Latest / Future Engineering Bets / Are European Car Makers in Trouble? | Future Engineering Bets
Transcript
- Drea & Fred Warner: So very recently there has been the 2026 Financial Times Future of the Car Summit held in the UK So very recently there has been the 2026 Financial Times Future of the Car Summit held in the UK and most of the world's major OEMs were represented there and we heard from all kinds of figures and I'm going to run through some of the key points that were talked about during that major OEM summit and a few of my opinions and thoughts on how you might use that to benefit your own business planning in the future. Hey everybody, I'm Fred. This is Future Engineering Bets where we're looking at future innovation and where you may be interested in investing your capital allocation in the future. Hey everybody, I'm Fred. This is Future Engineering Bets where we're looking at future innovation and where you may be interested in investing your capital allocation in the future. So we heard the positioning of the OEMs. So we heard the positioning of the OEMs. Now that's going to be very important for your tier one, two, tier three planning, Now that's going to be very important for your tier one, two, tier three planning, But there's a few pieces of the jigsaw moving around here that are very difficult for people to predict, so we'll probably just focus in on those a little bit because they're quite interesting. so probably not news to you, and I've talked about it on a previous episode, is really the slowing down ⁓ of battery electric vehicle programs by a number of OEMs, including some of the largest write downs in history, ⁓ and in their case, the first year they've ever made a loss. Now when we look at the EV update, things are fluid because of geopolitical issues going on in the Middle East in particular, currently as we make this video, which is changing people's stance a little bit, but fundamentally, the European model has not been fast to adopt EVs. Now the challenge for the OEMs is that they need to make EVs at scale to make margin on them. And if they're not making them at scale, they're not making any money on them. Now the Chinese have already been through 20 years of pre-planning of sourcing all of the raw materials, sourcing the building blocks and putting the cars in, and they can build these cars at scale. Interestingly, globally, there is surplus capacity to produce cars. There are too many factories ready to build cars. the challenge for the OEMs is that they need to make EVs at scale to make margin on them. Interestingly, globally, ⁓ there is surplus capacity to produce cars. there's more factory capacity than there is demand for vehicles. So something's got to give in that region in the future. So we are likely to see consolidation. Nissan and Sunderland have already switched one line off and are looking for partners to come in and use their second production facility and that might be going on throughout Europe which we'll get into in a minute. So ⁓ something's got to give in that region in the Great examples of decisions being made. Volkswagen are pushing their Golf ID, their electric Golf, to the end of the decade. That's a major decision, decision again has been made around scale, because they don't they can produce it at large enough volumes to make a margin on it and compete a light flight base with some of their Chinese competitors. Interesting times. If you take Stellantis, who for those of you don't know, own Fiat, Maserati, Citroen, Peugeot, Vauxhall, a number of other brands, they've been doing a turnaround. Their EV commitment nearly killed them and they've been doing a turnaround and putting diesels back into their production plans, petrol, hybrids, and they're not going fully EV. They will offer EV, but they're going with a mix. And this is the theme in Europe. It's a balanced mix and they're pushing regulators to consider, look. We're not ready to shift to full EV yet. Let's have a balance mix. And the reason that's an interesting subject is if you go full EV, like many of the politicians and the sustainable people really want us to, we are fully dependent on China. Now, geopolitically, right now as things are moving around the world, maybe that would have been fine 10 or 15 years ago, but right now it's starting to make people nervous. but right now it's starting to make people nervous. because if we are fully dependent on China for our production of cars... because if we are fully dependent on China for our production of cars... we have potential to have problems in the future. we have potential to have problems in the future. Now also add to that the fact that they are building cars at scale that are EVs that are by all means good family cars and European manufacturers can't compete with them at the scale and the margins that they're trying to make. So where does that leave the European car makers? Probably scrambling back a little bit towards hybrids, petrols, Not only from a position of not being able to persuade people to buy EVs en masse right now, but also from a defensive position. The European OEMs, including everyone in UK, have left it too late to really plan their EV raw material supply chain through to final production. What does that mean? It means when you take the minerals out of the ground and you turn them into battery packs and you turn them into the other elements needed to make an electric vehicle, we're all pretty dependent on China and that's not... really in everyone's interests long term. And it's going to take 10 or 20 years to turn that around. So that does mean that the OEMs in Europe are now looking around to say, well, what do we do? So there's a lot of talk of partnership. Partnerships really between the European OEMs and finding a partner in China that can be their supply chain partner and potentially even produce more things. At the same time, the automotive manufacturers in