Latest / Reformed Thinking / Compassion and the Great Commission
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Reformed Thinking. I'm really glad you're joining
- 0:02us for this deep dive. We are examining a topic that,
- 0:06you know, requires some serious, careful theological precision.
- 0:09We are looking at the precise biblical relationship between
- 0:12physical mercy ministries and the active proclamation of the
- 0:15gospel. And as always on this program,
- 0:17we are evaluating all of this strictly through the lens of
- 0:20God's absolute sovereignty and the doctrines of grace.
- 0:24Right, that is the only valid lens we can use.
- 0:26Yeah, absolutely. So our material today comes from
- 0:29excerpts of a brilliant book titled Biblical Missions,
- 0:33Principles, Priorities and Practices by Mark Tatlock and
- 0:35Christ Burnett. Specifically, we're going to
- 0:38look closely at essays contributed by Brian Biedenbach
- 0:40and Shannon Hurley. It is a phenomenal collection of
- 0:43resources, primarily because it refuses to let the reader settle
- 0:46for easy, pragmatic answers. The authors force us to look at
- 0:50our actions through the strict grid of Scripture, rather than
- 0:53taking our cues from modern sociology or corporate
- 0:56philanthropy. Yes, I mean, I want you to
- 0:58consider your own local church right now.
- 1:01Think about your specific congregation.
- 1:04Picture the lobby, the sanctuary, the budget meetings
- 1:07you might sit in on. Is your local body prioritizing
- 1:10social action at the expense of gospel proclamation?
- 1:14Are you pouring all your resources into community gardens
- 1:17and clothing drives while the actual preaching of the cross
- 1:20takes a backseat? That is a highly common scenario
- 1:23today. It really is.
- 1:24Or, on the flip side, is your church preaching the truth from
- 1:27the pulpit on Sunday morning while coldly ignoring the
- 1:30starving, desperate people sitting right outside its
- 1:32physical doors? We tend to drift toward one of
- 1:35those two extremes. OK, let's unpack this, because
- 1:38getting this wrong has massive consequences for how we execute
- 1:41the Great Commission. It is a critical evaluation you
- 1:43must make because the stakes involve eternal souls and the
- 1:46glory of God. Mark Tatlock presents a striking
- 1:49argument right at the beginning of his essay.
- 1:51He points out a theological reality that we just cannot
- 1:54ignore. Because Christians have received
- 1:56God's extensive compassion and total forgiveness for their own
- 1:59total depravity, they have a strict non negotiable mandate to
- 2:04show tangible compassion to their fellow man.
- 2:06We have to start right there with our own depravity.
- 2:08Precisely. Reformed theology teaches us
- 2:11that we were not just morally sick.
- 2:13We were spiritually dead. We were rotting corpses in our
- 2:16trespasses and sins. We were actively rebelling
- 2:18against a holy God. And in that state of complete
- 2:21spiritual bankruptcy, God showed us massive, unmerited mercy.
- 2:24We received grace we absolutely did not earn.
- 2:27Therefore, demonstrating mercy to the physically destitute is
- 2:30not an optional add on to the Christian life.
- 2:32It is a direct command. If you understand the sheer
- 2:35volume of grace you have received, it becomes impossible
- 2:38to look at a physically broken person with distinct.
- 2:40That makes total sense on a theological level, but Tatlock
- 2:43observes a terrible modern failure in this specific area,
- 2:47doesn't he? He knows that many modern
- 2:49missionaries, as well as local church leaders, fail terribly at
- 2:52modeling this compassion to the most hopeless individuals in
- 2:55their communities, the poor. Why do you think that happens?
- 2:59Well, I think it happens because physical poverty is incredibly
- 3:02messy. It is uncomfortable.
- 3:04It is demanding. When you engage with people who
- 3:06lack basic necessities, you are stepping into a world of crisis.
- 3:11You are dealing with trauma, addiction, unpredictable
- 3:14behavior, and massive emotional needs.
- 3:17Many well meaning church leaders and missionaries prefer a
- 3:20cleaner, more controlled environment.
- 3:22Yeah, predictable setting. Right.
- 3:24They want to minister to people who have their lives somewhat
- 3:26put together, people who can tithe regularly, people who show
- 3:29up on time and follow social norms.
- 3:31Engaging the absolute poorest demographics requires a level of
- 3:34sacrifice and patience that exposes our own selfishness.
- 3:37We naturally gravitate toward comfort.
- 3:39We do, but Tatlock forces us to look at Christ as our model.
