Latest / The Order of the Tile: Secrets from the American Mahjong Table / The best discard is the one no one expects.

Transcript

The best discard is the one no one expects. · The Order of the Tile: Secrets from the American Mahjong Table

0:26
My dearest table guests, welcome back.
0:30
This is the order of the tile, and I am Prim.
0:35
You are invited to enjoy issue #9 and this week your inboxes
0:39
were full of mothers and daughters and weekend tables,
0:43
and Prim has read everyone. The best discard is the one no
0:47
one expects. Prim is writing this on the
0:50
Thursday after Mother's Day and the pages of this newsletter a
0:55
full to the margin with the things you sent in over the
0:57
weekend. Photos of mothers and daughters
1:01
sitting down to play for the first time.
1:03
Photos of sets that were gifts from one generation to another.
1:07
A4 table set up in a backyard in Tulsa where three grown
1:11
daughters had surprised their mother with the mahjong brunch
1:14
she did not ask for but apparently wanted a single photo
1:20
from a woman in Portland. That was just two racks, 2 cups
1:24
of tea and the caption. First game with Mum and she kept
1:29
the extra tile. Prim read them all and cried a
1:32
little professionally and then got to work on this issue.
1:39
The thing Prim keeps thinking about as she sorts through your
1:42
weekend is how much of Mother's Day at a mahjong table is about
1:47
the unexpected. The mother who had never picked
1:50
up a tile, who turned out to be a natural.
1:53
The grown daughter who had avoided the game for years and
1:56
finally said yes. The sister who was only there to
1:59
watch, who ended up playing four hands.
2:03
The game has a way of producing surprise, and the community this
2:07
week has been full of it. Prim would like that to be the
2:10
spine of this issue because the tagline she has been carrying
2:14
all week is exactly about this. The best discard is the one no
2:19
one expects. The surprise is the point.
2:23
The game that can surprise you can be learnt by anyone at any
2:27
age, at any table, and can surprise the players who think
2:32
they have seen it all. We will talk about the backup
2:36
hand, which is the single most important unglamorous concept on
2:40
the 2026 card. We will talk about teaching new
2:43
players without killing the thing that made them curious in
2:46
the 1st place. We will meet one of the most
2:49
patient and skilled teachers of adult beginners in the country.
2:53
We will look at the arc of tile design itself, from bone and
2:57
bamboo to the acrylic, in your case right now.
3:00
And we will spend a quiet moment with the designers who are
3:03
making the sets that will define this era of American mahjong.
3:08
Pull up your chair. The wall is built.
3:11
Let us begin. Let's get started with what
3:15
everyone is talking about. This is the draw.
3:20
The weekend was exactly what the Facebook groups had been quietly
3:23
hoping for, which is to say, full of new players and full of
3:28
patient veterans, and largely free of the usual mahjong group
3:33
arguing, not to mention a little mahjong movie time.
3:37
I hope you all enjoyed that small bonus of game delight.
3:40
Prim watch Sunday unfold on her phone and on the TV, because a
3:45
professional mahjong writer has professional obligations, and
3:49
what she saw was a community doing its best work.
3:54
Mothers who had never played were being taught by daughters
3:57
who had learned last year. Daughters who had avoided the
4:01
game for years were being invited in by mothers who had
4:04
been hoping for exactly this Sunday.
4:07
And the photos kept coming, and the captions were unusually
4:11
gentle. And Prim would like to hold onto
4:14
the mood of Sunday for as long as it will last.
4:18
One pattern Prim noticed and wants to name a surprising
4:23
number of Mother's Day posts this year came from families
4:27
where the mother was the one teaching an adult daughter, but
4:30
the daughter was the one who had suggested the lesson.
4:33
The dynamic was not My mother taught me the game, as it has
4:37
been told for decades in this community.
4:39
It was I asked my mother to finally teach me.
4:44
That is a subtle generational shift, and Prim finds it
4:48
significant. The new players coming into this
4:51
game are not waiting to be invited.
4:54
They are knocking on the door. The veterans in their lives, if
4:58
they are paying attention, are opening it faster than they used
5:02
to. This is how a community grows.
