Latest / Deep Dive / The Stairwell of Identity: Why Culture Lives Between Borders
Transcript
- 0:00So imagine you are standing on the deck of this massive cargo
- 0:04ship. Right, OK, I'm picturing.
- 0:06And the ship itself? It was built by Korean laborers
- 0:09over in the shipyards of Olsen, but it's currently flying a
- 0:13Bahamian flag of convenience. Right, which is super common in
- 0:16global shipping. Exactly.
- 0:18And the crew, the people actually operating the cranes
- 0:21and navigating the bridge, they might be Salvadoran or maybe
- 0:24Filipino. And right at this exact moment,
- 0:27the ship is docking at a port in Norway.
- 0:31Hmm. There's literally a loudspeaker
- 0:33blaring the Norwegian national anthem in the background.
- 0:37O if someone were to walk U to you right then on that deck and
- 0:40just ask, you know, what is the culture of this ship?
- 0:42What would you even say? Yeah, that's it's a nearly
- 0:44impossible question if you rely on the old way of thinking,
- 0:47because usually we try to cram identity into neat little boxes
- 0:50like this is Korean, that is Norwegian.
- 0:52Right, we want a clear blueprint for everything.
- 0:54Exactly. We rely entirely on that kind of
- 0:57architectural logic to make sense of the world.
- 1:00A blueprint where you know the boundaries are completely solid,
- 1:04categories are absolute, and you always know exactly what room
- 1:07you are standing in. Well, welcome to the deep dive,
- 1:10because today we are basically taking a sledgehammer to that
- 1:14blueprint. You really are.
- 1:16Our mission today is to radically rethink how we
- 1:19actually define culture and identity, and we're pulling from
- 1:22excerpts of Hokey K Baba's groundbreaking book, The
- 1:26Location of Culture. That's an important text.
- 1:29It really is, and we're going to explore this idea that for you,
- 1:32for anyone navigating the present day, our true identities
- 1:35aren't actually found inside those neat historical boxes.
- 1:38They are forged in the messy kind of constantly shifting
- 1:41spaces between them. Yeah, because you mean, think
- 1:44about the world we live in right now.
- 1:45It's defined by mass migration, these deeply intertwined global
- 1:48economies, constant cultural collision.
- 1:50It's nonstop. Right.
- 1:52And Fappa argues that trying to understand modern politics or
- 1:56global conflicts or even just your own personal identity
- 1:59through those rigid old school categories, it's just a failed
- 2:03project. Yeah.
- 2:04You literally can't do it. We have to look at the
- 2:06borderlines instead. OK, let's unpack this.
- 2:09Because if culture isn't a fixed room on a blueprint, what does
- 2:13it actually look like? Like, how do we even begin to
- 2:15visualize something that exists strictly in the middle?
- 2:18So Papa Princess to a physical representation that captures
- 2:22this beautifully. I think it's a site specific
- 2:25installation by the African American artist Renee Green.
- 2:28Oh right, the sites of genealogy piece.
- 2:30Exactly. Sites of genealogy.
- 2:31And what she did was she used the actual physical architecture
- 2:35of a museum building to map out how we traditionally construct
- 2:38these binary identities. Like good and bad, black and
- 2:41white, that sort of thing. Spot on.
- 2:42So she assigned the attic of the building to represent these
- 2:45higher concepts. So whiteness, heaven, purity,
- 2:48light. And then way down below in the
- 2:50boiler room that represented the lower concepts, blackness, hell,
- 2:55darkness. OK, so we have the ultimate
- 2:57polar opposites here. You are literally either
- 2:59upstairs or you were downstairs. Right.
- 3:01But here's where it gets really interesting.
- 3:03The brilliance of Greens installation is that the focus
- 3:06wasn't actually the attic, and it wasn't the boiler room
- 3:09either. Really.
- 3:10Then what was it? The core insight was the
- 3:13physical pathway connecting them, the stairwell.
