Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Broadway Melody (1929)
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hey everyone,
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:40The podcast that takes you from every Best Picture
- 0:43nominee from 1927 to today. I'm your host Kyle.
- 0:46And I am Ryan. And you almost nailed it. Oh,
- 0:49where did I miss? It's the show that takes you.
- 0:52No! And I guess it doesn't really matter, but
- 0:56I think show allows it so like, if we ever do
- 1:00go video. That's true. We don't have to completely
- 1:02rebrand. Yeah, you're right. It would be a show.
- 1:06That makes sense. That was a joke. We wouldn't
- 1:08have to rebrand. That's fine. We're going to
- 1:10redo this anyways. Oh, okay. This doesn't go
- 1:12live. You're right. You're right. But hey, welcome
- 1:15back, everybody, to the... What is this? The
- 1:17second movie of... Third. Oh, yeah. Technically
- 1:20third. Yeah. If you count our Patriot Lost Media
- 1:23episode. Yep. Pretty excited today for this one.
- 1:26It's... It is a musical, and it's not just a
- 1:30musical. It's actually pretty historic. It's
- 1:33the first all -talk musical that was produced
- 1:36by Hollywood. Which is so wild to think about,
- 1:40musicals coming out that weren't all -talk. You
- 1:44know, I said something to you. I can't remember
- 1:47if it was off or on podcast, but there's something
- 1:50about the indomitable human spirit to where studios,
- 1:53producers alike... heard hey we can start making
- 1:57talkies now they're like that's amazing well
- 1:59what do you guys want to do first we should do
- 2:01outdoor westerns and musicals yeah that's insane
- 2:06it is so ambitious extremely ambitious and you
- 2:10know i think it pays off sometimes and i think
- 2:13it doesn't pay off in others um we'll we'll talk
- 2:15about that and i mean that kind of across the
- 2:17board right we talked about in old arizona how
- 2:20any outdoor scenes looked incredible but sounded
- 2:24very poor because they couldn't just keep the
- 2:26microphone above them at all times when they're
- 2:28running around. Right. So amazing that it was
- 2:31on location, but not the optimal experience for
- 2:35the first time that a camera is being used or
- 2:37a microphone. I keep doing that. So the musical,
- 2:39it's a similar situation. We'll get into how
- 2:42we thought it fared with this. But specifically,
- 2:44we should probably talk about the movie itself.
- 2:46I realize we haven't said the name yet. So we're
- 2:48talking about The Broadway Melody. Right. Which
- 2:51you can also find by the name of The Broadway
- 2:53Melody of 1929. Do you know why that is, Kyle?
- 2:56Yeah. There were three sequels after this one.
- 2:59So I don't know if originally it was The Broadway
- 3:02Melody of 1929. Maybe it was because they anticipated
- 3:05doing more. But there's the Broadway Melody of
- 3:081929, 1936, 1938, and 1940. Well, and here's
- 3:13my point. This isn't like us saying, you know,
- 3:16this is the Running Man of 1982 or whatever it
- 3:19was and the Running Man of 2025. That's the name.
- 3:22That's the title. Right. The Broadway Melody
- 3:25of 1929 and proper for the others. So I'm just
- 3:29confused. I feel like it could have just been,
- 3:32you know, Broadway Melody remade, but just continue
- 3:34that. Okay. I haven't seen the other, so I don't
- 3:36know if that continues the story or if it's just
- 3:38a full remake. Yeah, I honestly don't know. It'd
- 3:41be weird if they were remaking the same movie
- 3:44that frequently. Yeah. Like those three sequels
- 3:47are all two years apart. Right. So. Is the Broadway
- 3:50Melody changing that much? Yeah. No, I have no
- 3:54idea. So this is our first true musical that
- 3:59we've covered on the show. Yeah. Really, it's
- 4:01our first musical in general. That's true. All
- 4:04talky, at least. All talking. Was there a musical
- 4:07we covered that... Oh, that we covered. No, I'm
- 4:09sorry. I meant in general. But that we covered?
- 4:11No. But let's talk cast and crew. Yeah. So the
- 4:14Broadway Melody of 1929 was directed by Harry
- 4:17Beaumont, and it starred Bessie Love as Hank
- 4:20Mahoney, Anita Page as her sister, Queenie Mahoney,
- 4:23and Charles King as Eddie Kearns. Let's go back
- 4:26to Bessie for a second. Let's, please. Hank is
- 4:29her name. There is this sibling dynamic that's
- 4:33introduced pretty early on between the sisters.
- 4:36That would be Queenie and Hank. And it's established
- 4:39pretty quickly that Queenie is the brains of
- 4:42the operation. She has a lot of talent, and she's
- 4:45the brains. You got it backwards. Oh, you're
- 4:48so right. I do have it backwards. Sorry, I was
- 4:49going off the names. So Hank is the brains of
- 4:52the operation, right? She is very talented. She
- 4:57knows what she's doing. She kind of heads up
- 4:58operations. Queenie, per Hank's description,
- 5:02is very lucky that she's so pretty, right? So
- 5:06she just is kind of there. It bums me out that
- 5:10her parents, either their parents, would look
- 5:14at them and be like, oh, she's such a queenie.
- 5:16And then look at the other one and be like, Hank,
- 5:18I guess. And in our research, it didn't come
- 5:22clear in the movie. They may have said and I
- 5:24may have missed it, which is very easy to do
- 5:26with these microphones that aren't picking up
- 5:28everything. They have her name as Harriet. And
- 5:32you and I even discussed, if it was Henrietta,
- 5:34maybe we could pick up Hank from that. Right.
- 5:36But from Harriet, I'm not really getting Hank.
- 5:39Maybe that was an of -its -time thing. Yeah,
- 5:41I have no idea. That being said, I like Hank
- 5:46as a girl's name. Well, she has the spirit of
- 5:50a Hank. Yeah. Right? Of just kind of like, let
- 5:53me at him. type of personality. So she is a Hank
- 5:56in that regard. I just don't think that her parents
- 5:59saw her having, like, a very strong -willed personality
- 6:02and be like, oh, that's a Hank. Yeah. Like, imagine
- 6:05me doing that to my kid, and, like, she's three,
- 6:07and I see her have, like, a feisty spirit, and
- 6:09I'm like, we're changing her name to, like, Edward.
- 6:11Right. We're gonna do something that has a little
- 6:13bit of fire behind it. Yeah. Yeah, I don't know.
- 6:16It's... But the name definitely fits the character,
- 6:20because, like you said, she's got that fire.
- 6:22She's... constantly throwing out some pretty
- 6:25solid one -liners whenever she gets into an argument
- 6:28with either Queenie or Eddie or the other girl
- 6:33that is like the whole movie trying to sabotage
- 6:36their performance. Yep. She's great. She's a
- 6:39lot of fun. Very much a Hank. Very much a Hank.
- 6:42Of course, those two are paired with Eddie, Eddie
- 6:45Kearns, who is a Hollywood, well, Broadway, rather,
- 6:50a Broadway writer. Yes. Musician, performer,
- 6:54all of the above? All of the above. Yep. And
- 6:57in the movie specifically, he has written a piece
- 7:00called The Broadway Melody, and he has sold it
- 7:04to Zenfield. Zenfield. So Zenfield is a producer
- 7:09who puts on these plays, the musicals. And that's
- 7:13going to happen. Broadway melody is a surefire
- 7:15thing. And he's bringing in the sisters, appropriately,
- 7:18Hank and Queenie, to perform in it. Because he's
- 7:21known them for so long, and he has kind of a
- 7:23thing going with Hank. Right, right. That's the
- 7:25plot of the movie. That's it. The end. That's
- 7:28it. There's not a whole lot of substance here.
- 7:31There's some, like, love triangle drama. Shout
- 7:34out to Wings, the OG love triangle. Well, they
- 7:37try to do a love square here. Oh. Wait, who's
- 7:40the fourth one? Jacques. Why do I have no memory
- 7:43of Jacques? Oh, that's Queenie's. Yes. Yes. Wow.
- 7:47How could I forget Jacques? He's awful. It's
- 7:50not a square like traditionally, but there are
- 7:55like four love interests kind of like thrown
- 7:56around in here. So do you want to talk about
- 8:00the love interest for a minute? Yeah, let's do
- 8:02that. So the love interest for me was confusing
- 8:04because I kind of got from the very beginning
- 8:06that Eddie and Hank were very much, you know.
- 8:11Hey, we're interested. Wouldn't it be cool if
- 8:12we made this thing happen? It wasn't established
- 8:14like, this is my girl. Like, it was just kind
- 8:16of like, yeah, okay, here she is. And he kisses
- 8:18her. But then he kisses Queenie the same way.
- 8:21So at that point, it's a customary thing, right?
- 8:24So then there starts to be some like, you know,
- 8:26wow, I haven't seen Queen in a very long time.
- 8:28Wow, she's grown up. She's beautiful. So you
- 8:30start seeing that, like, you know, spread there.