5:06
It grows because the incoming generation asks and the outgoing
5:10
generation answers, and the answer is finally, reliably,
5:15
warmly yes. The other major event of the
5:20
week is a boat destination. Mahjong's Mediterranean cruise
5:26
aboard the Celebrity Ascent departs tomorrow, and Prim has
5:29
been watching her social feeds fill with pre travel photos of
5:33
packed tile cases, luggage tags, and the inevitable last minute.
5:39
Does anyone know if they have a good pusher for the ship tables
5:42
posts? This is the first major
5:45
destination Mashong event of the summer calendar and for the 100
5:49
plus players who have committed prim would like to say bon
5:53
voyage. The photos from the
5:56
Mediterranean Mashong sessions will flood your feed for the
5:59
next 10 days. Enjoy them, be gracious, try not
6:03
to get too jealous. Save the screenshots.
6:07
The cruise circuit is one of the most distinctive features of
6:10
this community in 2026, and watching it from shore is part
6:15
of the experience for the rest of us.
6:19
One quiet piece of news from the teaching side of the community.
6:23
Several of the instructors Prim follows have reported a clear
6:27
bump in class registrations this week, and the pattern is
6:30
consistent. The new students are adult women
6:35
who attended a Mother's Day game on Sunday, loved it, and then
6:39
went looking for a proper lesson on Monday.
6:42
This is exactly the hand off the community hopes for between a
6:46
casual introduction and a real relationship with the game.
6:50
If you are a teacher reading these pages, check your inbox.
6:55
Your spring class may be about to fill.
6:58
If you are a new player who is considering a class, the demand
7:02
is high and the good teachers are booking out move this week.
7:07
Which brings us to crack the card.
7:10
The backup hand on the 2026 card.
7:14
Prim has been sitting with a concept all week that she has
7:17
been trying to get into these pages for three issues now and
7:21
she is finally going to do it. The backup hand.
7:25
If you have never heard this phrase, it is because most
7:29
mahjong teaching is organised around the single hand you are
7:33
building, the one you commit to, the one you expose.
7:37
On the 1 you close with the backup hand is the one you are
7:42
quietly watching in the background, the alternative
7:45
route your rat could take if the tiles you are hoping for never
7:49
come. And on the 2026 card, the
7:54
players who hold a backup hand alive through the middle of the
7:56
game are the players who win the most often.
7:59
Prim would like to walk you through this.
8:03
MMM, number one, what a backup hand actually is.
8:08
A backup hand is not a second plan you switch to in a panic.
8:12
It is a second pattern you are quietly reading into your own
8:15
rack as the game develops alongside your primary hand, and
8:20
it is almost always in the same family.
8:24
A backup hand is the cousin of the hand you are building.
8:29
If you are committed to a particular hand in the 2468
8:32
section, your backup is probably another hand in the same section
8:37
with one or two different tile requirements.
8:40
If you are building toward a specific consecutive runs hand,
8:44
your backup is the adjacent consecutive runs hand that
8:47
shares most of the tiles you have already collected.
8:50
The backup is not a pivot, it is a reserve.
8:55
Knowing the reserve exists is what lets you throw unexpected
8:58
tiles without fear, because you are not throwing a tile you need
9:02
for any plausible hand, you are throwing a tile you do not need
9:06
for either of the two hands you are quietly holding open.
9:11
This is the direct connection to the tagline Prim has been
9:15
carrying. The best discard is the one no
9:18
one expects, and the way you become the player who discards
9:22
unexpected tiles is by having a rack that does not commit
9:26
prematurely. A player who has a primary hand
9:30
and a backup hand can discard tiles that look random to the
9:34
rest of the table. A player with only a primary
9:37
hand discards predictably because her discards are the
9:41
tiles that do not fit the single pattern she has locked onto the
9:46
table reads her. She loses the information game
9:49
before the game is half over. The backup hand is how you stay
9:54
unreadable #2 the 2026 card rewards this posture
10:01
specifically. Here is why the backup hand is
10:05
not a universal mahjong concept, but a 2026 specific skill.
