Latest / Humanise The Numbers - for ambitious accountants in practice / Stephan Meier, Professor and Author – Part One
Transcript
- 0:05Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the Humanize the Numbers podcast series Leaders, managers and owners of ambitious accounting firms sharing insights, successes and issues that will challenge you and connect you and your firm to the ways and means of transforming your firm's results.
- 0:21Stephan Meier: There is a guy which I really enjoy talking to him.
- 0:25Stephan Meier: Talking to him, he is at kkr, so it's a private equity, large private equity, globally private equity firm.
- 0:33Stephan Meier: Private equity firms are not particularly have a reputation of being employee centric.
- 0:38Stephan Meier: Um, and and he, pete stavros is his name, you know he figured out like that's actually the way to make stuff work.
- 0:48Stephan Meier: Now, he originally started everything with like ownership.
- 0:52Stephan Meier: So he said, like you know, if we give stock options to employees, you know that will lead to higher engagement and lower quit rates, and so they literally invest billions of dollars, millions and millions of dollars in companies and implementing this.
- 1:10Stephan Meier: But even he then figured out just giving stock options is not enough.
- 1:14Stephan Meier: In fact, about 50% of their portfolio company where they invest, where they do this program, it actually doesn't work.
- 1:21Stephan Meier: So he then looks at you know what is the missing piece?
- 1:25Stephan Meier: And he's still working on it.
- 1:26Stephan Meier: I mean, I told him it's actually the four motivators that I talk in my book about.
- 1:31Stephan Meier: He calls it leadership, empathy.
- 1:33Stephan Meier: At the moment, I mean it's more like putting this all together, but it's the humanizing part which then actually creates the profits.
- 1:43Paul Shrimpling: Even if you believe your team bring you and your firm an advantage, the chances are you can also see potential that's untapped within many of the people within that team.
- 1:55Paul Shrimpling: Well, on this podcast discussion with Stefan Meyer, we're about to unpack the strategies from companies like ING Bank, unilever, toyota, kpmg and many others to see how they have used not used how they have worked with their people to bring a real edge, a real advantage to their business.
- 2:19Paul Shrimpling: Let's go to that podcast with Stefan now.
- 2:22Stephan Meier: I'm Stefan Meyer.
- 2:23Stephan Meier: I'm the James B Gorman Professor of Business Strategy and the Chair of the Management Division at Columbia Business School.
- 2:31Stephan Meier: I'm extremely passionate about thinking and researching on the intersection of business strategy, human behavior and the future of work, and I love my job.
- 2:43Stephan Meier: But if I could do anything else, uh, I think I would be a lego stop motion movie maker.
- 2:52Stephan Meier: Uh, so I make in my free time, I'm making lego stop motion movies, um, and and my wife says I'm a little bit too obsessed, uh, doing so, but I, I don't, I don't think you can be too obsessed about this, because it's a serious business, uh, to make those, those lego movies brilliant, brilliant, my, uh, our sound engineer, who happens to be our number one son, joe um.
- 3:20Paul Shrimpling: him and his brother used to do lego stop motion videos when they were in their formative years, so he'll be giggling his head off in the background.
- 3:28Paul Shrimpling: That's fantastic.
- 3:29Paul Shrimpling: So, stefan, what's your journey, if you would, for the people listening to this, to completing or even starting the Employee Advantage which is the book doug and I think is a piece of genius?
- 3:45Paul Shrimpling: Uh, so what, what?
- 3:47Paul Shrimpling: What led up to what?
- 3:48Paul Shrimpling: You know?
- 3:48Paul Shrimpling: What were the key moments that led you to this place of compacting this insightful knowledge into the employee advantage?
- 3:55Stephan Meier: yeah, yeah, thank you so much.
- 3:57Stephan Meier: First of all, thank you so much for having me on this podcast it's uh it's a, it's such an honor, uh, to be here, and I think we're very, very like-minded people in thinking about this.
- 4:07Stephan Meier: So it was an interesting journey.
- 4:10Stephan Meier: Because when I started at the Columbia Business School, I would teach business strategy.
- 4:17Stephan Meier: That's what I would do in the classroom.
- 4:20Stephan Meier: I was thinking about with the students discussing what should Walmart do in their upscaling strategy, should PepsiCo split up their snack business, should Disney go into streaming?
- 4:34Stephan Meier: And it was all about kind of what the customer, the positioning and then I would go into my office and start researching about what motivates humans in their life, how to think about incentive, and I will go back into the classroom and talk about customers all the time and I would almost keep those two separate.
- 4:54Stephan Meier: And what really changed for me was, quite frankly, the pandemic.
- 4:59Stephan Meier: During the pandemic, I thought that first of all, it put a bright spotlight on what is not working well in the workplace and also for me, I kind of thought more about like technology.
- 5:13Stephan Meier: So I started to think about, started to what I'm actually studying.
- 5:24Stephan Meier: What motivates human is extremely relevant how firms operate and how strategy works.
- 5:32Stephan Meier: And so then I started to combine those aspects of like business strategy what makes businesses successful and thinking about more what happens inside firms, how we lead, what motivates people, and so that's when I started to write the book.
