Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Regulating the AI Boom: California Passes a New Package of Laws that Change the Game for Data Center Development
Transcript
- 0:03Hi, everybody. I'm Mark Hoag, chair of the Beverly
- 0:06Hills Bar Association's AI in the Law section,
- 0:08along with my co -chair, Amanda Harris. And I'm
- 0:11the founder of Axiomac LLC, an AI -first web
- 0:14and iOS app development studio. And for my day
- 0:17job, I do run hoagelaw .ai, where I serve as
- 0:21fractional general counsel to AI -first tech
- 0:25startups and companies. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:27our speakers today, Edgar Kalatian and Neda Marou.
- 0:32So Edgar is a partner in Mayor Brown's LA office,
- 0:35where he leads the firm's land use practice group
- 0:38and advises investors and developers through
- 0:41every stage of the real estate entitlement and
- 0:43development process. He guides clients through
- 0:46state and local regulations, government outreach,
- 0:48and CECA compliance on major projects, including
- 0:50the Capitol Records building in Hollywood, the
- 0:53Reef Broadway Square in downtown LA, and Harvard
- 0:55Westlake's River Park campus. Legal 500 USA has
- 0:59called him, hands down, the best land use attorney
- 1:02in the world. No, in LA at least. We'll get to
- 1:05the world later. Neda Maharoo is a partner in
- 1:08Mayor Brown's LA office as well, where she represents
- 1:11commercial and residential developers and businesses
- 1:14and land use entitlements, planning and zoning,
- 1:16and related environmental litigation, including
- 1:18CECA compliance. And with nearly a decade of
- 1:21experience spanning CECA, the Subdivision Map
- 1:23Act, and state housing law. She handles entitlement
- 1:26work for clients such as Avalon Bay Communities,
- 1:29The Post Group, and Hilton Los Angeles Universal
- 1:31City. She previously practiced land use and litigation
- 1:35at an Orange County real estate firm, completed
- 1:37a fellowship at the San Diego City Attorney's
- 1:40Office, and served on the editorial board of
- 1:43the California Land Use Law and Policy Reporter.
- 1:46And now, let's get started. Take it away. Thank
- 1:49you, guys. Great. Thank you for that introduction,
- 1:54Mark. Good afternoon, and thank you all for joining
- 1:58us for today's CLE regarding California's new
- 2:03data center legislation package. As Mark mentioned,
- 2:08my name is Netta Marrou. I am a partner at Mayor
- 2:12Brown's Los Angeles office practicing land use.
- 2:17And my name is Edgar Kaladian. I work for NETA,
- 2:22and our practice is essentially ever -evolving.
- 2:26We will represent developers of anything, and
- 2:29in particular, data centers and a lot of different
- 2:31renewable energy clients from A to Z, putting
- 2:35an appropriate team together. And for data centers,
- 2:38that's frankly very relevant, all the way through
- 2:41local, state, federal permitting. And in the
- 2:45unforeseen or unfortunate scenario when there's
- 2:47litigation, we also handle the litigation. By
- 2:53now, just about everyone has an opinion on data
- 2:56centers. And this land use has obviously become
- 2:59one of the most controversial types of development
- 3:02on a local, state, and national scale. I can't
- 3:05remember the last time or the... the last land
- 3:09use issue where the president had an opinion
- 3:13on it. And anybody that watches the news or social
- 3:15media knows President Trump has a lot of ideas
- 3:18and thoughts on data centers. As the AI arms
- 3:22race rages on, there's a spotlight on data center
- 3:25development, which provides the integral physical
- 3:28infrastructure needed to power AI development.
- 3:34Now for the policy backdrop, the US is home to
- 3:38the highest number of data centers in the world.
- 3:41And the data center and AI infrastructure sector
- 3:43is experiencing some of the fastest growth and
- 3:46largest capital deployment than any other modern
- 3:50industry. And for reasons we'll talk about later,
- 3:53ensuring that the US continues to dominate the
- 3:57data center and AI world is important for many,
- 4:00many reasons. This rapid growth has been accompanied
- 4:04by growing concerns about the downstream impacts
- 4:07that data centers could create for many aspects
- 4:11of everyday lives, including environmental impacts
- 4:14such as water and electrical use. For example,
- 4:18data centers consumed about four and a half percent
- 4:21of total U .S. electricity in 2023. and that
- 4:25number is expected to jump to approximately 7
- 4:29to 12 percent by 2028. States like California
- 4:34that are trying to become exclusively reliant
- 4:37on renewable green power, this presents a potential
- 4:40obstacle. As to water, California researchers
- 4:44estimate that statewide on -site data center
- 4:46water consumption will balloon from about 350
- 4:50million gallons of water in 2019 to about one
- 4:55and 1 .7 billion gallons by 2028. And regardless
- 4:59of the amount of rain we're going to be getting
- 5:01in Los Angeles today, that is not enough. These
- 5:06concerns have thrown communities into a panic,
- 5:09understandably, with many jurisdictions throughout
- 5:12the state adopting moratoria that outright ban
- 5:15data center development. That's where we believe
- 5:18the concern lies. For example, Los Angeles County,
- 5:21which includes 88 individual cities, including
- 5:24the city of Los Angeles, recently imposed a temporary
- 5:28ban on data center development while it studies
- 5:31a zoning amendment that would theoretically prohibit
- 5:34large scale data centers throughout the unincorporated
- 5:38parts of the entire county. Notably, LA County
- 5:43is also studying revisions to its renewable energy
- 5:47ordinance, which could further restrict energy
- 5:49intensive development in the region. In San Francisco,
- 5:54home to the booming AI industry, is the most
- 5:58recent city in the state to pass a moratorium
- 6:01that temporarily halts data center development
- 6:04until the city can study the impacts closer and
- 6:08develop local controls. Given that data centers
- 6:11have become such a hot topic, particularly in
- 6:14the political world as we approach elections,
- 6:18Governor Gavin Newsom just signed a package of
- 6:20seven bills into law last month that will take
- 6:24effect on January 1st that seek to strengthen
- 6:27California's regulations of data center development.
