Latest / The Team House / Netanyahu vs Everyone | EYES ON | Ep. 25
Transcript
- 0:00Hey guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today about
- 0:03a way that you can help support the podcast if you're not already to support
- 0:07the channel is to become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that
- 0:12start at just five dollars a month, and when you sign up, you
- 0:16get access to all of our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for
- 0:20that. I mean, we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers,
- 0:26but this is the biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse
- 0:30channel and podcast if you'd like to, and we really appreciate that, So
- 0:35go and check us out at patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. Hello everyone,
- 0:40welcome to another episode of Aizon. I'm Andy Mulban, I'm Jason Lyons,
- 0:45Dmitri Co Tacos the no shortage of news as usual. Yeah, it's
- 0:51pretty it's pretty wild. What do you want to kick off with? I
- 0:55mean, this horrible news of you know, the fire and some thirty five
- 1:00to forty deaths in in Rafa and I you know, I for one,
- 1:07I don't really have anything to pile on with at this point, and honestly,
- 1:14it's you know, it's just the images are horrible, and I have
- 1:19written about deconfliction procedures, the you know, the issues with deconfliction procedures and
- 1:29the gods of conflict or lack their off and so you know, I'm not
- 1:34going to pile in at this point and make assumptions, but just to say,
- 1:40you know, it's again another very tragic incident. Any anything else on
- 1:45that that, guys, No, I'm treading. I'm treading carefully because I
- 1:49know it's you know, the a lot of people are are as when these
- 1:56things happen on both sides become very emotion Yeah, yeah, I figured,
- 2:00yeah, we definitely have to mention it because it was in the news this
- 2:04weekend. Uh, front and center. Obviously seems like Israel doesn't, it's
- 2:07my opinion, doesn't really care about deconfliction whatsoever. Certainly there you know,
- 2:15it's fair to say, as I've written, their standards and I've been detailed
- 2:17about this and shown how their standards are a a lot different than ours in
- 2:25the US military, let me put it that way. But but how about
- 2:30how about this? You know, so the and US papers kind of they
- 2:36didn't gloss over it, but it I'm talking about Israeli Defense Minister You Gallant's
- 2:45declaration on on Wednesday night, he made a public address accusing the government of
- 2:52mismanaging the war. Let me say that again, that is the defense minister
- 2:57accusing the government of which he is part of, miss managing the war.
- 3:02But specifically, of course, he is targeting Netnahu. And I think that
- 3:08as I said, this was this, This wasn't kind of front page news
- 3:13necessarily in US papers, But this is huge in Israel because not simply because
- 3:16he is the defense minister, but because the belief is that he is not
- 3:23just representing himself or a political you know, small political group within within the
- 3:32government, conclude Benny Gance, those you know, the so called centrists,
- 3:38but indeed that he represents the institution, the the I d F and the
- 3:46Shinbet in particular and ranged on the other side, of course, are you
- 3:52know the extreme right wing members of who's cabinet, the most notory of which
- 4:00are Ben Gabeer and Small Dridge. And so this this is you know,
- 4:09in Israeli eyes, this is the final showdown. And there's no doubt where
- 4:15you know, the sympathies of I think most Israeli's lion. This Gallant is
- 4:21he is, He's an iconic figure. Yes, you know, he's by
- 4:27no means as centrist, but he is certainly a national hero. He was
- 4:32in as a I mean from the late seventies Israeli Special Operations Forces, specifically
- 4:42Plotilla of thirteen, which is their equivalent of of the Seals, just fewer
- 4:46movies and books. But I mean he was you know, he was tier
- 4:50one of Tier one. I mean, he was involved in these targeted killings
- 4:58over the seas that Ronan Bergmann has written about in that excellent book Rise and
- 5:04Kill First. You have. Gallant appears very frequently in that book, is
- 5:10leading these targeted killing teams. So you know, certainly he's he's not by
- 5:16himself on this. And he and Netnar who have had a long falling out
- 5:24that precedes even Netner who firing him back in March of twenty twenty three.
- 5:30And and you'll notice two other things that have happened this week that are not
- 5:35necessarily been you know that that haven't been connected, at least not in US
- 5:42media. The same this last week, the IDF made in a now released
- 5:51documents that showed that that Netnar who they had warned netnar who four times about
- 6:01Hamas in the period of late twenty twenty two early twenty twenty three. All
- 6:10right, so this is probably not coincidental. That's kind of a bombshell.