- 8:32And then throughout the rest of the movie, it
- 8:34seems like Hank and Eddie's connection is mostly
- 8:38out of just obligation. Yeah. Like, we said we'd
- 8:42do this, so we should, right? Like, that's kind
- 8:45of it. That, to me, was just absolutely, there
- 8:48was devoid drama for me, where I was like, you're
- 8:51picking Queenie. What are we doing? Like, if
- 8:53you guys had chemistry and, like, I could see
- 8:55why you're together, totally. That was never
- 8:57apparent to me. I don't know. How'd you feel
- 8:59about that? Yeah, I think that their relationship,
- 9:02Hank and Eddie's, feels business -related in
- 9:05a way. She probably... Well, I don't want to
- 9:08assume anything, but it seems like maybe she
- 9:10got close because he was a name that could get
- 9:13her onto the stage, and now they've just kind
- 9:16of hung on to that. And I think the reason for
- 9:19that was to allow for this love triangle, love
- 9:23square, and add this drama, but make it in a
- 9:27way where by the end of the movie, regardless
- 9:29of how things turned out, everything would work
- 9:32out and the three would still be... comfortable
- 9:34with each other because it was never that serious
- 9:36of a relationship. Right. Well, the other thing
- 9:40that we're not mentioning is that this is all
- 9:41happening in New York when the girls have had
- 9:45their uncle Jed, who's played by an actor named
- 9:48Jed, who has told them that he's secured, what,
- 9:5230? 300? Like, it was either 30 or 300 shows
- 9:56that he's lined up for them. Right. And it's
- 9:58ready to go, presumably in California, Hollywood.
- 10:02And they said, nope. We've done this all just
- 10:04so we can get out to New York and make it big
- 10:07here on Broadway. And Eddie is going to be our
- 10:09ticket to do that. And I think you're right.
- 10:11I think Hank sees Eddie a little bit more as
- 10:13that ticket. And Queenie is more like, look at
- 10:15how nice of him to help us out. Yeah. Right.
- 10:18So that's why I think for me, I never really
- 10:19pitched the whole. I never put much weight into
- 10:22the relationship between Hank and Eddie. Yeah.
- 10:25And like I said, I think that's to kind of let
- 10:28you down easy at the end and be like, everybody's
- 10:31happy. It was a happy ending. And I don't feel
- 10:33completely... It does not feel like everyone
- 10:36got the fair share. No, no, it definitely doesn't.
- 10:39But I think it's a happier ending than... I think
- 10:43it's like an old Hollywood happy ending. Yeah,
- 10:46where like everyone could be happy. Yeah, and
- 10:48everybody, all of your main characters are in
- 10:51the same room together at the end. Yeah, that's
- 10:54fair. So... Let's talk about the awards side
- 10:58of this, what it was nominated for. So specifically,
- 11:01it was nominated for Outstanding Best Picture,
- 11:03well, Outstanding Picture, Best Director, which
- 11:06was Harry Beaumont, as you mentioned, and then
- 11:08Best Actress. Do you have any kind of surprise
- 11:10as to which actress was nominated for this? No.
- 11:14So it was Bessie Love. So Bessie was nominated
- 11:17for her portrayal as Hank, which is interesting
- 11:20because I kind of think it's a little bit more
- 11:22Queenie's movie than it is Hank's. Okay. Right?
- 11:25Queenie is kind of like the morality of the movie.
- 11:27She's the one who, when her sister kind of blows
- 11:30the opportunity that they have with Zanfield,
- 11:31she goes in and makes the deal of, well, hey,
- 11:34hire both of us under my salary. And he's like,
- 11:38well, I can't turn that down. And she's the one
- 11:40who's kind of like trying to make her sister
- 11:41happy and then ultimately has to try and find
- 11:43a way to make herself happy. And she's the one
- 11:45who ends up with Eddie. So to me, it kind of
- 11:47feels like in terms of lead actress, she's up
- 11:50there. A little bit more than Hank. So I was
- 11:52a little surprised to see that nomination -wise,
- 11:54Bessie Love has that nomination. Yeah, but I
- 11:57think it's definitely a movie where you have
- 11:59two leads, two lead actresses. And that being
- 12:02said, when it comes to the actual performance,
- 12:05even though it kind of follows Queenie's story
- 12:07more, Anita Page's story, Bessie Love really
- 12:12puts on a solid performance at very specific
- 12:15points of this movie. Yeah. I mean, you're right.
- 12:18The Oscar, not that they did clips back then,
- 12:21but the Oscar clip of her would certainly be
- 12:23after she's admitted that she's not in love with
- 12:25him and Queenie should go after him. And she
- 12:28has that moment like putting on her makeup before
- 12:29a show of just like breaking down. Like, yeah,
- 12:32I get that. She goes between like crying and
- 12:35laughing and she's almost in hysterics. Yep.
- 12:39That's probably one of the most emotional female
- 12:43lead performances we've seen doing the podcast
- 12:45so far. So it's hard to deny that, yeah, Bessie
- 12:49Love probably deserved that nomination. Yeah,
- 12:52and I don't want to diminish that. She certainly
- 12:55deserved it. I was just surprised to see that
- 12:57it wasn't split, especially with the previous
- 12:59entries that we've done here where we see that
- 13:02they're nominated for multiple things and movies
- 13:04can be nominated multiple times. Yeah. Surprised
- 13:07to see they didn't decide to pull the plug on
- 13:09this and also nominate Queenie's actress. I'm
- 13:12curious when that first happens. historically
- 13:15in the Oscars that two actors from one movie
- 13:19were nominated. I guess it hasn't happened already
- 13:21now that I'm thinking back to this, but it certainly
- 13:23will come a little more recently now in the 2000s
- 13:29than maybe before. Yeah. But what was the first?
- 13:31I'm thinking maybe like Philadelphia or something
- 13:34like that might have been a nomination for both.
- 13:36Dang. Tom Hanks and Denzel. Oh. I was thinking
- 13:40the Philadelphia story from 1940. I was like,
- 13:42was Cary Grant and Jimmy Stewart both nominated?
- 13:45That's a good example, though. Yeah, I can't
- 13:47remember. I knew at one point, but I guess I
- 13:50should have done my research. Audience, remind
- 13:53me, and I'll look it up and announce it during
- 13:56this year's ceremony episode. Yes, please. Thanks,
- 14:00guys. Make sure you write in. If you don't write
- 14:01in, we're never going to talk about it again.
- 14:02Yeah, we'll forget it and we'll only talk about
- 14:04it. At home, they're like, everyone don't write
- 14:06in. Right. We talked about how it was the very
- 14:10early stages of musicals, right? It was not the
- 14:12first ever musical, but it was the first ever
- 14:14all -talk musical. So that means that they're
- 14:18kind of learning how to do this in real time,
- 14:20right? So any ability of how to record, they're
- 14:24figuring that out by trial and error. Right.
- 14:26So credit where it's due. That's an amazing feat.
- 14:31The downside is that it kind of results in a
- 14:35pretty uneven feeling. There are songs, like
- 14:39musical numbers in this, but a lot of them are
- 14:41repeats. You hear the Broadway melody quite a
- 14:44bit. So many times. So many times. And I kind
- 14:49of liked this movie when it was a satire. Like
- 14:52there's a portion of the movie where you're watching
- 14:55the Broadway melody happening, being put on.
- 14:58And you see a, it's like a Roman gladiator who's
- 15:02like trying to like, he can't sing without the
- 15:04spotlight being on him, even in practice. So
- 15:06he needs a spotlight on him. But there's someone
- 15:08else who wants a spotlight on them at the same
- 15:09time. And there's a little bit between that where
- 15:11it felt very satire of Broadway. Right. And I
- 15:15thought that was a really great thing. But beyond
- 15:17that, the songs were just kind of. Yeah, they're
- 15:23really not anything to write home about. I mean,
- 15:26okay, so the setup here is that Eddie tells the
- 15:30girls, like, they've come already to New York.
- 15:32And he's like, look, I got this song. I sold
- 15:35it to Zanfield. We're really excited about it.
- 15:38We're putting it on. Do you want to hear it?
- 15:40They're like, yeah, you got to play it. He's
- 15:42like, all right, let me play it for you. And
- 15:43he does like 45 seconds of just like the Broadway
- 15:46melody. And they're like, that is the best thing
- 15:50I've ever heard. Can you do it once more and
- 15:52dance? He's like, totally. And they do it once
- 15:55more and dance. And it's just, there's nothing
- 15:58quite as bad in a movie when like you're being
- 16:00told that something's amazing and you're like,
- 16:02that's good. Right. Yeah. And then you have to
- 16:04hear it four more times to be like, guys, isn't
- 16:06this amazing? It's good. And even like the Broadway
- 16:09level production that they do for the Broadway
- 16:12melody, when it is Eddie on stage in the suit
- 16:15and all the dancers and everything, it just feels,
- 16:19here's the thing. This is unfair. This is unfair
- 16:22to the movie because I'm watching what he's doing.
- 16:24I'm like, hey, this is great. I think Singing
- 16:26in the Rain does it better. Right. But Singing
- 16:29in the Rain got it from this. We're not there
- 16:31yet. We're not there yet. So there are versions
- 16:34of this that are done better in the future. Yeah.
- 16:38But watching this back now with the technology
- 16:41that they had, it's difficult to connect with
- 16:43these songs. Yeah. It's so fascinating, too,
- 16:46because there are a lot of times when I can watch
- 16:49an early, movie of a genre and kind of disassociate
- 16:53from anything that comes after and be like okay
- 16:55this is what is impressive about this particular
- 16:58entry we did it with the racket you know we were
- 17:01able to find the merits in that movie in old
- 17:04arizona we could find the merits in that western
- 17:06movie that being said i just like in old arizona
- 17:09in general but yeah as far as this musical goes
- 17:12it is so hard for me to just detach and look
- 17:17at the movie on its own And the music specifically
- 17:20and be like, okay, I get why people like this.
