Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Apple Q4 2025 Financial Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we're we're taking a
- 0:02massive stack of financial research and really cracking
- 0:06open the engine room of, well, arguably the world's most
- 0:09valuable company, Apple Inc, ticker AAPL.
- 0:12And our mission today is pretty clear, move past the headlines,
- 0:16you know, we're going to dissect their Q4 FY20 25 earnings,
- 0:20really get under the skin of that huge competitive Moat they
- 0:23have, and maybe most importantly, run the stock
- 0:26through a pretty rigorous valuation tech list.
- 0:29We want to see if that premium price tag is actually justified
- 0:33by the quality underneath. Yeah, this is such a great case
- 0:35study. Apple is like the perfect
- 0:37example of where you see absolutely phenomenal business
- 0:39quality meeting well, it's called aggressive financial
- 0:42engineering and capital allocation.
- 0:44And for you, the listener, understanding Apple isn't just
- 0:47about 1 stock. It's really about understanding
- 0:49the blueprint for how a modern global tech giant makes money
- 0:52and, crucially, protects those profits.
- 0:54OK. Let's get into it then.
- 0:55Starting with the big numbers from Q4 FY20, 25 total revenue
- 1:00$102.5 billion. That's up a pretty impressive 8%
- 1:04year over year. Yeah, solid growth at that
- 1:06scale. And the whole fiscal year closed
- 1:08out of $416 billion plus the diluted EPS that came in at
- 1:13$1.85, which actually beat the Streets expectations.
- 1:16That EPSB is definitely noteworthy, but I think if you
- 1:19look sort of under the hood, the quality of where that revenue is
- 1:23coming from is the real story. OK.
- 1:26I mean, yes, iPhone revenue is still the bedrock, right?
- 1:29It grew 6%, hit about $49 billion.
- 1:31But the thing that's really driving profitability, the big
- 1:34engine, is the services division.
- 1:36Wow. Services, we hear so much about
- 1:38that. Exactly.
- 1:39Services revenue hit an all time high $28.75 billion and that's
- 1:44growing 15% year over year. 15% Wow.
- 1:47Yeah. And what's really fascinating is
- 1:49how the whole business model has shifted.
- 1:51Think about this, Services now brings in more cash than Mac,
- 1:54iPad and wearables combined. Combined.
- 1:56OK, that puts it in perspective. It does.
- 1:58And this is the key driver for margin expansion because, well,
- 2:01services just carries way higher gross margins than selling
- 2:03hardware does. And that services success story,
- 2:06it's all built on their sheer scale, right?
- 2:09And converting those users. Tim Cook is always talking about
- 2:11the installed base of active devices.
- 2:14What's the latest number? It recently passed 2.35 billion
- 2:18globally. 2.35 billion, that's just a massive pool of potential
- 2:22customers. How good are they at actually
- 2:24turning that base into, you know, recurring cash?
- 2:27Oh, extremely good. They've really nailed the
- 2:29transition from just being a a company that sells you a phone
- 2:32every few years to being like a subscription hub.
- 2:35The sources show they now have over 1 billion paid
- 2:38subscriptions across all their platforms.
- 2:40That includes their own stuff like iCloud, Apple Music, but
- 2:44also really important taking a cut from third party apps via
- 2:48the App Store. So they've captured the long
- 2:50term value of the user, not just the initial device sale.
- 2:53Precisely. It's about lifetime value now.
- 2:55OK, so if the money machine is that big and sort of
- 3:00predictable, what's stopping competitors?
- 3:02Why isn't Samsung or Google really eating into that?
- 3:05What's the protection? This is the famous economic
- 3:07mode, isn't it? It is, and Apple's mode is
- 3:09exceptionally wide, I think, because it's not just one thing.
- 3:12It's like several layers of defense working together.
- 3:16OK, break it down for us. Well, you start with intangible
- 3:19assets. The brand power is just it's
- 3:22almost off the charts. That lets them charge premium
- 3:24prices and people remain incredibly loyal.
