Latest / Surrounded / Patrick Bet-David vs 20 Anti-Capitalists
Transcript
- 0:00This is not the United States of Patrick but David.
- 0:02This is the United States of America.
- 0:04Would you take money from a capitalist to help you go see a specialist?
- 0:07I mean,
- 0:07yeah,
- 0:07sure,
- 0:08why not?
- 0:08But would you also be open to seeing somebody
- 0:10else I choose as a psychologist that may,
- 0:13no,
- 0:13you're not.
- 0:14No,
- 0:14no.
- 0:14When you're offering people here jobs,
- 0:16right,
- 0:16you're saying that they would have to pay you money to get that.
- 0:19So in reality you're trying to convince them to pay
- 0:21you money to be part of your claims of defamement.
- 0:23Be very careful defaming.
- 0:24We know you don't know the facts.
- 0:29From Jubilee Media,
- 0:30this is the Surrounded podcast,
- 0:31where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:35In the center of today's episode is the American businessman,
- 0:38media personality,
- 0:39author and podcaster,
- 0:40Patrick Bett David,
- 0:42and he will be debating 20 anti-capitalists.
- 0:45Patrick will debate them one on one until
- 0:48they are voted out by their peers and replaced by someone new.
- 0:50Let's get into it.
- 0:52I'm Patrick David.
- 0:53I'm an entrepreneur and founder of PBD podcast.
- 0:55Today,
- 0:56I'm surrounded by 20
- 0:58anti-capitalists.
- 1:02My first claim is incentive is the engine of capitalism.
- 1:06Remove it and the system fails.
- 1:14Hey,
- 1:15great to meet you,
- 1:15Patrick.
- 1:16What's your name?
- 1:16My name's Mason.
- 1:17Mason,
- 1:17good to meet you.
- 1:18Yeah,
- 1:18um,
- 1:19I'm value attained.
- 1:20I'm a big fan of the channel.
- 1:21So yeah,
- 1:21I do watch it quite regularly.
- 1:23I just,
- 1:23I do not,
- 1:24uh,
- 1:24agree with your claim.
- 1:25I don't think that incentives are only born out of capitalism.
- 1:28Uh,
- 1:29most capitalist defenders say that incentive,
- 1:32uh,
- 1:32is because of scarcity
- 1:34and people's ability to get what is necessary.
- 1:36Necessary pushes them to work harder.
- 1:38Um,
- 1:38I disagree with that.
- 1:39I'd say that some of our hardest workers are single moms working 3 to 4 jobs,
- 1:43and the resources that they're able to acquire compared to those that
- 1:46utilize their workers in order to build profit for their own companies
- 1:49is not equivocal.
- 1:51So how would you do it?
- 1:52How would you change it?
- 1:53Yeah,
- 1:54so I,
- 1:54I think that humans inherently want to be meaningful.
- 1:56They,
- 1:56they want to contribute to their communities.
- 1:58They want to contribute to society.
- 1:59Um,
- 2:00when you look at depression rates,
- 2:01oftentimes it's people who aren't able to do anything besides
- 2:04laying in their bed and,
- 2:05and basically barely taking care of themselves.
- 2:07So I think that it's just a human
- 2:09intrinsic
- 2:10value to want to bring value to their community.
- 2:13Or grander society,
- 2:14so I don't think that it has to be through scarcity alone
- 2:16that scares people into working if I'm I,
- 2:18I worked for scarcity.
- 2:20I think there's levels to it.
- 2:21You have the survival folks who work for survival
- 2:23to pay their bills.
- 2:25Some work for status,
- 2:26some work for freedom,
- 2:26and some work for legacy.
- 2:28The folks that work 3 or 5 jobs,
- 2:30you know,
- 2:30to pay their bills and do what they're doing,
- 2:32if the incentive wasn't there,
- 2:33they wouldn't work 3 to 5 jobs.
- 2:35Some of the guys that build a bigger business that solve a lot of
- 2:37problems in the sense of there is either I die or I work,
- 2:40that's not really a system that rewards merit,
- 2:42that's a system that pushes people into insecure positions.
- 2:45Not necessarily.
- 2:45In many cases we put ourselves in situations as well,
- 2:49but when we're talking,
- 2:50are you saying that it's an individual failure for these single
- 2:52mothers that are working 3 to 4 jobs for some.
- 2:55Them,
- 2:55it is
- 2:56interesting.
- 2:56Some of them.
- 2:57I'm glad you bite that bullet because most people
- 2:59are not gonna say that it's a moral failure
- 3:01of people that are born into poverty that continue to live.
- 3:04Let me cyclical for somebody like me,
- 3:05I came from the single mother system.
- 3:07My mother was a single mother,
- 3:08you know,
- 3:09we had,
- 3:09you know,
- 3:10my parents got a divorce twice.
- 3:11They married each other.
- 3:12They divorced.
- 3:13They remarried each other,
- 3:14divorced again.
- 3:15I came up.
- 3:16We didn't have a lot of choices.
- 3:17I joined the army.
- 3:18I got out of that system,
- 3:19kind of wanted to see what I was gonna do for myself.
- 3:21Do I stay in the army?
- 3:22Do I get out of the army?
- 3:23I started working in sales,
- 3:24and then the incentive of working harder,
- 3:26eventually I build a good life for myself.
- 3:27Again,
- 3:28you're,
- 3:28you're
- 3:29totally dismissing the hard work that a lot of
- 3:31these people are putting into for just basic survival.
- 3:33I'd say that mechanic,
- 3:35uh,
- 3:35mechanics and plumbers and most people working blue
- 3:37collar jobs that are probably watching this video
- 3:39are working tirelessly day after day,
- 3:41I don't yet they still feel.
- 3:42Insecure positions to where they don't even know if they're gonna
- 3:44be able to afford rent in the next 6 months.
- 3:46So let me ask if most Americans have a $400 to $500 emergency,
- 3:50they can't even afford that with the basic savings that they have.
- 3:52So this is not something that we should celebrate as promises
- 3:55of a system that gives you more if you work harder.
- 3:57We should say that this is something that rewards few,
- 4:00and I'm glad that you're an outlier that's been
- 4:01able to build a lot of success for yourself.
- 4:03I know that you're a multi-millionaire.
- 4:04That's fan that's fantastic that you have those resources,
- 4:07but the thing is that
- 4:08that cannot happen for everybody in society.
- 4:10It's Possible for each individual to do it,
- 4:12but not everybody can be a millionaire.
- 4:14That's guaranteed.
- 4:14I don't,
- 4:15I don't think not everybody can be a billionaire or a millionaire,
- 4:18but I do think people can
- 4:20find ways to use their time to effectively
- 4:22increase their market value,
- 4:23and I don't think many people do that.
- 4:25When I talk to people and they tell me,
- 4:27I've watched this show,
- 4:27I've watched every one of these shows,
- 4:29I've watched every one of these Netflix shows,
- 4:31you can use that time to increase your market value instead of kind of,
- 4:34you know,
- 4:34focus on what's going on with the
- 4:36stories and shows that are out there.
- 4:37Let's move away from Netflix.
- 4:38and TV shows and and talk specifically about,
- 4:40do you think that capitalism is a system of
- 4:42merit that rewards people that are of higher merit?
- 4:44I do.
- 4:44OK,
- 4:45so how would you say that this is a meritocracy when we have
- 4:47some people that are born into excessive wealth and some people that are
- 4:51working minimum wage jobs to provide for 3 or 4 kids?
- 4:54How would you say that that's a meritocratic society?
- 4:56Those are two different things,
- 4:57when you,
- 4:57right?
- 4:58They are two different things,
- 4:58very unequal things.
- 4:59Well,
- 5:00no,
- 5:00not necessarily that the parents
- 5:02get credit for making responsible decisions so they can take care of their kids.
- 5:05The
- 5:06parents get meritocracy that we're,
- 5:07we're building dynasties of wealth.
- 5:09Not not I didn't come from dynasties of wealth.
- 5:11I know you're in 99 cents.
- 5:13I get that.
- 5:13I get that individual.
- 5:14We're talking about systems.
- 5:15Capitalism is a system.
- 5:16It's not an individual testimony that you get to use in your advantage.
- 5:21It's a system that's produced the best results
- 5:23than any other economical system.
- 5:25There's not an economical system.
- 5:26That's produced better results than this,
- 5:28I think based on the incentive.
- 5:30History is a march of progress,
- 5:31right?
- 5:31So there are going to be advancements that we make or
- 5:33there's going to be solutions that we make to previous ailments.
- 5:36I'm not saying that capitalism hasn't brought in better
- 5:38things than the systems like feudalism or monarchy,
- 5:41but that does not mean that we're at the end of history.
- 5:43Do you think that capitalism is the final solution,
- 5:45and this is what we're going to last
- 5:46I think capitalism is the best economical system because
- 5:49it gives an incentive for you to decide how big of a life you want to build.
- 5:51And by the.
- 5:52The best way to judge it,
- 5:53the best way to,
- 5:53let me just say this to you,
- 5:54the best way to judge it is in a very simple way.
- 5:57Take all the countries around the world.
- 5:59There's many different economical systems.
- 6:01What has the longest line of people wanting to get in there?
- 6:04It's America.
- 6:05Why is that?
- 6:0615 million people came here illegally.
- 6:09Millions came here illegally just the last 4 years.
- 6:11A lot of that is because of economic scarcity in other countries.
- 6:13Well,
- 6:13one of them we could talk about one is American exceptionalism,
- 6:16which is continuing.
- 6:17Good to meet you.
- 6:18Thank you.
- 6:28How are you?
- 6:29What's your name?
- 6:30Hi,
- 6:30I'm Ilana.
- 6:30It's nice to meet you.
- 6:32OK,
- 6:32um,
- 6:33so I think the issue is the framing of incentive here.
- 6:36Incentive doesn't disappear in a socialist or a communist society.
- 6:40It just changes and evolves.
- 6:42So we see in capitalism,
- 6:44the incentive is obviously
- 6:46monetary game,
- 6:47maybe even collecting capital itself,
- 6:49um,
- 6:50through,
- 6:51uh,
- 6:51land ownership in a communist.
- 6:53Or a socialist country,
- 6:54you would see incentive would just evolve into,
- 6:57I know it's a vague term,
- 6:58but the common good.
- 6:59Uh,
- 6:59you have an incentive
- 7:01to do your chores around your house because you don't want to live in a filthy house,
- 7:04right?
- 7:04That makes sense.
- 7:05It doesn't have to be just monetary.
- 7:07So you don't think monetary incentive drives people,
- 7:10or you're saying that that people should be
- 7:13excited to do their job,
- 7:14whether they're getting incentivized for it or not.
- 7:15That's what you're saying.
- 7:16People,
- 7:16people will be incentivized to.
- 7:19Give me a case study.
- 7:20Give me a case study of that that worked.
- 7:22Give me one case.
- 7:23We don't even need to look at case studies.
- 7:24We can just look at charity work.
- 7:26Well,
- 7:26why don't,
- 7:27why don't we actually look at a case study?
- 7:28You got two countries
- 7:30North Korea,
- 7:31South Korea.
- 7:32One is communism
- 7:33and one is capitalism.
- 7:35North Korea's GDP last year was $23 billion.
- 7:40Are we,
- 7:40are we judging many companies countries' values based on are GDP.
- 7:44Because that's a job,
- 7:45freedom of speech.
- 7:46You can't,
- 7:47like if you lived in North Korea,
- 7:49you wouldn't be able to do what you're doing right now.
- 7:50You wouldn't have a voice in South Korea.
- 7:52I'm,
- 7:52I'm gonna give you stats.
- 7:53In South Korea,
- 7:54their GDP is 1.7 trillion.
- 7:57Korea is also owned by like 5 companies in total in the entire country.
- 8:02You think that's something like if you aren't employed by the top five countries,
- 8:06you are practically unemployed in these countries.
- 8:08Do you like to be free?
- 8:09I'm not.
- 8:09Go to be free in a country like South Korea where
- 8:11I'm only employed in 5 companies or somebody like me.
- 8:14Do you like to be free where you can have a strong opinion?
- 8:16Do you like to be free?
- 8:17I like to be free,
- 8:18but that's why I'm anti-capitalist.
- 8:20Maybe you are.
- 8:21That is why I'm anti-capitaltalist because capitalism removes that choice.
- 8:24There is no real incentive of capitalism because the incentive is survival.
- 8:28If I when you get into communism,
- 8:31the incentive is for the common good.
- 8:32I love that.
- 8:33I got,
- 8:33I got an offer for you before we move on.
- 8:35If I were to give you
- 8:37your $2350 which is the cost to renunciate your citizenship,
- 8:42and I paid you your first class,
- 8:43you know,
- 8:44flight to whatever communist country
- 8:46and $20,000 of spending money,
- 8:48would you give up your citizenship to go to that country,
- 8:51whichever communist country you wanna go to
- 8:53Cuba,
- 8:54we can give you Venezuela,
- 8:55we give you North Korea,
- 8:56any one of those you wanna go to.
- 8:58Choose any one of them.
- 8:59I'll give you a one-way ticket,
- 9:00and I'll fund it for you if you want to.
- 9:03Thank you,
- 9:04yes.
- 9:12Hi,
- 9:12what's your name?
- 9:14My name's Hunter.
- 9:14I'm gonna be honest,
- 9:15I've never seen your videos before.
- 9:17Even though
- 9:18there is some real value to free enterprise,
- 9:20the profit motive often creates a perverse
- 9:22incentive and worse outcomes in certain situations.
- 9:25For example,
- 9:26healthcare.
- 9:27How much would you pay for a life saving
- 9:29treatment for yourself or one of your family members?
- 9:31How much would I pay for it?
- 9:32Say you have cancer and you have an 80% survival rate with chemotherapy,
- 9:36and less than 10% without it.
- 9:38How much would you pay?
- 9:39Whatever it takes,
- 9:40right?
- 9:41That's a situation of inelastic demand
- 9:43when
- 9:44the amount that you're willing to pay
- 9:46is not based on the value of the service because
- 9:49your life does not have a finite value.
- 9:51In the US,
- 9:5266.5% of all bankruptcies are because of medical debt.
- 9:56In most other developed nations,
- 9:58that number is way lower,
- 9:59if not zero.
- 10:00And at the same time,
- 10:01the US does not have one of the best healthcare systems in the world.
- 10:05We pay over 13,000 per capita.
- 10:07Meanwhile.
- 10:08One,
- 10:08which by most metrics has the best healthcare system
- 10:11and a national healthcare service,
- 10:12only pays about 2500 per capita per year.
- 10:15So what does that tell you?
- 10:16That tells you that's wasted expenditure.
- 10:18Yes,
- 10:19that is a massively wasted expenditure.
- 10:20That tells you,
- 10:21so
- 10:21that tells you the government doesn't know how to spend our money.
- 10:25They keep raising taxes,
- 10:26we keep spending money and they don't know how to spend the money.
- 10:28No,
- 10:29most of that money is coming from private insurance.
- 10:31In fact,
- 10:3177% of the people who
- 10:33went bankrupt from medical debt had insurance and
- 10:35then lost it because they couldn't pay.
- 10:36So,
- 10:36so we Can address that the fact that 60% of bankruptcies are due to health,
- 10:41which is you're right,
- 10:42we've done many content on that piece.
- 10:44I want you to come back to incentive,
- 10:46address the issue with incentive right now with capitalism.
- 10:49The reason why the medical debt is so high and that is because of the profit motive.
- 10:52If people will pay whatever it takes profit to not die,
- 10:55the profit motive in that case is perverse because healthcare shouldn't be a market
- 10:59in the same way that other things might be a market.
- 11:01So you don't think that the motive to have profit to come out with a solution.
- 11:06Is a good thing for the marketplace,
- 11:08specifically in the healthcares
- 11:09on which market you're talking about.
- 11:11It's way different.
- 11:12We're talking about video games or cell phones
- 11:14or TVs or other goods that aren't as necessary
- 11:16as your healthcare treatment healthcare.
- 11:18Yes,
- 11:19I'm talking specifically about healthcare.
- 11:20So there's in certain other markets where there's a natural.
- 11:22You ever heard of Home Depot?
- 11:23Yes,
- 11:23I'm aware.
- 11:24So one of the guys who's the founders of Home Depot,
- 11:26investors of Home Depot is Ken Langone.
- 11:28Uh,
- 11:28his My father died at 62 years old.
- 11:30Ken Langon today is roughly 90 years old,
- 11:32give or take.
- 11:33When he died at 62 years old,
- 11:35he tells the story that if there was a simple thing as blood thinners,
- 11:39his father would have lived to be 90 years old just like he is today.
- 11:42That came because of innovation,
- 11:44which he's been on for many years.
- 11:45My dad's been on blood thinners for the last 40 years,
- 11:47so I think the incentive to create you're conflating two things right now,
- 11:50not all innovation.
- 11:52is the result of the market
- 11:54because many healthcare developments are created by research grants from
- 11:59healthcare funding,
- 12:00whether it's in the United States or in other countries.
- 12:01In most other first world countries,
- 12:03the result of medical research developments,
- 12:05which are
- 12:06massively outpacing that in the US now
- 12:08because of our inefficiency,
- 12:10because we have a market-based system for healthcare,
- 12:11a very basic of that is because a very basic non-market-based system.
- 12:15Basic question for you.
- 12:16If that's the case,
- 12:17it keeps going back to the same thing.
- 12:19If it's better in other places
- 12:21than it is here,
- 12:23why are Americans and others not going there?
- 12:25Why are people coming here?
- 12:26It's very basic.
- 12:27How much does a plane ticket cost?
- 12:29No,
- 12:29they have the money to go to different places.
- 12:31They don't because they know America is the greatest country in the world.
- 12:35They know it.
- 12:36Appreciate you to meet you,
- 12:37by the way.
- 12:42Hey,
- 12:43I'm Luke.
- 12:44Luke.
- 12:44Yes,
- 12:45like the hat.
- 12:45Good to meet you.
- 12:46Oh,
- 12:46thank you very much.
- 12:47Good to meet you too.
- 12:48So
- 12:48I think incentives
- 12:49are exactly the fundamental problem with capitalism,
- 12:52that you say incentives are what make it work.
- 12:53And I think that's the whole issue is that
- 12:55the primary incentives
- 12:57are either either greed,
- 12:59a massive amount as much personal wealth as you possibly can.
- 13:02You think that's the problem?
- 13:03It's greed.
- 13:04Yeah,
- 13:04yeah,
- 13:05exactly.
- 13:05And,
- 13:05and
- 13:06Because you're not greedy at all.
- 13:07And then like you said,
- 13:08survival,
- 13:09right,
- 13:09that the person,
- 13:10you know,
- 13:10working 5 jobs,
- 13:11you know,
- 13:11that they're,
- 13:11they're doing that so they wouldn't have to,
- 13:13they wouldn't want to do that if they didn't need to survive.
- 13:15But that's such a horrible
- 13:17dystopian world to live in.
- 13:18If someone has to work 5 jobs just to survive.
- 13:21How,
- 13:21how did they get there?
- 13:22How,
- 13:22how much of that is on their decision making?
- 13:25How much of that
- 13:26is on their doing?
- 13:27How much of that is on
- 13:29Market where
- 13:30they're not finding ways to improve themselves.
- 13:32It doesn't matter how much onus is on the individual.
- 13:34We want to create a course it is.
- 13:35No,
- 13:35no,
- 13:36no,
- 13:36no.
- 13:36See,
- 13:36we want to create a world in which people don't
- 13:38have to earn their right to exist and live.
- 13:41We live,
- 13:41we live in a country where the majority of the world wants to come here.
- 13:45The most important
- 13:47citizenship country is America.
- 13:49People give up their lives to come here.
- 13:51Have you ever lived in another country before?
- 13:54No,
- 13:54not lived.
- 13:54No.
- 13:55Why do you think so many want to come here?
- 13:56I think the people coming here are coming from gang-ridden,
- 13:59corruption-ridden,
- 14:00violence-ridden.
