Latest / Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick, powered by CBT News / Brian Maas on California’s EV Trends and Dealer Advocacy
Transcript
- 0:07Announcer: Welcome to Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:11Jim Fitzpatrick: Hey everyone, Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:12Jim Fitzpatrick: Welcome into this special edition of Inside Automotive.
- 0:15Jim Fitzpatrick: We happen to have with us Mr.
- 0:16Jim Fitzpatrick: Brian Maas, who is the president of the California New Car Dealers Association and a good friend of CBT News.
- 0:24Jim Fitzpatrick: So California remains one of the most closely watched automotive markets in the country, as many of you know, and the latest numbers from the California New Car Deal Association offer some insight into where things are headed.
- 0:36Jim Fitzpatrick: Joining us now, as I mentioned, to discuss uh their Q3 auto outlook as well as share a general update on the association's advocacy efforts is Brian Maas, the president of the association.
- 0:47Jim Fitzpatrick: So, Brian, thank you so much for joining us.
- 0:49Brian Maas: Happy to be here, Jim, as always.
- 0:51Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure.
- 0:52Jim Fitzpatrick: So so let's uh jump right in here.
- 0:54Jim Fitzpatrick: What what stood out uh to you uh the most in the in this third quarter?
- 1:00Brian Maas: Uh well the obvious top line number was uh the increase in EV sales.
- 1:08Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 1:09Brian Maas: Um California, of course, um now sell sold at least in the third quarter, 28% of all the EVs sold in the United States were sold in California.
- 1:19Brian Maas: Um and our our market share uh is well into the mid-20s.
- 1:26Brian Maas: Uh so nearly one out of every four vehicles.
- 1:29Brian Maas: Wow, one sold in California was an EV.
- 1:32Brian Maas: Um that's largely due to the pull forward sales, yeah um, because consumers understood that all the federal uh rebates were going away.
- 1:43Brian Maas: Sure.
- 1:43Brian Maas: Um and uh everybody was kind of in a rush in August and September to get those cars.
- 1:50Brian Maas: Yeah.
- 1:50Brian Maas: So that's clearly the top line.
- 1:53Brian Maas: Um and I think uh what's missing from the top line is overall sales are pretty stable uh in California, and uh that's good news, even tariffs and high interest rates and all that kind of stuff.
- 2:07Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, that's fantastic.
- 2:08Jim Fitzpatrick: And it is interesting, as I've mentioned before on the show, that that the consumers came out, you know, even though you know we we heard so much, well, consumers don't want EVs right now.
- 2:17Jim Fitzpatrick: Obviously, in California they do.
- 2:18Jim Fitzpatrick: But even around the country where we saw this just this influx of customers coming in and picking up their EVs because of this tax incentive going away.
- 2:26Jim Fitzpatrick: Well, forget the tax incentive for a minute.
- 2:28Jim Fitzpatrick: People were buying EVs.
- 2:30Jim Fitzpatrick: I think that was a little bit of an eye-opener for the whole industry, don't you?
- 2:34Brian Maas: I do.
- 2:34Brian Maas: I mean, obviously, uh we're in a different market in California.
- 2:39Brian Maas: Right.
- 2:40Brian Maas: Uh and uh EVs have had and continue to have uh a place.
- 2:46Brian Maas: Uh I mean the Tesla Model Y is the number one uh selling car in California and has been for multiple quarters, even though overall Tesla sales have been dropping for for multiple quarters, but it's still the number one selling uh uh vehicle in the state.
- 3:02Brian Maas: So uh I think what this should uh tell automakers and all of us in the industry is there is a place for electric vehicles in the new car market.
- 3:15Brian Maas: Yeah.
- 3:16Brian Maas: Even in an we'll find out how much, obviously in the fourth quarter and beyond, without the incentives, but there's definitely a place for EVs.
- 3:26Brian Maas: Yeah.
- 3:27Brian Maas: I think the ambitions of some that we're gonna quickly transition to a hundred percent EVs over the next decade, those hopes have been dashed a little bit.
- 3:39Brian Maas: Yeah.
