Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Office Space (1999): A Generational Perspective
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting here in my attic room. Behind me
- 0:35is my desk, covered in stray papers, reference
- 0:39texts, and an ever -increasing inventory of crocheted
- 0:43keychains. This is where I work, revising my
- 0:48novel, crocheting as a craftsperson. I recognize
- 0:53that this is non -traditional work, making art
- 0:56and also not really making any money. I've spent
- 1:00most of my day as a full -time caregiver for
- 1:02my kids. It's also unpaid work, but it definitely
- 1:06contributes economically to my household. I save
- 1:10us tens of thousands of dollars every year. Child
- 1:13care is not cheap. But I did used to participate
- 1:17in the traditional workforce. I spent a couple
- 1:20of years in food service as the literal breadwinner
- 1:23for my household. My husband's assistantship
- 1:26in grad school covered the rent and utilities,
- 1:29but it was my paycheck that paid for the groceries.
- 1:33There was much to enjoy about the work, but the
- 1:36constant abuse from customers and the impact
- 1:39of such a stressful environment took its toll.
- 1:42I left shortly after my husband got a job in
- 1:45the corporate sphere as a software developer.
- 1:48And so today I'd like to talk about Mike Judge's
- 1:521999 film Office Space. It's part of a bizarre
- 1:57niche genre, 1999 films about white men having
- 2:02an existential crisis because of how stable and
- 2:05boring their lives are. But while Fight Club
- 2:09became drastically misunderstood by the demographic
- 2:12it was critiquing, American Beauty has the awful
- 2:16baggage of its star, and The Matrix's virtual
- 2:19reality of 1999 becomes more and more attractive.
- 2:24The satire of office space is still biting and
- 2:28relevant, even as much of corporate culture and
- 2:31the job landscape has changed. Mike Judge is
- 2:35a figure who has a lot of experience in the sitcom
- 2:38genre as the creator and writer of Beavis and
- 2:42Butthead, King of the Hill, and Silicon Valley,
- 2:45all satirical works that dip into absurdity.
- 2:50Office space is not unlike this. It has a plot,
- 2:55but it's almost more like a collection of episodes.
- 2:59Sometimes plot threads and characters are dropped.
- 3:02Other times the story logic is nonsensical, but
- 3:06here's the best way I can describe it. Peter
- 3:10Gibbons works at Inateck. A software engineering
- 3:13company working to update software so that it
- 3:17accommodates for the new millennium. Mind -numbing
- 3:20work, though obviously as important as this was
- 3:23the idea that caused the Y2K panic. Peter hates
- 3:27his job. Sitting in traffic, to go sit in his
- 3:31cage of a cubicle, getting badgered by several
- 3:34micromanaging bosses, including the iconic Bill
- 3:37Lumberg. who want him to fill out the nonsensical
- 3:40TPS reports instead of doing actual work, which
- 3:44he doesn't even enjoy. He feels so awful about
- 3:48his life that he's convinced to go see a hypnotherapist
- 3:52who hypnotizes him into imagining his worries
- 3:54away before promptly dying of a heart attack.
- 3:58In this new zen state, Peter decides to not go
- 4:02to work. then he decides to go in but only do
- 4:07what he wants to, playing Tetris, gutting a fish,
- 4:11dismantling his cubicle. His company has hired
- 4:16two efficiency experts to cut the extraneous
- 4:19workforce, and they like Peter's perspective
- 4:22so much that they offer him a promotion. They
- 4:26unfortunately also lay off his office buddies
- 4:29Samir and Michael Bolton, not the singer. Michael
- 4:33long ago wrote a program that would siphon off
- 4:36the fractions of pennies from the company's paychecks
- 4:39into a bank account and decides to use it with
- 4:42the other guy's help. Unfortunately, his code
- 4:45has a bug and steals far more money than they
- 4:48anticipate. Peter decides to take responsibility
- 4:52and leaves a confession along with the stolen
- 4:55money under the door of the office. Another employee,
- 4:59the easily ignorable, weirdly annoying Milton,
- 5:02whose treatment by the company gets more and
- 5:05more ridiculous over the course of the film,
- 5:07finds the money and takes it for himself, burning
- 5:10the building down. Now without a job, Peter decides
- 5:15to change careers and work in construction instead.
- 5:19This film wasn't a huge hit at the box office,
- 5:23but it resonated very deeply with Gen Xers, the
- 5:26generation it portrays, trying to work their
- 5:29office jobs while hating them, staring at their
- 5:33future in the corporate sphere and realizing
- 5:35how very bleak it actually is. And in that light,
- 5:40I think it's worth looking at what has changed
- 5:42in the nearly 27 years since this film's release,
- 5:46and what has become even more relevant since.
- 5:49And to do that, I need to talk about generational
- 5:52cohorts. Now, obviously, the idea of labeling
- 5:57generational cohorts is a little silly and arbitrary.
