Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Bob’s therapy, attractive clients, and suicidal thoughts
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, let's stop talking about the gory details of coolonaskapis which is
- 0:08par for the course for our age, and let's answer some emails instead.
- 0:13What do you say? Yeah? Sure? Middle tier patron and YouTube member
- 0:18Kimmi from Utah. She says, I just started working at my first agency
- 0:22and I'm feeling left out as a therapist, I'm feeling left out. There
- 0:26are less than ten employees total between two locations. I am the youngest by
- 0:30more than a decade to everybody. There are also two main groups or clicks
- 0:35I think is what she's referred to. There is a group of divorced or
- 0:40separated women with older children, and another group of women who are remarried to
- 0:45women. I have been married happily for nearly a decade and my old child
- 0:50is nearly ten. It's hard to come into a new agency and try to
- 0:54connect. How do you deal with feeling left out and isolated as an adult?
- 1:00Bob? What do you think? Well, you could focus on what
- 1:03you have in common as opposed to what your differences are. You all are
- 1:07therapists, I presume, and maybe someone there has interest clinical interests that are
- 1:12similar to your own or knows something that you want to learn about, in
- 1:17which case you get that to talk about, but you know, you don't
- 1:19have commonality around the other things. That's okay. You can relate to all
- 1:25kinds of people, but you know in the areas where you overlap. So
- 1:29my guess is that, yeah, or at least that's what I would do.
- 1:33Yeah, if these people are shutting you out, then it's going to
- 1:38be harder, But you're not saying that. Yeah, it's weird. When
- 1:44I started working full time at the university, I was also the youngest.
- 1:49I had Rebecca, and because she is around my age, very close to
- 1:53my age, and we had each other. But you know, most of
- 1:57the time, Rebecca and I weren't in the same meetings because he was our
- 2:00therapy. So I would often just kind of do my work and go home,
- 2:08and people would go to dinner together and socialize and go to each other's
- 2:14houses and they either wouldn't invite me, or I was busy with something else,
- 2:17and you know, it's okay, So there's that. The other thing
- 2:22is is that when I first became a therapist, my very first job,
- 2:25I was very young and very insecure and was terrified and I had that approach
- 2:31of just putting my head down, and it resulted in there was a number
- 2:38of bad things that conspired for this asshole supervisor to fire me. But okay,
- 2:45but yeah, but one of the factors was that I was very reserved,
- 2:50and apparently, according to him, people were interpreting that as me being
- 2:53hostile, which is just like what silly, like a twenty five year old,
- 2:58brand new intern. And I was the only intern too, there were,
- 3:01or at least I wasn't exposed to any other interns or something anyway,
- 3:07And so I was and you know, it wasn't like I didn't talk.
- 3:10I'm not like completely inept at responding to people, but I wasn't volunteering my
- 3:19thoughts and meetings and that kind of stuff. You know, as you consider
- 3:22that in retrospect here, would you say that it was a hostile place to
- 3:24try to work? Yeah, Well, later I confronted him, Yeah,
- 3:29and he told me that he said that the agency as a whole was going
- 3:34through like a huge amount of upheaval and drama and in fighting, and I
- 3:39didn't know about it because I was only there for like seven or eight weeks
- 3:43or something anyway, So what did I know? But anyway, the second
- 3:46place I worked at, I decided to overcome that social anxiety and because my
- 3:54career depended on it, uh huh. And so what I did is I
- 3:58leaned into just being a little extroverted and maybe gregarious. What I did,
- 4:04and so what I remember doing specifically is and I was in an almost identical
- 4:10situation to you, what's your name, Kimmy, Kimmy from Utah? Uh
- 4:17in that the agent, the second internship I had was a very small agency
- 4:23of about you know, ten therapists, ten employees, and it was in
- 4:28a renovated, one story little house in Federal Way. And I would go
- 4:36into and the bedrooms were the therapy offices, of course, and so I
- 4:43would go into the therapy offices when the doors were open and the therapists weren't
- 4:48working, and I would just chat. I would just I would just walk
- 4:53in and I would just chat. And a lot of people do this,
- 4:56but I would just find something to chat about. And there were some people
- 5:00that were easier to chat to than others, right, And I might also
- 5:03ask them clinical questions, yeah, and say like what do you think about
- 5:06this? Cause you know, other therapists I've never met another therapist that doesn't
- 5:13get really engaged with that kind of questioning, particularly if someone thinks to ask
- 5:17them for advice, you know, like as a therapist, you're like,
- 5:19oh, well let me help you with that. So, yeah, that's
- 5:25that's what I would do me too, because if you let it go on
- 5:29too long, it could feel weirder and weirder and going. You don't want
- 5:34to dread go into work and having friends, you know, connections. Now,
- 5:39like I said, the way you've framed it, there's a possibility that
- 5:43they're shutting up, but that doesn't seem likely. You know. You say
- 5:46that there's a group of divorced women with older children, and so you're like,
- 5:50I'm happily married and my kid is nine years old. So you know,
- 5:58I don't see any reason why you couldn't relate to each other. Yeah,
- 6:00and then you also say there's another group of women who are remarried to
- 6:02women. Again, I can't see any reason why you wouldn't be able to
- 6:08connect. So next email anonymous midlitier pager from Las Vegas. They say,
- 6:15dear doctor Kirkabob, first of all, I love you both, and maybe
- 6:17that's weird, but I mean it. Thank you well, we love you
- 6:23too. I have been in therapy for five years for childhood trauma, and
- 6:28I'm almost fifty. I am only just now forming a connection with myself.
- 6:32I have a wonderful therapist who I guess is about fifteen years younger, and
- 6:38who I love deeply. I have always been very aware of boundaries with my
- 6:44therapist and the therapeutic nature of their relationship. I feel the urge to talk
- 6:47about the feelings I experience toward them, but I can't. It seems impossible.
- 6:51So just chiming in. So it sounds like they're saying, I want
- 6:57to have an urge to say I love you, or I'm very appreciative of
- 7:01you, I think about you a lot or whatever. Yeah, but they're
- 7:05saying they can't and it feels impossible. What do you think about that?
- 7:11I think it's fantastic that it's coming up. It is your attachment insecurity right
- 7:16there in Frennia, and you find yourself, you know, avoiding speaking plainly
- 7:23about to somebody whom you formed a really lovely it sounds like a really lovely
- 7:28attachment with And isn't it wonderful that you noticed that you want to speak to
- 7:34them? About how you feel. I think you should do it and take
- 7:42the risk. What's the benefit? The benefit is a corrective experience of transparency
- 7:47and being accepted as you are. Yeah right, it's vulnerable, yeah,
- 7:51And to have that received safely but also very much appreciated and deeply felt can
- 8:01be a profound experience, repetit repeated over time, repeated over time, going
- 8:07out with email. I would love to hear more about, specifically Bob's experience
- 8:11in therapy. How do you feel well? Thanks anonymous military patient for shutting
- 8:16me out just jumming in here. It's just joking. Oh yeah, I
- 8:20missed us. How do you feel about your attachment to your therapist? Do
- 8:26you express your feelings to your therapists and if so, how how does your
- 8:31therapist respond? Does it bring up grief? About so? Just starting one
- 8:35question, do you express your feelings to your therapist? Yes? And how
- 8:41plainly? Like? What might you say? I might say I love you,
- 8:46I might say I'm really appreciative that you know, for for our time.
