Latest / NFL Talk | New York Jets / Protecting Justin Fields: Jets' Calculated QB Runs
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Welcome back to the deep Dive.
- 0:01Speaker 2: Today, we are jumping right into a really tough tactical
- 0:05problem in the modern NFL. It all kind of came
- 0:07to a head during that Jets loss to the Patriots
- 0:10twenty seven to fourteen on Thursday Night Football. And the
- 0:13dilemma is this, how do you use a dynamic, incredible
- 0:16running quarterback without putting him directly in Hong's way for
- 0:20a career ending injury.
- 0:22Speaker 3: It's the quarterback conundrum, isn't it. And what we've seen
- 0:25from the sources here, especially around Jets coach Aaron Glenn,
- 0:28is that the organization is choosing to protect the asset,
- 0:31even if it means stopping their quarterback justin fields, right
- 0:35when he's being his most effective.
- 0:36Speaker 1: That's the tension exactly.
- 0:37Speaker 2: So today our mission is really to understand that sutting
- 0:41shift and play calling and the high stakes thinking behind it.
- 0:43Because if you just watch the tape, the game started
- 0:46with unbelievable momentum for the Jets. Oh.
- 0:48Speaker 3: Absolutely. The sources we've got paint this picture of a
- 0:51perfect opening drive. It was textbook fourteen plays, seventy two
- 0:55yards and it ends with a touchdown run by Fields himself.
- 0:59But the key number, the really astonishing one, is that
- 1:01Fields rushed five times for twenty eight yards on that
- 1:04one drive alone.
- 1:05Speaker 1: Five times, five times.
- 1:07Speaker 2: I mean, that's basically treating your quarterback like an extra
- 1:09running back. It's aggressive, it works, it gets you a touchdown.
- 1:13But then, and this is where our whole deep dive begins.
- 1:16Right after that, those QB run plays just vanished.
- 1:20Speaker 1: They dissipated.
- 1:21Speaker 3: Yeah, the engine of the offense was just deliberately turned.
- 1:23Speaker 2: Off, and the result was, well, it was immediate, swift
- 1:26and devastating.
- 1:27Speaker 3: Really, after that first score, the Jets go three and
- 1:30out three times in a row. Suddenly the Patriots defense
- 1:35can just pin their ears back, they take control. Going
- 1:38from five QB runs to zero tells you a decision
- 1:41was made right there on the sideline.
- 1:42Speaker 2: Okay, So if you're the Jets and you're willing to
- 1:45just kill your own momentum like that, there has to
- 1:47be a very very good reason, and that takes us
- 1:50to co ch Aaron Glenn's defense of the decision after.
- 1:53Speaker 3: The game, right, and his whole justification was about longevity
- 1:57organizational thinking. He said, I'm quoting here that they don't
- 2:01want to make it a habit of their quarterback just
- 2:04continuing to run. Why because it puts him in harm's way,
- 2:08just like a running back.
- 2:09Speaker 1: But isn't that just part of the job managing risk?
- 2:12This feels different though.
- 2:14Speaker 2: It feels like the coaches are almost saying, we are
- 2:16okay with losing this game today. Yes, if it means
- 2:19Justin Fields is healthy for the.
- 2:21Speaker 3: Future, that is precisely the controversy. It's player health and
- 2:25the team's future versus maximizing your chance to win right now.
- 2:29Glenn's specific phrasing was, we just have to be calculated
- 2:32when we do those things. That tells you they know
- 2:35how powerful the runs are, but they see every single
- 2:38one as another tick on a risk counter.
- 2:40Speaker 2: And we know exactly why that risk assessment is so high.
- 2:43I mean, the sources point directly to Field's own injury
- 2:46history back when he was with Chicago. We're not just
- 2:48talking about the huge sax you see on the highlights.
- 2:51It's the accumulation of all those smaller routine hits exactly.