- 6:14And then the IDF spokesman, Rear Admiral Daniel Hagary Hagari, you know,
- 6:20the guy with those massive ears, looks like doctor Spock, not doctor Spock,
- 6:27mister spot anyway, so he he is. He made a comment today,
- 6:34I mean not today, on Tuesday that implied that the IDF, the
- 6:42IDEF was having to take a step back or all the gains made by the
- 6:46IDF were slipping away because and he worried at such like it would be different
- 6:55if we had some kind of national goals rategy. You know. That's and
- 7:00that's the public affairs guy from the IDEA. So you know, none of
- 7:04this is coincidental. So Gallant came on on Israeli TV and he asked three
- 7:13questions. And the first I thought this was very well delivered. It wasn't
- 7:17a rambling, long, rambling speech. But the first question was to net
- 7:23Nahu, do you want a short war or a long one? And you
- 7:28know this this question is really at the heart of a glance, demand that
- 7:31the government discussed, at least discuss and then decide on an alternative to Hamas
- 7:38and Gaza, which well, it would inevitably hasten the end of major fighting
- 7:44and give the IDEF some direction. So the second question, he asked Gallant,
- 7:53Well, it wasn't really a question. He asked Netnahu to declare that
- 7:57he opposes get this, that he that Netnyahu opposes and Israeli military or civil
- 8:05governance of post hamask Gaza. In other words, he's insisting that the Prime
- 8:11Minister tell the country and the world that he will not pursue occupying Gaza and
- 8:16managing civilian issues there the way that you know, a military government government would
- 8:26you know, as has happened in the territories for instance, after after the
- 8:31Sixth Day War with you know, with a lot of a lot of institutional
- 8:37bad memory for for the Israelis, and he doesn't want to, you know,
- 8:43and and also of course memories of Lebanon Golan. Doesn't want Israel to
- 8:48end up in you know, another quagmire like that or or indeed the West
- 8:54Bank, you know, in which it is in a situation that it rules
- 8:58over millions of hostel Palestinians, you know, to to to the security forces,
- 9:07that's a that's a terrible scenario that could possibly even destroy the state,
- 9:11you know, and then near a long term and you know, in orders,
- 9:20there's no doubt about it that on Netnya who's right and Ben Gavince Moldrich
- 9:26have been quite open about this. The you know, the right wing want
- 9:30to resettle Gaza with Israeli settlers, right, Gallant knows this. And then
- 9:35twenty years ago Gallant was the it was a military advisor to them Prime Minister
- 9:41Ariel Sharon when Schearan ordered the withdrawal, oversaw the total this Israeli disengagement from
- 9:50the Gaza Strip to include breaking down and removing the settlements, you know,
- 9:58I mean the Sharan, I mean the reasons for that of course quite quite
- 10:03separate. But but so interestingly, you see what I'm saying that that this
- 10:07is a really fundamental split now. And and that was you know, that
- 10:16was uh, although he didn't say so explicitly, Glant's not opposed to the
- 10:24Palestinian authority playing a role in management of the Gaza Strip, which is something
- 10:28that is enathma to Net me argue in the extreme right wing, and Gallant
- 10:33thinks that that is because well he knows, he thinks he knows or whatever.
- 10:39You know. The claim is that the right wing essentially support Harmas because
- 10:45her Maas is the unacceptable face of Palestinian authority small a right to the Israelis.
- 10:52So as long as her Maas represents Gaza, then there can be no
- 10:56talk of a two state solution. They know that and and therefore want helm
- 11:03As to continue front and center. But they can't say that, you know.
- 11:07So that's that that's the rift there, right. And then so the
- 11:16third so that that was the second to make a statement, you know,
- 11:18there's you know, we absolutely have no intention of military governance of occupation of
- 11:22the Gaza strip Gallant. Gallant, by the way, so it is said,
- 11:30has been in discussions about and you know, with the with the US
- 11:39about a solution that involved and interim Palestinian authority backed government backed by Arab states,
- 11:48notably Jordan's arm and Uh and and u A, possibly Egypt. So
- 11:56anyway, the third decision though that that he's asking Netnia who is is about
- 12:03the future of the government of the Israeli government, you know, it's basically
- 12:05which side are you on? That's what he's asking. Are you going to
- 12:11stand with me and and Benny Gantz and Daddy Eisencott, you know, two
- 12:16fellow generals who are relatively centrist, although you know, really right right of
- 12:22center, or are you going to go with the right ministers? Uh?
- 12:28What's his name? Sounds like Bielsa Beezel Smodrich and uh and item up Ben
- 12:35Gibeer And that was the you know, that's the subtext. But but the
- 12:41question is what what is you know, what is the future of the government.
- 12:48Gallant called for advancing the national interest over all other interests. All right,
- 12:54that's you know, that's very thinly coded text for yeah, you know,
- 13:03ditch your political ambitions and stop putting them before national interest. But you
- 13:13know it's son who has to make a decision. I mean, it's no
- 13:16way, there's no way that Glance going to make this the public challenge and
- 13:24then and then just back down. But who knows that a decision to place
- 13:30governance of Gaza in the hands of the Palestinian authorities will lead to confrontation with
- 13:37both Smoldridge and Ben Givie and possibly loss of of their support the right wing
- 13:43support. That's not going to bring the government down immediately, but it's certainly
- 13:48going to hurt who's chances then, which you know, I mean, it's
- 13:56surprising me he believes he does have them. It's a political few. So
- 14:01yeah, sorry, let me ask real quick. It seems and this is
- 14:05just my limited observation that these public back and forth between politicians is normal there
- 14:16like it is here. But is that normal between a defense minister and the
- 14:22Prime minister to be so public? No? No, no, that's all.
- 14:26This is unprecedented. Absolutely. I mean there have been you know,
- 14:33silky confrontation within the cabinet. Is it is, it is something that is
- 14:43more public than it is here, and it's almost an expectation at times,
- 14:50but nothing like this has occurred before. I mean, this is monumental,
- 14:58not it's not more of the same. And I think think you know,
- 15:01from anyone's perspective, it's good news. So anyway, any any decision by
- 15:09net Yahoo to to fully withdraw from Gaza, uh you know, in turn
- 15:15over governance to someone else, is going to leave the far right minister's parties
- 15:20in which are represent religious Zionism, and I think the other one is called
- 15:28you who did you? Who did it? It'll cause those parties to exit
- 15:33the coalition, and that's what's kind of hanging over his head. And then
- 15:37so so they can convere and small to bridge, they come tearing out of
- 15:43the wings, right and they demand that net Yahoo fire Gallant. Right,
- 15:48you can't make a shut up calling him a trojan horse. All right,
- 15:54this is you know, this is a guy who is again national hero.
