Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / What Every Supervising Attorney Must Know About Substance Abuse: Ethical Duties to Prevent, Detect, and Assist Colleagues with Substance Problems
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07What Every Supervising Attorney Must Know About
- 0:09Substance Abuse, Ethical Duties to Prevent, Detect,
- 0:13and Assist Colleagues with Substance Problems.
- 0:15I'm Alapoli Castro, Director of Education and
- 0:18Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:20Association, and today it's my pleasure to introduce
- 0:22our speaker, Jeff Parker. Jeff is the CEO of
- 0:26Vivon Recovery, an employee assistance program
- 0:29dedicated to helping lawyers and other high achieving
- 0:32professionals recover from substance abuse and
- 0:34addiction. A former practicing attorney in Seattle
- 0:38who built and led his own litigation firms for
- 0:40over two decades, Jeff draws on his personal
- 0:43journey through addiction and long -term recovery
- 0:46to inform Vivonne's approach to identification,
- 0:51intervention, treatment coordination, and ongoing
- 0:53recovery support. Today, he works with legal
- 0:56employers and professionals across the country
- 0:59to build healthier, more sustainable paths back
- 1:01to purpose and practice. We can't wait to hear
- 1:04what he has to share with us today, so I'm now
- 1:06going to turn it over to him. Good afternoon,
- 1:10everybody. I am, as excuse me, all I mentioned,
- 1:13I'm Jeff Parker, and we're going to go through
- 1:17today. I'm going to put my slides up. You should
- 1:19have them in the materials, but we're going to
- 1:21speak and talk about a couple of different things
- 1:24in the legal profession. One, the epidemic really
- 1:31of distress and substance abuse problems in the
- 1:35profession. Now, before I get started, this is
- 1:38going to sound kind of gloomy and doomy, but
- 1:40rest assured, there are plenty of ways that people
- 1:44can get help and can actually improve their lives
- 1:48by focusing on dealing with some of the more
- 1:53unique and difficult challenges of the emotional
- 1:56aspects of the practice of the law. So I'll get
- 1:59back to where we were. So we'll go through my
- 2:02story. We're going to take a look at substance
- 2:04abuse and emotional distress in the legal profession.
- 2:08Then we're going to get into the ethics, the
- 2:10rules of professional conduct. and specifically
- 2:13what managing and supervisory attorneys need
- 2:17to be aware of in terms of ethical duties. Then
- 2:20a little bit on the neurobiology. And finally,
- 2:23we're going to talk about the path forward. What
- 2:25to do if you have a substance abuse problem and
- 2:30or what to do if you are aware of a colleague
- 2:33that has a substance abuse problem. So we'll
- 2:37start my story. I. was born into a legal family.
- 2:42My grandfather was a prominent lawyer. My dad
- 2:46was a judge for about three decades in Washington
- 2:49state. Very highly respected people, and both
- 2:53of them liked to drink a lot. In fact, my genetic
- 2:59profile, which we'll see as we get through this,
- 3:02is littered with a lot of high achieving people
- 3:04who like to consume a lot of alcohol. And genetics
- 3:08plays a large part in developing substance use
- 3:13disorders. So I'm a proud graduate of the University
- 3:18of Washington and started my legal career back
- 3:24in the early 1990s. and was very successful.
- 3:28And over the course of a couple of decades, built
- 3:31a boutique litigation law firm. We did a lot
- 3:37of professional negligence work and a lot of
- 3:39complex commercial litigation. And also during
- 3:44that time, my drinking continued to escalate.
- 3:52To the point where my now ex -wife decided it
- 3:57would be a good idea for me to go to treatment,
- 4:00I agreed. So in 2011, I did my first stint of
- 4:06treatment for alcohol use disorder, what is colloquially
- 4:10called alcoholism. It was an outpatient program
- 4:14in Seattle. And it lasted two to three months.
- 4:19And I walked out of that program thinking that
- 4:22I was good to go. I was fine. And I lasted about
- 4:27three weeks before I started drinking again.
- 4:29And as we'll see, that's typical when we deal
- 4:32with people going through the addiction treatment
- 4:35as usual system. So I did my best to try and
- 4:40hide it, but that eventually stopped working.
- 4:46And my next round of treatment was in 2013. I
- 4:52went to a facility that at the time was called
- 4:56Hazelton in Minnesota. It's now Hazelton Betty
- 4:59Ford Foundation. They merged. And Hazelton is
- 5:03really where the first inpatient programs were
- 5:08started in the early 1950s. At the time, Hazleton
- 5:14had a substance abuse program specifically designed
- 5:18for lawyers. I went through that, was discharged
- 5:22and very confidently and I lasted a couple of
- 5:26months before I started using again. And then
- 5:32I went back about a year later into another outpatient
- 5:34program. Ultimately, my wife Holly decided she'd
- 5:39had enough of the chaos. I was bringing to her
- 5:41and my two children So she threw me out and I
- 5:48got a wonderful condo in downtown Seattle overlooking
- 5:52Puget Sound and No accountability my life spun
- 5:59out of control and ultimately I ended up back
- 6:05in treatment For the fourth and final time, but
- 6:09by that point in time, I'd lost everything and
- 6:14After that final round of treatment the thing
- 6:19that saved my life I had nowhere else to go.
- 6:23So I went to a sober living house in Seattle
- 6:27and I planned to stay for about a month. I ended
- 6:31up staying two years and helping them open other
- 6:35sober living facilities around the Seattle area.
- 6:39And what I didn't know at the time was I was
- 6:42really getting the kind of treatment that we
- 6:46see airline pilots and doctors and nurses get.
