Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Unlocking Global Politics: Understanding the Forces Shaping Our World Today
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, where we
- 0:03explore how global decisions ripple through human
- 0:06lives and ecosystems. The current political climate
- 0:10is affecting every nation's decisions. And here
- 0:13at Science Behind the Glass, we believe that
- 0:15sharing knowledge, not panic, encouraging critical
- 0:18thinking about how the dismantling of the legal
- 0:22frameworks impacts not just diplomacy, but the
- 0:25ecosystem's biodiversity and the future of Earth.
- 0:29To help us unpack this, we honored to welcome
- 0:32Professor Gary Mayers, a legal scholar, constitutional
- 0:35expert, and the fierce defender of international
- 0:38law. Gary, thank you very much for accepting
- 0:41this invitation. It's a pleasure having you here
- 0:44again. Yes, absolutely. Yeah, thanks. We want
- 0:48to know more about the current political climate
- 0:51that is affecting everyone's nation's decisions.
- 0:54And in Science Behind the Glass, we leave that
- 0:57sharing knowledge, no panic, encouraging critical
- 1:00thinking about how dismantling of legal frameworks
- 1:05impact not only just diplomacy, but ecosystems,
- 1:08biodiversity, and the future of Earth, basically.
- 1:12So with everything that is happening recently,
- 1:16but I think that it comes from quite way back.
- 1:21All that's happening with the U .S., with Israel,
- 1:27we want to know recent events like, for example,
- 1:31the invasion of U .S. to Venezuela. And everyone
- 1:35is speaking about the U .N. charter and the violation
- 1:38of international law. Yes. Can you please explain
- 1:42to us in simple, plain words, what is the UN
- 1:45Charter, what does it mean, and why it's so important
- 1:49and so symbolic now? It became just so symbolic.
- 1:54Sure. Well, the UN Charter is the fundamental
- 1:59document that underlies everything that the United
- 2:02Nations does. And it sets the tone for what is...
- 2:07permissible and not permissible within the international
- 2:11community. It is a treaty, okay? And when you
- 2:18enter into a treaty with other countries, you
- 2:22do a couple of things. Most importantly, you
- 2:26agree to be bound by that treaty itself, okay?
- 2:29So the provisions in the charter, for example,
- 2:33on the use of force, that in fact prohibit the
- 2:37use of force, okay, you agree to be bound by
- 2:40that as a nation state. So, for example, I don't
- 2:47know whether to call it invasion, but anyhow,
- 2:49the attack on Venezuela, for example, is two
- 2:52things. One, it's a violation of the UN Charter,
- 2:55which prohibits the use of force or the threat
- 2:57of the use of force. And I'll come back to that
- 2:59one. in international relations, the use of force
- 3:04that threatens the political or territorial integrity
- 3:08of another country. But it's not as if, unfortunately,
- 3:16effectively, in many respects, unenforceable.
- 3:18I suppose Venezuela could go to the International
- 3:23Court of Justice and say, look, the U .S. violated
- 3:26Article 2 of the U .N. Charter by attacking us,
- 3:32Venezuela, by bombing our ships and by bombing
- 3:38our ports and by kidnapping our president. So
- 3:44it's possible that... That aspect of the charter
- 3:49could be enforced in the International Court
- 3:51of Justice. More interestingly, the crime of
- 3:56aggression has now been recognized as a crime
- 4:00that triggers the jurisdiction of the International
- 4:07Criminal Court. In this particular instance,
- 4:12in the Venezuelan case, for example, Venezuela
- 4:15is a member of the International Criminal Court.
- 4:18The U .S. is not a member, but both parties don't
- 4:21need to be members to have the International
- 4:24Criminal Court jurisdiction enforced. So the
- 4:28International Criminal Court then could indict.
