Latest / The Vegan Report / Discouraging Vegans to Become Dietitians: A Case Study of Discrimination. With Astrid Prevost | Ep. 14
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:04If you're vegan for ethical reasons and you care to do more for animal rights but you're
- 0:10not sure where to start, then this podcast is for you.
- 0:14Every week, fall in love with passionate, thought-provoking and inspiring animal rights
- 0:20leaders who will help you find your voice, your own special contribution to the animal
- 0:27rights movement.
- 0:29However small or big it is.
- 0:32For those of you who don't know, last week's episode and today's episode are both on the
- 0:38topic of Vigaphobia and they have both been produced in partnership with the New York
- 0:44City chapter of the National Lawyers Guild.
- 0:47They are organizing a webinar on Tuesday, October 17.
- 0:52It is called Expanding Vegan Rights and it will feature vegans from all over the world
- 0:59who were the victim of discrimination and who decided to fight back.
- 1:04For the very first time ever, they will meet each other and share stories of what they
- 1:10went through.
- 1:12I invite all of you to show your support by registering to the webinar.
- 1:18Follow the link in the description and don't miss out on that amazing conversation.
- 1:24In last week's episode, I had on Tamara, the organizer of the webinar, this was one of
- 1:30our most listened conversation so if you haven't, make sure to check it out.
- 1:36But today we are having an exclusive one-on-one conversation with Astrid Prevot, one of the
- 1:43webinar's guests.
- 1:46Astrid is a French citizen and ethical vegan.
- 1:49As someone who has battled bulimia and as a vegan, she has the noble aspiration of becoming
- 1:57a board certified dietitian to help people who are struggling with their eating habits.
- 2:04However, she recently encountered discrimination in the context of her studies, threatening
- 2:10the accomplishment of her dream.
- 2:13But she is fighting back in a lawsuit that could forever change a French board of dietitians
- 2:20which is deeply prejudiced against plant-based diets.
- 2:26So hi Astrid, welcome to the podcast.
- 2:28Thank you so much for being here.
- 2:30Hi Ryan, thank you very much for having me.
- 2:34So Astrid, my first question for you is why did you decide to be vocal about your fight
- 2:41in this podcast and in the upcoming webinar?
- 2:46Well, I decided to be vocal about my fight because I think it's very important for other
- 2:53vegans to realize that we can fight for our rights and also that our rights defend animal
- 3:00rights.
- 3:01It's all linked.
- 3:02So I think it's very important not to just let it go.
- 3:07I'm wondering, do you think that discrimination against vegans is just one more face, one
- 3:18more mask of animal exploitation that it's not really about discriminating against vegans,
- 3:24it's about continuing that exploitation that you're just a collateral victim of this big
- 3:32animal exploitation?
- 3:34Well, I don't really know about it, but what I know is that discrimination against vegans
- 3:41really prevents people from becoming vegans because people are afraid to be discriminated
- 3:47against.
- 3:49Some become vegan and then they quit veganism because of the social injustice and because
- 3:55they feel they are not accepted and they are marked and they have a hard time finding food
- 4:02where they live.
- 4:04So yeah, I think discrimination against vegans have really very concrete outcomes.
- 4:12And so yeah, I think that's also why we should fight against it because the final outcome
- 4:20is that it promotes animal exploitation, even if it's not direct, but still.
- 4:28That's an amazing answer.
- 4:31And before talking about how you were discriminated against, let's start by telling the story
- 4:39of your vegan journey.
- 4:41So why did you become vegan?
- 4:45And you told me before that you were first vegetarian and then you became vegan.
- 4:50So how did that happen?
- 4:52Yes, right, I was first vegetarian.
- 4:56Well, actually, I never liked eating animals.
- 5:00I remember very clearly that when I was three years old, I perfectly understood that meat
- 5:07was dead animals.
- 5:08Well, I didn't understand so much the concept of death, but I understood that it was animals
- 5:14flesh and that they had to suffer for us to get meat.
- 5:18And I hated it.
- 5:19But I thought that there was no other way to do.
- 5:24And also during my whole childhood and teenage years, and I think even now sometimes, I really
- 5:32wanted to fit into the mold.
- 5:34I didn't want to be outside the box.
- 5:37So I didn't say anything.
- 5:38I didn't ask to become a vegetarian when I was a kid or a teenager.
- 5:43I just wanted to fit in so badly.
- 5:46So I just forced myself to eat animals and do as if nothing was happening.
- 5:56And well, this was a pattern for me.
- 6:00I did this for to eat meat, but also for other things.
- 6:05And well, my story is that during my teenage years, I became bulimic.
- 6:11And actually, this was not so much because I wanted to look like the supermodels or whatever.
- 6:17It was much more an issue of me not being myself.
- 6:21And so actually, when I decided first to become a vegetarian and then later on a vegan, it
- 6:28really helped me with this because it was like setting boundaries for me.
- 6:34It was telling myself and telling the world that I have my boundaries.
- 6:39I respect them, whatever you think.
- 6:41These are my boundaries and I'm not going to cross them because you think otherwise.
- 6:47So this was a very important step.