- 8:54Or I might say, in a scared moment, please don't leave me,
- 9:00which, of course you know he's very reassuring he's not going to leave
- 9:01me. Sometimes I can be haughty because my therapist is younger than me too,
- 9:09and sometimes I want to kill him, right, and I say that
- 9:15to him. Of course, it was funny when I told him that.
- 9:16He's like, yeah, I already knew that, Bob. And it was
- 9:22really cool about being plain about that. Is it took a lot of the
- 9:26feeling away, so I don't find myself trapped in haughtiness anymore. I think
- 9:30the problem with it wasn't that I felt houghty, was that I felt ashamed
- 9:33about how I felt. So it's not easy. It's easier. I still
- 9:39resist being plain about how I feel towards him. Um, and you know,
- 9:48I have therapy tomorrow morning, so now I know what I'm gonna do.
- 9:50Thank you. And then they ask does it bring up grief about what
- 9:58you were deprived of and other things that were perpetrated on you? Yeah,
- 10:03it does. It brings up grief. Yeah, it's funny because I don't
- 10:09have a frame of reference for what normal people get, you know, like
- 10:15you know, the kinds of you know. But I do notice that there's
- 10:18tremendous sadness in me and grieving around the abuse. So yeah it does,
- 10:24and I can feel that grieving when I am candid with him in the way
- 10:33that we're already talking about here about letting him know how I feel about him
- 10:35and letting him know how much I need him. Yeah, it's just tragedy
- 10:43that even when you're having a corrective experience and you're finally getting your needs met,
- 10:52it comes with this major asterisk, which is, well, now that
- 10:56I am opening myself up to this wonderfulness, I am also exposing myself to
- 11:03the acute knowledge that I was deprived of this, which, of course intellectually
- 11:07I know, but now I'm feeling. You know, it's like when you
- 11:13finally get a glass of water after two days of not having any water.
- 11:18It kind of hurts going down. Yeah, you know, Yeah, but
- 11:24better that than nothing else, right, agreed. And the grief is good
- 11:28to feel. You deserve to feel that grief, because why wouldn't you,
- 11:35all right? Next email? Okay, This next email is from patron and
- 11:41YouTube member Shelby from Denver. She says, Hi, doctor Kirk and Bob,
- 11:43do you think it's okay to feel the best when you're alone. I
- 11:48am married to a wonderful man and have two beautiful babies, so I'm not
- 11:52completely alone, but I have almost no desire to have friends outside my family.
- 11:56I don't want friends. I love being at home. I feel so
- 12:00at peace and happy on my own just being in my own mind. Is
- 12:05this normal or healthy? For reference? I am on the autism spectrum.
- 12:09Thank you, Bob. What do you think? You're already answering your own
- 12:11question. This is what feels good to you, This is what is fulfilling
- 12:16and satisfying to you. The only thing that came to mind is at some
- 12:18point your kids are going to launch, and you know, then you might
- 12:20have to make some kind of shift so that your social needs are met.
- 12:24But man, if you're happy right on, God bless you, that's fantastic.
- 12:30Yeah, that's what I would say. The only thing I would add
- 12:31is that sometimes things are the lesser of two evils in your mind and it
- 12:39feels great in contrast to having outside relationships, but it's because of something that
- 12:48went on for you in your past, or some belief that you have that
- 12:52is preventing you from actually enjoying outside relationship. You know. It's sort of
- 12:56like if someone goes through sexual abuse or assault and they engage in sexual behavior.
- 13:03You know, relationships they experience a lot of distress and a lot of
- 13:09discomfort, and after a while they conclude, I guess I don't like sex.
- 13:13But that may or may not be true. It's unknown they might actually
- 13:18be a sexual but it's possible that with recovery then they actually will be able
- 13:26to feel comfortable enough to have their sexuality realized. So whether you're on the
- 13:33autism spectrum or not, shall be you know, it could be that that
- 13:37would just be the thing to look into. But absolutely, you know,
- 13:43you hear people talk and they'll say like, that's not healthy, and you
- 13:48know, there's a wide variety of getting your needs BET, and if you're
- 13:52getting your needs BET, then yeah, don't don't let anybody say otherwise because
- 13:58they don't know what they talk about. Let's take a break, we get
- 14:01back more emails. What do you say, Yeah, all right, let's
- 14:07do an opp bob. These people became patrons in about the middle of twenty
- 14:13twenty one. We have m from Australia, Mara from b E B E
- 14:22B e B E Belgium, probably Sarah from Belgium, Professor Schnarky from Ontario,
- 14:28Maggie from Quebec, Leanne from Quebec, Maria from oh there's a lot
- 14:31of Canadians. Maria. I think I organized this by people not in the
- 14:37States. I guess Maria from Windsor, Ontario, Liz from Hamilton, Ontario,
- 14:41Gene from Toronto, a lot of people from Ontario. Vera from Berlin,
- 14:46Sarah from from a place I can't pronounce in Germany, Christina from Estonia.
- 14:54E E you no, no ee? Is that Ireland ee country code?
- 15:01Country code is Estonia? Estonia? Is that what I said? You
- 15:07did say that first? Yeahh Ireland is isn't it ir? I feel like
- 15:15it's not Ireland country code I E I E Ireland is I E is Northern
- 15:24Ireland a different country code? Probably? Yeah? Yeah, Okay. So
- 15:28we have Emma from London, Olivia from Glasgow, g from Great Britain,
- 15:35Suzanne from from Idaho, Sarah from Bologna, Italy. No Idaho, I
- 15:45guess I was like Bali. I was like Bali Idaho. Id is Indonesia
- 15:50of course, so Suzanne from Indonesia. And those are the people that became
- 15:58patrons in mid twenty twenty one who are not from the United States. Thank
- 16:04you so much for becoming a patron. I' the way back then you got
- 16:07Belgium, Canada, deutsch Land, Estonia, Great Britain, Indonesia and Italy.
- 16:15I wonder if we I don't usually hear Indonesia. I wonder if we
- 16:19don't have that many people from Indonesia, world's largest democracy. So going on
- 16:26with an email here patron Aarned from Australia. She says, Hi, Kirk
- 16:30and Bob, could you please discuss how you would gauge whether your client is
- 16:34ready for inner child work. I have been seeing my therapist for about eight
- 16:38months now, with two or three sessions a month. Last week we had
- 16:42what felt like a major breakthrough and tracing the route to one of my triggers.
- 16:48She has suggested exploring in her child work based on success on the success
- 16:52of that session. On one hand, I feel silly trying to connect and
- 16:57talk to myself as a child. It doesn't feel real. Is it something
- 17:03you just have to practice? Just chiming in here, Bob, what do
- 17:07you think? Yeah, you have to practice. It's okay if it doesn't
- 17:11feel real. It's okay if it feels awkward or embarrassing or whatever, and
- 17:15you'll know if it's helpful to you by willing, by engaging in it for
- 17:19some length of time. But if it's going to feel weird, just let
- 17:22it feel weird. So wet. Yeah. Also, what I'll say is
- 17:26it really depends on what she means by inner child work, because for some
- 17:30people that will mean that you talk to your quote unquote inner child as if
- 17:36it were outside of you. But I don't do that. I mean I
- 17:40have done it that way, empty chair work, that kind of thing.