- 3:43He does. While Christ showed immense
- 3:46mercy to the physically destitute, His absolute priority
- 3:50was always gospel proclamation. He did not avoid the mess, but
- 3:54he also never let the physical mess distract him from His
- 3:56primary objective. The physical acts of healing or
- 4:00feeding were never the end goal. They were constantly coupled
- 4:03with the Commission to evangelize.
- 4:05We really need to bring the Westminster Confession into this
- 4:08discussion to keep our categories clear.
- 4:11If we synthesize this mandate for compassion with the
- 4:13Westminster Confessions view of the ordinary means of grace, the
- 4:17picture comes into sharp focus for our listeners who might want
- 4:20a quick refresher. The Confession teaches that God
- 4:23uses very specific, ordinary tools to accomplish the
- 4:26extraordinary work of salvation. The primary tool is the
- 4:29preaching of the Word. That is a central tenet for us.
- 4:32Yes, because physical charity does not save us all.
- 4:35Handing someone a sandwich or paying their electric bill does
- 4:38not contain the spiritual properties required to
- 4:40regenerate a human heart. Only the preached Gospel applied
- 4:44by the Holy Spirit brings about the new birth.
- 4:46That is a crucial distinction. Let's break that down even
- 4:48further. Think about a loaf of bread.
- 4:50Bread feeds the stomach. It provides calories,
- 4:53carbohydrates, and physical sustenance.
- 4:56It can keep a physical body alive for another day, but bread
- 4:59cannot resurrect A spiritually dead heart.
- 5:02It cannot grant faith. It cannot justify A Sinner
- 5:05before a holy God. Only the objective truth of
- 5:08Christ's substitutionary atonement, proclaimed audibly
- 5:11and received by faith, can do. That I agree completely.
- 5:14However, completely ignoring physical distress denies the
- 5:17tangible grace God commands His people to demonstrate.
- 5:20It creates A horrific false dichotomy where we pretend we
- 5:23can love a person's eternal soul while despising their starving
- 5:26physical body. You cannot look at a man
- 5:28freezing on the street, hand him a gospel tract, and say be
- 5:31warmed and filled while refusing to give him a coat.
- 5:34That kind of behavior actively mocks the gospel you are trying
- 5:37to preach. That brings us directly into how
- 5:39Christ conducted His earthly ministry, which operates as the
- 5:43perfect blueprint for true compassion.
- 5:45We cannot just theorize about this.
- 5:47We have to look at how Jesus actually operated.
- 5:49Tatlock points us to the synagogue and Nazareth recorded
- 5:53in Luke chapter 4, verses 18 through 21.
- 5:55The Nazareth Manifesto. Yes, Jesus stands up in his
- 5:58hometown synagogue and he reads from the prophet Isaiah,
- 6:01specifically Isaiah 61. He announces to everyone present
- 6:05that he is anointed by the Spirit to preach the gospel to
- 6:08the poor, to release the captives, and to give sight to
- 6:10the blind. He then sits down and says,
- 6:13today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing.
- 6:15He's declaring his messianic credentials and explicitly links
- 6:19his ministry to the poor and the broken.
- 6:21He makes it clear that his mission involves addressing
- 6:23people who are in a state of absolute destitution.
- 6:25What's fascinating here is the dual nature of the poor in the
- 6:28teaching of Jesus Christ. We have to maintain both
- 6:31realities. First, it was undeniably a
- 6:34physical reality. There were literal beggars,
- 6:36literal blind men, literal lepers and literal captives in
- 6:391st century Judea. Rome was an oppressive empire
- 6:42and the taxation system left massive portions of the
- 6:45population and dire physical poverty.
- 6:47Jesus absolutely cared for these literal physically broken
- 6:50people. He had massive compassion for
- 6:52them. He did, but Jesus also used the
- 6:54social category of the poor to figuratively illustrate the
- 6:58spiritual reality of every single individual residing
- 7:01outside of God's saving grace. The poor in Christ's teaching
- 7:04generalizes all who are spiritually blind, spiritually
- 7:07deaf, spiritually captive to sin, and spiritually dead.
- 7:10So Jesus is using physical poverty as a visual aid for our
- 7:14spiritual condition before regeneration.
- 7:16Precisely. Think of a beggar sitting in the
- 7:19dirt with absolutely nothing to his name.
- 7:21He has no money to buy food, no influence to change his
- 7:23situation, and no ability to save himself.
- 7:26That physical beggar is a perfect, terrifying picture of
- 7:29every single human being before a holy God.
- 7:32Every human being, regardless of their bank account or social
- 7:35standing, is naturally in the state of total inability.