- 5:49Stephan Meier: In fact, an agent reached out years ago whether I should write a book, and I said no, because I said I'm not passionate about a topic enough to write a book.
- 6:00Stephan Meier: But then I really was, and I'm now extremely passionate.
- 6:04Stephan Meier: I'm thinking about how can we, yeah, make the workplace more human in order to make the businesses successful.
- 6:11Stephan Meier: You know, and that's kind of the combination to the strategy piece, like it's.
- 6:16Stephan Meier: I mean, I think it's also the right thing to do, but I think it's also has a business case to putting your employees first.
- 6:27Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, this podcast is called Humanize the Numbers, and we usually start with the question so what does humanize the numbers mean to you?
- 6:34Paul Shrimpling: And it sounds as though you've just encapsulated it there in terms of yes, there's that strategic insight, there's the fact that actually we've got an eye on the future.
- 6:42Paul Shrimpling: It has to be about the numbers, but the route to achieving the numbers is in the customer employee space, because they're the humans in the business yeah, yeah, paul and dog, I completely agree.
- 6:56Stephan Meier: You know, and I love this what you call like humanizing the numbers, because it really shows what I feel very strong about.
- 7:03Stephan Meier: But there are those numbers, they are important, but behind the numbers are human beings.
- 7:09Stephan Meier: And so if you don't think about what the human beings, what they care about, how they're engaged, how they're motivated, I think you don't make the numbers.
- 7:20Stephan Meier: I think nowadays it's similar when we think about the technology piece, you know, and I think we're over indexed a lot on the technology, think like there is technology and magic is going to happen and I hope there is magic going to happen but like there are humans behind, in the human machine interaction.
- 7:41Stephan Meier: There is a human machine interaction and I love what you do and, like you know, thinking about it is it is about the numbers, but behind the numbers are human beings that we need to care about.
- 7:53Stephan Meier: You know, otherwise you don't make the numbers yeah, absolutely well, we.
- 7:57Paul Shrimpling: we set up, if you imagine, a chain link and the end chain are the, the numbers of the business.
- 8:02Paul Shrimpling: So, whether that be the capital value of the business or the earning capabilities of the business, bottom line profitability, ebitda, whatever labels you want to put in that link.
- 8:09Paul Shrimpling: So one link back from that is the client loyalty.
- 8:14Paul Shrimpling: Without client loyalty you are never going to hit those numbers.
- 8:16Paul Shrimpling: Another link back from that is well, your team serve your clients.
- 8:21Paul Shrimpling: So without a team you're not going to serve your clients, they aren't going to be loyal and not hit the numbers.
- 8:26Paul Shrimpling: And one link back from that is the manager skills, the leader skills that enable you to have an engaged team which then builds on client loyalty, which then builds the numbers.
- 8:34Paul Shrimpling: That's the chain of events as we see it.
- 8:36Paul Shrimpling: I'm wondering is there a story in your lexicon of research that clearly demonstrates that, outside of accountancy, that actually plays out as well?
- 8:50Stephan Meier: I mean, there are many firms who don't get it right, but there are some who do and there are a couple.
- 8:57Stephan Meier: So one which I it illustrates it well is costco in the us.
- 9:05Stephan Meier: So, um, a subscription-based kind of retailers, and they really care about their employees in multiple and and this is not, like you know, we're here not talking about tech jobs those are like frontline workers.
- 9:21Stephan Meier: You know you're working in retail shops and the margins are relatively slim.
- 9:27Stephan Meier: So this is a tough business to be in and they still care about their employees tremendously.
- 9:34Stephan Meier: And then you see the benefit of that, you know.
- 9:37Stephan Meier: And then the benefit come like turnover is much, much lower within that which has a direct implication to cost.
- 9:45Stephan Meier: To your point, the customers are obviously important.
- 9:49Stephan Meier: If you have happy employees, you have happy customers.
- 9:53Stephan Meier: In the case of Costco, that means that sales per square feet are actually much higher.
- 9:59Stephan Meier: So people spend more in the stores.
- 10:02Stephan Meier: They're really loyal customers.
- 10:04Stephan Meier: So that allows, allows in that particular industry, costco to introduce more private labels which have higher margins.
- 10:11Stephan Meier: So the private label within Costco is called Kirkland, and so there are higher margin items.
- 10:18Stephan Meier: So the customers are happy, they're spending more money.
- 10:21Stephan Meier: People are leaving, the employees are leaving less, and that also then leads to more innovation as a result, and so they're very, very successful in being very employee-centric.
- 10:34Stephan Meier: I mean, they're paying more money as well, but they're doing many, many more things for the frontline worker.
- 10:42Stephan Meier: One in particular is giving them clear career path.
- 10:46Stephan Meier: So it's pretty clear when you enter and you start reshelving the shelves that you know if you do X, y and Z, you can actually be promoted and you can make your way up, and, as a result, about 80% 90% of their managers are promoted internally, and that's a super motivators for everybody in the organization and really leads them to make more money as a result it's that that sounds that connects with your um.
