Latest / Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson / Bachelor Producer Spills the BTS Tea on Reality TV w/ Michael Carroll
Transcript
- 0:00Alcohol was the greatest way to get tears out of a girl at the end of the bachelor, especially when she was eliminated.
- 0:05If you got a girl that's a little tipsy, she's a little more apt to have her emotions come to the surface quickly.
- 0:11And you needed that, especially when you've had five girls leaving.
- 0:14You need to interview each of them before the sun comes up.
- 0:17So make sure they're liquored up before you get them out or give them a drink right when they're eliminated and have them get to where you want them.
- 0:24Are you going through life blind?
- 0:26This is Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson.
- 0:29On this podcast, we share knowledge and stories that build human connection while elevating stigmatized societal issues such as mental health, holistic wellness, culture, free speech, and more.
- 0:41All to ensure we show up in the world with our eyes wide open.
- 0:46Hello, everyone.
- 0:47Welcome to this episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 0:49Our guest today, a very special guest, is Michael Carroll.
- 0:52Michael is an entertainment professional, executive producer, and former reality TV producer, having worked on several shows, including The Bachelor, The Bachelorette, Temptation Island, America's Next Top Model, and many, many others.
- 1:05But today, we're here to talk about that experience and your journey from entertainment and in reality TV.
- 1:13So how are you?
- 1:13Thanks for coming in today.
- 1:14Okay.
- 1:15Hey, thanks for having me, Nick.
- 1:15I'm great.
- 1:16Good to do this.
- 1:19Yeah, I am excited.
- 1:20So new question.
- 1:21I'm asking everybody to get started.
- 1:25What's top of mind for you these days?
- 1:27What's keeping you up at night?
- 1:30Well, as you could imagine, it's the election.
- 1:33Yeah, like I knew you were going to say that.
- 1:36Is that what everyone's saying at this time of year?
- 1:39The election upcoming is
- 1:41very much on my mind and keeping me awake at night.
- 1:44But I feel like there's good momentum towards something good happening.
- 1:48So I'm looking forward to it.
- 1:50Yeah.
- 1:52I think it's not only you can't even get away from it, it's everywhere.
- 1:55Like it is just this crazy.
- 1:56And luckily, I'm one of those news.
- 1:58Yeah, I'm a news junkie and I'm a political junkie.
- 2:01So I'm like eating it up.
- 2:02But I need to take like, you know, mental health breaks.
- 2:07So just to learn.
- 2:08Well, funny you say that away from this.
- 2:10Like, I like being the most informed guy in the room about politics.
- 2:12So I just need to sometimes remember there's other things to do.
- 2:17Again, we were talking about politics.
- 2:19I'm a total political junkie.
- 2:21So I try to be as informed as possible, but I need to take mental health breaks because it can be a bit much, especially right now.
- 2:30Yeah, you're spot on.
- 2:32I'm a political junkie too, unfortunately.
- 2:34And I just had a phone call with a friend a few minutes ago.
- 2:36And I was like, I got to take a break because it's going to make me crazy.
- 2:40It's just it's everywhere.
- 2:41It's like, it's literally like, it's everywhere.
- 2:45I can't escape it on social media.
- 2:47I can't escape it on the TV.
- 2:48I can't escape it on my newsfeed.
- 2:51It's just everywhere.
- 2:52Mental health break.
- 2:55Yeah.
- 2:55And being a media person in general, it makes me feel like I'm missing something.
- 3:00There's huge FOMO if I don't know exactly what's happening at all times.
- 3:03Like, what did Kamala Harris just say?
- 3:05What is Trump saying about what she just said?
- 3:06Like, I can't stop.
- 3:07I'm like, well, I got to look and see what happened and what they're talking about with the interview last night.
- 3:11Like, the entire thing is crazy.
- 3:13Me too.
- 3:15I literally like I went home.
- 3:16I was I was at dinner last night till like 10 o'clock.
- 3:18I came home.
- 3:19I had to watch the interview.
- 3:20And then I'm like, well, I got to go on truth, truth freaking social to see if someone's been live truthing it.
- 3:26It's like I tell my friends, I'm like, I'm on true social.
- 3:28So you don't have to be.
- 3:30Oh, there you go.
- 3:31I know.
- 3:31I need to follow you doing that.
- 3:33That sounds good.
- 3:34Yeah.
- 3:34Oh, man.
- 3:37We'll get through it.
- 3:38We'll get through it.
- 3:39So my other favorite question to ask people is, what did you want to be when you were a little kid, and how did that change to where you are now?
- 3:48I wanted to be an architect, someone who built things.
- 3:54But my freshman year, I was an architecture major at the University of Florida, and I
- 3:59And somehow I naively did not realize how much technical, mathematic, and granular work there was to be had in that field.
- 4:10I was, in my head, a little bit more designy.
- 4:12I was like, I want to make a pretty building.
- 4:14And that wasn't really what it was.
- 4:16So I kind of migrated out of that and ended up in the communications world, luckily.
- 4:22Well, that's a big difference.
- 4:24But, you know, I used to be obsessed with like...
- 4:27Oh, sorry.
- 4:29Um, moved into the communications world, luckily, and, uh, where I still got to build things.
- 4:33It was just, you know, building creative content for television, which is interesting.
- 4:38Which is definitely interesting, which is what we're here to talk about today.
- 4:41So amazing.
- 4:43How did you get into reality or producing in general?
- 4:47And then how did you land in the reality unscripted side of things?
- 4:52When I graduated college in 95,
- 4:55Um, I knocked around San Francisco for the rest of my time and then finally left in 98 to move to Los Angeles because I really wanted to work in the entertainment field somehow.
- 5:04Um, being that I was still young and fun and, you know, trying to figure out what I needed to do and wanted to do, I was an actor and a waiter and a model and doing all those things that a lot of people that first get to Los Angeles and have no idea what they're doing do.
- 5:17So, um, I did that for a couple of years and I was, uh,
- 5:20When I turned 30, I said, I really can't do this anymore.
- 5:23I really cannot wait one more table.
- 5:26How do I get into the business?
- 5:27And just randomly, a friend got a job on Project Greenlight.
- 5:32The first season was there.
- 5:33I was obsessed with that show.
- 5:34I know.
- 5:35I wanted to be a filmmaker back then.
- 5:37Yeah, so that was 99 or two.
- 5:39No, that would have been 2001 when it aired.
- 5:41He worked on it.
- 5:42And then his boss took him along to a new show called The Bachelor.
- 5:47And he called me and said, hey, I know you're trying to get into the business.
- 5:50the executive producer of The Bachelor is looking for an assistant.
- 5:53And I said, great.
- 5:56What do they do?
- 5:58How does that work?
- 5:59I had no idea what that meant, but it sounded like a good position and a cool opportunity.
- 6:04So I met with her and she happened to be like one year older than me.
- 6:07She's like a reality TV veteran icon, Lisa Levinson.
- 6:11She's basically known to be the creator of The Bachelor, even though,
- 6:15Everyone claims Mike Fleiss did it, but she was really the, you know, behind the scenes person who made that show happen.
- 6:21So we just clicked and hit it off.
- 6:23You know, I asked, I convinced her to hire me because I said, why would you want like a 22 year old kid out of college when you could have someone who's 30 and been around sets and has life experience and, you know, has a bigger interest than someone just going, I don't know what I want to do.
- 6:38So we just hit it off and it worked.
- 6:43So, yeah.
- 6:44what was your understanding of the show?
- 6:46Did she, did you get like a pitch or were you just like, I don't really care what it is.
- 6:49I'm here to work.
- 6:52Say again, you broke up.
- 6:54Oh, what was, what was the pitch or did you not care?
- 6:58Were you just happy to be breaking into the business?
- 7:01Do you understand the show?
- 7:03Yeah, there was no pitch per se per se for me getting into reality television, especially on the Bastard because the first season had just aired and it was like the biggest thing,
- 7:14happening at the moment.
- 7:15Like everyone's talking about the show and it seems so ludicrous and ridiculous.
- 7:18Of course I followed it and then I became a fan.
- 7:21I was watching it as I got the job.
- 7:25It was the season finale was coming on.
- 7:27So I was, I was like, okay, I totally know the show.
- 7:29And if it's going again, let's do it.
- 7:31So I got hired between season one and season two.
- 7:34It was a perk for the executive producer to get an assistant.
- 7:36She didn't have one season one.
- 7:39Yeah.
- 7:39So no, no big hard sell for me.
- 7:41I was like,
- 7:42And plus reality television was so new at this point, none of us knew what it meant or where it was going to go.
- 7:48But it seemed like a cool entry into the biz.
