Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Shaping the Defense: Strategic Jury Selection for Trial Victory
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to this morning's program, Shaping the
- 0:06Defense, Strategic Jury Selection for Trial Victory.
- 0:10I'm Alapoli Castro, Director of Education and
- 0:13Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:15Association. And today I am delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speakers, Keith Bremer and Vic Nagpal. Keith
- 0:23Bremer is a founding partner at Bremer White
- 0:25Brown and O'Meara and an acclaimed trial attorney
- 0:28recognized among California's top 100 attorneys
- 0:32with a long record of success in major civil
- 0:35commercial and high profile litigation. A member
- 0:38of ABOTA and the Litigation Council of America,
- 0:41he has earned numerous honors, including 17 consecutive
- 0:44years as a super lawyer and is frequently sought
- 0:47after nationwide as both a legal commentator
- 0:50and featured speaker. Vik Nagpal is the managing
- 0:54partner at Bremer White's San Diego offices,
- 0:58where he leads the firm's business development
- 1:00and handles cases involving complex general liability,
- 1:04construction defect, catastrophic injuries, toxic
- 1:06torts, and business litigation, just to name
- 1:08a few. With more than two decades of experience,
- 1:12he frequently provides training and seminars
- 1:15to the Department of Insurance on issues relating
- 1:17to his vast practice area. We can't wait to hear
- 1:21what they have to share with us today, so I'm
- 1:22going to turn it over to them. All right. Well,
- 1:26good morning, everyone. I hope everyone's doing
- 1:28well this Thursday, Friday Eve. Again, my name
- 1:31is Keith Bremer, my partner, Vic Nagpal. I've
- 1:33had the pleasure of sitting next to you for over
- 1:3520 years, and I love him. We're a majorly defense
- 1:39-oriented law firm. So today, I'm going to be
- 1:41talking about defense, about voir dire from the
- 1:44defense perspective. But a lot of times we do
- 1:47these seminars, and it's majority of the attendees
- 1:50or the people that participate are plaintiffs
- 1:52or plaintiff lawyers. So I want to talk a little
- 1:55bit about being a defense lawyer. First of all,
- 1:57it's a very tough job. Sometimes you have to
- 1:59defend absolutely terrible cases. So you can
- 2:02have admitted liability, horrific injuries, and
- 2:05your back is to the wall. The second part of
- 2:08being difficult is that we always go second.
- 2:12So great plaintiff lawyers get to go first in
- 2:14terms of introducing themselves, in terms of
- 2:16or dire. They get the last laugh with regard
- 2:19to a rebuttal closing. And we're always second.
- 2:22So plaintiff's case in chief is going to go first,
- 2:24and we're going to sit there and just hope that
- 2:27we're not getting killed too bad. So I want to
- 2:29talk a little bit about how do we handle those
- 2:30difficult cases? How do we handle being second?
- 2:34So there are some changes in the law, and almost
- 2:38all judges now are respecting that in terms of
- 2:40if there's a request for a meaning opening that
- 2:43the judge will then not provide the opening statement,
- 2:47a stipulated statement. Instead, he'll allow
- 2:49each counsel to do a two -minute opening statement.
- 2:53From a defense perspective, that's actually pretty
- 2:55good because for once, we get the last word before
- 2:59we go into voir dire. So plaintiff would go first,
- 3:02have a two -minute opening statement, and then
- 3:05defense would go. I would caution everyone on
- 3:07that opening statement to really be careful about
- 3:10not arguing. to try to stay neutral, to not polarize,
- 3:14anything like that. So there's that issue. And
- 3:18then we go into voir dire. Obviously, the judge
- 3:20would start the voir dire, and then the plaintiff
- 3:23would go first. So why is it a terrible job to
- 3:25be a defense lawyer? It's not a terrible job.
- 3:27It just can be very, very difficult or very hard.
- 3:29Let's talk about a clear liability case. You
- 3:32know, as a defense lawyer, we have so many different
- 3:34hats we need to wear. The client is in a really,
- 3:36really difficult situation and we need to be
- 3:39sympathetic with regard to where he or she is
- 3:42at, their company might be at. We have to deal
- 3:44with issues concerning insurance, no insurance,
- 3:48whether or not there's a reservation of rights,
- 3:52media, personal exposure, punitive damages. So
- 3:55there's a number of different things that we're
- 3:57juggling at the same time that we have to handle
- 4:00as a defense lawyer. At the same time, we have
- 4:02to consider the case, the facts, the circumstances,
- 4:06and our presentation, which I'm going to talk
- 4:08about. Where liability is admitted or acknowledged,
- 4:12it's important to acknowledge that someone's
- 4:13made a mistake to the jury and that we represent
- 4:16real people and that we, too, seek justice. I
- 4:18love that plaintiffs pound their chest and then
- 4:20we say they're seeking justice. Well, we seek
- 4:21justice just as much, and I make a point of saying
- 4:24that. Our job is to be their advocate and to
- 4:27hopefully do the best we can to mitigate their
- 4:30damages. including from many from from among
- 4:33other things we get involved in a rapid response
- 4:35program meaning that if there was a truck accident
- 4:37that happened tonight a large number of carriers
- 4:41have our contact clients have our contact i am
- 4:43a member of tita um and so i will get contacted
- 4:47in the middle of the night we'll have a rapid
- 4:50response so we're getting involved really really
- 4:52early from a defense perspective we're doing
- 4:54mock trials we're doing focus groups on issues
- 4:58We're acting as monitoring council on a tower
- 5:01backing up a primary council and we might even
- 5:05be brought in in a fire situation last minute
- 5:08to try to take over and kind of help out. So
- 5:11there's just so many different hats a defense
- 5:13lawyer has to wear in order to be totally prepared
- 5:16for the case and understand everything. Where
- 5:18there's a question of liability or damages, it's
- 5:20a little bit easier because you have a little
- 5:22bit more to argue. You can talk about shared
- 5:24responsibility and things like that. We're going
- 5:26to talk about how to handle that and sell that
- 5:28in voir dire. When we talk about shared responsibility,
- 5:32one of the things I like to do at the end of
- 5:34voir dire, my last question is act like I'm almost
- 5:36done and then say to the jury, does anyone here
- 5:41disagree that two people can be responsible for
- 5:44an accident? Is that a fair comment? Does everyone
- 5:47agree by a show of hands who agrees that two
- 5:50people can be responsible for the same accident?
- 5:53And so I kind of leave that with them. So I'm
- 5:55kind of jumping ahead a little bit only because
- 5:57I was talking about where there's questionable
- 5:59liability. And I want to talk a little bit about
- 6:00board dire. Consider a last question that resonates
- 6:03with the jury and makes them think about things.
- 6:06But from a defense standpoint, you know, we have
- 6:09the questionable liability and then we have the
- 6:11questionable injuries. whether or not the plaintiff
- 6:14had pre -existing and now they're trying to piggyback
- 6:17on the pre -existing. Is it an exacerbation?
- 6:19Is this an eggshell plaintiff? And we have to
- 6:23look at that. You have to look at the CACI instructions.
- 6:25You really, really need to understand Casey before
- 6:28ward ire. You need to understand what the instructions
- 6:30are, what's going to be read to the jury. Most
- 6:34judges will read preliminary jury instructions,
- 6:37a handful of jury instructions prior to um vor
- 6:41dire or prior to opening so you'll have to ask
- 6:43your judge some judges will not so be aware of
- 6:46that um from a defense perspective again being
- 6:50getting involved early in terms of looking who
- 6:53we have great experts in terms of accident recons
- 6:56biomechanics uh orthopedic surgeons neurologists
- 7:00radio neuro radiologists etc so building the
- 7:04right team so let's talk now a little bit about
- 7:07vor dire Everyone has a different approach to
- 7:12Bordire. For those who are attending this event,
- 7:16I'm sure that you've listened to five, six, seven
- 7:18other speakers. I've probably listened to 20
- 7:21different lawyers talk about Bordire. Everybody
- 7:24has a different tilt. Let me say this. The practice
- 7:27of law and Bordire is an art. The question is,
- 7:32what kind of picture are you painting and what
- 7:33do you want the jury to see? And remember, it's
- 7:36not always, it's not important as to what you
- 7:38say. What's important is what is received, what
- 7:40is heard, what resonates with that jury. So stop
- 7:44patting yourself on the back if you said the
- 7:46right things. If you haven't communicated something
- 7:48that resonated with the jury, you failed. So
- 7:51remember, what is the jury hearing? And so that's
- 7:53hard for us as lawyers, because we like to buy
- 7:55our own BS, so to speak. And so you've got to
- 7:59get out of that silo. And that's where the mock
- 8:00juries, that's where the focus groups really
- 8:03help. That's where talking to friends, talking
- 8:05to colleagues, talking to people on the other
- 8:08side of the bar and running issues by them and
- 8:10getting their ideas. So for me, board ire is
- 8:14about building a rapport. I call it the tribe.