- 11:17Paul Shrimpling: I was fascinated by diving straight into the practicalities of the, the, the four key elements.
- 11:23Paul Shrimpling: You know know that purpose, autonomy, just right tasks and social connections.
- 11:27Paul Shrimpling: So I think what you're talking there is the just right tasks, connected also with this career flight path.
- 11:34Paul Shrimpling: You've got going, those four practical pieces of the jigsaw puzzle, stefan.
- 11:42Paul Shrimpling: I want to unpack in a little while, but I just want to bring a conversation this week around a boardroom table in a substantially sized accounting firm into this conversation.
- 11:54Paul Shrimpling: And it's that you know you talk early in the book about.
- 11:57Paul Shrimpling: You know we've gone from being product-centric to being customer-centric, to being, if we get it right, team, team centric, but actually all three matter.
- 12:05Paul Shrimpling: But ultimately the emphasis has shifted over time and in around this boardroom table.
- 12:12Paul Shrimpling: There was one group around the board who were very much yes, we've, you know, this team first approach, and another, still anchored to the no, it's the services we deliver.
- 12:24Paul Shrimpling: There's this absolute obsession with service delivery, and by service I mean an audit service or a payroll service or, you know, an annual account service or management accounts and so on, and I just wondered what?
- 12:37Paul Shrimpling: What can we do to convince the audience that actually, yes, what you deliver matters, but everyone's delivering that in some way shape or form, and actually it's the interrelation between the customer, the client and the team member, and therefore your ability to influence those relationships, that matter the most.
- 13:00Paul Shrimpling: How?
- 13:00Stephan Meier: would you respond to that?
- 13:01Stephan Meier: Yeah, I mean it's a really important part because I do believe that, like, a lot of leaders need to change their mindset somehow and how to think about, like you know, fostering the right culture and treating their employees well Again in order to make the numbers work and be profitable.
- 13:21Stephan Meier: Be profitable, I mean how.
- 13:26Stephan Meier: How I try to convince them is, like you know, when you talk about like product to customer centricity, you know people were skeptical about customer centricity back in the days.
- 13:32Stephan Meier: Uh, they were.
- 13:34Stephan Meier: You know amazon, who is a very customer, not as employee centric, but even they got a lot of flag early on by being so customer obsessed and analysts say, like, well, where's the money?
- 13:47Stephan Meier: You're spending too much on the experience of the customer and whatever.
- 13:52Stephan Meier: Turns out that we're right, because there is actually win-win situations and if you think about your customer as like, if you make the customer happy, you're making a lot of money.
- 14:02Stephan Meier: And I think the same has to be true, like, if you make the customer happy, you're making a lot of money, and I think the same has to be true for your employees.
- 14:08Stephan Meier: But there is a long way to go.
- 14:10Stephan Meier: So I love this quote that Bezos says about his customer.
- 14:17Stephan Meier: He says I mean he says many things, but like one quote somehow he says you know, what is awesome about my customers is they're always dissatisfied.
- 14:27Stephan Meier: And what he means with that is, like I can always learn to be better.
- 14:33Stephan Meier: And, to your point, better also means in competition to others.
- 14:37Stephan Meier: You know, I want to be better than the others.
- 14:40Stephan Meier: Now, very few leaders would say you know what is great about my employees they're always dissatisfied.
- 14:46Stephan Meier: But it's the same logic like you can actually learn from them what is not going well and improve.
- 14:55Stephan Meier: And that's kind of the focus that we need to understand, like what do the employees need in order to be successful?
- 15:03Stephan Meier: Now, this is not a new idea.
- 15:06Stephan Meier: When you think about the Toyota way of making cars, the whole ideas of Kaizen, constant improvement is that everybody on this front line, on the assembly line, has something to say, has something to say.
- 15:21Stephan Meier: And if we can fix that problem, we make the assembly line better and we are improving, small steps maybe, in order to do that, but in order to do that and Toyota is a good example you need to be willing to stop the assembly line, which costs, I don't know, tens of thousands of dollars per minute.
- 15:42Stephan Meier: It's a very, very expensive proposition, but if you really believe there is ideas who come up from the ground up, you know you can be better.
- 15:54Stephan Meier: Now this is assembly lines, but I think the same idea applies to every single industry, including when you think about accounting firms.
- 16:02Stephan Meier: You know, think about, like, what is frustrating for our employees.
- 16:05Stephan Meier: You know how can we do everything better, and then, to your point, in competition, you're actually going to get better and the service is eventually also going to get better.
- 16:16Stephan Meier: Yeah, that you actually give to the clients, but you need to completely change how you think about the employees, how you think about the inputs of the employees and how to think about the human, humanizing the business brilliant.
- 16:31Paul Shrimpling: I'm going to bring doug in a second to talk about um employee voice and and the research we've been doing using the gallup q12 engagement survey, because there's a part of that which is about um voice isn't there, um, before we do.
- 16:46Paul Shrimpling: There's a part of that which is about voice isn't there Before we do.