- 6:31And I want to go back to where we started a few
- 6:33moments ago about this being a land use where
- 6:36the president has even opined. There are international
- 6:43implications, national security implications
- 6:47of the data center world and the AI world. Experts
- 6:51can disagree what will happen if the US loses
- 6:55the AI war, presumably meaning China wins the
- 6:58AI war and what that actually means from day
- 7:01-to -day perspective. But needless to say, it
- 7:04is very important some would say crucial for
- 7:08the U .S. to continue to dominate the market.
- 7:12And we believe, we're confident that the reason,
- 7:17the justification for most of this legislation,
- 7:19most of the moratoria are based on ill -informed
- 7:23false narratives that are pervasive through social
- 7:29media and the mainstream media has picked up.
- 7:32And for those who follow this industry very closely,
- 7:36like Neda and I do, Kevin O 'Leary of Shark Tank,
- 7:41you know, spent significant revenue, significant
- 7:43dollars in time, looking into where the hostility
- 7:48and the opposition comes from. So I'll say as
- 7:51land use lawyers with almost 50 years of combined
- 7:53experience, we've never seen a land use have
- 7:57such aggressive, frankly, intelligent opposition
- 8:04that pops up very quickly as data centers. And
- 8:09Kevin O 'Leary's conclusion, which has been supported
- 8:12by many other experts, is the opposition actually
- 8:15comes from the Chinese government and through
- 8:18social media and false information. which we
- 8:22think is really important. And frankly, there
- 8:24are a lot of interests that are looking into
- 8:27the background there. And then we'll get into
- 8:29this a little bit later in our presentation.
- 8:36Data centers, as Edgar was just mentioning, have
- 8:40become a divisive political topic on both sides
- 8:44of the aisle. In signing this particular legislative
- 8:48package, Governor Newsom specifically called
- 8:51out the Trump administration's move towards deregulation.
- 8:56As you might know, President Trump is a strong
- 8:59supporter of rapid data center expansion, and
- 9:03he'd use them as a critical national secure a
- 9:07critical national priority to win the AI race
- 9:11against China. Governor Newsom has gone in a
- 9:15different direction. He's referred to this package
- 9:19of bills as the most comprehensive data center
- 9:22laws in the nation, and has said that these California
- 9:26data center bills lay the groundwork for a stronger
- 9:31approach. that prevents working families in the
- 9:34state from shouldering the costs of data center
- 9:37development. He has expressed that these laws
- 9:41will ensure that those profiting from data centers
- 9:44aren't doing so at the expense of Californians.
- 9:50According to the governor, These laws are meant
- 9:52to give the people more information about energy,
- 9:56water, and land use related to proposed data
- 10:00centers, so people can better weigh the economic
- 10:03costs and benefits of data center projects in
- 10:06their communities. And of course, it has nothing
- 10:08to do with polling for a likely presidential
- 10:11run. Right. It is interesting timing. But for
- 10:19today's presentation, we're going to walk through
- 10:22each of the seven new bills, and we've grouped
- 10:25them generally together into three categories,
- 10:29environmental review, transparency and reporting,
- 10:33and tariffs and rate payer protection. So one
- 10:38threshold point before we dive in, several of
- 10:42these bills use a common definition of data center.
- 10:46And generally that is defined the same in each
- 10:50bill as a facility or part of a facility that
- 10:54houses computing infrastructure, including graphics
- 10:58and central processing units, servers, storage
- 11:02devices, networking equipment, and associated
- 11:06power and cooling systems for the primary purpose
- 11:10of processing, storing, or distributing electronic
- 11:15data. So it is a broad definition that's meant
- 11:18to capture all the uses involved with a data
- 11:22center facility. Now, you should keep an eye
- 11:27on the various caveats layered into each of these
- 11:31bills. For example, some apply to data center
- 11:35facilities with more than 10 megawatts of electrical
- 11:39capacity, whereas there are others that do not
- 11:42apply. to publicly owned or funded facilities
- 11:46or research facilities. So these new bills do
- 11:52not just apply in a blanket way to all data centers.
- 11:57You should also keep in mind though that local
- 12:00zoning regulations can also have different definitions
- 12:04for these types of uses. A data center can be
- 12:09defined in different ways based on each jurisdiction.
