Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / Examining the Arguments of Climate Change with Marc Cortez
Transcript
- 0:23Coming live from San Luis Obispo, California.
- 0:53Industries. And he is one of the solar
- 0:55Industries early Architects and is working on the front lines of
- 0:59the climate change industry for the case.
- 1:01So, he's done expertise our Master for today.
- 1:04Welcome to the show, man. Thank you very much.
- 1:06Great to be here. Thank you Mark.
- 1:09Thank you. So mark, this whole debate now,
- 1:13about climate has many a times. Whenever there is a discussion,
- 1:18it tends to go towards. You know, one.
- 1:22Is right. One is wrong towards a bit.
- 1:24On the political side, which we will avoid and try to break
- 1:29those difficulties in that understanding of this simple
- 1:33thing which has become so complex through you.
- 1:36And that's why you are the master for today.
- 1:39And you offer a new climate narrative, which is down the
- 1:43middle aisle away from today's climate extremes.
- 1:47So, Mark sitting from, from where you are, how how do you
- 1:52see this? And let's not take as you
- 1:55already, take a middle position. Where do we see this climate
- 2:00thing in reality going? What is this climate debate, all
- 2:05about, what is this climate change?
- 2:08All about whether it is real, is it, is it more of panic?
- 2:14What exactly? It is purely from.
- 2:16A Layman's perspective was walking down the street with
- 2:19spacing all the problems for his life and he Still trying to
- 2:23figure out what this climate King is all about.
- 2:26Yeah boy that's a lot of questions right?
- 2:27It's a big problem and it's certainly these days we're all
- 2:31talking about it's on the front page of all the newspapers
- 2:35certainly with politicians it's it's a it's a big issue and so
- 2:39let me start just my own thoughts on this.
- 2:42I've never I believe that climate change is real.
- 2:44I think, of course, the climate is always changing, it's been
- 2:47changing ever before we we got around and we as You know, as
- 2:53humans and as mankind are certainly exerting some
- 2:56influence on it. So so I've never said otherwise
- 3:00I've never said, you know, I'm not a climate denier as this
- 3:03called, like a lot of people but I also have spent years now, I
- 3:10sold my first solar panel in 1999.
- 3:13So I spent I've spent decades in the renewable energy field and
- 3:18really being a consumer of climate science for It's now.
- 3:22And so I've noticed probably over the past eight or nine
- 3:26years, how politicized it's gotten but also, how apocalyptic
- 3:31it's gotten, it's gotten, right? So we're all the stories we read
- 3:36in the big newspapers or hey, we're all going to be dead by
- 3:38Thursday because of the climate. And of course, the reality is so
- 3:41much different. And so I've had some growing
- 3:45differences in opinions with both sides of the argument and
- 3:49starting to really look into it. Read the ipcc reports.
- 3:52It's and have really dug into it a lot just to really try to find
- 3:56what's the truth. What's the the truth of the
- 3:58climate? And it's some Muddy Waters, and
- 4:00that's why I called it. The journey into the muddy
- 4:02climate middle. It's, it's really difficult to
- 4:05find true information. That is not, that's not run by
- 4:10by some of the media outlets and and really I think the our
- 4:15politicians now have sort of co-opted the whole message and
- 4:19and really driven that home. So we're seeing that more than
- 4:21ever now. And my goal was as a professor
- 4:25at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. I started to see you know, young
- 4:28adults going into the workforce who have had a steady diet of 22
- 4:33years, 23 years of hey we're all going to be dead because of the
- 4:37climate and they're starting to think that they can have kids.
- 4:40And well as someone who is you know who helped build this
- 4:45industry, I kept thinking man, how did we fail so bad?
- 4:47That's that is just absolutely not true and you know, No
- 4:52messages of hopelessness. The children is a really bad
- 4:56thing just in general. So sending king of giving kids
- 5:00education kicking them off into the world.
- 5:02And then saying oh by the way you're going to be dead because
- 5:04of the climate is a really bad way to have them start their
- 5:08professional lives. So so I took it upon myself to
- 5:11start to dig into this communicate, more try to
- 5:14understand really what's going on and that's what started me
- 5:17off on this journey. Right.
- 5:20Mike, what do we tell the Generation Z?
- 5:26What do we tell them? So that they get the right
- 5:29understanding of things as they are because, suppose it for a
- 5:35person like me if I am using water, then I think, okay,
- 5:39climate change or I should conserve water and I don't know,
- 5:43then I say, I come to know, okay?
- 5:46There is a pipe broken somewhere and water is Flowing down the
- 5:49street. Nobody is bothered.
- 5:51It's like or there is so much of consumption of Water by certain
- 5:56section of people and they are not too much bothered about this
- 6:00or anywhere else in the world so much flooding is happening.
- 6:04So much things are and nobody talks of that sort of water to
- 6:07conservation or water harvesting and all that the way it should
- 6:11be. And sometimes you feel like as
- 6:13if you are walking on a wrong sort of story.
- 6:17So what exactly, so you You don't know what do you tell
- 6:21others if they ask you? What?
- 6:23Exactly it is because you are an expert.
- 6:26You all you have a water conservation startup called.
- 6:29Yeah. Lick it.
- 6:31Liquidate. So you would be knowing this,
- 6:33these things better about water conservation related to climate
- 6:38and, you know, whether one should plant trees, what should
- 6:40one do not know? So you tell us what we tell the
- 6:45Next Generation. Yeah.
