Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Screen Time in Schools
Transcript
- 0:03>> Good evening. Welcome to
- 0:05Kentucky. Tonight I'm Christy
- 0:06Dutton. Thank you so much for
- 0:07joining us from Tablets in Tiny
- 0:10Hands to AI in the classroom,
- 0:12technology is rewriting the
- 0:14rules of education. Now there's
- 0:16a growing trend to reduce
- 0:17screen time for students.
- 0:19Tonight we'll hear from
- 0:21researchers, lawmakers,
- 0:22education leaders, and students
- 0:24as we discuss the classroom
- 0:26experiences shaping the future
- 0:27of learning. To tackle this
- 0:29topic, I'm joined in our
- 0:31Louisville studio by Marty Park,
- 0:33chief digital officer for the
- 0:35Kentucky Department of
- 0:36Education. Chase Colvin, senior
- 0:39advisor and former research
- 0:40lead for the Kentucky Student
- 0:42Voice team. William Ferguson,
- 0:44principal at Boyd County Middle
- 0:46School. State Senator Cassie
- 0:49Chambers Armstrong, a Democrat
- 0:50from Louisville and Kentucky
- 0:52Senate Minority whip, and state
- 0:55Senator Lindsay Tichenor, a
- 0:56Republican from Smithfield and
- 0:58vice chair of the Senate
- 1:00Education Committee. Thank you
- 1:01so much for being here. Well,
- 1:03there is a growing trend to
- 1:05reduce education technology at
- 1:07school. Legislation has passed
- 1:09in states like Alabama,
- 1:11Tennessee and Utah to
- 1:13reevaluate and limit the use of
- 1:16edtech or education technology.
- 1:18Several schools, including here
- 1:20in Kentucky, are deciding to
- 1:22cut back on the amount of time
- 1:23students spend on laptops like
- 1:26Chromebooks and tablets like
- 1:28iPads. We're going to start the
- 1:29discussion tonight with Marti
- 1:30Park from the Kentucky
- 1:32Department of Education. Marti,
- 1:34who decides what technology is
- 1:36used in each classroom, and how
- 1:39do you ensure that that type of
- 1:41technology really benefits
- 1:43student learning?
- 1:44>> I thank you, it's a great
- 1:45question, and this is such an
- 1:47awesome opportunity to have
- 1:48this discussion. You know, I
- 1:49think it's important to start
- 1:50in the beginning. And if it's
- 1:52okay, go back all the way to
- 1:54the Kentucky Education Reform
- 1:55Act that really sought after,
- 1:57you know, targeting efficient
- 1:59systems of common schools. And
- 2:01in that work from Kera
- 2:03established the Ket's system,
- 2:05the Kentucky Education
- 2:06Technology system, and that
- 2:08system for us in Kentucky set
- 2:10us apart from other states. And
- 2:12so, you know, for the last 30
- 2:14years, we've had the
- 2:15opportunity to work with what
- 2:17we like to think about as
- 2:19school efficiency technologies
- 2:20and learning technologies. So
- 2:22really kind of bucketize
- 2:24technologies, but important for
- 2:25us to define what education
- 2:28technology is. So statewide, we
- 2:30have efficient systems that
- 2:32help us work in schools, better
- 2:36serve more kids with
- 2:38technologies. These are things
- 2:39like even how we call schools
- 2:42and parents communicate with
- 2:44schools. The internet access
- 2:46that each school has all the
- 2:47way through to our student
- 2:49information systems, our
- 2:50financial management systems.
- 2:51We're one of the only states in
- 2:52the country that provides
- 2:54statewide services. So those
- 2:56are statewide shared services.
- 2:57And then to your question of
- 2:59the learning technologies, it's
- 3:00important that we recognize
- 3:02that when we have the
- 3:04foundations in place, then at
- 3:05the classroom level and school
- 3:07level, when you have great
- 3:08teaching practices and you
- 3:10focus on educational planning,
- 3:13laying technology on top of
- 3:14that can can help and, and, but
- 3:18focus on the educational
- 3:20practices first.
- 3:21>> Okay. Okay. Senator
- 3:22Titchener, you've been an
- 3:24advocate for reducing or
- 3:26limiting some of the technology
- 3:27and digital tools used in the
- 3:29classroom. What concerns you
- 3:31about the current level of tech
- 3:34use in the class?
- 3:35>> Well, we really saw a shift
- 3:37after Covid. During the Covid
- 3:39years. Obviously, we had to
- 3:40make accommodations for
- 3:41students to be able to learn at
- 3:42home, but we had seen an
- 3:44infiltration of tech devices
- 3:45and one on one devices in the
- 3:47years prior to Covid. But once
- 3:49we got home and students were
- 3:51learning in that that format,
- 3:53it never fully went back to
- 3:55normal. So that explicit direct
- 3:57teacher instruction started to
- 3:59be compromised, with tech being
- 4:01utilized as a teaching tool, as
- 4:03opposed to the teacher teaching
- 4:06directly to the student. And I
- 4:07think when, when we look at the
- 4:09amount of issues that our
- 4:11students are dealing with these
- 4:12days, we have mental health
- 4:13issues. We have also recently
- 4:16addressed the screens and with
- 4:18our phones being in the
- 4:19classroom and, and we're seeing
- 4:20great results from our schools
- 4:22who've pulled that back. Are we
- 4:24really utilizing technology as
- 4:27a tool to help learning, or are
- 4:29we leaning on it too much as,
- 4:32as a source of education? And I
- 4:35think as we have seen, and I
- 4:37know we're going to discuss a
- 4:38little bit more about some of
- 4:39the testimony we had in the
- 4:41Education committee there.
- 4:42There's a lot of evidence that
- 4:44leans towards returning back to
- 4:46that direct teacher instruction
- 4:49and not removing the human
- 4:50elements of learning that are
- 4:51so valuable to brain
- 4:53development.
- 4:53>> Yeah. And you mentioned one
- 4:55on one, just for those who may
- 4:57not know what one on one
- 4:58technology means.
- 5:00>> It means one Chromebook per
- 5:02student. Everyone has a
- 5:03Chromebook or an iPad or, or
- 5:05some device that oftentimes
- 5:07they take home with them and do
- 5:08their homework on and use as a
- 5:10resource and a tool in class as
- 5:12well.
- 5:12>> Yeah, there's a lot of
- 5:13jargon in tech. Yeah. Principal
- 5:15William Ferguson so at Boyd
- 5:17County Middle School, yes, you
- 5:19all made the decision to limit
- 5:22Chromebook usage for this
- 5:24school year.
- 5:25>> Yeah. You're correct. So it
- 5:27was just kind of like Senator
- 5:29Titchener said, we decided we
- 5:30wanted to bring that human
- 5:31element back into the classroom.
- 5:33When you think back about your
- 5:34favorite teachers, it was
- 5:35always those connections and
- 5:36the stories they told and
- 5:37things like that that really
- 5:39hit home with you. And that's
- 5:41what we want to bring back
- 5:43again, like what Senator
- 5:44Titchener was talking about,
- 5:46the Chromebooks were kind of
- 5:48taking over the educational
- 5:50process, and kids were coming
- 5:51in immediately, sitting down,
- 5:53logging in, doing lessons on
- 5:55there, and very few questions
- 5:56and discussions and
- 5:58interactions were taking place.
- 5:59And as a result of that was we
- 6:01were seeing some negative
- 6:02things. And so we felt like it
- 6:04Boyd County Middle School, we
- 6:05were going to turn that around
- 6:06and, and bring back that human
- 6:08element.
- 6:09>> Yeah. And I saw the Facebook
- 6:10post announcing that and a lot
- 6:13of positive comments under
- 6:15underneath what how are you
- 6:16going to restrict that? Is
- 6:18there a time limit or, or do
- 6:19you know what boundaries you're
- 6:21going to be using?
- 6:22>> So they're just going to be
- 6:24used sporadically just as
- 6:26needed, where our curriculum is
- 6:28changing back to more paper
- 6:30pencil, those are going to be
- 6:32just used as resources within
- 6:33the classroom and not the
- 6:34classroom itself. So that's the
- 6:36goal.
- 6:36>> Okay. Senator Chambers
- 6:39Armstrong, the other side of
- 6:40this argument, can you see that
- 6:43the reduction of educational
- 6:46technology, edtech or screen
- 6:47time, perhaps negatively
- 6:49impacting a student? And if so,
- 6:51in what instance?
- 6:53>> Sure. So I think you're
- 6:54going to hear a lot of us up
- 6:56here saying similar things,
- 6:57which is you're never going to
- 6:59find a substitute for that one
- 7:00on one connection with a good
- 7:02teacher. And especially when
- 7:03we're talking about our
- 7:04youngest children, children
- 7:05need to play. They need to
- 7:06interact with each other. They
- 7:07need those trusted adults that
- 7:09are guiding them along the way.