- 6:50And the treatment that they get is the most efficacious
- 6:55and it really works. And we'll get into that
- 6:58a little bit later. But I am... More than happy
- 7:02to be here. I have wonderful relationships with
- 7:04my kids. I have a purpose I have meaning and
- 7:09this may sound kind of strange but every morning
- 7:11that I get up now the first thing I do is thank
- 7:14my addiction because it gave me An awareness
- 7:19and a meaning And a life that I would not have
- 7:23had had I not had to go through that And you
- 7:27guys are getting the sanitized version of what
- 7:28I had to go through because I don't have enough
- 7:30time. But somebody going through the throes of
- 7:35addiction, it is it's a hellacious experience.
- 7:40But the people in recovery are some of the most
- 7:46incredible people that I have ever met, some
- 7:49of the most giving, caring. And if the experience
- 7:54is used correctly, uh, it really can be life
- 7:59changing in a very, very positive way. Um, we'll
- 8:03get into now kind of the unique issues pertaining
- 8:08to distress and alcohol and the legal profession.
- 8:12So, um, we'll go through the scope and substance
- 8:20abuse. And there's really two individuals that
- 8:24have done, uh, incredible work in this area.
- 8:28One, Andy Benjamin at the University of Washington.
- 8:31Andy's been very helpful to us in our mission.
- 8:34And Patrick Krill, who's based out of Chicago.
- 8:39And Patrick's authored probably the most authoritative
- 8:43or most famous study on substance abuse and distress
- 8:48in the legal profession. Patrick was also my
- 8:51counselor at Hazelton in my first inpatient.
- 8:56Both two incredibly wonderful people. And I've
- 8:59attached links. So if you just hover over these,
- 9:02these are their seminal studies. Andy started
- 9:05out doing this work in the mid 1980s. And even
- 9:08though it's old, it is still still very relevant
- 9:11today. Patrick in 2016 authored. what is the
- 9:17most famous study on lawyers and distress and
- 9:21substance abuse. He is due to update this at
- 9:24some point this year. So we should see a new
- 9:272026 study. And he also followed the 2016 study
- 9:32up with the 2021 study. And here's what they
- 9:36found. So there is a strong bidirectional correlation
- 9:42between emotional distress, stress, and substance
- 9:47abuse in the legal profession. Andy started out
- 9:50in 1985 and 1986 by looking at law students at
- 9:54the University of Arizona, and he looked at them
- 9:59at different points in time, right before they
- 10:01started law school, three years during law school,
- 10:04and then two years after they entered into practice.
- 10:08At the beginning of law school, Law students
- 10:12psychological profiles were normative. They were
- 10:14on par with the the rest of their the normal
- 10:19population, but within a few months of starting
- 10:22law school their psychological well -being deteriorated
- 10:26dramatically And after law school their distress
- 10:35levels didn't decrease significantly Now, Andy's
- 10:391985 and 1986 studies didn't report substance
- 10:43abuse, but he did take data that he collected,
- 10:46and we'll see. It was a subsequent study he did
- 10:49in 1990 that shows that drinking elevated dramatically
- 10:54during law school. Andy used what's called the
- 11:03brief system inventory psychological survey instrument.
- 11:07It's widely validated and it's used by mental
- 11:11health professionals all over the world. And
- 11:14here's what he found with law students. So there
- 11:18are nine subscales that deal with different psychological
- 11:24conditions. And then there is a GSI general severity
- 11:28index that combines all those nine subscales.
- 11:31And what we're looking at in this graph is the
- 11:35percentage of law students who measured more
- 11:40than two standard deviations above the norm on
- 11:44psychological distress indicators. And you'll
- 11:47see the general public, that's 2 .5%. This is
- 11:50a statistical bell curve measurement. So if you
- 11:55measure an entire population, 95 % are gonna
- 11:59fall within Two standard deviations either at
- 12:03the low end or the high end and we're interested
- 12:05here in the high end in comparing with the general
- 12:08public So as you can see on all these various
- 12:12different subscales law students are exceptionally
- 12:16elevated in terms of the percentage that are
- 12:19suffering a two standard deviations above the
- 12:23of the mean on a variety of these These BSI subscales.
- 12:29This is kind of a serious serious issue because
- 12:32two standard deviations above the mean is indicative
- 12:36of a need for mental health treatment. So he
- 12:43compared law students with medical students at
- 12:47the University of Arizona and he did a two -tailed
- 12:51t -test which doesn't allow us to do really a
- 12:53direct percentage comparison like the prior graph
- 12:56showed. But what he found was medical students
- 13:00were elevated, their distress levels were elevated
- 13:03above the normal population, but were still far
- 13:07below law students. So the takeaway from those
- 13:13studies, his takeaways were self -selection was
- 13:16ruled out because law students were normal when
- 13:19they started. He did a NOVA statistical analysis
- 13:22to rule out other variables, specifically age,
- 13:25undergraduate GPA, law school GPA hours studied,
- 13:30hours work, bar passage and practice setting.
- 13:32And what he found was it really was the education
- 13:37that was doing it. There's something about the
- 13:39law school education that sets people on a path
- 13:42to be distressed and his theories. Law school
- 13:48is an unsupportive environment. There's high
- 13:50student faculty ratio. You don't get a lot of
- 13:54constructive feedback and the workload is very
- 13:56high. And the Socratic method, too. No answer
- 13:59is ever right. Your professor is your enemy,
- 14:02not your mentor. And one test determines the
- 14:06entire grade in law school. There's intense competition.
- 14:10There's career uncertainty. So he followed up
- 14:16those studies with a 1990 study. And he examined
- 14:2110 % of the Washington State Bar Association
- 14:24membership. And here's what he found. He looked
- 14:28at depression, alcohol, and cocaine abuse. So
- 14:32depression, attorneys were significantly higher
- 14:37on this measurement scale than the normal population.