- 17:41But I will talk about inner children, and that's a way of helping people
- 17:51to connect with a side of themselves without the defenses, you know, typically
- 17:57the metaphor of the inner child, like if you ask someone like they're telling
- 18:04you about something happen at work, and you say how do you feel about
- 18:07it? And they're like, I don't know whatever. And then I might
- 18:11say, well, what does your inner child feel? And they're like,
- 18:12well, I guess my inner child probably feels hurt. So what does that
- 18:18mean? Does that mean the inner child is feeling hurt? I don't know,
- 18:22whatever you want to say, but it does help facilitate people to feel
- 18:27a permission or something to be able to express feelings that adults will typically deny
- 18:33because it feels childish or weak to have the feelings. It's wonderful going out
- 18:40with the email. Secondly, I feel like I am scared to go down
- 18:44this path. Anytime I start to delve into it, it literally feels like
- 18:48a neural pathway switch and I hear a voice that says no, no,
- 18:52no, no no. It's like I've been redirected. I feel like that's
- 18:56a sign that this is what I need in order to heal. But I
- 19:00don't know if I am ready and what I should tell my therapist at our
- 19:04next session. Do you have any thoughts or advice, Bob? What do
- 19:07you think? What does ready mean? Like? How do you define ready?
- 19:10That sounds just based on what I'm hearing in this email, that just
- 19:14sounds like fear like there is no ready. So so just just yeah,
- 19:18definitely talk about it in your therapy and you might embark anyways readiness aside.
- 19:26Yeah, I want to like use Yoda's line, you know, there is
- 19:32no try, There is only two and it's the same there. There is
- 19:37no ready, There is do or do not and the vast majority of things.
- 19:42And you're saying this Aaron that it feels like there's a resistance there inside
- 19:48of me, but that probably means I should be doing it, and that
- 19:52is a good guide to follow. However, if you have PTSD, then
- 19:59you should not be going there and there should be great care. So it
- 20:03really hinges on if you actually have actual PTSD, not just trauma, but
- 20:07actual current PTSD, meaning that you have great terror triggers, and when you
- 20:15go to your inner child or thinking about your childhood, that distress, that
- 20:19terror is physiologically triggered for you, that adrenaline response. That's just a question
- 20:26of triage, though, don't you think like learn PTSD how to manage symptoms
- 20:33or how to reduce them, or how to become acquainted or some version of
- 20:36exposure to ready oneself for the other thing. Yeah, what do you mean
- 20:41by triage though? First things first? Oh yeah, right, yeah,
- 20:45exactly so, because that feeling of no, no, no, no no
- 20:49could be PTSD. It's just I didn't hear enough detail today, right right,
- 20:55We could be dead wrong with this response, yeah, patron, Catherine
- 21:00says dear kirknboben. In a recent episode, you discussed whether it's ever okay
- 21:03to tell a client that they're attractive. I'd love to hear your thoughts on
- 21:07providing reassurance to clients more generally and my own experience. Well, I'm just
- 21:11trying to remember what we said. Do you remember what we said? Yeah,
- 21:14we talked about have you ever told one of your clients that that that
- 21:18they're attractive? And we in general couldn't see any reason to say it,
- 21:25though I've said it, but I've said it in a sort of a generic
- 21:27way, like, oh, I think any so and so would be lucky
- 21:30to have you, any man or any woman who would be lucky to have
- 21:33you. These are you know, some of your qualities or whatever. But
- 21:38I don't. I don't say to somebody you're attractive or I find you attractive.
- 21:42That would just be creepy and weird and irrelevant, right right. I
- 21:47think there's two layers here. One is if there's not a risk of harming
- 21:53a client creeping them out by saying you're attractive or I'm attracted to you,
- 22:00then it's a less risky layer where you're just saying, well, especially if
- 22:07the client is asking for that reassurance and say they have a distortion about their
- 22:14looks, you can say I have to tell you you're distorted about your looks
- 22:18that it doesn't make any sense. You see yourself in a way that I'm
- 22:23quite sure no one sees you, and including me, that's good feedback.
- 22:27So that's telling someone at the very least they're not unattractive, you know.
- 22:33So that's one layer. The other layer is to say to someone that they're
- 22:37attractive, with the potential implication that you, as a therapist, consider the
- 22:41cli't be attractive, and the old school or there was old school wisdom that
- 22:48still persists till today, that there's a version of therapy that is viable that
- 22:53you're just brutally honest. And I think that some therapists can pull it off
- 22:57and have it be not harmful, But generally speaking, I hear too many
- 23:03stories about therapists that reveal it to clients and it goes horribly wrong. It
- 23:10ruins the relationship. The therapists is saying it out of a place of lack
- 23:15of processing themselves, and as I walk myself through it, I'm thinking,
- 23:22if that happened to me, I was just trying to imagine a justification,
- 23:26because if I'm attracted to a client, as we all need to do,
- 23:30it's well researched, it's been discussed and written about for decades that I need
- 23:36to go to my supervisor or a colleague or my therapist. I need to
- 23:38like really explore what's going on and be very aware of it and not get
- 23:45rid of it necessarily, but get a handle on it. Maybe my marriage
- 23:49isn't going well. Maybe this client reminds me of someone. Maybe I'm avoiding
- 23:55something. Maybe I haven't had sex in a while or something. I don't
- 24:00know. Maybe the client is inducing something to me. It know's a lot
- 24:03of things other than just I'm attracted to someone and it's just this innocent thing,
- 24:08you know. And once I work all that out, Once I figure
- 24:15that out, or at least have a good conceptualization, I have a path
- 24:17forward. And I'm still attracted to client. I'm trying to I'm trying to
- 24:22think if there's any justification for telling the client unless the therapist cannot control the
- 24:29urge of revealing it having signals and it's crazy making to the client because the
- 24:34client might even be asking things. But I would say, if you,
- 24:40as a therapist cannot fucking keep it in your pants energy wise, then I
- 24:47don't know what to say. Like, I got to work on that man
- 24:49that's not going to work, Like, get a hold of yourself, you
- 24:53know what I mean. It's normal to be attracted, it might be normal
- 24:56to have that urge, but you know, double the therapy or something,
- 25:02or fix your personal life for something. So that's what we would say.
- 25:08But what patron Catherine is saying is, well, what about just reassuring clients
- 25:17more generally? So, going on as some background, this is something that
- 25:22comes up frequently with my therapist. Basically, I want reassurance. I want
- 25:26to be told I'm a good person. I want to be told I'm a
- 25:30good parent. I want to be told that I'm not broken. My therapist
- 25:33has told me plenty of things that are supportive and reassuring in some sense,
- 25:37such as that he enjoys working with me, that he finds it easy to
- 25:42like me, that he doesn't see me as broken or a terrible person.
