Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 219. Six Motivations, One Workplace: Who Are You at Work?
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: When it comes to work, and our relationships to work,
- 0:06and with our work, we often fail to focus on our personal motivations.
- 0:11My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:14Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:16Welcome to Think Fast, talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:21Today I'm very excited to speak with James Root.
- 0:24James is a senior partner at Bain & Company and Chair of Bain Futures.
- 0:28James is a fellow at Hughes Hall College, Cambridge, and an
- 0:31adjunct professor at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology.
- 0:35His latest book is The Archetype Effect.
- 0:38Welcome, James.
- 0:39I am really excited for our conversation.
- 0:42James Root: Delighted to be here.
- 0:43Thank you, Matt.
- 0:44Matt Abrahams: Thank you.
- 0:44Shall we get started?
- 0:45James Root: Yeah, let's do it.
- 0:46Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:48Among the many things that you study, you spend a lot of time
- 0:50thinking about the future of work.
- 0:52What insights can you share about what work looks like in the future?
- 0:57James Root: Yes.
- 0:57That's the question on everybody's minds.
- 0:59I think work is going to continue to be messy for a while.
- 1:02It is already.
- 1:03Gig work, remote work, self-managing teams, cross-functional teams, an
- 1:09aging workforce, skill gaps, and then this ever expanding universe of AI.
- 1:14It's stressful for many workers, I think, including with people who
- 1:17manage talent, it's hard for them.
- 1:19And part of the problem is that we spend so much effort thinking about
- 1:22skills and tasks and jobs, but almost no time thinking about motivations.
- 1:27And as soon as we stop to understand motivations, what pops up is
- 1:31unfortunately how poorly suited our talent systems really are to both
- 1:36recognize and then adapt to what turns out to be a very rich diversity
- 1:40of motivations people have at work.
- 1:42Those assumptions go back fifty years, longer even, and they're built
- 1:46for some kind of average worker.
- 1:48They sort of assume everybody is moving through the system, trying to be better
- 1:53as a worker or better as a manager.
- 1:55Trying to rise up through the organization, more spans, more
- 1:58layers, closer to the leadership team.
- 2:00Personal motivations don't matter at all.
- 2:03Every aspect of the standard organization model that we've grown
- 2:06up with is built around this idea.
- 2:08Rewards, reporting structures, decision rights, performance reviews.
- 2:12The reality today, I think is very different, both from an
- 2:15organization point of view and from an individual's point of view.
- 2:18There are plenty of roles now where personal progress and success and
- 2:21results are not defined by taking in just another step up the ladder.
- 2:25That's all from the point of view of the organization.
- 2:28From the individual's point of view, we've done this wonderful thing,
- 2:30we've said, let's empower people.
- 2:32Ask them to tell us who they really are at work and what they really want.
- 2:36And guess what?
- 2:37When we did that, it turns out it was a myth all along that everybody
- 2:40wants to just climb up the next step on the greasy corporate pole.
- 2:44Some still like the idea of the corporate ladder.
- 2:46Great.
- 2:47Others do not.
- 2:48What people want from work is highly varied.
- 2:50There is no such thing as an average worker anymore, and so that would
- 2:53be okay if these talent systems have kept up, but they haven't.
- 2:57I'm afraid that their light years behind, it's been routine for decades.
- 3:02Our sales teams, marketing teams, customer teams, product teams just become more
- 3:06and more specialized and develop more and more individualized solutions and products
- 3:11and offerings based upon segmentation.
- 3:14And that kind of de-averaging of what customers like has obviously gone crazy in
- 3:18the last twenty years now that we live in a world of social and search and location
- 3:22tracking and online payments and so forth.
- 3:24So, you know, Google and Instagram and XiaoHongShu and Byte Dance and Nava and
- 3:28Kakao and LINE, et cetera, they know an incredible amount of about us, of course.
- 3:32But the mystery is why haven't we applied that same thinking to our workers?
- 3:37Why do the firms who are selling us products or increasingly selling
- 3:41our profile to advertisers know so much more about our motivations
- 3:45than the firms we actually work for?
- 3:46Matt Abrahams: The point you just made there about why are we not looking
- 3:49at the motivations of employees, I think is a really profound point.
- 3:54Clearly work is changing and one of those changes, as you alluded
- 3:59to, is that workers, in terms of their age and generations,
- 4:04are increasing in the workplace.
- 4:06It's possible now to have four different generations all working together.
- 4:11What are your thoughts on how leaders can facilitate productive work and
- 4:15communication when you have people born from different generations
- 4:20having to interact with each other?