- 8:17Some people disagree with that approach, but
- 8:18for me, I think it's really important to build
- 8:20a tribe. Obviously my goal is to weed out bad
- 8:23jurors. My goal is to take advantage of four
- 8:27cause versus my preemptory challenges. For those
- 8:30who are not aware, we're only provided six preemptory
- 8:32challenges per side. So if there's more than
- 8:34one defendant, you could make a colorable argument
- 8:37that there's two sides. You may get 12. Some
- 8:41judges may give you six or three. They could
- 8:44break them up. But what you want to take advantage
- 8:46of obviously is the four cause challenges. And
- 8:49we'll talk a little bit about that. I know a
- 8:51lot of people talk a lot about that. My focus
- 8:54in court dire is to build a tribe. And what does
- 8:56that mean? I'm a staunch believer you have to
- 9:00be authentic. If you're not going to be real,
- 9:02if you're not going to be yourself, I think you're
- 9:04going to fail. So as much as I think John Morgan
- 9:07is amazing and I'd love to do everything he says
- 9:09in his podcast and follow along. And by the way,
- 9:12I steal a ton of his stuff and I'll be talking
- 9:14about that. I still have to be me. And so be
- 9:18authentic. With regard to being authentic, I
- 9:21think it's important as a defense lawyer that
- 9:23you appreciate empathy and what that means. Real
- 9:25empathy means you stand in the shoes of the plaintiff
- 9:27and what he or she went through, felt, smelled,
- 9:30touched, saw, where they come from, how they
- 9:32were raised, how far that apple fell from the
- 9:35tree, so to speak. I think credibility is probably
- 9:40everything. So the reason why I feel it's so
- 9:43important to build a tribe is that, first of
- 9:45all, I think when you get up and board dire,
- 9:47you only get one chance to make a first impression.
- 9:49So make sure when you get up there and your first
- 9:5120 to 30 seconds are impactful, that you're authentic,
- 9:55that you're real, and that you're trying to let
- 9:57them know that you genuinely care about the outcome
- 10:00of this case and you want justice. And that for
- 10:03me, I'm empowering this jury. So that's probably
- 10:06my biggest takeaway for me is I'm building a
- 10:09tribe and I'm empowering them. I love the system.
- 10:11I love the process. I love finding justice. But
- 10:15that only works with the jury. Keith, along those
- 10:18lines about you have that first impression, I
- 10:21think all is for us, and I've learned a lot from
- 10:23Keith who's done tons of trials, is we want our
- 10:25client present during barter. So we want to humanize
- 10:31our client. We want the jury to see that they
- 10:34think that this is important to them. We want
- 10:37them to get to know our client. And where I think
- 10:39on the other side, on the plaintiff's side, sometimes
- 10:42they do, sometimes they don't want their clients
- 10:45there because there's a perception that the jury's
- 10:48watching every move that that plaintiff makes,
- 10:51how they get up out of their chair, how they
- 10:53walk in and out of the courtroom. And potentially,
- 10:57I think from the plaintiff's side, there's a
- 11:00concern that this jury pool is predetermining
- 11:03the validity of their alleged injuries. So there's
- 11:06definitely a difference. I think from our side,
- 11:10we generally want our client there all the time.
- 11:13be able to introduce them and let the jury get
- 11:15to know them as much as they can. And then along
- 11:19the same line, I know Keith is going to be getting
- 11:21into the questions and sort of things that we
- 11:24look at and talk about and, you know, sympathy.
- 11:27I would also caution that, like, you should pay
- 11:31close attention to nonverbal cues as well. So
- 11:35when Keith gets into, you know, responses that
- 11:37we're getting or questions we're asking and whether
- 11:39we're setting someone up for a cause, Also pay
- 11:43close attention to the nonverbal cues, facial
- 11:46expressions, and their overall demeanor because
- 11:49I think that provides a valuable insight into
- 11:52a juror's attitude that the words might not fully
- 11:55reveal to you. Thanks, Vic. So I want to go back
- 12:00to building that report in that tribe and that
- 12:02first 20 to 30 seconds of coming out there. So
- 12:06for me, It's being authentic. And again, I have
- 12:10this love of the system. I love the process.
- 12:13And so as a defense lawyer, I always speak about
- 12:16how do we evaluate and value a case, because
- 12:20that's our job. And our job in a tripartite relationship,
- 12:23if we have a client, an insurance company, and
- 12:25then our representation, the tripartite relationship.
- 12:28Our client is our evaluation of the case, because
- 12:31the carrier wants us to say one thing, the client
- 12:33wants us to say another in terms of whether a
- 12:36policy is going to be open, not open, et cetera.
- 12:38Our job is to evaluate and value the case. So
- 12:41every case has a value every single day, and
- 12:46that value changes every single day based on
- 12:48the facts and circumstances and evidence that
- 12:51is learned, i .e. discovery through a deposition
- 12:54response to interrogatories. change in plaintiff's
- 12:57physical condition, plaintiff's presentation
- 12:58in the deposition, all of that in comparison
- 13:01to what would a reasoned jury in that jurisdiction
- 13:04do at this time. So I'm always looking to where's
- 13:10the jurisdiction? Who's the judge? Am I in a
- 13:13conservative venue or am I in a liberal venue?
- 13:18because I'm looking at the jury. So for me, I
- 13:21want to empower this jury to appreciate that.
- 13:23I appreciate the system and the process. I love
- 13:26that they're there. I know they don't want to
- 13:27be there, but I know they're going to love that.
- 13:30And I'm going to talk about that in a second
- 13:31in terms of them not loving to be there and how
- 13:34I play that. But I want to go back to the tribe.
- 13:36So for me, I tell the jury, look, today is going
- 13:40to be an amazing day for you. You are going to
- 13:43be the judges of the facts. you are going to
- 13:46sit as the judges. Now the judge is going to
- 13:48give you the law that you're going to follow.
- 13:49He gives you the law or she gives you the law
- 13:51and then you'll follow that law, but you'll apply
- 13:54the facts and circumstances of this case and
- 13:56the evidence that you get from that witness stand
- 13:58right over there to this case. And that's a pretty
- 14:01awesome amount of authority, a pretty awesome
- 14:03amount of power, and you get to do justice in
- 14:06this case. And while I may give you recommendations
- 14:08as to what I think the evidence is going to show
- 14:10or what I'm doing in terms of this case, ultimately,
- 14:13you're going to be the judges of the facts, and
- 14:15I respect that. So for me, the first 20 to 30
- 14:20seconds when you come out, I think you've got
- 14:22to have a spiel. And I'm going to get to that
- 14:23in a second. I'm going to talk about that first
- 14:25impression and what you should do. I want you
- 14:27to feel comfortable. Everyone should feel comfortable.
- 14:29Because if you go out and you're going to do
- 14:31a John Morgan first war dire, it's not you. You're
- 14:34acting. It's not authentic. So you need to have
- 14:36something that you can really, that's visceral,
- 14:38that's you, that you believe in, that you're
- 14:40going with. So we'll talk about that in a second.
- 14:43So before you start war dire, you have to start
- 14:45thinking about your case. And one of the things
- 14:47I want to talk about is for us, we're proactive.
- 14:52So we're offensive as a law firm. We're not defensive.
- 14:55So I guess I do care, but I barely care what
- 14:58plaintiff is doing in terms of two -minute opening,
- 15:01in terms of the voir dire. I have my themes,
- 15:05and I have my story, and I'm going to tell a
- 15:07story. So let me give you an example. One time
- 15:10I tried a case against a fantastic trial lawyer
- 15:12in San Bernardino, his name is Bill Shapiro.
- 15:15And Bill got up and it was a TBI, a clear liability
- 15:20case with a TBI on a TBA. And I really liked
- 15:24the case. I really liked where I was going. I
- 15:26really liked my arguments. And Bill got up and
- 15:29did a 45 minute opening that was the best opening
- 15:32I'd ever heard. And I started sweating. The judge
- 15:36said, do you want a break? I'm like, yeah, I
- 15:37need a break. I'm going to throw up and go to
- 15:38the bathroom. I'll be back if I don't have a
- 15:41heart attack. And I thought about rewriting my
- 15:44entire opening again and changing it and being
- 15:46reactive. But I didn't do that. I was offensive.
- 15:50And I'm going to be consistent and we're going
- 15:52to be consistent as a law firm in terms of doing
- 15:54that. We appreciate that plaintiff has themes,
- 15:57plaintiff has a story they're going to tell,
- 15:59but we have our themes and our story. So as amazing
- 16:02as, let's just keep using John Morgan, who is
- 16:05a legend, as our example, does a phenomenal two
- 16:08minute opening. I've got my two minute opening.
- 16:11I've already done it. I've already thought about
- 16:12it. I've thought about my thematics. I've thought
- 16:13about everything I've done and I'm going to move
- 16:16forward with what I'm going to do. Same in board
- 16:18hire. Now that's not to say that I'm going to
- 16:20abandon addressing certain things that are brought
- 16:22up. The great plaintiff lawyers bring up a number
- 16:25of things. They set a number of traps and you
- 16:27have to be aware of them and then you interweave
- 16:30them in with the theme and the story that you're
- 16:32going to tell and what you're trying to accomplish
- 16:34in war dire. Now look at don't try to accomplish
- 16:36too much in war dire. A lot of times people go
- 16:39in with with one goal. I'm going to get rid of
- 16:42jurors for cost and it's almost like a sport.