- 25:48But he is clear to phrase things in terms of his own experience, not
- 25:51a blanket statement like you are such a good person. I'll admit, as
- 25:56I have to my therapist that this is hard for me. So just chiming
- 25:59in here, thoughts on that, Bob, there's something tantalizing happening. I
- 26:04want my therapist to say the thing in a particular kind of way. I
- 26:07mean, they're saying something in the neighborhood, but it doesn't for some reason.
- 26:11I want them to say this other thing that might be interesting to just
- 26:15learn about, Like, what's the function here for me? What am I
- 26:18trying to accomplish. I'm not saying there's anything nefarious, nothing evil, nothing,
- 26:23you know, but just some energy inside you that compels you to kind
- 26:27of have this kind of you know, longing or impulse or I don't know
- 26:33what else to call it. Yeah, so I'm kind of interested to know.
- 26:37Yeah, yeah, it sorted of to know where your therapist is coming
- 26:40from. But I would say your therapist is doing a similar thing that I
- 26:45would do. Although if a client really wanted me to say it, just
- 26:51tell me I'm a good person, I might do that. A lot of
- 26:52therapists wouldn't, And I think there's some definite wisdom to that, because it
- 26:59is a shortcut that might not be helpful to the client. The other thing
- 27:03to think about is that it sounds like for you, Catherine, you're having
- 27:11very good transference that is corrective for you, and it's working and wherever he
- 27:18draws the line, you're probably going to want more, and some therapists will,
- 27:26you know, just figure out a comfortable place to draw the line and
- 27:29then no matter what, you just you just draw it there. Yeah,
- 27:33and you do everything you can within that line, you know, and you
- 27:38just know as a therapist that no matter where you draw the line, there's
- 27:42going to be some frustration. So you know, I've done that before,
- 27:48particularly with people who have transference like this, whereas with other clients I might
- 27:52be a little bit more loose because I'm not predicting that the client is going
- 27:57to be transferring that way, so didn't get to learn about what is the
- 28:03disappointment or frustration that's coming up. What is that? Yeah, your therapist
- 28:07could also be thinking we're on the path for you to conclude that you are
- 28:12a good person. So I don't see any point in trying to race to
- 28:18the end of the race. It's just not possible. You know. I've
- 28:22thought that before as well. Going on. A marriage and family therapist that
- 28:27my husband and I saw for a while was the complete opposite. He would
- 28:30regularly say to us, you guys are fantastic parents. He would often say
- 28:34to me, you are not broken as much as I liked hearing him say
- 28:38these things. Perhaps not surprisingly, these statements made no difference in how I
- 28:41saw myself. Maybe that says everything right there, Bob, what do you
- 28:45think. I think that's a great insight. Nice noticing. Yeah, it
- 28:49also could be that you just didn't have the transference with that therapist otherwise.
- 28:55But yeah, going on, what's your take on providing reassurance to clients.
- 29:00Is that something that you do, Bob? Yes, I definitely provide reassurance
- 29:04to clients. I didn't used to back when I was young and foolish and
- 29:10I had a mentor, sort of a mentor mixed anyways, He's like,
- 29:15provide reassurance. No, I wasn't doing psychotherapy back then. I was a
- 29:18case manager at the mental health clinic down the rent and Way, but we'd
- 29:22have clients and crisis and he's like, definitely, provide reassurance, things like
- 29:27it's going to be okay, You're going to find your way through it,
- 29:30that sort of thing to help people who are in pain and need a bit
- 29:36of hope. And so I still do that. I hope I don't do
- 29:41it at the exclusion of somebody's growth, like I wouldn't want to hamper their
- 29:45growth by providing reassurance, but I do still do it. Yeah. It
- 29:51should also be said that we're explicitly trained for good reasons that impulses of reassurance
- 29:59need to be heavily questioned by ourselves. When we have an urge or we're
- 30:04being requested to reassure a client and compliment a client, we have to be
- 30:11skeptical as to why we're doing that, because it's common for bad therapists or
- 30:18people lay people who are anxious about what they're being told. Like a common
- 30:26example that we use in training would be I'm just trying to think of like
- 30:30an easy one to demonstrate this, Like a client comes to you. A
- 30:37client comes to me and says, I'm depressed. I can't get out of
- 30:41bed. I've been just really down for five years now. I just feel
- 30:48worthless. I as a listener, it's natural for me to worry about the
- 30:53client and wish that things were different. Also, I'm being tasked with fixing
- 30:59this, so I'm worried about my own competence or failure or something. And
- 31:07I might say something like I'm trying to be reasonable because I could like an
- 31:11exaggerated version would be like everything will be okay, you know, just just
- 31:15try or something like that, or a more kind of reasonable reassuring mistake would
- 31:23be to say something like like say, you know, there's that I in
- 31:30the midst of all this depression talk. They're just like, yeah, I
- 31:33just I just feel like I'm worthless. And then I go, well,
- 31:37but you have so many reasons to believe that you're of a lot of a
- 31:42lot of worth. Oh yeah, yeah, it's just great some the nerves.
- 31:45Yeah yeah. So from the outside that might look like, oh,
- 31:51well, you're being reassuring, and because you know, what's the difference between
- 31:55that and telling someone that they have worth in a different context? Next,
- 32:00that isn't grading, you know what I mean. Yeah, it's invalidating.
- 32:02That's the problem with it. Yeah yeah, right, at least one problem
- 32:06with it anyways, right. Another problem is that it's trying to leap frog
- 32:09everything. It's it's the suggestion is that if you just reassure a client and
- 32:16they choose to believe it, then and there's low self esteem will just go
- 32:20away. Yeah and that works. No, Yeah, I'm kidding. Yeah,
- 32:23all right, take a break, we get back more emails. Let's
- 32:31do some more opp So these people are all from the US. So we
- 32:37got Gabriella from Houston, Texas, Day from Chicago, Diana from New York,
- 32:44Chrissy from Peru, Massachusetts, Nina from Chicago, Mary from Bowling Green,
- 32:51Kentucky. Isn't that where they have the the Kentucky Derby Bowling Green,
- 32:54Churchill Downs. I think is the tracks called Anyway, Why do I know
- 32:59Bowling Green? There's a college there. Oh, okay, yeah, that's
- 33:02probably what Kelly from Litits Pennsylvania lits litits how do you spell it? L
- 33:10I t I t z litits Litits. Kaylee from Naples, Florida, Uh,
- 33:19not to fure from the Colony, Texas. I like town names that
- 33:25have a phrase, you know, like Federal Way south of Seattle. It
- 33:32rolls off the tongue now because we hear it all the time, But when
- 33:37you first hear it, you're thinking Federal Way is It's a weird name that
- 33:39sounds like a street. But the colony is apparently the name of this town
- 33:45in Texas, the colony. The is in the name of the city from
- 33:51the colony. Yeah. Oh interesting. Caitlin from ann Arbor Michigan, B
- 33:55one two three from Merriam, Kansas, Sylvia from rich In, California,
- 34:00Candice from Delco, North Carolina, Janis from Surprise, Arizona. That's always
- 34:06a fun signed to steal if you're in Arizona. Madison from Los Angeles,
- 34:13and Karen from Seattle. Thank you so much for becoming a patron and staying
- 34:16a patron all of this time. I mean, you're literally no joke paying
- 34:24my bills and my family's bills, which gives me the ability to answer all
- 34:30these emails. Let's go on to another question. Patron Beca from California.