10:12
The 2026 card has an unusually high number of hand pairs that
10:17
share structural DNA. Many of the consecutive runs
10:21
hands share a spine. Several of the 2468 hands share
10:25
pairs. The singles and pairs section,
10:29
unusually, has hands that are adjacent enough that a careful
10:32
player can hold two of them open simultaneously through the first
10:36
third of the game. This is not true on every card.
10:40
On some years, the hand families are more distinct, and a backup
10:45
hand means fundamentally changing direction.
10:48
On the 2026 card, a backup hand means holding 2 closely related
10:53
hands in the same pocket, both of which are reachable with
10:57
slight variations in what the wall provides.
11:01
The practical implication is that the player who reads the
11:05
card carefully in advance and who identifies the pairs of
11:08
hands that share structure will play this year's card with a
11:12
flexibility that players who memorized only one hand at a
11:15
time will not have. This is less a game skill than a
11:20
homework skill. Before your next game, take the
11:24
card out, sit with it for 20 minutes, and map the pairs.
11:29
Which consecutive runs hand shares most of its tiles with?
11:32
Which other consecutive runs hand?
11:34
Which 2468 hand is 1 tile? Swap away from a different 2468
11:40
hand. Build a small mental library of
11:43
adjacent hand families. When the game begins, your rack
11:47
will start to sort itself into these families on its own, and
11:51
you will find that you are naturally holding two options
11:54
longer than you used to. That is the backup hand
11:57
technique in action #3 when to commit and how to commit.
12:05
The backup hand only works if you eventually let one of them
12:08
go. The player who tries to hold
12:10
three options through round 8 is not playing flexible mahjong,
12:14
she is playing indecisive mahjong, and the difference is
12:18
real. The rule of thumb Prim uses, and
12:22
which she would recommend to you, is that by the end of round
12:25
five you should have narrowed from two hands to one.
12:29
Round 5 is usually when the wall is tight enough that exposures
12:33
are starting to land and discard patterns are starting to signal
12:37
what the rest of the table is doing.
12:39
By round 5, the information has arrived.
12:42
Read it. Pick a hand.
12:45
Commit. The commitment is not a
12:49
ceremony. It is quiet.
12:51
It is internal. The tiles in your rack that
12:55
belonged only to the backup hand become immediately eligible for
12:59
discard. The tiles that belonged only to
13:02
the primary hand become tiles. You will defend your rack Titans
13:07
in one invisible motion, and from round six forward, you play
13:12
with the certainty that marks a real player.
13:16
The player across from you will not know the moment the
13:19
commitment happened. That is part of the beauty of
13:22
it. She will only notice in
13:25
retrospect that your discard suddenly stopped making sense to
13:29
her because they stopped fitting the pattern she thought you were
13:32
in. The best discard is the one no
13:35
one expects. The backup hand is how you earn
13:39
the right to make them #4 the cost of the discipline.
13:45
Prim will be honest with you. The backup hand approach costs
13:49
you something. It costs you the early feeling
13:52
of certainty. It costs you the satisfying
13:55
moment in Round 3 when you look at your rack and say, I know
13:59
exactly what I am doing now. It replaces that moment with a
14:03
longer, more ambiguous middle game where you are carrying more
14:07
in your head. Some players love this.
14:10
Some players hate it. If you are a player who enjoys
14:14
the ceremony of clean commitment, the backup hand will
14:18
feel like clutter for the first few games.
14:20
You try it, stay with it anyway. After five or six games of
14:24
running a backup, the discipline becomes background.
14:28
Your rack will feel lighter, not heavier, because you will no
14:33
longer be afraid of what you cannot control.
14:36
You will know that whatever the wall gives you, you have a path
14:39
through it. The game rewards players who can
14:42
hold complexity without anxiety. The backup hand is the training
14:47
ground for exactly that. Now this publication receives
14:53
questions, many questions. And this week the question
14:59
arrived from teachers, not students, and it came in a dozen
15:03
forms that all pointed at the same anxiety.
15:06
This is the table is asking. I finally got a new player to
15:11
the table. She is interested, she is
15:14
nervous, she is trying. And I cannot figure out how much
15:18
to teach at once without overwhelming her.