- 4:22James Root: We did some work.
- 4:23It said, I think about a hundred and fifty million jobs are going to move
- 4:27to people who are over fifty-five years old by the end of this decade.
- 4:30So it's an extraordinary number and you know, we all know why, populations
- 4:33are aging, more lives are lengthening, fewer people entering the workforce,
- 4:36fertility and people spending longer in education and so forth.
- 4:39So no choice.
- 4:41Organizations have no choice.
- 4:42They're gonna have to deal with this.
- 4:44You know, one piece of good news, I remember there was a very persuasive
- 4:46piece of OECD research from 2020 I think it was, that said, these
- 4:50multi-gen workforces are more productive and have better retention rates.
- 4:55So I think we need to update that.
- 4:56Somebody needs to do some more work on that, but that was at
- 4:58least encouraging back then.
- 5:00So I think it's very important.
- 5:02I'm glad you raised this topic because I also think there's a lot of confusion
- 5:06about older workers and about Gen Z.
- 5:10I wanna tackle both of them briefly and start with the older workers.
- 5:13On the one hand, what do we know about older workers?
- 5:16What we know is that what they want as they age can change.
- 5:19It's not the same as other age groups.
- 5:21Around fifty-five-ish the importance of good compensation, which from
- 5:25most cohorts, genders, countries, is the number one job criterion starts,
- 5:29to fade, other things rise up.
- 5:31Interesting work becomes very important, autonomy becomes important, and by
- 5:35the time you get to sixty, actually interesting work has become the number one
- 5:38most important thing for these workers.
- 5:40So the desire for autonomy shows up as a way of controlling hours.
- 5:45People want to do stair steps down from full employment to full retirement,
- 5:50but again, most firms just are not offering that kind of solution.
- 5:54There's also confusion about Gen Z.
- 5:55I get this question all the time.
- 5:58What are we gonna do about Gen Z?
- 5:59It's so difficult.
- 6:00It's so different from everybody else.
- 6:02It's so hard.
- 6:04And I think that framing is very misleading.
- 6:07Gen Z are not all one thing.
- 6:09Yes, there are some overlays, no doubt, as there are for Millennials
- 6:12as there are for Gen X. There are some Gen Z who wanna change the world.
- 6:17Some Gen Z who wanna just have some stretching milestones
- 6:20set and then achieve them.
- 6:21Some Gen Z who want to just have lots of variety, change jobs all the time.
- 6:25Some Gen Z, who the job is just a job.
- 6:28It's a means to an end of something that happens outside work.
- 6:31So it would be a terrible mistake to assume that we have to be tempted
- 6:34to, to say that Gen Z are all alike.
- 6:36So the path to come to your multi-gen question, the path or high functioning,
- 6:40multi-generational workforce is, it's challenging, but it's to create jobs that
- 6:45are adapted for the different age groups.
- 6:47Uh, some physical changes, differences and capabilities and so forth, but
- 6:51that don't just assume that each of those age groups wants exactly
- 6:55the same thing because they don't.
- 6:56Neither the older workers all want the same thing, nor the Millennials
- 6:59all want the same thing, nor the Gen Z all want the same thing.
- 7:02So success for me is design roles suited for workers at each life stage that still
- 7:09recognize the intrinsic motivations of each individual, rather than just assumed
- 7:13and more packaged into one cohort.
- 7:15Matt Abrahams: I'm sensing a theme among your responses, which is a really
- 7:19understanding and appreciating motivation of workers in general, but then looking
- 7:24generationally and understanding how that actually helps us to think about the
- 7:30programs we need to design and the ways we need to assess success in those roles.
- 7:38So I like thinking about motivation in communication is critical.
- 7:41What motivates the audience, what motivates your
- 7:43workers, what motivates you?
- 7:45And I really appreciate how you are highlighting the value that
- 7:48has for some of the challenges that we are facing in the workplace.
- 7:53I wanna switch now to the book you wrote.
- 7:55I first came across the idea of archetypes when I studied Carl Jung back in college.
- 8:01Your new book is called The Archetype Effect.
- 8:04Can you tell us what you mean by archetype and what are the six
- 8:08types that you have identified?
- 8:11James Root: I felt strongly that we needed something that recognized the
- 8:14importance of motivations because they often get lost in the shuffle when
- 8:18we're talking about tasks and jobs and skills, all of which are critical.
- 8:22Tasks, and jobs and skills are critical, but motivations, in
- 8:24my view, are also critical.