- 4:31including probably Trump, the Secretary of Defense,
- 4:35in respect of its attack on Venezuelan territory,
- 4:40even its attack on Venezuelan ships, even though
- 4:43the U .S. is not a member. So Trump and the Secretary
- 4:46of Defense could both be indicted. They're unlikely
- 4:48to face the court because the U .S. isn't going
- 4:52to turn the president over to the ICC, or they're
- 4:55going to turn over the Secretary of Defense to
- 4:57the ICC. But the important thing about the indictment
- 5:01is every member country of the court would then
- 5:11have to arrest and send to the court Trump or
- 5:17his secretary of defense if they traveled to
- 5:21that particular country. And that's why you see,
- 5:23for example, Vladimir Putin, Benjamin Netanyahu,
- 5:26they're not traveling anywhere. They travel to
- 5:28the U .S. They travel to China because China
- 5:31is not a member of the court, but they don't
- 5:33they're not traveling in any any respect to any
- 5:36Western country. So what was a year or so ago
- 5:39when they were talking about having a meeting
- 5:41in Hungary and it was quickly, quickly, quickly
- 5:44canceled. Why? Hungary is a member of the International
- 5:48Criminal Court. And if Putin had showed up in
- 5:50Hungary, Hungary would have been obliged to arrest
- 5:53him and send him off to the Hague to face the
- 5:56jurisdiction of the ICC. And I have a question,
- 5:59more like a background to give our audience like
- 6:03an understanding of the United Nations chart.
- 6:06So how did this start? And the U .S. was part
- 6:10of this United Nations agreement or they are
- 6:14part of this United Nations? How did this start,
- 6:17if I'm not wrong, was after the Second World
- 6:19War? Yes. Well. And generally speaking, the allied
- 6:27powers, the US, the UK, France, China, and Russia
- 6:33thought it would be a good idea. And they gathered
- 6:37the other countries from around the world in
- 6:41San Francisco, and they had a bit of a talk fest
- 6:44for a couple of years. And we got the UN Charter.
- 6:49And like I said, you know, one of the most important
- 6:51provisions is the provision in the charter, in
- 6:56Article 2, I think it's Article 2, Paragraph
- 6:584, that prohibits not just the use of force,
- 7:03but prohibits the threat of the use of force.
- 7:06Okay, so now let's think, what does that mean?
- 7:09Okay. Hey, Greenland, I'm coming to take you
- 7:13over. That's a threat of the use of force, and
- 7:16it's clearly unlawful under the UN Charter. So,
- 7:19you know, you've got another one. And there's
- 7:22one more. You've got another one that could trigger
- 7:25International Court of Justice. A second one
- 7:29that could trigger the International Court of
- 7:30Justice is sending a flotilla of Navy vessels
- 7:33off the coast of Iran and saying, Iran, you will
- 7:37do X, Y, and Z, or you're in big trouble. That's
- 7:40threat of use of force. You can't do that. You
- 7:43can't do that. As the U .S. is part of the United
- 7:47Nations or was. So if they are violating the
- 7:52U .N. charter, who enforces this charter? Because
- 7:57the idea is of escalating a huge conflict. Then
- 8:03the purpose is like avoiding exactly what the
- 8:06U .S. is doing, right? Like they're bullying
- 8:08the other ones, threatening like a... For example,
- 8:13what he's doing with Greenland or like a U -Don't
- 8:16Do This, we impose also tariffs. That is another
- 8:19way of like imposing a book in the other nations.
- 8:24So how the UN, what are the tools that they have
- 8:28to enforce this? Well, that look is a slightly
- 8:32complicated answer or complicated question. Maybe
- 8:36I'll try and make the answer reasonably simple.
- 8:38Member nation of the UN could in fact. file a
- 8:43claim in the International Court of Justice arguing
- 8:49that the U .S. has violated the UN Charter, okay?
- 8:53And that would invoke the whole process of the
- 8:57hearing in front of the International Court of
- 8:59Justice. The difficulty with that one is that
- 9:03the U .S. would probably not, even though by
- 9:07joining the UN, they've effectively consented
- 9:10to be bound by the decisions of the ICJ. The
- 9:15ICJ itself has a provision in its own rules that
- 9:18allows a country to decline jurisdiction. So
- 9:23the U .S. would probably decline to be there.
- 9:25It's done that in the past. The famous case,
- 9:27U .S. versus Nicaragua. The U .S. mined the Nicaraguan
- 9:30harbors. Nicaragua took the U .S. to the International
- 9:33Court of Justice. The U .S. didn't even show
- 9:36up. The court found in favor of Nicaragua and
- 9:39the U .S. said, well, we're not abiding by any
- 9:43ruling. So it's a difficult proposition there.