- 3:16The stairwell. Yeah, the stairwell is what we
- 3:18call liminal space. It's this connective tissue
- 3:21where identities are no longer fixed in place.
- 3:24What's fascinating here is how the physical temporal act of
- 3:29pacing back and forth in that stairwell, that movement
- 3:32actively prevents identity from settling into those static
- 3:35polarities at either end. Because you're constantly in
- 3:38motion. Exactly.
- 3:39It creates what Papa calls cultural hybridity.
- 3:42You know, think about how that plays out in everyday life for
- 3:44all of us. It's very similar to the mental
- 3:46mechanics of code switching, right?
- 3:47Well, that's a great analogy. Because consider how you, the
- 3:50listener, speak and sit and carry yourself when you are in a
- 3:54highly formal corporate board meeting.
- 3:57And then contrast that with how you act a few hours later when
- 4:00you're just grabbing a drink with your oldest childhood
- 4:02friends. It's totally different.
- 4:04Night and day you basically have a corporate room and a friend
- 4:06room, but you aren't being fake or dishonest in either of those
- 4:10rooms. Your true complex identity is
- 4:14the physical and psychological act of walking the stairwell
- 4:16between them. You are the fluid negotiation.
- 4:19I love that you are the fluid negotiation and if we scale that
- 4:23up to the global stage, we arrive right back at your
- 4:26opening scenario with the cargo ship.
- 4:28Oh, right. Because Papa explicitly cites
- 4:30Alan Sekulow's photographic project on global harbors to
- 4:34make this exact point. The ship built in Korea, crewed
- 4:37by Salvadorans arriving in Norway.
- 4:39That entire global supply chain? That is the modern stairwell.
- 4:42The whole ocean is the stairwell.
- 4:44Yes, the true culture of that moment doesn't belong purely to
- 4:48Korea or the Bahamas or Norway. It exists entirely in the
- 4:53transnational transit space connecting them all.
- 4:56OK, but if our true culture lives in the transit spaces, the
- 5:00stairwells, the harbors, the borderlines, it forces a pretty
- 5:03uncomfortable realization about where we go to feel safe.
- 5:06It definitely does. Like what happens to our
- 5:08traditional concept of home? You know, that isolated place
- 5:10where we can just shut the door, lock the deadbolt and keep the
- 5:13world completely out? Well, according to the text,
- 5:16that concept of the isolated sanctuary basically shatters
- 5:19completely. Yikes.
- 5:21OK. Yeah, Babha introduces this
- 5:23concept of the unhomely, or in psychological terms, the
- 5:27unheimlich. And it's critical to note here
- 5:30this is not about being literally homeless.
- 5:33Right, it's a psychological state.
- 5:34Exactly. It is the sudden, terrifying
- 5:37realization that the borders between your private domestic
- 5:40sphere and the massive public political world outside have
- 5:44just collapsed. History has invaded the house.
- 5:47So the world outside doesn't just knock on the door, it
- 5:49literally kicks the front door down.
- 5:51That's exactly it, and the sources provide a couple of
- 5:54devastating literary examples to really illustrate this invasion.
- 5:57Toni Morrison's novel Beloved is a prime 1.
- 6:00Oh wow, yes, powerful book. Unbelievably powerful.
- 6:05So the house in the book, 124 Bluestone Rd.
- 6:07It's not just a structure of wood and nails.
- 6:09The text talks about how it mutters and Mumbles with the
- 6:12unspeakable thoughts of women and this profound, violently
- 6:16oppressive history of American slavery.
- 6:18The trauma is built into the walls.
- 6:20The domestic space is entirely overwhelmed by the historical
- 6:23reality of the outside world. So when the mother in the story
- 6:26commits infanticide, the text reframes it from this purely
- 6:29personal tragedy into a desperate, agonizing political
- 6:33act. How so?
- 6:34It's a slave mother attempting to claim ultimate ownership over
- 6:37her own child, fighting against a massive capitalist
- 6:40institutional system that viewed both of them as mere property.
