Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Secret Decisions and AI Submissions: Civil Resolution Tribunal Challenges
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment, joined as always by Barrister and Solicitor with Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 0:04Adam Stirling: It's Legally Speaking on CFAX 1070 with Michael Mulligan.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Good afternoon, Michael.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: Hey, good afternoon.
- 0:11Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:11Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: Up first.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: Multiple problems, it says here, involving the Civil Resolution Tribunal.
- 0:18Adam Stirling: It seems to be somewhat of a theme.
- 0:21Michael Mulligan: Well, first of all, I should say we've talked about the Civil Resolution Tribunal from time to time, and not everything about it is bad.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: It was originally created for the purpose of dealing with tiny small claims disputes, like amounts less than $5,000, and dealing with things like minor strata disputes Think whether the person should have a barbecue on their patio, that kind of thing and the concept behind it was to create a kind of a more efficient hearing process for small claims, very small claims, which can often be done completely online, with the idea of each party sending in emails or maybe a telephone call or video connection if necessary to allow an adjudicator to make a decision.
- 1:09Michael Mulligan: And insofar as all of that goes, it's a great idea, right?
- 1:13Michael Mulligan: If somebody doesn't have to take the day off work to go to court, you probably don't need to have a provincial court judge spending their day sorting out a $300 dispute over a bicycle or something, or a barbecue with a patio.
- 1:26Michael Mulligan: All good, right.
- 1:27Michael Mulligan: The trouble, however, is that the provincial government has chosen to expand the role of the Civil Resolution Tribunal to deal with things that aren't really amenable to that kind of process, which is appropriate for those barbecue disputes and $300 bike repairs and things like that, which it does just fine, and one of the areas that they expanded it into that's inappropriate from a principled perspective is that they have it deciding disputes involving the government or crown corporations, like ICBC disputes, and that's not appropriate because the people who work at the Civil Resolution Tribunal are just employees of the government on renewable contracts, subject to being fired or not having their contract renewed, and so that's not the sort of person that should be deciding a dispute with ICBC, for example, because if the government doesn't like what some tribunal member is doing, they may just find well, no renewal of your contract next year.
- 2:24Michael Mulligan: So that's not appropriate.
- 2:32Michael Mulligan: Another area that they've tried to put into the civil resolution tribunal is the issue of dealing with intimate images, and so BC has this thing called the Intimate Image Protection Act, which is intended to allow for somebody to make an application to try to get like intimate naked images themselves removed from the Internet.
- 2:47Michael Mulligan: Now I pause here for a moment to say there's also now a criminal offense of distributing that kind of material, which would be dealt with as a criminal matter.
- 2:56Michael Mulligan: But what the government's done is that they've allowed this process whereby a person can apply to the Civil Resolution Tribunal using like an online form to get an order to, for example, require some pictures to be taken down or to order a service provider to take down images.
- 3:17Michael Mulligan: And that brings us to this recent decision that demonstrates several very serious problems with what's going on over at the Civil Resolution Tribunal trying to implement this Intimate Image Protection Act, and so this decision that just came out recently was a decision dealing with Twitter, or X, and apparently there was an application made through this online form process asking that some images or image or images be taken down, and apparently the Civil Resolution Tribunal made such an order directing X to take down some image or images.
- 3:55Michael Mulligan: Fine, I guess.
- 3:58Michael Mulligan: Now the response, though, from X was well, you have no authority outside of British Columbia, certainly outside of Canada, and so their response to this civil resolution tribunal order was to block anyone in Canada from being able to access the images, but their view was we have no authority to order what's going on in other countries, sorry, no.
- 4:19Michael Mulligan: And that then led to this decision where there was an application made by the applicant, led to this decision where there was an application made by the applicant for a penalty against X for not blocking these things worldwide, and also a request for money compensation.
- 4:33Michael Mulligan: So that brings us to this interesting decision.
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: It came out on September the 4th, so just recently.
- 4:41Michael Mulligan: Now, the first thing that's notable about it and this is a serious principled problem the adjudicator who wrote this decision confirmed accurately that the Civil Resolution Tribunal Act, which ordinarily requires that decisions that the Civil Resolution Tribunal make be published online so people can read them.
- 5:01Michael Mulligan: It's kind of a you know, there is no physical place to go and watch what the Civil Resolution Tribunal is doing.
