Latest / No Way Out / Naval Power in Action with CAPT Brent Sadler, USN (Ret.)
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, Brent Sadler is here with us today on No Way Out.
- 0:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Before we get airborne moose and to our listeners, I want to provide some context on how our paths crossed maybe 10 years ago.
- 0:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm a Navy reservist, uh, you know, knucklehead reservist, uh, guys that show up and work on their footrups and that type of thing.
- 0:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, I show up to Paycom J5, and Captain Sadler um grabs me and says, Hey, I want you to uh help us with something.
- 0:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm gonna introduce you to a Lieutenant Colonel uh Russell Davis.
- 0:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you remember Russell Davis there?
- 0:54Brent Sadler: Uh oh, I remember Russ.
- 0:55Brent Sadler: Yep.
- 0:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah.
- 0:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So um Russ grabs me, and the three of us sit down and we start talking about complex adaptive systems, the Kinevin framework and John Boyd's Observe Orient Decide Act Loop.
- 1:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm like, ah, great place to be, complexity thinkers, my type of people.
- 1:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And um, what I ended up getting tapped to do by by Captain Sadler, I'm a commander at the time, is to work with Russ on a resiliency war game.
- 1:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that war game, uh, we can't get into a lot of details about it here.
- 1:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, maybe Brent could talk a little bit more about what how that has influenced um maritime strategy and strategy in Indo PAYCOM.
- 1:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, but what we did there is we got away from the linear approaches to strategy, um, things that we learned in the cockpit.
- 1:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I hate this because a lot of people that come out of the cockpit start with the end in mind and work backwards.
- 1:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, this approach is more about understanding the context.
- 1:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What does the context tell us?
- 1:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are those affordances?
- 1:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What should we be doing with the strategy?
- 1:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what I think Brent really brings to our national strategy conversation is he he thinks like this.
- 1:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He looks at the world and says, This is what's happening, this is what is likely to happen.
- 2:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here's how we need to prepare for that.
- 2:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, uh, what I want to do is turn it over to you, Brent.
- 2:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, great to see you here.
- 2:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh, I know you want to talk about the South China Sea and what's happening there.
- 2:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, so build on that if you can.
- 2:16unknown: Yeah.
- 2:16Brent Sadler: Well, yeah, great, great to connect back with the shipmates and you're bringing back dusting off some cobwebs.
- 2:22Brent Sadler: Uh, the stories and what we were doing back there, uh, I was at PACOM 2012 to 2015.
- 2:28Brent Sadler: So when you came, when we met, I would been, I think about two years of very little sleep dealing with uh talking with all our folks in the Western Pacific and East Asia, so U.S.
- 2:41Brent Sadler: Forces Korea, uh, our embassy folks in places like India, but also in uh Malaysia, the Philippines, and of course, deployed units.
- 2:50Brent Sadler: And then at the other time of the day, I'm dealing with the DC folks.
- 2:53Brent Sadler: So I never got any sleep because Hawaii is like right in the middle of that.
- 2:56Brent Sadler: And we were doing the rebalance to Asia Pacific, and what became very clear early on is business as usual was just wasn't working.
- 3:04Brent Sadler: And the other thing is when I came to PayCom, into PayCom now, but PayCom at the time, my mandate was take the China expertise that I was able to put in place here in DC and start what was called a competitive strategic uh strategy.
- 3:21Brent Sadler: It informed a lot of other things.
- 3:23Brent Sadler: That's probably about as much as I can say on that one.
- 3:26Brent Sadler: But I came to PAYCOM with a mandate and it was execute what I'd started uh, you know, for my small role and started the defense uh strat defense strategic guidance, the rebalance of the Asia Pacific.
- 3:38Brent Sadler: Uh and the way that we did planning, uh a little bit of Navy and Army here for a little bit.
- 3:44Brent Sadler: You know, everyone in uniform Navy understands that Army is very doctrinal and can be almost like vapor locked into it.
- 3:52Brent Sadler: But it's also understanding their language.
- 3:56Brent Sadler: You can actually get them to become really big allies of ours.
- 3:59Brent Sadler: And and they did.
- 4:01Brent Sadler: So the way that planning was done, and this is what you came, this is what you're talking you were getting in in the mix of, the way that we did planning was very linear.
- 4:08Brent Sadler: It was very, you know, okay, we're in phase zero, one, two, three, four, five.
- 4:13Brent Sadler: These are the the ray the levels of conflict, and it was very, you know, cookie cutter.
- 4:20Brent Sadler: It's like you meet these conditions, the general or the admiral will say, now we're in phase one, and then things would just magically change.
- 4:27Brent Sadler: That's not human nature, that's not human existence, that's certainly not the way that our adversary, the Chinese, behave.
- 4:34Brent Sadler: And so we started in like 2012 through the 15, we moved to a much more gradual, graduated kind of thinking where we blended things.
- 4:43Brent Sadler: And you may be going up in escalation, but then you can also, you're planning to also go down in the way that you want.
- 4:49Brent Sadler: What we were trying to do was connecting war fighting into peacetime campaigning, and that we could seamlessly go back and forth.
- 4:57Brent Sadler: Um, a spectrum of rivalry is what eventually Admiral Munch uh called this this approach.
- 5:05Brent Sadler: And that was like 2019 time frame when he when he started calling it.
- 5:09Brent Sadler: So this was a year's effort that you were a part of.
- 5:12Brent Sadler: Uh it, I think we knew it at the time that it was a poison pill that we were putting into the the department's uh thinking, and a poison pill for all the right reasons.
- 5:22Brent Sadler: It changed the way we think.
- 5:24Brent Sadler: Uh, I think it's complicated our adversaries' understanding of how we how we would fight, thankfully.
- 5:31Brent Sadler: Um, a lot of work left to be done.
- 5:33Brent Sadler: It's a fight that I'm still engaged in.
- 5:35Brent Sadler: The first book that I wrote, heavily informed from our experience together uh at Paycom and a lot of other things.
- 5:41Brent Sadler: Uh, this is a U.S.
- 5:42Brent Sadler: Naval Power 21st Century new book, which just came out in September, uh, talks a lot about the details about one specific area, and that's the South China Sea, uh, but also in the new Cold War.
- 5:54Brent Sadler: How do we actually fight uh and persevere rather in this new Cold War that we're in with China?
- 6:00Brent Sadler: So I just fair, man.
- 6:02Brent Sadler: You took me back.
- 6:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I wanted to bring that up because I wanted to thank you for how that really changed my perspective that there are solid people in the DOD or DOW now uh that know how to plan, know how to do things.
- 6:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and Russ was a Sam's grad.
- 6:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh, yeah.
- 6:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to add one more thing, which is very important here for our listeners.
- 6:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, Grant Hammond was uh Russ's advisor, uh, I believe around our command of staff college time to his transition to Sam's.
- 6:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: For those of you who are not familiar with uh Grant Hammond, he is the author of A Mind of War uh and also the uh author of uh a discourse on winning and losing, which is John Boyd's work, uh, which we talk about quite a bit.
- 6:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So to have that type of influence, that nonlinear thinking, that understanding context, uh, is critical.
- 6:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And there are pockets inside the our our Department of War now that know how to do this.
- 6:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And Brent uh gave me that opportunity to actually utilize these tools and techniques and experiment and probe to see what we can get.
- 6:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I would say that that experience with the uh resiliency war game was probably that the one of the most exciting things I got to do as at a strategic level or operational level warfare.
- 7:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So thanks for that, Brent.
- 7:08Brent Sadler: Yeah, your legacy lives on, by the way.
- 7:10Brent Sadler: I was in Hawaii not too long ago in the midst of I wasn't invited because it was I stay away from the classified world now that I'm such a public figure uh uh out here now, out of uniform.
- 7:20Brent Sadler: So uh but they were doing a they were doing one of the successors of what what you were what you were beginning.
- 7:26Brent Sadler: So it's very much an appreciated challenge.
- 7:30Brent Sadler: Um lots of questions, and the more that you experiment, the more that you understand your own limitations.
- 7:36Brent Sadler: So, you know, to you to comment, Tun Tzu, know your enemy, but know yourself.
- 7:40Brent Sadler: And so these logistics exercises are profound.
- 7:44Brent Sadler: Uh they're being done in more places than than in DupeCom, too.
- 7:48Brent Sadler: So thank you for your effort on that as well.
- 7:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks again.
- 7:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, so we we've had folks come on and talk about Force Design 2030 uh from the Marine Corps.
- 7:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I think a lot of that has uh built on some of the things we may have looked at years ago.
- 8:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh it may be right or wrong.
- 8:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's we will maybe check in with you on that here in a moment.
- 8:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we also look at uh understanding context and probing and and that type of thing, uh, as well as unrestricted warfare by the Chinese, the the Chinese doctrine that may or may not be out there.
- 8:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um the the current sense that I get from folks is that we're waiting for a kinetic war to happen.
- 8:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh the way Moose and I look at it right now, we're already at war with the Chinese, right?
- 8:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're already at it's it's a it's a fifth generation, maybe a fourth generation type of warfare.
- 8:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can can we get your thoughts on that right now?
- 8:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are we is there are we at war?
- 8:34Brent Sadler: Yeah.
- 8:35Brent Sadler: Uh in the communist Chinese or the Chinese Communist Party's mentality, yes.
- 8:40Brent Sadler: And it was began it while the bodies were still warm in Tiananmen Square in June of 1989.
- 8:46Brent Sadler: And we know that from the leaked Tiananmen Square papers, which by 1998, 1999, uh it was out there, it was floating around, it was a little bit like a pirated copy back in the 90s to get your hands on this thing.
- 8:57Brent Sadler: Um, but you can find it now and you can read it and you can see the deliberations.
- 9:02Brent Sadler: Very clearly, the Chinese Communist Party under Deng Xiaoping, the supposed moderate and one that was going to bring China into the into like a Western free market economy, and one that we could live with, uh was the leader in making that distinction.
- 9:17Brent Sadler: So the Chinese Communist Party is what it is.
- 9:20Brent Sadler: Its colors remain Chinese, remain communist red, and it's not compatible with a free markets, and it's not compatible with individual liberties, the sovereignty being with the individual.
- 9:33Brent Sadler: So yeah, we're at war.
- 9:35Brent Sadler: Uh it's a it's a war with Chinese characteristics, so subterfuge, deceit, uh hedging every action uh so that you can actually further your own interests.
- 9:46Brent Sadler: Things like educational exchanges with like middle schools or high schools are in the context of this war in a chin in the Communist Party's mind.
- 9:56Brent Sadler: We don't think about it that way, but we have to.
- 9:58Brent Sadler: We're about 25 years late to task, uh, that it's economic, it's diplomatic, it's societal, it's informational, and where I think most of the listeners to your show, it's military as well.
- 10:12Brent Sadler: And um so yes, and you see it, and you know what you're looking for.
- 10:18Speaker 1: That's uh that's pretty amazing, especially when you talk about the the the kids in school being exchanged.
- 10:25Speaker 1: It was no different when I was in grad school.
- 10:27Speaker 1: I think half our cohort was from was from the uh from the PRC.
- 10:32Speaker 1: Um and that's all part of a grander strategy, I think, that most people are completely oblivious to.
- 10:40Speaker 1: And a lot of the the criticism that I've had on some of the and by the way, I'm I am a charter member of the South China Sea Yacht Club.
- 10:47Speaker 1: Um, I spent a year on a uh a cooperative engagement float uh back in 2000 when we were you know keeping our restoring relations, you know, keeping relations up and that sort of a thing.