- 7:50So I was just like, let's go.
- 7:51Let's figure this out.
- 7:52Sounds fun.
- 7:54I remember when it first launched, it did seem really fun.
- 7:56I watched part.
- 7:57I don't think I watched like I didn't watch it regularly, but I remember like watching parts of it, finding it so fascinating at the time.
- 8:04But what was it like on that?
- 8:06So you were at season that season two, right?
- 8:09I started in between one and two.
- 8:10So I started it in season two.
- 8:13We started with casting for that series, and then we went to Bachelorette right after that with Trista.
- 8:19So then it alternated like two Bachelors, then a Bachelorette at the time.
- 8:24So I did nine seasons.
- 8:25So my last season I did as a field producer, I was promoted over four years, was Jen in New York.
- 8:34And she was the person chosen by Andrew Firestone, who was the third Bachelor.
- 8:39So I got to see all the OGs.
- 8:42It was really fun.
- 8:43So how did it change over all those seasons from when you started and it was all fresh and new to, hey, we've got a franchise here that's not only profitable, but it's churning out multiple seasons?
- 8:54Unbelievable.
- 8:55Yeah.
- 8:56Like I said before, it was the genesis of new reality television.
- 9:00You know, reality television was a thing, but not really even referred to as such.
- 9:05You know, Real World was on.
- 9:07And the year that we launched The Bachelor, yeah.
- 9:10Amazing Race and Survivor started.
- 9:13So the three big tent poles that are weirdly still around started all about the same year, 2002, 2001.
- 9:20So there wasn't a huge glut of reality television on and no one had really done it in this sort of way.
- 9:25You know, if you think about the real world, it's a follow show.
- 9:29It's a docu show.
- 9:29It's a documentary at heart.
- 9:31And those had been done before, but nothing along this line where it was a competition.
- 9:36a large cast.
- 9:38None of that had been done, so no one really knew what they were doing.
- 9:40And we, of course, had no idea what we were doing.
- 9:43Thankfully, when I came on, they had at least done one season to learn what to do and what not to do in a certain
- 9:49respect.
- 9:50But we were just kind of like figuring it out.
- 9:53So to be a low person on the totem pole with a little cachet because I was following the executive producer around, that really afforded me a lot of creative input, weirdly, because I was sitting in every meeting that mattered, because I was taking notes for my boss, Lisa Levinson, fielding calls from CAA and from the network.
- 10:12And I was really involved in the nuts and bolts by proxy.
- 10:16But I'm not sure,
- 10:19Even if I hadn't been, even all of the producers that are on the show were still winging it themselves.
- 10:23So there'd be lots of times people were like, okay, they're just hanging out by the pool right now.
- 10:27Like, what do we do?
- 10:28And they're like, just point a camera at them.
- 10:31Like, it was hugely a docu-follow show at that point.
- 10:35If they weren't on a date, if one girl was on a date with The Bachelor and there were 11 girls back at the house, they were just laying by the pool or napping.
- 10:43And that's all.
- 10:44We just let them do whatever they wanted.
- 10:47And that got really boring really quick.
- 10:48So that maybe lasted two seasons of us just doing that, just following them, doing whatever they wanted until someone got smart and said,
- 10:56We need to make them do things to be interesting.
- 10:58At least even if they're just not on a date, like they can't just be hanging out.
- 11:03That's so boring.
- 11:03I want to stab myself in the eye if I watch any more of this.
- 11:07So then they all become friends.
- 11:11Yeah.
- 11:11And then they're just a bunch of tan, lazy chicks.
- 11:13Like that's all they did was lay around.
- 11:15Like, so, and they're just drunk the whole time.
- 11:17Cause that's, I mean, what else are you going to do but lay by the pool and drink and they're all friends.
- 11:20Exactly.
- 11:21So we made them talk, we got to the point where we started
- 11:24putting them in scenarios, even if they weren't on a date or doing something active in the show, they always had something to talk about or something to accomplish.
- 11:34How would you come up with those scenarios?
- 11:37Did you guys sit around or was it based on, okay, sorry, go ahead.
- 11:40Yeah, no worries.
- 11:42When we first started figuring out we needed to have the cast doing something at all times to make the show interesting for us that we're filming it.
- 11:49And of course, mainly for the audience that's watching it, we just started saying, well, we need to be constantly harping on what the concept of the show is.
- 11:59And that's that these women are here to compete for love with The Bachelor specifically.
- 12:03So let's always talk about that only.
- 12:06let's not let them talk about much otherwise, unless it somehow refers to why it makes them good for the bachelor.
- 12:14Like if you're going to talk about your past, I only want to know about your past that makes you attractive to the bachelor, like your college experience, your story kind of thing.
- 12:24Yeah, your upbringing with your family.
- 12:26How do you make friends?
- 12:27How you know, tell me about exes.
- 12:29Those are the topics they were allowed to talk about.
- 12:31And if it got derailed into Oh my god, I love shopping, like,
- 12:35you know, we would cut that, you know, off quick.
- 12:38Like, oh, let's get back on track to only things that matter.
- 12:41We're sure the Bachelor and how much you want him and how much you don't want these other girls to happen.
- 12:46Oof.
- 12:47Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.
- 12:48Yeah, I'm thinking about the evolution.
- 12:50But, and we also, I think we were on...
- 12:53I think our show was one of the first shows that figured out that the least amount of stimulation for them outside of that conceit or concept was hugely beneficial to us.
- 13:04So they were not allowed to bring – we made it on season two where they were not allowed to bring books, magazines, their cell phone, a computer, nothing.
- 13:14So – and they were not allowed to listen to music while they were hanging out in the house or on a date or anything.
- 13:20A, we can't clear that music.
- 13:21That's a whole other inside baseball thing.
- 13:23It just we don't want them distracted in any way.
- 13:26We don't want them jamming out to Rihanna while they're like supposed to be talking and thinking about The Bachelor.
- 13:31We don't want them in the corner reading a book when they're supposed to be thinking and talking about The Bachelor.
- 13:35So they had no stimuli outside of their conversations with the other girls and with The Bachelor and what they were doing and how they were doing it while they were there.
- 13:45That was it.
- 13:46And alcohol, of course.
- 13:48Yeah, we're going to touch on the alcohol.
- 13:50The truth serum.
- 13:51Yeah, we had to have the truth serum.
- 13:53That's what you called it on Vice.
- 13:55Yeah, the truth serum.
- 13:57Which it is.
- 13:58It is the truth serum.
- 13:59Absolutely.
- 14:01When you decided, hey, we're going to kind of take away all of their interaction with the outside world or distractions within there, was that –
- 14:07like how conscious of an effort was that?
- 14:10Cause I look at, you know, some of my experiences and when I look back on it now, I was like, there was some very conscious decisions made on that.
- 14:17And like the isolation and stuff like that, that really kind of puts you in this environment that's just so manufactured that it's all you can think about.
- 14:27Did you know that level you were doing it or was it more so like, we just gotta stop distracting them.
- 14:31So they're talking about this.
- 14:34At the beginning, it was probably a smidge of both.
- 14:40There was the idea that we didn't want too many distractions for them.
- 14:43Let's take away the things that would.
- 14:45And as a production, you don't wanna have to keep up with a phone and a thing and where'd we put it and oh, I left it in the kitchen and whatever it might be.
- 14:52I don't need to follow Caitlin's belongings around all day.
- 14:57So there was all and then also we were thinking, well, this is great because they don't need distractions.
- 15:02They need to be doing what the task at hand and let's keep them talking and, you know, focusing on the bachelor.
- 15:09But by nature, having having done that just one season, season two.
- 15:15we all started realizing how beneficial that was to us in making a cohesive storyline into making it expeditious towards that happening when we needed it, of course, on a schedule and for the conceit of the show.
- 15:28So it just it all kind of fell in place.
- 15:30And then, of course, it was never going back.
- 15:32We're never going to.
- 15:33OK, next season, we'll give them the phone.
- 15:34You know, like, why not?
- 15:35They can have the Vogue magazine now.
- 15:37just never was going to happen again.
- 15:38So it just, it just made it easy.
- 15:40It made it, you know, at least keep them semi-focused on what the task at hand was.
- 15:46Yeah.
- 15:47That makes perfect sense.
- 15:48Yeah.
- 15:48Let's, let's, let me ask you this.
- 15:50Were you involved in the casting process at all in, in the bachelor at any point?
- 15:55Weirdly, when I was an assistant to Lisa Levinson, executive producer, I was involved in the casting process only by nature of what I've told you before that I was always her sidekick and I was always there for her.