- 16:00But the thing is, who can't fire Gallant? He's you know, he's
- 16:06he's not as strong as he was when he's he's fired previous defense ministers and
- 16:11he's you know, counting Gallant before he's fired three he's but he's he's got
- 16:18no choice not only to endure this kind of revolt, but to make a
- 16:25decision. You know, I can't. It's going to be really interesting,
- 16:30really interesting to see what happens because I can't see Netno who making a decision.
- 16:34I can see him just keeping, you know, trying to edge it
- 16:37along and edge along. And so that puts the ball back into Gallard's court.
- 16:42But what's you know what I mean, this isn't even mutiny on the
- 16:45king. Mutiny I mean, I mean mutiny on what I said, the
- 16:49king mutinyry, mutiny on the bounty or something. But it's I mean,
- 16:52it's not like you're taking over a ship, You're how how are they going
- 16:56to seize power against Netnia as well? That's really what it's going to come
- 17:02down to, because I think it will come down to that. And and
- 17:08Innaho is in a corner because you know, other little KUD members not connected
- 17:14with the Defense establishment have come out of the woodwork and said, hey,
- 17:18yeah, you know what, Yeah, I warned him about Mars too.
- 17:22And I've been I've been saying for a long period of time that you know
- 17:27that we needed to come up with a solution or for Gaza anyway, Paul
- 17:34said, you guys, I'm not laughing about the situation that it's Yeah,
- 17:41it is going to be interesting to see what happens. I wonder how much
- 17:45of this is being pushed publicly as well too, too. I mean,
- 17:52as usual sway, public opinion one side or the other and maybe force one
- 17:56hand or the other, you know, publicly. Yeah, solutely, Jason,
- 18:00that is That's what I was kind of hinting at earlier, is a
- 18:07public opinion manipulation of public opinion via you know, leaked memos or open off
- 18:14but off the record comments by senior government officials or generals are fairly common.
- 18:22But you know, these things gather momentum, and it really looks as though
- 18:27that the you know, I don't want to use the analogy of rats leaving
- 18:32a ship, but you know, it does look as though people are running
- 18:36for the exits a little bit, distancing themselves from netting Yahoo, gotcha.
- 18:41And you know, and and there was something else that I wrote it down
- 18:45here. Gallant came up with some on Wednesday night, okay, the day
- 18:53after Hamas will only be achieved through the rule of Palestinian elements. That for
- 19:00an alternative to Harmas. Unfortunately, no such plan has been brought for debate,
- 19:04and worse yet, no alternative has been presented in its place. Ah.
- 19:11So you know, I mean, that's that's that's pretty unequivocal. And
- 19:18and he has said openly that he has no problem that not only no problem,
- 19:23that he thinks the only alternative to Hamas is a rule of Palestinian elements,
- 19:30whether that is a Palestinian authority or there has been talk of turning governor
- 19:36the responsibility of governance over to a coalition of influential Palestinian families who you know,
- 19:47may have the trust and support of the population, certainly more so than
- 19:52either the Palestinian authority or Harmas. So you know there are he's he's open
- 19:59minded enough to look at all these alternatives that involve Palestinians running either of the
- 20:03internal I mean run running the government. So and that is yeah, that
- 20:11that is absolutely anathema to two segments of the Israeli population. But what's going
- 20:15to be interesting to your point, Jason, is how far would the public
- 20:22manipulation go. Is there going to be a point where just the sheer pressure
- 20:30you know, not violence but or read of violence, but just kind of
- 20:33this sheer political social pressure for Natnia who to go, well, you know,
- 20:41we will force him to do so, to resign. I mean,
- 20:45there's already demonstrations in the streets and now open revolt in this cabinet. What
- 20:49more do you need other than to be physically forced out of power? And
- 20:55we all hope that it you know, it doesn't come to that. But
- 21:02you know, in the meantime, the the campaign continues. It while one
- 21:12you know, and an entire division is focused now on Rafa and you'll see
- 21:18that the you know, this time they are ceiling the Philadelphia cradle that cuts
- 21:25off Gaza from Egypt. Hence that incident the other day, d you you
- 21:32mentioned when we were chatting about this before and for the benefit of our listeners,
- 21:36the incident was a shooting incident involving both Israelis and Egyptians, resulting in
- 21:42the death of an Egyptian soldier. This last week, nothing released publicly.