- 10:59Speaker 1: And um I'm sure at some point we'll talk about Fat Leonard, uh, which is someone I saw with my own eyes and uh met.
- 11:07Speaker 1: Um but I I I what you were alluding to when you talk about things like exchange programs and things like I'm saying about like my grad school cohort being you know half from PRC, and we think of things that are happening like lawfare and currency war and other things that were written about in unrestricted warfare.
- 11:26Speaker 1: It seems to me that a completely myopic view of only focusing on kinetic possibilities is completely short-sighted given the the real and present danger of China, who tends to understand complexity in Sun Tzu and John Boyd more than it seems that our own our own country does.
- 11:48Brent Sadler: Yeah, I mean, there's a lot there.
- 11:49Brent Sadler: I mean, I I was probably a I was a flag lieutenant at Seventh Fleet, so I may have actually visited with the Admiral.
- 11:55Speaker 1: Well, you know, carrot float, right?
- 11:56Speaker 1: Cooperation afloat, readiness.
- 11:59Brent Sadler: We would, and we did a lot of things.
- 12:00Brent Sadler: So our paths crossed, yeah.
- 12:01Brent Sadler: Oh, yeah, I'm sure we are we crossed paths.
- 12:04Brent Sadler: Um uh both old Westpac sailors and Marines.
- 12:08Speaker 1: Luckily, as a first lieutenant field artillery officer, I was of no value to Fat Leonard.
- 12:12Speaker 1: So he was there though.
- 12:15Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 12:15Speaker 1: So anyway.
- 12:17Brent Sadler: Um yeah, my goal, I and I it's a shame what Fat Leonard was able to do, but again, like all of us that live on the sea, death can come at any moment.
- 12:28Brent Sadler: You always have to be vigilant.
- 12:29Brent Sadler: Yeah.
- 12:30Brent Sadler: Uh even when peacetime, because the sea, the ocean is unforgiving to the stupid.
- 12:34Brent Sadler: And when you make a mistake, uh she's willing to take you right away.
- 12:38Brent Sadler: So it's much the same way.
- 12:40Brent Sadler: There are a lot of grifters and and folks out there trying to take to take advantage, and leadership had a lapse.
- 12:47Brent Sadler: It's the best way to put it.
- 12:48Brent Sadler: And Fat Leonard was always an ever-present risk.
- 12:51Brent Sadler: He was known.
- 12:52Brent Sadler: I kept him away from the ship, the Blue Ridge, for my tenure.
- 12:56Brent Sadler: Not even allowed on the pier.
- 12:57Brent Sadler: He tried numerous times to get on board.
- 12:59Brent Sadler: Uh, my last J I did a very long junior officer tour back in the 90s.
- 13:04Brent Sadler: It was like almost four and a half years.
- 13:06Brent Sadler: Uh, and my last Westpac, we pulled into Padia, Thailand, and the skipper had me on the periscope, uh, said, Look at the pier.
- 13:16Brent Sadler: I'm not leaving if you see a big fat guy.
- 13:18Brent Sadler: And I'm like, Yeah, there's a fat guy.
- 13:20Brent Sadler: What kind of fat guy am I looking for?
- 13:23Brent Sadler: And and I I flip what we he looks he looks through the scope and says, I'm just staying on the ship, I'm not leaving.
- 13:29Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, fat Leonard, the the the name fat was actually an understatement.
- 13:32Speaker 1: I mean, he was a ginormous uh being.
- 13:36Speaker 1: Um I well, and I I certainly I love your comments.
- 13:40Speaker 1: I I I believe, you know, even as a Marine, you know, we're naval too.
- 13:43Speaker 1: And I think that our edge, uh, whether we're naval aviators, whether we're subsurface, surface, uh, anybody in the naval branches has that edge of calculating in the sea, which is the uh one natural, ever-present force of constant change.
- 13:56Speaker 1: You're constantly adjusting for it.
- 13:58Speaker 1: Um I wonder about the there's another dichotomy there that is kind of a weird thing, is when when he was operational, we actually were pretty effective with him.
- 14:08Speaker 1: And that was one of the the major points of the uh podcast series on him that we had Tom Wright on to come and talk about was the fact that, hey, all of this bad shit happened, and this is really bad and repugnant, and yet at the same time, our national security and whatever in in uh in the South China Sea and other places was actually pretty effective, irrespective of all the uh immoral and unethical things that uh you know, from time immemorial since sailors have put to sea, this stuff, this is not new.
- 14:37Speaker 1: This is nothing nothing new.
- 14:39Speaker 1: I guess it's probably new in a uh a media environment like we have.
- 14:43Brent Sadler: Well, you need to know you need to know who you're dealing with.
- 14:45Brent Sadler: And when you did, at least from my experience as a flag lieutenant, uh so junior officer or Westpac sailor all the way through to 2001 as a flag lieutenant, um, know who you're dealing with.
- 14:57Brent Sadler: Know what role they're playing.
- 15:00Brent Sadler: Um I mean, it's warfare and it's competition with bad people that we're trying to outmaneuver and outsmart.
- 15:07Brent Sadler: Uh you're gonna have bad actors that will be allies at times, but there's always a risk.
- 15:11Brent Sadler: And so uh again, it's a nature, it's just the nature of doing business.
- 15:16Brent Sadler: The the legacy of the Fat Linder scandal, I think, was uh far worse.
- 15:21Brent Sadler: The consequence was far worse than you know, they should have hammered the individuals that did the bad things.
- 15:26Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 15:27Brent Sadler: It had a chilling effect over port visits and engagement throughout Southeast Asia for, I mean, for a long time.
- 15:34Brent Sadler: I was a defense attache in Malaysia and I was fighting this, and this was 2017 to 18 timeframe.
- 15:41Brent Sadler: Uh and that actually had a tactical and strategic impact on our ability to deter what the Chinese were doing.
- 15:50Brent Sadler: So I think we've turned the corner, but we have to be always vigilant.
- 15:54Speaker 1: Let's pivot it back to the the overall theme and get away from Fat Leonard, but just really point to the fact that it does what Fat Leonard shows, amongst all the other things that we've talked about, is that the complexity of this.
- 16:05Speaker 1: There's nothing simple of point A, point B, we're the good guys, they're the bad guys.
- 16:10Speaker 1: It's not, it's it's not that simple.
- 16:11Speaker 1: It's extremely complex.
- 16:13Brent Sadler: No, the um the concept, again, from my lessons growing up in Asia, uh, and then as a junior, and all those experiences, you know, the Fat Leonard's in the mix of that.
- 16:23Brent Sadler: And this concept called naval statecraft.
- 16:25Brent Sadler: The last administration uh embraced the idea.
- 16:28Brent Sadler: This administration, under Trump, is also embracing the idea, uh, though they're not using, thankfully, the last administration's term.
- 16:35Brent Sadler: They took my term naval statecraft and called it maritime statecraft.
- 16:39Brent Sadler: And it it we need thinkers and leaders that think nonlinearly, able to see how different timelines, different efforts can actually come together in unexpected ways, and then lead those changes.
- 16:54Brent Sadler: Um economic statecraft, naval presence, active and aggressive diplomacy that's actually focused.
- 17:01Brent Sadler: Um, these things all come together in this cocktail called naval statecraft.
- 17:06Brent Sadler: And we need leaders to do that.
- 17:07Brent Sadler: Um there's a few examples that exist that I point to, but uh, we still aren't designing and acting on a plan.
- 17:17Brent Sadler: It's more happenstance and getting lucky by having the right person in the right place with the right tools.
- 17:24Speaker 1: What would you say is the gold standard or the or the model worth emulating?
- 17:27Speaker 1: Who's who who would you say?
- 17:29Brent Sadler: Yeah, so 2020, uh the West Kapala incident.
- 17:33Brent Sadler: Uh so I was already back in DC, I was already getting ready to retire when this and actually, yeah, I actually did retire as this was peaking.
- 17:41Brent Sadler: Um so I I was watching it from the outside.
- 17:44Brent Sadler: What I found out, what I'm about to tell you, was all by luck.
- 17:48Brent Sadler: Was not by design.
- 17:50Brent Sadler: And no one's gotten better at it yet.
- 17:52Brent Sadler: But so if we roll the clock back to 2019, uh the Malaysians charter this this offshore vessel, the West Kapala, to do offshore energy surveys in their own EEZ.
- 18:05Brent Sadler: But of course, the Chinese think it's theirs.
- 18:07Brent Sadler: So they start screwing with them.
- 18:08Brent Sadler: The classic form, maritime militia, Chinese Coast Guard.
- 18:12Brent Sadler: But this is also coming to an election in Taiwan.
- 18:16Brent Sadler: And as all of us know, in the military, there's one thing on the calendar that you can you always have to be ready for things going sideways, Taiwan presidential elections.
- 18:25Brent Sadler: So there was a lot of U.S.
- 18:27Brent Sadler: naval and military presence in the region or ready to come to the region if the Chinese wanted to try to do a repeat of the third Taiwan crisis, another thing that happened in the late 90s, that was about Taiwan presidential elections.
- 18:43Brent Sadler: And so these naval forces were in the area.
- 18:45Brent Sadler: The Chinese are messing with the West Kapala in the South China Sea.
- 18:49Brent Sadler: Uh naval forces kind of started being pr viewed by the Chinese and others in the region as being a deterrent against the Chinese.
- 18:58Brent Sadler: But it wasn't until the Seventh Fleet Admiral at the time connected very explicitly, and I don't I I I I kind of know how and why he did it, but it wasn't with the intent of a bigger purpose.
- 19:13Brent Sadler: And he said naval presence is also to assure the economic rights of our partners and upholding the rules-based order.
- 19:21Brent Sadler: I had never seen an admiral or political leader connect specific naval presence with the economic rights of our partners.
- 19:30Brent Sadler: Not normally you'd hear them like, oh, so much shipping, 80% of the world's sh trade is on sea lift, and it's free open sea lanes.
- 19:38Brent Sadler: That's that's anodyne.
- 19:40Brent Sadler: It's for say it's not going to move the needle if you're a Malaysia.
- 19:44Brent Sadler: But if you're a Malaysia trying to get money out of your seabed and energy that your government budget relies on, which it does, and it does it still does, having an ally say, hey, our military is in the area to keep bad guys from impacting your bottom line, your economy, your economic rights.
- 20:02Brent Sadler: And what happened after that statement is you started to see, uh, and Vietnam was the ASEAN chair, you start to see statements that you never really heard coming out politically that were in support.
- 20:14Brent Sadler: Not, hey, the military US needs to not stir things up.
- 20:18Brent Sadler: You you hear a softening.
- 20:19Brent Sadler: And then in July of 2020, Secretary of State says a speech, by the way, that was prepared to occur back many months earlier, that said China's claims on the South China Sea are illegal.
- 20:31Brent Sadler: They're excessive and they're illegal.
- 20:33Brent Sadler: Now, had the Admiral's statement happened after that, everyone in the region would have thought that we were being aggressive and that it is the U.S.
- 20:43Brent Sadler: that's instigating a problem that they would have to deal with and want and a military presence that's not going to serve their own national interest.
- 20:51Brent Sadler: But because we did it in that right sequence, because we have the naval presence there for other reasons, and it was there for a long time, everyone's like, well, wait a minute.
- 21:00Brent Sadler: The U.S.
- 21:00Brent Sadler: military, they are reliable, they're present, they're here also because of my national interests are aligned with them, and they're pushing back on the bad guys in a very forceful way that we can understand.
- 21:13Brent Sadler: Secretary of State's uh comments in July of 2020 were very explicit in unmistakable terms.
- 21:20Brent Sadler: And then to add the cherry on top, after that, polling across ASEAN countries showed that the United States was the security partner of choice by wide margins.