- 34:36She says, Kirk and Bob, I love the podcast, and you have
- 34:38been instrumental to my learning as an associate Marriage of Family therapist. So,
- 34:44for those who don't know, associate is postgrad but early career, as I
- 34:47am just a few weeks away from taking my licensing exam. Wow, I
- 34:52wanted to know how you both approach studying for your exams and how you celebrated
- 34:57passing. Also, Hi, Rebecca and Burdo, so how did you study?
- 35:05I studied to get a C. A C was passing, so I
- 35:07studied enough so that I could get a ce. What did you do?
- 35:10But I a colleague of mine had a manual, had nine hundred questions,
- 35:16and I read them twice. I just read them like multiple choice questions,
- 35:20like you know, test questions. So you just read through the manual twice
- 35:23twice, which took you how long? I don't know, maybe a week?
- 35:28Yeah, yeah, okay, yeah. And how did you celebrate passing?
- 35:31We would have been friends, Yeah, but it was ninety nine.
- 35:35I passed my licensure in ninety nine. Yeah, me too. That's twenty
- 35:37five years it is. Yeah, well, how did I celebrate? We
- 35:45probably had beer and cards. Well, we went out a lot back then,
- 35:49so yeah, we probably just by default were doing it. But I
- 35:53don't remember doing anything specific. No, I don't know. I wonder if
- 35:57it's in my journal. I might have written about it in my journal because
- 36:01it was a big deal to get that letter in the mail. That's snail
- 36:06mail letter. It says you pass you know, remember they gave you a
- 36:10license. It was a piece of paper, but then it had a little
- 36:13wallet sized you could you could perforated wallet size. You could take it out
- 36:17and put in your wallet. I did that for a little while. Now
- 36:21it's in a drawer somewhere. I did too. Yeah. In fact,
- 36:24I remember you and I because you know, I don't know, this sounds
- 36:30really immature, but when you and I would go out, we'd go out
- 36:34with a lot of friends and uh, you know, you're you're at the
- 36:37bars, you're at the clubs, you're at the ball game or something,
- 36:42and we would befriend everyone around us. And you were the life of the
- 36:49party. Well, you know, you were, and I was secondary.
- 36:53I don't know if that's true. Well, we were both very social,
- 36:58very and and very able. I remember, like, you know, we
- 37:01would walk into like even a house party or something, and everything would be
- 37:07subdued and and you and I would just kind of yeah, in a non
- 37:10obnoxious but pretty forward way, get people like talking and engaging. Yeah,
- 37:16and I remember there would be times when we would pull out our you remember
- 37:23this, I do? Okay in the Alibi room once. Okay, Yeah,
- 37:29is it safe for podcasts to tell the story. Yeah, it's pretty
- 37:31generous. Okay, I don't remember the exact we were just chatting with this
- 37:35group of folk and blah blah blah, what do you do. I'm a
- 37:37therapist? No, you're not, Like, Yes, I am yeah,
- 37:40because we were pretty jazzed about being a therapist and it was licensed. Yeah,
- 37:47and our whole well, we were certified. They didn't have license.
- 37:50Yeah I was. I was a certified mental health counselor, that's right.
- 37:53Yeah, And I was maybe I was a certified I think they had certification.
- 37:58Yeah, no, they had certification Emergiphan therapy too. I thought you
- 38:00but you were an LMFT. I thought you guys are from the start.
- 38:05No, all of us got licensed at the Washington State switched from certification to
- 38:09licensure. I think that very next two thousand, in the year two thousand,
- 38:14two thousand. Yeah, and so we were grandfathered in, right and
- 38:20so and it's interesting because my certification number is low. Mine is too.
- 38:25What what's your certification numbers? Zero zero zero zero four one seven nine four
- 38:30to one seven nine Mine is zero zero zer zero one zero subs Like I'm
- 38:36I'm because you know, there are fewer mariorgs of family therapy, right,
- 38:38but I'm like the thousandth Washington and they probably didn't start zero er zero one,
- 38:46like I could literally be the seventy ninth, you know what I mean,
- 38:50Like you could imagine they would start at one thousand when they have enough
- 38:53room to go like to ten million or something. I don't know that,
- 38:57but it's quite possible because one, marriage of family therapy is a much smaller
- 39:01profession than counseling. And two, the CFT program at Antioch had started the
- 39:09year before or the very year that I enrolled. So wait it did.
- 39:15Yeah, Paul had founded the program either that year or just shortly before that.
- 39:22When I went to graduation, there were thirty or forty counselors at graduation,
- 39:28and there were four of the marriage to family therapists. And I remember
- 39:30looking at that going like, how come there were so because the programs were
- 39:36the same size, but they hadn't had enough time to graduate people. Yeah
- 39:39yeah, well so oh so before that, before he showed up there and
- 39:45started that program, it was just they just trained counselors. That's fast.
- 39:49I didn't know that. Like Paul has had a light and continue to have
- 39:52a license in in counseling, right, yeah, yeah, that's amazing.
- 39:58Yeah. Was that certificateation fairly new as an availability? I think they from
- 40:06my memory, they introduced the certification process across the board for everybody. No,
- 40:14oh, because before that it was just a registered counselor, which you
- 40:19didn't need any education for. Yeah, background check, so sort of an
- 40:22interim before licensures. I don't know, but I studied for my exams by
- 40:29hiring my professor, one of my professors, and he was in charge of
- 40:37doing this kind of thing, and he gave me a study guide and he
- 40:38walked me through it, and I studied it and yeah, and passed.
- 40:44And there were some questions. There was a whole section on e f T
- 40:49that I had never even heard of. E f T. Wow, because
- 40:53it just wasn't talked about right much. But apparently whoever wrote up the test
- 40:59it was it was their thing. And I'm like, there were like five
- 41:04questions on emotionally focused therapy and I'm like, what what is this? I
- 41:07never even heard of it? How'd you doing them? Do you know?
