Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Theon Greyjoy (Game of Thrones)(2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07Hey, deserving listeners, It's just me today. I have been getting a
- 0:13lot of emails and messages from people asking me to do an episode on theon
- 0:19Gray Joy. I have done episodes on Jeoffrey, I've done an episode on
- 0:25Ramsey and Circe and The Hound. The one on the Hound is for patrons
- 0:31only, so become a patroon and you can hear that one. And people
- 0:35have been bugging me for i don't know, a couple of years now,
- 0:40asking me to do theon because his character is just so darn interesting. I
- 0:47think a lot of people identify with Theon. By the way, this is
- 0:50all from the Game of Thrones or the book series A Song of Ice and
- 0:54Fire. If you didn't know that, then you are not going to be
- 0:58interested in this podcast episode, is my guess. But anyway, I think
- 1:02a lot of people identify with theon Great Joy. He's particularly the TV version
- 1:07because in the book he comes to this. It's hard to identify with Theon
- 1:11in the books, but in the TV show they make it easier. You
- 1:15know, he's made mistakes. It's like some sort of Game of Thrones version
- 1:19of curby your enthusiasm or something. You know, you can just imagine Theon
- 1:25with that music in the background, boom bum bum, you know, that
- 1:30Curb Your Enthusiasm soundtrack, and just seeing Theon make all these mistakes and then
- 1:37later on he's just trying to be a good guy. He's just he's just
- 1:42an insecure guy with with faults and he's he's he's trying. And I think
- 1:46that in a certain way, I think for a lot of us we can
- 1:51identify with with that feeling, that feeling that we're trying and then we make
- 1:57mistakes or we lose our temper, or we make a bad joke, or
- 2:02we put our you know, our foot in our mouth, or we're insecure
- 2:07and we lash out, or we're insecure, we're immature, we're trying to
- 2:13act cool, and then and then we suffer a great deal because of that.
- 2:20And then in the end we just look back and think, you know,
- 2:22we just smack our head and say I can't you know, we face
- 2:25palm and we just say I can't believe I did all those things. And
- 2:29I think in the Game of Thrones universe, Theon Is is a character that
- 2:34really exemplifies that feeling for a lot of us. He has undoubtedly suffered more
- 2:43than any other character in this story. I'm trying to think of another character
- 2:46who suffered more. I mean, certainly people have died and been tortured and
- 2:52been through a lot of stuff, but Theon has just he's like, you
- 2:57know, since the beginning of his he's just been suffering. And so I
- 3:04think that that is makes him a very unique character. Also, in the
- 3:08TV show, Alfie Allen, the guy who plays Theon, he's the perfect
- 3:15actor because he's awesome at playing both a super arrogant person who is insecure deep
- 3:23down, and he's also awesome at playing a super pathetic person when he's reak
- 3:29and when he's depressed and sad. So the full range of Alfie Allen's acting
- 3:37really comes through, and I think makes Theon a much more sympathetic character.
- 3:42Again, particularly because of the way they write for the character in the TV
- 3:46show. And I'll get more into the differences between the book and the TV
- 3:49show in a bit, but first let's introduce the podcast. This is the
- 3:53Psychology in Seattle Podcast. I am your host, doctor Kirk Kanda. I'm
- 3:59a therapist and I'm also a professor. Before moving forward, I just want
- 4:02to say, become a patron of the podcast. When you become a patroon
- 4:06at patreon dot com. Go to patreon dot com. When you become a
- 4:11patron, you get access to hundreds of premium episodes in which we do deep
- 4:15dives on various different topics. All right, So before moving forre, I
- 4:20just want to say that I'm recording this in mid twenty seventeen, which is
- 4:26just before season seven of the TV show and before Book six has been published,
- 4:32so keep that in mind. So I don't know anything. If you're
- 4:35listening to this in twenty thirty or something, there's going to be stuff that
- 4:40I don't know about yet because I'm in the good old days in twenty seventeen
- 4:45when Donald Trump was president and all that kind of stuff. Also, I'm
- 4:48going to spoil the entire story up until season six and books or season seven
- 4:54in Book six, so keep that in mind too. But I'm guessing if
- 4:58you're listening to this, you're all just a little bit about the actor Alfie
- 5:02Allen born in London nineteen eighty six, which would make him about thirty years
- 5:09right now. I didn't realize this until looking this up just now, but
- 5:13he's the older sister of singer Lily Allen, which is interesting. And he's
- 5:17the third cousin of singer Sam Smith, which is also interesting. Okay,
- 5:23so Theon Gray Joy, he's one of the narrators of the books. If
- 5:29you haven't read the books, each book is narrated by a different character,
- 5:34So it'll say something like, you know, the title of the of the
- 5:39chapter will be Aria, and then that whole chapter will be told from Aria's
- 5:45point of view. Well, Theon is one of those people, so there
- 5:48will be chapters that'll just have Theon and then we go into Theon's point of
- 5:53view. And so a lot of characters we only hear about through these other
- 5:59people's point of view, Like I'm pretty sure Ramsey never has his own chapters,
- 6:03and so we hear a lot about Ramsey through Theon. So I believe
- 6:11that Theon is the primary person of the narrator of thirteen chapters. I don't
- 6:19know if narrator is the right term, because it's sort of like a third
- 6:21person. I'm not a literary person, but I hope you get my point.
- 6:26Anyway, thirteen chapters of all the books involved Theon as the quote unquote
- 6:31narrator. He has a number of different aliases that I just want to get
- 6:35out of the get out front here. Prince of Fools, theon turn Cloak.
- 6:44That's the main alias, nickname that he earned after betraying the Starks.
- 6:50The squid prints because there a coat of arms. Their symbol is a squid,
- 6:58and so he and since he's the Prince of Pike, he's the squid
- 7:01Prince. He was also known as Reek for a while. He was more
- 7:08formally known as the Rightful Lord of the Iron Islands. He was also nicknamed
- 7:15theon Kinslayer because he killed his kin, you know, the Starks being sort
- 7:24of his kin. And the Prince of Stink, the Prince of Stink.
- 7:29Okay. Other titles, official titles that he's had are Captain of the Sea
- 7:35Bitch. He would there's a there's a boat called Sea Bitch, and he
- 7:40was captain of it. He was Lord of Lord of Winterfell for a time,
- 7:46and Prince of Winterfell. Okay, history, so let's start from the
- 7:51beginning. This is all before the books begin. It's not sure when he
- 7:58was born. They don't tell the exact year. They just give like,
- 8:03you know, ten years ago, blah blah. So he was either born
- 8:05in two hundred seventy eight ac or to seventy nine, and he was born
- 8:13at Pike. Theon was apparently named potentially after Theon Stark, who was an
- 8:20old king in the North back in the day. And I believe Theon is
- 8:26not a common name in the Game of Thrones universe, and so it's possible
- 8:31that he was actually named after one of the early kings in the North,
- 8:35Theon Stark, which is an interesting twist right from the beginning if you think
- 8:41about if George Martin was thinking that foreign advance, which he probably was because
- 8:46he always thinks that foreign advance. So going back into the early childhood for
- 8:52Theon, whenever I do these deep dives into these characters for three R owns,
- 9:01I always want to know about their early childhood because early childhood development plays
- 9:07a large part in one's adult personality. So what do we know about Theon's
- 9:11childhood? Well, the fact is we actually don't know much about his early
- 9:16childhood. When I did episodes on Jeoffrey and Circe and Ramsey and even the
- 9:22Hound, there's more data in the books regarding their early childhoods, which helps
- 9:28us to understand how their personalities developed. For Theon. We just don't know
- 9:33much about his early childhood, but we can assume that his parents were not
- 9:39ideal, you know, as an adult Baylon gray Joy, his father,
- 9:46the Lord of Pike, was an asshole. Right, we just know if
- 9:50he's not he's you know, he's he's not a nice guy. I mean
- 9:54the very least. He's not warm. Right, But what about Theon's mother,
- 10:00Well, we don't know much about his mother. Alanislis, like Alanis
- 10:07Morisett. Later in life, Alanis would become mentally ill and very sickly.
- 10:15She I can't remember the exact quotes, but you know, she's locked in
- 10:20it, or she isolates herself in a tower or something and is ranting and
- 10:24raving. Or she because her two sons are killed during Grade Grade Joy's rebellion,
- 10:30which is later but later in life. Alanis during the time of the
- 10:35books, she's referred to as basically mentally ill because her sons were killed and
- 10:41and this sort of thing. So if we're to imagine that this was a
- 10:46real situation, clinically speaking, we could imagine that Alanis probably had precursors to
- 10:56either severe depression or schizophrenia, some sort of psychotic disorder early in life,
- 11:05which would have affected the way she parented all of her killed children, including
- 11:11Theon. So but again we don't know. But given Theon's personality, particularly
- 11:18in the books, we could surmise that his early childhood was not a deal.
- 11:24It's even possible that he, like many of the aristocratic youth, he
- 11:30was probably raised by wet nurses and slaves in the sort of thing or servants,
- 11:37I should say. And this doesn't always lend itself to proper attachment development
- 11:43as a young child, because if your servants are not always permanent, you
- 11:50know, these attachment figures can kind of come and go from your life.
- 11:52And so Theon has evidence in his adult life and there's you know, clues
- 11:58that is early childhood attachment was not was not great. We do know,
- 12:05however, that Theon was routinely beat by his older brothers, Roderick and Marin.
- 12:09And so this is the beginning of so this this bit bit of data
- 12:15we can really dig down on for a second here. So he's the youngest
- 12:20son. There's three sons. He has a he has a sister Asha as
- 12:24well. In the show they call her Yara, but he's he's the youngest
- 12:28of three boys, uh, the Iron Born or the gray Joys. You
- 12:35know, people from the Iron Islands, they're very tough and they value toughness
- 12:41and they hate weakness, and they you know, think of him like if
- 12:45you're in a star trek, they're at Klingons. They in some ways it's
- 12:50just like they're always fighting and if you can't keep up, then you know
- 12:54that them's the breaks. You're just going to be squished. And so he,
- 13:00being the smaller of the three brothers, was what was frequently being squished.
- 13:05And also we can imagine that it's not a routine thing at least for
- 13:13families to just allow beatings of younger boys. It's just I imagine that's just
- 13:18not exactly like always typical to the Ironborn. So we can imagine that Roderick
- 13:24and Maren were beating his young their younger brother theon partially because they might have
- 13:30been competing for their father's approval or attention from the mother or something. A
- 13:35lot of times in families, when you have children who are beating up on
- 13:39each other, it's the result of various different mistreatment or neglect that the older
- 13:46kids are going through. You know, if you are properly loved, properly
- 13:52attached, you know, well enough attached and given enough attention, then you
- 13:58don't have the urge to beat your younger siblings. Or I should say you
- 14:03probably have the urge, because I think everyone has the urge to beat their
- 14:07younger siblings, but you also have enough empathy and compassion and love so that
- 14:13you will show restraint when you do have that urge. Apparently Theon's older brothers
- 14:20did not have that restraint and routinely beat him. So you can imagine Theon,
- 14:24little Theon, age five, just being tormented by his older brothers,
- 14:30and how terrible that would have felt. And then we can imagine his mother
- 14:35having the precursors of major depression or psychosis. And then we can imagine Baylon
- 14:41great Joy, Theon's father, just you know, saying, well, Theon,
- 14:46you got to suck it up, you know, And just how emasculating
- 14:50and how humiliating, how terrifying that must have been for Theon, and how
- 14:56he would be left on his own to develop his own defense mechanisms, which
- 15:01I'll get into you in a second. Okay, So skipping forward to when
- 15:07Theon is ten years old, this is when gray Joy's rebellion happens basically in
- 15:13gray Joy's Rebellion, Baylon gray Joy, Theon's father, he tries to secede
- 15:22from the Iron Throne. So the Iron Throne is in king's landing right.
- 15:28So at the time Brathian, Robert Barrathian was was king right and at our
- 15:35Stark was Warden of the North. So when Theon was ten, this is
- 15:41about nine years before the beginning of the books, Baylon Grayjoy just randomly decides
- 15:46he wants to secede from the Seven Kingdoms and wants independence. And so Baylon,
- 15:54you know, says I'm king now and we're no longer part of this
- 16:00kingdoms, and he wanted independence. And part of this is because they used
- 16:06to actually be free. Then the reason why they call him the Seven Kingdoms
- 16:10is because they were actually in the past seven different kingdoms, and and the
- 16:14Iron Islands used to be free and independent until three hundred years ago when Agon
- 16:22the first Agon Targerian three hundred years ago he conquered most of Westros except for
- 16:27Dorn by the way, and Agon with his two sisters, who were riding
- 16:33on large dragons by the way, they Agon the first Egon Targarian he you
- 16:42know, went around Westros to subdue all the other kingdoms, including the Iron
- 16:48Islands. Incidentally, during Agon's conquest three hundred years before the book start haron
- 16:56Hall. If you remember Heron Hall from when Aria is there with Vallar Margolis
- 17:03and all that kind of stuff. The reason why it was in ruins is
- 17:07because the dragons breathed fire from above that burned Hairn Hall to the ground,
- 17:11and the swords of the Dead from Heron Hall were melted into the Iron Throne.