- 16:50Paul Shrimpling: There's a piece that you talk about that employee expectations are changing and I was like, well, and I couldn't quite get my head around.
- 16:55Paul Shrimpling: What are you talking about there in terms of these changes?
- 16:59Paul Shrimpling: Is this because of the generational shifts or is it something more intrinsic?
- 17:04Stephan Meier: Where were you getting that?
- 17:05Stephan Meier: Yeah, I don't.
- 17:07Stephan Meier: I don't think it's the.
- 17:08Stephan Meier: I mean you know, I mean I have three kids, so I mean I, as, as every generation, since there are parents and that's many thousands of years, every generation thinks like kids these days, you know, like like dude.
- 17:24Stephan Meier: But I mean I show sometimes, when I teach about this, I show a quote from the greek philosopher, socrates, yes, who also talks kids these days, uh, and I showed a quote without the name and they all the leaders are, yeah, kids these days, and I was like, well, that's like thousands of years ago, um, so there is some of generational, but I think it's it's a much more uh trend that affects everybody, where you now, you know, are used to personalization.
- 17:55Stephan Meier: Now, of course, it has some like my kids do not know that.
- 18:02Stephan Meier: Uh, you know, sometimes if you order something, it takes more than than a day to arrive.
- 18:06Stephan Meier: When we grew up it took many, many.
- 18:11Stephan Meier: I mean you obviously couldn't order online, but like, even if you order something in the store, it would take like weeks to come.
- 18:19Stephan Meier: They have no idea that, like you know, back in the days, families and kids were like fight over TV time Because there was just one TV and there was just one program and when you missed the seven o'clock show of whatever you want to watch, you missed it.
- 18:40Stephan Meier: And then you know afterwards you could recording and now it's everything is personalized.
- 18:44Stephan Meier: And I think that changes somehow the expectations of the employees as well, because as a customer, they have a very different experience than what happened, you know, 30 years ago or even 10 years ago, and and that now leads also to them having different expectations when it comes to work.
- 19:06Stephan Meier: I mean, why would you have a personalized experience as a customer?
- 19:09Stephan Meier: And then you come into the office and it's a one-size-fits-all and that's part of what changes.
- 19:16Stephan Meier: So technology changes somehow everything we do, including, kind of what, how we think about being customers, and that I think will spill over pretty dramatically into the workplace.
- 19:29Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, how's that connected with giving our team a voice?
- 19:33Paul Shrimpling: You know, there's this.
- 19:34Paul Shrimpling: There's a real difference, isn't it, between, say, a command and control style of leadership management and, uh, let's call it trust and inspire, to quote, um, yeah, steven covey, uh, piece, um, there's a real difference.
- 19:45Paul Shrimpling: So, what's what does?
- 19:47Paul Shrimpling: Because, look, we're all can, we're all control freaks, and the accountants could be argued that they're especially like to be in control because there's regulation, there's compliance, there's this sensitivity around it, um, but that, um, you know the toyota model, the toyota production system, where innovation is bubbling up from the bottom, as opposed to in accounting firms, where innovation tends to be, um, pushed down from the top.
- 20:15Paul Shrimpling: It's, there's that there's a real contradiction in terms of command and control versus, yeah, trust and inspire leadership and the team voice.
- 20:22Stephan Meier: Well, yeah, I mean, I think like there is.
- 20:25Stephan Meier: There's two things, you know.
- 20:26Stephan Meier: One is their expectations might change.
- 20:29Stephan Meier: Now that feels a little bit like we have to cave into kids these days, you know, like just because they want it, like now we have to give them some voice and whatever.
- 20:37Stephan Meier: But but I think that this is not even the biggest part.
- 20:41Stephan Meier: It's like because the world is changing so fast.
- 20:44Stephan Meier: Uh, you know, stuff is like moving so dramatically fast that this top down, which works really well in a well-structured, very stable environment, then if we know, okay, for the next 10 years we need to do this, yeah, and like just map it out what we need to do and push it down.
- 21:05Stephan Meier: But that's not happening anymore because it's moving so, so fast.
- 21:08Stephan Meier: And now you need to flatten organizations in order to create, kind of whether that's agile or like just a more innovative environment.
- 21:18Stephan Meier: And with flatten the organization, you need to empower everybody on the organization much more, because this top down is just not working anymore in this new environment.
- 21:28Stephan Meier: So I think it's it's not.
- 21:30Stephan Meier: It's not a reaction to the expectations.
- 21:34Stephan Meier: It's a reaction to the expectations, it's a reaction to the different business environment and it's necessary to be agile and to move forward and to beat the competition in being much more nimble, much more agile, much more innovative and empowering the employees to do their part.
- 21:55Paul Shrimpling: Amazing Doug.
- 21:57Paul Shrimpling: Do you want to just reference that employee?
- 22:02Doug Aitken: voice and the challenges in that space.
- 22:06Doug Aitken: Yeah, I've made about 40 questions so far just from what's been said.
- 22:12Doug Aitken: The Toyota thing actually challenged me a lot because I was trying to think what the equivalent was in accountancy of pulling the Andon cord and stopping the production line and all hands diving in to get the job finished.