- 41:09No idea? Yeah, I was just shooting in the dark. I'm guessing
- 41:13I got them all wrong. But you only had to get to see it
- 41:15get a seventy percent to pass that thing, and I thought, there's no
- 41:19point in getting an A on this. It depends. I mean, I
- 41:21don't know about counselors, but it's on a it depends on the test because
- 41:24each there's like they rotate in the tests. Oh really, and the passing
- 41:30percentage is different for each test, and I think it's also kind of on
- 41:32a curve if I'm not mistaken. But but to summer, it's always somewhere
- 41:37around there, like sixty five to seventy five percent right. And it's a
- 41:42multiple choice test. Typically the vast majority of questions are and you know,
- 41:46there's four options, and usually to the options are ridiculous and you're usually just
- 41:51debating between the final two and a lot of the quote unquote correct answers are
- 41:55stupid. So you have to study the past test and get to know what
- 42:02they think is correct, not what actually is correct, because they'll ask like
- 42:06these really debatable questions, Like like on reassurance, there'll be a question of
- 42:12so a client asks you for reassurance, what do you do? A You
- 42:15give them reassurance. B you don't give them reassurance. See you talk about
- 42:20whether or not they want reassurance, you know, and you're like, it
- 42:22depends, but there's a right answer. I'm not even joking. These are
- 42:30the questions. And the impression I get is that people who know what they're
- 42:35talking about have better things to do than to revamp this test every year because
- 42:39they have to continually add new questions because if you stick with the same test,
- 42:44people memorize them and it's too easy to cheat. Most it's outdated too,
- 42:49And so you have these people in my mind, must not know what
- 42:53they're talking about, and they're the only people that they can get because you
- 42:59know, it's the government. It paying for this service, and they're probably
- 43:02not paying very much. Yeah, it's it's it's pretty aggravating. Plus,
- 43:06like what's a discrete always in our industry, I mean, how many things
- 43:13like when you're testing for medicine, right, you have these symptoms, what's
- 43:17the most likely thing? Then that's much easier to test on. But like
- 43:22clinical questions, it really just depends. So a lot of the questions end
- 43:25up being memorization, like yeah, that's good. You know, what were
- 43:30Freud's five stages of psychosexual behavior or whatever? And that has and we've studied
- 43:36this has no indication as to the competence of your ability as a therapist.
- 43:40It's just the hoop you have to jump through, all right. This text
- 43:44emails from highest tier patron and YouTube member Kimmi from Utah. Again, she
- 43:50says, Hi, Kirk and Bob. And by the way, everybody,
- 43:52if you want your email to get prioritized, if you can become a the
- 44:00highest tier patrons. Because there's so many emails, I have to somehow limit
- 44:06it, and that's kind of what we do sometimes. So just a little
- 44:09tip there, but going out with the email. I recently got my CSUDC
- 44:15license to treat substance use for my state. I was working in inpatient treatment,
- 44:19but now I'm working an outpatient. With my inpatient clients, I was
- 44:22able to go over required CBD homework with them or specific paperwork required by the
- 44:28agency. That made our sessions feel as if they were as if there was
- 44:32always a goal. So she's saying, with inpatient, I felt like there
- 44:37was always a goal because we could go over all this stuff. With these
- 44:42outpatient clients, they come in and some of them say fix me and sit
- 44:45there and wait for me to speak. Others have legal issues that make it
- 44:50a requirement to have therapy. I want to help, but many of my
- 44:54clients have the idea that they have learned it already, like they might have
- 44:59been many treatments before, and they might just wait out the clock. When
- 45:05I ask them what goals they have or what they would like out of therapy,
- 45:07I typically get the answer of I don't know. How would you advise
- 45:13a new therapist and a situation like this. I am open to advice and
- 45:16suggestions or reading material. Bob, what do you think? Well, you
- 45:21do have the possibility of remaining curious they're there. I don't like working I
- 45:27haven't had much experience with and I don't not interested in working with folks that
- 45:30are court ordered because I just feel like that does not work. Man.
- 45:34There's two agendas. Actually, there may only be one agenda, the one
- 45:38that has to do with getting a legal system off your back. So,
- 45:43in my opinion, not a useful endeavor most of the time. Though I'm
- 45:46probably wrong about some percentage of folks who you know would make good use of
- 45:53that. But that's not something I really want to learn about or pursue.
- 45:59With your clients that you know you have that sense that they want you to
- 46:04fix them. You could just be interested and curious about them, like tell
- 46:07me more what's broken? You know, why what brought you here? Like
- 46:15what led you to picking up the phone and calling if that's what you did,
- 46:19or or seeking out you know, you know, counseling or whatever it
- 46:22is, and and just stay curious and interested. And perhaps it's useful to
- 46:32keep in mind that you're not there to supply motivation and that people get to
- 46:37be whoever, whoever they are, and they get to be where they are,
- 46:40and you're just a therapist. You can only do what you can do.
- 46:46And if you have someone that has limited or no motivation, I think
- 46:52just holding up a mirror about that, don't be a dick about it.
- 46:55I mean, no need to saying, well, you don't want anything limit,
- 46:59but just like you don't look motivated. Maybe I'm wrong, but but
- 47:04you don't look like you have much drive from inside? Is that right?
- 47:07And can we learn about that? Just keep learning? Ye. Yeah,
- 47:15there's so much to say. I'll try to be as brief as possible.
- 47:17One My first reaction is this is a it's possibly an impossible situation for you,
- 47:24and I'm guessing you feel responsible to try to get them to talk or
- 47:29something, but it's not your responsibility. And to be honest, when I
- 47:32get clients like this, you know my current career Within two minutes, I'm
- 47:38talking about getting them out of my office because I have better shit to do,
- 47:45and I don't appreciate being, you know, having clients foist it on
- 47:51me. I value my time too much. So you're in a very difficult
- 47:58spot. And I'm going to take a guess and say that this is not
- 48:02the end career position for your life. If it pays well enough and it's
- 48:10given you some experience personally, I would just stick it out and be currently
- 48:16looking for another position somewhere, because if this is the kind of clientele that
- 48:21they're giving you or attracting, it's not a fun job. It will grind
- 48:28you to a pulp and you'll hate everything about it. The other thing is
- 48:34is that some quart order people will use therapy. Well, two scenarios come
- 48:39to mind, but there's a lot. One is I had a client at
- 48:44the beginning of my career who was court ordered and he had been caught shoplifting
- 48:46from his employment from his employer, and as a part of his sentence was
- 48:52sentenced to therapy. And the motivation for him was that I was going to
- 49:00report to the courts, his probation officer or whatever, his meaningful, meaningful
- 49:07use of therapy or not. I wasn't going to report what he said or
- 49:10anything like that, but there was a lever there. Plus, he kind
- 49:15of wanted to know why he compulsively did this and it was a part of
- 49:20a bigger pattern, and so that as long as I played ball, he
- 49:27eventually came to therapy meaningfully. Another situation is, you know, every single
- 49:32intimate partner violence perpetrator, you know, domestic violence perpetrator that was court ordered
- 49:37to come into therapy with this you know mandated group. You know, there's
- 49:42a DV group and I was the therapist that was there in the room to
- 49:46provide the therapy angle. And none of them wanted to be there. They
- 49:52all hated being there. They all thought it was stupid, and you know,
- 49:57they all had their excuses. You know, abusers will do that,
- 50:00and yet ninety nine percent of them would turn around after six months. And
- 50:06it's complicated, you know, But again we had leverage because if they didn't
- 50:12do meaningful work, then they would do prison time, because you know,
- 50:16coming to the treatment was a less you know, it's like, well,
- 50:22we want to give you prison time, but if you agree to go to
- 50:23this treatment group, then you won't get prison SI. So there's that,
- 50:28but also, you know, the other group members would confront because there'd be
- 50:31more advanced group members that would I was like you too, and you know,
- 50:37just do the work. And you know, sometimes you can get people
- 50:40to just do certain activities that are easy to do, like let's review automatic
- 50:46thoughts or something, you know, but if they don't want to do that,
- 50:51then yeah, it's I would either just shoot the shit, watch YouTube
- 50:58with them, play a game, or I would just I've had sessions in
- 51:02the beginning of my career when I was I didn't have the power to say
- 51:07no to this where I literally just would grab a book off the shelf and
- 51:10read it because the client was refusing to interact with me at all and it
- 51:15was extremely uncomfortable and I didn't like it, but I didn't have any choice,
- 51:21and I did everything I could to engage with the client, and they
- 51:23just refused to participate. So you know, that's what I'll say about about
- 51:30that. I would also potentially talk to your supervisor and say, what's going
- 51:37on? Do you have any tips? And I also talked to whoever's giving
- 51:39you the clients and say, stop giving me these assholes, you know,
- 51:42these difficult clients because there's a chance that whoever is funneling the clients to you
- 51:49is screwing you over because the more experienced clinicians have leverage or rapport with that
- 51:55individual and are saying to that person's style, giving me these impossible people because
- 52:02the intake person will know if the person is up for therapy or at least
- 52:08susceptible to it. And I have a hard time believing that every single client
- 52:14that comes into your agency is like this. So there's a chance that you're
- 52:17just getting screwed over. Let's read another email, all right. This next
- 52:22email is from a middle tier patron and YouTube member, Hannah from Indiana,
- 52:25Good Old Hannah from Indiana. She says, krooknbog, I've been in therapy
- 52:30for eight years for depression, anxiety, and chronic suicidal ideation. I also
- 52:37have a diagnosis of PTSD, OCD and BPD. My chronic suicidal ideation started
- 52:43at the age of nine and as persisted with daily suicidal thoughts. I'm twenty
- 52:49six years old now. At the beginning of the year, I attempted suicide
- 52:52and spent three weeks in inpatient treatment, followed by two months in residential treatment.
