Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Path of Enlightenment - Stage Three - Part 1
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the meditation and attachment
- 0:03podcast with George Hoss. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medicare.gov org.
- 0:11That's www.mit.edu r0. U p dot org.
- 0:19So, welcome everybody, this is meditation and attachment.
- 0:22Deepening your practice. It is June 24th, 2021 and 7:36
- 0:29p.m. Pacific Daylight time.
- 0:32And we're going to be working with the third stage of the
- 0:38progress of inside. But I thought that if anybody
- 0:41had any questions, I would start there.
- 0:48Nope. Well, I always just try and
- 0:52connect it to the attachment work if you're just going
- 0:56straight for the Insight teaching.
- 0:58Today, I just like to ask that you connected to the attachment
- 1:03work somehow because that's been the main focus for me.
- 1:05So, if I get to put in my two cents, all right about Well, the
- 1:15third stage is knowledge of comprehension.
- 1:18And usually what we talked about there is comprehension of not
- 1:22self comprehension of impermanence and comprehension
- 1:26of Suffering, I guess suffering is one of the views.
- 1:33One of the ways it's translated. I often think of that as
- 1:42unsatisfactoriness, or Reactivity shins and used to
- 1:53translate it as reactivity. Sorry as unsatisfactoriness.
- 2:02And Dan, Brown tends to translated as reactivity.
- 2:07Dan's point of view is even if you resolve all of the
- 2:10conditions that create suffering experienced, you're in a body
- 2:15that still is going to react shins ends.
- 2:20You is that the the nature of The Human Condition itself is
- 2:23unsatisfying or unsatisfactory, mainly that you grow old, you
- 2:28get sick and you die. And there's nothing much you can
- 2:30do about that. The second level of course is
- 2:33the sometimes you get what you want because but because
- 2:37everything is impermanent, you lose it.
- 2:41Christian. I'm curious if when I hear the
- 2:45reactivity I hear and I take an implication of that.
- 2:51It's it's pointing to the sort of like my reactions to things
- 2:57are automatic on that if I were to step back, From my automatic
- 3:03to reaction to any particular thing, then I could kind of do
- 3:07something thoughtfully without without just reacting to it.
- 3:11But I'm not sure if I'm reading into that quite a bit or if it's
- 3:16sort of a different trip to attack.
- 3:18No, he doesn't mean that at all. It's just basically that you
- 3:23have these sense responses to objects, and if they're if even
- 3:28if you work through all of the conditioning, that would cause
- 3:31Suffering to arise. If a light, Photon hits the
- 3:36retina. There's a reaction of sensing if
- 3:41sound wave hits the eardrum. There's a reaction of hearing,
- 3:48even if there's no ear-consciousness or I
- 3:51Consciousness. There's still the sensing
- 3:56activity itself, okay? I think that it lets go ahead.
- 4:06So I read just establishing the idea that the nature of the six
- 4:12cent spaces is suffering. No, not necessarily the the
- 4:21activity of clinging to the sense Gates would be the origin
- 4:28of suffering. Is that how you think about it?
- 4:31Why was just asking to see how you how you think about it?
- 4:36Because I would consider that craving and clinging is its
- 4:40present in every moment of sense Consciousness for an enlightened
- 4:44people, correct? So that suffering is no, I know.
- 4:50But what that is saying is even if you work through all of that,
- 4:53so that there is no craving a version or unconsciousness in
- 4:57response to the sensing The sensing activity, still happens,
- 5:04right? Right.
- 5:06So that would be considered as suffering.
- 5:10I mean it has a characteristic of suffering.
- 5:12Doesn't it only? If you cling?
- 5:15Only if you are aversive only if you go unconscious.
- 5:20Okay. Not necessarily my formulation
- 5:25just by understanding of how it's been formulated.
- 5:31I think at that State, of course you wouldn't fixate anything.
- 5:34So there would be no say I Consciousness there just be I
- 5:41sensing or ears sensing Here. Activation right?
- 5:56Did you want to say something Harley?
- 6:02No, I'm good. Thank you.
- 6:11There we go. That broke the robotic sound,
- 6:15was it me but no. Sorry, I was unmuted.