- 3:40Brian Maas: But uh there's gonna be a significant uh piece of the market that's going to see um EVs in consumers' hands.
- 3:48Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, I agree, I agree.
- 3:49Jim Fitzpatrick: And it should be said that if the rest of the country uh suffered from the same prices, the same gas prices that California does, why we'd probably see you know pretty strong sales throughout the rest of the country.
- 4:02Jim Fitzpatrick: Because I was out there recently, I think I saw five or six dollars a gallon for a gallon of gas.
- 4:06Jim Fitzpatrick: And man, that'll get you headed in the EV direction real quick, right?
- 4:10Brian Maas: Yeah, we're about a uh give or take, a buck fifty more per gallon on average than uh the rest of the country.
- 4:20Brian Maas: And uh our commutes tend to be longer than uh they are in some other markets across the country.
- 4:28Brian Maas: So you combine a long commute with high gas prices, you're gonna think long and hard, how can I afford a hybrid or a plug-in hybrid or an EV or something to save me some money on gas?
- 4:40Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, for sure.
- 4:41Jim Fitzpatrick: Now that the incentive is gone, do you expect there to be a drop in EV sales in California?
- 4:48Brian Maas: I do.
- 4:49Brian Maas: Um, the other thing that people don't talk about too much is uh there there was a program that the federal government ran uh that allowed EVs to have uh high occupancy vehicle lane stickers, and that program also expired on September 30th.
- 5:06Brian Maas: So for a long time, people bought uh EVs so they could get in the HOV lane and go faster than their counterparts on uh the five or the 405 in LA uh and other freeways throughout California.
- 5:22Brian Maas: Well, that's not an option any longer.
- 5:24Brian Maas: So to answer your question directly, yeah, I think we're gonna see uh significant drop off in EV sales in the fourth quarter, especially compared with the high number in the third quarter.
- 5:38Brian Maas: But uh, as we were talking about earlier, uh EVs aren't going away.
- 5:43Brian Maas: Right.
- 5:43Brian Maas: And uh they'll still be a significant market for them in a state like California.
- 5:49Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, yeah, I agree.
- 5:50Jim Fitzpatrick: So let's get an update on the uh the ACC2 mandate, um, referring to the California Air Resources Board's advanced clean cars uh two.
- 5:59Jim Fitzpatrick: Is that still tied up in legal challenges?
- 6:02Jim Fitzpatrick: What's your association's latest position on this issue?
- 6:05Brian Maas: Yeah, so uh we uh earlier this year launched uh what we called the calibrate campaign because we wanted the Air Resources Board to kind of recalibrate their rules and uh understanding that uh the current rule ACC2 as drafted by CARB wasn't going to be met.
- 6:25Brian Maas: Uh CARB did that.
- 6:27Brian Maas: They paused enforcement of the rule uh for the 2026 model year, which is what we'd asked them to do.
- 6:34Brian Maas: Of course, the federal government passed the Congressional Review Act resolutions taking away CARB's waiver authority.
- 6:41Brian Maas: California and a few other states turned around and sued.
- 6:45Brian Maas: Um that case is uh currently proceeding through the courts.
- 6:51Brian Maas: I think most prognosticators think that it's gonna be a difficult case for California to win.
- 6:57Brian Maas: Uh the other significant development is today uh the heavy-duty truck uh manufacturers are suing to get out from the clean truck partnership.
- 7:10Brian Maas: And there's a hearing in federal court today um about that.
- 7:15Brian Maas: And so hopefully we'll get some news about whether uh the heavy-duty truck um manufacturers and dealers can be relieved of complying with uh ACC2 going forward.
- 7:27Brian Maas: So there's there's a lot going on um relative to ACC2.
- 7:33Brian Maas: The governor once uh on the day they filed the lawsuit issued an executive order uh asking CARB to begin conversations about uh what the next version of an EV mandate looks like.
- 7:48Brian Maas: Um they've already started having some workshops.
- 7:51Brian Maas: Um there's a listening public comment uh with the waivers taken away.
- 7:58Brian Maas: Uh there can't be any real action on those until uh there's a a new administration in Washington.