- 17:23I don't. I don't get it. It's really that one
- 17:26Broadway melody song. I don't think there are
- 17:29any other memorable songs. So that's the thing
- 17:32is like, we'll get to this later. There's a movie
- 17:36that I may or may not have already mentioned
- 17:38that has a song that feels like it also kind
- 17:41of lifted from this, but better. And there's
- 17:44a song that the sisters do together called Boyfriend.
- 17:47It's basically just them holding each other,
- 17:50walking one direction, and then turning around
- 17:51and walking in the other direction. And they're
- 17:53just singing about a boyfriend. It's fine. Like,
- 17:56it's not great. It's not memorable. I couldn't
- 17:58hum it to you right now. At least Broadway Melody,
- 18:00we all know, like, you know, the Broadway Melody.
- 18:02Like, we have that down. I love that, too. Right.
- 18:05But the rest of it is just, like, barely songs.
- 18:08Like, I was coming in here ready to prepare to
- 18:11say, like, is it really a musical? But there
- 18:13are, like, musical numbers listed. They're just
- 18:15so much smaller than the Broadway melody, and
- 18:17that's the majority that's being played. One
- 18:19thing we neglected to say that I did want to
- 18:21bring up to you, with the production level of
- 18:25this being kind of like grassroots, they're figuring
- 18:27out while they do it, the opening scene of this
- 18:29movie is in, I guess, like a showroom or a practice
- 18:32room where there's multiple rooms and people
- 18:35are playing different instruments, different
- 18:36songs. Was that an auditory nightmare for you?
- 18:42No. No, it wasn't. Because I knew if someone
- 18:45would have started speaking and it was like,
- 18:48hey, you really have to pay attention to one
- 18:49guy saying that would have been awful. But I
- 18:52think it was just to show the chaos of like the
- 18:55New York music composing and how everybody's
- 18:58working right next to each other to make the
- 19:01next big thing. I think it was effective in what
- 19:03it was trying to present. OK, that makes way
- 19:06more sense because I couldn't keep track of who
- 19:09was. doing what, and who I was supposed to listen
- 19:12to. Because there are a few moments where there
- 19:14is someone trying to speak while other people
- 19:15are performing, where I was like, oh no, if this
- 19:19is the movie, I'm concerned. But it was just
- 19:22the beginning, and I'm sure you're right, it
- 19:23was intentional to kind of show the, set the
- 19:27tone of Broadway in 1920s. Right, and the chaos
- 19:31that it is. You mentioned that being the opening
- 19:34shot, though, when the title credits are rolling,
- 19:36though. It's like helicopter footage of New York
- 19:39City. Yeah. That was interesting. I thought that
- 19:42was very cool. That was something we haven't
- 19:43seen done before. And it's so wild because in
- 19:46my mind, I automatically assume either they built
- 19:49a model or I don't want to say they CGI'd it,
- 19:55but they did something. That wasn't actually
- 19:57taking a helicopter into the sky to film it.
- 19:59But they probably took a helicopter up to film
- 20:02that. They probably did. It's so weird. Maybe
- 20:03they just, I don't want to say strapped, but
- 20:05like honestly held a camera. Yeah. And then just
- 20:08put it on the plane and just like aimed. Yeah.
- 20:11That stuff always seems completely out of the
- 20:13question for the time period. But I guess if
- 20:15just a couple years ago we were strapping them
- 20:18to planes for wings. Yeah. They had a helicopter
- 20:21mounted camera. Yeah. Yeah. That's how you say
- 20:24that. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Those words correct.
- 20:26A couple of hyphens in there. Yeah. No, I definitely
- 20:28think they did. And I will say that it did kind
- 20:30of set the scene for me of like, you know, the
- 20:32wide, like it felt like a epic scale that it's
- 20:36trying to portray, which is interesting because
- 20:38the movie is pretty contained. It's mostly a
- 20:41play. Mostly. Yeah. Yeah. Like it's mostly their
- 20:44apartment, their dressing room, the Zanfield's
- 20:47theater, I guess. And then Jock's apartment.
- 20:52That's. Well, Queenie's apartment, but that's
- 20:55about it. And I think that's interesting to bring
- 20:58up in old Arizona again, that the kind of claustrophobia
- 21:02I felt in this movie, because it was all on sound
- 21:06stages and things, it helps to emphasize how
- 21:09wildly dynamic the sets were in old Arizona.
- 21:14Yeah. It being filmed on location and out in
- 21:16the wide open spaces, it really does feel like
- 21:19an open epic movie. If you can call like a 1929
- 21:24Western epic. I think I would. I don't think
- 21:28that it really goes to like the epic distance,
- 21:31but it does feel kind of epic in size. Yeah.
- 21:36And I imagine for the time period, especially
- 21:38that, that must've just been like, wow, look
- 21:40at all of this space. I don't know. I felt very
- 21:43claustrophobic for the Broadway melody. I wonder
- 21:46too, if within old Arizona. I think you can all
- 21:50see where our ratings are going with this at
- 21:51the end. But I wonder if within old Arizona,
- 21:54it felt kind of like they're breaking past the
- 21:56fourth wall, right? Like you've always seen them
- 21:58go in the distance, but now you can actually
- 22:00hear them leaving this space and watch them leave
- 22:03that space. So I wonder if that's more of like
- 22:05for the audience, it's like they're going somewhere
- 22:07they haven't been before. They have. But you
- 22:10just have the audio now tricking you into thinking
- 22:13that they're leaving further than you can imagine.
- 22:16That's true. So that probably makes it feel a
- 22:18little bit bigger to the movie's credit. Right.
- 22:20With this, sound is mostly good. One thing I
- 22:24thought was funny, there's this and another movie
- 22:26we'll talk about here in a little bit that has
- 22:29an issue where the microphone is in one space.
- 22:32And again, these being sound stages, pretty easy
- 22:34to capture all the audio that you need to. Almost
- 22:37alarmingly well at times. But there's other times
- 22:40where someone's like, oh, let me pick that up
- 22:41for you. And you hear them walk in the other
- 22:43room and it's just dead silence. And they're
- 22:45just like. You see them walk back and then immediately
- 22:47start hearing steps again. You're like, okay,
- 22:48yeah, there's the issue with the cameras or the
- 22:51microphones. You can see it at home, but Ryan
- 22:53was making little baby steps. Yeah, of course,
- 22:57you have to. You just kind of feel it out. One
- 22:59day we'll be on video and you'll see it all.
- 23:01Not that way. We'll have footage. Well, what
- 23:04did you say? I said you'll see it all. Oh, and
- 23:07then not that way. Okay. You'll see the little
- 23:09baby steps. Yeah. I'm a very physical speaker.
- 23:13There are some things that stopped Broadway Melody
- 23:16from really hitting home with me. With that said,
- 23:20I did enjoy it. I think that it was very fulfilling
- 23:24to watch kind of the first ever, I mean, let's
- 23:28just say what it is, the first ever talking musical,
- 23:31full talking musical. Very cool to see that because
- 23:33I like musicals a lot. And I think that there
- 23:36are movies that have gone on to perfect what
- 23:38this tried to do. I think that they tried to
- 23:42do something before they fully had the technology
- 23:44to fully embrace it. And later on, when those
- 23:48projects did do this, they had the technology
- 23:51they needed to fully embrace it. And I think
- 23:53that that's the difference here, is you can't
- 23:55just say, well, yeah, of course, the one that
- 23:56comes after is better. Well, no, there's a reason
- 23:58behind it. So it's not just that we have to look
- 24:01at the first one and say, well, that's the best.
- 24:03There's ways that can make it not the best. Right.
- 24:05It's one of those instances, too, where... Initially,
- 24:09my brain says, this was nominated because it
- 24:12was the first. Sure. But, I don't know if you
- 24:15saw, this was also the top grossing film of 1929.
- 24:18That's crazy. So this was bringing in the audiences.
- 24:22Do you know, by chance, if Eddie Kearns, Bessie
- 24:25Love, or, it was Anita, correct? Anita Page.
- 24:28Anita Page. Were they, or the director, like
- 24:31a well -known name that kind of like could bring
- 24:34that on? Or is it really just like a phenomenon?
- 24:36I... I would imagine that it was mostly the musical
- 24:40thing that was bringing people in. Because that's
- 24:43what's so weird, too, is because you're in this
- 24:45shift from the silent film to the sound era,
- 24:48even if you have a well -known name, you know
- 24:51them from their silent films. So there's no guarantee.
- 24:55I feel like the hype of seeing an actor you know
- 24:57would be more like, oh, let's see what they sound
- 25:00like. I agree. But Bessie Love was probably the
- 25:04biggest name attached to the film at the time.
- 25:07Side note, there's a photo of Bessie Love in
- 25:10a Halloween costume that I'm going to post all
- 25:12over the socials. She's in a witch outfit. It's
- 25:15one of my favorite photos I've ever found of
- 25:18old Hollywood stars, and I feel like I post it
- 25:20every year. She's so cute. Celebrities, they're
- 25:24just like us. They are. I've never posted a witch
- 25:27costume, so I don't know what you're talking
- 25:29about. The night is young. It is only mid -October.
- 25:34This is true. Man, not when you're listening
- 25:37to it. That's true. That's still messaging. Wow,
- 25:38yeah, that's crazy. Happy Halloween, everybody.
- 25:41And happy Thanksgiving. Still posting that picture,
- 25:44so it'll be there if you want to look back at
- 25:46it. That old Thanksgiving witch poster. Yeah.
