Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Hair Pulling Disorder (2015 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00So, Paulette, you have anxiety? Oh yeah, I do. And
- 0:04do you ever pull your hair as a way of coping with your anxiety?
- 0:07You bite your nails, bite my nails and shake my leg. I bite
- 0:12my own tongue, like, chew my tongue. It's so gross and weird.
- 0:16I don't know. Why isn't that gross? You're blushing as you say
- 0:19that. I know, because it's weird to talk about how weird you are
- 0:22and tell people. You're not telling anyone, You're just telling me, Okay,
- 0:25you and forty thousand people. Can you imagine pulling your hair in a
- 0:31similar way of biting your nails? Yeah? Well, I wanted to talk
- 0:34about that today because a patron actually wrote in and asked us to talk about
- 0:38it. It's interesting that you think about, like anxiety and all the way
- 0:41that it manifests itself, like and people, my friends, and my sister
- 0:46now is moving here and she was just here and she's like, it was
- 0:48stop biting your nails gross o. And I was like, oh god,
- 0:51this is going to be but I can't stop. But it's so weird,
- 0:54Like why do I put my nail in my mouth and peel it off?
- 0:57Why do I why is that? That's not an less weird It's like destroying
- 1:02a part of your body, pulling a part of your body off itself.
- 1:04All right, well let's get into that. Let's talk about it, and
- 1:07I want to explore possible reasons why you and other people might do that.
- 1:11This is the Psychology in Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkanda.
- 1:15I'm chair of the Couple in Family Therapy program at Antioch University, Seattle,
- 1:21and I'm also a licensed therapist. I'm doctor Paullette Perhatch. Just kidding,
- 1:26I do want to get my doctorate in creative writing so I can make so
- 1:30I can make you call me doctor and you'll get mad. No, I
- 1:33will get mad at the doctor of writing, which is the thing. No,
- 1:37I am just a writer. I'm not just a writer. I'm a
- 1:38writer. I am writer and nailbiter Paultte Perhatch writer and nail better writer comment
- 1:44nailbiter. So a patron wrote in but wants to remain anonymous, so she
- 1:49writes first. I absolutely love the podcast. Your psychology of TV and films
- 1:53are definitely my favorite. I was wondering if you could spend an episode talking
- 1:57about tricotillo, trick of tillomania. That's a trick of tilomania and other bf
- 2:05rbs. Do you know what BFRBs are? Body? Yes, functional,
- 2:09no, body focused, focused? What is it bf bf rbs RB repetitive,
- 2:19repetitive yes behaviors. Yeah, it's a term for impulse control behaviors involving
- 2:24compulse compulsively damaging one's physical appearance or causing physical injuries. So nail biten could
- 2:30be considered that. I've suffered from trick or trick of tilomania for almost four
- 2:36years now, and it's a very difficult and frustrating disorder. Over the years,
- 2:39I have realized that a large portion of the population actually suffers from this,
- 2:45from this, from this disorder, but it is very unknown in the
- 2:47public eye, and research on trick and bf rbs is very slim. I'd
- 2:53love for you to speak about this topic and spread awareness. I'd also love
- 2:55to hear what you think should be done to help cope the issues. I've
- 3:00done everything from CBT, medication and meditation, but still can't stop pulling out
- 3:07my eyelashes. So her tricotillomania is pulling out her eyelashes. Thank you,
- 3:14so much. She says, all right, so what do you have to
- 3:17say for I would first of all say thanks for writing that. I think
- 3:21it's important to talk about different things and look into it. And I think
- 3:24that's an especially hard one because it's very evident. And also it's something that
- 3:30I think it's like everyone sees that that's what's going on. And I'd like
- 3:35to say that I had somewhere between an acquaintance and a friend, a light
- 3:39friend in high school who had this, but no one talked about it too.
- 3:44I never talked about it with her. People talked about it, you
- 3:46know, but it was just like and she was like super nice and awesome.
- 3:50But you know, everyone kind of knew that was going on or wondered
- 3:53about it. You know, it's high school, so god forbid anyone just
- 3:55like ask a question straight on. We're all just like whispering and wondering.
- 4:00So I think it's interesting. Yeah, it's important to talk about Yeah,
- 4:04so good. Yeah, I agree, Thank you listener and patron for writing
- 4:09in, because we need to raise awareness as this person is talking about.
- 4:13All right, so body focus. Repetitive behavior refers to any compulsive behavior that
- 4:18damages the body. As we talked about before. There are some common ones,
- 4:21like tricotillomania, which is compulsive hair pulling, and in the DSM five
- 4:27it actually says tricatillomania or hair pulling disorder, which I like. I like
- 4:32hair pulling disorder. It's much easier to remember than tricotillomania. Another one is
- 4:40on a coophagia, which is compulsive nail biting. Did you know that that's
- 4:44what I suffer from? Am I? In the DSM five hundred, what
- 4:46is it, DSM FiveM I trying to do a NASCAR? Yeah, it
- 4:51was like as a NASCAR what is it called? That'd be funny A bunch
- 4:55of Freudians therapists like in their civis going around like a block. Every car
- 5:01is like a metaphor for what it is. Yeah. So another one,
- 5:05So that's on a coophagia. I don't even know if I'm pronouncing it right.
