Latest / The Vegan Report / Jainism for Veganism.
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone and welcome to the vegan report
- 0:03podcast. My name is Ryan and today we're highlighting
- 0:06the efforts of passionate Jane animal rights
- 0:10activists who are promoting veganism from within
- 0:14the religious community. And you might be thinking,
- 0:18isn't Janeism that ancient Indian religion whose
- 0:22core teaching is ahimsa, the principle of avoiding
- 0:26harm to any living being, including animals,
- 0:30insects, and even microscopic organisms. So how
- 0:35come jains aren't already some of the biggest
- 0:38proponents of veganism out there? That's one
- 0:42of the questions we'll explore today along with
- 0:45others like what's the place of spirituality
- 0:48and religion in the vegan movement? What boundaries
- 0:52should you set as a compassionate person? And
- 0:55what does it feel when religious authorities
- 0:58within your own community oppose your veganism?
- 1:03To discuss all of this, I have with me Ruchika
- 1:06Shitrabanu. Interior Designer, Founder of the
- 1:11Earthen One, Co -Founder of Ahimsa Fest and Global
- 1:15Advisor for the Jane Vegan Initiative, and Mayor
- 1:19Shah, Chair of the Jane Association in North
- 1:22America's Ahimsa Eco -Vegan Committee. To connect
- 1:27with Rochika and Mayor, visit the episode notes,
- 1:31and as always, Follow or subscribe to the show,
- 1:35share the episode to help spread the word about
- 1:38the universality of veganism, and leave a positive
- 1:42review. Those are always encouraging. Thank you
- 1:46for your support and enjoy the episode. Wonderful.
- 2:02So I was thinking maybe as a nice breaker question,
- 2:05who is your vegan hero and why? I think it's
- 2:09a great way to get to know activists. Shum? Mario,
- 2:14do you want to go first? You know, that's the
- 2:18first time that I've actually been asked that
- 2:20question. And yeah, I want to say, I don't know
- 2:27if I have one answer. But one of the earlier
- 2:30influences of me considering veganism, but it's
- 2:34not actually when I became vegan, was two decades
- 2:38ago, almost two decades ago. And it's funny that
- 2:42you asked this question because the inspiration
- 2:45shares the same last name as our other guests
- 2:50here. So Ruchika Chitrabanu, right? So Gurudev
- 2:55Chitrabanu, Ruchika's father -in -law. I met
- 2:59him and his wife Pramodaman at a Jain convention
- 3:06for the young Jain professionals. So that's abbreviated
- 3:10YGP. It's kind of the like professional age Jains.
- 3:17And at the time I was co -chair of that group
- 3:21and we had a convention where Gurudev was the
- 3:25keynote speaker, and that planted the seed. The
- 3:30seed didn't actually grow and, you know, germinate
- 3:32and bloom until long, you know, way too long
- 3:38after. I actually became vegan in 2020, after
- 3:43one of the bigger chain of conventions, which
- 3:46was fully online during COVID. So that's when
- 3:50I actually made the transition, I think it was
- 3:52Sometimes I say this, I've never said it to you,
- 3:55Ruchika, but I've, you know, I kind of, in many
- 3:59ways, not just vegan wise, right, in many other
- 4:01ways, I had a, to borrow a phrase, I had a coming
- 4:05to Jainism moment, okay? So, you know, you can
- 4:10see the connection to the other well -known phrase,
- 4:13right? But it was really a coming to Jainism
- 4:15moment. I was like, you know, this is, this is,
- 4:19for me, this is, you know, personally a little
- 4:22bit hypocritical for me to believe, you know,
- 4:25and then this is not a judgment, judgment on
- 4:27other people, just, you know, on me. But to answer
- 4:30your question, it was initially planted by Gurudev
- 4:34Chitrabanu. Thank you for this. Sorry, Mayor.
- 4:40Just more similar my story is to that, because
- 4:44my inspiration and my heroes to veganism also,
- 4:48Gurudev Chitrabanu and Pramodavin, who are my
- 4:51you know, my in -laws. And again, they planted
- 4:56the seed and, you know, it took me a long time
- 4:59in spite of staying in the same house with them.
- 5:01It took me like nearly a decade to go completely
- 5:04vegan. I kept trying to go vegan, would go for
- 5:07a few months, keep turning around, again, try
- 5:10for some time, keep turning around. But 2005
- 5:14is when it really hit me and that's when I went
- 5:17completely vegan. So, These two people again
- 5:21are my heroes, my inspiration, and they continue
- 5:25to be that. Have your in -laws inspire other
- 5:31Jains out there to follow a vegan diet? Yes,
- 5:37they have. And I'll expand a little on that.
- 5:42My father -in -law Gurudev Chitrabanu was a Jain
- 5:45monk. for 30 years, for almost 30 years. And
- 5:50in his monkhood, he inspired people to go vegetarian
- 5:53that time, because the concept of vegan was not.
- 5:56And then, you know, he left monkhood and he and
- 6:02Ramodha Chitrapanu got married. They moved to
- 6:04U .S. in 1970 and spread the message of ahimsa
- 6:09and peace there. And a lot of people started
- 6:12turning vegetarian. including Americans. The
- 6:16Jains, they were very happy to have him there
- 6:18because they didn't have any, you know, Jain
- 6:21mentor. So they were very happy to have him there.
- 6:25But through 1970 to 1995, they continuously spread
- 6:29the message of vegetarianism. And as soon as
- 6:32they got to know about veganism, they started
- 6:35speaking. They went vegan. and they started speaking
- 6:38about veganism in the community, even though
- 6:43it wasn't very well accepted. But, you know,
- 6:46he felt that he should be speaking the truth.
- 6:50And sometimes when you're going against the tide,
- 6:54it takes some time for people to accept that.
- 6:59But I think people, you know, now when I see
- 7:02the change that he's got, you know, I see people
- 7:05turning around, I see more and more Jains turning
- 7:07vegan. So he has influenced a lot of people across
- 7:13the world to go vegetarian and then vegan. Mayor,
- 7:18you said that you felt hypocritical for being
- 7:23Jane and not vegan. What did you mean by that?
- 7:29Yeah, so for me, The reason I use that word very
- 7:35specifically is because it was simply, I did
- 7:45a little bit of due diligence on myself. And
- 7:49what does it mean to be Jain? Is being Jain going
- 7:54to the temple? Is being Jain doing a certain
- 7:58ritual? Is it saying a certain mantra? Or is
- 8:03it more than that, right? It's about, you know,
- 8:05am I living the principles? And if I'm living
- 8:08the principles, then what right do I have to
- 8:13call myself a believer in the principles? Forget
- 8:16Jainism, you know, Jainism is about more than
- 8:18Ahimsa, but Ahimsa is the paramount principle.
- 8:24And it was more the moment when I actually gained
- 8:28the knowledge, right? When you actually when
- 8:31you see, when you open your eyes, when you open
- 8:35your mind, and it's what you decide in that moment,
- 8:40once you get that knowledge, right? I think for
- 8:44a while, for me, it was maybe a little bit of
- 8:46blissful ignorance, right? I like pizza, I like
- 8:49cheese, I like milk chai, right? And I want to
- 8:54give you a little bit more context here. One
- 8:56of our friends, Gina Shaw, who you are aware
- 9:03of, she was kind of what I call an OG vegan,
- 9:08an old guard vegan, because she was vegan when
- 9:10it wasn't easy. And there were other people in
- 9:14my friend circle. One of the people that I want
- 9:17to also kind of, excuse me, share is somebody
- 9:21named Pravin Shah. Pravin Shah, he was the...
