Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / Why Your Last Promotion Didn't Fix Your Salary
Transcript
- Lucas: Let's start with a number that probably sounds familiar to half the people listening right now. The average internal promotion comes with a base salary increase of about three percent. That is barely enough to keep up with inflation in many markets, especially when you factor in the fact that your job description has just expanded by maybe twenty or thirty percent. Luna: And yet, most people accept it immediately because they are chasing the prestige of the new title. It feels like a win on paper, even if the bank account doesn't change much. Lucas: Exactly. And here is the thing that drives me crazy about this dynamic. Companies love it. For them, it is the ultimate retention hack. They give you a shiny new label, which boosts your ego and looks good on your LinkedIn profile, but they keep your compensation essentially frozen. It costs them almost nothing in terms of cash flow. Luna: It is basically buying loyalty with words instead of dollars. I have seen this happen so many times with project leads getting promoted to senior managers without a real pay bump. Lucas: Right. And let's look at why this happens structurally. It usually comes down to the budget cycle. Most companies do their annual compensation review in January or February. If you get promoted in March, you miss that window. You are stuck waiting twelve months for your next chance to negotiate, during which time your workload has already spiked. Luna: So you are effectively working for free for a year while carrying more stress. Does the market actually value the new title differently? Lucas: That is the second trap. Internal titles are meaningless outside your organization. When you leave, recruiters don't care that you were a Senior Vice President of Strategic Initiatives at your old firm if that role didn't exist anywhere else. They look at your last actual salary to determine your baseline. Luna: Which means if you stayed and took the underpaid promotion, you are anchoring your future earning potential to a lower number. That is a long-term tax. Lucas: Precisely. It creates a compounding error. If you jump from one company to another every two years, taking external offers that come with ten or fifteen percent bumps, you grow your salary much faster than someone who stays loyal and gets three percent raises. Luna: But isn't there some truth to the idea that staying longer builds institutional knowledge that pays off later? Lucas: Sometimes, yes. But not in direct salary terms. The payoff for loyalty is usually non-monetary, like better work-life balance or more flexible hours, not raw cash. If you are purely focused on income growth, loyalty is often a losing strategy. Luna: So what should someone do when they are offered that promotion? Do they just walk away? Lucas: No, you don't walk away. You renegotiate. You treat the promotion offer as a negotiation opening, not a fait accompli. You say, I am excited to take on this role, but given the increased scope, I need to discuss the compensation adjustment before I sign off on the new responsibilities. Luna: That requires a lot of confidence though. What if they say no and rescind the offer? Lucas: Then you have valuable information. If they rescind it because you asked for fair pay, they were never going to pay you fairly anyway. You would have taken the job, suffered through the low pay, and resent it for a year. Better to find out early. Luna: I like that framing. It turns a scary conversation into a filter for bad employers. But what about equity? Sometimes companies offer stock options instead of cash. Lucas: Equity is tricky. In public companies, it can be very liquid. In private ones, it is often worthless until an exit event that might never happen. If they are offering equity instead of a raise, you have to ask yourself if you believe in that company's long-term valuation enough to bet your current income on it. Luna: Yeah, I would rather have guaranteed cash in hand than a promise of future wealth that depends on a bunch of investors deciding the company is worth something. Lucas: Agreed. Cash is king for most people. Unless you are an early-stage employee at a rocket ship startup, cash gives you flexibility. You can invest it, spend it, or save it. Equity ties your financial fate to a single basket. Luna: Let's talk about the psychology of it too. Why do we feel pressured to accept these deals? Lucas: Because we are conditioned to think that career progression is linear. You go up, you earn more. When that link breaks, it feels like a personal failure. But it is really a market failure. The market does not reward loyalty; it rewards scarcity and leverage. Luna: So leverage is the key word here. How do you build leverage if you are currently stuck in a low-paying role? Lucas: You build leverage by becoming indispensable in a way that is visible. Document your wins. Quantify your impact. Make sure decision-makers know exactly how much money you save or generate for them. That data becomes your ammunition when you ask for a raise or a promotion. Luna: And you have to share that data externally too, right? Update your resume regularly so you know what the market thinks you are worth. Lucas: Absolutely. Interviewing