- 21:49What what I you know, what I am hearing is that it was a
- 21:55released a you know this, this is what is coming through the IDEF,
- 22:00that it was a kind of a cross fire incident. The IDEF thought that
- 22:06they had received shots, reported they received shots return fire. The Egyptians thought
- 22:11that they are under fire. You know, you've seen this play out anyway
- 22:15in our own forces. Unfortunately, so essentially a blue one bloom, but
- 22:22still, you know, it contributes to considerable tension between the Israelis and the
- 22:30Egyptians, but they are they are united for the moment on ensuring that that
- 22:36border is sealed and that no one from Hamas or even the population of Gaza
- 22:42crosses that border. The Egyptians have so many problems of their own and the
- 22:47Sinai. But within within Egypt, there are mounting tensions because this the Egypt
- 22:56is being hammered by problems in the Red Sea. Of all countries, Egypt
- 23:03is is you know, the country that's suffering worse. So Egypt in turn
- 23:08has been trying to make has been making some money on the situation in Gaza.
- 23:12For instance, the price of getting an AID truck from Ararish or Alexandria,
- 23:23the price that has to be paid to the Egyptian government is something like
- 23:26five thousand dollars per truck, you know, as opposed to pre war as
- 23:32one thousand dollars a truck. So there's like a you know, five time
- 23:36markup on these on these transit fees surge pricing essentially for fucking humanitarian need yep,
- 23:42same thing for our customs and so you know, but still the Egyptian
- 23:48economy is suffering, and of course the population is as amped tops as an
- 23:59error population and indeed some Western populations throughout the world over the situation in Gaza.
- 24:06So you know, the Egyptian military, of course, it's in military
- 24:10rule there. They're just holding they're calling the lead on a simmering pot.
- 24:15The Israelis suspect that the Egyptian army is heavily infiltrated by the Muslim Brotherhood and
- 24:23that this occurred under Morsy during the one year Morsey was in power prior to
- 24:30cisi overthrowing. And Morsey was a Muslim Brotherhood leader who was who was elected
- 24:37to power in Egypt before being overthrown by a coup. But then in any
- 24:41case, accorney of the Israelis, he has heavily infiltrated the Egyptian army with
- 24:48Muslim Brotherhood, which is going to be a problem if that is true for
- 24:51Cisis more so than the Israelis. I mean, remember of the history of
- 24:56the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, it's been one of violent revolt or action followed
- 25:03by incredibly, incredibly brutal repression. It was the Muslim Brotherhood who killed Amasada
- 25:11in nineteen eighty one during a military review, you know, the reviewing troops.
- 25:15I don't know if you've seen the video of it, but you know,
- 25:18they yeah, jump off one of the you know, the vehicle in
- 25:22the drive past and kill them and yeah, those were and so you know,
- 25:27so there's there's all kinds of domestic tensions on both sides of the border.
- 25:36That means, you know, have resulted in this kind of this fragile
- 25:41agreement between the Israelis and the Egyptians. But certainly no, not a lot
- 25:45of goodwill. Pause paused there for a moment. D Any any any questions,
- 25:52guys or Oh yeah, sorry, sorry, go on. I was
- 26:00gonna talk about the video that was not leaked but posted by Netanyahu's son.
- 26:08Oh yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, Jayson, Yeah, just outline
- 26:14that forever. Yeah. So, briefly, speaking of public opinion swaying public
- 26:18opinion, uh so, on Saturday, the IDF authorities uh stated that they
- 26:25were going to launch an investor formal investigation into a video that was posted on
- 26:29to Telegraph by Netahu's son, Yeah, heir. And in the video,
- 26:37it's shows an alleged IDF soldier and fatigues holding a rifle. He's wearing a
- 26:45black mask, and he's standing in what appears to be a blown blown out
- 26:48building, rubble graffiti on the walls behind him, all that, and so
- 26:52in the video he says we the reserve soldiers do not intend to hand over
- 26:59the keys to any Palestinian authority, adding that they would not see power in
- 27:03gods. That's Amas or Fatah, and then he so this is being addressed
- 27:11to net Yahoo, but that he is specifically talking about Galant and addressing him
- 27:21Gallant directly. He said, you cannot win a war. Resign, you
- 27:25cannot win the war. You cannot command us. We will listen to one
- 27:29leader. And it is not the Minister of Defense, It is not the
- 27:32chief of staff. It is the Prime Minister. Think carefully to whom you
- 27:36intend to give the keys after this, And so later in the video he
- 27:38told Gallant to change your record, change the record and understand that we want
- 27:42to win, and or we will all go only with the Prime Minister,
- 27:47only with whoever decides that we should win. We will follow him. Here
- 27:51I tell you, did you want a military coup? And then he goes
- 27:53on to say, we're the reservist who can no longer return home. We
- 27:57will show you what a decision is, we will show you what a victory
- 28:00is, and we will show you how real Jews win. So you just
- 28:07go again. You just can't make this up, can you? I mean
- 28:11you Gallant? And and that may have been what prompted you know, one
- 28:15of the things that prompted Gallant to to to do what he did, because
- 28:21this is absolutely absurd. So first of all, yeah yeah, oh yeah,
- 28:25net and Yahoo. Uh isn't even in Israel. In fact, he's
- 28:30not far from where I am now. He's in Miami, living in a
- 28:33luxury condo, where he has been since before the war, and hasn't you
- 28:38know, does not hasn't voluntive to go back to Israel to do anything else,
- 28:44you know. And the Israeli papers have written about this, even even
- 28:48the you know, right wing ones, showing both you know, I mean
- 28:52the paperst love doing this, you know, photographs of his apartment, the
- 28:56tennis courts, spa game lounge, private cinema, wind sellar, cigar um,
- 29:03you know, I mean, anyone who's been to Jack's house will recognize.