- 22:28Doug Aitken: I thought there's a real challenge there in accountancy firms, because they often pick up and then put down a job because they can't finish it, because they're missing something or they need to ask someone or whatever it might be, um, but they end up with loads of work in progress with, which makes it very inefficient.
- 22:48Doug Aitken: But I want to go back to one thing that you mentioned before, stefan, if I can.
- 22:52Doug Aitken: Um, because it intrigued me about you saying about leaders needing to change their mindset, and I'm really interested in that because is it a case that they still see it being a trade-off between profit or people or is it?
- 23:10Doug Aitken: I was intrigued as well and I did an MBA, so I can relate to the education that took place during that.
- 23:17Doug Aitken: There was nothing on people in my MBA, literally nothing.
- 23:21Doug Aitken: It was all about strategy, all about trends, challenges.
- 23:25Doug Aitken: It was all about you know what's happening in the world, what models can we apply, but there was nothing on people.
- 23:31Doug Aitken: So you know what is that mindset shift and how can we do it yeah, yeah, it's a it's.
- 23:40Stephan Meier: It's a very good point, dog, and you know, I'm teaching in a business school and we have we have a strategy division, we have a marketing division.
- 23:48Stephan Meier: We don't have a people division.
- 23:50Stephan Meier: I mean, we have psychologists who do like organizational behavior, so there's a little bit about that, but there is very little about people and I think that has to change.
- 24:03Stephan Meier: And I do think there is this mindset shift to thinking not about what you said, this trade off.
- 24:09Stephan Meier: You know that it's either profits or we treat the employees well, and thinking much more about like no, there is win-win.
- 24:19Stephan Meier: And part of the problem with thinking about the trade-off is, if we have this view and I'm an economist by training and in the economic model, what economists think about work is like work is painful.
- 24:36Stephan Meier: You know, people are only working because they get compensated monetarily.
- 24:43Stephan Meier: That's kind of the model we have and that's a lot of people still think that that, like you know, people show up to work because they're either controlled or they're compensated financially.
- 24:54Stephan Meier: And if, if you just think about money, it is actually much more a trade-off.
- 24:59Stephan Meier: You know, like, I give you 10,000 more, that is, 10,000 out of the bottom line, out of my margin, but I think the shift has to be that people are not just working for money.
- 25:13Stephan Meier: I mean to stress the customer centric analogy again.
- 25:20Stephan Meier: You know, like customer centricity is not lowering the price, customer centricity is increasing the experience and then actually increasing the price as a result.
- 25:31Stephan Meier: And I think when we start to think about, people are motivated by much more than money.
- 25:37Stephan Meier: Now you can actually think about how to improve the experience to make them more productive in order to actually lower the cost per unit, because they're doing more work, they're more innovative, they're less likely to leave and you know, they actually have an effect on the service and the experience of the customer um as well.
- 25:58Stephan Meier: But it but it takes time, you know, and I have how I try to convince them at the moment is um, there is, there is a, a guy which I, I, I really enjoy, uh, talking to him.
- 26:11Stephan Meier: He is at kkr, so it's a private equity, large private equity, globally private equity firm.
- 26:18Stephan Meier: Private equity firms are not particularly have a reputation of being employee centric and and he Pete Stavros, is his name, you know he figured out like that's actually the way to make stuff work.
- 26:33Stephan Meier: Now he, he originally started everything with like ownership.
- 26:37Stephan Meier: So he said like you know, if we give stock options to employees, you know that will lead to higher engagement and lower quit rates.
- 26:46Stephan Meier: And so they literally invest billions of dollars, millions and millions of dollars in companies in implementing this.
- 26:54Stephan Meier: But even he then figured out, just giving stock options is not enough.
- 26:59Stephan Meier: In fact, about 50% of their portfolio company where they invest, where they do this program, it actually doesn't work.
- 27:06Stephan Meier: So he then looks at you know what is the missing piece?
- 27:10Stephan Meier: And he's still working on it.
- 27:11Stephan Meier: I mean I told him it's actually the four motivators that I talk in my book about.
- 27:16Stephan Meier: He calls it leadership, empathy.
- 27:18Stephan Meier: At the moment I mean it's more like putting this all together, but it's the humanizing part which then actually creates the profits.
- 27:27Stephan Meier: And again, the private equity firms they're not in there for altruism or like they're actually in there to make the numbers, to make the returns.
- 27:37Stephan Meier: And it's very surprising to me maybe not to the world like if I tell that story, if Pete Stavros tells the story, suddenly everybody's like oh yeah, that makes sense.
- 27:48Stephan Meier: And I was like I told you.
- 27:49Stephan Meier: So I mean there is evidence on this.
- 27:51Stephan Meier: But I mean I can see he puts like really his money and the company's money behind it, so he really strongly believes in.
- 27:59Stephan Meier: You can actually make the numbers work by humanizing the workforce, but there is still work to be done to convince people leaders that there is win-win leaders that there is win-win, yeah, in that leading and managing change space, stefan, they talk about.
