Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / Nobel Buterin
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. This is David Bennett, and this is Bitcoin and, a podcast where I try to find the edge effect between the worlds of Bitcoin, gaming, permaculture,
- 0:08podcasting, and education to gain a better understanding of all. Edge effect is a concept from ecology describing a greater diversity of life where the edges of 2 systems overlap. While species from either system can be found at the edge, it is important to note there are species in the overlap that exist in neither system, and that is what I seek to uncover. So join me in discovering the variety of things being created as Bitcoin rubs up against other systems.
- 0:44It is 10:15
- 0:45am Pacific Daylight Time. It's the 9th day of October 2024.
- 0:51This is episode 9 70 of Bitcoin and
- 0:54the HBO documentary
- 0:56where they tried to air out who
- 0:59exactly was Satoshi Nakamoto
- 1:01dropped.
- 1:02And it seems to have fallen flat. And it certainly has pissed off a few people. And we're gonna get into that one right now. We're gonna do this one from CoinDesk.
- 1:11Then we're gonna do another one about the same issue from a different perspective,
- 1:16from
- 1:18Bitcoin Magazine. And then we've got some FTX stuff coming up and
- 1:23some Vitalik Buterin news, which is hilarious.
- 1:26And I've
- 1:27just it's not yes, I know. We're gonna be talking about some shit coinery today.
- 1:32But sometimes you just gotta do it so that we can remind ourselves why you'd never shit coin.
- 1:39It's the Vitalik news
- 1:42is almost it's almost a laugh in, dude. So let's just start this one out.
- 1:46CoinDesk,
- 1:47Mark Hochstein
- 1:49and Cheyenne
- 1:50Ligon
- 1:51writing for CoinDesk,
- 1:53former Bitcoin developer, Peter Todd.
- 1:56That's right. Peter Todd
- 1:58has denied that he is Satoshi,
- 2:01and he did so hours before the HBO
- 2:04documentary
- 2:05airs.
- 2:08Peter Todd, I can't believe that this is going this way. Of all the people, it was, Peter Todd was not on my bingo card, dude. Okay. So,
- 2:17clips from HBO's Satoshi Nakamoto documentary which leaked
- 2:22hours before the film
- 2:25premiered Tuesday night seemed to finger former Bitcoin developer Peter Todd
- 2:30as the cryptocurrency's
- 2:32creator.
- 2:32But Peter Todd denies it. In an email to CoinDesk
- 2:37Todd said filmmaker, Cullen Hoback,
- 2:40best known for identifying the person behind the QAnon conspiracy theory in an earlier series for HBO,
- 2:46was grasping at straws
- 2:49if he's identifying
- 2:51Todd as Satoshi. Quote, yes.
- 2:53That interview did happen,
- 2:55and I believe that specific shot isn't deep faked. He confirmed though he added he had not yet seen the documentary. Quote,
- 3:03of course I'm not Satoshi, Todd said. It's ironic that a director who is also known for a documentary on q anon has resorted
- 3:12to q anon style coincidence based conspiracy thinking here too, end quote.
- 3:18Even in the clip circulating on social media, Todd called the theory that he is Satoshi
- 3:23ludicrous.
- 3:25On Tuesday afternoon in New York,
- 3:28hours before the scheduled premiere of money electric, the Bitcoin mystery,
- 3:32the odds on poly markets bet over whom
- 3:36the film would identify as Satoshi
- 3:39overwhelmingly
- 3:40favored
- 3:41other slash multiple. And I don't know what the hell other slash multiple means, but bear with me.
- 3:48At the time
- 3:49of the Poly Market Bets creation,
- 3:52Todd was not listed as a possibility.
- 3:54Ah, okay. Now I get it. Now I get it. So, anyone
- 3:58who wanted to bet on him being the film's reveal
- 4:01would have to choose
- 4:02the other slash multiple category. That makes sense.
- 4:06Previously,
- 4:07cypherpunk,
- 4:09Lynn Sassaman and then computer programmer, Nick Szabo,
- 4:12held the lead on PolyMarkets'
- 4:14list of possible HBO
- 4:16Toshi's. Oh, for God's sakes. The documentary, which lasted about a 100 minutes, delved into the history of both Bitcoin and other crypto projects
- 4:25but did not present any firm evidence supporting the idea that Peter Todd was indeed Satoshi.
- 4:32There was some circumstantial evidence including Todd's interest in cryptography from a young age
- 4:38his relationship with Adam Back, who emailed with Satoshi
- 4:42his technical ability and Satoshi's use of British Canadian spellings juxtaposed with the fact that Todd is from Canada.
- 4:51The film's most tangible evidence hinged on a
- 4:542010 public forum post in which Todd responded to one of Satoshi's posts.
- 5:00Hoback
- 5:02argued Todd's post was a continuation
- 5:04of satoshi's post but accidentally sent from an account with Todd's name on it instead of satoshi's.
- 5:11However, the documentary did not definitively conclude that Todd was indeed Satoshi.
- 5:17Even the final confrontation between Hoback and Todd,
- 5:20the clip that was earlier leaked on social media, was speculative.
- 5:25Hoback followed up by citing
- 5:27another blog post where Todd said he was probably the world's leading expert on how to sacrifice bitcoin,
- 5:34though even the filmmaker acknowledges that this was a tenuous confirmation at best. Quote, it was hard not to read this as an admission. Like, Peter wanted his inner circle of trust that he had, in fact,
- 5:47sacrificed the Bitcoins
- 5:49and destroyed all access. But this wasn't proof, he said.
- 5:53Bitcoin,
- 5:55the Bitcoin that satoshi had mined, has never moved from its wallet,
- 5:59leading to speculation that satoshi is either dead or purposefully prevented themselves from touching the coins.
- 6:06In the documentary,
- 6:08Hoback confronts Todd laying out his theory of how and why Todd hid
- 6:14his supposed involvement in the invention of Bitcoin.
- 6:17Todd shakes his head and laughs at Hoback's assertions.
- 6:22I will admit you're pretty creative.
- 6:24You come up with some crazy theories.
- 6:26It's ludicrous.
