Latest / Situational Awareness Tactics / FBI PROFILERS DISCUSSES THE NUANCES OF UNDERSTANDING THE LAW
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Situational Awareness Tactics Podcast. This podcast provides the crucial art of understanding
- 0:09current elements in an environment to increase your safety and survival. Here's your host,
- 0:15forensic psychologist and consultant, doctor Carlos. Have you ever wondered what your
- 0:24furry friend is really thinking? Well, let me introduce to you my new
- 0:28book, Dog Psychology by doctor Carlos Vasquez. As a psychology professor with over
- 0:34ten years experience, I've unlocked the secrets of the canine psyche. I will
- 0:38teach you how to understand your dog's body language, to code their barks and
- 0:42wines, solved behavioral puzzles, and strengthen your pond like never before. With
- 0:48Dog Psychology, you'll see the world through your dog's eyes. Don't just be
- 0:52a dog owner, become a dog whisperer. So go get Dog Psychology by
- 0:56doctor Carlos Vasquez, available now on paperback on Amazon. Welcome back, everybody,
- 1:12Welcome back, Andy, Hey Carlos, how are you. I'm rolling
- 1:18along, how are you? Well, it's the middle of July already.
- 1:23It's crazy how fast the summer is flying by. But we'll be into the
- 1:27fall before we know it. Absolutely. Well that's not Russia too much.
- 1:32But yeah, yeah, well you don't have you do have kids, right,
- 1:36anyone with kids at home during the summer might want to rush it so
- 1:38they go back to school. That's right, that's right, they do.
- 1:42By the way, folks, we're going to continue our discussion we did one
- 1:46last time on the difference between premeditated murder and crimes of passion, and today
- 1:52we continue on. We'll be looking at different types of cases and defenses and
- 1:57things of that nature, as well as we explore domestic violence. You know
- 2:00what to do, Make sure to share, subscribe, hit that I like
- 2:04button. You know, we like it. So, Adie, what do
- 2:06you got for us today? Well, you know, I think we left
- 2:07off with motives, so it's a good place I think we should pick back
- 2:10up the differences between the motives of passions, crimes of passion usually manslaughter charges
- 2:17versus premeditative first degree murder charges that you get in a premeditated homicide. You
- 2:25know, remember the PEPs. It's a good place to start. Motive as
- 2:29we look at it as a personal, economic, political, or power and
- 2:34socials. The acronymis PEPs and a lot of a lot of crimes of passion
- 2:40are very personal and so as a result, because there's a lot of anger
- 2:45and even hatred at the time, and it's a lot of times it happens
- 2:49spontaneously to or contiguous to an argument or discovery of infidelity. For example,
- 2:57the crime scene is often disorganized because take a blunt instrument and they'll use that
- 3:00as a weapon, or they'll grab a knife and they'll use that as a
- 3:04weapon or something. That nature and the and the crime scene itself is typically
- 3:09disfrenzied and full of anger, and that the attack is often very vicious,
- 3:15whereas a premeditated crime scene may not even look like a crime scene. It
- 3:21could be staged as a suicide, uh, it could be set up with
- 3:25poison. So there's really very little obvious conflict. And oftentimes these these crimes
- 3:36come from something very personal, economic, power based, or or social.
- 3:42So that's that's one issue. The other thing with passion crime is emotional involvement.
- 3:47Both types of crimes obviously involve some kind of strong emotions such as love
- 3:52or jealousy, revenge, or an obsession even towards the victim, but romantic
- 3:59crimes crimes passion typically happened fairly quickly you find out that your spouse is cheating
- 4:05on you or captured them cheating at the time, and then you pull a
- 4:09gun out and you kill them. Whereas the Scott Peterson case, you know,
- 4:13was highly publicized. In the trial, he was convicted of murdering his
- 4:15wife, Lacy Peterson, and in that case, the defense tried to make
- 4:20the argument that it was a prime of passion, if in fact he was
- 4:25guilty of it, he was, you know, something that had happened spontaneously,
- 4:28Whereas the state successfully made the argument that it was premeditated and that his
- 4:33behavior is over a period of time, including his affair with another woman or
- 4:38inconsistent with the alibi that he was using, and the prosecution argued that Scott
- 4:44Peterson murdered his wife to escape the marriage and his impending fatherhood. He was
- 4:49found guilty in two thousand and four. But I think that case has recently
- 4:53been appealed successfully. That is that the case in the Peterson case, I'll
- 4:58take a look at as we're talking at no if that has been or has
- 5:00not. Yeah, I think I think that in that case, you know,
- 5:04the body of Lacy Peterson was found, remains were found in San Francisco
- 5:10Bay several months after the case. And I haven't kept up with it,
- 5:13but last I heard sometime last year, I thought the case was reversily appealed
- 5:18it, but I wasn't sure if they had appealed it. Yeah, Scott
- 5:21Peterson, Right, Yeah, Scott Peterson. But then that leads us to
- 5:27the legal consequences and why the defense may try to argue that the case was
- 5:32a crime of passion manslaughter versus you know, a murder first degree. And
- 5:39that's because there we go there by the way, if you want, Yeah,
- 5:43what what did you find? Six weeks ago, a month after being
- 5:47convicted, Peterson was originally sentenced to death. After two appeals at California Supreme
- 5:51Court or returned, Peterson's death sentence been upheld as conviction. Peters recedence in
- 5:56December twenty twenty one to life in prison without the possibility of In twenty twenty
- 6:00two, he was denied another trial. This is from USA today as of
- 6:04six weeks ago. Yeah, okay, yeah, so he's in jail life
- 6:10without paroles. Changed it. Yeah, and probably you know on this what
- 6:15were the topic we're talking about? Was it premeditated or did this state have
- 6:18enough evidence to show that the motive was premeditated. If that's not the case,
- 6:25then the legal consequences may be lesser. So they spare his life.