- 28:21Paul Shrimpling: You've got to change your skills, but you've got to change your mindset.
- 28:22Paul Shrimpling: You've got to improve your skills.
- 28:23Paul Shrimpling: You've got to improve your mindset, which is easier said, hard, hard to do, and we can.
- 28:28Paul Shrimpling: We can logic that and, you know, be very intellectual about that and share examples.
- 28:34Paul Shrimpling: I'm wondering what do we do to tap into a deep emotive response reaction?
- 28:40Paul Shrimpling: I mean that story from Steve Stavros helps because we can connect with the emotional challenges that must be going on in a private equity firm to actually acknowledge the fact that we've got to invest time, effort, energy in the way we work with our team to deliver the results that we really want.
- 28:57Paul Shrimpling: So I get that.
- 28:58Paul Shrimpling: I just wonder is there anything else which you know gets the buy-in of managers and leaders so that they become employee-centric managers, as you call them in the book?
- 29:08Stephan Meier: Yeah, I mean I don't know.
- 29:11Stephan Meier: I mean they should probably hire you to do this stuff, because I think what is important and I mean the two of you know this but it's hard, you know, it's not easy to do.
- 29:25Stephan Meier: Now, as I always say, in everything strategy, hard is good.
- 29:31Stephan Meier: If it were easy everybody would do it.
- 29:34Stephan Meier: But if it's actually hard, if you put in the work to, you know, and that's true for customer centricity as well, everybody cares about customer.
- 29:44Stephan Meier: You know, like I've never met somebody who says like I mean I'm sure you never met the leader who says like I don't care about my clients.
- 29:51Stephan Meier: I mean like they should suck it up what I showed up.
- 29:55Stephan Meier: I mean everybody cares.
- 29:57Stephan Meier: But to be really, really customer-centric, to really improve the service, needs a lot of dedication and a lot of effort.
- 30:05Stephan Meier: And the same is true with talent.
- 30:07Stephan Meier: Everybody says I care obviously about my talent, I want motivated workers and I want the accountants to be really top notch.
- 30:16Stephan Meier: But to really create an atmosphere where they are extremely engaged and productive is hard.
- 30:23Stephan Meier: I mean that's where you kick in, you know, and help them to do that, because you can't just do it just by thinking about it or printing it on the wall.
- 30:34Stephan Meier: You know there is probably very few firms who there is no.
- 30:37Stephan Meier: You know, in the break room it says respect and people care and teamwork and whatever, but there are very few who can actually pull it off.
- 30:46Stephan Meier: Yeah, but in competition, that's the edge, then.
- 30:51Stephan Meier: Where you then actually make a difference compared to your competitor and and I think that's how I try to convince leaders is like you know, you want a competitive edge, you're in it.
- 31:04Stephan Meier: Competition is tough, it's hard and it's getting probably harder because there is more international competition.
- 31:10Stephan Meier: You know there is a there's a lot of competition going on and so if you can get an edge, you should take it.
- 31:18Doug Aitken: I was talking with a group of managers maybe two or three weeks ago, stefan, and we were referencing the Gallup Q12 poll because there's a direct question about I've got someone that cares about me.
- 31:31Doug Aitken: So I said I challenged them about.
- 31:34Doug Aitken: You know, do you care about your people first of all?
- 31:38Doug Aitken: Oh, yeah, yeah yeah, of course we do.
- 31:39Doug Aitken: And I said how do you show it, how do you actually show that you care?
- 31:45Doug Aitken: And they were stumped.
- 31:47Doug Aitken: There was a lot of violence in the room and someone eventually blurted out well, but they just know, they just know that we care.
- 31:56Doug Aitken: And I said well, how much time?
- 31:58Doug Aitken: do you spend with them and you know the answer to that as well.
- 32:02Doug Aitken: Well, we'll see them.
- 32:03Doug Aitken: No, no, I mean organized time that's just between you and them, where you sit down with them and you have a chat and you check in with them and you don't just, you know, flippantly ask.
- 32:14Doug Aitken: You know, are you having a good day?
- 32:17Doug Aitken: You're deeply serious about how are you, what's going on in your life?
- 32:21Doug Aitken: and it's amazing still, most leaders still view that as a cost.
- 32:26Doug Aitken: They're very much in p and l mode and and they need we need to get them to capital investment mode that this will show a return on their investment over time, when they show that they care by deed and actions, not by just saying that they care.
- 32:43Doug Aitken: It's a real struggle even today to get them to spend time with people.
- 32:49Stephan Meier: Yeah, no, I completely agree, doug, and I think you know when they again think about like another stakeholder, which is the clients, the customers, you know they think differently.
- 33:00Stephan Meier: I mean, if you go to a marketing executive and say like is it a good idea to ask your clients or customers once a year how they're doing, they would like laugh their asses off.
- 33:13Stephan Meier: They're like, of course not.
- 33:14Stephan Meier: I need like constant feedback and inputs and pulses and surveys and focus groups and whatever.
- 33:20Stephan Meier: But with the employees we do it best case, you know, once a year, those engagement surveys, and then we ignore everything that is in there.