- 6:28But I'll say yeah of course I'm Satoshi
- 6:31and I'm Craig Wright, Todd said in the film.
- 6:34This is clearly a joke not a confession.
- 6:36Todd has previously made similar cracks that he is Satoshi
- 6:40telling what Bitcoin did podcast
- 6:42host Peter McCormack in a 2019 interview I am Satoshi
- 6:46as is everyone else
- 6:48Todd still laughing warns Hoback that he's drawn an incorrect conclusion quote
- 6:53This is going to be very funny when you put this into the documentary
- 6:57and a bunch of Bitcoiners watch it. I suspect a lot of them will be very happy if you go this route because it's yet another example of journalists
- 7:06missing the point in a way that's very funny, end quote.
- 7:12PubKey, a Bitcoin bar in New York City, showed the documentary on Tuesday night. Viewers
- 7:17there laughed at the suggestion Todd is satoshi. Someone said, quote, they left enough plausible deniability that you, a random person, could be satoshi.
- 7:28Oh my god.
- 7:30Hovach
- 7:31responds by asking what the point is. Quote, the point is to make Bitcoin the global currency, Todd responds.
- 7:38Back, Adam Back, the CEO of Bitcoin development firm Blockstream, who was standing next to Todd in the confrontation scene, did not respond to a request for comment from CoinDesk.
- 7:48I wouldn't either, dude. Though an early Bitcoin developer and someone deeply involved in the early years of Bitcoin, Todd has never been a prime suspect in journalists' years long hunt for Satoshi.
- 7:58Figures like Hal Finney, Nick Szabo, and Adam Back are most frequently suggested to be the creator, though all have denied it.
- 8:07During the McCormick podcast,
- 8:09Todd said that he bought his first Bitcoin when the price was,
- 8:1320¢
- 8:14per coin,
- 8:15which would mean he made the purchase around October
- 8:18of 2010, 2 years after Bitcoin's white paper was released.
- 8:22Bak posted on Twitter Monday that quote,
- 8:26for people betting,
- 8:27they are betting on what the documentary concluded,
- 8:30which is probably not going to be true because no one knows who Satoshi is. So they should keep that in mind.
- 8:38Previous attempts by the media to unveil Satoshi's true identity have failed, with outlets incorrectly
- 8:44naming figures like program Dorian Nakamoto
- 8:47and known pretender
- 8:50Craig Wright
- 8:51as Satoshi.
- 8:52Yeah, the Craig Wright thing, that whole if you don't know where Craig Wright came from,
- 8:58he came from a GQ
- 9:00interview.
- 9:01It was Gentleman's Quarterly.
- 9:04That's what started that boat rolling. So if you didn't know that, that's where that hole where Craig Wright nobody knew who the hell Craig Wright was.
- 9:13But some
- 9:14crackpot out at GQ
- 9:17somehow got a hold of him and they ended
- 9:21up creating
- 9:22this monster that destroyed lives
- 9:25and
- 9:26just
- 9:27burned money.
- 9:29That's all Craig Wright did, was destroy lives and burns people's money. Now,
- 9:34let's look at this from a different angle.
- 9:37Bitcoin Magazine's
- 9:38Pete Rizzo has written this article
- 9:41entitled money electric is an insult to bitcoin,
- 9:45cynical,
- 9:46stupid, and dangerous.
- 9:49Some say
- 9:51we live in the golden age of documentaries. Certainly,
- 9:54they are being created at a volume far higher
- 9:57than at any other point in history. But for every mister or rather my octopus teacher, a genuinely
- 10:04inspiring and unusual human story,
- 10:07there's the opposite.
- 10:08Cynical trash like Money Electric.
- 10:11Let's start by acknowledging that Money Electric upped its own stakes mounting a week long hype cycle with the promise of a big reveal
- 10:20that the world would at last know the actual identity of Bitcoin's anonymous creator Satoshi Nakamoto
- 10:27maybe let's also put aside the historical baggage there sure many journalists have died on this hill, but surely money electric might have something to add to the conversation?
- 10:38After all, from the trailer,
- 10:40they seemingly spent 1,000,000 of dollars paying for Samson Moe's dinner
- 10:46as he dinners as he evangelized Bitcoin around the world it's always great to subsidize education
- 10:53there were even hints that maybe there would be something inspired here a still
- 10:58shot showing a progression of cypherpunks, all of whom have interesting stories. Maybe the big reveal was just a ruse to keep our attention. And maybe there'd be a series of reveals, none taken too seriously, that added up to a compelling story about what bitcoin is and could be sadly not
- 11:18for most of its runtime money electric hides its motives following its star director director Colin Hoback as he dives into the bitcoin world but it's clear as the film unfolds
- 11:30that the creators had no other motive than outing someone as Satoshi.
- 11:35How else does a big budget film end up indulging in straight conspiracy theory dredging up the alternative history of the block size wars as a way to introduce
- 11:45accusations that are almost entirely
- 11:49uninteresting.
- 11:50Hint, the impetus for the big reveal here is that Peter Todd may have worked with a covert government agent to promote his ideas for the Bitcoin roadmap.
- 11:59It's here where things go off the rails
- 12:02or start going to the master plan after making us suffer his own misdirection.
- 12:08Hoback and company finally play their cards unearthing a series of purported evidences that show Adam Back and Peter Todd as well as Greg Maxwell for some reason
- 12:19were all secretly satoshi
- 12:22truly the most banal and oft repeated of theories
- 12:26from there we see a series of gotchas
- 12:29that would all have been easily disproved if the directors had done the basic follow-up research.
- 12:35Let's review, shall we? Number 1.
- 12:38Peter Todd and Adam Back corresponded on the cryptography mailing list when he was young. This is true and widely known.
- 12:46It's something Peter and Adam comment on publicly and doesn't really say much of anything
- 12:51besides the fact that the cryptography list was open to the public and included possibly 100 of members.
- 12:58Number
- 12:592. Peter Todd's 1st Bitcoin Talk post occurred around the same time that Satoshi left.
- 13:05Again,
- 13:06another known.