- 9:25the founder of the Jaina Yi Library, which is
- 9:30this huge database of Jain texts, many of which
- 9:34are in English. He became vegan because of his
- 9:37daughter, Shilpa Shah, who became vegan, and
- 9:41she influenced him. So there's this huge kind
- 9:46of early acceptance by many Jains of becoming
- 9:52vegan. And it all stems from this recognition
- 9:55that the modern dairy industry, unless everyone's
- 10:00getting their... Well, even then, I was about
- 10:02to say, even if you get your milk from a sanctuary
- 10:06where they take care of cows, even that is actually
- 10:09not technically vegan. But again, for me, it
- 10:13was once I had that knowledge that this is the
- 10:16way the commercial dairy industry is, it's a
- 10:19system. It's a system. I don't want to use these
- 10:24strong words here, but you know, it's a system
- 10:26of organized murder and other words too. It's
- 10:34just that once I had that awareness, you know,
- 10:38that at this, you know, either I stopped calling
- 10:39myself Jain or at least believing in Ahimsa or
- 10:43I change. So in order to be honest, I did not
- 10:51feel hypocritical because I was trying, you know,
- 10:56for a long time to go vegan. So I tried for a
- 10:59month, then six months, few weeks. So what I
- 11:03think I became very aware of was the conflict
- 11:06that was going on within me, you know, while
- 11:09I would be vegan and then again, turn around
- 11:11and be, you know, vegetarian. I also got aware
- 11:17of the temptations that were happening. So I
- 11:23think my awareness was, my observation was so
- 11:27much on this that I didn't feel hypocritical
- 11:30because I knew it was the right thing to do.
- 11:33for the longest time you know they want any there
- 11:36was no social media there were no videos on Indian
- 11:39dairy right on how the dairies are run in India
- 11:42what is the cruelty here so this entire concept
- 11:45of you know cruelty to cows here you know was
- 11:51it was all closed it was it wasn't out in the
- 11:54open because in India it you know cows are reared
- 11:57in the rural areas people look after them they're
- 12:01they're small dairy farms, usually having two
- 12:04to ten cows. So it wasn't like an organized industry
- 12:08like you have in the US. So the violence wasn't
- 12:10apparent like the US or the western countries.
- 12:14It was only when I saw the first video of PETA,
- 12:18which they made on Indian dairy, that's when
- 12:20I realized that it's not very different here.
- 12:23It's the same. And then after I became a mother,
- 12:29I think that's when it really hit me and I decided
- 12:32to go vegan. But I didn't feel like a hypocrite,
- 12:36is what I was trying to say, because I think
- 12:38I was just aware that there's so much conflict
- 12:41going on within me, or I probably, I didn't think
- 12:45of the term hypocrite that time. But I was aware
- 12:48of the conflict and I was aware that my mind
- 12:52and my senses are giving in to themselves. I
- 12:55think I was observing all that. And I think that
- 13:00probably that helped me. If I can add something?
- 13:03Yes, of course. The reason I put that label on
- 13:09myself is because I was aware of the harm, right?
- 13:14I mean, I was aware of the reasons why some chains,
- 13:18you know, some with some of the people that I
- 13:20just mentioned. became vegan, yet I still was
- 13:24comfortable with consuming the products. And
- 13:28so there was a disconnect and there was almost
- 13:34like a cognitive dissonance of what I was believing
- 13:41and what I'm actually doing. And I think what
- 13:45happened to me, What may be the case for a lot
- 13:48of people, maybe, and James again, is that we've
- 13:51become numb to that discomfort. We've become
- 13:55numb to that cognitive dissonance. And I think
- 13:59we need to reintroduce that sensitivity through
- 14:03knowledge, through awareness. And once people
- 14:06have that knowledge and awareness, then okay,
- 14:08fine. Then you're informed. Then you can say
- 14:14that, okay, knowingly. and choosing to not be
- 14:20vegan. So again, that's why I chose to label
- 14:24myself that. It's all very fascinating because...
- 14:30For the typical vegans out there, this is not
- 14:33the typical way you become vegan. Usually people
- 14:37will talk about how they encountered some violent
- 14:40footage of slaughterhouses and they got convinced
- 14:43by that, or it was a question of street activists
- 14:47challenging them. Something of the sort. Your
- 14:52experience of becoming vegan is very much connected
- 14:56to your faith and your community. Can you speak
- 15:00to how it is kind of different from the general
- 15:05vegan experience? And how do you feel belonging
- 15:08to the animal rights movement and the vegan movement
- 15:11in general? Do you feel like a bit of outsiders
- 15:16because you come from a more faith -based background,
- 15:20or can you still relate well and connect well
- 15:23with the rest of the movement? I think I connect
- 15:30very well with the rest of the movement because,
- 15:34you know, whether you're a vegan or whether you're
- 15:38coming from the gen background or any background,
- 15:40right? That one thing that's connecting everybody
- 15:43is that feeling of pain, the feeling that you
- 15:47feel for that other being suffering, right? And
- 15:52you're able to build a connection with that being
- 15:55and feel that, you know, that you feel that pain.
- 15:59So I think it's that connection that makes each
- 16:03one a vegan. So, you know, it doesn't matter
- 16:07what background you come from, but I think that's
- 16:09the common thread that brings everyone together,
- 16:13you know, and that is Ahimsa where you feel that
- 16:16you don't want to cause harm to any other living
- 16:19being because they feel the pain and pleasure
- 16:21just like you do. So, and Ahimsa is Ahimsa by
- 16:25itself is a religion or Ahimsa as a way of life
- 16:29or Ahimsa as the cornerstone of every religion.
- 16:33You can put it in any way. Ahimsa can exist by
- 16:37itself. It doesn't need any other philosophy
- 16:43around it. But I think philosophies will not
- 16:45be able to exist without Ahimsa. So Ahimsa is
- 16:49such an important part of Jainism that every
- 16:53scriptural talk about it. It's just based on
- 16:58that philosophy. Everything is periphery and
- 17:02that is the core. So I don't feel disconnected.
- 17:06I feel very comfortable. The one thing that I
- 17:10really like is that, and this is what I personally
- 17:13experienced just I think three or four years
- 17:16ago that veganism can make one unhappy, you know,
- 17:24because you're so, you're relating so much to
- 17:27that animal's pain, right? That it just disturbs
- 17:33you. It sometimes drains the person out. Well,
- 17:36as ahimsa is much larger, right? It also means
- 17:38not to cause harm to your own self, right? And
- 17:42somewhere you have to objectively work towards
- 17:44it. So, you know, as a vegan, and this is I speak
- 17:49for myself, just for myself. I would sometimes
- 17:52be opinionated. I would, you know, pass judgments
- 17:58or I would be imposing. But as I understood that
- 18:03concept of ahimsa better, you know, I realized
- 18:06that if I've taken so long to go vegan, I can't
- 18:10expect just because I've gone vegan, I can't
- 18:12expect the other person to go vegan just because
- 18:14I'm talking to that person. Right. And telling
- 18:17them something. It has to touch them. So I think
- 18:22Ahimsa brought that broader angle into me, where
- 18:26when I was talking to somebody else, I also got
- 18:29sensitive to what they are feeling. And I think
- 18:32it helped. It just helped because then I saw
- 18:35that people actually would understand what I'm
- 18:39trying to say. They would agree. You know, earlier
- 18:42there would be disagreements, there would be
- 18:44arguments, but then I felt they would start agreeing
- 18:46to some things. They would get conscious of it,
- 18:49whether they they stopped or they didn't was,
- 18:52you know, I'm not sure, but at least they got
- 18:54sensitive about it. At least they started making
- 18:57a little effort towards reducing, you know, their
- 19:02choices, which led to cruelty to animals. So
- 19:07that's, that's what I've, I think it's a, it's
- 19:11a never ending journey, right? You just keep
- 19:12evolving with time. And I think if, and you study
- 19:16Buddhism, right? So I think you'll be able to
- 19:19relate to that part as to when you bring in the
- 19:21philosophical angle also to that, you realize
- 19:24that veganism is a part of Aimsa and you have
- 19:26to look at it as a whole, as a, in a holistic
- 19:30way rather than just one approach. So yeah, but
- 19:35otherwise I don't feel, you know, I feel part
- 19:38of a community completely. That's beautifully
- 19:42said, and I want to go back to some of the points
- 19:46you made, Ruchika. But first, Mayor, your answer
- 19:49to my previous question. So I think a lot of
- 19:53what Ruchika said, William, would have come out
- 19:58of me. I think Ahimsa Ashi Tashdhan is universal.
- 20:06If you want an example of that, it's just us.
- 20:11like Ryan, you, and the other people in our little
- 20:19group that we recently made that we connected
- 20:22because of the shared value. Call it ahimsa,
- 20:29call it nonviolence, call it anything you like.
- 20:34I think ahimsa is rooted in something that Rishika
- 20:38touched on, which I would call empathy, being
- 20:43empathetic, right? And Ahimsa is not just towards
- 20:47animals, right? It's actually something at the
- 20:50core of you, right? So yes, you know, veganism
- 20:55is about animals, but Ahimsa is about more than
- 20:57that. It's about how we treat each other, how
- 21:01we treat ourselves, right? So it's really deeper,
- 21:06deeper than just veganism. Veganism is an outcome.