- 12:13So it is important to line up all these terms
- 12:16and classifications. And also keep in mind, with
- 12:23any new legislation, there will inevitably be
- 12:26many unanswered questions as the implementation
- 12:30process begins. And it doesn't help that many
- 12:35of the key provisions in each of these bills
- 12:39delegate significant authority to the California
- 12:43Public Utilities Commission, the California Energy
- 12:46Commission, and the Office of Land Use and Climate
- 12:49Innovation, which is previously known as the
- 12:52Office of Planning and Research. These regulatory
- 12:57agencies are going to be responsible for implementing
- 13:01regulations, methodologies, and standards. So
- 13:05the details of this legislative package will
- 13:08continue to evolve over time. And anybody that
- 13:12knows anything about the state bureaucracy, these
- 13:15agencies will, in our opinion, try to take as
- 13:22conservative regulatory interpretation as they
- 13:26can. So it is incumbent on the industry to keep
- 13:32an eye out on these interpretations on and they're
- 13:36always released in draft with an opportunity
- 13:39to opine and sort of consistent with the U .S.
- 13:42Supreme Court's decision in Chevron. I think
- 13:44the industry needs to be very careful to not
- 13:46allow the bureaucracy to make these bills, frankly,
- 13:51more than they already are. So we will start
- 13:58now with the first category. We were mentioning
- 14:01environmental review and The first bill that
- 14:05we will discuss today is SB 887 by Senator Padilla.
- 14:11This is likely the most significant bill for
- 14:15land use and environmental attorneys because
- 14:17it eliminates categorical exemptions that previously
- 14:22insulated certain data center projects from review
- 14:26under the California Environmental Quality Act
- 14:29or CEQA. To put this simply, it means that all
- 14:35data center projects in California are now subject
- 14:38to CEQA. In other words, every data center project
- 14:43proposed in California beginning January 1st,
- 14:462027, will require at a minimum an initial study
- 14:51and either a full environmental impact report,
- 14:56a negative declaration, or a mitigated negative
- 14:59declaration. So that was a lot of words right
- 15:03there. For those of you who may not be familiar
- 15:07with Sequa, here's a super high level summary
- 15:11of this very complicated environmental statue.
- 15:17Sequa is a landmark. a piece of California legislation
- 15:21that requires most discretionary development
- 15:25projects to undergo some level of environmental
- 15:29review to study the project's potential environmental
- 15:33impacts. And CEQA is meant to be an informational
- 15:37statue with the goal being to inform the public
- 15:41and decision makers about a project's impacts
- 15:45to the environment. Now, This environmental review
- 15:49process can be very rigorous and time consuming
- 15:53because it involves many different study areas
- 15:57related to the environment. For example, air
- 16:00quality, greenhouse gas emissions, noise, electricity
- 16:06and water usage, transportation impacts. Those
- 16:10are just a few. There are several other categories
- 16:13that are studied when reviewing a project under
- 16:17CEQA. If the environmental review identifies
- 16:21a potentially significant environmental impact,
- 16:25the project is required to mitigate that impact
- 16:29to the extent feasible, which involves adopting
- 16:33and implementing mitigation measures to reduce
- 16:36the significant impact. Now, one way to avoid
- 16:43all this extensive environmental review is if
- 16:46a project falls within a CEQA exemption. Up until
- 16:50now, certain data center projects have been able
- 16:53to avoid the CEQA process altogether by qualifying
- 16:58for a CEQA exemption. So SB 887 was specifically
- 17:05drafted to eliminate the possibility that data
- 17:08center projects could find a workaround from
- 17:11CEQA. And the legislation explicitly says, a
- 17:17project proposed to be carried out or approved
- 17:19by a public agency in furtherance of the development
- 17:23and operation of a data center shall not be exempted
- 17:27from CEQA. So I mentioned a bit earlier that
- 17:32CEQA is meant as an informational statue and
- 17:36the reason for requiring CEQA review for data
- 17:40center projects is so that the public and approval
- 17:45bodies fully understand and evaluate a project's
- 17:50potential implications for the environment, particularly
- 17:54because data centers can consume significant
- 17:58amounts of electricity, energy, and water resources.
- 18:04If your practice doesn't deal with land use development,
- 18:08let me add a bit. I know, as if the CEQA wasn't
- 18:13enough. If your practice doesn't deal with land
- 18:18use development, you might still be wondering
- 18:21why this bill matters from a practical standpoint.
- 18:25So let me add a bit more color. First, I mentioned
- 18:30earlier that CEQA involves some level of environmental
- 18:34review of various topic areas. And this process
- 18:38involves multiple technical studies analyzing
- 18:42noise, water usage, traffic counts. It also,
- 18:49the CEQA process involves public circulation
- 18:53of the environmental document and public hearings.