- 16:07So by nature of us all having...
- 16:11started this process together, I was just one of the team, so I could throw in my input at any time.
- 16:19It wasn't like I wasn't allowed to speak because I was an assistant and not a producer.
- 16:23By nature of being in a room that's new and fresh and we were all kind of collectively trying to make a quality show at the beginning, I had a huge voice.
- 16:34Once I moved up the ladder into different producer positions, yes, you do have a say in the casting process,
- 16:41until final casting.
- 16:44Your job as a regular producer, if you're an assistant associate producer, a segment producer, or a field producer, which was the team at the time, was to take care of compartmentalized dates and activities and things that the girls would be doing at the house.
- 16:59You were pre-planning that for the season.
- 17:01So you didn't have time to sit through a casting interview or a casting process or a casting debate.
- 17:08Once the girls were all flown out the final 50, it used to be we'd fly 50 girls to a hotel at Universal in Hollywood, Sheraton Universal.
- 17:18That was our camp.
- 17:20And we'd all spend the weekend interviewing on camera individually these 50 girls.
- 17:26And that would narrow them down to the final 25, actual 26, because there would always be an alternate that would get sent home night long.
- 17:32It's got to be awful.
- 17:33Yeah.
- 17:35Oh, that, I mean, I long suspected there's a list of alternates waiting to go if something goes wrong or someone.
- 17:41Absolutely.
- 17:42And I think that increased, that increased, that number increased over the years to like three people.
- 17:46So there's, you know, just because they wanted, you know, as the years increased and as we got smarter about the show.
- 17:53we not only wanted alternates to be there for night one in case someone got sick or a family emergency or something along those lines.
- 18:00But in case we realized in that first weekend prior to filming episode one, that someone wasn't as exciting as we thought they were going to be, or got cold feet.
- 18:10And we knew they weren't going to be good television.
- 18:11We'd swap them out at the last minute because sorry, you know, it's really about good television.
- 18:17Yeah.
- 18:17So there's a lot of people creatively got pulled out, not just because their grandmother died or they got COVID or something like they just, you know, got switched out last minute.
- 18:27You had to always be on.
- 18:30Yeah, so back to the casting process, the way that producers were always included at casting weekend, which was the final weekend before everyone was cast to be on the show, is that we all sat in a room and collectively said yay, nay, watched them on camera in another room being interviewed.
- 18:46And so there'd be 20 people watching you be interviewed for Love is Blind without your knowledge.
- 18:52Yeah, and then we'd bring them into the room and have natural interactions with them.
- 18:57And then when they'd leave, we'd be like,
- 18:59yes or no, you know, that's, that's the only way we were involved in creating and in the creative of casting was that final weekend.
- 19:09And plus we needed to get to know them prior to them arriving.
- 19:12And that was the best.
- 19:12Oh yeah.
- 19:13Yeah, right, right.
- 19:14That makes perfect sense.
- 19:15With Love is Blind, it was during COVID.
- 19:16So I did all my stuff virtual, but I often wondered, I'm like, how many people are being sent this video of me or this edited version?
- 19:26Because then we did like a sizzle type interview where they're like, we're going to edit this up to kind of make a little sizzle of you to present to Netflix.
- 19:32And so be vibrant, be bright, wear cool clothes, be well lit, like all of that stuff.
- 19:37But it was all over Zoom.
- 19:38It was so weird.
- 19:38Yeah.
- 19:39But on the casting piece, did you... Oh, go ahead.
- 19:42Yeah, go ahead.
- 19:43Sorry, I should let you ask the question.
- 19:45No, that's okay.
- 19:46On the casting piece, did you guys have profiles of the kinds of characters you were looking for?
- 19:51Did you have any, you know, things that would be like a hard yes or a hard no other than being boring or being super dramatic?
- 19:59How did you know what you were looking for?
- 20:01Or did you already have kind of like a template of who you were looking for and the types of characters you wanted?
- 20:07During the casting process,
- 20:09Let me quickly touch on the fact that this was 2002, so early 2000s.
- 20:14There was no Zoom interviews.
- 20:15There was no anything of that sort.
- 20:17So in the last casting process, everyone sent in a tape.
- 20:22So by the time they got to us and it was final casting weekend,
- 20:26By nature of us not being able to do anything digitally, the network was sitting in the room at the hotel.
- 20:31So there was 20 people sitting in a hotel suite watching this person be interviewed in the other room via a feed.
- 20:38So when they walked into the room afterwards to meet everyone, they're like, whoa, because you got the network in the agency.
- 20:45and executive producers and all the producers, everyone sitting there like this is overwhelming.
- 20:48So it's probably become an easier process at this point because you really, as a cast member now, can do everything from Oklahoma City and then show up day one in Hollywood and be ready to go and not have
- 21:01having to be flown out, meet the network, all of these things that were so hugely intimidating.
- 21:07So I imagine it's probably an easier process at this point.
- 21:10Not easier once you get there, but getting there easier.
- 21:13Right.
- 21:14When we were casting shows like The Bachelor, especially at the beginning, we didn't realize at the time in the early seasons that we were going to migrate towards casting for type.
- 21:26We at the time were looking for 25 girls that were lovely,
- 21:31pretty.
- 21:32You know, of course, look at on camera and genuinely and honestly, as far as we could
- 21:39looking for love in the right places and looking for it genuinely.
- 21:44We wanted that to happen because we wanted the right result at the end of the show.
- 21:49But by nature of making the show for a couple of seasons, by I'd say even season three, after having done two bachelors and a bachelorette, we started realizing how amazingly beneficial it was for us to have characters, definable characters, the fun girl,
- 22:07The easy girl who's like the party chick, the hoe, the villain, all these girls.
- 22:15I don't mean to laugh.
- 22:16Yeah.
- 22:17It's like, yeah.
- 22:19It was easy descriptors for us.
- 22:21So those were the ones.
- 22:22The hot girl, the hoe, the villain.
- 22:24the bitch, name it.
- 22:26We had all of them.
- 22:28You started seeing that those were popping in the edit every time we made the show, and that was what people gravitated towards when they talked about the TV show.
- 22:34So, of course, that's what we always wanted and needed going forward in the casting process.
- 22:39So there'd be times where it's like on our board, we would have a list of Nick,
- 22:44And Nick would have college graduates from University of Oklahoma, blah, blah, blah.
- 22:48He's now an investment banker.
- 22:51Got in a fight with his girlfriend and got arrested at a bar.
- 22:53Like you'd have all of their sort of hot buttons listed under your name.
- 22:56But then also we would have you in a category of potential, potential, you know, dude bro or potential villain.
- 23:06or a potential, you know, fuck boy, whatever.
- 23:09It would be like you'd be in a group of people that we'd want to consider you as prior to us casting you.
- 23:16I would love to see what my board looked like.
- 23:19What group were you stuck in?
- 23:21Well, I have theory on this and it's talking to you that kind of made me think, oh, this is actually true.
- 23:28And I think that I was cast as like one of the people that would likely get married on the men's side because I had, you know, my stuff together and I had a good job and I had a good career and I owned a house and I was a little bit older.
- 23:41I was 34 at the time.
- 23:42So it was like...
- 23:43I think it was just very much.
- 23:45So this thing where I was like, when I look back on it, I didn't at the time, but when I look back on, I was like, Oh, I think I was cast to be that, but I'd also just love to know what else was under, under my picture.
- 23:57You were probably, you were probably in the group of real guys.
- 24:03Like, okay, we have hopes for him to make this work.
- 24:06So you're probably in that bucket, but then I assure you that there was also, uh,
- 24:13a little mark or sticker on it that said could crash and burn or tears or something.
- 24:19Like they wanted to, you always got all the descriptors labeled onto you prior to that.
- 24:23And if certain things didn't apply after your casting process, then those would fall off, but they would keep you in that world just to make...
- 24:30our job as creative producers easier, to be honest, because I can always go, oh, where's the guy?
- 24:35I think he might cry, you know, whatever.
- 24:36Or I think, you know, he's going to crash and burn or he'll be crushed when he leaves.
- 24:40Or you just needed those moments because you start almost editing in the process of shooting.
- 24:46You're like, where's this moment going?
- 24:47What is going to happen right here?
- 24:49We need something to happen.
- 24:50It's crazy.
- 24:51Right.
- 24:51And do you like, would you like manufacture scenes and stuff at this point?
- 24:55I know they do that now because I participated in them, but when it's like, okay, we need you to do this in this scene, you're going to, and you kind of plan it ahead of time before they even know that they're going to be in this manufactured scenario.
- 25:07We never did that in the early seasons of The Bachelor.
