movies. This is just, it offends me.
- 54:15Well, we're going to move on then.
- 54:17I'm not there's, I'm going to kind of just skip over the
- 54:21trivia section as well because there really was.
- 54:24There any? There was, there was a couple of
- 54:27little pieces, but not much so. And I've already told you one
- 54:32that Akira Yama Yamaoka, who composed most of the original
- 54:36Silent Hill games, composed the music for this film.
- 54:38So I've already told you that one.
- 54:40I know there's different versions of this movie so.
- 54:43Budget. This movie had a $23 million
- 54:45budget, has currently grossed 47.7 million.
- 54:48So it's doubled its money, which is what the first film did.
- 54:51But the first film, the first film made was budgeted at 50 and
- 54:55grossed about 100. But it's it's doubled as money
- 55:00purely because it's Silent Hill and people are interested in
- 55:02Silent Hill as a property. Yeah, 2047 like.
- 55:06The only thing that pulled us to the cinema to see it was because
- 55:09it was a second one. Yeah, A. 100% So it got us, you
- 55:13know what I mean? And the other piece of trivia I
- 55:14have is Evie Templeton, who plays Laura, the little girl in
- 55:17this movie. She's actually the voice in
- 55:19motion capture of the same character in the 2024 remake of
- 55:23Silent Hill 2 All. Right.
- 55:25So she actually was in the she's actually the she's the Laura in
- 55:29the games as well. Yeah.
- 55:31Which is even worse for me then because.
- 55:34And I get that she's a child, but I get that she's a child.
- 55:39But they're making her act the same character completely
- 55:43differently. And it's like.
- 55:44Yeah, how the fuck, How the fuck is it done that right?
- 55:48Like if you've got that person. In that instance, why even
- 55:52bother getting her at all? Yeah, that, that doesn't make
- 55:57sense to me. So I didn't know that.
- 55:59So like that's made it even worse for me.
- 56:01Yeah, if, if I could take more points off, it would be more
- 56:05points off for that. That anyway, that's the trivia.
- 56:08We're not even doing a full section because that's literally
- 56:10all I could find. Every other piece of trivia was
- 56:12like, oh, the the bathroom in the opening of the game is
- 56:15representation of the bathroom in the beginning of Silent Hill
- 56:18too. And I was like, if I started
- 56:19reading out every fucking reference, then we'll be here
- 56:21all night. I know there's different
- 56:23versions for what the different versions were in the countries
- 56:27of this movie. So it was one of my other mates
- 56:31was thinking about it and she's like, well into Silent Hill.
- 56:33She was like, yeah, basically China's got a different one,
- 56:38America's Got a different one, we've got a different.
- 56:40One that's not uncommon in movies.
- 56:43I know that's not uncommon, but like, yeah, I'm just wondering
- 56:48if it's going to be like if Kandi comes on and she's like,
- 56:50this is a fucking masterpiece. I've seen a different version.
- 56:55I don't think that. I don't think any ending could
- 56:57make this a masterpiece. I don't know if it's just the
- 57:00end of that have changed. What I mean, I don't even
- 57:02remember. I nudged you in the cinema and I
- 57:04was like, the only thing that might save this if at the very
- 57:06end it took we get the dog ending, I think that might have
- 57:10been the only thing to save this fucking film because then
- 57:13everything that's happened is nudge, nudge, wink, wink.
- 57:16And at that point, I might have, I might have thought this was an
- 57:18OK film. I think that's the only ending
- 57:22you could have gave this, the sacrifice that to salvage this
- 57:25movie. Sorry, is the dog ending?
- 57:27Yeah, but no, it's just awful. I kind of wish they do, and I
- 57:32kind of wish they'd referenced it a little bit as well.
- 57:34I wish there was that, No, but like, you know what I mean?
- 57:37Like just, I don't know, like have like someone's there's so
- 57:42many things you could have done to reference it without making
- 57:44it too cheesy or corny and they just, they didn't bother.
- 57:48But anyways, let's move on then to our our other section or
- 57:51final section, which is the ratings and the reviews.
- 57:57Congratulations, you are still alive.
- 58:01Most people are so ungrateful to be alive but not you.
- 58:09And as always, we will start off with the critics.
- 58:13IMDb has this at a four out of 10.
- 58:17Metacritic has this at a 3.4 out of 10.
- 58:21Nico. Already higher than I thought.
- 58:23What do you think the Rotten Tomatoes critics scored this?