- 18:58All of this adds significant time and cost to
- 19:03the project entitlement process. But perhaps
- 19:07more importantly, from a practical perspective
- 19:10is the fact that project opponents regularly
- 19:14use CEQA as a tool, a strategic tool, to challenge
- 19:19project approvals, which can result in further
- 19:22delay because imagine you've gone through this
- 19:25entire entitlement process, you've done all of
- 19:28this environmental review, had all these studies,
- 19:30public hearings, and gotten the local government
- 19:34to approve your project, but then, a project
- 19:38opponent files a SQL lawsuit. So now, after all
- 19:42of that, you have to go through lengthy and costly
- 19:45litigation. So you can imagine why qualifying
- 19:50for an exemption, an exemption from the SQL review
- 19:54process is a game changer for any project, particularly
- 19:59increasingly controversial projects like data
- 20:02centers. Now, SB 887 introduces a discretionary
- 20:10element to the land use review process for all
- 20:13data center projects, even if the local zoning
- 20:17allowed the data center use by right. So this
- 20:21legislation now closes a pathway that previously
- 20:25allowed certain projects to proceed ministerially
- 20:28without any environmental CEQA analysis or public
- 20:32hearings. What is... paradoxical about this is
- 20:38that the governor's press release touted this
- 20:42legislative package as putting local communities
- 20:45in the driver's seat by giving them more control
- 20:48when it comes to data centers. But really that
- 20:52premise is flawed because it overlooks the fact
- 20:57that a bill such as SB 887 actually takes away
- 21:02local control from decision makers. because it
- 21:05limits their ability to approve projects how
- 21:09they want to under their zoning rules. For example,
- 21:14believe it or not, there are some jurisdictions
- 21:16that actually welcome data centers and want them
- 21:20in their cities, and they've created zoning rules
- 21:24that allow a data center use by right in certain
- 21:28industrial areas of the city. But now these jurisdictions
- 21:32are forced to go through a discretionary process
- 21:35to approve those projects under SB 887. And just
- 21:40putting a little bit of practical, more practical
- 21:43to this, why the legislation was introduced.
- 21:47There was Imperial County, which is near San
- 21:50Diego, allowed data centers ministerially. They
- 21:54had no issues and were fully supportive of the
- 21:57development. Some individuals local municipalities
- 22:02objected and Senator Padilla Reached out to Imperial
- 22:07County asking for analyses and questions and
- 22:12frankly from from what we can tell The county
- 22:15just ignored the senators requests and after
- 22:19a number of failed attempts to get answers the
- 22:24senator simply introduced this legislation to
- 22:28to trump the local control and said, fine, you
- 22:32think you can approve data centers ministerially?
- 22:35Well, you no longer can. So it really stemmed,
- 22:39frankly, from a particular jurisdiction getting
- 22:42into a fight with the senator and the politics
- 22:49were timely enough where the legislation was
- 22:53enacted. While SB 887 requires CEQA review for
- 22:59data center projects, it also opens a new door,
- 23:02certification as an environmental leadership
- 23:06development project, or ELDP for short. Again,
- 23:10for those who are not familiar with this concept,
- 23:13ELDP is a California program that streamlines
- 23:17judicial review processes for certain projects
- 23:20that the governor certifies as eligible. Since
- 23:24SQL litigation can be extremely time consuming,
- 23:28ELDP certification can be a valuable tool to
- 23:32reduce delay because if an action is filed against
- 23:36a project's approval, ELDP certification shortens
- 23:40the trial. and appellate, including the Supreme
- 23:43Court, review process to approximately 270 days
- 23:47if a sequel lawsuit is filed. Now, ELDP has been
- 23:51around in other forms for many, many years. And
- 23:55we've had a lot of multifamily mixed use projects
- 23:58obtain certification from the governor at ELDP
- 24:02that we've ultimately litigated. Courts have
- 24:05not met the 270 -day threshold, which is why
- 24:08I refer to it as approximate. Generally, the
- 24:12timeline is 13 to 15 months, which for those
- 24:15who litigate in California know to get through
- 24:17trial appellate court on an administrative record
- 24:20is pretty quick. But qualifying as an ELDP project
- 24:25is not easy, shocking, because it involves meeting
- 24:29several requirements to ensure that the project
- 24:31demonstrates environmental excellence and generates
- 24:34a significant amount of revenue and jobs for
- 24:37California. For example, ELDP certification requires
- 24:43the project to result in a minimum investment
- 24:46of $100 million in California upon completion
- 24:51and construction. Probably not an issue for most
- 24:55data centers. But the project must also create
- 24:59highly skilled jobs and pay workers prevailing
- 25:02wage. Said differently, you need a project labor
- 25:05agreement with the construction trades to be
- 25:09eligible for ELDP certification. In addition,
- 25:13for a data center to qualify for ELDP certification,
- 25:17the project must also check a number of boxes,
- 25:21including the fact that the project must pay
- 25:24the full cost of interconnection in advance.
- 25:28to prevent cost shifting to rate payers and must
- 25:32commit to fully pay for all electrical grid investments,
- 25:36including costs of new generating capacity that
- 25:39is needed to serve the data center. The commitment
- 25:42must include an early termination fee if the
- 25:45data center closes before costs are fully recovered.
- 25:50The project must show that it will not increase
- 25:52fossil fuel consumption and includes zero carbon
- 25:56energy storage with at least four hours of capacity
- 26:00at 100 % of forecasted peak demand for the facility.
- 26:06The project must use on -site zero carbon energy
- 26:10storage to provide demand response services to
- 26:13the electrical grid and is also required to rely
- 26:18on zero carbon generation located behind the
- 26:21meter to the maximum extent feasible, a lawyer's
- 26:25favorite term. The project must also rely on
- 26:29100 % zero carbon electricity resources to serve
- 26:34hourly energy needs within five years of initial
- 26:37operations, of which 75 % must be newly developed.
- 26:43Of course, the legislation does not say what
- 26:46happens in year five or year six if this test
- 26:49is not met. The project must use recycled water
- 26:53and water -efficient technology, or waterless
- 26:56cooling systems. Finally, the project must also
- 27:00enter into at least one legally binding and enforceable
- 27:04community benefits agreement with community -based
- 27:07organizations, such as workforce development
- 27:10and training organizations, labor organizations,
- 27:13community foundations, local government entities,
- 27:15or Native American tribes. As you can see, it
- 27:19takes a lot to... qualify for ELTP certification.