- 25:49So let's talk about the camera work. How did
- 25:52this look for you? You said it before. It's kind
- 25:55of like a play. There wasn't a whole lot that
- 25:58impressed me with the cinematography. The opening,
- 26:03like I said, with the helicopter aerial shots,
- 26:05that was cool. That was surprising. Beyond that,
- 26:08though, I don't know that the blocking or anything
- 26:11was really all that great. And it being a musical
- 26:14with what you assume would be big dance numbers,
- 26:18because that microphone is strapped to one spot,
- 26:20the dances are so limited. You said Bessie Love
- 26:24and Nita Page just kind of going back and forth
- 26:26like a Super Mario enemy. There wasn't a whole
- 26:31lot that thrilled me. Yeah, I agree. I think
- 26:34that there's some changes that I noticed, and
- 26:38I wanted to look it up, and I'm very happy that
- 26:40I did, that are kind of like you just barely
- 26:43notice them. But then there's others where it's
- 26:45just a shot itself, like in Wings, where you're
- 26:47like, how did they do that? So what I thought
- 26:49was impressive about Broadway Melody was that
- 26:52there's a sequence, one of the musical numbers,
- 26:55where I wasn't sure if it was like the version
- 26:57I was watching, but there's a color sequence.
- 26:59Did you catch that? No. So there's a color sequence
- 27:02on YouTube, at least. I forget what sequence
- 27:05it is. But specifically, there is color that's
- 27:08put into it. I think it might be The Wedding
- 27:11of the Painted Doll is the name of the sequence.
- 27:14Sequel. Wow. So I looked it up. John Arnold was
- 27:18the cinematographer at the time. So he shot.
- 27:22that specific scene with a type of lens. And
- 27:25at the time they're using 35 millimeter. So one
- 27:30sequence was in color. It was presented in an
- 27:33aspect ratio of one to 37 to 30, or sorry, one
- 27:37to 37 to one, which was like sound on disc version.
- 27:40And then there's like a sound on film version
- 27:42that he also did. The red and green filters are
- 27:46kind of the way that you can tell color. So it's
- 27:48not color proper, but you can definitely tell
- 27:50like there's peach tones and like things you
- 27:52can get from red and green. Right. It was a very
- 27:55big production of like, it almost looked like
- 27:56a clamshell on the stage. And there's like faint,
- 28:01like. tan and brown and like red that kind of
- 28:04comes out of it and i was very surprised because
- 28:06i was like well i know this is 1929 so we're
- 28:09not doing color yet yeah so how is this now so
- 28:13at the time he tried to do the color and in back
- 28:15on the back end there's ways you can do it but
- 28:18it's really just using the um red and green filter
- 28:20to kind of like pop that through technicolor
- 28:22it was early two color technicolor is what they
- 28:25called it interesting so it's interesting i agree
- 28:28with you because color was so quickly adopted
- 28:33by musicals, right? Yeah. To where musicals had
- 28:37to be very bright and colorful. Again, we'll
- 28:39get there. So it's interesting because it seems
- 28:42like everything that you need, this is the Bible
- 28:44for musicals. Because everything that was done
- 28:47after that is now, you know, used over and over
- 28:50again. So... It's cool to see. And I think that's
- 28:54my point in saying all this is that, you know,
- 28:55it may not be the flashiest looking thing, but
- 28:57they are taking their chances. They are doing
- 28:59the grassroots thing. They are figuring this
- 29:01out in real time. Sometimes that's great. Sometimes
- 29:04it's not. I know that they took three hours,
- 29:07I think, to film Bessie Love's ukulele scene
- 29:10in the movie. Three hours is not that much time,
- 29:14really. Well, I mean, to film a specific sequence
- 29:17that lasts about, like, you know, back then,
- 29:19at least. Right now, like, we're working days
- 29:21to get a shot. But, like, back then, three hours
- 29:24to get this shot of someone playing ukulele,
- 29:26and you have to drown out the sound of other
- 29:28people, a full orchestra that's playing. It's
- 29:31impressive. And it's still a very impressive
- 29:34movie. I think the way that we have to decide
- 29:36how we want to rank these, though, at least rate
- 29:39them, is if we want to rate them based on how
- 29:41impressive. it is now and how technically achieving
- 29:44it was or just how entertaining it is as a full
- 29:47product. God, I hate saying product, but a full
- 29:50encompassing project. Right. Yeah, it's so hard.
- 29:54I brought this up to you earlier. When I did
- 29:58the first run of the show, I think I gave this
- 30:00movie three, three and a half stars. And everybody
- 30:04that I follow on Letterboxd that has watched
- 30:07this movie and even just random people as I'm
- 30:09going through the reviews, Everyone was giving
- 30:11it like one star. And they're like, yeah, this
- 30:14isn't it. This was not good. I don't know what
- 30:18I liked so much about it before. I do really
- 30:21like Bessie Love and her wit and her comedic
- 30:25dialogue. Beyond that Broadway melody, nothing
- 30:31else stuck with me in this movie. So this watch
- 30:34was completely different to me than the first
- 30:36time. Do you think there's a romanticism? For
- 30:40the first musical, All Talk, that you had the
- 30:44first time, I mean? There must have been. There
- 30:46must have been something. Or maybe I was just
- 30:49in a better headspace, and I was like, I love
- 30:51movies. Give them all four stars. I don't know
- 30:55what happened. But I'm going through, and I'm
- 30:58reading these reviews, and I'm like, nobody is
- 31:00saying anything that I disagree with, really.
- 31:02I'll tell you that I had a very similar experience
- 31:05with it. Mostly to the point of what you're saying
- 31:08about how you specifically want to just kind
- 31:11of give them all praise and props. Yeah. Because
- 31:14we love movies. And I got to tell you, this far
- 31:18into the project, I'm not watching anything that
- 31:21I just outright hate. Because it is a movie.
- 31:23And it is just like, wow, I loved seeing where
- 31:25movies came from and what we were doing before
- 31:27then. Getting to know actors that I haven't known
- 31:29before and stories that I haven't seen or have
- 31:32seen. And this is where they stem from. It's
- 31:34very cool to be able to do that. So I'm very
- 31:36humbled by the ability to be able to do this
- 31:38with you. With that said, I think watching this,
- 31:42it was very easy for me to kind of compartmentalize,
- 31:46hey, wow, this is very cool that it is the first
- 31:48musical. And I think I walked into it, again,
- 31:51first talking musical, walked into it having
- 31:54that romance and ready to be swept off my feet,
- 31:58right? Swept off my feet. And it just didn't
- 32:01happen. And I saw everything there. I literally
- 32:03saw the ingredients for everything to sweep me
- 32:06off my feet with a grand musical gesture. And
- 32:10they came up with it. And they provided all the
- 32:11things. It just didn't hit for me. And it will
- 32:14go on to hit later on. In the years to come with
- 32:18musicals, they will use the exact same thing.
- 32:20The love triangle. The producer who has the show
- 32:24that's just about to take off. The idea of Technicolor
- 32:28popping in these musical sequences. They have
- 32:31it down. They just didn't do it as well as they
- 32:35could. At the time, they did it as well as they
- 32:37could have. But technology was not very much
- 32:40on the side of the adventurous with musicals.
- 32:44So I'm very glad they had it captured. It just
- 32:45doesn't make for a very engaging movie. We talked
- 32:48about the musical element of it. Yeah. I wanted
- 32:50to talk about sound in general. Sure. And how
- 32:52that's being used in the movies beyond just,
- 32:56okay, people are talking now. We missed it in
- 32:59old Arizona. We missed it in, in old Arizona.
- 33:03Confusing, I know. There's a scene where the
- 33:07captain that's on the hunt for the Cisco kid.
- 33:10Yeah. He says some kind of joke, and it sounds
- 33:13like he's about to swear. And then a donkey he
- 33:16haunts and cuts him off. Well, so the moment
- 33:19was when he realizes from the other villager
- 33:23that he had been talking to the Cisco kid. Yeah.
- 33:26And he's like, man, he made me feel like it.
- 33:29And then there's a donkey going like, and everything.
- 33:32Right. But then he proceeds to make the comment
- 33:34afterwards, too. Yeah, yeah. The exact joke.
- 33:36So I wonder if that was scripted. Or if it just
- 33:38happened. If it wasn't scripted, that's an incredible
- 33:42bit because... Great donkey. He just, the look
- 33:45on his face, like he holds it really well. There's
- 33:47no like smile. If there's smiling, it feels very
- 33:49kind of like, you know, in character. Yeah. And
- 33:51then that line delivery is great and you don't
- 33:53like see anything change with the camera. Right.
- 33:55So if anything, class production if that was
- 33:58not scripted. Yeah. But yeah, great line, great
- 34:01joke. Yeah, that's a moment that couldn't have
- 34:03happened in a silent film. Right. So... They're
- 34:06doing things like that. And there's a moment,
- 34:09not a moment, it's really a character in the
- 34:11Broadway melody that exists in a way that couldn't
- 34:15have if it was still a silent film. And that
- 34:18is Uncle Jed. Oh, yeah. He has a stutter. You
- 34:23could present a character with a stuttle through
- 34:25title cards, but it would not have the same,
- 34:27I'm doing air quotes here, comedic value that
- 34:30it does in a talking picture. He's played all
- 34:34for laughs. You know what's great is that he
- 34:36has played all for laughs, but at no point are
- 34:38you laughing at him. Like, I'm interested. This
- 34:42was 1929, so I do wonder if his stutter was at
- 34:46all inspiring to Porky Pig. And I don't just
- 34:50mean like they both have stutters, but there's
- 34:52a level to his stutter where he kind of like
- 34:54catches himself afterwards. Yeah. Where he'll
- 34:57be like, you know, are you going to the shh?