- 17:17So everything's kind of connected in that way in this in this book,
- 17:22which I which I think is pretty cool. But anyway, the gray Joys
- 17:26were or the early king of of Iron Islands was crushed by Agon during this
- 17:32time, as was the King of the North and other kings of the of
- 17:38the verious different kingdoms, and Bailon and the gray Joys and the Iron Born
- 17:45never really forgot that. So it's three hundred years basically with them feeling as
- 17:49though they're being subdued. You know, think of it like you're the Confederacy
- 17:55of the United States. You know, there's there's definite feelings and it's only
- 18:00been one hundred and fifty years or something since the Civil War and the Confederate
- 18:06there are still people that, you know, like to have the Confederate flag.
- 18:08I was just in Seattle, in Ballard of all places, actually,
- 18:12and I was down by the various boats that are in you know, the
- 18:18what do you call it. I'm from Seattle, I should know. But
- 18:22there's boats all docked. What do you call We're a bunch of boats anyway,
- 18:29a mooring area. Well, people have various flags flying from their masts,
- 18:33and one of the flags was a Confederate flag. And I'm just thinking,
- 18:37really, and I had I had a couple of beers, and I
- 18:44had aspirations of breaking into the boat area and carrying down that flag. But
- 18:52when you look around at all the different flags on the masts, most of
- 18:55them were Seattle, you know, Like there's a few gay flags, the
- 18:57rainbow flag, and there's other kinds of flags. So I don't know.
- 19:02I guess if you want to fly a Confederate flag like an asshole, then
- 19:04great. But so you know, that's one hundred and fifty years ago,
- 19:08and people are still upset about that. And there have been times when people
- 19:15in the South have said that they would like to finish the job and really
- 19:22defeat the North and all this kind of stuff. And so similar to that,
- 19:27the Ironborn on the Iron Islands are like, it's been three hundred years,
- 19:32we want to be free, and so they try to break free.
- 19:36And this is when Theon was ten years old, and Bailan Great Joy's like,
- 19:41we're gonna break free, and me and my two sons, Roderick and
- 19:45Marin are going to you know, defeat our enemies and we're going to establish
- 19:52independence. And it kind of makes sense because there are these islands one which
- 19:57are easy to defend, right, and the Ironborn are the are the navy
- 20:04of West Ros. They're they're the ones who have the ships and are the
- 20:08fastest at making ships and the best sailors and the best battle people at sea,
- 20:15and so it makes sense that if they wanted their independence, that it
- 20:18wouldn't be that hard for them, right, because they could defeat all the
- 20:22other navies and just sort of sit on their Iron Islands and be cool.
- 20:27But Robert, King Robert was not going to have that shit, and so
- 20:33King Robert and Edward Stark went to put down Gray Joy's rebellion, and incidentally,
- 20:44Lord Jura Mormont. You know, Jora was also there with Robert and
- 20:49Edard. This is back when Jora was still in good graces with King Robert.
- 20:56This is before Jora fled west Ros to escape execution for slave trading,
- 21:00which eventually led him to Denari's. But anyway, huh, So Jarrah,
- 21:07Robert Eduard put down grade Joy's rebellion and they kill I don't know if they
- 21:14personally killed, but they're force killed Theon's older brothers. And this made Theon
- 21:19the heir to House great Joy and the heir to the Lord of the Iron
- 21:25Islands, which was interesting. Suddenly Theon is like, whoa, I'm now
- 21:29heir to heir to the House of gray Joy. Well, so, Edward
- 21:34and Robert put down Baylon's rebellion and instead of killing Baylon, they leave Baylon
- 21:44in power, and they say, if you ever do this again, we
- 21:48will kill you and we're going to take your only heir, Theon grey Joy.
- 21:52We're going to take him and Edard is going to have is going to
- 21:56keep him as a ward, which is basically kind of like a haste and
- 22:00Baylon, if you get out of line, you know what's going to happen
- 22:03to your only son, and so whether this is a common tactic back in
- 22:10the day, right, And it makes sense, right because if you kill
- 22:14Baylon, maybe some other Ironborn will rise up and out of resentment and attack
- 22:22the North again. So it's like show mercy to Baylon, which Baylon is
- 22:29happy to receive, and at the same time, take one of Baylon's son
- 22:34sons or his only son and treat him well. Right, So you're treating
- 22:40Theon well by raising him and teaching him and not torturing him. So Baylon's
- 22:45happy about that, and you know, just always know if you get out
- 22:51of line, then your son is dead. So you know, it's a
- 22:55good tactic to kind of keep the peace. I guess it's it's similar to
- 22:57marrying between two different warring houses. Right. So Theon is you know,
- 23:06he's grown, he grows, he's a child in house great Joy, being
- 23:11raised probably poorly and being beat by his two older brothers, and then there's
- 23:15this massive war and he is taken hostage at the age of nine or ten
- 23:22by Edward Stark and he's raised in Winterfell for nine years. So imagine this,
- 23:30your young boy. Your father decides to go to war and in the
- 23:38end, your home is invaded by the enemy. You know, not just
- 23:42like any It's like the enemy is coming. Just think about how terrifying that
- 23:45would have been. And your older brothers fly into battle and are killed by
- 23:52the enemy at ard stark, your father is humiliated by bending the knee.
- 24:00Your mother starts to go crazy because of all this stress and the older brothers
- 24:03being killed, And then you're basically kidnapped by the enemy and forced to live
- 24:10with these people who hate you and despise you. You're isolated, you're afraid,
- 24:18you might be desperate for security, and you feel powerless. You're this
- 24:23young boy and you're just ripped away from your father. And just think about
- 24:30this psychological toll that would have on a ten year old, especially to a
- 24:34ten year old, right, because if you're older, you might be able
- 24:40to handle the stress, but at ten people need. Ten year olds need
- 24:45their parents. Ten year olds are really desperate for the security from their parents.
- 24:52Well, whenever I hear about families contemplating sending their ten year old or
- 24:59even twelve year old to boarding school, I just think you do not understand
- 25:03how people develop, and that is going to do unless you're a bad parent,
- 25:07which by all means send them away. But if you're you know,
- 25:11remotely good as a parent, a ten year old boy, a twelve year
- 25:17old boy, they need their parents, They need their parents love, they
- 25:22need their parents' attention, they need their parents' security. And even though ten
- 25:27year old boys can act like they're super independent, they're not. It's just
- 25:33not natural. And people will say stuff like, well, back in the
- 25:37old days, you know, ten year olds are treated like adults. Yes,
- 25:41ten year olds often were treated like adults, meaning that they were given
- 25:45responsibilities, but they weren't sent away. That's the difference here is that before
- 25:51industrialization, and really even before there was enough wealth for boarding schools, I
- 25:56suppose children even though they were put to work, most people were farmers.
- 26:02So you know, if you were if you were five, you were put
- 26:06to work on the farm, but you didn't leave the farm. You stayed
- 26:10on the farm. Maybe when you're fifteen, and you know, especially if
- 26:14you're a girl and you're married off, then you might move to the to
- 26:18the farm next door, or the farm across town or something. But you're
- 26:22not just going to be completely abandoned to some other, you know, situation.
- 26:27So it's unnatural to send kids away, and Theon was sent away,
- 26:33and he's to the enemy. He's a prisoner, a hostage of the enemy,
- 26:40ripped away from everything that he knows and and ripped away from the little
- 26:44bit of security that he had found. So Theon was raised with the Stark
- 26:52children, and there's so many of them, right, And he's tutored by
- 26:56meister Lewin. And he's also tutored by I think what I think he's called
- 27:02the Master of Arms, not sure, but the head fighter guy, Sir
- 27:06Roderick Cassell. And he thought of Rob as a close friend. Rob,
- 27:12you know, Rob Stark, who later became King of King of the North,
- 27:17was younger. So John Snow was the oldest of the of the Stark
- 27:23children, even though he's not a Stark kid's child, but I believe Theon
- 27:27was oldest. And then he had John John Snow and then he had Rob,
- 27:33and then you had Santsa, and it was brand next, and then
- 27:38Aria and then Ricard something like that. Anyway, so Rob was younger,
- 27:45and Theon considered Rob to be a close friend and considered him to be,
- 27:49you know, eventually considered him to be like a brother. He also Theon
- 27:55also started to see Edward Stark as a father. You know, Edward was
- 28:02a good father. He was distant, but he was a consistent father.
- 28:07Edward. They talk about this in the book. Edward only spanked Theon once
- 28:12after Theon had was playing as a as a young as a you know,
- 28:18twelve year old kid or something and bumped into old Nan and knocked her to
- 28:22the floor, and Edward took Theon aside and spanked him, and Theon actually
- 28:29thinks back at this time as actually fondly, not that he liked being spanked,
- 28:34but he was just like, compared to the shit I went through on
- 28:38a daily basis at Pike, it was you know, it was just like,
- 28:42oh, this is like normal parenting, you know. So he appreciated
- 28:48Edward as a as a father. In some ways. Theon fantasized that Edward
- 28:53would marry him to Sansa and claim him to as a on, you know,
- 29:00young Theon eleven, twelve thirteen is like, oh, maybe maybe Edward
- 29:07will find me worthy to marry his oldest daughter, and then I will be
- 29:11able to call Edward truly as a father, but in his older years.
- 29:21But looking back, Theon would chastise himself or sort of laugh at himself and
- 29:26think how naive and stupid he was to think that Edward would ever marry him
- 29:33to Sansa, you know. So uh yeah, so Theon really looked up
- 29:40to Edward. He in his in his teenage years, really began to bond
- 29:47with the Starks. And just think about how different those households would have been.
- 29:51Right at Pike. You have Baylon and what a what a guy he
- 29:56is, and then you have alanis his mother you know who we don't but
- 30:00probably had issues. And then you have his older brothers who are beating him
- 30:03all the time. And then instantly, you know, this war happens.
- 30:07You're invaded and you get taken away, kidnapped, and you're terrified, and
- 30:10you're like, oh, this isn't so bad Winterfell. It's kind of a
- 30:12nice place to live. These people are pretty cool. So but Theon,
- 30:19you know, had had really complicated feelings, right because he occasionally reminded himself
- 30:30that Edward was the one who invaded Pike. So this is all internally for
- 30:33Theon and the books and he I don't know if it was explicit I can't
- 30:40remember if it was explicitly discussed, but Theon would occasionally. Remember, wait
- 30:45a second, Edward was the guy who invaded my land and killed my brothers
- 30:49and humiliated my father. So should I really look up to this guy?
- 30:56So Theon was in a very difficult strain position regarding his loyalties and regarding his
- 31:03attachment figures. You know, he he was attached early in life to his
- 31:11own family, but his family was terrible to him. I mean, at
- 31:14least we have evidence his brothers are terrible, but in all likelihood, his
- 31:18whole family is terrible to him. And so he loves them, but they're
- 31:21terrible to him. And then he comes to live the Starks, and he
- 31:25loves the Starks, but they are they are his you know, they they're
- 31:29imprisoning him, and they killed, you know, half of his family.
- 31:36So everyone he's attached to has a very, I don't know, it's a
- 31:42very damaging role in his life. There's not a single person we don't know
- 31:47about Alanis. Maybe Alanis was great, but there's not a single person that
- 31:52we know of that Theon was attached to in his life that didn't play a
- 31:56major role in damaging his life. So just think about that. Also,
- 32:02not only his attachment and his loyalties. Not only are his attachment loyalties getting
- 32:07all confused, but his morality is also being pulled into completely opposite directions.
- 32:16The iron Born in Pike, they take pride and attacking and stealing from others.
- 32:22This is what they call paying the iron price, right. They they're
- 32:28like vikings. They will, you know, they like to raid innocent towns,
- 32:36take what they want. And that's what they consider to be, you
- 32:40know, best in life? What is conan? What is best in life?
- 32:44And to the Ironborn, they would say to you know, right,
- 32:47you know, to sail in your boat, to come upon a hapless village,
- 32:52to kill all the men, take everything and they have, and to
- 32:57take the women and the daughter as salt wives. They called him salt wives,
- 33:01which is I'm not exactly sure what assualt life is, but I'm pretty
- 33:06sure it's like a slave wife in some ways. Anyway. So that's the
- 33:12Ironborn and their morality. But ned Stark has this completely opposite morality, right,
- 33:20He has this classic sense of honor. Of anyone in the book,
- 33:23Edward Stark was the most truthful, the most honorable, He was the most
- 33:30faithful to his family spoiler alert, right, because I'm going to spoil the
- 33:36entire thing up until twenty seventeen, But the one thing that Edward did that
- 33:40was dishonorable was to have sex with a random person and have John snow as
- 33:47a bastard son. But then we learned that John Snowe is not Edward Stark's
- 33:52bastard son. That John snow is someone else's son. So the one thing
- 33:58that Edward did that he was ashamed of, he never actually did so.
- 34:00So ned is this super honorable guy, super truthful? When when Edward figures
- 34:07out that Jeoffrey, Tomman and and man what's the girl's name? Oh boy?
- 34:16Anyway, the three kids from the three the three Circe kids, they
- 34:23are not actually Robert's kids. This when when Edward figures this out, instead
- 34:30of running straight to the King or rounding up Circe and rounding up the kids,
- 34:37he goes to Circe and tells her, look, I'm about to tell
- 34:42the king the truth. You know. I'm about to tell the King that
- 34:45your kids are actually not his kids, and that they're actually they're actually Jamie's
- 34:51kids. And so I'm going to give you a chance to get your kids
- 34:54together and get out of town, because you know, once Robert finds out,
- 34:59he's gonna kill you, and he's probably going to kill your kids.