- 6:30He gets life without parole because it was not premeditated, planned out, and
- 6:34intentional. Well, that's sometimes we could look at the future shows too circumstantial
- 6:39evidence cases. Well, yeah, because you know, in all these cases,
- 6:44eventually, when they're adjudicated, it's the ability for the state to prove
- 6:48their case number one, and then if they do, it's up to the
- 6:51jury to determine whether or not they deserve death or life without parole. In
- 6:59many states, every fifty states, so they have different laws for murder and
- 7:02crime of passion can get one less jail time typically and often avoid jailed or
- 7:08a death sentence or as a premeditated even romance crimes highlight the diversity of motives
- 7:14and can range from from you know, life without parole to death in many
- 7:18states those states that have a death penalty. What's interesting is a contrasting case
- 7:25is the O. J. Simpson case. You talk about a disorganized crime
- 7:30scene in that case, I mean it appears that Nicole Simpson and Brown and
- 7:39Ronald Goldman were ambushed in nineteen ninety four, right now, on that night
- 7:46I think it was in June of nineteen ninety four, Goldman and Simpson were
- 7:50found brutally murdered. Remember what I said earlier about oftentimes these crimes of passion
- 7:58are spontaneous, and so the the perpetrator, the murderer will take a weapon
- 8:05it's close by or that they brought, maybe not intending to use, but
- 8:09then once they use it, they often, especially when when it's frenzied and
- 8:13full of anger, can do some barrific damage. I believe I have my
- 8:20fact straight. Nicole Simpson's head was almost decapitated in that case, I think
- 8:26so. Yeah, And that led to a lot of conspiracies in regards to
- 8:31his son doing it, not him, because his son was a chef.
- 8:35And here's you know, I want to make a point on that if I
- 8:37can. It's somewhat related to this, but just to kind of give a
- 8:41caveat to people out there. His social media is so much, so full
- 8:46of disinformation and misinformation. Misinformation is, folks, is somebody telling you something
- 8:52without them intentionally trying to deceive you or trick you. They just they don't
- 8:56have a knowledge for it, and then and the other one is disinformation,
- 9:01was intentional deception, and it's false information. But I think it's important for
- 9:05people to believe, to understand, right Andy, that these things are complex.
- 9:09It's not so simple. You can't just go off with three or four
- 9:11pieces of evidence that you see on the news, the little clips that they
- 9:16show, and everybody thinks, oh my god, this is slam dunk,
- 9:18and no, you haven't even gone to trial yet. Where then you start
- 9:22seeing even more stuff. And even in trial, right Andy, you don't
- 9:26see everything they're not going to show you. Prosecutor is not stupid, he
- 9:28was the defense side. I can't think of a better example than the O.
- 9:33J. Simpson on Nicole Brown case because of when the facts are presented,
- 9:37they are it's the job of the defense to cause doubt reasonable doubt in
- 9:41the minds of at least one jurorm and so the presentation of the evidence is
- 9:48very nuanced. If the glove doesn't fit, you must have quit was one
- 9:52of the you know stayings at the time. But the DNA evidence is also
- 9:58very, very very important in today's trial outcomes. And uh, in the
- 10:03O. J. Simpson case, it's It's important to point out that at
- 10:07the criminal case he was acquitted of the crime, even though in civil uh
- 10:11a civil trial later, he was he was found culpable for the murders.
- 10:18And in that particular case, and I can't think of one that's a better
- 10:22example, at least best known example. In that particular case, there was
- 10:26a veteral it was a lot of hatred, that was a you know,
- 10:30it was well known that that O. J. Simpson and his wife had
- 10:35a volatile relationship, or his ex wife had a volatile relationship, and then
- 10:39he was very jealous. And just to use that case as an example of
- 10:46how explosive passion can be, you can see how there's a distinction, a
- 10:52fundamental difference in the types of crimes between crimes of passion and those that are
- 10:56premeditated and require planning. And perhaps that's the biggest difference between these two is
- 11:03the planning that's involved. Crimes of romantic passion are impulsive, there's very little
- 11:09planning, whereas premeditated romance crimes involved careful planning, sometimes over an extended period
- 11:16of time. There's cases like the diet and I'm gonna mispronounce this the Dipolodi,
- 11:22Dippolodo. Yeah, Dipoloto, that's it, Dipolito. That was in
- 11:31two thousand and nine in Florida. And yeah, and this particular case,
- 11:37the wife was accused of soliciting a hit man to murder her husband, Michael
- 11:41in two thousand and nine in Boyden Beach. The police staged a fake crime
- 11:48scene and then informed her her husband had been killed by the hitman, and
- 11:52they even captured her. I think I've seen this video several times, her
- 11:56reaction on hidden camera, and the hit man, unbeknownst to her, was
- 12:01an undercover police officer. Now this is not, you know, unique in
- 12:05the sense that this is the same kin facts of case have happened before,
- 12:09but it clearly showed the planning that was involved in the intentional, attempted murder
- 12:16of her husband Michael. During the trial, which was again a national trial,
- 12:24the prosecution argued that she had carefully planned and orchestrated her husband's murder to
- 12:30gain access to his life insurance policy. So you have a personal issue,
- 12:35right, she hates this guy, but she also has an economic So,
- 12:39as we've said, kets oftentimes has an amalgam amalgamation of these motives, right,
- 12:46So she had a personal issue, didn't like the guy, but she
- 12:48also wants to benefit from his death. The defense team countered that the plot
- 12:54was the setup orchestrated by her husband and the police to gain fame and attention,
- 13:00right, that she had never had an actual intention of murdering her husband.
- 13:05She was convicted in twenty eleven for solicitation a first degree murder, and
- 13:09she was sentenced to twenty years. So it's not in this case she failed
- 13:13at the murder, which probably had a lot to do with the fact that
- 13:16she didn't get the death penalty, But this was an attempted murder case.