- 6:18My apologies George. So, one of the things about the
- 6:30progress of inside is that you begin at the beginning, you, you
- 6:35identify in the first stage, the difference between mental and
- 6:42physical phenomena. And in the second stage really
- 6:46conditionality, you understand that this moment leads into the
- 6:49next the previous moment led into this that you don't have to
- 6:54catch everything that you can infer based on a complete
- 7:01experience of one type of sensing experience that all
- 7:05types of sensing experience like that will unfold in a similar
- 7:09way. And then you move into this
- 7:12initial exploration of the three characteristics of the three
- 7:17marks of existence, Anita Notch and Duke, Anita is not self.
- 7:25Did I say not to or Nietzsche. And not is not self, and Nitra
- 7:30is impermanence, and dukkha is suffering or unsatisfactoriness,
- 7:35who are reactivity. It is really in this stage, a
- 7:49initial investigation. You really don't get to the Deep
- 7:52dive into this until the sixth seventh and eighth.
- 7:56And then also in the 10th where you really begin to deeply
- 8:00integrate, this understanding of the nature of things into the
- 8:06into the perception of self and world.
- 8:12I often talk about the Katrin stuff to touch on Jake's
- 8:18suggestion as the preliminary practices, in order to get into
- 8:22this stuff. Because if you don't have a
- 8:29foundation that you can safely explore from to begin to touch
- 8:36into these experiences, can be disorienting, and painful and
- 8:42that prevents you from going too much.
- 8:44Further into it, the habit of practice in the west is to come
- 8:51because your suffering has been on addressable and other
- 8:57modalities and turning toward meditation on one end.
- 9:03This is, if you look at a bell curve of people who come to
- 9:07practice on one end, it's people don't function very well, have a
- 9:11lot of distress and being alive. And are looking for ways to come
- 9:16out of it. And on the other end of the bell
- 9:18curve are people that function really well and still find that
- 9:23achieving all of the stuff that they find achievable doesn't
- 9:27provide a sense of meaningfulness in being here.
- 9:34this ties in, of course, to these basic attachment concepts
- 9:38of attachment exploration, and then, the collaboration system,
- 9:46In order to really explore deeply, you need to have a base
- 9:52in the attachment literature. It's called a secure base or
- 9:56John Bowlby, used to used it as a, his phrase was a secure base
- 10:02from which to explore from, but most people don't have a secure
- 10:05base to explore from. They just have a base but they
- 10:10try to touch it to depending on how it went for you.
- 10:15When you were a kid, A kid. One of the things that you learn
- 10:21in the secure attachment system is that the things that the the
- 10:28qualities that you have the interests that you have are
- 10:33valuable and important and worth pursuing and that you have
- 10:37caregivers that recognize those capabilities that you have in
- 10:43those interests that you have. And that's what they encourage
- 10:47you to begin. In to explore and to begin to
- 10:50develop. and so from the very earliest of your conscious
- 11:01awake, you know, your conscious experience, your
- 11:03autobiographical memory of what happens, you're pursuing that
- 11:11combination things that you're good at and things that are
- 11:13interesting to and things that you derive, meaning from And so
- 11:18that becomes the the nature of your understanding of what what
- 11:22life is really about and you develop the skills that you need
- 11:26in order to be able to do that. And we would call that a primary
- 11:30exploration. The reason that you're pursuing
- 11:33it is because you derive meaning from doing it. and you have the
- 11:40support that you needed part of that is the returning to your
- 11:45secure base and sharing what it is, that you've discovered and
- 11:50being delighted in and having an interest in what you found out
- 11:54and the sense of your view, your your understanding, your ideas
- 12:02about things being valued and the constant sense of support
- 12:07and encouragement, To go do more and so you, you go out and you
- 12:12explore and then you come back and you share your exploration.
- 12:16It's valuable. And then you go out and you
- 12:19explore, then you come back and the that's the natural flow of
- 12:27life. So the attachment mechanism goes
- 12:32off, you seek proximity to your secure base, your secure base
- 12:36helps. You emotionally regulate their
- 12:39they're interested in what your exploring that activates the
- 12:42exploring mechanism and you go back out into the world.
- 12:49And you develop this sense of self, which is based on those
- 12:52kinds of things, the sense of self arises based on the
- 12:57conditions in the present moment.