- 27:23So while certification provides an applicant
- 27:25with certainty that litigation filed will be
- 27:29resolved quicker than not, the costs are significant.
- 27:33And while we have not really costed most of these
- 27:37out, and obviously every different data center
- 27:40project, depending on location and jurisdiction,
- 27:43will have different impacts, we suspect that
- 27:46the costs of going through in the LDP certification
- 27:51and meeting these requirements is not going to
- 27:54make financial sense as opposed to lengthening
- 27:58the litigation process by about six to nine months.
- 28:04Right, so it was kind of a carrot and a stick
- 28:06with SB 887, but the carrot is very hard to achieve.
- 28:13That's certainly reflective of the California
- 28:15legislation. Okay, so next we're going to cover
- 28:21three bills that generally deal with transparency
- 28:25and reporting. This category of bills aims to
- 28:30provide the public, local governments, and utility
- 28:33providers with more information about data center
- 28:36operations. Data centers have historically operated
- 28:41somewhat under a cloak of darkness. After all,
- 28:46The entire operation is built around data, which
- 28:51requires the highest level of privacy and protection.
- 28:56But this lack of information about data center
- 28:59operations could actually be what's driving a
- 29:03lot of the misinformation that Edgar was alluding
- 29:06to earlier about the data center industry. For
- 29:10example, people generally voice concerns that
- 29:13data centers will dramatically increase electricity
- 29:17demands, strain local water supplies, and destroy
- 29:21communities. That narrative gets perpetuated
- 29:24because there isn't a lot of readily available
- 29:27and accurate information out there about the
- 29:31true nature of data center operations. So as
- 29:35you'll see, these three bills undoubtedly seek
- 29:38to address these concerns that data center growth
- 29:42has created increasing demand for energy and
- 29:45water resources, which creates a rippling implication
- 29:50for statewide sustainability goals. These three
- 29:54bills in this category are AB 1577, AB 2469,
- 30:00and AB 2619. AB 1577 authored by Assemblymember
- 30:10Barak Kehan can be best described as a transparency
- 30:14bill that requires data centers to submit energy
- 30:18usage information at the state and local levels.
- 30:21At the local level, data center owners and operators
- 30:26are required to submit specific information to
- 30:30the local government when they apply for a discretionary
- 30:33permit, an entitlement, or land use authorization
- 30:37to construct or operate a data center. This information
- 30:41includes expected annual energy consumption,
- 30:46expected annual quantity of electricity generated
- 30:49on site, including both behind the meter primary
- 30:52and backup power generation, as well as expected
- 30:56average and maximum noise levels generated by
- 31:00the facility. measured at the point along the
- 31:02property boundary where the average sound level
- 31:05is expected to be the highest. Of note, the local
- 31:09agency can use this information during the project
- 31:12review and approval process for various purposes,
- 31:16including land use and entitlement planning,
- 31:19infrastructure planning, and environmental reviews
- 31:21such as CEQA that Netta talked about earlier.
- 31:25At the state level, AV1577 requires larger data
- 31:29center owners, operators, those with an electrical
- 31:32capacity of at least 10 megawatts, to report
- 31:35detailed energy usage and efficiency information
- 31:38to the California Energy Commission. In addition
- 31:41to standard information about the data center,
- 31:45such as name, address, size, and so forth, the
- 31:47following data must be submitted to the CEC upon
- 31:51energization of the facility. Anticipate electrical
- 31:56peak capacity and anticipated quantity of electricity
- 32:00generated and consumed on site. Then following
- 32:05energization, the data center must submit information
- 32:08to the CEC annually, which includes maximum electrical
- 32:12load, total energy consumption and power usage
- 32:15effectiveness, refrigerant types used to cool
- 32:19equipment, and cumulative cooling degree days
- 32:22and whether the facility participated in any
- 32:25demand flexibility programs and the level of
- 32:28participation. Putting a practical twist to this,
- 32:31providing this information is probably not significant
- 32:35undertaking for most data center operators, but
- 32:39I am very, very confident based on years of dealing
- 32:42with this, there will be nobody at the CEC that
- 32:45really knows what to do with this information.
- 32:49The state budget is a mess, and that's certainly
- 32:51not an attack on anybody at CDC, but the state
- 32:54budget is a mess. State departments are extremely
- 32:59understaffed, and there is no funding mechanism
- 33:02in these bills to hire trained staff to have
- 33:05this information. So data center operators are
- 33:08going to collect and provide the CDC with the
- 33:11information, but the likelihood is the state
- 33:14will not be able to do anything with it. AB1577
- 33:18also requires the CEC not only to establish the
- 33:22process for collecting this information from
- 33:24data centers, but it must also create a process
- 33:27to annually publish the information collected
- 33:30in an anonymized and aggregated format. I am
- 33:33willing to wager that that will never happen.
- 33:37It's important to note that customer data...