- 5:06Michael Mulligan: It's just somebody sitting at home and their bunny slippers are in an office somewhere, I guess, right.
- 5:11Adam Stirling: I don't know.
- 5:11Michael Mulligan: There's no courtroom.
- 5:12Michael Mulligan: Yeah, one would hope they're wearing bunny slippers.
- 5:14Michael Mulligan: You want to be comfortable when you're making these kind of calls.
- 5:16Michael Mulligan: And so the adjudicator points out that the legislation has been amended so that the Civil Resolution Tribunal does not publish these orders about taking down or not taking down images, because the legislation has been amended to not require that.
- 5:41Michael Mulligan: Problematic, because when you have decisions being made by adjudicative tribunals or courts, particularly when there's absolutely no way to watch them or go down there and walk down to the courthouse and go in there and watch what's going on any day, you like right, and so it should be right.
- 5:55Michael Mulligan: We don't live in China where you get dragged out some secret courtroom.
- 5:58Michael Mulligan: It's public, it's open, it's transparent and that's good.
- 6:01Michael Mulligan: This isn't.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: That's not good and just not acceptable.
- 6:05Michael Mulligan: From a principled perspective.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: It would be entirely appropriate, as with this decision, which they did choose to publish, although they had no obligation to and they say in this decision they don't usually do so.
- 6:16Michael Mulligan: There's no problem with, for example, using initials in this case initials that aren't real initials so that you're not drawing attention to the person.
- 6:24Michael Mulligan: That's completely appropriate.
- 6:25Michael Mulligan: Courts do that routinely, right, but that doesn't interfere with your ability to read the decision or go down there and watch if you wanted to.
- 6:32Michael Mulligan: So there are ways to deal with it that don't require complete secrecy, which is apparently how this has been operating.
- 6:37Michael Mulligan: So that's problem, one identified by this recent decision.
- 6:40Michael Mulligan: We've got secret decisions from an administrative tribunal that no one can know about.
- 6:45Michael Mulligan: That's not good.
- 6:48Michael Mulligan: The next problem which is apparent here is what I alluded to, which was X's argument was well, look, they're not in breach of this order in the sense that from their perspective and they had authority for this dealing with a Google decision that the Civil Resolution Tribunal, in fact the province of British Columbia, has no authority to order things to happen in other parts of the world.
- 7:12Michael Mulligan: It's sort of your authority runs to the border and that's about it.
- 7:14Michael Mulligan: And so their position was look, we've complied with your order insofar as you have jurisdiction to make such an order.
- 7:21Michael Mulligan: And I must say, there's disputes going on in other parts, like in Southeast Asia at the moment, with various authoritarian regimes ordering social media companies to take down material that is critical of the government, for example, and the social media company's response has been sorry, no, we're not doing that, we're not a censorship organ of your country.
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: And so the problem on that front in terms of using the Civil Resolution Tribunal, and again the adjudicator's correct.
- 7:55Michael Mulligan: The Civil Resolution Tribunal is not a court of competent jurisdiction to determine constitutional disputes.
- 8:01Michael Mulligan: Just think about it right it's a system whereby people are filling out forms and uploading pictures and stuff like that Not really a forum to deal with serious constitutional disputes.
- 8:12Michael Mulligan: So the adjudicator in this case, when X said well, look, you don't have any authority to do this.
- 8:17Michael Mulligan: The provincial government doesn't have any authority to do this.
- 8:20Michael Mulligan: They certainly couldn't delegate it to you.
- 8:21Michael Mulligan: We're a Texas company and we have absolutely nobody in British Columbia or Canada.
- 8:26Michael Mulligan: You just can't order us around all over the world.
- 8:28Michael Mulligan: The response from the adjudicator was we have no authority to decide this, so I just must assume it's constitutional and proceed.
- 8:36Michael Mulligan: That's not really satisfactory.
- 8:39Michael Mulligan: No, no, it's not.
- 8:40Adam Stirling: I'm sorry, I just I wasn't ready for that, okay.
- 8:43Michael Mulligan: Yeah, so that's, that's what.
- 8:44Michael Mulligan: That's the second problem this identifies.