- 29:10But so now he comes, now he emerges right and and this and
- 29:15produces the video. The IDEF, of course, went ape shit launched an
- 29:22investigation of its own, citing all the violations of various rules. Jason,
- 29:27I thought, you know, I said earlier that I'd heard that the guy
- 29:32in the video wasn't even a reservist, you know, which is almost hard
- 29:36to imagine. If he isn't you know, in Israel and Israeli. But
- 29:40I can't find, you know, I don't know now where I got that
- 29:45information, so it could be it could be bogus. But regardless, it
- 29:48doesn't really matter whether he's a reservist or not. This was clearly a staged
- 29:55video for the benefit of his father, and but just the fact that he
- 30:00thought he could get away with it really blows my mind. Yeah, and
- 30:03he even said he made a Yeah, I made a separate post on telegram
- 30:07and said, in light of the reactions to the reserve video circling on the
- 30:11networks, let's sort out the question of what a military rebellion is. An
- 30:15army that announces that, in times of dispute, will only obey the government
- 30:19and the prime minister, it's not a rebellion. But on the contrary,
- 30:22is an army that obeys the law. Hey, you know what I've written
- 30:27about that. You know, when you're compelling when it is your duty to
- 30:32disobey orders. But no, that doesn't fall into that category. But you
- 30:38can see how you know, we talk when I say we, but I
- 30:45mean from time to time, there's somewhat hysterical speculation in the States about the
- 30:49prospects of the civil war. But I can tell you that the divisions in
- 30:56Israel feel far, far more raw when you're there than they ever do here.
- 31:07I mean, part of that's a function of geography, but part of
- 31:11it's a function of the times. But it's also a function of polarization,
- 31:19and not left right polarization, but polarization of issues. You know, the
- 31:25day and this day after in Gaza is one. What to do about the
- 31:29hostages is another. But yeah, you know, there was an unprecedented breakdown
- 31:37in discipline from government point of view in the military back in March when Netnya,
- 31:45who was fiddling around trying to change they trying to get essentially better control,
- 31:52greater control, governmental control over the judiciary, right, and there was
- 31:56army, a military pushback, popular pushback on that, and the military took
- 32:01front and center stage. There were reports, you know, of pilots not
- 32:07reporting to duty. Gallant himself resigned and Letnahu backed down. So all of
- 32:14this happened even before the war. The divisions were were there. The war
- 32:17has exacerbated them, and I think Gamar, you know, Rafa and uh
- 32:23and and this question of the day after has has brought them to a to
- 32:28a crescendo. HM and and I think you know what all this is going
- 32:35on, the question is what's her mass doing? Now? What's what's happened
- 32:40to Hamas? And I've you know, I've read, I wrote an article
- 32:45about this just you know, just yesterday. But if you look at you
- 32:52know, let's let's throw aside all this just talk about what her mask was
- 32:55seen here, here, her mass was seen there. Let's just look at
- 32:59you know, hamas leadership, infrastructure, the fighters, you know, their
- 33:06their units and their ideology. And I'm not going to you know all you
- 33:08guys, but you know, bottom line leadership. The Israelis have they say,
- 33:15killed one hundred and thirteen of Hamas's leaderships, you know, mid ranking
- 33:21guys. Where the BBC didn't challenge the claim about leadership, it challenged the
- 33:27names on the list because it was finding like, you know, found the
- 33:30name of the Janeta, found the name for I mean, not a journalist.
- 33:36It found duplicatet names and all of this, so the list may not
- 33:42be accurate. The Israelis again claimed that it represents seventy to eighty percent of
- 33:47the masses leadership. But I would argue whether it's accurate or not is irrelevant.
- 33:52Because of the way that HAMAS is structured, all of those guys will
- 33:55have been replaced seamlessly. You know, Hamas. You're seeing IDF briefs.
- 34:01You know, the Hamas referred to by it as though it's military structure,
- 34:08brigades and battalions, and indeed HAMAS uses that terminology. It uses brigades for
- 34:16you know, for regional organization, and it uses battalions just kind of a
- 34:22loose as a loose method of authority. But most of all the succession of
- 34:27command. Right, So someone does get killed, they get replaced quickly.
- 34:30So the whole structure is designed to replace people in a hurry. So whether
- 34:36or not they killed one hundred and thirteen are these people makes little difference.