- 35:00And I can't have that on my conscience. And so I'm telling you this
- 35:07to save your life. And this is what got Edward locked up. If
- 35:12he had just gone straight to Robert like a normal person. But because Edard
- 35:16is so honorable and so good and so caring about human life, he shot
- 35:25himself from the foot. Well, imagine how different of a morality Theon is
- 35:31experiencing. Now. We have hit the ironborn, who take from the Week,
- 35:38and we have Edward who tries to protect the Week. You know,
- 35:45for his people, it's it's a moral to not steal from other people.
- 35:51You know, if you don't invade an innocent village and take things from them,
- 35:54then there's something wrong with you. You know, these these weak people
- 35:58deserve to have things taken for them. But for ned Stark it's the opposite.
- 36:01For him, it's a moral to take from the Week because they are
- 36:07weak. In fact, it's your job to protect the Week. You might
- 36:09even put your life on the line to protect the Week. It's just a
- 36:13completely different morality. And this would have a very disorienting effect on Theon as
- 36:20Theon was developing his own morality, which we can see in the story that
- 36:27Theon has a very weird sense of morality. Okay, so that brings us
- 36:34up to the beginning. Oh and the last little bit here is they talked
- 36:37about Theon as having a lot of sexual partners. He has sex with a
- 36:40lot of women, sex workers, but also just random women. So that's
- 36:47all right. So that brings us to the beginning of the books, and
- 36:52so let's go into that. But before that, let's take a little break.
- 37:01Okay, we're back from the break. If you haven't become a patron
- 37:05of the podcast, do so by going to patreon dot com. That's Patreon
- 37:09dot com. Become a patron of the podcast and get access to hundreds of
- 37:15premium episodes in which we do various different deep dives. Also know that a
- 37:20portion of your pledge goes towards various charities that we support. If we reach
- 37:23our next goal, we will start donating to petfinder dot com, which saves
- 37:30animals from being euthanized and connects them with homes that want them. My cats
- 37:37are from petfinder dot com and I just love Petfinder dot com. I love
- 37:43Petfinder, all right, so become a patron. Do that, and if
- 37:46we get up to a certain goal, we'll start donating to Petfinder, all
- 37:51right. So the beginning of the books, first book, A Game of
- 37:54Thrones, theon is described with various different adjectives, including lean, so he's
- 38:04lean. The guy who plays Alfie Allen is also lean. Right. He's
- 38:08described as dark, which is interesting because Alfie Allen is not dark. It's
- 38:14hard to know what George Martin means by dark, but he's described as dark.
- 38:19He's described as handsome. I would say that Alfie Allen is handsome.
- 38:24He's described as being vain and arrogant. So that's interesting, right, Very
- 38:30vain and arrogant, so annoying in that way. And he has a distinctive
- 38:38quality to him in which he always seems to find everything amusing. He's always
- 38:44smiling at things. In the TV show, they don't really portray it the
- 38:47way that I pictured it in my head as I was reading the books.
- 38:52He in the books, he's always smiling. He's just or frequently he's smiling.
- 38:57He's just like, you know, like he's above everything. He's just
- 39:00like, oh boy, here we go. Again, Oh you little people
- 39:04and your stupid things. You know, he's always kind of smirking at everything,
- 39:07like it's like, I don't I think it's described as a cocky smile.
- 39:12Caitlyn for instance, Caitlyn starks, she says, quote this is in
- 39:17the book. She studied Theon gray Joy's sly smile, wondering what it meant
- 39:23that young man had a way of looking as though he knew some secrets.
- 39:29Oh sorry, that young man had a way of looking as though he knew
- 39:31some secret jest that only he was privy to. Caitlyn had never liked it.
- 39:38Unquote. So Caitlyn never liked Theon in the way that she never liked
- 39:45John Snow for obvious reasons. And Caitlyn's looking at this smiling kid, and
- 39:52see he always looks like he has some something up his sleeve, like an
- 39:55Eddie Haskell or something, and she didn't like it. So so that's how
- 40:01he's described. But he's also described as being insecure, which makes sense,
- 40:07right. You know, he, as we've been talking about, he has
- 40:10massive attachment injuries. His mother was seemingly a little off. His father.
- 40:19Baylon is definitely not a warm guy. He's probably not raised so well.
- 40:23His brothers beat him as a child, and his brothers are murdered. He's
- 40:28ripped away from his family, and this often results in insecurity, meaning that
- 40:34he has been given the message that he is not worthy. He's not worthy
- 40:38of love, he's not worthy of attention, he's not worthy of respect.
- 40:44So a common defense against this notion, because when you have that notion running
- 40:49around in your head, that psychodynamic of I am not worthy of love,
- 40:53I'm not worthy of security, I'm not worthy of respect. No one likes
- 40:58me, no one is thinking of mind well being. Then you need a
- 41:01defense against that because if you let that really you know, rattle around in
- 41:07your head, then it's terrifying. So you need some mental psychodynamic trick in
- 41:14the form of a defense mechanism in order to protect yourself from constantly having to
- 41:20worry that no one is there to help you well. A common defense against
- 41:24this notion is to create a persona that, you know, this fake person
- 41:30this fake identity that doesn't really care about love or attention. You know,
- 41:35it's an arrogant persona. It's like, well, you know, I don't
- 41:38care, I don't care about you. You know a lot of teenagers are
- 41:42this way why, because they're massively insecure human beings, and this protects theon
- 41:46from further ridicule because he believes that no one will know how scared he is
- 41:52on the inside and how ashamed he is on the inside. And it also
- 41:58protects him from acknowledge to himself how vulnerable he is because he can believe in
- 42:05this fantasy that he's super cool and he doesn't care. But deep down,
- 42:08he cares more than any other person around him. So that's where the arrogance
- 42:15comes from. He's massively insecure deep down because everyone has made him, has
- 42:21treated him in a way that would make him feel very insecure. But he
- 42:24puffs himself up in this very arrogant way as a way of protecting himself from
- 42:29further ridicule and from acknowledging to himself that he is in fact, extremely vulnerable
- 42:37to being hurt by other people. We can imagine that this was developed early
- 42:40in life when his brothers are beating him, which again, you have a
- 42:45number of different defenses available to you, one of which is to act like
- 42:51you don't care so your brothers are beating you or making fun of you or
- 42:55something. And even though it cuts deep. You realize is that your older
- 43:00brothers are just gonna make it worse if you let on that it cuts deep.
- 43:05And so instead you just act like I don't care. You know,
- 43:07I don't care what you say. You know, you can act whatever,
- 43:10you can say, whatever you want to. I'm Theon, great joy blah
- 43:13blah blah. But deep down he's extremely hurt. So this is Theon's go
- 43:19to defense because he's walking around in a constant state of fear and anxiety and
- 43:23security, and so he also walks around with a persona of arrogance. He's
- 43:30also described as wearing a fur lined cloak with black silk gloves. This is
- 43:37something you really miss out by watching the TV show because George Martin likes to
- 43:39describe how people dress. Typically, like when you when you read about how
- 43:46Ramsey dressed, you know, you just get these like really descriptive things that
- 43:52the TV show just doesn't show really very much. But anyway, so Theon
- 43:57is known to wear a fur lined cloak being in the cold north, black
- 44:00silk gloves, so black silk. Imagine that silk gloves. That's interesting,
- 44:06right, It's not leather gloves, it's silk, black silk like satin gloves.
- 44:13He wears black leather boots. He has a silvery gray lambswolb pants.
- 44:19He wears a leather belt, a white leather belt that's interesting, kind of
- 44:22eighties white leather and a black velvet doublet embroidered with the kraken of House gray
- 44:30Joy. So the kracking is, you know, it's a big squid like
- 44:34thing. He is extremely good with a bow, so Sir Roderick Kassel at
- 44:39Winterfel has taught him how to use a bow really well, and so he's
- 44:44he's a crack shot with a bow. And he's also very good on a
- 44:47horse, because that's what the gentry learned, they learn the arts of war.
- 44:55He is in that first scene in the books, well, the very
- 45:00first scene is beyond the Wall, but the but the next scene is with
- 45:07ed Ard, Rob and brand I think Cassell is there and Theon is there
- 45:12with them when they find the dire Wolves and when they execute Jared for deserting
- 45:19the Knight's Watch. Also early on in that first book, and it might
- 45:25happen right away, I'm not sure, but a group of wildlings and a
- 45:30group of Knight's Watch deserters are kind of roaming around On, you know,
- 45:37the winterfill side of the wall, and they come upon the Starks and they're
- 45:45going to attack Brand in the woods, and Theon comes to the rescue.
- 45:53So so let's kind of break this down because I think it kind of illuminates
- 45:59a family dinamic that will help us understand Theon. So, again, as
- 46:04I was saying earlier, Theon is the oldest. He is older than Rob,
- 46:07He's older than Bran, he's older than Jon Snow. I believe he's
- 46:13older than John Snow. Yeah right, yeah, maybe maybe he's not.
- 46:19Anyway, he's older than Rob, but he is, you know, a
- 46:23crack shot with the bow. And some wildlings and Knights Watch Deserters are attacking
- 46:30and he sees Bran in danger, you know, little Brand. Brand was
- 46:35probably I don't know, he's probably like eight or nine or something at this
- 46:38point, and Theon is thinking, here's my chance, here's my chance to
- 46:44do something good and valiant, and maybe I'll finally get the acceptance that I've
- 46:50been craving so much my entire life. I can save Brand's life, and
- 46:53maybe I'll be really accepted into this family. And so he rushes in and
- 47:00he shoots the attacker and saves Bran and he, you know, immediately he
- 47:07is probably just thinking, yes, nailed it. You know, I've saved
- 47:10Brand's life. Surely Edward will marry me to Sansan now and I'll be you
- 47:15know, I'll be loved and secure and everything will be great. But instead
- 47:21of being praised, Rob chastises him again. Rob's a younger, younger boy.
- 47:27Rob chastises him, chastises him in front of everybody because Rob thinks that
- 47:34that he put Brand in danger by shooting an arrow so close to Rob or
- 47:42to Brand, And Rob is like, you could have hit Brand with that
- 47:45arrow. That was too close. But Theon is like, I'm a crack
- 47:50shot with a bow man. I'm not going to hit something I'm not aiming
- 47:53at. But and wait a second, I just saved Brand's life. How
- 47:59about a little thing. But instead Rob chastises in front of everyone, just
- 48:01yells at him. So this might be an a glimpse into Theon's teen years
- 48:12while he was you know, a hostage at Winterfell, always being treated like
- 48:19a secondary citizen by the Starks. You know, even they talk about even
- 48:24the bastard John Snow was treated better than Theon and John Snow was not treated
- 48:29well, particularly by Caitlin. But John Snow was not treated great, and
- 48:34Theon was was treated worse than John Snow, which is why Theon particularly hated
- 48:38John Snows because he's like, I'm a prince. I'm a lord's son,
- 48:45you know, not a prince technically, but you know, I'm I'm actual
- 48:49not nobility, and John Snow's a bastard son. Why am I being treated
- 48:53worse than a bastard son? So, so Theon is, you know,
- 48:59he's just never treated like he's really a part of the family, and this
- 49:05furthers his insecurity and his defensive arrogance and his need to have sex with women
- 49:12to prove his manhood, all that kind of stuff. So moving forward in
- 49:15the story, when Eduard is executed by Joffrey and Rob is now Lord of
- 49:22Winterfel and decides to call the Bannerman and march south to war, Theon becomes
- 49:30Rob's trusted companion in battle. Rob doesn't really have anyone else in his family
- 49:37now, there's no other men that are related to him that he can really
- 49:43trust. I mean, the next son is Bran, and Brand's too young,
- 49:47and rick On is you know, woefully too young. John Snow he
- 49:52can kind of trust. But by now John Snow has gone to the wall,
- 49:58I believe. Know, Rob really looks to Theon as as a trusted
- 50:02brother in arms. And during the battle in which Jamie gets captured, remember
- 50:10when Jamie Lanister gets captured, Theon boasts to everyone that he almost fought Jamie
- 50:16in battle. Whether or not he would have actually fought well with Jamie is
- 50:22probably we'll never know. I'm guessing he would have been instantly killed by Jamie
- 50:28uh in hand to hand sword combat. But but Theon actually, you know,
- 50:32he he rode into battle and almost went toe to toe with Jamie.
- 50:37So you know, Theon was a legit, a legit fighter at this point,
- 50:42you know, and he was a legit trusted companion for for Rob.
- 50:47And Theon is always the warmonger advisor. He's always telling Rob to be more
- 50:55ruthless. Theon is like, look, if you're going to rule, you're
- 50:59gonna have have to You're gonna have to do some nasty things. He you
- 51:04know, he Theon's like, Okay, now that we've captured Jamie, I
- 51:07think he should just execute him because Jeoffrey killed just you know, they killed
- 51:15your father, and so this will begin the revenge and it'll tell your enemies
- 51:19that you're serious. So let's kill Jamie. Uh. They of course don't
- 51:22do that. And then Caitlyn lets Jamie go on the you know, the
- 51:30trade that Jamie will bring the daughters back to her, which never happens,
- 51:38you know, because of Brienne. But anyway, I think I messed up
- 51:45that entire sentence, but I hope you know what I mean. Anyway,
- 51:47So Theon also tells Rob that he should assault the twins the phrase and just
- 51:53you know, just take it over by force. Rob says, you know,
- 52:00he's always telling thean. Oh, I think I need to rule the
- 52:04way Eduard ruled, which was honorable, you know, not ruthless. Rob
- 52:09eventually becomes King of the North and Rob is thinking, okay, well,
- 52:15what if we had a navy on our side? What if the Iron Islands
- 52:19were on our side? So Rob sends Theon and Rob is saying, hey,
- 52:23Theon's my bud, and he's the Sun, the heir to the throne
- 52:30and the Iron Islands. I'm going to send my bud, Theon back home
- 52:36to the Iron Islands to forge an alliance between the gray Joys and the Starks,
- 52:42and then we'll have this awesome two pronged attack in terms of the Northmen
- 52:49and their armies and the cavalry, and then we have by sea with these
- 52:53with this you know, huge navy. This is going to be this is
- 52:57going to be awesome. So Rob's like, Theon go home and you know,
- 53:00forge an alliance between us and the gray Joys, and and Thean's like,
- 53:06absolutely, I'm gonna do that for Rob. This is gonna be awesome.