- 8:46Michael Mulligan: The third problem identified by this decision, unrelated to these other problems, is that the adjudicator points out that the quote complainant in this case, who's identified only by initials, of course, there's secret has was found to have, uh, provided misleading submissions generated by artificial intelligence and doing things like quoting cases inaccurately or decisions that didn't exist, and the adjudicator found that they were repeatedly doing that, despite being warned to stop.
- 9:19Michael Mulligan: And so the person whoever this initials are is sending in misleading, ai-generated submissions and they're seeking money from X.
- 9:29Michael Mulligan: Now think about that.
- 9:32Michael Mulligan: First of all, that's very problematic.
- 9:34Michael Mulligan: Next, of course, this is some online process.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: It's unclear whether there's even an actual human being here, right?
- 9:41Michael Mulligan: If you were an enterprising criminal, you might think great, we've got this online process to make application for things.
- 9:49Michael Mulligan: It's also trivial, of course, to create.
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: Think great, we've got this online process to make application for things.
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: It's also trivial, of course, to create images, right?
- 9:54Michael Mulligan: So you just put that together.
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: Somebody anywhere in the world could decide well, what I'm going to do is post on X intimate image generated by AI, and then I'm going to have my alter ego generate some AI submissions asking the civil resolution tribunal to order that I get some compensation.
- 10:09Michael Mulligan: I never have to appear anywhere.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: I can't appear anywhere.
- 10:12Michael Mulligan: It's a form I fill out and, frankly, if you succeed, the decision isn't even being published anywhere For all we know.
- 10:20Michael Mulligan: This is going on all day long.
- 10:21Michael Mulligan: There's no way of knowing.
- 10:22Michael Mulligan: It's all happening in secret, and so that's just completely unacceptable.
- 10:29Michael Mulligan: That you have a circumstance where you've got AI-generated misleading submissions from a person who may or may not be a real person seeking financial compensation from.
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: It could be individuals here or, in this case, some company in some other country.
- 10:42Michael Mulligan: That's just completely not appropriate and terribly thought out, and so that should not exist.
- 10:49Michael Mulligan: There must be some process whereby you can properly.
- 10:52Michael Mulligan: I mean, I appreciate why they want to make this quick and easy.
- 10:54Michael Mulligan: Everyone likes what's the three things?
- 10:56Michael Mulligan: It's cheap, fast or good.
- 10:59Michael Mulligan: You know, they've got cheap and fast.
- 11:00Michael Mulligan: The good part is seriously lacking.
- 11:02Michael Mulligan: The final serious problem that this case identifies at the end of it is that the adjudicator eventually decides that, because they just have to assume this is constitutional and they're assuming this complainant's a real person and not an AI seeking money to I don't know, buy more CPUs and take over the world or something they have decided that they were going to impose the maximum possible punishment per day of $100,000.
- 11:29Michael Mulligan: And then, kind of embarrassingly, at the end of it it says that the ex should mail the administrative penalty to a post office box in Victoria, which is you know, come on.
- 11:45Adam Stirling: It's a Texas company.
- 11:46Michael Mulligan: You know you've got this decision from the Civil Resolution Tribunal saying please submit payment to the via PO Box 9220, provincial Station, victoria BC.
- 11:58Michael Mulligan: Come on, it's unenforceable right.
- 12:00Michael Mulligan: The law in Texas, as I understand it, they do not enforce judgments for penalties period from other jurisdictions, and you can imagine why that is right.
- 12:12Michael Mulligan: I mean, just think about this from the perspective of I don't know.
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: Let's say, the provincial court of Zimbabwe has ordered some I don't know CFACs to take down some article on their website on pain of paying $100,000, right, just think about that.
- 12:29Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 12:30Michael Mulligan: The response is going to be I don't think so.
- 12:32Michael Mulligan: Zimbabwe Provincial Civil Resolution Online Tribunal.
- 12:35Michael Mulligan: Very unlikely that's going to be responded.
- 12:38Michael Mulligan: Nor would you want a circumstance where the Civil Resolution Tribunal from the province of Zimbabwe is somehow ordering that you know a media outlet or online service starts mailing checks to them, as if that's ever going to happen, and you shouldn't have a process which is, you know, meaningless in terms of making these kinds of orders.
- 12:59Michael Mulligan: That just undermines general confidence in the administration of the justice system.