- 5:10Oh and why ccho phagia compulsive nail biting, exoriation disorder, compulsive skin
- 5:17picking? Oh see, that's that's like on the side of Where's where is
- 5:24the skin picking? Could be? Anywhere? Okay, I knew. One
- 5:28of my favorite ladies used to have like a used to pick. It's all
- 5:31related. I think I have like five of these. Yeah, tricko temnomania,
- 5:36which is compulsive hair cutting just one hair at a time, Yeah,
- 5:41just one hair, just clip clip. But personally I don't like these Latin
- 5:45names. I wish we would just call them compulsive hair pulling, compulsive nail
- 5:48biting, because no one knows what on a coophagia is it's but everyone knows
- 5:53what compulsive nail biting is, all right. DSM five, tricatilomania or hair
- 5:57pulling disorder, is recurrent, recurrent pulling of your hair resulting in hair loss.
- 6:04You have repeating you need to be said, needs to be defined.
- 6:10DSM five is very specific, repeated attempts to stop. It causes distress or
- 6:16impairment, and it's not related to a different medical or mental issue. In
- 6:21a given year. According to research, about one percent of people suffer from
- 6:27hair pulling disorder. That's a lot of people. One percent. Females are
- 6:33how much more likely than males to have it? Do you think they are
- 6:39one thousand percent more likely? They are ten times more likely to have it
- 6:44than men, which is interesting. I'm curious and maybe we'll get to this
- 6:46about like is it hair on your head, eyebrows or eyelashes, could be
- 6:50any, could be any and maybe armpit armpit? I pulled my armpit hair.
- 6:57Did you know that there's a new trends. Someone told me there's a
- 6:59new tree and of coloring your armpit hair, like women will grow in America
- 7:05will grow their armpit hair and color it. Yeah. Well, I said
- 7:09the extra fuck you to people who want them to shave it. I think,
- 7:12okay, I see I said that if the Seahawks make it to the
- 7:15playoffs, I'm going to diet green and blue. Each one armpit green,
- 7:21the other armpit blue. What do you think about that? It's not my
- 7:26personal favorite, but I believe that people should be able to do whatever they
- 7:29want. That's how I feel about it. That is one of the most
- 7:36diplomatic answers I've ever heard in my life. All Right, So, females
- 7:42are ten times more likely to have it hair pulling disorder. The onset is
- 7:47often during when do you think adolescence? True, and specifically puberty, so
- 7:53early adolescence. As with a lot of mental disorders, they tend to emerge
- 7:57during that time. Puberty has an effect on the brain quite a bit.
- 8:01That's when all You're crazy comes out. Oh yeah. Tricotillomania can be affected
- 8:07by hormonal changes as the person ages, which is research is found it runs
- 8:13in families, tens to run in families, so nail biting as well,
- 8:16and it seems to exist in most cultures, which is an important important data
- 8:22point. My dad did bite his nails. Well, there you go.
- 8:24You got it from him, Thanks dad, Thanks Dad. Basically, the
- 8:28way that it works is you feel a massive urge to do it. It's
- 8:33like an irresistible itch. If you have a compulsion like nail biting, or
- 8:37alcoholism or cigarette smoking or coffee drinking, or hair pulling or any of the
- 8:43various masturbation. If you have, there's various different there's various different compulsions that
- 8:50people have, and if you can relate to it, then you don't really
- 8:56need it to be explained. But for some people, they literally have no
- 8:58compulsive history, which is bizarre. But if so, if you've never had
- 9:03one of those compulsions, it's a massive urge to do it. It's like
- 9:07an irresistible itch. I remember explaining, like trying to explain my anxiety and
- 9:13like when I was in high school, I didn't have that label, like
- 9:16I have anxiety. It just that's the way the world felt. And I
- 9:18was trying to explain it to my best friend and she's just like, yeah,
- 9:22I just can't relate. I don't have that. And I'm just like,
- 9:26oh, like that must be so nice. Yeah, some people,
- 9:31they have what we would call extremely environmentally congruent anxiety. Yeah, she wait
- 9:39congruent congruent, meaning that if a tiger is literally about to kill them,
- 9:43they are afraid, but they are almost never afraid in situations that anxiety suffers
- 9:50suffer from, which is like worrying about what you said last night, or
- 9:56worrying about what you're going to say later, or worrying about what you look
- 9:58like, or worrying about how you sound, or worrying about dying, or
- 10:05worrying about the future. You know, just your general worry that people experience.
- 10:09See, I think that, like, if a tiger is about to
- 10:11attack you, that's not anxiety. That's that's regular. It's like and then
- 10:15I call anxiety like my emotional like it's emotional hallucinations. That's how I explain
- 10:20it, because it's like you have this emotion that is there that is not
- 10:24congruent with the situation, that has nothing to do with the reality. That's
- 10:28just an invention of something some part of you, exactly. And so a
- 10:31compulsion is somewhat related to anxiety and some whatnot. And just think about it
- 10:39as an as an irresistible itch that is that just gets more and more intense
- 10:43as you ignore it. So if you have an itch on your leg and
- 10:48you feel it, and you have an urge to itch it, and all
- 10:50you just want to do is itch it, and then you try not to
- 10:52itch it, and all you're trying to and so all your effort is not
- 10:56to itch the itch, and the itch gets more intense and you people are
- 11:01talking to you, and all you can think is get you on my leg,
- 11:03get you my leg, Get you my leg. That's what a compulsion
- 11:05is like. And when you have a hair pulling compulsion, that's what it's
- 11:09like. It's not just like, oh, I want to pull my hair
- 11:11out of my eyelids, you know, it's it's an It just the urge
- 11:16just mounts and mounts and mounts, and it can make you quite stressed and
- 11:22depressed and distracted. So it can be quite intense. You know, this
- 11:28person who's writing in wants to stop. She's tried to stop through various different
- 11:31ways, probably for years, and it's having a really hard time doing it.