- 9:48You could do it. It could be good PR, but the
- 9:54U .S. isn't going to show up. The normal route
- 9:57in a situation like this would be for the Security
- 10:01Council of the U .N. to take up the issue of
- 10:04violation of the charter. Security Council resolutions
- 10:08are law. The declarations by the UN General Assembly
- 10:14are just sort of persuasive of what the international
- 10:18community thinks is a good idea or is law. The
- 10:23problem there is that the U .S. is one of the
- 10:25five original founding members of the UN, and
- 10:29along with China, Russia, the U .K., and France,
- 10:32has a veto in the Security Council itself. That
- 10:37means you could take everything to the Security
- 10:39Council and you could get a vote of 14 to 1,
- 10:4214 countries, and then one country saying no,
- 10:45and that would be the U .S. Motion doesn't pass.
- 10:50I mean, it is complicated and it's messy, you
- 10:53know, and that's the, I think. But it's like
- 10:57saying, for example, okay, we are in this, we
- 11:00are in a... in a table sitting all together and
- 11:03then we agree that there is not going to be aggression.
- 11:06We just, you know, put some rules in place to
- 11:10try to avoid escalation, aggression, and all
- 11:14this that is happening. But then if I violate
- 11:17that, it's like, oh, but those rules don't play
- 11:19for me because I don't want to take that. I don't
- 11:23want. It's like that. So there's more like a
- 11:27formality. It's animal farm in operation, okay?
- 11:39All animals are equal, but some animals are more
- 11:43equal than others, okay? And the five permanent
- 11:47members of the Security Council are more equal
- 11:51than the other members in that respect. The General
- 11:55Assembly has the power to expel a member or suspend
- 11:59a member. but it needs the permission of the
- 12:02Security Council to do so. So everything keeps
- 12:06coming back to the Security Council. How can
- 12:09we change? Because we are seeing that this is
- 12:12like they are abusing the power and being part
- 12:17of the board, but not committed to do, like if
- 12:20I make a mistake and I'm failing to accomplish
- 12:25with this law. So what rules are we established?
- 12:29How this can change? Do you think it needs updates,
- 12:34a security board? Or what is the next step? Because
- 12:39the message that the U .S. is sending to everyone
- 12:44is just like, I don't know, like rolling out
- 12:48or putting out down the U .N. Yeah, you would
- 12:54have to have those five members. Those five permanent
- 12:58members of the Security Council agree to get
- 13:02rid of the veto and replace it, perhaps, with
- 13:07something like a supermajority. Fifteen members
- 13:10sit on the Security Council, maybe to pass a
- 13:14resolution. If you get rid of the veto, maybe
- 13:16to pass a resolution, you've got to have 10 in
- 13:20favor. Uh, maybe you've got to have 12 in favor.
- 13:24I don't know, but you know, somehow you've got
- 13:26to have those five members say we're getting
- 13:28rid of, um, uh, those, uh, we're getting rid
- 13:33of the, the veto. And once you're rid of the
- 13:36veto, then the, the UN could operate like your
- 13:39basic legislature around, you know, if you get
- 13:41a majority, super majority, fine, two thirds,
- 13:44three quarters, whatever you want. Um, but no
- 13:48veto. that fundamental change would mark a huge
- 13:52difference in the way that the UN operates. The
- 13:56other problem that has the UN now is the defunding
- 13:59that the US is doing, right? So they are not
- 14:02funding or they just remove all the funding of
- 14:05more than 75 % of the funding. Yeah. What does
- 14:10it mean? Is it going to be dismantled completely
- 14:13because they are now in crisis and then all needs
- 14:16to change the strategy? How the UN works? Because
- 14:20I don't think that a lot of people say it's like
- 14:22a wolf without teeth. No, I don't think it's
- 14:30going to get dismantled in any way, shape, or
- 14:33form. Because, look, it's temporary. For another
- 14:38three years while Rumpy's in office, you're going
- 14:42to have problems. And we've had this in the past.
- 14:47You don't have to think back too far. During
- 14:50his first term, there were a number of withdrawals
- 14:54of funding as well from particular organizations
- 14:56like UNESCO because they don't like what UNESCO
- 15:00does. It's sort of interference. It promotes
- 15:04education, science, culture, kids, women, what
- 15:09have you. No, no, no. We don't want that. And
- 15:13so it's happened before, and it's even happened
- 15:15before the first administration of this current
- 15:19occupant of the Oval Office. So, you know, next
- 15:23person in office will probably change that and
- 15:26refund the U .N. to all of its levels. And it's
- 15:32not unusual for nation states, in some respect,
- 15:35to, you know, be late with their dues across
- 15:39the board. You know, it happens. But I'm not,
- 15:44you know, I'm not worried about losing the U
- 15:45.N. I think I'm more concerned about what's happening
- 15:49just sort of currently and how long it's going
- 15:51to happen. I'm beginning to see signs in the
- 15:55U .S. of at least some Republicans pushing back
- 15:59on some of this stuff because it's just messy.