- 8:26We needed something simple, some language that we could use with our
- 8:30firms to talk about current jobs, future choices and career paths.
- 8:35So it had to be data driven.
- 8:36We went out, we talked to almost fifty thousand people in the
- 8:38world, nineteen countries.
- 8:40Men, women, high income, low income, highly educated, not very educated,
- 8:43urban, rural, all types of jobs.
- 8:45It was an absolute privilege to listen to them.
- 8:48Tell us about what motivates them.
- 8:50And we had all this data and at one point it was quite concerning that it
- 8:54would be hard to find patterns because people are very personal about this.
- 8:58Individual in their own influences.
- 8:59But yeah, the patterns appeared and resolved themselves into six archetypes.
- 9:03So let me quickly bang through the six and hopefully people listening can go
- 9:08and take the little quiz that's on the website and find out what they are.
- 9:11The first we call the giver, and this is, in simple terms, it's
- 9:15the person who finds motivation at work by helping others thrive.
- 9:18So work is service for them.
- 9:19They're not particularly motivated by money.
- 9:21Very empathetic typically.
- 9:23So strong team spirit, very much care about relationships at work, but their
- 9:28mojo is, I wanna help other people shine.
- 9:30The operator.
- 9:31By the way, this is the biggest cohort.
- 9:33It's twenty-four percent of the world's work population.
- 9:36The operators are not looking for meaning, self-worth, or purpose at work.
- 9:41Work as a means to an end.
- 9:42They're not particularly motivated by status.
- 9:45They don't wanna stand out at work in particular, not risk takers at all.
- 9:48They wanna do a good job, but they like stability and predictability, and
- 9:52at the same time, very team oriented.
- 9:54So often the backbone of your teams.
- 9:56Artisans, which are about seventeen percent of the working population.
- 10:00They wanna do work that fascinates them and inspires them, and
- 10:03they wanna keep practicing.
- 10:05I always think about sushi chefs when I think about artisans,
- 10:07I can't get it outta my head.
- 10:08So this idea that I'm gonna go and just keep trying to get better every day.
- 10:12Very high quality standards, pursuing mastery basically.
- 10:16And they enjoy their expertise being of value, but they don't want to, don't
- 10:20send me any forms from HR to fill in because I just don't wanna do that stuff.
- 10:24We're not particularly focused on the camaraderie aspects of work
- 10:28that's important to some of these other archetypes, so leave me
- 10:31alone to get on with what I do best and I'll be very valuable to you.
- 10:35Explorers, they just value freedom to do new things all the time, and
- 10:40they will make incredible trade offs.
- 10:41They'll trade off money, they'll trade off status and titles for the chance
- 10:45to continue to try new things in life.
- 10:47And a very pragmatic approach to their own development, they only
- 10:50skill up as far as they think they're gonna need in the current job.
- 10:53And work is not a provider of a sense of identity for them.
- 10:56The last two, the strivers want to make something of themselves at work.
- 10:59They want to be motivated by success.
- 11:02They value status.
- 11:03They value the milestones and the recognitions.
- 11:06Sometimes the compensation that goes with those recognitions, not
- 11:10risk takers, they forward plan.
- 11:12They get a lot done, and they're often willing to tolerate less
- 11:15variety, so long as it's in the service of their longer term goals.
- 11:18And then the last and smallest cohort, we call them the pioneers, only ten
- 11:23percent of the workforce, they're on a mission to change the world in some way.
- 11:27They form these very strong views about how things should be and try to sort of
- 11:30bend the will of the organization and the people around 'em against that vision.
- 11:35Sort of a move fast, break things idea, perhaps, is the way I would simplify that.
- 11:38But these archetypes, unlike some of the other systems, they're
- 11:42not a test, they're an assistant.
- 11:44The idea is kind of a shorthand guide to help you understand more about who you
- 11:49are at work, why you hate your job, why you love your job, why you thrive, why you
- 11:53don't thrive, and to get a deeper insight into, you know, sources of fulfillment.
- 11:57And they also can turn a traditional kind of career dialogue, which is top
- 12:02down, the firm tells you, these are the skills we think you should develop
- 12:06next, into a two-way discussion, which says, this is, I've got these skills
- 12:10and, but I'm motivated about this.
- 12:12I'd like to change, I'd like to do this, I'd like to try that.
- 12:14It can change the dialogue between employer and employee in ways
- 12:18that I hope are very healthy.
- 12:20Matt Abrahams: I really appreciate you articulating the six archetypes
- 12:24as you've identified them.
- 12:25I see utility here in many ways.