- 14:42Alcohol abuse nearly twice the level of the general
- 14:45public. Cocaine abuse was only 1 % of attorneys
- 14:49abused cocaine compared to 3 % of the normal
- 14:53population. But 26 % of attorneys had tried cocaine,
- 14:58which is about double the rate found in the normal
- 15:03population. Now, we did a chi -square analysis
- 15:11of Andy's 1990 data showing the overlap between
- 15:15alcohol abuse and depression. And the data allowed
- 15:20us to do that. Andy didn't report that in his
- 15:22study. What we found was lawyers who abused or
- 15:27were dependent on alcohol based on Andy's data
- 15:29were 63 % more likely to suffer from depression
- 15:32than those without alcohol problems. And that
- 15:35gets back again to this bidirectional correlation
- 15:42between substance abuse and psychological distress.
- 15:51So as I mentioned earlier, There wasn't any alcohol
- 15:54use data on law students, but there was an alcohol
- 15:58use report on law students from Andy's earlier
- 16:01studies. But he did collect data and he came
- 16:03back in the 1990s study and reported those. And
- 16:06here's what he found in law school before law
- 16:09school. 8 % of people were concerned about their
- 16:15drinking the first year. 15 % of law students
- 16:18were concerned about their drinking. By the third
- 16:21year, that number had risen to a quarter. And
- 16:24post -graduate, two years after entering into
- 16:26practice, it was still about a quarter, which
- 16:29is significantly higher than what you find in
- 16:33a normative population. So 1995, he conducted
- 16:39another study of 10 % of Washington State Bar
- 16:42Association looking at distress in alcohol. And
- 16:46he used the brief symptom inventory again. And
- 16:51he measured he broke it out between male and
- 16:54female attorneys this time. And we can again
- 16:57see that the levels of distress on the BSI and
- 17:00attorneys are significantly elevated, although
- 17:03they did come down from law school levels somewhat.
- 17:07And on a lot of these scales in the normative
- 17:12population, you will find women are higher than
- 17:16men. And in this instance, In this study, Andy
- 17:20found that male attorneys reversed the trends
- 17:24that we see in the general population and were
- 17:27actually more distressed on many of these subscales
- 17:30than female attorneys. And then Andy's last study
- 17:36will look at a 1995 study and what he found was
- 17:44that anger was the The variable that really detect
- 17:50that really determined all the elevated subscales
- 17:54on the brief symptom inventory and He goes through
- 18:00in his study about ways and in the need for attorneys
- 18:05to learn how to properly channel harness and
- 18:10Deal with anger and it's not surprising The law
- 18:15is a very conflict oriented zero sum game. And
- 18:19when you're in an environment where you are constantly
- 18:24in conflict, you're going to end up with anger
- 18:28as a driving factor for a lot of behaviors and
- 18:34anger. Elevates alcohol consumption and alcohol
- 18:38consumption elevates anger. There's a study There's
- 18:40a link to it the Ellis study and that study goes
- 18:44through the previous work that was done That
- 18:48validates the finding that anger and alcohol
- 18:52are like peanut butter and jelly So, you know
- 18:56as an attorney finding ways to properly channel
- 19:01and, uh, and deal with anger is pretty critical,
- 19:04uh, as opposed to turning to alcohol. So if we
- 19:08look at, uh, for all substance use disorders,
- 19:12and this is general research, you know, what
- 19:16causes everybody wants to know what causes, uh,
- 19:20you know, substance abuse. Um, and the odds ratios,
- 19:24your risk ratio, if Early exposure, so if you
- 19:28start drinking or using drugs when you're very
- 19:30young, early adolescence, 12, 13, 14, 15, your
- 19:34odds ratio is going to go up dramatically, four
- 19:37to six times the chance of developing a substance
- 19:40use disorder. Genetics, that plays a large role.
- 19:46And that's three to five times. So if you have
- 19:50a genetic profile, a family history of substance
- 19:53abuse, that is an indication that you should
- 19:57watch your drug and alcohol consumption. And
- 20:00this is the one culture and peer influence that
- 20:03plays a large role in the legal profession. If
- 20:06you have a permissive culture, a culture that
- 20:10allows and or encourages the consumption of alcohol
- 20:15particularly, That's gonna raise your odds ratios
- 20:19of developing a problem impulsivity we addicts
- 20:24are impulsive people and Your odds ratios there
- 20:30come up a little bit age if you're young your
- 20:33odds ratios increase Typically, however, most
- 20:37people who develop a substance use disorder at
- 20:40a young age They naturally remit as they mature
- 20:43they get adult responsibilities they get out
- 20:46of that youthful environment that encourages
- 20:50drinking and drugging. So, and then trauma gets
- 20:56a lot of attention, but trauma, early childhood
- 20:59trauma really in terms of odds ratios, it's kind
- 21:03of on the lower end. Really the early exposure,
- 21:06if you're putting a lot of chemicals in your
- 21:08brain at a young age, that changes the brain
- 21:10and it makes the brain more apt to continue to
- 21:15use alcohol and drugs, genetics also. So here's
- 21:19what Andy found in his 1995 study on alcohol
- 21:24abuse and lawyers. So current alcohol abuse amongst
- 21:29lawyers, one in five, 20 % compared to about
- 21:349 % in the general population on the scale that
- 21:37he used, which was a Michigan alcohol screening
- 21:40test. This is the shocking one, the lifetime
- 21:43findings. So about 70 % of attorneys will go
- 21:49through a period in their careers where they
- 21:52are abusing alcohol. doesn't necessarily mean
- 21:55that they become dependent or addicted or fit
- 21:58the connotation of what we look at as an alcoholic,
- 22:02but they will drink at levels and experience
- 22:06some of the problems that people who are classically
- 22:10viewed and perceived as alcoholics do. And that's
- 22:12compared to 14 percent of the general population.
- 22:16So that's that's a fairly shocking finding. I
- 22:21will go to Patrick. Patrick's 2016 study, again,
- 22:26this is the most famous study in this area that
- 22:29you'll see. Large study, 12 ,825 attorneys. One
- 22:34of the criticisms, however, statistically, is
- 22:37that it was a convenient sample, which does give
- 22:39rise to the potential for self -selection bias.