- 34:59Are you going to the shh? Are you going to the
- 35:00theater? And, like, he'll find another word to
- 35:03say instead of the word that he's having trouble
- 35:04saying. And that's very much the punchline of
- 35:08Porky Pig. And it kind of stemmed here, it looks
- 35:11like. That's a good point. I'd be curious. I
- 35:15feel like I need to look up Porky Pig now. I'm
- 35:17on it. You keep going. Okay. I have Porky Pig
- 35:20history speed dialed on my phone. Perfect. Good.
- 35:23It's very easy for me to pull up. That is a really
- 35:25good point, though. We talked about, like, the
- 35:27origin of Bugs Bunny in old Arizona last week.
- 35:30And or last episode. But now we have another
- 35:33Looney Tunes reference. Yeah, I mean, while you
- 35:36research that, it's just interesting to me all
- 35:38of the different ways the studios and the movies
- 35:42are utilizing sound. That's not just showcasing,
- 35:46hey, we can talk now. When we talk next episode
- 35:48about alibi, there's some really, really interesting
- 35:52uses of sound, really innovative ways of kind
- 35:55of capturing a feeling. And I'm really excited
- 35:58to talk about sound that way. because the two
- 36:01examples I've provided so far are played for
- 36:03laughs, and that one is more to invoke the atmosphere
- 36:07of the movie. Uh -uh, got you. Uncle Jed is played
- 36:10by MGM stock player Jed Prouty. The character's
- 36:13pronounced stutter was a popular comic theme
- 36:15of the era, based on the premise of a comic struggling
- 36:17to find a word and ultimately settling for an
- 36:19easier -to -pronounce synonym, a compensation
- 36:21technique occasionally employed by Porky Pig.
- 36:23Yeah, so it doesn't even say that it was 100
- 36:25% done to it, but they're putting the two...
- 36:29together. Yeah. And in 1929, I mean, was Mel
- 36:33Blanc doing that? I don't think so. No, I don't
- 36:36know the history of the Looney Tunes, sadly.
- 36:38But yeah, I guess it was less inspired by this
- 36:41character in particular and more of just a common
- 36:44trope. Porky Pig wasn't introduced until 1935.
- 36:47So I mean, this is like... put in there. I'm
- 36:51not sure if Jed kind of introduced the idea of
- 36:54this or if this was done before, but to your
- 36:55point, at least in theaters, there wasn't much
- 36:57opportunity to do this kind of performance on
- 37:00film. So it is very cool to kind of see how this
- 37:03lends itself to the popular era and how it gets
- 37:07manifested. Just surprising. that in now two
- 37:11episodes in a row, we found Looney Tunes. Yeah.
- 37:14Just taking it on. But isn't that cool, though?
- 37:16If we grew up on Looney Tunes and watching this
- 37:18and knowing these characters, and there's these
- 37:20little ticks that they have that they took from
- 37:23characters in these movies. Yeah. And it makes
- 37:26sense. It kind of highlights, I want to say,
- 37:30the cliches or the tropes of the era of the characters.
- 37:34Because while we're covering... gangster movies
- 37:37like the racket or western movies like in old
- 37:39arizona a lot of times those characters do feel
- 37:42like caricatures almost sure and i i wonder if
- 37:47i was to sit down and watch 10 gangster movies
- 37:51from 1928 or 10 westerns from 1928 how often
- 37:55those particular tropes would show up as far
- 37:58as like characters go Oh, pretty often. Yeah,
- 38:01I guess Mel Blanc was just like, yeah, I don't
- 38:03know, just use all of them. Yeah. You said all
- 38:07of them, and I just heard that in Gary Oldman's
- 38:10voice in Leon the Professional. Oh. I can't do
- 38:13it in the mic, but shouting all of them. So,
- 38:17that aside, I think it's really cool to see that
- 38:19because I'm a big believer in, like, you know,
- 38:22you can't rip something off, but you can pay
- 38:24homage. Yes. And, like, you have to pay homage
- 38:26to, like, where you've been and the things that
- 38:28you've seen. And it's very cool to think that
- 38:30like Mel Blanc was just Blanc, however, was specifically
- 38:34looking at just the surroundings and just being
- 38:36like, I don't know. I loved that. And I loved
- 38:38this. And what if we did that? And what if we
- 38:40put this into that? And I just think that's so
- 38:42cool and lived in. Yeah. And it just feels like
- 38:45they are of this time. Yes. So not just with
- 38:49like cartoons and stuff, but I think that when
- 38:51any. Any creator can do that and can borrow from
- 38:55these things. It makes them feel more real and
- 38:57lived in. And it also makes it feel grounded,
- 38:59just in this world. It's not a separate universe
- 39:01where these things happen. It's they've watched
- 39:03this stuff. And they're just like, yeah, maybe
- 39:05they just watched a lot of 1929 musicals. And
- 39:08this is just kind of what they model themselves
- 39:10after. Yeah. It's so funny. We've now brought
- 39:13up the Muppets in an episode. And we brought
- 39:15up the Looney Tunes. We have a type. I think
- 39:17we're in the wrong business. We should be doing
- 39:21the history of Borderline Kids Media. Whenever
- 39:25you do decide to jump into the deep end of the
- 39:30history of the Muppets, I'm way more qualified.
- 39:34I'm way more qualified to jump into that. So
- 39:37here's Beauregard. And Beauregard's job is the...
- 39:39Yeah, no. I wouldn't do that to you. I mean,
- 39:42I would enjoy it. Maybe that'll be a Patreon.
- 39:45Hey, Patreon audience, if you want to see Kyle
- 39:48and I get into a whole Muppets episode, whether
- 39:51it be the movies or the history of the Muppets,
- 39:52leave a comment. Yeah. Or the Looney Tunes. Or
- 39:55Looney Tunes. That would be interesting. We'll
- 39:58probably draw the line at Smurfs. I don't think
- 40:02we'll cover Smurfs. No. Not as much historical.
- 40:05But see, that's the thing. People will joke about
- 40:07it and be like, yeah, these are kids things.
- 40:08And yes, we're going on this tangent. Those are
- 40:10just like kids shows and everything. Yeah, technically.
- 40:13But look at the inspiration behind them. The
- 40:16Muppets essentially are a vaudeville act. Right.
- 40:20Kids are not like, ah, yes, I love vaudeville,
- 40:22the old days. They don't know what that is. Yeah.
- 40:24So there's so much inspiration they can take
- 40:27from that and give to kids at a young age that
- 40:29they're not aware of. Looney Tunes, I mean, they're
- 40:31pulling caricatures of people like Abbott and
- 40:34Costello and a number of people that kids don't
- 40:37know anything about. But there's cool history
- 40:40behind that. And the Smurfs and stuff like that
- 40:42is just like, I don't know, do you want to have
- 40:44fun for 20 minutes and just turn your brain off?
- 40:47There's a lot of difference between the two.
- 40:49So I hold both Looney Tunes and Muppets in very
- 40:52high regard. Maybe Muppets a little bit more.
- 40:54That's just how I grew up. But yeah, that'd be
- 40:57such a fascinating thing to do, to talk about
- 40:58those and the history behind those. Yeah, especially
- 41:01in regards to modern cartoons and things. I wonder
- 41:04where they draw inspiration from. You know what
- 41:07would be really cool? You can cut this out of
- 41:09the episode if you want to. What would be really
- 41:11cool is if on Christmas Day we released an episode
- 41:15of us talking about the Muppet Christmas Carol.
- 41:17Yeah. And like the history behind it and like
- 41:19what it drew inspiration from and the versions
- 41:22of Christmas Carol that came before it. Because
- 41:24Christmas Carol has been like maybe more so in
- 41:27like the 50s and so nominated or recognized in
- 41:30the Academy Awards. Sure. And the Muppets have
- 41:33kind of been like Academy Awards adjacent. Like
- 41:35never nominated, but always like presenting.
- 41:37That'd be a cool little fun Patreon episode.
- 41:39Yeah. That's something to look into. Yeah. I
- 41:41don't think I'll cut this. Oh. I think maybe
- 41:44the audience can start getting excited or not
- 41:47for the Muppet Christmas Carol. This is like
- 41:49that thing where you say you're going to cut
- 41:51it, but then I decide not to. So then there's
- 41:53a grassroots campaign of everyone now being like,
- 41:55yeah, I want to hear that now. Yeah. But you're
- 41:57doing it yourself. So that's not that. Yeah.
- 41:59Thank you. Give us the Muppet cut. Everyone's
- 42:02like, yeah, get back to the movie. Yeah. Yeah.
- 42:04So back to the Broadway melody of 1929. You know
- 42:08what I really want to do? I want to watch the
- 42:10sequels. Yes. Are they considered the sequels,
- 42:13though? I have no idea. But I want to watch them.