- 7:11That said, there is a role for
- 7:13technology when it comes to
- 7:15supporting education,
- 7:16supporting learning. I think
- 7:17the question that we need to be
- 7:19asking is, are we being
- 7:20thoughtful about making sure
- 7:21that as we adopt technology, we
- 7:24understand how it's enhancing
- 7:25education and educational goals,
- 7:27not that we are redesigning our
- 7:29education system around
- 7:30technology because again, we
- 7:31have to invest in those things
- 7:33that we know work and making
- 7:34sure that we have good teachers
- 7:36in the classroom, that we're
- 7:38making sure that students are
- 7:39getting that real interactive
- 7:41experience, learning in those
- 7:42hands on ways, and that
- 7:43technology is a way to support
- 7:44that learning.
- 7:45>> Okay. Chase Colvin, now, a
- 7:47lot of times we're missing the
- 7:49student perspective from these
- 7:52discussions. So thank you so
- 7:53much for being here. What type
- 7:55of educational technology or
- 7:57technology tools did you find
- 7:58most beneficial in your high
- 8:01school career? You were a
- 8:02public school here in
- 8:03Louisville, and which one could
- 8:04you have done without?
- 8:06>> I would say I found most
- 8:07beneficial kind of just study
- 8:09tools. I think a lot of
- 8:11students find useful in like
- 8:13Quizlet, which is like flash
- 8:14cards on demand and just things
- 8:16that you can kind of have on
- 8:18the go. Or just when I'm
- 8:20walking in the hallways, I
- 8:21could just quickly like look
- 8:22over things very useful. And
- 8:24then, but I would say point to
- 8:26an instance of my teacher and
- 8:27one of my history classes. And
- 8:29I like how the conversation
- 8:30we're having is using this
- 8:32technology as a tool rather
- 8:33than replacing education. So
- 8:35one of my teachers had us take
- 8:37notes to better enhance our
- 8:39understanding for the history
- 8:41with like podcasting or YouTube
- 8:43videos. But we also took notes
- 8:45from a physical book, and she
- 8:46always encouraged us to take
- 8:48notes on paper. Even if you had
- 8:50a preference for digital, had
- 8:52to be on paper because it just
- 8:55been a lot of studies
- 8:56connecting that better to brain
- 8:58or like, you know,
- 8:59understanding it better and
- 9:00holding it in your brain better.
- 9:01So I would definitely think
- 9:02things like that, that using it
- 9:05with paper is such an easier
- 9:07option. And it's right there
- 9:09and there is all these studies
- 9:10that you can connect to, and it
- 9:12can help your brain stimulate
- 9:14better. And that physical
- 9:15medium and working it with your
- 9:16hands is definitely something
- 9:17you can't replace with digital.
- 9:20>> Okay. Well, Senator, you
- 9:22mentioned the testimony. And so
- 9:23I wanted to show some of that.
- 9:26So it's a clip and it's gained
- 9:29a lot of national attention on
- 9:31this subject and has really
- 9:33become a catalyst for
- 9:34discussions about the use of
- 9:35digital tools in education.
- 9:37Doctor Jared Cooney Horvath
- 9:39testified before the U.S.
- 9:40Senate in January, and
- 9:41Kentucky's interim Joint
- 9:43Committee on Education last
- 9:44month. Doctor Horvath is an
- 9:46educator turned neuroscientist
- 9:49specializing in learning and
- 9:50brain development. Here's what
- 9:52he had to say.
- 9:54>> So a sad fact our generation
- 9:56has to face is this our kids
- 9:59are less cognitively capable
- 10:01than we were at their age.
- 10:04Since we've been standardizing
- 10:05and measuring cognitive
- 10:06development since the late
- 10:081800s, every generation has
- 10:10outperformed their parents. And
- 10:11that's exactly what we want. We
- 10:12want sharper kids. And the
- 10:13reason for this largely has
- 10:15been school. Each generation
- 10:16spends more time in school. We
- 10:17use school to develop our
- 10:19cognition. Congratulations. You
- 10:20see your correlation until Gen
- 10:23Z. Gen Z is the first
- 10:24generation in modern history to
- 10:26underperform us on basically
- 10:28every cognitive measure we have,
- 10:29from basic attention to memory,
- 10:31to literacy, to numeracy, to
- 10:33executive functioning, to even
- 10:34general IQ. Even though they go
- 10:36to more school than we did. So
- 10:38why? What happened? What
- 10:38happened around 2010 that
- 10:41decoupled schooling from
- 10:42cognitive development? It can't
- 10:43be schools. Schools basically
- 10:45look the same. It can't be
- 10:47biology. This hasn't enough
- 10:48time to change. The answer
- 10:49appears to be the tools we are
- 10:51using within schools to drive
- 10:53that learning across 80
- 10:55countries. As Jean was just
- 10:56saying, if you look at the data,
- 10:57once countries adopt digital
- 11:00technology widely in schools,
- 11:01performance goes down
- 11:03significantly to the point
- 11:04where kids who use computers
- 11:05about five hours per day in
- 11:06school for learning purposes
- 11:08will score over two thirds of a
- 11:10standard deviation less than
- 11:11kids who rarely or never touch
- 11:13tech at school. And that's
- 11:14across 80 countries. Bring it
- 11:16home to the U.S. let's go to
- 11:17the U.S. we have our NAEP.
- 11:19That's our big data. Take any
- 11:21state. And here's here's a fun
- 11:22experiment. You can try. Take
- 11:23any state nAEP data. Compare
- 11:25that to when that state adopted
- 11:271 to 1 technology widely and
- 11:29watch what happens. The nAEP
- 11:31data will plateau and then
- 11:33start to drop. Now as Jean said,
- 11:35of course this is all
- 11:37correlative. What we really
- 11:38want is causative. To get
- 11:40causation. What you need is
- 11:41academic research and you need
- 11:43mechanisms, explanations for
- 11:44why we're seeing what we're
- 11:45seeing. Luckily, we have
- 11:46academic research stretching
- 11:47back to 1962 that shows the
- 11:50exact same story for 60 years.
- 11:52When tech enters education,
- 11:54learning goes down. In fact,
- 11:56one of the biggest ed
- 11:58psychologists right now, Dylan
- 11:59William out of the UK, recently
- 12:00said, Ed Tech is the revolution
- 12:02that's been coming for 60 years
- 12:03and we're going to have to wait
- 12:05another 60 because it ain't
- 12:06doing anything. Now that's
- 12:10research. But now we need
- 12:11mechanisms. Luckily, over the
- 12:12last about two decades, we've
- 12:13been doing a lot of work in
- 12:15what we call the science of
- 12:17learning. How do human beings
- 12:18learn? And we now have the
- 12:19clear understanding of why tech
- 12:21does not work for learning. And
- 12:22it is all biological. It's not
- 12:24that the tech isn't being used
- 12:25well enough. We haven't been
- 12:26trained enough. We need better
- 12:28programs. It's we have evolved
- 12:30biologically to learn from
- 12:31other human beings, not from
- 12:32screens and screens. Circumvent
- 12:35that process.
- 12:37>> All right, Senator Titchener,
- 12:38what stood out to you in that
- 12:40testimony?
- 12:40>> So many things. I related to
- 12:43that when I first saw it,
- 12:44because I was dealing with the
- 12:45same issues with my own middle
- 12:46schooler and her constantly
- 12:48having to be on a device and
- 12:49having to come and work, do her
- 12:51homework on a device, doing
- 12:52pre-algebra on a device, and,
- 12:54and being denied the
- 12:55opportunity to use paper and
- 12:57pencil in order to do math,
- 12:59basic math. And it's, it just
- 13:01seems like common sense that
- 13:02our brains don't work that way.
- 13:03And so much of what he was
- 13:05saying in that testimony when
- 13:07he came to talk with us, made
- 13:08me think back to when I was
- 13:10studying for the cursive Bill
- 13:11and just learning about those,
- 13:13those tests that they've done
- 13:14to show how the brain develops
- 13:16when you're putting a pencil to
- 13:18a piece of paper, and how that
- 13:20helps a child's development,
- 13:22memorization, memorization, and
- 13:23literacy, just all the reading
- 13:25skills that they need. And
- 13:26we've really taken that away
- 13:28and we've tried to replace it
- 13:30with something that's that's
- 13:31static and that doesn't get the
- 13:33brain to function the way that
- 13:35it should be functioning. So
- 13:38his testimony was phenomenal.