- 22:43But when you compare his findings with Andy's,
- 22:45which were statistically really good, solid studies,
- 22:50we find that they're essentially similar. The
- 22:54findings are very close when you take into account
- 22:57the different measurement instruments used. And
- 23:02if we look at Patrick's 2016 study, again, depression
- 23:08very much on par with what Andy found earlier.
- 23:16About three times the amount of depression and
- 23:18lawyers than the general public anxiety exceptionally
- 23:21elevated stress exceptionally elevated and His
- 23:27key findings If we'll take a look at here About
- 23:35a fifth of attorneys screen positive for hazardous
- 23:38harmful or potentially alcohol dependent Drinking
- 23:42and he is the audit test, which is another validated
- 23:45measure One of the things, not enough attorneys
- 23:48completed the full complement of the drug assessment
- 23:52screening test, so they couldn't really draw
- 23:55conclusions about drug abuse in the profession,
- 23:58but they were able to get enough information
- 24:01on drug profiles, what attorneys use compared
- 24:07to the general public. 84 % of lawyers use alcohol
- 24:12within the past year compared to about half of
- 24:15the adult population in the U .S. Less on tobacco.
- 24:20Sedatives are a concerning one, too, and we see
- 24:22a lot of this. About 16 % of lawyers have consumed
- 24:28sedatives in the past years, and sedatives generally
- 24:30benzodiazepines, xanax, Valium, lorazepam, and
- 24:36these are highly addictive drugs if abused and
- 24:40and very dangerous to withdrawal from them Can
- 24:45be life -threatening Marijuana Attorneys appear
- 24:49to use less less weed than the general public
- 24:52But this was 2016 and a lot has changed in marijuana
- 24:56consumption profiles since the wave of legalization
- 24:59that began right about 2016 That's when the peak
- 25:04of legalization state legalization kind of took
- 25:06hold opioids Five point six percent of attorneys
- 25:11use opioids compared to a little less in the
- 25:14general population I think that this number is
- 25:16probably higher. We see a lot of it unfortunately
- 25:20And again, the opioid epidemic is by no means
- 25:23over stimulants less than the general population
- 25:29and cocaine Again, lawyers less than the general
- 25:33population. So now Patrick also looked at treatment
- 25:41for substance abuse disorders or addiction with
- 25:45lawyers. And he found that about 6 .8 % of lawyers
- 25:49had received lifetime of treatment for a substance
- 25:52use disorder compared to 5 .9 % of the general
- 25:55population. But when you consider that attorneys
- 26:01have particularly alcohol problems at twice the
- 26:04rate of the general population. We need to get
- 26:07to about 12 % of attorneys being treated just
- 26:11to normalize with the general population. And
- 26:18the general population doesn't get enough treatment.
- 26:22So then this 2021 study, this was a random sample
- 26:28of 28. 263 attorneys in California and D and
- 26:33DC used different measurement instruments, but
- 26:38he measured alcohol and in that study as well.
- 26:46And again, same, roughly the same numbers, 80
- 26:48% of lawyers use alcohol within the past year
- 26:52compared to about half the general population.
- 26:56This was an interesting finding. former drinkers,
- 26:59so only 7 % of lawyers have quit drinking. Well,
- 27:0214 % of the general population has quit drinking.
- 27:05And this indicates that lawyers are resolving
- 27:08alcohol problems at a rate that's far less than
- 27:12what happens in the general population. Lifetime
- 27:15abstainers, only 10 % of lawyers are lifetime
- 27:19alcohol abstainers compared to 20 % of the general
- 27:21population. And then he, Patrick also looked
- 27:28at gender and alcohol in his 2021 study. And
- 27:31this was an interesting, another interesting
- 27:34finding. Women, female lawyers engaged in risky
- 27:37drinking at significantly higher rates than men.
- 27:41And, uh, that's the reverse of what we find in
- 27:46the general population where men engage in risky
- 27:49and hazardous drinking at far higher rates than,
- 27:52than women. And he also found that, uh, permissiveness
- 27:58of the workplace was a very significant factor
- 28:02in determining whether a person was likely to
- 28:06engage in hazardous or risky drinking. So for
- 28:10men, if you had a permissive workplace, you were
- 28:121 .71 times more likely to abuse alcohol. And
- 28:17for women, it was 1 .37 times. So the workplace
- 28:22does play a role in whether people uh, abuse
- 28:26alcohol and potentially end up, uh, addicted.
- 28:30So summary of those studies, you know, distress
- 28:34and substance abuse, there's bidirectional influence.
- 28:37You know, we drink to relieve distress and drinking
- 28:41then tends to exacerbate or cause distress. You
- 28:45get a little bit of relief, but it comes back
- 28:48to haunt you the next day. and continuing on
- 28:51into the next week. And if you continue that
- 28:53pattern, it becomes problematic. Attorneys level
- 28:57of psychological distress about three to six
- 28:59times out of the general population and problematic
- 29:02alcohol use two to three times out of the general
- 29:05population. So this gives rise to some ethical
- 29:09considerations because there are ethical rules,
- 29:13the rules of professional conduct that lawyers
- 29:15need to abide by. And the RPCs that are implicated
- 29:21in substance abuse impairment, RPC 1 .6, declining
- 29:27or terminating representation, 1 .3 diligence.