- 14:01You think that's just all it is?
- 14:02You think I came from a gang-ridden in Iran.
- 14:04I lived there 11 years.
- 14:05I think the majority of certainly coming from South America.
- 14:08Come here because what you're doing to me
- 14:10right you're sitting across from me right now.
- 14:12Millions of people are gonna watch this
- 14:14in America.
- 14:14You can call me out.
- 14:15You can say whatever you want.
- 14:17Nothing's gonna happen.
- 14:18You're free and safe here,
- 14:19right?
- 14:19Free freedom of speech you can't do that in Iran,
- 14:21of course it is.
- 14:22There's a lot of elements with America.
- 14:24You're talking incentive.
- 14:25The amount of benefits America offers against other countries,
- 14:28it's so much higher
- 14:29where somebody with big dreams,
- 14:31incentives,
- 14:32they're willing to come and say,
- 14:33I wanna come to America,
- 14:34please let me in,
- 14:35and some come and take advantage of it.
- 14:37But to save the individual
- 14:39that's working 3 to 5 jobs,
- 14:40if you do that for a season,
- 14:42if you do that for 2 years,
- 14:43if you do that for 5 years,
- 14:44fine.
- 14:45If you do that for 2030 years,
- 14:46you're doing something wrong.
- 14:48The point is life,
- 14:49liberty,
- 14:49and the pursuit of happiness,
- 14:50right?
- 14:51Those are the inalienable rights.
- 14:52We shouldn't have to earn
- 14:53those rights.
- 14:54We shouldn't have to earn the right to healthcare,
- 14:55to earn it,
- 14:55earn the right.
- 14:56No,
- 14:56no,
- 14:57I I because these are,
- 14:58this is just,
- 14:58we just want to live,
- 14:59just exist.
- 15:00We can't work our,
- 15:02our,
- 15:02our blood,
- 15:03sweat,
- 15:03and tears just to,
- 15:04just to survive.
- 15:05That's a horrible dystopian world that we live in right now.
- 15:07Then what do you think we're here for,
- 15:09to just sit around and play video games?
- 15:10We're,
- 15:10we're here.
- 15:11Everything we're here for to sit around and watch TV shows.
- 15:13We're here to sit and watch cat videos.
- 15:15What do you think we're put here?
- 15:16We are here to create a prosperous community,
- 15:18to lift.
- 15:18How do you create a prosperous community?
- 15:20How do you create a prosperous community?
- 15:21Matter of fact,
- 15:22for you,
- 15:23how have you,
- 15:24uh,
- 15:24positively impacted a community?
- 15:25Uh,
- 15:26I guess volunteering,
- 15:27food banks,
- 15:27volunteering food.
- 15:28I appreciate you for doing that.
- 15:29Have you created jobs for others?
- 15:31Created jobs?
- 15:32No,
- 15:32I wouldn't say so.
- 15:32Why have you not?
- 15:34I haven't had the ability to do so.
- 15:36Do you think it's easy,
- 15:37or do you think it's hard
- 15:38to create jobs?
- 15:39It's probably hard.
- 15:40Yeah,
- 15:40it's probably OK.
- 15:41So the people that create jobs,
- 15:42you think they should have a little bit of incentive
- 15:44for having risked their life savings,
- 15:46spend time away with their families
- 15:48to create jobs so somebody like you can work for that company.
- 15:50Sure,
- 15:51but that,
- 15:51that is,
- 15:51but that,
- 15:52that is the incentive,
- 15:53and,
- 15:53and bravo for them.
- 15:54But that does not give them the right to pay
- 15:55themselves $2 million dollar bonuses while they're their workers.
- 15:58But you don't,
- 15:59you don't,
- 15:59you don't,
- 16:00you don't get to choose how much money I choose to make.
- 16:03That's not your business.
- 16:04That's my business.
- 16:05If you have 4 girlfriends
- 16:07and I have 1,
- 16:08is it my business to tell you you can't have 4 girlfriends?
- 16:10If you play 7 hours of,
- 16:12you know,
- 16:12Fortnite every day and I don't play Fortnite at all?
- 16:14Should I tell you you don't,
- 16:15you shouldn't be able to play 7 hours of Fortnite a day.
- 16:17It,
- 16:17it,
- 16:17it,
- 16:17I,
- 16:18in my view.
- 16:20Hey,
- 16:20I appreciate you.
- 16:26How are you?
- 16:27What's your name?
- 16:28Xena Xena.
- 16:29Awesome.
- 16:30So this claim about incentive is one that we see often
- 16:33um promoted by um capitalism
- 16:36enjoyers,
- 16:36right?
- 16:37And it's this idea that,
- 16:38you know,
- 16:39profit incentives is the only thing that can make humans do things,
- 16:41get up out of bed every day,
- 16:43which
- 16:43has never been the case historically it's not the case psychologically
- 16:46historically it's never been the case.
- 16:48What has been the case?
- 16:49So we've seen what's been the incentive?
- 16:50The incentive is intrinsic motivation,
- 16:52intrinsic motivation,
- 16:53of course.
- 16:54Have you ever heard of intrinsic motivation?
- 16:55I have.
- 16:56So you think people are going to go just do anything for no incentives.
- 16:59The incentive is intrinsic,
- 17:00meaning passion,
- 17:02interest,
- 17:02and honing your skills.
- 17:03What do you get paid or not?
- 17:04Well,
- 17:05the problem is that we're forcing people to,
- 17:07you know,
- 17:07need to,
- 17:08you know,
- 17:08work to survive.
- 17:09And what's the alternative?
- 17:10So give me another solution,
- 17:12another may I finish the talking point actually I'm curious.
- 17:14So yeah,
- 17:14the psychological theory of self-determination
- 17:16is widely accepted in psychology.
- 17:19It basically explains that intrinsic motivation and
- 17:21passion is actually what predicts incentive.
- 17:23You're arguing that incentive is integrity.
- 17:25Um,
- 17:25to profit driven motivation,
- 17:27that's not true.
- 17:28Intrinsic motivation
- 17:29at all times at every single case is going to,
- 17:32you know,
- 17:32predict less creativity,
- 17:33um,
- 17:34less motivation,
- 17:35less skill,
- 17:36etc.
- 17:36Intrinsic motivation is what,
- 17:37what causes things like,
- 17:38um,
- 17:39technological development.
- 17:40Um,
- 17:41some of the greatest breakthroughs have been from
- 17:42people who are devoted and honing their skill.
- 17:44So should they get paid for it?
- 17:46I think that we shouldn't live in a system
- 17:47that,
- 17:48um,
- 17:48privately owner like owns the means of
- 17:50production and forces people in this position.
- 17:52What college did you go to,
- 17:53uh,
- 17:53USC.
- 17:54You went to USC.
- 17:54What did you major in?
- 17:56Sociology.
- 17:56Sociology.
- 17:57Who's your hero as a professor?
- 17:59Who's the,
- 17:59who's the professor you look up to?
- 18:01It doesn't seem like a topic that's related to ask this question.
- 18:03The reason why I ask this question is because somebody convinced you of that.
- 18:06Somebody convinced you that that is so psychology and
- 18:08studies convinced me of this fact about the unfortunately,
- 18:12to your claim,
- 18:13results show
- 18:14that the greatest economical system intrinsic motivationism,
- 18:18more creativity that allows people to go above and
- 18:20beyond and solve every single issue out there.
- 18:23An entrepreneur who gets up,
- 18:24who says,
- 18:25what was your claim again,
- 18:25mister?
- 18:26I'm going to incentive.
- 18:28What about incentive has an incentive to go out there and build their lives
- 18:31and you put so I'm saying that this incentive that you're talking about,
- 18:34what,
- 18:34what predicts the most,
- 18:35the best incentive,
- 18:36the best strive,
- 18:37and the best creativity do you think has been proven by psychology.
- 18:39Elon Musk.
- 18:40Can we respond to my claim?
- 18:41This is about incentive.
- 18:42All right,
- 18:42awesome.
- 18:43So you're arguing that incentive is intrinsic and tied to extrinsic motivation.
- 18:47What we find is that the best.
- 18:48Incentive comes from intrinsic motivation.
- 18:50So a person that's passionate about solving
- 18:52an issue is going to build something bigger
- 18:54than somebody else that's not.
- 18:55Yeah,
- 18:56so,
- 18:56so someone who has a true passion for this.
- 18:58So,
- 18:59so exactly.
- 18:59So profit motivation is not the thing that's driving innovation,
- 19:02right?
- 19:03Psychology,
- 19:03of course,
- 19:04so psychology proves that that's not the case if there's not that profit's
- 19:07not the reason that we have the greatest inventions that we do today.
- 19:09I,
- 19:09I don't know if I disagree with the fact that there's a passion behind it.
- 19:12Are you saying?
- 19:13People with passion,
- 19:14even if there wasn't the incentive to make as much money as they would make,
- 19:18people would still pursue it even with or without money.
- 19:20That's what psychology.
- 19:21Well,
- 19:21your claims are wrong because
- 19:24whoever your psychology professor is,
- 19:26if you look at data and you find out how America,
- 19:29that's only been around for 249 years,
- 19:31schooled all the other countries that have been around
- 19:33for hundreds if not thousands of years more,
- 19:35they did better than others because the incentive accuse was.
- 19:39Related profit right to 1% of the population
- 19:42and continue to produce on that basis,
- 19:44right?
- 19:44We have this,
- 19:45OK,
- 19:45it's not necessarily.
- 19:46Do we wanna,
- 19:46do we want to respond because you can
- 19:48say that you've been interrupting the entire time.
- 19:49So if you're,
- 19:50if you're saying about the 1%
- 19:52are the problem and they're the only ones that make money,
- 19:54a lot of people make money and you said that you
- 19:56can't profit goes to the 1% explaining how it is that,
- 19:59um,
- 19:59America has become the dominant power that it is now,
- 20:02right?
- 20:02What we see
- 20:03is that because
- 20:04We have this engine,
- 20:05right,
- 20:05this desire to accumulate profit,
- 20:06you know,
- 20:07we morally justify things like going to other countries,
- 20:09imperializing them,
- 20:10colonizing them,
- 20:11extracting their resources,
- 20:12right,
- 20:12to funnel our country,
- 20:13right?
- 20:14Social democracies in the Nordic countries don't do this,
- 20:16so yeah,
- 20:16they,
- 20:17they might not be the,
- 20:17the wealthiest power,
- 20:19but they,
- 20:19you know,
- 20:19have higher rates of education,
- 20:21literacy,
- 20:22um,
- 20:23human satisfaction,
- 20:24etc.
- 20:24right?
- 20:25So it depends on what we actually value in a society.
- 20:27Do we value well-being or do we value profit profit.
- 20:30Validates your point.
- 20:31If that's the case,
- 20:33people would move to those states.
- 20:35They don't.
- 20:36When you judge a great restaurant by the amount of people that come in,
- 20:40you can say the food sucks here.
- 20:41You can say the service sucks here that,
- 20:43but everybody's lined up to want to come here.
- 20:45They're not lined up to go into those countries.
- 20:47They're just used by professors as theories.
- 20:49There were millions of people that also lived in Germany in the 1920s.
- 20:52I lived in Germany before as well for two years.
- 20:57My next claim is capitalism has lifted more
- 20:59people out of poverty than any other system.
- 21:05Hey
- 21:05Patrick,
- 21:06how are you?
- 21:06I'm Gabby.
- 21:07Gabby,
- 21:07yeah,
- 21:08good to meet you.
- 21:09So I would argue that governments have actually
- 21:11lifted the most people out of poverty.
- 21:14If you look historically,
- 21:15we look at China,
- 21:16for instance,
- 21:16had the most significant poverty reduction
- 21:19in all of human history.
- 21:21They poured 8,
- 21:21they pulled 800 million people out of poverty
- 21:24using state-owned enterprises and state centralized planning.
- 21:28They did work with the capitalists.
- 21:30System,
- 21:30but they did it,
- 21:31um,
- 21:32most of it was done through state funded infrastructure,
- 21:35education,
- 21:35and contributing to
- 21:37strong literacy programs,
- 21:38redistributing the wealth.
- 21:40I think that my other argument would be
- 21:42that there hasn't been an opportunity for alternative systems like socialism
- 21:47to pull enough people out of poverty.
- 21:49So we look at examples,
- 21:51there hasn't been enough opportunities for them to succeed.
- 21:53And so when we say.
- 21:55I think that is because partly because of the US and I
- 21:58think because capitalist forces and global
- 22:00market insecurities have sabotaged these attempts to
- 22:04do socialism.
- 22:05So we look at an example in Chile,
- 22:07uh,
- 22:07in the 1960s they elected a democratic socialist,
- 22:11and
- 22:11he proposed literacy reform,
- 22:14wealth,
- 22:14uh,
- 22:14redistribution,
- 22:15land reform,
- 22:16and
- 22:17all of that,
- 22:18uh,
- 22:18was a threat obviously to the United.
- 22:19States because McCarthyism was on the rise at the time
- 22:22and so um instead of allowing uh Hollande to to have a chance with that,
- 22:27the US orchestrated a CIA backed coup
- 22:29to take over and to have a military dictatorship
- 22:33that led the country
- 22:34instead of Hollande who actually was having a lot of
- 22:37success in reducing the poverty rates before the US interfered
- 22:40and so I think we look at other parts of Latin America like Venezuela for instance
- 22:44and we see the.
- 22:44Same thing we see that the US has interfered several times,
- 22:47you know,
- 22:47with Chavez in Venezuela,
- 22:49he was able to reduce the poverty reduction in half
- 22:52in the first decade of him being in office,
- 22:54and
- 22:55he was sabotaged ultimately by the US and by a military dictatorship,
- 22:59so that the people that replaced them were actually,
- 23:01so may I respond?
- 23:01It's,
- 23:02it's a lot of different cases here.
- 23:03So let's thank you for that.
- 23:04So,
- 23:05uh,
- 23:05let's go to China first,
- 23:06OK.
- 23:07So when you say China was able to recover and.
- 23:09Because they use state-funded,
- 23:10you know,
- 23:11nationalized systems.
- 23:12So,
- 23:13in 1978,
- 23:14Xiaoping,
- 23:15the leader of China,
- 23:16went to Japan.
- 23:17He saw what was going on with Japan for two decades.
- 23:19Every year,
- 23:20their GDP was grown by 15%.
- 23:22The economy was doubling pretty much every four years.
- 23:24They go over there,
- 23:25they say,
- 23:25we got Find a way to compete with Japan.
- 23:27How do they have fewer people,
- 23:28but they're beating us.
- 23:29They sit down with their leaders after a few drinks.
- 23:31Eventually they say,
- 23:32How did you fix your economy to be
- 23:35growing the way that it is,
- 23:35a capitalistic society that they had in Japan.
- 23:38They asked the question from Xiaoping,
- 23:40uh,
- 23:40the Prime Minister Fukuda,
- 23:41asked the question,
- 23:42How many banks do you guys in have in China?
- 23:45He says,
- 23:45we have one bank.
- 23:47He said,
- 23:47it's a nationalized bank.
- 23:48He says,
- 23:48yeah,
- 23:48that's it?
- 23:49Yeah.
- 23:50How many loan officers do you have?
- 23:51Not many.
- 23:52You wanna compete with one bank?
- 23:53Yes.
- 23:54He says,
- 23:54if you want to compete with us or others,
- 23:57here's what you have to do.
- 23:58You need 5000 banks
- 24:00with 35 branches
- 24:02with 30 loan officers.
- 24:03That's a total of 5.25 million
- 24:06loan officers
- 24:08and a population of 600 million people that are living there.
- 24:11You do that every week.
- 24:12You take 10 applications with these loan officers for small business owners
- 24:16and you allow the small business owner to compete.
- 24:19They did that.
- 24:20China started competing.
- 24:21By the way,
- 24:21in America in the 1920s,
- 24:23we had around 30,000 banks when we were really,
- 24:26you know.
- 24:26Competing in a marketplace.
- 24:27In the 80s,
- 24:28we end up having around
- 24:2914,000.
- 24:30Today,
- 24:30we only have 4100 banks in America.
- 24:32That concept of allowing just one bank to compete,
- 24:36it's not gonna work.
- 24:37China takes on the idea from Japan.
- 24:39They start growing.
- 24:40I mean,
- 24:40I think that they start growing with certain capitalistic philosoph about this in,
- 24:44in very capitalist terms,
- 24:45which makes sense.
- 24:45You're a capitalist,
- 24:46but because it works.
- 24:47That's the idea,
- 24:48because it's produced a result about these scenarios in a situation where
- 24:51market mechanisms are in place,
- 24:53and this is the problem that I have with so many capitalists.
- 24:55Is
- 24:55they can't exit their worldview and try to see
- 24:59a world where socialism um
- 25:01could be in place because
- 25:02they don't understand the untapped potential of socialism and I'm,
- 25:05I'm a democratic socialist.
- 25:06I think that we need to build
- 25:08forward to the towards that um
- 25:09with reforms and I think we need to work with the government.
- 25:12I don't think that we should abandon the state.
- 25:13I also don't think that we should give
- 25:15state elites the complete control over society.
- 25:17I do think that we should
- 25:18work with the state to instill these reforms and then eventually erode capitalism.
- 25:22Unfortunately,
- 25:23socialism has.
- 25:23That hundreds of years you're thinking in terms
- 25:25of to produce results and it hasn't worked.
- 25:27Do you know why it doesn't work though?
- 25:28It's been sabotaged.
- 25:29It's been sabotaged or it's because it forces people
- 25:32to do something they don't want to do.
- 25:33Does capitalism not do the same?
- 25:34No,
- 25:35capitalism there's 7 million people in this country who have to
- 25:38work multiple jobs just to get by to work multiple jobs.
- 25:41They're forced to do that because either they do that or they starve.
- 25:44So if the options are to work or to starve,
- 25:46that's not freedom,
- 25:47that's economic coercion.
- 25:48If you respectfully,
- 25:49if you do that for a period of your life,
- 25:51I understand it.
- 25:52If you're doing that for 30 years,
- 25:54you're doing something wrong.
- 25:55You shouldn't be working multiple jobs for the rest of your life.
- 25:57So
- 25:58first of all,
- 25:58I'm not gonna argue with this moral argument.
- 26:00I think that people who live in poverty,
- 26:02especially when we look at how many people live in poverty in this country,
- 26:05and also it depends on how you define the poverty line,
- 26:07but there's 40 million Americans who live below the poverty line in this country.
- 26:11There's 3 guys in this country that own 40%
- 26:15of the wealth.
- 26:15How does that work in a country that is you really wanna go there?
- 26:19You wanna go there?
- 26:19OK,
- 26:20so let's talk about it.
- 26:21So,
- 26:22when we talk about the rich people at the top,
- 26:24OK,
- 26:24and,
- 26:24and you say,
- 26:25well,
- 26:26the rich don't pay enough taxes,
- 26:27do you know what the bottom 50% of taxpayers in America
- 26:30pay towards the revenue that the government gets in taxes?
- 26:33Do you know,
- 26:33do you know what the bottom 50% pays?
- 26:362% of taxes.
- 26:38Do you know what the top 1% pays?
- 26:40There's been several years.
- 26:41Do you know what the top 1%,
- 26:42do you know?
- 26:43No,
- 26:43no,
- 26:43hang on a second.
- 26:44This is from the IRS.
- 26:45I'm not writing a blog from Huffington Post.
- 26:47This is not Daily Beast.
- 26:48I'm telling you the story.
- 26:49The top 1% pays
- 26:5242% of all tax revenue about to pay,
- 26:55uh,
- 26:55a lot less in taxes because of the provision that just
- 26:58went into paying even more revenue to the big beautiful bill.
- 27:01Yeah,
- 27:02thank you so much.
- 27:02Thank you so much.
- 27:11That was fast.
- 27:12I'm Anne.
- 27:13Anne,
- 27:13good to meet you.
- 27:14Nice to meet you.
- 27:15Um,
- 27:16so I do wanna address
- 27:17part of the claim
- 27:19about poverty,
- 27:19but I also want to address what you brought up about like paying taxes.
