Latest / ThisWeekInGeek / Botched Roll - Trying Something New
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, It's time for another special feature. Hey guys, what's going on?
- 0:20You are listening to botsed roll only on this week in geek dot Net.
- 0:24I am your dungeon master, storyteller guy behind the game master screen.
- 0:29I am Mike the Birdman, and this is the show here on Twig that
- 0:33we have dedicated towards the tabletop role playing game hobby. I could be interviewing
- 0:37people from the industry. I could be talking about funny stories. It could
- 0:40be talking about theory. I could be talking about a specific book. Who
- 0:44knows. So Yeah, as I mentioned on the last episode, at least
- 0:49until I launched, this will be like a really really quick plug. I
- 0:53am gonna be launching my own dungeon Master for higher service slash Patreon, coming
- 0:58up by free Rpday, which is June twenty second, twenty twenty four.
- 1:04I will have details on my social media and here on the website. I'm
- 1:07sure alse will pop a link somewhere and yeah, you can find out more
- 1:11information if you and your friends want to join me and hire me to run
- 1:15you through the Forgotten Realms across the Alpha Quadrant, or perhaps across the lands
- 1:21of Cybertron and beyond I'm your guy. So last time on the show,
- 1:26I talked about the benefits of convention gaming and trying something new and different,
- 1:33kind of like going to the buffet and trying something like, Hey, that
- 1:36looks weird and fucked up, let's try that. And I kind of want
- 1:40to expand upon that into a different realm when it comes to actually sitting down
- 1:45at the table. And what I mean by that is, so I have
- 1:49been playing tabletop RPGs for I started back in nineteen ninety two, and I
- 1:56started with Advanced Dungeons and Dragons and the first character I was forced to play.
- 2:01Okay, I'm not saying someone held a gun to my head, but
- 2:05my first game master was a guy named Jamie, and we played D and
- 2:08D and I rolled up a cleric. Didn't want to play a cleric.
- 2:14Didn't want to I wanted to be kick ass, frigging Conan. I wanted
- 2:17to be the guy with the two hundred great sword, or like Aragon from
- 2:23like fucking Lord of the Rings. I wanted to be billy badass. I
- 2:25wanted to be something cool, but instead I had to do this a cleric.
- 2:30I didn't know what I was doing. I was just like, Hey,
- 2:32here's your role here. You can turn on dead yay. And since
- 2:38that time, I haven't ventured much outside of a certain realm. Like I
- 2:45always wanted to be, like all right, fine, I'm gonna be a
- 2:46fighter. Fine, I'm going to be a barbarian. But things changed for
- 2:53me probably about wow. When I really think about it, I guess it
- 2:58would have been about ten years. I had a friend of mine, I
- 3:00was living in a different city at this time, and I was playing Pathfinder
- 3:07first edition. Pathfinder was sort of like what of what if D and D
- 3:10three point five worked? I like to nickname it D and D three point
- 3:15seventy five, And it was the first time I'd ever played a utility character,
- 3:22a support character. I was a sorcerer and I was a skill monkey.
- 3:28I was. I had spells that didn't do a lot of damage,
- 3:30but they could really change the load out of the battlefield. I could do
- 3:36buffs, I could do D buffs. I could screw with the enemy,
- 3:39screw with my DM in really creative ways. But I wasn't going to run
- 3:44up and deal like two D twelve damage to something in its face. What
- 3:50I could do, however, is I could knock it out. I could
- 3:53make it my friend. I could make it so it couldn't grab its weapon.
- 3:57I could blind it, I could put conditions on it, so I
- 4:01kinda I used to listen to a friend of mine's podcast and they talked about
- 4:09the tabletop role playing game hobby and the biggest piece of advice I ever got
- 4:13from that, and it's something that I very much carry through into my own
- 4:15modern I guess procedure how I play is be more than a collection of stats,
- 4:26be more than a stat block. And what I mean by that is
- 4:30it's not just setting yourself up from role playing identity, although I will talk
- 4:33about that in probably a future episode. It's be willing to try something different.
- 4:39So playing a spellcast or playing a Sorcerer meant I had to learn how
- 4:44to approach the game differently. And I wasn't just running up and dealing damage.