- 34:39And you know, of the top three, the three guys who who organized
- 34:45and who planned and executed seven October, only one Muhammed Isha I'm going to
- 34:52mispronounce his name as w who was killed. Just as last week, only
- 34:57one of them has been killed. So leadership are pretty much intact. You
- 35:02know, infrastructure, you don't have to take it from me, you know,
- 35:07I can just tell you about Israeli targeting techniques. They target tunnel shafts,
- 35:14right, they have to. I mean, it's the most visible,
- 35:15detectable part of the tunnel. It's the most vulnerable. The thing is that
- 35:20the way the tunnels are structured in Gaza, the shaft is insulated by an
- 35:27outbra the only thing I can call it is another kind of an outshoot from
- 35:32the main tunnel. So the shaft doesn't even lead to the main tunnel,
- 35:37and the main tunnel will have you know, maybe four or five shafts,
- 35:43and the tunnels on the tunnel framework, which is one single tunnel with all
- 35:47those offshoots, is not connected to another tunnel. So you see, you've
- 35:54destroyed a shaft, and you've destroyed a shaft, and that's how the Israelis
- 35:59are reporting tunnel destruction. You haven't you haven't even destroyed the entire tunnel,
- 36:05let alone touched the network by hitting that shaft. So when the Israelis say
- 36:08that they have destroyed four hundred tunnels or whatever, that means four hundred strikes
- 36:14on shafts in which they could see they've destroyed just to you know, close
- 36:17the shaft. You know there's an and there was an expert quoted in Israeli
- 36:23papers this week. I forget her name, doctor at one of the main
- 36:29think tanks, but her area of expertise is an underground warfare, and she
- 36:34says, in her words, it would be impossible to destroy that framework of
- 36:39tunnels, her mass's framework of tunnels. And so you know the most important
- 36:45of those are the tunnels that go that connect ans in to the outside world
- 36:50to Egypt, that go under the Philadelphia crossing, and those have not been
- 36:53destroyed and are not being held right now, although the Israelis are sitting on
- 37:00top of them. So you'll see that when you're talking about destruction of buildings
- 37:04above ground, and you're talking about destroying har Maas's inventory of ordinance, which
- 37:12Israel has been you know, quite successful in doing. If you haven't touched
- 37:19Maas's means of replenishment, then it matters little what else you have messed up.
- 37:24So a lot of destruction, but I would argue that very little of
- 37:29it to Hamas's critical infrastructure. And then you've got and then you've got the
- 37:35fighters, right units or fighters. What I've said, it makes no sense
- 37:38to talk about. But below battalion you are talking about twos and threes.
- 37:44All right, the largest, one of the largest attacks, infiltration attacks in
- 37:50the entire war, and it tied down a battalion for three days. Was
- 37:53conducted by six guys, right, and I heard that from repeatedly brigade command
- 37:59of battalion, and that was one of the largest attacks. These guys are
- 38:01operating in one in two threes. Even once you know RPG minds I DSH
- 38:14you destroy something exactly exactly. So so that is why, uh, the
- 38:23Israeli, the IDF is so focused on a body count. You know,
- 38:29one one senior general commented to the papers, you know, we've become Westmoreland,
- 38:35which you know, and focused on that. But but that But the
- 38:38problem is that for the intelligence guys, they're like, look, you you
- 38:44can talk when you want about destroying brigades or battalions, but it doesn't mean
- 38:46shit. The only way to measure the effect you're having on him is to
- 38:51kill his people, because they because his those those little groups are his main
- 38:55component of combat power. And the way to hurt them somebody to kill people.
- 39:00That's the argument, and that's why it's been reported. So then take
- 39:05a look at you know, before the war, the Israelis said that Hamas
- 39:08had around thirty thousand guys. By that, I mean they made thirty thousand
- 39:15guys in Gaza who were being paid to do Hamas things most of the time,
- 39:21right, full time more or less full time fighters. They claim to
- 39:25have killed thirteen thousand. Now, if you look at total figures, that
- 39:30those killed thirty five thousand something. And yes, the figures come from the
- 39:38Ghazan Health Ministry HA mask control. But you know those two of the UN
- 39:45not just the UN, but independent there's a UK ANDNGO tracking casualties. But
- 39:51anyway, there isn't a lot of dispute about the number of figures, percentage
- 39:58of those women and children, There isn't a great of dispute, you know,
- 40:00two thirds, just over two thirds as they So my point is that
- 40:07if two thirds of thirty five thousand, there's you know, twenty four thousand.
- 40:13So even if every single military age male who was killed in Gaza was
- 40:22a member of her Maas, that's eleven thousand guys, okay, which is
- 40:27not the thirteen thousand. So that might be a little steep when they say
- 40:30they killed thirteen thousand people. But on the other hand, you know,
- 40:36they probably incapacitated two to three times that many, right, her wounds and
- 40:42everything else. So it's not unreasonable to say that they could well have you
- 40:49know, for one tenth and purposes destroyed her Mass's personnel, you know,
- 40:52destroyed they killed more than killed or incapacitated some Okay, does that mean her
- 41:02Mass is done? Though? You know, I mean, how how deep
- 41:07has the ideology seeped into the population. I mean, some say that the
- 41:12ideology was already deeply steeped in the population from decades of being holed up in
- 41:20Gaza together, right, But the question is, you know, has what
- 41:24has happened since seven October increased that support or reduced it to zero? And
- 41:31I would say it's very unlikely that it's reduced it to zero, and that
- 41:36ideology maybe her Mass's most deadly legacy and the greatest yet and the greatest threat
- 41:43yet to Israel. Yeah, all right, we got we got one more.
- 41:49I mean yeah, by itself, it seems like a completely feudal enterprise
- 41:53to be trying to do this. We got one thing that came in just
- 41:57before we started from The Guardian about a former Israeli spice chief threatned the International
- 42:04Criminal Court prosecutor over war crimes inquiry that was prior to October seventh, and
- 42:09like the kickoff of all this, Jay, you wanted to talk about this
- 42:13a bit. Yeah, so this is a classic. We talked in like
- 42:16I think one of our first two episodes about motivations for committing espionage and which
- 42:24is mice m i ce. One of those is coercion, and it seems
- 42:29that in this case that was the the goal. So the X massade chief
- 42:36yosse Cohen, it was alleged that he headed up himself personally a operation to
- 42:45course the International Courts prosecutor I'm gonna screw her name up fatal Ben Soda into
- 42:55uh dropping any pursuit of you know, any kind of charges against military personnel
- 43:04or higher ranking political figures. So the operation was like first, it started
- 43:10out kind of like, you know, whispers in her ear about that this
- 43:15may you know, it would be in her best interest to let this kind
- 43:20of thing go. But according to her, it got increasingly hostile and persistent.