- 11:37So if you don't understand what that's like, understand that it's a it's
- 11:39a very it's a very uncontrollable urge, should we say, yeah, which
- 11:45is so weird. It's like like bullieve me or anorexia and when people are
- 11:50just like just to eat, you know. And then I didn't fully understand
- 11:54it until I had a friend who had bulliemia and it was it's totally different
- 11:58from what I thought. It's really I don't know. It's like everyone's mind
- 12:03is a separate world, and they all function in these really different ways,
- 12:09right, that makes it so hard to connect sometimes, or like if something
- 12:11isn't your thing, you're just like, I don't you know, I don't
- 12:16know. I think that everyone can kind of map it onto their own experience,
- 12:18So especially if you have anxiety and you have one of those different things
- 12:22like I can't stop biting my nails, right, so you could imagine what
- 12:26it would be like to have a hair pulling compulsion. Yeah, I can
- 12:28totally map my experience from like biting my nails to like pulling your hair out
- 12:35right, So basically, you have a massive verge to do it. It's
- 12:39like an irresistible itch. Then you do it, and then you feel pleasure
- 12:43and relief. This is important is to know that it's not just oh,
- 12:46I'm pulling my hair. It actually gives you pleasure or relief from that anxiety
- 12:52or from that compulsion. Then people often feel ashamed. Do you feel does
- 12:56it release dopamine in your brain when you do it right? So there are
- 13:00various different ideas and data regarding what happens in the brain. And we have
- 13:05a rudimentary understanding of how dopamine relates to motivation and rewards and all these kinds
- 13:13of things, and yes it has to do with that kind of stuff,
- 13:15but our understanding of the brain is pretty limited. So like, for instance,
- 13:20what they've found is that someone can have no compulsion at all, and
- 13:24then when you give them a medication or they have a stroke that involves the
- 13:30dopamine centers in the brain, they can develop a compulsion. I've talked about
- 13:33this client that I had years and years ago about he was suffering from Parkinson's.
- 13:41I believe, And they gave him a dopamine medication because that's a common
- 13:46medication for Parkinson's. And what it did was it gave him a sex addiction
- 13:54for the first time in his life. My god, So for the first
- 13:56several decades of his life, no sexual addiction, no sexual compulsion. He
- 14:03takes this medication and he instantly becomes a sex addict, and he's he has
- 14:07a compulsion for sex, and he would he would drive around town looking for
- 14:13hookers, even though he was happily married, and this medication was ruining his
- 14:18life and his family and his marriage. And so it gives you this new
- 14:22idea of what these kinds of things involve. When you look at someone who,
- 14:28say, for instance, has a sex addiction or any kind of addiction
- 14:31without having taking medication, you wonder, is that if there's something wrong with
- 14:35their brain that creates this Because a lot of times when people say is,
- 14:39oh, that person's a dog, they're a scumbag, they're a douchebag.
- 14:43That's why they're doing this, and that and motivation, you know, you
- 14:46could say, might have a lot to do with obviously has a lot to
- 14:50do with biology, but it raises questions you know. Or pedophilia. It's
- 14:54a compulsion they have sex with children. Is it related to the disorder of
- 15:00something in the brain. There's some evidence of that too, like there someone
- 15:03have a stroke or an injury in a particular part of their brain and they
- 15:05will become a pedophile right after that. Oh my god. There was a
- 15:09really interesting radio lab about this where the guy had some brain issue and I
- 15:13think he got on medication and it made him start having an addiction to child
- 15:20porn. But it was like the episode was about blame and it's like whose
- 15:24fault is this? You know? So the police came, he got found
- 15:28out, and he just like they came and he's like, I know why
- 15:30you're here. He felt terrible. I mean, I mean like ethics implications
- 15:35out the wazoo here, you know. And it was like there are no
- 15:37easy answers. Here's the story and they just presented it and it's a crazy
- 15:41story. Yeah. So again there's an urge to do it. Then they
- 15:45do the behavior. There's pleasure in relief. They often will feel shame,
- 15:48and it's like any other compulsive behavior like smoking or eating a donut, or
- 15:54like I said, compulsive masturbation or snorting cocaine or masturbating with donuts. Masturbating
- 16:00with donuts, if that's what your compulsion is, and it's all basically the
- 16:03same brain mechanism, is what people are thinking, all right, different causes.
- 16:08Genetics is an obvious contributor in that compulsions tend to run in families.
- 16:15Trauma is something that also might lead to tricotilomania. If you experience any kind
- 16:21of trauma, whether it's a one time event or ongoing trauma as a childlike
- 16:25as in sexual abuse, physical abuse, ongoing emotional abuse, or your parent
- 16:29it was an alcoholic or something like this, stress can lead to tricotilomania.