- 33:39will be protected in similar manner with similar
- 33:44exemptions that are available under the California
- 33:46Public Records Act. So the legislature at least
- 33:49understood the importance both from a proprietary
- 33:53perspective but also from a security perspective
- 33:56of keeping the information confidential. Finally,
- 34:01starting in 2029, the Integrated Energy Policy
- 34:04Report issued by the CEC must include an assessment
- 34:09of electrical load trends for data centers, including
- 34:12a projection of future load trends, potential
- 34:15net peak load demands, and recommendations for
- 34:18mitigating data center electricity consumption
- 34:21impacts on grid reliability, which frankly is
- 34:25a great thing. Next is AB 2469 by Assemblymember
- 34:34Papin. which entails extensive water use disclosures
- 34:39at the local approval level. This bill prohibits
- 34:43a local agency from approving construction of
- 34:47a new data center project or expansion of an
- 34:50existing facility unless the applicant provides
- 34:54a water supply assessment and a water scarcity
- 34:57plan. So, under existing law, water supply assessments
- 35:02are required for certain types of development
- 35:05projects, such as large residential projects
- 35:09with more than 500 dwelling units, commercial
- 35:12or office projects with at least 1 ,000 employees,
- 35:18and retail projects with more than 500 ,000 square
- 35:22feet of floor area. These are very large projects.
- 35:27And the idea is to understand how much water
- 35:31is going to be needed to serve the project. So
- 35:36specifically, the purpose of the water supply
- 35:38assessment is to evaluate whether the public
- 35:41water system can handle the projected water demand
- 35:45generated by the project during normal, single,
- 35:50dry, and multiple dry years over a 20 year horizon.
- 35:56In addition to the water supply assessment, a
- 35:59water scarcity plan is also required which has
- 36:03to address various drought conditions including
- 36:07staged withdrawal reductions, curtailing non
- 36:11-essential uses, and water recycling and reuse
- 36:15strategies. Data center operators and their water
- 36:20scarcity plan must also distinguish between consumptive
- 36:24water uses, like evaporative cooling, where the
- 36:27water is lost to the environment, and non -consumptive
- 36:31uses, which is where water is returned back to
- 36:35the source. Separate from these required water
- 36:40plans, AB 2469 also requires a data center applicant
- 36:45to assume the full cost of any required water
- 36:49conveyance treatment or storage or distribution
- 36:54infrastructure improvements that are necessary
- 36:57to serve the project. Now this is very important
- 37:01because data centers need a reliable water supply
- 37:05and infrastructure costs are key due to the what's
- 37:09known as the peaking factor for data centers
- 37:12which is the factor of peak use over average
- 37:17use. And this can be double or more for data
- 37:21center projects than the peaking factor for other
- 37:25large water users. So depending on the type of
- 37:31equipment and technology used, data centers can
- 37:35have substantial demand for cooling water. The
- 37:39high peaks happen because data centers need to
- 37:42shift. to evaporative cooling, to exhaust heat
- 37:46during hot and dry weather conditions, or they
- 37:51need to use more water to remove heat. Shifting
- 37:55between these cooling technologies can create
- 37:58large surges in demand that need to be accommodated
- 38:02by water distribution infrastructure, even if
- 38:06the average water demand is much lower. In addition
- 38:12to these water -related provisions, AB 2469 also
- 38:18requires a data center applicant to provide information
- 38:22regarding its workforce needs, which is interesting,
- 38:27including information such as job classifications,
- 38:31employment duration, wage ranges and benefits,
- 38:35and even where the workforce would reside. whether
- 38:38they would be within the county where the project
- 38:41is located and also within the state generally.
- 38:46This actually represents the first instance in
- 38:50California law where workforce transparency is
- 38:54being tied to the data center permitting process.
- 38:58I would say to any land just permitting process.
- 39:02But again, it's obvious that that is language
- 39:06that was demanded and included to appease organized
- 39:11labor. The next statue, AB 2619, was also introduced
- 39:16by assembly member Poppin, and it's very similar
- 39:19to a bill that Governor Newsom vetoed just last
- 39:22year, which goes to show just how quickly things
- 39:25are shifting politically in the data center world.
- 39:28AB 2619 is similar to the prior to the prior
- 39:32bill that we just discussed, AB 2469, in that
- 39:36it relates to water use and supply information.
- 39:39While AB 2469 kicks in during the local project
- 39:44approval process, AB 2619 applies when a data
- 39:48center owner operator is applying for a business
- 39:51license or renewing one, which generally most
- 39:55jurisdictions require renewal on an annual basis.
- 39:58Specifically, this bill requires data centers
- 40:01to provide their water supplier with a good faith
- 40:05estimate of expected water use, anticipated water
- 40:09source, and projected water use volumes before
- 40:14applying for an initial business license. Then,
- 40:17When the data center applies to renew its business
- 40:20license, it must report actual data under penalty
- 40:23perjury, including annual water use for the preceding
- 40:27year. The bill requires specific information
- 40:31regarding the amount of water used on site for
- 40:33data center operations, such as for cooling systems
- 40:37and how much of that water was potable, non -potable,
- 40:41or recycled. Similar to AB 1577, which we discussed
- 40:46earlier, that requires annual energy reporting
- 40:49to the CEC. AB 2619 also includes an ongoing
- 40:54reporting requirement because a business license
- 40:58must typically be renewed on an annual basis.