- 13:39After I saw that clip, I bought
- 13:41his book. I have it here. I'm
- 13:43not being paid to advertise for
- 13:44this, but I would strongly
- 13:46encourage people to read this
- 13:47book. It is fascinating. It is
- 13:48a fascinating, fascinating read
- 13:50and so much information. With
- 13:52his background in being a
- 13:54neuroscientist. He just lays
- 13:55all of the data out. And I
- 13:56think there's a new copy coming
- 13:58out in September with some new
- 13:59data too, so.
- 14:00>> Okay. Okay. Well, Senator
- 14:02Chambers Armstrong, what is
- 14:03your reaction to that?
- 14:05>> Yeah. So I share with
- 14:08Senator Titchener as a parent
- 14:09of young kids, it's scary when
- 14:10you see that, right? It's scary
- 14:12when you're sort of thinking
- 14:13about the world that our
- 14:14children are, that they're
- 14:15operating in every day and not
- 14:18necessarily understanding how
- 14:19the things that are out there
- 14:21are impacting them in long term
- 14:22ways, the way their brains are
- 14:24forming, the way they're
- 14:25relating to other people, the
- 14:26way that they're relating to
- 14:27the world. And I think what I
- 14:29picked up on when I watched
- 14:30Doctor Horvath is the real need
- 14:32for evidence. The fact that
- 14:34we're at this moment where and
- 14:36I'm sure the Kentucky
- 14:37Department of Education can
- 14:38correct me if I'm wrong, we
- 14:40don't have a good sense of
- 14:41what's really happening in all
- 14:42of our schools across our.
- 14:44Related to how often students
- 14:46are on screens, how often
- 14:47they're not on screens, sort of
- 14:49what are the practices that
- 14:50we're seeing in different
- 14:51classrooms? I know that we have
- 14:53some base guidelines in the
- 14:54General Assembly, but how are
- 14:55local districts dealing with
- 14:56that? And what can we learn by
- 14:58looking at what one school
- 14:59district does and what another
- 15:01school district does, and how
- 15:02that produces different
- 15:03outcomes. And the idea that
- 15:04we're at this moment where what
- 15:05I want as a lawmaker is
- 15:07evidence, I want data, I want
- 15:08to know what's working. I want
- 15:10to know what people are doing,
- 15:11and I want to know how we can
- 15:13incentivize and encourage folks
- 15:14to adopt those best practices
- 15:16and to continue asking those
- 15:17questions, because getting the
- 15:18answers to those questions is
- 15:19really urgent. Our kids are in
- 15:21school now. They're learning
- 15:22now their brains are being
- 15:23shaped right now. And so I
- 15:24think all of us up here
- 15:26understand that this isn't a
- 15:27question for five years from
- 15:28now or ten years from now. This
- 15:30is a question that we should
- 15:32all be thinking about every day
- 15:33right now.
- 15:35>> Marty Park your take.
- 15:36>> Yeah, first and foremost, I
- 15:40completely agree in the
- 15:42approach of balance. In fact,
- 15:44we have just published a screen
- 15:46use guide from our Kentucky
- 15:48Department of Education
- 15:50recognizing the different types
- 15:51of use. I think that that
- 15:53you're targeting as well. And
- 15:55we've for a really long time
- 15:56have pushed on impact, trying
- 15:58to understand impact at the
- 16:00school, classroom, school and
- 16:01district level. And so I think
- 16:04that when you look at Doctor
- 16:05Horvath's book, and I bought
- 16:07the book as soon as it came out
- 16:09as well, and it is a good read.
- 16:11We we definitely agree on some
- 16:12points for sure. I think that
- 16:15when from, from the text, from
- 16:17the book and trying to pull
- 16:19together different research and
- 16:21evidence that you spoke to as
- 16:22well, I think. Page 21, he
- 16:24starts into the research
- 16:26gathering portion and page 33,
- 16:28he states, I think, put simply,
- 16:31digital tools that aid in
- 16:32building foundational skills
- 16:33can also benefit students who
- 16:35require more time and structure.
- 16:38That's the intelligent tutoring
- 16:40systems. So in other words,
- 16:41technologies can work to help
- 16:44when there is a balance, when
- 16:45there's what we like to say, a
- 16:47healthy digital diet. So
- 16:49there's a balance in technology
- 16:51use. There's definitely time
- 16:53and attention. There's a time
- 16:54and place for uses of
- 16:56technology. 2014, we published
- 16:58digital learning guidelines
- 17:00that tie right into that same
- 17:02concept and are extremely
- 17:03important. Those are all built
- 17:04into our statewide education
- 17:06technology plan. By the way,
- 17:07it's called the Ket's Master
- 17:08Plan, which this current
- 17:11version we think is our best
- 17:12version yet. And so I think
- 17:15it's really important to think
- 17:16about meaningful use,
- 17:18intentionality and our schools
- 17:19and districts like you just you
- 17:21mentioned in your school,
- 17:21you're working on the
- 17:23meaningful use, the
- 17:24intentionality when and where
- 17:25it's appropriate. It should
- 17:27never be technology for
- 17:29technology's sake. In fact, in
- 17:31Kentucky, we we don't work for
- 17:33big tech, and we never have
- 17:34since the beginning of the KET
- 17:36system, big tech works for us
- 17:39quite, quite frankly. And other
- 17:40states have recognized that.
- 17:42>> Yeah. Well, as we've been
- 17:44talking about, all tech is not
- 17:46created equally. And s t LP is
- 17:48an annual competition where
- 17:50students from across the state
- 17:52demonstrate their skill to code,
- 17:54compute, create and compete.
- 17:56KET. Kelsey Starks gives us a
- 17:57look.
- 17:59>> It isn't every day you see
- 18:01students this excited about
- 18:03academics.
- 18:04>> It blows me away to be here,
- 18:06because I don't think I've ever
- 18:08seen so many people my own age
- 18:09have all of this amazing
- 18:11technology in the room.
- 18:12>> They are computational
- 18:14thinkers, knowledge
- 18:15constructors, and creative
- 18:18communicators, all filling up
- 18:19Rupp Arena to share their ideas.
- 18:22Kentucky was the first state to
- 18:24connect schools across the
- 18:25Commonwealth to the internet
- 18:27back in 1994. Since then, the
- 18:30Kentucky Department of
- 18:31Education has sponsored STLP as
- 18:33a way for students to showcase
- 18:35what they've learned and what
- 18:36they've created using
- 18:38technology.
- 18:39>> Our project is cleaning up
- 18:41the Ohio River using robots. We
- 18:44decided to come here to show
- 18:45off what we think is a very
- 18:47important issue. We can, you
- 18:48know, outreach to other people
- 18:49who share a very similar common
- 18:51interest, which is robotics and
- 18:54engineering or coding. And, you
- 18:55know, we can share these ideas
- 18:57with each other and all come
- 18:58together.
- 18:59>> The projects range from
- 19:00elaborate coding to photography,
- 19:02art and media, all solving
- 19:05problems with an emphasis on
- 19:07teamwork and leadership.
- 19:09>> Every single community at
- 19:11Southside collaborated. We had
- 19:13welding, carpentry, culinary,
- 19:15EMR, EMT, English, mathematics.
- 19:19Everyone collaborated.
- 19:20Carpentry built the frame of it.
- 19:22Electrical did all the wiring.
- 19:24I actually designed the turning
- 19:26mechanism here to turn the
- 19:27Grinch back and forth.
- 19:28>> Well, I just really wanted
- 19:30to be in the program. And as T
- 19:32P stands for Student Technology
- 19:35Leadership Program, and I
- 19:36wanted to be a leader for the
- 19:38kids under my grade and the
- 19:40kids in my grade. Well, I've
- 19:42learned that helping others is
- 19:44the most important thing you
- 19:45can do in life. Because when
- 19:48you help others, it makes you
- 19:49feel good and worthy of being
- 19:53in Stlp.
- 19:55>> For KET, I'm Kelsey Starks.
- 19:59>> That is incredible. Well,
- 20:01with the video we just saw,
- 20:02we're seeing the end product of
- 20:04a lot of hard work from those
- 20:07kids. So, Marty, let me ask you
- 20:11if screen time was limited in
- 20:13schools to let an hour a day
- 20:16per kid, would Sdlp look
- 20:19different?
- 20:20>> I think what you saw in the
- 20:22video is students leveraging
- 20:24technologies to demonstrate
- 20:25learning. And, you know, that
- 20:28is built into our academic
- 20:31standards. It's built in chase.
- 20:32I think you gave a couple touch
- 20:34points and good examples of, of
- 20:35being able to leverage
- 20:37technologies when and where you
- 20:38need limiting time is what
- 20:42we've seen in a couple other
- 20:44states. And we, we do not
- 20:45believe that, you know, that
- 20:46that is the best move. What is
- 20:48the best move is working
- 20:49together and driving towards
- 20:52better understanding of what's
- 20:53making a meaningful difference
- 20:54and what's not. And so working
- 20:57with students to demonstrate
- 21:00learning if they choose to use
- 21:01technologies to do that is and
- 21:04you can see by way of example,
- 21:06at Sdlp and others throughout
- 21:07schools, you can walk through a
- 21:09school and see and by the way,
- 21:11one of the students from the J.