- 16:02You can't have the news this morning, the U .S.
- 16:06and India. just signed basically a free trade
- 16:10deal, okay? And all of the tariffs that had just
- 16:14been imposed against India because India was
- 16:17buying Russian oil are gone. So those tariffs
- 16:21existed for what, a month? You know, that sort
- 16:25of transactional, I mean, he's been described
- 16:28as a transactional president, and he is. You
- 16:32know, nothing's permanent. Nothing is related
- 16:35to legal obligations. It just happens. But now
- 16:41it's gone. No more tariffs against India. They've
- 16:43got a free trade agreement. Yeah. And also recently
- 16:47with the vice president of Venezuela, she's the
- 16:51one now in charge of the country. Correct. U
- 16:55.S. is imposing over them. how they have to manage
- 16:59their resources, specifically oil. But this is
- 17:03also part of the bullying. It shouldn't be allowed
- 17:06how the sovereignty is, how they run their own
- 17:09country. So what measures should be taken or
- 17:14would possibly to be taken to avoid this happening?
- 17:23That one was really, really, really messy because
- 17:27we don't, really have any idea of what level
- 17:32of management the U .S. is exercising over Venezuela's
- 17:38activities, its natural resources. We've got
- 17:40some idea of what it's doing with the oil, but
- 17:43it's not particularly clear. And again, one of
- 17:49the fundamentals of being a nation state is the
- 17:52capacity. to manage your own natural resources
- 17:55and that's in that's in the u .n charter and
- 17:57uh as i i mean i i don't teach international
- 18:00law again until the end of the year but when
- 18:02i was teaching it last year in you know october
- 18:06november what have you um you know i kept saying
- 18:09to the students look it's just it's just messy
- 18:11and it you know it isn't easily fixable um and
- 18:17there's no you know uh you and i go out and commit
- 18:21a crime You know, there's a police force there.
- 18:23They come and they get us and then they take
- 18:25us to court. We don't get to say no to the police.
- 18:28When the court sends us a summons to appear there,
- 18:31we don't get to say no to them. In international
- 18:32law, you get to do that, partly in part because
- 18:35there's no police and in part because, you know,
- 18:37the court has no capacity to force you to turn
- 18:39up. Neither one of them, neither the ICC or the
- 18:42ICJ has the capacity to enforce you to turn up.
- 18:46Do you think that this should change, like how
- 18:49they are enforcing this? And how can we change?
- 18:55How can we change it? How can we change it? Like
- 19:00I said, I think the change begins with the change
- 19:03in that veto. Get rid of the veto, then almost
- 19:08anything is possible. And I don't care what the
- 19:11supermajority is. I mean, you know, it could
- 19:13be 12 out of 15. That's fine. I don't care. Because
- 19:17most of the time you would get 12. Well, maybe.
- 19:21Maybe it's better to have 10 because of Russia
- 19:25and China and the U .S. all vote together. Then
- 19:27you've got a problem. You're right down to 12.
- 19:29So it gets a little bit tricky. That's the fundamental
- 19:32change that has to be made. In terms of the ICC,
- 19:35the ICC struggles and it struggles in part because
- 19:39it's a court of complementarity. In other words,
- 19:44the... International criminal law is supposed
- 19:48to be enforced by the country where the crime
- 19:51takes place. And it's only when that country
- 19:55is unable or unwilling to send someone to the
- 20:02court that the court acquires effective jurisdiction.
- 20:06And then it's a matter of, you know, perhaps
- 20:09a new administration. a new administration in
- 20:14the Philippines. The former president of the
- 20:18Philippines is now in the ICC. That's because
- 20:20the new president in the Philippines said, we're
- 20:23going to send Duterte there, despite the fact
- 20:26that his daughter is now the vice president in
- 20:29the Philippines. So you need the country that
- 20:35has jurisdiction over the individual to determine
- 20:38that, yes, we're either going to try this individual.