- 42:16And I think I'm going to make it a goal. I'm
- 42:20going to make a note that when we get to those
- 42:23years, the Academy years, I'm going to sprinkle
- 42:25those in and just kind of bring them up. So when
- 42:28I get to the ceremony episode, I'm going to be
- 42:29like, hey, guys. I'm six years older now, and
- 42:33let me tell you about the Broadway Melody of
- 42:361936. And we'll probably talk about that less
- 42:41than we just talked about the Looney Tunes and
- 42:42the Muppets. Probably. But it'll be so worth
- 42:45my hour and a half of watching the Broadway Melody
- 42:48of 1936. Well, to continue the cartoon talk,
- 42:52or at least to end it, we can't change that,
- 42:54Kyle, because we am who we am. I did it. So let's
- 42:59talk a little bit about how it was received,
- 43:00right? So Broadway Melody, you mentioned, was
- 43:03a huge success, right? Massive box office success.
- 43:07And I want everyone to put on their 2025 goggles
- 43:10when they hear this. Well, I guess earmuffs when
- 43:13you hear this, whatever. It made a profit of
- 43:15$1 .6 million. So back then, amazing. Now, a
- 43:22bomb. But that's how things go. So you mentioned
- 43:25it was the top grossing picture of 1929. Very
- 43:28exciting to hear that in musicals. You're totally
- 43:30right. I speculated earlier if maybe there was
- 43:32some fuel or excitement for someone in the cast
- 43:37that kind of brought that on. But I think you're
- 43:39100 % right. Having a full, all -talking musical
- 43:43is going to get people really excited. I mean,
- 43:46we had a musical last year in Wicked, and look
- 43:48how much money that made. Yeah. All eyes on you,
- 43:51Wicked for Good. So reviews were pretty great.
- 43:54Generally positive. Basic story with some sense
- 43:57to it. You know, surefire moneymaker that will
- 43:59drag them in everywhere. Just the full expectation
- 44:03that like, of course, this is going to make money.
- 44:04And of course, this is going to do well. Because
- 44:06it is what it is. Yeah. And that's kind of my
- 44:09thought of the movie overall. Is like, of course,
- 44:12this had the success that it did. Both, you know,
- 44:14in box office and in the Academy Awards. It's
- 44:18a musical. And it's the attempt of doing that
- 44:20musical and it's supposed to have that feel good
- 44:22ending that you're talking about. And I think
- 44:25we're kind of getting to the end here. Let's
- 44:26talk about that feel good ending. Yeah, sure.
- 44:29It's so weird because the plot in general, you
- 44:32don't like any of the male characters. No, not
- 44:34at all. They're all gross. Eddie is kind of a
- 44:36jerk. He's a big jerk. Yeah. He goes behind,
- 44:40hanks back, gets with Queenie in like the grossest
- 44:44way too. He's just like, yeah, your sister's
- 44:47fine, but. Boy, howdy, you're better. It's you.
- 44:50Yeah. And Queenie's so sweet the entire movie.
- 44:54She's like, no, I don't want to hurt my sister.
- 44:56I love my sister. She also gets just the worst
- 45:00experience with Jacques, who gets very, very
- 45:03forcefully aggressive with her. Eddie shows up
- 45:06to take out Jacques, doesn't, gets completely
- 45:10rocked by Jacques. But ultimately, the movie
- 45:13ends with Queenie ends up with Eddie. her knight
- 45:17in shining armor, even though he's gross. And
- 45:19Hank continues on that show run that Jed was
- 45:25proposing to her. The blonde that she starts
- 45:29working with and had the beef with earlier on
- 45:31is Flo, by the way. Yes, Flo. So she ends up
- 45:34doing this tour with her arch rival, if you will,
- 45:38Flo. Yeah. And they head out to catch the train
- 45:41and start that big journey. And that's kind of
- 45:43how... And Queenie's back at home with Eddie,
- 45:45just living... The, I don't know, traditional
- 45:47lifestyle? Yeah, there's a moment that you feel
- 45:52like the movie's over, where Hank and Flo and
- 45:55Uncle Jed are leaving, and we kind of just focus
- 45:58a little bit more on Queenie and Eddie at their
- 46:00house. And then it cuts to the street, and you're
- 46:03in a car. And you're in the car with the three
- 46:05that I just mentioned. Jed. hank and flo and
- 46:08i can't remember the last line it wasn't anything
- 46:10too like prophetic i think it actually kind of
- 46:12ends on like a joke line from him of like a word
- 46:15that he can't say he's having trouble saying
- 46:16and then it ends and to me that felt kind of
- 46:18like a fake ending like it felt like it probably
- 46:21should have wrapped on eddie and queenie and
- 46:24not try to like do one last joke at the end but
- 46:27i guess that's the you know they're trying to
- 46:28send people home laughing yeah that is weird
- 46:31I was kind of waiting for a bigger reveal of
- 46:34something, of maybe a sadness in Hank's eyes
- 46:36or something, but it really was just a punchline
- 46:38from Jed. Yeah, and that goes to show, again,
- 46:41the movie is built in a way that's just feel
- 46:45-good, and you're here for laughs, and even though
- 46:48Queenie has an awful moment with Jacques, lights,
- 46:51sound, dance, comedy, the end. Yeah, the world
- 46:55picks you up. I do like the line where... Eddie
- 46:58tells Queenie to make sure that people know that
- 47:00it took six people to take him, to throw him
- 47:02out of that party. Yes. I don't like Eddie. No.
- 47:06I think literally he just like, there's a similar
- 47:09movie that's out right now that we'll talk about
- 47:11in, you know, a couple months where he's being
- 47:13heralded. The character is being heralded and
- 47:16all he did was show up. Like, that's it. The
- 47:19dude just shows up, which I guess is enough sometimes.
- 47:22In this movie, I'm going to say it's not. Eddie's
- 47:24showing up in that one moment is not enough to
- 47:26redeem him just like pretty much two -timing
- 47:28the sisters off and on. Yeah. But again, of the
- 47:31time. So an interesting thing here, we're going
- 47:34to talk a lot about pre -code, right? Yes. So
- 47:37do you think that this movie was affected at
- 47:41all by the pre -code? Oh. Man, that's a great
- 47:44thing to bring up. There's a lot of Bessie Love
- 47:47and Anita Page kind of in not a whole lot of
- 47:51clothing. Yeah. That's... Essentially what they
- 47:54call their undergarments while they're brushing
- 47:56their teeth. Right, yeah. And even Queenie's
- 47:59in the bathtub at one point. Yeah. You know,
- 48:01from shoulders up, but still pretty risque for
- 48:05old Hollywood. I know pre -code is a completely
- 48:08different ballgame, but we're kind of heading
- 48:10into that code era. So this is all going to go
- 48:13away. Yep. It's always, I wonder how much that
- 48:18affected the box office, you know? Well, if it
- 48:21was the highest grossing at the time, I can't
- 48:23imagine it capped it too much, right? Like people
- 48:25kind of want to see the salaciousness of it.
- 48:28But I think, you know, that goes the complete
- 48:30opposite way of what musicals tend to be. It's
- 48:33not always salacious. It's more like the joyful,
- 48:35happy experience. And I ask that question because
- 48:38it feels like there's something between not just
- 48:40the love triangle, but like the character of
- 48:43Eddie and the character of Jacques and the things
- 48:46that happen in this that feel very much a pre
- 48:49-code. That when the code does come in, they
- 48:52dance around this topic a lot more delicately.
- 48:55Right. And that's the Hollywood that we've come
- 48:58to know. in like the 40s and 50s in the way that
- 49:01they depict these relationships. Right, yeah.
- 49:04It's kind of like if you were to show this movie
- 49:07to someone that doesn't normally watch older
- 49:11films, they would be shocked at the level of
- 49:14certain things you see, like Jacques' advancements
- 49:16on Queenie and things. Yep. And as you said,
- 49:19you get to the 40s and the 50s, and that's more
- 49:21of what you'd expect. being in the code era.
- 49:25Well, I think specifically about relationships
- 49:27on camera, and if you think of your Roman holidays,
- 49:33there's a romance element to it that is a lot
- 49:37more innocent than it is in these scenarios.
- 49:41It's a little more gritty, I guess. I would not
- 49:44say that Broadway Melody is gritty, but in comparison
- 49:46to those, I'd say maybe a little bit more...
- 49:48It's edgy, I guess is the word for it. But specifically,
- 49:52there's something about it that feels very raw
- 49:55without feeling that dangerous. You're referring
- 49:59to the Roman holiday feels raw? No, sorry. No,
- 50:03that there's more in the Broadway melody that
- 50:05feels like kind of like a rawness to the idea.
- 50:07Yeah. Where it's more fabricated, but we've embraced
- 50:11that fabrication. later on of like, that's not
- 50:14how love is, but like, that's what we want love
- 50:16to be. Right. Whereas this, it feels kind of
- 50:19like that is actually how love is. It's messy.