- 6:47Well so no one ever talks about Raishin right.
- 6:50Conserving water conserving. Electricity in our climate
- 6:53problems, our contribution to the climate is a consumption
- 6:56problem. We're just using too much stuff,
- 7:00so using less stuff, always a good idea.
- 7:03So, here in California, we have a drought.
- 7:06I know, drought is, is endemic all over across the world in
- 7:09different places so trying to conserve water and being aware
- 7:13of it. Like you just said is, of
- 7:15course, completely responsible. You know, the best thing that
- 7:19that happened. I hate to say it like this, but
- 7:22the best thing that happened to The Climate, over the past 25
- 7:25years was covid because we in one year we cut our emissions in
- 7:30the u.s. Anyway by over 11 percent and
- 7:33the reason we did that was because we just use less stuff,
- 7:36we did bless things we stayed at home.
- 7:39So conservation works and I don't know why people don't talk
- 7:43about that. I don't know why any cop
- 7:44politician doesn't talk about it other than I think they're
- 7:47probably nervous about looking into a camera.
- 7:49Say all right. You know I'm going to be the
- 7:51first politician that tells you that you, maybe you should use
- 7:54less stuff right. But it's true, right.
- 7:56This is just a responsible thing.
- 7:57Go home turn off the lights. Use less water.
- 8:01Don't throw things away. Don't don't buy a TV.
- 8:03Every six months you know if things like that I just make
- 8:07make complete Common Sense. The other thing I try to tell
- 8:11people when they're concerned about the climate is you got to
- 8:15peel the onion a little bit. If you're if all you're doing is
- 8:18getting your information. I'm from from the media.
- 8:21If you're hitting the New York Times version of the climate,
- 8:24you're getting a very, very biased version of the climate.
- 8:27They have made a choice of which scenario to communicate to you.
- 8:31And they're very clear, they have an apocalyptic view of the
- 8:35climate and it fits certain people's agenda.
- 8:37So, my recommendation is, if you're going to read the media,
- 8:41read a broad broad brush media, you know, read media from both
- 8:46sides, make a point of it, you may not agree with it but at
- 8:49least Different views of it and if you can try to get into some
- 8:53of the signs because most people never ever ever read the
- 8:57science, right? We read The Washington Post
- 9:00version and at that point it's already been sanitized and
- 9:04you're reading points of view. So you're not reading real
- 9:07science and you're not reading the real, the real thing.
- 9:10So I always say, you know, try to dig into that a little bit
- 9:13more and then when you, I've trained myself now to start
- 9:16looking for qualifiers things, you know, secret word.
- 9:19Words, like could maybe might if you know, if something bad
- 9:24happens then hey this could result, you know, in the
- 9:28Himalayas mounting or melting, and things like that.
- 9:30Well, that just means that it's complete fiction, right?
- 9:33It just means that this is someone's making up a story and
- 9:37there's lots of information to support these stories.
- 9:39But the point is, these are not facts.
- 9:41These are just stories. There are narratives that are
- 9:44being out there and, of course, politicians, pick up on them
- 9:47because it's a great way to Help sway public opinion and it's a
- 9:51great way to get money for projects that they're interested
- 9:54in. And so we've been doing this for
- 9:56a really long time. So I would say try to dig deeper
- 10:00as you can, and read a bunch of different Outlets to try to get
- 10:04different perspectives on this. Because I think when you really
- 10:07understand it and when you really try to dig into this most
- 10:12one thing I always say about the climate and I always remind
- 10:15myself, this our entire climate effort is an Sighs and trying to
- 10:20predict the future that's that's just absolutely true.
- 10:24We're spending trillions of dollars to try to because we're
- 10:28we're trying to predict the future and I always I always
- 10:32point that out because we can't we've never been right about
- 10:35this stuff. There are certain things we know
- 10:37if we turn and we look backwards and we look at science and
- 10:41studies that have shown the way the world has changed great.
- 10:45That's great information, but then turning around and trying
- 10:47to project those futures, It's complete fiction, and it's just
- 10:52really important to remember that.
- 10:53So when you read in the New York Times, that, you know, that
- 10:56things are going to get really bad and that New York's going to
- 10:59flood and the Himalayas are going to mount and displace two
- 11:02billion people that's just pure fiction.
- 11:04And so it really is. And so I would just say, you
- 11:08know, to have people look at and read it this stuff and trained
- 11:11themselves a little bit, to really have a more Discerning
- 11:15Eye about this. Because if you really dig into
- 11:18it, you'll find that A lot of these narratives are just not
- 11:22not true. There are such, there's some
- 11:24signs that leads us in certain directions.
- 11:26The climate science tells us that we should be concerned and
- 11:30that we should pay attention to what's going on with our effect
- 11:32on the climate. But it certainly doesn't tell us
- 11:35that we're all going to be dead by next week.
- 11:36So so that's that's that's what I typically counsel people is to
- 11:42is to really dig into it and spend some time with it.
- 11:44Don't take the headlines version of it.
- 11:46Try to take into a little bit more than that.
- 11:49Right? So it's time from for climate
- 11:53maturity, which you put it as climate charity, if I mean,
- 11:57surely. Yes.
- 11:58Yes, if I'm and that's, that's the book that you have written.