- 16:33Anxiety, depression, low self esteem, which is interesting. Can you imagine
- 16:37low self esteem leading to nail biting and hair pulling? I think low self
- 16:41esteem can be a kind of anxiety, and it's this like anxious feeling that
- 16:45you're not good enough. And why would hair pulling or nail biting help with
- 16:48low self esteem? I don't know, Yeah, I don't think it would
- 16:52really help. Well, why do you think it leads to it? So
- 16:55if you feel bad about yourself, it can be kind of like a self
- 16:59like a harm kind of thing where like a punishment, like a punishment almost
- 17:03maybe like I'm bad, so I'm going to punish myself. Yeah, yeah,
- 17:07yeah, I think that's that's exactly right. I'm doing an episode soon
- 17:11by myself because it's I have like pages and pages of notes and I want
- 17:15to bother you or an embargo with it. But it's about self injury in
- 17:18general, like cutting and all these kinds of things and so, and it
- 17:22goes into that in terms of self punishment, inner personal problems will lead to
- 17:26hair pulling and nail biting, family systems problems, so problems in the family.
- 17:33And also it might be caused, so to speak, by a need
- 17:38for a release of the brain chemicals that are released when you have pain.
- 17:44So when you bite your nails or when you pull your hair, there are
- 17:48certain chemicals that might be released in the brain that might you might become addicted
- 17:52to. Essentially interesting. Right when you said pain, I was pulling on
- 17:56this little skin tab on my nail and it started to hurt really bad.
- 17:57I'm like, that's why I laughed. I'm like, oh and that right
- 18:00now to myself. Okay, so what form of treatment do you think is
- 18:04the most common meditation, maybe medication, a lot of the similar things to
- 18:10anti anxiety stuff. Great good. Yeah, basically medication and CBT are the
- 18:15main things that are given. But the things that I'll say is that it's
- 18:21important not to be ashamed of it. That's step one, because in order
- 18:25to face it, you have to be okay with it. You have to
- 18:27accept it. This is what's happening. I have this compulsion. No big
- 18:33deal, it's not the end of the world. Yeah, I think that's
- 18:34hard. I think, especially with something that would be difficult for a lot
- 18:37of other people to understand, that's hard. I know that I have a
- 18:41lot of I feel like ashamed about my anxiety. I've gone through that where
- 18:45I'm like, especially in college, and for me, my dad died in
- 18:49an accident right before two months before I left for college. Oh I don't
- 18:53know that. I go off to college to the number one party school in
- 18:56the country and my dad has died, and so I was like I would
- 19:03like try to be party girl, and then like it was just terrible,
- 19:07and it's like, why why can't I feel better? And a lot of
- 19:10those like Choose Happiness Today articles really piss me off because I'm like, some
- 19:15people like you can really try, but it's not a choice. Some people
- 19:19are just like, of course i'd want to be a happy, go lucky
- 19:22person. Of course I would want to be the kind of person that wouldn't
- 19:26you know, bite their nails out of anxiety, or you know, maybe
- 19:29someone would feel like, yeah, I don't want to be the kind of
- 19:30person that's going to pull out my own eyelashes. I don't understand it.
- 19:33I don't know why I do it. So you have to get rid of
- 19:36that like personal blame on yourself. And one of my favorite spiritual guys is
- 19:42at Karttotley, and he talks a lot about that. He's like, whatever
- 19:47your shit is, everyone has shit that's being a human being, and you
- 19:51just you can't like identify with that. You can't say I am this disease.
- 19:56You have to just say like, oh, this is what I don't
- 19:59know, this is something I was born into. This legacy of humanity that's
- 20:03so crazy in so many different ways. You know, Yeah, take it
- 20:07for me as someone who come who people come to with their secrets that they're
- 20:11ashamed of. Everyone has secrets that they're ashamed of. Everyone suffers from things
- 20:18that they are ashamed of. And so often what people will tell me is
- 20:22they feel like they're the only one, and I'm they're telling them, believe
- 20:26me, you're not the only one. I think that's been a really great
- 20:27part of the Internet where everyone who has I mean is not a bad part
- 20:33of the internet too, where like everyone has god knows what, you know,
- 20:36fetish, as we saw with the link I sent you yesterday. You
- 20:40know, you can find other people who feel that way, which is really
- 20:42nice. And I think for me as a writer, that's an important part
- 20:45because part of me just wants to like not tell anybody anything about anything.
- 20:49And then when I read other writers. Jonathan Ames has this great story about
- 20:56uh he like smoked crack on Christmas night. He was like, had a
- 20:59shame. I don't know. It's a long story, but it's good.
- 21:00Look him up. If you like stories like that, let it know.
- 21:03Let it. Yeah. I think it's important to like be out with your
- 21:07shit, and that's what a lot of artists do, and I think that's
- 21:10a way that art can help people connect and feel more feel more connected with
- 21:15the whole of humanity. Yeah, okay, Yeah, So there are medications
- 21:25for chickatillomania. There are various means that might help, but most of the
- 21:30ones that are good for compuls Do you kind of smell a fart right now?