- 27:22You said the top 1% pays
- 27:24a large amount of taxes.
- 27:25The problem is,
- 27:26is that
- 27:27the bottom two quintiles
- 27:28can't pay taxes because they quite literally have no wealth.
- 27:31Do you understand that?
- 27:32Like the,
- 27:32the bottom quintile of the United States doesn't have
- 27:35any wealth?
- 27:36In fact,
- 27:36they're in debt,
- 27:37so they have literally like negative wealth.
- 27:39Why do you think that is?
- 27:40I think.
- 27:40That's for a lot of reasons.
- 27:41I think that's because workers have been exploited.
- 27:43I think that they haven't had the opportunity to gain social mobility.
- 27:46Why do you think that is?
- 27:47Because I,
- 27:48because of exploitation.
- 27:49You think they're being exploited?
- 27:51Yes.
- 27:51Oh,
- 27:51so people are being forced to work at companies.
- 27:53They don't have a choice.
- 27:54I didn't say that they were,
- 27:55so people are being,
- 27:56they are,
- 27:57they are being forced.
- 27:58If the other option is starve or die.
- 27:59What job do you have right now?
- 28:00What do you do for a living?
- 28:01I,
- 28:01I do work from home stuff.
- 28:02I don't want to disclose that.
- 28:04So you chose to do that,
- 28:05right?
- 28:05That's your choice.
- 28:06Great.
- 28:06If somebody works at Starbucks for as a barista,
- 28:09it's their choice.
- 28:10If somebody has a job that they're working,
- 28:12it's their choice.
- 28:13If somebody is not utilizing their time properly and accordingly,
- 28:17of course the market's not gonna pay you.
- 28:18Do you think that like they brought up single mothers earlier.
- 28:20Do you think that single mothers are sitting around playing Fortnite 15 hours a day,
- 28:23single mothers were manipulated on what happened that a yes or no.
- 28:27Single mothers were manipulated by
- 28:29what Lyndon Johnson came out where they changed
- 28:31the benefits on giving single mothers the incentive
- 28:34to have kids on all the welfare programs that changed our system in a major way.
- 28:38The feminist movement got single mothers to believe they don't need men,
- 28:41and they're going to do everything by themselves,
- 28:42and
- 28:43they don't need a man to help them out.
- 28:45This division that's happened between us
- 28:47caused many people to be in the situation that they're in.
- 28:49Households are 50/50.
- 28:50They're closer to 50/50.
- 28:52That has nothing to do with feminism.
- 28:53Feminism didn't just like convince women because they're too stupid.
- 28:56Feminism was one of the worst things that happened
- 28:58in America because it pinned men against women.
- 29:00Do you think that women are so stupid that they've been brainwashed?
- 29:04OK,
- 29:04so you don't think.
- 29:04That they've just fallen to this feminist propaganda.
- 29:07You don't think they're they're idiots.
- 29:08No,
- 29:08I don't think that,
- 29:09but I do think
- 29:10people can be manipulated and they're brainwashed stupid enough to
- 29:13do that because the majority of people are splitting narratives.
- 29:15There are so many people that bought into a
- 29:17philosophy that stole decades away from their lives,
- 29:20decades away
- 29:21from their lives,
- 29:22because they bought into an idea that didn't produce the results.
- 29:25What are you talking about?
- 29:27I'm talking about capitalism
- 29:29is the best economical system.
- 29:31That provides the best results for people,
- 29:33but we can't just jump back and forth between claim to claim to claim.
- 29:36So the claim about feminism brainwashing people into being single mothers,
- 29:40how does that,
- 29:40I didn't say,
- 29:41I said feminists
- 29:42originally
- 29:43brainwashed women to believe men are the enemy.
- 29:46That led to where we are today.
- 29:48Last week report came in mothers,
- 29:51yes,
- 29:51in many cases because they don't need men.
- 29:53Do you have evidence for that?
- 29:54You really think a single mother wants to be a single mother?
- 29:56Absolutely we have evidence of that.
- 29:57You think the single mother making minimum wage down the road,
- 30:00like working for some grocery store,
- 30:02having to take care of all of her children is just like I just.
- 30:04I don't need a man.
- 30:05I just want to be independent.
- 30:07What percentage?
- 30:07I live in abject poverty to be the percentage of the US revenue
- 30:10that we get in do you think we use for entitlement programs?
- 30:12What percentage?
- 30:13Um,
- 30:14I don't remember the exact.
- 30:15What do you think the number is?
- 30:16We,
- 30:16so we bring in $4.9 trillion in private spending.
- 30:19We bring $4.9 trillion in.
- 30:21OK.
- 30:21The US revenue comes in.
- 30:23What percentage do you think goes to entitlement programs?
- 30:26I don't know.
- 30:26What do you think is a reasonable number?
- 30:28Well,
- 30:28what you're calling entitlement programs,
- 30:30I'm actually not sure what you mean by that.
- 30:31I'm talking about Social Security.
- 30:32I'm talking about,
- 30:33so social welfare 8.
- 30:34I'm talking about any of these.
- 30:35It's much less than other OECD countries.
- 30:37What percentage do you think?
- 30:38I don't remember the exact percentage,
- 30:39but it's much less than other OECD countries.
- 30:41You think we are 10%,
- 30:42far behind,
- 30:4220%,
- 30:4330%.
- 30:44What do you think the number is?
- 30:45No,
- 30:45but it's relatively low compared to other OECD countries think it is?
- 30:47Can you guess?
- 30:48I don't remember the number off the top
- 30:49of my head.
- 30:50I've 68%.
- 30:52How much more entitlement?
- 30:54You can fact check that.
- 30:55Please do so.
- 30:5668% goes to entitlement programs.
- 30:59No,
- 31:00of,
- 31:00of the revenue that comes in,
- 31:0168% GDP,
- 31:03not GDP.
- 31:04You're,
- 31:04you're confusing the two different things here.
- 31:07Actual tax revenue that we get,
- 31:0968% of it goes towards entitlement programs,
- 31:1368%.
- 31:15Thank you.
- 31:25Hi,
- 31:25how are you?
- 31:26Grace.
- 31:27Yes,
- 31:27Grace.
- 31:28Hi.
- 31:28I want to say that I think it's pretty comical that an elite such as
- 31:31yourself has the goal to tell us average Americans who's in poverty and who's not.
- 31:36A lot of times I was an average American.
- 31:37You're not a guy that was in poverty.
- 31:39You're not anymore.
- 31:39You can you're very,
- 31:40you can also change
- 31:42anyways,
- 31:42you're talking down.
- 31:44A lot of times that
- 31:46the market for poverty is actually
- 31:48very low.
- 31:48So a lot of times like $2 a day is the line for how they measure poverty.
- 31:51That,
- 31:52and that's ridiculous.
- 31:53So.
- 31:53If I make $5 a day,
- 31:54I,
- 31:55I'm not in poverty.
- 31:56I can,
- 31:56I can actually live.
- 31:57I can pay the rent,
- 31:59but we're talking about this country,
- 32:00right?
- 32:00We're not talking about around the world.
- 32:02I,
- 32:02I've noticed that you like to do that.
- 32:03You like to
- 32:04like skirt from America and talk about other countries
- 32:07to try to make it look like we're better,
- 32:08but we're actually getting the greatest country in the world
- 32:11anyways.
- 32:11Oh,
- 32:11it's the greatest country.
- 32:12We're at the,
- 32:13we are at the highest that we've ever been with homelessness
- 32:16since we started collecting data.
- 32:17Ask you,
- 32:18are you from we haven't had a,
- 32:19we haven't had a pay raise since 2009.
- 32:22Our minimum wage nationally is $7.25
- 32:25and you wonder why we have the highest poverty rate.
- 32:27You think that capitalism's winning.
- 32:29Can,
- 32:29can you survive?
- 32:30Would you like to live off $7.25
- 32:33an hour to work for 425 cents at Haagen-Dazs.
- 32:36Then I,
- 32:36and that was a work at Burger King for $4.75.
- 32:39And how much do you make now?
- 32:40Then I want to,
- 32:40I make millions today.
- 32:42Then I work and that's why you like capitalism because we're not all making that.
- 32:45And the difference is,
- 32:46the millionaire is critiquing the people in
- 32:48poverty and saying you should work harder.
- 32:50You should.
- 32:50You should work.
- 32:51You know,
- 32:51you can be me.
- 32:52You can't all be it.
- 32:53My hope is
- 32:54that you believe you can change and improve,
- 32:57that you believe you can upgrade yourself.
- 32:59That's my belief.
- 32:59It's very,
- 33:00you know what,
- 33:00that's what rich people like you want to keep telling us.
- 33:03But you can be just like me.
- 33:04Do you want to be like me?
- 33:05If you work hard enough,
- 33:06I'm not saying be like me.
- 33:07It's not very realistic.
- 33:08It's actually,
- 33:08you wouldn't be able to be like me because you wouldn't work that hard.
- 33:11Would you work that hard?
- 33:12You don't.
- 33:12I'm not gonna tell you.
- 33:13I don't have to answer that if,
- 33:14if you I don't have to measure my,
- 33:17like,
- 33:17I don't have to measure my work ethic to be.
- 33:20You don't have to.
- 33:21Then you can't be upset for others who do so.
- 33:23You can't be upset for people,
- 33:24no,
- 33:25because they work harder than you with capitalism.
- 33:27But go back to the homelessness.
- 33:29Do you live in the state of California?
- 33:31OK.
- 33:32You said homelessness.
- 33:33Do you,
- 33:34do you,
- 33:34what do you think about your governor Newsom?
- 33:36What do you think about him?
- 33:36I don't like him.
- 33:37I'm a progressive.
- 33:38He doesn't do enough for the people.
- 33:39Do you know when he was,
- 33:40he takes corporate money,
- 33:41fantastic from people like when he was,
- 33:43I've never given him money.
- 33:45But do you know when he first became a governor,
- 33:47I would never give him money.
- 33:48But when he became a governor first,
- 33:50when he became a governor first,
- 33:52from then till today,
- 33:53he's raised the amount of homelessness in this state by 36,000 people.
- 33:57He was given 24 billion people.
- 34:01Taxpayers gave him $24 billion.
- 34:03Taxpayers
- 34:04gave him $24 billion and he didn't do nothing with it and it increased.
- 34:09You vote him out.
- 34:09You have him.
- 34:10It's not that it's,
- 34:11but no,
- 34:12I would tell you,
- 34:13you,
- 34:13you can go.
- 34:13You're not much different than him.
- 34:15That's all I'm saying.
- 34:16You're in the same class,
- 34:17but you're,
- 34:17you're,
- 34:18you're,
- 34:18you're sitting here blaming a
- 34:21person who's changed their lives for the better,
- 34:24and it's their fault.
- 34:25My dad was not the United States dad.
- 34:27Patrick.
- 34:27Do you know where the United States of America?
- 34:29I know,
- 34:29and I'm so grateful to be here.
- 34:31I'm so grateful to be here you willing to pay more tax?
- 34:32I am.
- 34:33I am so grateful to be here.
- 34:34Are you willing to pay more taxes?
- 34:35I am so grateful to be here.
- 34:38My,
- 34:38my dad,
- 34:39my dad,
- 34:40my dad was a cashier.
- 34:42In Inglewood at a 99 cent store
- 34:44we had nothing.
- 34:45No,
- 34:45no,
- 34:45I don't tell you that's great.
- 34:46We had nothing.
- 34:48I'm the guy that had,
- 34:49no,
- 34:49no,
- 34:49I'm the guy that had a,
- 34:50I'm the,
- 34:51but what you don't,
- 34:52but what you don't wanna hear is that because it's the truth.
- 34:55Can I ask you a question?
- 34:56When's the last time you read a business book?
- 34:58When's the last time you read a self-help book?
- 35:00When's the last time you read a self-help?
- 35:02Tell me.
- 35:03Tell me what self-help book you read.
- 35:06Give me one.
- 35:07Give me one you read.
- 35:08Are you willing to take one recommendation?
- 35:11No,
- 35:11you're not.
- 35:12Then I can't help you.
- 35:13That's OK.
- 35:13I don't need your help.
- 35:14I didn't come here for your help.
- 35:15You've been flagged out.
- 35:17Awesome.
- 35:27How's it going,
- 35:27man?
- 35:27What's your name?
- 35:29Arman Crow.
- 35:30When you said capitalism
- 35:32is the best form of economic organization the world has ever seen,
- 35:37it made me think of a very particular picture from history.
- 35:40So,
- 35:41I don't know if you know this,
- 35:41it's a little history lesson.
- 35:43In 1900,
- 35:44uh,
- 35:44King Leopold the Second of Belgium,
- 35:46uh,
- 35:46Belgium determined that
- 35:48the entire land of the Democratic Republic of the Congo was his personal property.
- 35:52And within 10 years,
- 35:54um,
- 35:54capitalists came out.
- 35:56They exploited all the land,
- 35:58extracted trillions of dollars of resources.
- 36:0015 million Congolese died.
- 36:03For reference,
- 36:03the Holocaust killed 6 million people.
- 36:06And
- 36:07the most famous picture from that time in history
- 36:09is a rubber worker.
- 36:11Uh,
- 36:12staring at the disembodied hands of his eight year old daughter
- 36:16because he didn't hit his rubber quota.
- 36:17I'm willing to bet that man worked harder
- 36:20to hit that rubber quota
- 36:21than anything you've ever worked for in your entire life.
- 36:24And I think when you say this is the best system that's ever been created,
- 36:27to me,
- 36:27that's the result.
- 36:28That's what happens when there's no rules.
- 36:29It's devastating when you hear stories like that.
- 36:31I don't disagree with you.
- 36:32They had it hard.
- 36:33They worked very hard,
- 36:34and they had risk on the line.
- 36:36Many times it was their lives that was on the line.
- 36:39Uh,
- 36:39and you see that in many different places when you go back and study history.
- 36:43That's why today in America,
- 36:45that can't happen.
- 36:46In America,
- 36:47you have a choice to do what you want to do with your life.
- 36:49When we go back and look at those stories,
- 36:50we can go to see what communism did,
- 36:52how many lives were
- 36:54killed because of communism control.
- 36:55You,
- 36:56you don't need to go through that number.
- 36:57You're.
- 36:58The numbers between 60 to 100 million
- 36:59we can go that route,
- 37:00but if you're talking about
- 37:02which provided the best economical system
- 37:05today,
- 37:05you judge it
- 37:06by how many
- 37:07want to go live somewhere that gives you that opportunity,
- 37:10and that is America.
- 37:11Do you know why kids can't work in America?
- 37:13Why kids can't work in America?
- 37:15Why there's child labor laws.
- 37:16Yeah,
- 37:17because of child labor laws.
- 37:18It was labor unions.
- 37:19They were getting shot at by police officers to fight for the weekend,
- 37:22to fight for the 40 hour work week.
- 37:24Another good example is the 1908
- 37:26ill children's strike.
- 37:28It was thousands of kids who were working 80 hour work weeks,
- 37:31striking so they would only have to work 50 a week.
- 37:34That's what happens when there's no rules,
- 37:35right?
- 37:36And then the government had to come in and say you can't employ children.
- 37:39So I think
- 37:40capitalism,
- 37:41we don't disagree here with that.
- 37:42I don't think we're sitting here talking about child labor.
- 37:45Are you hearing me talking about capitalism is the best system because
- 37:48it provides child labor in America?
- 37:50I'm saying that capitalism,
- 37:51there's no guardrails inherently.
- 37:52The government has to come in.
- 37:54People have to go and organize,
- 37:56and I think what you've seen for the past 50
- 37:57years under neoliberal politics is that's slowly being chipped away.
- 38:01All the good things of the New Deal,
- 38:02like Social Security,
- 38:03the 40 hour work law and order.
- 38:04I do think you need law and order,
- 38:06but also at times.
- 38:07You know,
- 38:07the,
- 38:08the,
- 38:08the amount of rules you put in place
- 38:11can prevent incentives.
- 38:12Right now,
- 38:12if you think about drones,
- 38:14warfare is changing,
- 38:15OK,
- 38:16and 70 to 80% of all drones that are being built today
- 38:20are being built by a company called DJI
- 38:22in China.
- 38:23Ukraine was building 1000 drones a day at $500
- 38:27and going and hitting $5 million equipment of Russia,
- 38:30destroying them.
- 38:3068% of their attacks was from drones.
- 38:33When you come to America,
- 38:34look at us,
- 38:35we're at 1 to 2% at the top.
- 38:37Let me explain my point to you here.
- 38:38Part of it is over-regulation.
- 38:40Over-regulation,
- 38:41FAA laws,
- 38:42this laws,
- 38:43that loss of 500 startups
- 38:45that got into the drone business,
- 38:46they walked a bit because it's over-regulation.
- 38:49Many cases,
- 38:50when you say,
- 38:51I want to put this rule in place,
- 38:52great.
- 38:52Another person,
- 38:53no,
- 38:53I want to go this much.
- 38:54No,
- 38:54no,
- 38:54I wanna go this much.
- 38:55No,
- 38:55no,
- 38:55I wanna go this much.
- 38:56It eventually gets to the point.
- 38:57It chokes the innovator,
- 38:59and that's also not good.
- 39:00I would disagree.
- 39:01I think regulation is the reason why there's no lead in our gas.
- 39:04You were talking about incentives.
- 39:05The only incentive that really matters to a good capitalist is profit.
- 39:08It is profitable to put lead in the gas,
- 39:10and it doesn't matter if it
- 39:12lowers the IQs of kids living nearby by
- 39:15convince points you.
- 39:15Someone's unfortunately,
- 39:16someone's convinced you at a young age.
- 39:19That these capitalists are bad people,
- 39:22that they're terrible human beings.
- 39:22Why are they fighting against taking lead out of their gas?
- 39:24Think,
- 39:25think about it this way,
- 39:26you know,
- 39:26the,
- 39:26the main thing,
- 39:27I don't know if you know Michael Burry,
- 39:28have you ever seen the movie Big Short,
- 39:30you know,
- 39:30at the end of the movie where it says
- 39:31Michael Burry now is focused on water because he thinks
- 39:34water is the future of gold or whatever he calls it,
- 39:36right?
- 39:36OK.
- 39:37Go to the company that's Coca-Cola
- 39:40that sells Coke,
- 39:40and how much criticism have you had over the years with Coke,
- 39:43right?
- 39:43I think Nestle's had a lot of criticism because they don't think water.
- 39:46As a human right
- 39:46for the that's a,
- 39:47that's a different conversation.
- 39:48If I may finish the point.
- 39:50One thing with Coca-Cola is the following.
- 39:51Do you know,
- 39:52even Coke
- 39:53got to a point
- 39:54that they realized in order for Coca-Cola to be around
- 39:5850 years from now,
- 39:59100 years from now,
- 40:01they went and invested billions of dollars to fix the water issue around the world.
- 40:05They're trying to get cleaner water.
- 40:06Capitalists eventually get forced to take care of the person
- 40:09because having lead in the water is just not a good policy long term,
- 40:12OK.
- 40:13My next claim is if all the money in the world were divided equally,
- 40:17it would return to the same pockets within 5 years.
- 40:25What's your name?
- 40:25Caleb.
- 40:26Caleb,
- 40:27yeah,
- 40:27so you just said that you're proposing if we
- 40:30divided all the wealth equally in like 5 years,
- 40:34how would you
- 40:34propose we divide the wealth in that way in this thought experiment again,
- 40:37if we're going to give it a serious
- 40:40look,
- 40:40I want to understand how would you propose that happens.
- 40:42I hope you realize this is just a
- 40:45question we're asking everybody,
- 40:46right?
- 40:46But if you take all the wealth,
- 40:47which is around $500 trillion
- 40:49OK,
- 40:49give or take.
- 40:50You divide it by 8 billion people,
- 40:53it would be around $62,500 each.