- 50:20It's like dangerous. It's weird. Yeah. But the
- 50:23way it's portrayed here just doesn't paint people
- 50:25in the best light, i .e. Eddie. Right. And I
- 50:28think when the code is enacted, you get to movies
- 50:32showing these same themes, but they have to be
- 50:34creative in how they present them. Totally. So
- 50:37in this, it's like Jacques made an advancement
- 50:40and that is what you're going to see. Yeah. There's
- 50:44adultery or whatever, and that's exactly what
- 50:47we're going to show you. Yeah. Still, you know,
- 50:49to a very, I don't know, modest audience, I guess,
- 50:53but you're still seeing it just blatant. One
- 50:56thing I'm really excited for in the coming weeks
- 50:59and months is that you mentioned there's a lot
- 51:02of remakes, right? Sequels, whatever it might
- 51:04be, even the Broadway melody of 1930, whichever
- 51:07ones they were. There's a time where these movies
- 51:11that are being remade are being remade after
- 51:13the code, right? So there's pre -code and then
- 51:16post -code or mid -code. So I'm very interested
- 51:19in going back and watching these movies and discussing
- 51:22them with you in terms of how they compare to
- 51:24their pre -code counterparts. Because that's
- 51:26going to show directly what they did not think
- 51:28was acceptable for the Hollywood image at that
- 51:31time. Yeah. Pre -code is a whole genre in itself
- 51:35that I'd want to dive more into. Because we're
- 51:38talking about it now with the Broadway melody,
- 51:39and this is very tame compared to what some other
- 51:43pre -code films are. But you're right. I'm excited
- 51:47to see the remake specifically and how they present
- 51:52some of the same themes and topics in a kind
- 51:55of skirting the line way. Right. I mean, we talked
- 51:59about it off pod, but I picked up a criterion
- 52:01of His Girl Friday. And that, of course, is going
- 52:04to make its way to the Academy Awards in its
- 52:06respective year. But it came with a bonus Blu
- 52:10-ray disc, which, I mean, Criterion's giving
- 52:12away bonus Blu -rays is just, you know, God's
- 52:15work. Thank you. They are, go listen to our Lost
- 52:17Media episode. They included the pre -code version
- 52:21of that movie, the original version, which is
- 52:23the front page. So it's going to be very interesting
- 52:26for us to do our research, which, again, that
- 52:28is also going to be in the talks when we get
- 52:30to the year. I think it's 1931, where it is nominated.
- 52:35So we will have the ability, and on this podcast,
- 52:37to have an episode where we do talk about these
- 52:39pre -code films and then their counterparts later
- 52:43on that were affected by the code. So it's interesting
- 52:46to see how that breaks up. Yeah, I think that
- 52:49is not only our first example of pre -code to
- 52:53code remake. But just remake in general. So that's
- 52:57going to be a fun two episodes spaced like a
- 53:00year apart, I think. Maybe we'll do a Patreon
- 53:03episode after the His Girl Friday episode where
- 53:07we kind of like split the two. Yeah. And talk
- 53:09about those specifically. Yeah, that would be
- 53:10cool. I think they fall in the same year. I think
- 53:1331 and 40 will end in the same like calendar
- 53:15year. Oh, yeah. Okay. So that'll be cool. I was
- 53:17going to say, I know you're wrong. It's like
- 53:19nine years between the two movies. But yeah,
- 53:21I hear you. Yeah. As far as the show goes. Yeah.
- 53:23I want to bring up two real quick things, and
- 53:26then we can get into ratings. We didn't mention
- 53:28the studio that produced this. It's MGM. Yes.
- 53:30Funny enough, the last film we're talking about
- 53:33for this round of the Oscars, also an MGM production,
- 53:36also partly a musical, The Hollywood Review of
- 53:401929. So two big MGM musicals, and that's kind
- 53:44of what MGM has come to be known as. the musical
- 53:49studio. So that'll be fun to talk about in regards
- 53:53to just MGM pumping out musicals around this
- 53:56time period. Right. The other thing I wanted
- 53:58to bring up is Arthur Freed was head of music
- 54:02in this movie. And while we didn't have a ton
- 54:04of praise for the music other than the Broadway
- 54:06melody, he later goes on to do music for some
- 54:11big films that we'll be covering on the show,
- 54:13An American in Paris and Gigi. Big names attached
- 54:17to this movie that we are going to talk about
- 54:19more in depth later just didn't add a whole lot
- 54:23to the discussion today. Well, I mean, that's
- 54:26what I think is really interesting about this
- 54:28is that we kind of see the beginning of these
- 54:29people, right? Like the beginning of what they're
- 54:31fully capable of because. I'm a big believer
- 54:34that you kind of have to go through it to fully
- 54:37experience it. And in order to manage something,
- 54:39you have to go through all the steps below so
- 54:41you know what you're managing. So I think being
- 54:44involved in these movies and being nominated,
- 54:46that's awesome. But you have to go through it
- 54:48to really find what you truly want to do. And
- 54:50it makes sense that there's things that Arthur
- 54:52Freed does later on that make a little bit more
- 54:54of an impact than they did here. Yeah. And this
- 54:57movie could have been the catalyst for all of
- 55:01these people to go on and do bigger projects.
- 55:03We didn't mention this, but this is the Outstanding
- 55:06Picture winner of this year. So that alone could
- 55:09be the entire reason we have an American in Paris.
- 55:12I understand what you're saying now. I honestly
- 55:14thought you meant there's an American correspondent
- 55:17in Paris right now. I was like, just one? Yeah,
- 55:19but we don't talk about him. It's top secret.
- 55:21Good luck, bud. Jacques. Oh, God, I hope not.
- 55:24I almost spit out my coffee. We do not want Jacques
- 55:26to represent us. Anybody. Over there. I don't
- 55:29want him to represent anybody. Let's talk about
- 55:31ratings now. Yeah. I've gotten better about Letterboxd.
- 55:34This is not a joke. Every time I feel like I'm
- 55:37going to say this, I was talking with someone
- 55:38the other day and they asked for my Letterboxd
- 55:41account and I gave it to them. And then the next
- 55:43day that I saw them, they said, you got to get
- 55:45your numbers up, dog. Yeah. And I was like, that
- 55:48is the worst. Like, that's an offensive thing
- 55:50that you just said to me. But, I mean, he's right.
- 55:53And the problem is that for the longest time
- 55:55using Letterboxd, I didn't know that you had
- 55:57to, like, do anything other than like put the
- 55:59star review and then press done. You have to
- 56:01like review and log. Yes. And that way people
- 56:03can see it. And you get your nice diary. Yeah,
- 56:06exactly. And so then I'm going back and I'm like,
- 56:08there are so many movies that I have seen that
- 56:10I don't have on my diary because I haven't reviewed
- 56:13and logged them. I just put the star. So disappointing.
- 56:16I promise I'm a cinema head, but so I'm point
- 56:20is I'm doing that now. Like very, very regularly
- 56:22doing that. So for the Broadway melody, I did
- 56:26think about how we talked about how we wanted
- 56:29to rate these, right? And I think that for the
- 56:33achievement of what it's done and how it birthed
- 56:36this idea of what musicals can, should, and do
- 56:41ultimately become to be, I wanted to give it
- 56:43a lot of credit. But as an enjoyment factor,
- 56:46I can't say that I enjoyed my time with this
- 56:48movie that much. There's aspects that come and
- 56:51go. There's moments where I was kind of expecting,
- 56:54like, you know, they go and have a musical number,
- 56:56and I'm like, hit me like White Christmas. Like,
- 56:58hit me right now with something that's just like
- 57:00a tearjerker, just like a great musical number,
- 57:02and then we get back to the story. And it's just
- 57:04kind of, there is a musical number, but it's
- 57:06not going to resonate with you the way that other
- 57:08musicals later on tend to do. So I ultimately
- 57:12landed on 2 .5. Okay. Two and a half stars. for
- 57:15me on this one. It's not a bad movie by any means.
- 57:19It's just, it kind of meanders a little bit for
- 57:21a while. Like you said, the narrative is extremely
- 57:24thin and it does go on for an hour and 40 minutes.
- 57:26It does make it feel a bit longer than it should
- 57:29be. Right. I think technically in old Arizona
- 57:32was just about as long and that flew by for me.
- 57:36Yes, I agree. We're going to keep up the trend
- 57:40of your reviews being higher than mine. This
- 57:43did change from when I originally watched it.
- 57:45Like I said, I don't know what I was feeling
- 57:48that day, but I was like, the Broadway melody.
- 57:51You were doing the dance, I remember. Yeah, but
- 57:54this time it just, it kind of fell flat with
- 57:56me. I would say the highlight of this movie beyond
- 57:59that one musical hook that I've now sang like
- 58:03six times, which is probably the same amount
- 58:06that Eddie does in the first 10 minutes of the
- 58:08movie. Yeah. Beyond that and Bessie Love having
- 58:11some really fun. dialogue uh little quips i wish
- 58:15i could remember any of them beyond that this
- 58:18movie's not it's not great for me it's it's sing
- 58:21its praises for it being the first and all of
- 58:23that but as far as entertainment goes i'm giving
- 58:26it a two stars two star geez yeah no there's
- 58:29stars anyway there's plural i love i i really
- 58:33want to make that spreadsheet of our ratings
- 58:35because it's so funny to me that your ratings
- 58:37are all higher than mine i i think the problem
- 58:39is that you've been here before And I'm like,
- 58:42I want to give you credit for what you've done
- 58:44here, but I do want to make sure you know that
- 58:46I didn't like the movie that much. Right. And
- 58:48you're just like, nah, dog. That's a no from
- 58:50me. I'm like, Ryan, you should come on this podcast
- 58:53and talk old movies and open your mind to what
- 58:57these movies provide for us on an intellectual
- 59:01level. Also, I don't like these movies. Also,
- 59:04they suck. I'm glad you are enjoying them. Hey,
- 59:06that brings up a good point, though. These are
- 59:09like... The first musical, the first Western
- 59:11film outdoors. Yeah. And all of that. First,
- 59:14first, first. Next year, we're not going to be
- 59:16able to say that anymore. So we can't use that
- 59:19as a kind of like a crutch to alter our feelings
- 59:23on the movie. That's where the one stars come
- 59:25out. You think that's going to start happening?