- 12:59So and we have a working model of gists, these little sort of
- 13:08algorithms of that are activated, that generate sensing
- 13:14experiences in the body mind and depending on the pattern of that
- 13:19we recognized and identified that as the experience of self.
- 13:24And so if you have a positive model of the sense of self, when
- 13:27the experience of self arises, it's a pleasant experience.
- 13:31Are you and you have a sense of value in that news, have a sense
- 13:35of enjoyment in the experience of self.
- 13:38You have a strategies for emotionally regulating the
- 13:42experience of self that are positive and beneficial.
- 13:47But that isn't the the nature of the self experience for
- 13:51everybody as it arises. Depending on that process.
- 13:59Did you have a question? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 14:01So I mean, I just want to iterate on that a little bit,
- 14:04so, I mean, it kind of makes sense.
- 14:06Then that people within - sense of self would feel that, it's
- 14:11something that they should annihilate or is something that
- 14:13they should destroy or that their ego is wrong or bad.
- 14:17I mean, I just wonder if you must see that a lot in the, in
- 14:21the Buddhist world that I was just looking for some kind of
- 14:24confirmation about that topic. You know, the link the linkage
- 14:29between self-esteem or negative self esteem and the desire for
- 14:33annihilation and how that could get acted out through, you know,
- 14:37believing in not self. For instance, well, it's it
- 14:41might be just that simple aversion to pain, a painful
- 14:46experience, not so much. This kind of advanced concept of
- 14:53the annihilation of self, but each time the sense of self
- 14:56arises. It's an unpleasant experience.
- 14:59It's that you then become aversive to and then you begin
- 15:02to look for strategies that relieve you from having to have
- 15:05that experience over and over again.
- 15:08And then if you pull yourself in the direction of practices where
- 15:13the self experience gets weaker and weaker.
- 15:15In some sense, the advanced, the advantage that you're
- 15:19experiencing is less and less pain.
- 15:22And if you can get really good at certainly in the terror Vada,
- 15:29Practices having these no self experiences than there really is
- 15:35very little pain in those experiences.
- 15:38And so you have the positive reinforcement of the absence of
- 15:41pain and when the sense of self activates strongly, you have a
- 15:46strong experience of pain and would suggest not the most
- 15:52Equanimity with the experience of the sense of self rising.
- 15:56But even without that capacity and skill and meditation to get
- 16:02that to happen. People who build a working model
- 16:05of self and contains a lot of negative experiences.
- 16:12They become quite aversive to the experience of self.
- 16:15They can't get out of it but they become aversive to it which
- 16:20I think is the origin of self-hatred.
- 16:23The experience of self arises, it's very painful and then you
- 16:27just hate it. When you begin to pay attention
- 16:32to the nature of self and the arising of self, it's constantly
- 16:37arising based on the conditions of the present moment, most of
- 16:41which you have no control over. So you may also find that the
- 16:46tendency is to want to withdraw from the world to withdraw from
- 16:50stimulation. So that you have more sense of
- 16:53control in when the selfing experience arises.
- 16:58Right? But the conditioning around the
- 17:01the experience of self arising really does come from that early
- 17:05experience of the exchange with the caregiver.
- 17:09I was doing some ideal parent figure work myself in the last
- 17:14few days. And what I was noticing that was
- 17:17so interesting about where, the practices for me now is that
- 17:21when I imagine myself as a young child, I see myself is this
- 17:28delightful beautiful energetic, curious little boy, And then I
- 17:36see the way that my bio parents reacted to that and it's
- 17:41troubling and puzzling that they dislike that so much and that
- 17:47they were so punitive in getting me to be different than the way
- 17:51that I was when I when I look at myself and then the memories and
- 17:56that I have of myself, I really like that that that little boy.
- 18:06And his way of being in the world.
- 18:10And so that's this, this process of shifting into really
- 18:17repairing the, the were helping to change those negative, the
- 18:26negative input from the caregivers themselves.
- 18:33I don't know. And I really do recommend that
- 18:38you not try to figure this out because then you just get
- 18:41involved in the mind states of the caregivers.
- 18:43But why are they would react to this kid who was just sort of
- 18:47curious and exploring and light and funny?
