Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage a Team Member Who Keeps Asking for Feedback
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to talk about a manager who wrote in with a problem that sounds flattering at first but can actually be exhausting over time. She has a team member, a marketing coordinator, who asks for feedback constantly. Not just after big projects — after every email, every draft, every meeting. Luna: Right, the 'can you look at this real quick?' type. I've seen that. It can feel like they respect your opinion, but it also slows everything down. Lucas: Exactly. And the manager's instinct is usually to give feedback because she wants to be supportive. But over weeks and months, this coordinator's output grinds to a halt unless she gets a sign-off. The manager starts to wonder: am I creating a dependency here? Luna: So how do you distinguish between a healthy feedback loop and a crutch? I imagine there's a line. Lucas: There is. First, let me say that feedback seeking isn't inherently bad. Some of the best employees are the ones who want to improve. But when the frequency exceeds what's reasonable for the role and the person stops making decisions independently, it's a problem. Luna: What's 'reasonable'? Is there a benchmark? Lucas: I think it depends on the role and the person's tenure. For someone new, checking in once or twice a day might be fine. But for someone who's been in the role six months, you'd expect them to handle routine tasks without input. In this case, the coordinator had been there over a year. Luna: So it's about expectations. Did the manager set clear boundaries early on? Lucas: That's the core of it. She hadn't. She was so happy to have someone eager that she never said 'here's when you should come to me, and here's when you should trust your judgment.' So the coordinator developed a habit. Luna: That's a common trap for first-time managers. You want to be accessible, but you end up being a bottleneck. Lucas: Right. So the fix starts with a conversation. The manager needs to say something like 'I appreciate how much you care about quality. I want to help you grow, but I also want you to feel confident making decisions on your own. Let's set up a system.' Luna: A system. Meaning scheduled check-ins instead of ad-hoc requests? Lucas: Exactly. One concrete strategy is to move to a 'feedback at specific times' model. For example, a fifteen-minute stand-up each morning and a thirty-minute review on Friday afternoons. Outside those windows, she handles it herself unless it's a true emergency. Luna: And define what counts as a true emergency. Lucas: Yes. That's part of the conversation. 'If a client is about to walk, come find me. If you're unsure about a word choice in a social media post, go with your instinct.' You have to make the default 'decide and inform' rather than 'ask and wait.' Luna: I also wonder if some of this is about confidence. Maybe the coordinator doesn't trust her own judgment because she's been told what to do her whole career. Lucas: That's a great point. This can be especially common with people who came from very structured environments or who are perfectionists. In that case, the manager might pair the new system with a 'self-assessment first' rule. Luna: Meaning before they bring something to you, they have to write down what they think works and what doesn't? Lucas: Exactly. 'Before you send me that draft, jot down three things you like about it and one thing you'd change. Then we'll compare notes.' It forces them to think critically and builds their internal filter. Over time, they need less external validation. Luna: That's smart. And it also shifts the dynamic from you being the gatekeeper to you being a coach. Lucas: Right. And there's another layer here: sometimes the feedback seeking is actually a signal of something else. Maybe the person doesn't know what good looks like. Maybe they've been burned before by a mistake and now they're afraid to fail. Luna: So the manager might need to dig into that. Ask 'what's the worst that could happen if you make a call without my input?' Lucas: Exactly. And then you can address the fear directly. Say 'Look, if you make a mistake, we'll fix it together. That's how you learn. I'd rather you try and learn than come to me for permission on every tiny thing.' Luna: Yeah. And that's the kind of culture we talk about on this show a lot — psychological safety. It's interesting because the coordinator might actually feel less safe because she's constantly checking, not more. Lucas: That's a great framing. She's seeking safety through approval, but real safety comes from knowing you can recover from a misstep. The manager has to model that. Luna: We've talked about a lot of different manager challenges on this show — seventy-nine episodes now. And one thing that keeps me coming back is that we don't run ads. We keep this free because we want anyone who needs this advice to be able to find it without a paywall. Lucas: That's intentional. And if you've gotten value from these conversations — maybe you've used one of these strategies with your own team — there's a simple way to support that choice. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No perks, no gimmicks, just helps keep the show ad-free. Luna: Appreciate that. And we're back to the coordinator. So you set up the system, you teach self-assessment. What happens if they still keep asking? Lucas: Then you might need to escalate. If after a few weeks the behavior hasn't changed, have a firmer conversation. 'I've noticed you're still asking for feedback outside our scheduled times. Can we talk about what's getting in the way of you making those calls?' Luna: And if it's still a problem, is it a performance issue? Lucas: It can become one. Because at that point, it's not about feedback — it's about a refusal to take ownership. And that's a core job requirement. You say 'Part of this role is independent judgment. If you can't exercise it, we need to figure out if this is the right fit.' Luna: That's tough. But fair. I guess the key is to catch it early before it becomes a pattern. Lucas: Absolutely. The earlier you address it, the easier it is to course correct. And the most important thing is to be clear and consistent. If you say 'decide on your own,' don't get pulled back into micromanaging. Luna: So the manager has to change her own behavior too. It's a two-way street. Lucas: It always is. She has to resist the urge to fix things, and instead ask questions. 'What do you think?' 'What's your recommendation?' That becomes the new script. Luna: I like that. And I'd add one more thing: sometimes people from cultures with high power distance are more likely to seek constant approval. So managers should be culturally aware too. Lucas: Great point. That's not an excuse to avoid the conversation, but it might change how you approach it. You might need to be more explicit about your expectations around autonomy. Luna: Right. 'In this team, we value independent decision-making. I'm here to guide, but I want you to take the lead.' Lucas: Exactly. And over time, you'll see them start to own their work. They'll bring you finished products, not questions. And that's when you know it's working. Luna: So to sum up: set clear boundaries, teach self-assessment, address the underlying fear, and be consistent. And if all else fails, escalate. Lucas: That's the framework. And one more thing: celebrate the wins. When they make a good call without asking, say 'that was great. I love that you owned it.' Positive reinforcement goes a long way. Luna: Absolutely. Thanks Lucas. Good episode. Lucas: Thanks Luna. See everyone next week.