- 59:27I mean, realistically. Yeah. Like, you know,
- 59:29it's, I'm sure if I know myself well enough,
- 59:32what's going to happen, and you guys can quote
- 59:34me on this, is that next year, next month. I'm
- 59:38going to be a little bit meaner, but mostly just
- 59:43be like, you know what? It's still early on.
- 59:45You guys are still figuring it out. I get it.
- 59:47When we get to 1935, I'm like, you know better.
- 59:50What are you doing? Why are you doing this? One
- 59:52star. So we'll see. But I want to grade these
- 59:55the way that I think of a miserable experience.
- 59:59And if I'm rating anything a 0 .5, it must have
- 1:00:03been threatening to kill my family. What is it
- 1:00:07doing? yes so and don't get me wrong i've seen
- 1:00:09movies that have made me feel like it's threatening
- 1:00:11to kill my family so i have rated things 0 .5
- 1:00:13so i will we'll see but uh right now it's still
- 1:00:17it's there it's fun it's enjoyable it's really
- 1:00:20nice to have on in the background but it's not
- 1:00:22great yeah so i probably would be happily live
- 1:00:27in the two to two uh two and a half stars yes
- 1:00:29that we have given it Yeah, because like you
- 1:00:31said, none of these movies are bad. Yeah, not
- 1:00:33yet. I've not had a bad experience. Even if these
- 1:00:35weren't the first of their kind, they're fine.
- 1:00:39Yeah. And it's not even the movie that I like
- 1:00:41the least that we will talk about for this month.
- 1:00:44Interesting. Okay. That being said, that covers
- 1:00:48everything we have to say about the Broadway
- 1:00:50melody of 1929, at least. Stay tuned for the
- 1:00:52sequels. Do you want to talk about Paired? Oh,
- 1:00:55yes, yes. I almost forgot. Oh, I've got to think.
- 1:00:58Do you want me to go first so you can think?
- 1:01:01No, yes, please, if you go first. I'm not going
- 1:01:03to tell you anything that isn't going to be surprising,
- 1:01:05but everything that I wanted Broadway melody
- 1:01:09to be, it reminded me of these things in the
- 1:01:13moment. And it reminded me of, what about this
- 1:01:15great love triangle? What about this great idea
- 1:01:19of standing up for your person? What about this
- 1:01:22great idea of these musical numbers that just
- 1:01:24completely... Blow everything out of the water.
- 1:01:28Stop for a moment and just do these things. And
- 1:01:31I'm thinking of two movies. And I'm legitimately
- 1:01:33trying to decide in real time between the two.
- 1:01:36I will tell you my White Christmas. White Christmas
- 1:01:41for me. I think is the one where you really need
- 1:01:44to try and have the male counterpart shown as
- 1:01:49he has humility. And there's no part of Eddie
- 1:01:52that has that humility. But the humility is brought
- 1:01:55out by the two lead characters of White Christmas.
- 1:01:58And you have this really interesting dynamic.
- 1:02:00It's not necessarily a love triangle, but love
- 1:02:02dynamic between Bing Crosby and the two other
- 1:02:06leads. Actually, George Clooney's mom is in that
- 1:02:09movie. Oh, really? Yeah. She's one of the...
- 1:02:11I need to go back. I need to prepare these so
- 1:02:13I can say names and everything. But she is one
- 1:02:15of the leads in White Christmas. And... Just
- 1:02:20going back to it, it felt like that was a movie
- 1:02:22that did not mind having the drama and the comedy.
- 1:02:26And they'd be like, hey, by the way, almost like
- 1:02:28a variety show, here's our musical. And then
- 1:02:30just like they do a musical. And the colors pop.
- 1:02:33And it doesn't even make sense that they were
- 1:02:35able to film this on location at this cabin in
- 1:02:38Vermont. But they do it anyways because it's
- 1:02:41a musical and you can. And everything that I
- 1:02:43wanted Broadway melody to be and the notes that
- 1:02:47I wanted to hit. I saw the moments where they're
- 1:02:50like, wow, what if we did this pop of color?
- 1:02:52What if we had this romance? What if we had this
- 1:02:54like number that just completely changed the
- 1:02:56way that people thought about musicals? That's
- 1:02:58what White Christmas did. So granted, White Christmas
- 1:03:01isn't going to exist without something like Broadway
- 1:03:03Melody. But I think that's a really good pairing
- 1:03:06to kind of see like how it should have started
- 1:03:08or how it started and what they wanted to do
- 1:03:10and how we got to a point where we could do those
- 1:03:12things a little bit more effectively. I like
- 1:03:15it. But also handle the idea of like, you know,
- 1:03:16there's a lot of toxic masculinity inside of
- 1:03:19Eddie and Jock. Yes. And I think there's some
- 1:03:22masculinity that's a bit toxic in White Christmas
- 1:03:24that is immediately kind of like put on display
- 1:03:27and spotlight and kind of made fun of a little
- 1:03:29bit by the male counterpart to Bing Crosby's
- 1:03:32character. So there's like a little bit of like
- 1:03:35delight in like them still kind of showcasing
- 1:03:37that toxicity. Okay. I've never seen White Christmas.
- 1:03:41Really? Yeah. I hadn't seen it up until like
- 1:03:43four years ago. And then when I did, it was kind
- 1:03:45of just like, oh, I've missed out. I think December
- 1:03:50is a perfect time to watch musicals. So for me,
- 1:03:54that just felt like the perfect combination of
- 1:03:56Christmas, musical, but could be a classic you
- 1:03:59could watch at any time. Bing Crosby and his
- 1:04:01actions aside. Right. Yeah, I think this is going
- 1:04:05to be the year then that I watch White Christmas.
- 1:04:07Yeah. I probably won't do the double feature.
- 1:04:09I like Broadway melody more. Yeah. Melody. Man,
- 1:04:13you know, I was really trying to think of a good
- 1:04:15double feature, and I should have prepared for
- 1:04:18this. I'm definitely preparing before the next
- 1:04:19episode. But I think— I mean, I gave you a freebie.
- 1:04:23Yeah, but I'm not taking it. Good for you. I
- 1:04:26can do it myself. I'm going to go with Moulin
- 1:04:29Rouge. Oh, yeah. The love triangle in that is
- 1:04:33kind of weird because nobody really wants part
- 1:04:37of that whole isosceles. Yeah. But— It's a later
- 1:04:41musical, early 2000s. I really enjoy the music
- 1:04:44in that, so can't really compare it to the Broadway
- 1:04:46melody. The risque nature of Broadway melody
- 1:04:50lends itself to like the full risque element
- 1:04:52of Moulin Rouge. Sure. Yeah, that's a good point.
- 1:04:55And I don't know, this feels kind of like a shallow
- 1:04:58double feature. I just picked another musical
- 1:05:01that I like that has a love triangle. Well, you
- 1:05:04know, I think I always like to find the connection
- 1:05:06beyond that because, yeah, you can't just say
- 1:05:08two musicals. That's kind of what I did. But
- 1:05:10you've got to find the things between that make
- 1:05:12them linked a little bit more. And for you, I
- 1:05:14mean, there's like, again, there's a risque nature
- 1:05:16to like, oh, look, they're in their very not
- 1:05:19revealing at all undergarments in this. Isn't
- 1:05:21that crazy? Right. And then how we kind of embraced
- 1:05:24the element of like the more sexy style of musicals.
- 1:05:28Like Moulin Rouge. So there's an interesting
- 1:05:30dynamic there. Yeah. And Moulin Rouge does follow
- 1:05:33the story of them putting on a big performance
- 1:05:36and all of that. And kind of the background of
- 1:05:42creating that stage performance or whatever,
- 1:05:44that stage play, influencing the relationships
- 1:05:48of the characters. So that's what I've got. Smart.
- 1:05:51I like it. It's something. Yeah. I think that's
- 1:05:54going to do it for this episode. We're running
- 1:05:56a little bit long, which is surprising for the
- 1:05:57Broadway Melody. If you'd like to support the
- 1:05:59show, follow us on Patreon .com slash OUTAOPodcast.
- 1:06:06And if you would like to write into the show
- 1:06:07and give us your thoughts and feelings on musicals
- 1:06:09in general or the Broadway Melody or any other
- 1:06:11movie that we're covering on the show, shoot
- 1:06:13us an email at OUTAOPodcast at gmail .com. We'll
- 1:06:18read those on the ceremony episodes. And social
- 1:06:21media, you can follow us there. The links will
- 1:06:23be in the show notes. What is it? Once Upon a
- 1:06:25Time at the Oscars on most things. O -U -T -A
- 1:06:27-O podcast on other things. And I think that's
- 1:06:31it. That's it. Next episode, we'll be covering
- 1:06:34Alibi, another early gangster film. Two more
- 1:06:37episodes of this Oscar year before we get to
- 1:06:40our ceremony. Yep, yep. Hope you're looking forward
- 1:06:42to that. Hope you're watching the movies along
- 1:06:44with us. A quick reminder, if you want to watch
- 1:06:47these early films, you can head over to the Once
- 1:06:50Upon a Time at the Oscars YouTube page, and I've
- 1:06:53saved a list of all of these movies that you
- 1:06:56can watch on YouTube with the correct soundtrack
- 1:06:59and scores. Yeah, he looked directly in my eyes
- 1:07:01as he said that, by the way. I did. So check
- 1:07:04us out there. But that's going to do it for this
- 1:07:07week's episode. As always, I'm your host, Kyle.
- 1:07:09And I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the movies.