- 6:50And I became a vegetarian only when I was 20 years old because at this time I traveled
- 6:56a lot and I met, well, many people.
- 7:00Some of them were vegetarians, some of them were vegans.
- 7:03And I realized that this was possible.
- 7:05So I wanted to do the same and stop eating animals.
- 7:09But at this time, I was not aware at all that milk and eggs were also killing animals.
- 7:16I just did not see the link.
- 7:19I thought you don't kill a cow to get the milk.
- 7:22You don't kill a chicken to get the eggs.
- 7:24So what's the problem?
- 7:26And actually it took me eight years, I think, to know about this.
- 7:30It was thanks to an NGO that I learned that dairy and eggs also kill animals.
- 7:37And so I never planned on stopping eating dairy and eggs.
- 7:43But when I learned about this, I thought to myself, okay, so I have a choice.
- 7:48Either I go this way and even though I never planned to do it, and I was even afraid that
- 7:54it would bring back some bulimia and binge eating because it would bring back the obsession
- 8:03of food.
- 8:04I was very afraid of this, or I thought to myself, maybe I can just do things as if I
- 8:11didn't know, but I cannot unknow something I know.
- 8:15So I decided to give myself a try.
- 8:18I thought, okay, I'm going to try to veganize my eating habits for six months.
- 8:24And if it works, okay, great.
- 8:26If it didn't work, at least I tried it.
- 8:29And it worked very well because I've been an ethical vegan for eight years now.
- 8:35Amazing.
- 8:36And congratulations.
- 8:40Usually when people say, oh, everyone can be vegan, I think, not everyone.
- 8:46I mean, there are people who have like health conditions that stop them from eating lots
- 8:51of fibers.
- 8:54But also, there are people like you who have an eating disorder and I feel uncomfortable
- 9:00preaching veganism to those people.
- 9:05What is your take on that?
- 9:07Should we talk about veganism with people who have eating disorders?
- 9:12Should we be more sensitive about advocating for veganism, thinking about, oh, maybe there
- 9:19are some people with eating disorders.
- 9:21And they might want to become vegan, but they just can't because of their condition.
- 9:29So what is your take on that?
- 9:30Well, from my point of view, we shouldn't just forbid ourselves to talk about veganism
- 9:37with these people.
- 9:39But in the end, it all depends on how they are and how they take their journey.
- 9:46For example, I know that if I had become vegan for, well, in the hope that I would have lost
- 9:55weight, it wouldn't have worked.
- 9:57If it was about myself, well, I would have quit it and well, you know, it would have
- 10:02been a failure.
- 10:03But I didn't do it just for myself.
- 10:06It was something bigger.
- 10:07It was about a philosophy.
- 10:09So that's why it worked.
- 10:10But I think any change in food habits is very hard to implement, actually, whether it is
- 10:19for, well, to lose weight or for ethical reasons or for the planet, you need to have a very,
- 10:25very good why.
- 10:27And so if your why is strong enough, then it's going to work.
- 10:31I wholeheartedly agree.
- 10:33I mean, I often say the health argument for veganism is kind of weak.
- 10:39I prefer the ethical and philosophical one.
- 10:43And I'm happy that we're on the same page on that topic.
- 10:49So you did not only become vegan, you started advocating for animal rights.
- 10:57And I want you to tell us about how you made that transition, because this podcast, the
- 11:05goal of my podcast is actually to encourage vegans to take the extra step and to do more
- 11:13for animal rights.
- 11:14So how did that happen for you?
- 11:17Well, first of all, I would say that it took me some time to go from vegan to vegan activist,
- 11:27because at first I really needed to take time for myself to see how it worked for me.
- 11:34And well, I'm someone who really needs time about everything.
- 11:39And you know, I just needed not to be influenced by anyone.
- 11:43I hated when people looked into my plate and told me like, why do you eat like this?
- 11:48And what about your proteins?
- 11:50And like, well, blah, blah, blah.
- 11:52But also I needed not to be influenced by vegans or activists to tell me, oh, this is
- 11:58very good, and you should do this, and you should do that.
- 12:01I really like cut myself a little bit from the world and just tried it for myself to
- 12:07see how it felt really, rather than know a lot of things.
- 12:13And it took me some years.
- 12:14And when I saw that it was working perfectly well for me, then I felt confident enough
- 12:20to go and be an activist and share with others what I saw and what I felt for myself.
- 12:29And so I began with diverse organizations.
- 12:33First, it was very small things.
- 12:36It was, you know, just some street actions.
- 12:40And I'm, well, I'm not very much about advocating, like showing people images, like very violent
- 12:48images and like this, because I don't like it.
- 12:51I'm very sensitive to it.
- 12:52So I cannot stand it for myself.
- 12:55And I'm much more about advocating, like showing people it's possible, showing that vegan
- 13:02food is good, that you can enjoy yourself, and, you know, like this, because I think
- 13:08for me it's things that work.
- 13:10So I share this kind of things.
- 13:13And also I became like, you know, I made some chronicles like a journalist for a small web
- 13:20media some years ago.
- 13:22Yeah, so I worked with diverse NGOs and I volunteer in a sanctuary also in Switzerland.
- 13:29So yeah, diverse actions.