- 20:42Or we're going to send this individual to the
- 20:45ICC. So if you look at the various, you can go
- 20:48to the International Criminal Court and look
- 20:51up indictments, for example. And you can see
- 20:54who is currently being indicted and the past
- 20:58as well. And you look down that list. And in
- 21:01many of the instances, it says at large, at large,
- 21:04at large, at large. In other words, that person
- 21:06is somewhere. probably in their own country or
- 21:09another friendly country, and they can't get
- 21:13out. And on that one, I suspect there's no way
- 21:17to change that. Yeah, that's very complex. It
- 21:22is complex. It is complex. A week ago in Davos,
- 21:28I think that it was the Economic World Forum,
- 21:32Trump launched the Board of Peace. All the Board
- 21:37of Peace. Yes. A new initiative originally linked
- 21:41to gas reconstruction, new pitch as a broader
- 21:46peace mechanism that actually has a high fee.
- 21:50Yeah. I did take a few notes. The Board of Peace
- 21:55is a U .S.-led organization established by Trump.
- 21:57He's the chairman. OK. With the stated purpose
- 22:00of peacekeeping around the world and particular
- 22:03in. overseeing the process in Gaza. He sent out
- 22:11invitations to others to join the Board of Peace.
- 22:14So far, not a large number of takers. There are
- 22:18some takers, including one... I think it might
- 22:23have been... Including Israel. Netanyahu. Accepted.
- 22:28Yeah, yeah. He's accepted. And a couple of others
- 22:34have. What is it? The current right -wing president
- 22:36of Argentina, I think. Yeah, Millet. I think
- 22:39he has accepted. And there are a few others.
- 22:43We haven't heard anything from the UK. We haven't
- 22:48heard anything from France. We haven't heard
- 22:50anything from Canada. Australia has been offered
- 22:55a spot, and our current prime minister hasn't
- 22:58accepted that spot yet. So we'll see about the
- 23:01Board of Peace. It seems to me I saw a video
- 23:08the other day, and the video showed Trump's son
- 23:16-in -law, Kushner, standing in front of a...
- 23:20a projected view of what Gaza would look like
- 23:24in the future. And it was all of these fantastic,
- 23:26almost science fiction -like high -rise buildings.
- 23:30Without the Palestinians. Yeah, yeah. I didn't
- 23:34see any Palestinians in the picture. I think
- 23:36the Palestinians had all been saying, can you
- 23:39guys move to Egypt or something like that? But
- 23:43no, there wasn't. Look, the border piece is just
- 23:45another mechanism for Rumpi and his family to
- 23:48make a few bucks. A lot of bucks, in fact. Yeah,
- 23:51because he has a high fee to join. Yeah, I think
- 23:54it was, I mean, I think this projected plan for
- 23:57rebuilding Gaza was something like $50 billion.
- 24:00You know, it's a lot of money, a lot of money.
- 24:03This is not like compared to the United Nations
- 24:07terms of legitimacy and authority. Yeah. I mean,
- 24:13it's not going to replace the U .N. And interestingly
- 24:15enough, the Security Council actually passed
- 24:18a resolution welcoming the Board of Peace. But
- 24:21I think the understanding of the Board of Peace
- 24:23was that the Board of Peace would be specific
- 24:25to Gaza without getting it involved in any of
- 24:33the other conflicts, particularly, for example,
- 24:36the conflict between Russia and the Ukraine.
- 24:40This is not undermining more the UN and also,
- 24:45well, the ICC, because Netanyahu was the ICC.
- 24:53Yeah, well, yeah, he's got, Netanyahu's got five
- 24:56indictments. I think three for crimes against
- 25:01humanity and two for war crimes or vice versa.
- 25:04I can't remember which way it went. Putin's got
- 25:08two. And like I said, they're not traveling.
- 25:11You don't see Putin traveling outside. He goes
- 25:13to China. He can go to North Korea if he wants
- 25:15to. He can come to the U .S. and talk to his
- 25:18buddy Don. But that's about the only place he
- 25:21can go. And you don't see Netanyahu traveling
- 25:24outside of the U .S. either. It's just not happening.
- 25:33It will dissolve at some point in time. I don't
- 25:36understand why the Security Council went ahead
- 25:38and sort of endorsed it unless they were just
- 25:39thinking, oh, limited. Yeah, let's rebuild Gaza.