- 21:31Brent Sadler: That was a change from a year before, and also that China was not the economic partner that they wanted.
- 21:38Brent Sadler: It was more aspirational.
- 21:40Brent Sadler: So things changed all for the better for at the populous level, and the elites in the region started submitting demarches, public demarches, to the United Nations uh as well as to Beijing, that their actions were unhelpful.
- 22:55Brent Sadler: That is an example of naval statecraft economics and understanding your partners' needs, backed with a with a visible and persistent presence at the right place with the right type of platforms, and of course, very aggressive diplomacy, targeted aggressive diplomacy.
- 23:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Brent, at the moment you have two aviators leading up, one leading up Indo PayCom, and then you have another one leading up Pac Fleet.
- 23:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know how I started the statement that hey, we can't take that aviation mindset and start with the end in mind and work backwards.
- 23:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, you have them in a room, you have an opportunity to talk to them about what should they should be doing.
- 23:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What is your advice to them right now given the current situation?
- 23:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And maybe you should provide some context as to what's going on in the South China Sea today and what we need to be doing to counteract that, and maybe what we ought to be doing in the future with our forces positioning there.
- 23:47Brent Sadler: Yeah, I've actually talked to a couple of those folks in the past, uh, and I've worked with uh Admiral Paparo, uh shipmates together on the CNO's personal staff while we were both captains.
- 23:58Brent Sadler: Um so they wouldn't be surprised by the following.
- 24:02Brent Sadler: Uh first, we're not organized for task.
- 24:05Brent Sadler: Um the Chinese have been waging an aggressive long-term maritime insurgency.
- 24:10Brent Sadler: The target, there's the center of gravity is not the US Navy in the South China Sea for them.
- 24:15Brent Sadler: It's a peacetime competition over the patterns of behavior and what the its competitors, its neighbors, view as their waters.
- 24:23Brent Sadler: They want to change that.
- 24:25Brent Sadler: It's not it's not a war fight.
- 24:27Brent Sadler: So it's it's an insurrection or an insurgency against the rules-based order, which is unclause, you know, where territorial seas begin and end, and where pe what economic rights are included in everyone's EEZs.
- 24:41Brent Sadler: The Chinese are trying to make it all their waters.
- 24:44Brent Sadler: And so that's the goal, and we haven't really realized it.
- 24:48Brent Sadler: So the leadership now in the last few years, I think everyone gets it.
- 24:51Brent Sadler: Um but the nice thing.
- 24:53Speaker 1: Is that like a Monroe Doctrine, the like a like a Monroe Doctrine type framework?
- 24:57Brent Sadler: Uh not really.
- 24:58Brent Sadler: Uh it I I I again using army doctrine uh to help rally.
- 25:03Brent Sadler: So counterinsurgency, it the people are the center of gravity.
- 25:08Brent Sadler: In a maritime counterinsurgency using army doctrine, the center of gravity are the fishermen, it's the offshore oil exploration, it's the economic livelihood that's the center of gravity.
- 25:20Brent Sadler: It's why the West Kapala incident was so instrument, why it worked.
- 25:24Speaker 1: Um and Well, I I just mean from the standpoint of do they have a sphere of influence uh premise that we do here in our own hemisphere with say the Caribbean and everything else.
- 25:36Brent Sadler: Yeah, that so absolutely.
- 25:38Brent Sadler: But once upon a time on this on Admiral Greenert's personal staff, when I first 2011, this was one of the early go find out what's driving them, why are they reading all about Mahan?
- 25:49Brent Sadler: Um yes, they do have that kind of, and they've they've very diligently read our history and the world history on this to try to make their case.
- 25:59Brent Sadler: So they knew they know what they want, and they're trying to rationalize it.
- 26:04Brent Sadler: And the rationalization is like, well, yeah, you use your Monroe Doctrine, but it's a misunderstanding of the history.
- 26:09Brent Sadler: The Monroe Doctrine was about protecting uh the uprisings and the revolutions for, you know, Boulevard revolution throughout Latin America in the early part of the 1800s, uh, to keep the Europeans, specifically the Spanish Empire, which was kind of the evil empire of its day for Americans, out from suppressing and murdering all of the potential democratic revolutions that were going on at the time.
- 26:33Brent Sadler: So that's kind of the historical genesis was we were trying to keep these influences out because the British, the French, the Dutch, they were already there with their own colonial presence.
- 26:45Brent Sadler: Um, so it's important to understand.
- 26:46Brent Sadler: But for a Chinese communist narrative, they know that historical difference.
- 26:50Brent Sadler: They use it of like this is our area, our sphere of influence.
- 26:54Brent Sadler: Um so they definitely got and studied that uh very much.
- 26:59Brent Sadler: They've also studied our World War II history in the Pacific, which, if we want to go back to the logistics, um, they they're taking a page out of our lessons learned of 1941, 1942.
- 27:18Speaker 1: I'm I'm interested that you you mentioned World War II.
- 27:21Speaker 1: There's another thing about World War II in China that I had not been aware of until uh a mentor of mine from the Marines, a retired colonel and history professor, taught me about.
- 27:30Speaker 1: It was called Seiko, and it was the Sino-American Cooperative Organization.
- 27:34Speaker 1: And this was a guerrilla force that uh it was it's sometimes called the uh I think the Rice Patty Navy, and it was uh headed by Admiral uh Milton Miles, uh, a future Commandant Robert Barrow was he did his lieutenant time in the world World War II there.
- 27:49Speaker 1: Um but basically they were guerrilla insurgents against the Japanese on mainland China, uh, and it was a it was a joint effort between the Navy and the Marine Corps, and yeah, they'd ambush and they'd um they they'd create a lot of havoc.
- 28:03Speaker 1: And as I understood it, it was two major camps between this rice padding navy that was more affiliated with Chen Kai-shek and and um what became uh the Republic of China and Taiwan, uh sort of versus uh William Donovan and the Office of Strategic Services that was more with Mao, and and as those as those were conflicting.
- 28:26Speaker 1: And there were a lot, it's it's a book called A Different Kind of War.
- 28:28Speaker 1: It's been out of print for years, but it was actually through the Naval Institute where I had first heard of it.
- 28:33Speaker 1: And I don't know if that history has anything to do with it because we we we were supporting both gangs, so to speak, you know, both factions in China that that make up modern day China today, with the one exiled to what was then known as Formosa, but then of course the the mainland PRC.
- 28:50Speaker 1: So I did they look at that and what do they think of that?
- 28:54Brent Sadler: Uh I think the Chinese so the Chinese Communist Party has a and Chinese people have kind of a mixed feeling about that history.
- 29:02Brent Sadler: They're very proud of like the Flying Tigers.
- 29:05Brent Sadler: Uh they protected it at the worst moments of the Cultural Revolution, they protected uh Stillwell's headquarters, they kept a lot of the memorabilia safe.
- 29:13Brent Sadler: You can still kind of go find it, and so they revere that that moment in history.
- 29:17Brent Sadler: So um they view us as an ally in that moment in history, an important one.
- 29:23Brent Sadler: And I think the Chinese people, it's endearing too broadly, the Chinese Congress Party hasn't been able to suppress us, suppress it all these many years later.
- 29:31Brent Sadler: Uh they're not taking lessons from it, I think, there because it doesn't serve their purpose.
- 29:36Brent Sadler: Their purpose is to suppress their people and move out to acquire more resources, more influence, you know, and they're near abroad.
- 29:45Brent Sadler: And how do they actually persevere in a war over Taiwan?
- 29:48Brent Sadler: Those are the last one's the most important.
- 29:50Brent Sadler: The persevere in a war over Taiwan is really what animates a lot of us.
- 29:54Speaker 1: But so another strateg another strategic orientation question.
- 29:58Speaker 1: So you know, uh again, we as naval forces, I mean, we've we've been doing something in China since the 1800s, right?
- 30:06Speaker 1: I mean, we've we've we've we've had a lot of exposure.
- 30:09Speaker 1: Uh, I think that the the naval forces, the Navy, specifically the Navy and the Marine Corps, you know, we've had a lot of Eastern influence, and it's uh uh it's traceable back very far.
- 30:20Speaker 1: Um James Bradley, who wrote the book Flags of Our Fathers, and the other one about the Aishima raids, and I can't think of the name, Fly Boys.
- 30:30Speaker 1: Um, he also wrote a book called The China Mirage, and he's talking about how the past hundred years that China is recovering uh morally, you know, from what they view as Western damage upon them or Western incursion upon them, uh starting with the opium wars and going through things like the Boxer Rebellion and the China Marines and the Shanghai presence and everything like that.
- 30:52Speaker 1: And how how much of that history still weighs on their minds when it comes to diplomacy?
- 30:59Speaker 1: Because, you know, for most Americans, if you know our age, uh history started on 9 11.
- 31:04Speaker 1: You know, for most uh people at a young age, say like my kids in college, you know, history started on the day that Trump took office and everything's gone to hell, right?
- 31:12Speaker 1: So like we don't have the scope and breadth of history in a strategic lens that that they do, which can go several seconds.
- 31:18Speaker 1: Centuries, what what effect is that having on things?
- 31:21Brent Sadler: Yeah, no, the Chinese Communist Party has uh hijacked that history of the 100 years of humiliation.
- 31:27Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 31:27Brent Sadler: Uh and they and they use it as a rationale for for their excessive behavior, um, and their bullying, quite frankly.
- 31:34Brent Sadler: Most m their their neighbors in the region know better, and but they don't have they don't have a whole lot of options unless they get strong partners like the US acting a lot smarter and informed by this, understanding this history.
- 31:45Brent Sadler: So the Chinese Communist Party, they they use it as part of their mandate, is that they are bringing back China to its global dominant role that they always felt entitled to.
- 31:55Brent Sadler: And it is a form of entitlement.
- 31:57Brent Sadler: I mean, China is, you know, look at the characters, it's central country or central empire, central kingdom.
- 32:04Brent Sadler: Uh they they view themselves as that, very literally.
- 32:08Brent Sadler: Um but it's also not honest historically.
- 32:13Brent Sadler: And I think there's a lesson here for Americans to take.
- 32:16Brent Sadler: And and I've got a book that I got when I was like 10 years old sitting on the bookshelf behind me down here, uh, that's the Hundred Years of Humiliation.
- 32:23Brent Sadler: It's the title.
- 32:24Brent Sadler: It's a lot of really graphic pictures.
- 32:26Brent Sadler: Uh, but I read it when I was like seventh grade, eighth grade.
- 32:30Brent Sadler: Um the lesson from this is that China, the the Empire of China at the in the early 1800s, basically picked a fight with the British Empire.
- 32:40Brent Sadler: Uh two very proud empires rather than try to figure out how to actually benefit in a relationship mutually respectful, the Chinese were too arrogant, and the British Empire was too proud to accept that arrogance.
- 32:54Brent Sadler: And eventually, because the Chinese lost sight of having a strong, vibrant military and society, become corrupted over time, a lot of weaknesses, they eventually over series.
- 33:05Brent Sadler: It wasn't just the British, the French also had an opium war as well with the Chinese.
- 33:10Brent Sadler: The Chinese had basically picked fights uh in the first half of the 1800s with basically every major imperial power.
- 33:19Brent Sadler: Uh so they didn't, they weren't, they were not smart diplomatically at the time, highly arrogant, uh, and they kept losing.
- 33:27Brent Sadler: Eventually they had the Taiping Revolution, and it was a massive bloodbath.
- 33:32Brent Sadler: At one point in time, you had a Christian revolutionary, the Taipings, that almost toppled the entire Chinese empire, and you would have had a very different China today if had that happened.