- 13:33And how did that engagement impact you in your personal life?
- 13:40Did it feel good to do more for animal rights?
- 13:45Or does it sometimes get, you know, tiring and you're thinking, oh, maybe I should, you
- 13:51know, take some distance from my activism?
- 13:57Take some distance?
- 13:58No, never.
- 14:00But actually about how it feels, I think it feels both ways, because on the one hand,
- 14:05you meet a lot of people and it's very encouraging and you really build a community and learn
- 14:12things also.
- 14:13And this is very important.
- 14:14On the other hand, you are really confronted with the fact that the world doesn't move
- 14:20past at all.
- 14:22And now I also work on more political subjects.
- 14:27And so when you are in this world, I mean, I just have a toe in this world, but still
- 14:32you really can see how sometimes hypocrite it is.
- 14:38They you know, they say that they want to do some things and it's a lot of very beautiful
- 14:43words, but it's only words and it's never actions.
- 14:46Yeah.
- 14:47I mean, that's politicians for you.
- 14:51I want to know because you're from France, how is veganism perceived in France?
- 14:59What is the reality of vegans in France?
- 15:03It's complicated.
- 15:05We are not very well perceived.
- 15:09I mean, now I think most of the population think that vegans are just people who go and
- 15:16and like break, break batteries or break slaughterhouses during their weekends or things like this,
- 15:24or people who just eat like grass and grains and that's it.
- 15:30Or some of them think that it's only about eating like fake things, fake food.
- 15:37That's it.
- 15:39But on the other hand, it brought a little bit vegetarian vegetarianism out of the box.
- 15:46Now being vegetarian is much more acceptable than it was.
- 15:50And I think this is because veganism is actually much more like not so well perceived.
- 15:56Some years ago, even vegetarian, it was like you were an alien.
- 16:01That's such an interesting point.
- 16:02So because there are more people who are becoming vegan and vegan is more in the mainstream
- 16:07and it's perceived as extreme, then vegetarian is more acceptable for people because they're
- 16:14comparing it to vegan.
- 16:16Now the extreme thing is being vegan and being vegetarian is okay mostly.
- 16:23Basically people are saying, oh, at least you're not vegan.
- 16:27You're vegetarian.
- 16:29Okay, so let's get into the topic of what happened, the discrimination that you went
- 16:38through.
- 16:39So as I understand it, you decided to study nutrition.
- 16:47Why did you choose that field?
- 16:50How did you make that choice?
- 16:52What is nutrition and passion of yours?
- 16:55Well, I think given my history with food, it was like obvious.
- 17:01Well, it was a call, I think, because both because of my history with bulimia and also
- 17:09with my history with veganism, I really wanted to show people first that it was possible
- 17:16to be vegan and to be healthy.
- 17:18And I met quite a lot of people who maybe not wanted to become vegan, but began to question
- 17:26their food habits, but were afraid about like lacking some nutrients and like this.
- 17:32So I really saw that there was something to do about this.
- 17:37And also being a former bulimic, I thought, well, you know, I know that actually food
- 17:44is much more than just like putting gas into a car.
- 17:48It's not just energy.
- 17:50It's a lot more.
- 17:51It has so many psychological links to it.
- 17:57So I really wanted to talk about this and to be able to share with people.
- 18:05First I took a certification to become a nutrient therapist.
- 18:10And this was great.
- 18:11Actually, I loved it.
- 18:13But in France, it's not recognized like it's not official.
- 18:17I still could help people like individuals that I could not work on the collective level.
- 18:24And I really wanted to do this, to be able to help more people and to help change society
- 18:30at a bigger level.
- 18:32So I registered for the dietitian course.
- 18:36This is the only diploma, the only degree that is official in France.
- 18:42So yeah, that's how I came to this degree.
- 18:47So I guess you got a sample of what it's like, the field of nutrition, doing your certification.
- 18:56And then you decided to level up and get more serious about it and become like a board
- 19:02certified dietitian.
- 19:04Yes, right.
- 19:06Exactly.
- 19:08And what is, because you mentioned how you wanted to talk about veganism, at least create
- 19:17more resources, be an expert in the field and be of help of people who want to transition
- 19:25and adopt a vegan diet.
- 19:27I want to know what is it like to be vegan in France and you want to try getting some
- 19:35professional help to help organize your diet?
- 19:39Are you going to find easily like a nutritionist, a dietitian, an expert to help you?
- 19:48Or are you going to be judged?
- 19:51Are there any prejudices?
- 19:54Well, you should really research specifically for a professional who knows about veganism,
- 20:02because otherwise, if it's just any medical help you search, you are going to be judged
- 20:07and you are going to be told that you have to eat meat, especially if it's for children,
- 20:14like for example, parents who go to the doctor or to the dietitian to get advice.
- 20:20If it's not someone who is well, really trained about veganism, they are always going to tell
- 20:27them that the children have to eat meat and that it's a big problem if they don't and
- 20:33they will have like a big nutrient lack.
- 20:37So yeah, it's complicated still.
- 20:40Wow.
- 20:41So the baseline is it's a hostile environment.
- 20:46And did you know that it was a hostile environment before getting into the field?