- 21:11of this acceptance of this greater empathy and
- 21:16greater responsibility, accountability, all of
- 21:19these things. And I think I feel very much connected
- 21:23with you, right? I mean, I'll just say that.
- 21:25I mean, with the other people that believe that
- 21:30this is the right way to live. And I feel I want
- 21:37to say, let's just say, I feel instantly connected
- 21:41to people who share this belief. So, yeah, that's
- 21:48it. Well, let me go back to the point Rushdi
- 21:54Ahmed made on how some vegans feel strongly about
- 22:00their veganism and can feel alienated from society
- 22:05and angry all the time. We get that a lot and
- 22:09I think it's justified, the trope of the angry
- 22:13militant vegan. And there are lots of burnouts
- 22:19in the community, let's be honest, and lots of
- 22:24people who decide after a few months or even
- 22:27a few years to abandon veganism behind And I
- 22:32thought, you know, a lot about why, why all of
- 22:36this pain when what we're trying to do is cause
- 22:40good in the world. And I think part of the answer
- 22:45is the lack of spirituality around veganism.
- 22:50Would you agree with me? Absolutely. I would
- 22:55agree because I went through this entire journey
- 22:58myself, right? And see, it's very natural when
- 23:02somebody goes vegan in the beginning, when they
- 23:05see the violence and it's hit them, right? It's
- 23:08hit them hard and they're guilty that all this
- 23:11time they've been doing it. And there's, you
- 23:13know, maybe they're conscious of that guilt or
- 23:16maybe subconscious guilt. But that's the thing
- 23:19they want to share with the world. It's so natural
- 23:21that when you learn about something, you want
- 23:23to share with the rest of the people and especially
- 23:24with people around you. So we go around telling
- 23:27people, you know, you should be vegan, this,
- 23:29that, this is what happens. And for some reason,
- 23:32it doesn't hit them, right? Their moment hasn't
- 23:36come. It hit me after so many years in spite
- 23:39of having, you know, my in -laws in the house,
- 23:42in spite of seeing them. I used to get milk from
- 23:45a shelter home where I knew the cows would never
- 23:47go for slaughter. But I would just never get
- 23:50the concept of why can I not give up dairy? Why
- 23:53do I need it? And even after giving up, you know,
- 23:56I was, as I said, what happens is your opinion,
- 24:01you get so attached to your opinion, to your
- 24:03beliefs that if somebody doesn't comply with
- 24:06it or somebody just doesn't understand, even
- 24:09though it's the truth, it disturbs you. So somewhere
- 24:12you have to disconnect, right? Because if you
- 24:16are going to be unhappy, then you are carrying
- 24:18that emotion of being unhappy, of being frustrated.
- 24:22And that is what I'm passing on to people. And
- 24:25that is what is coming back to me. And that is
- 24:27why the burnouts happened. That is why people
- 24:29get frustrated, move away from it. And it did
- 24:33happen to me, you know? I mean, I used to get
- 24:34so frustrated because I was talking to people
- 24:37for over a decade, you know, and I was holding
- 24:42festivals, vegan festivals here. But still in
- 24:46the community, within the Jain community, it
- 24:48would be very hard for me to convince them because
- 24:51I would go with this strong opinion that, you
- 24:54know what, this is the right thing. And even
- 24:58though I would not come across very aggressively,
- 25:01but because the opinion was so strong that the
- 25:07other person, you know, there wasn't room to
- 25:09look at the other person's perspective. And I
- 25:13think once when I realized that, you know what,
- 25:15I am getting unhappy in this. I am getting frustrated
- 25:19in this and that is the feeling I'm carrying
- 25:21around and that is what I'm passing on to others.
- 25:25And, you know, as soon as I realized that I'm
- 25:27first causing harm to myself, and as soon as
- 25:30I realized that, and I moved my perspective from
- 25:33that, that this is not about me. This is not
- 25:36about my opinion, you know, and my job is just
- 25:41to make somebody aware, right, that this is what
- 25:45it is, just like what a mirror does. and then
- 25:47leave it there, you know, and not get disturbed
- 25:51if somebody follows or doesn't follow. I think,
- 25:54and as I said, once I started, you know, doing
- 25:57that, I think I got much better results because,
- 26:03you know, I was carrying, even though it is the
- 26:06right thing, sometimes even the right thing,
- 26:10you know, we make it into a negative thing because
- 26:14you end up putting down somebody else. you, you
- 26:17know, you tend to offend them, you tend to attack
- 26:22them, even in a subtle way, but they immediately,
- 26:24you know, the first response is defensive, right?
- 26:28Somebody tries to correct me, my first response
- 26:30is going to be defensive. It's only when I pause
- 26:32and reflect, I'll be like, Oh, yeah, you know,
- 26:34maybe, maybe you're right. But for that, I have
- 26:38to be, you know, I have to have the pause first
- 26:41to understand that other person. So if I'm extending
- 26:46my compassion. And, you know, you have to keep
- 26:49pushing that boundary of compassion, right? Not
- 26:52just for the animals, but also towards others.
- 26:55That compassion is not it's not conditional.
- 26:58It doesn't come with any conditions. So if you
- 27:02if you just carry that compassion with you, I
- 27:04think I think that works better. That was my
- 27:07personal experience. Let me add on to that. I
- 27:11think my my thought on that. I agree with everything
- 27:15Ruchika said, is I think many people who are
- 27:20very active in wanting to spread that knowledge,
- 27:24awareness and the message are very emotionally
- 27:28invested, right? So when we involve our emotions
- 27:32and we don't get that reaction, we don't get
- 27:38that, oh my God, you're so right about this.
- 27:41you know, I didn't see this, we don't get that
- 27:44instant change, that instant awareness, then
- 27:46we get disappointed, then we keep trying, then
- 27:49we get disappointed. We have to remember our
- 27:51own journeys, right? You know, we shared our
- 27:56journeys and how it wasn't necessarily overnight,
- 28:01right? You know, some people planted seeds, other
- 28:04people watered those seeds, and eventually those
- 28:08seeds grew. And so we have to remember that.
- 28:11I also want to say burnout, we don't have to
- 28:16necessarily label burnout as a terrible thing.
- 28:21Let's just say that the burnout, pause, take
- 28:25a step back. I think the message, maybe easier
- 28:33said than done, is don't let that emotional investment,
- 28:37don't let that burnout change. the reason why
- 28:41you are the way you are, right? I mean, I think
- 28:44you asked the question in a way, you know, why
- 28:46do people burn out? Burnout could be defined
- 28:48as they disconnect from being active. It could
- 28:51be they start being vegan. It could mean any
- 28:54number of things. But I think being resolute
- 28:58to ourselves, maybe disconnecting some of the
- 29:02emotion, taking a pause, right? I mean, just
- 29:04like, you know, almost like therapy. There are
- 29:10ways in which we need to be aware that this burnout
- 29:15is coming, this disappointment is there, and
- 29:19be highly sensitive to the fact that, okay, let
- 29:23me pause. I'm doing too much. There's a lot of
- 29:27people who do way too much. I know some of those
- 29:30people and they disappear. They're active one
- 29:36day and then Where are they now? You wonder where
- 29:40they went, because they may be sad. They may
- 29:45be just not feeling that their effort is doing
- 29:50anything. The reality is, we have to remember
- 29:57there's a prince. We have our other main principle
- 30:02in Jainism, which is anekantavada, which is the
- 30:07multiplicity of viewpoints, you know, just seeing
- 30:10the other person's side. So maybe a little bit
- 30:13of that, you know, can be mixed in here and seeing,
- 30:18hey, you know, that other person was where I
- 30:23was at some point, right? And give people some
- 30:27grace, give people time. right? And that can
- 30:32go a long way. So that's what I can add. Yeah.