- 8:08Brian Maas: Uh but uh carb is gonna do what they can uh to prepare for the EV transition.
- 8:15Brian Maas: And our goal in our communications with them is it needs to be market-based and reflect uh the pace at which consumers are buying these cars.
- 8:25Jim Fitzpatrick: Right, right.
- 8:26Brian Maas: And if they do that and recalibrate kind of their original thinking, uh they'll get it right.
- 8:31Brian Maas: We look forward to participating in that process.
- 8:34Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, that's great.
- 8:35Jim Fitzpatrick: That's great.
- 8:35Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, the Sony Honda situation, AFEELA, what what um what's the deal?
- 8:41Jim Fitzpatrick: What's the any updates on that that you can share?
- 8:44Brian Maas: Sure.
- 8:44Brian Maas: So um as as your viewers probably know, we sued VW Scout um back in April.
- 8:52Brian Maas: Yep.
- 8:53Brian Maas: Uh and that case is proceeding uh through the courts um in federal district court in San Diego.
- 8:59Brian Maas: Uh in August, we sued uh the Sony Honda uh uh joint venture along the same grounds, arguing that they're illegally competing uh with uh Honda and Acura dealers in California.
- 9:17Brian Maas: Um that case was filed in LA Superior Court.
- 9:21Brian Maas: Uh some initial responses uh were just filed by uh the defendants, and we're gonna respond to those in the next few weeks.
- 9:30Brian Maas: So that case is a little bit uh behind the VW Scout case procedurally.
- 9:37Brian Maas: Um and we expect that uh Sony Honda will resist our uh lawsuit.
- 9:44Brian Maas: And uh our hope is that we can survive uh what are called demurs or motions to dismiss, and then get to a place where we're uh uh asking uh the judges in those respective cases to enjoin the companies from illegally competing with uh their franchisees.
- 10:04Jim Fitzpatrick: Gotcha.
- 10:04Jim Fitzpatrick: It would seem that, and I don't I'm not a lawyer and I don't play one on TV, but um it would seem to me that if the Volkswagen, if you win in the Volkswagen case, then then the Sony case is a is kind of a no-brainer for for this, right?
- 10:19Brian Maas: I mean the the arguments are very similar.
- 10:21Brian Maas: There's some uh uh factual differences in terms of how the uh companies are organized, but the underlying underlying law is the same.
- 10:32Brian Maas: Yeah a manufacturer that has franchisees can't compete against its franchisees directly or critically through an affiliate.
- 10:42Brian Maas: And we argue that Scout is an affiliate of VW in that case, and we argue that um AFEELA, the Sony Honda partnership, is an affiliate of Honda.
- 10:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, and it is.
- 10:57Jim Fitzpatrick: That's our view.
- 10:59Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 11:00Jim Fitzpatrick: Walks like a duck, talks like a duck, right?
- 11:02Jim Fitzpatrick: It's a it's a it's a duck.
- 11:03Brian Maas: Well, and what's it what's interesting, and you know, these are public comments that have been made by uh VW executives in particular, acknowledging that Scout Scout is part of the VW family, and uh VW's investing five billion dollars in building a new plant in South Carolina.
- 11:23Brian Maas: These are public statements that the company has made.
- 11:26Brian Maas: So it's pretty hard to argue, in our view, uh that uh that is not right uh uh an affiliation.
- 11:35Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 11:36Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 11:37Jim Fitzpatrick: That's that's amazing that they're even trying.
- 11:39Jim Fitzpatrick: But uh so as we head towards the end of 2025, uh what what are the key issues you know that that you're gonna be focusing on there at the association, uh, even if you're if it you know going into 2026, what's on the what's on the agenda?
- 11:53Brian Maas: Yeah, I would say two things.
- 11:54Brian Maas: One is um one of our main missions in addition to advocacy is compliance.
- 11:59Brian Maas: So Governor Newsom signed a bill SB766.
- 12:04Brian Maas: It's called the California Cars Act.
- 12:07Brian Maas: And um this uh bill changes some of the processes for dealers in how they um advertise vehicles, uh their record keeping requirements, add some new prohibitions.