- 20:51I knew it was a hostile environment and well, really, you know, I just wanted to get this
- 20:57degree to be able to do what I wanted afterwards.
- 21:01But what I learned after registering is that you have a class that is called like culinary
- 21:09techniques and basically it's a cooking class.
- 21:13There are some other subtleties, but still it's basically a cooking class.
- 21:18And during this class, especially for the exam, you only have animal products to cook.
- 21:24I was studying from home.
- 21:26I was like a distance, you know, distance student.
- 21:31Yeah, it was during COVID, I think.
- 21:34Yes, right.
- 21:35Well, at home I could do whatever I wanted, but still at the exam, it's a national exam.
- 21:42So you are only provided with animal products.
- 21:46And what's crazy is that in the text, the text low, it's not written down that you should
- 21:56use animal products or whatever.
- 21:58They even say that the students should be able to advise people with ecological advice
- 22:06and like this, so it's very, very beautiful words, but still in the practice, it's always
- 22:13animal products.
- 22:15So the problem was this particular class, this cooking class, part of your curriculum,
- 22:22and there were only animal ingredients.
- 22:28And I mean, is it like, did you have like a limited number of ingredients?
- 22:37Because I guess for the people listening, it's like, oh, but what if you just don't use
- 22:43the animal products?
- 22:45What if you use only the vegetables or things like that?
- 22:51But actually, you have like a meal that you need to make and that meal is made up of animal
- 23:00products.
- 23:01So can you make that nuance?
- 23:04Yes, well, actually, as you said, it's like you have a recipe to make.
- 23:10Well, usually it's two recipes for the exam.
- 23:13And they, well, because they only give you animal products, it's like you have a limited
- 23:17list of ingredients, as you said.
- 23:19And you cannot, obviously, you cannot bring any ingredients from your home because it's
- 23:24a national exam and they only authorize you with what's directly on the exam site.
- 23:32So for example, we have to cook some very traditional French dishes.
- 23:38I don't know if you know about it, but we have like blanquettes that is made with beer
- 23:45or bourguignon, some things like this that can be asked.
- 23:50And so, well, these are some recipes that I can do with vegan ingredients.
- 23:54I know how to do them.
- 23:55I can cook them vegan.
- 23:57But still, if you don't give me any vegan ingredients, if you only give me veal and like carrots,
- 24:04I cannot give you a blanket with a, well, a blanket, blanket with just veal.
- 24:11If, yeah, I won't use veal because I'm vegan, but if it's only carrots, then it's not what's
- 24:18expected.
- 24:20And by the way, this class is required.
- 24:23You can't pass the class and just get your degree.
- 24:27Yeah, right.
- 24:28It's compulsory.
- 24:29Okay.
- 24:30And I guess people would have told you, oh, but just make it, you know, make the meal.
- 24:38You don't have to eat it.
- 24:40Just make it.
- 24:41You know, close your eyes, do it, and just forget about it.
- 24:45Get your degree and do your good work in the field of veganism.
- 24:49Why was that not an acceptable option for you?
- 24:53Well, it was totally unacceptable.
- 24:56And I actually, there are some, some vegetarian or vegan dietitians who do this and who just
- 25:02skip it for the day.
- 25:04But I can't, I can do this because, because of my history with food.
- 25:09I mean, it would have meant for me crushing my boundaries down.
- 25:13And it's like, tell me, okay, just for one day, you can, you can leave your boundaries
- 25:17at the door and just, you know, walk on it and crush it down.
- 25:22It doesn't matter.
- 25:23And well, it matters actually.
- 25:26Okay.
- 25:27So what did he do then?
- 25:29How did you react?
- 25:31Well, obviously, it was very complicated for me.
- 25:36And at first, I didn't see any, any issue to this problem.
- 25:41So at first I quit it.
- 25:43After some months, I chose to quit this degree and thought, okay, I'm going to do otherwise,
- 25:49whatever, I don't know, but I'm going to do otherwise.
- 25:52Then after some months more, I reflected about this and I thought, okay, this is very important
- 25:59for me, for my career.
- 26:00If I want to work with NGOs and with official institutions, I need to be a dietitian because
- 26:08otherwise I won't be heard.
- 26:10So I thought, okay, I'm going back to, to get this degree and to tackle it.
- 26:15I don't know what I'm going to do about it, but I'm going to do it.
- 26:19And well, to make it a little bit like easier for me, I chose to, to take first the very
- 26:27scientific courses during the first year because intellectually, this is the more difficult.
- 26:34So I thought, okay, I'm just going to tackle this part first.
- 26:37And if I, if I get it, then I will be too advanced to quit again.
- 26:43So that's what I did.
- 26:44This was last year in 2022.
- 26:48And well, when I came back to this class, I still was lost.
- 26:52I didn't know what to do about it.
- 26:54But I thought actually that you could at least go to the jury on the day of the exam and
- 27:02explain them what you did and why you did it.
- 27:05I thought it was a little bit like during, you know, what you see on TV for the cooking,
- 27:11cooking soap shows.
- 27:12MasterChef.
- 27:13I don't know how you call it.
- 27:14Yeah, like MasterChef.