- 25:09It took years for it to really come around in reality television.
- 25:12It might have happened on other shows, but my narrow focus was The Bachelor.
- 25:16So I'd say for the first two years I was there, and let's call it five seasons, there was not much manufacturing of specific scenes.
- 25:25There was manufacturing of a conceit or a concept for a date.
- 25:31okay, I know this girl's shy, but he really likes her.
- 25:34So my job as a producer is going to get her to come out of her shell.
- 25:38And we're going to do this by him asking this.
- 25:39So we would prep them in a way to just make sure that the content was at least usable, but, you know, interesting in some way.
- 25:47So, hey, he would love to find out from you this, and you need to find out from him this.
- 25:53So we coached them on how to be a good person.
- 25:56person on a date, but we are not necessarily setting up some sort of scenario that we were hoping for a specific result out of yet.
- 26:03But we did.
- 26:04You know, I actually think that's not a horrible thing.
- 26:08It's when the intention is to like stoke an insecurity and not like overcome it.
- 26:14Like if someone's shy, but you want to put them in a situation where it's going to make them more shy because they're going to get embarrassed in some way.
- 26:20Like, yeah, like comedy club and get called out.
- 26:23Yeah.
- 26:23Something like that.
- 26:24Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 26:25But when you're sitting there and you're like, I'm actually going to coach her out of her shell so that they can get closer.
- 26:29There's something, it's like a little therapeutic, right?
- 26:32There's something genuine about that.
- 26:33It's when it's like malintentioned or in bad faith or to produce, you know, like you said, a scenario where you're in a comedy club and now they're getting called out and they're super shy in front of crowds.
- 26:43And it's just, you didn't do anything to help that person or their partner or their relationship there.
- 26:48Yeah.
- 26:48So that being said, though, we did get smarter, if not crueler as the years went on.
- 26:54in order to do exactly what you're just saying, where it's like, okay, let's get a specific result quickly, and especially a teasable moment, but also something that will affect the entire process for us going forward.
- 27:06Like, let's make this chick cry by putting her in a place that's gonna make her very uncomfortable.
- 27:12Because we know she's either not feasible for the bachelor, so she's expendable in a way.
- 27:18So let's use her in a way to drive story.
- 27:21you know oh she broke down and cried because she loved him so much but we were just actually trying to find a way to make her upset or uncomfortable like you were just saying it's crazy we would do anything we could to keep the story driven forward towards the result we were looking for um like you know there were seasons it got even worse on the bachelor like there were times that it got really gross after i left
- 27:42There was a girl, I think, I can't remember her name.
- 27:44She became the bachelorette, but her boyfriend or former fiance or something like that died in a race car accident.
- 27:53She was a race car driver.
- 27:55So, of course, what was her date?
- 27:57Going to a race car, you know, a race at a racetrack.
- 28:01I was like, why would the, I know exactly why you do that, but it's so gross.
- 28:07That was her first date was at a race, you know.
- 28:10How does that make like, not you feel because you didn't do it, but like, how do people not feel any empathy or emotion to do that?
- 28:20And I know when we talked initially, you had said like there was a point where you kind of just stopped looking at them as people and you start looking at them as like props or story points or characters.
- 28:28So, man, like I can't imagine doing that.
- 28:32At the beginning of –
- 28:35working on reality television, there were often moral dilemmas that were faced.
- 28:40You know, I would often go, wow, this is really messed up.
- 28:44But that being said, you know, considering myself a decent person, I also got caught up in the excitement of making television and finding moments where you go, gosh, that was amazing.
- 28:55Can you believe that just happened?
- 28:56You'd feel there was a huge sense of accomplishment to make television.
- 29:00Quality television, someone crying, someone fighting, some big moment, you know, that wasn't just two people eating in front of each other, you know, which is so boring.
- 29:11So anytime you had drama or fun moments that you were a part of, that those more dilemmas sort of would slide away.
- 29:18And you'd go, oh, okay, that was so much fun.
- 29:20Oh, my gosh.
- 29:20But then you'd have moments to think about it afterwards and be like, okay, I don't know how long I'm going to keep doing this.
- 29:25But okay, I'm signed up for season six.
- 29:28It's terrific.
- 29:29The train just kept running.
- 29:31So the longer you were in it, the more you were working, it just kind of became a job.
- 29:37And it became, well, I'm working still and I'm not gonna speak up now.
- 29:42I won't be working on this if I say, I don't wanna do that.
- 29:45You know?
- 29:46It became sort of just your thing.
- 29:48And that became, you know, repetitive tasks and things like that just breed comfort.
- 29:54So it became easy to do.
- 29:56But that being said, towards the end, I was every other season going, this is really awful.
- 30:01And I'd be like, I don't care.
- 30:03They signed up.
- 30:03You know, like it was back and forth, back and forth.
- 30:06And I do want to, one of the things I want to touch on is that you signed up for it.
- 30:09But before that, one thing I want to say, and this is more for like my audience and there's people that think, and I've talked to several producers like off the record and a lot of them are like, Hey, like we're just doing a job.
- 30:22Like we have a job to do.
- 30:23And, and, you know, there's things you do at your job that don't align with your values or align with, um, or that's like the dirty part of the job.
- 30:32Right.
- 30:32And so while I, um,
- 30:35I don't understand how people can do some of these things because, you know, of who I am and how I am and stuff like that.
- 30:42And me too, I consider myself strong moral compass.
- 30:45But I think there's an element there that should be considered is that this is a systematic thing, not an individual producer thing.
- 30:53And that I'm fighting against.
- 30:55And so I actually try to look at the producers as like almost tools of a bigger thing.
- 31:02And that's just a systematic thing.
- 31:06form of entertainment that hasn't been regulated or hasn't like faced its maker yet in some way to be like, hey, we actually have to do things a little bit more ethically and a little less exploitative.
- 31:17So I almost like don't really blame people.
- 31:21And I think there's bad people that probably don't have a moral compass that make bad decisions.
- 31:25I think I probably met some of them on Love is Blind.
- 31:27But yeah,
- 31:28But I also think there are some people that it's like, this is just their job.
- 31:32And they're thinking of it as a job, just like you think of your job as a job, whoever's listening right now.
- 31:37And there's times that things go on that really frustrate you and you don't want to do them and you don't think it's the right thing, but you do it because you got to feed yourself.
- 31:44Absolutely.
- 31:44There's a lot to unpack in that, unpack in that question.
- 31:49Honestly, I do think that you could blame producers like myself that were there at the beginning because we were creating out of nothing and we were trying to figure out how to make television interesting that were just regular people.
- 32:01So that concept had not been done before.
- 32:03No one knew what they were doing.
- 32:04We had no idea what we were doing.
- 32:06So we had to do things that would make it.
- 32:08people interesting.
- 32:09And some of us, I don't know who it was at the time, figured out how to push people's buttons and set up scenarios that would make them upset or enraged or...
- 32:20feel sexual or whatever it might have been.
- 32:22And by nature of that all working, networks loved it.
- 32:26So they were more prone to push that sort of activity or just support the producers that did that and promote them and make them successful.
- 32:36So that sort of became the norm over the years.
- 32:39And then being hired for it now, if you start as a production assistant or someone low on the totem pole, you're going to be able to do that.
- 32:45and you watch that activity happening on a set, you know that's how I have to do it in order to be a producer.
- 32:49This is what the machine is.
- 32:51So the machine is driving it now.
- 32:53Of course, it had to start somewhere and have a genesis and a place to grow, but that was the beginning when we didn't know what we were doing, so we just figured it out.
- 33:01But yeah, I mean, everyone knows now, if you're going in to be a reality TV producer, you need to be A, good with people, and that good with people could not mean I'm a good person with people.
- 33:11I'm good at manipulating people.
- 33:14Or I'm good at relating to people and tricking them or deceiving them.
- 33:19But that's the nature of how the business transformed and grew.
- 33:25And by nature of that being done that way, like finding really interesting and quick ways to get reactions or good quality television quickly, it made our schedules better.
- 33:38compact.
- 33:39It made the networks and the production companies hire people that knew how to do that quickly to find good quality moments quickly and make television happen faster than it would if you just sat around and watched people do things.
- 33:51So that made the business model shrink.
- 33:53It made show schedules go from six weeks with The Bachelor when it first started to now four, whatever it might be.
- 34:01The whole thing just becomes that's how you have to do it in order for this to work.
- 34:06kind of just builds on itself then too.
- 34:08Absolutely.
- 34:09So I don't know how a dating reality show, for example, just because that's mainly what we're talking about, could work right now with the issues that you're addressing.
- 34:20Yes, it needs to happen.