- 6:01Is life really that different for people born
- 6:05in 1980 versus 1981? And on one level, no. But
- 6:12labeled generational cohorts are a valuable tool
- 6:15for talking about shifting ideas over time, and
- 6:19those demarcating years are sometimes random
- 6:22and sometimes not. Take the silent generation,
- 6:27the cohort born from 1928 to 1945. 1945 is a
- 6:33notable year. Obviously, there is going to be
- 6:38a difference for kids born under the shadow and
- 6:41stress of World War II and those born in a post
- 6:45-World War II world. But while 1928 is before
- 6:49the economic hardship of the Great Depression,
- 6:52it does ensure that all members of the so -called
- 6:56greatest generation before it became adults by
- 7:00the end of World War II. while all members of
- 7:04the silent generation were children during the
- 7:07war. And that does something to you. Having your
- 7:12first experiences or your first memories or your
- 7:15childhood innocence happen in a time of turmoil
- 7:18rather than the time of economic growth that
- 7:22followed World War II. And it does something
- 7:26to you as well to experience that economic growth
- 7:30as a young adult. This generation hit adulthood
- 7:35before the tumultuous change of the mid -1960s,
- 7:39and while some of the most influential voices
- 7:41and figures of that change, including Muhammad
- 7:45Ali, Bob Dylan, and Martin Luther King Jr. were
- 7:49part of this cohort, generally, the silent generation
- 7:53quietly worked for stability and upholding the
- 7:56status quo. Honestly, can you blame them? They
- 8:02remembered what it was like to not have enough
- 8:05and got to a point where they were economically
- 8:08comfortable. It makes sense they wouldn't really
- 8:12want to blow it up, which is where the name The
- 8:16Silent Generation comes from. And I can't help
- 8:21but think of Office Space's Tom Smakowski, a
- 8:25co -worker of Peter's, who is terribly anxious
- 8:28about being laid off, and who is, actually, almost
- 8:32in a self -fulfilling prophecy. While his actor,
- 8:36Richard Riley, is technically an older boomer,
- 8:39born 1948, his character definitely feels older
- 8:44than that. close enough to retirement that the
- 8:48idea of starting a new career is a fate worse
- 8:51than death. He's also adamant that it would be
- 8:55best to have a good business idea, particularly
- 8:59if it's a gimmick that will earn millions of
- 9:02dollars without doing any work. And his happy
- 9:05ending is receiving a substantial insurance payment
- 9:08after being t -boned by a drunk driver. He no
- 9:12longer has a job, and he's in a wheelchair with
- 9:15a halo bolted to his head, but he's financially
- 9:17stable, so who cares? Peter's boss, Bill Lumberg,
- 9:22is a baby boomer. This cohort was born in the
- 9:26economic prosperity following World War II. The
- 9:30end date for this cohort is 1964, which I've
- 9:34always thought was a weird year to end this.
- 9:37It isn't because the boom ended that coincided
- 9:41in 1960 with the introduction of the birth control
- 9:43pill. It might be because of the ramping up of
- 9:47military activity in Vietnam, but that would
- 9:50be a better argument for having it end in 1963,
- 9:54where JFK's assassination could serve as the
- 9:57end of an era, which it very much was. But that's
- 10:01my opinion. The point is that baby boomers were
- 10:06born in a literal baby boom, where things weren't
- 10:10actually that great, but everyone was trying
- 10:12really hard to pretend they were. Baby boomers
- 10:16were the ones drafted to fight in Vietnam. And
- 10:19when you grow up in a stable world and suddenly
- 10:22have to face the specter of death for a war that
- 10:25wasn't really accomplishing much of anything,
- 10:27it makes sense you would rankle against that.
- 10:31The older members of the cohort protested or
- 10:35had to struggle with the consequences of the
- 10:37war, which meant entering adulthood with a level
- 10:40of unfairness, either because you didn't think
- 10:43you should have to fight, or you did go and struggled
- 10:47with the unfairness of coming home to a disgruntled
- 10:50country, or you assumed your adulthood would
- 10:54include that terrible unfairness. And then out
- 10:59of that unfairness, the whole of institutions
- 11:02comes crumbling down in a post -Watergate world.
- 11:06And with no institutions, individual autonomy
- 11:10becomes the way forward. What can you make of
- 11:14yourself? What can you build? Which frankly explains
- 11:18the 1980s. Lumberg dresses like a knock -off
- 11:23version of Michael Douglas' Gordon Gekko from
- 11:26the 1987 film Wall Street, with his slicked -back
- 11:30hair, two -toned shirts, and suspenders, unnecessary
- 11:34as he is also wearing a belt. On one level, he's
- 11:38similar to a number of idiot bosses who show
- 11:41up in media. He's not really doing anything that
- 11:44unique. But his skeezy, entitled narcissism is
- 11:48very iconic, as he wields his power over his
- 11:52employees with an, um, yeah, or a, what's happening?