- 4:49It was like, I have to think tactical. I have to think
- 4:53smart. I have to think I'm not just going to get by on a
- 4:58boatload of hit points and that's going to be it, right. I have
- 5:01to really think about this if I want this character to survive, if I
- 5:04really want to experience their story. Now that character actually became part of a
- 5:12Kickstarter campaign. She was in Freeport, which is a book which was set
- 5:19in Pathfinder, but you can also pourt it to D and D. I
- 5:24think it was called fuck. I know it's called Freeport, the City of
- 5:31Pirates or something. And I was a water witch, which was really cool.
- 5:39They kind of fleshed it out, and even the ship they gave me
- 5:43was called the Wiley Depth that it was named after my best friend, my
- 5:46cat, who since passed away, doctor Wiley, which was kind of cool.
- 5:50But anyway, point when I'm trying to get across here is playing that
- 5:56Spellcaster kind of changed how I started to approach different games. And I really
- 5:59wanted to not be the damage guy. I wanted to be the rogue.
- 6:04I wanted to be the warlock. And I've been playing in a long running
- 6:11D and D campaign for the last year or so, actually a year almost
- 6:15to the day as of this episode recording. And in the one game,
- 6:19I played a rogue with the intention of being I want to be sneaky,
- 6:26I want to do things. But I started taking levels in Monk because at
- 6:30the time I was watching a lot of Dragon ball Z, so I'm like
- 6:32Okay, I want to be able to put out some damage. But then
- 6:36I started playing in a different game, and I started not metagaming, but
- 6:41I started fleshing out the world because they were interconnected in a sense, so
- 6:45I was allowed to play in two backyards at once. So what I did
- 6:49is I started creating a background where that character one of them was a damage
- 6:55machine, but I multi class to give them levels into something. So what
- 7:00I did was I took one of the characters was a monk slash druid who
- 7:05couldn't wild shape yet, but the other one was a rogue who was like
- 7:13a bounty hunter and started taking levels of a monk because she was falling in
- 7:15love with another character, and that gave me reason to try something new,
- 7:21and I was like, okay, this is not the most optimal build.
- 7:27Like I think I am, I'm a rogue soul Knife, and I think
- 7:30I'm a monk way of the shadow. But even that's changing for me drastically,
- 7:36and I can't say too much more because I some of my friends might
- 7:40be listening. But it's leading me down a very unique path that I never
- 7:46considered before, and that's from playing, for example, Balder's gay three,
- 7:50which is a wonderful computer game. If you love D and D, you
- 7:53got to play this thing. And it really got me thinking about different types
- 7:57of characters and different things that I want to accomplish from a role playing perspective,
- 8:01but also from a enrichment of the environment perspective, like I'm able to
- 8:07interact in a different way. And it led me to my current game,
- 8:11which I'm currently playing with a bunch of friends who's lineup has recently changed.
- 8:16And I'll talk about that a little bit later in a future episode, probably
- 8:20the one after this, where I talk about how do you deal with problem
- 8:24players? But it became where I wanted to play a Druid because I just
- 8:33think they're cool and it very much aligns with my indigenous identity. But I
- 8:37wanted to play a Bard because I like that idea of being social. I
- 8:39like the idea of diplomacy. I like the idea of being able to talk
- 8:43my way out of a situation. I love role playing. I don't like
- 8:48dungeon crawls. Right. Most people play D and D because they want to
- 8:50be Oh my god, I'm gonna kick these things after like Fireball three,
- 8:54D eight Damage or whatever. The piss it is no, I'd much rather
- 8:58try arms said person like, Hey, I'm your buddy, I'm your friend,
- 9:03I'm your pal. Me and my friends got to get in here,
- 9:05so why don't you let me in here. Here's fifty gold. You let
- 9:09us through, and the next time you need help, I will be right
- 9:11there to help you. I love that thing. I love being more than
- 9:16just I cast a spell, I kick its ass, roll sneak attack,
- 9:22damage cool, attack of ill take like. I don't like that, and
- 9:28that's why I have other people in the group who fill that role. And
- 9:31I found myself getting a much more enriched role playing experience because I was trying
- 9:37stuff like that. And even when I was playing the damage dealing characters,
- 9:43I wanted to make sure there was a reason why they were badass or why
- 9:48they I wanted to be flawed. I wanted to be different. My one
- 9:54character in the other game was a monk slash druid Genessa, and her thing
- 10:01was she was part of an order I created called the Cloakwood Monks, and
- 10:07their big deal is they have when they gain their ability to use key,
- 10:13they have to come back to the temple within one year and explain to the
- 10:18grand Master, how did you find your focus? Where do you draw your
- 10:20spiritual energy from? And then they get their name, like her name was
- 10:24jenessa fox dancer, and the I have a very complicated backstory, and maybe
- 10:31I can talk about creating interesting backstories later. But the idea was when I
- 10:37made Genessa, I wanted her to be this kick ass Goku kind of stand
- 10:43in, but I wanted her to have a role playing reason as to why
- 10:48she had other abilities. And it was something I'd never played before, like
- 10:52I'd never played a monk before. My other character of Sara, who is
- 10:58a rogue, I've never played age before. I've never played a monk again.