15:21
And I cannot figure out when to correct her, and I cannot figure
15:24
out whether to let her lose or to steer her toward a win.
15:28
What is the actual method? Prim has a method and she is
15:33
going to give it to you because she has now taught enough adult
15:36
beginners to be confident in what works and what does not.
15:41
This is not the method you learnt from your own teacher
15:44
necessarily. It is the method Prim has
15:47
refined from teaching Nan and so many others, and from watching
15:51
the best teachers in this community work with their own
15:54
students and from her own mistakes.
15:58
There are 4 principals. Follow them in order for
16:03
principle one, teach only what the current hand requires.
16:08
The single most common mistake experienced players make when
16:12
teaching a new player is trying to teach the whole game in the
16:16
first session. The Charleston, the card, the
16:19
hands, the jokers, the scoring, the etiquette. 6 systems, none
16:27
of which anyone absorbs on 1st exposure.
16:31
All delivered while the new player is trying not to drop her
16:33
tiles. Stop.
16:37
The new player does not need to fully understand the card on
16:40
game one. She does not need to understand
16:43
all joker nuances on game one. She doesn't need to do the
16:47
Charleston yet. She needs to understand the
16:49
tiles, the letters and numbers on the card and how the two tie
16:54
together. And finally, how to follow the
16:57
rhythm of a turn. Teach her those three things.
17:01
Play an open face hand. Everything else will be
17:05
introduced 1 concept at a time over sessions.
17:10
The patience here is not virtue, it is technique.
17:15
Principle 2. Expose your own thinking, not
17:19
hers. When you are teaching, narrate
17:23
what you are doing with your own rack.
17:25
Say out loud what you are considering, what you are
17:28
choosing and why. Do not hover over her rack and
17:33
offer suggestions about her tiles.
17:36
Do not ask her what she is going to do.
17:38
Do not quiz her on what she should do.
17:41
Chances are she couldn't tell you at first anyway.
17:45
The new player learns by watching a confident player
17:48
play, not by being coached through her own moves.
17:53
Your narration is a window into strategic thinking.
17:57
Her private struggle with her own rack is where she develops
18:00
her own judgement. Respect the privacy of her rack
18:04
as you would respect the privacy of a veteran's rack.
18:07
She will figure out more faster if you let her figure it out.
18:13
Principle Three. Let her lose early and often.
18:18
This is the principle most teachers resist, and it is the
18:22
one that matters most. The new player must be allowed
18:26
to lose games. She must be allowed to make
18:28
wrong calls. She must be allowed to walk into
18:31
the obvious trap, to expose too early, to fail to spot the
18:36
Charleston strategy that any veteran would have seen.
18:40
The losses are the teaching. Every loss produces a question,
18:46
and the question is the thing she will bring to you later, in
18:49
her own words, at a moment when she is ready to hear the answer.
18:54
If you steer her toward a win on game three, you have stolen the
18:58
loss she needed to have. You have also subtly signalled
19:04
that winning is the measure, and the new player will spend the
19:07
next year playing fragile mAh shong because she is afraid of
19:11
losing. Let her lose.
19:14
Tell her you also lost many times and that losing was how
19:19
you got good. Then play the next hand.
19:22
See Principle 4. Answer the question she actually
19:26
asks. When a new player asks a
19:29
question, answer only that question.
19:33
Do not take the question as an invitation to explain 6 adjacent
19:37
concepts. Do not use the question to teach
19:40
a mini lesson. The new players attention span
19:43
during a game is short and precious, and the question she
19:47
asked is the thing she is ready to understand.
19:51
If she asks why you threw a tile, explain that single
19:55
discard. Do not explain defensive
19:57
discarding as a concept. Do not explain the history of
20:01
the game. Do not explain the 2026 card she
20:06
asked about 1 tile. Give her one answer.
20:09
The next question will come when she is ready.
20:13
Prim will close this section with the hardest thing to say to
20:16
teachers, which is that the goal of teaching is to produce a
20:20
player who eventually does not need you.
20:23
The teachers Prim most admires are the ones whose students are
20:27
playing confident, independent mashong within a few months.