- 33:43Speaker 1: Um that's also a major force, though, too, of the of the of the Taiwanese and the like Chen Kai-shek was a Christian too, wasn't he?
- 33:51Brent Sadler: Yes.
- 33:51Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 33:52Brent Sadler: Yes.
- 33:53Brent Sadler: So there's there's a there's a tension there.
- 33:55Brent Sadler: And the Chinese Communist Party has taken another history lesson from dynasties of the past.
- 34:01Brent Sadler: Secret, they'll call them secret societies, why they hate the Falong Gong.
- 34:05Brent Sadler: It's like an exercise and meditation group, but they view them with high suspicion and therefore they go, they overreact.
- 34:11Brent Sadler: Because in the past, the yellow turbines, the red turbines, there are all these like secret societies in the past that became the genesis for you know insiditious and revolutionary behavior that eventually caused the demise of dynasties.
- 34:27Brent Sadler: So the Chinese Communist Party, acting like a Chinese dynasty of the past, cannot allow any type of independence.
- 34:36Brent Sadler: They cannot allow any type of grouping of people, no matter how benign.
- 34:40Brent Sadler: And this is this is something they they know, but they don't address.
- 34:45Brent Sadler: We should certainly take lessons from China's experience of the Opium Wars uh and be very, you know, we need to nurture our society and our constitutional republic.
- 34:54Brent Sadler: That it that is at the core of what sets us apart, and it's our strength.
- 34:58Brent Sadler: Uh, we also need to take very seriously the threats around us, but never be so arrogant as to think that just because we are, that we will dominate.
- 35:08Brent Sadler: Nothing is given freely, and things will be taken from us if we're not careful.
- 35:13Speaker 1: Our last guest is a retired Marine colonel who um was born and raised in Pakistan, who's Pashto, and had come to the United States, uh, became a Marine officer, and then was fighting in Afghanistan.
- 35:26Speaker 1: Uh, and and you know, he certainly knows the culture there uh because he knows the tribes and the codes and things like that, and he's of that.
- 35:34Speaker 1: And one of the things that we talked about was cultural misalignment and lack of empathy, um, how there's the there's a there was a wide cultural chasm between the Americans and the Afghanis, you know, when we were intervening.
- 35:46Speaker 1: How do you assess that cultural chasm right now with the Chinese?
- 35:53Brent Sadler: Well, it so you we may be, and I would say on our side, we have had a we have a very deep bank of goodwill and empathy on the Chinese part.
- 36:03Brent Sadler: Um and they've reneged and they have violated, and again, deceit, the 36 trajeams are a historical Chinese kind of approach to competition.
- 36:13Brent Sadler: It's based in foundational and deceit.
- 36:15Brent Sadler: Um, we didn't appreciate that.
- 36:17Brent Sadler: And when you when you expect a partner or another country to react, behave in a certain way, and they don't they don't meet that, then that makes you the aggrieved party.
- 36:27Brent Sadler: It's better to understand who you're dealing with, going back to the fact, Leonard.
- 36:31Brent Sadler: Know who you're dealing with and what their motivations are, and don't have high expectations that they're gonna meet or live up to an American's gold standard on anything.
- 36:41Brent Sadler: But embrace them for who they are and what they are and treat accordingly with with with suspicions and also with uh vigilance as required.
- 36:51Brent Sadler: That's true of allies too.
- 36:53Brent Sadler: We don't always agree.
- 36:54Brent Sadler: Well, but in the case of China, um there's a lot that are that we are not in the same moral sphere.
- 37:03Brent Sadler: We have very different histories, very different cultures.
- 37:06Brent Sadler: That's not to say that we are preordained as peoples to be at each other's throats.
- 37:11Brent Sadler: The only reason why we have a potential of being at each other's throats is because the Chinese Communist Party is driving them in that direction.
- 37:20Brent Sadler: And I would say, yes, we need to understand the Chinese, but we're a far different place than we were in the 80s when I was growing up in Asia and what I've seen of America changed in appreciation of.
- 37:33Brent Sadler: But we still have a long way to go.
- 37:35Brent Sadler: Um we tend to accept the think the best in people, even when it's not there.
- 37:43Speaker 1: Give us some context.
- 37:44Speaker 1: You mentioned growing up in Asia.
- 37:45Speaker 1: Give us some context for the listeners, you know, that you're you're coming at this, not from someone that just wrote about this stuff in books.
- 37:51Speaker 1: Uh give it, give us some more context on that.
- 37:54Brent Sadler: Uh um so I moved, so the best thing is elementary school was in northern Virginia.
- 38:00Brent Sadler: So I got that my parents very all that DC kind of world.
- 38:04Brent Sadler: But then middle school, I grew up in Guam.
- 38:06Speaker 1: So was your dad Navy too?
- 38:09Brent Sadler: No, DOD, not uniform.
- 38:11Brent Sadler: Um worked like labor union disputes, com troller of budgeting and things like that.
- 38:16Brent Sadler: Really not very exciting, very prosaic stuff.
- 38:19Speaker 1: The guys that actually make it all work, though, right?
- 38:22Brent Sadler: Yeah, all that stuff.
- 38:24Brent Sadler: I said, shut up, it's boring, boring, boring.
- 38:26Brent Sadler: When I became a captain, it's like, all right, Dad, tell me, let's go back in time.
- 38:29Brent Sadler: Tell me about how this budget thing works and how this, you know, labor disputes.
- 38:34Brent Sadler: Guam in the 80s, so 83 to 86, Japan, 86 to 89.
- 38:39Brent Sadler: Some of the key life moments, the people power movement in the Philippines.
- 38:45Brent Sadler: Um, very important moment.
- 38:47Brent Sadler: Marcus, when he got kicked out of a peaceful, large, it was, I don't think there were very many deaths, and it was like a handful of deaths accidental, but it was a peaceful uprising that toppled a very brutal dictatorship.
- 38:59Brent Sadler: And an alley.
- 39:01Speaker 1: Corazona Kino came in, right?
- 39:02Speaker 1: After they had killed Nino, yeah.
- 39:04Brent Sadler: So he flew through Guam.
- 39:06Brent Sadler: Um, it was in the news going off to exile in Hawaii.
- 39:10Brent Sadler: Um uh also around that time, well, before that, I also went to China with my father through Hong Kong in 1985, early 85, and we went into the new terror into southern China in the early days of the open door policy under Deng Xiaoping's uh efforts.
- 39:28Brent Sadler: Very, very different China.
- 39:31Brent Sadler: Everyone was in white mouth suits.
- 39:33Brent Sadler: Uh, there was a very tense moment where my father was going to take a photograph and the entire street stopped.
- 39:38Brent Sadler: Like you went, like you walk into the wrong bar and the record stops.
- 39:41Speaker 1: Yeah, the record scratches, yeah.
- 39:43Brent Sadler: Yeah, so it was exactly like that because we were taking a picture and there was a PLA senior officer smoking a cigarette leaning against a light post, and everyone stopped and looked at us.
- 39:53Brent Sadler: And we got my father got extremely nervous, and our handlers were nearby but didn't see this.
- 39:59Brent Sadler: And as we're walking away, a Chinese gentleman, maybe my age, but he looked a little older in a mouseuit, was looking around, but he was making a beeline for me.
- 40:10Brent Sadler: And he came up and he looked around and he shook my hand and he leaned in and he said, I love America, and then he scooted off.
- 40:17Brent Sadler: Fast forward 1989.
- 40:19Brent Sadler: Friends of mine were in Tiananmen Square uh the day before the tanks.
- 40:24Brent Sadler: They were tourists.
- 40:25Brent Sadler: I don't uh I had words with their parents now, but we were high school classmates and they got stuck in Beijing.
- 40:31Brent Sadler: And of course, we heard all the news and all the stories, things that weren't getting out, we were getting um through this.
- 40:40Brent Sadler: Was not the internet days, but we were getting a lot of that.
- 40:43Brent Sadler: And so these kind of events and life experiences definitely shaped, and again, the books I write and my work is all the you're kind of getting at what's the thing, what's my North Star?
- 40:53Brent Sadler: It's preventing what the Chinese have said they want to be prepared to win to wage a war and win in 2027.
- 41:01Brent Sadler: It it's been all towards that.
- 41:02Brent Sadler: So our time at Indopaycom was all driven by the same understanding that the calculations, you know, the goal remains the same in Beijing.
- 41:12Brent Sadler: They feel entitled to preeminence across the world economically, socially, diplomatically, and militarily.
- 41:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One thing I've noticed about our leaders is we always push back when we hear from our friends and enemies that they're gonna do something.
- 41:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And our our you know, the common response is, oh no, they won't.
- 41:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're not gonna do that.
- 41:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So 2027, can you talk a little bit more about that?
- 41:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then how are we prepared for uh that potentiality?
- 41:38Brent Sadler: Yeah, so I've done the math.
- 41:40Brent Sadler: I was one of the and and I actually was one of the guys that actually started talking about this back in 2011 and 12 timeframe.
- 41:47Brent Sadler: Uh it you know, it was with the CNO's personal stuff, but it was more broad than that in the government at the time.
- 41:53Brent Sadler: Um I also again, there were things that I saw in late uh 2020 uh that also got my attention.
- 42:02Brent Sadler: And so in January of 2021, I wrote an article that basically said for the following reasons the Chinese have accelerated their timelines from 19 2035 to 2020 before the end of the decade.
- 42:14Brent Sadler: I knew I was postulating 2027, but I didn't say that because at that time we had Admiral Davidson hadn't said his famous March uh 2021 testimony where he said 2027.
- 42:26Brent Sadler: Um but it was there for everyone to see it.
- 42:29Brent Sadler: The data is is is irrefutable.
- 42:31Brent Sadler: But um are we ready for for 2027, if that's the question?
- 42:36Brent Sadler: Um not really.
- 42:39Brent Sadler: And I say that because war is perhaps the most unpredictable, riskiest endeavor that human beings ever enter into.
- 42:49Brent Sadler: An underdog can defeat the Goliath.
- 42:52Brent Sadler: It's in the Bible.
- 42:53Brent Sadler: Um it's it's a it's a nature of if of human beings.
- 42:57Brent Sadler: Just because you have the most modern and largest military doesn't bestow upon you guaranteed victory.
- 43:04Brent Sadler: And I think we have had this kind of uh victor's euphoria for far too long, which is not deserved.
- 43:10Brent Sadler: And we have to know ourselves better.
- 43:12Brent Sadler: So there is a competency at sea in war fighting that we need to be much more sincere and honest.
- 43:18Brent Sadler: We've performed very well as sailors, marines, soldiers, airmen, um, like in the Red Sea, but that ain't a fight with the Chinese.
- 43:27Brent Sadler: That's like junior varsity or kids' soccer compared to pro that we have to be ready for.
- 43:35Brent Sadler: And there's gonna be a lot of bloodshed.
- 43:37Brent Sadler: And that shock of the first punch, um, we need to be ready for it.
- 43:41Brent Sadler: I'm not sure we're there.
- 43:43Brent Sadler: Uh, we have some leaders, we have some, we have a lot of chiefs, we got a lot of gunnies, we got a lot of good folks.
- 43:49Brent Sadler: Uh, but they need the backing of the political leadership, which I think we got now.
- 43:54Brent Sadler: Uh, but I also think we need to have the ships and the munitions that matter.
- 43:59Brent Sadler: It's not enough to have the spirit or the heart of the sailor if they don't have the ship and the weapon to put lead on on target.
- 44:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm right in Virginia Beach, not too far from Newport News.