once a year, even if you don't want to leave, keeps you calibrated. It reminds you that your skills have value outside your current employer. It stops you from accepting lowball offers based on internal comparisons rather than external reality. Luna: That is such a practical tip. Just keeping one foot out the door, metaphorically speaking, helps you stay grounded. Lucas: It does. And it takes the fear out of negotiations. If you know you could easily find another job, you stop being afraid to say no to unfair terms. You become the one setting the price, not the one begging for scraps. Luna: Okay, before we dive deeper into the mechanics of that negotiation, I want to pause for a quick moment. Lucas: Sure. Luna: If this show has helped you think through a career move or decision, and you want to support us, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo is the link. It keeps the show ad-free and running. Lucas: We appreciate any support you can give. It really helps us keep digging into these topics for you. Now, back to the negotiation. Luna: Right, so let's get into the actual script. What does a good counter-offer look like? Lucas: It starts with enthusiasm. You say, I am thrilled about the opportunity to lead this team. Then you pivot. However, looking at the market rate for this level of responsibility, I was expecting a base salary adjustment closer to twenty percent. Luna: Twenty percent seems high. Won't that shock them? Lucas: It might, but it sets a anchor. They will likely come back with something in the middle, maybe eight or ten percent. Which is still double what they usually offer. You want to aim high so you don't settle for mediocrity. Luna: So you are trading off the standard three percent for something that actually matters. That makes sense. Lucas: It does. And if they push back, ask them what specific metrics you need to hit to earn that full amount. Put the ball in their court. Make it clear that the money is tied to performance, which benefits them too. Luna: That shifts the dynamic from asking for a favor to proposing a business deal. Very smart. Lucas: Exactly. You are treating your career like a business. And businesses negotiate. They don't just accept whatever the other side hands them. You have to advocate for your own value. Luna: What about the timing? Is there a best time to bring this up? Lucas: Always after you have delivered a significant win. Not when you are struggling. When you have just saved the department fifty thousand dollars or launched a successful product, that is when you have maximum leverage. Do not wait for the annual review if you can avoid it. Luna: So ride the wave of your success while it is fresh. That is good advice. Lucas: It is. Momentum is everything in these conversations. If you wait six months, the excitement fades, and the budget gets tight again. Strike while the iron is hot. Luna: I think a lot of people miss that window because they are too polite or too shy to speak up. Lucas: Politeness is overrated in compensation discussions. Respect is important, but assertiveness is necessary. You are not being rude; you are being professional. You are discussing the value you provide and the compensation required to sustain it. Luna: Do you think remote work has changed this dynamic at all? Lucas: It has complicated it. Remote workers sometimes get left out of informal networks where promotions are discussed. If you are not in the room, physically or virtually, you might not hear about opportunities until it is too late. You have to be more proactive in remote settings. Luna: So visibility is even more crucial when you are not sitting next to your boss. You have to manufacture that presence. Lucas: Yes. Regular updates, clear communication, and making sure your contributions are documented in shared spaces. Don't assume your manager sees everything you do. Show them. Luna: That is a huge shift in mindset. From doing good work to proving good work. Lucas: Both are required. But proof is what gets you paid. Good work without proof is invisible, and invisible work rarely gets rewarded. Luna: So the takeaway is: chase the title only if it comes with the cash, or prepare to leave soon after. Lucas: Or chase the cash directly, regardless of the title. A junior role with great pay is often better than a senior role with poor pay. Focus on the bottom line. Luna: That is a refreshing perspective. Most people obsess over the label, but the label doesn't pay the mortgage. Lucas: Exactly. The label opens doors, but the cash keeps the lights on. Prioritize accordingly. Luna: One last question. If someone is currently stuck in that three percent trap, what is the first step they should take today? Lucas: Update their resume. Even if they aren't applying. Just seeing their achievements listed out clearly helps them realize their worth. It is a small step, but it changes your internal narrative from victim to negotiator. Luna: I love that. It is actionable and immediate. No waiting for a promotion to feel empowered. Lucas: Right. Empowerment comes from preparation. Get ready, then make your move. Luna: Thanks for breaking this down, Lucas. It is a lot to process, but definitely worth thinking about. Lucas: Anytime. Just remember, your career is yours to manage. Don't let anyone else set the price.