- 25:42Let's use this Board of Peace thing. And Trump
- 25:45is the chairman of this thing. And it looks like
- 25:47a company. And the next thing you know, they're
- 25:48going to make billions of dollars, billions of
- 25:51dollars out of trying to rebuild Gaza. The indictments
- 25:55against Putin are a number of years old. Even
- 25:57the indictments against Netanyahu are a number
- 26:00of years old. And I think the court, the ICC,
- 26:03has just given up because you could indict Netanyahu
- 26:06almost every day for a war crime. It's just a
- 26:10series of war crimes, one after another, after
- 26:12another, after another. Yesterday's or the day
- 26:15before, I think yesterday's, was an attack on
- 26:18a civilian bus that was taking 20 miners to a
- 26:22mine. Why blow up a bus that's taking 20 miners
- 26:25to a mine? You know, at least 70 ,000 dead there,
- 26:30almost a third of them children, more than 20
- 26:33,000 kids. And it's just, you know, one war crime
- 26:37after another is just incredible. And the Ukraine's
- 26:43almost as bad, almost as bad. The targeting of
- 26:47civilian installations, civilian buildings, apartment
- 26:49buildings, power stations, all of that stuff.
- 26:52uh is is a war crime and the icc i think well
- 26:56we've got two indictments here we got five over
- 26:59here there's not much more we can do you know
- 27:01i mean we could sit around and indict these people
- 27:03every other day how needs to enforce or change
- 27:08it because this is nothing is happening and changing
- 27:12they are doing whatever they want and the idea
- 27:15is like a that nobody pronouns or they European
- 27:20Union doesn't say anything nobody keep it very
- 27:24quiet they don't make like a remarks or they
- 27:28don't do any remarks directly to what is happening
- 27:31they just completely change it's like oh just
- 27:34not the news anymore but actually this is continuing
- 27:38escalating so and and then together with this
- 27:44like a continue with this These countries that
- 27:48already reject or haven't signed the border peace.
- 27:52Do you think that is a sign of dividing the global
- 27:55community about how peace should be pursued and
- 27:58how it gets lead that conversation? Do you think
- 28:01that this is more about how actually the things
- 28:04had to be done, like undermining what is the
- 28:07efforts that have been done? Do you think that
- 28:10it's necessary to change things to work? properly
- 28:15because the UN and the ICC don't have the tools
- 28:20to actually. Well, they have the tools. They
- 28:23just can't use them. And like I said, I mean,
- 28:28we've talked about the Security Council veto.
- 28:31That's got to go. That's the most important thing
- 28:35that the international community could do is
- 28:37pressure those permanent members to give up that
- 28:39veto and change that. for a supermajority. In
- 28:45terms of the ICC, interestingly enough, in my
- 28:49view, I think that both Trump and Hegsbeth, the
- 28:54Secretary of Defense, and probably the admiral
- 28:58that launched that attack on a ship that had
- 29:02already been sunk, basically, and there were
- 29:04a couple of folks hanging on to what was... you
- 29:08know, rubbish in the sea. And then he went ahead
- 29:11and bombed them again. Look, that's a clear violation
- 29:14of the Geneva Conventions on the rules of war.
- 29:17You don't do that. You're supposed to rescue
- 29:19people, whether they're on land or at sea. But
- 29:23look, you might include the Secretary of State,
- 29:29although his... relationship to all of this stuff
- 29:32is less direct than Trump through the Secretary
- 29:34of Defense or Secretary of War, as he's calling
- 29:37him now. But I would, if I was the ICC, I'd indict
- 29:41them, both of them, for their attacks on Venezuela.
- 29:47And then, okay, with that indictment, then Trump
- 29:52can't travel and Hagsbeth can't travel in any
- 29:57country that is a member. of the ICC, because
- 30:00then they're obliged to arrest him and put him
- 30:02away or send him off to the Hague. So that's
- 30:05all of Western Europe. And then most of South
- 30:10America, certainly all of North America, you
- 30:16know, couldn't travel and talk to the president
- 30:18of Mexico, for example. So most of the world
- 30:20would be off limits. And that would seriously
- 30:24confine his ability to go. You know, for example,
- 30:27he was just at the World Forum, the Davos World
- 30:29Forum. He couldn't have gone to the Davos World
- 30:31Forum because that country would have been required
- 30:35to arrest him and turn him over to the Hague.
- 30:37So I'd go ahead and indict him and, you know,
- 30:40put the pressure on. Yeah. And and recently I
- 30:44was reading that actually Trump and his administration
- 30:48were trying to impose like a. pressure over the
- 30:53ICC to avoid this indictment. Yeah. So how? So
- 30:59how is possible that he has to say it is not
- 31:04even part of that? He doesn't have to be part
- 31:06of the ICC for an indictment to occur. If he
- 31:09is not part of that and to be indicted, but he
- 31:13why he can bully the ICC or threaten. If they
- 31:18threaten them, if they impose sanctions over
- 31:22the country or Trump. I don't think that's actually
- 31:27I don't think that's particularly problematic.