- 44:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've had folks come on the show to talk about uh shipbuilding in the past.
- 44:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've had uh actually folks that looked at um uh Charlie Pratzman, who who really understands the toilet production system and and lean manufacturing and how awesome our production capability was in Newport News just 80, 90 years ago, right?
- 44:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't have that today.
- 44:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we had the uh former skipper of the USS Ford on here talking about that.
- 44:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I spent some time with him and and some other folks as they were working on the uh elevators in 20, what, 2019, 2020, something like that.
- 44:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, you know, that that ship's coming out of the yard, it has some problems.
- 44:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um our shipbuilding capability.
- 44:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about that?
- 44:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where are we and what do we need to do?
- 44:52Brent Sadler: No, so I've been uh on the leading edge of this.
- 44:54Brent Sadler: So as soon as I got out of the Navy, one of the great things of being at, you know, at a think tank in DC is that uh I have a platform and I can basically talk truth to power and everything I back up with facts.
- 45:05Brent Sadler: On the shipbuilding, I came out shooting gunning for how to improve Navy's shipbuilding, and I knew the commercial maritime industrial sector was pretty bad.
- 45:14Brent Sadler: But everywhere I look to try to find out, okay, well, let's bolster up naval shipbuilding by standing on top of or helping this part of the commercial sector, and there wasn't anything there.
- 45:24Brent Sadler: So the problem was actually much worse than I ever imagined.
- 45:29Brent Sadler: And it's still, I get surprised on how bad it is.
- 45:32Brent Sadler: That's not to say that it's impossible.
- 45:35Brent Sadler: Defeat is a choice.
- 45:37Brent Sadler: And we can and we have recovered from very bad industrial capacity in shipbuilding.
- 45:44Brent Sadler: World War I is the case study in this.
- 45:47Brent Sadler: Uh we were late to task, but in the next war, we're not going to be able to rely on the British Empire or the French to bail us out or to delay in the next World War.
- 45:58Brent Sadler: We will be the ones on the front.
- 46:00Brent Sadler: And so when it comes to shipbuilding, we have the people.
- 46:04Brent Sadler: There's a lot of industries that are adjacent to shipbuilding, technical competencies that transfer into it, say in construction.
- 46:10Brent Sadler: Wire and cable runs, you do that in apartment buildings, you do that in big uh tech centers that are being built, you can do that on a ship.
- 46:18Brent Sadler: Uh you have to learn a little bit, of course, and transfer that, but skill sets that are transferable.
- 46:24Brent Sadler: Same thing with welding.
- 46:26Brent Sadler: It's not a question of we don't have enough people.
- 46:29Brent Sadler: It's a question of paying them, training them, and getting them the work.
- 46:33Brent Sadler: And so the orders come to mind on this.
- 46:35Brent Sadler: We need to have a steady and predictable demand signal for stable designs as a Kickstarter to get the capital investment to grow the waterfront.
- 46:45Brent Sadler: Um, the way that we've been doing business with these publicly traded prime is not the the number one customer is not the Navy, it's the shareholders.
- 46:54Brent Sadler: And that's not a ding.
- 46:56Brent Sadler: I don't ding the business folks for doing what they do.
- 46:59Brent Sadler: They have to make a profit, they have a business.
- 47:02Brent Sadler: The people that work for them's livelihoods depend on that business model.
- 47:07Brent Sadler: But what Congress needs to do is they need to change the incentive structure.
- 47:10Brent Sadler: This is not for the Navy.
- 47:11Brent Sadler: This is beyond Navy's capability.
- 47:13Brent Sadler: Congress needs to change the incentive structure.
- 47:16Brent Sadler: So inside things like the Ships for America Act, another thing very much been involved in from its genesis, is that we need to like look at tools like what the Estonians do use, which is a distributed profit tax, to encourage reinvestment of profits into workforce and capital infrastructure.
- 47:36Brent Sadler: That's how you grow the shipyards without a war that demands like national, you know, presidential authorities like moving resources.
- 47:44Brent Sadler: We're talking peacetime.
- 47:45Brent Sadler: And ideally, it always stays there.
- 47:48Brent Sadler: Uh so and also attracting capital from like our allies, not China.
- 47:53Brent Sadler: They're not in this discussion, but to attract investment in the United States, like Hanhua in Philadelphia Shipyard, a canary in the coal mine of this idea, quite frankly.
- 48:04Brent Sadler: And we'll see how it goes.
- 48:05Brent Sadler: By all accounts, it's it's proceeding as planned and having the desired effects there.
- 48:10Brent Sadler: But um we need to attract investment, which seems to it, which is happening.
- 48:15Brent Sadler: Tens of billions of dollars is flowing into this industrial sector.
- 48:19Brent Sadler: Uh, but we need the orders.
- 48:20Brent Sadler: And Congress and the Navy's business as usual approach here ain't gonna do it.
- 48:25Brent Sadler: It's one of the reasons why I've been calling for a Naval Act.
- 48:28Brent Sadler: Uh, you know, using the language and the ideas of the late 30s naval acts.
- 48:33Brent Sadler: Um the Navy knows what ships it needs, and in designs that are already in series production.
- 48:38Brent Sadler: Flight three uh destroyers, okay.
- 48:40Brent Sadler: Yeah, we've been building those, we're gonna continue building those.
- 48:43Brent Sadler: We need those.
- 48:43Brent Sadler: Virginia class nuclear submarines, we know that.
- 48:46Brent Sadler: So if you look at the five-year, the future years uh plan, the fight it, and you just say, okay, let's add up all of the stable design ships that are in there.
- 48:55Brent Sadler: And I've looked at the last few years and I said, let's just build these 45 ships.
- 48:59Brent Sadler: Give me a dedicated budget, appropriate it, and let's get a lot of that money into the system so that capital investments can be made to deliver this order of ships.
- 49:10Brent Sadler: The other thing is it it also helps the Wall Street side of it too, because now they've got the backlog and they've got the assurety of orders.
- 49:18Brent Sadler: So you do those other things I mentioned earlier, like a distributed profit tax to incentivize, but it also makes a lot of sense from the way the business works.
- 49:27Brent Sadler: And you're gonna get what we need: more shipbuilding capacity, more shipyard workers.
- 49:33Brent Sadler: Not by pushing money to hire them without orders, but by ordering the ship, which is the only thing the Navy should care about, is I want 10 destroyers, I want them in 10 years.
- 49:44Brent Sadler: Give me my ships.
- 49:45Brent Sadler: You figure out the labor, you figure out the cranes and your warehouses.
- 49:49Brent Sadler: That's not my business.
- 49:50Brent Sadler: Here's the requirement, here's the design, go build me a goddamn ship.
- 49:54Speaker 1: What effect would uh more complex than that?
- 49:57Speaker 1: What what effect, and you know, I I'll disclose my bias.
- 50:00Speaker 1: You know, we've both been stationed in Hawaii.
- 50:03Speaker 1: Um I I know that you lived in Guam, and uh I'm also ethnically Puerto Rican.
- 50:08Speaker 1: I I have a massive aversion to the Jones Act.
- 50:11Speaker 1: And the and the Jones Act uh it seems to me is putting a stranglehold on us on a uh from a maritime perspective that most people won't let on.
- 50:20Speaker 1: And it's uh it's 102 years old that needs to needs to go away.
- 50:24Speaker 1: What do you what are your thoughts?
- 50:26Brent Sadler: Yeah, some people had the wrong impression of me.
- 50:28Brent Sadler: So I was nominated to be the maritime administrator, but I come from one of the illustrious organizations that's virulently anti-Jones Act.
- 50:35Brent Sadler: Uh that's not the case.
- 50:37Brent Sadler: I come here and I've brought with me a very pragmatic approach to it.
- 50:41Brent Sadler: Um, one, the Jones Act, it's very inward looking.
- 50:46Brent Sadler: It's the wrong focus on the wrong type of ships.
- 50:49Brent Sadler: Great at safeguarding and production of barges, intercoastal waterway from the Gulf of America up to the East Coast, great for lakes movement, not good at building ships that are competitive or viable in interocean trade.
- 51:07Brent Sadler: And those are the ships, quite frankly, and that's the type of ship building that the Navy needs.
- 51:13Brent Sadler: So the Jones Act hasn't been delivering to no one's surprise the types of ships needed.
- 51:18Brent Sadler: It hasn't helped the industry because the industry is not hungry enough.
- 51:23Brent Sadler: So my take on the Jones Act has been it's not the right thing to focus on.
- 51:29Brent Sadler: There's a lot of invested uh uh self-interest or interest groups that are focused on it, but it's not the thing we're shooting at.
- 51:36Brent Sadler: What's better worth the time politically, economically, and militarily is let's focus on building an American comparative advantage in the shipping and shipbuilding sector in the global marketplace.
- 51:50Brent Sadler: Let's get hungry for global market share.
- 51:54Brent Sadler: That does not conflict with the Jones Act.
- 51:58Brent Sadler: And in fact, some elements of the Jones Act are helpful to kick start that effort.
- 52:04Brent Sadler: And that's captured in the Ships for America legislation.
- 52:08Brent Sadler: Uh that spirit is in there.
- 52:10Brent Sadler: Uh President's Executive Order, re-regaining America's maritime dominance.
- 52:14Brent Sadler: That spirit is in there too.
- 52:17Brent Sadler: Uh and it's you know, eventually, if we get a competitive edge and we start to get a call it a fiducial level of market share, that we have a healthy, not a dominant, but a healthy maritime industrial base in the global marketplace.
- 52:34Brent Sadler: We'll be able to build Navy ships on time at cost.
- 52:37Brent Sadler: We'll be able to meet our national security needs to shipping and repair if we're in a war to get those ships back to the fight.
- 52:44Brent Sadler: We can't do that today.
- 52:46Brent Sadler: And when you do that, the need for the Jones Act will evaporate.
- 52:51Brent Sadler: It won't be necessary anymore.
- 52:53Brent Sadler: We will have a very healthy maritime industrial base, and you never have to take it off the books, it's just there, but it's no longer really an issue.
- 53:02Brent Sadler: And the special interest will have adapted and they will overcome it, and it will no longer be necessary.
- 53:09Brent Sadler: So, my point on that is you don't need to repeal it.
- 53:12Brent Sadler: Revising it is also, you know, an anthema to too many folks.
- 53:16Brent Sadler: Better is focus in on what matters, competition in the global maritime space.
- 53:20Brent Sadler: That'll get the Navy the types of capacity, the types of ships the nation needs.
- 53:25Speaker 1: How about so this is uh my my dad grew up in Panama, and I've always wondered about you know, the the my my grandfather worked in the canal zone and we we handed it over, it's no longer ours.
- 53:39Speaker 1: Um there's always been uh a move, and the Chinese seem very serious about this, um, of expanding their influence in Latin America, certainly around uh the sea lanes of a of a Nicaraguan canal, which would be a sea level canal and would not require locks, unlike the Panama Canal.
- 53:56Speaker 1: No matter how much you widen it, you still have to deal with the fact that the Pacific and the Atlantic are not on the same altitude.
- 54:03Speaker 1: Um what are the discussions around that?
- 54:06Speaker 1: You know, you hear things, people say, oh, and you know, when so-and-so's elected, you know, we're gonna take the canal zone back, or you know, we're gonna we're gonna build the Nicaraguan Canal.
- 54:15Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 54:15Speaker 1: Um how important are those things, um, especially with China, because they have had so much influence on South America?
- 54:22Brent Sadler: Yeah, so um I'm with you uh on the Panama Canal.
- 54:26Brent Sadler: I remember the history of this.
