Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Private Tech Companies Are Buying Back Employee Shares Before IPO
Transcript
- Lucas: So it's June 3rd, 2026, and I want to talk about something that's quietly reshaping the path to an IPO for dozens of major private tech companies. Over the last twelve months, we've seen over twenty billion dollars in employee tender offers from companies like Stripe, Databricks, and OpenAI — buying back shares from staff years before any public listing. Luna: That's a huge number. And it's not just a few outliers, right? I've been tracking secondary volumes and they've hit records this year. Lucas: Exactly. Private markets are now valued at over five trillion dollars globally. And with that scale, companies are realizing they can't ask employees to wait seven to ten years for liquidity. So they're creating it themselves. Luna: Let's zero in on Stripe. Their August 2025 tender valued shares at ninety-seven dollars each. That's essentially a public price set two years early. Lucas: Right. And that price became a benchmark. When Stripe eventually does list, that ninety-seven dollar number will be in every analyst's model. It creates a reference point that didn't exist five years ago. Luna: But doesn't that take some of the air out of the traditional IPO pop? If insiders have already cashed out at a fair price, the first-day spike might be muted. Lucas: That's the big question. Historically, the IPO pop was compensation for illiquidity risk. If that risk is removed through tender offers, the pop shrinks. We saw hints of this with Palantir — they did direct listing with heavy secondary sales. Palantir's currently at one hundred forty-two dollars, down point-nine percent on the week, but it's been a volatile ride. Luna: And speaking of volatility, look at the ARKK Innovation ETF at seventy-eight dollars. That's down three point six percent in five days. The public market for tech is choppy right now. Lucas: Which reinforces why companies are doing these tenders. If you're a founder watching ARKK drop, you're thinking: 'My employees would rather have cash today than wait for an uncertain public debut.' That psychology is driving a lot of these decisions. Luna: Let's talk about the mechanics. How do these tenders work in practice? Lucas: Typically, the company partners with a secondary market platform like Forge or SharesPost. They set a valuation — either based on the last funding round or an independent appraisal. Then employees can sell a portion of their vested shares — often up to twenty or thirty percent. The company or a group of investors buys them. Luna: And the company isn't raising new capital. It's spending cash to buy shares. That's a different use of capital than we're used to seeing. Lucas: Exactly. And it signals confidence. If a company is willing to deploy its own cash to buy shares at a certain price, they're telling the market 'we believe this valuation is real.' Databricks did a three billion dollar tender in April of this year. That's a massive vote of confidence. Luna: But it also puts pressure on the company to keep growing into that valuation. If they buy at a high price and then the next funding round is lower, you've got problems. Lucas: Absolutely. Down rounds are toxic when you've committed to a tender price. So companies are getting more disciplined about when they do these. They want to be close to profitability or have clear line of sight to a public listing. Luna: OpenAI is a fascinating case. They did a tender last year that valued the company at around eighty billion. But they're structured as a capped-profit entity. How does that affect the equation? Lucas: That's the wild card. OpenAI's tender was mostly for early employees and investors to get some liquidity, but the cap on returns means the upside for later buyers is limited. It's almost like a hybrid model — part charity, part venture. Luna: So we're seeing a spectrum of liquidity approaches. On one end, companies that go public early with tiny tenders. On the other, companies that delay IPOs for years but offer multiple tender rounds. Lucas: And the middle ground is getting crowded. I think what we're witnessing is the maturation of the private market. It's no longer a binary choice: either stay private and illiquid, or go public and have liquidity. There's now a third path. Luna: What does this mean for the retail investor who's waiting for the next big tech IPO? Because they can't participate in these tenders. Lucas: It means the IPO itself may be less of a windfall. The big gains might have already happened in the secondary market. Retail investors need to adjust expectations. The days of buying the IPO and tripling your money in a month — those are probably behind us for large tech names. Luna: Unless you're investing in the secondary market through funds that have access. But that's still limited to accredited investors. Lucas: Right. And that's a structural issue. The SEC is looking at expanding access, but for now, it's still largely an institutional game. Which brings us back to why these conversations matter — especially for what you're building or running. Luna: Yeah. And speaking of that — a quick honest thing. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many of these. No ads, no sponsors, just listener support. Lucas: It's true. And we're grateful for every contribution. It keeps the show independent and allows us to dig into topics like this without commercial constraints. Luna: So if you find these episodes useful for your work or investments, consider joining that group. And now back to the liquidity landscape. Lucas: So one company that's taking a different approach is SpaceX. We've talked about their water access as an IPO risk factor before. But they've also been running regular tender offers for employees — the latest at around one hundred eighty billion valuation. Luna: Right. And SpaceX has no immediate plans to go public. So these tenders are essentially a permanent feature of their equity compensation. Lucas: Exactly. And that sets a precedent. If a company as capital-intensive as SpaceX can offer liquidity without going public, then many others can too. I think we'll see more large private companies adopt this as standard practice. Luna: Let's talk about the risks for employees. If you sell in a tender, you're locking in gains but also giving up potential upside. With Stripe at ninety-seven, some employees who sold may have missed out if the IPO prices higher. Lucas: That's the classic trade-off. But most employees are under-diversified. They have their salary and equity tied to one company. Selling some shares in a tender is often smart risk management. The bigger risk is holding everything and the company falters. Luna: And we've seen companies falter. WeWork, for example. Employees who held through the crash lost everything. Lucas: Exactly. So I think these tenders are actually a healthy development. They allow employees to de-risk while the company retains its private status. And for the company, it's a retention tool — if you know you can get liquidity every couple of years, you might stay longer. Luna: That's a good point. It changes the calculus for talent. Especially in AI, where competition for engineers is fierce. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's one reason OpenAI and Anthropic are doing these. They need to keep their top researchers happy. Anthropic raised sixty-five billion earlier this year — a huge round — but they also did a tender to give early employees an exit. Luna: So where does this leave the traditional IPO? Is it dying? Lucas: I don't think it's dying, but it's becoming less central. IPOs will still happen for companies that need a public currency for acquisitions or want to raise large amounts of capital. But the IPO is no longer the only liquidity event. For many employees, the tender is the real liquidity event. Luna: And for investors, the IPO is just another step, not the finish line. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a fundamental shift in how we think about the journey from startup to public company. It's less of a transformation and more of a gradual process. Luna: Alright, I think we've covered a lot. Let's leave listeners with one concrete thing to watch for. Lucas: Watch the secondary market volumes. If they continue to grow, it means private companies are providing liquidity at scale. That's a signal that the IPO calendar may stay light, but the private market will keep humming. Luna: And for retail investors, look at the companies doing these tenders. If a company like Stripe is buying at ninety-seven, that's a data point you can use when they eventually go public. Lucas: Good note. Thanks, Luna. Luna: Thanks, Lucas.