- 13:20She got twenty years for attempted murder. The conviction was later overturned an appeal
- 13:26related to jury selection issues, and the subsequent trial she continued to argue the
- 13:33same defense, which was entrapment, and she was convicted and given sixteen years
- 13:39in twenty seventeen. So, but what's interesting in that case and the reason
- 13:43why it's notable, is because it involved the government's involvement in a pre planned
- 13:50murder and intrinsic intrinsic part of it, you know, the complicated part of
- 13:56her hiring a hitman and them doing the you know, wire the car up
- 14:01and gathering all that evidence. I can tell you from personal experience, that's
- 14:05a lot of work. And so that's why that case is pretty well known.
- 14:11You know. The other one of the other differences between the two is
- 14:15the emotional state at the time of the crime, when when people have crimes
- 14:20of passion and the reason why the wounds oftentimes are over top right. You'll
- 14:28see not just one or two stab wounds, You'll see forty fifty sixty stab
- 14:33woings. You'll see a decapitation, You'll see you'll see some really horrendous injuries.
- 14:39And when the perpetrator is is fueled with hatred and it's and passion that's
- 14:46misplaced. So this impulsive type of violence is oftentimes different than the premeditated.
- 14:54Not to say that they can't be horrific wounds from a pre medated case oftentimes
- 15:01not oftentimes, but there are cases where a premeditated murder includes putting the body
- 15:07in a wood chipper or severing the limbs more easily disposal. There's a case,
- 15:18the Chris Coleman case, which was in two thousand and nine, and
- 15:22he was a security chief for televangelist Joyce Meyer's ministry, and he was convicted
- 15:28of murdering his wife, Sherry, and as well as his two young sons
- 15:33in their home in Illinois. Their bodies were found the eleven year old son
- 15:39and the nine year old son, along with the thirty one year old wife,
- 15:41discovered in their beds, strangled to death. Now imagine how personal that
- 15:46is to strangle your kids. It's to me, it's beyond pale. I
- 15:52can't even fathom a human, let alone everything else. Yeah, that sounds
- 16:00like it's a delusion of some kind of psychotic episode. Usually when you see
- 16:03those kind of violence. Yeah, in this case, and in many of
- 16:07these types of cases where they involve murders of family members, the first suspect
- 16:14is the husband and or wife. It's like you and I have talked about
- 16:18this in the past, that the investigative process starts like a stone in a
- 16:22pond, and where the rock hits, that first ring is usually the people
- 16:26closest to them family members are known associates, and then it expands. And
- 16:32you've heard of the general rule of forty eight hours to try to solve the
- 16:36case within forty eight hours. Those rings, just like in a pond when
- 16:40you throw that rock, those rings are very strong at the epicenter, but
- 16:44then they get more faded as they gradually go out. In Chris Coleman's case,
- 16:49and this is not unusual due to several factors, including inconsistencies in his
- 16:56statements. The police looked at him, but his lack of emotion is what
- 16:59really struck the police. So this is a guy who had been thinking about
- 17:03this act for some time. He had already reconciled the emotional aspects. Imagine
- 17:07again the type of mindset it takes to strangle the life out of your children,
- 17:14your eleven year old son and your nine year old son. They've got
- 17:17to be gasping for air, they've got to be fighting back, and you're
- 17:18strangling them to death. And it was found in the investigation that the murders
- 17:26were planned because he wanted to start a new life with another woman. He
- 17:30had an extramarial affair with a woman named Tara Lynz who they were high school
- 17:34friends. They became romantically involved, and they argued that he planned these murders
- 17:42to eliminate his family so he and Lynz could live without the burden of his
- 17:47ex wife and children. And you know again, how much of that is
- 17:52financial because when you get divorced, I'm telling you straight up as a man
- 17:59who's gone through two of them, Uh, it's it's expensive, right,
- 18:03But there's something else going on there because if you can't I don't care if
- 18:08I'm living in a shoe box, you know, and and living day to
- 18:12day. There's a whole different dimension that these people have to go through cognitively
- 18:18to say I'm going to kill my family so that I can, you know,
- 18:23buy a new car next year. Just to me, it's it's when
- 18:27we you know, when people hear about somebody committing suicide, We're like,
- 18:33wow, how could they do that? How could they reconcile that? Well,
- 18:36because you're not in their mental state, you know that. And similarly,
- 18:41these people who plan these murders, they already reconciled the death of the
- 18:45people they want to kill, so they do so with less emotion. As
- 18:48the point, he was convicted of three counts of first degree murder and sentenced
- 18:52to life in prison without the possibility of parole. But it highlights that case
- 18:57particularly highlights with you see in domestic violence and those types of cases, they
- 19:04don't always end. In crimes of passion, oftentimes there's a you know,
- 19:11a more gradual, slippery slope to the end of the relationship that goes from
- 19:15anger to hatred. There's another case that's pretty well noted, the Smith case
- 19:23Morgan Smith case of two thousand, which set a legal precedent in Canadian jurisprudence
- 19:30in terms of self defense. You and I were talking about this earlier,
- 19:33is when they you know, when the battered wife syndrome is argued. Right.
- 19:41In this particular case, Shannon Smith was convicted in Canada second degree murder
- 19:45of her husband, Michael Morgan. The reason it gained attention was because of
- 19:51the element of domestic violence and the argument of the battered woman syndrome of defense.
- 19:59Shannon Smith had a history of abuse at the hands of her husband,
- 20:03which included physical, emotional, and psychological mistreatment. But her defense was that
- 20:08Smith that she had endured years of abuse at his hands and it culminated in
- 20:15the moment where she feared for her life, leading to her fatally shooting him
- 20:18in self defense, you know, and that self defense argument is one that
- 20:23you have to make. And go back to what we were talking about earlier.