- 13:07In fact, the post is written in Todd's snarky style but we're supposed to believe
- 13:13this was him misremembering
- 13:15that he was actually Satoshi
- 13:16and responding to himself or so the director thinks. Never mind that his forum name at the time was Retep,
- 13:25r e t e p. And being that no one knew who he was, he could have easily deleted it. Number 3. Peter Todd once made
- 13:34a joke about deleting Bitcoin.
- 13:36This is used somehow to support the idea that he burned satoshi's keys.
- 13:43Number 4,
- 13:44Adam Back discussed bitcoin on the cryptography mailing list after bitcoin was launched.
- 13:50Giving credit where credit is due, this is also something I didn't actually know. But again,
- 13:56once looking at the archive, we can see the material supports Bak's claim that he wasn't interested in Bitcoin.
- 14:02Not yet, anyway.
- 14:04In the emails, Bak is passively reacting to the hype around Bitcoin, then surging right around $30
- 14:10And there's even a reply where he makes a complaint about why Satoshi,
- 14:15whose name he misspelled,
- 14:17didn't add some feature he thought would be beneficial.
- 14:21Again, dude, 5 minutes of googling.
- 14:23And number 5,
- 14:25Todd and Back were in cahoots involved in a cover up to mask the fact that they created Bitcoin.
- 14:30Tada.
- 14:31That's why he never joined Blockstream.
- 14:35Seriously, this is stated actually by the director in the film.
- 14:39Now taking a step back, it's hard to know what to say about this sequence except that it's both a marvel of creativity
- 14:46and cynicism. And in saying this,
- 14:49no, that's in no way a compliment.
- 14:53To start, Hoback makes no legitimate attempt
- 14:56to engage Bak or Todd on his finding. He merely presents the material as he found it,
- 15:02films them reacting,
- 15:04and closes up shop.
- 15:06It makes sense. Even someone like me will admit there's a non zero chance
- 15:11Bak or Todd was Satoshi.
- 15:13There aren't many people you can't rule out entirely and they're among them. Sadly, a non zero chance is not a smoking gun. It ain't proof.
- 15:22Todd and Bak's Internet presence, while scrubbed from the web, is accessible.
- 15:27I've read it. No. They weren't the only ones involved in digital cash who erased things. Of course, with the magic of editing and by exposing the quote findings to no criticism,
- 15:38I'm sure many viewers will walk away thinking that they've been shown a clever and well researched theory.
- 15:44All Hoback proved to me is that he understands the shortcuts you can take when making a documentary.
- 15:51It alone,
- 15:52among creative works, allows you to hide all of your errors behind editing
- 15:58while making baseless and dangerous accusations seem plausible. And to be clear,
- 16:03claiming that someone is satoshi without evidence
- 16:06is exactly that,
- 16:09dangerous and baseless.
- 16:11Let's hope no one gets hurt because of his idiocy.
- 16:15That's a better article than the other one that I just read.
- 16:20Pete really nails it on the head.
- 16:23This is this
- 16:25is something that we should not be playing with.
- 16:28If you want to play with it, by all means, go ahead and play with it. But understand
- 16:34that this is a very dangerous situation.
- 16:37I stopped conjecturing
- 16:38long ago about who I think Satoshi might be. And I'm not even going to say who I thought it was anymore.
- 16:45I'm I'm probably it's probably in the in the podcast somewhere. If you wanna go scrub through all the
- 16:50969
- 16:51episodes, be my guest. Please do it.
- 16:54Play them several times. I need all the help that I can get. But
- 17:02if you say if you point the finger at somebody
- 17:06and say that and you have some kind of credibility
- 17:09and you have some kind of, like, reach, like a larger voice,
- 17:13like a a larger platform than most other people. And you point the finger at somebody and says, that guy is sitting on, like, $69,000,000,000
- 17:21worth of Bitcoin
- 17:22or whatever the whatever it is. It's like a 1,000,000 Bitcoin. Alright? That's a lot of dough, brother. That's a lot of money.
- 17:32By
- 17:33directing the world and shining a light onto Peter Todd,
- 17:38this film director
- 17:40has actually put Peter Todd in the crosshairs
- 17:43of some of the, like,
- 17:46out of humanity
- 17:47there is at least a handful of people that are bat shit crazy
- 17:52and ready to believe anything that they see
- 17:55and act on it and are psychopaths and sociopaths, which means that they will have absolutely no regrets if they cause
- 18:02Peter Todd some physical harm or God forbid end his life or just straight up make his life a living hell for years.
- 18:11Hoback has done this. Now, I can only hope
- 18:15that Peter Todd took my advice I wrote him on Noster and I said, Look, man,
- 18:21I'm really sorry that
- 18:23the light was shined on you because you didn't deserve this.
- 18:26You should go to Mexico
- 18:28and go cave diving for the entirety of the winter.
- 18:32You know, because you gotta have south enough in Mexico, even in the northern hemisphere it's north of the equator,
- 18:38it's not gonna matter. This is gonna be some nice,
- 18:41beautiful,
- 18:42warm, crystal clear blue water and cave diving,
- 18:46which Peter Todd is a spelunker. If you didn't know that, he likes to go explore caves. And he's he is done.
- 18:54Hold on for a sec.
- 18:58Sorry. I got distracted by shiny things.
- 19:02Peter Todd likes to go cave diving and spelunking and stuff, so I was like going, you know what? You should just get the hell out, drop out of the public sphere,
- 19:10go to somewhere where no where there's no comms,
- 19:13no nothing,
- 19:14go go spelunking, go cave diving, take, you know, if you got to, you know, take a communications device for emergency purposes only, but stay out of the public.
- 19:23Let the public forget you.
- 19:25I don't know if he's going to take that advice. He probably won't. Maybe he doesn't. I don't know if he's got the money to do it or not or the time. Maybe he's working on a project. I don't know. But it's not fair
- 19:36that Colin Hoback
- 19:38pointed the finger
- 19:39at Peter Todd.
- 19:41It it could have been anybody. If he pointed the finger directly at Adam back, that wouldn't have been fair either. But it just so happens that Peter Todd was the target,
- 19:49or at least that's what people are going to come away with.