- 58:27I I would have put it in like a 20 but with those scores I'm not
- 58:30sure now I'll go my luck in #22. You're not 1,000,000 miles away.
- 58:38The Ron's mouse critics have this at 18%.
- 58:41Rotten. See, that's what I thought would
- 58:44be, but for you say the scores beforehand.
- 58:46I'm like, no. Yeah, but remember, Matt Craig
- 58:47and IMDb are usually much more centrist in their values.
- 58:51True, so you know Rotten Tomatoes is very you vary so
- 58:57that's why we do the game for the Rotten Tomatoes, but 18%
- 59:00creates consensus a visually tacky sequel that lumbers along
- 59:04with applauding pulse and the lacking the thematic resonance
- 59:08that distinguished its source material returned to Silent Hill
- 59:11gets lost in the haze. What do you think the Ron
- 59:15Tomatoes audience scored this? Please below.
- 59:21It's normally always higher. So what did you say it was 18?
- 59:2418. I'll go, I'll go higher than 22,
- 59:31I'll go 24. You should have went a little
- 59:35higher still. The Rod Tomorrow's audience had
- 59:38this at 29% stop. We're just.
- 59:42I wasn't. I wasn't going to go higher at
- 59:4425, that's for sure. It's still a terribly low score
- 59:47so. I think that's the worst I've
- 59:49done in the fucking score in a while.
- 59:51Can't. He would have a shot.
- 59:55This is this is one of the worst movies we've reviewed in a
- 59:58while. Like yeah, we could, depending
- 1:00:00on what me and you score this. I know I'm scoring this.
- 1:00:04We could have something right down at the bottom of our
- 1:00:06leaderboard, but anyways before. We get.
- 1:00:07We're going into before. We get there.
- 1:00:10Let's just read out some of the thoughts and opinions from our
- 1:00:12followers and listeners and people on the Internet, Dimitro
- 1:00:15says. Honestly, it was painful to
- 1:00:16watch. It's just so dumb, like it
- 1:00:19doesn't even try and it looks very cheap and without the
- 1:00:21atmosphere. Probably the worst movie of the
- 1:00:23year I hope. Correct.
- 1:00:25Alexander says. I'm convinced no one hates
- 1:00:27Silent Hill as much as Christoph Gantz hates Silent Hill.
- 1:00:31Just takes a big CGI shit all over the story, the drab, the
- 1:00:34aesthetic, the characters in every movie He makes one out of
- 1:00:3710. It's worth knowing that
- 1:00:38Christoph Gantz has seven directorial credits to his name,
- 1:00:42and this is the lowest rated one on IMDb.
- 1:00:46Mild artist Bonsai says men would rather go to Silent Hill
- 1:00:50than go back to therapy. One out of 10.
- 1:00:55I can't. You can't.
- 1:00:57He's got a point. You can't.
- 1:00:58Argue with that. The other thing says I have no
- 1:01:02idea how anyone who doesn't already know the franchise lore
- 1:01:05could comprehend what happens in this movie.
- 1:01:07Just a bunch of nods to the game and a minimalist plot to go
- 1:01:10along with it. Don't waste your time, just go
- 1:01:13play the video games. 4 out of 10 after that review.
- 1:01:17That that's too high after that review.
- 1:01:19BK Lima finishes us off with this is insultingly bad.
- 1:01:22Bad accents, bad acting, bad pacing, bad right in Bad Wakes,
- 1:01:25and worst of all, a frustratingly bad
- 1:01:27misunderstanding of one of the best and most influential horror
- 1:01:30games ever made. One out of 10.
- 1:01:33So all of the scores that we received, thank you very much.
- 1:01:37So return to Silent Hill from our listeners gets an average of
- 1:01:402.7 out of 10. That's too high.
- 1:01:44And that means Nico, it just leaves me and you.
- 1:01:48Do you want to go first or second?
- 1:01:52You go first. I'll go first, OK?
- 1:01:57Honestly, I've I've talked my score down.
- 1:02:01How can you talk it down any further?
- 1:02:03Because I I. What were you initially going to
- 1:02:07score it like? Well.
- 1:02:08I'll tell you in a minute. I, I have and always will do
- 1:02:15have this just deep rooted love for Silent Hill as a property.
- 1:02:20I would take the game out of it. I think would you let me say my
- 1:02:23piece, Thank. You very much because you're
- 1:02:25right that you're taking it down that's.
- 1:02:27What I'm saying? Well, just let me say my fucking
- 1:02:28pieces. This is my moment.