- 7:39A billionaire is just a spiritually bankrupt as a man
- 7:42living in a cardboard box. But the gospel is specifically
- 7:45for those who confess their total neediness, who realize
- 7:48they are spiritually bankrupt, and who receive mercy through
- 7:51faith. When Jesus says he came to
- 7:53preach the gospel to the poor, he is saying he is the only one
- 7:55who can meet the spiritual needs that earthly poverty perfectly
- 7:58illustrates. He came for those who know they
- 8:01bring absolutely nothing to the transaction of salvation.
- 8:04You see this vividly illustrated in how Jesus chose to live his
- 8:07life and who he chose to associate with.
- 8:10He provided a massive, unmissable contrast with the
- 8:13Pharisees. Let's think about the religious
- 8:16elite of his day. The Pharisees loved comfortable
- 8:19locations. They demanded the respectable
- 8:21seats at banquets. They wanted the places of honor
- 8:24in the synagogues. They essentially wanted the VIP
- 8:27section of the religious world. They wanted distance from the
- 8:29mess. Absolutely.
- 8:31They completely separated themselves from anyone they
- 8:33deemed unclean, uneducated, or socially inferior.
- 8:37They built massive walls of tradition to ensure they never
- 8:40had to brush shoulders with the messy realities of poverty and
- 8:43sickness. Jesus did the complete opposite.
- 8:46He completely avoided those comfortable environments.
- 8:48He chose to live simply, constantly interacting with tax
- 8:51collectors, social outcasts and the heavy laden.
- 8:54He walked the dusty Pilgrim highways.
- 8:56He went to the margins of society to find people who are
- 8:59physically exhausted and physically needy, bringing the
- 9:01message of salvation directly into their messy, broken
- 9:04realities. And we see the theological
- 9:07motive behind this in Matthew Chapter 9, verses 36 through 38.
- 9:11The text tells us Jesus was moved with intense compassion by
- 9:14the sight of physically needy people.
- 9:17He looked at the crowds and saw that they were distressed and
- 9:19downcast, like sheep without a shepherd.
- 9:21They were harassed and helpless. He felt intense, visceral
- 9:25sympathy for their physical and emotional condition.
- 9:28But look closely at his immediate response.
- 9:30He did not ask his disciples to set up a soup kitchen.
- 9:33He did not ask them to establish a medical clinic or political
- 9:36action committee, even though he cared about their physical
- 9:39state. No, He turned their attention to
- 9:41something else. He did.
- 9:42His immediate response was to ask for prayer for workers for
- 9:45the spiritual harvest. He said the harvest is plentiful
- 9:48but the workers are few. Therefore beseech the Lord of
- 9:51the harvest to send out workers into his harvest.
- 9:54He immediately pivots from their physical distress to their
- 9:57spiritual crisis. He absolutely does the true
- 10:00harvest. The main goal of his entire
- 10:02earthly ministry was always the conversion of souls to faith for
- 10:06eternal life. The physical needs elicited his
- 10:10compassion, but that compassion immediately drove him to
- 10:13prioritize the spiritual rescue of eternal souls from the wrath
- 10:17of God. He understood a terrifying
- 10:19reality that modern social ministries often forget.
- 10:21Healing a physical body only delays physical death by a few
- 10:24years. You can cure a man's disease,
- 10:26and he will eventually die of something else.
- 10:28But preaching the gospel resulting in regeneration
- 10:31rescues a soul from the second death.
- 10:32It secures eternal life. Therefore, the spiritual harvest
- 10:35must always take precedence over the physical relief, even while
- 10:37the 2 are frequently paired together.
- 10:39That dynamic makes me think of Second Corinthians chapter 8,
- 10:42verse 9. The apostle Paul beautifully
- 10:44captures this entire concept. Paul writes that Christ, though
- 10:48possessing all heavenly wealth, voluntarily became poor.
- 10:53He did this so that sinners, through his willing poverty,
- 10:56might become spiritually affluent.
- 10:58Let's really look at the magnitude of that statement.
- 11:01Christ existed in eternity past, possessing all the glory of
- 11:04heaven. He had absolute authority,
- 11:06perfect fellowship within the Trinity, and total absence of
- 11:09suffering. Yet He voluntarily left that
- 11:12glory, took on human flesh, and lived a life of extreme material
- 11:15poverty. The incarnation itself is a
- 11:17staggering display of descending into poverty.
- 11:19It truly is. He was born in a stable.
- 11:22He had no place to lay his head during his ministry, and this
- 11:25culminated in the agonizing, humiliating death on the cross.