- 6:44God, it's the ultimate public trauma violently invading the
- 6:47most intimate private bond imaginable.
- 6:48Exactly. And we see a different, but I'd
- 6:51say equally powerful manifestation of this in Nadine
- 6:54Gordimer's novel, My Son's Story, which is set in apartheid
- 6:57era South Africa. OK.
- 6:59What happens in that one? There's a character named Ayla
- 7:01and she takes her quiet, highly domestic safe home and she turns
- 7:05it into a secret cover for revolutionary gun running.
- 7:08Yeah, her home becomes a strange house to her own family.
- 7:12Yeah, the private sphere is entirely weaponized for the
- 7:15public struggle. OK, hold on.
- 7:17I need to push back on this a little bit.
- 7:18Sure, go ahead. Because if the private and
- 7:20public spheres merge so completely, that implies
- 7:23literally everything we do in private is politically charged.
- 7:26Like if I'm standing in my kitchen making a sandwich on a
- 7:29Tuesday night, is that somehow a reflection of global
- 7:33geopolitical struggle? I see where you're going with
- 7:35this. Because honestly, exhausting is
- 7:37an understatement If I can't even view my kitchen as a safe
- 7:40haven, aren't we just driving people to complete psychological
- 7:45burnout? I mean, does anyone ever get to
- 7:47just relax? Look, the exhaustion is
- 7:50incredibly real. It is arguably A defining
- 7:53symptom of the modern condition. But Fava argues that ignoring
- 7:57this unhomely state, just pretending it doesn't exist,
- 8:01that it's a luxury, it's a privilege that marginalized
- 8:04people have never actually had. Because they can't just shut the
- 8:06door on history. Exactly.
- 8:08Recognizing that history is in your house forces you to see
- 8:12that the body politic, you know, the health, the laws, the
- 8:15direction of a nation isn't just about civic virtues debated in
- 8:19some distant marble parliament building somewhere.
- 8:22It is intimately personal, right?
- 8:24Your kitchen is only a haven if the laws outside actually
- 8:27protect it. When the political invades the
- 8:30personal, it means the personal has the power and really the
- 8:33obligation to push back. But how do you actually push
- 8:36back? You know you can't just fight
- 8:37systemic historical forces with good intentions and sheer
- 8:40willpower if the invisible rules of society are literally
- 8:43invading your home. You need a way to decode those
- 8:46rules first. And this is exactly where Bapa
- 8:49launches into a fierce, passionate defense of academic
- 8:52critical theory theory. The thing everyone loves to
- 8:54hate? Right.
- 8:55We often hear the complaint and the text actually quotes an
- 8:57activist explicitly saying this. They say we are not artists, we
- 9:00are political activists. Right there is this pervasive
- 9:03idea that theory is just, you know, privileged Western elite
- 9:07jargon that just distracts from the real on the groundwork of
- 9:12protesting on the streets. The classic Put down the book
- 9:15and pick up a protest sign argument.
- 9:16Exactly. But if?
- 9:17We connect this to the bigger picture.
- 9:19Papa argues that theory is not a luxury, it is the decoding
- 9:23mechanism. Theory and political practice
- 9:26are essentially the front and back of a single piece of paper.
- 9:29You can't have one without the other.
- 9:31OK, give me an example of how that works in real life.
- 9:34Think about organizing a labor strike with a physical leaflet.
- 9:39Handing out the leaflet, organizing the workers.
- 9:41That is the practice. But the entire reason that
- 9:44leaflet has any power at all relies on embedded theoretical
- 9:48principles. Like what?
- 9:50Like the right to strike, the theory of Labor value?
- 9:53The concept of worker solidarity?
- 9:55If you don't have the theory backing you up, you are just
- 9:58swinging blindly at the symptoms of an oppressive system rather
- 10:02than dismantling the disease itself.
- 10:04That makes a lot of sense. So what specific theoretical
- 10:06tool does Papa give us to actually dismantle it?