- 12:02Yeah. I mean, the muddy climate model
- 12:05middle. Yeah.
- 12:06Yeah, so from it, from looking at that, I will come to the
- 12:10book. But even in terms of becoming
- 12:14climate mature to understand it into, how do you See where
- 12:19exactly is our position at the moment as Humanity in terms of
- 12:27climate as per your understanding, who have no axe
- 12:30to grind so that will that will level.
- 12:32Second thing is, when do we move into the position of, you know,
- 12:38when towards climate Panic. So where is that ground?
- 12:43Which is real, and which is the, which is the ground, which is,
- 12:47you know, we are then. Reading into some agenda,
- 12:51whatever it is. Whoever it is sick, ask you
- 12:56again, is that why are people creating these, this sort of a
- 13:02either Panic or, or or some people are saying nothing is
- 13:06going to happen, then the middle ground or the real ground is
- 13:10also lost. I'm asking again, couple of
- 13:12questions at the same time so that as an expert, you answer
- 13:16them at your own pace. Mark Sure.
- 13:19Well, let me start with the second one.
- 13:20What why do why have we created climate panic?
- 13:23Because it sells right. Lemme, let's just be honest.
- 13:26I think Al Gore infamously made his movie Inconvenient Truth and
- 13:31he in his interviews. He was very clear.
- 13:34He said, he said, I'm paraphrasing and I actually have
- 13:37the exact quote in the book but he said, hey it's fine to
- 13:41exaggerate things in order to get people's attention.
- 13:44And, and then he had some scientists that helped That
- 13:49helped him do that dr. Stephen Schneider from Stanford
- 13:52won a Nobel Prize alongside Al Gore as his scientific
- 13:56right-hand man. And he he was very clear about
- 14:00this. He said there's science and then
- 14:02there's my opinion of the science and I have no problem
- 14:05giving you my opinion, even if it's Strays from the science,
- 14:09and hopefully they're the same. But if not, that's okay.
- 14:12I believe certain things and I want to, I want you to
- 14:16understand that this is an important issue.
- 14:17So, So it started a long time ago, we've been getting a steady
- 14:21diet of What I Call Scientific advocacies which is there is
- 14:25some science. Yes of course and there's lots
- 14:27of signs that I'm not a clan climate scientist so I don't
- 14:30want to pretend that I am but the scientific Community has
- 14:34been very clear about their also advocating.
- 14:37They're also taking positions on things and there's a whole
- 14:42section of climate science that believes that this is, you know,
- 14:47it's their opinion that This is something really bad and they
- 14:50have no problem telling you. They, they said it very clearly
- 14:55that they have no problem exaggerating all this because
- 14:58they want to get your attention. So politicians trying to scare
- 15:01you is nothing new, it's always done and they do it because of
- 15:05what just happened in the us, where we had an election.
- 15:08But before that, we just signed all of these bills where there's
- 15:11massive spending bills because they have successfully scared
- 15:16enough, people to believe that we actually have to fund.
- 15:18All of these projects to help, you know, build solar energy,
- 15:23Wind Mill, electric vehicles, all these things, which I have
- 15:26nothing against all of these Technologies.
- 15:28But to break the bank, to try to solarize the world is not a very
- 15:32good plan. You know, I worked in solar
- 15:34group for decades the idea that we can solarize the world and
- 15:38somehow save the planet is is is a bit ridiculous.
- 15:42And and I'll use that word. It's just the I mean even the
- 15:46simple math just doesn't work. So So you know that's how I feel
- 15:51about it. I think that, you know, there's
- 15:52a reason that people get scared and it's a strategy.
- 15:56It's politicians wanting to scare us.
- 15:59They have Partners in the media that help them with that and
- 16:03then they have science Partners as well that help them craft
- 16:06this very carefully crafted narrative you know just as a
- 16:11little bit of an aside you know everyone talks about this one
- 16:13point, five degree 2 degree these tipping points.
- 16:19I'm in the middle of digging into this now but everyone
- 16:22assumes that that is this incredible science Baseline that
- 16:26there's all these studies that show that when in fact, the
- 16:29opposite is absolutely true. These are just numbers.
- 16:31Some guys came up with you, can they admit it?
- 16:35They say you know it's just a number I made up because it's
- 16:38about right and people can remember it and politicians can
- 16:42create good sound bites but it has become the Baseline for all
- 16:46of these things, you know? And And so, the scientific basis
- 16:50for these things are just not there in a lot of ways in a lot
- 16:54of ways. So so we've turned science into
- 16:57this sort of mounts attribution science where there's a whole
- 17:01field of study that does nothing.
- 17:02But try to blame events on the climate and there's a big long
- 17:08list of things, you know. Hey, this is probably because of
- 17:10the climate and nowadays, if you walk outside and it's two
- 17:14degrees hotter than it was last year at this time, then people
- 17:17go, oh my God, it's climate. Change.
- 17:19And the real answer is no, it's just a hot day, you know, things
- 17:24like that. So Right right?
- 17:27Whether whether scientists can go left or right or Center or
- 17:32whichever way it is, the fact is that if nobody speaks the truth
- 17:37nature certainly will and nature is speaking in its in its way
- 17:42different ways at different places across the planet.