- 21:33I sort of, I've sort of. It's not I don't actually smell
- 21:36a fart, but I feel like I've been thinking about farting for the past
- 21:38three Minutesesia, Yeah, exactly, it's like a phantom fart. But if
- 21:42it's anesthesia, where like when your phone rang, you smell the fart.
- 21:45I know, Oh my god, there's probably people like that, right,
- 21:51Okay, So, but most most of the medications that are good for compulsive
- 21:57hair pulling often have significant side effects, so it's important to think about that.
- 22:04I hate. That's what I hate about modern medicine. Medicine isn't like
- 22:08it doesn't treat your problem. It gives you an option between two problems.
- 22:12It's like, generally, when it comes to psychotropics, Yeah, you will
- 22:17stop pulling your hair out, but you're gonna have uncontrollable diarrhea and you're just
- 22:21like, hmmm, which is worse. That's the question with modern medicine.
- 22:25That's right. In general, I should emphasize that medications for chickatilomania do not
- 22:32have a encouraging rate of success. So you could try meds, but I
- 22:37would give it, I don't know, a ten to twenty percent chance of
- 22:41working. Wow. Yeah, it's kind of like with anorexia. The survival
- 22:47rates and the rates of recovery are like abysmal. Yeah, yeah, it's
- 22:51and that's why I'm in business. It's because if there was a medication,
- 22:56then So the preferred treatment for chickatilomania is talk therapy or CBT. And let
- 23:03me kind of go over this a little bit. CBT is the preferred treatment
- 23:07cognitive behavioral therapy. But I will say that if PTSD or a relational issue
- 23:12is involved in the hair pulling disorder, you might not benefit only from CBT.
- 23:18You might need also like psychodynamic work or trauma therapy or something. But
- 23:23if it's just hair pulling, like yours is mainly just nail biting pull it,
- 23:30it's not necessarily Although I want to ask you, and you know,
- 23:33feel free to tell me to screw off by asking. But but your your
- 23:38dad. You said your dad bit his nails and did you see him growing
- 23:42up biting his nails? Yeah? Yeah, And when now that he's gone,
- 23:48and that's sad for you, I'm guessing, right, Yeah, And
- 23:52when you bite your nails, is that some kind of subconscious way of holding
- 23:56onto them. It is interesting there there have been a lot of ways in
- 24:02which I exhibit behavior that my dad had, and I've come to understand some
- 24:07of the especially restless behavior of my dad that didn't quite make sense before,
- 24:11because I think that I inherited a lot of his feelings and his kind of
- 24:15emotional patterns. So that is an interesting point. And my mom pointed out
- 24:21that my dad bit his nails, and then it is a little bit of
- 24:25like a point of connection that in one way, it kind of makes it
- 24:29okay. It's like an excuse, like, oh, my dad bit his
- 24:32nails. Now I bite my nails. And I do enjoy all the ways
- 24:36in which I'm like my dad, because my dad was pretty fucking awesome.
- 24:38So right. We want to take in the people we love, yeah,
- 24:42And one of the ways that we do that is we become them. We
- 24:47love a rock star, for instance, On a lighter note, we love
- 24:49a rock star, so we start acting like them and talking like them.
- 24:53Madonna loves English people, so she starts talking with an English accent. It's
- 24:57all the same thing. So with your nail biting, for instance, cognitive
- 25:03behavioral therapy is, without going into the details, is very pragmatic. It's
- 25:08very skill based and awareness based. And it's not even necessarily awareness based,
- 25:14but it's very pragmatic. I'll just put it that way. But with your
- 25:17nail biting, it might have an element in the grief and loss regarding your
- 25:22father. It might have to do with your childhood in terms of the way
- 25:26your family was, it might have to do with the way you think about
- 25:30yourself and your identity, and in that way, cognitive behavioral therapy isn't the
- 25:36preferred mode of therapy for issues like that. It's more psychodynamic, interpersonal,
- 25:41these kinds of therapies. So to the listener when she says that she's tried
- 25:48CBT and it doesn't work, maybe different forms of therapy that will get at
- 25:53other factors involved might be key. Does that make sense? So just to
- 25:57get a little bit more specific with you, Paulette, and again tell me,
- 26:02feel free to tell me to screw off or or whatever, but as
- 26:04long as you're not going to build me, yeah, yeah, Is there
- 26:08a way, for instance, if you know, if you were in therapy
- 26:12along these lines, you might explore ways of remaining loyal to your dad without
- 26:18having to do the nail biting. Is there a way to remind yourself of
- 26:22your dad and reminisce in a positive way, in a way that promotes grieving
- 26:27and connection that doesn't involve nail biting? Or when you nail bite, are
- 26:33you thinking of your dad and you go to the nail biting instead of some
- 26:37other activity that is less destructive? Does that make sense? Yeah? I
- 26:41mean, overall, it doesn't seem that linked to my dad in an overt
- 26:47kind of way like that, But I think definitely I could acknowledge that I
- 26:51might use it as an excuse that, you know, oh it's something my
- 26:53dad did in something I do. And you know, there's definitely ways in
- 26:56which it's really cool. I'll see my nephews say things that my dad used
- 27:02to say because and he was born after my dad died, but it's because
- 27:04my sister and I say them, and then you know, he learned from
- 27:07us. It's really fun. And the other day, like my I was
- 27:10listening to my headphones and my headphones got ripped out by the doorknob. And
- 27:12I was just like, well, it's the end of that. And I
- 27:15was like, oh my god, I haven't said that in years. And
- 27:17that's something my dad used to always say, like if we broke a toy
- 27:19or something like, well, that's the end of that, you know.