- 29:31If somebody's got a drug or alcohol problem,
- 29:34they are far more likely to not be diligent to
- 29:40the standard that the ethics rules require. RPC
- 29:441 .4 communication with clients people who who
- 29:48have a substance use problem typically don't
- 29:52engage with their clients as frequently as they
- 29:55should and then this RPC 5 .1 this is the responsibility
- 30:00of partners managers and supervisory attorneys
- 30:04and I walk into law firms all the time and explain
- 30:11this particular RPC and It's amazing to me how
- 30:16many just kind of sit there and open their eyes
- 30:19and say I had no idea that we had any sort of
- 30:22Responsibility to ensure that our people weren't
- 30:25practicing impaired and we'll get into that a
- 30:28little bit later then RPC 8 .3 reporting professional
- 30:32misconduct this applies to not only supervisory
- 30:37attorneys and managing attorneys, but uh, any
- 30:41attorney who's aware of a colleague, whether
- 30:44they work with them in the same legal services
- 30:46organization or law firm or not. If there is,
- 30:50uh, if you see a problem, um, you're ethically
- 30:54obligated to report it. And then RPC 1 .6, uh,
- 31:00confidentiality of information. This essentially
- 31:03deals with, uh, lawyers, um, representing lawyers
- 31:09who have a substance abuse problem and or lawyers
- 31:12who have reported to a legal assistance program
- 31:16to get help for a drug or alcohol problem. There
- 31:21are ethics opinions on this. There's ABA formal
- 31:25opinion 03 -429. That's in appendix two and ABA
- 31:31formal opinion 03 -431 again in appendix two
- 31:35and we'll go over those. kind of briefly here
- 31:38in the next few slides. There are a few state
- 31:41bar association legal ethics opinions, particularly
- 31:45related to substance use opinion. There's a DC
- 31:48bar legal ethics opinions. You can click on these
- 31:52North Carolina, Virginia, but by and large, there
- 31:55really is not a lot of guidance for, um, for
- 32:00people on what to do, uh, with a colleague. that
- 32:05has a substance abuse problem, or really what
- 32:08the obligations are when you do actually have
- 32:11a substance abuse problem. So generally, if we
- 32:16look at what, from an organizational standpoint,
- 32:22there is RPC 1 .16, 5 .1, and the ABA formal
- 32:27opinion 03429 require that there be something
- 32:32some systems in place so that there's prevention
- 32:39so that people don't get to a place where they
- 32:41are practicing impaired and it requires establishing
- 32:46internal policies or procedures that depends
- 32:51on the circumstances if it's a small firm and
- 32:54people see each other and you know that somebody's
- 32:57got a problem You probably don't need to have
- 33:02a systemic surveillance system, but if you're
- 33:06getting into a larger law firm setting, and generally
- 33:10all larger law firms that I've dealt with have
- 33:14some sort of a system, how effective they are,
- 33:19I would argue that they're not as effective as
- 33:21they should be. But there should be something
- 33:25to identify to prevent. And there are a lot of
- 33:30things that can be done. And we'll get into that
- 33:35a little bit later too. The next issue is detection.
- 33:41So, you know, if you see something, essentially,
- 33:44you can't shut your eyes to it. Rule 8 .3 in
- 33:48ABA formal opinion 03431. you know if you suspect
- 33:55somebody does and you actually then develop knowledge
- 33:59that somebody has a problem you can't just shut
- 34:02your eyes to it you've got to do something and
- 34:07that ultimately that is reporting an attorney
- 34:12to the bar association the standard is one of
- 34:18reasonableness so You know what's reasonable
- 34:23under the circumstances and then the the final
- 34:27one rectification You know, what do you do when
- 34:32somebody in fact does have a problem? Now the
- 34:37rules require that withdraw where necessary And
- 34:41this is the tricky one because there are duties
- 34:45in some circumstances to advise clients of facts
- 34:49reasonably necessary for them to make an informed
- 34:52decision about whether or not they want to continue
- 34:55with the law firm and the lawyer. Here's essentially
- 35:00what needs to happen practically and from an
- 35:05ethics standpoint when you've got a colleague
- 35:07that has a problem. and that that is get them
- 35:12into treatment and get professional qualified
- 35:18addiction experts involved and usually that means
- 35:24going to either inpatient or outpatient and inpatient
- 35:29treatment is generally for those who are farther
- 35:33along in their course of addiction for people
- 35:36who are more moderate, an outpatient program
- 35:40may be appropriate. That's one thing. That's
- 35:46the first thing, get the people to help. The
- 35:47next thing is, how do you deal with the client?
- 35:51And it is not necessary in all circumstances
- 35:55to tell the client that the lawyer has got an
- 35:58alcohol problem and the lawyer is in treatment
- 36:03or is in rehab. If that is not a fact that is
- 36:08reasonably necessary for the client to make an
- 36:11informed decision about counsel, you don't need
- 36:14to disclose that. In a lot of litigation, a lawyer
- 36:18being away for a month and matters being handled
- 36:21and covered by other staff isn't necessarily
- 36:27a problem. But in a minimum, And when I'm talking
- 36:31to people about this, I usually say, you know,
- 36:35tell the client that the lawyer's taking a break
- 36:39and you're going to have somebody else cover
- 36:41it. Now, if, if there's been mistakes that have
- 36:46happened, obviously the client needs to be told
- 36:50of those mistakes. And you may need to get into
- 36:54a situation where the. The client is advised
- 36:58that hey, the lawyer has a drug or alcohol problem.
- 37:01They're getting help So that there is a lot of
- 37:06nuance to that and that really needs to be dealt
- 37:10with with ethic lawyers Where as possible and
- 37:14that we get into these, you know RPC 1 .4 This
- 37:22is where we talk about this communication with
- 37:24clients. A change in lawyer personnel is a significant
- 37:29development under comment one, and you need to
- 37:33discuss that. Now, materiality is the threshold.
- 37:39Rule 1 .4 only requires disclosure if that's
- 37:42material to the client's representation. And
- 37:46impairment isn't automatically material. It becomes
- 37:50material when it significantly affects the representation.
- 37:54So if errors have been caused, missed deadlines,
- 37:58harmed the client's interests, then that needs
- 38:01to be disclosed. Okay, now 1 .4 also. This is
- 38:07the tricky one. What happens when you have an
- 38:10impaired lawyer who leaves the firm or the partnership?
- 38:14The client has the right to choose whether to
- 38:16stay with the firm or follow the impaired lawyer.