- 12:28From an organization's point of view, as you said, it can help you
- 12:32build career plans for people and help have a conversation that is
- 12:37enriching rather than dogmatic.
- 12:39It also causes an organization and leaders in that organization to think about
- 12:44what kind of blend and mix do I want.
- 12:46I don't want just all of one category.
- 12:48So diversity of approaches certainly matters.
- 12:51And then from an individual's point of view, it's very powerful to think
- 12:55about and reflect on what motivates me and what brings me fulfillment.
- 12:59And having categories can help put us on a path to see what it
- 13:05is that's really important to us.
- 13:07And I assume it can help us understand how and why we might gravitate
- 13:13towards certain people versus others.
- 13:16When I reflect on the definitions you gave in certain phases of my life, I feel like
- 13:21I was one archetype and as I have matured and experienced things, I've changed.
- 13:26Is this something we can exert agency over?
- 13:28Is this like a personality trait?
- 13:30What, what have you found in terms of our sense of agency in all of this?
- 13:34James Root: Yes.
- 13:34Such a good question.
- 13:36So I have found some people just are who they are at work their
- 13:41entire career, and that's fine.
- 13:43Good for them.
- 13:44Bravo.
- 13:44The motivation does not change even deep into their late
- 13:47fifties into their sixties.
- 13:49Others, and I would probably say more, have an evolution.
- 13:53And the typical journey, I'm not saying it's happened to you or to me, but the
- 13:58typical journey that the data reveals is that pioneers and strivers, when young,
- 14:03become artisans and givers as they age.
- 14:06And if you go back and think about the definitions that
- 14:08I gave, I won't redo them.
- 14:09It's intuitive.
- 14:11Artisans, perhaps I wanna be left alone a little bit more to do
- 14:14things I'm very interested in.
- 14:15And givers, I want to give back.
- 14:17I wanna mentor, I want to coach, I want to be able to pay it back
- 14:19as I get deeper into my career.
- 14:22But I wanna answer your question head on because while those two things are
- 14:25happening, I don't think we should actively try to change our archetype.
- 14:30I think it can happen to us because of circumstance or conditions or
- 14:33current roles, or just our own personalities and characters evolving.
- 14:37But I think become aware of what you are now and become aware of what the
- 14:41critical talent around you is, and when that happens, usually two things emerge.
- 14:46The two questions that emerge are, why do I feel what I
- 14:49feel about aspects of my work?
- 14:51And why do I feel, to your point, why do I feel what I feel about
- 14:54certain other people at work?
- 14:55And what I have come to believe just from thinking about this a lot and talking
- 15:00to many firms is that most firms have unconsciously built their talent systems
- 15:08around one archetype, and it may reach back to the founders, it may reach back to
- 15:12some seminal moment in the firm's history.
- 15:14Or it may just be that those sort of norm assumptions that I referenced
- 15:19at the beginning of our conversation, that everyone's just trying to
- 15:22plot up the ladder, in other words, everyone's a striver, are what embody
- 15:27the talent systems that we've built.
- 15:29And think about your own organization, which is the archetype that
- 15:32talent management is favoring.
- 15:34Who's getting promoted?
- 15:35Who are the people that we're putting in front of the organization to say, be
- 15:38like her, be like him, subconsciously.
- 15:41And then go, okay, now what about all the people who are not that archetype?
- 15:45How does it feel for them?
- 15:47I find this, when I get into this conversation at various
- 15:50firms, it's a little bit of a jaw dropping moment for people 'cause
- 15:54they haven't considered that.
- 15:56They've done the very best they can to design the system and fairness
- 15:59and equality and all the rest of it.
- 16:01But they haven't thought about the fact that person just doesn't care about the
- 16:03things that we're rewarding that much.
- 16:05That giver wants to be recognized and rewarded for being a culture carrier
- 16:09and helping other people thrive.
- 16:11Not being in the limelight themselves, but we don't recognize that person doing that.
- 16:15So I think, don't try to change, but change can happen
- 16:19and welcome it if it arrives.
- 16:21Matt Abrahams: I am struck by this notion of there are pathways
- 16:27that archetypes tend to follow over time, and that's interesting.
- 16:31As you advocated, we might not want to actively try to change ours, just see
- 16:36how things unfold and what feels right.
- 16:38But it's interesting to me that there are different paths that tend to
- 16:42occur, and it seems to me that as we are looking for mentorship and growth
- 16:48in our careers, that if we are to understand that, hey, somebody who
- 16:51starts out as a striver, perhaps earlier in their career, knowing that I might
- 16:56land somewhere else, in a different archetype, searching it out, mentors,
- 17:04tools, advice and guidance, that can lead me there might be very beneficial.