- 16:45I think you're missing the point. The next thing
- 16:47is a lot of lawyers go into board hire saying,
- 16:51I'm going to communicate a message. I'm going
- 16:52to win this case in board hire. I'm going to
- 16:54start to really plant some seeds. First of all,
- 16:56most of the judges aren't allowing that these
- 16:57days and they're going to shut you down. And
- 17:00the second thing is that you're going to get
- 17:01off track and you're going to lose sight of what
- 17:04you're really trying to do. And that's find the
- 17:06right jurors for the right cases. So first thing
- 17:09you want to do. is get identified. What is your
- 17:12juror profile? What are you looking for from
- 17:14a defense perspective? I'm not going to give
- 17:15you anything you hadn't already thought about.
- 17:17You have like business owners, managers, guys
- 17:20who care about budgets, fiscal responsibility,
- 17:24frivolous lawsuits. They're less emotional. They're
- 17:27more pragmatic. You like engineers. We like accountants,
- 17:30detail or any professionals. They like objective
- 17:33proof, right? Listen, the other thing I want
- 17:37to tell you is just because somebody else has
- 17:38suffered a similar injury. in a case doesn't
- 17:41mean you want to throw them out with the bathwater.
- 17:43And when we talk about bad cases, I just got
- 17:45out of trial in the city of Modesto on a child
- 17:48molestation case. By far the worst experience
- 17:51of my life in terms of trying a case. I hate
- 17:53it. I didn't like anything about it. Facts were
- 17:55bad. Evidence was bad. Horrible experience. But
- 17:59in that case, when I talked about what's the
- 18:01perfect profile, initially I thought... anyone
- 18:05who had been molested or anyone who had a family
- 18:08member or good friend had been molested. And
- 18:10by the way, the questionnaire we sent to 60 people
- 18:13and 26 of them either personally were molested
- 18:16or had a personal friend or family member that
- 18:18were molested. So I had a lot to work with there.
- 18:23But the truth of the matter is that some of those
- 18:26potential jurors were pretty good jurors. They
- 18:29went through a traumatic situation when they
- 18:31were in third grade or fourth grade. But They
- 18:34processed it, they went through it and they're
- 18:37way better and they've moved on. In my case,
- 18:39I had a plaintiff who, I hate to use the word
- 18:41malingering because everyone's going to say,
- 18:43oh, it's such a defense comment. But someone
- 18:45who I thought was utilizing that to tie all their
- 18:50ill wills or all their bad luck in their whole
- 18:52life to and didn't take any personal accountability
- 18:54for trying to make a difference or make a change
- 18:57and go in a different direction. So just because
- 18:59someone else had been in a motorcycle accident,
- 19:01just because someone else had been molested,
- 19:03Don't just write them off. Look at the impression
- 19:05of that person. In fact, I just did this seminar,
- 19:08one just like it with Jan Kramer the other day,
- 19:10and we were vorediring an individual. And we
- 19:12talked about the fact that the plaintiff doesn't
- 19:15speak English. And when we voredired, somebody
- 19:17said, well, I'm initially a little critical of
- 19:19someone who's been here 20 years that doesn't
- 19:21speak English. And then as we voredired that
- 19:23witness, we all concluded that that would be
- 19:25a good juror for the plaintiff in this case.
- 19:27So while we started off thinking that jury doesn't
- 19:30work, so don't write people off right away. Be
- 19:33open to it. Be receptive. Again, you're trying
- 19:35to start a dialogue. and build a rapport. For
- 19:39me, I'm building a tribe. And what do I mean
- 19:40by that? I want them to believe that I'm someone
- 19:43they would hang out with, someone they would
- 19:45rely on, someone that they might ask an important
- 19:47question to. And if they trust me and I want
- 19:50them to trust me and I'm being authentic, then
- 19:52they might let a little bit of that wear on my
- 19:54client. They might throw a little bit. So if
- 19:56my client doesn't do so well on cross. If my
- 20:00client doesn't present so great, if the facts
- 20:02aren't great, maybe the client gets a little
- 20:04bit of the benefit of the doubt by 2%. I'm not
- 20:06saying it's anything significant. But again,
- 20:08I've got a job and my job is to do the best job
- 20:12I can for my client. And that means maintaining
- 20:14authenticity and professionalism. And along those
- 20:17lines, most lawyers lose it in board dire. If
- 20:20I say that I've seen lawyers lose it. Sure, I've
- 20:24seen cross where they've lost it or a witness
- 20:25that wasn't going well, but it's in for dire
- 20:28sometimes when when a juror doesn't give him
- 20:30or her a simple, easy answer that's so elementary.
- 20:35And so, for example, I understand you don't like
- 20:38police officers, but you'd agree that on occasion,
- 20:41you know, you might need a police officer. In
- 20:43fact, have you ever needed a police officer in
- 20:45an emergency situation? Never. Have you ever
- 20:47thought that there are people that needed a police
- 20:49officer in an emergency situation? Probably not.
- 20:52And you want to go, what is wrong with you right
- 20:54now? Clearly, that's OK. You know that there
- 20:57are police officers who add value on occasion,
- 20:59right? So you don't ever want to do that. This
- 21:02is the perfect example of why we went to law
- 21:04school and what we've learned to be pragmatic
- 21:07is to be patient and understand. And listen,
- 21:10in trial, we've got a gun firing out her head.
- 21:12That gun is coming from. from the judge. It's
- 21:15coming from the jury. It's coming from the plaintiff.
- 21:17It's coming from my client. It's coming from
- 21:19the insurance carrier behind me. It's coming
- 21:21from monitor counsel behind me. It's hard and
- 21:24there's a lot of pressure in that cooker, but
- 21:25you got to keep your cool and you got to work
- 21:27with the jury. Do not fight with the juror ever.
- 21:31That is terrible. OK, so we already talked about
- 21:36the good jurors. Now let's talk about the bad
- 21:37jurors. You've got to lay out what are the red
- 21:40flags you're looking for, who are the jurors
- 21:42you don't want, and identifying what those red
- 21:45flags are. Vic, where are you at? No, I totally
- 21:48agree. And just before we move on, you're going
- 21:51to ask all these questions to jurors. And I agree.
- 21:56If you don't get an answer that you don't like
- 21:58or think is a bad answer or response, don't just
- 22:01move on. you need to talk through it, because
- 22:04I think what you do is you'll shut off more jurors
- 22:06than you realize at that point if you do that.
- 22:09And even when you're asking all these questions,
- 22:11there's never any guarantee of who you're gonna
- 22:14get, right? You're gonna do your best job, you're
- 22:16gonna ask these questions, you're gonna try to
- 22:18delve deeper into their background or why they
- 22:22feel a certain way, but at the end of the day,
- 22:25there's never a guarantee of who you're gonna
- 22:26get. So for example, we had a case, this was
- 22:29a while ago, went to verdict with three parties.
- 22:34And we were excited, personally, I was excited
- 22:36to have a juror who was a paralegal because there
- 22:39were some contract terms that were at issue,
- 22:42expressed indemnity, and we thought that she
- 22:44would have the legal acumen to understand that.
- 22:48It was like a hybrid real estate case. I was
- 22:50like a sick house because there was some physical
- 22:52injury components to it. So in closing, plaintiff
- 22:56used an analogy that This was their client's
- 23:00dream home. And when it finally got into the
- 23:03home, it was more of a sick house because once
- 23:07they moved in, it was just full of problems,
- 23:09not only from a physical injury standpoint, but
- 23:11from the way the house was built. So he used
- 23:15the analogy that this home that they bargained
- 23:17for was a home that fell off a truck because
- 23:21it had so many problems. So long story short,
- 23:23we got a defense verdict. The other defendant
- 23:25got hit pretty hard. and we had an opportunity
- 23:27to pull the jury afterwards. So we went up to
- 23:30the paralegal juror that served, and we found
- 23:34that, you know, asked her the general questions
- 23:35of, why did you rule this way? Or what did you
- 23:39like? What didn't you like? And then why did
- 23:41you find in favor of the plaintiffs versus the
- 23:44other defendant? And her response was, because
- 23:47the house fell off a truck. She actually believed
- 23:50that. So my point is that although we're trying
- 23:53to do our best by asking questions, There's absolutely,
- 23:57as everyone knows in law, there's 100 % no guarantee
- 24:00of what jury you're going to get or what they're
- 24:02actually thinking. Now, if you're asking questions
- 24:05to a juror and you like what they say, so there
- 24:08was another case that we had with one of our
- 24:12other partners, and that case was dealing with
- 24:15someone who claimed that they were injured by
- 24:17a dart in a bar. So during voir dire, our partner
- 24:22asked if anyone thinks having darts in a bar
- 24:25is inherently dangerous and a specific juror
- 24:28said no and then she started talking about that
- 24:30how she's been to bars with axe throwing and
- 24:33so that was great for us and then she talked
- 24:35about how you know people need to start taking
- 24:38responsibility for their own actions so when
- 24:41we like a response like that we just you know
- 24:44we ask them what else and we take them down a
- 24:46path that's beneficial for us and then surprisingly
- 24:49she made the jury And that's probably because
- 24:52the other side didn't take her down a path to
- 24:55get her removed for cause or with a peremptory
- 24:58challenge. But we'll get into that in terms of
- 25:02for cause, Vic, in a sec. I want to talk about
- 25:06that first impression now. So again, for me and
- 25:11for our law firm, when we get a new case in,
- 25:14And it's a bigger case. And we see it's one that's
- 25:16going to go down the road a little bit. We definitely
- 25:19have a roundtable meeting and talk about what
- 25:23are the themes of this case? What's our story?