- 17:46That that is one thing. One cannot ignore whether it's
- 17:48part of climate change or not. But one thing is there, there is
- 17:53a lot of things not, not, there are a lot of Things that nature
- 17:57is trying to tell us, ah, asking you about this particular issue.
- 18:03Who do you think is getting is being the most impacted from
- 18:08whatever change the maybe not work towards the Panic side but
- 18:12even from the real, real reality site, whatever.
- 18:15The way the nature is trying to say, which is that, which are
- 18:19the places were getting most impact?
- 18:21Is it the u.s.? Is it somewhere else?
- 18:23Because a lot of noise may be happening in the US.
- 18:26But other areas other parts of the planet are also get your
- 18:30bearing, the brunt of it. Yeah, I think I think it's an
- 18:34economic question. I think, you know, anything that
- 18:37happens and you know, as has always happened, the the poorest
- 18:42people in. You know, the poorest people
- 18:45always get hit the most by anything.
- 18:47So, if, if there's weather events, if there's economic
- 18:51events, the poor people always always get it the worst.
- 18:53And that's, you know, that's one of the things.
- 18:56The reasons that I have been on this journey to try to dig into
- 19:00the truth because, you know, here in the US we talk about
- 19:03climate change is hurting the poor, and we've allocated all
- 19:06this money, but I can tell you one thing, there's no Tesla's in
- 19:09poor neighborhoods, you know, poor neighborhoods, I come from
- 19:13Oakland and it's a pretty rough, rough town.
- 19:16And, you know, it's now being gentrified and it's starting to
- 19:20transform. But, you know, in the bad parts,
- 19:22the ports of Auckland, they don't need Tesla's, they need
- 19:26help. Care.
- 19:26They need mental health care. They need jobs, they need
- 19:29security. They need safety for their kids,
- 19:31they need schools. So, you know, so I really cringe
- 19:36a bit when, you know, I look at these Tesla's, their great
- 19:38Vehicles. They're wonderful to drive their
- 19:41fantastic technology, but there's twenty to thirty
- 19:44thousand dollars of public money attached to each car and you
- 19:48know, they're not going to the inner-city.
- 19:50They're not going to the poor people.
- 19:51So, you know, poor the poor people across the world, tend to
- 19:55get it. By these problems, the most, of
- 19:58course, and we have used. Unfortunately, we have used
- 20:04words, like, social justice of things like that to justify all
- 20:07of our spending programs, but they're not getting the benefits
- 20:09of it. You know, you know, Al a couple
- 20:12weeks ago or a couple months ago, John Kerry are, you know,
- 20:16Ambassador climate Ambassador. They had big photo ops of him
- 20:20standing in Africa, telling them that they're going to get, you
- 20:24know, a bunch of solar panels and a bunch of car.
- 20:26Even credits, when what they really want is the oil and gas,
- 20:30they want, they want the same technology that helped live lift
- 20:34civilizations, out of poverty. They don't want stuff.
- 20:36That's only working 56 hours a day so that kind of stuff, just
- 20:40drives me crazy. I think, you know, how out of
- 20:42touch are we especially as a developing Nation or a developed
- 20:46Nation, who is trying to be a leader in climate Let's be,
- 20:50let's be real here, developed Nation developing nations.
- 20:53They don't want just partial energy, they want cheap,
- 20:55abundant 24/7 365 energy. They want stuff that works all
- 21:00the time so they can help build societies, lift people out of
- 21:03poverty. So, if ever they were affected
- 21:06more by this, they need the resources to climb out of to
- 21:10climb out of poverty and build Builder Nations.
- 21:12So, Right. Right.
- 21:16So you you said that you are trying to find the truth.
- 21:20Where do you, where will you find the truth?
- 21:22When almost everybody is speaking half truth, there is
- 21:26nothing called Full truth. How what is it easy?
- 21:29Is it what you are trying to deal?
- 21:31Have you tried trying to deal in your book?
- 21:34Is that what your book is all about?
- 21:36Yeah, that's that's part of what I do.
- 21:38So, I, you know, I should, I should say, I am not a climate
- 21:40scientist. I don't conduct climate
- 21:42research, so I'm not going to do battle.
- 21:44Well, as to, if one scientist is more right than another science
- 21:48scientists. You know what?
- 21:49I what, I what I highlight and, of course, the way I'm doing
- 21:53this is I'm just reading everything I can possibly read.
- 21:55So everyone holds up these big International governmental panel
- 22:00on climate change the ipcc. They write these reports every
- 22:03six or seven years, the latest set of reports was I think it's
- 22:07eighty three hundred pages. So it's it's enormous but and
- 22:12it's a summary of climate It's from all over the world over
- 22:16the, you know, this climate science and boy, the results are
- 22:20all over the map. And if you read these things you
- 22:22realize the language that they use.
- 22:25There's nothing definitive. It's all very, you know, it's
- 22:28likely that this is happening or it's not likely they assign
- 22:31probabilities the the number of things that are that are can
- 22:36actually be proved is really really small.
- 22:39You know, you can when you look backwards and you chart
- 22:42temperatures and things you can actually measure Measure.
- 22:44Okay, those are, those are fine. But then when they project their
- 22:47models forward, they are literally all guesses and
- 22:51they're made that way. But people take those as, as
- 22:55fact, and they have some extreme scenarios.