- 1:02:30This is my moment, OK? Try to pick it up for you.
- 1:02:33I don't need you to. I don't.
- 1:02:35I don't. Fucking need you to pick it up
- 1:02:36for me. I'm perfectly capable of doing
- 1:02:38it myself. We need someone to fucking pull
- 1:02:41fork in for this episode because they got me the movie.
- 1:02:46As always, people come for the hilarity that is me.
- 1:02:49Thank you very much. Oh yeah, because you voted for
- 1:02:51yourself? That's funny, I forgot.
- 1:02:53Anyways, can I say my fucking review now please?
- 1:02:57OK. I don't interrupt your reviews,
- 1:03:00thank you very much. And This is why people think
- 1:03:03we're not friends anyways. We're not.
- 1:03:06We hate each other. Yeah, we're bringing, but we've
- 1:03:08decided that we're bringing back a little bit of the nastiness,
- 1:03:11haven't we? God how Scotsman show love to
- 1:03:17each other. Fuck, you're perfect.
- 1:03:20Dickhead anyways, right? I will and always will have a
- 1:03:24deep seated love for Silent Hill as a property.
- 1:03:26It's, I can say the thing that got me into horror is one of my
- 1:03:29favorite franchises of all time. But the movies have in general,
- 1:03:34Nah, been a bit of a let down. I still have.
- 1:03:36I still rate the original Silent Hill movie.
- 1:03:39I still think that's a good movie.
- 1:03:41I think there's a lot of really cool stuff in there.
- 1:03:42I think it's a flawed movie, but I think ultimately Christophe
- 1:03:46Gantz did a pretty good job with that first movie of recreating
- 1:03:49the setting, recreating aesthetic, the tension, blah
- 1:03:52blah blah blah blah blah blah. Here, all of that is gone and
- 1:03:57all the goodwill that he gained with that first movie is
- 1:04:00completely gone. Here he's went to make a more
- 1:04:03direct remake of the second game, which is the greatest game
- 1:04:07within that franchise. And he's just, for me, he's just
- 1:04:12ripped the heart and the soul completely out of it.
- 1:04:17You know, there's huge portions of really important plot line
- 1:04:20that's in the game that are completely missing.
- 1:04:23He's changed parts of the story, which in itself is not
- 1:04:27necessarily a bad thing if you do it correctly, but they're the
- 1:04:31story almost. The story feels unfinished.
- 1:04:35We have got characters that are there from the game but are
- 1:04:38completely inconsequential and get no growth or arc.
- 1:04:42Our villains, our creatures, none of them have the same
- 1:04:45resonance and have the same, you know, meaning as they do in the
- 1:04:49game. It's a very deep dark
- 1:04:51psychological game and in they they instead of making it a very
- 1:04:56deep dark psychological movie, they've just made it really
- 1:04:59angsty. And you know, you the third,
- 1:05:03there is nothing really here other than a few shots of
- 1:05:08moments from the game that you can look at and go, yeah, that's
- 1:05:10cool. Like I mentioned earlier with
- 1:05:12like the bathroom scene or James look at himself in the mirror
- 1:05:15or, you know, the the appearance of Pyramid Head and things like
- 1:05:18that. That, that is kind of it.
- 1:05:20That and the score are kind of the two things for me in terms
- 1:05:22of positives around this movie. So because those are my 2
- 1:05:26positives, I'm going to give it 2 out of 10.
- 1:05:31I was originally going to give it a four.
- 1:05:35I'm glad you because that would have had words.
- 1:05:38OK, Nico, you're up. So I I need you to go check
- 1:05:43something for me for my review. What's the lowest score I've
- 1:05:46ever gave any movie? You gave troll to a 0.5.
- 1:05:51OK so I go in half and a 0.5 of his lowest I've ever gave.
- 1:05:58I will give this movie a fucking 0 because it is that but I've
- 1:06:03never given a zero to anything. I I I gave the .5 to trolls
- 1:06:07because at least it was entertaining in some way shape
- 1:06:11or form. This is so fucking dog shit I
- 1:06:15can't even give it a .5. It is it's destroyed the best
- 1:06:21horror game I've ever played in my life.
- 1:06:24It has taken taken it to pieces to try to rebuild it in just the
- 1:06:30shittest way ever. Like I I genuinely directed this
- 1:06:37movie is so fucking awful. You would not think they did the
- 1:06:39first one which was all right. So yeah, I am giving this a 0
- 1:06:46because as I said, I would recommend never seen this to
- 1:06:50anyone like the It's a waste of time, it's a waste of money,
- 1:06:55it's a waste of potential, it's a waste of everything.