- 27:15Yes, right.
- 27:16Exactly.
- 27:17I thought that you, you just meet the, the examinators and present them your dishes.
- 27:23So I thought, okay, I'm going to prepare something like something like a little bit, a little
- 27:28speech to, to explain to them why there is nothing on my plate and why it's like not
- 27:35good at all.
- 27:36But at least I can tell them, okay, this is for the animals.
- 27:40And this is my story.
- 27:41And you know that for the, for the planet, it's not good.
- 27:45So yeah, at least I can just express myself.
- 27:49And finally I learned that this was not the case at all, that on the day of the exam, you
- 27:55prepare your dish.
- 27:58After, afterwards, you just leave it in the fridge.
- 28:01And after you leave the room, they come and take your dish and taste it.
- 28:05So this was like a big catastrophe for me because I didn't even have this platform to
- 28:11express myself.
- 28:14So finally, after some months, someone gave me the idea that actually I had this medical
- 28:21condition and that I can use it and I can ask a doctor to give me a note saying that
- 28:27I cannot cook with animal products.
- 28:30So that's what I did.
- 28:31And actually I went to a very understanding doctor and she gave me this, this certificate
- 28:40saying that I should not cook with animal products.
- 28:43But I don't know if it's the same in the US or in Canada, but here on the medical certificate,
- 28:49the reason is not, is not written down because this is medical secrecy.
- 28:55Like you know, if, if you give something to your boss, yeah, they should not write the
- 29:00reason on it.
- 29:02That's your, you know, your, your stuff.
- 29:06Yeah.
- 29:07And so what did they say?
- 29:09I mean, you, they have the paper from your doctor saying you cannot use those ingredients.
- 29:16You need to take that class.
- 29:20It is required.
- 29:22You program that class for your last semester of school.
- 29:27You can't give that speech.
- 29:29So what was their response?
- 29:32Well, first of all, it took a very long time to get a response.
- 29:37Of course.
- 29:38I got this paper from the doctor late February this year, so 2023.
- 29:46And they only responded to me in May.
- 29:49So this was several months before they gave me an answer.
- 29:53And first of all, they accepted.
- 29:56So I was very happy about it.
- 29:58And I even got the paper that it was okay and that I would cook this for this exam without
- 30:05animal products.
- 30:06And then 10 days later, I got a call from, well, here we call it the rector like the,
- 30:13you know, the administration, the national administration who organizes the exam.
- 30:19And it was a very embarrassed man who told me that they were sorry, but actually it was
- 30:24not possible to adapt to the exam without animal products because everyone should cook
- 30:29the same thing with the same ingredients.
- 30:33And that the best they could do was provide me with a protective equipment like gloves
- 30:39and, you know, a full equipment to protect myself from the animal products.
- 30:43Because what I understood from this call is that they thought I was allergic.
- 30:47They couldn't see any reason, any other reason why I could ask to cook without animal products.
- 30:57That's just crazy.
- 30:58I mean, they gave you a pair of gloves.
- 31:01They were just like, yeah, we can't adapt.
- 31:05Why?
- 31:06Why is it so hard to just give you like a, like any kind of vegan recipe, like a salad
- 31:12or I mean, it's healthy, a salad is healthy.
- 31:15Why is it so hard for them to just accommodate your needs for that exam?
- 31:22Well, actually, I, I wrote them back and that's what I told them.
- 31:27I told them that either I could have another recipe, but even if they just provided me
- 31:33with, with vegan ingredients, like, you know, some soy proteins or some, well, plant based
- 31:40milk or whatever, I can cook vegan recipes like traditional French dishes, but make it
- 31:45vegan.
- 31:46There is no problem with this.
- 31:48And what they answered me is that all the students should have the same recipe.
- 31:53But actually they didn't answer about the part of me telling them that I can still cook
- 31:58the same recipe, but with vegan ingredients.
- 32:01But I think the why is just because it's like so far from their way of thinking it's like,
- 32:06yeah, it's so strange to them.
- 32:08Well, do you think there is a more, you know, I don't want to, to judge their intentions.
- 32:17We don't know, you know, the real intentions.
- 32:20So do you think they have like, like an animal pro animal industry agenda?
- 32:28Like I'm thinking about discussion I had on episode 12 of the podcast with Dr. Heath.
- 32:34And she's this vegan veterinarian.
- 32:38And when she started speaking up for animal rights, she got this big backlash from her
- 32:43colleagues and from veterinarian associations.
- 32:47And she told me that the reason why lots of vegans, lots of veterinarians are not vegan
- 32:54was because in the selection process, they will reject people who are vegans from, you
- 33:01know, starting a degree in veterinarian school, which is crazy.
- 33:07And I'm thinking, maybe this is what's happening here.
- 33:11Maybe they don't want vegans in your profession.
- 33:13Maybe this is why there aren't many board set your phallic dietitians in your, in your
- 33:22field, you know, vegan in your field.
- 33:25So what do you think?
- 33:26What is your instinct saying here?
- 33:31Well, I think that what you say is true, but at a bigger level.
- 33:36I mean, when they build the nutritional recommendations, there are the lobbies sitting at the table.
