Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Kennerspiel des Jahres Special-Interview with Matt Leacock on Daybreak
Transcript
- 0:00Freshly dug from the cold face of the board game world, we bring you
- 0:06five games for Doomsday News. So I'm delighted to have in the virtual five
- 0:14games for Doomsday Studio. Matt Leecock, co designer of one of the Kenshpielder
- 0:19Gjaris nominees Daybreak Math, thank you for joining me. Hey, thanks for
- 0:22having me. And if anyone watched the previous Ticket to Ride legacy video,
- 0:28the fact that we're wearing exactly the same clothing is just a pure coincidence.
- 0:33So my first question is, then, is how did you get on board
- 0:38with the Daybreak project? Because, if I'm correct, Mateo Menapache, the
- 0:42co designer, approached you, am I right now. Actually, I had
- 0:46started working on a climate change climate crisis game prior to that. It just
- 0:52started though. I've been challenged by a climate scientist in Scotland to come up
- 0:57with a pandemic version that was about the climate crisis, and I rejected that
- 1:02I didn't think pandemic was a good fit. So I started working on a
- 1:06new one, and I saw Mateo on Twitter actually and reached out, and
- 1:10shortly after we had a meeting, and that meeting turned into a weekly meeting
- 1:14and pretty soon we were working on a game together. And so why did
- 1:17you What was it about Mateo's Twitter presence that made you reach out to him?
- 1:22He had posted so he had seen my op ed on New York Times
- 1:26about like what pandemic can teach it about the pandemic and saw a parallel with
- 1:30the climate crisis that you know, what can games teach us about the climate
- 1:33crisis? And reference pandemic? I'm like, Oh, here's a guy who
- 1:37understands games and want you know, sees an opportunity for a game about climate.
- 1:42So yeah, it turns out he does workshops, designs cooperative games and
- 1:49presents workshops and so on. So he had game design cred and the interest,
- 1:53and we saw that our goals were very much in a line. So
- 1:56it's great. Up, it was a great fine. So how long was
- 2:00it after meeting that you realize that you that you were two people who could
- 2:06work together because sometimes, you know, you think the same way, you
- 2:09agree the same way, but when the rubber meets the road, it can
- 2:12be difficult to have a working relationship. How long was it until you realize
- 2:15that this could be fruitful and profitable. Well, I think we hit it
- 2:21out right away. You never really know, and so I think we cautiously
- 2:23stepped forward and you know, in good faith, and things just went very
- 2:27smoothly. We had very complimentary skill sets, and he was a very good
- 2:30communicator, and we were able to navigate the time zone difference because Materio's in
- 2:35London. And yeah, it just worked well. And so I played Daybreak
- 2:42quite a lot. And you can definitely see your fingerprints on the game.
- 2:49It feels like a matt Leecock cooperative game. I don't think it feels like
- 2:53Pandemic, but certainly you know, you have a designer's voice that is that
- 2:59is audible in How did you split up the process of designing the game between
- 3:04each other. I don't think there was a whole lot of splitting up when
- 3:09it came to the design. There was a lot of integration where we were
- 3:14like, we might explore different aspects of it, but we were talking quite
- 3:17a bit about the core design. I mean, the core design, ultimately
- 3:21in what you see in the game is fairly simple. I don't know,
- 3:24It's not this big, massive, sprawling design, I guess, And so
- 3:30we were able to kind of like hone that, but it took a long
- 3:31time to get there. There were certain things we did split up though.
- 3:35Mitto's very technically inclined, so he would set up like massive databases for keeping
- 3:39track of all the data in the game, which was a huge win because
- 3:43there's like over one hundred thousand words in the game, a lot of research
- 3:47to manage, a lot of contacts to manage, so that was a huge
- 3:51relief. He kind of took on the role that I often do in game
- 3:55partnerships of a lead role in like maintaining the documentation and so on, and
- 4:01was really a great spearhead for research, especially when it came to the EU,
- 4:06so that was hugely beneficial. And they also helped develop like the game
- 4:14in tabletop. I'm trying to think which in the online remote testing environments,
- 4:19because we were using those for this, which is kind of unique for one
- 4:23of my designs. I'd not done any online playtesting before, and so when
- 4:29you play the game, it's clear that it feels now I am scientifically illiterate,
- 4:34so you could you could string a couple of multi syllable words together and
- 4:40I would believe that it's a real thing, but it feels very plausible.