- 40:57Within 5 years,
- 40:58the people that don't know how to handle money themselves,
- 41:00they would lose it all,
- 41:02and within 5 years,
- 41:03the same wealthy would get the same amount of money.
- 41:05As someone who certainly doesn't make that much money,
- 41:08I'm willing to take that as a gamble just for fun.
- 41:10I'll be honest,
- 41:11but at the same time,
- 41:12like,
- 41:12OK,
- 41:13so you're just now claiming
- 41:14that people
- 41:15who don't have wealth don't know how to manage it.
- 41:17And that's fair because a lot of them have never had it before.
- 41:20So,
- 41:21what do we do to basically ensure that people like myself who are currently,
- 41:25thank you to the United States,
- 41:27thank you to the state of California for
- 41:29giving me medical insurance to get blood work,
- 41:31for giving me food stamps so I can have food.
- 41:33I've applied to,
- 41:34I don't know how.
- 41:35Many hundreds of jobs.
- 41:36I can show you the receipts.
- 41:37I can show you
- 41:39the email confirmations.
- 41:40Like,
- 41:40I am trying my best
- 41:42to use my values with the freedom that we have.
- 41:44So if I gave you a job,
- 41:45you would work 40 hours a week.
- 41:46If the job is in alignment with something that's noble and good,
- 41:50I think I could.
- 41:50The issue is,
- 41:51and again,
- 41:52You,
- 41:53you may say that this is a personal weakness,
- 41:55but like right now,
- 41:56substitute teaching,
- 41:57tutoring,
- 41:58trying to help in that way
- 41:59is making it so that I'm able to scratch by.
- 42:02But without the supplemental income and the help
- 42:05from
- 42:06the society of people who make more money,
- 42:08I'm gonna not have enough food.
- 42:09I want to address something which you,
- 42:11you made a point that I agree with,
- 42:13uh,
- 42:13uh,
- 42:13on why don't,
- 42:14why don't some people create wealth.
- 42:16In my family when I was growing up and I was telling this young lady over here.
- 42:19Well,
- 42:19my dad was a cashier at a 99 cent store.
- 42:22We've never owned an insurance policy before.
- 42:24My parents,
- 42:24we've never owned a house before.
- 42:26I've never lived in an apartment with a swimming pool before.
- 42:29We've never had a 401k stock mutual fund,
- 42:31none of that stuff.
- 42:32I had no clue how money worked.
- 42:34So for me,
- 42:34when I got out of the army with a 1.8 GPA
- 42:37out of high school,
- 42:37I went straight to the army
- 42:39because I didn't know how money works.
- 42:40If you look at our system today,
- 42:42In high school
- 42:43we learn about a lot of different things.
- 42:45They don't teach us about taxes,
- 42:46finances,
- 42:46mutual funds,
- 42:47stocks bonds.
- 42:48Colleges don't even teach a lot of that right now.
- 42:50So you come out of high school.
- 42:51Did I work at a high school?
- 42:52Have you,
- 42:52have you have experience like me,
- 42:54someone who's essentially on those front lines working in I've,
- 42:57I've worked with many high school teachers and the
- 42:59directors of psychology to talk to the youth.
- 43:02Yes,
- 43:02I have right now I'm in a position where I have options like you said.
- 43:07I do have some options,
- 43:08but they seem to be somewhat destructive and exploitative of me,
- 43:12of my peers.
- 43:14So I'm trying to think you're too selective for jobs right now.
- 43:16You don't,
- 43:16you don't have the ability to be selective.
- 43:18At this stage,
- 43:19well,
- 43:19but the thing is I do because I'm instilled
- 43:21with a freedom that is maybe God universe given,
- 43:24and I don't actually have to because of the system,
- 43:26like you said,
- 43:27I don't have to play along with some corrupt game.
- 43:30So I gave up.
- 43:30I think California is perfect for someone like you.
- 43:33Well,
- 43:33thank thankfully California agrees,
- 43:36but you,
- 43:36you mentioned earlier in a previous discussion that we have free speech,
- 43:39we can say what we want,
- 43:40right?
- 43:40But the thing is,
- 43:41have you been punched on the train?
- 43:43For how you look and how you,
- 43:45how you share your ideas,
- 43:46do,
- 43:46do you,
- 43:46do I look like an American to you?
- 43:48Do you see this nose?
- 43:49I'm Middle Eastern.
- 43:50You know what's happened to this guy?
- 43:51You know what's happened to me when I was discriminated all over the place.
- 43:55But no,
- 43:55but,
- 43:56but I don't mind it.
- 43:57I don't,
- 43:57I,
- 43:57I don't under I don't mind it because I understand there is a risk
- 44:01that you may be disrespected.
- 44:03They're like,
- 44:03here,
- 44:03I've been disrespected here many times.
- 44:05I've been offended here many times.
- 44:06A lot of you are coming here.
- 44:08Finding a way to attack me and tell different stories,
- 44:10I'm OK with that.
- 44:11That's you.
- 44:11You're being very respectful.
- 44:12I'm not talking about you,
- 44:13but what I'm saying to you is,
- 44:15when you say,
- 44:15Have you ever been punched in the face on a bus,
- 44:18you don't wanna hear about what things have happened to me because of the way I look,
- 44:21but I don't wanna use that.
- 44:22You've been through a lot of trauma.
- 44:23I don't want your life.
- 44:24But what I,
- 44:25and now you're kind of clinging to things.
- 44:27I'm not.
- 44:27What I don't wanna do that,
- 44:29I have my son is sitting right here,
- 44:30my 13-year-old son,
- 44:31my 4 year,
- 44:31uh,
- 44:32I have 4 kids.
- 44:32I bring him.
- 44:34I want them to see that it's OK.
- 44:36People are going to disagree with you.
- 44:37You have to be comfortable with this year olds all the time.
- 44:40You are with 13 year olds all the time because of my job,
- 44:43because I'm a substitute teacher and a tutor.
- 44:44The thing is,
- 44:45you can imply many different things,
- 44:47and that is your right.
- 44:48But what I'm saying is right now,
- 44:50I care deeply about having a good experience.
- 44:53The incentive that I feel is for peace and prosperity.
- 44:56I respect it.
- 44:56And,
- 44:56and again,
- 44:57I'm using my free.
- 44:58Now,
- 44:58but the issue is you're saying we have all these options.
- 45:00But whenever I tour the globe,
- 45:02I see franchises that have monopolized pretty much everywhere.
- 45:06So when you talk about options,
- 45:07it's really,
- 45:08there's these select few people
- 45:09who have this infrastructure that's really benefiting them more than others.
- 45:13And
- 45:14without some sort of conscious spiritual,
- 45:16moral awakening,
- 45:17what can we do except for beg
- 45:20and appeal and amass you can't be too selective.
- 45:23At the beginning when I worked at Haagen-Dazs,
- 45:26I couldn't be too selective for a job.
- 45:27I can't whenever I can.
- 45:29It's a choice.
- 45:31Thank you so much.
- 45:32Appreciate you for being respectful.
- 45:41I'm glad y'all tripped over each other because I did too.
- 45:44How's it going,
- 45:44James?
- 45:45James.
- 45:45So
- 45:46one of the things that you have stated is that we have options.
- 45:50OK,
- 45:51so just to give you a little bit of my background,
- 45:53um,
- 45:53I come from a divorced family.
- 45:56And we lived below the poverty level from the time that I was born,
- 46:01uh,
- 46:01until now,
- 46:02frankly,
- 46:03um,
- 46:03so I'm one of those people
- 46:05that you're talking about that,
- 46:06uh,
- 46:07isn't pulling themselves up by their bootstraps enough,
- 46:09which like,
- 46:10I didn't have boots to begin with,
- 46:11and like,
- 46:12I don't know if you've ever had
- 46:13boots,
- 46:14but like legs are load bearing structures
- 46:17and like you can't really pull up a boot when you're wearing it,
- 46:19you know.
- 46:20So
- 46:22where exactly am I failing.
- 46:24When I am working 80 hours a week,
- 46:27I am taking the only jobs that will hire me.
- 46:29I have put in
- 46:31477 applications over the last 2.5 years,
- 46:34not even gotten a call back once.
- 46:36Why do you think?
- 46:37You tell me you're,
- 46:38you're a job creator,
- 46:38but I don't know your resume.
- 46:39You know your life better than I do.
- 46:41Why do you think you have not gotten a callback on 477?
- 46:43Because
- 46:44I a lot of do not have a degree.
- 46:46OK,
- 46:46because I do not have a degree because I could not afford one.
- 46:49OK.
- 46:49I live in an area where the
- 46:52physical job.
- 46:53The market is very limiting.
- 46:55Where do you live?
- 46:56Uh,
- 46:56I live in rural Texas.
- 46:57OK.
- 46:57So in that,
- 46:59like in the town that I grew up in,
- 47:00for instance,
- 47:01there are 8 jobs,
- 47:03period.
- 47:04Does all,
- 47:04does your family live there,
- 47:05Mom,
- 47:06dad,
- 47:06everybody's in that same city?
- 47:07Uh,
- 47:08everybody was at one point.
- 47:09OK.
- 47:09Most of them are dead now.
- 47:10OK,
- 47:10sorry to hear.
- 47:11Yeah,
- 47:11it is what it is.
- 47:13It's poverty,
- 47:14you know,
- 47:14we're kind of used to that on this side.
- 47:16Um,
- 47:16why do you,
- 47:17why do you feel like you're a victim?
- 47:19Why do you feel like you're a victim?
- 47:20Why do you feel like the way you speak,
- 47:21like,
- 47:22you know,
- 47:22you,
- 47:23you're the victim where all this happened to you?
- 47:26Because I exist and
- 47:28things happen to you,
- 47:30and as such things happen,
- 47:31and that's why I say that they happen to me.
- 47:33Good looking guy.
- 47:34Why do you think you're a victim?
- 47:36Why do you think you're somebody that's got into a
- 47:38situation because it's not fair what happened to me?
- 47:41Let me,
- 47:41let me give you a couple options.
- 47:42Are you open to leaving the city you're in?
- 47:44I've already left it.
- 47:45So what city?
- 47:46I've left multiple cities.
- 47:47So if somebody else gave you a job in a different place,
- 47:49you'd be willing to move there,
- 47:51OK,
- 47:51on your resume.
- 47:52On your resume,
- 47:53what,
- 47:53what do you have on your resume?
- 47:54Skill set?
- 47:55What do you offer?
- 47:56Uh,
- 47:57transportation expertise,
- 47:58logistics expertise.
- 47:59You consider yourself a hard worker.
- 48:01I mean,
- 48:01I,
- 48:01I feel like 80 hours a week.
- 48:03That's a hard worker.
- 48:05How about we do this?
- 48:05How about I
- 48:06interview and I give you a job.
- 48:08Would you move to Fort Lauderdale?
- 48:10Oh man,
- 48:10how's Florida?
- 48:11Why not?
- 48:12Would you move to Fort Lauderdale?
- 48:13Why not?
- 48:13How about you and I document this after this,
- 48:15you come,
- 48:15I do an interview with you,
- 48:16and I give you a job,
- 48:17and let's see what you do 90 days later.
- 48:19OK.
- 48:20Let me,
- 48:20and I'll,
- 48:21I'll look up your company and all that kind of stuff,
- 48:22and I'll see it.
- 48:23But you see what just happened right there.
- 48:24But watch what you just did.
- 48:26You just said
- 48:27you.
- 48:28Fly to 477 companies who's not gone back to you.
- 48:32A business owner
- 48:33who's hiring aggressively just made an offer to you.
- 48:37You said you're willing to move.
- 48:38Then you said,
- 48:39I'll look at it.
- 48:40You became selective.
- 48:41I didn't say,
- 48:41I'll look at it if you'd let me finish my sentence.
- 48:43Go ahead.
- 48:43I wanna hear it.
- 48:44I would like to look into your company to see exactly what you guys do.
- 48:48You would like to,
- 48:49because I don't know what you guys do.
- 48:51So as far as I'm concerned,
- 48:52I may be wasting my time going if you guys are a finance company,
- 48:55if you guys are a bank or something like that.
- 48:57I don't have the certifications.
- 48:58I don't have the degrees.
- 49:00So even interviewing me would be if I gave you a job period to work 80 hours a week.
- 49:05Would you take it
- 49:06and I paid you a reasonable wage?
- 49:08Are we talking a livable wage or a reasonable wage?
- 49:10And whose version of reasonable are we talking about?
- 49:12Your version of reasonable or my version of reasonable But you see,
- 49:14so now for me,
- 49:15what I'm noticing from you is,
- 49:17is I need specifics.
- 49:18No,
- 49:18no,
- 49:18not necessarily.
- 49:19No,
- 49:19most of the people I hired need specifics.
- 49:21They're different.
- 49:22I'm trying to hire them
- 49:24in this instance.
- 49:25You're trying to get a job and you're being selective.
- 49:27It's gonna work against you.
- 49:28I mean,
- 49:28I'm not trying to get a job.
- 49:29Originally I was trying to ask you where the moral failure was
- 49:32off the table because you're gonna be difficult to work with.
- 49:34OK,
- 49:34sure,
- 49:34but my question was,
- 49:36where is my moral failing.
- 49:38Like,
- 49:38where is it that you are saying that I am not working hard enough
- 49:42and I am not doing I just experienced it right now because you,
- 49:44the way you just handled the situation,
- 49:47so I should accept anything that somebody gives me
- 49:49at first blush if it is a guaranteed thing.
- 49:51No,
- 49:52not necessarily.
- 49:52I agreed today.
- 49:53I agreed to do your interview.
- 49:54I agreed to be interviewed by you and you agreed to,
- 49:56to consider me for hiring.
- 49:58So therefore,
- 49:59I am taking that opportunity.
- 50:00I've chosen to,
- 50:01but because I am asking you for specifics,
- 50:04your immediate reaction is that,
- 50:06oh well,
- 50:06you're trying to be picky
- 50:07when I'm not.
- 50:08I'm asking specifics.
- 50:09I,
- 50:10you could have said I said I need to look up your company.
- 50:11That's all I said.
- 50:12I have said is I'm willing to have the interview,
- 50:14and I did.
- 50:14You would have had the interview,
- 50:15and I did.
- 50:16No,
- 50:16you said it depends.
- 50:17I don't know.
- 50:18Let me look.
- 50:18Yeah,
- 50:19sure,
- 50:19I would look into your company.
- 50:20That's all I said.
- 50:20I appreciate you.
- 50:21Thank you,
- 50:22James.
- 50:27Hi,
- 50:28I'm Fayy,
- 50:29yeah,
- 50:29nice to meet you.
- 50:30So how would you define socialism because I think
- 50:33you're kind of misunderstanding what anti-capitalist ideals look like.
- 50:37I think we are just trying to advocate for basic rights
- 50:41for our people in this country and across the world.
- 50:43Of course,
- 50:44but I don't think it's
- 50:46necessarily about equal wealth disparity around around the
- 50:49world for most people that are anti-capitalists.
- 50:51I think it's more about just standard rights that are provided by the government,
- 50:55standard rights that are provided by the government.
- 50:58OK,
- 50:59great.
- 51:00Yeah,
- 51:02so
- 51:02go a little bit deeper.
- 51:03So for you,
- 51:03when,
- 51:04when the claim here is
- 51:05If the money in the world were divided equally,
- 51:07it will return to the same pockets within 5 years.
- 51:10Do you disagree?
- 51:11Yes.
- 51:12Tell me why you disagree.
- 51:13Yeah,
- 51:13so I disagree because I don't even think many people are trying to argue for that.
- 51:18People are not trying to like,
- 51:19who are you arguing in this
- 51:21debate?
- 51:21What I'm trying to,
- 51:22there's like a very select amount of people that
- 51:24are trying to argue for equal wealth disparity.
- 51:26Most people are at least trying to at least advocate
- 51:30for wealth
- 51:31and at all for people that have
- 51:33that don't.
- 51:33Have access to healthcare right now that don't
- 51:35have access to a good education right now,
- 51:38that don't have access to their basic needs
- 51:40like food.
- 51:41Do you think our system right now allows
- 51:43people to stay in those situations long term?
- 51:46They force them to stay in those situations long term.
- 51:48OK,
- 51:49so part of me actually agrees with you,
- 51:50but why do you think they force them to stay in those
- 51:53situations long term?
- 51:54I think because they are trying to convince
- 51:56the working class that they don't have rights.
- 51:58I actually don't think that's what it is,
- 52:00although that's fair to your point here.
- 52:01What's the chances that any of you here voted for Donald Trump in 2024?
- 52:06Exactly right?
- 52:07What is the,
- 52:08what is the chances that all of you here can't stand the phrase MAGA,
- 52:12Donald Trump,
- 52:12any of that stuff?
- 52:13Is that a fair assessment?
- 52:14Fair.
- 52:15OK,
- 52:16so,
- 52:16so think about it this way.
- 52:17So
- 52:18maybe you're right that the Democratic Party
- 52:20that's been earning your vote for a long
- 52:22time wants to keep you there because they'll have your vote for the rest of.
- 52:25Vote.
- 52:25They have never earned my vote.
- 52:26Who did you vote for in 2024?
- 52:28In 2004,
- 52:29I voted for the socialist candidate.
- 52:30Who was that?
- 52:31Claudia de la Cruz,
- 52:32I believe.
- 52:33Who did you vote for in 2020?
- 52:34Um,
- 52:34I was actually
- 52:36not able to vote.
- 52:37I was in a hospital.
- 52:39Oh,
- 52:39I'm so sorry,
- 52:40yes,
- 52:40because of results of capitalism.
- 52:42Tell me more.
- 52:42Yeah,
- 52:43so I didn't have access to proper health care
- 52:45or even access to a proper job that would.
- 52:48Sustain me as a disabled person.
- 52:50Are you comfortable being specific on what happened?
- 52:53You don't have to.
- 52:53I mean,
- 52:54I'm also mentally ill,
- 52:55so that was something I had to deal with.
- 52:57But um,
- 52:57I'm mainly mentally ill because I am disabled in a capitalist country.
- 53:01Tell me more about mentally ill.
- 53:03Who qualified you as somebody that's mentally ill?
- 53:05Um,
- 53:05me and my doctor team.
- 53:08Who,
- 53:08who,
- 53:09who convinced you that you're mentally ill?
- 53:12Um,
- 53:12me and my doctor team.
- 53:14What's the specific,
- 53:14uh,
- 53:15category
- 53:16of mental illness?
- 53:17Is there one?
- 53:18You know why I asked this question.
- 53:19Let me explain to you why I asked this question.
- 53:20I don't even like the psychological industry.
- 53:23I don't really stand for like Sigmund Freudian politics or anything like that.
- 53:27So
- 53:27if you're gonna debate the,
- 53:29the,
- 53:29um,
- 53:30ethics of psychology,
- 53:31where I'm going with this is going back to the same
- 53:33thing with if the money were to divide it equally,
- 53:35it'll end up being worked out within 5 years.
- 53:37My trouble is
- 53:39in many cases.
- 53:41Somebody you and I look up to
- 53:43will say something to us that we choose to believe for the rest of our lives.
- 53:47Unfortunately it could be something where you have ADHD,
- 53:51you're mentally ill,
- 53:52you're poor,
- 53:53you're this,
- 53:53you're that,
- 53:54and we get to choose to buy into that or not.
- 53:57And if you do,
- 53:58so you're saying I'm not mentally ill or I'm not disabled you are or you're not.
- 54:02I would challenge you to go a little bit deeper
- 54:03to see if there's anything you can do about it.
- 54:05So you're asking me about my health.
- 54:07You're asking me about my disability and my,
- 54:09I will say we are in a market where,
- 54:12stay with me here,
- 54:13there is a market where there's profit to convince you to have,
- 54:16you have.
- 54:17Issues to take the medication
- 54:18because they're making money,
- 54:19but I don't have access to the medication.
- 54:21I don't have access to even a result or a solution
- 54:25to my disability as someone with a connective tissue disorder.
- 54:28It's genetic.
- 54:29Have you been able to go to different doctors and get yourself tested and see?