- 33:28Stephan Meier: Everybody knows that, so nobody participates in the first place.
- 33:32Stephan Meier: So we kind of need to think about this very differently.
- 33:35Stephan Meier: And again, like very cost.
- 33:37Stephan Meier: To your point, you know very customer-centric organizations like require their.
- 33:42Stephan Meier: So there's um home depot like the, the store in the us that does, like you know, home repair all those goods.
- 33:50Stephan Meier: They require executives, I think, once a month to visit the store and talk to clients, talk to customers on the floor.
- 33:58Stephan Meier: It's a structured way.
- 34:00Stephan Meier: I mean you can probably even do that better, but, like you know, do we have a systematic way to your point in understanding, how are our employees doing, you know, creating a safe space, that they're also okay to voice criticism.
- 34:18Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 34:18Stephan Meier: Because if you just, you know, have a town hall meeting, it's like, how are you guys doing?
- 34:26Stephan Meier: I mean, there's nobody who says like you know, this is not working or this is a pain, or I see, this is like really slows us down.
- 34:35Stephan Meier: Or why are we having this regulation or this policy that really affects the services that we give to our clients and creating kind of this safe space to for people to really express um their discomfort or like something that go that, that should go better, I think goes a long way.
- 34:54Stephan Meier: But to your point, dog, you know it, it needs a shift that we're actually investing in it as leaders in that.
- 35:02Paul Shrimpling: So just picking up on that shift piece.
- 35:05Paul Shrimpling: Uh, you tell us the story of the shift in the bank, ing, in your book to you know, small squats, and and the reason I just wanted to pick up on that ing story is because we've got and I had it this week a pushback on the fact yeah, paul, you're telling a toyota story or you're telling a higher story.
- 35:26Paul Shrimpling: These are manufacturing businesses, professional services is different and it's like really um, and so I turned to your book, to, and I couldn't respond well enough in that, in that particular meeting, and then, oh, I wish I'd got this ing story hardwired because they made the shift to smaller teams.
- 35:44Paul Shrimpling: I'm just wondering is creating a sense of psychological safety so that team members have got more of a voice, is directly connected to those smaller teams that higher have made so successful?
- 35:54Paul Shrimpling: And if those who don't know higher, they're the, you know, I think now the largest white goods manufacturer in the world, the chinese company, and then ing bank did the same shift.
- 36:04Paul Shrimpling: As I can't remember the um, the ceo's name, it'll pop back into me, I'm sure.
- 36:08Paul Shrimpling: Um, they made a big shift to create an environment where innovation started bubbling up from the bottom.
- 36:15Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I think, like the Small teams.
- 36:19Stephan Meier: Yeah, exactly, it's not just you know the small teams is a good start, but actually the culture needs to change as well.
- 36:25Stephan Meier: How you know how those innovation and how you create those psychological safety that people are actually willing to express voices and obviously they need to empower.
- 36:38Stephan Meier: You know, if you have no power and there is nothing you can, I mean, why would you express anything or put in effort in doing so?
- 36:46Stephan Meier: And ING is a really good example.
- 36:47Stephan Meier: I mean, they also got hit by competition, you know, by more nimble, for technological reasons somehow as well, and I could imagine that might happen in the accounting industry as well.
- 37:00Stephan Meier: You know like suddenly smaller firms with technology together might suddenly be a competition.
- 37:10Stephan Meier: That were not before and now you have to.
- 37:14Stephan Meier: Ing had to change because they were now competing against those fintech firms who are organized very differently.
- 37:20Stephan Meier: You know, much smaller, much nimbler, and they needed to completely change their operational model smaller teams, flatter hierarchies and then on top of it, kind of the culture shift.
- 37:36Stephan Meier: You know, empowering the employees, creating those safe psychological safety environment to actually get those innovation going.
- 37:47Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, so I guess that's back to Doug's point a little bit in terms of is there actually diary time allocated to those conversations?
- 37:55Paul Shrimpling: That you establish a safe space for individuals to talk in, not just small teams to talk in, and that's very powerful yeah, I mean, I think, like a lot of it has to, one has to be very intentional about those.
- 38:08Stephan Meier: You know you have to it.
- 38:10Stephan Meier: Just it doesn't just happen by accident.
- 38:14Stephan Meier: Um, I mean, that's true with you know, the water cooler moments, or the innovation, or checking in, uh, the mentoring aspect, the learning, whatever we do we have to be much more intentional.
- 38:27Stephan Meier: And that's, you know, when I started talking about like how I think the pandemic for me changed, because if you some, the pandemic kind of for me showed that, like you know, certain things we take for granted just because we're in the same space, we thought like, oh, stuff happens.
- 38:45Stephan Meier: You know, I can check in on how you're doing.
- 38:47Stephan Meier: Uh, you know we meet at the coffee, at the coffee or the coffee machine or the kombucha tap or whatever.
- 38:54Stephan Meier: You have fancy, fancy free snack bar or whatever, um, but but it's like we were phoning it in, we were hoping those things happen.