20:31
The teachers whose students are still deferential to them five
20:35
years later have, however, warmly failed.
20:40
Let your new player become her own player.
20:43
The best gift you can give her is the confidence to walk into a
20:46
table of strangers and hold her own.
20:50
That gift takes patience. The patience is the method.
20:54
The rest is details. Now, this publication makes it a
21:01
point to recognise those who distinguish themselves in the
21:04
community. Not through volume.
21:07
Heavens no. Through substance.
21:10
This is who's talking. And this week we are talking
21:14
about a teacher whose voice is the voice of the patient table.
21:18
Her name is Toby Salk, she is a long time American Ma Chong
21:23
teacher with a substantial online following, and her
21:27
teaching voice is as close to the ideal Prim has described in
21:32
the table is asking as any voice in the contemporary community.
21:37
Toby has built her practice around the adult beginner, which
21:41
is the demographic this game is attracting in the largest
21:44
numbers right now, and the pacing of her instruction, the
21:48
patience of her explanations, and the warmth of her presence
21:52
make her exactly the right feature for an issue about
21:55
teaching without overwhelm. She teaches at the speed the
22:00
student actually learns. What sets Toby apart for Prim is
22:07
that her teaching respects the actual absorption rate of a new
22:10
learner, which is slower than most teachers want to admit.
22:14
Most beginner instruction is calibrated to how fast the
22:17
teacher wishes her students would pick it up.
22:20
Toby's instruction is calibrated to how fast they actually do.
22:26
This means more games where the goal is not to close a hand, but
22:29
to practice the pacing of play. This kind of teaching looks on
22:35
the surface less impressive than a high speed curriculum that
22:39
claims to produce tournament ready players in a month.
22:42
It is in practice, significantly more effective because the
22:48
students who learn at their own speed stay with the game.
22:52
The students who are rushed tend to quit within the first year,
22:56
and the community rarely notices they were there.
23:01
The online footprint is doing quiet work.
23:04
Toby's Facebook presence and her broader online teaching
23:08
footprint have become, over the last several years, a resource
23:12
for adult beginners who are not near a local instructor and who
23:16
needs somewhere to go with their questions.
23:19
Prim would describe what she has built as an accessible
23:22
classroom, available in the kitchen of any woman who has a
23:25
phone and a beginner's curiosity.
23:29
This is the kind of infrastructure the game needs
23:31
more of, not less, and Prim would encourage any reader who
23:36
is either teaching or learning to spend some time with Toby's
23:40
content. You will find, even if you have
23:42
been playing for years, that her framing of a concept you thought
23:46
you understood will produce a fresh way of explaining it to
23:49
the next new player at your table.
23:52
Find her, follow her, send her your beginners.
23:58
If you have a new player in your life who is not ready to sign up
24:01
for a formal class but who wants a lower stakes way to start,
24:06
Toby's material is a gentle on ramp.
24:10
Her approach is the opposite of the January learner problem.
24:13
She does not deliver confident, bad advice.
24:16
She delivers patient, correct, sequenced instruction.
24:20
And she does it in a voice that feels like the voice of a friend
24:24
who happens to know the game. The community is better because
24:28
she is in it. If you have benefited from her
24:31
work, Prim would encourage you to say so publicly where she can
24:36
see it. Teachers who do this work rarely
24:39
hear back from the students they helped.
24:42
A few words from you this week would not be wasted.
24:46
And now a brief indulgence because this author believes
24:50
that one cannot play well if one does not play beautifully.
24:55
This is Tile Envy, where we cover it openly and without
25:00
apology. Prim would like to spend this
25:04
section with the people who are designing the tile faces that
25:07
you will be playing with for the next 10 years.
25:11
Because the face of the American Mahjong set is in the middle of
25:15
a quiet reinvention and the community has not quite named
25:19
what is happening. For most of the last 50 years,
25:24
the American Mahjong set looked more or less like the American
25:28
Mahjong set had always looked Traditional carvings, standard
25:33
colours, recognisable but unremarkable.
25:38
The last five years have changed this.
25:40
A generation of designers has started treating the tile face
25:44
as a canvas and the results are some of the most aesthetically
25:48
rich game objects on the market in any category.