- 13:03Michael Mulligan: So this single decision identifies for, to my mind, fatally problematic elements to what the provincial government has created here.
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: It's taken a process the Civil Resolution Tribunal very well suited for what it was originally intended to do.
- 13:22Michael Mulligan: And, in the interest of being cheap, they bolted on these things to it which it just has no meaningful capacity to deal with.
- 13:32Michael Mulligan: And just like it should not be dealing with disputes where the government is one party and the adjudicators are not independent of the government.
- 13:38Michael Mulligan: That is inappropriate.
- 13:39Michael Mulligan: It's inappropriate to have secret decisions.
- 13:41Michael Mulligan: It's inappropriate to have a circumstance where you may not be able to identify whether somebody is a real person.
- 13:46Michael Mulligan: It's not appropriate to have an entity that can't figure out, has no authority to decide whether what it's doing is constitutional, or to be making unenforceable orders by yelling into the ether that you should mail a check to a post office box.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: So this one, to my mind, this single decision makes clear why this needs to be completely rethought, and maybe the answer is that of course, this is now criminal, and perhaps that's a better way to deal with this, rather than having chatbots potentially trying to get money out of X by applying to the Civil Resolution Tribunal in an online form.
- 14:20Michael Mulligan: By applying to the Civil Resolution Tribunal in an online form.
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest decision of the CRT on the Intimate Image Protection Act in British Columbia.
- 14:28Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defence Lawyers, legally speaking on CFAX.
- 14:31Adam Stirling: Continues right after this Legally speaking continues with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defence Lawyers, on CFAX.
- 14:40Adam Stirling: 1070.
- 14:40Adam Stirling: Michael up next it says not advising an insurance company of a marijuana grow operation.
- 14:42Adam Stirling: Back to 1070.
- 14:43Adam Stirling: Michael up.
- 14:43Adam Stirling: Next it says not advising an insurance company of a marijuana grow operation is a breach of duty to inform of changes in risk and not doing so is a valid reason for cancelling coverage and not paying for a house fire.
- 14:51Adam Stirling: Seems reasonable, but the courts are grappling with it.
- 14:55Michael Mulligan: All the same, you're quite right and I must say.
- 14:57Michael Mulligan: Here's the interesting thing about it and why I think this is a very important decision and thing for people to know about.
- 15:03Michael Mulligan: So it would seem obvious to people.
- 15:09Michael Mulligan: I think if you were running a giant grow operation in your house, you didn't tell your insurance company about it and the house burned down because of the grow operation, I think most people would probably intuitively say, yeah, probably that wasn't covered, right.
- 15:19Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 15:19Michael Mulligan: But that's not what happened here and it's important to know just how broad the circumstances can be that can result in you effectively being uninsured.
- 15:28Michael Mulligan: And the starting point for the analysis it comes from this proposition that an insurance contract is what's referred to sometimes as a contract of utmost good faith, meaning both the insurance company and the person buying the insurance need to act with good faith towards the other.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: Ok, and in BC we actually have a provision in the Insurance Act that has like statutory conditions that are made part of policies pursuant to how that act works.
- 15:56Michael Mulligan: And one of the requirements there and it flows from that general idea of this being a contract of utmost good faith is that where there is a material change in risk, the insured must promptly give notice in writing to the insurer or its agent of the change if it's a material change of risk.
- 16:17Michael Mulligan: Now here's why that matters in this particular case.
- 16:21Michael Mulligan: The house fire here had absolutely nothing to do with the marijuana.
- 16:25Michael Mulligan: The fact pattern was that there's a house on a very large property, big acreage, and the house had an outbuilding which was some 200 meters away from the main house.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: You could see it, but it's this old, dilapidated building, and in the main house a fire started in one of the kids' rooms.
- 16:43Michael Mulligan: In fact it was sparked by a prayer cabinet candle.
- 16:46Michael Mulligan: I guess the prayer cabinet candle wasn't working very well on several levels, including the capacity to catch things on fire, and the dad smelled smoke and wound up trying to put the fire out, running back and forth using a salad bowl, trying to throw water in it but wasn't able to put it out, and the whole house burned down, destroying all kinds of things.
- 17:07Michael Mulligan: Very, very large, tragic fire.
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: Absolutely nothing to do with the marijuana in the bar or in the outbuilding.