- 54:28Brent Sadler: I had friends that actually went and fought there in the 89 uh to go after Noriega.
- 54:32Brent Sadler: So very familiar with it.
- 54:34Brent Sadler: Um but set aside the history and the patriotism aspects of it, just from a pure economic and security aspect, the Panama Canal is critical for the United States.
- 54:47Brent Sadler: Uh the Suez Canal, when it got shut down because the ever given turned sideways back in 2021, it had it was not really a matter to the U.S.
- 54:55Brent Sadler: economy.
- 54:56Brent Sadler: If the same thing were to happen in the Panama Canal, because we rely on it to move so much commerce from one side to the other, it would impact the U.S.
- 55:06Brent Sadler: economy in a very severe way.
- 55:07Brent Sadler: Eventually things stable out, but the cost will have been sunk and we will have uh we will have uh swallowed in an additional cost to doing business, and that's prosperity, lost prosperity.
- 55:18Brent Sadler: On the national security side, I mean, the reason why we built it was for national security because there was, you know, the newspapers were following every day the movement of steamers to go from the East Coast to the West Coast during like a gold one of the late gold rushes in Alaska, and they're like, oh, this is we need some a better way to do this.
- 55:36Brent Sadler: Uh and then, of course, the Spanish-American War gave another impetus for this.
- 55:40Brent Sadler: So that geography, you know, doesn't change, but you can build canals and you kind of kind of help work around it.
- 55:48Brent Sadler: So on what the Chinese have done specifically, it was clear that they were buying in to have influence.
- 55:56Brent Sadler: Uh, when C.K.
- 55:58Brent Sadler: Hutchins was trying to sell off its its ports early after the election last year, and with the new administration of President Trump was going to make an was facilitating an offer, it riled the Chinese Communist Party because this has been part of their plan.
- 56:14Brent Sadler: Control the terms of trade, control strategic ports, be able to nullify any access or tactical advantage the United States might be able to gain by moving through the Panama Canal and by buying those ports out from them in order to balance.
- 56:29Brent Sadler: So CK Hutchins was going out, they had like massive debt.
- 56:32Brent Sadler: So the $19 billion deal equals their debt.
- 56:36Brent Sadler: They were trying to level out their debt by selling off a lot of their overseas ports.
- 56:40Brent Sadler: It was more than the Panama Canal.
- 56:42Brent Sadler: But the Chinese Communist Party would have had their entire decades-long strategic plan upturned by that smooth.
- 56:49Brent Sadler: And they still, I think, should have that canal purchase deal go forward without the Chinese Communist Party.
- 56:56Brent Sadler: There's an effort to include Costco in their state-run Chinese shipping company.
- 57:00Brent Sadler: That's like letting the fox in the in the hen house and cannot should not be allowed.
- 57:04Brent Sadler: Um, on the Panamanian side, in my estimation, by looking at the record and even their own public statements going back, you know, over the last 10 years, they have knowingly violated the treaties.
- 57:17Brent Sadler: And that abrogation of the treaty means that the president, on the behest of the American people, can go back in and say, well, let's go back to pre-79 status quo any and start over again.
- 57:32Brent Sadler: That's not what Trump's actually doing.
- 57:33Brent Sadler: He's threatening it, and I think there's a legal case, certainly in terms of the treaty, that could be made.
- 57:38Brent Sadler: Not necessary.
- 57:40Brent Sadler: Get the port's ownership out of the Chinese hands, make sure that the Panamanian government understands that element of the neutrality treaty that we signed.
- 57:50Brent Sadler: So anyway.
- 57:53Speaker 1: What about the prospects of a Nicaraguan canal?
- 57:55Brent Sadler: Oh, that one, yeah, I looked at that.
- 57:57Brent Sadler: I mean, it's been a long time.
- 57:59Brent Sadler: Um the Chinese have talked about doing similar things across the the Kra Peninsula in Thailand.
- 58:06Brent Sadler: Um but the problem is it it's it's a lot of you're gonna have to move a lot of land.
- 58:12Brent Sadler: The other thing is you have to have the ability, even with the Panama Canal expansion, you have to keep water flowing into it and also to operate the locks.
- 58:21Brent Sadler: And as you mentioned, it's not ocean levels are not exactly the same.
- 58:25Brent Sadler: The world's not a perfect ball.
- 58:28Brent Sadler: Um, so it's lopsided.
- 58:30Brent Sadler: And the geography is is is kind of a it's an SOB.
- 58:34Brent Sadler: I don't know if sailor language is.
- 58:36Speaker 1: What's our largest ship that can get through the canal, the current the Panama Canal now?
- 58:40Speaker 1: What's the largest?
- 58:41Speaker 1: What's uh you can't get a a Nimitz class through the Panama Canal?
- 58:45Speaker 1: They they still have to go around the horn, right?
- 58:47Speaker 1: I mean, what's the largest ship?
- 58:50Brent Sadler: Well, there's two canals the old canal, absolutely not.
- 58:52Brent Sadler: The one that we built.
- 58:53Brent Sadler: The one that was built and finished in like 2014-15 time frame.
- 58:58Brent Sadler: I think operations started in 15, but construction was done in 14.
- 59:01Brent Sadler: Um, I think you probably could.
- 59:04Brent Sadler: Would you?
- 59:05Brent Sadler: Probably not.
- 59:07Brent Sadler: Um and I'm not a hundred I'm not sure on that, to be honest with you.
- 59:11Brent Sadler: But you can move some very large container ships through the expanded Panama Canal.
- 59:17Brent Sadler: And they have a draft that's comparable to a nuclear aircraft carrier when the container ships are fully laden.
- 59:23Brent Sadler: Um, which I'm not sure if that's in some cases they do offload cargo and then they train it across to the other side.
- 59:30Brent Sadler: So some of these ultra-large container ships have they've taken cargo and weighed off so they can ballast up.
- 59:39Brent Sadler: Uh, but they are roughly comparable to an aircraft carrier, a four-class aircraft carrier.
- 59:43Speaker 1: So it's a dumb marine question.
- 59:45Speaker 1: Do do subs transit the canal or no?
- 59:47Brent Sadler: Uh I I did twice.
- 59:49Speaker 1: Oh, okay.
- 59:50Brent Sadler: Well uh on an SSBN.
- 59:51Brent Sadler: We didn't have nuclear weapons on board because we were coming out of a major availability, and that was known at the time.
- 59:58Brent Sadler: Um but we went through canal, I went through two different submarines.
- 1:00:03Brent Sadler: Uh one was a training cruise for major update for the weapon system, and then I went through as a as a department head on the next submarine to go through to do the certification of the of the missile systems off of uh off of Florida.
- 1:00:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, Moose, I was gonna say every Marine should know that submarines go underneath the continent, right?
- 1:00:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know that, right?
- 1:00:23Speaker 1: Yeah, I thought there were tunnels under the under the continent, yeah.
- 1:00:25Speaker 1: The water tunnels.
- 1:00:26Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 1:00:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to shift gears a little bit.
- 1:00:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the uh POTUS was out here at Norfolk over the weekend.
- 1:00:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh went out to an aircraft carrier.
- 1:00:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I want to talk about a couple things.
- 1:00:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh force design 2030, if you have any comments on that.
- 1:00:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Fleet design, and I think in the news right now we're looking at the sixth generation stealth fighter FA XX.
- 1:00:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll get your thoughts on any of those two.
- 1:00:47Brent Sadler: Well, this I'll start with the simplest one.
- 1:00:48Brent Sadler: The the next strike fighter needs to kind of go back to the the re because we're in a similar world why we needed uh the Tomcat, the F-14 Tomcat.
- 1:00:56Brent Sadler: Uh range of the aircraft, speed too, but I that's lesser uh in my mind.
- 1:01:03Brent Sadler: I'm not a pilot, wasn't a pilot.
- 1:01:04Brent Sadler: Uh, the other is the range of the weapon.
- 1:01:06Brent Sadler: So the Tomcat had had a really like a thousand plus mile range.
- 1:01:10Brent Sadler: It was like 1,300 mile range.
- 1:01:12Brent Sadler: And it also had the Phoenix.
- 1:01:14Brent Sadler: Uh, at the time, the longest air to air missile.
- 1:01:17Brent Sadler: The Chinese now have.
- 1:01:18Brent Sadler: That air, the longest range air-to-air missile, so they can outstick us and they can also outrange us.
- 1:01:25Brent Sadler: So we need to have the range and the speed.
- 1:01:27Brent Sadler: So that I think the the next uh fighter aircraft for the carry needs to be a dedicated uh like the Tomcat was dedicated to that kind of fight.
- 1:01:35Brent Sadler: Range and speed, get the Chinese uh bombers before they get close enough.
- 1:01:40Brent Sadler: Get in.
- 1:01:41Brent Sadler: The other side of this is get in also to launch longer strike to prevent the China so you can still operate beyond their anti-ship ballistic missiles.
- 1:01:50Brent Sadler: Yeah.
- 1:01:50Brent Sadler: So if you look in my new book, you'll see these two pictures where it kind of is a concept graph about how these operations play out, and you'll see this rectangular area about a thousand miles off the China's coast.
- 1:02:02Brent Sadler: That's the reason.
- 1:02:04Brent Sadler: Because that's also when you start thinking about the range of the anti-ship ballistic missiles, um, it's a nice place to be to launch sorties, and then you move in, you you surge, and you and yeah, but that that fighter is critical, so but it needs to have range.
- 1:02:19Brent Sadler: Range, range, range.
- 1:02:20Brent Sadler: Um force design 2030, the Marines.
- 1:02:24Brent Sadler: I kind of was there when the idea was berthed.
- 1:02:27Brent Sadler: Um, we had Department of the Navy, uh be careful how much I share, but uh Mattis uh and others from the Marines and future forces would come and brief us.
- 1:02:39Brent Sadler: And this goes back to you might have seen some of the success, some of the follow-on conversation, but Kravenovich came out in 2012 at PACOM and we talked about archipelagic defense.
- 1:02:49Brent Sadler: So things like distributed lethality, Loki, all of that was just coming together and these long-range fires ideas.
- 1:02:57Brent Sadler: So I'm a big fan of Force Design 2030.
- 1:03:00Brent Sadler: I'm not a big fan about how the Marines and the Navy work together uh on trying to figure out how they're gonna get the a critical element, which is their their logistics connector ship.
- 1:03:11Brent Sadler: Now the medium landing ship or medium amphibious.
- 1:03:15Brent Sadler: Um, the names change so many times I lose track of it.
- 1:03:18Brent Sadler: But the requirements were pretty straightforward 10 years ago.
- 1:03:22Brent Sadler: Um and dinking around with the con ops that you haven't actually exercised on as a reason for delaying never really made sense to me.
- 1:03:31Brent Sadler: So in the meantime, the Filipinos and the Japanese are building the types of ships that our Marines and Army folks could be traveling on.
- 1:03:39Brent Sadler: Um this is the biggest thing on it.
- 1:03:42Brent Sadler: I I do agree that armor, the M1 tanks for the Marines, I'm not a big fan of it.
- 1:03:47Brent Sadler: I mean, the Marines need to be on ships.
- 1:03:48Brent Sadler: I'm a big fan of FMF.
- 1:03:50Brent Sadler: The fleet marine folks.
- 1:03:51Brent Sadler: Oh, yeah.
- 1:03:51Brent Sadler: Get them back.
- 1:03:53Speaker 1: That's why we have an anchor on the well, but but I guess I think some of the criticism has been um the logistics of sitting on rocks and waiting for something to happen, it eliminates the first strike capability or the shock troop capability, uh, the projection capability um of a mission that the Army already does.