- 27:22So yeah, I can definitely acknowledge that I don't need to bite my nails
- 27:26to be like my dad in the good ways, you know, I don't
- 27:30have to bring on his or take on his negative traits. Right, So
- 27:33it's not that we would know per se that it's related to your dad,
- 27:37because it would be an unconscious thing in all likelihood. But if you were
- 27:41trying to stop it and the regular methods weren't working, as with the emailer,
- 27:48then maybe looking at these other kinds of issues, and in general,
- 27:52the grieving that we do regarding losses that are important like this, like a
- 27:59father or is something that we can address ongoing anyway in a healthy way.
- 28:06And so it couldn't hurt, you know, to address grieving. And if
- 28:10a side effect of the grieving work makes you less likely to bite your nails,
- 28:15than great, But otherwise it's it's good in and of itself anyway.
- 28:18Anyway. So with CBT in a nutshell. When you're addressing hair pulling,
- 28:26you are training your brain to stop doing it, to put put it an
- 28:32outshell. It's like it's a habit, like smoking it, and the habit
- 28:34needs to be broken essentially, So each time you feel the urge, you
- 28:40employ an established replacement behavior. That's that's important. That's an interesting idea,
- 28:45yeah, because what people will say is you need to stop doing it.
- 28:48Stop biting your nail, stop pulling your hair. That doesn't work. What
- 28:52you need to do is replace it with something else because your brain can't.
- 28:57It's so desperate to complete that cycle that it it just just sitting on your
- 29:04hands will just make it worse. I've seen like a ring that has an
- 29:08inner part that circles around you can kind of play with it, and I've
- 29:12thought about getting a ring like that. So that's a replacement behavior. Okay,
- 29:17I need to work on that. Yeah. So there's things like you
- 29:18could rip paper something, because that's because when you're pulling your eyelashes out or
- 29:25you're biting your fee nails, there's a certain kind of ripping. There's certain
- 29:27kind of like breaking something that that is satisfying, and so ripping paper might
- 29:33help, or something that often isn't considered that I'm always inserting everywhere is hugging
- 29:37a friend? She just rolled her eyes. It sounds like the old like
- 29:45abstinence training or and it's just like, instead you could hug, I mean
- 29:48ingrinned. Having sex is better than biting your nails. But it's like,
- 29:52wait, what kind of hugs do you have? I just said hug Do
- 29:57you remember that? Like a in straining and instead of having sex, hug
- 30:03And it's just like not as good, say missionary hugging. I just said
- 30:12hugging. I feel like biting my nails. Can I have a hug?
- 30:15I don't have that many friends around. I'm at work. I can't hug
- 30:18a coworker. Well, the issue with hugging is that hugging, or any
- 30:22kind of physical contact, holding hands, or or any kind of social warmth,
- 30:27shall we say, is a very soothing thing to the brain. And
- 30:32so when you are experiencing anxiety or you know, stress, and you get
- 30:37any kind of physical warmth, even if it's just like a text with somebody,
- 30:41physically, your brain will be altered and that might be a good replacement
- 30:45behavior, is the point. How about if people who are addicted to masturbating
- 30:48bite their nails instead. People who bite their nails just switch from one to
- 30:52the other. Yeah, yeah, I guess. Well. They used to
- 30:56say when people would quit alcohol at AA meetings, there would be everyone would
- 31:03be smoking cigarettes, and everyone's drinking coffee and sleeping with each other, probably
- 31:06right. And so for some people they'll say, well, smoking cigarettes is
- 31:11better than drinking alcohol, which I would say is empirically true. But what
- 31:17other people will say is to replace one addiction for another isn't helpful because you'll
- 31:22you'll just go round and round the addiction sort of circle, and you need
- 31:26to stop all compulsive behavior. So anyway, it is like this kind of
- 31:30well from which all these different compulsions and addictions spring. You know. It's
- 31:34like the same thing that makes me bite my nails is the same thing that
- 31:37makes me like chwo on the side of my cheek or something. Right,
- 31:41That's an idea that's true for many people, but I would say from experience
- 31:45that for some people it's not that way. Really, yeah, for some
- 31:48people, So what other way is it? So the idea is is like,
- 31:52well, if you quit alcohol, you need to go through certain steps
- 31:55in or to quit alcohol. And if you transfer your addiction to another substance
- 31:59likeigarettes, you're just postponing the inevitable of all the difficult work you're going to
- 32:04have to do to get rid of all addictions. So that's the that's one
- 32:07perspective, and it's true for many people. But for some people that's not
- 32:12the case. For some people, when they transfer their addiction to a lesser
- 32:17problematic thing like cigarettes, the steps they need to do to get off cigarettes
- 32:22is actually easier than it would have been if they would have just gone cold
- 32:25turkey off of alcohol. Does that make sense? And so it might be
- 32:29like a good transition substance while they're moving for It's sort of like when people
- 32:35quit smoking. I'll talk with people about this. They'll say, I'm just
- 32:38eating all the time. All I'm doing is eating all the time. And
- 32:43you could say, oh, as if you're going off of that stern approach,
- 32:47you would say, well, you have to stop eating all the time
- 32:50too, because you're just transferring your addiction of cigarettes to eating. But what
- 32:52I found for some people is is just kind of a necessary phase you go
- 32:55through, you know, for a couple of weeks or even a couple of
- 32:59month months because you're so stressed out and you want to smoke cigarettes so badly
- 33:05that yeah, you might gain five or ten pounds, which is bad,
- 33:07but in the long run it might be a necessary step. Does that make
- 33:12sense. Yeah, So other replacement behavior are things like drinking water, doing
- 33:15a relaxation exercise like deep breathing, or a mindfulness exercise, and you can
- 33:22keep a log of your process and your progress. That's an important part of
- 33:27CBT. Today, I was five on a scale of stress, and I
- 33:30had a sudden urge to bite my nails, and I did this replacement behavior
- 33:37and this worked. And yesterday I did this replacement behavior but it didn't work.