- 54:33You have.
- 54:34Yes,
- 54:35in California.
- 54:36Yes,
- 54:36but not enough.
- 54:37I can't find a specialist.
- 54:39You can't find.
- 54:40I can't find a specialist for who I am
- 54:41in your life that's I can't find anyone specialist.
- 54:44Well,
- 54:44they could if or they would if they had money.
- 54:47But
- 54:47would you be OK if I pay for a specialist for you to go see?
- 54:51Would you take money from a capitalist to help you go see a specialist?
- 54:53I mean,
- 54:54yeah,
- 54:54sure,
- 54:55I'm gonna have you go see two.
- 54:56What do you,
- 54:56do you live in California?
- 54:58I'm gonna have you go see two specialists,
- 54:59but would you also be open to
- 55:01seeing somebody else I choose as a psychologist that may,
- 55:04no,
- 55:05you're not.
- 55:05No.
- 55:06So you,
- 55:06you choose as a psychologist,
- 55:08you're choosing who gets to determine what my mental health looks like.
- 55:11No,
- 55:12no,
- 55:12OK
- 55:13then,
- 55:13I wish you nothing but the best,
- 55:15yeah,
- 55:15so I think.
- 55:17All right,
- 55:18thanks for talking so much.
- 55:19Yes,
- 55:19anytime.
- 55:26How are you doing,
- 55:26man?
- 55:27What's your name?
- 55:27Seth.
- 55:28Seth,
- 55:28good to meet you.
- 55:29Uh,
- 55:29I think your claim
- 55:30kind of doesn't make any sense because it would
- 55:32not inherently be a capitalist society you're describing,
- 55:35because I'm surprised nobody's really addressed this issue.
- 55:38We haven't even defined what socialism is.
- 55:40Capitalism is a,
- 55:41is a
- 55:42system in which
- 55:43all businesses are funded by millionaires and billionaires,
- 55:45investor classes.
- 55:46If this society,
- 55:47everybody had the same amount of money,
- 55:49I don't really know how the money would be generated up and down.
- 55:51I don't know
- 55:52in this theoretical,
- 55:53it sounds more like an anarchist society,
- 55:54which.
- 55:56It would make more sense.
- 55:56You know,
- 55:57we're using this as a hypothetical,
- 55:58but I wanna make sure I qualify that we're not,
- 56:00we haven't even describe what capitalism is,
- 56:02but stay on this point here because you came here.
- 56:04Let me go back to this one.
- 56:05If all the money in the world divided equally,
- 56:07it would return to the same pockets within 5 years.
- 56:10Do you agree or disagree?
- 56:11Well,
- 56:11I disagree.
- 56:12Tell me why you dis I believe in a system more akin to that kind of system.
- 56:15I think that a system where people with more
- 56:17wealth inequality,
- 56:18do you know why the wealth would go back to the same
- 56:20people and the same people at the bottom would be poor?
- 56:23Why do you think it would?
- 56:24Well,
- 56:24it.
- 56:24It wouldn't go back to the same thing or
- 56:26places because I don't think that we have an inherent
- 56:28equal starting point in the beginning.
- 56:30But this is a starting point.
- 56:31What I'm saying to you is if that's what I'm saying why it wouldn't go
- 56:34to the same places because we have never even tested some sort of free market.
- 56:37We've never seen any sort of system akin to that,
- 56:40a genuine free market,
- 56:41not one that's distorted by capitalists,
- 56:43by business owners.
- 56:44Capitalists generally protect their own,
- 56:46their own class.
- 56:46That's why people rise to the top.
- 56:48Yes,
- 56:48I absolutely don't know about that.
- 56:49I actually think it's a very competitive place to be.
- 56:52No,
- 56:52there's not.
- 56:53No,
- 56:53people start at the very bottom.
- 56:54They have no shot to even.
- 56:55Do you know why
- 56:56I make the claim of if all the money in the world were divided equally,
- 57:00would return to the same pockets within 5 years?
- 57:02I'm assuming that you think that because people work harder or something like that,
- 57:04but I would,
- 57:05I would argue the people that work the hardest,
- 57:06the people that make the least amount of money.
- 57:08The people that
- 57:09work the least,
- 57:09live on their yachts are the ones that are owning all
- 57:11this company have never been inside the businesses that they own.
- 57:13I don't know if I agree with that.
- 57:14I,
- 57:15I was just in Arkansas 3 days ago.
- 57:17The richest.
- 57:17I was just in Arkansas a week ago,
- 57:19and I went to a city called Hot Springs,
- 57:20Arkansas.
- 57:21It was a,
- 57:22uh,
- 57:23two friends from high school started a windows company,
- 57:25250 employees.
- 57:27The city loves them.
- 57:28They work their tails off,
- 57:30but I'm talking about,
- 57:31but many big businesses started small.
- 57:33Walmart wasn't big day one.
- 57:35Walmart was small when it first got started.
- 57:36Why are they still a monopoly?
- 57:38Because they,
- 57:38they exist.
- 57:39They're not a monopoly.
- 57:39Amazon has taken a big share away from them oligopoly,
- 57:42whatever.
- 57:43They own a large market share because their ability to.
- 57:47Use their money to know how many jobs they've created around the world.
- 57:50Walmart does.
- 57:51I'm we're not,
- 57:51I'm not even referring to 3 million jobs worldwide.
- 57:54The point being is they distort capitalists distort the market so it's unfree.
- 57:57How could it be a free market if everybody in the,
- 57:59in the market
- 58:00inherently wants to make an unfree because they want to rise to the top.
- 58:03I'm watching.
- 58:04If everybody has
- 58:05the incentive to maintain a free market,
- 58:07then that,
- 58:07that's something that.
- 58:08So let me go back.
- 58:09The reason why I said if all the money in the world were divided equally,
- 58:11it would return to the same pockets within 5 years.
- 58:14To me.
- 58:15It's
- 58:16because of market value,
- 58:17what value you bring to the place,
- 58:19your contacts,
- 58:20your relationship,
- 58:21how hard you're working,
- 58:22all of those combined,
- 58:23habits that you have in place,
- 58:24habits that you have in place,
- 58:26and also habits at the bottom.
- 58:27The habits at the bottom are not long-term thinking,
- 58:29it's short term.
- 58:31When I didn't have any money and I was,
- 58:32I was broke $49,000
- 58:34if I had $500 to my name,
- 58:36we're driving on the freeway to go to Vegas to party for the weekend and come back.
- 58:40If I had a penny to my name,
- 58:41I'm having a blast
- 58:42until 25 years old,
- 58:44I changed my habits financially.
- 58:46Then things changed.
- 58:47But this point here that we're talking about with the,
- 58:50some people are so far off from that point.
- 58:51They're so far in debt that small decisions would not alter.
- 58:54It's not true.
- 58:55Yes,
- 58:55absolutely,
- 58:55it's not true.
- 58:56That's not,
- 58:57that's you.
- 58:57You're just privileged and you've lived in a certain example I'm privileged.
- 59:00I'm privileged.
- 59:01You're privileged to become a millionaire because of your hard work.
- 59:04That's,
- 59:04that's amazing.
- 59:04That's,
- 59:05that's my mom ran out of money and went back to Iran.
- 59:07You're talking to a guy that would have done 20 years in the army if.
- 59:11One guy doesn't call me.
- 59:13If one guy would have called me to government funding you,
- 59:15I understand that,
- 59:16and I joined the army because I had given up on life.
- 59:19No,
- 59:19no,
- 59:19I had,
- 59:20I was not confident on what I could do,
- 59:22but I changed.
- 59:23So can you.
- 59:24Look at the way you're speaking to me.
- 59:26Do you know somebody like,
- 59:27do you know somebody like you?
- 59:28Do you know somebody like you that speak,
- 59:29speaks this eloquently?
- 59:31If somebody gets a hold of you in real estate,
- 59:33insurance,
- 59:33finance,
- 59:34you can learn how to sell
- 59:35and you can make some real good money.
- 59:36Somebody like you that I'm watching,
- 59:37everybody's born I think.
- 59:39You have to be like
- 59:40somebody who's white,
- 59:41tall,
- 59:426'4,
- 59:42whatever.
- 59:43I'm Middle Eastern.
- 59:44I'm from Iran.
- 59:45Do you realize a lot of stuff that goes against me?
- 59:48OK,
- 59:48but many people have no choice to but that's an excuse language to be making.
- 59:51That's not a language.
- 59:52If you never have the opportunity to compete because you're pre-designed.
- 59:56I appreciate you being respectful.
- 59:57Truly you need to know that.
- 59:58So I,
- 59:58and I,
- 59:59I'll be respectful to everybody,
- 1:00:00but I appreciate you for being respectful right now.
- 1:00:02Everybody that's here,
- 1:00:03me changing your mind,
- 1:00:05it's not a very high likelihood,
- 1:00:06OK.
- 1:00:07The audience that's watching,
- 1:00:0840% of them
- 1:00:10are gonna agree with what you say,
- 1:00:11what you say,
- 1:00:12what you say,
- 1:00:13what you say,
- 1:00:14and they hate me.
- 1:00:1540% of the audience is gonna agree with me.
- 1:00:1720% of the audience is in the middle saying,
- 1:00:20I don't know,
- 1:00:20man,
- 1:00:21what do you think I should do?
- 1:00:21Should I feel like a victim or should I not make excuses or what
- 1:00:24is that guy saying or should I do this or should I sympathize.
- 1:00:26The 20% that's watching this
- 1:00:28that has a fighting chance,
- 1:00:30I'm hoping they realize they can do something about their lives.
- 1:00:33We're not gonna be able to solve 100% of people's problems,
- 1:00:36unfortunately.
- 1:00:37I don't think people should keel over,
- 1:00:38but that doesn't mean most people have
- 1:00:39an equal competitive advantage to something.
- 1:00:42I think like somebody like me is a certain
- 1:00:44somebody like me is more privileged inherently everybody.
- 1:00:47Listening to her present,
- 1:00:48she could be a lawyer.
- 1:00:50Listening to her present,
- 1:00:51she's got fire in her belly.
- 1:00:52Everybody here has got a gift.
- 1:00:54Every single person here has got a gift.
- 1:00:56Whether they choose to use it in a way to help them advance in life,
- 1:00:59that's not my fault.
- 1:01:00Everybody can afford to increase their market value.
- 1:01:02You can't.
- 1:01:03You actually can everybody.
- 1:01:04Well,
- 1:01:04we respectfully disagree.
- 1:01:07Thank you again.
- 1:01:07Appreciate you.
- 1:01:10My final claim is the US is more socialist than capitalist today.
- 1:01:14If you hate the system,
- 1:01:16you're anti-socialist.
- 1:01:22Hello back at it again,
- 1:01:23yep,
- 1:01:24yeah,
- 1:01:24so I think it's super important here
- 1:01:26for
- 1:01:26all leftists alike,
- 1:01:27but for the audience in general to define what these terms are,
- 1:01:30and I think the best way to do it would be to look at the theorists,
- 1:01:33right?
- 1:01:33Over history we've seen communism and socialism talked about
- 1:01:36by governments and by,
- 1:01:37I guess,
- 1:01:38um,
- 1:01:39programs,
- 1:01:39but not we,
- 1:01:40we never actually read the actual theory
- 1:01:41and what theorists,
- 1:01:42um,
- 1:01:43all agree on
- 1:01:44is that.
- 1:01:44Um,
- 1:01:44Socialism would be a transitionary state between capitalism and
- 1:01:47communism where the means of production are specifically owned
- 1:01:50by workers,
- 1:01:51not privately.
- 1:01:52The idea that any country now,
- 1:01:55um,
- 1:01:55is,
- 1:01:55is,
- 1:01:56is anywhere near socialist,
- 1:01:57let alone communist,
- 1:01:58would,
- 1:01:58would simply be ridiculous and just it wouldn't reflect theory whatsoever.
- 1:02:02What is the,
- 1:02:02what is the definition of communism to you.
- 1:02:05Moneyless class of society and you,
- 1:02:06you prefer that,
- 1:02:07yeah,
- 1:02:07so I think that we should be moving towards,
- 1:02:09you know,
- 1:02:09communism,
- 1:02:10yeah,
- 1:02:10yeah,
- 1:02:10stateless moneyless class of society.
- 1:02:12So you,
- 1:02:12you don't think a person like me should exist with the amount of wealth that I have,
- 1:02:15yeah,
- 1:02:16because I think that we're getting to this point where we're creating,
- 1:02:18um,
- 1:02:18fake scarcity for people like you to accumulate the wealth that you have
- 1:02:21on the basis of private ownership.
- 1:02:23OK,
- 1:02:23so you're not even,
- 1:02:24you're not even
- 1:02:25not capitalist,
- 1:02:26you're definitely not capitalist,
- 1:02:27you're not socialist.
- 1:02:29You want to go full communism.
- 1:02:30So what do you think that looks like though is a thing,
- 1:02:32right?
- 1:02:33So what,
- 1:02:33what Marx actually wanted was for us to reach a point
- 1:02:36where we no longer have the scarcity of resources that has kind of predicted,
- 1:02:39you know,
- 1:02:39history as it looks like now.
- 1:02:40It wouldn't happen now.
- 1:02:41It would happen as we automate.
- 1:02:43At this point in time we can decommodify housing
- 1:02:45and food,
- 1:02:46um,
- 1:02:46and education
- 1:02:47for around 5% of the government budget.
- 1:02:49That's 1/5
- 1:02:51a little bit over.
- 1:02:521/5 of what we spend on the military already
- 1:02:54we don't because we were living in the state where we,
- 1:02:57we,
- 1:02:57we,
- 1:02:58it almost seems utopian
- 1:02:59that things like food and were you the first
- 1:03:01time you thought you wanted to be a communist?
- 1:03:02How old were you?
- 1:03:03Is that gonna,
- 1:03:03is that a response to any of the statistics?
- 1:03:05No,
- 1:03:05because the statis statistics are against you.
- 1:03:08It's never worked.
- 1:03:10It's never,
- 1:03:10there's so many Cubans that moved to Miami.
- 1:03:14They love their country.
- 1:03:14They hate the politics.
- 1:03:15In Russia,
- 1:03:16they do you know much away from you know how much money because it didn't work.
- 1:03:18It killed so many that almost,
- 1:03:20almost like it wasn't communist.
- 1:03:21It's almost was there a?
- 1:03:23Yes,
- 1:03:23there was.
- 1:03:23Was there class communistic argument there was.
- 1:03:25It's almost like you're not replying to any of
- 1:03:27the statistics that you're a I've presented to you.
- 1:03:29I think that's the biggest problem.
- 1:03:29You're a dictator telling me would not be allowed under communism.
- 1:03:32Dictators end up,
- 1:03:33of course,
- 1:03:34running communism.
- 1:03:35They weren't.
- 1:03:35If somebody's taxing 100%,
- 1:03:37what is a dictatorship?
- 1:03:37So again.
- 1:03:38How,
- 1:03:38how much money do you think 100% in taxes?
- 1:03:41What is communism?
- 1:03:42How much money do you dictatorship?
- 1:03:43How much money do you think would it take to,
- 1:03:45I don't know,
- 1:03:46allow everyone food,
- 1:03:47shelter,
- 1:03:48water,
- 1:03:48and education in this country?
- 1:03:50How much money would it take?
- 1:03:51But going back to your question here with communism,
- 1:03:54stay on that point there with communism,
- 1:03:56but I'm,
- 1:03:56I'm trying to,
- 1:03:57I'm trying to find out from you here.
- 1:03:58You're saying communism is not dictatorship.
- 1:04:01Define dictatorship.
- 1:04:02Yeah,
- 1:04:02so when one person or when one small entity,
- 1:04:05you know,
- 1:04:05is able to,
- 1:04:06you know,
- 1:04:06enforce its will
- 1:04:07on,
- 1:04:07on the people,
- 1:04:08when we have a private ownership,
- 1:04:09when we have a,
- 1:04:10when we have a system based on private private ownership,
- 1:04:12that's what happens every single time dictatorship,
- 1:04:14yeah,
- 1:04:14so we see dictatorship as private ownership.
- 1:04:15Yeah,
- 1:04:15so,
- 1:04:16so let me get owner under communism
- 1:04:19under communism doesn't Elon Musk exist?
- 1:04:22Yeah,
- 1:04:22no,
- 1:04:22no.
- 1:04:23So that's dictatorship.
- 1:04:24Thank you.
- 1:04:24That's completely incorrect.
- 1:04:25Under capitalism,
- 1:04:26we don't have,
- 1:04:27you know,
- 1:04:27the freedom for people to.
- 1:04:29You do.
- 1:04:30OK,
- 1:04:30so under capitalism,
- 1:04:32right,
- 1:04:32we don't,
- 1:04:32we don't see that the mod modification,
- 1:04:35would you consider we don't modification of communism,
- 1:04:38shelter,
- 1:04:39or water or education when we can with 5% of the budget.
- 1:04:42Why don't we see that?
- 1:04:43Would you consider China communist?
- 1:04:44Why haven't you answered any of my questions?
- 1:04:46Would you consider?
- 1:04:47Why haven't you responded to any of my statistics?
- 1:04:48Would you consider China?
- 1:04:49It's almost like we're not having a conversation
- 1:04:50and you're talking about having a conversation.
- 1:04:52An argument that's been proven that it's not worked.
- 1:04:55It's almost like I just gave you a definition of communism for you to critique,
- 1:04:58and you haven't been able to.
- 1:04:59It's such a great system.
- 1:05:01Why are other it hasn't happened yet because it's never,
- 1:05:03we've never been at a point for it to happen because we've
- 1:05:05not found a noble person that can do it the right way,
- 1:05:07that's not,
- 1:05:08if you were to read the plain text of Marx,
- 1:05:09we would see that he wanted to.
- 1:05:10I've read the Communist Manifesto.
- 1:05:12I've I promise you,
- 1:05:13if you have,
- 1:05:13you wouldn't have said that that capitalism.
- 1:05:15Stay a socialist.
- 1:05:16Have you read Wealth of Nations?
- 1:05:17So I've read Das Capital.
- 1:05:19I've read,
- 1:05:19um,
- 1:05:20the Communist Manifesto as well,
- 1:05:21wealth,
- 1:05:22Engel's Collective works,
- 1:05:23etc.
- 1:05:24What do you think?
- 1:05:24If you think that that communism is in any way
- 1:05:27us having wages,
- 1:05:29um,
- 1:05:29or us having,
- 1:05:30you know,
- 1:05:30a privatized dictator production,
- 1:05:31you don't know what it is.
- 1:05:32Choose my dreams,
- 1:05:33and I refuse to do that.
- 1:05:35Who are you arguing with dictate my Where did you get that from?
- 1:05:37What do you mean?
- 1:05:39Well,
- 1:05:39I,
- 1:05:40you know,
- 1:05:40that was that was interesting.
- 1:05:45Woo,
- 1:05:46let's go.
- 1:05:47Justin.
- 1:05:47Nice to meet Justin,
- 1:05:48good to meet you.
- 1:05:48How are you doing,
- 1:05:48Patrick?
- 1:05:49I'm doing good.
- 1:05:49How are you doing?
- 1:05:50Doing pretty good.
- 1:05:50Uh,
- 1:05:51so I need to pick your brain a little bit.
- 1:05:53You're saying US is largely socialist.
- 1:05:54I want to focus on the word largely.
- 1:05:56So why do you believe it is largely socialist?
- 1:05:59Because 68% or so
- 1:06:02of the money that we,
- 1:06:03the money that we take in
- 1:06:04goes towards entitlement programs.
- 1:06:06So I think one of the things that is going to be major to me,
- 1:06:09it's like Zena was touching on earlier,
- 1:06:10is going to be the fact that Socialism is a big part
- 1:06:14of it is going to be workers owning the means of production.
- 1:06:17When we have President Biden,
- 1:06:18for example,
- 1:06:19telling that the
- 1:06:20railroad railroad strikers,
- 1:06:22it's going to be illegal for them to strike,
- 1:06:24I don't see that as much of a workplace democracy.