- 20:26The nuances of the introduction of evidence during the court case in trial,
- 20:33and whether you can convince either a judge and a bench trial or the jury
- 20:36in a jury trial that there's some doubt. There was an FBI agent when
- 20:42I was an agent at the academy going through a divorce. But at the
- 20:45same time I was going through my divorce, and he went home one day
- 20:52for lunch. Now I was at the FBI Academy for a long time,
- 20:56Carlos, I rarely wore my gun when I was on d I mean if
- 21:03I was, because you're at the FBI Academy, it's an educational institution.
- 21:07You're surrounded by cops. Those are your students are either cops or new agent
- 21:11wannabes, right, That really not. It's pretty secure and there's a police
- 21:17force protecting the academy. So a lot of times I would take my gun.
- 21:21If I was wearing it to the academy, I'd put it in my
- 21:23drawer and that's where it would stay all day, and I would take it
- 21:26out going home. This particular agent decided to carry his gun home. Now
- 21:33he was separated from his wife. They were going through a divorce, and
- 21:37he went to his house during his lunchtime and allegedly well. The evidence shows
- 21:45that at least the evidence accepted by the court was that they got into an
- 21:48argument altercation. She grabbed a knife spontaneously, came at him with a knife,
- 21:52and he took his pistol and shot her twice in the chest, killed
- 21:57her. He was brought on trial. It was a mistrial I think once
- 22:02or or twice a bench trial. He was tried again, I think the
- 22:07third time, and he was acquitted and the defense was, in all cases
- 22:12was self defense, that she had come at it. I often wonder what
- 22:18would have happened if he hadn't had his service pistol with him. And most
- 22:25women are much now. She might have gotten him with the knife. Who
- 22:27knows, but I would have And I'm not gonna play arm check quarterback,
- 22:30but I just wonder what would happen if you hadn't had the pistol. I
- 22:36never, for the record, carried my gun when I was in close contact
- 22:41with my ex wives, not that I didn't trust my emotions. I wonder
- 22:48if you was suspicious or just didn't take it off, or as one of
- 22:51these guys that carries around. Do you know a lot of guys that carried
- 22:52their guns around. Yeah, I know there are a lot of agents that
- 22:56carry their weapons everywhere they go. There are a few that might carry too
- 23:02so, but it depends a lot on what they do and what they work.
- 23:06I carried mine my service weapon when I was in the field all the
- 23:10time. But there are certain areas where I you know, you make a
- 23:14calculation, a choice whether to carry a weapon. There are times I would
- 23:18go to the grocery store without my gun. There were times often that I
- 23:22would go to the pool or beach. I'm not carrying my gun. You
- 23:26make it, you make a determination, you know when it's appropriate and not.
- 23:30My advice is you can't shoot a gun you don't have. And if
- 23:34you're in a ball situation with a wife who you're protracted negotiations through a divorce,
- 23:41probably not a good idea to carry a weapon. But this incident happened
- 23:47and I think in Santa Monica. Again, this is not advocating to carry
- 23:51a gun at the beach, but it was weird because there was a guy
- 23:53running around shooting people at the beach. I think it was either Miami or
- 23:57Kata Monica and somebody the beach covers took out his gun and neutralized the subject.
- 24:04But it was kind of interesting. It's like, really, guns at
- 24:07the beach. You just don't think about it. Yeah, you know,
- 24:10I I on my Instagram feed. You get stuff. I don't even know
- 24:12how some of the stuff I even get, but you know, you get
- 24:15I get this police incident, oh channel, and I it just comes on,
- 24:21you know, so this morning I get it and uh it's a road
- 24:25rage incident. I don't know how this was even a videotaped, but I
- 24:29think he was a twenty nine year old male I believe it was in Indiana
- 24:33or Illinois road rage. Gets out of his car. He's got a gun
- 24:37at his side, goes up to the truck, starts yelling and screaming,
- 24:41puts the gun in his left hand, about the time that the driver shoots
- 24:45him twice in the head and neck. Dead gun ski. I mean,
- 24:49I don't know what else you would do. The guy put puts a gun
- 24:52at you. Well, yeah, but that's I mean, we make the
- 24:55Second Amendment argument, and you know, you know, bad guys carry gun,
- 24:57good guys carry and this stigle in case this guy had just been married,
- 25:02and uh, it was no criminal history, and but both guns are
- 25:06when you're available, you're gonna get right. That's so I'm not making a
- 25:14judgment right wrong. I'm not suggesting that this guy was wrong to shoot him
- 25:18and didn't have self defense. I'm just simply stating what I saw. If
- 25:22this had happened, they might have gotten out and beat each other up.
- 25:26Who knows, they might have strangled each other. But uh, you know,
- 25:29in this particular case right there for the world to see. Uh And
- 25:33and uh, that's kind of the weird thing about this world now is a
- 25:36lot of people try to get to the upper hand, whether it's a gun
- 25:38or an iron rod, a baseball bad. We saw that the other day.
- 25:41It's well, it's just I think we you and I had this conversation
- 25:45earlier too. I think there's a diminished value of human uh existence, And
- 25:53I think, you know, becoming more callous and in our opinions and uh
- 25:57and our behaviors. I'm starting to wonder if it's finally caused by things that
- 26:03we used to think would cause it. You know, are watching of horror
- 26:07movies, watching of TV crime shows, But it wasn't so prevalent forty years
- 26:11ago. And now I don't think. I don't know. I don't want
- 26:15to get too far off topic, but I think that humans we go through
- 26:19a cycle. And if you go, I'm watching you know, Game of
- 26:25Thrones spin off, the House of Dragons, and of course it's not history,
- 26:30but it is historic that people did some very awful things during the you
- 26:36know, fifteen sixteenth century against other humans. We are, we have the
- 26:40capacity to be very inhumane to one another, and then culturally it becomes unacceptable.