- 11:01It all started with me watching dragon Ball and I was really worried for
- 11:05a long time, like ah am I becoming that damage dealing more on No.
- 11:13I wanted to enrich that because I wanted to try something different. And
- 11:16the more I look at the character classes, and I'm focusing a lot on
- 11:20D and D here, but I'll kind of spread that out in just a
- 11:22minute to other game worlds. I wanted to try something to. I want
- 11:26to see how the other shoe fit. And I've discovered that when I look
- 11:31at my own personal philosophy. I really align with a lot of stuff that
- 11:35the Monk does, that idea of inner peace being driven by a higher purpose.
- 11:41Maybe I'm full of myself. I don't know, But I look at
- 11:46the Druid and the connection to nature and how my own spiritual beliefs kind of
- 11:50influence that, and I'm realizing I can really bring a lot of that to
- 11:54the table to enrich the role playing experience. But it's something different that I've
- 11:58never done before. Like I said, it used to be fighters and barbarians
- 12:01and all this stuff, and it's really evolved over the last easily couple of
- 12:05years to be being more than here's a stat block, here's the optimal build.
- 12:11I very rarely look up build guides. Sometimes I might, for like,
- 12:18if I do want a deal damage, at least I'm gonna be cool
- 12:20and it's gonna make sense as to why I have these feats or this ability
- 12:26array or whatever I want it to make sense. I don't want to fall
- 12:31in the trap of being a power gamer, and I think that's a lot
- 12:35of my issue, and I kind of wonder if this kind of sucks.
- 12:39But I look at people who power game and I'm thinking, I don't like
- 12:43that, but I realized that's a very valid way to play. To you.
- 12:46If that's your fantasy, If this is how you enjoy going across the
- 12:50worlds of whatever, cool, all the power to you. But that's not
- 12:56me, and I don't have to play like that. And I guess it
- 13:00finding your own niche within the group, because you know, if you're a
- 13:03talky character and you're constantly running into the tomb of annihilation, you're not talking
- 13:09your way out of that. Maybe you're gonna gonna have to have a talk
- 13:13with with with your kind of storyteller and like, Okay, what can I
- 13:16do differently here? And most problems can be solved by that. And you
- 13:22know, there's nothing wrong with talking with your DM or talking with your players
- 13:26around you say hey, guys, can we do X, Y and Z?
- 13:30And that's cool. I mean, honestly, the group that I'm playing
- 13:33with now, there's a lot of interesting overlap because we're playing in a very
- 13:39paramilitary focused campaign where we have a mission, we have an objective, and
- 13:43we have to think like military, not like adventurers. And that actually led
- 13:50to a lot of group tension early on in our game. And now things
- 13:56have changed in that dynamics a little bit different now, but it really brought
- 14:01out some really good role playing and it really changed the direction of the story
- 14:05because it forced people to think differently, and it was interesting in how some
- 14:13of it resolved. Some of it didn't go the way that we all wanted
- 14:16to, but ultimately in the end, I think it turned out okay in
- 14:22a lot of good ways. And whatever happens happens next, I guess.