- 11:58And now we get to the Gen X of it all. This is
- 12:02the cohort born from 1965 to 1980, the last year
- 12:07before Reagan changed the world. Also the year
- 12:11the divorce rate peaked. They were the first
- 12:14generation born after the pill. Roe v. Wade happened
- 12:19in this stretch of time, as did the women's liberation
- 12:22movement, as did the increase of women in the
- 12:25traditional workforce. These kids are famous
- 12:30for raising themselves. One author called them
- 12:34the wolfpack generation. Parents weren't around,
- 12:38so they processed their problems and needs in
- 12:41a group. This cohort is famous for its cynicism,
- 12:45its distrust of authority, its distrust of institutions,
- 12:49and objective truth. They hit adulthood in the
- 12:5380s and 90s in the midst of several workplace
- 12:56shifts. First, a combination of global events,
- 13:01national turmoil, and breakthroughs in technology
- 13:04throughout the 1970s had moved the US from being
- 13:08a manufacturing economy to a service -based one.
- 13:12Most US factories closed, some as their companies
- 13:16folded, others merely moving overseas. Second,
- 13:21the rise in corporatization during the 1980s
- 13:24and into the 90s meant a lot more white -collar
- 13:27jobs. This is obviously a gross oversimplification,
- 13:31but the long and short of it is that far more
- 13:34Gen X kids were expected to move out of more
- 13:37physically demanding jobs into desk jobs and
- 13:40service jobs. There were good things here, but
- 13:45it was difficult. Probably Peter Gibbons never
- 13:49should have ended up in software development
- 13:51to begin with. He enjoys being outside, spending
- 13:56one of his days not working by going fishing,
- 13:59and his job at Initech is neither physically
- 14:02nor intellectually stimulating. But it's what
- 14:05he's supposed to do. Get a good job. Make a good
- 14:09paycheck. Maybe get married, build a life, and
- 14:13I bet that expectation of conformity was a little
- 14:16weird. Baby boomers generally grew up in a time
- 14:22of high societal conformity, so when they hit
- 14:25adulthood, they rebelled, throwing off traditions
- 14:28and norms, only to find themselves back there
- 14:33in the 80s. Gen Xers were raised with much less
- 14:37stability. their parents weren't around as much
- 14:41or didn't expect them to be. And so it must have
- 14:45been odd to hit adulthood and suddenly be expected
- 14:49to embrace conventional cultural norms. Some
- 14:53did, like Samir and Michael Bolton in this film,
- 14:56who just wanted to not make too much of a fuss,
- 15:00especially in the plot when the computer program
- 15:03goes wrong. By the way, the three of them solving
- 15:07their problems by only consulting each other,
- 15:09not looping in Thomas Makowski, is very Wolfpack
- 15:13of them. Some Gen Xers resonated with this film
- 15:18by making choices similar to Peter. Changing
- 15:21careers, getting out of the predicted career
- 15:24path. Others stayed in, but liked to imagine
- 15:28that maybe someday they could be like Peter,
- 15:32and that swagger. also pervaded their life and
- 15:36work. I'm a millennial, the generation born from
- 15:411981 to 1996. The name and original end date,
- 15:462000, were meant to capture our identity as the
- 15:49first generation to hit adulthood in the new
- 15:51millennium. Then 9 -11 happened, completely altering
- 15:56the global and national landscape. An end date.
- 16:00of 1996 means our youngest members could have
- 16:04memories of 9 -11. That rupture in normalcy is
- 16:09important. For many of us, it was the first time
- 16:13that we learned the world was a dark and dangerous
- 16:16place and what evil and suffering looked like.
- 16:20Our first members entered adulthood in 1999 and
- 16:24are also probably part of the reason for Office
- 16:27Space's cult classic status. It did really find
- 16:31an audience among college students who were fans
- 16:34of Mike Judge's sitcoms as kids, but for most
- 16:37members of the cohort, the Great Recession hit
- 16:41at a point to cripple our entry into adulthood.
- 16:45For some, it was the event they barely survived,
- 16:49as younger and therefore cheaper employees at
- 16:52a job, which let them buy a starter home after
- 16:55someone else was evicted. But for most, it drastically
- 16:59delayed and stalled our careers. I graduated
- 17:03from college when the recession was technically
- 17:06over, but now that companies were rehiring, they
- 17:10were doing so with the option of picking more
- 17:12experienced employees. Thus, my husband kept
- 17:16encountering job applications for entry -level
- 17:19positions asking for five years of experience.