- 33:40And you bring that into therapy and you talk about and you strategize and
- 33:44that sort of thing. All this might lead to a much larger discussion about
- 33:46how you deal with stress, how you assert yourself, how your marriage is
- 33:51going, how well you sleep, how well you eat, et cetera.
- 33:54So it might not just be focused on the hair pulling or the nail biting.
- 33:58It might involve a lot a lot of different areas in your life.
- 34:00Does that make sense? And something that's often left out of the literature on
- 34:05the treatment of compulsive hair pulling is the power of social support. For whatever
- 34:09reason, this is something in the United States anyway that gets completely ignored.
- 34:15This is why AA exists. You know, you don't need AA to quit
- 34:20drinking. But the reason why AA works so well is because you're in a
- 34:24group of people and you're getting support and you're hearing other people and you feel
- 34:30less shamed because people have the same problems that you do, and you're being
- 34:34inspired by other people's commitment to sobriety. There's something magical about a social environment
- 34:40to move motivation. The people will say to me, why should I go
- 34:45to AA. It's just a bunch of drunks, you know, sitting around
- 34:49talking. How is that going to help me? Well, the reason why,
- 34:52I don't know why it helps precisely, but for whatever reason, when
- 34:55you're committed to sobriety and you go to AA, you walk out out more
- 35:00committed to sobriety that day. Well, there's the benefit of peer pressure,
- 35:04positive peer pressure and right also when you're around people and you're not being judged,
- 35:07Like I feel like I'm at a point where with a lot of people
- 35:10in my immediate circle, I can just be like, oh, I'm having
- 35:15a lot of anxiety today and we all know that, Like there's no reason
- 35:17for it. I don't need them to try to solve it. I don't
- 35:21you know. It's just like just saying that it's there helps, right,
- 35:24helps alleviate the anxiety. Right. So, in summary on the treatment how
- 35:30to get treatment for hair pulling and other kind of compulsions is the first step
- 35:35is to reduce your shame, because you can't face it unless you reduce your
- 35:39shame. If you have shame, shame is what drives addictions. Shame is
- 35:45the key component to what drives addictions because it keeps you from facing it because
- 35:49you're ashamed of it. And that shame leads to more stress and more reason
- 35:53to be compulsive about something. So you need to find a way to reduce
- 35:58the shame. That's focus number one. The second thing is to be committed
- 36:01to the long term goal. People often have this idea of just like,
- 36:06oh, I tried quitting blank for a month and it didn't work, I'll
- 36:09never quit. That is completely an inaccurate idea of what it takes to quit
- 36:15something that's compulsive. It takes years. And if you but but if you
- 36:19stick to it. But there but in the what there is a high chance
- 36:25that you will be successful. But you have to commit to the long term
- 36:29goal. You have to say I am committed to this, and I might
- 36:32not succeed right away, but I'm committed to this. I'm I'm going to
- 36:37visit this as often as I have energy for and I'm going to recommit myself
- 36:40to quitting as often as it takes. I you know, I can't remember
- 36:45the average, but like for quitting smoking or something, I think the average
- 36:50quitter who actually eventually quits quits something like ten twenty, thirty forty times.
- 36:55They never it's the average amount is several times. People almost never quit something
- 37:01the first time that they quit. Yeah, so you have to be committed
- 37:06to the long term goal. And what a lot of people do is they
- 37:07try for a little bit, it doesn't work right away because they think it's
- 37:10supposed to, and then they just give up and say, screw it.
- 37:14I guess this is what I'm gonna do for the rest of my life.