- 31:30I don't think Iran is a member of the ICC. I'd
- 31:35have to go back and check. Venezuela is, though.
- 31:37So, you know, you've got one country that that's
- 31:40a member, one country that's not a member. You
- 31:42don't need both countries to be a member. Because
- 31:45the attack occurred in Venezuela, the indictment
- 31:49could go forward. And I think it probably should.
- 31:53And like I say, that would limit the capacity
- 31:56of these people to travel most places around
- 32:00the world. That's very insightful. I don't think
- 32:04that everyone knows about that. You know, I don't
- 32:08think anybody's thinking about it. And again,
- 32:12I don't know what would happen if the ICC indicted
- 32:15the U .S. Secretary of Defense or indicted the
- 32:18U .S. President. I think it'd be a good thing
- 32:20for all of us if they did. Yeah, that's true.
- 32:24I'm changing a little bit, but not much of the
- 32:27topic. How these treaties, environmental treaties.
- 32:31How does this get affected with everything that
- 32:36is happening in this moment? Because, for example,
- 32:39Trump removed the U .S. from the Paris Agreement
- 32:44of climate change. For him, that doesn't exist.
- 32:47And then he did it again. Yes, he did. Twice,
- 32:52yeah. But they can rejoin again. Yes. But then
- 32:58he's also tried to ease. the law related to Environmental
- 33:04Protection Act in his own country and also trying
- 33:09to breach other laws that are already imposed.
- 33:14How this is affecting not only U .S., but other
- 33:19countries. I mean, I haven't seen it. I don't
- 33:22really think any other country. I mean, they
- 33:25care, particularly about climate change. I mean,
- 33:28the two biggest climate change polluters are
- 33:31the U .S. and China. And that's significant.
- 33:36And so if the U .S. is able to, and China's to
- 33:39some extent trying to move forward and into alternative
- 33:43energy sources. Interestingly, I mean, the U
- 33:47.S. is actually making progress in that area
- 33:49because states like California and other Pacific
- 33:52Coast states, some East Coast states, Massachusetts,
- 33:56Pennsylvania, et cetera, are doing their own.
- 34:01I mean, California is rapidly becoming almost
- 34:04a net zero state in terms of energy use, which
- 34:10is good. But we do need those two largest polluters.
- 34:14And the EU is moving ahead very, very rapidly
- 34:17as well. Trains that run on solar energy, for
- 34:23goodness sake. They're burning trash for power.
- 34:27They're recycling tires for pavement instead
- 34:31of using asphalt. And they're getting rid of
- 34:34the tires by putting them down as pavers as opposed
- 34:39to putting them in a landfill or trying to burn
- 34:42them up. So the EU is fantastic. It's moving.
- 34:46pretty dramatically. Australia is not doing too
- 34:49bad. That's low transition, I could say. Yeah,
- 34:52but it's not doing too bad. But as a polluter,
- 34:57Australia is 1 % of global greenhouse gas emissions.
- 35:03Even if you throw in the coal that Australia
- 35:06produces and sends to other countries, you're
- 35:08talking 3 .5 % to 4%. So I suppose if Australia
- 35:12stopped mining coal, then those other countries
- 35:16wouldn't be able to burn coal. I don't know what
- 35:18they'd do for power, but they'd have to do something.
- 35:21But the other thing to remember across the whole
- 35:24number of issues that we're looking at, the current
- 35:27administration in the U .S. is temporary. It's
- 35:31temporary. And it's probably more temporary than
- 35:35just the end of a four -year presidential term.
- 35:39Everything indicates that the midterm elections
- 35:41coming next November are going to put a Democratic
- 35:45majority in both houses of Congress. Everything,
- 35:49everything leans that way. And, you know, and
- 35:53then in many respects, the president is stymied.
- 35:58And in fact, I mean, the whole system could just
- 36:00go nuts. because nothing might get done. You
- 36:04could have Congress passing legislation and the
- 36:07president refusing to sign it, and then it would
- 36:09come back to Congress, and unless you got your
- 36:11two -thirds veto -proof majority, then you get
- 36:16no legislation. So it could be a giant stalemate
- 36:20in two years. Lord knows what will happen in
- 36:22four or three when we have the next election.