- 18:56In the way that they did is a mystery, really in a sense, but
- 19:01it but it was extreme. My mother was extremely correct.
- 19:05Active in terms of how I presented myself.
- 19:10And so what, of course happens that it's that you begin to
- 19:14associate those natural expressions of self, and those
- 19:18natural interests that you have with something negative and you
- 19:22begin to attempt to suppress them so that you don't get the
- 19:26negative feedback from the caregivers.
- 19:29But if that is actually the core of the essential nature of what
- 19:33interests you, and what has meaning.
- 19:35To you, then you're being instructed and out of your
- 19:39primary exploration into a secondary exploration, which is
- 19:45pursuing things that get you a response from the caregivers
- 19:51that it's easier to be with if that makes sense.
- 19:54So, you direct yourself away from the things that are of
- 19:59primary importance to toward the things that are of primary
- 20:04importance. The caregivers that you have so
- 20:08that you can get their care and that you can survive from that
- 20:12and it can be such a harsh treatment that you lose track of
- 20:18the things that are essential the things that really motivated
- 20:24and and had meaning to you and pursue the secondary exploration
- 20:29of what was meaningful to them, that would shift you out of the
- 20:34secure functioning Place into a dismissing functioning place,
- 20:38you have to shut down and suppress the, the natural
- 20:41experience of yourself and become.
- 20:46Something else, so that your caregivers will respond to you.
- 20:53Often in those situations. There's a kind of pressure to be
- 21:03autonomous way way too early so that you become independent or
- 21:10independent requiring. Their care is really what it's
- 21:14about, but at the same time acknowledging in a way that's
- 21:19meaningful to them, that they're good at taking care of you, that
- 21:24kind of conundrum really causes suppression of your of the The
- 21:29vitalist of your emotional life because you can't hold the
- 21:33contradiction. In, in order to become
- 21:41preoccupied, of course, what ends up happening is that the
- 21:45experience of being separated from the child is unbearable to
- 21:51the caregiver. And so they, they restrict the
- 21:54exploration of the child, and what happens there, of course,
- 22:00is the same loss of attention to the primary sense of
- 22:06exploration. Mainly because the child is
- 22:12prevented from developing the capacity to explore.
- 22:16So they don't have the experience of deciding what's
- 22:19meaningful and what is it, meaningful.
- 22:20They're just prevented from doing it.
- 22:25Both of these create these absences of thought processes
- 22:30that make up that model of the self, when it activates, if what
- 22:35ends up happening for preoccupied, person is when the
- 22:40sense of self arises, none of that working model of the sense
- 22:45of self includes an understanding of how to explore.
- 22:51And so that doesn't arise in the mind in the same way that a
- 22:54child, that's encouraged to be autonomous to early, doesn't
- 23:01figure out how to collaborate. So, in that original description
- 23:05that I gave you, the child goes out, and is encouraged and
- 23:09supported to explore, and then they come back and they share
- 23:13the Explorer ation and then they're encouraged and supported
- 23:16to explore more. And that's the beginning of this
- 23:19collaborative. Model disagree, Change.
- 23:22But dismissing people don't have that.
- 23:25So you have these three mechanisms the attachment
- 23:28mechanism, the exploration mechanism in the collaboration
- 23:32mehcad method mechanism in Secure people, all three of them
- 23:38function really well in an insecure.
- 23:40People often the collaborative system is shut down because it
- 23:45wasn't developed The sense of self arises and then it's
- 23:56reflected back to you from the from your caregiver and
- 24:02evaluated, and you take in that, that experience of it and you
- 24:07build it up as working model. In dismissing adults.
- 24:16They tend to be very good at exploring but it's almost always
- 24:20secondary exploration and they don't have a sense really of,
- 24:23what would be meaningful to them.
- 24:25And they find that they're able to get these secondary goals but
- 24:28they don't really resonate that much.
- 24:31They don't feel anything because the main way that they regulate
- 24:35their emotion is by not feeling so that when the sense of self
- 24:38arises it's incomplete. In that sense and they tend to
- 24:44be idealizing so that they tend to inflate value.