- 21:12Graham Brown School, also
- 21:14recognized as a nation leading
- 21:16from News and World Report just
- 21:18two days ago. And so these are
- 21:20highly performing students and
- 21:21highly performing schools where
- 21:23you see when they choose to use
- 21:25technologies to demonstrate
- 21:26learning that it is impactful.
- 21:28So we always say with Sdlp
- 21:30helping our communities in very
- 21:32specific ways is exactly what
- 21:34we're here to do.
- 21:35>> Yeah, different kids have
- 21:37different skills and talents,
- 21:39right?
- 21:39>> The right tools for the
- 21:40right kids at the right time.
- 21:42>> Yes, I like that. That's
- 21:44very individualized approach.
- 21:46Well, Senator Tichenor, you
- 21:48pointed out that, you know,
- 21:50there's a difference between
- 21:52teaching kids technology and
- 21:55teaching through technology.
- 21:56Explain that a little bit.
- 21:57>> Well, I think if we rely too
- 21:59heavily on it, we really aren't
- 22:02crippling our kids in some way,
- 22:03that they aren't developing
- 22:05their own foundational skills
- 22:06of learning to be able to do
- 22:07amazing things like the program
- 22:09that you just showed us. And I
- 22:11think what Marty is saying is,
- 22:12is not anything different than
- 22:14what I'm saying. We need to
- 22:15build, make sure we have strong
- 22:17foundational skills so that
- 22:18those students can then join a
- 22:20program and, and just soar and
- 22:23utilize the gifts that they
- 22:24have. And I think I often think
- 22:26about my generation and, you
- 22:29know, we didn't grow up with
- 22:30technology at all, really, it
- 22:32started to come into the
- 22:33classroom when I was, I guess,
- 22:35a senior in high school
- 22:36computer started coming around.
- 22:37But think about all of the
- 22:39tools that we utilize now.
- 22:41Those programs, those devices
- 22:43were built by people who did
- 22:44not have technology in their
- 22:46schools. Elon Musk did not have
- 22:49technology in his schools. He
- 22:51was not raised on technology,
- 22:53yet he was able to do
- 22:55incredibly amazing things and
- 22:57build, you know, reshaped our
- 22:59world essentially with the
- 23:01technology he's developed. And
- 23:02that goes back to to the
- 23:03leaders before him in
- 23:04technology. So we are able to,
- 23:07if we have the right knowledge,
- 23:09if we're taught the right
- 23:10information, have the right
- 23:11skill set and have a
- 23:12well-rounded education to do
- 23:14incredible things, and we don't
- 23:16necessarily have to utilize
- 23:17that tool in order to do those
- 23:20incredible things, but we can
- 23:21use it as a tool, but it
- 23:23doesn't have to become a crutch
- 23:24for us.
- 23:25>> Yeah, not a crutch. Yeah.
- 23:27Well, Principal Ferguson in
- 23:29that video, in those amazing
- 23:32robots and projects that those
- 23:34kids brought to compete with, a
- 23:36lot of those projects, used
- 23:40screen time in order to
- 23:42research, to code, to build, to
- 23:47amplify is limiting Chromebook
- 23:50screen time at Boyd County
- 23:52Middle School, and the ability
- 23:55for a kid to compete in
- 23:57something like Sdlp or to
- 23:59create something of that level,
- 24:01how can those go hand in hand?
- 24:04>> So what we are going to look
- 24:06at doing is we still have a
- 24:08computer lab. We're still going
- 24:09to be teaching coding during
- 24:10those those elective types
- 24:12classes. We're still going to
- 24:14offer Sdlp. We love Sdlp and
- 24:17the kids love that. And those
- 24:19are opportunities for those
- 24:20kids. It's just going back to
- 24:22kind of the theme that we've
- 24:23got here, just not letting that
- 24:25be at the forefront of
- 24:27education, letting that be a
- 24:28supplemental part and just a
- 24:30tool that we use as a resource
- 24:32to and just kind of emphasize
- 24:34or actually enhance everything
- 24:37that, that we're doing with
- 24:39education.
- 24:39>> Okay. Chase, in your high
- 24:42school education here in
- 24:44Louisville, what was screen
- 24:47time used for most in high
- 24:50school?
- 24:51>> Yeah, I would say screen
- 24:52time was honestly having this
- 24:55conversation. I've done a lot
- 24:56of reflecting because like the
- 24:58first clip we watched, my Gen
- 25:00Gen Z's being mentioned by name.
- 25:02My generation.
- 25:03>> We're calling.
- 25:04>> You out. Yeah. So I'm like
- 25:05trying to do my own reflecting
- 25:07on how, what is this process?
- 25:08And it really is kind of all
- 25:11consuming just in my everyday
- 25:13life, everything I do in school
- 25:15and out of school now does
- 25:16revolve around technology. So I
- 25:18feel like in school, I see a
- 25:21lot of us using it to just do
- 25:23assignments. I mean, on paper
- 25:25is not really a thing anymore.
- 25:26We use like Google Doc or word
- 25:30and just typing, having more
- 25:33checks like that. AI is, I
- 25:36think, a huge conversation
- 25:37everyone sees now that is
- 25:40definitely mentioned all the
- 25:41time in school. Whether you use
- 25:42it, don't use it. Policy
- 25:44changes by teacher and by
- 25:46approach. And I feel like what
- 25:47I'm seeing now, how much we use
- 25:49it in school for replacing any
- 25:51basic kind of entry level thing
- 25:55is fatigue from afterwards. I
- 25:57don't want to I like this
- 25:59approach that you're taking in
- 26:00Boyd County. How. Removing it
- 26:02from the school. So hopefully,
- 26:03because if right now I do
- 26:05technology in school and then I
- 26:06go out of school and I'm on my
- 26:08phone or and I see, I feel like
- 26:10we're less excited to go
- 26:12outside almost and like we're
- 26:13just fatigued from constantly
- 26:14being strained and exhausted
- 26:16from that screen time. And also
- 26:18like our attention spans going
- 26:20down and just needing that,
- 26:21like another dopamine hit from
- 26:22scrolling on TikTok or
- 26:24something like that. And what
- 26:25I'm excited about, what you
- 26:26showed with the previous clip
- 26:28is just the soft skills being
- 26:29built as well with that
- 26:32leadership training, that
- 26:34communication, teamwork. And
- 26:35then also just like creativity
- 26:37as a whole, that's what I'm, I
- 26:39love being a creative person
- 26:41and having my creative outlets
- 26:42with like, I do a lot of
- 26:43writing. So definitely having a
- 26:46creative outlet there. And I
- 26:47think that expresses with
- 26:48having creativity to be
- 26:49expressed through technology
- 26:51rather than technology being
- 26:52all consuming and doing the
- 26:54creativity creating for us. So
- 26:57I definitely think we've gotten
- 27:00accustomed to using technology
- 27:01in Chromebooks for things that
- 27:02we don't need to be necessarily.
- 27:05>> Yeah, digitizing, digitize
- 27:09worksheets and that sort of
- 27:10thing. Yes. Well, Central
- 27:12Chambers Armstrong, you teach
- 27:13at the higher level, higher
- 27:16education. And do you see this
- 27:19reliance on screen time? And if
- 27:22so, how does that look like at
- 27:25the higher levels?
- 27:26>> Sure. Yeah. So I do teach at
- 27:28a law school and I'm here in my
- 27:30personal capacity and not
- 27:31speaking for them today. But I
- 27:34do notice. So one of the things
- 27:36when students get to law school
- 27:37is we have them engage in
- 27:39conversations, right? That's
- 27:39how you learn as a lawyer is
- 27:41you have to learn how to answer
- 27:43questions. And so on the first
- 27:44day I show up and I'm first, I
- 27:46ask them what happened in the
- 27:48case. And then my second
- 27:49question is, was it right? And
- 27:51really getting students to
- 27:52think and use those critical
- 27:53learning skills. And so, you
- 27:54know, I am fortunate that I've
- 27:56had students that have those
- 27:58foundational skills that have
- 28:00really learned and, you know,
- 28:01been successful. And one of the
- 28:03things I think that we're
- 28:04thinking about in higher
- 28:05education, very similar
- 28:06questions, right? How do we
- 28:07make sure that we're still
- 28:08teaching those foundational
- 28:09skills? I don't think anyone
- 28:10here is saying throw out
- 28:12technology, right? No one is
- 28:14saying stlp is bad. No one is
- 28:16saying, get rid of all the
- 28:17computers and ban them from the
- 28:19buildings. What we're saying is,
- 28:20let's be thoughtful about the
- 28:21purpose that they serve, and
- 28:23let's make sure that they're
- 28:25serving the purposes we've
- 28:26already identified in the
- 28:27curriculum that we're
- 28:28implementing. Yeah. I want to
- 28:30pick up on what we were talking
- 28:31about, about AI, because I
- 28:33think in higher education, and
- 28:34certainly I think when we're
- 28:35talking about our high
- 28:36schoolers as well, that's one
- 28:37of the things that we have to
- 28:39resolve also, right? We, we
- 28:40have these amazingly powerful
- 28:42AI tools that can produce
- 28:44incredible work and with strong
- 28:46foundational skills. I mean,
- 28:48students are going to enter a
- 28:49world where they are in the
- 28:51workplace, they are in the
- 28:52world, and they are part of our
- 28:54society. And so I think for me,
- 28:56that's one of the things I'm
- 28:57thinking about every day is how
- 28:59do we equip our students to go
- 29:02into a world that is going to
- 29:04be increasingly driven by AI
- 29:06and understand its power and
- 29:08understand its limitations, and
- 29:11understand how you make it work
- 29:13for you and you don't work for
- 29:14it.