- 38:18You know, if the impaired lawyer is leaving and
- 38:21the client's deciding what to do, rule 1 .4 requires
- 38:25the firm to give the client enough facts to make
- 38:27an informed choice about counsel. And that may
- 38:30require that the firm tell the client that, hey,
- 38:33this person's leaving, but they have a problem
- 38:37with drugs or alcohol. Now, this is the one that's
- 38:40strange to me. The lawyer's already left. There's
- 38:43no obligation to inform the client of the impairment.
- 38:46But you can't engage in any communication that
- 38:51could be read or seen as endorsing the employed
- 38:54impaired lawyer's ability to handle client matters.
- 38:59I don't know why this rule exists, quite frankly,
- 39:02if the goal is to protect the public. The client,
- 39:08in my opinion, should know that there is an issue.
- 39:12So this is a... Disclosure to client chart here
- 39:18that you can take a look at at your own Leisure
- 39:24now there is rule point or rpc 8 .3 the duty
- 39:28to report that doesn't require that You have
- 39:34duty to report if there's a suspicion or there's
- 39:38rumors or there's innuendo You have to have knowledge
- 39:45And rule 1 .0 defines knowledge as actual knowledge
- 39:51of the fact in question. Now, if you suspect
- 39:57somebody's got a problem, do you have a duty
- 40:01to investigate further? That's a question. I
- 40:07think if it's somebody that you work with, you
- 40:11should. And we've got this again. You don't have
- 40:19a duty to support if there's suspicion. Now if
- 40:22somebody gets, this deals with sanctions. Substance
- 40:28use disorder is not an excuse for committing
- 40:32an ethical violation. It is a mitigating factor
- 40:36only in meeting out lawyer discipline. And generally,
- 40:43If you've got, and this is 9 .32, the ABA standards
- 40:48for imposing lawyer discipline, there's medical
- 40:51evidence that the respondent is affected by chemical
- 40:54dependency and that chemical dependency caused
- 40:58the misconduct. The recovery from the chemical
- 41:02dispendency is demonstrated. It has to be by
- 41:06meaningful and sustained period of successful
- 41:08rehabilitation. And recovery is rested. and the
- 41:13recurrence of that misconduct is unlikely, then
- 41:16you can, and a lot of people do save their law
- 41:19licenses. And we'll get into the best way to
- 41:23do that here right now. So essentially don't
- 41:27ignore suspicion. Now let's get into how lawyers
- 41:32get clean and sober. Most of us unfortunately
- 41:36don't recover. Natural remission without any
- 41:40assistance is the primary pathway. Most lawyers
- 41:43do the thing that the general public does. We
- 41:47use private therapists, inpatient or outpatient,
- 41:50specialty addiction treatment, rehab, 12 -step
- 41:53programs, AA, NA, and a few lawyers use lawyer's
- 41:58assistance programs. And all 50 states have an
- 42:01LAP, but there are no national standards. Funding
- 42:06and service is provided very greatly. LAP and
- 42:11bar disciplinary functions are separate. There
- 42:13are confidentiality protocols. And a referral
- 42:17of a colleague to an LAP doesn't necessarily
- 42:20satisfy ethical obligations to report. And here's
- 42:25the important thing. LAPs serve only a minority
- 42:29of attorneys with substance abuse problems. It's
- 42:31somewhere in the two to three percent range.
- 42:34Most of us who have a problem will not go to
- 42:37an LAP. They are too closely associated with
- 42:42bar associations and we're too afraid of that.
- 42:46And that's really the biggest problem that LAPs
- 42:49face. Wonderful and credible people they're willing
- 42:52to help and a great resource and I would encourage
- 42:54anybody to use them. But here's another problem.
- 42:58Very few LAPs provide long -term aftercare services
- 43:04and that's really the crux to getting people
- 43:06well. And here's why. The traditional methods
- 43:10of treating people, relapse rates in the first
- 43:13year following treatment are about 80 to 85%.
- 43:17And the research indicates that only about 30
- 43:22% of us are point prevalence abstinent at five
- 43:25years following discharge from treatment. Relapse
- 43:29is the rule. And for those who do achieve abstinence,
- 43:34it takes about a decade. in an average of four
- 43:38treatment episodes or serious cessation attempts.
- 43:40So for people who've gotten to the point where
- 43:43they need treatment, they go to treatment, it
- 43:46doesn't work very well. But there are, this is
- 43:49the good news, there are programs and models
- 43:52that work. And there's three that we'll talk
- 43:56about. And the first is human intervention motivation
- 44:01study adopted by the airline pilots in the 1970s.
- 44:0686 % of the people that go through hems never
- 44:09relapse, and the few that do, the vast majority
- 44:14don't relapse again. They have long -term success
- 44:17rates of over 90 % getting people clean and sober
- 44:21and keeping them that way. Physicians adopted
- 44:23a similar model called physician health programs.
- 44:27And 78 % first year success, no relapse with
- 44:31doctors. There's a study that shows their long
- 44:33-term success rate is 96%. Get and stay clean
- 44:36and sober long -term. And nurses, same thing.
- 44:42Now these programs all have kind of the same
- 44:46methodology. You initially go to treatment at
- 44:49a typical treatment as usual treatment facility.
- 44:53They're vetted. They're discharged into aftercare
- 44:58structures and the key feature of those aftercare
- 45:02structures are frequent abstinence testing. And
- 45:07they've got mandated support group participation,
- 45:11compliance with any co -occurring mental health
- 45:13issues, and professional licensure and recovery
- 45:18support work together. So there is, you don't
- 45:22get to work if you continue to use and drink.
- 45:25Your license gets suspended. to continue to earn
- 45:28a living, which provides a lot of leverage and
- 45:31incentive that gets and keeps people clean and
- 45:35sober. Their mandated three to five year participation
- 45:39to sustain professional licensure. So you've
- 45:43got to be in the program for three to five years
- 45:45and really get tested for three to five years
- 45:47to ensure that you're staying sober and that
- 45:49you're doing the work. So long time, but it works.