- 2:55Speaker 3: It's the death by a thousand cuts. The sources bring
- 2:58up a parallel a player like Jackson Dart to illustrate
- 3:01that if your offense relies on the quarterback taking hits,
- 3:04eventually injuries inevitable, shoulder, hamstring, concussion, you name it. Glenn
- 3:09seems completely unwilling to run what the source is called
- 3:12a military academy style offense.
- 3:14Speaker 2: Hold on, let's unpack that term. What do they mean
- 3:16by a military academy style offense.
- 3:19Speaker 3: It's basically an old school brute force ground game. I think,
- 3:24lots of Reid options, lots of QB power, runs right
- 3:27up the middle between the tackles. It's designed for the
- 3:30quarterback to take a constant stream of hits. It's aggressive
- 3:34and physical, and Glenn is basically saying, nope, we're not
- 3:37doing that. We won't intentionally put him in that position,
- 3:40even if his running.
- 3:41Speaker 2: Is his best trade, which is so interesting because it's
- 3:44a total contrast with Fields himself. I mean, he came
- 3:46out and said he's willing to do whatever it takes
- 3:48to win, and that includes running the ball.
- 3:50Speaker 3: And that's the tragic part of it, all right, the
- 3:52player's competitive fire versus the coach's mandate to protect the asset.
- 3:56But you know, this whole debate to run or not
- 3:59to run, it only really exists because the quarterback's primary
- 4:02job isn't being done at an elite level, and that
- 4:07brings us to the real root of the problem, the
- 4:09court inefficiency.
- 4:10Speaker 2: Okay, so let's get into the passing game. If his
- 4:12running is a crutch they're afraid to use, just how
- 4:14broken is the passing operation? What did the numbers from
- 4:17that Patriots game tell us?
- 4:19Speaker 3: Well, the stats are pretty damning, honestly for what you
- 4:22need to win in this league. Fields completed just fifteen
- 4:25of twenty six passes for only one hundred and sixteen
- 4:28yards in one touchdown. That's just it's a kneemic. You
- 4:31can't sustain drives with that kind of production.
- 4:33Speaker 1: And this wasn't just a one off bad game for him,
- 4:36was it not?
- 4:37Speaker 3: At all? Digging into the sources, that was the fifth
- 4:39time in nine games that his completion rate was below
- 4:42sixty percent, And the analysis is pretty harsh. It basically
- 4:45says his overall passing operation hasn't really improved much in
- 4:50his five years in the league.
- 4:51Speaker 1: What's the mechanical issue they're pointing to.
- 4:53Speaker 3: It's what happens when he has to stay in the pocket.
- 4:56The critique says, he often reverts to panicked feet and
- 4:59slow processing and when you have panic feet, your whole
- 5:03basis off. Your accuracy suffers, and slow processing means those
- 5:07tight NFL windows just slam shut before you can get
- 5:09the ball out.
- 5:10Speaker 2: So that inability to consistently win from the pocket is
- 5:12why they're so tempted to just let him run in
- 5:14the first place.
- 5:15Speaker 1: It's a cycle.
- 5:16Speaker 3: It's the entire dilemma.
- 5:17Speaker 2: Now. To be fair, coach Glenn did try to deflect
- 5:20some of that blame away from Fields. He mentioned some
- 5:22good throws that were dropped, and he even called out
- 5:24the wide out Adenai Mitchell specifically.
- 5:27Speaker 3: He definitely provided some cover. He said something like Fields
- 5:30put some balls out there and that they need other
- 5:31guys to make some plays for him too. But you know,
- 5:34when you zoom out from a few dropped passes and
- 5:36look at the whole picture, the low yardage, the sub
- 5:39sixty percent completion rate games, the conclusion from the sources
- 5:42is pretty clear. Those good things Field did were there, sure,
- 5:46but they were not enough to keep winning alive. The
- 5:49pattern of inefficiency is just too strong.
- 5:52Speaker 2: So we're stuck in this this impossible strategic bind. A
- 5:56quarterback who is an elite runner, but using that skill
- 6:00is seen as too dangerous by the coaching staff, and
- 6:02at the same time, his primary skill, his passing, is
- 6:06too inconsistent to win games on its own.