25:52
Southern Sparrows Shih Noiseri work under Jessica Rose Creative
25:57
direction is probably the most visible example of this shift.
26:01
The tile faces carry hand illustrated floral and botanical
26:05
elements that feel at once traditional and completely
26:09
contemporary. Prim would argue that Jessica
26:12
has done more than any other single designer to demonstrate
26:16
that a tile face can be a small work of art without losing
26:19
readability. At speed.
26:22
The tiles are fast to read, the face is beautiful.
26:25
Both things are true at once, which is harder than it looks.
26:30
And the rest of the industry is studying her work, whether they
26:33
will admit it or not. The Mahjong line has taken a
26:38
different approach. 1 rooted in colour palette rather than
26:42
illustrated detail. Their spring collection this
26:46
year, and the Ranch Dusty Rose line in particular, has shown
26:50
that the emotional register of a tile set can be shifted
26:54
dramatically by chromatic choice alone.
26:57
A set in the right tones does not feel like a traditional set
27:01
in a new wrapper. It feels like a different kind
27:04
of object. Prim has played on a Mashong
27:07
line set recently and can report that the effect on the table is
27:11
real. The game feels softer, warmer,
27:15
slightly less competitive, entirely without losing the
27:19
rigor of the tiles themselves. What the brand has done with
27:23
colour is design thinking, and Prim recognises it.
27:28
Oh my mAh Shong has been doing something subtler, which is
27:32
reimagining the geometry of the tile face itself.
27:37
The proportions, the typography of the numbers, the negative
27:42
space around each symbol. These are choices most players
27:46
never notice consciously, but that register in the reading
27:50
speed and the tactile satisfaction of the set.
27:55
A well designed tile face is the difference between a set you
27:58
enjoy playing on and a set you barely register.
28:03
Oh my Ma Shong has been pushing the baseline of what a modern
28:06
American tile face can look like, and their spring and
28:10
summer drops this year have continued that work. 1/4 name
28:15
Prim wants in Your head Bespoke Garden has been doing custom
28:20
Commission work on tile faces for clients who want something
28:24
genuinely specific to their family, their home, or their
28:28
taste. The commissioned sets run in the
28:32
high 4 figures, which is not a price for everyone, but the
28:36
craftsmanship is serious and the client base is growing.
28:41
If you have ever thought about commissioning a set as an
28:44
heirloom object, Bespoke Garden is the conversation to open.
28:50
The common thread across all four of these designers is that
28:53
the tile face is no longer being treated as a neutral, functional
28:57
surface. It is being treated as the
29:01
primary design object of the set and the secondary design, the
29:05
case and rack and accessory design, is being built to
29:09
support the tile face rather than the other way around.
29:13
Prim finds this development extraordinarily encouraging.
29:18
The game is finding its contemporary visual voice, and
29:22
the players who are buying these sets are voting with their
29:24
dollars that they want the game to look like them, not like
29:27
their grandmother's mahjong closet.
29:30
Both are valid. The range is healthy, pick the
29:34
set that looks like the table you want to play at and do not
29:37
apologise for the choice. Now to matters of the calendar.
29:42
Where shall one be seen this season?
29:45
This is set your rack. Mediterranean boarding is
29:50
tomorrow. Destination Mahjong's
29:54
Mediterranean cruise aboard the Celebrity Ascent boards
29:58
tomorrow, and by the time you read the next issue, the first
30:01
tournament sessions will be underway.
30:05
For the players going Prim wishes you smooth seas and
30:08
steady tiles. For the rest of us, watch the
30:12
hashtag. The photos will be unreasonably
30:16
beautiful. The wall in the Mediterranean
30:19
shot is already a genre, and this year's crop will set the
30:23
new standard for what a mahjong cruise looks like on social. mAh
30:29
Shong Fever Las Vegas 3 weeks later The mAh Shong Fever 10th
30:36
anniversary event in Las Vegas finished three weeks ago, and
30:40
the community pulse on it has settled enough for Prim to say
30:43
something substantive. The consensus is that the event
30:48
honoured its decade well. The fields were large, the
30:52
format ran cleanly. The anniversary programming,
30:56
including the recognition of long tenured Fever participants,
31:00
struck exactly the right note. The community seems to be
31:04
particularly appreciative of the way Fever has maintained a
31:08
warmer, less intensely competitive culture than some of
31:11
the other major tournaments. Several players Prim heard from
31:16
described it as the one where you actually make friends, and
31:21
that is a reputation worth having in this community.