- 19:54That's why this is dangerous.
- 19:56We need to stop conjecturing about who Satoshi is. Does it even matter?
- 20:01Does it matter? It doesn't matter to me. I don't give a shit. My life is not going to change one iota if I find definitive proof of who Satoshi is, and it's beyond a shadow of a doubt that there's there's not a single shred of evidence that somebody could bring to change that
- 20:18some guy x is actually Satoshi Nakamoto. It's not gonna do
- 20:23It won't change the numbers in my bank accounts.
- 20:27It won't change
- 20:29the fact that you know I don't know that that I'm going to be doing
- 20:34show number 971
- 20:36tomorrow
- 20:37of Bitcoin and podcast none of this changes if I find out who Satoshi Nakamoto is why do we care?
- 20:44Why does it matter?
- 20:45And why on earth
- 20:48would somebody
- 20:49care about it so much
- 20:51that they would forget to care
- 20:54about someone like Peter Todd?
- 20:56Now, one of the other stories about Peter Todd one of the reasons why I know Peter Todd is not Satoshi Nakamoto
- 21:03it's not because he doesn't have the chops.
- 21:08He just isn't the guy.
- 21:10His attitude
- 21:12is not it's not the attitude that you need for this.
- 21:16It's just
- 21:18everything about Peter Todd just screams no. He was involved.
- 21:22And I'm I will give it up to the filmmaker here and say, it's possible that at one point or another, Peter Todd may have been on the early satoshi Nakamoto crew,
- 21:32but he wasn't satoshi Nakamoto. And I say that because of the accidentally signing in under a different, you know, email thing on the on the,
- 21:41on the the list serve or whatever and responded to his, you know, his own email and forgot and all that thing. I okay.
- 21:49Let's say he was part of the early development crew of Bitcoin. So what?
- 21:53So what?
- 21:55There were lots of people on the early development crew. We still don't know if Satoshi Nakamoto was one person or a group of people. I'm leaning towards a small group of people that rapidly
- 22:05expanded
- 22:06the second that that white pay or the second that the actual first
- 22:10Bitcoin was mined on January 3rd
- 22:14after October 31st the previous year when the white paper dropped I can imagine that that small core of people
- 22:21expanded
- 22:22rapidly
- 22:23had rapid explosion
- 22:25of people that wanted to get their fingers into that code and did so because the bitcoin code has always been open to the public
- 22:35Peter Todd was one of the guys that ushered in Zcash
- 22:40right I mean he did he he was what he was one of the guys that he drove cross country with laptops
- 22:47to do this super secret
- 22:50signing procedure that inaugurated
- 22:53Zcash to come to life and even he calls bullshit on that
- 22:58Right? This is not your guy.
- 23:01And honestly, we need to stop looking for the guy.
- 23:04We you know, we've we've got better things. We've we've got better things to worry about, like Carolyn Ellison,
- 23:11who's got to give up all of her assets in the FTX settlement according to Martin Young and Cointelegraph.
- 23:18FTX has filed a motion
- 23:20seeking the approval for a settlement agreement with former Alameda Research boss, oh, boss girl, Carolyn Ellison that would see her turn over substantially
- 23:30all of her assets.
- 23:32The motion filed on October 7th requests that the court authorize the settlement with Ellison who agreed
- 23:38to transfer any assets not forfeited to the government in her criminal case or used for legal fees to the FTX creditors.
- 23:46The motion noted that once she meets those terms, Ellison will have no remaining assets other than certain physical personal property,
- 23:54but did not specify the value of the assets that she would forfeit.
- 23:58She also agreed to cooperate with the bankrupt
- 24:01crypto exchanges, investigations, and court cases, which may include sharing documents or knowledge that she gained
- 24:08as the former head of FTX's sister trading firm and ex girlfriend
- 24:12of the Exchange's founder, Sam Bankman Fried.
- 24:15FTX argued that the settlement is as beneficial as continuing to pursue Ellison
- 24:21in an adjacent court case because it gives substantially
- 24:25all that they could recover anyway, and her additional cooperation provides
- 24:30significant value.
- 24:31They noted that
- 24:33pursuing litigation
- 24:34would just deplete Ellison's remaining resources and cost time and money.
- 24:39FTX's bankruptcy estate sued Ellison in 2023
- 24:43alleging breaches of fiduciary duties,
- 24:45waste of corporate assets, and fraudulent transfers.
- 24:48They sought to recover $22,500,000
- 24:51in bonus payments dated to February of 2022
- 24:54and $6,300,000
- 24:56in bonus payments in 2021.
- 25:00Additionally, the latest filing mentions call options and FTX Equity fraudulently transferred to Ellison.
- 25:06A hearing on the proposed settlement is scheduled for November 20th.
- 25:10Ellison did cooperate with federal prosecutors in the criminal case against Bankman Fried and
- 25:16received a reduced sentence of 2 years on September 24th for her role in the fraud.
- 25:22So she's got to give up all of her ill gotten gains
- 25:27and she's gonna be left with nothing but some personal property. And God only knows what the hell that is. Okay. Coinbase users
- 25:35can rejoice because now now they can finally send Bitcoin to Taproot addresses.
- 25:41I'm actually kinda shocked
- 25:43that they did
- 25:44this because they Coinbase drags its feet on any implementation of Bitcoin
- 25:49all the time, but Vismaya v has it from decrypt. So after years of missing out,
- 25:56Coinbase
- 25:57users can finally access the major upgrade,
- 26:00the ability to send Bitcoin to Taproot addresses. On Tuesday,
- 26:04Coinbase addressed this gap allowing its millions of users to take advantage of Taproot's privacy and cost saving features creating
- 26:13access to more on chain destinations.
- 26:16The address or the update addresses
- 26:18long standing
- 26:20frustrations
- 26:21for Coinbase users who since Taproot's launch in November 2021
- 26:26have been unable to take full advantage of the upgrade.
- 26:29Prior to this update, many Coinbase users had reported difficulties
- 26:33in sending Bitcoin to Taproot addresses leading
- 26:36to delays and failed transactions.