- 12:23Brian Maas: Um they're gonna have to have a bunch of new forms to comply with this law.
- 12:28Brian Maas: And uh the uh law enacted for the first time uh that we're aware of a three-day cooling off period for used cars priced at less than $50,000.
- 12:41Brian Maas: So our dealers are gonna have to uh make sure that they're properly complying with that rule.
- 12:48Brian Maas: And by the way, that applies to all used car dealers, whether it's a franchise new car dealer that sells used cars, independence, Carvana, CarMax, everybody's gonna have to comply with that.
- 13:00Brian Maas: So uh the law takes effect next October.
- 13:04Brian Maas: Um, but we do a series of new law seminars and webinars for our dealers, and we're gonna educate them about getting ready to comply with a significant uh change in statute.
- 13:18Brian Maas: The other thing we're preparing for is uh we have a gubernatorial election in California next year.
- 13:24Brian Maas: Uh Governor Newsom's termed out, and we have to uh select a new governor, and yeah, our our dealers are likely to be actively engaged in that process, uh trying to figure out who can uh be most responsive to our industry.
- 13:40Jim Fitzpatrick: So that three-day waiting period, that that's a stunner right there.
- 13:44Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, I you know, I'm putting my car dealer hat on and thinking, you know, obviously it the the I think the law is uh maybe a federal law where if you sell a car at somebody's home or you sell any product at somebody's home, they always had a three-day write, you know, of uh to you know, kind of a cooling off.
- 13:59Jim Fitzpatrick: But but this is at at the dealership if they buy it.
- 14:02Brian Maas: This is at this is at the dealership.
- 14:04Brian Maas: It doesn't matter whether it's sold remotely in your driveway or at the store.
- 14:09Brian Maas: Um consumers have the option to return the car.
- 14:12Brian Maas: Now there's all kinds of um restrictions on how they do that, including a restocking fee.
- 14:20Brian Maas: So it's not a free rental for the weekend.
- 14:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 14:23Brian Maas: Um we made sure we added those uh kind of belts and suspenders uh provisions.
- 14:29Brian Maas: For sure.
- 14:30Brian Maas: Uh but we already had a two-day right to purchase the ability to return the car.
- 14:37Brian Maas: We've had that for 20 years.
- 14:39Brian Maas: Okay.
- 14:39Brian Maas: Um and many of our dealers already offer policies where they allow consumers to return cars uh over a few days or a week or what have you.
- 14:52Brian Maas: So it's not gonna be significant a change.
- 14:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Okay.
- 14:57Brian Maas: Um it's the details though that matter, and that's our job to educate our dealers about what those details are going forward.
- 15:04Brian Maas: But it is a first in the nation thing.
- 15:07Jim Fitzpatrick: I was gonna say uh let's hope we have a three-day return rate.
- 15:10Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, let's hope it's the last in the nation thing.
- 15:14Brian Maas: W ell, we'll see.
- 15:15Brian Maas: As you know, Jim, we've talked many times on your show.
- 15:18Brian Maas: That's right.
- 15:18Brian Maas: Uh what starts in California tends to spread uh north and east.
- 15:24Brian Maas: So um it's highly likely other states will be look uh looking at similar proposals.
- 15:31Jim Fitzpatrick: Hence the reason we need law more lawmakers that are either former dealers or at least friendly and empathetic to the automotive industry, which is one of the drivers in any economy in any state.
- 15:44Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh we we need more more people to
- 15:47Brian Maas: Well, that's one of the things we do, especially with election season coming up next year, is try and communicate with legislators about the significance of our industry.
- 15:57Brian Maas: I mean, uh one out of every eight new cars sold in the United States, sold in California.
- 16:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Wow, one out of eight.
- 16:04Brian Maas: Um uh Orange County alone sells more cars than 25 states.
- 16:10Jim Fitzpatrick: Oh my gosh, that's incredible.
- 16:12Jim Fitzpatrick: What a market.
- 16:14Brian Maas: So yeah, it exactly.
- 16:16Brian Maas: It's a huge market.
- 16:17Brian Maas: Right.