31:24
If you missed Vegas, the Fever calendar has additional events
31:28
throughout the year, including a late summer resort event that is
31:32
currently open for registration. The next Fever on the calendar
31:38
The next major Mahjong Fever event on the public calendar is
31:42
a destination weekend in early fall, and Prim will say now what
31:47
she said about the Mediterranean cruise last week.
31:50
The good destination events fill faster than you expect.
31:54
If Fever's warmer culture sounds like your speed, and if you have
31:57
been circling a destination event this year, the full Fever
32:01
is 1 to prioritise in your registration queue.
32:04
Full details on the Fever website.
32:07
The summer local circuit is now visible.
32:11
Prim wrote about local JCC tournaments in Issue 7 and 8,
32:16
and this week the spring and summer schedules are posting in
32:19
larger numbers across major metro areas.
32:23
Specifically, the Philadelphia mainline circuit has opened for
32:27
spring and summer dates, the Atlanta area JCCS have announced
32:32
a joint tournament weekend in late June, the Bay Area Jewish
32:36
Community Centres are running coordinated sessions through
32:39
July, and South Florida is publishing its annual summer
32:43
charity tournament calendar. The pattern Prim flagged in
32:47
earlier issues is holding. The local circuit is robust.
32:52
The destinations are the Spires. Both matter. 1 Quiet note on the
32:58
tournament economy Prim has been watching the price points of
33:02
tournaments this year, and she wants to note a gentle trend.
33:07
Entry fees at major destination events are edging upward, while
33:11
entry fees at local JCC events have held remarkably steady.
33:16
This is not a crisis and the destinations are still worth
33:20
their prices if the destination is the draw.
33:25
But the widening gap between the two tiers is worth being aware
33:28
of, particularly for players on a fixed budget who might
33:32
otherwise default to a destination event without
33:35
realising how much more accessible the local circuit has
33:38
become in relative terms. Prim will keep an eye on this
33:43
and report as it develops. Boarding tomorrow.
33:48
Destination Mahjong Mediterranean Cruise Celebrity
33:53
Ascent May 15th through 25th open destination Mahjong San
34:00
Diego. Double tournament June 5th
34:04
through 7th, Open Shriners Mahjong tournament Austin, TX.
34:11
June 20th open destination Mahjong Atlantic City August
34:17
16th through 18th open mAh Shong Fever fall destination event
34:23
open Mahjong World Championship Paris Las Vegas October 16th
34:29
through 18th Check your local JCC spring and summer local
34:34
tournament circuit Full event calendar at the order of the
34:38
tile.com. And finally, because this author
34:43
believes every player deserves at least one piece of knowledge
34:47
that makes her the most interesting person at the table.
34:50
We close with crack intelligence.
34:53
Here is a fact that Prim has been saving for the right issue,
34:58
and this one Is it. The tile you are holding in your
35:01
hand right now, whatever it is made of, is the most recent
35:05
chapter in a material history that goes back nearly 400 years.
35:11
Mashong's predecessor games, and later Mashong itself, have been
35:16
played with tiles carved from bone, bamboo, ivory, horn,
35:21
shell, glass, bakelite, catalin, celluloid, polystyrene, urea,
35:30
ABS, plastic, and finally, in most modern American sets,
35:37
acrylic. Each of those materials changed
35:40
the game in ways the players who adopted them did not fully
35:44
understand at the time. Prim would like to walk you
35:47
through the arc because the material is not incidental.
35:51
The material is part of the play.
35:55
The earliest mahjong tiles, in the game's late 19th century
36:00
Chinese form, were carved from bone, often in two layers, with
36:05
a bamboo backing glued to the bone face.
36:09
The craftsmanship was painstaking.