- 26:47And so when it's unacceptable, then the pattern of behavior changes. And
- 26:52we can see this through various eras, and now we're going through an era
- 26:56where it's very culturally acceptable to insult people that if we see our leaders doing
- 27:03that, it's okay, so we can do it too. And you know,
- 27:06we all have an opinion because we can all get on and have a
- 27:07podcast and we can all tell the world exactly what we think, even if
- 27:11we have nearly one brain cell operating, synaps firing. So we all have
- 27:18an opinion, even if it means nothing, because it there's a scary pollet
- 27:22came out the other day. It's twenty five percent believe that violence is justified.
- 27:26To get your opinion, across or to make your political agenda, which
- 27:30does, back to your point, does not surprise me at all, because
- 27:34we've lost any sense of decorum and to and it's not just people, it's
- 27:40institutions as well. And to me, the the more dangerous aspect of what's
- 27:45happening in culture that may lead to violence, so we'll keep it in topic,
- 27:51is the erosion of trust in the institutions we have that hold our society
- 27:56together. And unless you have some voice out there that says, okay,
- 28:03look, these institutions, which are the fabric of our morality, our morals,
- 28:10and our moral code, are important because they determine what we determine as
- 28:15humans individuals, what is right and wrong and how we treat one another right
- 28:19and we if we don't pull back on the reins there a little bit and
- 28:25understand that it's not okay and well, I'm not talking progressives or liberals or
- 28:30is it's don't body shame. If you're fat, you're fat, Okay,
- 28:34lose weight because it's a health issue. It's not you're fat because you know
- 28:38you're ugly. Because you're fat, it's because you get diabetes. If you're
- 28:41fat, I'm fat. I need to lose weight. My doctor told me,
- 28:45if you call me fat, you're making an observation, that's all.
- 28:49That's not insulting unless you mean it to be insulting. And that's the problem
- 28:55is that people say you're fat. They don't mean, hey, you need
- 28:57to you know, get healthy. They're saying you're an ugly fat person.
- 29:03Let me ask you this. I know we only got about ten and topic,
- 29:06but yeah, I want to bring it back to topic, but keeping
- 29:10keeping off the theme you just mentioned, and see what your thoughts are in
- 29:12regards to you said erosion of truth of institutions, and if we apply that
- 29:18to marriages in this case, as we're talking about domestic violence, erosion of
- 29:23love and erosion of trust even that partner, what do you think are you
- 29:29seeing common themes in the sense of are a lot of these cases directed towards
- 29:33somebody being selfish, somebody wanting something like I, like the guy you mentioned
- 29:40a minute ago, I want this new relationship, but I got something hanging
- 29:42me, hanging me back, it's keeping me back from having it. So
- 29:47you have this pursuit of pleasure and you'll do anything to get it, or
- 29:52is it something I'm so unhappy. I got to get rid of this on
- 29:55happiness. So I'm going to eliminate and neutralize the threat or is it both
- 29:59or what? Well? I can't if selfishness is a symptom of narcissism.
- 30:04I can't think of anything more selfish than strangling your eleven year old and nine
- 30:11year old son and then putting a bullet in the head of your ex or
- 30:15your wife so that you can be with your mistress and live a separate life.
- 30:19That is the definition of narcissism and selfishness. Now, how selfish are
- 30:26we in this culture today? I think we're very selfish. I think we
- 30:30don't think about society or the collective as much as we should. And here's
- 30:36the reason. Is my humble opinion, everybody has one. There are really
- 30:41three types of morality. You and I have had this conversation in the past
- 30:45as well. Right the absolute moralists believe in right and wrong, good and
- 30:51evil, and they often draw their moral code from God. God's law is
- 30:56superior to man's law. So you have these evangelicals, religious people, and
- 31:00they you know, everything's black and white in terms of right and wrong.
- 31:03It's right to it's wrong to steal you know, and so for instance,
- 31:07okay, then you have the moral relativists, and these people the beast majority
- 31:12of us. We say, well, it depends if somebody is stealing bread
- 31:18to feed their family. Stealing is bad, but they're trying to feed their
- 31:22family. So in that particular case, okay, it deals with social contract
- 31:29issues and so on. Right, So, a moral relativist means that morality
- 31:33depends on the circumstance and culture they're in. Then my favorite, there's the
- 31:38moral nihilists. These people don't believe in right or wrong, or good any
- 31:44evil. They only believe in winning and losing, winning and losing. If
- 31:49I were to say where's America today, most of us have given up on
- 31:55the church. We've given up on the idea that what's good for the society.