- 26:39With the new integration coinbase users can now send bitcoin to Taproot addresses joining platforms like OkX,
- 26:46Binance, and Kraken.
- 26:47Introduced as the largest bitcoin upgrade since Segwit in 2017
- 26:53Taproot promised enhanced privacy but Coinbase users were left behind
- 26:57for years.
- 26:58Proposed by Bitcoin Core developer Greg Maxwell, Taproot uses
- 27:03Schnorr signatures
- 27:04which compress
- 27:06complex transactions into smaller more efficient data packages.
- 27:10This reduces the amount of information stored on the blockchain
- 27:14improving scalability
- 27:15and of course lowering transaction fees.
- 27:18With the Taproot upgrade, complex transactions
- 27:21like those
- 27:22requiring multiple signatures can be made to look like standard bitcoin transfers.
- 27:27This limits the amount of data exposed on the public blockchain making it more difficult to trace transactions.
- 27:34Yeah. But it's not a miracle pill. You still we still have to be careful with that kind of stuff depending on what you're doing. So just be aware of that. But finally,
- 27:42Coinbase got off its ass and and added something that I didn't realize how long it had been
- 27:49since uh-uh taproot
- 27:50November of 2021.
- 27:52So coinbase
- 27:54I guess I'm not surprised that coinbase took this long for some reason or another
- 27:58I
- 27:59went through a time warp there and didn't realize that wow, November of 2021
- 28:04is when Taproot launched.
- 28:07Shit, man.
- 28:08I'm losing time. Let's run the numbers.
- 28:21Oil is down again, I guess because Israel isn't bombing the living shit out of some brown people. West Texas Intermediate is down 1.39%
- 28:30to 72.50.
- 28:31Brent Norsee likewise down 1.5 to 7595.
- 28:35Natural gas following suit, 3.4%
- 28:38to the downside.
- 28:39Gasoline chilling out down
- 28:420.76%
- 28:43to the downside.
- 28:45$2.5 a gallon.
- 28:47Shiny metal rocks are mixed. Gold is down a third, silver is up 0.18%.
- 28:52Platinum is down a quarter, and copper is down as well, 1.18%
- 28:56to the downside.
- 28:57Palladium, however, knocking it out of the park 3.5%
- 29:01to the upside.
- 29:02Ag is looking pretty much green today.
- 29:05Biggest winner is chocolate, 4.8%
- 29:08to the upside.
- 29:09Biggest loser is sugar, one
- 29:110.8%
- 29:12to the downside. Live cattle down a 3rd. Lean hogs down 2. And feeder cattle are down 2 thirds. But the Dow, whoop dee doody day, having a 400 point changeover
- 29:24after 0.94%
- 29:26uptick.
- 29:28S and P is up a half.
- 29:30Nasdaq is up over a half. S and P Mini is, wow, 2 thirds to the upside. So I guess those guys are doing well, but we are still 15 minutes away by my clock for the FOMAC minutes. We'll have to wait and see.
- 29:44Bitcoin took it on the chin today, $61,790.
- 29:48That brings us back to a $1,220,000,000,000
- 29:51market cap, but we can still get twenty 3.4 ounces of shiny metal rocks with our 1 bitcoin of which there are 19,765,171.11
- 30:02of. And average fees per block have risen to the highest I've seen it in a long time. 0.12
- 30:10BTC
- 30:11on average in fees on a per block basis, of which there are 97 blocks carrying 203,000
- 30:18unconfirmed transactions,
- 30:20waiting to clear at high priority rates of 12. Count them 12 satoshis per vbyte.
- 30:26Low priority is gonna get you in at 9. And the hash rate has fallen considering that we just had a difficulty adjustment.
- 30:34We are now back down to 587.2
- 30:37exahashes
- 30:38per second. So I'm seeing a pattern.
- 30:41Right before
- 30:43the difficulty adjustment changes,
- 30:46the amount of hash rate
- 30:47steadily increases.
- 30:49Right after the difficulty adjustment,
- 30:52we lose a shit ton of hash rate off the network.
- 30:55Why? Man, I don't know. There's probably all manner of reasons, but I don't have them for you here. But from gas, grass, or BTC, yesterday's
- 31:05episode of Bitcoin, and I got Golf Winch.
- 31:086,777
- 31:10says, this is my favorite podcast to support. Please donate to the show. Thank you for the information.
- 31:17Your information diet is important.
- 31:20Choose your sources wisely. Oh, man. That is one hell of a compliment there, Golf Winch. I appreciate that.
- 31:26Ghost of Whitman with a 1,000 says, Here's a boost, you fucker.
- 31:30God's death with 537 says, Thank you, sir. No, thank you.
- 31:34User
- 31:35115-568-42
- 31:36with 500 says gas, grass, or sats? Yeah. I probably should have named it that. Pies to Pleb with 4:20. Thank you, sir. No. Thank you. And wartime with 333
- 31:46says
- 31:47thanks.
- 31:48No.
- 31:49Thanks
- 31:50user with a shit ton of numbers and a 100 sat says another great informative show not sure if you've talked about it but can you talk about the 3 best hot bitcoin wallets
- 32:01I know cold storage is what we should be doing Not everyone will own enough to make it worth the purchase.
- 32:07Sure.
- 32:09I'll tell you what hot 2 hot wallets.
- 32:13Cash App
- 32:14and Strike.
- 32:15That
- 32:16I don't have a third one for you.
- 32:19I probably should, but I don't. Because I spend if I'm gonna spend Bitcoin I generally do it out of my hot wallet.
- 32:28If you have your own lightning node,
- 32:31and which means you're running your own Bitcoin node, you can use either the Bitcoin node wallet which I don't suggest.
- 32:37But if you're running like LND,
- 32:39the, hot wallet for Bitcoin is actually pretty good. It
- 32:44it it it's up to date. It does what it's supposed to do. And that node is under your control, but it's still a hot wallet, which means that its keys are exposed
- 32:53to the universe of the of the of the World Wide Web. So please be aware. But I mean, honestly, dude, there's nothing wrong. I've used the hot wallet out of Cash App on many occasions. It's fine. I've used the strike hot the strike Bitcoin wallet.