- 10:09He introduces this concept called the third space of
- 10:11Annunciation, the. 3rd space OK, what is that?
- 10:13So whenever a statement is made, there is the literal text of the
- 10:16statement, right? Then there is the person making
- 10:18it, and then there is an enormous cloud of cultural
- 10:22baggage, historical context, and power dynamics surrounding both
- 10:26of them. Like the unspoken subtext.
- 10:28Right. The meaning isn't just in the
- 10:30words themselves. It is forged in this messy
- 10:33negotiated third space, and colonial powers absolutely
- 10:36despise the third space. Why?
- 10:39Just because it's ambiguous. Because ambiguity destroys
- 10:42absolute authority, oppressive systems rely heavily on having
- 10:46the final, unquestioned say on what is true or real.
- 10:50They want a monopoly on reality. Which you can't have if meaning
- 10:53is always up for debate. Exactly.
- 10:55If meaning is always negotiated in this third space, it means
- 10:58the colonizer's rules are never absolute.
- 11:00The marginalized subject always has room to reinterpret things,
- 11:03to mock them, to subvert the meaning of the rules.
- 11:06The third space basically prevents the colonizer from
- 11:08locking reality into a fixed permanent state.
- 11:11Now here's where it gets really interesting.
- 11:13Because if the colonizer realizes they are losing control
- 11:16in that fluid third space, they have to deploy a weapon to try
- 11:20and force reality back into those rigid, predictable boxes,
- 11:25right? Yes, and the primary weapon of
- 11:27colonial discourse is this concept of fixity.
- 11:30Fixity, meaning keeping things fixed in place.
- 11:33Right. The colonizer looks at the
- 11:35colonized subject. They recognize a difference, a
- 11:37skin color or language, but they completely refuse to engage with
- 11:41the complex humanity behind it. Instead, they flatten the person
- 11:45out. By obsessively repeating a
- 11:47stereotype, they lock the human being into a static, unchanging
- 11:51category. And the text grounds this in a
- 11:53really visceral anecdote from the philosopher Franz Fanon.
- 11:56Yeah, Fanon describes this primal scene of colonial racism
- 12:00that happened to him on a train. It's incredibly striking what
- 12:03happened. He's on this train and a white
- 12:04child points at him and yells, Look a Negro Mama.
- 12:07See the Negro. I'm frightened.
- 12:09And in that exact moment, Fatten writes that his own identity was
- 12:13shattered under the weight of that stereotypical gaze.
- 12:16He was suddenly split into three parts.
- 12:19He was responsible for his body, responsible for his race and
- 12:22responsible for his ancestors. He was entirely erased as an
- 12:25individual. Completely erased and just
- 12:28crushed under the historical weight of a fixed label.
- 12:31You know, the text makes a really striking claim here about
- 12:33this. It says a stereotype isn't just
- 12:36bad information or a simple lie. It operates exactly like a
- 12:40psychological fetish. Yes, that's a crucial point.
- 12:43And I am really trying to wrap my head around that.
- 12:46How does a racial stereotype function mechanically like a
- 12:48fetish? It comes down to a profound
- 12:50unresolved ambivalence. A psychological fetish is
- 12:54essentially A coping mechanism for something that causes the
- 12:56subject deep existential anxiety.
- 12:59The stereotype vacillates wildly between two totally
- 13:02contradictory poles. What are the poles?
- 13:04So on one hand, the colonial discourse paints the colonized
- 13:09subject as a terrifying, lustful, dangerous savage, the
- 13:13ultimate existential threat like a cannibal.
- 13:17But simultaneously, in the exact same breath, it paints them as a
- 13:22mystical, obedient, simple minded, innocent child.
- 13:25So it's horror mixed with this bizarre, twisted desire.
- 13:29Exactly. It's kind of like dealing with a
- 13:31hardcore conspiracy theorist, isn't it?