- 34:22It needs to, you know, cast members and the process needs to be a little more ethical and they need to take care more of cast members.
- 34:29But as the machine is built now, it's almost impossible to do.
- 34:34It has to be a complete overhaul.
- 34:36Well, I've noticed specifically it.
- 34:38Oh, go ahead.
- 34:40It's very interesting.
- 34:41If you look at the British model of reality television, there's huge ethical guidelines that are in place in the UK.
- 34:49And I think a lot of it comes from a moment where they, a reality show did a piece on the Queen when she was alive.
- 34:56And they used her words and...
- 35:00actions out of context, which is what a lot of reality television is, especially in the edit.
- 35:05And she enacted a law that said that they have to do things a certain way.
- 35:09So, I mean, it can be done.
- 35:11The UK has still, you know, has still produced great quality content.
- 35:16Reality television.
- 35:17So there are ways to enact regulations and things that can help a cast and help producers do it more ethically.
- 35:28It can happen.
- 35:28It's just it's not going to happen overnight.
- 35:31Yeah, no, I agree with that.
- 35:31And I got to tell you one funny thing and then I'll share something else.
- 35:34One funny thing.
- 35:35I had a dream a few months ago that Donald Trump decided that he was going to support legislation to regulate reality TV.
- 35:48And then I was like, I was in this dream.
- 35:50I was like, oh my God, now he's inviting me to his rally to talk about it.
- 35:55And I just remember I'm like, this can't, this can't be it.
- 35:58Cause I'm always like, is there something, you know, he could do that would ever make me support him.
- 36:02And I like had this dream and I was like, this is fucking crazy.
- 36:05Like, there's no way, there's no way.
- 36:09If that statement you just made makes it into the edit and a member of his team or he sees that, he might just adopt that policy just because.
- 36:19Well, I mean, he did The Apprentice.
- 36:20He could be like, I've seen the things we do to people.
- 36:22It's terrible.
- 36:23It's horror.
- 36:23It's some of the worst things you've ever done to people.
- 36:25And I've seen it.
- 36:26Because he now wants the reality TV vote.
- 36:28Like, that's a huge thing.
- 36:31I hope no one, I'm going to leave that in because it's something that I shared with the foundation.
- 36:36I love it.
- 36:36But it was just funny.
- 36:38The other thing too is I think like what I think with production, and I think you're right.
- 36:42I know changing this stuff is really, really hard and it's a lot of hard work and all that stuff.
- 36:46But I think there's just little things that we can do too.
- 36:49And viewers watch this stuff, as I'm sure you know, and they take whatever they see as if they are watching a documentary or as if they are watching a true documentary.
- 36:59following around of people like it maybe wasn't the first season where you're just watching people and act in the way that they are.
- 37:05And they watch it and they just take it so seriously.
- 37:08And they think that people can't be edited out of context or they think that, well, even if you were, you signed up for this.
- 37:15What are your thoughts on that?
- 37:16And you signed up for it too.
- 37:17We can take that separate, but to viewers out there who watch this stuff and think it's gospel.
- 37:22It is amazing that it's still that way, that viewers at home still have this idea that if Nick comes off the show and he was crying and upset about leaving Caitlyn, and then people automatically assume, oh, wow, what's wrong with that dude?
- 37:38Like, you know, have a backbone, figure it out.
- 37:40Like, yeah.
- 37:41the way you come off on television is not exactly who you are at all times.
- 37:45It's amazing to me that people still buy that or that's what they think, but that's what's fed to them.
- 37:51And by nature of us being so good at what we do and adding the beautiful music and the beautiful settings and the great editing to keep thoughts very concise and pointed towards a certain direction, it's inevitable that the viewer is going to take away what we feed them.
- 38:10They're going to say that's exactly who they are.
- 38:12Well, great, because we made it look like that's exactly who they are.
- 38:14You know, it's fascinating to me.
- 38:17But the reason reality television is so successful is because that conceit works and people still buy it.
- 38:24So if people stop buying it, you know, it might go away.
- 38:29So of course, the machine is going to feed that conceit as often as they can.
- 38:34Make them hate Nick.
- 38:35Make them love Michael.
- 38:37You know?
- 38:38And who cares if that's the real...
- 38:41person or not.
- 38:41Yeah.
- 38:42Yeah.
- 38:44The whole, even the whole escalation thing, which was the other thing I was going to mention a minute ago, when I had someone on my podcast named Matthew from last season of love is blind.
- 38:54And they edited him to make him look like he was walking out of the pods in the middle of dates and took footage of him just leaving at the end of dates.
- 39:03And they did that to a multiple times to the point.
- 39:06It looks like a dick that was leaving.
- 39:07Yeah.
- 39:08Yeah.
- 39:09And people were horrible to him online.
- 39:13And he, and he had since left and he has a new girlfriend.
- 39:16And like, he was telling me, he's like, I had to sit there like with my girlfriend who I love and who loves me and like, watch me be represented and hear people say how, how I'm like abusive and a serial killer and disrespectful of these women.
- 39:31And he's like, I was hated for something.
- 39:34the world saw me do that I never did.
- 39:37And it like sat with me at that moment.
- 39:38And I'm like, my God, like I had some stuff out of context, some stuff out of order, and you watch it back and I'm kind of like, well, that didn't happen that way.
- 39:45And then you're like, wait, did it?
- 39:46And there's like those things, but like to have something like that happen, I just can't even imagine because you don't even get a chance to speak about it.
- 39:54Yeah, well, to that point, that could have happened in two ways out of my head.
- 40:00One way is that, again, the machine is,
- 40:04is built in a way that everything is so compacted, a schedule and a budget that they might just need a way to get rid of him on camera quickly or to wrap that storyline in a, in a,
- 40:17cute little package let's move it on or it might have been an immoral producer on set or a combination of both but i am erring on the side that it's probably that i need my character to have an ending what's an ending that makes sense chicks are figuring him out because he's walking out on them you know what i mean yeah yeah so what's the most expeditious way to get this character out of my story
- 40:40Yeah, that's fair.
- 40:43And also, he didn't drink.
- 40:44He was, what do they call that?
- 40:48Living a sober life, right?
- 40:49He's living a sober life, so I know they didn't like that.
- 40:51But that's his story.
- 40:52That's a difficult character to produce, right?
- 40:54So it's going to make anyone who doesn't drink, doesn't lower their inhibitions.
- 40:57So it makes it more difficult for producers like myself to find ways in and manipulate them quickly.
- 41:05Honestly.
- 41:05So let's, let's talk about the, yeah, yeah, let's talk.
- 41:09And actually, so I picked up on it real quick when we were in the pods and we were there for 15 days.
- 41:15And I remember there was one day where I got a little tipsy and I was like, oh, I can see exactly how this goes wrong for a lot of people.
- 41:23And after that, I would do it like here and there with the guys or in on a date, I'd have some champagne, but like, I was very careful with my alcohol consumption after that
- 41:35You know, it's like if you're at the bar or something and that's, yeah, that four is now a nine because you've got the, you know, it's like that kind of mentality.
- 41:44And so I slowed down after that and I didn't get really more than like maybe slightly tipsy on camera.
- 41:50I still had my wits about me.
- 41:52But you call it the truth serum.
- 41:54That's alcohol.
- 41:55Yeah.
- 41:56First of all, brand that and sell it.
- 42:00You should brand that and sell it.
- 42:02And second of all, tell me your experience using the truth serum as alcohol and why it's used and how you used it and all of that fun stuff.
- 42:10Not so fun stuff.
- 42:11You will.
- 42:11Absolutely.
- 42:12I mean, we discovered it early on the bachelor at the at the rose ceremony, which is the first night when they meet the bachelor.
- 42:19It's a cocktail party.
- 42:20You know, that was sort of a conceit.
- 42:21Like what do people do at that age?
- 42:22They go to cocktail parties or they hang out and have cocktails.
- 42:25And then quickly we realized that the more liquored up people were, the more apt they are to show their emotions.
- 42:32Everything's escalated.
- 42:33And the more apt they are to lower their inhibitions and give us what we need and to say things they wouldn't normally say.
- 42:40So of course that's great for us.
- 42:41Let's go for that.
- 42:42You know, heightened animated versions of a character that we didn't
- 42:46that we liked already.
- 42:47So great, they're giving us even more.
- 42:49So alcohol is just readily available, especially on shows like The Bachelor.
- 42:53It's just, you know, if it's a house-type show, their fridge is fully stocked, as you realize on your show.
- 42:59And it's just because...
- 43:01Even if you're not on a date or on a challenge or being in a pod, you still have to be on camera.
