Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Lithium Recovery from Oilfield Wastewater
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back. Today we're diving deep into
- 0:11something absolutely critical for the clean energy transition
- 0:15lithium. It's a essential right for EV
- 0:17batteries, grid storage, everything.
- 0:20But the supply chain, well, it's draining and it demands a whole
- 0:23new way of thinking about where we get it.
- 0:25Demanding is definitely the word.
- 0:27Our sources show we're looking at serious lithium supply
- 0:30deficits, maybe, maybe as soon as 2030.
- 0:32And the real kicker, The way we get most lithium now for this
- 0:36green tech carries a pretty heavy environmental cost.
- 0:40Exactly. You know, traditional methods,
- 0:41Hard Rock mining, huge energy use, huge water use.
- 0:45But even the famous sour brines, those giant salt flats in South
- 0:48America? They look incredible, sure, but
- 0:50they guzzle something like 500 tons of water for every single
- 0:52ton of lithium. And that level of water use, it
- 0:55completely changes the local hydrology often in places that
- 0:59are already incredibly dry. So the point is to really secure
- 1:03the US supply chain, cut down reliance on just a few spots
- 1:06globally and, you know, meet this demand more sustainably, we
- 1:11have to look beyond those virgin resources.
- 1:13We need secondary sources, things that maybe repurpose
- 1:16infrastructure we already have. And that brings us right to the
- 1:18heart of today's deep dive. We're exploring a really
- 1:21breakthrough idea, something that flips the whole concept of
- 1:24waste on its head. We're talking about pulling
- 1:27battery grade lithium out of wastewater, specifically that
- 1:30produced water from oil and gas operations.
- 1:33Yeah, it's this fascinating intersection, isn't it?
- 1:352 very different energy sectors kind of colliding.
- 1:38We've got two key sources guiding us today.
- 1:41First, some big commercial news. A company that's actually
- 1:44hitting commercialization like right now.
- 1:46And 2nd, a really detailed academic paper that digs into
- 1:50the science which U.S. oil and gas regions are actually the
- 1:53best bet long term based on the geology and the chemistry.
- 1:56So our mission is to connect that immediate commercial race
- 2:00with the, let's say, the complex science that dictates where the
- 2:03real long term potential lies. Let's kick off with the
- 2:06commercial story. Then the first mover, the race
- 2:09to get the stuff deployed. This is centered around a
- 2:11company called Element 3 based in Fort Worth.
- 2:13They're all in on this specific process.
- 2:15And the big news, just last month, September 2025, they
- 2:18closed their Series A funding pretty significant round led by
- 2:22Tijo VC with EIC, Rose Rock and Cubic Capital as Co leads.
- 2:27Yeah. And this isn't just, you know,
- 2:28speculative VC money. This is deployment capital.
- 2:31This funding means Element 3 can get their first extraction
- 2:33plants built and running on double Eagles water
- 2:35infrastructure in the Permian Basin literally by the end of
- 2:38this year. They are moving fast.
- 2:40And that speed, that's the headline here.
- 2:42It makes Element Three the first new lithium player to actually
- 2:46reach commercial scale in the US using this kind of resource.
- 2:51Think about that timeline difference.
- 2:52You've got other US projects, Hard Rock mines, conventional
- 2:55brines. They're still tangled up in
- 2:57permits, planning years, maybe decades out.
- 3:00Element 3, they're talking about shipping commercial product
- 3:03within months. Right.
- 3:05Their CEO Hoodwitzen talked about this exact point.
- 3:08He said they're building American lithium independence by
- 3:11being faster, cleaner, and more capital efficient.
- 3:14Why? Because they're essentially
- 3:16piggybacking on existing, already permitted oil field
- 3:20infrastructure, they're turning a liability into an asset, not
- 3:24digging a new hole. And the sheer scale of that
- 3:26liability this this feedstock, it's mind boggling.
- 3:29We're talking about produced water from oil and gas.
- 3:31Yeah, it's generated constantly, every single day, the.
- 3:33Numbers are huge. the US oil and gas sector generates over a
- 3:36trillion gallons of this wastewater annually.
- 3:38A. Trillion gallons.
- 3:39It's just a colossal amount of water that currently costs a lot
- 3:42to get rid of, mostly through deep well injection.