- 25:25What is the story that we're going to tell? Where
- 25:27are we going? And then we organize our thoughts
- 25:31with regard to what those themes are and how
- 25:33we're going to run those themes through discovery,
- 25:35how we're going to run those themes through deposition,
- 25:39how we're going to do that by way of direct evidence,
- 25:41cross -examination, trial, et cetera. And we
- 25:44weave that into our story. So when we start off
- 25:48in Bordire, you're going to have that first minute
- 25:50to introduce yourself. and to talk about your
- 25:53theme or your story for just a second. And I've
- 25:56just got a few that I just are my quote unquote
- 25:59go -tos with regard to what is the case. So let's
- 26:02just say it's a case that I think is a highly
- 26:05questionable liability case. Great damage case,
- 26:07but a highly questionable liability case. Maybe
- 26:09a slip and fall on an arguably open and obvious
- 26:13condition with a significant injury. So one of
- 26:16the things I'll say is, ladies and gentlemen,
- 26:18my name is Keith Bremer. I represent, you know,
- 26:20Joe's diner here. Joe's with me. I can't wait
- 26:24for you to meet Joe. Joe's a great guy. He's
- 26:26owned the diner for 20 years. If, you know, don't
- 26:30forget, Motions of Limne are going to be heard
- 26:31about five minutes before this war dyer. Let's
- 26:33assume that in the Motions of Limne, I got in
- 26:35that I could talk about the fact that there's
- 26:37been no other accidents ever. And Joe's going
- 26:39to tell you in his 20 years, he's never had anything
- 26:41like this ever happen. And this has been a horrible
- 26:43situation. certainly empathetic and sympathetic
- 26:47to the fact that plaintiff was significantly
- 26:49injured, but it's our contention that we didn't
- 26:52do anything wrong, ladies and gentlemen. So with
- 26:54that, does anyone here believe that just because
- 26:58we're here, Joe or my client might have done
- 27:01something wrong? We have a board dire, we have
- 27:03a judge, I'm wearing a tie, I generally don't
- 27:05wear a tie. Does anyone believe just because
- 27:07we're here that we must have done something wrong?
- 27:10no one raises their hand, I then push a little
- 27:12bit. So listen, today in Vor Dire, I'm just as
- 27:15nervous as you are. This is a difficult situation.
- 27:18What we're looking for is the right juror for
- 27:21the right case. And I need everyone to give me
- 27:24some honesty and just to be open as much as you
- 27:26can, and I'll be open as well. This is the no
- 27:29harm zone. You can say whatever you want to say,
- 27:31and you're going to be OK. Clearly, there are
- 27:34people out there that think that potentially,
- 27:37My client must have done something wrong or we
- 27:38shouldn't be here. And I appreciate that. That's
- 27:40a natural, normal thing for someone to think.
- 27:42Does someone agree that someone must be doing
- 27:44something wrong or we wouldn't be here, right?
- 27:46Fair. Now you're going to get someone to raise
- 27:48their hand. You're going to say, thank you, jury
- 27:50number three, Vic. I appreciate that. But I want
- 27:53you to appreciate that this is our system. And
- 27:56I love our system, ladies and gentlemen. Our
- 27:58system's amazing because you are the judges of
- 28:00the facts. And you get to determine whether or
- 28:03not this case should be here or it shouldn't
- 28:05be here. And we take the position that this is
- 28:09a case of no liability. But we believe this is
- 28:12the right place to have this case heard. And
- 28:15we don't want vigilante in the street. We want
- 28:16justice. And you're part of that justice. Does
- 28:19everyone appreciate that? So you haven't heard
- 28:21any evidence. You don't know anything. And so
- 28:24plaintiff hasn't met any burden of proof. The
- 28:27slate is clean right now. Just because we're
- 28:30here doesn't mean anyone did anything wrong.
- 28:31It's that these two parties have a dispute amongst
- 28:33themselves, and we need your help as the judges
- 28:36of the facts to determine where we're going.
- 28:38So that might be one way that I start the trial.
- 28:41Another way I might start the trial is just to
- 28:43say, hey, ladies and gentlemen, my name is Keith
- 28:44Bremmer. I represent Joe, Joe Zeiner. Love Joe,
- 28:47I can't wait for you to meet him. He's going
- 28:48to make a great witness. He's a great guy. He's
- 28:51genuine. And we're certainly empathetic about
- 28:53what's going on here. So this is Vordire. And
- 28:56Vordire is a weird word and confusing. And I'm
- 28:59sure a lot of you are intimidated. And I'm intimidated.
- 29:02And there's a lot of pressure to be here. Vordire
- 29:05means speak the truth. But that's not really
- 29:07what we're doing here in Vordire. What we're
- 29:09really doing in Vordire is determining whether
- 29:10you, the juror, a potential juror is the right
- 29:13juror for this case. So let me give you an example.
- 29:15So not all jurors are the right jurors for a
- 29:17particular case. Say, for example, that I was
- 29:20asked, I told you I'd bring up John Morgan, I
- 29:22was asked to be a judge in a pie eating contest.
- 29:27Well, it turns out I don't like cherry pie. So
- 29:30I wouldn't be the best pie eating. Judge because
- 29:33if you made a cherry pie, you're gonna be sunk
- 29:35as a result of that or let's say that you were
- 29:37involved in a motorcycle This is not a motorcycle
- 29:39case. Let's say that you were involved in a motorcycle
- 29:41case A year ago and you had a terrible A terrible
- 29:47recovery. It was horrible and you are extremely
- 29:51critical of people on motorcycles And this is
- 29:54a motorcycle case. Well, you wouldn't be the
- 29:55right juror for this case. So what we're doing
- 29:57in voir dire. So we're going to ask questions
- 29:59to determine whether or not you can be fair and
- 30:01impartial in this case. And let me talk a little
- 30:04bit about being fair and impartial. What that
- 30:05means is since we haven't heard any evidence
- 30:07and all the evidence is going to come from that
- 30:08witness stand back there. We have two white blank
- 30:11pieces of paper in front of us. We don't nobody
- 30:14is is it has anything written that gives anybody
- 30:18an advantage. It's as if we have two horses at
- 30:20the starting gate at the exact same place. No
- 30:23horses ahead of the other. And that's what we
- 30:25want. We want a jury that's fully impartial before
- 30:29we get started. Once the evidence comes in, that's
- 30:31going to change. When I do do that spiel, I then
- 30:35move into the next spiel, which is I'm the defendant,
- 30:37ladies and gentlemen, and as the defendant, I
- 30:39go second. That's the way the system works. We
- 30:41can't both go at the same time. So plaintiff's
- 30:43going to go first, then I'm going to go second.
- 30:45So one of the key things that I need from you
- 30:47is can you be patient? I'll tell you what, life
- 30:51is interesting, isn't it? We all have first impressions,
- 30:53right? This morning, I went to Starbucks and
- 30:57I ordered a latte. And so I walk up to the counter
- 30:59and I looked up at my barista and she had three
- 31:04earrings in her nose. She had a big feather.
- 31:07Half her hair was purple and half her hair was
- 31:09black. And I'm like, I don't know that you're
- 31:11the best person to make me a latte, but I'm here
- 31:14and I ordered the latte. and when I got the latte
- 31:17she had this beautiful heart in the latte and
- 31:19it was the best latte I ever had so my first
- 31:22impression or my quick judgment would have been
- 31:24off and that's how this trial is you have to
- 31:28be patient and one of the things the judge is
- 31:30going to say to you the judge gives you the law
- 31:32that you have to follow One of the laws the judge
- 31:34is going to give you is that you're not to talk
- 31:36amongst yourselves, you're not to talk at home
- 31:39to your friend, to your spouse, no Google searches,
- 31:42because we want you to get all the facts and
- 31:44evidence in this case from that witness stand
- 31:46after all the evidence comes in. Since plaintiff
- 31:49goes first, it's easy to make a quick judgment
- 31:51and go, oh, I don't like that coffee at all,
- 31:54or I don't want that barista at all. Be patient.