- 53:09This is gonna be glorious. Two houses is one, and and I
- 53:15get to go home. I get to go home where I'm not some sort
- 53:19of reject prisoner of this of a family. I get. I get to
- 53:22go home and become you know, the the heir to the throne. And
- 53:30surely when I return home, everyone's going to receive me as finally the sun
- 53:35is back, and uh, Theon goes home and no one treats him.
- 53:44Well, he's just you know, he's just like, how come no one
- 53:45respecting me? No one respects him? Because the iron Eyelids have a completely
- 53:49different version of how you earn respect. You don't get it by They have
- 53:55a much less of a hierarchy in terms of who earns respect. Right,
- 54:00you earn respect to your actions, not through your titles. So Theon goes
- 54:06home and he asks his father, Baylon, to join Rob in attacking the
- 54:13Lanisters. And Theon asks his father, he says, you know, hey,
- 54:21Baylon, you know, let let me lead the iron Fleet against against
- 54:28the Lanisters, and when we take castlely Rock from House Lanister, I would
- 54:34like to be Lord of cashley Rock, you know, and I will you
- 54:37know about imagine that, right. The story would have been so much different
- 54:42if Baylon would have gone along with this, which would have been a pretty
- 54:45good plan. I mean because at this point the this is before the Red
- 54:50Wedding and all that kind of stuff. At this point, Rob Stark is
- 54:54looking pretty good. Well the Lanisters are looking pretty good too, but you
- 54:59know, Lanisters, they got Stanis coming from the south and you know,
- 55:04Rob from the north. And imagine if the gray Joys had and the Navy
- 55:08had joined up with the Starks, it just would have been, you know,
- 55:14just would have been pretty great. But of course, uh, that's
- 55:20not what Baylon decided to do, because Baylon is a fucking asshole, And
- 55:25of course didn't listen to his son. But that's what happens, you know,
- 55:30when you hold on to a three hundred year old grudge, right like
- 55:35the Confederate flag people in the South. If I lived in the South,
- 55:40I'm I'm guessing I would have a different kind of view on that or something
- 55:45if I had, if I had ancestors who fought on the Confederate side of
- 55:49the war in the Civil War United States. So you know, me living
- 55:53at Seattle, I just have no sympathy for that kind of way of thinking,
- 55:57particularly when the Confederacy was, at least in part, trying to uphold
- 56:02slavery of human beings. I mean, I don't understand how any human can
- 56:08hold on to that as a point of pride. You know, my ancestors
- 56:15fought to systematically enslave a race, you know, an ethnicity of people.
- 56:23You know, Like I just I can't imagine how that could be something you
- 56:30would hold on to. It. Just it just shows you how motivated reasoning,
- 56:36you know, it can be so strong because you know, people in
- 56:39the South have just as much empathy for human beings as anybody else, So
- 56:43how could they think that way? Right? Well, because you really want
- 56:49to you know, you have this internal need to have pride because your your
- 56:52narrative is such that if the South is cool, then I'm cool. And
- 56:58if the South is a bad, bad place, you know, with a
- 57:00bad history, that I'm a bad person. But you know it doesn't have
- 57:05to be that way. You can all of us, all Americans, are
- 57:07guilty of our American history. I mean, we're all guilty of the slavery
- 57:13issue, not just the South, the entire United States is I mean,
- 57:15so we can all share in that shame. The Confederate. The Confederacy was
- 57:22just the last group that was really holding on to that particular form of racism.
- 57:28And again it's not even racism is still alive and strong, you know
- 57:31across the United States. Why in the world am I talking about this right
- 57:37now? I'm talking about it because Baylon great Joy was holding on to this
- 57:44three hundred year old grudge and that's why he did not join up with Rob
- 57:49Stark. And that is why, uh And if only he had, If
- 57:53only Baylon had listened to the on and joined up with Rob Stark, this
- 57:59whole story would have played out differently and everyone would have won. But of
- 58:02course the books would not have been as interesting. Right. All right,
- 58:06let's take a break before I go on another random jag, and when I
- 58:10get back, we'll continue with the story in the analysis of Theon Great Joy.
- 58:21Okay, we're back from the break again. If you haven't become a
- 58:24patron of the podcast, do so by going to patreon dot com. That's
- 58:29patreon dot com. Become a patron of the podcast. That is the best
- 58:34thing you can do to make us feel like we're loved here at Psychology in
- 58:37Seattle. Okay, So we left off with Baylon and Theon having a conversation.
- 58:45Theon is like, come on, join rob and we can rule the
- 58:47world. And Baylon is looking Theon up and down. He hasn't seen Theon
- 58:52in nine years. And Baylon says to Theon, Bailon, this is from
- 59:01the books. Uh. He says, my daughter has taken an axe for
- 59:07a lover. I will not have my son but deck himself like a whore.
- 59:13It is as I feared. The greenlands have made you soft and the
- 59:19Starks have made you theirs. And Theon says, you're wrong, ned Stark
- 59:24was my jailer, but my blood is still salt and iron. So this
- 59:30is a great little exchange here, he's I'd love to So this is the
- 59:35genius of George Martin because they're talking in a cultural code. But you understand
- 59:42it, right. He says, the green lands have made you soft.
- 59:46So just that little line there, it's such a it's a another a less
- 59:54good author would write something like, you know, the Starks have made you
- 1:00:01soft, but instead he says the green lands have made you soft because it
- 1:00:07it gives you so much context in that because the Iron Islands there's no there's
- 1:00:15I don't think there's anything green on these islands. And that's how they see
- 1:00:22because winterfill. You wouldn't call it the green lands because it's it's mostly tundra,
- 1:00:28right, it's cold, cold lands, But to them it's the green
- 1:00:31lands. And he's just like, you know, the Iron Islands are where
- 1:00:36tough you you know, you become tough by living on the Iron Islands,
- 1:00:39and the green lands have made you soft, and the Starks have made you
- 1:00:44theirs. And Theon says, no, ned Stark was my jailer, but
- 1:00:49my blood is still salt and iron. So Theon's giving his best shot,
- 1:00:55but Baylon is not having it because he's looking at Theon and going. You
- 1:01:00know, you're a soft boy, and just as I worried, the Starks
- 1:01:07have made you into a Stark and you're no longer a great Joy. Baylon
- 1:01:13rejects Rob's offer of allegiance. Baylon tells Theon that he's actually gonna invade the
- 1:01:19North. So not only so, Baylon's like Theon, my son, not
- 1:01:23only am I not going to join Rob, but I'm actually gonna attack him
- 1:01:28while he is weak in the North, while Rob and as Bannerman are off
- 1:01:31fighting in this you know, further south, I'm going to attack the North
- 1:01:36because I'm still pissed off about this, you know, three hundred year old
- 1:01:42grudge. And Theon is now in this weird position. He's like, so,
- 1:01:46I was basically Rob's brother in arms. I come here to, you
- 1:01:52know, join our families together. And now not only is my father my
- 1:01:57father not joining, but he's going to attack Rob. So but surely I
- 1:02:02wouldn't go back to Rob because I'm a I'm a I'm a great I'm a
- 1:02:07great Joy. I'm I'm heir to the to the throne in in the Iron
- 1:02:14Islands. And so now I have to join a force that is going to
- 1:02:20start attacking the lands that I used to live. It's this crazy position.
- 1:02:24And Theon is given a minor position in the military. He's not even given
- 1:02:30a ruling position. He's captain of the Sea Bitch. That's that one tiny
- 1:02:37little boat, the Sea Bitch. Theon meets his sister Asha and the TV
- 1:02:43show. Her name is Yara because there is a previous character Osha, the
- 1:02:49wildlying Osha, and so they didn't want to confuse Asha with Osha, so
- 1:02:53they named they changed Ash's name to Yarra. But Theon doesn't recognize Asha because
- 1:03:01you know, they're both a lot older now. But Asha knows that Theon
- 1:03:07is Theon because he introduces himself as the young but Asha doesn't introduce herself fully
- 1:03:10at first, and they start to flirt with each other just like they did
- 1:03:15in the TV show, and Asha later reveals herself as his sister, and
- 1:03:22she you know, says she basically indicates that he was only flirting with him
- 1:03:27to make fun of him. Asha says, this is a conversation between Asha
- 1:03:32and Theon at this time. Asha says, ten years a wolf and you
- 1:03:37land here and think to and and think to Prince about the islands again.
- 1:03:43This this cultural way of talking. Just love it. You land here and
- 1:03:46think to Prince about the islands, but you know nothing and no one.
- 1:03:52Why should men fight and die for you? Theon says, I am their
- 1:03:58lawful prince replies, but the laws of the Greenlands you might be. Oh,
- 1:04:03sorry, by the laws of the Greenlands, you might be. But
- 1:04:09we make our own laws here or have you forgotten? So here we see
- 1:04:15that Theon doesn't really understand his homeland because in the Greenlands in Winterfell, if
- 1:04:24you're the lawful prince, then people have to respect you. But in the
- 1:04:30Iron Islands that doesn't mean anything. You have to earn people's respect, and
- 1:04:34they make their own laws. They're extremely independently minded, which makes it much
- 1:04:41harder for them to deal with the fact that they have to bend the need
- 1:04:44to the king and King's landing. Also just dipping into a TV show here
- 1:04:49a little bit, because the TV show sort of dramatizes the confrontation between Theon
- 1:04:57and his father. He says, he says, you act as if so
- 1:05:03this is Theon yelling at his father. So Theon's yelling at Baylon. You
- 1:05:10act as if I volunteered to go. You gave me away. If you
- 1:05:14remember the day you bent the need to the day you bent the need to
- 1:05:18Robert Brathian after he crushed you, did you take what what was yours then?
- 1:05:27So you know, Baylon is like, you know, we take what
- 1:05:31we want, we don't, you know, blah blah blah, and Theon's
- 1:05:35like, uh so, just to remind you when when Robert Brathian crushed you,
- 1:05:42did you take what you want? Then? Know in fact he took
- 1:05:45your son from you? And Baylon slaps Theon and the TV show this point,
- 1:05:49and Theon continues, you gave me away, your boy, your last
- 1:05:54boy. You gave me away like it was some dog you didn't want anymore.
- 1:05:58And now you curse me because I've come home. So we see here
- 1:06:02Theon's inner struggle coming out in terms of feeling rejected by his father, which
- 1:06:09I guess I hadn't thought about till just hearing this line. Is not only
- 1:06:14would Theon, as a ten year old, feel terrified that the enemy has
- 1:06:18kidnapped him and take and taken him for a hostage and a prisoner, but
- 1:06:26children, even when their parents are well meaning children, will often take this
- 1:06:33as meaning that their parents didn't want them right. It's so even if Baylon
- 1:06:41resisted as best as he could theon being taken away from him, theon could
- 1:06:46have definitely felt as though Baylon just didn't care, especially if Baylon was a
- 1:06:51little stand office to begin with as a parent. And so that's a further
- 1:06:59injury to the attachment. Is like, well, you know, my family
- 1:07:01just just threw me away. You know they didn't. They just gave me
- 1:07:04away like a dog. It just didn't matter to them. When I talk
- 1:07:10with kids in my practice, I'm continually reminded about how children do not understand
- 1:07:17how the world works because they're kids, you know, they're young. I'll
- 1:07:21never forget this. One time I was talking to this to this kid.
- 1:07:26He was, you know, he's eight or nine years old, and this
- 1:07:30was a couple of years after his parents had divorced, and I was asking
- 1:07:35him how he felt about the divorce and all this kind of stuff and he
- 1:07:40and he looked at me straight in the eye and he said, well,
- 1:07:42you know, the reason why my parents divorced is because it's my fault.
- 1:07:45It's it's all. It's my fault. And I was like, oh,
- 1:07:48what do you mean, how is it your fault? He said, well,
- 1:07:53this one day, my dad asked me to mold the lawn and or
- 1:07:57do some chore, some big chore. It wasn't a little towards a big
- 1:08:00jar, like mowing the lawn. He said, my dad told me to
- 1:08:03mow the lawn today, and I told him that I would do it later,
- 1:08:09and I put it off, and I put it off, and I
- 1:08:12didn't do it. And then later that night, my dad came downstairs and
- 1:08:17told all of us that he was moving out and that our parents were getting
- 1:08:21a divorce. And it's all because I didn't mow the lawn that day.
- 1:08:27And doesn't that just break your heart? It just breaks your heart to think
- 1:08:30that a child would blame themselves for something like that, because kids don't understand
- 1:08:35how marital relationships work, or at least they shouldn't understand how marital relationships work,
- 1:08:42and they don't necessarily see all this subtle conflict that's happening. And so
- 1:08:48in his world, he was looking for a reason as to why something happened.