- 22:58And those are the ones that the media has typically run with
- 23:02these very extreme scenarios that have almost zero
- 23:05probability of happening. So part of what I'm doing is
- 23:09just reading and communicating what I'm finding and what I'm
- 23:12reading the the stuff Not reading in the New York Times or
- 23:15the Washington Post or some of the big media Outlets.
- 23:19If you actually read a lot of the stuff, you get a bit of a
- 23:22different perspective. You also, there's I've developed
- 23:26a bit of an understanding of how the scientific Community works
- 23:30and so, you know, they're they're motivated by getting
- 23:32grants, they have to get grants to publish and the only things
- 23:36that get published are things that you know, that are not
- 23:39boring. So most of the research that
- 23:42gets that gets done are in Conclusive and when I say most
- 23:45you're talking 90 you know above 90%.
- 23:48Well if it's boring and inconclusive it doesn't get
- 23:50published which means no one sees it with it means it never
- 23:53makes them so By and By Nature, you know, our focus is on the
- 23:58things that look strange and then of course it gets conflated
- 24:02into these big stories. So part of what I'm doing is
- 24:05just reading everything, I can reading different perspectives,
- 24:08trying to peel back the layers. I think I mentioned that I'm
- 24:11I've trained myself a bit to try to look The qualifiers and and
- 24:16separate storage. When I read a story.
- 24:17Now, boy, within within seconds, I can see whether or not this is
- 24:21this is something that's true or it's just made up.
- 24:24And so when you start seeing things like if if America keeps
- 24:28doing what we're doing, then the world is going to die, right?
- 24:32Those those sorts of stories are they're just they're just made
- 24:35up and so starting to do that and try to extract some of that
- 24:39information and and put out some solutions that That seemed
- 24:45seemed plausible. So in my book one of the things
- 24:48I did was I developed I didn't develop it but there's there's a
- 24:52organization called project drawdown that has a list of 70
- 24:57to 100 Solutions with dollar amounts that could affect CO2
- 25:01levels. And I include that in there with
- 25:04a, with the prioritize ranking based on dollars and money
- 25:07spent. And it shows, you know that the
- 25:10first 30 or so Solutions are really nature-based.
- 25:14Based Forest preservation better, farming education of
- 25:19people in developed countries to have less children, is the
- 25:23number one in. The number one thing that could
- 25:25have the biggest worldwide benefit, you know, if we educate
- 25:28ourselves to really be aware of these things.
- 25:34So that's those are some of the ways that I'm trying to help
- 25:37communicate some of these things.
- 25:40Right, right Mark. Now let me understand.
- 25:43One thing from you for the audience is that a lot of this
- 25:48debate is happening in the US and people have taken their own
- 25:52positions even media in your opinion has done.
- 25:57So you read a lot of stuff and so much of almost all that stuff
- 26:02is available online. Yeah.
- 26:04What is your understanding of the international Media or
- 26:08International writings on? On this particular topic does
- 26:12the world think world media World?
- 26:15Writers were scientists beyond the u.s. do.
- 26:19They also think the same way that the, that that responsible
- 26:25people in the US are writing or talking about how our is there a
- 26:31difference, how it all will reflect?
- 26:34Because I have not had the chance to reach too much Indian
- 26:38media or In writing is a bit different in that sense and IL
- 26:44of. Now we don't have that sort of a
- 26:46climate Panic. Do we have gone for NetZero 2070
- 26:50that sort of a Target and even electric pickup but we are doing
- 26:53at your own pace. Our government has been very
- 26:56pragmatic in that sense and looking at our needs but we also
- 27:01want to do whatever we can for the planet and we have that sort
- 27:06of a you can say mindset that has been for Quite some time
- 27:10now. So what is your understanding of
- 27:13the u.s. sort, u.s. sort of a, you can say writing or
- 27:19understanding that is trying to be imposed and is a, we the
- 27:23other part of the world? Yeah, that's a great question.
- 27:26I mean, I think it varies I Europe tends to be, especially,
- 27:32Germany tends to be very similar to the u.s. in that regard in
- 27:37terms of their, their, their green.
- 27:40Approach to things but that's also.
- 27:41Now, run into all kinds of problems with the current war
- 27:45and energy prices. And, you know, most times
- 27:48reality tortoise, slaps you in the face.
- 27:50So as much as you want to go down a certain Road when you're
- 27:53paying $6 a gallon for gas, all of a sudden, you know, it kind
- 27:58of wakes you up a bit. So I can look, I think that most
- 28:02most media that follows the climate, there were just sort of
- 28:06repurposing everything. So you're a former journalist,
- 28:09right? So, So maybe someone will do
- 28:11some investigation or dig into it and then that just gets
- 28:15repeated all over the place. My, what I want my experience
- 28:18with the international, the ipcc documents is, you know, these
- 28:23things, these things are massive.
- 28:25They they're they're written by hundreds and hundreds of people.
- 28:28And, you know, the ipcc is an arm of the United Nations.
- 28:33We started talking about the United Nations, right?
- 28:34And so what is the United Nations?
- 28:36Their political group? And, and is primarily an
- 28:39economic All right. So so you know, what's the
- 28:42standard story? What's the story that?
- 28:44What, if you're developing Nation?
- 28:46What do you want, you want money, you want money from rich
- 28:49countries? You want?