- 29:15>> Yeah. You're reading my mind
- 29:16because we are going to talk
- 29:18about AI, and I have some more
- 29:19questions about that here in
- 29:21just a minute. First, though, I
- 29:22just want to point out that
- 29:24Boyd County Middle School isn't
- 29:25the only school isn't alone
- 29:26when it comes to dialing back
- 29:29education, technology use at
- 29:30school. A middle school in
- 29:31Fleming County is also trading
- 29:33in the keyboard for pencil and
- 29:38>> Back in May, leaders at
- 29:39Simmons Middle School in
- 29:41Fleming County decided it was
- 29:42time to reduce the amount of
- 29:44technology students were using
- 29:45during the school day. Now, the
- 29:47entire district has adopted
- 29:49that policy with screen time
- 29:50limits of 45 minutes a day for
- 29:53elementary school students, 60
- 29:54minutes for middle schoolers,
- 29:56and 90 minutes for high school
- 29:58students.
- 29:58>> We could definitely tell
- 29:59that kids, especially at the
- 30:01end of the year, were really
- 30:02not engaged in their learning
- 30:03because they were really
- 30:04focused on everything on their
- 30:06computer screen. And sometimes,
- 30:07no matter how much you monitor
- 30:09it, they still have figured out
- 30:11ways to circumvent all the
- 30:12things that are supposed to be
- 30:14a protection for them, and they
- 30:16are doing anything and
- 30:17everything, but they're not
- 30:18doing what we ask them.
- 30:20>> To do. Simmons Middle School
- 30:21principal Doctor Whitney
- 30:22Shannon Wilson said her
- 30:23teachers were some of the first
- 30:24to question what it would look
- 30:26like to scale back tech use in
- 30:28the classroom. Her response?
- 30:30Let's give it a shot.
- 30:31>> It was very much like kind
- 30:32of just rip the band aid off
- 30:34moment and let's try it.
- 30:35>> But the Fleming County
- 30:37Schools superintendent said it
- 30:38wasn't just the teachers who
- 30:39were ready for a change.
- 30:41>> A lot of times over the past
- 30:43year, students have said, we're
- 30:45looking at Chromebooks too much.
- 30:47>> Chromebooks and iPads became
- 30:49commonplace in many Kentucky
- 30:50school districts during the
- 30:52height of the Covid 19 pandemic,
- 30:54when students were learning
- 30:56remotely. But Fleming County's
- 30:57superintendent believes online
- 30:58learning methods went a bit
- 31:00overboard.
- 31:01>> You can make real world
- 31:03learning without a computer,
- 31:04and that's one of the things
- 31:06that we're really pushing that,
- 31:07you know, this is a great
- 31:09opportunity to almost reset.
- 31:11>> Christman said. The school
- 31:12board voted unanimously on the
- 31:14screen limit policy, and he has
- 31:15yet to hear any negative
- 31:17feedback. Teachers at Simons
- 31:19Middle are meeting before the
- 31:20school year kicks off to
- 31:22determine what changes they
- 31:23need to make to adapt to the
- 31:24new policy.
- 31:26>> I'm excited. I'm really
- 31:27excited about it. I know our
- 31:28students are excited.
- 31:29>> It's a welcome. Yes, we're
- 31:31ready for this change, but we
- 31:32all have to work on what does
- 31:34that look like? How can parents
- 31:36still be supportive at home
- 31:37without them instantly going to
- 31:39an online source?
- 31:41>> And even though some screen
- 31:42time is allowed, Principal
- 31:43Wilson has been sharing this
- 31:45message with her teachers.
- 31:47>> There is a way to use
- 31:48technology with balance, but
- 31:50please do not use it for just
- 31:52routine things. It needs to be
- 31:54intentionally planned. And my
- 31:55message to them has been pretty
- 31:57much if you don't need it, you
- 31:58don't have to use it, don't use
- 32:00it.
- 32:01>> Superintendent Christman
- 32:01said he recognizes, especially
- 32:02for older students, that
- 32:04technology is necessary for
- 32:05some subjects.
- 32:06>> A lot of these programs, for
- 32:08instance, like computer
- 32:10programing, they're looking at
- 32:11a screen. It's hard not to look
- 32:13at a screen. So we don't want
- 32:15to limit that. But also we have
- 32:16a lot of students in online
- 32:18dual enrollment classes. We
- 32:20obviously, we really want to
- 32:21push that. We don't want to
- 32:23limit that in any way.
- 32:24>> While the superintendent
- 32:25said this first year will be a
- 32:27learning experience for
- 32:28everyone in the school system,
- 32:29he believes it will lead to
- 32:31more well-rounded students.
- 32:32>> We really need them just to
- 32:35engage. But also this is a
- 32:37chance to say, you know, let
- 32:38kids be kids.
- 32:40>> Teachers at Simons Middle
- 32:42said they're looking forward to
- 32:43collaborating with one another
- 32:44and seeing their students put
- 32:46pencil to paper in Fleming
- 32:48County for KET. I'm Emily
- 32:50Prince.
- 32:51>> Principal Ferguson. After
- 32:53seeing that with Simons Middle
- 32:55School and Boyd County Middle
- 32:56School intentionally reducing
- 32:58that screen time, how soon
- 33:00until you think you may see
- 33:01some positive results and how
- 33:02are you going to measure them?
- 33:04>> Well, obviously we give
- 33:05benchmark tests throughout the
- 33:06year just to see where those
- 33:08reading and math scores are at.
- 33:10And so hopefully within, you
- 33:12know, that winter screening
- 33:14that we do, we'll see some
- 33:15increase in that. It's, it's
- 33:16kind of exciting to wait and
- 33:18see what happens.
- 33:19>> Yeah.
- 33:19>> Yeah, it's definitely.
- 33:20>> Yeah, we'll be watching.
- 33:21Well, Senator Chambers
- 33:23Armstrong, we talked about that
- 33:251 to 1 technology, one device,
- 33:28whether it be a Chromebook or
- 33:29tablet or laptop to each child,
- 33:33if we reduce that. So it's not
- 33:361 to 1. Maybe a child goes to
- 33:39school and shares a computer
- 33:41for half the school day and
- 33:43another child the other half.
- 33:46Will there be any unintended
- 33:48consequences that you can think
- 33:49of in certain districts?
- 33:52>> Yeah. So of course, when we
- 33:54talk about access to technology,
- 33:56as someone who grew up in a
- 33:58more rural part of the state, I
- 34:00think a lot about making sure
- 34:02that if we're reducing access
- 34:04to technology, we're not
- 34:05unintentionally harming the
- 34:06students who are already
- 34:07struggling to get that access
- 34:08right, that, you know, having
- 34:11access to things like computers
- 34:12is important in the world today.
- 34:15Having access to the internet,
- 34:17which we've done a great job of
- 34:18in Kentucky, but we certainly
- 34:19wouldn't want to do anything
- 34:20that would set some students up
- 34:22to have a disadvantage, set
- 34:24some students up for success
- 34:25while not setting every student
- 34:27up for success. And so I think
- 34:28when we think about unintended
- 34:30consequences, again, it starts
- 34:31with that, that principle of
- 34:33how are we teaching? What are
- 34:34our goals? How does technology
- 34:36support it? And as we move
- 34:38forward, how do we make sure
- 34:39that we're bringing every child
- 34:40along in that process? And so
- 34:42if a technology is good and it
- 34:44supports learning, let's make
- 34:45sure every single child and
- 34:46every single district has equal
- 34:49access to that. And if there
- 34:50are some students that might
- 34:51not be getting the same
- 34:53exposure to technology and
- 34:55opportunities and things at
- 34:57home, or maybe the
- 34:58opportunities don't exist as
- 34:59much in their community, how do
- 35:00we then support that and
- 35:02support bringing that in and
- 35:04support even using technology
- 35:05in some ways to, to bring those
- 35:08experiences to every single
- 35:09student?