- 4:43The technological solutions within the game. How much research was there to making the
- 4:49game feel plausible and realistic, and how how realistic is it to current scientific
- 4:57thinking. Yeah, this is different from any other game on and that We
- 5:00started with the research first. So, like amongst our goals, the first
- 5:04goal was like, we want to make a fun game. We don't want
- 5:06to make a quote educational game because no one's going to want it. You
- 5:10don't want to play it, then it doesn't matter how good it is as
- 5:12far as like, you know, how close it is to the topic.
- 5:15So uh, you know, take take a fun game as a baseline.
- 5:19We wanted basically by playing it, you would internalize sort of like the scope
- 5:25and the dynamics of the climate crisis and also show you that this is a
- 5:29problem that can be solved by people. And that's a pretty tall order.
- 5:33But we really wanted it to be realistic, not science fiction. So we
- 5:36did a lot of research, so we read a lot of books. We
- 5:39reached out to several book authors who then ended up playtesting the game, and
- 5:44several of those actually ended up providing content for the game, so that was
- 5:47a huge win. We had a board of advisors that we met with pretty
- 5:51frequently really amazing people who were like endlessly patient playing some very broken, very
- 5:58long prototypes, giving a lot of tremendously good feedback. So it's all steeped
- 6:02in research. It's not like a simulation, but it does show like all
- 6:09the proportions are correct and that the underlying model is correct. So if you're
- 6:13quite curious about what the climate crisis is all about, you can play it
- 6:16and get it and get a pretty good idea. So we live in a
- 6:19febrile world, and a lot of the febrility, if that's a word,
- 6:24is due to the idiocy of social media, the experiment of social media that's
- 6:30been performed on an unsuspecting public for the last fifteen years. And what struck
- 6:35me is that you're talking about the proportions. When you set up the game,
- 6:40each player takes a part of the world, and each part of the
- 6:44world has particular climate challenges. Was there any worry while developing the game that
- 6:48you would be criticized for the way you portrayed Asia or Africa, for instance,
- 6:54or were you just wedded to that they're a similitude of it and you
- 6:57thought we have to portray it as it really is I think our bigger concern
- 7:01was like leaving out certain parts of the world. We wanted to be as
- 7:04inclusive as possible, but we also wanted it to be true. So I
- 7:11mean, like trying to figure out like what the players represented was tricky.
- 7:16You know. We decided on the scope and the scale, on the framing
- 7:20pretty early on. We wanted to be fully cooperative, which is, you
- 7:25know, you could say as controversial. We wanted it to be a worldwide
- 7:29scope, not a like individual action, not not focused on individuals or even
- 7:33towns or cities or countries. Even it's really about I mean countries, I
- 7:39guess play a role. You got the United States in China, but you've
- 7:42also got this block Europe and the majority world that was informed by some of
- 7:45our research just looking at who the who essentially the big players are. It
- 7:49does leave some countries out, but I guess you can kind of abstract them
- 7:55into the larger hole. But yeah, there wasn't a whole lot of concern
- 7:59about are where we representing these folks and know, you know, in a
- 8:03strange way, we just try to be true and I think there's an abstraction
- 8:07there that we weren't terribly concerned, and so within the game, each player
- 8:13kind of has equal agency. I'm i'm, I'm I'm. I don't really
- 8:18tend to accept the alpha player criticism in games because I figure that if someone's
- 8:22an alpha player, that's a problem of their personality rather than the game itself
- 8:26generally. But do you think it's a realistic summation of the world situation that
- 8:33everyone from this from these different areas has equal agency in fixing the climate crisis
- 8:39or there or are there certain parts of the world that need to get in
- 8:43line because without them it'll never be solved. Yeah, I mean, I
- 8:48think there is unequal power. You've got some of these world powers actually have
- 8:52clearly more power, and I don't necessarily think that's something that we we nailed
- 8:58in the game. But when you are playing and you're the global South,
- 9:03right, you're the majority world player. It's it's quite evident when you're playing
- 9:07that you have some very big needs. Your communities can be in crisis very
- 9:13quickly. You've got massive energy demands, and you've got relatively comparable income when
- 9:20compared to and you're the majority of the world, right. It's named that
- 9:26for a reason. You're the majority of people on the planet, and you've
- 9:28got an income in the game at least that is roughly comparable to the United
- 9:31States or China. So it may not be one hundred percent accurate when it
- 9:35comes down to dollars and cents or power, but when you are playing it,
- 9:41you do see that kind of need play out, and you see the
- 9:43innerdependencies, and you see how the different world powers do need to cooperate in
- 9:48order to win. I mean, you don't technically need to cooperate in the
- 9:52game if you don't want to. It just makes it a lot harder to
- 9:54win. And so when what I was struck by is that the game doesn't
- 10:03make any slide digs at political parties, and it would be when designing a
- 10:09game like this, because I think I wouldn't ask you to comment on this,
- 10:13but I think I think without mentioning names, there are certain political entities
- 10:18that are more responsible when talking about the climate crossis and another political entities,
- 10:22and there is none of that in Daybreak. There's no snide remarks, there's
- 10:26no kind of overt partisanship shown in the game. Was that important to you
- 10:35that it remains sort of as far as it could be politically neutral. Well,
- 10:39I will say that we tried it. So we spoke with adviser.