- 1:08:51And he's like, well, when I'm a bad boy, bad things
- 1:08:56happened. And I was a bad boy that day, and the world punished
- 1:09:00me because by having my dad move out and having my parents divorced, which
- 1:09:03was like this really terrible thing. And so Theon could absolutely, at the
- 1:09:09age of ten, thought I'm a bad person, I'm unworthy, I'm unlovable,
- 1:09:13and that's why my dad sent me away, when in fact Baylon might
- 1:09:16have had no choice. I'm guessing that's the case, is that Edward forced
- 1:09:23Baylon to give his child over. So Theon in the TV show anyway,
- 1:09:30reveals that he felt really rejected by Theon being sent away. Okay, so
- 1:09:38Baylon says, not only I'm not going to join rob, but I'm actually
- 1:09:41going to attack and Theon. You're going to be a minor player in this
- 1:09:44because I don't respect you. And so Theon is given the captain of the
- 1:09:49Sea Bitch, and Theon engages in the war against the North and he raids
- 1:09:58several villages. In the books, they don't to pick this in the in
- 1:10:01the TV show because in the TV show they're trying to make Theon likable.
- 1:10:08And if you if you read the books, Theon is as many people are
- 1:10:14in the books, just way more terrible in the in the books than they
- 1:10:17are in the TV show, if you can imagine that. But anyway,
- 1:10:20So theon at this point is going full he's going full ironborn at this point.
- 1:10:28His but his men don't respect him because he hasn't earned their respect and
- 1:10:32he has difficulty controlling them. And to gain the respect of his men,
- 1:10:40to show he's you know, he's trying to show his men that he's a
- 1:10:43tough guy, he is advised to drown a bunch of captives. So people
- 1:10:50are like, hey, if you want to earn the respect of your men,
- 1:10:54you'd probably take all these captives. And the captives are just these village,
- 1:10:58you know, peasant people, and he's like, okay, I'll drown
- 1:11:01these people. So he drowns them all and is completely ruthless in this way,
- 1:11:08which I just want to pause and say that this is more trauma for
- 1:11:13him. Not only has he experienced a lot of really difficult traumatic situations in
- 1:11:17his life, but when you are responsible for killing people or just when you
- 1:11:21witness people dying, it's a it's a trauma to the brain. Not for
- 1:11:27everybody, but for many people and for many situations. Many situations like for
- 1:11:32instance, I've accidentally seen videos on live leak Live leak that you know,
- 1:11:40the other YouTube I've accidentally seen videos of people dying, people getting shot in
- 1:11:46this sort of thing. You know. I'll click on a link and I'll
- 1:11:49think like, I'm just curious, and I'll be like, oh, I
- 1:11:53wonder what I'm going to see, and then I see just this horrible,
- 1:11:56horrible video. And it's happened a handful of times. Every single one of
- 1:12:00those times have been burnt into my brain, like the way images used to
- 1:12:04get burnt into an old CRT screen back in the old computer days. Those
- 1:12:11our brains are designed to take notice of those kinds of things, and so
- 1:12:15when we kill people or when we witness death, it also gets burnt into
- 1:12:21our brain, even though we're not the ones that are threatened. But the
- 1:12:27notion that human beings can be arbitrarily killed by people is an indirect threat to
- 1:12:33us, even when we're the ones who are doing the violence, and so
- 1:12:39we will absolutely be traumatized by this. So for theon, when he's raiding
- 1:12:45these villages and raping and killing all these people, it's it's not doing good
- 1:12:50things for his brain. And this doesn't make him soft. This is normal
- 1:12:56for everyone. The one thing that they I wish that they would depict better
- 1:13:00in TV and movies, which I suppose would make it kind of boring.
- 1:13:02But the most movies, most TV shows, when people are killed, no
- 1:13:11one really reacts to it, especially if they're if they're just sort of like
- 1:13:15extras that are being killed. But the way real people react to that is
- 1:13:20very different. Take it from me, when when we see even a random
- 1:13:25person, even someone that we don't like, even if it's the enemy.
- 1:13:30You know, you're in World War two and you're a British soldier and you
- 1:13:34kill a Nazi, Well, the Nazis are the enemy, but you can
- 1:13:40absolutely be traumatized by killing that Nazi as a British soldier, even though they're
- 1:13:44on the other side. So that's something that they just don't show enough of
- 1:13:48because it's a real thing and it's very common and a lot of the people,
- 1:13:57you know, the war stories that people talk about. You know,
- 1:14:00I think we're sympathetic or culturally we understand that if you see like your brother
- 1:14:04in arms being killed right before your eyes, we understand that that's traumatic.
- 1:14:09But another traumatic thing is when you pull a trigger and blow someone's head off.
- 1:14:13That's that's a traumatic thing to happen to you, and that gets burnt
- 1:14:16into your brain, and it is not it's not a healthy thing to have
- 1:14:21that burnt into your brain. So this is a major turning point in Theon's
- 1:14:26development in terms of his character and in terms of his maturity. He's really
- 1:14:31stuck between a rock and a hard place. Does he choose at this point
- 1:14:38to be loyal to Rob and turn against his family and run from his family
- 1:14:44and run to Rob? Does he? Does he choose to be you know,
- 1:14:49disloyal to his father and basically renounce his house. He's heir to house
- 1:15:00uh grade Joy. He's you know, that's a big deal. Does And
- 1:15:04if he if he goes to Rob, then he's basically throwing all that away
- 1:15:10and he'll always be a second rate citizen to the Starks if he runs to
- 1:15:15the Starks, or he can be loyal to the to his family to the
- 1:15:19grade Joys and secure his or try to secure his seat as the heir to
- 1:15:27to the grade Joy house. But by doing this he has to completely betray
- 1:15:31the Starks, the honorable ed Ard, the honorable Rob Stark. And if
- 1:15:39he does this then he might gain approval from his family, but he might
- 1:15:43not. So this is you know, this is a this is an impossible
- 1:15:48choice to make. He's damned if he does, damned if he doesn't.
- 1:15:51In the TV show, there's this conversation about this between Theon and Master Lewin.
- 1:15:57When Theon invades winter there's this conversation. Lewin says, Lord Stark went
- 1:16:03out of his way to make it your home. So Master Lewin is like
- 1:16:10Edward went out of his way to make you feel welcome in his home,
- 1:16:15And Theon says, yes, I know, my captors were so very kind
- 1:16:18to me. You love reminding me of that. Everybody in this frozen pile
- 1:16:24of shit has loved, has loved to remind me of that. You know
- 1:16:29what it's like to be told how lucky you are that you are someone's prisoner,
- 1:16:33to be told how much you owe them, and then to go back
- 1:16:38home to your real father, blah blah. So we see that Theon,
- 1:16:43you know, he's he's a very conflicted man. All right, Well,
- 1:16:49we all know that Theon decides to be loyal to his family and he invades
- 1:16:54Winterfell, even though his father said to not invade Winterfell. He disobey his
- 1:17:00father, presumably to impress his father that he could, you know, take
- 1:17:03the seat of power in the north, and also presumably to get some sort
- 1:17:10of revenge for being held captive and being made to feel like a second rate
- 1:17:14citizen. So he he invades Winterfil. Theon captures NFL because everyone's fighting in
- 1:17:21the south. Theon takes Bran and Rickon hostage and declares himself Prince of Winterfil.
- 1:17:30And he starts acting like a dick because he's always been a dick.
- 1:17:35And two he's trying to impress his men so he can gain power in his
- 1:17:40house. You know, he's learned, Oh boy, in order I can't
- 1:17:44just say that I'm heir to house a great joy and get respect, I
- 1:17:48have to actually be ruthless in order to get respect. So he starts being
- 1:17:54a jerk to a lot of different people and killing a lot of people.
- 1:17:59He free, he meets this guy named Reek in the castle's dungeon and takes
- 1:18:04him into a service. So, you know, Theon takes over Winterfell and
- 1:18:10he goes into the dungeon and there's this there's this guy in there named Reek,
- 1:18:14and any enemy of your enemy is your is your ally right? So
- 1:18:18he's like, well, anyone in the anyone who is being imprisoned by the
- 1:18:23Starks must be a friend of mine. And who's this Greek character, Well,
- 1:18:27he's probably a good guy. Well this is actually Ramsey Snow. So
- 1:18:30we have to back up here a little bit here. So recently before Theon
- 1:18:39invaded Winterfel, Sir Roderick Cassel, the Master of Arms at Winterfel, he
- 1:18:45went to go find Ramsey because Ramsey was his reputation was well known, and
- 1:18:55there were lots of accounts of Ramsey committing all these really terrible crimes. So
- 1:19:00this is before Ramsey has any power, and he's just Ruth Bolton's bastard son.
- 1:19:04And Ramsey is running around the North killing and raping and doing all these
- 1:19:09terribly sadistic things. And so Sir Rodrick Cassell rides off to find Ramsey.
- 1:19:16Rodrick's party comes across Ramsey shortly after after Ramsey had raped and killed a peasant
- 1:19:24girl. So Ramsey just randomly finds his peasant girl, he rapes her and
- 1:19:32then kills her. And then in the books, this is in the books,
- 1:19:39Ramsey has has this servant boy named Rieke. So Reek was an actual
- 1:19:45person in the books, and Ramsey had had this servant boy named Riq,
- 1:19:49and he Reeked his real name was Heekh, but everyone called him Riek because
- 1:19:55he reeked so bad. And so Ramsey had had this you know, servant
- 1:20:00boy named Rieke, and Rieke was also a sadistic terrible person too, and
- 1:20:04Ramsey and Reeke did all these terrible things. Well after Ramsey raped and killed
- 1:20:10this girl, Rieke was raping the dead body of this girl, so trigger
- 1:20:15alert. When Ramsey spots Sir Roderick's men approaching, Ramsey realizes that both of
- 1:20:24them are not going to be able to escape. So Ramsey, in an
- 1:20:29attempt to hide his true identity, he pulls Riek off the dead body and
- 1:20:34gives Reek his close So Ramsey says, Drake, let's switch close, and
- 1:20:41you know, let's switch all over close, and Reek's like, oh okay,
- 1:20:45And Ramsey tells Rieke to ride off. And Rieke has learned over the
- 1:20:51years not to question Ramsey because Ramsey is even more of a sadistic terrible person
- 1:20:57than Reek is. Soreeke puts on Ramsey He's closed and rides off, and
- 1:21:01as Ramsey expected, Sir Roderick's men chase down Reek. They think Greek is
- 1:21:09Ramsey and they kill him. The dead girl so spoiler alert here, the
- 1:21:15dead girl had soiled herself before she died. So while Reek is being killed
- 1:21:23by Roderick and those guys, Ramsey dresses up as Reek and smears her pooh
- 1:21:30on himself to make him seem like he's Reek and not Ramsey. And when
- 1:21:36Roderick's men come back, they think Ramsey is Reek and they make him a
- 1:21:41prisoner at Winterfill. Roderick wants to kill Reek, but Roderick needed Rieke to
- 1:21:47be alive as a witness to Ramsey's crimes because when rus Bolton hears that Ramsey
- 1:21:54was killed, they need a witness to say, look, we killed Ramsey.
- 1:21:59You know, Rus, we killed your son because he was doing all
- 1:22:01these terrible things, and we have this witness here to tell us that.
- 1:22:04Well, that's why they kept Riek alive. They didn't realize that Reek was
- 1:22:08actually Ramsey. So when Theon gray Joy takes Winterfell, his men find Ramsey
- 1:22:15in the in the dungeons and they and Ramsey is posing as Reek, and
- 1:22:25Theon releases Ramsey in exchange for a vow of service to Theon. So he's
- 1:22:30like, I'll release you know, Theon says, I'll release you from the
- 1:22:32Dungeons. Only if you serve me Theon, and and Reeke says yes,
- 1:22:36yes, I will serve you. And Rieke slash Ramsey quickly becomes one of
- 1:22:42Theon's more trusted attendants. He helps Theon hunt the escaped brand and Rickon Stark
- 1:22:49back to Winterfell. He helps Theon cover up the fact that the Stark boys
- 1:22:55escaped by killing two peasant boys who were similar in age to the Stark boys,
- 1:22:59and then Theon flayed the corpses to avoid recognition so no one would know
- 1:23:05that the Stark boys got away. Because Theon is terrified that people will learn
- 1:23:11that he can't hold on to these two boys and then none of us men
- 1:23:15will respect him, so he, you know, Reek slash Ramsey helps him
- 1:23:18cover that up. Theon then approves Ramsey Slash Reek killing three of Theon's men
- 1:23:26who knew the truth about the bodies, so three of Theon's men had to
- 1:23:30be killed to the cover up. Theon then uses the Winterfell kennel master as
- 1:23:39a scapegoat and has him executed for the murders of Theon's men. Theon contemplates
- 1:23:44killing Reek slash Ramsey, but he fears that Reek slash. Ramsey has written
- 1:23:49and hidden an account of the truth, so about you know, the Stark
- 1:23:55Boys. So he doesn't kill him yet. So in this instance we see
- 1:23:59Theon is, you know, going full asshole at this point. You know,
- 1:24:02he's just he's I suspect he's desperately trying to be as ruthless as he
- 1:24:09cans to gain the respect of his men. And we can see that it's
- 1:24:15hard to like Theon at this point. He's he's he's nearly as bad as
- 1:24:19Ramsey. Really, I mean, no one is nearly as bad as Ramsey.