- 11:29He did all this specifically to secure the spiritual wealth of
- 11:31justification and adoption for His elect.
- 11:34He gave up everything so the destitute sinners could inherit
- 11:37the Kingdom of God. We cannot overstate the
- 11:39significance of that exchange. Christ did not just become poor
- 11:43to show solidarity with poor people.
- 11:45He became poor as an act of substitution.
- 11:48He absorbed our spiritual poverty.
- 11:50He took the wrath we deserved, the complete bankruptcy of our
- 11:53sinful record, and he credited us with his perfect
- 11:56righteousness. That is the highest act of
- 11:59compassion. When a church forgets that
- 12:01substitutionary act and reduces Jesus to a social activist who
- 12:04just wanted to fix income inequality, they lose the entire
- 12:08gospel. Here's where it gets really
- 12:10interesting, especially when we look at the book of James and
- 12:12apply a rigorous Reformed analysis to the text.
- 12:15James deals with the practical outworking of this theology in
- 12:18the early church. In James chapter one, verse 27,
- 12:21we are told that pure and undefiled religion involves
- 12:24visiting orphans and widows in their affliction.
- 12:27Then in James chapter 2, verses one through 13, the early church
- 12:30is severely warned against the sin of partiality, specifically
- 12:34the sin of favoring people based on their physical appearance and
- 12:37earthly wealth. The partiality issue was tearing
- 12:39those congregations apart. Yes, James paints a picture of a
- 12:42wealthy man coming into the assembly with a gold ring and
- 12:46fine clothes and a poor man coming in with dirty clothes.
- 12:49The church was giving the best seat to the wealthy man and
- 12:52telling the poor man to sit on the floor.
- 12:54James rebukes this harshly, and then he asks A piercing question
- 12:58in chapter 2, verse 5. Did not God choose the poor of
- 13:01this world to be abundantly blessed in faith and heirs of
- 13:04the Kingdom? That verse is a direct,
- 13:06unavoidable statement regarding God's sovereign choice.
- 13:09James is explicitly telling the church that their favoritism
- 13:12toward the wealthy is a direct contradiction of God's elective
- 13:15purposes. God explicitly decreed that many
- 13:18who are poor in the eyes of the world would be the recipients of
- 13:20His saving grace. As Reformed believers, we must
- 13:23link this directly to the Apostle Paul's theology of
- 13:25unconditional election found in Ephesians chapter 1, verses 4
- 13:29through 6. Paul tells us that God chose us
- 13:31in Christ before the foundation of the world from eternity past.
- 13:35Operating an absolute sovereignty, God predestined for
- 13:38faith many whom He also decreed would live their earthly lives
- 13:41in physical poverty. So God's election is not based
- 13:44on any foreseen faith, nor is it based on someone's earthly
- 13:47status or potential. It is entirely unmerited.
- 13:51God did not look down the corridors of time, see who would
- 13:54be successful or influential, and choose them so they could
- 13:57help build His Kingdom. He simply chose to display His
- 14:00glory by saving those the world despises.
- 14:03He chose the weak things of the world to shame the strong.
- 14:06He chose the poor to be abundantly blessed in faith.
- 14:10When a local church ignores the poor in its community, it is
- 14:13ignoring the very demographic that God has historically and
- 14:16sovereignly targeted for His electing grace.
- 14:19And we have to be extremely clear here so we do not fall
- 14:22into a different kind of error. James is not saying there is
- 14:24inherent moral merit in lacking money.
- 14:27Being broke does not make you holy.
- 14:29A poor person is just as totally depraved as a wealthy person.
- 14:32Poverty is simply a physical picture of a person's total lack
- 14:35of spiritual merit. It vividly highlights human
- 14:38inability to purchase forgiveness from from a holy
- 14:40God. You cannot buy your way out of
- 14:42total depravity. No amount of money, or lack
- 14:44thereof, changes our fallen nature.
- 14:46Right. However, worldly poverty
- 14:49actively removes false earthly security.
- 14:53Let's put this into perspective. When you do not know where your
- 14:57next meal is coming from, when you cannot afford basic medical
- 15:00care, you are placed in a position where you are acutely
- 15:03aware of your desperation. You cannot rely on your bank
- 15:06account to shield you from the harsh realities of a fallen
- 15:08world. This physical vulnerability
- 15:11often makes a person much more receptive to hearing the gospel
- 15:14called to faith and repentance. Compare that to the snare of
- 15:17wealth, which Jesus speaks about extensively.