- 30:38And I think the definition of activism, it doesn't
- 30:42have to be going on the streets, standing with
- 30:45a placard, arguing with people or even telling
- 30:49them, sorry, or even trying to tell, making them
- 30:51aware of what's happening in the industry, animal
- 30:54agriculture industry. I mean, it is great, but
- 30:57that's not the only way of activism, right? For
- 31:00everyone, it's different. It could be just making
- 31:03some delicious food, feeding that to people and
- 31:06telling them this has no animal product. It's
- 31:08also a form of activism, right? Or not buying
- 31:13animal products. It's also a silent way of animal
- 31:16activism, you know, or just bringing it up as
- 31:20a conversation, which would be like... It's really
- 31:22short, like two minutes or five minutes. It's
- 31:24also a form of activism. So there are multiple
- 31:27ways of doing activism, right? So it shouldn't
- 31:31be just because I see that a lot over here as
- 31:34well, that I see every weekend people going for
- 31:37activism, which is great. You know, it's I mean,
- 31:40hats off to them. It's fantastic. But when you
- 31:44realize that, you know what, it's getting too
- 31:45much for me, as Mayur rightly said, just take
- 31:48a pause. Don't feel you've burnt out. that burnt
- 31:51out is a very negative one. Take a pause, you
- 31:53know, stop for some time. You're still a vegan.
- 31:56You're still doing activism. You know, maybe
- 31:58and maybe adopt another way of doing it. Right.
- 32:03It doesn't have to be just this way. So I had
- 32:06to change the way I started speaking to people
- 32:08about veganism because I started observing as
- 32:12to, you know, how is it that people want to hear
- 32:14it? Like, what way do they want to hear it? And
- 32:16I would change it according to that. So, you
- 32:20know, take a pause, change the way you talk about
- 32:22it, change the way you do things. You don't necessarily
- 32:27have to just completely withdraw. You know, sometimes
- 32:29taking a six hour break, focusing on yourself
- 32:32is also good. If I can add one more thing and
- 32:36then we can move on if you want to. What I was
- 32:39thinking this as Ruchika was speaking is that
- 32:42pause, pausing in general in life can be very
- 32:45powerful. outside of the context we're talking
- 32:49about, one of the other really important things
- 32:52is sharing, right? If we're feeling a certain
- 32:56way, if we're feeling burnt out, don't keep it
- 33:00in, right? Like share, just in general. Like,
- 33:02you know, we teach people, you know, emotional
- 33:05intelligence or just being able to be open and
- 33:09share your emotions. That can go a long way to
- 33:13really relieve that feeling of burnout. And in
- 33:20addition to that, I think just being, you know,
- 33:28mindfulness, there's a lot of mindfulness involved
- 33:30here. I think that if we lean on other people,
- 33:35there are plenty of people out there who can
- 33:37carry the torch, right? So if I'm feeling burnt
- 33:40out, if I need to take a pause, communicate,
- 33:42share, you know, the network. right? And there
- 33:47are other people who can continue the work while
- 33:50you take a step back and heal and then get through
- 33:54whatever you're feeling. So I love that. And
- 34:01I love how we've been talking about spirituality
- 34:03for a moment now, and we haven't brought up,
- 34:06you know, God or any supernatural stuff. And
- 34:11I think that's what most secular people are vegans
- 34:16because most vegans are secular. When they think
- 34:20about spirituality, they think, oh, it's a big
- 34:24guy in the sky. And they have all sorts of preconceived
- 34:29ideas about religion and spirituality and all
- 34:33of that. But yeah, I often try to make the case
- 34:38that spiritual practices should be considered
- 34:43should be integrated in your life and in your
- 34:47activism to enrich that activism and to find
- 34:53wellness. So you gave lots of amazing recommendations.
- 34:59I think there's also meditative practice in Jainism.
- 35:04I guess my next question is what is present in
- 35:09Jainism as a practice that could be useful for
- 35:13the people listening right now. Jane is a smaller
- 35:17religion and I think it gains to be understood
- 35:21and studied and learning from what it has to
- 35:25offer. So yeah, what should people understand,
- 35:30take from the Jane religious practice? Ruchira,
- 35:37do you want to start off? I was thinking of something.
- 35:40Let me start off. My mind immediately went to
- 35:46this upcoming period that Jains observe. It's
- 35:53called Baryushan and Daslakshan. They're kind
- 35:56of two similar but distinct periods when Jains
- 36:02annually observe. They do penance, they do fasting,
- 36:14and in the end, it culminates into asking for
- 36:18forgiveness. This is an annual tradition of self
- 36:23-reflection and also transformation. So to me,
- 36:28this practice that chains have, to me is... in
- 36:33one way, a lesson of doing with less, right?
- 36:36A lesson in doing without. And, you know, so
- 36:42we, you know, without getting into some of the
- 36:45finer details of this period of time, what people
- 36:47eat and don't eat. And in fact, in general, to
- 36:50me, my mind goes there, is that, you know, if
- 36:53we are so infested in self -discipline, self
- 37:01-control, doing with less, doing without. My
- 37:08mind always goes back to this, again, when it
- 37:11comes to dairy and veganism, that is such an
- 37:18easy thing for people to incorporate into their
- 37:20lives, especially in the modern context. And
- 37:22so this coming period to me would be an example
- 37:26of a practice. that applies. Yeah, I love that
- 37:34because I've in the past described veganism as
- 37:37some form of ascetic practice. And if you think
- 37:42about what kind of changes you need to adopt
- 37:46in your life in order to become vegan, it is
- 37:49comparable to converting to a religion. big transformation
- 37:55in what you do in your social life, in the clothes
- 38:01you decide to wear and not wear. So yeah, there
- 38:04are lots of parallels. Um, I think, uh, you know,
- 38:14the practice of ahimsa, I think it's an ongoing
- 38:20process. It, uh, And that's why one has to be
- 38:24constantly aware. Now when a child sees a dog
- 38:29being beaten up, they just start crying. They
- 38:33feel the pain. Or the child sees somebody else
- 38:35being beaten up, they will start crying. They
- 38:37will get uneasy about it. I know people from
- 38:41different religions where they hardcore meat
- 38:44eaters. But at the age of nine or at the age
- 38:48of eight, I know another friend's daughter at
- 38:50the age of six. decided that they don't want
- 38:54to eat meat anymore. One of them was a restaurant
- 38:58guy, went to buy some meat and he saw the butcher
- 39:03slaughter the bird, slaughter the chicken and
- 39:06he immediately, or I think when he was returning
- 39:07from school, I'm sorry, I'll correct myself there.
- 39:09He was returning from school and he passed the
- 39:12butcher shop and he saw the butcher killing the
- 39:14animals. And that's when he immediately decided,
- 39:16you know what? I mean, I don't want to eat meat
- 39:18again. The same thing with this nine -year -old
- 39:21boy when he saw a goat getting slaughtered in
- 39:23front of his eyes. And he was so attached to
- 39:26that goat that he decided, I don't want to eat
- 39:28meat again. And later he went vegan. And this
- 39:32other girl where her parents eat meat every day,
- 39:35she's a vegetarian. She doesn't eat meat. I mean,
- 39:38she obviously hasn't gone down to the dairy.
- 39:41She's not aware of that. But I think this sensation
- 39:45and to recognize that sensation and to respond
- 39:49to that. To have that awareness, that's the practice
- 39:52of ahimsa, which is constantly there, where you're
- 39:57keeping that sensitivity on all the time. As
- 40:02Mayur said earlier, that we become so numb to
- 40:05the suffering of others that we just don't get
- 40:09it soon. It takes us so long to understand. And
- 40:13that's true for me because I took so long to
- 40:16understand the cruelties that's going in the
- 40:18dairy industry. Why is it that I didn't get it
- 40:22earlier? So I think this is just, it's honestly
- 40:28not a rocket science. I think we all have it
- 40:31within us. We can't see injustice being done
- 40:35to another living being, especially when we see
- 40:39the reasons behind that. But somewhere when it
- 40:43comes to something that we are consuming, I think
- 40:46that connection breaks. right? Like if I'm consuming
- 40:48dairy products, if I love leather bags, I'm not
- 40:52able to create the connection, you know, with
- 40:54that animal that's going through the torture
- 40:56to create that leather bag. So somewhere to be
- 41:00aware of yourself, of your sensations, of what
- 41:04you feel. I think that's the practice and that's
- 41:08the practice we should be working on every single
- 41:11day, you know. and reflect on it, I think every
- 41:16day and every night that, okay, this happened
- 41:20today, you know, and this could be like maybe
- 41:22even speaking to somebody very rudely, right?