- 28:50So so what are you going to say? You're going to say, of course,
- 28:53of course we're getting ravaged by the climate so us China, you
- 28:58know, Great Britain, help us. You need to give us tons of
- 29:01money so we can because we're the victims of this now.
- 29:04Is it true? Well, no, you know, we have this
- 29:08we have this discussion earlier, you know, So if your poorer than
- 29:11your affected, more by all kinds of different problems.
- 29:15So, so that's been my experience in reading this thing, you know,
- 29:18the the, the developed Nations, they have an official position.
- 29:23And so, you know, the the US media will say climate's, very,
- 29:27very bad, it's very, and super super important.
- 29:30China will go come will stand up in front of the world.
- 29:34Say, yes, we believe it's good. It's a big problem and we're
- 29:36going to go to Net Zero. And then when the camera turns
- 29:39off, They order a bunch of coal plants, so they're not to word,
- 29:43right? And so so it varies all over the
- 29:46place. I think you're finding that
- 29:49these stories get out there and then they just travel the world
- 29:52these days, you know, it can be done, instantly through social
- 29:55media and things like that. So there are some standard
- 29:58stories that have that go around and and that's part of the
- 30:02challenge. What is the truth?
- 30:04Finding the truth is really difficult in finding, you know,
- 30:07I appreciate India's pragmatic. Roach, because it's what we
- 30:11need. You know, no one's going to
- 30:12break the bank. If gas is $6 a gallon, you know,
- 30:17you're not going to spend, you know, 80 thousand dollars on a
- 30:19Tesla. If you can't afford it, you just
- 30:21not going to do it. Right.
- 30:24Right mod. Not to understand your book
- 30:27coming out, or is it already available for people to buy?
- 30:31Yeah, it's available on on Amazon.
- 30:34I've been selling it through there and or my website, climate
- 30:38journey.com. So it's gone out there and
- 30:42starting to like, you know, it's not a, it's a journey when you
- 30:45do that, especially if you're coming from the the rural energy
- 30:48industry because there's a sort of a standard thing that you're
- 30:52supposed. Say when you come from that
- 30:54industry and this is this is a bit of a strain from that.
- 30:57So a lot of different opinions, a lot of emotions evolved around
- 31:03with this, with this sort of approach, but I believe that we
- 31:06need to be having a lot more of these discussions because we
- 31:08don't we don't have them very much having as much as excited
- 31:11as we are in the u.s. about this.
- 31:13There's very few debates back. There's never if there's no
- 31:15debates, it's just the, the True Believers yelling and the true
- 31:21non-believers not listening there.
- 31:23Just got their fingers in their ears.
- 31:24No. One's talking about everyone's
- 31:25talking about it, but no one's debating.
- 31:27We're not allowed to ask questions.
- 31:29We're not allowed to question the science.
- 31:31If you, if you do what I'm doing, which is get out there in
- 31:34the middle and try to ask questions and really search for
- 31:37the truth or you're going to catch a lot of arrows and it's
- 31:40not it's not a it's not for the faint of heart so I don't know
- 31:49whether good or bad for one side but that's Philip very
- 31:53unfortunate for the Lonely Planet that we have the only
- 31:57planet and the Lonely Planet. The I have yes.
- 32:00So, but to understand from you Mark is that you said, electric
- 32:05vehicles are good but they are obviously there or the solar
- 32:09panels there is. You cannot obviously solid
- 32:12parents. Cannot solve all the problems
- 32:15and they cannot perhaps all save the planet either.
- 32:17You can say windmills and all that stuff's in.
- 32:20What is going to save the planet if there?
- 32:23Is an answer to that. Well, I think, you know,
- 32:26regarding, you know, again, our climate problem, our
- 32:29contribution to the climate is a consumption problem.
- 32:31So my issue with solar panels wind Mills, electric vehicles.
- 32:37If you think about it, you know, if you take a step back all were
- 32:40doing, is consuming more, you know, having, right?
- 32:44So if you, if you install solar panels on your house, you're
- 32:47adding CO2 because they're manufactured product.
- 32:49Now it's, if you use solar versus My coal plant, is it
- 32:54better? Sure, but it's still becoming
- 32:56worse. So the only thing you're really
- 32:58doing is making things, less worse, you're not necessarily
- 33:01making it better. You're not removing CO2, you're
- 33:05just making it less worth. You're slowing down the growth
- 33:07of the problem. So, electric vehicles are the
- 33:10same thing. So best thing you can do is go
- 33:13home, turn off the lights. Best thing you could do is not
- 33:15drive that car and not buy those cars and not sperm or
- 33:19consumption. That's just where we're now
- 33:21incentivizes people to go out and By a bunch of more stuff.
- 33:24And so that seems to be the wrong way to do this, which is
- 33:28we're just continuing to consume and consume consume.
- 33:31So at some point, if we're worried about CO2 and too much
- 33:36CO2 in the atmosphere, and that's what this whole
- 33:38discussion is about. We got to start removing it, we
- 33:41got to start managing it directly and one of the ways you
- 33:43do that is preserving Nature. Good, cut down trees to build
- 33:46electric vehicle factories, you know.
- 33:48It just makes no sense. So reforestation I keep, In the
- 33:53u.s. I can imagine all of our
- 33:56national parks becoming official carbon sinks.