- 13:33Like whenever a conspiracy theorist is presented with hard
- 13:36evidence that contradicts their worldview, they don't change
- 13:39their mind. They just repeat their
- 13:40conspiracy theory even louder and more obsessively to maintain
- 13:44their illusion of control. That is a perfect way to look at
- 13:47it. The colonizers doing the exact
- 13:49same thing. They are terrified by the
- 13:51complex humanity of the colonized because it
- 13:53fundamentally threatens their entire justification for ruling
- 13:56them, so they just keep shouting the stereotype louder and louder
- 13:59to drown out reality. Precisely.
- 14:00The colonizer needs the stereotype to maintain their own
- 14:03sense of mastery over the world. Which brings us to a fascinating
- 14:07question. How does the marginalized
- 14:09subject actually fight back against that?
- 14:11Right, because if stepping into the light just gets you hit with
- 14:14that paralyzing, fetishistic gaze, you have to find a totally
- 14:19different battlefield. You do, and the sources
- 14:21highlight this really fascinating strategy found in
- 14:24post colonial poetry, specifically the work of Adil
- 14:27Gisawalla and Mailing Jim. The strategy is to actively
- 14:31weaponize your own invisibility. So if the colonizer wants to fix
- 14:35you in place with their gaze, you just refuse to give them a
- 14:38target. Exactly.
- 14:39You turn the refusal to truly see your humanity into a
- 14:42mechanical trap. For example, in Jin's poetry, we
- 14:45see the concept of the evil eye. It's this marginalized presence
- 14:48that refuses to be fully seen, yet it remains there to watch
- 14:52and haunt the oppressor from the periphery.
- 14:54Oh. It's chilling.
- 14:55It is, and Juusawala writes about the missing person, which
- 14:58is an identity only faintly penciled in behind a trendy
- 15:00jacket. By remaining deliberately
- 15:03incomplete or invisible, they totally dismantle the
- 15:05colonizer's power. Because the colonizer's
- 15:08authority requires a visible subject to dominate.
- 15:10Right when the subject becomes a ghost, a missing person, the
- 15:14oppressor's gaze just hits empty space.
- 15:17They are left haunted by an unseen presence they can no
- 15:20longer control or categorize. But I mean, weaponizing
- 15:23invisibility definitely has a limit, doesn't it?
- 15:25You still have to survive in a physical society controlled by
- 15:29the colonizer's rules. If you can't just hide in the
- 15:32margins forever, how do you navigate their institutions
- 15:35without losing yourself? That is the $1,000,000 question,
- 15:38and that is where Baba introduces what might be the
- 15:41most dangerous game of all. Mimicry.
- 15:43Mimicry, like copying the master.
- 15:45Yes, and to grasp the intense anxiety that mimicry causes the
- 15:49colonizer. The text pulls this fascinating
- 15:52quote from 1839 by Sir Edward Kust, who was a British
- 15:55official. OK, what was he saying back in
- 15:571839? Kust was complaining bitterly
- 15:59about the policy of conferring A mimic representation of the
- 16:02British constitution on African colonies.
- 16:04He called it a dangerous mockery.
- 16:06He was scared of it, terrified. He was terrified that giving
- 16:09these colonies the, you know, maces and ceremonies of British
- 16:13law would cause them to forget their colonial dependence.
- 16:16He feared they would use the very tools of British
- 16:19civilization to completely defy the mother country.
- 16:23Cus was panicking because he actually saw the fatal flaw in
- 16:26the entire colonial setup. He absolutely did.
- 16:29The core strategy of the colonizer is to demand
- 16:32assimilation. You must act western.
- 16:34Learn our language, wear our clothes, adopt our legal
- 16:37systems. But, and this is the absolute
- 16:40crux of Bob's argument, the colonized must remain almost the
- 16:43same, but not quite. Wait, why not quite?
- 16:46Because if they become exactly the same, the justification for
- 16:49colonialism evaporates overnight.
- 16:50Oh. Right.
- 16:51If the colonial subjects are perfectly equal, fully civilized
- 16:54British citizens, the Empire can no longer justify treating them
- 16:58as subhuman subjects to be exploited.