- 14:26But the biggest lesson I learned from that was if you're willing to try something
- 14:33different, sometimes you might get something absolutely wonderful. Sometimes you might also get
- 14:39mixing ice cream and hot sauce, not exactly a great combination. Sounds interesting,
- 14:43but probably not fun. So there are things that you can do.
- 14:50And I guess the biggest piece of advice that I encourage people to do,
- 14:56and it's not just limited to fantasy, but it's try a thing in like
- 15:01Shadow Run or stuff like Star Trek. You don't always have to be Captain
- 15:07Picard, you always you don't always have to be you know, the street
- 15:11samurai. Don't think more than damage. Think what what will give you the
- 15:16best role playing experience while working with your storyteller, like I know in some
- 15:24of the Shadow Run games I've played in before, my game master. At
- 15:28the time, when I really look back on how he adapted, he really
- 15:31did a really fantastic job. Like my character was a street samurai, and
- 15:37he found a way to work in a way to give me magic in a
- 15:41very cool and unexpected way. Long story short, he turned me into an
- 15:46aunt shaman and I didn't see it coming, and it was just one of
- 15:52the most magical times in my life as a role player, because I've really
- 15:58felt fulfilled for that. I'm like, wow, you didn't have to go
- 16:03this hard, and you did, and it was just such a fun time
- 16:10for me to try out. So it was something like I'm primarily a damaged
- 16:15dealing class, but now you're changing me into something else. I can work
- 16:19with this, like I can really craft some magic here. And I was
- 16:26totally blown away by that because they wanted to give me something different and exciting
- 16:33and I really did really did kind of get that, which again super super
- 16:40surprising that I was turned from this death dealing machine with an MP laser and
- 16:48now I'm throwing spells like stink Cloud and I'm doing all this really really really
- 16:52cool shit, and it's something that I didn't necessarily expect to have happen from
- 16:57the hop and again, wonderful experience. And I would advise you when you're
- 17:06trying something different. I mean, I mean, talk to your storytellers,
- 17:10talk to your groups, see what do you need. I mean a friend
- 17:15of mine gave me some great advice years ago, is like, be careful
- 17:17if you ever drive vehicles, like if you're the bus driver so to speak.
- 17:22Like if you play I don't know, like a game like Cyberpunk Red
- 17:25or Shatter Run and you become a rigger, right like are you gonna be
- 17:27the guy driving the car or the you know, the truck. But you
- 17:34have options, you have drones or if you're a decker or a net Runner.
- 17:40And that's about the only exper I mean, I'm sure there's like other
- 17:42games that probably have this problem too. You almost run a different game now
- 17:47because you have to worry about cyberspace and how turns are. I mean,
- 17:51it may be different than Cyberpunk Red. I've never played a net Runner.
- 17:53The only characters I've even designed remotely are a solo and a media because damage
- 18:00dealer talkie character. Maybe I'd create a Rocker. I don't know, but
- 18:06everybody wants to play Johnny Silverhand. I'm more interested in being Walter Cronkite or
- 18:11the Terminator. But yeah, I mean again, working with your group,
- 18:15everybody can take different roles. Like one thing I've thought about, really really
- 18:22thought about, is if I want to learn world Lord, there's maybe a
- 18:26way for you to play something different and maybe incourage something new, new and
- 18:30different from you. And that might be play a character class that really relies
- 18:33on world building. And what I mean by that is if your table's into
- 18:38this thing, I think you can actually have a really freaking a huge amount
- 18:42of fun with this. If you play a cleric or a paladin, you
- 18:47don't have to be, you know, thy pious prick, but you could
- 18:52really lean into like, for example, in D and D, I'm a
- 18:55paladin or Cleric of Tear, I represent the god of Justice. What what
- 19:00does that mean to you? Right? And that's a healing class and a
- 19:03support class, but you can also do some pretty cool damage or as a
- 19:07paladin you can do ass kicking and cool spell casting. And again, you
- 19:11can do a lot of things, but you've tried something different, you're not
- 19:15just a fighter with a sword or a barbarian, or you know, a
- 19:19character like a druid has so many options. Again, just from a role
- 19:25playing perspective, you've got combat wild shape, but you could be like a
- 19:29spore druid and putting all sorts of crazy shit around you. Or there are
- 19:34different flavors of barbarian now that can not quite do like druid type stuff.