- 33:59Their job is to just suck, you know, Carbon out of the
- 34:02atmosphere, do that across the globe employ as many natural
- 34:06solutions. As you can natural farming
- 34:09methods, really preserve nature as much as possible and then
- 34:12invest in carbon removal Technologies.
- 34:15They're out there. We just have to get them to
- 34:17scale and then also, you know, solar panels have been around
- 34:21since the 50s they've made. Although we've made almost
- 34:23Newton, no Innovations. If we want this, if we want to
- 34:27get our emissions down quickly, we need some Innovation.
- 34:30You know, I mean, no one likes to say the word nuclear but
- 34:33nuclear has the lowest energy footprint of all that stuff and
- 34:37so if we want to get serious about this, we have to really
- 34:40look at the numbers. And and, and look at which of
- 34:44these things are going to have the biggest effect for the least
- 34:47amount of money. So that's, that's what I propose
- 34:50is to is to preserve nature. Conserve begin to act adapt.
- 34:55Okay, we're not going to we're not going to solve this problem,
- 34:57but we can, we can certainly adapt to some of the things that
- 35:01we're seeing out there in the world.
- 35:03Right. But oh, the word seem to have
- 35:06zeroed on this term called Net Zero.
- 35:10Yeah. How do you look at that?
- 35:13What, what is it exactly the I understand a bit but then it
- 35:17would be nice to hear it from from an expert.
- 35:20And secondly, what should we make out of it again?
- 35:24Like, is it going? Is it the answer that we are all
- 35:27looking for burden? Every country has their own
- 35:31destination regarding this. They The Outlook is different.
- 35:35Plus they have their own ways of committing a committing to this
- 35:39particular thing? Yeah, NetZero is code for not
- 35:42making the problem worse. Okay, so so Net Zero means I'm
- 35:47going to stop being bad rights because it's focused.
- 35:51What are the what are the the challenges?
- 35:53And one of the things I think is a bad focus is the world's
- 35:57entire focus is on a missions, right?
- 35:59How much are we spending out into the air?
- 36:01So let me use it. I'm going to use a Algae with.
- 36:04Hopefully this works. So imagine you go to a doctor
- 36:07and he the doctor tells you that you are 100 pounds overweight.
- 36:11So you have to lose 100 pounds, well, in the climate world,
- 36:14that's CO2 levels. We've got too much CO2 in the
- 36:16atmosphere so we're 100 pounds overweight.
- 36:19So you have at you eat, 20, doughnuts a day and so your plan
- 36:24for that is well, here's what I'm going to do.
- 36:28I'm going to go from 20 donut today, 25 doughnuts a day and
- 36:32I'm going to, I'm going to save. 15 doughnuts a day.
- 36:35That means I'm saving, right? And so if you do the math and
- 36:39you say, well I've saved $15 a day in divided goes into 100
- 36:43pounds. Boom, I've lost all that weight.
- 36:45Well then if you really step back and you think we'll wait a
- 36:47sec, I'm still eating five Donuts today so I'm still making
- 36:51the problems worse. So emissions and Net Zero is
- 36:54focusing on the donuts. So so in this analogy it's going
- 37:00from 20. Doughnuts a day, 20 doughnuts
- 37:02today but hey, guess what? Good for you.
- 37:04You're not getting fatter now, you still have to lose 100
- 37:08pounds. That's the issue.
- 37:10So the reason I don't like NetZero approaches is because
- 37:14it's focused only on the growth. It's at the end of it.
- 37:18Even if we get to NetZero tomorrow we still have to deal
- 37:21with CO2. We still have to make the whole
- 37:23total lower and no one ever ever ever talks about that.
- 37:28So it's super expensive to get emissions down to zero.
- 37:32It's going to take you know how Half of a century to do that if
- 37:35we can ever get there because the truth is there's no such
- 37:38thing as zero carbon energy. Every energy source adds adds
- 37:43it. So at the end of the day when
- 37:44you do the accounting it's still with the with.
- 37:47If you put all of this new technology into the world,
- 37:49you're still going to have more CO2 than you have today.
- 37:53It's just going to be less bad. So even if you had Net Zero, you
- 37:57still have to start removing carbon from the air and making
- 38:00total CO2 lower. So so mi You is what if we know
- 38:05that we have to do that. Why don't we start that today?
- 38:07Why don't we start massive rainforest station?
- 38:09Why don't we start with all these natural preservation
- 38:12programs? Why don't we start developing
- 38:15and deploying a large carbon capture plants?
- 38:19And doing that today as opposed to focusing all of our energy on
- 38:23things like electric vehicles, which may or may not have any
- 38:27effect ever on the total picture.
- 38:30So, so Net Zero is what everyone's focused on because
- 38:33it's easy To say and there's a bunch of products that are made
- 38:36that supposedly help you get to Net Zero.
- 38:38But my view is, it's a false, hope it when you do the math,
- 38:41you never get there. Even if you're successful with
- 38:44Net Zero, if we got to NetZero tomorrow, we still have a big
- 38:47CO2 problem. It doesn't solve the problem.
- 38:49So, so that's why I, that's why I kind of question.
- 38:52That's why I think it's a big spend we and, you know, if you
- 38:55look at the amount of spending, that's in the new US, inflation
- 38:59reduction act bill, if all that money gets spent and all that
- 39:02product gets Floyd, I think the model showed that it will only
- 39:06have .001 degree effect on the temperature.