- 17:00Exactly, They need the assimilation to be slightly
- 17:03flawed so they can stay in charge.
- 17:04So how did the colonized use that?
- 17:06The colonized take this to man and turn it into a tool of
- 17:09subversion. The text provides a brilliant,
- 17:12highly specific linguistic example of how this operates in
- 17:16practice. It involves the phonetic
- 17:18teaching of English in colonial India.
- 17:20OK, I love linguistic examples. Lay it on me.
- 17:22So the British impose the English language obviously, but
- 17:26when the Indian subjects are taught to speak the Hindi vowel
- 17:29in English, it comes out as and the text writes it phonetically
- 17:33like this, ER a cough. Wait, seriously?
- 17:36So just a slight mispronunciation?
- 17:38A literal cough is considered an act of rebellion.
- 17:41How does that actually threaten the massive British Empire?
- 17:43It threatens them because it is a double scene.
- 17:46The colonial power demands you speak their language, and you
- 17:49comply. You speak it, but you speak it
- 17:51with a difference. The slight slippage of the
- 17:53Arakoff is a quiet, undeniable assertion of cultural identity.
- 17:57The colonized subject is mimicking the master, but the
- 18:00subtle distortion actively mocks the master's authority.
- 18:03It's camouflage. Yes, exactly.
- 18:05You use the colonizer's own language, their own
- 18:08institutions, to basically build a suit of armor.
- 18:11You hide in plain sight, conforming just enough to
- 18:15survive the brutal surveillance of the state, but that not quite
- 18:18preserves your inner difference. You are secretly plotting your
- 18:22resistance from inside the master's house.
- 18:24It's brilliant. It subverts the power structure
- 18:27from the inside out, turning the very tools of oppression into
- 18:31the actual instruments of liberation.
- 18:33Man, that is just, it's mind blowing.
- 18:36So what does this all mean for us today?
- 18:38We have journeyed through some incredibly dense, vital
- 18:42territory today. We really have covered a lot of
- 18:44ground. We started in the physical
- 18:46stairwell, recognizing that our true identities don't live in
- 18:49neat historical boxes, but in the fluid, liminal spaces
- 18:51between them. And then we confronted the
- 18:53unhomely you know, the terrifying reality of history
- 18:56crashing through our front doors and merging the private with the
- 18:59political. We examine the absolute
- 19:01necessity of theory to decode the invisible rules of power,
- 19:04and we dove deep into the psychological warfare of the
- 19:07borderlines. Right How oppressors use the
- 19:10fetish of the stereotype to freeze reality.
- 19:13And how marginalized people fight back by weaponizing their
- 19:16invisibility and turning forced mimicry into subversive
- 19:19camouflage. It's all connected.
- 19:21It is knowing this framework helps you, the listener, see the
- 19:25hidden machinery operating behind the world right now,
- 19:29behind modern culture, the political arguments dominating
- 19:32your screen, and the news you read every single day.
- 19:36You are not a fixed point on a map.
- 19:38You are a fluid, ongoing negotiation.
- 19:40And I think this raises an important question for you to
- 19:42take away and Mull over. We focused heavily on historical
- 19:45texts and colonial subjects today, but the mechanics of
- 19:48power operate in your life right now.
- 19:51Think about the masks you are required to wear in your own
- 19:53daily routines. Yeah, that's a great point.
- 19:56Think about the moments you are forced to mimic the behavior
- 19:58expected of you by your boss, by societal norms, or by the
- 20:02dominant culture around you. Ask yourself, when you were
- 20:05putting on that mask and playing the part, are you simply
- 20:07conforming to their power, or are you perhaps unconsciously
- 20:11building your own camouflage? Are you just surviving the room
- 20:15or are you secretly learning how to dismantle the house?
- 20:19The blueprint tries to tell you the walls are solid, but your
- 20:22real power is in the stairwell. Thank you for taking this deep
- 20:25dive with us today. Keep exploring the spaces in
- 20:27between.