- 1:06:27Did you want,
- 1:06:27did you have a question,
- 1:06:28or you're just saying the fact that you don't
- 1:06:29agree with President Biden and what he said?
- 1:06:31I'm just saying a core tenet of socialism
- 1:06:33is the workers owning the means of production.
- 1:06:35So workers currently do not own the means of production.
- 1:06:38So why do you believe?
- 1:06:39It is largely socialist,
- 1:06:40so you're saying the workers should own the means of production.
- 1:06:42That is correct.
- 1:06:43OK,
- 1:06:43so to you that's the definition of socialism.
- 1:06:45That is a core tenet of it.
- 1:06:46What else would you define as socialism?
- 1:06:48I'm curious.
- 1:06:49Um,
- 1:06:49there's a lot of different things.
- 1:06:50It's like Xena was touching on as well,
- 1:06:52uh,
- 1:06:52moneyless,
- 1:06:53stateless class of society,
- 1:06:54but I think more important than not,
- 1:06:55workers owning them in production and workplace democracy,
- 1:06:58more socialist.
- 1:06:58They're the same term,
- 1:06:59man.
- 1:06:59Marx use them interchangeably.
- 1:07:01The only difference I would put is because what I see in America,
- 1:07:04I think we are.
- 1:07:06Extremely
- 1:07:07getting close to being a socialistic nation with the amount
- 1:07:09of taxes that we have in place right now,
- 1:07:11but at least under communism,
- 1:07:14I can't survive.
- 1:07:15I would prefer us staying
- 1:07:17at the 10% tax rate.
- 1:07:18I think we're paying way too much taxes,
- 1:07:20and would you not be able to survive.
- 1:07:22I wouldn't be able to pursue my dreams that I have in place under communism.
- 1:07:25My mother's family,
- 1:07:26my mother's family,
- 1:07:27they were part of the two-day party.
- 1:07:29The two-day party in Iran was a communist Party.
- 1:07:32They had escaped Armenia and Russia and came
- 1:07:34down to Iran and they pursued communism.
- 1:07:36I grew up in a family where everything was about the rich are greedy,
- 1:07:39the rich people are bad,
- 1:07:40the rich people are this,
- 1:07:41and the rich people are that.
- 1:07:42My dad's side,
- 1:07:43they were imperialists.
- 1:07:44My dad's side,
- 1:07:45they said,
- 1:07:46poor people are lazy.
- 1:07:47So one side
- 1:07:48rich people are greedy,
- 1:07:50the other side,
- 1:07:51poor people are lazy.
- 1:07:52Who's right?
- 1:07:53I would say that neither are right,
- 1:07:55of course.
- 1:07:55I would say both are right and wrong
- 1:07:58is what I would say.
- 1:07:58Both are right and wrong.
- 1:08:00Both are right and wrong,
- 1:08:01because I do believe
- 1:08:03there are extremely greedy rich people.
- 1:08:06And I do believe there are extremely lazy poor people,
- 1:08:09but I also believe there's a lot of hardworking poor people
- 1:08:12that are working,
- 1:08:13but they haven't found a way to get out of it.
- 1:08:15I agree with that as well.
- 1:08:16That's actually,
- 1:08:16but under,
- 1:08:17right there,
- 1:08:18but they're not able to get out of.
- 1:08:20But you can get out of it.
- 1:08:21You,
- 1:08:21you could actually get out of it.
- 1:08:22They're not able to because they're choosing.
- 1:08:25Not to,
- 1:08:26I just made an offer for a book recommendation here,
- 1:08:28so I'm not interested.
- 1:08:29I,
- 1:08:29if I,
- 1:08:30if I sit there and somebody's giving you feedback
- 1:08:32and saying,
- 1:08:33what about if you think about finding a way to improve your life,
- 1:08:35then I'll,
- 1:08:36I'll,
- 1:08:36you would read the book.
- 1:08:37I'll give you a handful of them.
- 1:08:38We'll talk about this.
- 1:08:39I'll give it to you afterwards,
- 1:08:40but all I'm saying,
- 1:08:40the point I'm trying to make to you is if
- 1:08:42you can exist under a capitalistic society
- 1:08:45and I can exist under a capitalistic society,
- 1:08:47so can she.
- 1:08:48OK,
- 1:08:49we can both exist under a socialistic society,
- 1:08:50not under communistic,
- 1:08:52and under socialism,
- 1:08:53the incentive would be bad.
- 1:08:54Think about it this way.
- 1:08:55Incentive is during COID,
- 1:08:57during COVID,
- 1:08:58during COVID,
- 1:08:59take the two states.
- 1:09:01California and New York,
- 1:09:02they lost $11 trillion of wealth
- 1:09:05that left.
- 1:09:06Do you know where they went to?
- 1:09:07They went to Texas,
- 1:09:08Nevada,
- 1:09:09Florida,
- 1:09:10Tennessee.
- 1:09:11You know why?
- 1:09:12Because it's a better climate for entrepreneurs
- 1:09:14today.
- 1:09:15If you look at New York City,
- 1:09:16you know Mamdani.
- 1:09:17You know how Mam,
- 1:09:18you know who Madani is.
- 1:09:19You know who Mamdani is.
- 1:09:20Are you a fan of Madani?
- 1:09:21OK,
- 1:09:22from New York.
- 1:09:23Zoran's up there saying he doesn't believe billionaires should exist.
- 1:09:26I hope he wins.
- 1:09:28I hope he wins.
- 1:09:28You know why.
- 1:09:29Because he says,
- 1:09:30I don't believe billionaires should exist,
- 1:09:32and he's gonna be the mayor of a city that has the most billionaires in America,
- 1:09:34123.
- 1:09:36I hope he wins so we can see what happens to New York
- 1:09:39when the billionaires leave.
- 1:09:40When they leave,
- 1:09:42here's who's gonna pay the price.
- 1:09:43The people that are left behind
- 1:09:45who were taking advantage of the taxes that billionaires were paying.
- 1:09:48You think the government's gonna change their budget expenditure?
- 1:09:50$30 minimum wage America,
- 1:09:53middle America is gonna take the biggest hit
- 1:09:55if billionaires leave
- 1:09:57the state of New York.
- 1:09:58You'll see.
- 1:10:04Oh,
- 1:10:04you're back.
- 1:10:05How are you?
- 1:10:05Good to see you.
- 1:10:06Learn a bit more.
- 1:10:07OK.
- 1:10:08Firstly,
- 1:10:08I want to start by saying that
- 1:10:09the US is not largely socialist because that's not what socialism is.
- 1:10:13Socialism is social or collective ownership
- 1:10:16by the workers
- 1:10:17or a community
- 1:10:18of the means of production,
- 1:10:19right?
- 1:10:19So we're talking about like city run grocery store.
- 1:10:21Stores or we're talking about worker cooperatives
- 1:10:22or even in some cases credit unions,
- 1:10:25where a local community
- 1:10:26owns the bank that they
- 1:10:28take part in,
- 1:10:28right?
- 1:10:29That's what socialism is.
- 1:10:30Socialism is not when the government does stuff for you.
- 1:10:32It's not when they build roads.
- 1:10:33It happens under capitalist economies,
- 1:10:34it happens under socialist economies.
- 1:10:36But I'm also not sure you entirely know what capitalism is,
- 1:10:38and
- 1:10:39if it's OK,
- 1:10:39I'd like to ask a couple questions about your job,
- 1:10:41because you're offering that.
- 1:10:42Um,
- 1:10:43I know that you're value attainment,
- 1:10:44right?
- 1:10:44You run a YouTube podcast.
- 1:10:46You also run PHP Agency,
- 1:10:47right?
- 1:10:48Yes,
- 1:10:49um,
- 1:10:50and you sell life insurance policies,
- 1:10:51right?
- 1:10:51Life insurance and annuities.
- 1:10:53Yes,
- 1:10:54um,
- 1:10:54I read an article by The Daily Beast which argued that you
- 1:10:56make more money from recruitment fees to get people to work for you
- 1:11:00than you make money
- 1:11:01from selling those policies.
- 1:11:02Capitalism is when you provide a service
- 1:11:05and sell the labor of yourself or the person who works for you
- 1:11:08in return for money,
- 1:11:10but you're not really doing that,
- 1:11:12right?
- 1:11:12You're selling.
- 1:11:13Being part of the company
- 1:11:15through recruitment fees,
- 1:11:16I'm not sure that's capitalism.
- 1:11:18How familiar are you with the insurance industry?
- 1:11:20Pretty familiar.
- 1:11:21Are you?
- 1:11:21Yes,
- 1:11:22you've been,
- 1:11:22you've been in the industry before.
- 1:11:23No,
- 1:11:24my grandfather was,
- 1:11:25and I asked him a lot of questions.
- 1:11:25So in the insurance industry,
- 1:11:27when you're in it,
- 1:11:28yes,
- 1:11:28you get paid
- 1:11:29by selling life insurance policies and you get paid
- 1:11:32by selling annuities.
- 1:11:33Yes,
- 1:11:34we built a distribution channel
- 1:11:36of a company
- 1:11:37right after I left Morgan Stanley.
- 1:11:38And Transamerica,
- 1:11:40we started the insurance company.
- 1:11:41We grew it helping
- 1:11:44middle-income families who didn't have,
- 1:11:45who didn't have another opportunity
- 1:11:47to create wealth for themselves.
- 1:11:48I just came back from our event in Vegas.
- 1:11:50Let me say this to you though.
- 1:11:52It is though.
- 1:11:52It's not I just,
- 1:11:53let me make my point.
- 1:11:54I just came back from,
- 1:11:55we don't make money from the,
- 1:11:56we don't make more money from recruiting.
- 1:11:58I read the Daily Beast article that did that.
- 1:12:00I also watched Cilla's debate with you where you pulled up receipts
- 1:12:03that the majority of the employees of your company don't make any.
- 1:12:05Here's a question for you.
- 1:12:06Here's a question for you.
- 1:12:07Bring up Coffeezilla.
- 1:12:09Daily Beast is a different story.
- 1:12:10Go to Coffeezilla.
- 1:12:11Do you think if I was worried about my business model,
- 1:12:14I would go on Coffeezilla?
- 1:12:15What do you think?
- 1:12:16Do you think if I,
- 1:12:16do you think if I really,
- 1:12:18hang on a second.
- 1:12:19Do you think if I was worried about my business model,
- 1:12:21I would go on Coffeezilla?
- 1:12:23They were actually very strong when they came back after me.
- 1:12:25We had a 2-hour conversation.
- 1:12:27We finished it.
- 1:12:27It was good to go.
- 1:12:28We moved on.
- 1:12:29Their claims
- 1:12:30that only 1% or 2%.
- 1:12:3220% make
- 1:12:33and nobody makes it in insurance,
- 1:12:35they're right.
- 1:12:36Most people don't make it in insurance
- 1:12:37just like most people who move to California don't make it in Hollywood.
- 1:12:40So I believe that most people don't make it
- 1:12:41in when you make more money from getting people
- 1:12:43to be part of a company than from actually
- 1:12:44selling a service is called a multi-level marketing scheme.
- 1:12:47Do you think that that's a fair characterization of your company?
- 1:12:50Why not?
- 1:12:50a multi,
- 1:12:51Do you know what a multi-level is?
- 1:12:52Yes,
- 1:12:52I know it's where you make more money from,
- 1:12:54it's sort of like a pyramid scheme wherein
- 1:12:56you make more money from getting people to be part of it.
- 1:12:59And selling them to be part of the company.
- 1:13:01A pyramid scheme doesn't have a product
- 1:13:03that's criminal.
- 1:13:04A multi-level marketing company is more like an Amway,
- 1:13:07an Herbalife,
- 1:13:09a new skin,
- 1:13:10those companies,
- 1:13:11because it pays you.
- 1:13:12You are making more money from getting people to be part of your
- 1:13:14company than you are from making money from actually providing a service.
- 1:13:17true.
- 1:13:18It's,
- 1:13:18I would argue Daily Beast,
- 1:13:20by the way,
- 1:13:20do you know what a quality of earnings is?
- 1:13:22What's the quality of earnings?
- 1:13:23Tell everybody what a quality of earnings is.
- 1:13:26Go ahead.
- 1:13:27Fair point.
- 1:13:28The quality of earnings is,
- 1:13:29isn't that like the value that's produced
- 1:13:32from when you make the money?
- 1:13:33Like how much
- 1:13:34from the labor that's produced,
- 1:13:35or am I wrong?
- 1:13:35What is quality of earnings?
- 1:13:37I give you what I think the definition is.
- 1:13:38OK.
- 1:13:39So quality of earnings is I sit there
- 1:13:42and I wanna sell the business to you.
- 1:13:45You make an offer of $250 million
- 1:13:47OK.
- 1:13:48I tell you,
- 1:13:50this is my business.
- 1:13:51Here's how much profit we make.
- 1:13:53You leave and you say,
- 1:13:54great,
- 1:13:54let's make a deal.
- 1:13:55I'll pay $250 million.
- 1:13:56We shake on it.
- 1:13:57Then
- 1:13:58you validate whether it is worth that or not by going and paying a big company
- 1:14:03a few $100,000 to
- 1:14:05check
- 1:14:05the quality.
- 1:14:07So same deals like having someone look at the
- 1:14:08quality of the gold that you're gonna buy.
- 1:14:09PWC came and they do a quality of earnings to say,
- 1:14:13is this company really worth this?
- 1:14:15They get to make a decision whether the company is truly doing
- 1:14:18what you or Daily Beast claims to do.
- 1:14:19And you know what comes a brand.
- 1:14:21It comes know going on podcasts like that,
- 1:14:23even when they expose the business what ended up because you're not selling,
- 1:14:26you know what ended up.
- 1:14:26Happening.
- 1:14:27Don't make claims.
- 1:14:28Do you know what you're selling.
- 1:14:29Do you know what ended up happening you know what you're selling?
- 1:14:30Do you know what ended up happening?
- 1:14:31You know what you're selling.
- 1:14:32The company you're selling your personal brand.
- 1:14:34You're selling the idea because when you're offering people here jobs,
- 1:14:37right,
- 1:14:37you're saying that
- 1:14:38they would have to pay you money to get that.
- 1:14:40So in reality,
- 1:14:40you're trying to convince them to pay you money
- 1:14:42to be part of your company of defamement.
- 1:14:44Be very careful defaming.
- 1:14:45We know you don't know the facts.
- 1:14:46You have a recruitment fee careful.
- 1:14:48No,
- 1:14:48no,
- 1:14:48be very careful have a recruitment fee.
- 1:14:49Be very careful making that claim when you said people here
- 1:14:52have to pay to work at our company.
- 1:14:54It's a recruitment very careful.
- 1:14:55No,
- 1:14:56those are two different things.
- 1:15:01Hi,
- 1:15:02how are you?
- 1:15:02Good.
- 1:15:02How are you?
- 1:15:03Tatiana
- 1:15:04Tatiana,
- 1:15:04yeah,
- 1:15:05Anya,
- 1:15:05but yes,
- 1:15:06and your niece Patrick,
- 1:15:07right?
- 1:15:07And I don't know a lot about you
- 1:15:09before coming in today,
- 1:15:11but um,
- 1:15:12why do you
- 1:15:13use socialism and capitalism like in this instance
- 1:15:16I've noticed a lot of people have defined.
- 1:15:18The vast differences,
- 1:15:19but you're insisting
- 1:15:20that we're still
- 1:15:21like a more socialist-like country.
- 1:15:24Why,
- 1:15:24why are you insisting on?
- 1:15:26That's a fair question.
- 1:15:26So for me there's different definitions you can have.
- 1:15:29Under communism,
- 1:15:30to me it's 100% taxes,
- 1:15:31meaning I can't go create my own property if I want to build a
- 1:15:35billion dollar company.
- 1:15:36I can't do it under communism.
- 1:15:37Is that a fair assessment?
- 1:15:40Yes,
- 1:15:40I guess it is.
- 1:15:41It is OK.
- 1:15:42So capitalism,
- 1:15:44I would ideally like to see taxes between 10 to 30% max.
- 1:15:48I'd like a flat tax,
- 1:15:49but somewhere between 10% to 30%.
- 1:15:51Because I still do think there's certain things that the government needs to do,
- 1:15:54military
- 1:15:55protection,
- 1:15:55certain things.
- 1:15:56Socialism to me is 30% and up.
- 1:15:59Anything above that,
- 1:16:00that you're taking the money away from me without my choice
- 1:16:03to use it for things where we get to 68% of entitlement programs,
- 1:16:06I'm not a fan of that.
- 1:16:07OK,
- 1:16:08so let's talk about where we're at.
- 1:16:09I believe you said reasonable wage and minimum wage.
- 1:16:12What about a livable wage?
- 1:16:14And we haven't really talked about livable wages because they kind of differ.
- 1:16:17Minimum wage.
- 1:16:18So what,
- 1:16:18what do you think?
- 1:16:19So I think we have a long way to go.
- 1:16:21Um,
- 1:16:21I'm not really a big fan of these little increment things,
- 1:16:24especially when it's like,
- 1:16:26it's not like rent,
- 1:16:26it's,
- 1:16:27you know,
- 1:16:27stopping and leveling out.
- 1:16:28It's like it's,
- 1:16:29you know,
- 1:16:30far exceeding what most people,
- 1:16:31I don't disagree,
- 1:16:32for make.
- 1:16:33And so
- 1:16:34I'm just wondering how you still can sit here and say that when you,
- 1:16:37I know you like to talk about you came up from Haagen-Dazs and
- 1:16:40all this other stuff in Glendale Galleria 20 minutes away from here.
- 1:16:43Love that for you.
- 1:16:44But we're talking about where you are today
- 1:16:47and where I am a majority of these people in the room,
- 1:16:50and I haven't really heard.
- 1:16:52Yes,
- 1:16:53we can change,
- 1:16:53but I think that there's certain systems.
- 1:16:55Are you talking minimum wage?
- 1:16:56You want to address the minimum wage minimum wage,
- 1:16:59but I like to say livable wage because I think they're two very different things.
- 1:17:03What do you think it should be?
- 1:17:03I,
- 1:17:04I think that we should go per state because every
- 1:17:06state is different in terms of what they get.
- 1:17:08Where do you live?
- 1:17:08You live in I live in California,
- 1:17:10so based on the MIT living.
- 1:17:11Wage calculator.
- 1:17:12It's an actual livable wage calculator.
- 1:17:15It's $2781 should be the starting.
- 1:17:17And then if you have kids and so forth,
- 1:17:19then you can like go up from there,
- 1:17:21but starting at about $27 hourly.
- 1:17:23So,
- 1:17:24so what,
- 1:17:24let's look at case studies of what happened.
- 1:17:27California chose to increase the minimum wage for fast food workers to $20 an hour.
- 1:17:32Restaurant workers.
- 1:17:33Do you know what happened in the state of California?
- 1:17:35Mass exodus.
- 1:17:36People left and went different places.
- 1:17:37You know what restaurant owners did.
- 1:17:39Like I can't compete with these guys if you raise the minimum wage,
- 1:17:41but the,
- 1:17:42but the challenge with minimum wage is also the following.
- 1:17:44So,
- 1:17:45say there's two companies,
- 1:17:47you have Walmart,
- 1:17:48OK,
- 1:17:48in Bakersfield,
- 1:17:49pick a city,
- 1:17:50and you have a different supermarket that's been in the same family for 60 years.
- 1:17:54The governor here says we're gonna raise the minimum wage to $20 an hour.
- 1:17:57Who do you think can afford it?
- 1:17:59The market that's been within the family,
- 1:18:01the small business,
- 1:18:02who do you think Walmart,
- 1:18:03who do you think can afford to go to $20 an hour minimum wage?
- 1:18:05So that's,
- 1:18:06uh,
- 1:18:06that's why I think we have to factor in other systems
- 1:18:09other than capitalism.
- 1:18:10I think you're kind of making the point that's been made a few
- 1:18:12times today where we can't just look at one hasn't been made.