- 31:56Wait. If you love what plaintiff has to say,
- 31:59that's great too, but I'm gonna get up next and
- 32:01I'm gonna do the cross of that witness. Then
- 32:03there's gonna be another witness, another witness,
- 32:05and it's all gonna come together. So you have
- 32:07to be patient to see whether or not you like
- 32:09the coffee at the end. And by talking to each
- 32:12other, or by not being patient, then you start
- 32:14to form opinions. based on those conversations
- 32:17or talking to someone at home or Google searching
- 32:20or any of those things. We don't want that. We
- 32:22want you to hear the entire case. So patience
- 32:24is such an important part of this case. So hard
- 32:27to do because we all make first impressions.
- 32:28I did it this morning, but I could tell you I
- 32:30had the best latte and I'm pretty fired up right
- 32:33now. So that's another way you can kind of get
- 32:35started and go where you're going. Vic, did you
- 32:38want to chime in at all? No, I think that's right
- 32:40on the mark. That's exactly what I was going
- 32:42to say. Okay, so, you know, and nothing wrong
- 32:47with saying, you know, getting up there and say,
- 32:49hey, my name is Keith Brammon. I've got Joe,
- 32:50Joe's Diner. Hey, it looks bad in this case.
- 32:54I'm not saying it doesn't look bad, ladies and
- 32:55gentlemen, but I need you to keep an open mind
- 32:57because we definitely have a caser and we take
- 32:59the position that this is a case of shared responsibility.
- 33:03That plaintiff, too, is responsible for this
- 33:05accident, not just my client. And can everyone
- 33:07keep an open mind now? Can everyone be patient
- 33:10and let plaintiff put on his or her case? then
- 33:13I'll do my cross, then we'll go to the next witness,
- 33:15then plaintiff's gonna rest their case, then
- 33:16I'm gonna put my case on, and then we're gonna
- 33:19have closings, et cetera. You have to wait to
- 33:21hear everything come together, to see all the
- 33:24puzzle pieces come together before you make a
- 33:26decision whether or not you like the picture
- 33:28and the puzzle, or whether or not the coffee
- 33:29tastes good or not. Can everyone be patient and
- 33:32do that? So, find your own spiel with regard
- 33:35to what you're doing, because you wanna make
- 33:39that first minute like comfortable for yourself
- 33:41because you want to get the butterflies out.
- 33:43Everybody's nervous. John Morgan said it himself.
- 33:45There isn't a trial. He doesn't get up real quick
- 33:47in the board hour for that first second or two
- 33:49and get nervous. And if a guy like him gets nervous,
- 33:51well, that's that's a license for me to stay
- 33:53nervous the entire trial for six straight weeks
- 33:56every single day. So again, that first two minutes
- 33:59is important. Again, for me, from a defense standpoint,
- 34:03I talk about patience. I hit it. I spent a lot
- 34:05of time on it. I have different examples. I just
- 34:07shared one with you on a Starbucks. But come
- 34:09up with your own, whatever you like. From there,
- 34:14obviously, from a defense standpoint, the next
- 34:16biggest thing is sympathy and emotion. Before
- 34:18I go there, Vic, anything on your end? No, I
- 34:20think just to close up what you're saying. Look,
- 34:23everybody's different. Everyone has different
- 34:24personalities. You have to be genuine to yourself.
- 34:28Because if you're not, If you're trying to fake
- 34:30it and trying to be someone that you're not in
- 34:32front of a jury, trying to be more animated and
- 34:35that's really not your personality, don't see
- 34:38right through it, right? We're asking them to
- 34:39be honest, and we ask for their brutal honesty.
- 34:43And so I think also we need to play that part
- 34:46and be true to ourselves, because I think the
- 34:48jury's smarter than we think they are, and they're
- 34:50watching what we do as well. Just like we're
- 34:52watching them, they're doing the same with us.
- 34:56Thanks, Vic. OK, so the next thing I say is,
- 35:00hey, ladies and gentlemen, another thing that
- 35:02the judge is going to give you, the judge is
- 35:03going to give you the law that you have to follow.
- 35:05And by the way, that can be a tough situation.
- 35:08And so I will go into, hey, is everyone comfortable
- 35:10following the law that the judge likes to follow,
- 35:12that the judge gives you? You guys are the judges
- 35:15of the facts. You're going to determine this
- 35:16case. You're going to talk about the evidence.
- 35:18You're going to weigh the evidence. You're going
- 35:19to talk about a decision in this case. But the
- 35:23judge is going to give you the law. that you
- 35:25have to follow. And one of those laws is you
- 35:27can't base this case, you can't make a decision
- 35:30on this case based on sympathy or emotion or
- 35:32passion. That's one of the laws he's going to
- 35:34give you. And the reason why we want that is
- 35:36we want you to decide this case based on the
- 35:38facts and evidence from that witness chair. From
- 35:41the facts and evidence, not from emotion and
- 35:43passion because we feel bad for the plaintiff.
- 35:46Listen, ladies and gentlemen, this is a hard
- 35:48one. I'm a super visceral person so you can't
- 35:51just walk through those doors back there and
- 35:53there's a little box and says put your emotion
- 35:54and your passion and your sympathy in the box
- 35:57and then sit in this jury box. I understand that's
- 36:00not that easy to do but it's important that you
- 36:04understand what the judge is giving you in terms
- 36:05of law on that issue that you have to set that
- 36:08aside. and decide this case based on the facts
- 36:10and circumstances. So even though plaintiff may
- 36:13have a catastrophic injury, may not have a catastrophic
- 36:15injury, you have to determine whether or not
- 36:17my client caused that, whether or not there's
- 36:21shared responsibility, there's arguments of pre
- 36:23-existing, you have to weigh all of those things.
- 36:25And we don't want you to be swayed by sympathy.
- 36:29So opening frame, I threw a few out there. All
- 36:32of us are sympathetic as to anyone who's been
- 36:35hurt. That's just human nature. That's a good
- 36:38thing. Does everyone agree with that? By a show
- 36:39of hands, everyone agrees. By a show of hands,
- 36:42does everyone appreciate what I'm trying to say?
- 36:44That we need to put that sympathy aside and just
- 36:46based on the evidence and the facts, decide this
- 36:49case. That's really hard to do. Can everyone
- 36:51do that? By a show of hands, raise your hand
- 36:52if you can do that. Again, the judge is going
- 36:54to instruct you on that. And by the way, I do
- 36:56go and we talk about patience. I do say the judge
- 36:58is going to give you an instruction over and
- 37:00over again. Don't talk amongst yourself. Don't
- 37:02go home. Don't talk. And the reason why that's
- 37:04so important. So I forgot to say that. I'm going
- 37:06to talk about that law first. So again, this
- 37:08is going to be hard. I'm not going to pretend
- 37:10it's easy. But do you think you can follow that
- 37:12instruction? And listen, the judge is going to
- 37:14give you the law that you have to follow. And
- 37:16sometimes that's hard. Let me give you an example.
- 37:19Flag burning in the United States is legal as
- 37:21a matter of law because a judge, a federal judge
- 37:23has determined that that's not a violation. That
- 37:26is in accord with the free speech provided it's
- 37:29not associated with violence. I strongly disagree
- 37:32with that. I don't want flag burning. So I would
- 37:35have a hard time following that law in that case.
- 37:37But I understand as a juror, if that was the
- 37:40law the judge gave me, flag burning in and of
- 37:42itself is not illegal in the United States. Can
- 37:46you accept that? As a juror, I have to accept
- 37:48that. So the judge is gonna give you the law.
- 37:51I think you're gonna agree with 99 % of it, I
- 37:53would imagine, but that's the law you guys have
- 37:55to follow. And again, one of those laws is sympathy
- 37:58and emotion. You have to set that aside. Another
- 38:00one of those admonitions is don't talk amongst
- 38:03yourself until you get in the jury room and you've
- 38:06heard all the evidence in totality and you've
- 38:08given Mr. Bremmer, the defense lawyer, a chance
- 38:10to cross and put his or her case on, my case
- 38:13on, okay? So, again on sympathy and emotion,
- 38:17I spent a lot of time on sympathy and emotion.
- 38:18Is that hard for you? Can each of you put that
- 38:21issue aside? We all have sympathy, but can you
- 38:23follow the law? Is there anyone who feels when
- 38:26someone's harmed, it's impossible to separate
- 38:27emotion from legal responsibility? So, if you
- 38:30were selected as a juror and you did feel sympathy
- 38:33for the plaintiff, but you felt plaintiff had
- 38:35not met the burden of proof with respect to certain
- 38:37issues, could you, in that setting, decide against
- 38:40the plaintiff on an issue? That's really the
- 38:42big question. As empathetic as we may all be
- 38:45for the injury, if plaintiff doesn't meet the
- 38:47burden of proof, can you say that the plaintiff
- 38:50takes nothing? Raise your hand if you can't do
- 38:52that. Now, I'd like you to raise your hand if
- 38:55you can. If at the end of the day, no matter
- 38:57how bad or how sorry I feel for the fact that
- 38:59the plaintiff was injured, and I'm acknowledging,
- 39:01ladies and gentlemen, the plaintiff was unequivocally
- 39:03injured in this case, can you award plaintiff
- 39:06nothing? if plaintiff doesn't meet the burden
- 39:09of proof. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. So
- 39:12even if you have bad feelings, let's see what
- 39:14it solves. Plaintiff's story is emotional. So
- 39:16the next thing I would talk about is I lost my
- 39:20train of thought there. Give me one second. Is
- 39:28sympathy an emotion? Okay, so I want to get into
- 39:33four college challenges, but I think I'm missing
- 39:35something. Oh, I wanted to talk next about burden
- 39:37-approved. So that slides nicely into when you're
- 39:41finding it, what's the evidence, what's the burden
- 39:43-approved? So many times this happens. In fact,
- 39:47it happened the other day with Dan Kramer and
- 39:49Robert Glassman where they talked to the jury
- 39:52first and they talked about the burden of proof
- 39:54and they talked about criminal and it's beyond
- 39:56a reasonable doubt. And then in our case, it's
- 39:58a preponderance. And what's a preponderance?