- 37:15Yeah, that's definitely hard. I can certainly relate to that, right And
- 37:22the other thing that I say, so reduce shame, commit to the long
- 37:24term goal, And the other thing is to address yourself holistically rather than just
- 37:30saying I'm gonna quit. You have to think about your stress level, your
- 37:32sleep level, your diet, your social support, your trauma, your mourning,
- 37:37your grief, your everything. You have to really think about a lot
- 37:42of areas in your life because that might help to reduce it. There's a
- 37:46book that I really like to called Mindset. Have you read that? Carol
- 37:50Dweck? Do you never stop reading? But it seems like you've read every
- 37:53book ever. That's so funny because I really didn't read during it high school
- 38:00on like colleges, and I used to like have a panic attack when I'd
- 38:02go into stores bookstores and be like, I haven't read anything, And now
- 38:07I'm like catching up, and I think I'm clearly I'm getting there. I
- 38:12really love to read, and I really like learning about how to live and
- 38:15filling all the holes that I feel like our education system leaves when you're quote
- 38:20educated. It's a great book about having a fixed mindset or a growth mindset,
- 38:25and with a growth mindset, with a fixed mindset, you say this
- 38:29is the way I am, I'm not going to change, So then you
- 38:31don't start to take those steps, so then it's a self fulfilling prophecy.
- 38:35Then you don't change if you have a growth mindset and you say, Okay,
- 38:37I don't have this yet yet is a very key word of that book
- 38:40and of her research. You say, I don't have this yet, but
- 38:44I'm going to work toward it. And then you do work toward it.
- 38:47You have that hope and you do change. And it really affected me and
- 38:52called me out on some of my own stuff that I thought, I'm like,
- 38:55oh, I learn all the time. Of course I have a growth
- 38:58mindset. No, No, there was a lot of things that I caught
- 39:01myself having a fixed mindset about. So there's a book that I would recommend
- 39:05to people who are trying to change. It really helped me. So you
- 39:08found that you were having automatic thoughts that were counter to that. Yeah,
- 39:14like I'm not this way. I am this way, and especially I think
- 39:16in my generation, which I'm like on the I'm a old on the old
- 39:22side of millennials. But it's like the your special culture and you're smart and
- 39:28smart kids don't have to study that much. If I have to study,
- 39:30then that means I'm not a smart kid. So I had to prove I'm
- 39:32a smart kid and just wing it and you know, and I'm special,
- 39:37so I don't have to work that hard towards something and all these things that
- 39:40I was like, ooh, sounds familiar, you know. So it's like
- 39:45and with me with being a writer, it's just like if I am a
- 39:49writer, that I should just be able to write beautiful stuff, but it's
- 39:52like, no, you have to really work on growing those skills and getting
- 39:55good. Yeah, doing this podcast has taught me that I listened back to
- 40:00the first few podcasts that we do that we did and realize how far we've
- 40:07come as a group, Me and Embardo particularly, We were terrible at this
- 40:15thing when we first started, and you just have its repetition and trial and
- 40:20error and listening back and getting feedback and changing things and trying new things,
- 40:23and eventually you get to the you know, where we're at today, depending
- 40:29on whether or not you like us or not. So getting back to the
- 40:31podcast listener, you've tried CBT, you tried medication, and you've tried meditation,
- 40:37and yet you keep pulling your eyelashes. So here's what I would say
- 40:42is if you were going to therapy, then I would try a different therapists.
- 40:46Unless you really like your therapists and you want to stick with that person,
- 40:49then I might stick with that person. If you haven't been a therapy,
- 40:51you should go to a therapist. You should try more self help.
- 40:54You should again be dedicated to the long term goal. As I said before,
- 40:58I don't know how long you've been trying, but it clearly isn't long
- 41:00enough. But know that you can actually succeed. You have to believe in
- 41:05yourself. Also, if you've had any trauma in the past, you might
- 41:08have to address that because CBT, you won't necessarily address that. You might
- 41:13have to address any attachment issues in your life. I wonder how close you
- 41:16feel to the people around you, how loved and secure you feel. You
- 41:21have to address any current stressors or triggers. So I'm wondering what's triggering the
- 41:27hair pulling and if there's a way to reduce contact with those triggers. You
- 41:31want to get ongoing support. You want to reach out like you're doing to
- 41:36us. You're sending us this cemail, And you might want to consider coming
- 41:39out of the closet if you haven't already, because again that's a part of
- 41:45getting support. And also it helps to commit you, you know, when
- 41:49you say to a bunch of people, I have a hair pulling problem and
- 41:53I am committed to stopping and I would love it if everyone helps me do
- 41:58that, And I would love it if everyone didn't shame me and let me
- 42:01explain what my situation is. And here's how you can help. When we
- 42:05pool resources like that, we tend to do better. But I can't tell
- 42:10you just to come out of the closet because I don't know your situation and
- 42:14I don't know how you feel about that. But I say let it fly,
- 42:19man, Let your hair pulling flag fly, because you might actually find
- 42:22that there are a lot of other people like you around you, and you
- 42:25might be able to come together and have a little friend group where you support
- 42:29each other in quitting. Yeah, and I just googled hair pulling support group
- 42:34and at the Tricotillomania Learning Center they have a whole list of support groups around
- 42:39the nation. A lot of them are linked with skin Pickers, Anonymous hair
- 42:45Polers and skin Pickers Peer Support Group. Well, that does it for another
- 42:49episode of psychology in Seattle. Thanks for joining us out there. Please take
- 42:52care of yourself and remember to take care of yourself. Because you're worth it.
- 43:00You deserve it, was our tagline. Both are fine, essentially the
- 43:05same thing, Right, you deserve it but you're not worth it, or
- 43:08you're worth it, but yeah, you deserve it because you're worth it.
- 43:10You're worth it because you deserve it. That's right,