- 33:08It works just fine.
- 33:10But if you really want to get
- 33:14knowledgeable about different kinds of wallets that are hot wallets,
- 33:18then you really really really really want to,
- 33:21either ask BTC sessions,
- 33:24but more importantly, I think I think more the more knowledgeable guy about the wallet stuff is gonna be Matt Odell.
- 33:32And I think he's act I think he curates a list of wallets on, his website,
- 33:37which
- 33:38I've never actually been to. Because I don't actually go to many people's websites.
- 33:42I don't know why, but that's just me. Anyway, that's the weather report.
- 33:57Did you want to laugh?
- 33:59Well,
- 34:00welcome to part 2 of the news that you can laugh at.
- 34:04Check this shit out from
- 34:06decrypt Ryan s Gladwin.
- 34:08Economists
- 34:10vouch for Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin
- 34:13as
- 34:14Nobel Prize Contender.
- 34:21Oh my God. The Nobel Prize has lost all credibility.
- 34:24Ethereum creator Vitalik Buterin may be up for the Nobel Prize in economics thanks to his contribution to cryptocurrency.
- 34:302 notable economists argued on a recent podcast.
- 34:35This comes ahead of the award announcement on Monday, October 14th.
- 34:39Tyler Cohen
- 34:41and Alex Tabarro,
- 34:432 ex economics
- 34:45professors,
- 34:46spoke on the podcast
- 34:48for their joint economic blog marginal revolution as they questioned
- 34:53who may win
- 34:54the upcoming Nobel Prize in economics.
- 34:56Well, after throwing around a few names,
- 34:59they eventually pondered if Ethereum co founder could win
- 35:03I have an unusual picked
- 35:05pick? I suspect you'll agree with me I would give it to Vitalik Buterin, Cohen explained
- 35:11Vitalik has built a platform
- 35:13created a
- 35:14You could say refuted
- 35:16Mises regression theorem in the process
- 35:20obviously
- 35:21following in the footsteps of Satoshi Nakamoto
- 35:24end quote Oh my God, this is making me sick After the list of accomplishments
- 35:28he quipped
- 35:30my goodness.
- 35:31What does someone have to do to get a Nobel Prize?
- 35:35Buterin co founded Ethereum alongside 4 others in 2013.
- 35:39The asset has since established itself as the second largest
- 35:43well, actually the first, the largest
- 35:46shit coin
- 35:47that there is in the world at a market capitalization
- 35:50of $293,500,000,000
- 35:53although there's no way to know because nobody knows how much Ethereum is actually in circulation.
- 35:57And if people tell you that they do know ask them to prove it
- 36:01I can do it just by going to my node
- 36:04nobody can run a full ethereum node this has been known this is an issue
- 36:09there's no way to know if Ethereum is has a market cap of $293,500,000,000.
- 36:17It's bullshit.
- 36:19Buterin
- 36:20has remained at the forefront of the Ethereum community
- 36:23pushing conversations around account abstraction,
- 36:26decentralization,
- 36:27and industry alignment. Quote, I think you would have thought Bitcoin and Ethereum were impossible if you had thought about it in advance, yet they're actually working in the real world, Tabarro said in response.
- 36:39Quote, not only that, but Vitalik has continued to contribute towards the mechanism
- 36:44design of Ethereum by going to proof of stake. Yeah. Just like you fiat assholes want. In 2022,
- 36:51Ethereum changed from, you know, real proof of work consensus mechanisms
- 36:55to proof of stake in what's colloquially being called the merge.
- 37:00This move
- 37:01reduced the network's energy consumption by 99%
- 37:05and was completed with relatively no hitches. Cohen and Tabarro laughed together at how smoothly it went, comparing it to changing
- 37:13car tires while the car is still moving.
- 37:15Quote, he writes on monetary economics, and there's no economist who has anything better to say on the topics that he writes on.
- 37:23Talk about kissing
- 37:25ass. Oh, my God. And quote, and that to me is worth a lot in this consideration,
- 37:30Cowan said.
- 37:31And he's super polite.
- 37:33He would bow to the king or whatever is required.
- 37:38He'd be wonderful at the ceremony.
- 37:41There's no issues there
- 37:43at all.
- 37:45The pair also suggested Satoshi Nakamoto, the creator of Bitcoin, but speculated
- 37:50if the award could even be given to someone who is anonymous or not.
- 37:54On Tuesday,
- 37:55an HBO documentary claimed to have identified Bitcoin Core developer, Peter Todd's,
- 38:00as the crypto's
- 38:02elusive inventor.
- 38:03This has since been denied by Todd himself as we've seen and rejected by most of the crypto Twitter community.
- 38:09That talk about a throwaway paragraph at the were you just trying to make up the word count, guys? Really?
- 38:16That had nothing to do with this.
- 38:20For God's sis. You know what that was? That's probably,
- 38:24search engine optimization.
- 38:25That's probably why that's in there.
- 38:27Okay. So the SAP
- 38:30dripping
- 38:31out of these 2 fiat economists mouths
- 38:35is everything you need to know about what is wrong with ethereum
- 38:39vitalik buterin and the rest of that crew
- 38:43I
- 38:45mean
- 38:46the amount
- 38:47of changes
- 38:48that the economic policy of this one shit coin has gone through
- 38:53since its inception is eye watering
- 38:56it's as bad if not worse
- 38:59than any fiat central bank's monetary policy.
- 39:04In fact, I conjecture
- 39:06that you will not be able to find a central bank anywhere in the world
- 39:12that changes its economic policy
- 39:15as much as Ethereum has in the same time span?
- 39:20I'll bet you can't find 1. I'll bet you you can't.
- 39:24Moving from proof of work to proof of stake,
- 39:27all that
- 39:28did was lock Ethereum into what we've already built in the fiat legacy world.
- 39:34And putting this guy up for a Nobel Prize,
- 39:38I mean, they're not as far as I can tell, unless they have nomination
- 39:43power
- 39:45at the Nobel Prize Committee, whatever the hell they call it, then he's not technically being,
- 39:51you know, nominated.
- 39:54But these 2 assholes it's like
- 39:56hold on here. Where see?