- 41:27Maybe somebody working for me. There are times
- 41:29when I speak to my chauffeur rudely and later
- 41:32I realized that, you know, I mean, I feel that
- 41:34something didn't happen right. And then I realized
- 41:36that, oh, I was rude to that person. So, and
- 41:39this has to be like constantly worked on, right?
- 41:42You just keep working on it. You just be aware.
- 41:44And I think it comes so that I think that's the
- 41:47practice we have to do and how we make ourselves
- 41:50a little more sensitive towards what we're doing
- 41:53to others and what we're doing to ourselves in
- 41:56return. I like the way she said that, by the
- 42:00way, I just want to add on, you know, just keeping
- 42:03that sensitive sensitivity level up, you know,
- 42:05it's like watching the news. We get so numb to,
- 42:08you know, the bad news and the violence that
- 42:12when we see it, it doesn't affect us anymore.
- 42:15So that numbness is something that we really
- 42:18need to address, right? And, you know, it's a
- 42:22hamster to me is very much like a muscle. Like,
- 42:25you know, it's a muscle looks like muscles will
- 42:27atrophy muscles need to be exercised on a daily
- 42:32basis. And, you know, that's, that's one way
- 42:35that I personally look at it, you know, am I
- 42:37perfect? Or do I make mistakes? Yes. But It's
- 42:41that ability, that awareness to see that and
- 42:45to correct things and to constantly make sure
- 42:49I'm aligned with the principles that I say that
- 42:54I believe in. Like she said, it's not too complicated.
- 43:01Do you believe in nonviolence and Aamsa? Am I
- 43:07living it? And if I'm not, Let me do something
- 43:11about that. Let me push you to get deeper into
- 43:16this concept. Often when we talk about being
- 43:21compassionate to others, people adopt a kind
- 43:25of a pleaser personality attitude, which I think
- 43:30harms them on the long run because they become
- 43:34a pushover and they forget themselves. There's
- 43:38also kind of an interesting concept in my religious
- 43:42tradition, Buddhism, that concept of like fierce
- 43:46compassion. They have those bodhisattva statues
- 43:49that are scary, but they embody a form of, yeah,
- 43:55fierce compassion where compassion doesn't look
- 43:59like being soft or being passive, but it looks
- 44:04like being very active and maybe even aggressive
- 44:08in a way. I interviewed Captain Paul Watson and
- 44:13he told me that the Dalai Lama offered him one
- 44:16of those statues because he looked at his work
- 44:20of going after whale ships as a form of fierce
- 44:25compassion. I think Buddhism and Jainism would
- 44:28be similar in that aspect because they first
- 44:31say that you have to practice Aimsa towards yourself.
- 44:34So if somebody's like you know, walking over
- 44:37you or taking you for granted, taking advantage
- 44:41of you. That's not compassion. That's foolishness.
- 44:45So there has to be like a, you know, one has
- 44:48to understand you don't have to be dumb. You
- 44:50have to be intelligent, right? And know the difference
- 44:54that is this really what I need to do? I don't.
- 44:59It's okay to say no. You can't please the whole
- 45:01world. What did Buddha and Mahavira do? They
- 45:04stepped out. They first attained enlightenment,
- 45:08then came and spoke to the world. Right? I mean,
- 45:11they could have started from before, but they
- 45:13didn't. They first got their enlightenment. Of
- 45:16course, also because, you know, I mean, you have
- 45:19to first secure yourself. So I think that's the
- 45:22greatest example that these themselves first
- 45:25did what was right and then came and gave to
- 45:28people. And then when they give it to people,
- 45:30whether people took it or they didn't take it,
- 45:32it didn't affect them either. It's not that they
- 45:34became unhappy with that. And this is what usually
- 45:42happens, right? Because we must understand compassion
- 45:44when we say no to people. I mean, there's a limit
- 45:49to how much we can do as humans, right? We chose
- 45:52to speak for animals. Doesn't mean that we are
- 45:55also going to go speak for all human injustices
- 45:59that are happening as well. Of course, I don't
- 46:01agree with them. But do I have the bandwidth
- 46:04to also, you know, go stretch myself there? And
- 46:07when people tell me that, and I tell them it's
- 46:09great if you do, you have to choose what touches
- 46:13you. You have to grow your circle of compassion.
- 46:17Okay? And it could be whichever areas touch you.
- 46:22But I can't be everywhere. I have to understand
- 46:25my limitation. My physical limitation, my mental
- 46:29limitation, my limitation with time. resources,
- 46:34right? And it's very clear. It's not that, you
- 46:38know, you, you give in to everybody. You just,
- 46:42you know, it's very clear. It's like, you don't
- 46:46let anybody take advantage of yourself. So you
- 46:49have to draw clear here. You have to know when
- 46:51you're being foolish versus, and there's nothing
- 46:54wrong in being selfish either. There's why do
- 46:57we see being selfish? I'm not taking advantage
- 46:59of somebody. If I'm taking advantage of somebody,
- 47:04then that is being selfish, then that is negative.
- 47:07But if I'm only protecting myself, then that's
- 47:13selfishness is not bad. It's understanding my
- 47:16boundaries, I'm not causing harm to anyone, and
- 47:20that's fine. Very fascinating. Mayur, did you
- 47:27want to add something? The way that I heard your
- 47:34question is that, is there a parallel to the
- 47:40fierce compassion, the example that you gave
- 47:43me, maybe that's one question, and is there maybe
- 47:46a little bit of that push over attitude also?
- 47:50Is that correct? Yes, basically how compassion
- 47:56is often seen as something very passive and where
- 48:00if you adopt a compassionate approach, you have
- 48:03to put yourself on, not prioritize yourself or
- 48:07your wellbeing. And yeah, I just want to explore
- 48:11how compassion can take many more forms. Yeah.
- 48:15I mean, compassion could be as simple as being
- 48:17very resolute in how you practice AIMSA, how
- 48:22you are vegan, you know, give you an example
- 48:25of them just being very opinion here, but almost
- 48:30a little bit blunt here is that because we're
- 48:34having a discussion about Jainism and Jains,
- 48:36many Jains are okay with eating eggs if it's
- 48:41already baked into a cake, right? It's okay.
- 48:45It's in there. I don't see it. It's a thing.
- 48:48But to me, compassion is being resolute also,
- 48:53not having the little gray areas. I don't think
- 48:57there are any in my knowledge, in my limited
- 49:01knowledge. I became vegan in 2020, but I don't
- 49:07love any examples of that fierce compassion,
- 49:11that fierce behavior is like a parallel in Jainism.
- 49:15To kind of speak to like people out there who
- 49:18are like so active in the Jain community. People
- 49:23are active. in the way of really being, unless
- 49:27you're on social media, always kind of spreading
- 49:30the word, spreading the message. There are Jains
- 49:33who are so pro -dairy religious speakers, almost
- 49:39violently so pro -dairy. It's almost shocking,
- 49:45you know, the degree to which they are trying
- 49:50to counter. you know, this, this argument that,
- 49:53you know, dairy is okay. Dairy, you know, like
- 49:56dairy is good for the cow. Like us consuming
- 49:59dairy is actually good for the cow. Okay. There
- 50:02are those arguments that are being made by religious
- 50:05figures. There's, you know, very lax, occasional
- 50:09lax kind of adherence to being vegetarian. You
- 50:15know, I'm talking about eggs as an example, because,
- 50:18you know, that's It's such a common thing in
- 50:21the US. Eggs are in a lot of foods. If you don't
- 50:25see it, and if somebody offers it to me, I don't
- 50:29want to make them feel bad. It's like maybe that
- 50:32little bit of a push over type of a thing. I
- 50:35don't want to hurt somebody's feelings. I'll
- 50:37have a cookie. I'll have a cake. So to me, compassion
- 50:41could be as simple as standing firm, standing
- 50:43your ground, and being very resolute, not having
- 50:47the gray areas. This is a great segue to my next
- 50:53question, which is about your activism, the activism
- 50:56that you're doing in the Jain community. Now
- 51:00you gave that example of Jain figures being pro
- 51:04-dairy. There's the same thing happening in Buddhist
- 51:09community. I remember a recent article, I think
- 51:13it was from last year on tree cycle, which is
- 51:17this big Buddhist magazine. featuring a ranger,
- 51:23a Buddhist priest ranger. And he was talking
- 51:28about how the fact that he was a ranger was not
- 51:32a contradiction with the Buddhist teachings of
- 51:36compassion. Very shocking article, very shocking
- 51:40figure in the Buddhist world. So yeah, how come
- 51:47not all Jain of people aren't vegan? To tell
- 52:00you honestly, for me, and this is my personal
- 52:05view, just because one is born in a Jain family
- 52:09doesn't make you a Jain. Just because you're
- 52:12following certain kind of a lifestyle doesn't
- 52:15make you a Jain. I think Buddhism would be the
- 52:19same. As long as you're following the principles,
- 52:22because this is not, you know, the concept of
- 52:26God doesn't exist in both Buddhism and Jainism,
- 52:30right? They are spiritual leaders who showed
- 52:32the path to liberation. So they didn't create
- 52:36the world. They showed how the world works. So,
- 52:41you know, which means that this is a lifestyle
- 52:44you follow. You follow that path. For that, I
- 52:49don't really want to be born in a Jain family.