- 41:02Interestingly, the water disclosures are made
- 41:04under penalty of perjury but there is no actual
- 41:07verification process and no consequence of the
- 41:11annual water use numbers are wildly off as compared
- 41:15to the data center's original estimates that
- 41:17it used when applying for the initial business
- 41:20license. So this brings us to the next set of
- 41:28bills which seek to address the increasing pressure
- 41:33data centers create for transmission and distribution
- 41:37infrastructure. Data centers often operate 24
- 41:42-7 and they can consume large amounts of electricity.
- 41:48So each of the bills in this category implicate
- 41:51the California Public Utilities Commission and
- 41:55tariffs for large energy users such as data centers.
- 42:01Now these bills do not arrive in a vacuum. Earlier
- 42:05this year in April, the Public Utilities Commission
- 42:08opened a rulemaking proceeding on California
- 42:12advanced electric rate design that will explore
- 42:16opportunities to address affordability challenges
- 42:19associated with rapid load growth and will consider
- 42:23stranded costs and cost shifts for large loads
- 42:27with a focus on data centers. It was against
- 42:31that backdrop that the legislature also enacted
- 42:35the following three bills to protect ratepayers.
- 42:38Those are SB 886, AB 2383, and SB 1168. SB 886
- 42:48was co -authored by Senators Padilla, remember
- 42:52she was the the CEQA bill author as well, and
- 42:55McNerney, and is titled the California Technology
- 42:58Innovation and Ratepayer Protection Act. Great
- 43:01author, great name. This bill is meant to avoid
- 43:04cost shifting to rate payers by creating tariffs
- 43:07that ensure data centers pay their fair share
- 43:11of electrical grid service needs. SP886 tasks
- 43:16the California Public Utilities Commission with
- 43:18establishing tariffs by January of 2028 for interconnection
- 43:23to the grid and transmission facility upgrades.
- 43:27This tariff requires the CPUC to determine a
- 43:31methodology that assigns cost responsibility
- 43:34for necessary interconnection infrastructure
- 43:37upgrades. The CPUC will also be required to establish
- 43:42an early termination fee that would apply to
- 43:45any data center that leaves the electrical system
- 43:48within 10 years of initial interconnection or
- 43:52fails to achieve adequate load ramp up. The early
- 43:56termination fee could be significant because
- 43:59it is at least the amount of the revenue gap
- 44:02associated with the originally projected energy
- 44:05demand of the facility over the 10 -year term.
- 44:09SB 886 also requires electrical corporations
- 44:12to publish utility maps showing low -cost interconnection
- 44:17sites. That way, data center operators can determine
- 44:21locations where they can interconnect without
- 44:24needing to complete significant, costly, and
- 44:27time -consuming transmission upgrades, which,
- 44:29if created and prepared, would be, frankly, fantastic
- 44:32for the industry. Yeah, right. It would definitely
- 44:36help with infrastructure upgrade costs. Like
- 44:42SB 886, which Edgar just discussed, AB 2383 by
- 44:48Assemblymember Zuber, also involves the Public
- 44:52Utilities Commission and tariffs. Specifically,
- 44:56this bill requires the Public Utilities Commission
- 44:59to establish two types of tariffs for data centers,
- 45:04a transmission and distribution service tariff,
- 45:08as well as a generation service tariff. First,
- 45:13the Public Utilities Commission must require
- 45:16each electrical corporation to file a transmission
- 45:20and distribution service tariff that ensures
- 45:24data centers pay their reasonable share of costs
- 45:28relating to wildfire mitigation and wildfire
- 45:31liability, electrification and environmental
- 45:35programs, and quote, other societal obligations
- 45:40typically collected from distribution level rate
- 45:44payers, end quote. societal obligations. I love
- 45:48that. I've not seen that in legislation recently.
- 45:53But really, I mean, the goal here is to ensure
- 45:57that data centers are paying their fair share
- 45:59of costs upfront to avoid cost shifting and rising
- 46:03rates for regular customers. The Public Utilities
- 46:08Commission will also need to approve a mechanism
- 46:11ensuring that data center customers pay incremental
- 46:15cost increases resulting from their load to prevent
- 46:19these costs from being passed on to other customers.
- 46:23So this would be in the form of the generation
- 46:25service tariff that includes the early termination
- 46:29concept that we saw with SB886 because the payment
- 46:33will be for at least 10 years to avoid stranded
- 46:37generation costs for data center facilities.
- 46:40that do not complete interconnection or consume
- 46:44less than their anticipated load. There's also
- 46:48a requirement for data centers to provide upfront
- 46:51collateral and prepayment for incremental generation
- 46:56cost increases that result from their electrical
- 46:59load, but it's not clear how much money that
- 47:03could be or how it's calculated. The tariffs
- 47:08created by AB 2383 do not just apply to electrical
- 47:13corporations. Community choice aggregators and
- 47:18electrical service providers will also be required
- 47:21to adopt tariffs for generation service that
- 47:25apply to data centers at or above a minimum peak
- 47:30electricity demand threshold. And that minimum
- 47:34threshold cannot be more than 25 megawatts. Finally,
- 47:42this is our last bill. SB 1168 by Senator McNerney
- 47:49is the least controversial bill in the package.