- 24:49So that you have a sense of self that's very distorted from what
- 24:53actually is there. One of the things about this
- 24:58process of exploration, particularly through meditation
- 25:01is to contemplate the nature of self as a rising based on these
- 25:08working models. And to see that, if you, if you
- 25:11can move yourself toward a experience of self that arises
- 25:16that's actually reflective of what your capacities are, your
- 25:20interests are and that also is infused with enough positivity.
- 25:25So that the experience of it arising is peasant.
- 25:29You do come in Tech when dimity and you do come into this
- 25:33knowledge. That it is a temporary sensing
- 25:37experience that arise is based on conditioning, but the freedom
- 25:44comes from being able to move in and out of it out of the, that
- 25:48particular moment of self rising into the next moment without
- 25:54clinging, or holding onto the or gripping onto the nature of Self
- 25:59being permanent that touches into that, contemplation of
- 26:04everything is impermanent from the individual sensing
- 26:08experience to the thing that you make out of those individual
- 26:14sensing experiences that all making sense.
- 26:22One of the reasons I like to talk about attachment so much is
- 26:25because it describes that experienced in quite a bit of
- 26:29detail and it's and the descriptions of those views help
- 26:36to decode the moment by moment experience of it so that you can
- 26:40see the modeling of it as distinct from the, the activity
- 26:47of sensing that creates it and in that way gain the in Insight
- 26:52into the nature of it, being ephemeral and temporary.
- 27:01You know, and traditions vary the to the Tibetan ideas, not to
- 27:07come into a hard, no soul State, and it is to really identify
- 27:12mainly with awareness and make that, quite expansive, or than
- 27:15allow all of these sensing experiences to come and go.
- 27:19You beat, you identify with the sky and then the clouds of
- 27:23experience. Roll through, Dan says that, in
- 27:28different studies, they've done of advanced Practitioners that
- 27:33depending on the practice you do different parts of the brain
- 27:37become active or deactivated. And that in the Tera vaada
- 27:41practices, particularly around a strong sense of no self that the
- 27:45ACC shuts down. And so you don't have a self
- 27:49experience in that can be quite depersonalizing, whereas in the
- 27:53Tibetan practices, it shifts from the the local part of the
- 28:00prefrontal cortex. Text to the parietal lobe which
- 28:03is more Global in terms of how it perceives things.
- 28:07And so the that we come again to this idea of the type of
- 28:14practice you do tends to lead to the type of insight that you
- 28:18have and so what is it that your understanding to be the
- 28:26exploration of your practice or the, I know that we're not
- 28:32supposed to have goals in practice or at least when I came
- 28:35to practice early on them. They were said, we're not
- 28:39supposed to have goals for our practice, so we would call it
- 28:42the non goal of our practice, as a way of getting around that.
- 28:46But, you know, in the west were very oriented toward goals and
- 28:51so making goals in terms of practice, actually can move you
- 28:55forward. It's just in that moment of the,
- 29:00in the Tera vaada practice of trying to come into those
- 29:04profound cessation experiences that in that moment before when
- 29:09you need to be without goals, you're not clinging to the goals
- 29:13that you establish so that you can just let go of them and My
- 29:18one-time likened, it to standing at the edge of a pool and just
- 29:24letting go of all tension and falling into the pool and shins
- 29:29and said for him, the experience was more like you're standing at
- 29:32the edge of the pool and then the pool Rises up and surrounds
- 29:37you. So, however, you want to think
- 29:40about it, are you coming to that place?
- 29:45I have a sense that something big could happen.
- 29:47In the sense that it's going to happen and then you come out of
- 29:51it and the sense of self reassembles.
- 29:58And you have that direct experience of none of the
- 30:03conditioning, or any of its meanings are interfering with
- 30:10the expression of just the liveliness of being and then of
- 30:17course, it all comes back on and you see that it in the
- 30:20limitations of it in it and understand that that has some
- 30:27limiting beliefs and then that because you have the direct
- 30:31experience of knowing the the way of being without that there
- 30:37and then it attaching Mainly fuels the the goal of being able
- 30:45to have agency in moving back and forth between them.
- 30:56One of the practices that I recommend in working with the
- 31:01experience of self is loving, kindness, practice or
- 31:05compassion, practice or sympathetic, Joy, practice
- 31:08Equanimity that all of those from the Brahma of a whore, has
- 31:13particularly focused on the expression of self so that you
- 31:18can begin to infuse into the working model that you currently
- 31:22have of the self experience. Very Positive experiences.