- 10:43As I said, Bill mckibbon was actually pretty We had a conversation in whom
- 10:46I was pretty impactful and that we were trying to figure out exactly how to
- 10:52embody the antagonist of the game, and his advice was it there's like two
- 10:56main obstacles. One is inertia, and we felt like we had that pretty
- 11:01well captured. You can see how when you're playing it that the carbon accumulates
- 11:05and you have this inertial forces in the game. They're pretty well evident.
- 11:09The other was the fossil fuel industry as an active antagonist, and we try
- 11:13to embody them in the crisis deck, so you'll see cards for fossil fuel
- 11:18misinformation, all sorts of cards related to that. About twenty percent of that
- 11:22deck is that and that was bolsterred after that conversation with him, because that
- 11:26is an actual negative force. We did stay straight out of the political realm,
- 11:33although you'll see that there's a crisis card that ventures into that territory.
- 11:39Yeah, so I don't. We definitely didn't want to make this game a
- 11:43satire. We just wanted to show what needed to be done, and so
- 11:46we embodied that and tried to communicate that really clearly and cleanly, rather than
- 11:52trying to have you know, some kind of snide digs so's we ended up
- 12:00with and so on on furthering that, then, have you had any pushback
- 12:05from people, firstly for just dealing with the topic at all, or you
- 12:09know, people climate change denials or people who have political issues with the game.
- 12:16Have you had any pushback on the game since spin out? I'm surprisingly
- 12:22little. I've only gotten one hate email, which I was like, oh
- 12:26great, you know, I was kind of excited to see that, because
- 12:28it just meant that we were our reach was increasing, and that people felt
- 12:33it was important enough to actually, you know, write that kind of an
- 12:35email. And what did the email say? Without I can't repeat it here.
- 12:39You can leave the explete anxiet. You can just do crazy with There
- 12:43wouldn't be a whole lot left to talk about nice to say. They didn't
- 12:46want, you know, they wanted my kids to run away with my wife
- 12:48and leave me something like that. Yeah, crazy stuff like that. So
- 12:52I found it. Yeah, I put that in my memorybilia file right away.
- 12:56But yeah, and then I think our big concerned it was not that.
- 13:01It was more about like, do we get the science right that are
- 13:03there climate scientists are saying, hey, look, you know you're teaching something
- 13:05that's not true. That was a horrifying idea to us. And for the
- 13:11most part, the response from that community has been really, really positive,
- 13:16very heartfelt responses. In that regard, you might quibble over like a specific
- 13:22card, you know, are we representing nuclear or some other contrac you know,
- 13:26like geo engineering in the correct way, But those have been just at
- 13:28the margins and very small things. And so what struck me about the game
- 13:33is you can lose the game, right, which is essentially a pessimistic outcome.
- 13:39But what struck me is from the product design, the colors, the
- 13:41way it looks on the table, to the way the game plays, the
- 13:46agency that you have, it seems to be an optimistic game. Was it
- 13:50important that it wasn't just doom laden and pessimistic? Oh yeah, hundre percent.
- 13:58I mean that was one of the the visions for the product was to
- 14:01show both the scope and scale something you get from a lot of climate news,
- 14:07and it's very dumerism, right. You don't see the way out.
- 14:11So we want to show that and show that it is an important problem and
- 14:13that you can lose, and typically we expect you to lose the first game,
- 14:18but we also want to show that it's possible, and that's something that's
- 14:22very important I think in climate communication that look that you know, if we
- 14:26do something about it this, you know we can handle it. And then
- 14:30we hand that the player's agency to actually do something about that. And so
- 14:33you can play in your little sandbox and actually understand the levers and their relative
- 14:37importance, and you can experiment and then you basically internalize the forces that are
- 14:43required in order to win and the forces in play that would result in a
- 14:46loss, and then you become, you know, much more conversant in climate
- 14:50matters. So but that positive aspect that you're talking about is central to the
- 14:56design and help inform a lot of the art direction that Alex hey go see
- 15:03mi Kay did such a tremendous job. He and his partner Kristen just knocked
- 15:09out of the park with that. And so you've designed games about disease transmission
- 15:18and now you designed games about the climate crisis. Do you do you feel
- 15:24like you want to design games that are about topics of weightiness. Do you
- 15:31do you feel that you can express something to the gaming public through your work.