- 15:19Think about Luke 12 with the parable of the wealthy fool and
- 15:22Matthew 13 regarding the deceitfulness of riches.
- 15:25Earthly wealth deceives people. It tricks them into thinking
- 15:28they are self-sufficient. It makes them believe they can
- 15:30live completely independent lives without ever acknowledging
- 15:33the Creator who gives them every single breath.
- 15:36The wealthy person in Luke 12 builds bigger barns.
- 15:38He accumulates massive amounts of resources.
- 15:40And then he says to his soul, Soul, you have many goods laid
- 15:43up for many years to come. Take your ease, eat, drink and
- 15:46be merry. He completely ignores the
- 15:48impending judgement of God. He thinks his wealth makes him
- 15:51untouchable. But God says to him, You fool,
- 15:53this very night, your soul is required of you.
- 15:56Yes, his wealth provided a fatal illusion of security.
- 16:00Poverty strips away that deceitful illusion.
- 16:02It forces a person to confront their mortality and their
- 16:05helplessness. And for the elect who are poor
- 16:07in this world, God promises A glorious eschatological hope.
- 16:11They may have absolutely nothing here.
- 16:13They may suffer hunger, disease, and oppression on this earth,
- 16:16but they are promised a home in heaven.
- 16:18They are promised a glorified body completely free from pain,
- 16:21sickness, and hunger. They promised a crown of life
- 16:24and a permanent inheritance in the new heavens and the new
- 16:27earth. These are promises decreed in
- 16:29ages past by a sovereign God who cannot lie.
- 16:32When you preach the gospel to a destitute person, you are
- 16:34offering them an eternal inheritance that makes all the
- 16:36wealth of this world look like dust.
- 16:38This theological reality makes the hypocrisy Tatlock describes
- 16:42so incredibly glaring. Think about the massive
- 16:44disconnect here. How can a local church honestly
- 16:48claim to preach a message of divine, unmerited grace while
- 16:51coldly ignoring the starving people living in its own
- 16:53neighborhood? It is a terrifying
- 16:55contradiction. You were telling people from the
- 16:57pulpit that God loved his enemies enough to die for them,
- 17:00but you as a congregation will not even cross the street to
- 17:02give a starving neighbor a piece of bread.
- 17:04You will not organize a food pantry or open your doors to the
- 17:07freezing. It shows a catastrophic
- 17:09disconnect between the theology a church claims to believe and
- 17:12the fruit that theology is supposed to produce in the lives
- 17:14of the congregation. If your theology does not
- 17:17produce radical compassion, your theology is entirely
- 17:20theoretical. And we must remember that the
- 17:23unbelieving world watches the local church very closely.
- 17:26Your secular neighbors are observing how you live.
- 17:29They are watching how your congregation spends its money
- 17:32and utilizes its building. If they see a group of believers
- 17:35who claim to have the love of Christ completely ignoring
- 17:38physical affliction right in front of them, the message of
- 17:40the gospel becomes almost impossible for them to hear.
- 17:43They will look at your localized body of believers, see your nice
- 17:46cars in the parking lot and your expensive sound systems, and
- 17:49then watch you step over a homeless person on the sidewalk.
- 17:53They will conclude that your religion is entirely
- 17:55hypocritical. You become a massive stumbling
- 17:58block to the very gospel you claim to cherish.
- 18:00The early church in Jerusalem as described in Acts chapter 2
- 18:03provides the correct model for how this should look.
- 18:06When the Holy Spirit fell at Pentecost and thousands were
- 18:09converted, their true spirit wrought.
- 18:11Repentance directly affected their sinful pride in their
- 18:14natural self love. It LED immediately to radical
- 18:17self denial. They willfully sold their
- 18:19property and possessions and they share their goods to meet
- 18:22the physical needs of those in their community.
- 18:25No one forced them to do this. It was not a religious tax.
- 18:28It was the organic result of regenerated hearts.
- 18:31Their theological belief produce tangible sacrificial action
- 18:35toward the physically needy among them.
- 18:37I want you, the listener, to carefully evaluate your own
- 18:40church body right now. Take a hard look at your local
- 18:44congregations ministries. Does your congregation purposely
- 18:47pursue broken, impoverished populations to gain a hearing
- 18:50for the gospel? Do you intentionally go into the
- 18:53hard neighborhoods in your city, or are you looking for a more
- 18:56comfortable audience? Are you designing your outreach
- 18:59programs to attract people who look like you, dress like you,
- 19:02and have the exact same tax bracket as you while actively
- 19:05ignoring the destitute? If a destitute person walked
- 19:08into your sanctuary this Sunday, how would the ushers react?