- 32:00You know that it's okay to steal bread because everybody in society should be
- 32:04fed. Now all we give is crap about is winning and losing, and
- 32:07we want to be winners. And you're the loser. I'm the winner,
- 32:10I'm the bigger winner. You're the loser. You're the bigger loser. Right,
- 32:15So we don't care about right or wrong or sin. We don't We
- 32:19don't have to ask God for forgiveness. There's no need because as long as
- 32:22I'm a winner, that's all it counts. And if I means that I
- 32:28have to demean you, even if you're my spouse that I want to you
- 32:31know, get rid of, then I'm going to win this divorce or I'm
- 32:37going to If that means killing you to win the divorce, then so be
- 32:39it. And it's it's not even a it's not a passionate thing. It's
- 32:44not an emotional thing. It's a very calculated, instrumental thing that leads us
- 32:47to our ultimate goal of winning. And we just have to be careful because
- 32:52you know, winning should be done with grace and humanity, right, and
- 32:59if it's otherwise, it's just empty. And that's I think bringing it back
- 33:04to our conversation today, I think that there are people that are in relationships,
- 33:09and we have a whole different podcast for our audience to enjoy the Psychology
- 33:15of Romance where we talk about elements of relationships. And I can't think of
- 33:20any marriage, not one Ronald Reagan and Nancy included. I can't think of
- 33:24any marriage that has lasted more than seven years that doesn't have some form of
- 33:30conflict that doesn't have some form of emotional evolution. You can't have in this
- 33:39is my opinion. I'll be clear. I don't think you can have a
- 33:43relationship that is passionate from day one to past ten years. They say seven,
- 33:51so we can use a seven year itch. Passion has to evolve into
- 33:54something much deeper and more meaningful that includes trust, compassion, loyalty, commitment,
- 34:04and those relationships said cannot transverse that and go from the passion that you
- 34:09have in an early relationship to the love. The deep rooted love of committed
- 34:15relationships end up on the pile heap of divorce or breakups. And that's a
- 34:21calculate oftentimes much more calculated than emotion. Right. And so when it gets
- 34:28to the point where at seven, ten, twelve years, you're like,
- 34:31the passion's not there, but you know what, I'm hooking up with this
- 34:35other check and there's a lot of passion, but I got this big albatross
- 34:38around my neck, this wife and these two kids. Hmmm, maybe I
- 34:45could kill them cashing on the insurance and then you know, bang this other
- 34:49good looking check and start over. And that is the mindset there. That's
- 34:54a very calculated. That's the kind of mindset that you have with individuals like
- 35:01Chris Polman, who who are very narcissistic, very selfish, and very and
- 35:09lack of motion and attached to their criminality. Yeah, in our world,
- 35:15polinical world will look at a lot of these what we call it's how it's
- 35:19complicated because in our world there's so much debate about the different diagnoses. But
- 35:22I would say it is probably it's a personality disorder, a certain personality Distaurers
- 35:25will have this a lot of interpersonal difficulties. They don't really care right attachment,
- 35:32there's an attachment to them. And you know what it's not. You
- 35:36hit it right on the head, doctor, It's it's a disorder. It's
- 35:38a character disorder or social disorder. Is not a mental illness. These people
- 35:44know right from wrong. They know they're not they're not insane. They can
- 35:47stop themselves at any time. But they make a choice. And as you
- 35:52know, I'm a rational choice theorist, and these people do a calculated choice.
- 35:57Now, they may not sit down with a pen and pencil and pro
- 36:00and con kill my wife, not kill my wife, but in their mind
- 36:04they create this this fanciful future that doesn't include their their wife and their kids,
- 36:13and it starts over like I get a mulligan. And the damage that
- 36:17they leave in their wake, not only to the victims, but the victims'
- 36:22families and to society and at large is tremendous because we get desensitized. When
- 36:31I was a kid. When I was a kid, I used to watch
- 36:37Mutual of Omaha Wild Kingdom and they would have this lion chasing the antelope or
- 36:42you know, the gazelle whatever gazelle, and then right as the line's about
- 36:47to pounce, they would cut to a commercial. I never got to see
- 36:51the kill. They didn't want you to see that it was. It was
- 36:54they were gonna show Disney right after. Then fast forward to today, Not
- 37:00only do I see the lion catch the gazelle, I see the lions eating
- 37:05the gazelle from inside out. I see the gazelle fighting for its life while
- 37:09they're literally eating it alive. And so having a little blurred thing on my
- 37:15Instagram saying you know sensitive content, Well, of course we're humans. We
- 37:21want to see, so we click and then we see that, or we
- 37:22see the guy getting shut twice in the head, and what does that do
- 37:25to US as a society long term. Well that was my comment earlier.
- 37:30Have we just sensive ties ourselves by the increase of violence because we have so
- 37:35much more? As you mentioned to me, you can go on X and
- 37:37you can see the shooter the assassinate the I want to try to assassinate the
- 37:42former president. You can see the picture of his head blown off. But
- 37:45it's worse because now you see memes of his head blown off with the Huktua
- 37:50girls spitting on him. Yeah, it's really wild now because that would,
- 37:53like you said before, it would just cut commercial right. Well, hell,
- 37:58even in the old days it would be like a you shoot somebody and
- 38:00there's never blood. But yes, exactly, it's right. Tell Sam Peckinpah
- 38:05started putting blood packs in people on the movies and you saw there. I
- 38:09think he was one of them. But you know, here's the other thing.
- 38:12Then people say, oh god, it's you know, it's Hollywood,
- 38:15or it's this or desensitizing. You know, it's the social media, and
- 38:19it okay, maybe today, maybe in art era, but it's broader than
- 38:22that. It's bigger than that, because again go back to the fifteenth you
- 38:27know, sixteenth century fifteen hundreds. I guess i'd be fourteenth century fifteen hundreds
- 38:34of sixteen hundreds. And you know, was it Ladmir the Impaler? Oh?
- 38:40Yeah, the Impaler? He did ottomn Turks and stuck a poll right
- 38:46up there and wrecked them out through their throats, and the HUDs are lining
- 38:51up when people went to go to dinner to visit him the leaders. His
- 38:54NATO summit was an interesting one, right, So yeah, I mean,
- 38:59listen, there's a The question is, though, is it You know,
- 39:04here's one of the challenge to it. But it's just another observation of that
- 39:07example is that I know we're going into really kind of law and philosophy now,
- 39:10folks. But the question I have with that is, yes, we
- 39:15had the Impaler, but we also have very limited ability to write, so
- 39:21you know, you're only going to write what stories stick out. The question
- 39:22becomes, do we have today more Vlad Impaler types compared to what they had
- 39:30back then? We don't have access to that, right, with society much
- 39:34less violent back then compared to it is today. I know people compare it
- 39:38to certain wars and people die, but there's also much more hand to hand
- 39:43combat. There's also many more people on the earth than there were back in
- 39:46the day, and natural phenomenon took those people out, and particularly the illness,
- 39:52I mean, the mubonic plague took those people out, and I think
- 39:54that resets society, right. And we had a reset, sort of a
- 40:00reset back in twenty twenty with COVID, right, crimes went down, people
- 40:04were trying to think more community based and community orient and then that we broke
- 40:07through that because we don't have the same situation we had with COVID back pre
- 40:13you know, twenty twenty thereabouts. Who knows where it's going to end,
- 40:17but I know this, there's a cycle, and we have we haven't gotten
- 40:21to the bottom yet, and it may take World War three, it may
- 40:24take those types of calamities worldwide, another pandemic. Here's you know, it's
- 40:31funny. We're in the middle of the Olympics. I haven't watched one thing
- 40:36of the Olympics, the Summer Olympics right here. Yeah, you got to
- 40:39find the channel nowadays, right, But there was a time that the Olympics
- 40:44brought the United States together, regardless of party in religion. Now we're way
- 40:47off topic, but the point is that the Olympics were a time for the
- 40:52nation to come together as one. Now we need a nine to eleven for
- 40:58that to happen, right, the only time that happens we're so divided.