- 43:25And most intel ops don't normally start that way. It's you know,
- 43:30it's usually pretty or I should say they don't normally start full steam. It
- 43:36usually ramps up that way depending on the intell agency. But these veil threats
- 43:42eventually got to like an old school mob style. Hey, it's a dangerous
- 43:46world out there, got it, you know, why don't you let us
- 43:50protect you, you and your family. So that was the backhanded way of
- 43:55issuing a threat that you never know what's going to happen. You know,
- 44:00it's a bad world out there, a lot of wolves at the door,
- 44:02so let us protect you. And then eventually it would be, well,
- 44:07we're protecting you in exchange for that, why don't you back off a little
- 44:10bit? So sometimes that works, a lot of times it doesn't. And
- 44:17I'm gonna say this in my own little bubble that I worked in. I
- 44:22do not speak for the US government or Intel agencies when we say this we
- 44:28don't use or we're taught that we don't use coercion. I'm not saying that
- 44:31in you know, way above me that someone hasn't done it or authorized it.
- 44:37And I'm sure it was done a long time ago. But most of
- 44:39the time it doesn't work. It's just like, you know, if I
- 44:45beat you long enough, you're gonna tell me exactly what I want to hear,
- 44:47whether that's the truth, or not so coersion can it can go one
- 44:53way or the other. And so that's why most Western intel agencies don't use
- 44:59it. So like you'd said, you you said earlier, it happened before
- 45:02October seventh, and uh, Cohen, I don't know what his influence is
- 45:07now. I do know I'd read that he had been a rising political star.
- 45:13Uh some political scheme. But Andy, maybe you know a little better
- 45:16than me what I don't. I don't. But actually I've got a good
- 45:22at question totally off off, not off topic. But going back to your
- 45:29comment about coercion, So so is blackmail regarded as a former coercion? Yeah,
- 45:36uh, certainly. I mean, but that seems to be when when
- 45:42we look at motivation for for for essentially US traders, right who turn over
- 45:51what is isn't money? That is that? That is the usually from what
- 45:57I've studied, Uh, it looks like usually it's money and ego going hand
- 46:01in hand most time. Look at Hanson, Robert Hanson. He needed the
- 46:07money, but he also was one hundred percent sure that he could get away
- 46:12with it because he was a smart guy, you know, very very smart
- 46:15guy. He knew his job, he knew the ins and out of it.
- 46:17So he knew how to get around all of it. But those two
- 46:22things his ego and need of money, although at a certain point he really
- 46:27didn't need it, it just became a thing overtook him. And plus he
- 46:32got you know, well I shouldn't say him, but others got family involved.
- 46:37So once you start adding those loose ends, as they say in something's
- 46:44gonna go wrong. So Corson, at least from a US standpoint, doesn't.
- 46:50I don't know of any incidents, and I'm sure someone can tell me
- 46:53in the comments. Ideology. I think more played into it. Towards the
- 47:01end of the First Golf War and the beginning of the War on Terror.
- 47:06You had people who had been radicalized, and so eventually, you know,
- 47:09if they were in that position to give information, they started doing that,
- 47:13but mostly was money and ego, and they usually go hand in hand,
- 47:15just like corigion and compromise usually go hand in hand. So yeah, that's
- 47:21really good. So coercion and compromise. So I would say the initial for
- 47:29the US, for US traders, essentially he'd sell secrets motivated by greed.
- 47:37But regardless of motive, after that initial contact, there's always coercion. Yeah,
- 47:43right, and even and even for US case officer after that initial hook,
- 47:50after the initial transfer, there's the there's implicit coercion. Yeah, and
- 47:54if he doesn't intend it, even if you don't intend it, yeah,
- 47:59because yeah, part of what your your relationship with that recruitment is, uh,
- 48:08is you want to ensure them that their safety is your priority. You
- 48:15know, so you have your training, but you also want to impart on
- 48:19them that you're, uh, you're gonna use your training to keep them and
- 48:23their family safe and uh, you know, their jobs safe and all that
- 48:27stuff. So that's the implied coercion. It's like, Okay, well,
- 48:32now we've you've taken a little money, you've give me a little information.
- 48:37Even if they haven't taken money yet. It's like you're not going to actually
- 48:39come out and say it, but it's like you just took a step down
- 48:42that road. Now you know, now I have to keep you safe.
- 48:45So that's always in the back of their head, like, you know,
- 48:49you don't come out and say it, but it's implied and in the back
- 48:52of their head they're thinking, well, shit, I just gave them information,
- 48:55so now I have to you know, rely on this and now I
- 49:00have to keep it going. And some do somewhere down the road or early
- 49:05on, say you know what, I'll take my chances. I'm not doing
- 49:07it, and okay, you know, here's your little bit of money or
- 49:10whatever, thanks you know, for you know, for working with us.