- 39:10Think about that, we're going to spend, we're going to spend
- 39:13trillions of dollars and it will have .001 degree effect.
- 39:18That's that's just that's a bad investment.
- 39:21That's a bad investment. Okay so it means we have only
- 39:25buying a bit of time. Yeah but but what but we might
- 39:30reach to a point of no return and That will be a very
- 39:35different time actually. So am I right?
- 39:40Yeah. Well, the point of no return
- 39:41again is is a narrative. You know, we've been, we keep
- 39:45hearing about this Tipping Point and the Tipping Point is always
- 39:4810 years away, right? We read about this.
- 39:50And so 30 years ago was 10 years away, 20 years ago was 10 years
- 39:54away, you know, today, it was supposed to happen and it's not
- 40:00happening, right? So, I what is the Tipping Point?
- 40:02Where is the point of no return? Sorry, I don't know that there
- 40:05is such a thing. I'll just I'll just say that I
- 40:07think no one can prove. It science certainly doesn't
- 40:10prove it. There's no there's no scientific
- 40:14basis for this idea that we're going to hit this point of no
- 40:17return. The one thing we know about the
- 40:20Earth is it adapts with or without us and so, so I don't
- 40:25know what such a thing is to me that's just this made up this
- 40:28made-up point of the point of no climate return.
- 40:31I don't know that there is such a thing.
- 40:34You know we I don't know that there is we haven't reached it?
- 40:38Yes we are. We are certainly seeing signs
- 40:40that we are stressing the planet but we have eight billion people
- 40:45on the planet. We have twice as many as there
- 40:46were 30 or 40 years ago so it only holds your logic holds that
- 40:51hey maybe we're stressing some of our resources and that we
- 40:54have to be better stewards of the planet.
- 40:56If there's if there's one good thing that has come out of this
- 40:59entire discussion, it's that right?
- 41:01We now know we Now see that hey we have a big effect on on the
- 41:07planet and that we need to be better stewards of this.
- 41:10You know, we're not going to we're not going to kill two
- 41:12billion people to save a bunch of trees.
- 41:15We have to figure out how to coexist, and we have to figure
- 41:18out how to do this smartly. And, and to be able to afford
- 41:22it, we're not going to reverse goal whole economies to do this.
- 41:26It's just not going to happen. And so, so, again, a realistic
- 41:30approach. I think what you said that, you
- 41:31know, India has goals. To hit 2017 at zero.
- 41:35Seems pretty realistic. Right?
- 41:37It seems reasonable. You're not going to break the
- 41:39bank and break the world's Bank to go do this.
- 41:43You seem to be a that seems to be the right way to do it.
- 41:45Now, there are some who argue that.
- 41:48Hey, that's way too late. But I would argue hey, you know,
- 41:51Net Zero programs that are going to take us 30 or 40 years to
- 41:56implement. If we're running out of time,
- 42:00then that's going to run out of time to sew.
- 42:03So, you know, that's that's my thoughts on that.
- 42:07Right. Right, Mark.
- 42:08I think you have colored all those things.
- 42:11Purely purely on the from the middle ground, and you have put
- 42:16us both sides of the whole issue.
- 42:19Very, very well. And it has educated us quite a
- 42:23bit. Now, what, how do people connect
- 42:25with you? If they know want to know more
- 42:27about your water, conservation startup may want to engage with
- 42:32you and also to understand more about what you are doing, but
- 42:36you are right. Writing how to consume that part
- 42:38of your. Yeah, I am.
- 42:40Surely available on LinkedIn under Mark Cortez.
- 42:43So that that's one way to do it. I have my website as climate
- 42:46Surety climate journey.com. So that's a great way to do it
- 42:49as well. If they're interested in reading
- 42:51this, the, my thoughts on this concern, we buy it on Amazon and
- 42:57do it that way. And I'd love to talk more about
- 43:00this. One of the things that, that I
- 43:02really am encouraged. And one of the things that the
- 43:04big Services, I think that what you do is Is we're having
- 43:08discussions about it in the u.s. There are no discussions.
- 43:11There are no debates. It's just one one group of
- 43:14people yelling at the other who isn't listening.
- 43:16But if you ever want to get into a quick argument, try to discuss
- 43:19the climate and boy, it gets heated real fast, no pun
- 43:23intended. So I think what you're doing is
- 43:25fantastic, you know, we have to be open to having this
- 43:28discussion to be challenging things, that just don't make
- 43:30logical sense. Look, we're paying them a Big
- 43:33Bill and, you know, we're all being handed, the Bill for this.
- 43:37So we should be asking questions for this so.
- 43:40So I think that that's, that's one thing to do.
- 43:42So I'm always available to discuss this.
- 43:45Would love to have more discussions about this with
- 43:48whoever wants to contact me. Absolutely that people could
- 43:58agree to disagree. Yeah, Roars.
- 44:01And that does not happen. That's a very unfortunate thing
- 44:05from. So I do understand it and I see
- 44:08it for what's happening at. The world's largest democracy to
- 44:14the world's biggest democracy. So there's nothing we can, we
- 44:18can fully understand but I hope that there is Hope for the
- 44:22planet left as we go by with this, it's a wrap on this, very
- 44:26special edition of the cage, a masterclass light.
- 44:29Thank you so much, Mark for coming on to the show.
- 44:32Thank you so much. It's been my pleasure.