- 1:24:24But you know, Theon's given it his best shot. So Theon is
- 1:24:28in charge of Winterfell. But soon the stark Men, the north Men,
- 1:24:32the good guys, they start marching toward Winterfell to take it back from Theon
- 1:24:38and his men, and Theon reaches out to his sister Asha for help,
- 1:24:45and she arrives at Winterfell, and she tells Theon that the Ironborn will never
- 1:24:50succeed in holding a landlocked castle like Winterfell. She's like, you know,
- 1:24:58we're people of the sea. We don't we don't sit in castles and defend
- 1:25:01them. You know, we're people of the sea. And if this castle
- 1:25:04was on the sea. We might be able to defend it with our navy,
- 1:25:08but but we're not. And so I don't know why you even did
- 1:25:12this, because there's really no point. And so Asha leaves Theon and Winterfell,
- 1:25:18and Ashes says Theon, you know you you're an idiot for invading Winterfel.
- 1:25:25I understand you're trying to impress everyone, but it's not impressive because you
- 1:25:29clearly don't understand our ways. So let's put this to rest and come with
- 1:25:33me. And Theon becomes enraged. He finally achieves something worthy and no one
- 1:25:42is congratulating him. He considers it to be this, you know, humongous
- 1:25:45achievement, and you know it sort of is to take Winterfell, right,
- 1:25:48and nobody is appreciating how big of a deal this is. And Asha leaves
- 1:25:56and Theon stays because he's prideful and he wants to prove himself somehow. He
- 1:26:03should have just gone with Asha, but he didn't, and instead he stays
- 1:26:09in winter Fell and he's thinking, you know, maybe there's a way I
- 1:26:12can pull this out. Well, I need reinforcements. So Reek Slash Ramsey
- 1:26:15says, I'll go get reinforcements. For you, and so Theon sends Reek
- 1:26:18out to get reinforcements. Ramsey is allowed to leave winter Fell, and Ramsey's
- 1:26:26like, ah, I'm free once again. Now. Something that's not portrayed
- 1:26:30in the TV show is that not only was Theon much more of a dick,
- 1:26:36but he also had, you know, as I was saying earlier,
- 1:26:40like a very Ramsey you know, dark streak to him. For example,
- 1:26:45during this time, Theon is really you know, starting to head downhill.
- 1:26:50He's just like, crap, I'm in Winterfell. I'm sort of sort of
- 1:26:55digging myself in here. My family has turned on me. I don't have
- 1:27:00that many men. My men don't even really respect me. The good guys
- 1:27:03are coming, you know, I'm dead. And Theon is getting very stressed
- 1:27:08out and so he he brutally rapes a tavern girl. He you know,
- 1:27:17he gets this tavern girl and he sends for her and he's like, bring
- 1:27:20that tavern wench to my bed as a as a bed warmer. And then
- 1:27:26one night he's really stressed out and he brutally rapes her just for no reason.
- 1:27:30I mean, there's really no reason to rape anybody, but you know,
- 1:27:34and they describe it and in the end, this this girl, she's
- 1:27:39she's sobbing and crying and her and her neck and her breasts are covered with
- 1:27:45bruises and bite marks. So imagine that, and instead of feeling bad about
- 1:27:51it, he he shoves her from the bed and tells her to get out.
- 1:27:58So, for those of you that just watched the TV show, you're
- 1:28:02like, oh, Theon is this? You know, he's a good kid,
- 1:28:04He's just you know, a little misguided. Well, George Martin writes
- 1:28:09this scene in the in the book, and we see that that Theon is,
- 1:28:14you know, he's just a he's just a smaller version of Ramsey.
- 1:28:16He's a terrible, terrible human being. And so the TV version of Theon
- 1:28:26is, you know, at least somewhat likable. The book version of Theon
- 1:28:30I don't know. So, as Theon is freaking out about being killed by
- 1:28:35the good guys, master Lewin, who's still alive at this point, he
- 1:28:40convinces Theon to join the Knight's Watch, and Rieke returns, Ramsey reveals himself
- 1:28:49and by the way, you know, so, so at this point Theon
- 1:28:54is is seriously contemplating joining the knights Watch. He's like, maybe that's my
- 1:28:58way out. That's the thing. You know, if you know the story
- 1:29:01about the Knight's Watch, you know that you can join them. You can
- 1:29:05take the Black and all of your previous sins are basically forgiven. But you
- 1:29:12have to always be at the Knight's Watch for the rest of your days.
- 1:29:15You can never have a wife, and you're stuck in the cold. So
- 1:29:18it's sort of like the you know, the society needs a group of men
- 1:29:24to man the wall, but no one wants to do it, and so
- 1:29:29the only people who who go there are people who are kind of running away
- 1:29:32from something, and so Theonis is, you know, considering that, but
- 1:29:38he's also like, well, john Snow's up there, and you know,
- 1:29:41Johnson is going to kill me because he thinks that I killed his brothers and
- 1:29:46I, you know, killed all these people at Winterfell and so babwa anyway,
- 1:29:49but Rieke returns, Ramsey reveals himself. Ramsey tricks the good guys,
- 1:29:55the Stark Bannerman and slaughters them as Theon attempts to think Reek, Greek reveals
- 1:30:04himself as Ramsey Snow and says, I'm not Riek, I'm Ramsey, and
- 1:30:11I'm here. I'm not here to help you. I'm here to win the
- 1:30:15day and to take over Winterfell. And Ramsey hits Theon in the face and
- 1:30:18shatters his cheekbone, and Ramsey orders his men to set Winterfel Winterfel ablaze.
- 1:30:28So when Theon took Winterfell, he just wanted to take it over, But
- 1:30:32when Ramsey took it over, he wanted to burn it to the ground.
- 1:30:36And so Ramsey sets off to He doesn't burn it to the ground, but
- 1:30:42you know, he catches a lot of things on fire, and he starts
- 1:30:43slaughtering all these people, including maser Lewin. I believe Theon's father, Baylon,
- 1:30:50falls to his death and Pike e skiving me forward the story the Red
- 1:30:56Wedding happens. Rob dies. Theon thought after he found out about the Red
- 1:31:01Wedding, He's he thought I should have been there with him? Where was
- 1:31:06I? I should have died with him, meaning that Theon thought he should
- 1:31:11have died with Rob. I thought, I find this to be, you
- 1:31:13know, a real sweet kind of moment for Theon. He's just like,
- 1:31:16you know, my poor brother Rob, the good boy. Rob gets slaughtered
- 1:31:21by the bulletins and the phrase, and I, you know, I should
- 1:31:27have been there with him. I should have been I should have died with
- 1:31:29him. That would have been a good way to go, I think,
- 1:31:31is what Theon thought, especially as he is being tortured by Ramsey. All
- 1:31:39right, well, let's take a break and we get back. Let's start
- 1:31:42to go into the downfall of Theon. Okay, we're back. So this
- 1:31:54this begins the horrible chapter of Theon's life. But before we get into that,
- 1:32:00we shall also mention that in the in the books, Uron Great Joy,
- 1:32:04Theon's uncle, he claims the Sea Stone Chair after Baylon dies. The
- 1:32:10Sea Stone Chair, that's the throne of of the Iron Islands. Some lord,
- 1:32:16some one of the Iron Born says that Theon is the rightful heir to
- 1:32:21the throne, and Uron says, fuck that ship, and he drowns the
- 1:32:27guy for saying this. The King's moot is called to see who will be
- 1:32:31the King of Pike, and Uron has decided he'll be the King of Pike.
- 1:32:39This is kind of jumbled up in the TV show. Theon isn't actually
- 1:32:43there in the in the books the way that he is in the In the
- 1:32:49TV show, Asha comes back to Winterfell to find Theon, but she can't
- 1:32:55find him, and she can't tell if he's dead because there are many dead
- 1:32:59bodies, you know, a lot of bodies are burnt and eaten by the
- 1:33:02wolves after Ramsey you know, went through there. But so at this point
- 1:33:09in the books, we actually don't have we don't hear a lot from Theon.
- 1:33:15After Theon gets captured by Ramsey, Theon kind of disappears from the books
- 1:33:21for a while. But we later learn in the books that Ramsey has been
- 1:33:27torturing Theon this entire time, and it's ongoing terrible torture. Ramsey and his
- 1:33:33Bastards Boys. This is something they don't have in the TV show. He
- 1:33:36had, he had this group because Ramsey was a bastard, right, Ramsey
- 1:33:41had this group. So this group of boys called Bastards Boys, that he
- 1:33:45you know, used as his own personal kind of SS troops or something.
- 1:33:50And Ramsey and the Bastard Boys, they tortured Theon over and over again.
- 1:33:57One of the things they did to Theon is they removed his skin on Theon's
- 1:34:00toes and fingers. They don't show this at the TV show. They removed
- 1:34:04the skin on his toes and fingers. And from what I understand, this
- 1:34:10is an incredibly painful situation. And so after a while, you know,
- 1:34:15days of this, Theon begs Ramsey to cut off his fingers and his toes
- 1:34:20to stop the pain. And they, you know, wait a few days
- 1:34:24and they say, okay, let's cut off his fingers and his toes.
- 1:34:28So he also hates Theon's smile. So remember how Theon has that smirk that
- 1:34:35everyone notices. Well, Ramsey really really hates Theon's smile. So he decides
- 1:34:42he's going to you know, break his teeth out of his mouth. So
- 1:34:47he he pulls or breaks or you know, maimes his face so that a
- 1:34:53lot of his teeth come out. And it's also implied that Ramsey cuts off
- 1:34:59his penis. Ramsey makes Theon change his name to Reek. Theon is forbidden
- 1:35:04to bathe, and Theon is you know, spread with filth, and he's
- 1:35:10just super gross. And in the book they talk about how Theon looks like
- 1:35:15he's aged forty years. He looks like a sixty year old man. He
- 1:35:19doesn't have much of his teeth left, and the teeth he does have left
- 1:35:24are all kind of loose and raggedy. Theon has lost a lot of weight,
- 1:35:29like a third of his weight or something, and he was already lean
- 1:35:31to begin with, but he looks like really bony now. His hair has
- 1:35:36turned white, which is interesting, he has white hair. In the books.
- 1:35:43He only has a few of his fingers and a few of his toes,
- 1:35:45and he hobbles when he walks. They you know, they really don't
- 1:35:49show this in the TV show because basically in the TV show he looks exactly
- 1:35:56the same after tortured as before. But in the books he is a he's
- 1:36:02a broken man inside and outside. He just like his sister doesn't even recognize
- 1:36:08him later on. And I think this is a more powerful point that's being
- 1:36:15made in the books. You know, anyway, in the TV show also
- 1:36:20we see a lot of scenes in which Theon is being tortured. But in
- 1:36:24the books, Theon does not appear at all in the third and fourth novels
- 1:36:29as a narrator, and he's barely mentioned by other people. Theon's torture by
- 1:36:34Ramsey is revealed in a series of flashbacks throughout the fifth novel. So,
- 1:36:40as I was saying, as soon as as soon as Theon is captured by
- 1:36:44Ramsey, we don't even hear about him for two entire novels, and we
- 1:36:48wonder is he dead? You know, it's just there's all these question marks.
- 1:36:53So he shows up in the fifth novel as Reek, and so so
- 1:37:00we where we leave. So in the second novel, we leave Theon as
- 1:37:05he is just you know, he's at the top of his game, and
- 1:37:09then Ramsey thwarts him and then we don't hear about him for two bucks.
- 1:37:14And then in the fifth book we are introduced to this to this Reek character
- 1:37:20and he's this terrible, emaciated, toothless, fingerless, toeless, you know,
- 1:37:28weirdo. And then it comes out, Oh, that's Theon. You
- 1:37:30know, it's this, it's this crazy reveal in book five. You're just
- 1:37:34like, wait, what has happened to Theon? You're just like, how
- 1:37:40did we get from where we last saw him to now? And then in
- 1:37:44the fifth book they do all these flashbacks to all these torture and all these
- 1:37:48you know, breaking down of his personality into this Reek character, and you're
- 1:37:53just like, oh, I see how we got here. Ruth Bolton asks
- 1:37:58Ramsey to take Mote Kylin back from the Iron Born, and Ramsey cleans up.
- 1:38:04So Ramsey's like, okay, well, how am I gonna, you
- 1:38:06know, take back Mote Calen. How am I going to do that?
- 1:38:10From the Ironborn? Well, what if I trick them? Because I'm Ramsey
- 1:38:13and I'm super sneaky like that. So Ramsey cleans up Theon and makes them
- 1:38:18look like a prince again, and Ramsey makes Theon go to the iron Born
- 1:38:26and Mote Caylen to convince the Ironborn. This is all depicted in the TV
- 1:38:29show too, so he sends Theon into Mote Caylen to convince the Ironborn,
- 1:38:34convinces people to surrender in exchange for their lives. Ramsey promises food and safe
- 1:38:42passage to the sick and starving if they surrender, and the iron Born are
- 1:38:47like, well, we're gonna die either way. So we're going to die
- 1:38:51if we stay, because you know we're surviving, but not for long.