- 16:17Brian Maas: The sales tax revenue is massive.
- 16:20Brian Maas: Yeah um I can't your viewers will appreciate uh the state and local government roughly get about 10% in sales tax on the sale of a new car.
- 16:34Brian Maas: Wow.
- 16:35Brian Maas: Every dealer would kill for a 10% margin on new cars.
- 16:42Jim Fitzpatrick: Oh my god, could you could you imagine?
- 16:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Wow.
- 16:45Jim Fitzpatrick: Um and and yet and yet dealerships are still being bought and sold in California.
- 16:50Jim Fitzpatrick: I've got friends of mine that and dealers, you you know many of them that they're either totally against doing business in California or they're totally for it, and they're like, I know, but with all of that that stuff to put up with, it's still an incredible place to do business, and you can make a lot of money in your stores.
- 17:07Brian Maas: Yeah, Lithia just announced this week they acquired three more stores in California, they've got over 50 in our state.
- 17:14Brian Maas: Right.
- 17:15Brian Maas: Uh, they're a publicly traded uh company.
- 17:18Brian Maas: Yeah, many private groups are expanding in California.
- 17:21Brian Maas: Yep, and it's a fantastic market to be an auto retailer.
- 17:28Brian Maas: Yeah, no question.
- 17:28Brian Maas: And notwithstanding the regulatory and compliance and legal challenges uh that happen here, uh the customer base, uh service opportunity.
- 17:43Jim Fitzpatrick: The economy is always strong, You know, y'all get out of it.
- 17:45Brian Maas: We're the we're the fifth largest economy in the world.
- 17:48Jim Fitzpatrick: Unbelievable.
- 17:49Brian Maas: The state of California.
- 17:50Brian Maas: So, you know, you can poo-poo it, and I don't want to live here, and you know, um, there's too much regulation.
- 17:56Jim Fitzpatrick: But uh it's just an incredible place, isn't it?
- 18:00Jim Fitzpatrick: And by the way, you know, if if in the event one dealer has got to put up with all of those different regulations and taxes and everything, so do all the dealers.
- 18:07Jim Fitzpatrick: It's not like you're, you know, if you're a dealer, you're the only one that's got to pay that.
- 18:11Jim Fitzpatrick: So it it levels the playing field if you're a dealer in California.
- 18:15Jim Fitzpatrick: They they all have got to do it, right?
- 18:16Brian Maas: It does.
- 18:17Brian Maas: And obviously, look, if you're a business person and you're saying, well, it'll be easier to operate in some other state than it is in California, perhaps, but you're not gonna have the potential customer base or throughput uh in your uh retail operations, service parts, etc., that you're gonna have at a California store.
- 18:40Brian Maas: I mean, I was in Southern California yesterday, and you drive by these uh dealerships, they're just massive with dozens of service bays and what have you serving their clientele.
- 18:53Brian Maas: That's right.
- 18:54Brian Maas: And uh when you've got 40 million residents, most of whom have to drive someplace to do anything, right?
- 19:02Brian Maas: That's an incredible market.
- 19:04Jim Fitzpatrick: It is no question about it.
- 19:05Jim Fitzpatrick: There they listen, if anybody is out there thinking about you know the California market or doing business in California, maybe you need to spend some time with Brian Maas.
- 19:13Jim Fitzpatrick: He can tell you the real deal out there because it's uh it's an incredible car market for sure.
- 19:19Jim Fitzpatrick: And thank God for people like Brian Maas that are fighting a good fight for California dealers out there and his team uh because you need you need him on your side for sure.
- 19:28Jim Fitzpatrick: And those California dealers, I know I know a number of them, are very grateful to have you and your team out there just because these things come up and you gotta have somebody at the table saying not so fast-
- 19:39Brian Maas: Thanks for the the kind words, Jim, and uh it's good timing because we're about to send out our membership uh uh dues.
- 19:47Brian Maas: So hopefully the dealers in California watching uhrenew their membership.
- 19:53Jim Fitzpatrick: If there is a California franchise dealer right now that is not a member of your association, uh I the the person needs to have their their brain checked because with all that's going on out there, they absolutely need to be engaged.