- 3:27Sure, the brand is huge. But maybe the most powerful
- 3:30element is the high switching costs.
- 3:32You hear this called the ecosystem lock in.
- 3:35Yes, the walled garden. Exactly.
- 3:37It's how smoothly everything works together, right?
- 3:39Your iPhone, your Watch, your Mac, then services like I
- 3:42message iCloud, your photos. If you try to switch to Android
- 3:48or Windows, it's a pain. It's a massive pain.
- 3:50You lose your apps, your media, your workflow gets disrupted.
- 3:53They've very deliberately designed it to be difficult to
- 3:56leave. I get the ecosystem lock in, but
- 3:58Android actually has more users globally, doesn't it?
- 4:01So why are the network effects around Apple's App Store
- 4:03considered so much stronger than, say, Google's Play Store?
- 4:06That's a really good question. It comes down to the quality and
- 4:09maybe more importantly, the perceived affluence of the iOS
- 4:13user base. Meaning and they spend more
- 4:14money. Generally, yes.
- 4:16Developers know that iOS users are historically more willing to
- 4:19pay for apps and services, so that attracts millions of
- 4:22developers, including the best ones who build high quality apps
- 4:26first for iOS sometimes. So it creates a feedback loop.
- 4:29Exactly. More great apps attract more
- 4:32users who spend, which attracts more developers.
- 4:35It's a classic powerful network effect, a virtuous cycle driving
- 4:39cash flow. OK, makes sense.
- 4:40What's the last piece? The Moat.
- 4:42The last part is cost and process advantages.
- 4:44Their sheer scale gives them enormous leverage, with
- 4:47suppliers getting better prices than anyone else.
- 4:50But strategically, the really big advantage is their massive
- 4:53R&D spend on their own custom silicon.
- 4:56The A series chips and iPhones the M series and Max.
- 4:59Precisely designing their own chips gives them performance and
- 5:02power efficiency advantages that competitors relying on off the
- 5:05shelf chips from, say, Qualcomm or Intel just can't easily
- 5:09match. It's a deep technical advantage.
- 5:11So summing it up, the whole strategy has shifted from just
- 5:15selling you a box to basically capturing your entire digital
- 5:18life inside their ecosystem. That's a good way to put it.
- 5:22But it can't all be smooth sailing.
- 5:24Let's pivot to the risks. What are the big structural
- 5:28threats that can actually undermine this incredible
- 5:30position, especially that booming services growth?
- 5:33Well, the number one threat I think has to be regulatory risk
- 5:37because it strikes right at the heart of that super profitable
- 5:4070% plus gross margin services segment.
- 5:43Right, the goose that lays the golden eggs.
- 5:45Exactly. We're seeing intense regulatory
- 5:48and antitrust scrutiny everywhere, but especially in
- 5:51places like Europe with the Digital Markets Act, the DMA,
- 5:54and. What are the regulators focused
- 5:55on? The sources point mainly to the
- 5:57App Store, specifically that mandatory 30% Commission Apple
- 6:01takes and the rules that prevent developers from using
- 6:04alternative payment systems or directing users outside the app.
- 6:07So if regulators force them to open things up, allow other app
- 6:11stores, other payment options, that could seriously permanently
- 6:15damage the profitability of the services division.
- 6:17And this isn't just theoretical anymore, it's actually
- 6:19happening. It's an operational reality
- 6:21they're dealing with right now, especially in the EU.
- 6:23OK, that's a big one. What about physical risks?
- 6:27Supply chain? Geopolitics.
- 6:29That's the second major structural threat, their deep,
- 6:32deep reliance on China. It's a double edged sword,
- 6:35right? China is crucial for
- 6:37manufacturing and it's a massive market for selling iPhones.
- 6:41So any increase in geopolitical tensions between the US and
- 6:44China creates huge vulnerability.
- 6:47It forces them into these really expensive diversification
- 6:50efforts, trying to build up manufacturing in places like
- 6:53India or Vietnam. Which costs more, presumably.