- 1:38:56And so the iron Born fine, well, well, if our if our
- 1:39:00prince, Theon is here, then sure, okay, we'll surrender. But
- 1:39:03then Ramsey, like he always does, he read eggs on his promise and
- 1:39:08he has them all played alive, and as a reward, Theon is allowed
- 1:39:13to sleep with Ramsey's dogs. Theon is there when Ramsey is introduced to Aria
- 1:39:19Stark. So this is in the book, so this is different than this
- 1:39:24is a big difference than the TV show. So Theon so this this girl
- 1:39:30comes to Winter or to wherever they're at at this point, and these people
- 1:39:34are like, Okay, this is Aria Stark and you're in Ramsey. You're
- 1:39:38going to marry Aria Stark, and this is going to end the war in
- 1:39:42the North because you know there's going to be a Stark in control with Ramsey.
- 1:39:48But Theon is looking at this girl and he's like, that's not Aria,
- 1:39:51that's actually Jane Poole. I know, I know Jane Poole. Now
- 1:39:56in the TV show, this is Sansa, which is a better storyline in
- 1:40:00my opinion. But anyway, so in the book, Jane Poole is disguised
- 1:40:04as Aria sort of, and Jane is sent to Mary Ramsey to help end
- 1:40:10the wars in the North. So you know, if the Stark allies think
- 1:40:15that a Stark girl has married Ramsey, then they might end the war in
- 1:40:18the North. And presumably Theon is kept alive because he's the one person who
- 1:40:25can say yes, that's Aria because everyone else is dead. And Ramsey's like,
- 1:40:30well, Theon is my little slave. So surely Theon will say whatever
- 1:40:35I want him to say. And if I want him to say that Jane
- 1:40:38Poole is Aria, then he'll do that. Ramsey cuts off some of Theon's
- 1:40:44skin and sends it to Asha. Ramsey says he'll kill Theon if Fasha doesn't
- 1:40:48stop attacking the North. Also, there's evidence that Theon actually believes he is
- 1:40:55Reek, not that he is just acting like he's Reek. There's evidence that
- 1:41:00Theon, deep down actually believes he is in fact Reek because of the severe
- 1:41:08torture he went through. There's a quote from the book. Theon is saying,
- 1:41:14you know, I'm not I'm not Theon. He's saying, I'm not
- 1:41:16him, I'm not the turn Cloak. He died at Winterfell. My name
- 1:41:21is riek. It rhymes with freak. My name is riek At rhymes with
- 1:41:26freak. During the wedding between Ramsey and Jane Poole, who is disguise as
- 1:41:31Aria, Theon gives away the bride because he's the closest person. He's the
- 1:41:36he's the he's the closest kin to Aria, even though he's not actually kin.
- 1:41:41But everyone else is dead, so or presumed dead so or not around,
- 1:41:45so they're just like, well, Theon, you have to give away
- 1:41:47the bride. Several times Jane begs Theon to rescue her, but Theon is
- 1:41:54too afraid of Ramsey. The night of the wedding, as Ramsey makes Jane
- 1:42:00Poole to his bedroom, Ramsey makes Theon strip Jane's clothes off. Then Ramsey
- 1:42:06makes Theon prepared Jane to be raped by Ramsey. So this is this is
- 1:42:12all depicted in the TV show in this very brutal fashion, but instead of
- 1:42:16Jane Poole, it's Sansa. Theon admits to someone that he's always wanted to
- 1:42:23be a Stark and that he, you know, didn't want to be a
- 1:42:29great joy. So this is when a different Theon seems to be emerging somewhat.
- 1:42:35It's almost like he's being reborn, particularly in the TV show, but
- 1:42:41in the book kind of too. Theon starts praying at the Heart Tree.
- 1:42:45He visits the heart tree a number of times in the woods in the north.
- 1:42:54He says to the heart Tree, he says, please a sword,
- 1:42:58that's all I ask. Let me die as Theon, not as Reek.
- 1:43:04So he's starting to really identify with the gods in the North, and he's
- 1:43:10starting to turn to religion to help him get through these difficult times. During
- 1:43:16one visit to the Heart Tree, Theon sees Brand's face, presumably because Brand
- 1:43:21is, you know, one of the tree Face people, and he hears
- 1:43:28Bran whispering Theon, and this helps Theon regain his identity and to move away
- 1:43:35from the identity of Reek. The free Folk and Stanis are marching on Winterfell
- 1:43:42from the north, remember that whole part of the story. So Stanis joins
- 1:43:45up with mans Raider's people and at the wall and they start marching south to
- 1:43:50Winterfell. Theon grabs Jane Poole and tries to escape. In the TV show,
- 1:43:58this is when Theon kills Miranda, who is about to shoot Sansa in
- 1:44:02the leg. But that's that Miranda isn't a character in the books. The
- 1:44:08Bolton Men see or I don't think Miranda is a character anyway, that didn't
- 1:44:12happen in the books when but in the books, the Boltan Men see Theon
- 1:44:17and Jane trying to escape and the guards try to kill them. Actually Manserraider
- 1:44:23is involved in this, but anyway, Theon picks Jane pool up and he
- 1:44:30jumps off the wall. So in the in the TV show, Sansa and
- 1:44:34Theon jump off together holding hands. But in the books, you know,
- 1:44:40Jane doesn't know what to do, and Theon just picks her up and jumps
- 1:44:43off the wall, and Theon and Jane Poole land in the snow and they
- 1:44:49run to Stanis. When they get to Stanis, they realize that Asha is
- 1:44:56a prisoner of Stanis because Stanis has run into Asha as she has been attacking
- 1:45:02the North, and Stanus is like, well, we're not going to have
- 1:45:04that, and so Stanis in prisons and prisons Asha, and so Theon and
- 1:45:10Asha are reunited, and as I said earlier, Asha doesn't even recognize Theon
- 1:45:14because he looks so old and weird from all the torture he's been through.
- 1:45:20So so that's where the books end, actually, which might kind of shock
- 1:45:25you because if you've been watching the TV show, there's a lot more to
- 1:45:28the story. But yeah, that's where the books end. Theon is looking
- 1:45:32like shit, He's looking like a sixty year old emaciated man with no teeth
- 1:45:35and no fingers, you know, with only a few fingers on a few
- 1:45:39toes. And he's a prisoner of Stanis, and he's no but he's no
- 1:45:46longer under Ramsey's thumb, you know, which is definitely a good thing.
- 1:45:50And he actually managed to rescue Jane Poole, which is pretty cool. Now
- 1:45:56there's a sample chapter from The Winds of Winter from book six. George Martin
- 1:46:00released a sample chapter which might change when the actual book comes out, so
- 1:46:05this could be just like a rough draft. But we did learn a little
- 1:46:11bit more about Theon's story, not much, but a little bit. So
- 1:46:15again, Theon is a prisoner of Stanis, and Stanis questions Theon about Ramsey's
- 1:46:20army, and Theon answers all of his questions, honestly, because Theon's like,
- 1:46:26I don't care about Ramsey. I hate that guy. And Stanis plans
- 1:46:30on executing Theon because Stanis wants to placate the men in the North who want
- 1:46:36Theon dead because Theon presumably killed Brandon Rickon. But remember he didn't kill Bran
- 1:46:42and Rickon, but the people, the men in the North think that,
- 1:46:45and so the men in the North North are like Stanis, if you want
- 1:46:47us to be on your side, you have to you have to kill you
- 1:46:53have to kill Theon. Theon actually hopes that Stanis will kill him to end
- 1:46:59his suffering and to end his guilt for betraying the Starks, and to end
- 1:47:03his suffering as a broken man. But Asha pleads with Stanis to spare Theon's
- 1:47:10life. But Stanis is not really that sort of guy. He is not
- 1:47:15the sort of guy to give mercy. So when that fails, Asha asks
- 1:47:18Stanis to not burn him alive and instead just chop his head off, which
- 1:47:24is a quicker death. So that's all we know about the On from the
- 1:47:29sample chapter. It's not much more, but it seems a little bit more
- 1:47:32so in the books, it looks like Theon could be executed by Stanis.
- 1:47:39But I'm guessing that Martin will spare Theon's life because Martin loves to keep miserable,
- 1:47:45miserable people alive so we can put them through more misery. Also,
- 1:47:49the TV show presumably follows the rough outline of the story. George Martin has
- 1:47:57told the producers of the TV show, you know, here, here's a
- 1:48:00rough outline of where all the characters are going to go. And we learned
- 1:48:04in the TV show that Theon does survive all this and so it seems likely
- 1:48:11that Theon will survive. So we'll see. All right, well let's talk
- 1:48:15about the TV show, So all of this could be completely you know,
- 1:48:20not what happened in the books. I'm really curious to see what Book six
- 1:48:24is going to be like, because because this is the first time that the
- 1:48:29TV show has come out before you know, the TV has a season.
- 1:48:35Wait am I saying this right? Yeah? Season six of the TV show
- 1:48:40came out ahead of the books, right, And you know, up until
- 1:48:44season six of the TV show, all the stuff on the TV show had
- 1:48:46been already sat in the books, and George Martin had, you know,
- 1:48:53has been telling him, look, here's the rough outline. But I think
- 1:48:55the producers are like, well, you know, we might go your way
- 1:48:58or we might go our own way. And I think George Martin's like,
- 1:49:00fine, it's your TV show, do what you want. I mean,
- 1:49:02he's not that cavalier about it. But George Martin isn't being a stickler.
- 1:49:06He's like, look, you know, it's a TV show. I write
- 1:49:09the books, you make the TV show. They're related to each other.
- 1:49:13But anyway, in the TV show, Theon does a lot more stuff.
- 1:49:17Right after he and sans get out of Winterfell. They're running away in the
- 1:49:25snow, and there's this heartbreaking scene. There's this wonderful scene in which Theon
- 1:49:32and Sansa are hiding under that fallen tree and it looks like they're about to
- 1:49:39be hunted down by Ramsey's men and the dogs, and sans Stark says in
- 1:49:46the TV show, she says, when when you take the Black, all
- 1:49:50your crimes are forgiven. So Sances is trying to say, hey, you
- 1:49:55know, join the Night's Watch, and Theon says, I don't want to
- 1:49:59be forgiven. I can never make amends to your family for the things I've
- 1:50:02done. So he's He's like, I don't want to be forgiven for the
- 1:50:08things I've done. You know, the things I've done to your family,
- 1:50:13Sansa can never be forgiven. I should never be forgiven for that. Now,
- 1:50:19again, this is different than the books because Theon is exhibiting actual remorse
- 1:50:24at this point, whereas in the books it's it's definitely not so much that
- 1:50:29way, but anyway, this is the moment that I, you know,
- 1:50:34when Theon won my heart, when he became someone that I cared about.
- 1:50:40In this show, in terms of you know, he's always been an interesting
- 1:50:43character, but I always you know, every time he was on screen,
- 1:50:45I was I was just like, ah, there's theon again. But and
- 1:50:49even when he was being tortured, I'm just like, well, you know
- 1:50:51you're you deserve it. You know, you look at all this stuff you
- 1:50:55did. You know, you're terrible human being. I don't care about you.
- 1:50:58But at this point, when he saves Sansa and he's running away and
- 1:51:04he's protecting her and he's getting her away from the wolves, and she's like,
- 1:51:11Okay, you know, we'll go north to john Snow and you can
- 1:51:14come with me and you'll take the black and all will be forgiven. And
- 1:51:16Dean's like, I don't want to be forgiven because I've done terrible things.
- 1:51:23He's finally reached a point that you know, he truly empathizes with the people
- 1:51:29that he's hurt. After all he's been through, after all the torture he's
- 1:51:32been through, he still doesn't think he's been through enough. When I heard
- 1:51:38him say that, I wanted everyone to forgive him. At this point,
- 1:51:44some of Ramsey's men arrive and Theon tries to sacrifice himself to save Sansa but
- 1:51:48it doesn't work. But then Brion and Pod arrive and they say the they
- 1:51:56So I just want to comment a little bit on the psychology of what's going
- 1:52:00on here. You know, we have theon who has been abused and really
- 1:52:04his whole life, particularly in his early life. You know, when he
- 1:52:09was at the Stark, when he's at Winterfell, under at Art he was
- 1:52:13that was the good years. But as a child he was abused, and
- 1:52:15then under Ramsey he was massively abused. When you're abused, you start to
- 1:52:20believe that you deserve the abuse. And I've seen this a lot. People
- 1:52:25who are repeatedly abused. They have to make a choice. There's two different
- 1:52:30options they can choose. From one, they can choose to believe that they
- 1:52:34are being treated unfairly, which is logical, but this results in them getting
- 1:52:40angry and trying to break free, which often results in more abuse. So
- 1:52:46they have another choice though too, They can choose to see the abuse as
- 1:52:51justified. This this viewpoint makes them just give up, so they don't fight
- 1:52:59back and they accept their fate. But after they are free from the from
- 1:53:04the abuse. So I hope this makes sense. You know, if you're
- 1:53:10being repeatedly abused, particularly by your parents or by your older brothers, you
- 1:53:14can look up and you can say like, oh, okay, this is
- 1:53:16this is unfair, this is not my faults. And when you're coming from
- 1:53:20that mindset, you fight back, you try to break free, you you
- 1:53:24talk back, you try to get allies to help you. Well, if
- 1:53:28that doesn't work, as in the case of his older brothers and with Ramsey,
- 1:53:32then it doesn't do any good to fight back. It doesn't do any
- 1:53:36good to think that it's unjust. It's just it's just a weight on your
- 1:53:42back, on your mind that wait, this is unfair. Or you can
- 1:53:45adopt a different point of view where you're just like, yes, all this
- 1:53:47is fair because I'm a terrible person. And when you when you adopt that
- 1:53:53point of view, it's not a great point of view, but it's but
- 1:53:55it can work better for your life because then you just accept the fact that
- 1:53:59you're going to get beat, because you're going to get beat either way.