- 43:07We're showing the difference between what you're doing and what someone else is doing at this point.
- 43:11So if you're having drinks and being more animated than you normally would be, then all the better for us.
- 43:16So let's keep it readily available.
- 43:20And there'd be times where we'd have a boring cast or have something not happening.
- 43:24So we'd shut the cameras down.
- 43:27Hey, everybody and producers will come in because we're all friends.
- 43:29Let's have a shot.
- 43:30What's up?
- 43:31We'll turn on some music real quick and jam out.
- 43:33Have a shot.
- 43:34Camera's back in.
- 43:35Producers back out.
- 43:37Let's just pump up the party.
- 43:39Like, you've just got to fuel the machine, and alcohol was a great way to do it.
- 43:43And plus, alcohol was the greatest way to get tears out of a girl at the end of The Bachelor, especially when she was eliminated.
- 43:49If you got a girl that's a little tipsy, she's a little more apt to have her emotions come to the surface quickly.
- 43:55And you needed that, especially if you had five girls leaving, you need to interview each of them before the sun comes up.
- 44:01So make sure they're liquored up before you get them out or give them a drink right when they're eliminated and have them get to where you want them.
- 44:09Again, the machine wants the production to move and the budget doesn't afford you another day of filming.
- 44:15Let's keep going.
- 44:17Nor does it afford good alcohol, at least in my experience.
- 44:21Well, it does afford it, but they're never going to buy it, right?
- 44:26Exactly.
- 44:27Exactly.
- 44:28Big plastic handles from Costco were the norm.
- 44:32Oh, my goodness.
- 44:33We had El Jimador tequila, which, you know,
- 44:37Not what I would choose.
- 44:38Not what I would choose.
- 44:41Well, maybe I used to choose it when I was younger and couldn't afford anything better.
- 44:44But now it's like, that is brutal.
- 44:47Yeah, but cast members, if that's what's there and that's it, bring it on.
- 44:51Right?
- 44:52It's not like you're saying, no, I'm waiting for Patron.
- 44:55No, it's not happening.
- 44:55Yeah.
- 44:57So what is, uh, one of the things that I've, I've heard you also mentioned before is producing versus editing.
- 45:04And I think what's interesting and I, cause I don't know, I mean, I, I think like, you know, I only have my experience when I've heard from others, but like producers are trying to produce a story, but once it goes to editing, what happens is, is your story produced?
- 45:16Is it sometimes completely different than expected or is there any say or control or communication between the two parties?
- 45:22Yeah.
- 45:24Absolutely.
- 45:25So during filming at the beginning, when we first started doing The Bachelor, producers did everything.
- 45:32So my job would be to create the date, expedite the date by planning it.
- 45:38I got to book a helicopter.
- 45:39I got to book the Hollywood Bowl.
- 45:40I got to make sure that someone's performing.
- 45:43whatever, I would go on the date, I would interview them at the same time, and then that would all go back to editing.
- 45:49As TV moved on, as reality television moved on and got more successful, they started compartmentalizing these positions.
- 45:56So now there's always a story producer on set, either interviewing the cast or sitting in the control room, watching the cast be interviewed or interact just in a regular scene.
- 46:07And those would be, that's, that's sort of
- 46:09producers taking notes for the edit.
- 46:11And it's highlighting hot buttons, hot moments, things that they like and don't.
- 46:16They can highlight it real quick.
- 46:18So then when it goes to the edit with that tape, it's easy for an editor to go, this is cool moment, this isn't.
- 46:23You're easily transcribing and looking at that footage.
- 46:26At the beginning, they had transcribers.
- 46:28They would sit and watch every moment of film that ever happened.
- 46:31So there was a whole bay of like four people that were always when you'd walk by just watching every moment of tape that was ever shot.
- 46:39So now it's in a place where you've got people editing it as they're watching it.
- 46:44So, and those are the people just sitting in the room.
- 46:46They might not be editors on an Avid machine or something that has the software, but they're just going, oop, highlight, love that, cool moment, feasible moment, super teased moment.
- 46:55Like, all these things are happening so that when me as an editor, I get that information, I just only look at those moments.
- 47:01So, you're not actually siphling through the hours and hours of footage.
- 47:04Absolutely not.
- 47:05And then story producers, as they come out of the field and go to the edit, story producers sit in front of an Avid and cut scenes themselves.
- 47:13So they'll take those moments that they've highlighted and written down as teasable cool moments or fun story arc moments, the beginning, middle and end, and they'll cut it quickly themselves.
- 47:23and then hand it off to an editor to polish and finish and make cool.
- 47:28And then it's like, you've got two parties making the edits.
- 47:31You have story producers who know the story because they were there or have been fed the information via hot sheet that has been transcribed every day about what moments were great on, on camera that day.
- 47:41Or they were there and watched it and typed it themselves.
- 47:45And that's just going straight to editors.
- 47:47Editors now have become a little less hands-on or creative than they used to be because they're just polishing and making things pretty.
- 47:53And if they need a moment, they'll search for it.
- 47:55But they'll often just ask a story producer that's sitting down the hall to find that moment for them.
- 48:00And now technology's in a place where it's like, I need Nick saying, I'm so fucking over this.
- 48:06So I can just type in under Nick's...
- 48:09you know, bucket or Nick's file over this.
- 48:14And I could find any moment you might've said that.
- 48:16Boom.
- 48:16There's that scene.
- 48:17I probably said that a lot actually.
- 48:19Yeah.
- 48:21Or that it was that, or I'm not fucking doing this.
- 48:24Yeah.
- 48:25But I need to make it say, I can't wait to do this.
- 48:29as opposed to I'm fucking never doing this.
- 48:31So let's say I need, I can't wait and I need not fucking doing this or to make my Franken bit moment.
- 48:38Those things happen so quickly now.
- 48:41Can you tell everyone- Back in the day you'd have to literally go through beta tapes and go splice, splice, make it.
- 48:47Now it's digital, boop, boop, boop.
- 48:49I can match the voice and I can't imagine what AI is gonna do to this business.
- 48:53Well, I can tell you, Michael, this Riverside that we use to record, I shouldn't say the name because it's free advertising, but where we're recording, they actually have an AI voice right now.
- 49:03They'll go into a video and they'll take my voice and then I can copy in a script and it'll record my voice using AI.
- 49:10It's like 95% how I sound.
- 49:13It doesn't get all the inflections right.
- 49:15But if I put a long and I tried it with like a LinkedIn post that I wrote, I put it in there and I listened to it.
- 49:21I'm like, this sounds like me, except it's a little off on some of the inflections.
- 49:26So they can definitely do that.
- 49:29That's unbelievable.
- 49:30But imagine that if you're, you know, next year, a contestant on Love is Blind and they want a Franken bit moment.
- 49:36they can almost create it with AI.
- 49:39They can't create something you haven't said so, but the AI can search all of the data they have of Nick speaking inside of a computer or in a database and go, boop, let's just make a new conversation.
- 49:50It's easy.
- 49:51It can happen in a moment, where it's like you used to have an editor doing it for a week.
- 49:55I need Nick to say all these things.
- 49:57Now it's like, boop, boop, boop, boop, here you go.
- 50:00And then as an audience member, if it's like a line or two, they wouldn't notice the inflection difference because they don't know me very well.
- 50:07Right.
- 50:07But like someone who knows me and how I talk and stuff or myself would know what those are.
- 50:10That's that's crazy.
- 50:12I do like I worry about AI, but we don't have to get into that.
- 50:15I know.
- 50:16But to watch for Frankenbites as a reality TV fan, the astute reality TV fans know that if they cut away from Nick's thing,
- 50:26and you still hear him talking, that might not be exactly what he said or that might not be when he said it.
- 50:32But with AI and things coming and technology, there's going to be ways to make your mouth move and make it look like you're saying it on camera.
- 50:39It's going to be crazy.
- 50:41They own your image and your words, so they can't make you say something you haven't.
- 50:46and put that in your mouth.
- 50:48But if you said it, they can piece it together and make it.
- 50:50So it's fine.
- 50:51Yeah.
- 50:51It's crazy.
- 50:52That's so crazy.
- 50:53Well, this is a good place to bring up the, you signed up for it, which you mentioned a little bit earlier.
- 50:59So, you know, I get that a lot and I'm not going to preach.
- 51:03You know, I think there are,
- 51:06There are things you do sign up for, but until you go through it and experience it yourself, you don't really know what you signed up for.
- 51:11And there's a lot of reasons behind that, including like the manufactured environment.
- 51:15You don't know that you're going to be stuck in a hotel room for days at a time that you can't leave.