- 17:22It took him nearly a year to find a job. The
- 17:26corporate software development world had changed
- 17:29since 1999. I can see what Peter Gibbons' life
- 17:35would look like now if he had accepted the promotion
- 17:37instead of switching careers. First, his casual
- 17:42dress during his days of coming to work and not
- 17:44working is now the software development standard.
- 17:48If Bill Lumberg was cosplaying Gordon Gekko,
- 17:52A lot of Gen X bosses are cosplaying Peter Gibbons,
- 17:55coming to work in Hawaiian shirts and t -shirts.
- 18:00Next, he would have removed all the cubicles,
- 18:04letting everybody get to watch the wind blow
- 18:07in the trees outside, inventing the open floor
- 18:10plan office. After that, he would get rid of
- 18:14TPS reports, no more forms with covers to fill
- 18:18out. And finally, He would let people take off
- 18:22whatever time they needed, just as long as the
- 18:25actual work got done. But as much as he would
- 18:28change the office, it would stay the same. Many
- 18:33software developers wouldn't mind coming to the
- 18:35office in sweatpants. Having to wear polos or
- 18:39open button -downs isn't as comfy as all that.
- 18:43Next, the open floor plan office is just a panopticon.
- 18:49Peter got to play Tetris because Lumberg couldn't
- 18:52see his screen. In an open floor plan, your boss
- 18:56can walk around and see if you're being productive
- 18:58or slacking off at work. And that really just
- 19:01allows them to micromanage you more. Software
- 19:05engineers don't have to fill out silly reports
- 19:08anymore. They just have to attend meetings and
- 19:12respond to all their emails and work messages
- 19:15and Boy, does that make actual work difficult.
- 19:19My husband has been through several seasons where
- 19:22the work on his plate couldn't get done because
- 19:24of the sheer amount of meetings to attend and
- 19:27messages to write. And of course the emails never
- 19:31stop. Your boss might not make you come in on
- 19:34a Saturday, but he will send you emails after
- 19:37work expecting you to respond before work the
- 19:40next day. Finally, unlimited PTO is a great idea.
- 19:46That is completely impractical. If there is no
- 19:50guarded amount of PTO, any amount you can take
- 19:53off will be held against you as slacking off.
- 19:56And all of this put millennials in the same haggard
- 20:01place as Peter Gibbons and his friends. Instead
- 20:05of day drinking at TGIF, my cohort builds side
- 20:09hustles. I'm not the only millennial dabbling
- 20:12in the arts, even though it isn't my actual full
- 20:14-time job. In that way, we're a weird reverse
- 20:19of Thomas Makowski, choosing to pursue our gimmick
- 20:23now rather than waiting until we retire. Of course,
- 20:28we're not the youngest members of the office
- 20:30anymore. That would be Gen Z. This is the cohort
- 20:35born between 1997 and 2012. Personally, I think
- 20:41that date should be shifted to 2015 so the demarcation
- 20:45between Gen Z and Gen Alpha would be the memory
- 20:49of the COVID shutdown, but I'm just a film hobbyist,
- 20:52not a sociologist. Gen Z is known for being internet
- 20:57fluent, always having access to the information
- 21:00pipeline, never knowing life without it. And
- 21:04that global connectivity has influenced how Gen
- 21:07Z builds community and understands the world,
- 21:10for better and worse. This generation is entering
- 21:14adulthood in a very difficult time, speedrunning
- 21:17all the crises of the 20th century in a decade.
- 21:20And while that chaos hit millennials just as
- 21:24we were getting to our feet, it's the chaos that
- 21:27defines Gen Z's normal. So Gen Z... highly identifies
- 21:33with this film as well. Whether that's because
- 21:36they are quiet quitting by not answering emails
- 21:39outside of work hours, or because they do not
- 21:43dream of labor, the idea of Peter just deciding
- 21:46to collect his paycheck without doing a smidge
- 21:49of work feels pretty cathartic. And it's their
- 21:53Peter Gibbons cosplaying bosses who complain
- 21:55about the young people not wanting to do any
- 21:59work. I suppose that's the universality of a
- 22:02film like Office Space. Generational cohorts
- 22:06are real in that the impact of a specific time
- 22:10does influence perspective and worldview and
- 22:13cultural normalcy. And yet, it's not an uncommon
- 22:18thing to struggle with adulthood, to squirm under
- 22:21the weight of what middle -aged, established
- 22:23workforce assumes is normal. In that sense, I'm
- 22:28certain that millennials have their own pop culture
- 22:31figures that we cosplay at work, our aspiration
- 22:34for what a good worker should be. And I'm certain
- 22:38that when my kids enter the workforce, their
- 22:41Gen Z bosses will also have faults and foibles
- 22:44to push against. So let's be kind to one another.
- 22:50Let's listen. and see if maybe these cohorts
- 22:55don't need to mean conflict, but understanding.
- 22:59Which may be the most millennial thing I could
- 23:04possibly say. Thanks for coming.