- 39:59Pewdiepie steak.
- 40:01This one. This this paragraph right here. He writes on monetary economics and there's no economist who has anything better to say on the topics he writes on.
- 40:10And he's super polite, guys. Super polite. He would bow to a king or whatever is required. Yeah.
- 40:16Yes, he would. That's the point.
- 40:20Not only do we know who he is, he's completely malleable. He will do what ever he's told.
- 40:26And if you hold any of your wealth
- 40:29or something that you consider value in that shit chain of his, I would get it out today.
- 40:35I would have gotten it out yesterday,
- 40:38but
- 40:38yesterday's gone and we only have today. If you have any Ethereum,
- 40:43you need to get rid of it. You need to sell it directly into Bitcoin.
- 40:47Please do that. Not
- 40:49yes. It's not investment advice. This is getting your money out of a clear
- 40:55losing proposition.
- 40:57It may not lose tomorrow. It may not lose the next day, but it's going to lose sooner than you think. It's not that it's going away
- 41:05kind of loss. Ethereum,
- 41:08for God forbid, is always like Jesus and the poor.
- 41:12Jesus said this about the poor, the poor will always be with you. Well, Ethereum is always going to be with us. There's no way to get rid of this rat that has hitched its little red wagon to the boat that is Bitcoin.
- 41:26We talk about riding shirt tails.
- 41:29This kid
- 41:30has taken everybody to the cleaners, and nobody figures out the fact that every time you change economic policy,
- 41:37you're just doing the same thing
- 41:40that all the people that we're trying to run away from are doing
- 41:45they're going to inflate the value of that chit chain away
- 41:49I guarantee it
- 41:52Now, that doesn't mean Bitcoiners can't be stupid.
- 41:55We can.
- 41:57As evidenced
- 41:58in this one by Andrei Bogansky
- 42:00writing for Decrypt,
- 42:02Bitcoin holders lock up $1,400,000,000
- 42:06as Babylon
- 42:07staking
- 42:09expands.
- 42:10So again, this is a warning. I'm not I'm not suggesting you look at Babylon other than to figure out where it is so that you can run-in the opposite direction,
- 42:20run away and run away fast. The Bitcoin staking protocol, Babylon,
- 42:25pulled in roughly 23,000
- 42:28Bitcoin on Tuesday
- 42:30during its second staking round, a much larger sum than the first wave, And a much smoother experience for network users since bitcoin fees did not surge this time around.
- 42:42Babylon co founder,
- 42:44and here it is,
- 42:46Stanford University
- 42:47professor David See.
- 42:49What is Stanford?
- 42:51It's a spook school.
- 42:53It's like Georgetown
- 42:54University.
- 42:55If you wanna be a spook, you go to Harvard or Stanford or Georgetown
- 43:00or Brown.
- 43:02It is a spook school.
- 43:04David See helped launch the staking startup's mainnet 6 weeks ago, and he told Decrypt that the round dubbed cap 2 went pretty well. Having users delegate $1,400,000,000
- 43:17worth of bitcoin to the protocol was certainly beyond expectations, he said in an interview on Tuesday.
- 43:22Babylon has been constructing a 2 sided marketplace rooted in bitcoin's reserves.
- 43:28On the one
- 43:29side, users will be able to lock up their Bitcoin in exchange for rewards
- 43:33one day.
- 43:35While proof of stake networks can leverage that capital to provide security
- 43:40on the other.
- 43:41We already have proof of work.
- 43:43We don't need this.
- 43:45This is all bullshit, but the project is focused on
- 43:49building up Babylon supply side before integrating with various roll ups and networks
- 43:54previously indicating that networks like Ethereum
- 43:57and Solana
- 43:58could benefit from bitcoin staking. How? I don't know how. Nobody does either.
- 44:04And though
- 44:05Tuesday's staking round saw whopping amounts of bitcoin delegated, the process proved far more orderly than the initial lockup back in August, Limiting the amount of bitcoin staked to 1,000 BTC,
- 44:17the median cost per bitcoin transaction cost skyrocketed
- 44:20to $132
- 44:23during the first staking round. But this time, the median cost per bitcoin transaction only rose as high as $2.37
- 44:32skirting a network wide headache for bitcoin users.
- 44:35The difference can be attributed to updated parameters in the protocol's developers,
- 44:40Babylon Labs,
- 44:41set for Tuesday's intake.
- 44:44Instead of limiting the number of bitcoin that could be staked,
- 44:47Babylon's developers shifted to a so called
- 44:50duration based approach.
- 44:53During Tuesday's 10 block window beginning at block number 864790
- 44:59users could stake an unlimited amount of bitcoin
- 45:02while being limited to 500
- 45:04bitcoin per transaction.
- 45:06Previously, users were limited to staking 0.5
- 45:09bitcoin per transaction
- 45:11with an overall cap of 1,000 on the first staking round
- 45:15the parameters for Babylon's initial staking round created a situation where speed was crucial
- 45:21and people paid a premium to participate
- 45:24Luxor Mining CEO Nick Hanson told Decrypt
- 45:28quote when there's a limited amount of space and everybody's racing to get into that space
- 45:33that produces a high time preference for transactions
- 45:36The only way to speed up transactions is to increase the fee, Hanson said in an interview.
- 45:42The parameters were changed
- 45:44ahead of Tuesday's staking round to broaden access to the protocol, Cee said,
- 45:49adding that there will likely be similar opportunities in the future. Of course, because scammers never stop scamming.
- 45:55The delay between the first and second staking rounds was technical in nature, he explained.
- 46:01The first round was very, very small, mainly for security reasons. We wanted to make sure that our protocol was secure
- 46:08and had a bounty program to get people to attack the system.
- 46:13Babylon announced that it had completed a $70,000,000
- 46:17funding round in late May that was led by Paradigm
- 46:21also drawing participation from Galaxy and Polychain Capital.
- 46:25The funding round followed an $18,000,000
- 46:28series a funding round late last year.
- 46:31While the project
- 46:32is still in its early stages,
- 46:34Babylon will eventually build out its own proof of stake network called Babylon Chain, Seeh said.