- 39:03Stephan Meier: And if we're much more intentional and during the pandemic we had to be when we're not on the same, when we're not in the same space, and I think that should be a learning, even if we go back to the office five days a week some firms are not.
- 39:19Stephan Meier: But even if we do, we should be much more intentional about creating those check-ins, those interactions, those social connections.
- 39:30Paul Shrimpling: So I think if I hear you right, stefan, you're saying the way the managers and leaders behave with their individual team members and their group teams ultimately determines how effective that business works, because that has an impact, either positive or negative, on the team, on individuals, which then has a rub off impact on the speed of work, the quality of work and the client care.
- 39:57Stephan Meier: Yes, I think, like the, you know there is this classic saying I mean I'm not, I definitely didn't invent it and you know people don't leave jobs, they leave bosses.
- 40:06Stephan Meier: But I think there is a lot of research as well to show, you know, the effect leaders are very, very important.
- 40:14Stephan Meier: I think there is one study you show, like if you are a leader is in the top 10 percent of the distribution of leadership skills.
- 40:22Stephan Meier: You know that's that's as good as adding a ninth person to to an eight person team.
- 40:29Stephan Meier: Uh, it's a very important way of doing so.
- 40:33Stephan Meier: But the problem with leaders often is we're promoting on, like past skills.
- 40:38Stephan Meier: You know you're, you're an amazing accountant and then you're going to be promoted to lead the team of accountants.
- 40:46Stephan Meier: Now, just because you're a good accountant or a good salesperson doesn't mean you're a good manager of accountants and or salespeople and you can, obviously.
- 40:58Stephan Meier: I mean you should train them.
- 40:59Stephan Meier: I mean that's one or, and you know, select also on like who is actually going to be a good leader, which is a very different quality than being good in, you know, accounting or sales or or whatever.
- 41:14Stephan Meier: Or running, or being a doctor or whatever.
- 41:16Stephan Meier: It's very different than like actually running a team of doctors there's it is that.
- 41:22Paul Shrimpling: That's an interesting segue into the four motivators.
- 41:24Paul Shrimpling: I think, stefan, in in terms of you know the um skills can be built, can't they?
- 41:31Paul Shrimpling: It's, it's, not's not.
- 41:32Paul Shrimpling: You know it's nurture versus nature.
- 41:36Paul Shrimpling: We can build, like we can learn to drive a car, we can learn to give people a voice.
- 41:41Paul Shrimpling: By investing in a weekly one-to-one, for example, we can learn those skills.
- 41:46Paul Shrimpling: So I think it would be prudent for us to ask you to unpack the key elements of those four motivators, the key elements of those four motivators.
- 41:57Paul Shrimpling: So far, stefan's unpacked some powerful, valuable insights to help you build an employee advantage in your team with your firm.
- 42:03Paul Shrimpling: On part two, stefan's going to dive into the detail around how you put the four motivators to work with your team.
- 42:12Paul Shrimpling: In this discussion with Stefan Meyer, we've been unpacking an awful lot of insight, strategies, ideas, skills even that help you build the human skills into your accounting firm, which is exactly what we do with like-minded, ambitious accountants coming into the Accountants Growth Academy.
- 42:33Paul Shrimpling: If you want to join in, go to the show notes and you'll find a link to the Accountants Growth Academy.
- 42:39Paul Shrimpling: You'll find more valuable discussions with the leaders of ambitious accounting firms at humanizethenumbersonline.
- 42:47Paul Shrimpling: You can also sign up to be notified each time a new podcast is made available.
- 42:52Paul Shrimpling: Be notified each time a new podcast is made available.
- 43:02Paul Shrimpling: You're about to hear a short excerpt from a podcast discussion with Dan Crowther, ceo of Thorn Widgery.
- 43:05Paul Shrimpling: If you like what you're hearing and you want more, please go to humanizernumbersonline or go to your favourite podcast platform humanizethenumbersonline or go to your favorite podcast platform.
- 43:14Speaker 3: How are the client's expectations changing?
- 43:17Speaker 3: So they one thing is quicker.
- 43:18Speaker 3: The communication is an awful lot quicker than it would have been previously.
- 43:26Speaker 3: So I think that they have an expectation now of the service level which is higher than perhaps it was in the past.
- 43:36Speaker 3: So you know, and it's like, it's like the data, um stuff, I suppose, if that you know, that does need to be up to date.
- 43:46Speaker 3: You know it's not.
- 43:47Speaker 3: It's not okay for it to be kind of, um, nine months behind or however long.
- 43:52Speaker 3: Now that needs to be up to date.
- 43:54Speaker 3: The communication piece is really important.
- 43:55Speaker 3: You know that.
- 43:56Speaker 3: Making sure that we hit that, because you know you used to send letters back in the day.
- 44:00Speaker 3: Do you know what I mean?
- 44:00Speaker 3: It takes, you know, three days to get there and take three days for them to respond, but that that no longer I mean an email is like I said.
- 44:06Speaker 3: We have a.
- 44:07Speaker 3: We have a one day working day response time on that.
- 44:09Speaker 3: So, um, that's much quicker than perhaps what it would have been back then.