- 1:04:14Brent Sadler: So on this one, this is a good one about nonlinear thinking and action.
- 1:04:18Brent Sadler: So, Bonj, when we were together at PACOM, I was just winning this debate.
- 1:04:22Brent Sadler: And the debate was because we and I was twisting Army arms.
- 1:04:26Brent Sadler: I had the 94th AADC talking with me on the sidelines to get Army invested in long-range fires.
- 1:04:32Brent Sadler: So if you're gonna so the first thing is, all right, if you're gonna operate in the first island chain and you're gonna challenge the Chinese, you're gonna need certain types of weapons.
- 1:04:40Brent Sadler: Longer range surface-to-air missiles than we had in our inventory.
- 1:04:44Brent Sadler: Surface to surface, you know, land as well as going after enemy ships, missiles that we didn't have in our inventory.
- 1:04:52Brent Sadler: And the INF treaty, this is 2012 timeframe, was still in force, even though we knew other people weren't following it.
- 1:04:58Brent Sadler: Um, so we didn't have the weapons that validated why you would operate there.
- 1:05:03Brent Sadler: But we knew we needed to operate there in a way that would cause the Chinese problems.
- 1:05:07Brent Sadler: The other argument that I had is like, well, we're not being invited there, so therefore we shouldn't plan on being there.
- 1:05:12Brent Sadler: It's like, well, wait a minute.
- 1:05:13Brent Sadler: The reason you're not invited there is because you're you're operationally meaningless without the weapons.
- 1:05:18Brent Sadler: And you go there on exercises, maybe you should start exercising like you would actually fight in the first island chain, and the host nations would start to see that you're credible and start bringing some weapons that matter.
- 1:05:32Brent Sadler: And I would point you to, and back in 2015 in a Balakitan exercise, we had a high Mars go and shoot into the ocean.
- 1:05:41Brent Sadler: Yeah, whoop whoop-de-doo.
- 1:05:42Brent Sadler: It wasn't the right kind of munition.
- 1:05:43Brent Sadler: But everyone saw it and the light bulbs were going off.
- 1:05:47Brent Sadler: So you have to think kind of think multiple timelines.
- 1:05:50Brent Sadler: It's like they're not going to invite you in if you're not a competent, reliable partner.
- 1:05:54Brent Sadler: So therefore, you have to actually invest in the weapon systems that assumes that you're going to be invited in to operate in the first island chain.
- 1:06:01Brent Sadler: So you had to do both, you had to you had to basically eat both ends of the spaghetti noodle at the same time.
- 1:06:07Brent Sadler: And maybe that's not the right analogy, but anyway.
- 1:06:10Brent Sadler: Um you asked about the the Navy force design.
- 1:06:14Brent Sadler: I got ideas on that one too, but uh I'll pause there.
- 1:06:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so fleet design.
- 1:06:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh the HIMARS thing you bring up, you know, I work with the Army as an area defense commander uh under a JFAC type of scenario.
- 1:06:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh counter error scenario.
- 1:06:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh then we start integrating into ballistic missile defense, and then the uh the HIMAR conversation.
- 1:06:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I know that gets into command command and control problems just like the tomahawk does.
- 1:06:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Who owns a tomahawk when it's inside of a theater, right?
- 1:06:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it the JFAC?
- 1:06:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it CFAC?
- 1:06:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, does it really matter?
- 1:06:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I don't know.
- 1:06:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But you that's where I think you start crossing um uh I don't know, laser beams, if you will, between a a component commander and another component commander where they're looking at it and going, hey, how do I use this army asset when I need it for air or sea capability, maritime capability?
- 1:07:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh any thoughts to that where you know they don't want to cross streams on in that type of thinking?
- 1:07:07Brent Sadler: No, absolutely.
- 1:07:08Brent Sadler: So this used to frustrate me to all end.
- 1:07:11Brent Sadler: Um it's why we do fleet experimentation, it's why we do exercises, field exercises.
- 1:07:17Brent Sadler: Um perfect cannot be allowed to become the enemy of good enough.
- 1:07:22Brent Sadler: So get out into the field, test the command structures, test the systems, test your soldiers and sailors and airmen.
- 1:07:29Brent Sadler: Um and when we started doing that, we learned very quickly.
- 1:07:34Brent Sadler: And I think from when we were dealing with this, everyone wanted to stick on PowerPoint deep because they were risk-adverse on, oh my God, it's gonna cost money to go do an exercise, and we don't have enough money.
- 1:07:43Brent Sadler: And so no one was willing to put put money down to actually start testing it.
- 1:07:47Brent Sadler: Um, I would credit Putin for changing that.
- 1:07:51Brent Sadler: Uh, one is he violated the INF treaty and we broke that, so now we could start making these weapons that were needed.
- 1:07:58Brent Sadler: Two, he invaded Ukraine in 2022, and the Ukrainians like stumped him with a lot of this uh long-range fires.
- 1:08:06Brent Sadler: High Mars got in there, so everyone started to see the value.
- 1:08:09Brent Sadler: They even used some old uh Soviet ballistic missiles to take out a cargo ship, or I take it back, it was an amphib that was moving munitions in Burdansk in the Sea of Azov in about the first within the first year of the war.
- 1:08:23Brent Sadler: So everyone, the veil came off of everyone, and the blinkers were removed, the side, the blinders were removed on people's thinking in DC, on these long-range fires, uh, and on the possibility of using these kind of systems, and that command and control could be addressed.
- 1:08:41Brent Sadler: They didn't know what it is yet, but again, don't let perfect be the enemy of good enough to go out and try and work it out.
- 1:08:49Brent Sadler: Um, ugly is fine in an exercise.
- 1:08:52Brent Sadler: Ugly is death in combat.
- 1:08:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And a related uh question, Tomahawks have been in the news as being transferred to Ukraine.
- 1:09:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh vertical launch systems and you know, we launch where we launch them from and all that matters.
- 1:09:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just want to get your thoughts on that uh narrative that's uh going around right now.
- 1:09:08Brent Sadler: Yeah, I mean, so on a strategic part, uh our leadership in DC had a had a complete misunderstanding of Russians.
- 1:09:16Brent Sadler: Uh you've heard me, probably even when we were at PACOM, I was bitching about this back in those days too.
- 1:09:21Brent Sadler: Um complete misunderstanding of Russian mentality.
- 1:09:26Brent Sadler: Uh when they were threatening escalation, that's not what really was going on.
- 1:09:30Brent Sadler: We should have called their bluff in 2022, 2023, uh, and basically made the cost of their prolonged war insurmountable for them.
- 1:09:39Brent Sadler: And instead we allowed it to we were always chasing them.
- 1:09:43Brent Sadler: We were allowing the Russians to set the tempo and to dictate where on the escalation ladder things were.
- 1:09:50Brent Sadler: Um and we went fell right into their preferred method of warfare, attrition.
- 1:09:54Brent Sadler: It's also one that the math works for them better than anyone else, and they knew it, so why not?
- 1:10:00Brent Sadler: So we were kind of stupid.
- 1:10:02Brent Sadler: The technical term, we were stupid with and and didn't understand what we were dealing with as a country with the Russians.
- 1:10:08Brent Sadler: So the Tomahawks, now fast forward to today, I think there's a strategy.
- 1:10:14Brent Sadler: I think it's much more based on what motivates the Russians, I think it's also much more informed by the necessity to end the war.
- 1:10:21Brent Sadler: Uh there's a lot of reasons why we need to end this war beyond Russia and Ukraine.
- 1:10:27Brent Sadler: Um and so a weapon system like a tomahawk, and I'm very familiar with it, um because they do launch them from submarines, there is a way to actually manage it in an operational and oper in a technical way.
- 1:10:44Brent Sadler: Uh but having those systems or weapon like that in theater that the Ukrainians are operating and targeting, uh that's the interesting piece.
- 1:10:56Brent Sadler: Uh that will cause Putin a lot of consternation because so far he has protected the the wealthier, the middle class, upper part, the the white Russian population.
- 1:11:08Brent Sadler: Again, you gotta kind of understand.
- 1:11:10Brent Sadler: I don't want to go through like the whole history of what and what's going on in Russia today, but it it stabs right at the center of gravity of Putin right now.
- 1:11:20Brent Sadler: And you're seeing some of this play out with Ukrainians targeting of Russian oil refineries.
- 1:11:27Brent Sadler: Oil refining, that's refined products, not really what the Russians are selling and making their money.
- 1:11:33Brent Sadler: They sell crude and LNG.
- 1:11:35Brent Sadler: The refined fuel is what their military and their citizens use to live their daily lives or to f fight day to day.
- 1:11:43Brent Sadler: So when the Ukrainians are taking out their refineries, they're hurting the Russian populace and they're having an impact on military operations.
- 1:11:52Brent Sadler: Uh and you can see this angst.
- 1:11:55Brent Sadler: The war is coming home uh for the for the Russian people in a way that it hadn't uh and hasn't really.
- 1:12:01Brent Sadler: That's not to say that bombs landing in Belgorod, which is like 20 miles away from the border, isn't registering with the Russian people, but it's not significant enough to move the needle in a Russian sensibilities.
- 1:12:15Brent Sadler: So we can't mirror Americans into Russians.
- 1:12:18Brent Sadler: We're very different.
- 1:12:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the Tomahawk was one of my favorite weapons to plan for as a at the operational level of war when I was working at an airspace operations center.
- 1:12:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Navy guy at an airspace operations center, going through CMSA, uh coming to Norfolk to learn all that stuff, and to really integrate that into a scheme of maneuver that it's just absolutely insane.
- 1:12:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm not going to go into a lot of details here, but as a planner, and I think you know this, um, that weapon brings so much to the table.
- 1:12:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and and you know, our surface warfare officers and our submarine community when they're launching them, um big show, big, big, big, big excite excitement for them.
- 1:12:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Just so people know, that planning actually helped happen somewhere else.
- 1:12:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's kind of cool how it works.
- 1:13:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's it's probably one of the greatest stories in our military right now is how we integrate that weapon and plan for it.
- 1:13:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, so you know, I'm not gonna say I'm for or against uh giving it to the Ukrainians, but it is it gives a um a great potential for them to do some good work there.
- 1:13:16Brent Sadler: Um back to Well, I will say I will say it's important.
- 1:13:19Brent Sadler: There are various varieties of that weapon.
- 1:13:22Brent Sadler: Yep.
- 1:13:22Brent Sadler: And since it's digital, uh you can make changes to the programming of it, which is the targeting, such that you don't need that other place being an American other place.
- 1:13:36Brent Sadler: So Putin's full of crap when he's talking about only Americans can target it.
- 1:13:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we we we got into a lot of that uh type of uh uh that approach uh later on when I was at the Air Space Operations Center.
- 1:13:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So really, really glad I got to spend some time with that.
- 1:13:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Back to fleet design, though.
- 1:13:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Any any other uh comments on that?
- 1:13:55Brent Sadler: Ah, so uh I wrote I wrote about it.
- 1:13:57Brent Sadler: So it's a short piece about a week ago because I've heard, and the reason I wrote that is I was hearing rumors that this new fleet design was coming out uh very soon, like maybe this week.
- 1:14:10Brent Sadler: I don't think that's gonna happen.
- 1:14:11Brent Sadler: I think it's probably delayed.
- 1:14:13Brent Sadler: Um, but I was I was given the indication by several sources that it was coming very soon.
- 1:14:17Brent Sadler: I don't know the specifics.
- 1:14:19Brent Sadler: Uh again, I I I don't know, but I haven't seen behind the curtain on this, which has also part caused me a little concern because I hadn't heard any rumors or murmuring about or outreach that you normally would hear in town when something of this magnitude is being considered.