- 52:52You know, like I told you about those three people,
- 52:55they were touched by Himsa and, you know, they
- 52:58changed their life. So it's not about, you know,
- 53:03just because I'm born in a Jain family and I'm
- 53:06a Jain and I call myself a Jain, I do all the
- 53:08rituals around, you know, I live in a particular
- 53:12way. But if something is still not working, you
- 53:15know, your compassion is still not growing. And
- 53:18I can understand, like, I myself, for me, it
- 53:20didn't hit me for such a long time, right? For
- 53:22like, it took me seven or eight years to go fully
- 53:25vegan. Right? So it's not that I have also been
- 53:29perfect or I'm still perfect or something. But
- 53:33somewhere we have to consciously keep evolving.
- 53:36We have to make that effort to look beyond, you
- 53:40know, what is uh what is culturally and what
- 53:43is societally you know it's being followed and
- 53:46to to look at it objectively i think that's what
- 53:52both these philosophy encourage you they encourage
- 53:55you to be curious they encourage you to see objectively
- 53:58they encourage you to question it encourages
- 54:01to reflect it encourages you to implement so
- 54:06uh you know it's i mean That's the reason why
- 54:11a lot of Buddhists, a lot of Jains are not vegan,
- 54:15because it just doesn't resonate with them. And
- 54:17what doesn't resonate? They are not able to feel
- 54:20the pain and the suffering of their other living
- 54:23being. I mean, they do see suffering. There have
- 54:25been times when these people who are saving the
- 54:27cows from slaughter, that's a very difficult
- 54:29thing to do, actually. And it's amazing that
- 54:31they do that. But one of the leaders actually
- 54:34told me that we feel that If the cow is undergoing
- 54:37a certain amount of suffering, but can at least
- 54:40live, then it's at least acceptable. You know,
- 54:44and I was very shocked when he said that I was
- 54:47like, why should the cow undergo suffering in
- 54:50order to live? Right? Some things, some things,
- 54:55that's not the right way to look at it. The way
- 54:57to look at it is why is the cow suffering? You
- 55:00know, what is it that I'm doing? Because of which
- 55:04the cows suffering. That's the reflection that
- 55:07we need to do. So that's where I think, you know,
- 55:11people miss out is to look objectively, to think
- 55:15over it, to reflect, you know, to, you know,
- 55:20without any opinions, even, you know, when there
- 55:23are times when people say that they're not vegan
- 55:26for, you know, whatever reason. Sometimes it's...
- 55:31They feel they don't agree with certain things.
- 55:33Like, you know, they feel almond milk is also
- 55:35causing so much harm or something like that.
- 55:38And of course they're baseless arguments. But,
- 55:41you know, think beyond. You're not vegan for
- 55:44almond milk. Right? I mean, you're vegan for,
- 55:48because you don't want to contribute to someone's
- 55:50suffering. So I think, you know, and I think
- 55:57since I stopped looking at it that way and sometimes
- 56:00it is frustrating that in spite of being Jains
- 56:02and they spend so much money in rescuing these
- 56:05animals actually and they spend a lot of money
- 56:08to even look after them but they don't get that
- 56:12you know that is such a that's like a drop in
- 56:14the ocean whereas there are you know a hundred
- 56:18thousands of cows like one lakh cows one and
- 56:21a half lakh cows being killed every single day
- 56:23in India. When I say cows, I also mean buffaloes
- 56:27because buffalo slaughter is absolutely illegal.
- 56:30And most of the products that are consumed are
- 56:31coming from buffaloes, but that connection is
- 56:35not there. And I can understand the connection
- 56:39not happening for some time, but to also reflect
- 56:42on why is the connection not happening? What
- 56:45is it that I need to do so that I understand
- 56:47that pain? Not making any progress in that. is
- 56:55also, you know, I feel when you have the ability
- 56:59to do it, like when I have to do research on
- 57:03universities, I do a thorough research, right?
- 57:05If I'm going to go to study, then why can one
- 57:08not do research on, you know, what is happening
- 57:11in animal agriculture? It's all out there. Resources
- 57:14are available today. So I strongly believe just
- 57:18because you're born in a certain... you know,
- 57:22religion like Jainism or Buddhism doesn't mean
- 57:24you're a Jain because Jainism is a way of life.
- 57:27If you're not able to follow the principle it's
- 57:30saying, then, you know, you're lacking something
- 57:33somewhere. And just because I'm a vegan doesn't
- 57:36mean I'm a Jain either, right? It's a journey.
- 57:38As I said, it's a lifelong journey. I'm trying
- 57:42to walk on that, you know, the principles those
- 57:45are given to me. But It's a lifelong journey.
- 57:50It's not like ticking the box. I love this answer.
- 57:56I always make sure to say that I'm a practicing
- 57:59Buddhist. I always make that point because yeah,
- 58:03I also get the feeling that in Buddhism, we give
- 58:08too much importance to the traditions, the customs,
- 58:13you know, all of the candles and all of that.
- 58:16Mayor, do you agree with Rishika. Yes. Okay.
- 58:24I'll say more than yes. There's a phrase that
- 58:28I use, which is, you know, not in English, but
- 58:31I often use this phrase, dharam over janam. It
- 58:36speaks to what Rishika was saying. Dharam means
- 58:39how you live your life. Janam means, you know,
- 58:44being born, right? you're not born Jain. You
- 58:50learn Jainism, you live Jainism. So speaking
- 58:53to what you said, a practicing Buddhist, a practicing
- 58:57Jain. I almost think, what is the phrase, rites
- 59:03of passage? That's a common phrase that's used
- 59:07in different contexts, but you really have to...
- 59:15really fully incorporate Jainism to the point
- 59:19where you're living it. It's almost like, okay,
- 59:23you know, you don't, you don't, you know, if
- 59:25you're taking let's say master's program or PhD
- 59:28program, they don't give you the PhD upfront,
- 59:31right? You go through some study, you go through
- 59:34some classes, you go through some exercises.
- 59:37Once you pass the test, once you go through the
- 59:39rich, the process, then you get your PhD. I almost
- 59:44want to say, to me, this is kind of my process.
- 59:50I'm not perfect. I'm not a perfect Jain. Veganism
- 59:53is maybe, to me, just one part of the practicing
- 59:58Jainism, practicing Jain principles. There's
- 1:00:00so many other elements. I think that we have
- 1:00:07lost sight. We lose that focus. Like you said,
- 1:00:10We focus on the rituals, lighting the candles,
- 1:00:14saying the prayers. One of our biggest prayers
- 1:00:17is Naukar mantra, which we don't need to get
- 1:00:21into defining at the moment, but that's one of
- 1:00:23the biggest prayers. Saying the Naukar mantra,
- 1:00:27doing a puja does not necessarily make you Jain.
- 1:00:31Those are Kriyas. Kriyas is a term for vehicles.
- 1:00:38prior exercises that take you to the actual practicing
- 1:00:43of the principles. But the thing is that people
- 1:00:47are actually defining the kriyas, these practices,
- 1:00:51as Jainism. And that's not really where it is.
- 1:00:56It's how you live your life. And so that's where
- 1:01:01the work is. That's where people need to realize
- 1:01:08Practicing a faith, Buddhism, Jainism is not
- 1:01:11in the rituals. It's not something you inherit.
- 1:01:18Sorry, I'm sorry. It's not something you inherit,
- 1:01:23right? Like you inherit property, you inherit
- 1:01:25wealth. It's not something you inherit. It's
- 1:01:28something you have to earn. And you can only
- 1:01:31earn it if you follow a lifestyle. fellow Janes
- 1:01:38respond to those arguments? Am I talking to with
- 1:01:43two pariahs of the Jane community? Are they aggressively
- 1:01:48opposing your views? Or is there a certain degree
- 1:01:52of welcoming this criticism that you might have?