- 51:20You don't know what it's going to be like without the normal structure of your life and being able to take walks.
- 51:25And no phone and no contact and everything.
- 51:28Yeah, exactly.
- 51:29Exactly.
- 51:29So what do you what do you think about people who who speak out and say I was wrong or I was misedited or misrepresented and then people that say well you signed up for it.
- 51:43Yeah, I've left the business for the most part.
- 51:47I still do things like this, and I still like being involved, but I don't produce as a profession.
- 51:52So having left the business, I have a lot more compassion for the cast members, and especially the types of shows that I went through, because I know how specifically manipulative it can be.
- 52:04So now I'm way more or less apt to say, sorry, you signed up for it, because it is, like you said, a whole new world that they're not used to.
- 52:13And it should be a little more transparent for them going in because it's a lot.
- 52:24But that being said, if I was producing television right now, I might have a completely different opinion because I know what I've got to get in four weeks.
- 52:31And under the budget, I have to get it.
- 52:32So do I have the time to walk these people through this and.
- 52:37Give them a moment when they arrive to show them how things are going to go.
- 52:40And like even that amount of time is eating into my budget and my schedule.
- 52:45So to have a psychologist on set and to have all of these things that would help creates a budget model that might not work.
- 52:54So that's a difficult animal.
- 52:55But no, you signed up for it.
- 52:57It's not something I would often say anymore because it is.
- 53:02member on these shows and it's rough you know sometimes this of course the majority of the time it's an amazing experience and people it's something the majority of the country doesn't and the world doesn't get to do so yay for you but the people that have a hard time coming out of it it's really difficult for me to say you signed up for it sorry you got screwed buddy you know fuck off yeah it's just like guys like matthew
- 53:24Yeah, that's rough.
- 53:25I mean, that's just awful to do to someone.
- 53:28So I think going forward, in order for this to make – for there to be a difference to where it's not that we use the cast as props and just as someone on set to achieve our ending or our finished product, they need to be hired as employees, A –
- 53:49Because that's going to regulate their time commitment, which is great because it's going to make it a little more sane for them to...
- 53:57you know, exist on a set and not be abused.
- 54:01That would be probably the first thing I would do if I was revising the system.
- 54:05And then transparency as far as what you're, because if you have that in place, if you're an employee, you've got to be transparent with what your work requirements are.
- 54:12And that would say, you're not sleeping for, and only, you only get four hours to sleep this night.
- 54:18Great.
- 54:18I know that, but I'm getting OT because I'm going to 2am because I'm on a date at the Hollywood Bowl.
- 54:24next morning I have to go on a second date at 6am because it's a hot air balloon.
- 54:27This is a schedule-based thing, but I know this and I'm being, you know, rewarded and paid for it.
- 54:33So those things could be laid out.
- 54:35It'd be like a syllabus of your job description if you went to work for entrance company A, you know?
- 54:41I think that's probably the best thing moving forward now just to start the process of not abusing cast members.
- 54:48I completely agree.
- 54:49And one of the first things I did once we started the UCAN Foundation was file a charge for myself with the National Labor Relations Board to try and get that classification changed from contractor, which is what they're able to sort of hide behind and do that, get that change to employee.
- 55:07So we do get to talk about working conditions.
- 55:09One, obviously you said wages, overtime, all of that stuff.
- 55:12The other cool thing is,
- 55:14that where I kind of realized there was something here was when they issued me a W-2 for telling me or for my tax purposes after telling me in my contract that I'm a contractor.
- 55:28And when I kind of put that together, I'm like,
- 55:31Huh.
- 55:31And the reason I think that they did that was because we spent so much time in California and under California labor law, the amount of time we spent in California, the amount of hours that we were filming slash working, we would be legally by the government considered employees.
- 55:45So I think they were kind of like, and I don't know for sure, but like playing out of both sides, like because we did this in California, you're a California employee.
- 55:53We got to give you the W-2, but we're going to have you sign a contract that says you're a contractor.
- 55:57and hope that the two don't ever match.
- 55:58And what we'll do is renew you weekly so it looks like you're an independent contractor that's not involved for this amount of time.
- 56:05But collectively you are, yeah.
- 56:07And it confused my accountant too, because when I first gave her this, she's like, wait, you worked in California for a time too?
- 56:14And I was like, no, I didn't.
- 56:15I had some contractor work out there.
- 56:17And she was like, well, then you wouldn't have got a W-2.
- 56:19And then when I kind of started doing this, I was like, oh, that's where I figured it out.
- 56:23Thank you to my accountant.
- 56:25Yeah, because if you're there the whole time and if you're a successful character and you're being brought back, your collective time on television is enough to make you an employee.
- 56:33But they don't want to pay you for that initially, of course.
- 56:36But the other problem with this whole scenario of let's start paying cast members, making them employees and giving them rights is that the producers of these shows often do not have those same things.
- 56:47So why is me as a producer should, as an independent contractor and as a gig employee, should I be concerned about making cast members, employees of a TV show when I'm not one myself?
- 56:58Well, and I wouldn't, as I've said to the producers who have said that to me, I'm like, I am happy to join you in becoming employees and getting your rights as well.
- 57:07Because I think that's totally, it's an unfair balance of power.
- 57:11You switch it from one unbalanced of power to the other.
- 57:13And that's not a way either.
- 57:15Yeah.
- 57:16Yeah, the producers of Reality Television need to be signed into a guild like the Producers Guild.
- 57:21We've never been allowed in.
- 57:23So until that happens, that would be, you know, it trickling down to cast members is not going to happen.
- 57:28So the first step would probably be now thinking about it.
- 57:31Put Reality Television as make that a compartment of the Producers Guild.
- 57:37Then we have rights, you know.
- 57:39Then again, that's going to make the whole business model tricky because it's going to make us have more rights to negotiate.
- 57:45Less time on set.
- 57:46All the things that we have now that we're required to do because we're just independent contractors.
- 57:51We can't bitch too much.
- 57:53We don't have a union looking over us and monitoring us.
- 57:56It's going to make the business model that much more difficult because...
- 58:00It takes time and money to do all these things and make things right.
- 58:04So it's a tricky one.
- 58:06You can speak better to this than I can, but with the producers that I know, they're always like hustling for that next gig.
- 58:13It's not like they're sitting around saying like, oh, let's figure out how we can form a union or something like that.
- 58:19Because you're basically gig workers in the entertainment industry.
- 58:23Yeah, I was a gig worker for 22 years.
- 58:26I was never, the only time I was hired as an employee of a TV show for longer than three months was when I was in talk television for Tyra Banks.
- 58:36I was hired for the year.
- 58:38But that was two years out of 22.
- 58:41So every job I did, I was always thinking.
- 58:43And towards the end of the show, you start thinking about, hey, what are you doing next?
- 58:46And you start shaking your moneymaker looking for your next gig.
- 58:50Yeah, there's not a lot of time to sit around because you're on unemployment or not making money in between shows.
- 58:55You're like hungry to get your next one.
- 58:56It's not like, let me go march for the union.
- 58:59Yeah, the reality TV producers union.
- 59:03Yeah.
- 59:03Can I get all y'all to come out here and march with me on Hollywood?
- 59:07Probably not happening.
- 59:08Yeah, so it's a rough one.
- 59:10But we'll see if that happens.
- 59:11I hope it does.
- 59:13Maybe we'll do that next.
- 59:15I've got that and then people telling me you should go unionize WWE wrestlers.
- 59:18And I'm like, guys, let me finish this job.
- 59:21I'm good.
- 59:21I'm going to let them handle that themselves.
- 59:24So you mentioned this already.
- 59:26Yeah, exactly.
- 59:27You mentioned this already, but you left reality TV.
- 59:30And before we finish up and I give you a chance to ask me anything.
- 59:33I just want to get your exit story.
- 59:35Why did you decide to leave reality TV?
- 59:38Do you ever see yourself?
- 59:39Well, you're probably never going to be able to go back because now you speak about it so openly.
- 59:43But, you know, how do you- I can probably consult on television shows.
- 59:49They wouldn't have me on a set per se, yeah.
- 59:51Yeah, yeah.
- 59:53So what made you leave and what are you doing now?
- 59:57I loved my career in reality television.
- 59:59I had a blast to be a kid from the South.
- 1:00:03from a small town to make it to Hollywood and do big things was great.
- 1:00:06And I got to make a mark in entertainment.
- 1:00:08It's like, you know, it's a dream.
- 1:00:09It was great.
- 1:00:10It was amazing.
- 1:00:10I got to travel the world and do cool things and be cool people.
- 1:00:13I did all this stuff.