- 1:06:58There is nothing good about this.
- 1:07:00If you want to listen a good score, just go to the game.
- 1:07:04It's not bad. Wow, the first ever 0 on part of
- 1:07:09the dam the only took until episode 160.
- 1:07:13Because we always, you know, we, we, we can be hypercritical
- 1:07:16sometimes, but we do genuinely always try to find a positive
- 1:07:22something that is even just minorly redeemable about
- 1:07:26something. But for you, there's just
- 1:07:28nothing. Right person right he's plus
- 1:07:32he's director guy. It's the first silent hell a
- 1:07:36Ryan Freeman, one of my one of my favorite movies.
- 1:07:39Crying free, my love. Fucking crying Freeman.
- 1:07:43What else was our Beauty and the beast?
- 1:07:45That was all right, But this genuinely, if this was the last
- 1:07:51movie you did, you need to do another movie.
- 1:07:54So you're not remembered by this.
- 1:07:56Because if you died tomorrow and this is your last movie, they
- 1:07:59would say you are the shittest director that's ever lived.
- 1:08:02Wow, so just for reference sake, you gave the original Silent
- 1:08:06Hill a 4.5. Yeah.
- 1:08:09Which I think is low. I think that's a low score.
- 1:08:12Candy only gave out four, to be fair.
- 1:08:14But I, I, I think that's low for the first Silent Hill movie.
- 1:08:18I think the Silent Hill first Silent Hill movie is a good
- 1:08:21movie. But for reference, so, so that
- 1:08:24movie, it was in 118th place on our leaderboard.
- 1:08:29So it was they were still down low with a 5.26 average.
- 1:08:34That's what it that's what it says on our leaderboard.
- 1:08:36So all of our scores combined with the critics and the
- 1:08:38listener scores gives Return to Silent Hill an average score of
- 1:08:432.4 out of 10. And it means it is now 144th out
- 1:08:52of 146 movies. It is the third lowest rated
- 1:08:57movie that we have reviewed on this show.
- 1:09:00I guarantee I'd rather watch the last two.
- 1:09:03Well the lot, the 2 below it are Attack of the Herbals and Lost
- 1:09:07Boys the tribe. Definitely rather watch both of
- 1:09:11them. I'm I'm not going to go that
- 1:09:14far. I'm not going to go that far,
- 1:09:18but the the two or three movies that are above it.
- 1:09:21So it's one place below Troll 2 which you gave the .5 score to.
- 1:09:26It's 2:00 but it going going up the sort of 5 or 6 movies above
- 1:09:30it. Winnie the Pooh, Blood and
- 1:09:31Honey, Halloween Resurrection, Human Centipede, Blood and Honey
- 1:09:342, Bloodbath at the House of Death.
- 1:09:38These are the movies that are are directly above it.
- 1:09:41So return to Silent Hill. It's been a long time since
- 1:09:45something has broken into our bottom 5.
- 1:09:49Yeah. So there you go.
- 1:09:51And and in my opinion it should be two places lower.
- 1:09:57Wow, there you go. There you have it everyone.
- 1:09:59Then. So return to Silent Hill,
- 1:10:01officially the third worst movie that we have ever reviewed on
- 1:10:06this podcast. Something tells me that Candy's
- 1:10:10not going to have a score that's going to redeem it as well.
- 1:10:12Something tells me that she is also going to think that this is
- 1:10:15dog shit and is on the exact same page as we are.
- 1:10:19It might be totally different in the other places, there's
- 1:10:21different versions, you never know.
- 1:10:22It might save it, but the version we've seen is just
- 1:10:26honestly, I kind of see, I kind of see how it could redeem it.
- 1:10:31Well, I, I don't think there's any redemption in this.
- 1:10:37I, I, maybe I'm ever a smidge higher on it than you are, but
- 1:10:41you know, I've still only given it a 2 out of 10.
- 1:10:45And that is also, you know, an unusually low score for me, my
- 1:10:51lowest. I'm actually surprised.
- 1:10:53I thought you were gonna go for like a one or something on it.
- 1:10:55Well, my lowest score that I've ever handed out is once, and
- 1:10:58I've only done it twice, and it's for the 2 movies that are
- 1:11:01below this. Yeah, and not that matched your
- 1:11:04score that you gave for those two movies as well.
- 1:11:06So we were in agreement there. I've never given below.