- 1:54:01And when you are beat, you act subservient, which actually calms people down.
- 1:54:08When you know Ramsey presumably would beat Theon less when theon was more subservient,
- 1:54:14right, and Theon's older brothers might have been the same way unknown.
- 1:54:17But the point is is that when you truly adopt a perspective on the inside
- 1:54:24that you deserve to be hurt and therefore you don't get angry and you don't
- 1:54:29fight back, then it actually makes your life easier. So you're rewarded for
- 1:54:31believing that you deserve to be punished. Well after people that make this choice
- 1:54:39to say that they deserve to be punished, you know, once they're free
- 1:54:44from the abuse as an adult, they will often seek abuse from other people
- 1:54:49or they seek out abusive people because deep down they believe that they deserve to
- 1:54:54be punished for their sins. This is what we call masochism, right,
- 1:54:59and this is why many people who grow up in abusive families will seek out
- 1:55:02abusive partners later in life. And it's just heartbreaking. It's just this double,
- 1:55:08terrible, unfair thing that happens to people. Okay, so again we're
- 1:55:13in the TV show here, Sansa and Brian decide to go to John a
- 1:55:18Castle Black, and since Theon has betrayed the Starks, Theon believes that John
- 1:55:24will kill him, which is very possible, so he decides to go a
- 1:55:28different way and he goes home to Pike. They have a king's moot,
- 1:55:33which in the books he wasn't there, but on the TV show at Theen
- 1:55:36is there. Theon nominates Yara or Asha to be queen of the Ironborn,
- 1:55:44which I don't believe happened in the books. But Uron wins the favor of
- 1:55:48the people, so Theon and Yara flee because they think Uron will kill them,
- 1:55:54which he probably will. So they go across the Narrow Sea to Valantis
- 1:56:00and all the other Ironborn are having fun and a brothel, and we see
- 1:56:03Theon just sitting there, can't you know, you can't have any fun,
- 1:56:05and he's plagued with guilt and shame. And Yara commands him to drink,
- 1:56:12and you know, it commands him to be a to be a man.
- 1:56:14So he drinks his entire cup of booze, but he doesn't seem to be
- 1:56:17enjoying it. Theon and so at this point, you know, this is
- 1:56:21all season six stuff. They really my guess is is that they know what
- 1:56:28George Martin's outline is, and when it comes to Theon and Yara and you
- 1:56:32know, Yara Slashasha, they have to They seemingly just really accelerated Theon's story
- 1:56:40to kind of get him to a certain point so that season seven can start
- 1:56:44at a certain point. So Theon and Yara are suddenly with Denari's and Marine.
- 1:56:54So normally, you know, in a in one of George Martin's book
- 1:56:57they would have Theon traveling across you know this, and there would be other
- 1:57:01adventures and stuff. But you know, suddenly they go from Volantis to Marine
- 1:57:06and and Theon and Yara are with meeting with Denaries and Tyrian is there right,
- 1:57:13And Theon and Yara become allies with Denarius and Tyrian, and Theon and
- 1:57:18Yara say that they can get a bunch of ships. So and then at
- 1:57:24the very end of season six we see we see Theon, and I believe
- 1:57:30ashes they're not sure, but we alyst see Theon is traveling back to Westros
- 1:57:35with Denaries and Tyrian and Varies and uh uh, you know, the the
- 1:57:45Iron Fleet, the doth Racki, the unsoulad Olena Terrell and her army,
- 1:57:50Ilaria sand and the Dorn Army, and of course the dragons, and so
- 1:57:55Theon is a part of the Denaris crew which is bringing together a lot of
- 1:58:00different sorts of people, which is just amazing to see Denari's finally sailing on
- 1:58:08you know, a lot of ironborn ships, but other kinds of ships to
- 1:58:12to Restros. And so this was another kind of you know, super skipping
- 1:58:15forward in the story, because the whole very story was you know, it's
- 1:58:20like varies as suddenly back with them. They've met up with the Terrells and
- 1:58:28the Dorn people, and so it's pretty amazing. So season seven, which
- 1:58:33starts in a couple of months, I can't wait for. So that's what
- 1:58:41I'll say about Theon Grayjoy. What will I say overall? Though, here's
- 1:58:45what's the final word on Theon. I I let's see, let's let's make
- 1:58:53some maybe predictions about what will happen to Theon. I think as we go
- 1:58:58into season seven and a of the of the TV show, I think,
- 1:59:03and uh, you know, this obviously could be very different from the books,
- 1:59:06but I think what we're going to see is Theon is not going to
- 1:59:11play a major role. I don't think that the way because you know,
- 1:59:16season seven and eight are just going to have like seven episodes each or something
- 1:59:19like that, and they have a lot of things that they need to work
- 1:59:25out before they get to the topic of Theon. You know, they have
- 1:59:30Denari's and the Dragons and Tyrian and Circe and John Snow and then you have
- 1:59:36you know, the Army of the Dead and all that kind of stuff,
- 1:59:40and you have I don't know, you just have a lot of different major
- 1:59:45characters and major storylines that need to be fleshed out. And I have a
- 1:59:49feeling like the episodes are because the last episodes of season six and the TV
- 1:59:55show they were more like little movies, you know, And I suspect that
- 2:00:01season six and or season seven and eight are going to be similar to that,
- 2:00:04and Theon is just gonna probably show up barely because moving forward to the
- 2:00:11story, he doesn't there's not really a big need for him in the storyline,
- 2:00:15you know, does he need to face off with anybody? Does he
- 2:00:18need you know, Bramse, He's already dead, so he can't really get
- 2:00:21revenge in that way. Sansa took care of that. So I suspect that
- 2:00:28the TV shows Theon isn't because really, where do you go with that character
- 2:00:31at that point? He's he's with Denari's. He doesn't think he is fit
- 2:00:36to rule. I suppose maybe In the end, Theon will go home and
- 2:00:41Bylon will accept him. Maybe maybe that'll be in the prologue episodes or something.
- 2:00:46Theon will return home with Asha or no, sorry, the Father's staff.
- 2:00:53Uh, yeah, that's probably what will happen. I'll probably you know,
- 2:00:56again, this is all to just be predicting things, and I'm usually
- 2:00:58wrong about this sort of stuff. But so Uron will join with Circe probably,
- 2:01:04and then Uron will be defeated, as will Circe hopefully, and then
- 2:01:12Theon and Asha will return to the Iron Islands and rule, maybe as brother
- 2:01:17and sister or something. And so that is my guess, Denaris, will
- 2:01:25you know, place them in power over there or something? Who knows,
- 2:01:30or you know, it could it could also end in a horrific, terrible
- 2:01:33way, and maybe Uron as King of west Ros or something. You know.
- 2:01:38You just never know what's going to happen in the books, however,
- 2:01:43I imagine George Martin has is going to flesh out Theon's story. I don't
- 2:01:51given the way that George Martin is writing, I don't think he's going to
- 2:01:57be able to wrap up the entire story within the next couple of books.
- 2:02:00So, uh, I could the way he's writing, I could absolutely see
- 2:02:05him having like a whole other you know, adventures in storylines for for Asha
- 2:02:13and for Theon. But you know, who knows. I guess we'll just
- 2:02:16have to find out. What can I say about Theon's psychology? In summary?
- 2:02:23I think Theon's character is an excellent case study in UH one who is
- 2:02:33forced to develop defense mechanisms of arrogance, defense mechanisms of false narcissism, defense
- 2:02:44mechanisms of always trying to prove yourself, and being in a social situation.
- 2:02:51In all, he's never in a social situation in which he's acceptable. As
- 2:02:57a young child, he was the small, weaker brother. As a teenager,
- 2:03:02he was a prisoner and a second rate citizen and would never be good
- 2:03:08enough. You know. He was the son of this asshole Baylon in the
- 2:03:12Iron Islands, and then under Ramsey he was you know, made to feel
- 2:03:16terrible. And then now he's with Stanis and he's you know, being punished
- 2:03:23for his crimes. Maybe his head's going to be lopped off, you know,
- 2:03:27he's just been bouncing around from one thing to another. But the thing
- 2:03:30we can say is that he could have made different choices. There was a
- 2:03:35time when, you know, a lot of his choices made sense looking back,
- 2:03:45until he gets home to Pike and he tells his father, look,
- 2:03:49let's join Rob, and his father's like, nope, I'm not joining Rob.
- 2:03:54In fact, I'm going to attack Rob. At that point, Theon,
- 2:03:58you know, quote unquote, has a choice. He could have ran
- 2:04:00back to Rob and said, my father's gone off the rails. I don't
- 2:04:04know what to do. I'm on your side. Da Da da. He
- 2:04:09could have done that. Now he would have died alongside Rob at the Red
- 2:04:13Wedding, but he wanted that. In the end, He's like, it
- 2:04:15would have saved me for all this torture from and humiliation from Ramsey. So
- 2:04:21it's but at the same time, you can totally understand why Theon made that
- 2:04:26choice. He is the heir to the you know, to House great Joy,
- 2:04:31and he is a grade Joy and he was never made to feel really
- 2:04:36at home at Winterfille, and so why would he run back to his captors,
- 2:04:43to his jailers. Why would he do that? So it was a
- 2:04:46really really tough choice for Theon, very very difficult choice. And then once
- 2:04:51he chooses that, he's going to try to be an ironborn. Then he's
- 2:04:57choosing a life of brutality and of of taking things from people and of disregarding
- 2:05:02human life, which he you know, jumped headfirst in because he wanted to
- 2:05:08impress his family, which led him to attacking Winterfel, which led him to
- 2:05:15acting like he had killed the Stark boys, and which led him to Ramsey,
- 2:05:21and which led him to stand I mean, you just get this sense,
- 2:05:26like, my god, this guy was just dealt like a really shitty
- 2:05:30hand, and I you know, when I talk about him this way,
- 2:05:34I just feel so bad for the guy. And of course it makes sense
- 2:05:39that he's arrogant, you know. I think the book version is much more
- 2:05:44realistic in that when you're treated this way, you have personality traits that are
- 2:05:50kind of persistent over time. And it you know, because at this point
- 2:05:55in the TV show, theon is A is a born again nice guy.
- 2:06:00Right in the TV show, he he's you know, he's talking about I
- 2:06:04would have I would have died to get Sansa to safety. He's like,
- 2:06:10he's like one of the most chivalrous person people in Game of Thrones at this
- 2:06:15point at the end of the TV show, But in real life, people
- 2:06:19don't change that that much. You know, if if if you're an arrogant
- 2:06:24prick, you'll change a little bit, but you're not gonna change drastically in
- 2:06:29that way. And so the book portrays it much more accurately, which I
- 2:06:33think is is interesting. It's just an example. It's just another example of
- 2:06:38the fact that I can do five. You know, I don't know how
- 2:06:42long this episode is a couple hours. The fact that I can, you
- 2:06:45know, do five several hours episodes on different characters and their psychology and their
- 2:06:53development and their choices and how consistent the personalities are and how their personalities makes
- 2:07:00sense given their traumas and their histories is a testament to the genius of George
- 2:07:05Martin. There's so many things that he does right. Not only does he
- 2:07:09understand humans, not only does he understand trauma and personality development, but he
- 2:07:15also writes interestingly. He you know, he has a fully fleshed out world
- 2:07:20that you get a very good sense for. And he's not a cheesy writer,
- 2:07:28and he doesn't pull any punches every you know, everyone can die at
- 2:07:30any moment, and it's just yeah, I just it's why, it's why
- 2:07:39the books are so popular. And why the TV show is so popular.
- 2:07:42Well, that does it for that episode of psychology in Seattle. Again.
- 2:07:45If he haven't become a patron of the podcast, do so, go to
- 2:07:47patreon dot com. The more people become patrons, the more time I have
- 2:07:53to dedicate to this podcast, which means I have more time to do episodes
- 2:07:57like this. There's so many characters in Game of Thrones I'd like to do,
- 2:08:00but the preparation for these Game of Thrones episodes takes hours, and I
- 2:08:05mean it took me weeks to prepare for this episode. Just takes so long,
- 2:08:09you know, I have to get the books out, look up stuff,
- 2:08:11and it's a lot of work. But I love it. And the
- 2:08:16more people who are patrons, the more I'm able to dedicate time to this
- 2:08:20because I have to take away from my regular job. And the more episodes
- 2:08:24we can do on Game of Thrones and other characters, you know, Batman,
- 2:08:26Superman, whoever. I know people are asking to do. They want
- 2:08:33me to do an episode on Uron, Great Joy, and do an episode
- 2:08:35on little Finger and Varies and Jurra, and no one's asked me to do
- 2:08:43an episode on Denari's, which I find that'd be interesting. No one wants
- 2:08:46because I think her character isn't that compelling, you know, She's just kind
- 2:08:50of I don't know, but everyone wants. Youuron a little finger and varies.
- 2:08:56Who else people have been asking about. Maybe that's it, but anyway,
- 2:09:00John Snow probably people want to hear about him. All right, Well
- 2:09:03that does it for that episode of Psychology and Seattle. Thanks for joining me
- 2:09:05out there. Please take care of yourself because you deserve it. Even if
- 2:09:11you're a theon, you deserve it.