- 52:58So at the beginning of the year. I think twenty two attempted suicide
- 53:00and spent three weeks in inpatient treatment, followed by two months of residential treatment.
- 53:06I think meaning day treatment. Isn't that what you would think? That
- 53:12means maybe something because there's impatient and then I guess it could have been another
- 53:17resident I could have been another inpatient facility that is not like a hospital.
- 53:23The residential treatment program was DBT focused, and I felt like I started to
- 53:29make some progress. I feel like that progress started to happen because I didn't
- 53:34have any other distractions from treatment like work, relationships and finances. So residential
- 53:39treatment must have been also generally inpatient, but maybe like a more like in
- 53:45a not a hospital setting. Since being released from residential I've been in weekly
- 53:51therapy and medication management. However, the chronic suicidal adation has persisted. I
- 53:55believe that a lot of the suicidal ideation stems from childhood sexual abuse. I
- 54:00don't feel like making significant progress as possible in an outpatient setting with weekly therapy
- 54:07appointments while working full time. What do you think is the best way to
- 54:10recover from chronic suicidal ideation and sexual abuse trauma? Just chiming in here,
- 54:15Bob, what do you think, Well, we should definitely take those one
- 54:20in a time. When you say recovering from chronic suicide ideation, I think
- 54:25what you're saying is you want it to stop. If that's true, then
- 54:31maybe what a person would do is start looking at what are the things that
- 54:36bring it out? Like, is there a particular time of day that it
- 54:39happens to show up? There, is there some kind of event that seems
- 54:45to probably more than one, that seems to bring it into emotion, and
- 54:51are those at all resolvable? Like, let's see if I can think of
- 54:54an example. Oh, okay, let's say I'm driving down the road and
- 55:01I passed this particular part of town and this is a part where you know,
- 55:07has some bad memories for me, and I find myself thinking about suicide,
- 55:10which you know, for lots of folks, suicide is an escape patch.
- 55:15It's sort of like, well, I can always do that, I
- 55:19can always I can always just do that. Anyways, you might consider not
- 55:22driving down that part of the world, or you might consider I'm not going
- 55:29to tell you what to do. What I'm going to suggest to you you
- 55:31should do in a very planful way with your therapist. But you can expose
- 55:36to the place if or the queue or the trigger or whatever, and if
- 55:40you do it enough times, you can habituate to it and such that you
- 55:44don't have the need to escape it anymore. You could consider what are the
- 55:47emotions that come up right as suicidiation or right before suicide? Suicidal thinking come
- 55:55on, come online, because I've met many people that are just emotion a
- 56:00bit that their emotions actually scare the shit out of them. And so you
- 56:02know, one of the ways to escape is to you know, take the
- 56:06ultimate escape, though nobody knows if it helps. Let's be real, it's
- 56:09not a viable option and nobody knows if it helps, So don't do it
- 56:13just but you want it to go away. So you might consider, well,
- 56:16you know, what emotional is it, like the feeling of pressure in
- 56:22my chest or that offul catch in my stomach or whatever whatever body sensation might
- 56:30be linked to the suicide. Or you might consider what are the consequences of
- 56:37me having this suicidiation, Like, for instance, if I have it and
- 56:40then I tell my sister about it, they're really sympathetic, and it could
- 56:45be that I'm getting inadvertent operant conditional reinforcement for having the thing though, hold
- 56:52that one loosely, and you know, sometimes that's the case, but sometimes
- 56:54it isn't. So there's that so so, But basically, what's it for,
- 57:00Like, what's its function? What when my when my brain goes there?
- 57:04What is it? What's it trying to do? And and sort of
- 57:06work with that and how can I recover from what was it? Childhood sexual
- 57:10abuse? Well not really my field, but as I understand it, exposure
- 57:17therapy is a really good way to help with the PTSD symptoms of childhood sexual
- 57:23abuse. It isn't that a person can be relieved of the anxiety, and
- 57:30the anxiety is probably too small a word, the terror that comes from the
- 57:36cues of memory, though. I guess the question one of the questions that
- 57:38goes through my head is well, how is it showing up in your life
- 57:40now? And DBT could be a really good option to help you with managing
- 57:45the ways in which it shows up. You know, if it makes you
- 57:49afraid when you're walking down the street, you know, like somebody's approaching and
- 57:52that somehow sets your body into motion, there's ways to handle that. I'm
- 57:57thinking of somebody that we know that was in the a DBT class I taught
- 58:00a long time ago, where they were combining DBT plus exposure therapy, and
- 58:05what the person said was just it's amazing. What she said was she said,
- 58:14I can no longer live a meaningful life and avoid these things that I'm
- 58:17avoiding. And what they used to avoid is men. So walking down the
- 58:22street, if there was a man coming, they crossed the street. If
- 58:23they were at the bus stop and a man showed up, they'd walked down
- 58:25the street to the other to the next bus stop, which kind of expensive
- 58:30because you missed your bus. And they said, I can no longer live
- 58:34this way and have a meaningful life, so I'm going to live an exposed
- 58:37life. And exposed life is most people on the street are not dangerous.
- 58:43Now. Should they walk down a dark alley in the middle of the night,
- 58:45no, No. But if you're on a city street in the middle
- 58:47of the daytime, in a reasonably safe part of town, and you happen
- 58:52to be walking past someone who you know their presence just sets the PTSD stuff,
- 58:58the anxiety stuff in motion, then they're probably not dangerous. So probably
- 59:06not, They're most likely I mean, most people are not dangerous. Most
- 59:09people are not going to hurt us, So so don't cross the street.