- 1:00:14But I didn't realize until COVID happened, which changed a lot of people's mind about a lot of things, made a lot of us very introspective about what we were doing and what we want to accomplish.
- 1:00:25Having slowed down from a crazy career, like being a reality television producer, once you slow down from something like that and sit around for a year in your house in L.A., it made me go, oh, like I just went, oh, it's like when the roller coaster comes to the end and the brakes come on and you go, wow, that was a lot.
- 1:00:44It just made me not want to go back to it, if that makes any sense.
- 1:00:47You can work 60 hours a week and travel every other week to who knows where and have a blast and keep doing that and sleep for four hours a night.
- 1:00:55But once you slow down from that, you you can't do it anymore.
- 1:00:59You can't you can't fathom going back to it.
- 1:01:01And then I also realized in the year of sitting home during COVID and not working in reality television that I got to see my friends and family and have a relationship and do things that normal people do.
- 1:01:11It was almost impossible to do that the 20 years that I was, you know, working.
- 1:01:15My friends were at work.
- 1:01:16My friends were cast members and producers, you know, like that was it.
- 1:01:21You couldn't see anyone do anything and have a real life.
- 1:01:23So slowing down from it made me not want to go back.
- 1:01:26And when I went back and did one show after COVID, I said, I think I've had enough.
- 1:01:30So it just changed life, you know, and there's people, luckily, I feel like that I made the right choice.
- 1:01:35And mine was purely based on wanting to live a better, more peaceful life and not be so stressed and not chase the dragon anymore.
- 1:01:43But I think I got out at the right time because the reality television model is changing so quickly, especially because of streaming, that it's just a really difficult, you know, niche to be in at this point.
- 1:01:56It's really rough.
- 1:01:57It's hard to work right now.
- 1:01:59Yeah, I remember we chatted about that briefly.
- 1:02:01And I guess one last follow up, like how how has it changed from your perspective, having lived it and now looking at it?
- 1:02:08How has it changed?
- 1:02:11The reality television model has changed in such a huge way that I don't even know how to address how it changed.
- 1:02:17But the only thing that I know basically from speaking to people I worked with and looking
- 1:02:24people I know looking for work is that streaming came about way too quickly.
- 1:02:29The, the model of streaming chain is changing entertainment in such a big way in content creation in general, that reality television was not thought out well enough about in the way of how that fits into the model.
- 1:02:43Um, uh, streaming services are only paying for big temples.
- 1:02:46They know that can work because it's a sub.
- 1:02:49That's a very sub part of their budget.
- 1:02:52They haven't thought out how to make their budget work with new content in reality.
- 1:02:55So there's not a lot of tiny little shows happening anymore.
- 1:02:57There's Love is Blind, there's Survivor, there's The Traitors.
- 1:03:01There's these big ones now, but Netflix is not really going to go, let's make a show about Nick and Michael talking about stuff in the woods.
- 1:03:07Like that's not going to happen, you know?
- 1:03:09So it's just creating and it's getting rid of small cable channels like Lifetime, Style.
- 1:03:15All of these are drifting away because everyone's, you know, coming together, making big, huge streaming networks and all those small channels are just going away.
- 1:03:25So that makes content creation more limited, you know, so it's rough.
- 1:03:31And it's like universes.
- 1:03:32Like you've got the Bachelor universe.
- 1:03:34You've got the Netflix universe.
- 1:03:36You've got the 90 Day Fiance universe to survive.
- 1:03:39It's like, yeah, they're just kind of like taking these tentpole brands and just making new shows on those.
- 1:03:44Yeah, because it's brand recognition and it gets a lot of traction in social media, which has taken over too.
- 1:03:50So it's social media having changed over 20 years and also streaming taking over the entertainment business.
- 1:03:56That's really compartmentalized what successful reality TV is.
- 1:04:01Not successfully creative, but successfully in the world of financial world.
- 1:04:07So it's a rough one now.
- 1:04:09I'm kind of glad I got out of time.
- 1:04:11Good, good.
- 1:04:12Well, I'm, I'm glad that you did too.
- 1:04:15Um, so I appreciate you taking this time, but before we go, I like to give people a chance to ask me anything.
- 1:04:22So I'll turn it over to you.
- 1:04:24And I'm a little nervous about this one.
- 1:04:29What, what show would you do?
- 1:04:34What reality show would you be?
- 1:04:37Would you do if they asked you to
- 1:04:41Oh my goodness.
- 1:04:42You know, it's kind of funny because up until how everything played out, it would probably have been, like if I hadn't had the experience, probably would have been Love is Blind because, like, I kind of think the concept is a good concept.
- 1:04:54And I think there's so many things that are good about it and so many things that help combat the struggles of dating nowadays where you do get to, like, focus.
- 1:05:03You get to take the time to get to know someone, all of that kind of stuff.
- 1:05:07But otherwise, I would probably –
- 1:05:10I don't know if this is more of a competition, but there was the floor is lava on Netflix.
- 1:05:15I really wanted to do that because I used to play that as a kid.
- 1:05:19But if I was blind to everything, I would say I would probably want to do a dating show.
- 1:05:26I don't really know which one.
- 1:05:28It wouldn't be like a married at first sight.
- 1:05:30It wouldn't be, it may be like something like the bachelor, even though I know it's a shit show.
- 1:05:36So it's like hard to say, but I would also do a competition show.
- 1:05:40It's very narrowly focused.
- 1:05:41It's the bachelors that you date people, you either pick or you don't.
- 1:05:45Exactly.
- 1:05:46And that's why it's so successful.
- 1:05:48It's the pitch in the room is very easy.
- 1:05:51One dude dates 25 chicks, he picks one at the end.
- 1:05:53One chick dates 25 dudes, one wins.
- 1:05:56That's it.
- 1:05:57There's no all, and then they're in a pod, then they have to go here and there, you know, all these things, it's crazy.
- 1:06:02Yeah, I would, if I had to be on any reality show right now, I would be on the traitors.
- 1:06:08I've never, I haven't watched it, but everyone talks about it.
- 1:06:11It is so good.
- 1:06:12And knowing, knowing how to produce television, I just think I'd be really good at it because I see people, but the cast members also seem from my perspective to have a really easy time because at night they, they go to bed off camera.
- 1:06:25So I'm like, that sounds great.
- 1:06:27You're not following them to bed.
- 1:06:29They go to the castle and you never see them again till morning.
- 1:06:31So I'm like, at least they get to have their own time.
- 1:06:33So that sounds nice.
- 1:06:35My last question for you, though, would be Kamala or Trump?
- 1:06:41Oh, God, please don't.
- 1:06:43I can't.
- 1:06:44I'm like, I can't stand either of them.
- 1:06:50You know, I'm lucky.
- 1:06:51I'm lucky I'm in Illinois where it's going to go blue and I can do, I can really vote for whoever I want.
- 1:06:56You can just ride, ride that wave.
- 1:06:58Right.
- 1:06:58Yeah, exactly.
- 1:06:59And I'm actually very partial.
- 1:07:01Cause I had, I had Jill Stein as a guest on from the green party and she was so nice.
- 1:07:06And I was just like, she is the U S is grandma and she's kind of a hippie grandma and we should listen to her.
- 1:07:13And she's, you know, and it's like, man, man,
- 1:07:17put her and Bernie in the room and see what happens oh god well yeah I was a big Bernie supporter and despite what you might read on the internet that there's some people that think I'm like a hardcore alt-right MAGA there's definitely there's definitely like I I loved Bernie in 2016 and 2020 and I worked on his campaign and but yeah but it's going to be a wild one I know but stay tuned well I'm sure we'll all be watching the election talking about it again before it happens
- 1:07:44All right.
- 1:07:45Well, this was fun.
- 1:07:46Anything else for me?
- 1:07:48Is there any social media or anything you want to share for the audience if they want to connect with you?
- 1:07:52Yeah.
- 1:07:53My Instagram's at the Michael Carroll.
- 1:07:55Two R's, two L's.
- 1:07:56All right.
- 1:07:57That's awesome.
- 1:07:57We'll put that link down here in the show notes.
- 1:08:00And again, thank you so much for doing this.
- 1:08:01I really appreciate it.
- 1:08:02Hey, Nick.
- 1:08:03It was great.
- 1:08:08Thank you for joining us on this week's episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 1:08:11If you enjoy the show, the best way to support us is by sharing or dropping a review.
- 1:08:15For more information and content, check out engagewithnick.com or find me on Instagram at nthompson513.
- 1:08:23Don't go through life blind.
- 1:08:25Do the work so you can show up in the world with your eyes wide open.