- 31:27So over and over again. You're in, you're generating
- 31:33these positive states. That intentionally generating,
- 31:36the experience of self. So that when you go through the
- 31:39process of remembering that and these gists, he's working models
- 31:44of that, experience are created and associated with this, help
- 31:48each time as you move into the future.
- 31:54When the sense of self is Rated those new intentionally positive
- 31:59experiences are associated with the sense of self.
- 32:03And if you do that, practice consistently enough, that
- 32:09positivity that's been associated with the experience
- 32:14of self, becomes the dominant experience of self and the
- 32:18condition negativity. Particularly if it comes from
- 32:23the early attachment relationships become Secondary.
- 32:27And so then the sense of self arises and it's a pleasant sense
- 32:31of self. It's enjoyable in the sense of
- 32:34self Rises. And then that aversive reaction
- 32:37is overcome, of course, we have to be careful to hold have
- 32:42Equanimity with it so that the craving a version of the
- 32:46clinging of version doesn't overtake, the reverse of
- 32:51experience of it. Christian. you noticed in
- 32:57working with people with different types and patterns and
- 33:00he kind of correlation or sense that people with different
- 33:05attachment patterns have a weaker or stronger sense of
- 33:09self, whether that be positive or negative, then then other
- 33:12patterns, I do I think that if you look at Attachment the
- 33:21attachment system attachment, which of course, activates and
- 33:26deactivates, the explosion system drives, you back to
- 33:29somebody who will protect you, when that turns off the
- 33:34exploration system turns on and then you can go explore, and
- 33:37then you have the collaboration system.
- 33:40In Secure people that all works really well and so when the
- 33:48sense of self arises, you have this vital alive, Lively sense
- 33:55of self and dismissing people. The attachment system is shut
- 34:00off and the exploration system is on and the collaboration
- 34:05system is off. and so, the sense of self that arises for them is
- 34:10quite rigid. It's a very rigid sense of self.
- 34:19It's a very grandiose sense of self.
- 34:22It's very fragile and preoccupied people, the
- 34:29attachment system is hyperactivated, the exploration
- 34:32system is deactivated and the collaboration system is off.
- 34:38And so they tend to have much less strong sense of self
- 34:43because they're so oriented toward Ding to be what the
- 34:49person they're interested in ones.
- 34:52So they're very active in interpreting what they need to
- 34:56be teleologically and then attempting to present that.
- 35:00So the that consistent model of self arising is, is quite varied
- 35:09depending on who the attachment figures at the time and more of
- 35:13a reflection of that. In the disorganized person the
- 35:21attachment system is off. The exploration system is off
- 35:26and the collaboration system is off.
- 35:29And they're really the ones that we think of as having the
- 35:32weakest sense of self that. They don't, they're they don't,
- 35:41they hide? And so the sense of self that
- 35:45would arise base and be mirrored back to them, that would
- 35:50reinforce a positive sense of self or a strong sense of self
- 35:55typically doesn't happen to them, because they're hiding so
- 35:58much. And so, they don't have a sense
- 36:01of how other people see them as much.
- 36:06Which is where that sense of self comes back to us.
- 36:10It's we put it out and then it's reflected back to us from the
- 36:14people around us that making sense.
- 36:17So we go ahead. So we really need the feedback
- 36:24from others in the process of moving from an insecure state to
- 36:29a secure State. We really need to be in that
- 36:32process of receiving the positive reinforcement or the
- 36:35positive information. Nation from others.
- 36:39Well, you know, if you look at the ideal parent figure
- 36:43protocol, you can develop those models that are internal their
- 36:52facilitated by somebody who helps you do that but you create
- 36:57those models intentionally and they're they're a better match
- 37:02for what you need. Then if you simply rely on what
- 37:06The people do. So you're taking in the
- 37:09information and comparing it to the internal working model, in
- 37:13some sense of what you're trying to do is effectively
- 37:17communicate. This is what I think is going
- 37:20on. What do you think is going on?