- 1:01:58Yeah. I think it's both now because there's so
- 1:02:04much out. On social media, there's so many videos
- 1:02:09out there. There's just so much more awareness
- 1:02:12on what's happening in the dairy industry. There's
- 1:02:14also a lot of adulteration that happens in India.
- 1:02:17So when I speak to monks and saints, not consuming
- 1:02:25dairy, they feel, is not an answer. But the way
- 1:02:29the dairy is coming today, that's the problem.
- 1:02:32They agree that that's cruel. They agree that
- 1:02:34there's exploitation and there's cruelty there.
- 1:02:38But they feel the, you know, the process is wrong.
- 1:02:42The process is bad, but the product is not bad,
- 1:02:46right? So they have come to that agreement after
- 1:02:52so many years. And at least now, thankfully,
- 1:02:58a lot of JN youth, you know, they see it. They
- 1:03:01agree. And basically, now what I see is that
- 1:03:05nobody is able to disagree to the fact of what
- 1:03:07is happening. I think that itself is an opening.
- 1:03:12That itself is positive. That itself is a victory
- 1:03:15to have people accept that. And slowly, probably,
- 1:03:21and when it's done respectfully, you can slowly
- 1:03:26start telling them, okay, please don't use the
- 1:03:29products. you know, where you don't know what's
- 1:03:31happening to the cows and the buffaloes, you
- 1:03:34know, where they are surely going for slaughter.
- 1:03:37And I think nudging that little bit, I think
- 1:03:40it helps. At least they've opened up for conversations
- 1:03:44now. But one thing I see is that there should
- 1:03:50be respect, right? If I go with, okay, just my
- 1:03:54point of view is right, even if it's the truth.
- 1:03:58And as the Israelis said, the truth can be bitter.
- 1:04:00You don't have to be bitter to show the truth.
- 1:04:05You can still be respectful. You can still be
- 1:04:09objective and show it. So the other person can
- 1:04:13open up. And even if they have viewpoint, and
- 1:04:18there are times when people have told me that
- 1:04:20your vision is wrong. This vision of veganism
- 1:04:23you carry is wrong. We don't agree with veganism.
- 1:04:26There are multiple theories behind that. And
- 1:04:30then I'm like, okay, fine. And I probably turn
- 1:04:34the conversation and say, but do you think what's
- 1:04:36happening right now is right? Do you think this
- 1:04:38is how it should be happening? Do you think cows
- 1:04:40should be artificially impregnated? Do you think
- 1:04:44they need to get pregnant every year? Do you
- 1:04:46think the child should be sent to slaughter?
- 1:04:50Do you think the mother should be sent to slaughter
- 1:04:52after five or six years? Do you think it's okay
- 1:04:56when fathers are treated like that? So, you know,
- 1:04:59now who's going to agree to that? They're not,
- 1:05:04right? I mean, unless somebody just doesn't care.
- 1:05:08So I think the conversations are turning. I definitely
- 1:05:14see a lot more positivity. I would want to give
- 1:05:18that little credit to Jain people because, you
- 1:05:22know, they're assume, you know, they're taught
- 1:05:24Ahimsa from birth. They're taught about, okay,
- 1:05:28don't harm another living being, right? And that's
- 1:05:31why you'll see this community has maintained
- 1:05:34being a vegetarian. And we don't have, you know,
- 1:05:40I mean, unless somebody just doesn't care and
- 1:05:42eats non -veg, but from the philosophy point
- 1:05:45of view, there is absolute clarity, you know,
- 1:05:49that harm should not be caused to another living
- 1:05:53being. Of course, if I still don't care and I
- 1:05:57wear leather and I wear silk, that's different.
- 1:06:00And that is my lack of understanding and my attachment
- 1:06:05to these products. But otherwise it's very clear.
- 1:06:10And I see the community moving towards this positive
- 1:06:15direction because they've always been made sensitive
- 1:06:18towards themselves. Mayor, do you want to add
- 1:06:26something? Yeah, I mean, I think I was thinking
- 1:06:30earlier that there is some silver lining. The
- 1:06:34younger generations are much more open to accepting
- 1:06:42plant -based lifestyles, and they see the violence.
- 1:06:47So it is somewhat generational. And it doesn't
- 1:06:50mean that you you only focus on certain generations
- 1:06:57and certain people, the younger people. I think
- 1:07:00it's about conversation, right? It's about friendly,
- 1:07:04cordial, respectful conversation. It's about
- 1:07:08asking the very strategic questions that Ruchika
- 1:07:12just asked to highlight that this is not... history
- 1:07:19that we're making up. This is reality that we
- 1:07:24want to welcome them to go and explore on their
- 1:07:27own, right? We're not asking them to accept our
- 1:07:33words as true. Go seek the truth yourself. And
- 1:07:38then you do that internal reflection. Does this
- 1:07:46align with without, you know, with our principles.
- 1:07:50And I think more often than not, a lot of people
- 1:07:53are opening up to the reality, right? I mean,
- 1:07:59you know, there's something to be said about
- 1:08:02what Ruchika said about how, you know, the people
- 1:08:07think the process is wrong, but the product is
- 1:08:10okay. There is maybe, you know, to some degree,
- 1:08:14some historical thing that people started lashing
- 1:08:17onto, but it's okay. As long as the cows are
- 1:08:20taken care of, the dairy is okay. These type
- 1:08:23of farms that produce this milk is less than
- 1:08:301%. How many people actually get their milk from
- 1:08:33a cow that's taken care of? It's about asking
- 1:08:38the right questions and sparking the thinking,
- 1:08:43sparking the threats. And I'm optimistic, just
- 1:08:48like Richard, I think it's a slow process that
- 1:08:53that's the way it has to be, I think. I love
- 1:08:59your optimism. It's truly appreciated. One last
- 1:09:03question for you before we stop this recording.
- 1:09:07How do you feel when respected teachers from
- 1:09:11your faith and that's something that other, I
- 1:09:14think, religious people out there who are listening
- 1:09:17might relate to. When they oppose your views
- 1:09:22on veganism, when they kind of decide to close
- 1:09:28their ears to what you're saying, how do you
- 1:09:31deal with that? Because those are important people
- 1:09:35in your faith. I know that there are great influential
- 1:09:43monks and nuns in Buddhism. If I think about
- 1:09:47myself who are not vegan and are not interested
- 1:09:51in having that conversation, and it's always
- 1:09:54destabilizing to encounter that kind of attitude.
- 1:09:58And I've met Buddhists who have become disillusioned
- 1:10:02with Buddhism itself because of those leaders.
- 1:10:08And yeah, how do you deal with that in Jainism?
- 1:10:15Oh, I think lately I'm just, you know, sometimes
- 1:10:20lately, you know, earlier, as I said, I used
- 1:10:23to put a lot of resistance and that time it used
- 1:10:26to be frustrating. But once I changed my way
- 1:10:31of looking at things. And as I said, once I started
- 1:10:34looking at this entire movement objectively,
- 1:10:36and once I realized that this is not about me,
- 1:10:40it's not my ego. It's only about showing what
- 1:10:43the truth is and then it depends on the other
- 1:10:45person whether they want to take it on. I think
- 1:10:48that made a difference. So there are times when
- 1:10:51they don't agree with me and they might just
- 1:10:54hear me and you know, that's about it. But there
- 1:10:57have also been times when there have been monks
- 1:10:59who are absolutely opposed to veganism. Okay.
- 1:11:04But still have come down to agree. When I use
- 1:11:07terms from scriptures, I've still come down to
- 1:11:10agree. that what they and I are saying is not
- 1:11:14very different. We just disagree on one point.
- 1:11:17And that is, you don't need to stop dairy. Okay?
- 1:11:22They feel you don't need to stop dairy. I say,
- 1:11:24you need to stop dairy in order to stop this
- 1:11:26cruelty. But then I take this middle path and
- 1:11:29I tell them, but do you think the commercial
- 1:11:31dairy should be used? Because that's where the
- 1:11:33cow's definitely going for slaughter. So at least
- 1:11:36they come around and agree on that entire part.