- 6:56Initially, yes, setting up new supply chains, duplicating
- 6:59efforts, it adds complexity and cost, which could definitely put
- 7:02pressure on those hardware margins down the line.
- 7:04Let's just quickly touch on that cost structure difference again,
- 7:06because it really highlights why services is so key
- 7:09strategically. Yeah, it's stark.
- 7:11Hardware products, iPhones, Macs, they run at a gross margin
- 7:15of say 3040%, which is good, solid, respectable, respectable,
- 7:19yes, but services that golden goose we mentioned consistently
- 7:24above 70% gross margin. 70%. Yeah.
- 7:28So think about it. Every dollar of services revenue
- 7:31is just exponentially more valuable to Apple's bottom line
- 7:35than a dollar of hardware revenue.
- 7:36When you upgrade your iCloud storage, that's almost pure
- 7:39profit compared to them selling you like a new charging cable.
- 7:43Got it. And what about costs like R&D?
- 7:46That's another key point. R&D spending is rising
- 7:48significantly. It's absolutely critical as
- 7:51strategic necessity for staying ahead, especially now with the
- 7:54race and generative AI and continuing to develop those
- 7:57custom chips. But it's a fixed cost
- 7:59essentially. Largely, yes.
- 8:01It's a semi fixed cost, which means if revenue were to
- 8:03suddenly drop, maybe a sharp recession or geopolitical shock
- 8:06disrupt sales. Those high R&D costs don't go
- 8:09away overnight. That creates operational
- 8:11leverage risk, meaning profits could fall much faster than
- 8:14revenue. OK, now let's shift to the
- 8:15people steering this this giant ship management.
- 8:18How would you describe Kim Cooks leadership style and the team
- 8:21around him? Well, Cook style is very
- 8:23different from Steve Jobs, obviously.
- 8:25It's seen as more democratic, very collaborative, and
- 8:28intensely focused on operational excellence.
- 8:32Supply chain mastery is his background, after all.
- 8:34And the results speak for themselves, right?
- 8:36Absolutely. He guided the company past the
- 8:38$3 trillion market cap milestone.
- 8:41And look at the stability, the senior team, the board, they
- 8:44have very long 10 years, average war 10 years over 12 years.
- 8:48That provides incredible strategic continuity.
- 8:51And alignment with shareholders seems like that's a big focus,
- 8:53especially looking at how they handle cash.
- 8:55Oh definitely. Executive pay is heavily skewed
- 8:58towards performance based stock options and grants.
- 9:01Their personal wealth is directly tied to how the stock
- 9:03performs long term. Which probably fuels their
- 9:06capital allocation strategy. I think it absolutely does.
- 9:08It leads directly to one of the most defining features of modern
- 9:12Apple, the buyback machine. Let's.
- 9:14Pause on that for a second. The scale is just mind boggling.
- 9:17They authorize another $110 billion for share repurchases
- 9:19just back in May 2024. Yeah, $110 billion.
- 9:24And that's on top of what is it Over the last decade, they've
- 9:28returned something like $847 billion to shareholders, mostly
- 9:32through buybacks. 847 billion. It's almost impossible to
- 9:35comprehend that number. It really is.
- 9:37The sheer volume of shares they repurchase is just unparalleled
- 9:41and the effect is like a powerful financial booster
- 9:44rocket. How so?
- 9:45Well, by constantly reducing the number of shares outstanding,
- 9:49they automatically amplify the earnings per share growth.
- 9:52Even if their total net income only grows moderately.
- 9:54The EPS looks much better because the pie is being divided
- 9:58into fewer slices. It's a key part of their
- 10:00financial strategy, A massive tailwind.
- 10:03OK. So we've established Apple is an
- 10:04incredible business, phenomenal operations, wide Moat, smart
- 10:08management. But here's the rub.
- 10:10The core dilemma for investors, quality versus price.
- 10:13How do savvy value investors look at a stock like this that's
- 10:16clearly high quality but also, you know, expensive?
- 10:19And this is where you see a real split, even among the giants of
- 10:22value investing mentioned in the sources.