- 37:22So that's the the secure exchange, you're willing to
- 37:26express yourself authentically and then see how other people
- 37:30understand that. And in that communication, that
- 37:36At exchange, you get a better sense of it of yourself, and how
- 37:41you express and how people experience that expression that
- 37:46helps you, adjust the working model, so that you can be more
- 37:50efficient in getting the things that you want that.
- 37:56So that your exploration is more supported.
- 38:02But if you can't do that, of course you don't have that that
- 38:05collaboration. Word of cycle in that but also
- 38:10requires being in contact with other secure, people doesn't it
- 38:15because if you're if you're coming from an insecure place
- 38:18and trying to get the positive feedback for secure relating,
- 38:23but you're not online to figure out like, you know, who's
- 38:26secure, who's not, what's a secure relationship or cocoa?
- 38:31Or, you know, what's cooperative and what's uncooperative?
- 38:34Because in the world people, maybe?
- 38:36Presenting themselves as Cooperative when in fact,
- 38:39they're quite uncooperative. I think that that might be
- 38:42relatively common. Yeah, I think one of the things
- 38:45that happens is that, if nobody's modeled security to you
- 38:49don't know what it is. Yeah.
- 38:51And so you can't learn it in that way, right?
- 38:56One of the things about ideal parent figure, of course, is
- 38:59that you have a facilitator that understands the differences can
- 39:04recognize each of the Expressions of different
- 39:07attachments and then can interpret that in real time as
- 39:11it's happening and constantly redirect you toward security so
- 39:16that you build the model of security internally.
- 39:20Once you have the model of security internally, you can you
- 39:24can begin to operate from that place.
- 39:29Sorry, let me ask. What do you think is the
- 39:31potential for this work to enter into like school systems and
- 39:35like social? Well, you know, like just be
- 39:37part of the common knowledge of people that if if the secure
- 39:43functioning is so important, you know, what do you think is the
- 39:46potential that this information could be disseminated more
- 39:50widely into society? I think that.
- 39:58It is like anything new. They're the people have studied
- 40:03how new ideas arise and enter into the mainstream.
- 40:09In the beginning, of course, is the exploration that discovers
- 40:12the new idea. And then there's a formulation
- 40:16of the idea in such a way that it can be expressed.
- 40:21And then, in a small group of people who hear the teaching
- 40:26are, then interested in are drawn to it and begin to
- 40:29practice it. You have?
- 40:32You've heard the hundred monkey Theory?
- 40:37No. so, When it was originally described to me, it was about a
- 40:50troop of baboons who lived in a in a sort of tropical in a
- 41:00tropical environment and the they survived largely on fruit
- 41:08and they were very particular about eating the fruit only when
- 41:11it was ripe. But as soon as the fruit of got
- 41:15ripe, it would drop off the tree and get covered with sand.
- 41:18Sand. And so the monkeys, the baboon's
- 41:23were often in trouble because the the they wouldn't be able to
- 41:28eat the fruit when it ripened necessarily and then once it
- 41:33dropped onto the sand, they wouldn't be able to eat it
- 41:36because it was covered with sand.
- 41:37So there was always food shortage.
- 41:42And then one of the baboon's figured out that if they took
- 41:46the the fruit Had the sand on it and they washed it in the river.
- 41:50The sand came off in the they could eat the fruit and it was a
- 41:54big troop but she was the only one who was doing it and then
- 41:58she taught her children to do it and then they learn to do it,
- 42:02and then their friends, their children taught, their friends,
- 42:07to do it, and then their friends taught their parents to do it.
- 42:14And so the knowledge moved out very slowly through these He's
- 42:18social connections until enough people were doing that.
- 42:23It just almost overnight everyone in the troop was doing.
- 42:30So I think that that's I'm I'm sure I've wrecked the story so
- 42:37but you get the gist and so attachment was presented The in
- 42:48the mid-80s by John Bowlby, that research was incomplete.
- 42:54It really wasn't presented to the clinical population until
- 43:02the 2000s and modality that actually could create change has
- 43:15been So new, that what we're beginning?
- 43:20What phase were in here is just the dissemination of the
- 43:24knowledge into these small groups that are then.