- 35:09>> Well, Senator Titchener, as,
- 35:12as schools think about this
- 35:14topic and make those decisions
- 35:15to either reduce screen time or
- 35:17maybe veer away from 1 to 1
- 35:19technology, since the schools
- 35:20are already making some of
- 35:22these decisions, is it
- 35:23necessary for legislation to
- 35:26start setting rules?
- 35:28>> Is it necessary? Maybe not.
- 35:30Maybe it is a local decision.
- 35:32What I would question is if if
- 35:35schools are not anticipating
- 35:37this as a need to start
- 35:39addressing, maybe we do need to
- 35:41step in. Maybe we need to work
- 35:43together with the KDE and
- 35:44figure out what is the best way
- 35:45forward to make sure. For me
- 35:47personally, when I filed Senate
- 35:48Bill 318, I was hyper focused
- 35:50on K through five because
- 35:52that's again, where those
- 35:54foundational learning skills
- 35:55are being learned. And if we're
- 35:57jeopardizing that in basic
- 35:59reading, basic math, and those
- 36:00those critical thinking skills
- 36:01that develop at those very
- 36:03early ages, then maybe the
- 36:05state does need to get involved,
- 36:07at least at that level. I love
- 36:08to see our middle schools even
- 36:10addressing this. When when
- 36:12really you think once you get
- 36:13to middle school, they've got a
- 36:14little bit of that foundation
- 36:16built and they're able to
- 36:17monitor some of their own tech
- 36:19use. But, but being intentional
- 36:21about this, even at the middle
- 36:22school level and even at the
- 36:23high school level, to make sure
- 36:25we're using technology properly.
- 36:27And that's something I know
- 36:28Chase's generation is, is
- 36:30grappling with because it's
- 36:31just everywhere. And my
- 36:32children are, are your
- 36:34generation as well. So it's an
- 36:36interesting thing to, to
- 36:38balance between how much local
- 36:40control versus how much state
- 36:41needs to be involved. But we're
- 36:43talking about the education of
- 36:45our kids. And we have data from
- 36:48the nAEP scores to show once we
- 36:50went more towards one on one
- 36:52technology, the numbers started
- 36:53dropping. Of course, there's
- 36:54other factors, but this is one
- 36:56thing we do know that we can
- 36:58address. And we we put such a
- 37:00high priority on education in
- 37:02Kentucky. We. We don't want to
- 37:04miss an opportunity for any kid
- 37:05to get a very strong
- 37:07foundational education.
- 37:08>> Yeah. So do you. Might you
- 37:11consider refiling that bill and
- 37:13tell us what that bill did for
- 37:16that K through five age group?
- 37:18>> Yeah, it it really put just
- 37:20a time limit on there. And this
- 37:22was a bill to start the
- 37:23conversation. And I absolutely
- 37:24love that we're having this
- 37:25conversation. So it worked. So
- 37:27we put just a random time limit
- 37:3045 minutes a day. And there's a
- 37:32lot of conversations I knew
- 37:33that would need to go into.
- 37:35What does that look like on, on
- 37:37the state level? But we
- 37:38obviously had carve outs for
- 37:40students who have certain
- 37:41disabilities or students who
- 37:42have health issues, who have to
- 37:44be at home, or students who are
- 37:45doing online learning. We have
- 37:47some online learning that is
- 37:48available throughout Kentucky
- 37:50schools. So we kind of tried to
- 37:52think through a lot of that.
- 37:53But just more than anything,
- 37:55this was a conversation starter.
- 37:57And I'm just happy that we're
- 37:59now at a spot where we're
- 38:00starting to realize, and
- 38:01schools like Boyd County and
- 38:02Fleming County are already way
- 38:04ahead of us in making. And
- 38:06because you're on the ground,
- 38:07you see it, you understand
- 38:09where the issues lie, and
- 38:10you're able to just go for it
- 38:11and address it. And I so
- 38:13appreciate that.
- 38:14>> Starting conversations,
- 38:15continuing conversations, and
- 38:16just thinking logistically,
- 38:18Marti Park, if each school said
- 38:20its own screen time limit for
- 38:23different grades and different
- 38:25exceptions, how would that be
- 38:26handled from a technology point
- 38:28of view, is that possible?
- 38:30>> Well, I think that's a
- 38:31that's a great question. And I
- 38:32do appreciate and actually, we
- 38:34are energized and excited to
- 38:36bring folks together to have
- 38:37these conversations. So we we
- 38:40would prefer to think about
- 38:42screen use, the type of use. So
- 38:43we look at passive use
- 38:46scrolling, you know, scrolling
- 38:47kind of use passive versus
- 38:50active use. And so we, we'll
- 38:52talk a lot more about the use
- 38:54type versus the, the quality
- 38:57versus quantity conversation,
- 38:58which I think is very helpful.
- 39:00It's back to that balanced
- 39:02approach. There are tools right
- 39:03now, one of our statewide
- 39:04shared services that and again,
- 39:05we're very different than other
- 39:07states, but we provide tooling.
- 39:09It's called the internet
- 39:10content management solution
- 39:12that every school district has.
- 39:14It's not a state system. It's
- 39:16distributed out. So every
- 39:17school district has that
- 39:19tooling and they districts and
- 39:22schools can can see those types
- 39:23of uses, not just the time. If
- 39:26you wanted to look at the
- 39:27quantity of time, but also the
- 39:29types of use, and then have
- 39:31those additional conversations
- 39:32inside the school building to
- 39:34say, you know, hey, is this
- 39:35what we're, you know, targeting?
- 39:36Is this what we're after? And
- 39:38then additionally, that same
- 39:40internet content management
- 39:41solution that we have in
- 39:42Kentucky, again, a 30 year kind
- 39:45of strategy in the cats program
- 39:49also is available to parents.
- 39:50And parents can if parents have
- 39:52concerns, they can, you know,
- 39:53work with the school to say,
- 39:55what kind of screen use are we
- 39:56looking at during the day on
- 39:58campus and beyond campus to
- 40:00really hone in that grappling
- 40:03with personal use that you
- 40:04mentioned, Chase, personal use
- 40:06of personal technologies versus
- 40:08school education technologies.
- 40:10>> Okay. Well, last year, the
- 40:12Kentucky General Assembly
- 40:12passed House Bill 208, a
- 40:15bipartisan law banning cell
- 40:16phone use at schools during
- 40:18instructional time. The law
- 40:19also prohibits social media on
- 40:21school devices. The original
- 40:22bill was more strict, but the
- 40:24bill that passed allows for
- 40:25some flexibility in
- 40:27interpretation. Chase, what did
- 40:28this look like in your senior
- 40:30year?
- 40:31>> Yeah, I would say we were
- 40:32definitely I was my last year
- 40:34in high school. I was the
- 40:35transition year between having
- 40:37phones to not having phones
- 40:39completely. It definitely
- 40:40raised a lot of like upset with
- 40:42students just because we were
- 40:44so routine and used to having
- 40:45our phones easy access in our
- 40:47pockets, walking around. So it
- 40:49definitely took some use. And I
- 40:52think by the end of it,
- 40:53students came around to it. I
- 40:54mean, I know there was that
- 40:57article of Ballard with
- 40:58students checking out more
- 40:59books. That definitely happened
- 41:01at manual as well. I checked
- 41:02out my first library book my
- 41:04senior year.
- 41:05>> You checked out your first
- 41:06library book? Okay. Well,
- 41:08congratulations. Thank you.
- 41:10>> But I, I think little things
- 41:12also, just like taking photos
- 41:14of the teacher's lecture before
- 41:15the screen changes, doing
- 41:18little reminders in the hallway,
- 41:19or like texting a friend about
- 41:21like an assignment, like just
- 41:23to be prepared for or like my,
- 41:25my sophomore year before it
- 41:26went, one of my classes was I
- 41:28was in a videography class and
- 41:30we filmed on phones. So little
- 41:32things like that my senior year
- 41:33were a little bit more rough
- 41:35just because we were in that
- 41:36transition. But I could tell by
- 41:38the end of the second semester
- 41:39we were in routine. People were
- 41:41connecting with each other. I
- 41:43mean, as a freshman, I use my
- 41:45phone as a crutch. I know we
- 41:47mentioned like technology as a
- 41:48crutch, and I use my phone as a
- 41:50crutch when I didn't know
- 41:51anyone first class, just
- 41:52scrolling just to buy time by.