- 10:24Take Warren Buffett at Berkshire Hathaway.
- 10:26Right. Buffett's biggest holding for a
- 10:28long time. Exactly.
- 10:29He famously called it a consumer products company with an
- 10:33incredibly powerful brand back when he first bought in around
- 10:362016. He saw the Moat, the loyalty.
- 10:39But he's been trimming, hasn't he?
- 10:40Significantly, yes. The reports show he sold off
- 10:43about 70% of his peak holdings through mid 2025.
- 10:48Now the stated reason involves managing portfolio size, but.
- 10:51But it suggests maybe he thinks the valuation got a bit
- 10:54stretched, even though it's still his largest single stock
- 10:57holding by far. It certainly raises that
- 10:59question. It signals a belief in the long
- 11:01term company perhaps, but maybe not the same conviction at this
- 11:04price level or size now. Contrast that with someone like
- 11:07David Tepper at Appaloosa. Tepper's approach seems much
- 11:10more tactical, less buy and hold.
- 11:13Appaloosa apparently liquidated their entire Apple position in
- 11:16the second quarter of 2025. The whole thing.
- 11:19The whole thing. That's a pretty clear signal,
- 11:21isn't it? It strongly suggests the belief
- 11:23that the stock was overvalued at that point, offering basically 0
- 11:26margin of safety in the traditional sense.
- 11:29Lock in the profits and move on. OK.
- 11:31Let's quantify this using our checklist sort of Buffett style.
- 11:33First, the quality metrics. How does Apple stack up?
- 11:36Oh, on quality it's a slam dunk. Gross margin 46.9%, Net margin
- 11:4126.9% and the returns are just spectacular.
- 11:44Return on invested capital ROIC is 62.1%. 62%.
- 11:49Yeah, that shows incredible operational efficiency.
- 11:52How won't they use their actual operating assets to generate
- 11:55profit? On return on equity Roe.
- 11:57Roe is even higher, a massive 151.9%.
- 12:01But you have to be careful with Roe here.
- 12:03That huge number is significantly boosted by the
- 12:05debt they take on to fund those buybacks.
- 12:07The ROIC, the 62%, that's a cleaner measure of pure
- 12:11operational brilliance. The ROV reflects the financial
- 12:14engineering component too. OK, quality gets a big green
- 12:16check, but now the valuation metrics based on traditional
- 12:20value screens. How does it look?
- 12:22Well this is where it kind of screams fail the trailing 12
- 12:25month price to earnings ratio. The PE is sitting at 29.8.
- 12:28Nearly 30, double the old value benchmark of 15X.
- 12:32Exactly. Way above traditional value
- 12:34territory. What about the balance sheet
- 12:35metrics? Debt.
- 12:36Liquidity. Those also flash warning signs.
- 12:38On a typical screen, the debt to equity ratio is 1.54 and the
- 12:43current ratio is actually below one at 0.89.
- 12:47OK. Debt to equity over 1.5 current
- 12:49ratio below one, right? Those would normally get flagged
- 12:52as risky, wouldn't they? For most companies, yes.
- 12:56For Apple it's more nuanced. The high debt reflects that
- 12:59deliberate strategy of using cheap debt to fuel buybacks,
- 13:02leveraging their massive cash flows.
- 13:04Is it risk free? No, but they can handle it
- 13:08currently. And the low current ratio, the
- 13:09point that means negative working capital, right?
- 13:12It does, but for Apple, it's actually a sign of strength, not
- 13:15weakness. It shows their incredible
- 13:16negotiating power that collects cash from customers instantly
- 13:19when they sell an iPhone or a service, but they can stretch
- 13:23out payments to their suppliers. So they're effectively being
- 13:25financed by their suppliers. In essence, yes.
- 13:27It highlights their operational efficiency and scale.
- 13:30So while the metrics fail traditional screens, they
- 13:33reflect Apple specific, very effective business model.
- 13:36The real problem isn't the balance sheet structure itself,
- 13:38it's simply the high price the market demands for owning it.