- 46:40That network will serve as a primary coordination layer, he added, allowing others to tap locked Bitcoin to help secure other chains. And it's all
- 46:50100%
- 46:51bullshit
- 46:52scam.
- 46:53It's designed to take your Bitcoin away from you. They're offering you a carrot that does not exist, but the stick that it's hanging from does. And they will beat you around the head and shoulders with it when they finally rug pull your ass.
- 47:08There's no reason for the existence of Babylon chain.
- 47:12Why did they get 2 rounds of funding that did that was actually USD funding? Not Bitcoin funding.
- 47:19No. No. Nobody was staking in their Series A round. They were giving them cold hard cash.
- 47:24For what?
- 47:27Did they need to build a building?
- 47:29How much did how many developers did does it take to screw in this particular light bulb? And did they get paid $1,000,000
- 47:36each? Because that's a lot of that's still like 90 developers.
- 47:41If they all got a million I mean, did they have to buy a supercomputer?
- 47:46Because you don't need one to run Bitcoin.
- 47:49So what was the initial funding round for?
- 47:52That that's really the canary in the coal mine.
- 47:55That's how I know this is a scam.
- 47:58And they're running the exact same playbook that I watched FTX
- 48:03run.
- 48:04And when FTX was buying all the Bitcoin,
- 48:07they were like going they were just buying Bitcoin hand over fist or at least that's what they were saying. And it looked that way given that the price was skyrocketing
- 48:15around the time that FTX was in existence
- 48:18and doing all announcing that they were buying these massive tranches of Bitcoin.
- 48:23And even I made the mistake of saying, this is good for Bitcoin.
- 48:26I was wrong.
- 48:28It wasn't good for Bitcoin. It was good for Bitcoin's price in the short term. That's the only good that came from it. Because then everything blew the fuck up. Bitcoin's price crashed again.
- 48:40And we've been waiting to get out of the doldrums ever since.
- 48:43And here we have the exact
- 48:46same
- 48:48playbook.
- 48:49They're announcing
- 48:50how much Bitcoin is going into this system. Now they're not buying it here. People are they they they're doing away with that. They they they're they've read the bankruptcy proceedings from FTX. They know how to keep their little noses clean this time around, by God. And they're just gonna use staking
- 49:06instead of actually having people give them the money so that they can, you know, or or or buy the bitcoin on the open market or whatever. Right? This time,
- 49:16they're letting the user themselves
- 49:20give them the money
- 49:22by staking the Bitcoin on the chain. So they have the Bitcoin.
- 49:26It's an asset.
- 49:28It exists inside one of their other assets, this whatever this chain is called, this Babylon crap.
- 49:36They could probably show that on their books
- 49:38but they didn't actually buy the bitcoin this time
- 49:43so maybe that gets them out of maybe when this shit hits when the shit hits the fan on this one and it will
- 49:50maybe they won't go to jail. Maybe there will be some plausible deniability that they can pull because
- 49:57people were staking the Bitcoin.
- 49:59I don't know, man.
- 50:01Everything about this
- 50:02smells bad,
- 50:04and I don't think you should take part of it. And that is investment advice. And, sure, if you want to get mad at me and say that you lost out on being a millionaire,
- 50:14fine. Whatever. I don't care. But I'm telling you, everything about this, we've seen it before.
- 50:20It ends in tears.
- 50:22It ends in
- 50:23the suicide hotline number being posted to Reddit.
- 50:27It ends with you having no money or much less, you know, money in the form of Bitcoin than you started out with. And you end up making these people rich.
- 50:37And they will go spend their money on Lambos
- 50:39and
- 50:40houses in the south of France.
- 50:43And you will never get your money back.
- 50:47Stay away from this guy. This Stanford dude, you don't want to have nothing to do with spook school. Alright?
- 50:53Alright.
- 50:54That's the end of the show.
- 50:56Please remember donate to the show. Send me, send me, like, some, some good boostograms. And and, like, if you got a birthday coming up and you want me to say happy birthday to you on the air, do it.
- 51:08I mean, I
- 51:10I I like interacting
- 51:11with the people that listen to this show. That's the boostergrams is the best way
- 51:16to interact. And it's part of the value for value
- 51:20issue that I'm trying to really push nowadays.
- 51:24It's the only way forward, guys.
- 51:26The legacy media
- 51:27is already dead. It just hasn't started rotting, so we can't tell by the stench that something is actually dead. Not yet, but soon.
- 51:37I mean, everything in legacy media has just fallen by the wayside. It's it's all dead. All the gatekeepers are dead. They're just walking around like zombies.
- 51:45And if we wait on them to die fully, then we're not going to have any outlets at all. And the only outlets that we can point to right now is stuff like Nostr
- 51:55and,
- 51:56like like doing a podcast that has the ability to take in boostograms
- 52:01and you can stream these satoshis
- 52:03and if you do that I can make the show better the less I worry about the external world
- 52:09by making the money that I need to make with this show,
- 52:12the better the show can get.
- 52:14That's the feedback loop of value for value, as well.
- 52:18It's like, if I can do right by you
- 52:21to a degree that you guys give me some, you know, give me some satoshis
- 52:25and then I can do stuff like, you know, buy a mobile rig with those satoshis as I have done
- 52:31and go out and record other people, then I now I need to be able to grab the time involved instead of worrying about the rest of the stuff.
- 52:40If I can grab the time to go do some of these other things then the show gets better. And I can do that with donations and you guys leveraging your end of the value for value ecosystem.
- 52:52Because the legacy media is that in 10 years is going to look completely different. And if you think it's bad now,
- 52:59oh, boy.
- 53:00Just wait.
- 53:02In fact,
- 53:03the first thing that I'm gonna go do is I'm going to make myself some lunch, and I'm gonna watch this piece of shit Bitcoin documentary.
- 53:10I don't wanna do it,
- 53:12but I'm doing it for you. I'll see you on the other side of that.
- 53:16This has been Bitcoin, and and I'm your host, David Bennett. I hope you enjoyed today's episode and hope to see you again real soon.
- 53:24Have a great day.