- 3:45Which, as you know, isn't without its own problems.
- 3:48That injection process can be costly, and it's been linked to
- 3:51induced seismicity, the small earthquakes.
- 3:54In some areas you're pushing huge volumes of fluid
- 3:57underground under pressure. Exactly.
- 3:58So Element 3 is looking at this massive operational cost, this
- 4:02environmental headache and saying, hey, there's value here.
- 4:06And estimates suggest that within that trillion gallons of
- 4:09wastewater, there could be around 250,000 tons of lithium
- 4:13carbonate potentially recoverable.
- 4:15Wow. 250,000 tons. Put that in context.
- 4:20How does that compare to the need?
- 4:22Well, projections show the US facing a significant lithium
- 4:25supply deficit by 20-30. That 250,000 tons, that's more
- 4:28than half of that projected deficit.
- 4:30So they're taking this unconventional resource, this
- 4:32waste stream, and potentially turning it into a major domestic
- 4:35supply source without the years and billions needed for
- 4:38traditional minds. And Element 3 isn't thinking
- 4:40small. Their stated goal is to be a top
- 4:43three domestic lithium producer within just three years.
- 4:46It reflects the scale of the opportunity they see.
- 4:49OK. That potential is huge,
- 4:50definitely. But let me push on that a bit.
- 4:52That 250,000 ton number that must assume you can get the
- 4:56lithium out efficiently from all that water, right?
- 4:59Element 3 is starting in the Permian, specifically the Wolf
- 5:02Camp formation. What are the sort of practical
- 5:05on the ground challenges they might hit that could, you know,
- 5:08bring that big number down to earth?
- 5:10That's a really important question, and it leads us
- 5:12straight into the science because you're absolutely right,
- 5:14Just having a massive volume of water doesn't automatically mean
- 5:17it's all good or easy or economic to process.
- 5:21Not all produced water is created equal.
- 5:24OK, so let's unpack that. If it's not just about volume,
- 5:27how do we figure out which wastewater sources are actually
- 5:30viable? What does the science say?
- 5:32Well, the academic research lays out three really key things we
- 5:35need to look at together. First, the specific water
- 5:37chemistry, what's actually in the water besides lithium.
- 5:40Second, the production rates, how much water are we getting?
- 5:44And 3rd, critically, geography. Where is this water located
- 5:48relative to where the lithium needs to end up?
- 5:50Right. And this gets us to what we
- 5:52could call the lithium paradox, maybe the sheer volume of water,
- 5:55which is what gives the Permian that huge potential number we
- 5:59mentioned, it doesn't necessarily line up with the
- 6:02quality or the concentration of the lithium in that water.
- 6:04Exactly. You see this right away
- 6:06comparing different formations. Take the Wolf camp in the
- 6:09Permian where Element 3 is starting.
- 6:11Yes, it produces enormous amounts of water.
- 6:13That's why the total resource estimate is so high.
- 6:16But the average lithium concentration, it's pretty low,
- 6:19around 14 parts per million or PPM, OK. 14 PPM help us picture
- 6:24that. How does that stack up against
- 6:26other major place? Think of it like trying to
- 6:29extract flavor. 14 PPM is like using a huge, huge amount of
- 6:32water to make very, very weak tea.
- 6:34Compare that to the back in formation up north, that's
- 6:37closer to 27 PPM, roughly double the concentration.
- 6:40But the real standout purely in terms of concentration is the
- 6:43Marcellus Shale, mostly in the northeast.
- 6:45That comes in at around 84 PPM on average.
- 6:47Wow. OK.
- 6:48So Wolf Camp where the commercial leader is right now
- 6:51has about 1/6 the lithium concentration of the Marcellus?
- 6:54Pretty much, yeah. And the operational reality of
- 6:56that is crucial for these lower grade Brian's like Wolf camp.
- 6:59You simply have to process much, much larger volumes of water to
- 7:03get the same amount of final lithium product.
- 7:05That means bigger facilities, more energy, more reagents, just
- 7:08to get the same output you could get from a smaller volume of
- 7:11that richer Marcellus brine. OK, so low concentration is 1
- 7:15hurdle, but that's only part of the chemistry story isn't it?