- 1:18:14No,
- 1:18:15this hasn't made the point I'm making.
- 1:18:16Here is,
- 1:18:17any time a Bernie Sanders gets up and says,
- 1:18:20let's raise the minimum wage for $15
- 1:18:23and he was caught in his campaign
- 1:18:25not paying his own workers $15.13 dollars an hour,
- 1:18:28and he had to talk about it and apologize
- 1:18:30that even a guy that's a socialist wasn't paying a minimum,
- 1:18:33minimum wage.
- 1:18:34But if you raise it to $15
- 1:18:36Amazon celebrates.
- 1:18:38Walmart celebrates.
- 1:18:38Do you know why?
- 1:18:40Because the employers from this supermarket
- 1:18:42that have been working for this family for the longest time,
- 1:18:44they can't afford to pay that.
- 1:18:46So they leave and go to Amazon and Walmart.
- 1:18:48What happens?
- 1:18:48The bigger companies keep getting bigger.
- 1:18:50The small businesses go out of business
- 1:18:52because of minimum wage.
- 1:18:53OK,
- 1:18:54so
- 1:18:54you've mentioned Bernie Sanders.
- 1:18:56I didn't mention him.
- 1:18:57Cool,
- 1:18:57for Bernie Sanders,
- 1:18:58whatever.
- 1:18:59Do you pay a livable wage or a minimum wage for your employees for there's not a.
- 1:19:03Single soul in our company that I pay 15 bucks an hour or 20 bucks an hour.
- 1:19:07OK,
- 1:19:07so
- 1:19:08are you paying them livable wages though?
- 1:19:10you,
- 1:19:11OK,
- 1:19:11based on your standards or based on like the,
- 1:19:14because of my choice.
- 1:19:15So you're determining what people's livable wages are.
- 1:19:17No,
- 1:19:17I look at the marketplace and I see what's going on and I get to pick and choose
- 1:19:22what percentile of people I wanna hire.
- 1:19:24Do I wanna hire bottom 10%,
- 1:19:2525%,
- 1:19:2650%?
- 1:19:27I'll hire a little.
- 1:19:28I'll pay a little bit more
- 1:19:29because I want to get somebody that's got a little bit more experience,
- 1:19:32OK.
- 1:19:33OK.
- 1:19:35Tanya
- 1:19:37Titania,
- 1:19:37thank you.
- 1:19:42Hi again,
- 1:19:43Patrick.
- 1:19:43How are you?
- 1:19:44Good.
- 1:19:44How are you doing?
- 1:19:44Good.
- 1:19:45Can you remind me again why you think this country is largely socialist?
- 1:19:48Out of the $4.9 trillion of revenue that we get in,
- 1:19:514.8,
- 1:19:524.9%,
- 1:19:5368% goes to entitlement programs.
- 1:19:56That's the reason why I say America's socialism.
- 1:19:58Do you think that we should have a say in where our taxpayer dollars go?
- 1:20:02That's why we have elections,
- 1:20:03and you vote for it.
- 1:20:04So you agree that we should have a say in where our taxpayer dollars go.
- 1:20:06If you're asking me who should have a right to vote,
- 1:20:08I would change the system in.
- 1:20:10way of who would have the right to.
- 1:20:11I'm not asking you if you're asking me a question.
- 1:20:14I'm not asking you who should have the right to vote.
- 1:20:15I'm asking you,
- 1:20:16do you think that our current system taxpayer dollars should be dictated by us,
- 1:20:20where the current
- 1:20:21election allows you to vote and decide who you want to be your candidate.
- 1:20:25Absolutely.
- 1:20:25OK,
- 1:20:26so I would argue that the biggest handouts go to billionaires because we
- 1:20:30give billions and billions of dollars in
- 1:20:32subsidies to billionaires every single year.
- 1:20:35Musk just got a huge raise.
- 1:20:37Not sure why.
- 1:20:37He's worth over
- 1:20:39like hundreds of billions of dollars.
- 1:20:41You be specific.
- 1:20:42You're talking about SpaceX.
- 1:20:44I'm talking about subsidies.
- 1:20:45You're.
- 1:20:45I'm talking about the company that we fund as taxpayers.
- 1:20:48So why did we never vote for that?
- 1:20:50Why did you never vote for the money going to some of these you see an
- 1:20:54issue with the fact that we as taxpayers didn't have a say in first of all,
- 1:20:57electing this tech oligarch.
- 1:20:58Once you elect somebody.
- 1:21:01Deciding where our taxpayer dollars go.
- 1:21:03Once you elect who you elect,
- 1:21:05what they do next,
- 1:21:06you don't have a say during that time.
- 1:21:08We didn't
- 1:21:08until the next election.
- 1:21:09No,
- 1:21:09I'm talking Congress,
- 1:21:10Senate.
- 1:21:11They make a decision on who
- 1:21:12they give the money to and they approve,
- 1:21:13but he's been,
- 1:21:14he's been getting this amount of subsidies through every administration.
- 1:21:17I'm not just referring to the Trump administration.
- 1:21:19Let's talk about how they,
- 1:21:20how he's done,
- 1:21:20OK.
- 1:21:21So the NASA was shut down many years ago,
- 1:21:23OK.
- 1:21:24Since then,
- 1:21:25how has NASA done
- 1:21:26trying to find a way to go to space?
- 1:21:28What has SpaceX done?
- 1:21:29SpaceX has been able to do to go to space.
- 1:21:32NASA gave us the satellite which you use every time you use your phone.
- 1:21:37If you let me finish,
- 1:21:38NASA versus SpaceX.
- 1:21:40Elon Musk,
- 1:21:41as much as you hate him,
- 1:21:42Elon Musk was able to go to space for 1/20 of a cost
- 1:21:46because government organizations.
- 1:21:47Elon Musk has the ability to eradicate extreme poverty in this country,
- 1:21:51and he chooses to send rockets into space and make extremely ugly cars that we never
- 1:21:55actually funded.
- 1:21:56Believe it or so I would liberals drive his cars.
- 1:21:58So,
- 1:21:59well,
- 1:21:59I would say the cyber trucks,
- 1:22:00it's,
- 1:22:00it's a poor decision aesthetically.
- 1:22:02The cyber truck.
- 1:22:03I'm not discussing the aesthetics of his,
- 1:22:05of his products.
- 1:22:05It's,
- 1:22:06it's so funny because when you say what you say about,
- 1:22:08say,
- 1:22:08the Democratic side on the climate change side.
- 1:22:11The guy that's worked towards that the most,
- 1:22:13you guys loved him till he supported Trump.
- 1:22:15Elon was your favorite eight years ago until he supported Trump.
- 1:22:18The moment he went into Trump,
- 1:22:19this guy's a horrible guy.
- 1:22:21This guy's a terrible guy.
- 1:22:22To be fair,
- 1:22:22I've hated Elon Musk consistently throughout my adult life,
- 1:22:25and
- 1:22:26I also think that he is someone who has benefited immensely from the government.
- 1:22:31That's why I find hypocrisy in what you're saying.
- 1:22:32I don't.
- 1:22:33I also think that he's benefited immensely
- 1:22:35from the exploitation of labor overseas.
- 1:22:37He's benefited immensely from his extremely aggressive union.
- 1:22:40Tactics,
- 1:22:41union busting tactics,
- 1:22:42tactics.
- 1:22:42So I'm saying like,
- 1:22:43why is he a net positive to you for society?
- 1:22:46Is he a net positive for me personally?
- 1:22:47Is he a net positive for society,
- 1:22:49not for you?
- 1:22:50I wouldn't say so.
- 1:22:51You don't think he is.
- 1:22:51No,
- 1:22:52I wouldn't say so.
- 1:22:52is a net positive to society?
- 1:22:54Bernie Sanders.
- 1:22:55I would,
- 1:22:55I mean,
- 1:22:56Bernie Sanders is,
- 1:22:57I would say he's a compromise candidate,
- 1:22:58but I would say that he's a compromise candidate.
- 1:23:00Yes,
- 1:23:01I would say AOC,
- 1:23:01a,
- 1:23:02a net positive to society.
- 1:23:03I would say net positive,
- 1:23:04yes,
- 1:23:04more than Musk is.
- 1:23:05Yes,
- 1:23:06really.
- 1:23:06Tell me why.
- 1:23:07Because AOC wants to introduce.
- 1:23:09Green New Deal and I think that the New Deal is the closest thing $1 trillion.
- 1:23:13OK,
- 1:23:14Trump literally just added $3.4 trillion to our deficit.
- 1:23:17So I really don't want to hear $30 trillion.
- 1:23:19OK,
- 1:23:19so I'm saying trillion dollars,
- 1:23:20I'm saying that I think that,
- 1:23:22you know,
- 1:23:22when we look at
- 1:23:24the system that we currently have,
- 1:23:26I think that we need to redistribute the wealth in a significant way,
- 1:23:29and we need to reintroduce something like the New Deal.
- 1:23:32And I think AOC has been the closest to doing that.
- 1:23:34I'm not saying I'm the biggest fan of her,
- 1:23:35but I'm saying that we need a marginal tax rate.
- 1:23:38That is,
- 1:23:39uh,
- 1:23:40something similar to the New Deal,
- 1:23:4170 to 90%.
- 1:23:42Ideally,
- 1:23:42I would go for a wealth tax.
- 1:23:43Anyone over $999 million has to pay every year.
- 1:23:46Um,
- 1:23:47but I'm saying that,
- 1:23:48say that one more time.
- 1:23:48You would do what?
- 1:23:49Anybody that I would,
- 1:23:50I would introduce a wealth tax.
- 1:23:51So,
- 1:23:51I'd say that anyone who makes over $999 million
- 1:23:55needs to pay.
- 1:23:56So I think that no one should be a billionaire.
- 1:23:58I think that we should put the cap.
- 1:24:00No one should be a billionaire.
- 1:24:01Absolutely not.
- 1:24:02Do you think that people can survive on $999 million?
- 1:24:04This isn't how life works.
- 1:24:06Do you think someone could survive on $999 million?
- 1:24:09I'm asking you,
- 1:24:09do you think someone would be OK?
- 1:24:11dictate?
- 1:24:12Do you think someone's life would be?
- 1:24:13if they had only $999 million instead of a billion dollars.
- 1:24:16You're not answering the fortunately,
- 1:24:19these companies that continue to grow,
- 1:24:21why are you avoiding created jobs for others?
- 1:24:23Do you think someone could reasonably survive on $999 million.
- 1:24:27How big a person wants to build their business?
- 1:24:29That's not your goal,
- 1:24:30by the way,
- 1:24:31why don't you elect someone
- 1:24:33that pursues those policies?
- 1:24:34Bernie was your hero for many years.
- 1:24:35He became compromised.
- 1:24:36I never said he was my hero,
- 1:24:37but how did Bernie become compromised?
- 1:24:40I said that he is a compromise said he's a compromised candidate is a compromise.
- 1:24:43I mean,
- 1:24:43he was definitely compromised by the Democratic Party who didn't want him elected.
- 1:24:46I'm saying he's a compromise candidate in that I would go further than him,
- 1:24:49but I also know that he's probably the best we have right now,
- 1:24:52and I would like to see him as president ideally or someone similar.
- 1:24:55I think Zaron Mamdani,
- 1:24:56who you mentioned earlier,
- 1:24:57I think he's an excellent candidate for him to win.
- 1:25:00You know why I can't wait for him to win?
- 1:25:02Because I can't wait for the data that comes out after he wins.
- 1:25:05I can't wait to show you all the numbers.
- 1:25:06The next 4 years after rich people have to flee New York because of his policies,
- 1:25:10that means that they're too economically fragile,
- 1:25:13to handle those taxes people that create jobs,
- 1:25:16they will go somewhere that they're appreciated creating a
- 1:25:18high paying job to look past job creation,
- 1:25:21high paid jobs.
- 1:25:22Many of the jobs bring value to the market.
- 1:25:24The reality is that Elon Musk,
- 1:25:26Mark Zuckerberg,
- 1:25:27and Jeff Bezos,
- 1:25:29they
- 1:25:30have huge monopolies over our market,
- 1:25:32and they're able.
- 1:25:33Able to pay as little in wages as they'd like a monopoly.
- 1:25:36I think the only company that has literally control
- 1:25:37the wages and the costs in our economy.
- 1:25:42If when Amazon has
- 1:25:4360% control over e-commerce,
- 1:25:45they can quite literally decide what wages and what costs people can earn and pay.
- 1:25:50Your candidate,
- 1:25:51AOC,
- 1:25:51I never said she was my candidate.
- 1:25:53She's a net positive to society endorsements on.
- 1:25:55You said AOC is a net positive to society more than Elon Musk.
- 1:25:59When
- 1:26:00AOC was in New York,
- 1:26:02Amazon wanted to bring 25,000 jobs to New York.
- 1:26:05These were jobs that were paying 150 a year because from what I understand,
- 1:26:09these were jobs that were Amazing 150 a year,
- 1:26:1110 to 15 miles.
- 1:26:12These ships.
- 1:26:13They have higher jobs that rates paying than 1500 per year.
- 1:26:16These were jobs that were paying 150 a year.
- 1:26:19She went against it.
- 1:26:20They went to a different place.
- 1:26:2125,000 jobs they lost in New York.
- 1:26:23And what would those jobs look like?
- 1:26:241500 a year minimum.
- 1:26:27Thank you.
- 1:26:33Patrick will now choose someone from the outer circle to debate again,
- 1:26:37but based on their claim.
- 1:26:3810 minutes.
- 1:26:40I'm going to go with my friend here.
- 1:26:44Good talking to you again.
- 1:26:46So I chose Mason because he was the only one that came up to me and said,
- 1:26:50Pat,
- 1:26:51I'd like to have a reasonable conversation with you.
- 1:26:53You came up.
- 1:26:53There were 3 other people I was thinking about,
- 1:26:55and because you were fair and respectful,
- 1:26:56I chose you.
- 1:26:57So my claim is America has never been a meritocracy.
- 1:27:01Tell me why.
- 1:27:02So I think that when you see wealth disparity and
- 1:27:03the amount that it gives influences to certain individuals,
- 1:27:06specifically from a starting point,
- 1:27:07if we're looking at America like a race and someone is starting
- 1:27:102 inches from the finish line and somebody's starting 1 mile back,
- 1:27:13we would not say that this is a judgment of their merit.
- 1:27:16We'd say that this is a system that allows those
- 1:27:17with the most influence to continue to be successful.
- 1:27:20So you,
- 1:27:20you is your,
- 1:27:22is,
- 1:27:22is it about some of the people that got generational
- 1:27:24wealth have an advantage over others that didn't get it?
- 1:27:26Yeah,
- 1:27:27and I,
- 1:27:27I'm not necessarily saying that.
- 1:27:28That's a moral failure.
- 1:27:29I'm just saying when people claim that capitalism is a meritocracy,
- 1:27:32that's just factually inaccurate,
- 1:27:33and we shouldn't be allowed to lie here.
- 1:27:35Like we should try to be coming to a common consensus.
- 1:27:37Capitalism is not a meritocracy.
- 1:27:38No.
- 1:27:39So you mean to tell me nobody here can go out
- 1:27:41there and win if they wanted to at the highest level?
- 1:27:43No,
- 1:27:43I think that there's a probability that people can
- 1:27:45have social mobility or increase their economic conditions.
- 1:27:48It does not mean that everybody is able to.
- 1:27:50Uh,
- 1:27:50so while some people could be a billionaire in the circle,
- 1:27:53not everybody's saying not everybody's able to,
- 1:27:55I fully agree.
- 1:27:56I can play baseball,
- 1:27:57but I'm probably not gonna play in Major League Baseball.
- 1:27:59I can spend the money on a lottery ticket.
- 1:28:01It doesn't mean I'm guaranteed to win the lottery.
- 1:28:02I agree.
- 1:28:03So what's your point?
- 1:28:03I agree with you,
- 1:28:04Dan.
- 1:28:04So my point is that,
- 1:28:05uh,
- 1:28:06America is not
- 1:28:06a meritocracy.
- 1:28:08You said that.
- 1:28:08No,
- 1:28:08you said there's two things.
- 1:28:10Anybody at what levels you can have success.
- 1:28:14To me,
- 1:28:14in life,
- 1:28:15there's 3 different types of people.
- 1:28:16You got overachievers,
- 1:28:18you got achievers,
- 1:28:19you got underachievers.
- 1:28:20Let me unpack this for a second.
- 1:28:21We've got 10 minutes.
- 1:28:22Oveachiever,
- 1:28:23achiever,
- 1:28:23underachiever,
- 1:28:24OK.
- 1:28:24You can find a guy in school.
- 1:28:26We all remember the kid in school that was gonna,
- 1:28:28we're like,
- 1:28:28that kid's gonna win in life,
- 1:28:29and he didn't.
- 1:28:31He was supposed to be an overachiever.
- 1:28:32He ended up being an underachiever,
- 1:28:34and there were kids in school that we looked at.
- 1:28:35We said,
- 1:28:35that guy is not gonna do anything with life,
- 1:28:37dude.
- 1:28:37Stay away from that guy.
- 1:28:39He ends up winning.
- 1:28:39He's an overachiever.
- 1:28:41So it's not about what you're,
- 1:28:43you know,
- 1:28:43do end up doing in your life.
- 1:28:44It's what you,
- 1:28:45how close you reach to your capacity.
- 1:28:47The winning that you're talking about,
- 1:28:48quote unquote is wealth accumulation,
- 1:28:50not necessarily wealth accumulation to me,
- 1:28:52you said if,
- 1:28:52if you.
- 1:28:53I have friends that
- 1:28:55make $120,000 a year.
- 1:28:57They have a good life.
- 1:28:57They're happily married,
- 1:28:58got two kids,
- 1:28:59and they chose to go live in a place like Victorville.
- 1:29:01They chose to go live in a different place,
- 1:29:03but to me that is winning.
- 1:29:04They're contributing to society I have a genuine question for you,
- 1:29:06Patrick.
- 1:29:07Do you think that a nurse or a hedge fund manager offers more social utility?
- 1:29:12This is documented in 14 years ago I made a video talking about the 10 most.
- 1:29:16Honorable
- 1:29:17professions
- 1:29:18and a hedge fund manager wasn't on that list,
- 1:29:20but a nurse was.
- 1:29:21I believe what nurses do when my father's at the hospital
- 1:29:24and I see how they attend to him,
- 1:29:26you have no idea how much respect I have for nurses.
- 1:29:28It's a tough job.
- 1:29:29However,
- 1:29:30I would say the hierarchy of what our society looks like
- 1:29:32does not prioritize that's the same way that you're saying,
- 1:29:34but there's a difference.
- 1:29:35So there's a difference.
- 1:29:36Do I think a nurse is More important to the market than a basketball player.
- 1:29:41Yes,
- 1:29:42but the market wants to watch a basketball player play,
- 1:29:44so they pay Steph Curry 60 million we both agree that America's failing,
- 1:29:47right?
- 1:29:48Your last claim was about how America's socialist,
- 1:29:49and that's a bad thing.
- 1:29:50I assume that you're saying because of government intervention.
- 1:29:53So you think capitalism can exist without government intervention?
- 1:29:56I think you need law and order because there will be abuse if you don't have it.
- 1:29:59In our insurance company,
- 1:30:00when I
- 1:30:01Uh,
- 1:30:02uh,
- 1:30:02was run the company.
- 1:30:03I had to make sure there was a law and order in there.
- 1:30:05If you don't have certain compliance,
- 1:30:07abuse will come in.
- 1:30:08When abuse comes in,
- 1:30:09if it's a free for all,
- 1:30:10are part of those laws like labor laws,
- 1:30:12uh,
- 1:30:12that can also be abused.
- 1:30:13No,
- 1:30:14it's a fair question you're asking,
- 1:30:15but a part of that can also be abused.
- 1:30:16A lot of those guys go in with the right intentions,
- 1:30:20then they become dividers and they pin the employer against the employee.
- 1:30:24So then that that is the divide and conquer model is very effective.