- 43:32Developing the skill to practice it in order for it to
- 43:36disseminate. Widely of course, we have to
- 43:38have a lot of people who are skillful at being able to offer
- 43:43it, so people can have the have the effect of it. and that it's
- 43:51an exponential expression, but But get there, my guess is what
- 44:08I'm trying to say. I'm seeing a note from Harley.
- 44:18One of the things about it, attachment parenting.
- 44:24Which Harley is mentioning, is there have been lots of
- 44:31different approaches to understanding that the the care
- 44:37of children is essential in to developing secure attachment and
- 44:41attempting to understand that. And one of the conversations I
- 44:45had with Mary main was that she was not so interested in
- 44:51repairing people's attachment. Because it was so resource and
- 44:56time intensive to do it, that it would be better that we simply
- 45:02let everybody was attached. Word is is you know fucked up
- 45:06just go and then Focus mainly on child-rearing so that we can
- 45:12begin to eliminate it at that level where it's it's not as
- 45:17challenging to do. Well, I'm sorry.
- 45:21I'm sorry I was just going to ask if you Expand on that
- 45:24theory, though. I mean, how is that possible?
- 45:26How is it? You know?
- 45:28How is that mathematically even going to work you mean
- 45:33attachment parenting? No, no, I mean just the idea
- 45:36that it seems really prominent in the Psychotherapy and
- 45:40attachment Community which is that basically just how our
- 45:46children's attachments going to get repaired if their parents
- 45:49don't have the skills to do it. It's just what I mean.
- 45:53In is that you you engage in psychoeducation of the parents
- 45:59so that they don't create the attachment injuries in the first
- 46:02place. But they're going to if they if
- 46:05psychoeducation doesn't change the attachment pattern, it
- 46:08doesn't matter. I totally agree with you on that
- 46:11one. And I think that it that
- 46:12actually, in fact, it doesn't work, but that might be one.
- 46:21Certainly One Direction that That is being pursued Christian.
- 46:30I was just saying that luckily for that plan, a lot of time and
- 46:36resources and money into our children and education.
- 46:40So that should work out just great.
- 46:43I mean we I did this study, we met a group.
- 46:47I took the metal group called cohort that we'd been studying
- 46:50to see how we could get attachment to ship, just through
- 46:53meditation and psychoeducation and we established In at least
- 46:59in our cohort that psycho education and mentalizing
- 47:04development does not shift. Underlying attachment.
- 47:07It adds secure functioning to the end of the long chain event,
- 47:11but it doesn't change the fundamental underlying
- 47:15attachment strategy. But when you add to that, the
- 47:18ideal parent figure protocol, it does shifted and it reliably
- 47:23shifts it. So you need all three of these
- 47:26things you need to teach. Treatment, you need to teach
- 47:30exploration and you need to teach collaboration and without
- 47:34those three systems being developed people aren't aren't
- 47:39able to learn security, does it mean you get a new secure brain?
- 47:46You can't swing by the Ford dealer and have them put in a
- 47:50new part. You have your brain which
- 47:54developed and physically is structured like your native
- 47:58attachment. But You have a way of operating
- 48:01that brain so that you can be, you know, functionally secure.
- 48:07That's basically what happens. So why don't we leave that there
- 48:13and do some meditation practice? I thought that we might do a
- 48:20self-inquiry practice. So in using the basic, see here,
- 48:27field technique exploring where the location of the self is One
- 48:36of the things about self-inquiry work, is that intellectually.
- 48:41We can understand all the sense of self arises based on
- 48:44conditioning. It's a sensing experience, which
- 48:48is in different from any other sensing experience, and we then
- 48:52have this perception of Duality. I am the self viewing things.
- 48:57At least, I think that cognitively that's easier to to
- 49:01grasp than to exhaust yourself. Looking for the seat of the the
- 49:07experience of self somewhere. But if you don't do an Arden
- 49:12search, the self itself does not give up on the idea that it's
- 49:16actually substantial. And so you need to really pursue
- 49:21this with intention. So in see hear feel we're just
- 49:28dividing sensory experience into these three broad domains.
- 49:32And then each time we come into a particular sensing experience,
- 49:36we're going to inquire is this self located here.
- 49:44The correct answer just in case you didn't pick this up is no,
- 49:57alright then. So we're going to do an Ardent
- 50:02search.