- 6:08Speaker 3: And that dichotomy, that stark contrast leads us right to
- 6:12the future of the organization.
- 6:14Speaker 2: Right And this is where it gets really interesting, because
- 6:17while all of this is happening on the Jets sideline,
- 6:20what was going on.
- 6:21Speaker 1: At the Patriots.
- 6:22Speaker 2: Their quarterback Drake May was and I quote, lighting up
- 6:26Glenn's defense with deft pocket movements and accurate darts.
- 6:31Speaker 1: It's just a painful side by side.
- 6:33Speaker 3: Yeah, the analyst couldn't ignore it. The source material says
- 6:36that dichotomy between the qbs couldn't be any more stark.
- 6:39And when you see a traditional effective pocket passer carve
- 6:42up your defense, well, it really underscores the idea that
- 6:46Fields is probably not the long term answer under center
- 6:50for the Jets.
- 6:50Speaker 1: That's a brutal assessment.
- 6:52Speaker 2: It's like the Jets are being shown the blueprint for
- 6:54what they want to be by their biggest rival, and
- 6:55it sounds like they're going to keep searching for their
- 6:58own Drake May next offseason and they want that traditional
- 7:01pocket passer for sure.
- 7:03Speaker 3: And all of this is happening in a pretty tough
- 7:05team context. Already, we should mention that their top receiver,
- 7:08Garrett Wilson, just went on injured reserve with a knee injury,
- 7:12so he's out for at least four games, which just
- 7:14makes Field's job even harder. Meanwhile, the Patriots are on
- 7:17an eight game winning streak. The gap is widening.
- 7:20Speaker 2: The analysis really sums it up by calling the Jets
- 7:22offense a square peg roundhole attack. They're trying to force
- 7:26this specialized player into a system he's just not built for.
- 7:29Speaker 3: That's it. That's the miscast. You're intentionally neutralizing his superpower,
- 7:33his legs out of fear. But the skill you want
- 7:36him to have, elite pocket passing, isn't consistent enough to
- 7:39win on its own.
- 7:40Speaker 1: So let's wrap this up.
- 7:41Speaker 2: The central tension is maximizing a unique skill set for
- 7:45a win today versus protecting that player for the long term.
- 7:48And we know coach Glenn is choosing protection even if
- 7:50it costs them games.
- 7:52Speaker 3: So if we build on that square peg round hole idea,
- 7:55it leaves you with a really tough question for the
- 7:57Jets coaching staff. If you refuse to run that aggressive
- 8:00smash mouth offense that risks hits, but you need his
- 8:05running to even be competitive. What do you do? What
- 8:08tactical changes can you make right now?
- 8:10Speaker 2: Is there a middle ground? I mean, if you can't
- 8:12run them up in the middle like a full back,
- 8:14can you at least design plays that get them to
- 8:16the edge, bootlegs options, something to minimize those direct hits.
- 8:21Speaker 3: That's the sweet spot they have to find. There's a
- 8:23huge difference between a QB power play, which is an
- 8:25invitation for a linebacker to light you up, and a
- 8:28designed bootleg. A bootleg uses the threat of his running
- 8:31to freeze defenders and open up passing lanes. You're using
- 8:34his legs defensively in a way to create offense elsewhere.
- 8:37If they can't figure out that tactical nuance, that square
- 8:40peg is just going to stay stuck.
- 8:42Speaker 2: And that's really the big question to think about as
- 8:44you watch these teams. Is the dual threat quarterback ultimately
- 8:47a concept that's just too risky for an organization to
- 8:49fully commit to. Or can smart play calling find that
- 8:53perfect balance between talent and risk.
- 8:56Speaker 3: It's a fascinating strategic problem. We definitely encourage you to
- 8:59keep it. Eyes on how these teams navigate it.
- 9:02Speaker 1: Thanks for diving deep with us. We'll catch you on
- 9:04the next one.