- 19:41But there's like a beast totem where you can like be like the beast Master,
- 19:45or maybe you want to play like a ranger or something like that.
- 19:48Again, I think if you're willing to look beyond damage and what you can
- 19:53do to a battlefield, explore it, explore what other options, and you,
- 20:00in my opinion, you're able to read what your group is pretty easy.
- 20:04Like if you're a dungeon crawl, well, I don't know what to
- 20:08telling you. Hopefully you get a more enriching experience other than go kick lord
- 20:15douchebags ass each and every week, or go kill these goblins. I hope
- 20:19you're getting into political intrigue. I hope you're finding out why this evil god
- 20:25is cursing the land's fertility rates, or why there's a crashed Decepticon ship in
- 20:32the middle of Russia or something like that. You like, you know,
- 20:34like, I really hope you're getting a chance to explore what the game can
- 20:38be, to really dig into the meat and potatoes of it than just simple
- 20:44hey, go fight so and so, because again, experiences like that can
- 20:48be absolutely role playing game life changing. Like I said, the experiences I've
- 20:56had playing as a rogue and a druid and a druid and am but especially
- 21:00right now the druid and the Bard, I've had so much fun and I'm
- 21:06not dealing the most damage on the field. And even right now, I
- 21:11tried to do something damage dealing and I fucked somebody because I didn't read the
- 21:15spell description. I used the spell ice knife, and the player I was
- 21:21player, was like, don't do that again. I'm like, what are
- 21:22you talking about? I do one d ten ice damage blah blah blah.
- 21:26He's like, don't you say blah blah blah. I'm likeing, oh,
- 21:29okay, I read. I'm thinking, uh shit, and I never thought
- 21:33about it. Basically, I covered them in ice damage because I wasn't reading.
- 21:38And that's partially on me. I own that, but it's I tried
- 21:44something new and different and I had a mistake, but it was a learning
- 21:47experience which led to a really great role playing moment later and again I really
- 21:52had a good time with something like that, just learning something new and exciting,
- 21:56like I know, for Star Trek, for example, I've always wanted
- 22:00to play a ship's counselor when I used to play play by email if you
- 22:06can remember that, or play by post once upon a time, I tried
- 22:10that, and I honestly had an amazing time. I played a ship's counselor
- 22:15who was assimilated by the Borg way back when, and it was honestly kind
- 22:22of kick ass, and I, like I said, I had such a
- 22:29good time because I wasn't the security officer, I wasn't tu Voc, I
- 22:33wasn't Warf. It was neat. It was really really, really cool,
- 22:37and I had a really emotional moment. And I kind of wish that game
- 22:41went a different direction because it ended not too abruptly, or ended pretty abruptly
- 22:45after the one really great scene. But it was fun. And yeah,
- 22:52I mean, ultimately, we all play these games to try out something different,
- 22:56to try something fun, But I'm encouraging you to think beyond smash.
- 23:02I'm encouraging you to think beyond what's the most optimal build, What is the
- 23:07most exciting thing that I can do with this character? What do I want
- 23:17to get out of it? And what can you and your game master create
- 23:19together? Because, like I said, by trying something new, maybe by
- 23:22introducing a poud into your group, you introduce an entirely new subplot. Maybe
- 23:27by introducing a cleric. You know, it's not just looting dead bodies.
- 23:30You're like, hey, you're kind of defiling the dead here, guys.
- 23:33I'm not entirely cool with this. I mean, obviously you don't want to
- 23:36get too deep into the muck there with stuff like that, but it could
- 23:40create maybe for some funny moments who knows, right, Or maybe if you
- 23:44play as the rigor would be kind of funny if you got like a parking
- 23:48ticket or something like that. Right, Like, there's tons of opportunity for
- 23:52you to do really really interesting things if you're willing to look beyond what damage
- 23:59something does. And my personal philosophy to role playing now is especially more than
- 24:06anything else, is to be more than a stat block, be more than
- 24:10just the optimal build, Be more than just the coolness something seems like on
- 24:17the service, And I mean, of course you should play to have fun.