- 13:41Which brings us perfectly to the ultimate valuation reality check
- 13:45discounted cash flow analysis the DCF.
- 13:47Given the stocks trading around what, $214.00 recently, what did
- 13:51the DCF model suggest its intrinsic value might be?
- 13:54Right. So using what I think are
- 13:56reasonable assumptions, an 8.5% discount rate or WACC and a
- 14:00standard 2.5% terminal growth rate long term term, the DCF
- 14:04really throws the current market price into sharp relief.
- 14:07It shows just how much growth is already baked in.
- 14:09OK, layout the scenarios. What's the conservative view?
- 14:12In the conservative case, let's assume basically 0 growth and
- 14:15free cash flow going forward. Unlikely, but a baseline, the
- 14:19intrinsic value comes out at $135.21 per share.
- 14:22OK, A. 135 dollars, way below the current 214 dollars.
- 14:26Way below now the nominal case. Let's assume Apple continues to
- 14:29grow its free cash flow at its historical average rate, which
- 14:31has been about 10.5% per year. OK, seems more realistic
- 14:35perhaps. Under that scenario, the
- 14:36intrinsic value lands at $189.65.
- 14:39Still below the market price $190.00 versus 204 dollars.
- 14:42Still underwater? Yes, it implies the market is
- 14:45demanding more than just its average historical growth rate.
- 14:47So what growth rate does the market seem to be pricing in?
- 14:50What's the optimistic case look like?
- 14:52To get the intrinsic value comfortably above the current
- 14:54market price, you have to run the optimistic case.
- 14:57This assumes Apple manages to grow its free cash flow at a
- 15:00rate close to its peak historical performance, nearly
- 15:0320% a year. 19.89% was the input for the next 5 years before
- 15:08settling down. Wow, 20% growth for five years
- 15:11straight. Yeah.
- 15:12Only under that very aggressive growth scenario does the
- 15:15intrinsic value reach $265.78 per share.
- 15:19So the take away is that the current market price around
- 15:21$214.00 is trading significantly above the value suggested by
- 15:26historical average growth. It implies the market fully
- 15:29expects Apple to deliver growth closer to that peak optimistic
- 15:33scenario. That's exactly right.
- 15:34There's basically no traditional margin of safety at the current
- 15:37price. You're paying for very strong
- 15:39future growth already. OK, let's try to synthesize
- 15:41this. What's the final picture?
- 15:42The final picture is, I think pretty clear.
- 15:45Apple is a financially incredibly robust company.
- 15:48It's operationally brilliant. It possesses one of the widest,
- 15:52most durable economic moats probably in the world today.
- 15:55Driven increasingly by. Driven increasingly by that high
- 15:58margin predictable services segment, which is built on top
- 16:01of that enormous locked in user base in the ecosystem.
- 16:04OK. And that brings us to our final
- 16:07provocative question for you, the listener to think about.
- 16:10We've seen that the current stock price seems to demand a
- 16:12growth trajectory close to the optimistic scenario for the DCF.
- 16:18So future stock performance seems to hinge entirely on Apple
- 16:21navigating 2 huge challenges simultaneously.
- 16:24They need to successfully innovate and lead in the next
- 16:27big tech wave, let's say generative AI, while also
- 16:30managing to avoid serious damage to their core services business
- 16:34from all that regulatory pressure targeting their
- 16:36ecosystem. Mode, right?
- 16:37They need to win on both fronts. So the question for you is which
- 16:40of those two risks poses the greatest threat to Apple
- 16:42maintaining its current premium valuation?
- 16:44Is it the regulatory threat potentially crippling those high
- 16:46margin services? Or is the risk of failing to
- 16:49innovate effectively and leave the next big thing like AI
- 16:52something to ponder? Thank you again for sharing all
- 16:54these sources for this deep dive today.
- 16:56And as always, a reminder to everyone listening, this content
- 16:59is purely for educational purposes.
- 17:01It's not investment advice. Always do your own research and
- 17:04due diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 17:07We'll catch you on the next deep dive.