- 41:54I really hope that these
- 41:55upcoming freshmen can not
- 41:57without phones having the
- 41:59opportunity to build that
- 42:00connection early on and start
- 42:01that process. And again, with
- 42:03like teachers building that
- 42:04connection as well. So I really,
- 42:06I think hopefully it's a
- 42:07positive, it's going to a
- 42:09positive direction.
- 42:10>> Yeah, absolutely. Well,
- 42:11while conversations about
- 42:13Chromebooks, tablets and cell
- 42:14phones continue, artificial
- 42:17intelligence, AI is also making
- 42:18its way into classrooms. What
- 42:20was once a hypothetical concept
- 42:22has become a daily reality.
- 42:25Students are not only using AI,
- 42:27but they're learning how to
- 42:28create it. KET Laura Rogers
- 42:30takes us to Bowling Green High
- 42:31School, where students and
- 42:33teachers have transformed
- 42:34learning with AI.
- 42:37>> 1910 Blake teaches history
- 42:39at Bowling Green High School,
- 42:41but he's also focused on the
- 42:43future.
- 42:43>> I've always been someone
- 42:44that's very big into like,
- 42:46gadgets and tech.
- 42:46>> That made him an early
- 42:48adopter of AI in the classroom.
- 42:50>> I kind of played around with
- 42:52some of the new tools and kind
- 42:53of figured out what would work
- 42:55for me and what I could use day
- 42:57to day in my classroom. Coming
- 42:58back from World War One.
- 43:00>> He says AI tools like
- 43:01notebook L, M can work as a
- 43:03personalized tutor, and he can
- 43:04make sure the information
- 43:05students access is credible and
- 43:06safe.
- 43:07>> It's not pulling data and
- 43:08information from the entire
- 43:10internet. It's only pulling
- 43:12from the sources of information
- 43:13you provide it.
- 43:14>> You can input up to 50
- 43:16sources like PDFs and textbook
- 43:18chapters to help students study
- 43:20and complete assignments. In
- 43:21his AP history courses.
- 43:23>> I feed in our college
- 43:24textbook. I feed in our review
- 43:26textbook that we use. I feed in
- 43:28primary sources. I feed in
- 43:30videos from YouTube that
- 43:31correspond to the content.
- 43:33>> Central says. It can also
- 43:34help them study for advanced
- 43:36placement exams without having
- 43:38to purchase extra materials.
- 43:40>> I can create podcasts for
- 43:41them. I can create videos, I
- 43:42can create slides mindmaps, I
- 43:44can create all these great
- 43:46study tools, flashcards, quiz
- 43:48questions.
- 43:49>> Our teachers are using it in
- 43:50a lot of different ways in the
- 43:52classroom.
- 43:52>> Megan Markham is the school
- 43:54district's digital learning
- 43:55coach.
- 43:55>> AI sort of broke onto the
- 43:57scene. It's sort of like an
- 43:59explosion with absolutely no
- 44:01warning.
- 44:01>> She advises teachers on
- 44:03meaningful integration of
- 44:04technology in their classrooms.
- 44:06>> We sort of had to scramble
- 44:07to figure out what this was
- 44:09going to look like and the
- 44:11potential pitfalls and
- 44:13opportunities it provided. Now,
- 44:15I think we're turning that
- 44:16corner of really seeing the
- 44:18potential behind AI in the
- 44:20classroom.
- 44:20>> Melanie Dickinson's English
- 44:22classes students are using
- 44:23Magic School to research
- 44:25conspiracies and mysteries,
- 44:27with her guidance on using AI
- 44:29as a tool, not a shortcut.
- 44:31>> When you have an assistant
- 44:32that can deliver instruction
- 44:34and give immediate feedback and
- 44:36guide the student on a
- 44:37personalized learning path,
- 44:38that's what we want for every
- 44:40student. AI makes that possible.
- 44:42AI makes that even easy.
- 44:44>> It can also make some things
- 44:45easier for teachers, like
- 44:47grading and giving feedback on
- 44:49hundreds of assignments.
- 44:50>> Grading is just very
- 44:52grueling and giving that high
- 44:54quality feedback to every
- 44:55single student. Whether you
- 44:57have 75 students or 150
- 44:59students or 200 students, we're
- 45:01human. So somewhere in that
- 45:04stack of papers you're going to
- 45:07fatigue, whereas AI does not.
- 45:10>> Both acknowledge concerns
- 45:12over artificial intelligence in
- 45:14schools. Specifically if it
- 45:16helps students cheat.
- 45:17>> We have the same concerns
- 45:18with calculators. We had the
- 45:20same concerns with Google. The
- 45:22old theory you can really
- 45:24unlock a great potential for
- 45:26students and their personalized
- 45:27learning if you start using.
- 45:29>> It, she says. Some
- 45:30assignments may need to be
- 45:31redesigned, but also there
- 45:33needs to be honest
- 45:34conversations with students
- 45:35about how to appropriately use
- 45:37AI.
- 45:37>> And what's acceptable and
- 45:39what's not acceptable. You know,
- 45:41using AI to help you brainstorm
- 45:44is acceptable. Maybe using AI
- 45:45to write your entire essay for
- 45:47you is not acceptable.
- 45:48>> We're never going to put the
- 45:50genie back in the bottle. The
- 45:51genie's out. Kentucky plays a
- 45:52huge role. You just have to
- 45:54find ways that it can enhance
- 45:55what you do in the classroom,
- 45:57and it can enhance what
- 45:58students are able to do in
- 46:00terms of preparation, in terms
- 46:01of deeper learning.
- 46:02>> Much of that learning useful
- 46:04for building the skills they
- 46:06need for college and career.
- 46:09>> What's known.
- 46:09>> As four KET. I'm Laura
- 46:12Rogers.
- 46:13>> AI seems to be evolving at
- 46:16lightning speed. Principal
- 46:17Ferguson in Boyd County Middle
- 46:19School. In your opinion, are
- 46:20teachers ready for AI and what
- 46:21are some of your concerns?
- 46:23>> Well, ready or not, here it.
- 46:24>> Is exactly.
- 46:25>> Like she said. It's just
- 46:27kind of exploded onto the scene.
- 46:28And there it is. It's right
- 46:30there in our face. And we're
- 46:31still working to develop
- 46:32policies. And you know how
- 46:33we're going to use this and,
- 46:35you know, trying to avoid
- 46:36opening Pandora's box, so to
- 46:38speak, and creating a mess. But
- 46:40we there are positive things.
- 46:42You know, back when I was in
- 46:44school, Google came onto the
- 46:46scene and it completely changed
- 46:48the way we
- 46:49>> To do research, and I think
- 46:50we can harness this and do good
- 46:52things with that. And so our
- 46:53teachers are working as quickly
- 46:56as they possibly can to be
- 46:57ready for this.
- 46:58>> Well, Marti Park, the
- 47:00Kentucky Department of
- 47:01Education, encourages teachers
- 47:03to about AI literacy to know AI
- 47:05literacy and responsible use of.
- 47:08How how do they find out how to
- 47:10do that? And how do they know
- 47:13where the guardrails should be
- 47:14to protect student learning and
- 47:16student safety? Really?
- 47:17>> Yeah, that's part of our
- 47:19challenge, right? It is the
- 47:20fastest adopted technology that
- 47:21we've ever seen, and that's
- 47:24outside of schools, outside of
- 47:25classrooms and our personal
- 47:26lives. Artificial intelligence
- 47:28is the toothpaste out of the
- 47:29bottle, so to speak. And so,
- 47:32you know, artificial
- 47:33intelligence has been around
- 47:34for a really long time. But how
- 47:36we all can interact with
- 47:37generative AI is relatively new
- 47:40in the last several years. And
- 47:41so we're trying to grapple with
- 47:44understanding what we refer to
- 47:45as a safe, secure and
- 47:46responsible uses of AI. And so
- 47:48it is learning guardrails. I
- 47:50think our schools and districts,
- 47:52it is a body of work. You know,
- 47:55superintendents and principals
- 47:56are digging in to figure out. I
- 47:58think it changes what
- 47:59demonstration of learning looks
- 48:00like. I think about, you know,
- 48:03for us, we think about learning.
- 48:04I'm a former classroom teacher
- 48:05myself, and we think about
- 48:07learning quite a bit in a sense
- 48:09of is there, does there become
- 48:11an overreliance on technologies?
- 48:13We never want that. We don't
- 48:14want that at all. And so
- 48:17understanding when where it's
- 48:19appropriate becomes important.