- 1:11:38That no, this should not be used. Right? They
- 1:11:42obviously agree on meat, they agree on eggs,
- 1:11:45they agree on, you know, silk, leather, pearls.
- 1:11:51So majority of the battle, anyways we are together.
- 1:11:56Right? It's not that they and I are on separate
- 1:11:58page. We are definitely together. It's just that
- 1:12:01little bit of difference. Let's say five or 10%.
- 1:12:04That's fine. Let's agree to disagree on that.
- 1:12:07But let's just still work together on the other
- 1:12:10parts. So, you know, and I think that's worked.
- 1:12:15That's really worked, you know, for me. So they
- 1:12:22might not, you know, and it's also, we have to
- 1:12:25remember that both in Buddhist and Jainism, they
- 1:12:28live in a community. So just because, let's say
- 1:12:33if I'm a nun and I feel in a certain way, it
- 1:12:37does not, I cannot Just go out and practice it.
- 1:12:41Because I live in a community, right? There's
- 1:12:44certain resistance. Versus when I'm living in
- 1:12:47my own house, I have the liberty to, you know,
- 1:12:50make something that I can eat, make something
- 1:12:52different for the family, etc. You know, they
- 1:12:56don't have that liberty. Their life is a lot
- 1:12:59more constrained, a lot more restrained on their
- 1:13:01life. And I understand that. So, I think bringing
- 1:13:07that understanding towards the other person,
- 1:13:10reduces the frustration, it opens up to a dialogue,
- 1:13:14and that's what is needed. To open up to a dialogue,
- 1:13:19to come to agreements, to come to agreements
- 1:13:22and disagreements as well also respectfully is
- 1:13:25also needed. So as I said, I'm very positive
- 1:13:33about this community. That is great to hear.
- 1:13:38Meher, do you feel the same way? Yeah, I also
- 1:13:41do feel the same way. I do want to add on something
- 1:13:46that just because somebody is an important figure,
- 1:13:52a religious figure, or just otherwise influential
- 1:13:54figure, doesn't mean that they have full knowledge,
- 1:13:58full awareness, right? They're still... I don't
- 1:14:06want to diminish the importance of these people
- 1:14:07because they are very highly influential people,
- 1:14:11especially the religious figures. They have followers.
- 1:14:16There are thousands of people that may follow
- 1:14:18a certain priest, for example. And so that priest
- 1:14:23wields a lot of power, I guess, influence. But
- 1:14:29that doesn't mean that that priest who has devoted
- 1:14:33himself or herself to Jainism and was taken out
- 1:14:37of the chastity or just become fully dedicated
- 1:14:44to Jainism. It doesn't mean that they also don't
- 1:14:49need that awareness. They're in certain bubbles,
- 1:14:55honestly, and having the conversations with them,
- 1:14:59sharing information, sharing knowledge, It's
- 1:15:04very much needed, just like it's needed with
- 1:15:07lay people. Whether it's the person coming to
- 1:15:11the temple who doesn't know what's going on,
- 1:15:15the same thing applies to highly placed people
- 1:15:19in the community. I remember a conversation with
- 1:15:23a rich guy in my head with one such person. It
- 1:15:28was a very cordial dialogue. Ruchika came very
- 1:15:31well prepared with some slides and information.
- 1:15:37And I think that made a difference, right? Showing
- 1:15:42the truth, showing the reality in a friendly
- 1:15:49conversational way, I think makes a big difference.
- 1:15:54So I completely agree that I am optimistic, but
- 1:15:58it doesn't mean just because they're being these
- 1:16:02highly influential people that they know everything.
- 1:16:08And for people who are listening here, I full
- 1:16:10respect to all the religious figures and the
- 1:16:14people who are influential in our community,
- 1:16:17but they're still prone to that lack of knowledge
- 1:16:20and information. And so the job remains the same.
- 1:16:26So to not add to that, I did meet um you know
- 1:16:30when I mean and there have been times when I've
- 1:16:34met monks and uh shown what happens in the industry
- 1:16:37and they were just not aware about it because
- 1:16:39you know they these they don't have phones they
- 1:16:42don't see videos so they really don't know they
- 1:16:45don't read newspapers they really don't know
- 1:16:47what's really happening in the material world
- 1:16:49so they genuinely didn't know that's happening
- 1:16:52and after some time when I met them again uh
- 1:16:55and he told me you know after we saw that we
- 1:16:57stopped consuming milk, you know, otherwise they
- 1:17:01do consume milk by itself. They're like, at least
- 1:17:03we are trying. We stopped consuming milk. We
- 1:17:06stopped consuming cottage cheese. We're trying
- 1:17:09for other things as well, but because they're
- 1:17:12dependent, same as Buddhist monks, right, to
- 1:17:14get the alms from people, from the layman. That's
- 1:17:18getting a little difficult. So there are times
- 1:17:20when they genuinely don't know what's happening.
- 1:17:22There are times when they know what's happening,
- 1:17:25but, you know, tradition plays a big role. And
- 1:17:29somewhere we are not able to differentiate between
- 1:17:32tradition and philosophies. Tradition and philosophy
- 1:17:35don't always go hand in hand. There have been
- 1:17:38times when traditions were wrong. You know, like
- 1:17:42in India, there was a practice called Sati, where,
- 1:17:47you know, the husband died, the woman had to
- 1:17:49like jump. you know, into the fire alive and
- 1:17:54kill herself. Now that was a practice that went
- 1:17:57on for a long time, but was that the right tradition?
- 1:18:00No, it wasn't. So philosophy and tradition should
- 1:18:03not be mixed. They don't always go hand in hand.
- 1:18:06Traditions can be wrong. Philosophy cannot be
- 1:18:08wrong, right? How can Ahimsa be wrong? It's a
- 1:18:11sense of feeling. So feeling somebody's pain
- 1:18:14cannot be wrong. So that distinction is required
- 1:18:19and Sometimes to speak up against tradition takes
- 1:18:23a lot of courage. And many times, you know, it's
- 1:18:27difficult for them. As I said, they're in a community.
- 1:18:29There is a hierarchy. It's difficult. My father
- 1:18:32-in -law was courageous. He did speak against
- 1:18:35it the day he learned about it. It didn't matter
- 1:18:38to him whether he lost following, whether people
- 1:18:41would stop following him. It didn't matter. What
- 1:18:44mattered to him was speaking the truth and speaking
- 1:18:48for them. So it takes both. It also takes education.
- 1:18:52It also takes courage as both. Beautiful. Ruchika
- 1:19:00Mayor, this has been such a pleasure getting
- 1:19:05to know you and talking about genusim and where
- 1:19:09you're coming from. You're two such amazing animal
- 1:19:14rights activists. Did you want to add something
- 1:19:18before we stop the conversation? Thank you. On
- 1:19:36my side, I just want to say I appreciate having
- 1:19:39this conversation. I think we are very passionate
- 1:19:43about what we what we do, what we believe in.
- 1:19:48And we try to do it in a way that is respectful,
- 1:19:54as objective as possible, and really just not
- 1:20:01lose sight of our principles and in the process.
- 1:20:06And that really is all that matters. And then
- 1:20:11the rest, come what may. Yeah, I agree with what
- 1:20:17Mayuri said that we shouldn't lose sight of the
- 1:20:21main principles. And I also think, I think, you
- 1:20:24know, connecting with different faiths, people
- 1:20:27coming from different backgrounds across the
- 1:20:30world, you know, it's so important to come together,
- 1:20:35work together. Otherwise it becomes like, you
- 1:20:39know, when it's just one community or just one
- 1:20:42religion working towards something, it becomes
- 1:20:43like a cult. But when there are people coming
- 1:20:46from different faiths and they're coming together
- 1:20:48from different backgrounds, different ethnicities,
- 1:20:51they're coming together. I think there is something
- 1:20:54that's true, something that's authentic. And
- 1:20:59there's a common message, right? It's just compassion.
- 1:21:04So I think that's very important. Thank you for
- 1:21:06doing this. I mean, I'm so grateful I could be
- 1:21:08a part of this. Absolutely. Thank you, Ryan,
- 1:21:11for having us. Really good to have this conversation
- 1:21:16with both of you. Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:21:21I kindly invite you to share this podcast with
- 1:21:24the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 1:21:27to take action. Again, thank you so much for
- 1:21:30caring and I will see you next Tuesday for a
- 1:21:33new episode.