- 24:19Like I said, I don't. I'm not a power gamer. I'm
- 24:22not And the few times I've done it it felt kind of icky. But
- 24:26the times I've really taken the time to craft something unique and new, to
- 24:30learn something about the game, to learn something about myself, I've had a
- 24:33really amazing time. And my character of fox Singer, the druid who is
- 24:41searching for his lost love but wants to bring back knowledge to the grove,
- 24:48his sacred grove, to his skulk, is important because he needs those levels
- 24:53and barred to be that voice of the people, the voice of reason,
- 24:57but he also has to be that druid connected to the world. Or Genessa,
- 25:03this impetuous youth who's trying to figure out why her sister left her behind,
- 25:08but she also has this need to connect with nature because it calls her
- 25:12because that is her namesake. Or rather a character of Sarah. She fell
- 25:18in love by training with someone who was a monk. What does that mean
- 25:22when that love is eventually betrayed? Right, like, does she turn into
- 25:27like a rok Osak versus Hamato Yoshi from you know the Ninja turtles where they
- 25:33become rivals. Right, Like, there's so many cool things because I wanted
- 25:37to try something different. It wasn't just like I have a sword and I'm
- 25:38gonna kick your fucking ass. It was cool, right Like, be more
- 25:42than that street samurai, Be more than that solo, Be more than that
- 25:45security officer. Be more than just whatever's on the sheet. Think beyond that.
- 25:52And like I say, if you've got a really good group and a
- 25:56really talented storyteller, you can have some amazing stuff. And like I said,
- 25:59this doesn't all always apply for like one shots or if you're running through
- 26:02the Tomb of Annihilation or you know, Ghosts of Salt Marsh or whatever.
- 26:07Your mileage may vary, but this is just my own personal philosophy to it.
- 26:11And yeah, just go out there and find cool stuff. I mean,
- 26:15hell game masters like me, we love it when you bring cool stuff.
- 26:21I mean, I'm not saying break the freaking table because you don't get
- 26:25to use homebrew item that does X, Y and Z, But if you
- 26:29bring me an interesting background, I'm more likely to do something cool for you
- 26:33because you try something different, or if you tried a different kind of character
- 26:36class I know you've never played before. Like if you're used to playing paladins
- 26:40and you randomly bring me a wizard, Okay, that's kind of neat.
- 26:44Or if you play a solo and now you're gonna bring me a nomad,
- 26:48what does that mean? Right? Like again, I value experimentation, Like
- 26:53experimentation is how we find out cool stuff about ourselves and the world around death.
- 27:00So I I guess that would be my role playing kind of stick here
- 27:06is experimentation is the spice of life, and I really hope you take advantage
- 27:11of seeing that. So whether I'm seeing you across the dunes of the Aracus
- 27:17or whether we're gonna go, you know, march across the Imperium or fight
- 27:22Cobra or whatever, I hope you'll try something new and cool. And I
- 27:26really hope you find something neat out of some of all these wonderful books.
- 27:30And I hope you really have a cool experience with your storytellers and your friends
- 27:33as time goes on. So anyway, guys, I'm gonna get out of
- 27:37here. The next time here on BOSH, well we're probably gonna talk about
- 27:41how do you deal with problem players and a problem DM, like, how
- 27:45do you approach that that that sit situation because it can be hard, it
- 27:52is hard, but it doesn't have to end things, So that'll be an
- 27:56interesting conversation, uh to have. So anyway, guys, I've been Mike
- 28:02the Birdman saying, may all your roles be with advantage and may you always
- 28:06hit that critical So I will catch you guys next time right here on this
- 28:08weeknd geek dot At no point in your rambling incoherent response were you even close
- 28:15to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Thanks for listening to this
- 28:22episode of This Week in Geek Hungry for more, check out our website at
- 28:26this week in geek dot Net. You can subscribe to the podcast, browse
- 28:30our Twitter and Instagram, and leave your thoughts on today's topics. If you'd
- 28:33like to give us some feedback, send us an email at Feedback at this
- 28:37Weekend geek dot Net. Tune in next time and remember, lower your shields
- 28:41and surrender your listenership. We would be on a if you would join us.
- 28:45Thank you for your cooperation. Good night,