Latest / Friendship Project: Friendship, community & belonging / Why I’m Still Friends With My Ex’s New Girlfriend | Friendship Project
Transcript
- I haven’t spoken to my best friend of twenty-three years in six months, and I am terrified that the silence is louder than any argument we could have had. We used to share everything, but now the one thing we can’t share is each other’s hearts. Let’s sit with that for a second. The weight of it. Because I know you might be sitting in your car right now, or folding laundry, or staring at a ceiling fan, feeling that exact same hollow ache in your chest. You’re holding your phone, thumb hovering over a name you’ve known since you were twelve years old, and you don’t know if you should press send or let the silence win. It feels like you’re standing on a bridge, looking down into dark water, wondering if jumping is better than staying frozen in the cold. And I want you to know, before we go any further, that this pain is valid. It is real. It is heavy. And you are not alone in carrying it. I remember when I first realized that the person who knew me best—the one who saw me grow up, who knew my mother’s cooking recipes by heart, who held my hair back when I was sick—was becoming someone I couldn’t even talk to about the news without my voice shaking. That shift doesn’t happen overnight. It creeps in. Like fog. One day you’re laughing about a movie, and the next day, the news headline sits between you like a third wheel at dinner. A silent, judgmental guest that no one wants to acknowledge. Think back to why this hurts so much more than a disagreement with a coworker or an acquaintance. It’s because these friendships are built on a foundation of shared history that is almost impossible to replicate. They were there when you failed your driver’s test. They were there when you got your heart broken for the first time. They know which songs make you cry and which snacks comfort you when you’re sad. That depth creates a kind of intimacy that most people never experience in their entire lives. So when politics enters that space, it doesn’t just feel like a difference of opinion. It feels like a betrayal of that shared history. It feels like they are rejecting the version of you that exists inside them. And that is terrifying. I think about how we construct our identities around the people we love. If my best friend sees me as a monster because of how I vote, then who am I? Do I become the monster they fear? Or do I become the person who stays silent to keep the peace? Both options feel like losing a part of myself. One option feels like losing my integrity, and the other feels like losing my community. There is no winning move here. There is only the choice of what kind of loss you can survive. We are told that we must debate. We are told that if we care about justice, we must argue. But what happens when the person you need to argue with is the same person who needs you to stay? I tried it. Oh, I tried it. I sat down with my friend once, thinking we could use logic, facts, data. I thought if I just explained the nuance, if I just showed him the statistics, he would understand. He didn’t. He got defensive. I got frustrated. And then, in a moment of raw exhaustion, I said something I didn’t mean, and he said something I couldn’t take back. And just like that, the door closed. We stopped debating because the cost became too high. We realized that every conversation was a minefield. Every text message was a potential landmine. So we retreated. We stopped talking about anything substantial. We talked about the weather. We talked about work. We talked about sports. But we never talked about the things that actually mattered. And slowly, the friendship began to starve. Because friendship isn’t sustained by small talk. It’s sustained by being seen. By being known. And when we remove the political reality from the equation, we aren’t really seeing each other anymore. We’re seeing ghosts of who we used to be. This is a form of grief that society rarely acknowledges. We mourn deaths. We celebrate marriages. But we don’t have rituals for the death of a friendship caused by ideology. There is no card to send. No meal to drop off. Just awkward silences at family gatherings and muted social media posts. I feel this grief daily. I miss him. I miss the ease of it. I miss the way we used to finish each other’s sentences. And I hate that I miss him, because part of me feels like missing him is a betrayal of my values. But feelings are messy. They don’t follow logical rules. You can believe strongly in something and still miss the person who challenged you to be better. You can disagree with someone’s worldview and still ache for their presence. This complexity is hard to hold. It requires us to sit in the discomfort without trying to fix it immediately. We have to allow ourselves to grieve the loss of the future we imagined together. The weddings we’ll miss attending. The grandchildren we won’t meet. The quiet Sunday mornings that will never happen again. It’s okay to cry for that. It’s okay to admit that some bridges burn, and the smoke gets in your eyes, and you can’t see where you’re going anymore. So, what do we do? Do we cut them off completely? Do we try to force a reconciliation? I’m not sure there’s a right answer. But I do know this: we cannot control their beliefs. We can only control our boundaries. For me, that meant stepping back. It meant telling my friend, gently, that I loved him too much to destroy our relationship with arguments. I told him that I needed time to process my own anger and disappointment. And he did the same. We both needed space. But space doesn’t mean abandonment. It means preservation. We decided that we would remain friends, but we agreed to a truce. We agreed not to discuss politics. Not because I agreed with him, and not because he agreed with me. But because the friendship was bigger than the disagreement. Is that naive? Maybe. Is it practical? Sometimes. But for us, it was the only way forward. It required immense humility. It required me to admit that I wasn’t always right. It required him to admit that he didn’t have all the answers. And it required us both to prioritize the human connection over the ideological purity. We chose each other. Again and again. Even when it was hard. Even when it felt like we were walking on eggshells. We chose the fragile, imperfect, beautiful bond of decades-long loyalty. If you are in this situation right now, I want you to breathe. Take a deep breath. You don’t have to decide today. You don’t have to choose sides forever. You just have to find the next right step. Maybe that’s sending a text saying, 'I miss you, but I need some time.' Maybe that’s setting a boundary at Thanksgiving dinner. Maybe that’s realizing that this friendship has run its course, and that’s okay too. Both paths are valid. Both paths require courage. There is no shame in walking away if the toxicity outweighs the love. And there is no weakness in reaching out if the love outweighs the disagreement. Listen to your gut. Listen to your heart. Ask yourself: does this relationship add life to my days, or does it subtract from it? Does it make me feel smaller, or does it make me feel seen? Trust that answer. We’re all just figuring it out as we go. None of us have the manual. We’re all stumbling in the dark, hoping to find light. And sometimes, the light is another person. Sometimes, the light is letting go. Either way, you are worthy of love. You are worthy of respect. And you are worthy of peace. However you define that peace, I hope you find it. I hope you find the courage to honor your values without losing your humanity. And I hope you find the grace to extend that same humanity to those who love you, even when they don’t see the world exactly the way you do. I’m Rhiannon. Keep showing up. Keep being brave. And remember, you are loved, exactly as you are. Talk soon.