China are looking to Europe to say, how do we do more of our production in Europe or certain elements of that production in Europe to avoid the potential EU tariffs, which I talked around about being 35%, which may or may not apply for a long time, who knows. So we've got motivation from China to build more in Europe and we've got motivation from Europe to align with the Chinese OEMs, particularly the big companies like BYD who are major in making a lot of the car batteries. So where does that leave you? Well, we can say that it would appear the plug-in hybrid is going to be around for a long time. I would say that's a sensible decision based on the fact that not every application suits an EV, regardless of what anyone's position is on sustainability and political opinions. If you look at it from a technology aspect, particularly in trucking, long range vans and everything, EV doesn't really work at this point in time. Now the Chinese are also hearing this and so they are also adding plug-in hybrids to their range of cars. So you're going to have an extra piece of competition cutting that will also hit The Chinese companies are not only offering the EVs but they're also offering the plugins the other things to compete with Europe. Where do I think it's going this is really hard to say but if you think there's an over capacity issue and then we come on to the next one which is an energy issue we talked a lot during the week about energy the energy costs in Europe are high when you look at China energy costs are much lower the government has much more strategic control over its energy it has far further reaching agreements in place to protect their energy prices and when you look at that versus Europe where we are quite on edge we take a lot of our energy from either Russia and the UK is a massive importer of energy people are starting to question those strategies obviously as a way to protect yourself long term but from an automotive point of view expensive energy goes into the price of a car. And if someone else is able to make a car at a far lower price, some of that is labour, but a lot of it's energy. And so that energy question is a kind of an unsolved problem. If you can't predict the future energy requirements that you're going to have to spend in your capital investment, you may be safer to go and build in China. So that leads me on to the point, are we really going to see a shift of Either production moving to China or certain elements of production maybe being then sub-assembled and then finally assembled in Europe. Option one, reduce energy. So European OEMs partnering with Chinese OEMs. Number two, I could see this really happening. ⁓ the Chinese are smart enough to know that brand is everything, And you've seen that with MG where they bought the Rover MG brand and I'm sure someone's going to launch a Rover one day. But it's worked quite well in the UK, launching a brand everyone's familiar with. They all know this is Chinese cars coming in. You stick a brand on it, it's an MG. It's a British car. Now imagine the future where maybe a Fiat, or maybe a Maserati, maybe a BMW. They're all going to be made in China. Will the companies survive? Some of them will and some of them won't, but maybe Chinese companies will be buying up more of the European brands and selling us cars from China in the future. It's going to be some tricky days ahead for the automotive OEMs as there is too much capacity and too much competition. Will the companies survive? Some of them will and some of them won't, but maybe Chinese companies will be buying up more of the European brands and selling us cars from China in the future. It's going to be some tricky days ahead for the automotive OEMs as there is too much capacity and too much competition. So where do you put your money? Well, I think being safe, you would say there will be an ever increasing demand for EV. It won't go away, but there will be a long term play for hybrid powertrains. that won't go away and as we get through the practicalities of full EV strategies which are flawed there will always be an ongoing need for hybrid powertrains. Now there's other areas that we discussed heavily at the summit such as the future of the car in terms of software and AI and driving experiences. If you're interested in that stuff go and have a look. That's not what we're discussing here today. We're focused more on the powertrain and the geopolitical positioning of companies and I think it's really interesting. So if you're a tier one, tier two, ⁓ You've got to be looking at how the supply chain may be shifting and thinking about how you source components both in the next five to ten years but where are going to go after that? There are people that are looking into how they source those components outside of China but that's going to take time but at the same time do you want to be fully reliant on China as your core source of all raw materials in the future? I hope you've enjoyed that discussion. It's a really interesting topic, lots of different opinions on it. So many things to talk about. What do you think about the whole geopolitical piece and then the defensive strategy of do we need to make sure we don't rely on China in the future in case of geopolitical tensions that could change as we go forwards? What happens with the global OEMs when they start shifting potentially their production to China and the Chinese OEMs making European branded cars either in Europe or in China or both? And what happens to the powertrains when EV and hybrid are going to coexist together? Does that still leave room for hydrogen fuel cell or is a plug-in hybrid with potentially sustainable fuels with e-fuels in the future going to be an answer that comes alongside EV permanently? Thank you very much for watching. I'm Fred Warner of Future Engineering Bets. Do like and share this with other people, do subscribe and I will see you in the future.