- 33:43So yes, this is the part where they intervene.
- 33:47But for example, I think that in the program, the program is built in a way that it already
- 33:56discourages vegans to get into this, this degree.
- 34:01And I'm the exception or it will be vegans who, and there are not many of us, but it
- 34:07will be vegans who just like cook the, the, the recipe that is asked on the D day.
- 34:15And after, after all, they do whatever they want, but still, you know, the recommendations
- 34:19are still very anti vegans.
- 34:21So I think it's not the people from the administration, the people I talked with who are anti vegans
- 34:27or who are like paid by the lobby or whatever.
- 34:30I think on their part, it's really ignorance.
- 34:34It's not wanting to bother themselves and to, you know, just to do things the way they,
- 34:39they are used to do it.
- 34:41But I don't think it's, it's being anti vegan or pro lobby or whatever.
- 34:46Yeah, it's mostly ignorance, but on a bigger, on a bigger level.
- 34:50Yes, it is.
- 34:51Yeah.
- 34:52Yeah.
- 34:53It's not like a nefarious plot against you.
- 34:57It's just, you know, this ignorance that you're talking about that is being fed by the animal,
- 35:03by the influence of the animal industry.
- 35:07Okay.
- 35:08So by the way, how did you feel about all of this?
- 35:13Because you know, I would have felt like just so anxious.
- 35:19So this is such a stressful situation because first of all, you started the degree, then
- 35:26you left, then you came back, then you, you programmed that class for your last semester
- 35:32and you're just, I mean, you're approaching more and more to the date of the exam.
- 35:41And so it's like, it's a very stressful situation.
- 35:45How did you feel?
- 35:46How did you keep your mental health in check?
- 35:53Well, I think I didn't keep it so much actually.
- 35:57And yes, it was, it was very stressful.
- 36:01And during the first year, even though I was not taking this, this class, well, the example,
- 36:07this class at the end of the year, I still relapsed into bulimia actually, because this
- 36:12still put a lot of stress on me because I didn't know what to do about it.
- 36:17And during the second year, well, actually it was not about bulimia, but I was just unable
- 36:24to study, especially this class, I was just totally unable to study if I tried to read
- 36:30some things or listen to some things.
- 36:32You know, every time I saw the name of an animal product, it was just like so stressful
- 36:37for me.
- 36:38And also I was very angry about it.
- 36:40So at this moment, it was just like words were mingling in front of my eyes.
- 36:45So yeah, it was a lot of stress.
- 36:48Totally understandable.
- 36:49And the other students, were they understanding of your situation?
- 36:55Did you share what you were going through?
- 36:57What was your opinion?
- 37:01Well, because I was studying from distance, you know, like, yeah, distention, I was not
- 37:06in touch with a lot of students.
- 37:08But actually the students who were not vegan, they just didn't understand at all.
- 37:13And there are some students in dietitian class who are totally anti-vegan also.
- 37:20And there are some vegan students that I knew who were very supportive of me.
- 37:27But, well, you know, for them, they just wanted to do what they were asked to on the
- 37:32day of the exam, to secure the exam.
- 37:35But still they were supportive, but not ready to like to do as I wanted to do.
- 37:40At this time, I didn't know how, but just be sure that I wouldn't cook or touch animal
- 37:46product on the day of the exam.
- 37:49And it's sad because I guess you had to hide the fact that you were vegan to certain teachers.
- 37:58And that was just a missed opportunity to maybe ask them questions that were relevant
- 38:04to veganism because you don't know if they're prejudiced.
- 38:09So yeah, it's a complicated situation.
- 38:12Well, as for this, as for the part about the questions, I also took another, like, degree
- 38:19it's not like, well, it's not it's not official, but it's not like something you can you can
- 38:27put on your CV or something like this.
- 38:29But it was something specific about vegetarian eating, which included vegan eating as well.
- 38:35And it was a class was made by two doctors who are very like pro vegetarian, pro vegans.
- 38:42So I had this class in 2022.
- 38:47So you know, about the knowledge I needed, I could ask it on this, yeah, on this part.
- 38:52So yeah, I didn't need like the regular course to give me this knowledge.
- 38:59Nice.
- 39:00That's great to hear.
- 39:02And there are other countries where it is more acceptable to be vegan of vegetarian.
- 39:07So you have resources there too, that you can access.
- 39:11Okay.
- 39:12So what happened next, they're suggesting you to use, you know, gloves, you're insisting
- 39:20that you this is not about skin, this is not a skin condition.
- 39:26So you still had to take the exam.
- 39:28What happened?
- 39:31So this was in late May that they told me that finally I should cook with animal products
- 39:39like everyone else.
- 39:41And the exam, well, my exam was on June 6.
- 39:44So it was very, very short notice.
- 39:48So at this time I was asking myself a lot of questions, but still, I thought about going
- 39:53to justice and I told the man who phoned me from the administration that I was going
- 39:58to bring this to justice.
- 40:01I was not 100% sure myself because I feared a lot that, well, you know, it was embarrassing
- 40:08for me and that I could, well, be seen like, you know, the, the bother, well, someone who
- 40:15bothers everyone and like this.
- 40:17But still I thought to do this.