- 41:02Does that mean it's whate is me the world's ending? No, it's we're
- 41:07going through a cycle, and oftentimes to bring it back home. It is
- 41:13more indicative of a small blimp in history and not something that's more pervasive or
- 41:17that's going to last much longer. These cases that we're talking about are all
- 41:22too common, but I don't know that they are any more common historically.
- 41:28Even political violence, and we were talking about remember Aaron Burr and Alexander Hamilton,
- 41:34the vice the City and vice president at the time, it's like eighteen
- 41:37oh something eight or whatever. Alexander Hamilton was the Secretary of the Treasury.
- 41:43They challenged each other to a duel. These are frigging politicians. Could you
- 41:46imagine that today? Right? And they went out in New Jersey. They
- 41:51paced it off and Burr shot Hamilton in the in the chest or stomach.
- 41:55He lasted a day or two and he died. Right, That's how they
- 41:59settled. Little. There were no ballots. It was all bullets. And
- 42:02so when we look at today's environment, we said, boy, we're changing
- 42:06now. Unfortunately we're regressing. We're going back and revisiting the more basic,
- 42:14vile aspects of human behavior. And those were rejected. Those behaviors were rejected
- 42:20in the past, and they'll be rejected again. But this generation has to
- 42:24exhibit, you know, and learn that. And and we transitioned back,
- 42:29you know, because there's a juxtaposition of these We Trician go back to relationships.
- 42:35And there used to be a very well accepted and regarded standard for monogamy
- 42:44that when you were married, you were married for life. That there was
- 42:46it was almost a business pack. My mother I once asked her, do
- 42:52you and dad have passion? We're married sixty five years, son, we
- 42:55love each other. What are you talking about passion? Right? Because pre
- 43:00nineteen sixty the roles were very defined. The husband was the breadwinner. The
- 43:05mother stayed home. Mother, you know, knows best and she would be
- 43:07with you know, like June Kleaver. The nineteen sixties, women were told
- 43:13and they should they are. They were told they equals in every respect and
- 43:17so they can have their cake and eat it too. You could be superwoman
- 43:22at a house, and you can be a career woman as well. And
- 43:27not only that, but you can have the BFF of your life. Your
- 43:30husband could be your best friend, your ride and die your first kiss as
- 43:37your last kiss, and also be your passionate rock and roll guy. And
- 43:42that's very difficult to have your cake and eat it too, and so we
- 43:46but culturally we were taught this. Now this generation, the millennials and the
- 43:52gen xers, they're into een M. You know what n M is,
- 43:58right, ethical non monogamy and m polygamy right. Some groups are yeah,
- 44:06yeah, but it's becoming more culturally acceptable this And again it's not a progressive
- 44:10thing. It's not a conservative thing. It is a mindset, you know.
- 44:14And and part of that is, hey, everybody do your thing.
- 44:17And I think you can trace it back to the sixties and the cultural revolution
- 44:23as their own thing, post modernism and social constructivism, where everything is moral
- 44:29laws or what you want it to be. It's what's moral to you is
- 44:34moral, and what's right to you is right. Most of us, most
- 44:37of us are somewhere in the middle of that. We understand that yes,
- 44:40I can have my way, but I also have to give to the collective
- 44:45I can't be selfish. What we're talking about in these cases are people who
- 44:47have gone to the extreme, these narcissists who believe that, you know what,
- 44:52I'm so more I'm so much more special than my wife and my two
- 44:55kids that I can strangle them and kill her and go off with my mistress
- 45:00and start my life in you. How does he in any way? I
- 45:05think his life is more valuable than the three lives he took, but he
- 45:09made he rationalize that. This could be an interesting conversations. I'm getting read
- 45:14to wrap up for another show, but you are my final thoughts. Of
- 45:15course you can have yours as well, but my final thoughts would be interesting.
- 45:20Is you're touching on a point. I don't know if I necessarily see
- 45:23it as narcissism, but what I do see it as is the danger that
- 45:28I do see a lot in criminal activity. And what can scare most people
- 45:32is that dark shadow inside of us. All is the ability to rationalize behavior.
- 45:37Whether as an individuals or a collective, you can rationalize behavior. This
- 45:42is right for me. I need to do this. It's my life.
- 45:45I die and it's over, so I'm going to stop whatever is stopping me
- 45:49from getting what I want because when I die, it's over, so I
- 45:52should take care of me first. And rationalization is a very dangerous component to
- 45:57our behavior because it's also intrinsically human to rationalize in the decisions. And so
- 46:05as a rational rational behavior therapists or therapist specialist, I look at humans making
- 46:14their decisions and based on those modes that we've talked about, so rational rational
- 46:19and rationalization are a little there's a distinction there, right. Rationalization is like
- 46:22I want to take this stapler for my company because they're worth a billion dollars.