- 19:11Would they be welcomed as a potential heir of the Kingdom or
- 19:14would they be viewed as a nuisance?
- 19:15We need to bring in the answer from Brian Biederbach here
- 19:18because he issues a massive warning about how missions have
- 19:21drifted regarding this very issue.
- 19:24Over the past 50 years, there has been a drastic shift in the
- 19:26world of missions. The focus has moved sharply away
- 19:29from church planting and gospel proclamation and shifted heavily
- 19:33towards social action, medical missions, and well drilling.
- 19:37Beedebach outlines 3 distinct approaches to this issue that
- 19:40have developed over the last few decades.
- 19:42Let's look at the first one, holistic missions.
- 19:45This idea really gained traction in the 1980s during the Lausanne
- 19:48movement. The core concept here is that
- 19:51spiritual renewal comes through preaching and social action
- 19:54happening simultaneously. Proponents of this view argue
- 19:57that because Jesus fed people and preached, we must do both in
- 20:00equal measure. They treat social action and
- 20:02evangelism as 2 equal wings of an airplane.
- 20:05It sounds appealing on the surface, but Beat It Back
- 20:07provides a very cautionary anecdote from his own experience
- 20:10in Central Africa regarding this first approach.
- 20:14He describes a situation where he went to the mission field.
- 20:16With this holistic mindset, he found himself constantly busy
- 20:19managing agricultural projects. He was raising chickens,
- 20:23breeding goats, building orphanages, and organizing wall
- 20:25drilling projects. He was doing absolutely
- 20:28everything under the sun to improve the physical community.
- 20:31He was working exhausting hours to raise the standard of living
- 20:34for the people in his area. But what was the spiritual
- 20:36result of all that physical labor?
- 20:39The result was disastrous from a Great Commission perspective.
- 20:42The local church in that area remained incredibly weak and
- 20:45completely immature. Why?
- 20:47Because all the missionary energy, all the funding, and all
- 20:50the time was poured into physical administration.
- 20:53There was absolutely no time left to disciple anyone in the
- 20:56Scriptures. The newly converted believers
- 20:58had no one to teach them sound doctrine, no one to train local
- 21:01pastors, and no one to establish church discipline because the
- 21:04missionaries were too busy acting as farmers, project
- 21:07managers, and social workers. They gave the people better
- 21:09diets, but starve them of the Word of God.
- 21:12Which leads to the second approach.
- 21:13He identifies extreme holism, sometimes called the revisionist
- 21:16approach. So if the first approach is
- 21:19well-intentioned but highly distracting, this second
- 21:21approach sounds downright dangerous.
- 21:24This is an alarming trend in modern missiology.
- 21:27In this model, human welfare becomes the sole goal of the
- 21:29mission. It is a strict either approach
- 21:32where actively proclaiming the gospel of salvation from sin is
- 21:36actually considered non essential.
- 21:37You can just dig a well, build a school, or hand out medicine and
- 21:40they call that missions. The focus is entirely on
- 21:43achieving what they call biblical Shalom and overcoming
- 21:45societal evil through political or social means.
- 21:48They want to fix the culture without fixing the human heart.
- 21:51From a strict Reformed stance, this extreme holism is a
- 21:54complete theological disaster. It completely dilutes the Great
- 21:58Commission commanded by Christ. It abandons the absolute
- 22:02necessity of substitutionary atonement.
- 22:05It assumes that giving a spiritually dead person a better
- 22:08standard of living somehow advances the Kingdom of God.
- 22:11But we know from Scripture that the Kingdom of God does not
- 22:13advance through improved agriculture, better political
- 22:16systems, or higher education. The Kingdom of God advances
- 22:19exclusively through the effectual calling of the Holy
- 22:22Spirit. Operating through the preached
- 22:24Word. Making a person more comfortable
- 22:26on their way to eternal judgement is a colossal failure
- 22:29of Christian love. If you give a man clean drinking
- 22:32water but never tell him how to be saved from the wrath of God,
- 22:35you have completely failed him eternally.
- 22:37You've practiced philanthropy and not biblical missions.
- 22:39That brings us to the third approach, which Beadabach
- 22:42champions Is the only truly biblical approach, the priority
- 22:45of preaching? In this model, spiritual renewal
- 22:49comes only through gospel proclamation.
- 22:51Social action is a byproduct. It is a fruit of changed hearts,
- 22:55not the root of the change itself.