- 45:57The people we've interviewed probably the 120
- 46:00now, I think pilots, doctors and nurses have
- 46:03gone through these programs and it's by the time
- 46:08they're in year one or year two, uh, they enjoy
- 46:11it. It's not a drag on their, their lives. They
- 46:17get a lot out of it and they're very grateful
- 46:19for it. Um, so These these models are called
- 46:24high celerity models where abstinence is confirmed
- 46:27by frequent biological testing There's swift
- 46:30certain consequences for using and here's the
- 46:34thing though The best thing to get you to stay
- 46:38clean and sober is to stay clean and sober the
- 46:42more time somebody has in sobriety the greater
- 46:46the odds are that that person will continue to
- 46:49stay sober and it typically takes at least two
- 46:53years. These programs require three to five,
- 46:57but if you can get somebody to the two year mark,
- 47:00they have an excellent chance of sustaining recovery.
- 47:06And it works through operant conditioning of
- 47:09the brain and extinction learning. And we'll
- 47:13get into that. There's some theories or some
- 47:16theories that have actually gained a lot of traction
- 47:19and there's a lot of evidence supporting them.
- 47:22Two researchers, Kahneman and Tversky actually
- 47:25won a Nobel Prize. They found that losses loom
- 47:29larger than gains in terms of our neurobiology.
- 47:33We're always looking for carrots and sticks and
- 47:37we fear the sticks more. So if you know you're
- 47:41going to get drug and alcohol tested, you're
- 47:45far less likely to use. Then we get into Becker's
- 47:51deterrence model, and that says that if detection
- 47:56and loss are large, you're not going to be engaged
- 48:01in the behavior that leads to that loss. And
- 48:06here's another issue in addiction, hyperbolic
- 48:09delayed discounting. Those of us that have an
- 48:13addiction problem We really don't care what happens
- 48:17tomorrow, you know right now we've got a state
- 48:19I save stay stave off craving and And withdrawal
- 48:25so, you know if if there's going to be a consequence
- 48:28tomorrow that consequence is less important than
- 48:33the power emanating from our midbrains it's screaming
- 48:36use Craving and withdrawal are no fun to deal
- 48:40with so and this is And this is that theory of
- 48:48if you can keep people in a structured program
- 48:51and keep them abstinent, there's a particular
- 48:55pathway in the brain called the lateral hibunala.
- 48:58And that is essentially our stick signal. And
- 49:03if we know we're going to be tested, if we know
- 49:05there's going to be an adverse consequence, this
- 49:08particular pathway actually neurobiologically
- 49:12reduces craving. and reduces the drive to continue
- 49:18to engage in drug seeking and drug consuming
- 49:20behaviors. That's really why the programs with
- 49:22the doctors, pilots and nurses work so well.
- 49:27So if you've got somebody that's got a problem,
- 49:33the best thing to do is to ensure that they get
- 49:36into a very structured support system. Just sending
- 49:40them to treatment isn't going to work. Very well
- 49:46I seem to have lost my screen. I somehow lost
- 50:00my screen. So I'll wrap it up here The critical
- 50:05thing Okay, the critical thing to do if you've
- 50:12got a colleague with a drug or alcohol problem
- 50:15and your supervisory attorney is don't ignore
- 50:18it You know enlist the resources of an LAPA legal
- 50:25lawyers assistance program you know, and or,
- 50:29uh, find somebody in there. There are lots of
- 50:33professionals out there and treatment centers
- 50:34out there that do specialize in helping lawyers.
- 50:39Um, and that that's the critical thing. Uh, it's
- 50:44easy to take a look at a lawyer and say, let's
- 50:47just fire him or her. And that's not, you know,
- 50:54one, I don't think that that's necessarily moral
- 50:56or ethical. because we can be rehabilitated.
- 51:01And secondly, you're losing a great resource.
- 51:02Once you get somebody clean and sober, you will
- 51:05have, uh, uh, an incredible human being. So with
- 51:11that, I'll, uh, if there's any questions, cause
- 51:15I think we're running out of time here and, uh,
- 51:24okay, let's see. Does anybody have any questions?
- 51:32Looks like we have one question from Oh Mitchamani.
- 51:35What if the lawyer has diabetes, migraines, or
- 51:37takes prescribed medication under doctor's supervision?
- 51:40However, a pernivorous issue such as diabetes
- 51:45or even back problems with the lawyer may take
- 51:48pain medication or may not affect the lawyer's
- 51:51performance. Is there a duty to report diabetes
- 51:55medications or a vertigo or epilepsy? If so,
- 51:58at what point does the disclosure rule violate
- 52:00ADA rules? um this line of thought may lead to
- 52:04all lawyers who are taking medications to disclose
- 52:07their medications um let's see i guess your thoughts
- 52:12on that uh there's not you know if if the lawyer's
- 52:17taking medication under doctor's uh doctor's
- 52:21care i i don't see that there's any ethical duty
- 52:24to disclose uh to disclose that to a client If
- 52:30it becomes a problem, if it's a psychoactive
- 52:34drug or an addictive drug and it becomes a problem,
- 52:36then we get into a whole different analysis.
- 52:39But just taking medication, I don't think gives
- 52:44rise to any duty to disclose anything to anybody.
- 52:50All right. Looks like we have another question.