- 15:37I think that's certainly possible. I look at the projects I take on
- 15:41a kind of a case by case basis. I don't think I necessarily like
- 15:46deciding this is all I want to do. So a number of people have
- 15:50approached me about, hey, let's make a game about the healthcare system of
- 15:54the United States or education system in the United States. I'm like, oh
- 15:56my god, that sounds like such a big problem and it sounds like so
- 16:00little fun. So I'm taking them on a case by case basis. Really,
- 16:06I think what I would say is that I I you know, as
- 16:08I work longer and longer in my career, I'm realizing that games can be
- 16:14powerful, that that games always have a point of view. They're not.
- 16:18There's just these neutral statements. Necessarily, Like a lot of people just think
- 16:21that we've come a long way. Like twenty years ago, people dismissed board
- 16:25games as oh, those are for kids, why are you playing that?
- 16:26Right? So we've come a long way there, and at least now we
- 16:30understand them as media. I don't, you know, I don't do these
- 16:37trying to express something as art. But I think I do think there's a
- 16:41lot of potential in doing meaningful games, and so I like to evaluate projects
- 16:47now. And I'm like, why am I in? You know, I'm
- 16:49fortunate enough that I can kind of pick projects, So I look a little
- 16:52bit more of it, my motivations and what kind of message that the games
- 16:57will will have. So I guess I'm just more selective and I see a
- 17:00lot I recognize a little bit more power in that regard. And so if
- 17:03anyone's watched the previous Ticket to Ride video, they know that you watched the
- 17:07stream when the when the game's re announced, did you expect Daybreak to be
- 17:11nominated? I hoped it would be nominated. I really think it breaks a
- 17:17lot of ground when it comes to a game that's sort of adjacent to a
- 17:21series game, something that has an underlying purpose. I think it does a
- 17:26lot of great things when it comes to like the environmental how we thought about
- 17:30the packaging and all the components in it in a sustainable way from the get
- 17:33go, And I thought it was actually an innovative game. So I thought
- 17:37that it had a lot of things, you know, pulling for it.
- 17:38The people on the jury seem to like it, so, you know,
- 17:42I was hoping and I really think that it shows a way for what games
- 17:51can do. So I think it would be great if it got recognized in
- 17:53that regard. So if it wins on Sunday, it's announced and daybreaks the
- 17:57Kennish Bridles Jars winner and then when they talk about why it wins, they
- 18:03talk about its important message and how this is a pressing concern for the rest
- 18:07of the world. Will there be a part of you that thinks, no,
- 18:12it should be recognized primarily as an enjoyable play experience as opposed to the
- 18:19message that it's selling. Or are those things completely so entwined that they're indivisible.
- 18:25I would hope that they'd be entwined, because that was the goal.
- 18:27You know, we really wanted to create a product that hobby you know,
- 18:32actually gamers people would really enjoy, right, But at the same time,
- 18:37we wanted to capture folks that were interested, curious, you know, care
- 18:42about the climate crisis as well, and really want to hit that intersection as
- 18:47hard as we could, so we could you know, pull in book both
- 18:48camps and so I don't really necessarily care what their motivations are. If they
- 18:55omminated, if that's wonderful, because I do think, honestly, I think
- 18:57they would be doing I don't think they would ever nominate it if it didn't
- 19:00work as a game. That's their fundamental, their fundamental thing. I think
- 19:04the other stuff is maybe a reinforcer, gravy, maybe another reason to lift
- 19:08it up, but I don't think that would be their primary motivation. So
- 19:12one last question, then, how optimistic are you that we'll get out of
- 19:17this climate debacle that we're in. Well, I mean it ebbs and flows.
- 19:23Let me say that there are certain political developments that could be really bad,
- 19:29but then there's certain technological developments that are amazing. If you look at
- 19:33the growth of solar just being I was just reading some miracles about that.
- 19:37It's just mind blowing how it's exceeding our projections. So I think it's going
- 19:41to be very messy, but I think we all have to not let perfect
- 19:45be the enemy, be good and just keep doing the work and keep talking
- 19:48about it. And if that happens, then I'd say I'm more optimistic than
- 19:55pessimistic. But it's a bit of a roller coaster. Excellent, Well,
- 20:00thank you very much. Hey, thanks for having me. You can support
- 20:03the show by going to patreon dot com. Forward slash five g D,
- 20:07thank you for listening.