- 22:57You treat the gospel, the Holy Spirit regenerates the heart,
- 23:00and that new believer then loves their neighbor and care for the
- 23:02poor. Kevin Deyoung and Greg Gilbert
- 23:05capture this perfectly in their writings.
- 23:07They point out that Jesus is driving ambition on earth was
- 23:09not to heal every sick person in the Middle East.
- 23:12It was not his ambition to empty the poverty rolls of Judea or
- 23:15overthrow the oppressive Roman government.
- 23:17His driving ambition was to save his elect from eternal
- 23:19condemnation. Improving A sinner's earthly
- 23:22life means absolutely nothing if they lose their immortal soul
- 23:25for eternity. Beatabach spent 19 years
- 23:28observing this dynamic first hand in Africa, and his
- 23:31observations are incredibly sobering.
- 23:33Over nearly two decades, he watched foreign churches
- 23:36continually send social action workers.
- 23:39They sent doctors, engineers, and agricultural experts.
- 23:42But while those numbers swelled, the number of men dedicated
- 23:45exclusively to pastoral training and church planting steadily
- 23:48dwindled. He uses a striking analogy to
- 23:51describe this massive Western imbalance.
- 23:53He says Western churches left a garden hose on pouring water
- 23:57wastefully into Africa without cultivating the Kingdom God's
- 24:00way. I love that analogy because it
- 24:02provides such a vivid mental picture.
- 24:05We have all accidentally left a hose running in the yard.
- 24:08What happens? It does not gently water the
- 24:10plants. It floods the flower bed.
- 24:12It washes away the top soil, exposes the roots and causes a
- 24:15massive mess. Bidabak is saying that Western
- 24:17churches have flooded the African continent with millions
- 24:20of dollars in aid and social programs, but they have
- 24:22completely neglected the spiritual soil.
- 24:25They provided the physical water, but they failed to plant
- 24:27the seeds of the gospel and established local doctrinally
- 24:30sound churches to actually disciple the people.
- 24:32It is a massive call for reassessment.
- 24:35If you are a listener, involved in church leadership, if you are
- 24:37a pastor, an elder, or if you sit on a missions committee.
- 24:40You must evaluate where your church's focus lies.
- 24:43Look at your missions budget. Where is the money actually
- 24:45going? If you're funds are going
- 24:47exclusively to social organizations that only deal
- 24:49with physical needs, your church is failing the Great Commission.
- 24:53You are funding humanitarian aid, not biblical missions.
- 24:57Now let me be clear, there is a place for humanitarian aid.
- 25:00Christians can and should support efforts to relieve
- 25:02suffering. But we must never confuse
- 25:05secular humanitarian aid with the strict mandate Christ gave
- 25:08to his Church. Christ did not command us to go
- 25:11into all the world and dig wells.
- 25:12He commanded us to make disciples, baptize them, and
- 25:15teach them everything He commanded.
- 25:17Shannon Hurley's insert provides excellent best practices for how
- 25:19we should handle this tension. We know we have to care for the
- 25:22poor, but we know preaching must remain the absolute priority.
- 25:26So how do we actually do this? Hurley starts by pointing out
- 25:29the scar contextual differences between a Western outlook and a
- 25:33majority world outlook. This is something we often miss
- 25:35in America. In the West, we have strong
- 25:38medical services, relatively stable justice systems, and
- 25:41general financial security. Even our poorest citizens often
- 25:45have access to state funded assistance.
- 25:47We take basic survival for granted.
- 25:49In the majority world, missionaries face heavily
- 25:51corrupt justice systems and a daily scarcity of basic
- 25:54necessities. People literally starve to
- 25:57death. When you preach the gospel to
- 25:59someone who has not eaten in three days and has no social
- 26:01safety net, you cannot ignore their physical reality.
- 26:04So Hurley's first practice is the constructive application of
- 26:07biblical commands. He points right back to the book
- 26:09of James. Faith without works is dead.
- 26:12Christians must embody pure religion.
- 26:14We must show mercy because God showed us mercy.
- 26:17And this is where the motive becomes everything you mentioned
- 26:20earlier, the danger of doing the right thing for the wrong
- 26:23reason. Hurley rightly cites First
- 26:25Corinthians chapter 13 verses one and three to address this.
- 26:29Paul says that even if you give all your possessions to feed the
- 26:32hungry or surrender your body to be burned, if you do not have
- 26:35love, it profits you nothing. You can be the greatest
- 26:38philanthropist on the entire planet.