- 20:05Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh we've talked about that before.
- 20:07Jim Fitzpatrick: You know, it's one thing to write a check, it's another to be truly engaged in what's happening out there.
- 20:12Jim Fitzpatrick: And the dealer community in California, obviously, how many dealers are there in California? New car dealers?
- 20:18Brian Maas: Okay, we have about 1400 rooftops.
- 20:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Right.
- 20:22Jim Fitzpatrick: That's a huge political muscle right there that can certainly influence lawmakers, right?
- 20:30Brian Maas: Yeah, the more the you know, the more they're engaged, yep.
- 20:33Brian Maas: Um the more power we can reflect at the statehouse.
- 20:38Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 20:38Brian Maas: And uh, you know, the average dealer in California employs about 95 folks.
- 20:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Wow.
- 20:45Jim Fitzpatrick: Wow, that's fantastic.
- 20:46Brian Maas: Yeah.
- 20:47Brian Maas: So, you know, we we employ almost 140,000 people statewide.
- 20:51Brian Maas: Incredible.
- 20:52Brian Maas: Um that's a huge impact.
- 20:55Brian Maas: And uh, you know, we already talked about the sales tax.
- 20:58Brian Maas: It's massive.
- 20:59Jim Fitzpatrick: No question.
- 20:59Jim Fitzpatrick: No question.
- 21:00Jim Fitzpatrick: Uh in fact, I uh you know I had an idea that if in the event that uh every Honda dealer or every Volkswagen dealer and Audi dealer and Porsche dealer just said, listen, we're not gonna order another car until we get approved, you know, the or or we do away with this notion that you're gonna sell directly to consumers and compete with us, you can that would probably never happen.
- 21:20Jim Fitzpatrick: But you could imagine if they if the dealers just turned off the orders across the board all of a sudden, you know, those two companies would come to the table real quick, right?
- 21:31Brian Maas: Yeah, we're not in a position to be urging boycotts, that's for sure.
- 21:35Brian Maas: Um the impact of California's market is massive.
- 21:42Brian Maas: Yeah.
- 21:42Brian Maas: And especially for the two brands we've been talking about, yeah.
- 21:47Brian Maas: Um Honda and uh VW, it's a it's a place they need to be.
- 21:52Brian Maas: Oh, there's a quick thing.
- 21:54Jim Fitzpatrick: I think the largest comply with the law.
- 21:58Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 21:59Jim Fitzpatrick: I think the largest Honda dealer in the country is in California and has been for many years, right?
- 22:04Brian Maas: I mean they keep uh Yeah, that that is that's true.
- 22:08Brian Maas: Yeah, uh I bel I believe it's Norm Reeves from the Cerritos Auto Mall.
- 22:11Brian Maas: Yep.
- 22:12Brian Maas: Um, they've been number one for a long time.
- 22:14Brian Maas: Yeah, but we've got several cities.
- 22:16Brian Maas: Oh, I know you can um Honda dealers up and down the state.
- 22:20Brian Maas: So um yeah, it's it's it's a tough place to do business, but as I like to tell folks, if you can figure out how to do business in California, you can figure out how to do business anywhere.
- 22:33Jim Fitzpatrick: That's true.
- 22:34Jim Fitzpatrick: That's exactly right.
- 22:34Jim Fitzpatrick: That's right.
- 22:35Jim Fitzpatrick: If you can make it here, you can make it anywhere.
- 22:37Jim Fitzpatrick: Brian Maas, the president of the California New Car Dealers Association.
- 22:40Jim Fitzpatrick: Thank you so much for all the time you've given us.
- 22:43Jim Fitzpatrick: And any way that we can help you here uh at CBT News, let us know.
- 22:47Jim Fitzpatrick: But uh keep keep doing what you're doing.
- 22:49Jim Fitzpatrick: I know the dealers out there very much appreciate it.
- 22:52Brian Maas: Well, thank you, Jim.
- 22:53Brian Maas: Really appreciate the opportunity.
- 22:54Brian Maas: Thanks.