- 40:00It's the scales of justice. It's a feather. So
- 40:03I'll get up there and say, hey, ladies and gentlemen,
- 40:05I understand that plaintiff talked a little bit
- 40:06about the burden of proof. I'd like to talk a
- 40:08little bit about the burden of proof with you.
- 40:11And I appreciate that plaintiff used an illustration
- 40:13or talked about a feather, but that's really
- 40:15not what's going to happen in this case. That's
- 40:16really not what the law is. The judge is going
- 40:19to give you a law that you have to follow. And
- 40:20what the judge is going to say is it's a preponderance
- 40:23of the evidence. And plaintiff has the burden
- 40:26of proof. And a preponderance of the evidence
- 40:28is different. Plaintiff has a burden of proof.
- 40:33that they have to make in this case. So the law
- 40:36says plaintiff must prove each element of their
- 40:37case by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning
- 40:39more likely than not 51%. The plaintiff has to
- 40:47prove an issue by 51%. If you're undecided and
- 40:50you can't decide, if the evidence is, say, 50
- 40:53-50 equal, then notwithstanding whether plaintiff
- 40:56was heard or not heard, you would award plaintiff
- 40:58nothing. So that's the burden of proof. So plaintiff
- 41:01has the burden of proof. Does everyone understand
- 41:02that? And I know we're not doing this, ladies
- 41:05and gentlemen, but if everyone was to go back
- 41:06to the jury room right now to deliberate, you
- 41:08would find for the defendant, because there's
- 41:10been no evidence. So they're at 50 -50 right
- 41:13now. The two white pieces of paper remain white.
- 41:15The two horses remain at the starting game. OK?
- 41:18And again, I want everyone by a show of hands,
- 41:21if plaintiff does not meet the burden of proof
- 41:23as it relates to a certain issue, and you're
- 41:25going to have a number of issues to decide here,
- 41:27damages, liability, allocation of responsibility,
- 41:31can you vote no against plaintiff, even though
- 41:34we're sympathetic or empathetic to the fact that
- 41:35he or she was injured, if in fact they didn't
- 41:38meet the burden of proof for you? I see everyone's
- 41:40raised their hand, so thank you. And then from
- 41:44there, I would probably go into anchoring. I
- 41:47would start looking at my four cause. jurors
- 41:51and talk a little bit about them. So let's talk
- 41:53a little bit about anchoring. So you just heard
- 41:57plaintiff ask, if the evidence supported an award
- 41:59of millions of dollars, would you be comfortable
- 42:01with that? So here's what I'm going to have a
- 42:03couple of jurors that I want to go after, and
- 42:06I'm going to target. Now, listen, when you're
- 42:09going after a juror or you're targeting them,
- 42:11again, this is not sport. And I've seen in board
- 42:14dire. Both plaintiff and defense lawyers really
- 42:17go after a juror and you have to be careful It's
- 42:19a great place to offend the jury pool This is
- 42:22a person that's being honest and forthright in
- 42:24terms of impartiality where he or she's coming
- 42:26from on an opinion ie I'm critical of someone
- 42:29who doesn't speak English that's been in our
- 42:30country for 20 years It would be easy for plaintiff
- 42:33to attack that that person and then try to establish
- 42:36a bias or even a prejudice and then say that
- 42:40that person for cause cannot be fair and impartial
- 42:42because the defense is going to have a head start
- 42:44because the plaintiff doesn't speak English.
- 42:47That's not what happened the other day. Dan did
- 42:49a great job and he kept going with this guy,
- 42:51talking a little bit about it and opened it up
- 42:53and then he moved on. So when we talk about anchoring,
- 42:58it's where the plaintiff says, you know, the
- 43:01plaintiff gets up and says, I'm going to be asking
- 43:03for a lot of money in this case that my client
- 43:05was. It was really, really hurt. I want you to
- 43:08appreciate that. And you're going to be asked
- 43:11whether or not you can award. There's two types
- 43:13of monetary damages. One is out of pocket. Those
- 43:15are called special damages where we have the
- 43:18receipts and one is called general damages. And
- 43:21that's for pain and suffering. And listen, there's
- 43:24two schools of thought. There's a school on one
- 43:26side that says, hey, I'm not in favor of people
- 43:29getting pain and suffering. I'm good with the
- 43:30receipts. And then there's a school of thought
- 43:32that says, well, of course, if someone has some
- 43:34pain and suffering, they should be awarded. By
- 43:36a show of hands, who's in the school of, I'm
- 43:38not comfortable giving an award of damages for
- 43:40pain and suffering. So that's what a plaintiff's
- 43:42going to do and start to go down that road and
- 43:44then talk about, are you good with me asking
- 43:46for millions and millions and millions and then
- 43:48getting the jury to say yes. And I'm going to
- 43:50find out which jurors I might be annoyed with
- 43:52and I might go for cause at that point. Let me
- 43:54quickly just jump into for cause before I go
- 43:56into anchoring. So what I would do, what my spiel
- 43:59is with regard to for cause is I say, I appreciate
- 44:02what you told the plaintiff there that, you know,
- 44:05you have a cap. You have a cap. So this is called
- 44:10rehabilitation. I would be rehabilitating this
- 44:12witness if he or she said that they believe in
- 44:15caps and that they couldn't be fair and that
- 44:17they couldn't award anything over that. I would
- 44:19say, hey, I understand that in Gordiah that you
- 44:23told the plaintiff that you're not comfortable
- 44:25with pain and suffering, that you'd have caps.
- 44:27You don't know what their caps are, but there's
- 44:29a limit to what you would award, but you haven't
- 44:31heard the facts or the evidence. And again, we
- 44:32have no evidence in this case, so we have no
- 44:34idea what this case is about. But if the facts
- 44:38and circumstances warranted an award of millions
- 44:42and millions or something above your cap, you
- 44:44wouldn't know that yet. Is it fair to say that
- 44:46you wouldn't know that yet because you haven't
- 44:47heard the facts and evidence? That's fair. So
- 44:50if I was to tell you that the defendant in this
- 44:52case was Osama bin Laden, would you still have
- 44:55a cap or would you not? So most jurors are gonna
- 44:58say they probably wouldn't in that situation
- 45:00I'm gonna say well clearly Osama Bin Laden isn't
- 45:02our defendant in this case But again, that was
- 45:05a new fact that I just added that would come
- 45:08into evidence that the defendant is Osama Bin
- 45:09Laden So I'm asking you Can you be patient and
- 45:13can you wait for the coffee to be brewed before
- 45:15you make a decision? Because you haven't heard
- 45:17the facts and evidence So, if in fact plaintiff
- 45:20does do an amazing job and puts on the case and
- 45:22is able to show that the case is worth millions
- 45:24and millions, is that something you would be
- 45:26comfortable considering based on the facts and
- 45:28evidence that come in here? So, that's how I
- 45:30might rehabilitate someone as it relates to money.
- 45:33On my own side of it, when someone says to me,
- 45:35I'm very sympathetic to someone who gets hit
- 45:37on a motorcycle, I think that people don't see
- 45:39motorcycles, I ride a motorcycle, and... I really
- 45:44think motorcyclists get the short end of the
- 45:45stick because they're loud people don't like
- 45:47them and I would get up there and say listen
- 45:50you'd agree we have two white pieces of paper
- 45:52but in your situation as a result of your life
- 45:54experiences which I respect and I love your love
- 45:56of motorcycles and I'm thinking about getting
- 45:59a tattoo with a motorcycle so I'm on board with
- 46:02you here. So that being said would you agree
- 46:05that you've already got the plaintiff horse a
- 46:08little bit ahead of the defendant horse because
- 46:10the plaintiff's riding a motorcycle and you think
- 46:12potentially people don't see the motorcycle,
- 46:14they don't pay attention to those things, is
- 46:16the horse a little bit ahead in the starting
- 46:18line or on your piece of paper do you have a
- 46:20little bit more you've written already before
- 46:21we got started as it relates to the plaintiff
- 46:24in this case because of your sympathy and your
- 46:26prior experience? I might have a little bit.