- 7:18If we dig deeper, the really big technical challenge isn't just
- 7:22how much lithium is there, but what else is in the water
- 7:25fighting to get out. Yes, this is where the
- 7:28processing difficulty can really spike.
- 7:31It's about the other dissolved stuff.
- 7:33Hi, total dissolved solids. TDs is common, but specifically
- 7:37it's the presence of other ions, particularly magnesium, amigun
- 7:41and calcium K. These secondary occasions when
- 7:44they're present in high concentrations, they seriously
- 7:46mess with the efficiency of the lithium separation technologies
- 7:50we're. Talking about things like
- 7:51specialized absorbents or membranes designed to grab the
- 7:54lithium ions. Exactly those.
- 7:56You can kind of picture these separation materials like very
- 8:00selective bouncers at a club, right?
- 8:03They're designed only to let lithium, the VIP through the
- 8:06door. But if you have tons and tons of
- 8:09magnesium and calcium hanging around these competing cations,
- 8:12they effectively crowd the entrance.
- 8:14They block the active sites on the absorbent or membrane that
- 8:18are met just for lithium. So they literally clog up the
- 8:20works, making it way less efficient to grab the lithium.
- 8:23They interfere, they reduce selectivity.
- 8:25It means your initial lithium capture isn't as pure.
- 8:28You then need more downstream processing steps, more
- 8:31chemicals, more energy to purify it to battery grade.
- 8:35And that academic paper specifically flags this as a
- 8:38major challenge for the formations Element 3 is
- 8:40targeting initially. The ratios of these competing
- 8:42metals to lithium are pretty bad in some cases, right?
- 8:45Yeah, they really are the Bakken and Wolf Camp waters.
- 8:48The paper highlights them as the least favorable for easy
- 8:51downstream separation. Why?
- 8:53Because the ratios are just so high.
- 8:55In those brines, you've got magnesium levels anywhere from
- 8:5840 to 100 times higher than the lithium and calcium it can be
- 9:02more than a 400 times higher than the lithium concentration.
- 9:06Imagine trying to pick out your one VIP guest when there are 400
- 9:09other people crowding the doorway.
- 9:10OK? That sounds like a purification
- 9:12nightmare. Potentially very expensive.
- 9:14So flipping that purely based on the chemistry, which brine's
- 9:17look cleaner, easier to process? From that chemistry angle, the
- 9:20clear winners are the Marcellus and also the smack over
- 9:24formations, which is mainly in Arkansas and Texas.
- 9:27They just have much lower ratios of those major competing metals,
- 9:30magnesium and calcium relative to lithium.
- 9:33They're inherently cleaner brines to start with, and that
- 9:35translates directly into potentially lower separation of
- 9:38purification costs. Less energy, fewer chemicals,
- 9:41maybe a simpler process overall. So the science seems to favor
- 9:45high grade and clean chemistry, pointing towards places like the
- 9:48Marcellus. But you know, good chemistry
- 9:51doesn't guarantee a successful business.
- 9:53If you can't get your final product to the customer
- 9:56economically, does that perfect chemistry even matter?
- 9:59Let's pivot to that third criterion, geographic location.
- 10:03Absolutely crucial, especially when you think about building a
- 10:07resilient long term domestic supply chain.
- 10:09You've got to connect the dots between where the lithium is
- 10:12extracted and purified and where it's actually used.
- 10:16And the biggest, fastest growing use for battery grade lithium in
- 10:19the US right now, it's battery manufacturing gigafactories.
- 10:23Right. And we're seeing huge
- 10:24investments pouring into that sector, creating what people are
- 10:27calling battery belt across parts of the Midwest and the
- 10:29South. That's where the demand is
- 10:30concentrating. So when you overlay the
- 10:32geography, the Marcellus shell looks pretty attractive.
- 10:36Again, it's geographically much closer to many of those key
- 10:40battery manufacturing hubs compared to say, the Bakken.
- 10:43Lower transportation cost for the final lithium chemical,
- 10:46simpler logistics. The Bakken, being way up north,
- 10:49just doesn't have that same proximity.
- 10:51That adds cost and complexity getting the product to market.
- 10:54OK, let's pull back for a second.
- 10:55We started this by talking about the environmental footprint of
- 10:58traditional lithium. So where does this wastewater
- 11:01extraction method fit in? Is it actually cleaner overall?