- 49:15But some people just eventually something else takes over, whether it's I think it
- 49:22moves out of coercion after a while, and it becomes the money is great,
- 49:27the medicine for my child is great, the promise, possible promise of
- 49:31being bought to the US, you know, all those things start to take
- 49:36over. Whereas when you have somewhere like maybe the Chinese MSS or something like
- 49:40that, where it's like that guy's in a hotel or that female's in a
- 49:44hotel and they come walking out of the closet with a camera like, hey
- 49:47gotcha. You know, I think after a while that fear, i'm not
- 49:54gonna say it starts to wear off. But because they become desensitized to it,
- 49:59and that's why a lot of them at certain points just choose to defect.
- 50:02They just choose to well, I'll take my chances to get the hell
- 50:05out, you know. So yeah, and I know This may sound,
- 50:09you know, a little bit hokey to some, but it's fair to say
- 50:13too they think that they're in the for the US at least, I mean,
- 50:20only that I can speak of. But when a case officer establishes that
- 50:24relationship, trust has to be involved, absolving trust, and and that protection
- 50:30physical protection of sources is central to for instance, the agency's ethos. Now
- 50:37you know, regardless of whatever happened in the past, it is absolutely central
- 50:40and to each case officers, you know, you're never I mean, it's
- 50:45it's almost it's like it goes beyond attorney client privilege, right because people's clients
- 50:51are at stake, and it's very and the whole you know, the ability
- 50:55to the institution to do what it does as well depends on absolutely yeah.
- 51:01And that's why as you get to an early point, as early as possible
- 51:07in the relationship, you want to move that relationship from public whereas hey,
- 51:10I just met this person at a embassy ball or you know, on the
- 51:16tennis court as quickly as possible, but as safely as possible, move that
- 51:21into a semi and then a fully clandestine relationship behind closed doors, you know,
- 51:28and at every meeting you are reiterating that their safety is paramount at paramount,
- 51:35and that you are doing everything in your power to keep them safe,
- 51:39which behooves them to listen to what you're saying to them and heed your instructions,
- 51:45those kind of things, because I always you know, it was taught
- 51:50to me, and I always say that usually depend you know, depending on
- 51:53the situation that the country you're working in, the most you're gonna get I'm
- 51:59gonna get, you're gonna get is you know, thrown in jail. They're
- 52:01gonna you know, if you get caught, they're gonna, oh, we're
- 52:05gonna keep you here forever, you know, blah blah blah, that kind
- 52:07of thing. And behind the scenes, state department, depending on your cover,
- 52:12is working on getting you back a trade whatever it is. You get
- 52:15kicked out of country, your persona on gratti, you don't come back,
- 52:19but you emphasize to them you get caught, it's your life or your freedom,
- 52:23So it behooves you. So think about now on the front end of
- 52:28that, if you just coerce somebody into doing it, Hey, I have
- 52:30these you know, I've got these photos of you with this prostitute. I'm
- 52:37sure your job doesn't want to find out, blah blahah whatever. Well,
- 52:40situations change. What if six months from now that guy and his wife or
- 52:45that woman and her husband are getting a divorce and they don't give a shit
- 52:49that you have the papers anymore, the pictures anymore. So now your coresion
- 52:52is just fizzled out. So I think it's easier to go with the money
- 52:57and the ego and possibly the ideology as well. Yeah, ego is a
- 53:01big one. Yeah, yes, it is just finished that just reading the
- 53:06book Fat Leonard, by the way, I recommend it to everyone. And
- 53:08you want to talk about Unfortunately Fat Leonard was not a foreign agent because he
- 53:15would have been He would have wrecked havoc. Havoc not just on US seventh
- 53:20Fleet, but on US security. But you want to talk about reed and
- 53:24ego as motivations. Ninety one admirals were caught up in the investigation. And
- 53:34you know, when the view of many and many more should I mean a
- 53:37number of them should have gone to prison, only one ended up going to
- 53:39prison in the end. But when you read it, it's incredible. You
- 53:45know, our peers, navy captains, a marine colonel just making idiots themselves
- 53:53for you know, party favors, prostitutes, sham pain arties, but most
- 54:02of them having their REGOs stroked. Absolutely, It's just unbelievable. It is.
- 54:09That was great, all right, So choke Andy's ego a little bit.
- 54:13Check out his book. It's a link is in the description. It's
- 54:15a great book, award winning, it's my pocket book. I already had
- 54:25to spend a night at your house. Don't forget to like and subscribe if
- 54:30you're listening to us on audio, rate and review it best thing you could
- 54:31do. Also share it, tell a friend about it, and our patreon
- 54:36Patreon dot com, slash the teamhouse you can find Andy. All the links
- 54:39are in the description, from his Twitter to his book, to his LinkedIn
- 54:43to his sub stack Jason, No, not happening, and uh I gotta
- 54:49shout out. I got a shout out real quick. Uh okay, I
- 54:52want to try and get this message to the second Battalion Role Rifles the CEO,
- 55:00Colonel Nick, thank you so much for just an awesome time last Friday.
- 55:07I got to speak to the regiment and I'll tell you what. If
- 55:12you are at all intrigued by elite forces, then then read up on the
- 55:21gurkhas most extraordinary group of individuals and there remains so and it was my great
- 55:25privilege and honor to be able to talk to them. So yeah, roll
- 55:31Gokha rifles, Hurrah, whatever they say, I are go, karlimh