- 1:11:08A1 you've done your you gave Lost Boys a Tribe A1, Attack of
- 1:11:14the Herbals. A1 you gave Halloween 3A1 and I
- 1:11:21think that's it for the ones obviously a .5 for Troll 2 and
- 1:11:24Now and nothing for Return to Silent Hell.
- 1:11:27You haven't ever given out a 1.5, so you've given out twos
- 1:11:31for both the Blood and Honey movies.
- 1:11:34You gave a 2 for 2019's Child's Play.
- 1:11:40You gave a 2 for in. I would rather watch Child's
- 1:11:44Play than this. You gave a 2 for Insidious.
- 1:11:51So so I've just looked at his directed movies, right.
- 1:11:55I'm not going to lie, I would watch any of them out the ones
- 1:11:59I've seen any of the four before this again.
- 1:12:01Well. That's.
- 1:12:02What I'm saying, but that's decent.
- 1:12:04This is his lowest rated project that he's ever done so.
- 1:12:07It should be lower than a fucking 4, that's for sure.
- 1:12:11But yeah, that is going to do it.
- 1:12:13Then for the show this week. Wow.
- 1:12:17It's but I can say it's been a long time.
- 1:12:19We we we've kind of been focusing on movies that we've
- 1:12:22maybe missed and we've been doing some high things.
- 1:12:24Like we in one of our recent episodes, we had a movie break
- 1:12:27into our top ten. That's not happened for a wee
- 1:12:29bit. So it's been a long time since
- 1:12:32we've done something that's been this bad.
- 1:12:33I think that it fires down to the bottom there.
- 1:12:37And you know, if candy is as low.
- 1:12:42Well, put it this way, I'm just going to let me just make let me
- 1:12:45just go and and do something quickly before we get out of
- 1:12:48here. If my laptop, if my PC decides
- 1:12:50to stop being up a table if candy gives this a zero out of
- 1:12:54town like you it would it would drop one more place.
- 1:13:00So just because this. Still not enough so just because
- 1:13:04it needs its own leaderboard of shit movie.
- 1:13:06So, yeah, the scores for Lost Boys the Tribe are so low that
- 1:13:11it it, it, it will not go down that low because Lost Boys the
- 1:13:15Tribe, number one, it didn't have a Metacritic score.
- 1:13:18It got a 0% on Rotten Tomatoes. It has a lower Rotten Tomatoes
- 1:13:24audience score. So, yeah, all those sort of
- 1:13:27factors combined means that you know that that return to Silent
- 1:13:31Hill, nothing Candy can do can get to bottom, but she can drop
- 1:13:34it down to second from bottom, conversely.
- 1:13:39You know how much I hate that Lost Boys movie, right?
- 1:13:42I know. Because everyone knows how much
- 1:13:45I love Lost Boys, and that shits all over its memory, right?
- 1:13:48I just want to. I would still rather watch that
- 1:13:51than this movie. I just want to say though,
- 1:13:52conversely, if Candy were to love this movie and think it's
- 1:13:56with the greatest masterpiece of all time and give it a 10 out of
- 1:13:5910, it would still only go up by three places into 141st.
- 1:14:05If if she does that she needs to be thrown off the fucking
- 1:14:08podcast for being smoked for smoking crack on the job because
- 1:14:12it's the only way she could ever give it a 10.
- 1:14:17That or if she sees a different version and she needs to show
- 1:14:19us. Well, you can discuss that with
- 1:14:21her when we are all on the show again.
- 1:14:23Next back when all three of us will be together again, we're
- 1:14:27going to be reviewing The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, The Next
- 1:14:30Generation. We have got some other stuff
- 1:14:34coming up as well. Coming up later.
- 1:14:37Well, I think relatively soon is our latest episode of Trash
- 1:14:40Talk, which is headed up by Candy and Randy.
- 1:14:43They're talking about faster Pussycat Kill kill.
- 1:14:46We've got a mini sort of Scream 7 going to be coming up shortly.
- 1:14:50We've got a huge amount of other great fun episodes for everyone
- 1:14:53to look forward to as well. So until then guys, Nico, thank
- 1:14:56you very much for joining me as always.
- 1:14:58Thanks for having me on. It was just a pity it was this
- 1:15:00movie. And thank you to everyone for
- 1:15:03downloading and listening to this podcast.
- 1:15:05And until next week, on the part of the damned, just remember,
- 1:15:08you're damned if you do and you're damned if you don't.