- 11:04Well, the potential upsides are really significant.
- 11:07First, you're taking something that's currently classified and
- 11:09managed as a hazardous waste that produced water.
- 11:12Remember the issues with reinjection causing micro
- 11:14seismicity processing? It avoids that specific problem.
- 11:19You turn a liability into a potential asset.
- 11:21Second, the process of removing the lithium and often some of
- 11:25those other problematic ions like calcium and magnesium,
- 11:28actually reduces the overall salinity of the water.
- 11:31This could open up pathways for beneficial reuse of the treated
- 11:34water, maybe for certain industrial purposes, or
- 11:37potentially even some types of irrigation, depending on how
- 11:40clean they can get it. That's a huge potential water
- 11:43win. And fundamentally, it means less
- 11:45need to dig new mines, disturb new land.
- 11:48Definitely less pressure on Virgin Resources, but there's an
- 11:52important however here linked back to what we discussed about
- 11:54concentration right the. Energy needed for processing.
- 11:57Exactly because these Ong brines are generally speaking much
- 12:01lower grade than traditional lithium sources like South
- 12:04American sellers or Hard Rock ores.
- 12:06Especially in high volume places like the Permian.
- 12:10Getting that lithium out and purified to the very high
- 12:12standards needed for batteries might actually require more
- 12:15energy input and potentially larger volumes of chemicals for
- 12:18the separation and purification stages compared to processing
- 12:21higher grade conventional resources.
- 12:24We really need thorough life cycle assessments, you know,
- 12:26comparing the entire footprint cradle to gate to fully
- 12:29understand the trade-offs. But the potential to use
- 12:31existing waste infrastructure is still a massive advantage.
- 12:34OK, so let's try and synthesize this for everyone listening.
- 12:37It's a complex picture, isn't it?
- 12:40On one hand, you have element 3 in the Permians Wolf camp,
- 12:43clearly leading the commercial charge right now.
- 12:46They're leveraging that huge water volume and existing oil
- 12:50field setup to move incredibly fast and start filling that
- 12:54domestic supply gap. Speed is their edge.
- 12:57But on the other hand, if you look purely at the scientific
- 13:00criteria, this lithium concentration, the water
- 13:03chemistry, the geography relative to battery plants, the
- 13:07Marcellus Shale emerges as having perhaps one of the most
- 13:10attractive long term potential, even if the infrastructure to
- 13:13handle that water might take longer to build out.
- 13:16It really highlights this tension between immediate
- 13:18commercial opportunity and the underlying geological and
- 13:22chemical realities. And that brings up a really
- 13:23fascinating point for the future.
- 13:25What happens as the technology evolves?
- 13:27Because this assessment, you know which locations are best.
- 13:30It's not set in stone if we see breakthroughs and separation
- 13:33tech, new adsorbents, new membranes that get much much
- 13:35better at selectively grabbing lithium even when calcium and
- 13:38magnesium are super high. If the bouncers suddenly get way
- 13:41better at filtering out those 400 gate crashers.
- 13:44Precisely that kind of technological leap could
- 13:46completely change the economics. It could potentially make those
- 13:50currently challenging high volume but low grade brines in
- 13:53places like the wolf camp or the back end suddenly much more
- 13:56viable, much more competitive, almost overnight and.
- 13:59That would fundamentally redraw the map for critical materials
- 14:02in the US, wouldn't it? Shifting away from relying only
- 14:06on concentrated, often environmentally taxing sources
- 14:10toward tapping into these massive distributed waste
- 14:13streams that we already manage. That's a pretty profound shift,
- 14:16turning something that costs billions to dispose of into a
- 14:20strategic national resource. That's the challenge,
- 14:23definitely, but it's also the huge opportunity that's
- 14:25unfolding right now. Really fascinating.
- 14:27We've gone from a funding announcement to brine chemistry
- 14:31to resource maps, all connected by this idea of turning
- 14:34wastewater into something valuable.
- 14:37Thanks so much for joining us on this deep dive at exploring
- 14:39these connections with us. Yeah, we hope this gives you a
- 14:41richer picture of the complexities involved in
- 14:44securing these critical materials.
- 14:46Please do follow the channel so you don't miss out on our future
- 14:49insights.