- 46:28They're not going to care, but that's technically stealing. You're committing a
- 46:30misdemeanor. And you rationalize it to that all of a sudden, that I
- 46:36should take this because it's a bike and I need a bike because I can
- 46:38only walk and I need to get to work. Well, that's not again,
- 46:40irrational. Something rational choice is that process of rationalizing what your decision is
- 46:47going to be. And to that extent, I think, going back to
- 46:52our conversation, what we've permeated, what's permeated through our culture is this sense
- 46:58of entitlement and has resulted in selfishness, not necessarily narcissism. And I'm not,
- 47:04you know, suggesting clinically that these people are narcissists. However, they
- 47:07exhibit narcissistic behavior in terms of their selfishness and their processing, their cognitive processing
- 47:14of rationalizing their choices. What may seem irrational to me may be normative to
- 47:21you. Right. So may I see somebody getting out of the car with
- 47:24a gun and yelling at some stranger in the road, and that's irrational,
- 47:30But not to the person who got out of their car with the gun,
- 47:32who rationalized, Hey, I'm going to get out in this car and threaten
- 47:37the shit out of this guy. At least at that time, it wasn't
- 47:38to him that the reason is what we're talking about today in our podcast.
- 47:45This emotional base and this and this intellectual cognitive base. Right, This collectivism,
- 47:53the group versus the individualism myself, and these elements when they're in play,
- 48:00can lead to a number of rationalizations that ultimately lead to a murder,
- 48:07including the relationship between the victim and the perpetrator, the evidence, the type
- 48:12of evidence that you see at these crime scenes, and some of the other
- 48:16things. I wanted to mention that we're going to run out of time on
- 48:21rationalizing, too, is resolving the internal conflict we have with some moral discrepancy.
- 48:24Right, we have a moral issue with what we're doing, so we're
- 48:27going to rationalize to eliminate that internal conflict. And I think that there are
- 48:32those who you know, have cascading decisions. Is a great show concluding this
- 48:38particular episode. There's a great show I just finished on Netflix called Your Honor,
- 48:46which starts with a poor decision and then cascades and yeah it was based
- 48:54on but yeah, he tries to help his son protect his son, which
- 49:00is an altruistic kind of motive. Right, He's benevolently trying to protect his
- 49:06son, but by doing so, he has to tell a lie, and
- 49:07then that lie becomes a second lie, third lie leads to another person's death,
- 49:13then three or four other people's death, and then leads to the you
- 49:16know, I won't give the show away, but it shows the type of
- 49:21slippery slope that we can find ourselves on, as we now conclude as a
- 49:25culture, when we start normalizing these rational processes of selfishness leading to what's good
- 49:34for Andy, his best winning. As long as Andy wins, he's okay.
- 49:38And if you're the loser. You're a loser, right, And when
- 49:43that happens, God loved this country, right, God bless the United States
- 49:47when we're all individuals seeking our own individual needs and our pleasures at the cost
- 49:53of everyone else. I've always found the philosophy of law and the philosophy of
- 49:59psych called you. When you look at it, it's really interesting, and
- 50:01I think it's great to look at because I think it illustrates, not only
- 50:05to myself and to others as well, the complexity of life and the nuance
- 50:08that's involved. You cannot go into binary thinking of this or that. It's
- 50:13very dangerous to do that. Even your comment about altruism and reminded me of
- 50:16ayn Rand and when she used to say, is altruism really altruism? Isn't
- 50:21that just being selfish because it brings you pleasure in some sort? Right,
- 50:24I'm going to donate money to ten million dollars, but it's still giving you
- 50:28pleasure. I used to irritate my mom. I used to tell my mom.
- 50:34Humans are all self interested, but the extremes are selfishness and selflessness.
- 50:38Very few of us are selfless, and very few of us are selfish.
- 50:43Mother Teresa, mother tersa you would define as being selfless, was still and
- 50:47her altruism was looking at a greater benefit, which is life eternal in heaven.
- 50:52Right, So if I give this life to these lepers of Calcutta,
- 50:57God will reward me for life eternal. So that's a pretty good deal,
- 51:00right. And it's the same mindset that a young Palestinian boy might have when
- 51:06he blows himself up, because he's like, he's indoctrinated that if he gives
- 51:09his life up as a martyr here on earth, he gets to live forever
- 51:13in paradise. Antike particles family a lot of times too. And you know,
- 51:17Saint Francis not to compare the two mother Teresa and a Palestinian blowing himself
- 51:22up, but the motive and mindset and the cognitive process rationalization is similar.
- 51:27And what's interesting too is we look at these cases and we try to figure
- 51:31them out, and I, honestly, I couldn't rationalize personally. I could
- 51:37not rationalize giving my life up to servicing lepers in Calcutta anymore than I could
- 51:45strapping a bomb to my chest and yelling you know, or killing your own
- 51:49children, or killing my own children, or killing myself those are things that
- 51:53just you know, again, we're not talking about vast majority of people.
- 51:58We're talking about these these are unique and that therefore interesting because they're unique.
- 52:04But what's not unique is, and you and I want to continue this conversation,
- 52:07is the factors at play in our culture today that are desensitizing the collective
- 52:15and allowing for us to think in terms of winning and losing versus good and
- 52:20bad or right and wrong. And that's a dangerous slippery slope at least in
- 52:24this era that we live in. Absolutely think that's a good place to stop.
- 52:28Folks. Thanks again for listening. Hey, put your thoughts in there.
- 52:31It's a complicated topic. I know we kind of veered off a little
- 52:34bit, but we brought it into the philosophy of law, which is inherited
- 52:37into a lot of the cases that we discussed today. So make sure you
- 52:39share, subscribe hit that I like. But you know we like it.
- 52:44Do we like it because we're selfish? Well that's a question for another day.