- 1:30:28I just want to break this down.
- 1:30:29Do you think that there are not mutually exclusive interests in owners and workers?
- 1:30:34Do I,
- 1:30:34do I think there's mutual interest with owners and workers?
- 1:30:37Do you think that they have a a symbiotic relationship
- 1:30:40and when they're trying to achieve the same goal,
- 1:30:41I like to give my employees equity because if you own equity.
- 1:30:45in the company,
- 1:30:46you no longer are an employee,
- 1:30:48you treat it as if it's your own company.
- 1:30:50So,
- 1:30:50I prefer
- 1:30:51to give my employees equity,
- 1:30:52but it's my choice.
- 1:30:53I don't want the government forcing me to give them equity.
- 1:30:56I'll give you a story.
- 1:30:57Do you remember that story of a guy
- 1:30:59who said,
- 1:30:59I pay every single one of my employees $70,000 a year.
- 1:31:01What was this guy's name?
- 1:31:02I don't know if you remember this guy.
- 1:31:03This story went viral.
- 1:31:05Socialism,
- 1:31:06what a noble guy.
- 1:31:07Everybody.
- 1:31:07Retweeted at the Bernie's of the world.
- 1:31:09Phenomenal guy.
- 1:31:10I invited him on the podcast.
- 1:31:11He comes on the podcast.
- 1:31:12I said,
- 1:31:13So tell me about your noble cause that you pay everybody $700,000 a year.
- 1:31:16He says,
- 1:31:16Well,
- 1:31:16I don't think anybody should make over $700,000 a year.
- 1:31:19You can live off of $70,000
- 1:31:21a year.
- 1:31:21I said,
- 1:31:22Perfect.
- 1:31:22How many employees do you have?
- 1:31:23Let me make the point.
- 1:31:24I said,
- 1:31:24you're saying,
- 1:31:25but I don't think that this is a conducive to,
- 1:31:26I said,
- 1:31:27how many employees do you have?
- 1:31:28He says,
- 1:31:28100.
- 1:31:29I said,
- 1:31:29how many of those 100 own
- 1:31:31a single
- 1:31:32share of your company?
- 1:31:33None of them do.
- 1:31:33Who does?
- 1:31:34I do.
- 1:31:35You're a socialist.
- 1:31:37Claiming everybody should make that much money,
- 1:31:38but you're not giving equity.
- 1:31:39I'm not endorsing this particular person.
- 1:31:41I'd love to look into this and maybe I'll watch,
- 1:31:43watch the interview later.
- 1:31:44But what I'm trying to say,
- 1:31:45what I'm trying to say,
- 1:31:46yes,
- 1:31:47when it comes down to action,
- 1:31:48there are contradictions in the way that workers are
- 1:31:50trying to get as much wages as possible.
- 1:31:52That's just guaranteed.
- 1:31:53I'm,
- 1:31:54I want to get the maximum amount for the labor that I put into it.
- 1:31:57An owner that wants to do the exact opposite.
- 1:31:59It's not that they want to pay people
- 1:32:01what they're deserved.
- 1:32:02They want to pay people what they can get away with.
- 1:32:04That's just virtually true.
- 1:32:05Yes,
- 1:32:05because what you say,
- 1:32:06that's,
- 1:32:07yes,
- 1:32:07because you think that say's the case.
- 1:32:08No,
- 1:32:08you already agreed that coercion exists in the system.
- 1:32:11You're just saying that socialism,
- 1:32:12you're saying that socialism is the government mandating owners to do it,
- 1:32:15but
- 1:32:16you're saying that markets do the exact same thing.
- 1:32:17You just said that the market price determines don't put words in my mouth.
- 1:32:20I like you.
- 1:32:21You're respectful.
- 1:32:21You're a nice guy.
- 1:32:22Don't put words in my mouth.
- 1:32:23Did you not say that markets determine market rates?
- 1:32:25I haven't.
- 1:32:26I,
- 1:32:26I'm.
- 1:32:27What I'm telling you is there will be abuse in business.
- 1:32:30And if there is a person I'm gonna ask you the same question as soon as you're done,
- 1:32:33but there is abuse in business.
- 1:32:35Some people will take advantage of that.
- 1:32:36But the benefit of a free market capitalism
- 1:32:39is if I don't treat you fairly,
- 1:32:41you go work for him.
- 1:32:42If he doesn't treat you fairly,
- 1:32:43you go work for him.
- 1:32:45Eventually,
- 1:32:45if you bring enough value,
- 1:32:47guess who can't afford to lose you?
- 1:32:48I can't afford to lose you.
- 1:32:50If I can't afford to lose you determine if I can't afford to lose you,
- 1:32:53guess what I have to do to you?
- 1:32:55Do you think the markets determine market rates?
- 1:32:57You didn't answer my question.
- 1:32:58If I can't afford to lose you,
- 1:33:00guess what I do to you?
- 1:33:01Do you know what a monopsopy is?
- 1:33:03Tell me about it.
- 1:33:03So do you know the difference between a monopoly and a monopoly.
- 1:33:06Tell me about monosy.
- 1:33:07OK,
- 1:33:07so a monopoly is a single seller who has rare competition within the selling of the,
- 1:33:12the distribution
- 1:33:14that creates like inflated prices and that can hurt consumers.
- 1:33:17But a monopopy
- 1:33:18is,
- 1:33:18uh,
- 1:33:19one single buyer.
- 1:33:20So this is an employer.
- 1:33:21Uh,
- 1:33:21there are things called company towns.
- 1:33:23You brought up the example of Walmart outpricing small businesses.
- 1:33:26I think that's a fantastic.
- 1:33:27the minimum wage side,
- 1:33:28right,
- 1:33:28of,
- 1:33:28of how there are large businesses that
- 1:33:30utilize their leverage and their influence and their
- 1:33:32capital in order to determine what those wages
- 1:33:34look like in a given particular place.
- 1:33:36So what I want to argue is
- 1:33:38minimum wages
- 1:33:40seem to stifle monosymies because they allow people to start at the same floor rate.
- 1:33:45You're saying that big businesses have an advantage when
- 1:33:47there's a minimum wage because they can pay more.
- 1:33:48We are also advocating for higher taxation rates and capital gains taxes on
- 1:33:53these businesses that are supposedly taking advantage of the system and we,
- 1:33:56we,
- 1:33:56we.
- 1:33:57You can invest this in tax breaks for small businesses,
- 1:34:00for people that have less employees.
- 1:34:02Maybe you say that less than 5 employees,
- 1:34:04they have certain tax incentives,
- 1:34:05so they're not taxed at the same rate as these large conglomerates.
- 1:34:08But that does not mean that a minimum wage is a bad idea
- 1:34:10because like most people here said,
- 1:34:12you can't survive on less than $7 an hour in most places.
- 1:34:16You know what's the great thing about
- 1:34:18business and numbers and data
- 1:34:20is every idea is getting.
- 1:34:21Exposed
- 1:34:23during COVID,
- 1:34:24all the policies that came out from the leftist side,
- 1:34:27they're all getting exposed today.
- 1:34:29Within time,
- 1:34:31everybody
- 1:34:31realizes what works and what doesn't work those policies when,
- 1:34:34when states who chose kids to stay home instead of going to school,
- 1:34:37is that a socialist policy?
- 1:34:38That is a control because when a government is ran in a way that they're controlling,
- 1:34:42that's not socialism.
- 1:34:43Socialism is a form of control is a workers' control of their own.
- 1:34:46Ultimate control.
- 1:34:47Socialism is workers' control of their own workplace.
- 1:34:49Socialism is a form of control.
- 1:34:51Communism is the ultimate control.
- 1:34:52You're using this rhetorical device as saying that capitalism equals freedom.
- 1:34:56Socialism equals control.
- 1:34:57I want and I respectful to you,
- 1:34:58and I've given you a couple questions that you haven't answered yet.
- 1:35:01I'll answer any questions.
- 1:35:01I want to go back to the question that I asked the rhetorical
- 1:35:03strategy that you're using might be beneficial for a large media platform.
- 1:35:08It's not based in reality.
- 1:35:09If you bring value to me.
- 1:35:11And you're so effective to my company.
- 1:35:13If you get to a point that I don't give you a good salary
- 1:35:15and I don't give you equity,
- 1:35:17what's gonna happen to you most likely?
- 1:35:18I'm gonna try to start a union with my workplace so that way we
- 1:35:21can collectively bargain on how to raise the floor for one of the options.
- 1:35:24But guess typically what ends up happening?
- 1:35:26What happens?
- 1:35:27You're busted leave and you go to a different company,
- 1:35:29and they,
- 1:35:29are you saying the owners bust the union?
- 1:35:30Is that what you're saying?
- 1:35:31No,
- 1:35:31it's not what I'm saying.
- 1:35:32I'm not talking union.
- 1:35:33You're talking about a different candidate,
- 1:35:35a different person.
- 1:35:36Uh,
- 1:35:36I think in some places they work.
- 1:35:37I told you earlier,
- 1:35:38in many cases they're divisive.
- 1:35:39We agree.
- 1:35:40You also mentioned Wealth of Nations.
- 1:35:41Uh,
- 1:35:42you like Adam Smith.
- 1:35:43Um,
- 1:35:43I think a lot of his ideas,
- 1:35:44yes.
- 1:35:45Do you disagree,
- 1:35:45or do you also agree that landlords are parasites?
- 1:35:48I don't agree.
- 1:35:49Landlords are parasites.
- 1:35:49Adam Smith,
- 1:35:50even Wealth of Nations author said that.
- 1:35:52I don't.
- 1:35:52He said that rent is,
- 1:35:53you're cherry picking.
- 1:35:54I don't think landlords are parasites.
- 1:35:56I think in many cases
- 1:35:58when you think about what's happening with New York right now,
- 1:36:00this is why I'm telling you guys,
- 1:36:02I hope all of us reunite.
- 1:36:04In 4 years and we have a conversation
- 1:36:06and I hope Mamdani wins.
- 1:36:08I am hoping Mamdani wins because that case study is gonna
- 1:36:11get opened up and all of you guys are gonna see.
- 1:36:13Can we both,
- 1:36:14can we both agree that corporate Democrats are a stain on this country?
- 1:36:17Corporate like Democrats that utilize their
- 1:36:19leverage and utilize their influence to maximize
- 1:36:21their own private wealth is a bad thing that we should discourage.
- 1:36:24I think if it's their choice,
- 1:36:25I don't think you and I get to tell them what to do and what not to do.
- 1:36:28So you think that like insider trading should be allowed.
- 1:36:30I'm not for insider trading whatsoever.
- 1:36:31You just said it's their choice.
- 1:36:32No,
- 1:36:33you.
- 1:36:33If you're you can use your influence if you're specific with insider trading,
- 1:36:37that's a different conversation.
- 1:36:38I just think that all of these are examples of why capitalism is not a meritocracy,
- 1:36:42especially when you're saying that politicians who
- 1:36:44utilize their influence to maximize their own wealth
- 1:36:46could be when you're talking about landlords who
- 1:36:48are profiting off of necessity for people,
- 1:36:50or you're talking about business owners who stifle unions
- 1:36:52for people that just want to collectively organize.
- 1:36:53You could be right if the data was shown.
- 1:36:56I'll shake your hand absolutely.
- 1:36:57I'm not trying to disrespect you.
- 1:36:58No,
- 1:36:58you've been very respectful.
- 1:36:59No,
- 1:37:00no,
- 1:37:00but for me to tell you this.
- 1:37:02Everything here can be proven based on data.
- 1:37:05If your policies are so attractive,
- 1:37:07I'm gonna come to you.
- 1:37:08Empirical data shows that worker cooperatives are
- 1:37:11not only more sustainable to market collapses,
- 1:37:14but they also provide more of an actual
- 1:37:16attachment to the work that those workers have.
- 1:37:18The alienation of labor is absolutely making people hate their jobs.
- 1:37:22Why do you think most people watching probably
- 1:37:24don't like the workplace that they're in,
- 1:37:25but still agree that there's some problem in America,
- 1:37:27whether they're saying it's.
- 1:37:28Immigrants or whether they're saying it's billionaires,
- 1:37:30what the problem is in America is people don't feel an actual
- 1:37:33attachment to what they're producing in the world about Social Security.
- 1:37:36What do you think about what FDR did?
- 1:37:38Wait,
- 1:37:38actually,
- 1:37:38do you have nothing to say about this worker your point's been made.
- 1:37:40Go back to Social Security.
- 1:37:41This has been done with,
- 1:37:42right?
- 1:37:42If we have a couple minutes,
- 1:37:43what do you think about Social Security and how FDR came up with it?
- 1:37:46Yeah,
- 1:37:46I think FDR from most historians are placed in the top 3 of all presidents,
- 1:37:50and that's from conservatives and,
- 1:37:51and Democrats.
- 1:37:52I think that FDR got a lot of things great.
- 1:37:54I really like.
- 1:37:54His second bill of economic rights.
- 1:37:56I think it's very vital that we provide people with housing.
- 1:37:58We decommodify things that are necessities.
- 1:38:00Do you know the difference between elastic and inelastic goods?
- 1:38:03Stay on Social Security.
- 1:38:04Oh,
- 1:38:04so you don't know the difference.
- 1:38:05What do you think about Social Security?
- 1:38:06Stay on that.
- 1:38:07OK,
- 1:38:07well,
- 1:38:07Social Security,
- 1:38:08I think,
- 1:38:08was initially had as a social safety net
- 1:38:11to add a supplemental income to people's pensions.
- 1:38:13So most people going into like the 1950s all the way up to the 1980s
- 1:38:17were given pensions by corporations as a promise to if you work for my firm.
- 1:38:21I'll make sure that I supplement the exact same salary
- 1:38:23that you're getting throughout the rest of your life.
- 1:38:25Now,
- 1:38:25what Ronald Reagan did was he
- 1:38:26changed the pensions to contribution-based retirement,
- 1:38:29which means I have to put this in the 401k.
- 1:38:31I have to put it in the stock market.
- 1:38:32And if the stock market collapses,
- 1:38:34do you think Social Security ended up being a system that works?
- 1:38:37I think that Social Security is definitely needed as a supplemental income.
- 1:38:40And right now,
- 1:38:41since we have contribution-based retirements,
- 1:38:43it's absolutely needed because if you don't want old people eating cat food,
- 1:38:46we.
- 1:38:46Probably need some sort of sustainable income when he,
- 1:38:48when he came up with Social Security,
- 1:38:50do you think his intention was to have 74 million people use it today?
- 1:38:54Do you think that's what he thought it was gonna happen?
- 1:38:56Yeah,
- 1:38:56and I think it's because you're not gutting the program in its entirety.
- 1:38:59You can say that Social Security is a failure if you take the wheels off of a car.
- 1:39:03The car's not gonna run.
- 1:39:04So if you continue to buff it up and you make sure that you have good guard rails,
- 1:39:07but it can be a successful.
- 1:39:08The challenge is,
- 1:39:09a lot of time when you come up with a noble idea to try to fix something today.
- 1:39:13Ends up getting bigger and you never expected it.
- 1:39:15When Social Security first came out in 1935,
- 1:39:18the first benefits were paid in 1937
- 1:39:20and it was paid in a lump sum.
- 1:39:22At that time we had 128 million people living in America.
- 1:39:25Do you know how many people got Social Security?
- 1:39:2754,000.
- 1:39:29Do you know when benefits started?
- 1:39:31Tell me
- 1:39:3165 years old.
- 1:39:33So let me say this again to you.
- 1:39:35Life expectancy
- 1:39:36was 61.
- 1:39:38Social Security benefits started at 65.
- 1:39:42And you're saying because we've increased life,
- 1:39:43people need to work longer,
- 1:39:44right?
- 1:39:4404.
- 1:39:46Working at the,
- 1:39:47let me make my point and then you can say anything you want to say.
- 1:39:50Well,
- 1:39:50I'm just saying you said as life expectancy increases,
- 1:39:53people should be working longer.
- 1:39:54tell you,
- 1:39:54you want to extend the retirement age.
- 1:39:56No,
- 1:39:56no.
- 1:39:56If you bring that to today
- 1:39:58and you bring the math exact same formula as the great FDR came up with,
- 1:40:01Patrick,
- 1:40:01here's the difference between our worldviews.
- 1:40:03You're saying that because Social Security 340 million people,
- 1:40:07let me say the point,
- 1:40:08and then I'll
- 1:40:08let you speak
- 1:40:09as long as you wanna speak.
- 1:40:11So that went from
- 1:40:12math again for you,
- 1:40:1354,000.
- 1:40:15Out of 128 million people,
- 1:40:170.04%.
- 1:40:19Life expectancy,
- 1:40:2061,
- 1:40:21benefits starts 65.
- 1:40:22Today
- 1:40:24it's 74 million out of 340 million.
- 1:40:28That's 21%
- 1:40:30when life expectancy is 78.
- 1:40:33Benefits start at 65%.
- 1:40:34Do you know who's gonna pay the price on Social Security?
- 1:40:37Not my generation.
- 1:40:38Yours is keep doing cuts,
- 1:40:39correct?
- 1:40:39If we keep doing cuts,
- 1:40:40no,
- 1:40:40because you're gonna run out of money.
- 1:40:41You're gonna run out of money.
- 1:40:42That's not how it works.
- 1:40:43So the difference between our worldview,
- 1:40:45Patrick,
- 1:40:45is you're saying not only should people work.
- 1:40:47Longer into life because life expectancy has increased,
- 1:40:49but they should work longer into life without guarantees for healthcare,
- 1:40:52without preventative care,
- 1:40:53and that's not only going to increase
- 1:40:55the deterioration of people's living conditions,
- 1:40:57it's also going to lead to a worse economy,
- 1:40:59because let me tell you,
- 1:40:5970 year olds not going to be the most productive members of our economy.
- 1:41:02They should be spending time with their families.
- 1:41:04They should be easing into their passing away.
- 1:41:06We shouldn't be forcing Grandma to go to the mill.
- 1:41:07It's going to be on your back.
- 1:41:08You,
- 1:41:08you'll be paying for this in 30 years.
- 1:41:10Appreciate you.
- 1:41:14Yeah,
- 1:41:15I think that Patrick is a really great salesman.
- 1:41:17I think that he came in and confidently sold what capitalism is,
- 1:41:21but I think that the main point of today really showed
- 1:41:24that capitalism's best product is giving excuses for its own failures.
- 1:41:27I don't think that we should be giving these people
- 1:41:29a large platform to amass a larger following,
- 1:41:32but I do think that we should expose these people to the light,
- 1:41:35um,
- 1:41:35and I think that even if people have
- 1:41:37horrendous.
- 1:41:38And repulsive views like he did.
- 1:41:40I want to hear them because I want to know who those people are.
- 1:41:42I also don't think
- 1:41:44that he really listened to a lot of the claims.
- 1:41:46I also don't think everyone listened to his claims either,
- 1:41:49so I don't know how productive of a dialogue it was,
- 1:41:51but maybe we convinced some people at home one way or the other,
- 1:41:53and
- 1:41:54maybe there's some value to that,
- 1:41:55maybe not.
- 1:41:56My vision for America is if there's anything that's happened after COVID,
- 1:42:01we used to.
- 1:42:01Here
- 1:42:02we disagreed on issues here.
- 1:42:03This is center,
- 1:42:05this is libertarian,
- 1:42:06this is
- 1:42:07conservative,
- 1:42:08and then
- 1:42:09during COVID,
- 1:42:09we went here,
- 1:42:10here,
- 1:42:11here,
- 1:42:11here,
- 1:42:11here,
- 1:42:12where we are
- 1:42:13in a very interesting place that
- 1:42:16some people don't even want to talk to somebody else that they don't agree with.
- 1:42:18It's gotten to the point that we are a little bit
- 1:42:20too divided right now and I'd like to see America be more
- 1:42:24united
- 1:42:25than as divided,
- 1:42:26divided as it is.
- 1:42:28Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:42:31your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:42:33And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:42:36subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.