36:12
A single set could take a skilled artisan weeks to
36:15
produce. The tiles were heavy,
36:18
beautifully tactile, and extraordinarily expensive by the
36:21
standards of the time, which meant that the game was
36:24
initially a pursuit of families who could afford artisan made
36:28
goods. The bone and bamboo aesthetic is
36:32
what the Western imagination still associates with authentic
36:36
Mashong, and there is something to that association.
36:41
Many of the most beautiful vintage sets in collectors hands
36:44
today are bone and bamboo, and the feel of those tiles on a
36:48
table is distinctive. They click differently.
36:52
They warm to the hand differently.
36:55
They are, in a word, alive. The transition to American
37:01
mahjong in the 1920s coincided with a broader material
37:05
revolution. Bakelite, one of the first
37:09
synthetic plastics, had been invented in 19 O 7, and by the
37:14
1920s it was being used in everything from telephones to
37:18
jewellery to, yes, mahjong tiles.
37:23
The American market in particular embraced Bakelite
37:27
tiles because they could be produced faster, coloured more
37:30
boldly, and sold at a price point that let the game move
37:34
from a curiosity to a mass market phenomenon.
37:39
The Abercrombie and Fitch sets from the 1920s boom, which Prim
37:44
covered in letter three, were often Bakelite.
37:47
The look and feel of those tiles defined what a modern American
37:51
set was supposed to be. Chris Lloyd, based in
37:56
Providence, RI, became one of the most important American
37:59
producers of Mashang tiles in the mid century period and
38:04
remains A notable manufacturer today.
38:07
They're tiles made from a modern resin that descends
38:10
aesthetically from the Bakelite era, have the density and
38:14
clarity of colour that longtime players associate with a serious
38:18
American set. If you have a set that feels
38:22
slightly heavier than a standard acrylic set, and if the colours
38:26
have a certain saturation that is hard to replicate, there is a
38:29
good chance you are holding something in the Chris Lloyd
38:32
family or something inspired by it.
38:35
Prim would like more players to know Chris Lloyd by name.
38:39
The company has been shaping the American tile aesthetic for
38:42
longer than most contemporary brands have existed.
38:48
The shift to acrylic, which dominates the current market,
38:52
happened gradually over the last 40 years.
38:55
Acrylic is lighter than the older resin based tiles.
38:59
It is easier to manufacture in high volumes.
39:02
It takes paint and engraved detail well.
39:05
It is importantly cheaper, which has allowed the modern custom
39:11
design Renaissance prim discussed in Tile Envy above.
39:15
The designers working today can afford to iterate, prototype,
39:20
and release limited runs precisely because the underlying
39:23
material is accessible. The trade off is that acrylic is
39:28
slightly less weighted in the hand than the older sets, and
39:31
some players prefer the feel of the older tile.
39:35
Both preferences are valid. The point is that the tile in
39:39
your hand is the product of 100 years of material choices, and
39:43
each choice has changed the play of the game in ways that are
39:47
worth noticing. The thing Prim wants you to take
39:51
away from this section beyond the history, is a small ritual.
39:57
The next time you sit down to play, pick up a tile and hold it
40:01
for three seconds before you set it in your rack.
40:04
Feel the weight, feel the surface, feel the temperature,
40:09
which will always be slightly cooler than your hand.
40:12
You are holding a small piece of the long history of human craft.
40:16
Miniaturized into a 2 inch rectangle and pass through your
40:20
life as part of a game that was being played before your
40:23
grandmother was born. The tile has a history.
40:28
The history is part of the game. The best discard is the one no
40:34
one expects, and the tile you are about to throw is older than
40:37
any of us and will outlast most of what we do with it.
40:43
Play with that awareness, it will change how you hold your
40:46
rack. You're welcome until next week.
40:52
May your rack be blessed and your Charleston ruthless.
40:57
This has been the order of the tile issue #9 the best discard
41:02
is the one no one expects. Do forward this to your favorite
41:06
4th. Everyone deserves a seat at this
41:09
table, and everyone deserves to be properly informed before they
41:13
take it. Until next Thursday, dear
41:17
listener. Prim as always.