- 1:14:33Brent Sadler: So it was kind of like the absence of any noise on this, which typically there are in circles like I run, I would hear about it, or I would have been like included in some unclassified discussions.
- 1:14:46Brent Sadler: They try to figure out, okay, well, how's this jackass going to attack this once it's released, just to mitigate the outside flapping heads like me uh when it gets released.
- 1:14:55Brent Sadler: None of that has happened.
- 1:14:56Brent Sadler: So the first thing is, wow, this group's really good at opsec.
- 1:14:59Brent Sadler: The other thing that's nagging in my mind is maybe this thing was done in a vacuum.
- 1:15:03Brent Sadler: So I wrote an op-ed uh and said, hey, here are the things that matter.
- 1:15:07Brent Sadler: Number one, get firepower to see.
- 1:15:10Brent Sadler: And you got to do it in the next 15 months, uh, and sustain getting more firepower to see into the future.
- 1:15:17Brent Sadler: Uh, the only way you're gonna meet that 15 month, you're gonna have to start using unmanned systems like the US V Ranger that shot an SM6 back in 2021.
- 1:15:26Brent Sadler: And we haven't done it since.
- 1:15:28Brent Sadler: So just get it out there.
- 1:15:30Brent Sadler: They can do picket ship kind of duty like we do with destroyers for missile defense of freaking Guam, put some missiles on it or containers, let the Chinese guess, and just drill holes in the Philippine Sea within missile range.
- 1:15:42Brent Sadler: Uh, that's number one.
- 1:15:44Brent Sadler: Number two, operate in ways that actually cause concern and complicate Chinese war planning.
- 1:15:51Brent Sadler: So fleet scale exercises or events operating, surging in, not just as like a couple ships or a carry strike group, but as a fleet.
- 1:16:01Brent Sadler: Fleet scale operations, start doing them.
- 1:16:04Brent Sadler: And there's a lot inside that that folks like the CNO's been talking about for years.
- 1:16:09Brent Sadler: Uh you go, you go basically MCON, no signals, and you're operating as a self-contained kind of local Wi-Fi or whatever you want to call it, where you're talking amongst yourselves, but you're operating independently.
- 1:16:20Brent Sadler: Start start doing that.
- 1:16:22Brent Sadler: There's some other things in the South China Sea by reorganizing for the purpose.
- 1:16:26Brent Sadler: Like I'm a big fan of First Fleet.
- 1:16:28Brent Sadler: You could do that too.
- 1:16:29Brent Sadler: Establish a First Fleet and operate to contest the Chinese in the peacetime, but you're also building up the backbone operationally, logistically, to sustain a fleet if you know for a long war with China at the same time.
- 1:16:44Brent Sadler: Um, the third and very critical, and this is the one that gets lost and sometimes just kind of gets shoved off on its own or given to others.
- 1:16:52Brent Sadler: What Navy decides to place its orders on has to be very deliberately done to increase the shipbuilding capacity and repair capacity of the same fleet that it's trying to build.
- 1:17:07Brent Sadler: So the 30-year shipbuilding plan should have an investment portfolio, part of it, and say, hey, we're gonna buy these destroyers, and oh, by the way, we're gonna try and get a second yard to build the flight three so that we can grow out.
- 1:17:18Brent Sadler: Here's part of the plan and why it's gonna cost more, Congress, because it's necessary.
- 1:17:23Brent Sadler: Oh, by the way, we're gonna we're gonna go ahead and do that second follow-on yard, even though the frigate is a little wobbly as a program, but we have a design that we can maybe tweak.
- 1:17:32Brent Sadler: We're gonna go get a second yard to start building more frigates because the Navy needs them, but we're gonna go do it in a different place so we get more workforce, we get more capacity.
- 1:17:42Brent Sadler: Yeah, it's gonna be more expensive.
- 1:17:44Brent Sadler: It's not gonna be an exact carbon copy of the constellation that Fincantieri is building, but it'll be it'll definitely incorporate all the lessons and all of the competencies that we're learned to build so far to date, that ship.
- 1:18:00Brent Sadler: So those are the three elements of the force design that I'll be looking for and be grading it on an A to F scale.
- 1:18:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, so I want to kind of wrap it up here, but before we do that, I've got some general questions for you.
- 1:18:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What and and what is it, what is it like to do what you do up in DC?
- 1:18:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it frustrating?
- 1:18:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is it fun?
- 1:18:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, just give me some sense of what it your what your day-to-day is like.
- 1:18:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Being on TV, I see you on TV from time to time.
- 1:18:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm like, I know that dude.
- 1:18:24Brent Sadler: Um Yeah, you probably recognize the background.
- 1:18:26Brent Sadler: All the stuff the wife doesn't allow to stay at home.
- 1:18:29Brent Sadler: So this is my office up in Capitol.
- 1:18:31Brent Sadler: So uh very rewarding.
- 1:18:32Brent Sadler: I got lucky.
- 1:18:33Brent Sadler: Um, Heritage Foundation is not your normal think tank.
- 1:18:38Brent Sadler: I'm conservative, um, so it fits.
- 1:18:40Brent Sadler: They're a conservative think tank.
- 1:18:42Brent Sadler: Um facts matter.
- 1:18:44Brent Sadler: And the man, the, the, the mandate that I was given is follow, you know, make your recommendations based on facts.
- 1:18:52Brent Sadler: You'll get your day in court.
- 1:18:53Brent Sadler: And if it's if if your case is strong, then it becomes the voice of heritage.
- 1:18:58Brent Sadler: And I've won several big fights.
- 1:19:00Brent Sadler: I mentioned the Jones Act I uh earlier on.
- 1:19:03Brent Sadler: So credit to Heritage Foundation that I've got a place to where my voice uh is heard, and I'm allowed to be, and I go out and again have a platform, then to telegraph that out and to speak truth to power.
- 1:19:15Brent Sadler: And our audience in the DC world, again, most think tanks are focused on the executive branch, the White House or State Department.
- 1:19:23Brent Sadler: We focus on Congress, both Republican and Democrat.
- 1:19:27Brent Sadler: So if you look back in the 2020 time frame when I joined in the summer of 2020, you start to see me in an old, she followed me as a flag lieutenant at Seventh Fleet, Elaine Luria.
- 1:19:36Brent Sadler: Uh don't agree with a lot of her politics, but we both agreed very vigorously on Navy.
- 1:19:43Brent Sadler: And she talked truth to power.
- 1:19:45Brent Sadler: Uh, you know, enabling that was something that I consider very, very powerful.
- 1:19:50Brent Sadler: And also folks like Mike Gallagher.
- 1:19:52Brent Sadler: Now he's out of Congress, both of them are out, but he was also, you know, so both a Republican and a Democrat.
- 1:19:58Brent Sadler: The Ships for America Act, et cetera, I can go on and on.
- 1:20:00Brent Sadler: So for me, it's been highly rewarding.
- 1:20:03Brent Sadler: Um and again, I make a case.
- 1:20:06Brent Sadler: It's based on math, it's based on good, solid, solid logic, uh, and then make the case.
- 1:20:13Brent Sadler: Because a strong Navy is not a partisan issue, it's an American issue.
- 1:20:17Brent Sadler: And that didn't happen organically.
- 1:20:19Brent Sadler: And it also, I have to also put a pitch out.
- 1:20:21Brent Sadler: Uh, it's more than one person.
- 1:20:23Brent Sadler: I think you saw this when when we were at Paycom.
- 1:20:25Brent Sadler: It takes a team or takes a network to defeat a network.
- 1:20:29Brent Sadler: And there's a lot of competit, there's competition, you know, armies out there, and sometimes they're not on side.
- 1:20:36Brent Sadler: Um, and of course, China is always trying to derail things uh that could be a threat.
- 1:20:43Brent Sadler: So it takes a network to defeat that network that's that's either benign neglect or benign uh delay or distraction to the malign, which is the Chinese, and they're different.
- 1:20:58Brent Sadler: So anyway, I've I'm also part of a network of about a dozen or so navalists that are all very committed to this effort.
- 1:21:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and you have friends that are not only in Congress, but they're uh getting selected for undersecretary of the Navy.
- 1:21:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we have friends that have become admirals and three stars and four stars.
- 1:21:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's that like to see some people that you've worked with in the past uh get into these positions?
- 1:21:21Brent Sadler: Uh well, I mean, I I take their success as, you know, they're team, they're a shipmate.
- 1:21:25Brent Sadler: So I take a lot of pride in the fact that, you know, I worked with those folks.
- 1:21:29Brent Sadler: I might have helped.
- 1:21:29Brent Sadler: We may have helped each other at some point in time.
- 1:21:32Brent Sadler: Um, I'm, you know, high discretion.
- 1:21:35Brent Sadler: Uh folks know my reputation on the high discretion.
- 1:21:38Brent Sadler: So I will talk truth to power, and I'll do the gentlemanly thing first and say, look, you're you're heading into shoal water, and if they go too bad, I uh I know it, I'm gonna do it anyway.
- 1:21:48Brent Sadler: I'm like, well, then I'm gonna start talking out of out loud.
- 1:21:52Brent Sadler: Uh so usually, well, always, I give the gentleman's uh courtesy of, you know, with this network of folks, and the assumption is that people that are in government are there because they have the interests of American people at heart.
- 1:22:07Brent Sadler: Unfortunately, it's not always the case.
- 1:22:08Brent Sadler: But when it comes to the Navy, I haven't been disappointed in that regard.
- 1:22:12Brent Sadler: Um, and so that's another good thing.
- 1:22:14Brent Sadler: But it's been remarkable.
- 1:22:16Brent Sadler: I mean, it's a different relationship uh with a lot of these.
- 1:22:18Brent Sadler: Like I can talk to senators and congress members, I can talk to very senior folks in government, political as well as uniform.
- 1:22:25Brent Sadler: And there's a there's a respect there because of the access uh and the clarity, the the you know, the discretion in all of those conversations.
- 1:22:34Brent Sadler: Um probably for another place, another time for many of those sea stories to come out.
- 1:22:39Brent Sadler: But um yeah, it's been very rewarding.
- 1:22:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, hey, I appreciate your time.
- 1:22:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we've been looking forward to having you on the show.
- 1:22:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We definitely want to have you back.
- 1:22:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's so many things going on in the world today that I know we could talk about.
- 1:22:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But uh, do you have any questions uh to us or about the show or anything that uh you you know we've talked about today?
- 1:22:56Brent Sadler: No, um well, thanks for quite a long platform.
- 1:22:59Brent Sadler: I don't get a chance often.
- 1:23:00Brent Sadler: It's got to be like these little 30-second little sound bites, which drive me crazy.
- 1:23:04Brent Sadler: So thanks for the chance to have a have a conversation, quite frankly.
- 1:23:08Brent Sadler: A very long uh conversation, and you brought me back, you really dusted off some cobblers there in the beginning of paycom time.
- 1:23:14Brent Sadler: Um, but it was good to good chat.
- 1:23:17Brent Sadler: Send me the link when it goes live.
- 1:23:19Brent Sadler: Uh definitely love to repost it if it's okay.
- 1:23:22Brent Sadler: Yeah, once you once you put it out.
- 1:23:24Brent Sadler: And um, yeah, let me know how I can help in the future.
- 1:23:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Absolutely.
- 1:23:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, thanks again.
- 1:23:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, we'll keep you on for a few minutes, but thanks for being on No Way Out, and we'll talk to you soon.
- 1:23:33Speaker 1: Beat Army.
- 1:23:34Speaker 1: Yeah, beat Army.