- 17:09So I think that not only does this help us as an individual, but it might be
- 17:12interesting for organizations to think about leveraging what you've learned
- 17:16about archetypes in terms of how they help people go through their careers.
- 17:21James Root: I couldn't agree more with what you just said.
- 17:24Matt Abrahams: Before we end, I'd like to ask you three questions.
- 17:27One I create just for you, and the other two are similar to everyone
- 17:31I've interviewed across the show.
- 17:32Are you up for this?
- 17:33James Root: Definitely.
- 17:34Matt Abrahams: One of the things I found really interesting about your
- 17:36background is that you've lived and worked in numerous countries.
- 17:39What advice do you have for people working in cultures other than their own that will
- 17:43help them be more effective in their work?
- 17:46James Root: A few things.
- 17:47Find a mentor or a coach as soon as you can after you
- 17:49land, or actually even before.
- 17:51And spend a lot of time with them.
- 17:52Read everything you can about the culture you're coming to.
- 17:54For at least the first year in the new country do not say, when we
- 17:59did this in my old country, it was like this, because nobody cares.
- 18:02It's humbling working in other cultures.
- 18:04So it shows you there are dozens of ways to lead teams and run
- 18:08meetings and define success.
- 18:10So just be quiet and listen for a while.
- 18:12You gotta adapt how you ask for input as well, because
- 18:15there are some flat cultures.
- 18:17The power distance is a certain number and open dialogue works, but
- 18:21there are others where it does not work in hierarchical structures, so
- 18:25don't compute silence with agreement.
- 18:27Matt Abrahams: This notion of looking outside yourself for some helping guidance
- 18:31makes a lot of sense, being observant, appreciating that it is different and it's
- 18:36going to be different, and that's okay.
- 18:38Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 18:43James Root: Christopher Hitchens.
- 18:44He was a British American author, journalist, wrote books about culture
- 18:48and politics and religion and literature.
- 18:50Died horribly young, more than a decade ago.
- 18:52If you want a sample type in Christopher Hitchens, University of Toronto,
- 18:56free speech 2006 into YouTube.
- 18:58He had this ability in written work, particularly in spoken, just to kinda
- 19:02marshal quotations and arguments with facts and searing intellectual honesty
- 19:08into this warm blanket of perfect English.
- 19:11Matt Abrahams: I will absolutely look into that and appreciate anybody who can be
- 19:15that eloquent and also that informative.
- 19:18Final question for you.
- 19:19What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 19:25James Root: Audience analysis.
- 19:26Got to do that first.
- 19:27Who are you talking to?
- 19:28What do they already know?
- 19:29Et cetera, et cetera.
- 19:31Second is, you must have something interesting to say.
- 19:34Say it precisely, say it briefly with one or two arrestingly, memorable words
- 19:39or phrases that you'd like the audience to remember when they get home at night.
- 19:44Third, I think be entertaining.
- 19:45Don't tell jokes, but relatable stories, analogies, metaphors, things that go just
- 19:50beyond sharing the facts and the opinions.
- 19:53That feels important.
- 19:54Oh, I got, sorry.
- 19:54I'm gonna grab one more.
- 19:55I know you said three.
- 19:56If you have to use slides.
- 19:59Make them very few, mostly pictures.
- 20:02Matt Abrahams: Amen to that last point.
- 20:03I usually penalize people for adding a fourth, but that is so
- 20:07important that I'm gonna not only echo it, I'm gonna reward it.
- 20:11So know your audience, make sure you're providing value that's memorable, and
- 20:16then also engage your audience to help.
- 20:19Well, James, you have been very engaging yourself.
- 20:22You've given us an insight into ourselves and into how potential organizations can
- 20:27help us all be more successful at work.
- 20:29And you've helped us better understand what the future of work might look like.
- 20:34Thank you for your time and thank you for your insights.
- 20:37James Root: Thank you so much, Matt.
- 20:38Very much enjoyed the conversation with you.
- 20:42Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 20:44Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:47To learn more about intergenerational work, please listen to episode
- 20:51167 with Bob McCann and to better understand motivation, check out
- 20:55episode 104 with Katy Milkman.
- 20:58This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 21:04Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 21:05With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 21:09Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 21:12Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 21:15Also follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 21:18And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 21:22learning content and our newsletter.
- 21:25Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 21:29Ask Matt Anythings, and much more at fastersmarter.io/premium.