- 17:14Michael Mulligan: But what happened is that the insurance adjuster showed up and they said well, what's over there in that outbuilding?
- 17:19Michael Mulligan: And the homeowner said well, what's over there in that outbuilding?
- 17:22Michael Mulligan: And the homeowners well, what are you talking about?
- 17:23Michael Mulligan: Does that have to do with anything?
- 17:24Michael Mulligan: And indeed there was even a dispute about whether the outbuilding was insured.
- 17:29Michael Mulligan: The homeowner said he'd asked that it not be insured to save money on the policy because it was falling down and dilapidated.
- 17:37Michael Mulligan: But nonetheless the insurance adjuster went over and looked in there and found what was not an active marijuana grow operation.
- 17:44Michael Mulligan: In fact it took some pictures and it was clear to the judge that this was kind of an abandoned marijuana grow operation in this outbuilding, like a bunch of dead plants, basically right, no lights on, nothing was actually going on.
- 17:59Michael Mulligan: It certainly didn't cause the fire in the bedroom bedroom and it wasn't even active at the time.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: But the judge found that indeed this had been active since they had lived in, since they purchased this property several years earlier.
- 18:12Michael Mulligan: I must say the homeowner said no, we didn't even know about what was in this old outbuilding.
- 18:16Michael Mulligan: But judge didn't believe that.
- 18:18Michael Mulligan: And so the decision was based on the fact that having a marijuana grow operation in an outbuilding on the property is a material change in circumstances in terms of the risk, material change to the risk because that could have caught fire when it was operating and because the homeowner didn't notify the insurance company in writing about that.
- 18:41Michael Mulligan: The net result was it was a breach of the statutory provision to provide notice in writing and as a result, wal-mart Insurance Company was permitted to cancel the policy and not pay.
- 18:56Michael Mulligan: And so that outcome unlike the actual thing catching fire and spreading to the house I don't think many people would appreciate that.
- 19:06Michael Mulligan: You may find you are, despite paying your premiums for years and years, you may find out that you in fact have no insurance.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: If something occurred on your property that amounted to a material change of risk it need not be a marijuana grow operation.
- 19:21Michael Mulligan: It could be all kinds of things that you might do what amounts to a material change of risk.
- 19:22Michael Mulligan: It need not be a marijuana grow operation.
- 19:22Michael Mulligan: It could be all kinds of things that you might do what amounts to a material change of risk.
- 19:26Michael Mulligan: And even if you did that and then stopped doing it, you may still be in breach of your policy.
- 19:33Michael Mulligan: Right, and I should say here, interestingly, these people they actually had in the past at a prior property the judge referred to this they actually had a permit to grow marijuana.
- 19:43Michael Mulligan: Oh wow, so it wasn't the fact that that might have been illegal, it was just that you didn't tell the insurance company about it.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: And so just think about that, think about all the things that somebody might do in their home that might have at some point created some increased fire risk.
- 20:01Michael Mulligan: Right, maybe you've you know something.
- 20:04Michael Mulligan: Say you're parking some kind of a vehicle in your garage, or maybe you made some change to your house, or maybe you did some renovations, or you can just imagine all kinds of things.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: There are even cases here that were referred to, and there's some differing authority for when the owner that's got the insurance doesn't even know about the increased risk, like what happens if you have a property and you rent it out and your tenant does something that increases risk, like starts growing marijuana in it.
- 20:30Michael Mulligan: There's conflicting authority about that, and so what is your duty?
- 20:34Michael Mulligan: To know about that and inform the insurance company.
- 20:36Michael Mulligan: So, cautionary tale, that's the outcome here.
- 20:39Michael Mulligan: That is the law, and so you'd be well advised that if you make any kind of a material change to your property that could impact the risk, even if it doesn't, and even if you're well advised to send notice, do it in writing, send an email, and that way, if your house does catch fire, because your prayer candle in your kid's room catches fire, you're not going to find out that you're uninsured for, in this case, $300,000 or $400,000.
- 21:04Michael Mulligan: Wow, so that's the latest on the Walman East Insurance Company.
- 21:07Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, mulligan, fence Lawyers, legally speaking, second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 21:11Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 21:12Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:13Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:14Adam Stirling: It's always great to be here.
- 21:14Adam Stirling: All right, talk to.