- 47:53It requires the California Public Utilities Commission
- 47:57to assess opportunities for rate structures,
- 48:01again, to ensure that data centers are paying
- 48:04their fair share for transmission and distribution
- 48:07upgrades, as well as load increases. So this
- 48:11just reinforces the concept we were just talking
- 48:14about regarding preventing costs from being passed
- 48:18down to non -data center customers. This bill
- 48:23is meant to also study rate structures to alleviate
- 48:28cost pressures, specifically on residential ratepayers.
- 48:33The PUC estimates the annual cost to complete
- 48:37the report will be just over $200 ,000, but it's
- 48:41unclear from this bill whether that's a one -time
- 48:43report or if there will be multiple reports prepared
- 48:48in the future. The assembly floor analysis for
- 48:53this bill acknowledged that it's largely directing
- 48:57the Public Utilities Commission to study topics
- 49:00that are already extensively covered. as it relates
- 49:04to data center rate structures and rate payer
- 49:07protections as we saw with the prior two bills
- 49:10we discussed in this category. So that rounded
- 49:17out our summary of each bill in the governor's
- 49:20seven bill package of data center legislation.
- 49:24So let's talk about a few key takeaways. First,
- 49:28it's important to note that None of the bills
- 49:31we discussed today prohibit data centers in California.
- 49:36Those are more so addressed in local moratoriums,
- 49:40moratoria that get passed city by city. So there's
- 49:43no statewide prohibition on data centers. Instead,
- 49:48these bills impose new requirements on the process
- 49:51of getting a data center approved and on disclosure
- 49:54obligations. The bills also make it more expensive
- 49:58to operate a data center by way of tariffs and
- 50:02compliance requirements such as environmental
- 50:05review. So, a key takeaway is it's important
- 50:10to budget for CEQA review. You should assume
- 50:14that every data center project needs at least
- 50:17an initial study, even on by -right sites. And
- 50:22that time and litigation risk should be built
- 50:24into the project schedule. Second, evaluate whether
- 50:28the ELDP pathway early, whether it's worth the
- 50:34expense. And some of that determination really
- 50:38depends on the particular locality, both whether
- 50:43litigation and opposition as anticipated, coupled
- 50:46with the costs to go through and maintain the
- 50:51LTP certification. You should also ensure that
- 50:57your clients understand the disclosure requirements,
- 51:01which are extensive and will be part of the application
- 51:04and review process. Clients should develop defensible
- 51:09estimates and supporting data for water, sound
- 51:13and energy use. It's also critical for clients
- 51:17to model the full cost of service when analyzing
- 51:21infrastructure upgrades and improvements to avoid
- 51:25early termination fees and stranded investment.
- 51:29Engaging with the community and local leaders
- 51:31early on is very important. We are absolute advocates
- 51:36of early public outreach and engagement. We have
- 51:40found that Most individuals, once they learn
- 51:45of the actual impacts, perceived or real, of
- 51:49a particular data center can go from aggressive
- 51:53opposition to being neutral. So while these bills
- 51:58make developing a data center in California more
- 52:01expensive and complicated to operate, there's
- 52:04absolutely a pathway and we have worked in...
- 52:08multiple jurisdictions to successfully entitle
- 52:13data centers. It certainly will be interesting
- 52:19to see how these bills impact the flow of data
- 52:21center development in California. It's worth
- 52:24noting that California is by no means an outlier
- 52:27here. In fact, other states have introduced or
- 52:30enacted restrictions on data centers, more aggressive
- 52:35regulations, including New York. which is past
- 52:38a one -year moratorium on data centers over 20
- 52:40megawatts. So no data center larger than 20 megawatts
- 52:44can be built or approved in the state of New
- 52:47York. Even states that were previously avid supporters
- 52:51of data center development, such as Texas and
- 52:53Utah, have scaled back following intense community
- 52:57opposition and pushback. At the end of the day,
- 53:00California remains a premier market for data
- 53:03center investment, and these new laws do not
- 53:05change that opportunity. Rather, they make thoughtful
- 53:09planning and coordinated execution even more
- 53:11important. And we're running out of time, so
- 53:15I'll just close with there are There are a lot
- 53:17of discussions at the federal level about potential
- 53:21preemption opportunities, which are likely to
- 53:27not get very far considering the expected results
- 53:31of the upcoming election. So with that, we've
- 53:37reached the end of our substantive presentation
- 53:40and can open it up for questions. OK, so. Not
- 53:52currently seeing questions from our audience.
- 53:55Do you have any other looks like someone? Daniel
- 53:59is attempting to raise his hand. Daniel, if you
- 54:01could put your question within the Q &A and then
- 54:04Neda and Edward would Edgar would be happy to
- 54:06answer your question. And while we're waiting
- 54:10just on the federal preemption, a lot of discussion
- 54:12I've heard, you know, similar to my 90s with
- 54:16cell towers, where local municipalities, because
- 54:20of opposition, were not approving cell towers,
- 54:24federal preemption stepped in. We've heard of
- 54:28similar discussions in DC. But again, as Nana
- 54:31mentioned earlier, because the data center opposition
- 54:34crosses aisles, of House of the Isle, it'll be
- 54:38very difficult to get the respective parties
- 54:42to agree on any type of federal legislation that
- 54:48will be meaningful. All righty. It looks like
- 54:58we don't see a question submission here. This
- 55:02concludes today's presentation. Thank you so
- 55:04much, Edgar and Netta, for an excellent presentation
- 55:07today, and thank you so much to our audience
- 55:08for joining us. Have a great day, everyone.