- 59:16That's what they did. They didn't cross the street. They didn't walk away
- 59:20from the bus stop. They just stayed. And at first they were scared
- 59:22to death, and they just were willing to keep at it, willing to
- 59:25keep at it, and it subsided. I think it took a matter of
- 59:30maybe weeks to maybe a couple three months for it to settle enough. I
- 59:35mean, I don't know if they didn't experience it at all, but I
- 59:38think it became manageable to them, and so the way in which they were
- 59:44plagued by the abuses they suffered was mitigated because it wasn't intruding on their life
- 59:51in the way that it was the way it had been before they started that
- 59:53particular therapy program. So I don't know, I'm going to be interested in
- 59:59what Kur has to say about this. There's probably more I could say,
- 1:00:01but off the top of my head, that's what comes in. Yeah,
- 1:00:06it's good. The only thing I'll add is, I think what you're drawing
- 1:00:10a connection, Hannah from Indiana, is that one when you're in residential treatment
- 1:00:19it's a very different emotional milieu. One you don't have the distractions, but
- 1:00:23also you have this constant presence of humans, and that could have been the
- 1:00:30protective factor in your suicidal ideation. The other difference is that you were doing
- 1:00:35intensive DBT, maybe every day, and I don't hear that you're doing DBT
- 1:00:40in your outpatient in weekly therapy appointments. You could, for example, add
- 1:00:47a DBT group to your weekly therapy, and that could be in the direction
- 1:00:53of not only having DBT, but also having more contact and regularity with people
- 1:01:00that you trust. So there's that. Also, if you, of course
- 1:01:05had safe relationships in your personal life, then that would be even better.
- 1:01:12I didn't hear that you didn't comment on that, but I imagine that that
- 1:01:15is a pretty big part of it. The other thing is is that when
- 1:01:21you know, there's two general types of suicidal ideation that I've experienced clinically.
- 1:01:25One is that people have ups and downs. The other one is that it's
- 1:01:30just chronic and it's almost like the neurons become habitually firing. And especially since
- 1:01:38you've been thinking about it since you were nine, it's like it's analogous for
- 1:01:45me in that there's this one memory I have of being on vacation with my
- 1:01:49friends when I was about thirty years old at Lake Chlan, and I'm sitting
- 1:01:52at this table in a restaurant and I'm looking down at this candle and it's
- 1:01:58completely innocuous moment, nothing happened that moment, but for whatever reason that that
- 1:02:04little scene will just pop into my head. And I've investigated, there's nothing
- 1:02:07psychoanalytic about it. It's just I had that memory and I recalled it soon
- 1:02:13after, and my brain just decided this is going to be something that I'm
- 1:02:17you know, and the more I remember it, the more it's remembered.
- 1:02:22And so it's similar to this what fires together, wires together, and so
- 1:02:29it's just it's just a habit, a chronic habit of your unconscious mind.
- 1:02:35And and as Bob was saying, it in all likelihood points to something,
- 1:02:40you know, whether it's avoidance of emotion or some particular emotion. And it
- 1:02:46isn't like there's a there's a healthy end result of all your work that might
- 1:02:54actually include occasional thoughts of suicide that popped into your head and you just regard
- 1:03:01it as well, it's not actual motivation or you know, an indication that
- 1:03:07that's a path, But what is it telling me? You know, usually
- 1:03:10when I have that thought pop it in my head, it's because of some
- 1:03:15feeling that I'm having, or some fear, or some disconnection or some low
- 1:03:20self esteem or something. And Okay, now I have a direction to go
- 1:03:27in terms of what do I do because of that? You know, just
- 1:03:30trying not to think about something is not very easy, right, Don't think
- 1:03:34about a pink elephant, don't think about every and it creates a lot of
- 1:03:37distress. So there's that, plus you know, PTSD O CD borderline.
- 1:03:45There's a lot to work on and it's going to take a long time.
- 1:03:50And it's great you're at You're at a phase of your treatment. You went
- 1:03:53to impatient, you went to residential treatment, You've done tremendous work, You've
- 1:03:58you have a pretty good foundation, and it's expected that when you go back
- 1:04:03to your regular life that a lot of the feelings are going to re emerge.
- 1:04:10So now the task is, now that I have this under my belt
- 1:04:15and I'm back in the thick of my life, what do I do differently
- 1:04:19this time? And you're in weekly therapy, I'm guessing one hour a week.
- 1:04:27That would be the first thing I would attack is adding a DBT group.
- 1:04:30You could also ask your therapist to go twice a week. That would
- 1:04:33not be uncommon, especially if you have ongoing suicidal ideation, especially if you
- 1:04:39have borderline. Now that's the childhood sexual abuse trauma. I would address that
- 1:04:46later because the thing that you're doing now seems to be emotional awareness and regulation
- 1:04:53that will help you in exposure therapy down the line anyway. So there's that,
- 1:04:58plus, don't want to go headlong into that recovery while you're still actively
- 1:05:04at risk of suicide. That is like, oh, yeah, you know,
- 1:05:08recovery want on one really? Yeah, so that has to be off
- 1:05:12the table. Yeah, And you can consider if available occasional returns to residential
- 1:05:18treatment, if your insurance will pay forward or whatever, or something akin to
- 1:05:25that, like relatives or I don't know, a break something, you might
- 1:05:30consider that as part of the plan moving forward. The notion that somehow you're
- 1:05:36just going to slot into the capitalistic society of working fifty weeks out of the
- 1:05:42year and getting two weeks off and doing all your chores and responsibilities outside of
- 1:05:47that is unrealistic. For most people, maybe everybody, let alone someone going
- 1:05:53through what you're going through. So you know, maybe there's there's some other
- 1:05:57manageable plan. I don't know, and a perfect work we'd have taxes raised
- 1:06:01and spent so that you could take a break off work for a few years
- 1:06:06and just go to residential treatment that whole time, or at the very least
- 1:06:12have a much more robust treatment program, perhaps every day and outpatient, and
- 1:06:18you don't have to pay for it. But the way economics are right now,
- 1:06:21the way insurance companies are, but typically they will authorize well, I
- 1:06:27don't know, depends on where you're at, depends on the insurance you have,
- 1:06:32but I would give it a more than fifty percent chance that you can
- 1:06:36get two sessions a week and have it be paid for. If that's not
- 1:06:43the case, then you can ask your therapist to reduce the fee. Perhaps
- 1:06:47you can also supplement the therapy with a more affordable situation or something. I
- 1:06:54don't know. But hang in there, and you're at the beginning and you're
- 1:06:59doing great, and all of this is normal, and you know, just
- 1:07:04just keep working on it. And the idea is that you go down the
- 1:07:12road of recovery and five years from now you'll still have issues, but it'll
- 1:07:16be a lot more manageable. And five years later, I'm saying, and
- 1:07:19you just keep going down, chip away, don't kill yourself. Do not
- 1:07:24kill yourself. Yeah, And that does it for that episode of psychology.
- 1:07:27And see, I'll everyone out there, please take care of yourself truly,
- 1:07:30because you deserve it.