- 36:26What would you recommend people with all this
- 36:29news, all this panic, all this misinformation?
- 36:32What would you recommend to people to read besides
- 36:36the critical thinking? Where should they look
- 36:40for information? Information. Well, you need,
- 36:44that's a tough one. Hopefully people out there
- 36:46can look and see us and know that we're not AI.
- 36:50People, if you're watching, I am not an AI. I
- 36:53don't like AI. I refuse to use AI. I conscientiously
- 36:57object to AI. But you've got to be careful. I
- 37:00think you have to go to your most reputable sources
- 37:03for information. You know, if you're interested
- 37:07in international law, go to the UN site. It's
- 37:10pretty good. in terms of providing, you know,
- 37:14direct and clear information. And, you know,
- 37:18and you've got some really outstanding news organizations
- 37:21out there. SBS is excellent. In the U .S., the
- 37:25public broadcasting system is excellent. And
- 37:27in fact, it's so good that the Trump administration
- 37:30is pulling federal funding out of the public
- 37:33broadcast system. That's how good they are. But
- 37:37look, they'll survive. And they'll do well because
- 37:42the public supports the PBS system. You've just
- 37:46got to find reputable sources for your information.
- 37:48I'm going to put some resources. Yeah. You sort
- 37:53of got to jump around, too. I mean, I'll show
- 37:56you. We've got SBS. They're very good. And we
- 37:59even get Al Jazeera. And despite it being Al
- 38:02Jazeera, they're actually pretty good. They're
- 38:05thorough. Do they have a bias? Yeah, they probably
- 38:07have a bias. I think all of them have bias. Yeah.
- 38:11But the reporting is at least thorough and largely
- 38:17factual. Largely factual. And I think that's
- 38:21where you go. Yes. And also, to finalize, what
- 38:26gives you hope that diplomacy, justice, or shared
- 38:30humanity can prevail? What gives you hope with
- 38:34SOAP? with everything that is happening. Well,
- 38:37I actually think, despite all the stuff that's
- 38:40going on, there are actually some hopeful signs.
- 38:44You know, I mean, both Canada and the UK have
- 38:47gone off to China to develop new relationships
- 38:49with China. Now, the UK's adventures in China
- 38:53are not nearly. nearly as significant as China's.
- 38:58China and Canada are becoming reasonable economic
- 39:04partners. And there's some stuff that Canada
- 39:07is just turning away from the U .S. and saying,
- 39:08we can do that in China. We can do it with Chinese
- 39:12products. By all means, we don't need U .S. cars.
- 39:15China, please send us some cars and some of those
- 39:18lovely SUVs that you're making. And I think that's
- 39:24a good sign. Despite the fact that the EU has
- 39:28not really committed a lot of, not prepared to
- 39:31commit troops at this point in time to Ukraine,
- 39:34it probably should, and just, you know, severely
- 39:37push back. They're at least committed to commit
- 39:42security forces once some form of peace agreement
- 39:46is set. But the other thing that the EU has done
- 39:50is say, oh, look, sorry, U .S., you're not coming
- 39:54to Greenland. No way are you coming to Greenland.
- 39:58And in addition to just saying, you know, you're
- 40:02not coming to Greenland, the U .K., Germany,
- 40:06France, Norway, and I think one other country
- 40:10have already sent. military of one sort or another
- 40:14to Greenland to assist in any sort of defense
- 40:17of Greenland. Germany, I think, sent two naval
- 40:20vessels. So that response is pretty critical.
- 40:24And it says, say, look, Denmark is NATO, and
- 40:29you don't mess around with NATO. And I think
- 40:31the pushback, even the pushback from the Republican
- 40:35Party, particularly in the Senate, uh has said
- 40:40sorry dude get your hands off of nato and quit
- 40:45messing around with you know what has been our
- 40:48essential line of defense for the last you know
- 40:5180 years so i think there i think there are good
- 40:54signs out there uh you know on a daily basis
- 40:57that doesn't mean that he can't do something
- 40:59stupid um and that has an impact on all of us
- 41:04i wouldn't go hopeful um i i'd like To hope I
- 41:08could be hopeful. That's true. Let's see what
- 41:13happens. Yes, we will. We will. Indeed. Thank
- 41:17you very much, Gary. It's been my pleasure again.
- 41:20I always enjoy this. Thank you. Yes, that's fantastic.
- 41:24Thank you for everything and for sharing your
- 41:27knowledge and updating people.