- 46:29And I appreciate that I want to put that horse
- 46:31back in the starting gate with you, but it sounds
- 46:33like as a result of your life experiences, you're
- 46:35someone that just couldn't be fair and impartial
- 46:37in this case, and that you'd put that horse a
- 46:39little bit ahead. That's probably true. I probably
- 46:41would do that. And I don't care what the plaintiff
- 46:44comes up here and says or does, at the end of
- 46:46the day, You're a little bit more ahead with
- 46:49the relates to the plaintiff than the defendant,
- 46:51correct? And again, even if the judge was to
- 46:53ask you some more questions for you, you believe
- 46:56that horse is just a little bit ahead as we get
- 46:58started here. And that's fair because remember,
- 46:59I'm not judging pie eating contests because I
- 47:03love I hate cherry pie and you might make a cherry
- 47:05pie. So in that case, the lemon, the lemons and
- 47:09the other pies, the apples have a little bit
- 47:11of a head start. Are you in the same boat? I
- 47:13am. So I've kind of boxed him or her in a little
- 47:15bit. and I'm going for cause, and that's sort
- 47:18of how I go about doing that. Vickis? Yeah, I
- 47:21wanted to go back and touch a little bit on the
- 47:23anchoring. So I know you talked about plaintiffs
- 47:27going to get in there, and they may ask a question
- 47:31and say that they're going to ask for a certain
- 47:34amount of money and if people will be offended
- 47:36by that, et cetera. So if plaintiff's counsel
- 47:39walks in there and says, hey, if we were to ask
- 47:41for a billion dollars in this case, would anyone
- 47:44feel that just too much that no one's worth that.
- 47:47And then from the defense side, I don't think,
- 47:51and Keith, I don't know if you disagree with
- 47:52me, that you can't afford to just let it sit
- 47:54unchallenged. Well, you don't have to necessarily
- 47:57refute the number, but I think you have to sort
- 47:59of reframe it as a claim that requires some sort
- 48:03of proof. And so in that hypothetical about the
- 48:05billion dollars, I think a question, paraphrasing
- 48:10is, does anyone? here expect that if someone
- 48:13asked for that kind of money that they would
- 48:16have to show exactly how they got there and provide
- 48:19some sort of proof. I think from a defense side
- 48:22you don't necessarily have to give a number but
- 48:25I think you can afford to just let it sit unchallenged
- 48:29and don't say anything to that. So I'm sure you
- 48:32get that all the time with Plains Council coming
- 48:34in on these high -profile cases and they're giving
- 48:36a number to you. You have a defense perspective
- 48:39without giving a number, but you don't just let
- 48:41it go, right? I mean, from the defense side,
- 48:43you want to reframe that. Exactly. So does everyone
- 48:48here appreciate that a cup of coffee is $3 .99
- 48:52at Starbucks in San Bernardino on the corner
- 48:55here? And that cup of coffee, that $3 .99 has
- 48:59the exact same value as a dollar in that jury
- 49:02room when you go back there. Does everyone agree
- 49:03that a dollar outside the courtroom has the exact
- 49:06same value as a dollar in the jury courtroom,
- 49:09in the jury board eye room, where you're going
- 49:11to be deliberating. So remember that, ladies
- 49:13and gentlemen, that I'm empowering you to be
- 49:17the judge of the facts, and I want you to be
- 49:18reasonable. And if you conclude that plaintiff
- 49:20is entitled to damages, plaintiff is entitled
- 49:21to reasonable damages, real dollars, real dollars,
- 49:26the same dollar that's outside the courtroom,
- 49:28out there, the same. house that's worth $500
- 49:30,000 outside this courtroom is worth $500 ,000
- 49:33inside this courtroom. So I might do that just
- 49:36to kind of remind them of the value of the dollar.
- 49:40And then I'll go through a little bit of individual
- 49:44damages. So in this case, plaintiff is claiming
- 49:46damages to portions of his or her body or making
- 49:51claims for damages to conditions that we don't
- 49:55believe were possibly caused by this accident.
- 49:58So I would then say, you know, in this case,
- 50:01if I'm able to show, let's just say that plaintiffs
- 50:04claiming he caught a cold as a result of this
- 50:06rear end car accident. If I was able to show
- 50:08that that cold was not caused by this rear end
- 50:10accident, fair to say that you would. say the
- 50:13plaintiff didn't meet the burden proof you could
- 50:14award plaintiff zero as it relates to the to
- 50:17plaintiff catching a cold as a result of this
- 50:19this accident i know i'm being sarcastic everyone
- 50:21but do you follow what i'm saying so in the same
- 50:23breath to the extent plaintiff claims he's got
- 50:25a lower back problem and we claim that's a pre
- 50:27-existing problem and wasn't caused by this accident
- 50:29similar to a cold could you again if plaintiff
- 50:32doesn't meet the burden of proof and you hear
- 50:33our experts and you decide the plaintiff could
- 50:37you award plaintiff zero on that low back issue
- 50:39on that traumatic brain injury issue. So I might
- 50:42start off with a cold. I've got some other examples.
- 50:46I've used the example of if plaintiff claims
- 50:49that he or she lost their hearing as a result
- 50:51of this T -bone accident, and didn't prove that
- 50:55they couldn't have lost it, although I've had
- 50:56hearing cases, actually. But I've used hearing,
- 50:59common cold, ear infection as an example to try
- 51:03to say that plaintiff claims a brain injury in
- 51:05this case. We claim plaintiff had, yes, a brain
- 51:07injury, a minor concussion. Plaintiff was good
- 51:10almost overnight and released from the hospital.
- 51:12But again, plaintiff claims it's something more.
- 51:14You're the judges of the facts. I'm empowering
- 51:16you to make that decision. But if, in fact, plaintiff
- 51:18doesn't show that that injury is as extensive
- 51:22like the ear infection as plaintiff's claim,
- 51:26can you get plaintiff zero on the TBI if that's
- 51:29justified? And again, can you get plaintiff $100?
- 51:31So again, what plaintiff said, Vic, can you get
- 51:34millions and millions? if in fact plaintiff doesn't
- 51:37meet the burden of proof or in fact if you in
- 51:39the jury room find reasonableness to be five
- 51:41hundred thousand even though plaintiff asked
- 51:43for five million can you award the plaintiff
- 51:46five hundred thousand even though plaintiff has
- 51:48given you that figure of five million you're
- 51:50going to make your own decision you're the judge
- 51:51of the facts you're comfortable with that fair
- 51:53so that's how i kind of deal with money victor
- 51:55i answer your question yeah you did that's great
- 51:57thank you so then kind of going into that so
- 52:01like if you're admitting fault right if you admit
- 52:04fault And we're talking about that real quick.
- 52:08So really fast. I don't really stipulate to admitting
- 52:11fault. I generally will do that in board dire.
- 52:14I will get up and say, ladies and gentlemen,
- 52:16we're admitting that we caused this accident.
- 52:18We take full responsibility. We feel terrible
- 52:20about it. The facts for you as the judge of the
- 52:23facts in this case is what is plaintiff's damages.
- 52:26There's a recent case out there that says that
- 52:28the time and place in which you stipulate to
- 52:31liability cannot be used. as evidence against
- 52:34you, I will generally speaking tell the plaintiff
- 52:36lawyer, hey, I will stipulate to liability, but
- 52:39I want to be the first one that says it in board
- 52:41dire. If we have that agreement, I'll stick to
- 52:42liability. And if we don't, then I won't. And
- 52:44I may still do it, even if plaintiff doesn't
- 52:46nine times out of 10, the plaintiff will stipulate
- 52:48with me and we'll have a gentleman's agreement
- 52:50and we can go from there on that issue. I just
- 52:53want to hit a couple of quick issues. There's
- 52:55obviously you want to talk about defense. We
- 52:57talk about lean treatment and financial motivation.
- 53:00How many of you know what it means? when medical
- 53:03treatment is put on a lien by a raise of hands.
- 53:07So that's a situation where a doctor gets paid
- 53:10when the plaintiff gets a verdict in this case.
- 53:13So he or she might be working off of a lien.
- 53:15You're going to hear about that in this case.
- 53:16Has anyone ever had any treatment provided to
- 53:19him or her by a doctor that was on a lien? Anyone
- 53:21here have such an experience? Does anyone have
- 53:24concerns about whether a doctor might overtreat
- 53:26or recommend unnecessary treatment when they're
- 53:28only paid if the case is successful? So there
- 53:31are little questions you can start to go into,
- 53:32and you want to kind of lay the foundation on
- 53:34leads. We've got damage reality check questions,
- 53:38problem jurors. Just find your areas. You've
- 53:41got gaps in treatment. You want to talk about
- 53:43that. Who here believes that if someone is truly
- 53:45injured in an accident, they need to see a doctor
- 53:47right away, and that they need to keep treating,
- 53:50and they need to take care of themselves? an
- 53:52affirmative obligation to mitigate their damages,
- 53:54to take care of themselves and not let it exacerbate
- 53:56and get worse at the cost of another party who's
- 53:59admitted liability. Who here understands that
- 54:01theory? So there's all kinds of little antidotes.