- 40:21And after thinking about it for some days, well, this was the good decision for me because,
- 40:28you know, I, I thought a lot about why I went to this, to this class and why I wanted to
- 40:34get this degree.
- 40:35And in the end, it was for the animals, it was not just about myself.
- 40:40So I thought, okay, even if I need to, to wait one year more to get my degree, I'm still
- 40:47going to do this because, well, you know, getting my degree is more about something about my
- 40:51ego, but yeah, that's not the final, the finality of it.
- 40:57And let's not, you know, get into the details of it, but how do you start, you know, suing
- 41:07someone for something?
- 41:08Did you have to look up for a lawyer?
- 41:13Then you had to explain the situation.
- 41:16What is the process that you have to go through?
- 41:19Well, here, when you sue the administration, it's, it's a court, a specialist court for
- 41:28the administration, you don't have to get a lawyer.
- 41:32But still, you know that it will be better for you if you have a lawyer.
- 41:36So I, well, I didn't really search for a lawyer at this time because I was in contact with
- 41:42the, with one, but he's in Switzerland and I'm in France.
- 41:46So the first thing I did is that I CC him with, in my emails that I sent to the administration.
- 41:53And at first he told me, okay, I'm going to take your case.
- 41:56But after all, we phoned each other and we thought, okay, so this is maybe too complicated
- 42:01because even if he's, if he's specialized in international rights, it's international.
- 42:07It's not about the French law, especially.
- 42:10So he found a colleague in Paris who could help me.
- 42:15And yeah, so that's how I found a lawyer because I knew that if it was just myself, you know,
- 42:20there are very, some very specific language like low language, if you don't fit into it,
- 42:28it's not so good.
- 42:29So I wanted to take a lawyer.
- 42:30Yeah, it's called, I think, legalese, the language of lawyers.
- 42:36And it's horrible.
- 42:37I start reading, you know, texts of laws and I just, I want to go to sleep.
- 42:43It's so boring.
- 42:45Okay.
- 42:46And then what, you know, did you get that diploma?
- 42:51Or, I don't know.
- 42:54How did they, I still, I still, I still didn't finish it because it's a, well, it's a degree
- 43:02where we get the results very late.
- 43:04And actually I'm still going to take one part of the exam next week.
- 43:08No, this week, actually, in two days.
- 43:12It's about the memoir that you have to, you know, something written and then you explain
- 43:17it and I get the results only next week.
- 43:20So I still don't know if I got it.
- 43:23And are you worried because I feel like, you know, you're suing them and they have to grade
- 43:29your papers now and, you know, decide whether to give you that diploma or not.
- 43:36Are you worried that they won't be objective in their assessment of your profile, of your
- 43:44student profile?
- 43:46Well, I was very much worried at first.
- 43:50And when I was in this, like wondering, okay, am I going to do this or not?
- 43:55I was very much worried about this.
- 43:58But what I realized since last June is that actually the examinators, I think they don't
- 44:05know about it.
- 44:07They don't communicate that much.
- 44:09And you know, the examinators, they just come and grade you or correct your, well, what
- 44:15you wrote, but they don't have like your whole resume.
- 44:19So I think it's, it can be done.
- 44:23I don't know.
- 44:25That's good.
- 44:26And, okay, now you're suing them.
- 44:30What is going to happen if you win your case against them?
- 44:37Well, what I hope is that it will become compulsory, you know, it will become, here we say jurisprudence.
- 44:45I don't know if it's the same word.
- 44:47Yeah.
- 44:48I think so, yeah.
- 44:49It will become jurisprudence that there should be vegan ingredients in the exams, in the cooking
- 44:55exams for the dietitian.
- 44:58I really hope so, and that's why I went to justice, because if it would have been just
- 45:03for myself, I don't know if I would have bothered that much.
- 45:08But it's also because I thought, okay, if nobody says anything, if, well, it will just
- 45:13continue like this.
- 45:15If even vegan students don't say anything and just comply on the day of the exam, no,
- 45:22nothing will happen and nothing will change.
- 45:25And that's amazing, because you know, you're going, if this succeeds, you're going to change
- 45:32the field of nutrition in all of France.
- 45:37And students, vegan who want to get into that field won't have to go through the struggle
- 45:46that you went through.
- 45:48So yeah, it's an amazing story, because it's like if you wanted to do more for animal rights,
- 45:58and often the whole team of this podcast is choose your fight, choose your way of making
- 46:04a difference.
- 46:05But you did not choose that fight.
- 46:07That fight chose you, which is crazy and amazing in its own way.
- 46:16What can we do to support your fight?
- 46:20Well, first of all, giving me a platform to talk about it is really great, because I think
- 46:27that's important to take the word out and to make people realize that they have power,
- 46:34that they can do things.
- 46:35And that's also why I do this and I went to justice.
- 46:40Because yeah, I think it's important not to just say, okay, I'm going to let this go.
- 46:46And after, well, as for me, I think this is really the most important.
- 46:53There is another fight that I'm supporting actually very much.
- 46:59That's also about justice for vegans and so for animals as well.
- 47:05That is very important.
- 47:07It's an appeal that is happening at the European Court of Human Rights right now.