- 48:21We also have published a, an AI
- 48:24guidance brief that several
- 48:27school districts across the
- 48:28state have used and worked
- 48:30together to develop where those
- 48:31guardrails are. I think that's
- 48:33important. Additionally, I
- 48:34would I would just add our
- 48:36Kentucky academic standards for
- 48:37technology as well as our
- 48:40Kentucky academic standards for
- 48:41computer science. We look at
- 48:42grade band appropriate age and
- 48:44ability, appropriate, you know,
- 48:47entry points of where AI is
- 48:49important to learn. So it's not
- 48:50AI literacy, it's AI fluency,
- 48:53which becomes super important
- 48:54because when our students leave
- 48:55our campuses and go off campus
- 48:57with personal technologies, we
- 48:59have to understand where the
- 49:01guardrails are, our standards
- 49:03do that. And digital
- 49:04citizenship is a concept that
- 49:06we were the first state, thanks
- 49:07to our General Assembly members,
- 49:09who helped us pass a law early
- 49:11on. Digital citizenship is a
- 49:13concept in Kentucky that's part
- 49:15of our core DNA.
- 49:16>> Okay. Chase Colvin from the
- 49:20Kentucky Student Voice team,
- 49:21your big research was on AI for
- 49:25last school year. What are a
- 49:26couple of the findings that you
- 49:29discovered?
- 49:29>> Yeah. So for this research,
- 49:31we had around over 870
- 49:34responses by a survey. And when
- 49:36we did over 200 oh no, sorry,
- 49:3820 interviews to follow that up.
- 49:41And I think some of the key
- 49:43responses that we had was that
- 49:4645, 45% of students use AI to
- 49:49primarily do studies, study
- 49:51guides, sorry, excuse me to do
- 49:54study. Oh my gosh, study guide
- 49:56tools. There you go. Yes,
- 49:57exactly. Or brainstorming was
- 49:59over 55%. People use that. So
- 50:01you really being able to
- 50:03increase your fluency and
- 50:05comprehension with like a book
- 50:06you can plug in AI. Can you
- 50:08generate questions for
- 50:10comprehension on Animal Farm, a
- 50:11book I read my freshman year
- 50:13and it helps build that fluency.
- 50:15Another thing that we found in
- 50:17our surveys, our in our
- 50:19interviews was kind of fear of
- 50:22critical offloading and how we
- 50:24are scared that people that AI
- 50:26is replacing the steps it takes
- 50:27to learn and that we are
- 50:29focusing now more on just
- 50:31getting the answer rather than
- 50:32the process of getting to that
- 50:34answer. I like how in the clip
- 50:35we just saw, one of the
- 50:37teachers that was doing AI
- 50:38research had each step on
- 50:40finding. I think I saw, like
- 50:41finding your topic, finding
- 50:43your research resources. So
- 50:44there were steps to it outlined.
- 50:46I really don't that's one of my
- 50:48fears is that AI is just going
- 50:50to generate a math solution,
- 50:52and we're not going to know how
- 50:53to solve that, or it's just
- 50:55going to tell us the, the
- 50:57sources of to or the summarize
- 50:59the research and the sources of
- 51:00it, rather than students
- 51:02building those skills of
- 51:03sorting and analyzing through
- 51:04that and picking out what's
- 51:06important and what they want to
- 51:07highlight. And then the last
- 51:08thing I want to touch on that
- 51:10we found is that over 75% of
- 51:12students had fear of
- 51:14misinformation being spread
- 51:15around with AI, whether that
- 51:16being digital content and
- 51:18photos being created or just
- 51:20false information that can
- 51:21produce because it's not
- 51:22perfect either, just as humans
- 51:23aren't perfect.
- 51:24>> And that is a huge problem
- 51:26to really keep in mind as we
- 51:27have this AI conversation. And
- 51:30Senator Chambers Armstrong, if
- 51:31we limit screen time, will we
- 51:34be reducing learning
- 51:36opportunities for students to
- 51:38grasp this AI literacy?
- 51:40>> I think the students are
- 51:41going to learn about AI no
- 51:43matter what we do. I think it's
- 51:45so much a part of our society
- 51:46that we just are going to have
- 51:48to learn how we adapt and teach
- 51:50our students to use it
- 51:51responsibly. The thing I do
- 51:52first day of law school in my
- 51:54legal writing class is I have
- 51:56my students read an opinion
- 51:57from attorneys being sanctioned
- 51:58for filing briefs written with
- 52:00AI that had hallucinated bad
- 52:02citations. The people's legal
- 52:04license is at risk, right? And
- 52:06so I talked to them about how
- 52:08AI can be a tool. It's
- 52:09expensive to hire lawyers. If
- 52:10you can save some time and have
- 52:12a lawyer do some of that
- 52:14preliminary work and save folks
- 52:15money that increases access to
- 52:16justice. That's good. But you
- 52:17have to understand how to look
- 52:19at that output, how to evaluate
- 52:20that output, how to know that
- 52:22that output is worth filing
- 52:23with the court because
- 52:24otherwise you're going to lose
- 52:25your license. And so I think we
- 52:27need to start teaching our
- 52:28students those tools, quite
- 52:29frankly, very early. I think
- 52:31that, you know, making sure
- 52:32that our students, when they
- 52:33graduate high school understand
- 52:34the power of AI, both the good
- 52:36side of it and the potential
- 52:37downside, and that they feel
- 52:39comfortable making sure that it
- 52:40is working for them in the ways
- 52:42that they need it to.
- 52:43>> Senator Titchener, does that
- 52:44concern you?
- 52:45>> Oh, absolutely. I'm the one
- 52:47who brought back cursive. I
- 52:48don't like AI. If I could go
- 52:51back 100 years, I would go back
- 52:52100 years in education. I think,
- 52:55you know, obviously it's here
- 52:56and we can't do anything but
- 52:58learn how to deal with it and
- 53:01make sure that that students,
- 53:02as they become adults, know how
- 53:04to utilize it properly in their
- 53:06careers. That's a brilliant
- 53:07point that you brought up. I
- 53:08saw that in the news about
- 53:10people losing or jeopardizing
- 53:12their their law licenses
- 53:14utilizing AI. I think we as we
- 53:18look at addressing tech again,
- 53:20so much of it is just focused
- 53:21on do they have those
- 53:22foundational skills? Can they
- 53:23critically think? Can they
- 53:24critically look through
- 53:25information and make decisions
- 53:28the right way? Right. So I will
- 53:31be a huge proponent of making
- 53:32sure kids have physical books
- 53:34in their hands. And, and we do
- 53:36a lot of, of assisting kids and
- 53:38having audio books read to them
- 53:40if they have learning struggles.
- 53:42But man, we are, we're
- 53:44jeopardizing their ability to
- 53:46really develop those hard
- 53:48earned skills by picking up a
- 53:49book and turning a page and
- 53:51working through a difficulty in
- 53:54being able to understand and,
- 53:55and know how to read. So I'm
- 53:58going to always be pushing for
- 53:59the traditional way of
- 54:00education if I can. But I'm
- 54:02also not ignorant to the fact
- 54:03that we have to address this.
- 54:05>> Yeah. Okay. Just a quick one
- 54:07word, one quick sentence.
- 54:08What's the biggest mistake
- 54:09Kentucky can make in this
- 54:10debate of edtech in schools
- 54:13acting?
- 54:13>> Before we have the evidence
- 54:15to make the best decisions for
- 54:16our kids.
- 54:17>> Okay, Chase.
- 54:18>> Let not letting wait. Sorry.
- 54:21They need to let kids struggle
- 54:22rather than just turning
- 54:23towards an a quick answer.
- 54:24>> Okay, Marty Parks.
- 54:26>> If not, who? If not us, then
- 54:28who? Okay, if if we can't, if
- 54:30we're not teaching our students
- 54:32with the access that we
- 54:33currently have in our, in our
- 54:35schools, then who can who?
- 54:36>> Principal Ferguson.
- 54:37>> I think we just keep doing
- 54:39what's best for our kids.
- 54:40That's the focus of all of it.
- 54:42>> Tichenor we've got to put
- 54:43education first and making sure
- 54:45kids learn with the tools that
- 54:47they have already been gifted,
- 54:49and with the educational
- 54:51knowledge that we have to
- 54:53impart those skills in their
- 54:54lives.
- 54:55>> Well, the tools used to
- 54:56teach students that continues
- 54:58to change now faster than ever.
- 55:00But the goal remains the same
- 55:02help every student reach their
- 55:04greatest potential. And how
- 55:06Kentucky strikes that balance
- 55:07between innovation and
- 55:10instruction. And that can be a
- 55:11difficult but critical
- 55:13conversation. And I appreciate
- 55:15so much for you being here and
- 55:17having that conversation with
- 55:18us tonight. Thank you so much.
- 55:20And that does it for us. That
- 55:22does it for Kentucky tonight.
- 55:23We hope that you will join us
- 55:25tomorrow for Kentucky edition
- 55:27at 630 eastern, 530 central
- 55:30right here on KET. I'm Christie
- 55:32Dutton. Thank you so much for
- 55:35watching.