- 54:04I want to just give you a couple other headings
- 54:05I'm not going to hit because I'm one minute away
- 54:07from opening it up. Again, authenticity is super
- 54:11important. Be yourself, be open, be honest. Credibility
- 54:14matters. If I know that plaintiff has answered
- 54:19questions in discovery that are going to be contradicted
- 54:22in his or her testimony on the witness stand,
- 54:24I talk about whether they're familiar with the
- 54:25legal process, if they know what discovery is,
- 54:28that the judge is going to instruct them that
- 54:29written discovery has the exact same weight as
- 54:31if they took that witness stand. Because people
- 54:33appreciate that. So while you might not see it,
- 54:35I'm going to read it. Do you appreciate that
- 54:37the judge is going to give you law that you have
- 54:38to follow that? So even if the live testimony
- 54:39seems more powerful, can you give them equal
- 54:42weight if the judge tells you that's what you
- 54:43have to do as a matter of law? So I'll go through
- 54:45discovery. I'll talk about whether they believe
- 54:48people sometimes overstate injuries in a legal
- 54:51setting because they want to get money. Do you
- 54:53believe that people exaggerate their injuries?
- 54:55There's a lot of billboards out there promising
- 54:57millions and millions of dollars to you if you
- 54:58can get in a car accident. Do you think that
- 55:00people take advantage of that situation? Are
- 55:02you offended by the billboards that you see in
- 55:04LA? Why? Do you believe that it's the promise
- 55:06of a new day to someone who gets rear -ended?
- 55:08or do you believe they're entitled to just reasonable
- 55:10compensation? So there's all kinds of little
- 55:12things you can say. We talked about stipulating
- 55:15the liability. There's countering the reptile
- 55:17theory. If plaintiff says your verdict protects
- 55:19the community, does that sway you? Judges aren't
- 55:22going to allow this these days, but sometimes
- 55:24accidents just happen. Should defendant be punished
- 55:26as an example if an accident just happens? I've
- 55:30got another talk about expert witnesses. Again,
- 55:33I'm going to have a list in my board dire. It's
- 55:36gonna be about six pages I'm generally gonna
- 55:38get to my top 15 issues and I'm not gonna get
- 55:41to my bottom ones Does anybody here hate lawyers?
- 55:43Why do you hate lawyers? There's shitty mailmen.
- 55:45There's good mailmen So there's you got to kind
- 55:47of have your little themes that you're doing
- 55:48on your heading So I think that's where we're
- 55:51at and we've got four minutes left Vic. I think
- 55:53you did a great job Yeah, that's good. Thank
- 55:55you All right, we wanted to open it up for questioning
- 56:00and I see we've got some questioning no If we
- 56:05don't have anyone popping in here, I'll finish.
- 56:08So it looks like we do have a few questions.
- 56:12Christopher Rose asks, how do you defend in the
- 56:15face of incontrovertible evidence, like the video
- 56:19of the ICE shooting now in the headlines, how
- 56:21to voir dire the jury to believe ICE in this
- 56:31case? Right, so in that case, I would acknowledge
- 56:35that the video, a picture's worth a thousand
- 56:38words. I'd get up there on behalf of ICE and
- 56:40say, listen, a picture's worth a thousand words
- 56:41and you're gonna be the judge of the facts and
- 56:42you get to determine what happened. But again,
- 56:45you're not gonna hear any sound and you're gonna
- 56:46hear the evidence of what those officers subjectively
- 56:49believed and where they were at and what their
- 56:51threats were and what their concerns were. Can
- 56:53you keep an open mind as to what happened out
- 56:55there and listen to my client tell you what he
- 56:58or she said out there? Or do you believe that
- 57:00you can? Now, I would start by getting people
- 57:02who are prejudiced against ICE. I would try to
- 57:04get into the Trump conservative versus liberal
- 57:07issue because I think it's relevant in this case
- 57:09as to whether they're polarized. I would be having
- 57:11a for -cause heyday in that trial. But I would
- 57:15acknowledge that a picture's worth a thousand
- 57:17words that you, the jury, get to weigh that picture.
- 57:19I'm not going to argue with the video. But what
- 57:22I am going to show you is I'm going to present
- 57:23evidence of the officer. He's going to take a
- 57:25stand. He's going to talk about what he subjectively
- 57:27believed, what he felt, what she yelled at him,
- 57:29what he thought he heard, what the circumstances
- 57:31were, whether his officers, whether he felt his
- 57:34officers were threatened. Can you keep an open
- 57:36mind or do you believe just based on the video
- 57:38and what you've seen in the media already, a
- 57:40plaintiff has a little bit of a head start. So
- 57:42in a civil matter, that's what I would say. And
- 57:43then say, and you couldn't reverse that. You
- 57:45can't get back. You can't keep an open mind and
- 57:47wait to hear from my client. Can you? And then
- 57:49I would try to get him for cause. Great, thank
- 57:54you. And then I do have someone asking, can you
- 57:58repeat the name of the podcast that you'd referenced
- 58:00earlier? I think you'd mentioned something at
- 58:03about 20 minutes or so. I don't know the name
- 58:06of John Morgan's podcast, but if you Google John
- 58:09Morgan on podcasts, it'll come up. And let's
- 58:12see. Sarah Pedrani asks, how do you approach
- 58:16jurors who stay quiet during voir dire? What
- 58:19cues or follow -up techniques help you assess
- 58:21whether they're neutral, disengaged, et cetera?
- 58:24So I'm definitely someone who wants to touch
- 58:26everybody really quick. I try to kind of quickly
- 58:28touch everybody. And so I'll say, Juror 7, number
- 58:317, I know that you haven't raised your hand.
- 58:33This is as intimidating of a setting for me as
- 58:37it is probably for you. Let me just start by
- 58:40saying thank you for being here. I know it'd
- 58:42be easy not to have come. Second, have you heard
- 58:45anything here that's kind of offensive to you
- 58:46or anywhere or something that you said yourself?
- 58:48I totally disagree with what I just heard there.
- 58:51Have you heard that? They're gonna say no and
- 58:53say, how about something you loved? You know,
- 58:55there's two sides to every story, right? Some
- 58:57groups come in, you know, even on that ice thing,
- 58:59I would say, you know, there's gonna be two factors,
- 59:01right? There's gonna be two factions in this
- 59:02ice thing. I've already seen it in the media,
- 59:04ladies and gentlemen. There's gonna be the group
- 59:05that says, that ice guy could do no wrong. He
- 59:07could have shot her point blank, blah, blah.
- 59:09And there's gonna be other side that said, oh
- 59:10my God, it doesn't matter what happened in that
- 59:12circumstance. She could have come out with a
- 59:13machete, one foot from his face, and they'd say,
- 59:16you can't shoot her. So. There are the polarizations.
- 59:19Have you seen that in this case, ma 'am? And
- 59:21is there something you totally do agree with?
- 59:23I want to know. So I would try to get them to
- 59:25agree with something or disagree to get the conversation
- 59:28started. You know, I like to say that I'm like
- 59:30I'm like the boyfriend that showed up for the
- 59:32first time at Thanksgiving and nobody really
- 59:35wants him. You know, you've got to try to to
- 59:37win them over a little bit in that setting. All
- 59:44right, well, that looks like we're. That's it
- 59:47for questions. Any other closing remarks you'd
- 59:50like to make? Again, I would just end where I
- 59:53started, is you got to finish strong. a real
- 59:57hammer or anything like that. Just have a question
- 1:00:00or two ready that is going to resonate. Hey,
- 1:00:03thank you so much. This has been an amazing experience.
- 1:00:05I just want to confirm, to the extent plaintiff
- 1:00:07isn't able to prove at the end of the day a certain
- 1:00:09issue. For example, the traumatic brain injury.
- 1:00:12Everyone by a show of hands, are you comfortable
- 1:00:14to tell the plaintiff, I don't believe you have
- 1:00:15a traumatic brain injury? By a show of hands,
- 1:00:17a plaintiff doesn't meet the burden of proof.
- 1:00:19Can you get a plaintiff nothing on the traumatic
- 1:00:20brain injury? So just something that's ... within
- 1:00:23your theme of your ending, you know, if it's
- 1:00:25shared responsibility or comparative fault, even
- 1:00:27though it looks like someone around a red light,
- 1:00:29but we saw the guy coming in a freight truck,
- 1:00:31you know, could there be comparative? Can you
- 1:00:33keep an open mind and strong with something that
- 1:00:36resonates? Yeah, and I'll just say thank you
- 1:00:40for the opportunity. Obviously, Keith and I are
- 1:00:42available if anyone wants to reach out or follow
- 1:00:46up on anything that we talked about. All right,
- 1:00:50I agree with that. Thank you, Vic, for saying
- 1:00:51that. Yeah, so everyone has our email. I'm on
- 1:00:54Instagram. If you want to try to find me at kbzsenior,
- 1:00:58you can hit me there. I'm happy to help out anyone,
- 1:01:01anytime. All right, perfect. Well, this concludes
- 1:01:04today's presentation. Thank you so much, Keith
- 1:01:06and Vic, for an excellent presentation. And thank
- 1:01:08you so much to our audience. Have a great day,
- 1:01:10everybody. Thank you. Take care, everyone. Bye.