- 26:40You can give away billions of dollars and build hospitals
- 26:42across the globe, but if your giving is not motivated by a
- 26:45desire to see God glorified and eternal souls saved, it is
- 26:49spiritually useless. Your physical charity must be
- 26:52driven by a biblical love that desires the eternal spiritual
- 26:56good of your neighbor, not just their temporal comfort.
- 26:58Which brings us to Hurley's second practice.
- 27:01He clearly states that preaching is the sole means of true
- 27:04spiritual renewal. This raises an important
- 27:06question regarding humanitarian aid.
- 27:08Is it enough to just show love through actions?
- 27:11Hurley argues, and Reformed theology agrees, that love
- 27:15cannot replace truth. Mercy ministry operating without
- 27:18evangelism is just humanitarian aid.
- 27:20It is not Christian missions. the United Nations can dig a
- 27:23well. A secular non governmental
- 27:25organization can build a hospital or distribute grain,
- 27:28and those are good things. But only the Church of Jesus
- 27:31Christ holds the keys to the Kingdom.
- 27:33Only the church can preach the gospel of substitutionary
- 27:36atonement. Therefore, mercy must always
- 27:38remain A subordinate assistant to the gospel.
- 27:40It is the servant of the message, never the master.
- 27:43Physical acts of compassion are the vehicle that delivers the
- 27:45cargo of the gospel. If the vehicle arrives empty,
- 27:48the mission has failed. Which perfectly sets up his
- 27:51third practice. Everything must be centered on
- 27:53the local church. Doing mercy ministry about
- 27:56pointing people to a local biblical church is, as Hurley
- 27:58says, like swimming without water.
- 28:01I think about the massive parachurch organizations that
- 28:03operate globally. They drop into a town,
- 28:05distribute food, holds a massive medical clinic, maybe even pass
- 28:09out some Bibles. And then they leave.
- 28:11You are leaving new converts completely orphaned.
- 28:14If you feed someone and share the gospel with them, but fail
- 28:17to integrate them into a local body of believers where they can
- 28:20be shepherded by qualified elders, disciplined when they
- 28:22stray, and fed the preached Word of God weekly, you are
- 28:26abandoning them to the wolves. The Apostle Paul makes this
- 28:29abundantly clear in Ephesians chapter 4, verses 12 and 13.
- 28:34Christ gave pastors and teachers to equip the Saints for the work
- 28:37of ministry and for building up the body of Christ.
- 28:40Christ did not establish para church organizations as His
- 28:42primary instrument for Kingdom growth.
- 28:45He established the local church. Para church organizations, no
- 28:48matter how well-intentioned or heavily funded, cannot replace
- 28:51the disciple making mandate given exclusively to the local
- 28:54church. The local church is God's
- 28:56ordained institution for the gathering and perfecting of the
- 28:59Saints. Any compassion ministry that
- 29:01bypasses the local church or fails to funnel the people it
- 29:04helps directly into a local congregation is operating
- 29:07outside the biblical framework. So what does this all mean?
- 29:10Let's synthesize everything we have covered in this deep dive
- 29:14so we walk away with a crystal clear understanding.
- 29:17Christians have a strict, unavoidable mandate to show
- 29:20physical compassion, especially to the destitute and broken in
- 29:24our communities. We do this because God showered
- 29:27massive, unmerited compassion on us while we were still His
- 29:31enemies, spiritually dead in our sin.
- 29:33But this physical compassion must always operate as a vehicle
- 29:37for the primary mission. The main goal, the highest
- 29:40priority, is always proclaiming the gospel of grace to
- 29:43spiritually dead sinners whom God is sovereignly elected to
- 29:46save from before the foundation of the world.
- 29:49The physical bread we give is meant to point them to the Bread
- 29:51of life. The physical healing we
- 29:53facilitate is meant to point them to the Great Physician who
- 29:56heals the disease of sin. If we connect this to the bigger
- 29:59picture, I want to leave you with a final thought to ponder
- 30:01long after you finish listening today.
- 30:03Consider this. What if the greatest act of
- 30:04social justice you could ever perform for your neighbor is
- 30:07ensuring they hear the gospel, making every physical act of
- 30:10mercy you do nothing more than the opening line of an eternal
- 30:13conversation? Thank you for joining us for
- 30:15this session of Reformed thinking.
- 30:16We strongly encourage you to look at the outreach programs
- 30:19and the budget of your own local congregation this week and
- 30:22measure them against the strict standard of Scripture.
- 30:24Ensure your compassion is fueling the proclamation of the
- 30:27truth. Until next time, keep your focus
- 30:30on the supremacy of Christ and the authority of His Word.