- 52:52Could you also provide the stats again on attorneys
- 52:56utilizing LAC programs? Yeah, and this is kind
- 53:00of a tough one the the ABA Colap Commission on
- 53:07lawyers assistance programs the last Data that
- 53:11they published on this was 2014 now they have
- 53:15authored a subsequent study that came out in
- 53:172024, but They're keeping that internal. They're
- 53:21not sharing that with people outside of the the
- 53:24Colap environment and from what We've gathered
- 53:29from the data only about two to three percent
- 53:34of the lawyers with a substance abuse problem
- 53:37Utilize the lawyers assistance program for help
- 53:40and that's based upon estimates if we take the
- 53:4420 % figure of lawyers who have a substance abuse
- 53:48particularly alcohol problem and project that
- 53:52rate onto the entire population of lawyers in
- 53:56the U .S. which is about 1 .3 million currently
- 53:58and then they provided data that the numbers
- 54:03and if you want that report I can just email
- 54:07me and I can get you that 2014 report but that's
- 54:10what it looks like only about two to three percent
- 54:13of lawyers used with substance use disorders
- 54:16use an LAP. All right and it looks like we have
- 54:20one last question here. From a management perspective,
- 54:24how do you handle the sometimes cyclicality of
- 54:27substance abuse? Once a firm knows about a substance
- 54:30abuse issue, how do they monitor the situation
- 54:33without micromanaging or closely monitoring the
- 54:35attorney? Barry, yeah, I mean, that's a really,
- 54:38really good question. And I mean, that's essentially
- 54:41what we do. We do the monitoring. And I would
- 54:49say there are People that do him style monitoring
- 54:55and him style programs. We're one of them There
- 54:58are other providers out there too. We're the
- 55:00only ones that I'm aware of that does it for
- 55:01the legal profession but it shouldn't be monitoring
- 55:06shouldn't be done by family members and it shouldn't
- 55:09be done by the employer and the system that we
- 55:14found works best is we take care of the biological
- 55:18drug testing and We give, and we make sure that
- 55:25the attorney in recovery, especially early recovery,
- 55:28is doing the work they need to do. So we work
- 55:31with the law firm on that. We provide a report
- 55:35card weekly to show to one responsible person,
- 55:40maybe two at a law firm, to show that the lawyer
- 55:43is doing what the lawyer needs to do. That works
- 55:52best, you know, I got to tell you, you know,
- 55:55if you do a report card to the law firm, the
- 55:59law firm then knows. And if there's any positive
- 56:02tests, uh, we work with the law firm and notify
- 56:06the law firm. Yeah. Hey, there was a slip. And
- 56:10then we work with the addiction professionals
- 56:13that we work with to get the person right back
- 56:16on track. Uh, it. You know relapses are to be
- 56:22expected unless there is a Unless their structures
- 56:27in place, but there are ways that that Attorneys
- 56:32can be monitored that are very effective We use
- 56:37a device that measures the pupillary light reflex
- 56:40of the eye So lawyers don't have to go to a testing
- 56:43facility two or three times a week You can do
- 56:46it all remotely the technology on drug testing
- 56:49has gotten so much better in the last five years
- 56:52But you should have somebody who knows How to
- 56:57do the drug testing do it and it's going to be
- 57:00there for the long term it really needs to be
- 57:03a fully integrated kind of a system where It's
- 57:07not just the drug testing. It's the making sure
- 57:09that they're doing their, their meetings. It's
- 57:12making sure that they're taking care of any co
- 57:14-occurring mental health issues. And, uh, and
- 57:19if you do that, 90 % of the people get out of
- 57:22it. If you don't, most of us are going to go
- 57:25back and relapse and the numbers aren't good.
- 57:28So, you know, if you have any questions, you
- 57:32know, if anybody has any questions, feel free
- 57:34to just email me. then the email is is on the
- 57:37slides. All right, that is it for questions today.
- 57:44Jeff, do you have any other concluding remarks
- 57:46that you'd like to make to our audience? No,
- 57:49I don't. Sorry, we got off to a rough start,
- 57:50guys. It kind of discombobulated me a little
- 57:53bit. But, you know, in closing, I would just
- 57:57say this, you know, if you're concerned about
- 57:59your own drinking, drug use or depression, you
- 58:03know, there's a lot of stigma around that. But
- 58:07please reach out. You will find the most incredible,
- 58:10wonderful people if you just take that step,
- 58:14that little baby step to reach out and get some
- 58:17help. And anybody can recover from a substance
- 58:22use disorder given the right circumstances and
- 58:26given the right environment. If you're struggling
- 58:29with depression, anxiety, anything like that,
- 58:32there are so many resources out there. take the
- 58:36baby step to get the help. And the other thing
- 58:39is, if you run a law firm or other legal service
- 58:44organization, the smartest thing you can do and
- 58:48probably the greatest investment that you can
- 58:50make is in your people and their wellbeing. There
- 58:54was a study that American Airlines did and they
- 58:57found that for every dollar that they put into
- 59:00their their HIMS program, getting pilots well.
- 59:04The rate of return on that was 38%. And there
- 59:07are other studies too. The Unmined group did
- 59:10a very good study specifically on lawyers and
- 59:14found that distress, psychological issues, and
- 59:20substance abuse, you know, are a huge cost to
- 59:24law firms in the form of presenteeism. People
- 59:27that are there at work but aren't working at
- 59:29their optimal. because they're distressed, hung
- 59:33over, or preoccupied, you know, with other issues
- 59:39instead of focused on work. And it's costing,
- 59:43you know, just economically, it's costing law
- 59:45firms millions and millions of dollars in burnout
- 59:48and turnover and presenteism. So really, you
- 59:53know, we're all worried about marketing budgets
- 59:55and what's happening with AI and how do we make
- 59:58money, you know, in this way. Focusing on people
- 1:00:02always brings the biggest returns on investment.
- 1:00:07So I would encourage people to really, and there
- 1:00:10are so many resources out there and we can point
- 1:00:12you in that direction. You know, that's not really
- 1:00:15our bailiwick. We help individuals, but we have
- 1:00:17that information. So if you want to set up a
- 1:00:19program like that, uh, feel free to reach out
- 1:00:22to me. And on that, I will conclude. All right.
- 1:00:28Thanks guys. That was a lot of information. I
- 1:00:31appreciate it. Thank you, Jeff. And thank you
- 1:00:35so much to our audience. Have a great day, everyone.