- 47:13And this is based on the story of a former vegan prisoner who was a, well, who is a friend
- 47:19of a friend actually, and it's his lawyer who found me my lawyer actually.
- 47:26And this is a very, very big fight because it's the ECHR.
- 47:33And so if he wins, it will make that European countries will be obligated to give vegan
- 47:44options, at least in prisons.
- 47:47And I hope also in hospitals and we can hope maybe one day in schools as well.
- 47:53So yeah, it will be 46 countries if he wins.
- 47:56So this is something huge.
- 47:58And he is leading a crowdfunding right now to pay his lawyer.
- 48:03So this is a way to help also defend the vegan rights and so animal rights as well.
- 48:10Yeah.
- 48:11And listeners will find a link in the description to support that crowdfunding campaign.
- 48:18So what I understand from this story is that he went to prison and there were no vegan
- 48:23options.
- 48:24So he basically starved.
- 48:25Yes, that's exactly it.
- 48:28There was no vegan options.
- 48:30For some days he could not eat anything because even the pasta, the rice or the vegetables
- 48:36were cooked with dairy or with eggs.
- 48:39So for days he could not eat.
- 48:41At first he was not given any B12 supplement.
- 48:46It took him two months before the prison gave him some.
- 48:49And at first they gave him some vegan supplement, sorry, some B12 supplement with animal products
- 48:56in it.
- 48:57But he could not even take it and it took maybe two months more before he was authorized
- 49:02to get B12 supplements from his friends, bringing them, bringing it into prison.
- 49:07So yeah, this was crazy.
- 49:09And yeah, it's a very good thing that he went to court with it.
- 49:13It's a horrendous story.
- 49:15But yeah, like you said, I'm so happy that he's fighting for the rights of vegans.
- 49:23And it's good that you mentioned his story because I guess I'm sure that there are listeners
- 49:30right now who went through some form of discrimination being vegan.
- 49:37And maybe this is the sign for them to fight against that.
- 49:46I don't know if there is any Facebook group or any kind of group network to support vegans
- 49:56who lived through discrimination because of their dietary choices, like a support group.
- 50:04So maybe this could be an initiative that a listener could start.
- 50:09So yeah.
- 50:10Yes, totally.
- 50:11This would be a good idea and yet to support each other.
- 50:15I think I'm encouraged each other to do something about it.
- 50:19Yeah, well, what do you want to say to vegans who want to do more but are still on the fence
- 50:26about it?
- 50:27Well, I think first of all, maybe find your way to do it.
- 50:33I mean, don't think, okay, this is the good thing to do.
- 50:37Like the only way is to show people horrendous images of slaughterhouses.
- 50:42So I should do this or this is the efficient way.
- 50:45So I should do this.
- 50:46I think first of all, begin by yourself.
- 50:49Like think about what you like, what you are good at, what you want to do.
- 50:54And yeah, put this at the service of the vegan cause and of the animal cause.
- 51:01So that's the way you will thrive, I think, at what you do.
- 51:06And also about vegan discrimination, well, discrimination against vegans.
- 51:12I think that we should always say something and maybe not being very vocal about it.
- 51:18I mean, I'm not shouting everywhere like, okay, this is a big injustice and I'm so miserable
- 51:26and like this, but still I think it's very important to say, okay, this is a no, this
- 51:31is my limit and you're not going to cross it point like a period.
- 51:36Yeah, I agree with that perspective.
- 51:38Yeah, we want more people to be vegan and to stay vegan.
- 51:42And if we allow those institutions to continue, you know, marginalizing vegan, then our mission
- 51:51will be harder or sometimes even impossible.
- 51:58So Astrid, did you want to add something before we end this conversation?
- 52:03That's a big thank you for having me on your podcast and yeah, that's really, really great.
- 52:10I think that's very important to make our voices heard.
- 52:16And also in some way it is to make the animals heard because, you know, I don't say so much
- 52:22that they don't have a voice because actually when you are in contact with an animal, they
- 52:27really know how to speak with you and how to communicate with you.
- 52:31But I think to other humans, it's important that we humans speak up and tell our stories
- 52:39and encourage other people to follow not our path, but their own path to being more empathetic
- 52:46and vegan because vegan is good.
- 52:49Amazing, that's a great message to end the conversation.
- 52:53Thank you so much Astrid for having been a guest on this show.
- 52:57Thank you so much for sharing this incredible story of yours and for continuing your fight
- 53:03for animal rights.
- 53:05You have my full admiration.
- 53:07So thank you very much Astrid.
- 53:09Thank you everyone for listening.
- 53:11Let me remind you that the webinar will be happening on October 17.
- 53:16There is a link in the description for registration and more details.
- 53:21I want to thank the National Lawyers Guild for hosting the event.
- 53:25As always, please tell your friends about the show and why you love it so much.
- 53:30Let's inspire more people to take action.
- 53:34If you are listening to this on Apple Podcasts, please leave me a 5 stars review.
- 53:40Finally, you can always reach out to me on Instagram at VeganReportPodcast.
- 53:47Thank you again for listening.
- 53:49Take care and see you next Tuesday for a new episode.